HAL Id: ijn_00000285
https://jeannicod.ccsd.cnrs.fr/ijn_00000285
Submitted on 6 Nov 2002
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Postcripts to ”A pragmatic approach to the problem of logical omniscience”
Paul Egré
To cite this version:
Paul Egré. Postcripts to ”A pragmatic approach to the problem of logical omniscience”. 2002.
�ijn_00000285�
!"# $&%'()#+*,( , -
.0/2143 57698(:
;=<?>9@BADCE@B8GF9H I2JKJEI
LNMPORQSUTVWYX2W9QZS\[]L_^S`X2abTcXbORdecLfW?W?S`g2XbeihGORgjORh?Qc^ESRgbk?lQTg2Mnmg2abdeX2lNoETcp?dq
r
edQp?eQsfh?Xbt7k9QQp7u S`dORORQpX2pYt7W?S`Q
r
QpvORQtORgfX
r
TcXbllBXbw?t?dQp?eQEgbM?WKQgbW?lQyxz{S`QeQZd|bQt
p?gMPQQt?k?Xbe~}M]g2S)XMPQu&TcgbpvORh?Q
r
Xbp?tORwYSRp?QtO`gg2ORh?QS)W?S`g?PQeO
r2
zg2p?lVSRQeQpvORlV r QO
g2w?OORgung2S`}g2plg2abdeX2lg2Tcp?d
r
edQp?eQUXba2Xbdp4xvX2OORh?QUO`dTcQUu h?QpjO ungeg2llQXba2w?Q
r
Xbp?t
MPS`dQp?t
r
gbMTcdp?QyxYp?X2TcQlV
4
g2deX2pYt
4
W9QZeO`g2S2x?W9g2dpvORQtgbw?ONXMPQu!W?S`g2k?lQT
r
dpGTVXbSRabw?TcQpvOx
r
gbTcQcgbMEu h?deihGzNh?X2tDX2l
r
gjkKQegbTcQcXunX2S`Qcg2MndpDORh?QcTcQXbpvORdTcQ
^4Qp?t?dp?aGXMPw?ll)S`Q|vd
r dgbp+g2MfORh?Q=W?X2W9QSxz7W?S`QZM]QSORgGQBW9g
r
Q=X2p?t+S`Q
r
WKg2pYt+ORgORhYQZdS
eSRdORdeZd
r T r dpO`h?QMPgbSRTgbM9X7W?SRg|Bd
r dgbp?X2lYW9g r Or
eSRdW?OW?XbWKQS
z4h?gbWKQORh?d
r
u dllYQp?hYX2p?eQ
kKgbORh7O`h?QEabgBgvtX2p?tORh?Qnk?X2t4xXbp?t7hYQZlW7MPgbSORh?Qnt?d
r
ew
r`r
dgbp7gbMyO`h?Q
r
Qnd
rRr w?Q
r dp r QTcdp?X2S
0U(Uj¡ fUfjf07j7
¢
h?d
r
t?d
r
ORdp?eO`dg2pkKQO unQQpXS`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblXbp?tXTcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORXbORdg2pYX2l
r
O`X2p?eQ
g2p£kKQldQM
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r
egbp
r
ORdORw?O`Q
r
ORh?Q0eg2S`QgbM)TVt?QM]QZp
r
Q0g2M)O`h?QW?S`dp?edW?lQ0g2M
r
w?k?q
r
O`dORw?ORdg2p¤gbMflgba2deXbllV\Q¥vw?d|XblQZpvO
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r dp'kKQldQMfegbpvORQvO r2
zTcXbdpvORX2dp¤ORh?XbO
ORh?d
r
t?d
r
ORdpYeZO`dg2pjd
r Q rRr
QpvORdXbl{ORgcX2pjw?p?t?QS
r
O`X2p?t?dp?acgbMO`h?Q¦W?S`g2k?lQT§g2Mlg2abdeX2l{gbTcp?dq
r
edQp?eQ
¨
QO dO r
h?gbw?lt?p4©OkKQUTcdvQtjw?Wju dORhjp?QdabhvkKgbw?SRdp?at?d
r
ORdp?eORdgbp
r
xBX2lO`h?g2w?abh
dO TcXV
r
gbTcQORdTcQ
rr
gbw?p?tjelg r
QUORgcORh?QT
ª7«y¬j®]¯ °y®²±³~°y®´±®]¯ ±y´Y° µG¶4·9¸b¹Gº9»R¼¾½y¿NÀK¬Á¯Â¯fÃ9¿vÄ2Åv¸2¼ÆE»R¼¾½y¿0®]¯ °y®²±³~°y®´±ÇÈ¢
h?Q
lX2O`ORQSt?d
r
O`dp?eORdgbp£d
r
TcgbSRQ0abQp?QSRXbl
¨
QO7gbp?Q0TcXVDORh?dp?}GORhYX2OXTQZO`X2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2q
ORdgbp?X2l
r
QTcXbpBO`de r
gbMfk9QZldQZM
r
ORX2O`QZTQpBO
r dr t?Q
r
eSRdW?O`d|2Qyx
r dp?eQjdOd
r
S`QlX2O`d|2QjORgDORh?Q
w?ORORQS`X2p?eQjgbMfkKQldQMfS`QWKgbSRO
r dp¤gbSRt?dp?XbSRV\eg2pv|bQS
r
X2O`dg2p?Xbl eg2pvORQvO
r2
Lfp?t¤ld}2Qu d
r Q
ORh?XbO)XcSRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2l
r
QTcXbpBO`de r dr
p?gbSRTX2ORd|bQyxbdp=W?XbSRO`dew?lX2S kKQeXbw
r
Q¦zEtYQ
r
eS`dkKQ
É dpvORd}v}X{©
rcr
QTcXbpvORde r X r
XGS`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?Xbl
r
QTcX2pvORde r
xXbp?t+Tg2S`QZg|2QS
r dp?eQ=ORh?Q
lX2O`ORQS h?X
r
Xcp?gbSRTcXbORd|bQ¦dpvORQS`W?SRQO`X2ORdgbp
z p£O`h?Q0W?XbWKQS7hYguEQ|bQSxz¦W?w?S`WKgbSROORgt?QMPQp?t£O`h?Q0W?SRdp?edWYlQ0g2M
r
w?k
r
O`dORw?ORdgbp£gbM
lg2abdeX2l{Q¥vw?d|X2lQpvO
r dp=k9QldQMeg2pvO`QZvO r X r
XTQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?Xbl
r
QTcX2pvORde¦W?SRdp?edq
W?lQ L
rfr w?e~hdOfd
r
eZQS`ORXbdp?lV=Xp?gbSRTcXbORd|bQ7W?SRdp?edWYlQvx
r dp?eQ7uEQ7Ê?p?tegbpvORQvO
r
u h?QSRQ
X r eSRdk9QS
r
XbW?W?X2S`QpBO`lVDMPX2dlnORgw
r
QdOX2p?t
r dp?eQORh?QTX2dp\ORhYSRw
r
OgbM ORhYQ0WYX2W9QZSSRQq
TcX2dp r
ORga2d|bQ7XbpX2eeg2w?pvOËPMPg2llgu dp?a0ÌQeX2pYX2ORdÍ©
r
ORh?QgbSRVÎ4g2M
rdO`w?X2O`dg2p
r
u h?QSRQORh?Q
W?SRdpYeZdWYlQd
r
p?gbONXbW?W?ldQt
r V r
O`QZTX2ORdeXbllV md}2Qu d
r
QyxYdONd
r
eg2S`SRQeONORg=ORh?dp?}O`h?X2ONXbp
r r r r r r r`r
ORh?Q¦QW?d
r
ORQTcde r dORw?XbORdgbp=g2MSRQXbl{X2abQpBO
r
xBu h?g
r
Q¦}vp?gu lQt?abQNd
r
k?XbSRQlV0elg r
Qt=M]g2S X2pvV
lg2abdeX2lW?SRdp?edWYlQUu h?X2O
r
gvQ|bQZS
f
w?eih
r
QTcXbpBO`deUMPS`X2TQZungbSR}
r
h?X|bQUkKQQpt?QÊ?p?QtjXbp?t
zNt?d
r
ew
r`r
g2p?QgbM)ORh?QTx{p?X2TQZlV É
w?ey©
r7r V r
O`QT x{dpDX
r
Q¥BwYQZlEORgORh?d
r
W?X2W9QSQpBO`dSRQlVDt?Q|2gbORQt£O`gORh?Q W?S`g2kYlQT gbM lg2abdeX2lng2Tcp?d
r
edQp?eQ
Ë"!#$Íx%!&'$ÍÎ
(
w?ey©
r lg2abde¦d
r
MPS`QQ¦gbMX2pvVW?SRdp?edWYlQ¦gbMelg r
w?S`Q¦u h?XbO
r
gvQ|2QSËPg2p?QUTcXVkKQ
h?X2W?WvVORg
r
XVjO`h?X2ONdONd
r
t?Q
r
eS`dW?ORd|bQdpORh?d
r¦r QZp
r
QyÎRxYk?w?ONdONd
r dpvORQS`Q
r
O`dp?aW?S`QeZd
r
QlV
kKQeX2w
r
QdOfd
rfr
ORdllXbk?lQORgVBdQZltW?SRQt?deORdgbp
r
Ëgbp?QTcXVjkKQh?XbW?WvV=O`g
r
XVjORh?XbOfdOfd
r
p?g2S`TcXbORd|2QUdpjO`h?d
r r Qp
r
QyÎ
z O
r
h?g2w?ltjk9QUQp?g2w?abhjORg
r
w?aba2Q
r
O ORhYX2O O`h?Q¦pYg2S`TcX2O`d|2Q*)
t?Q
r
eS`dW?ORd|bQ7t?d
r
ORdp?eORdgbpg2M]ORQpORQp?t
r
ORg0a2QO
r lg2W?WvV=u h?QpunQUegbTcQ7ORgQ|Xblw?XbORQ7ORh?Q
X2t?Q¥vw?XbeV0gbMX
r
QTX2pvORdeUMPS`X2TcQung2S`}
ª7«y¬¡®²¯ °y®]±³i°y®´±!®]¯±y´K°+¯(®+-,(./µ¹D¿v¶4»Rº10ÀK¬Á¯(¯20¼ ¶4365¼ Ä»R¼ Å'®]¯ °y®²±³~°y®´±Ç
z r w?a2abQ
r
OdpjO`h?QUW?XbWKQSORh?XbO ORh?Q7lX2ORO`QS dtYQZpvO`dÊ?eX2ORdgbpjung2wYltjkKQ7X []SRgbw?a2huEXVBsORg
w?p?t?QS
r
ORXbp?tu h?XbONzTcQX2pGkBVORhYQS`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblqTcQORX2S`QW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdg2pYX2l4t?d
r
ORdp?eq
ORdgbp4xX2lO`h?g2w?abhzÊ?p?tdOEh?QlW?M]w?lYORg7abQOX7Ê?S
r
OabSRX
r
WgbM9dO
)
g7uEQpYQZQt0ORg7kKQfeX2S`QZM]w?l
h?QSRQ
-7 g2S
r
w?S`Q=ORh?QjlQ|2Ql g2Mfgbk{]QeZO`q²S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p
r
g2MfX2p¤Xba2QpvOcd
r
TcQpvORX2lRxXbp?t
XjTcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QpBO`X2ORdgbp?Xbl
r
ORXbORQTcQpvOUd
r
XjW?dQeQg2M)lX2p?abw?Xba2Q
nw?O7ORh?X2O7d
r
XORS`d|BdXbl
SRQTcXbSR}689u h?XbO4ÌfQZeXbp?X2O`dyeX2llr
X¦TcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QpBO`X2ORdgbpd
r
Xbl
r
gNX¦S`QZWYSRQ
r
QpBO`X2ORdgbpdpcORh?Q
Ê?S
r
ONW?lX2eQyx?Xbp?td
r
X2ONÊ?S
r
ONt?d
r
ORdp?eONMPS`g2T ORh?Q
r
ORX2O`QZTQpBONORh?XbONQBW?S`Q
r`r Q r dO É
Qp?eQ
TVGelXbdT dr
t?d99QSRQpvO:8ORh?QSRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2lqTcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2lnt?d
r
ORdpYeZO`dg2p\d
r
X2k9g2w?O k9QldQM;<=4>)dpjQdORh?QSeZX
r Q
z OUd
r
eg2S`SRQeOUORg
r
XVORh?XbOUXjS`QW?SRQ
r
QpBO`X2O`dg2p?XblORh?Qg2S`VgbMnkKQldQMnM]gveZw
rRr Q r
gbpDORh?Q
t?Q
r
eS`dW?ORdgbp=g2MORh?Q¦eg2pvORQpvO)gbMkKQldQMgbMXbp=X2abQpBO2xbdp?t?QWKQp?tYX2pvORlV0g2MORh?Q¦kKQldQM
r
XbSRQ
X r eSRdk9Qt
)
w?e~h0X7ORh?Qg2S`Vh?X
r
ORg7QBWYlX2dp0h?gu'k9QZldQZM{eg2pvO`QZpvO
r
X2S`Qdp?t?d|vdt?w?XbORQtXbp?t
W?SRgveQ
r`r Qt
27
gbSXbll)ORh?X2O2xXlgba2deXblnO`h?Qg2S`VDXblg2pYaORh?Q
r
Q=ldp?Q
r
TXVDW9QSRM]QZeO`lVDunQll
kKQ7XORh?QgbSRV=g2MkKQldQM
r
QpBO`Qp?eQ
r
g2MORh?Q7MPgbSRT@?BA
¢ h?QS`QUXbSRQ7O uEg0g2kPQeORdgbp
r
h?QSRQyx
dp r
W?dSRQtjkvV0¥vw?Q
r
ORdgbp
r
ORhYX2O
g2deUX
r
}bQZtjTcQC8
D É QZS`Qfeg2TcQ
r
ORh?QfÊ?S
r
OEg2kPQeO`dg2pE8FGHJI>KGHELGNMPOH RQKGLS IR<=4T
>L>HNU M2VF% LGWX4U>WILHYHZ[UOWH>NUSN\^];>W
HT_>H U O`%UH4H aGNMBIS I>GHZC O`SVP%T
UH4H bKQKGHU>GcVPHdeGHfOHUU>UHB> \
V'Xbp
r
unQSd
r
ORh?XbOunQ
r
h?gbw?lt&eX2S`QMPw?llV'TcXb}2QQvW?ldedOu h?X2O=ORh?Qp?g2O`dg2p&gbM
>N%UHTcQX2p
r dpcO`h?d
r
eZX
r Q ¢ h?QSRQ d
r
XUuEQXb}X2p?tctYQZM]X2w?lO
r
QZp
r
Q gbMKORhYQ p?g2ORdgbpcgbM
>N%UHXbeeg2S`t?dp?a=O`g=u h?deihGX2pvVORh?Qg2S`VdpGu h?de~hGVbg2wGÊ?p?tGgbk{]QeZO`q
r
ORXbORQTcQpvO
r
g2MEORh?QcMPgbSRT28R?WgAExYu h?QS`Qh)t?Qp?gbORQ
r
XbpXba2QpvO¦X2p?t-? SRQMPQS
r
ORg=O`h?Q}vp?gu lQt?abQgbM
ORh?d
r
X2abQpBO2xBp?QeQ
r`r
X2S`dlVdTcW?ldQ r
ORh?QUQBd
r
O`QZpYeZQUgbMX2pjgbw?O
rdt?QUTcgvt?QllQSxBp?XbTcQlVORh?Q
ORh?QgbSRd
r
Ou h?gw
r Q r
ORh?QTQZO`X2lXbp?a2wYX2abQ
¢ h?d
r dr O`h?Q
r
Qp
r
Qdp+u h?de~h
7
Xba2dpji Xbldd
u SRdO`Q[8
¢
hvw
r
ORh?QfXba2QpvO
r
eg2w?ltkKQft?Q
r
eSRdk9Qt0X
r lgba2deZXbllVcg2Tp?d
r
eZdQZpvO
¢ h?d
r
t?gvQ
r
p?g2OnQ
r
W9QZedXbllVcORSRgbw?k?lQfw
r dp0ORh?Qfeg2pvO`QZvOEgbM{Tw?lORdqXba2QpvO rV r
O`QZT
r x
r dp?eQcdpGORh?XbO¦eg2pvORQvO¦unQc|BdQugbw?S¦p?gbORdgbpgbME}vp?gu lQt?abQcX
r
X4N
¢
h?XbO d
r
xB}vp?gu lQt?abQ¦d
r
>NS<OkvV0ORhYQ
r V r O`QZT§t?Q
r da2pYQZSORgcORh?QUX2abQpBO
r
ËF!k$86&'lm9Î
r r r r r r
w?ORORQS`SRXbp?eQcg2MnkKQldQM
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r
kvVSRQWKgbSRO`QS
r dpGgbSRt?dpYX2S`VtYd
r
egbw?S
r Q r dORw?XbORdgbp r
L
ORh?QgbSRV0gbMkKQldQM
r
QZpvO`QZpYeZQ
r
eZXbpjkKQ¦X
r
eSRdW?ORdg2p?Xbl{dpjORh?QUuEQXb}
r
Qp
r
QUu dORh?gbw?O X2dTcdp?a
X2O¦ORh?Qt?Q
r
eSRdW?O`dg2pgbMX
r
eZS`dW?ORdgbp
r dpORhYQ
r
O`SRgbp?a
r
Qp
r
QC8
r
w?eihX=ORh?Qg2S`Vd
r ld}2QlVORg
kKQ XUSRQW?S`Q
r
QZpvO`X2ORdgbp?Xbl?ORh?QgbSRVyxXbp?tcd
r
eQSRO`X2dp?lVp?gbOXUTcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QZpvO`X2ORdgbp?Xbl?ORh?QgbSRV
g2pv|2QS
r
QlVvxbX2pvVTcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORXbORdg2p?Xbl9ORh?QgbSRVg2Mk9QldQM
r
ORX2O`QZTQpBO
r dr X r
eSRdW?O`dg2p?Xbl
dpjkKg2O`h
r
Qp
r Q r2
D É
QZS`Q7eg2TcQ
r
ORh?Q
r
QZegbp?tg2k]QZeO`dg2pE8eM:ZB> V@GH ];UUdd
GNMcIeST
UIF4>=FF4 GHNMfS>HZ[ UKUGHZ4GHTHNUON\
Z[JJ>2)NMLQK SfGHJZ[>=GccGHNMLUeVPPQK T<ZCUOeI<H GH Z[NT
4HPIa%)O 2GHPVP>eI HO4HNML>N%UH4eGHBcGHNML d
><H eQKGHP MLUeZ H4OccSPGHJNI GP>NS M:\
¢ h?d
r
g2kPQeORdgbp£d
r
Tg2S`Q
r
QSRdgbw
r
xX2p?t\d
r
X2eO`w?X2llVGO ungbMPg2ltE8UÊ?S
r
O2xORh?Q0egbpvORSRX
r O
kKQO unQQZp É dpBO`d}B}X9©
r
X2p?t gbpBO`X2abw?Qy©
r
S`Q
r
W9QeZO`d|2QGORh?QgbSRdQ r
gbM7kKQldQM
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r dr
k?SRgbw?a2hvOMPgbSRunX2S`t\ORgQp?h?X2pYeZQ=ORh?Qt?d
r
ORdp?eORdg2p\k9QO uEQQp\XSRQW?S`Q
r
QZpvORXbORdgbp?X2l)X2p?t\X
TcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2l
r
ORX2p?eQ
z OEd
r
ORS`w?QfO`h?X2O É dpvO`d}B}X9©
r
X2p?tg2pvO`X2abw?Qy©
r
ORh?QgbSRdQ r
kKgbORh0TcXb}2QNeZlXbdT r
XbkKgbw?OEk9QZldQZMS`QZW9g2S`O
r X r unQllKX
r
X2k9g2w?OnORh?QfW
r
Vveih?g2lgba2VcgbM{k9QldQM
)w?OORh?d
r0r
h?gbw?lt?p4©OX9KQeOORhYQjunQllqMPg2w?pYt?Qt?p?Q
rRr
g2M¦ORh?Qt?d
r
ORdp?eORdgbp
z OS`QZTX2dp r
eg2S`SRQeO¦dpGTV|vdQu!O`g=t?d
r
ORdp?abw?d
r
hGkKQO unQQpGX=ORh?QgbSRVORhYX2O¦M]gBew
r`r Q r
gbpGu h?XbO¦ORh?Q
X r
eSRdk9QSUQp?t?g2S
r Q r dpGXjk9QldQMES`QWKgbSROx9Xbp?tGXjO`h?Qg2S`Vu h?g
r
QX2dTÈd
r
ORgjXbeeZgbw?pvOUMPg2S
ORh?Q0unXVDkKQldQM eg2pvORQpvO
r
XbSRQdp?t?d|vdt?w?XbORQt£Xbp?t\W?SRgveQ
r`r
Qt\dp?t?QWKQp?t?XbpvORlVGgbM h?gu
X2O`ORSRdk?wYORdg2p
r
ORh?QS`Qg2MXbSRQUTcX2t?QUdpjQ|2QS`VBtYXV0t?d
r
egbw?S
r Q
gux2dOnd
r dp?t?QQtXS`QX2l9d r`r
w?Qfu h?QO`h?QSnunQfO`X2}bQfdpvO`gX2eegbw?pvOnORh?QNkKQldQMungbSRlt r
g2M{O`h?QXba2QpvO
r
u h?Qp0TcX2}vdp?aX7kKQldQM{XbORORS`dk?w?ORdgbp
L r
QvW?lX2dp?Qt0dp0ORh?QfW?XbWKQS2x
É dp?q
ORd}v}X{©
r
O`h?Qg2S`V
r
O`SRXbda2hvORM]g2S`uEXbSRtYlVX2eeg2w?pvO
r
M]g2SORh?QUM]X2eO O`h?X2O
r
gbTcQgbp?QUeX2pjk9QldQ|2Q
ORh?XbO É Q r W9QSRw
r dr X r
O`X2S0u h?dlQt?d
r
kKQldQ|vdp?a£ORh?XbO0^h?g
r
WYh?g2S`w
r d r2
¢
h?d
r
}BdpYt'gbM
QBWYlX2p?XbORdgbpTcXV=kKQ7QvORQp?t?QtORg0X2eegbw?pvOMPgbSM]X2dlw?S`Q
r
gbM
r
w?k
r
ORdO`w?ORdgbpg2M
r
Vvp?gbpvVBq
Tcg2w
r
W?SRQt?deXbORQ
r dpkKQldQMSRQW9g2S`O
r
x?g2SNQ|bQplgba2deXbllVjQ¥vw?d|XblQpBO
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r
xYdMgbp?Q
dpvORSRgvt?w?eQ
r
ORh?QTcXbe~h?dp?QSRVg2M)WKg
rRr
dk?lQung2S`lt r dpDu h?de~h
r
ORXbp?t?XbSRtDlgba2deXblQ¥BwYd|X2q
lQp?eQ
r
k?S`QX2}jt?gu)p Ër
g2qeX2llQt^VF4S ;4HUS LQaN OH
z X2abSRQQORh?XbOfORhYd
r
unXV
g2MX2eegbw?pvORdp?aMPgbSNt?d
r
eSRQW?Xbp?edQ r
g2Mdt?QpvORdÊ?eXbORdg2pg2pORh?QWYX2S`OfgbMXbpXba2QpvONd
r
%T
=4UH U M7W?lXbw
r
dk?lQ¦Xbp?tjW?SRgbk?X2kYlV0MPwYp?t?X2TcQpvORXbl
h?QORh?QSORh?d
r
abd|2Q
r w r
Xa2Qp?QS`X2lnW?SRdp?edW?lQeg2p?eQSRpYdp?aO`h?Q0unXVGdp£u h?deih£Xbp
X r eSRdk9QSNd
r ld}bQlVjORgTcXb}2Q
r
w?k
r
ORdORw?O`dg2p
r
g2pORh?Qk?X
r dr
gbMXkKQldQMX2O`ORSRdkYw?ORdgbpd
r X
t?d
r
ORdp?eOf¥vw?Q
r
ORdg2p
V=elXbdT dpORh?QW?XbWKQSfd
r
Tcg2S`QTcgvt?Q
r
OfXbp?teg2p?eQS`p
rfr WKQedÊ?q
eX2llV7ORh?Q)W?SRgbk?lQT!g2MYXbeeg2w?pvORdp?a¦MPg2S
r
w?k
r
O`dORw?ORdgbpg2Ma 4U>H U M Z[)H
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r2
z OUTcXVkKQORh?XbOUORh?Q
rdORw?XbORdg2pDd
r dpDMPXbeOUTcg2S`QeZgbTcW?lQORh?XbpDÌQZeXbp?XbORdelX2dT r dp
ORh?Q eX
r
Q)gbMKW?S`g2W9QSp?X2TQ
r
g2S
r
Vvp?gbpvVBTg2w
r
W?SRQt?deXbORQ
r2
)w?OX
r
SRQabX2S`t
r
TcQS`Q)lgba2deZXbl
Q¥BwYd|X2lQp?eQyxzUORQp?t\ORgORh?dpY}Gld}2QÌQeX2p?XbORdnORh?X2O
r
w?k
r
ORdO`w?ORdgbp£d
r %NN)XegbSRq
SRQeO
r
QTcXbpvORdefW?S`dp?edW?lQ r gMPXbSEX
r
g2pYlVcORh?QfW9QS
r
WKQeORd|bQfg2MORh?QNX
r
eSRdk9QSEd
r dpB|bg2l|bQt
¢ g£¥vw?g2O`QMPS`g2T Xbp'QvX2TW?lQgbM É QdT i¦S`X2O`ZQS0dpB|bg2l|vdp?a£lgba2deZXbllV+Q¥vw?d|XblQpvO
QT7k9Qt?t?Qt
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r
xBzEk9QldQ|2QUORh?XbO)X
r
W9QX2}bQS u h?g
r
XV
r 8
Ë Ï
ÎXbSRVkKQldQ|2Q
r
ORh?XbO dMÌg2k?dpjegbTcWKQORQ
r
xBh?Q¦u dllu dp
dr
QpBO`dORlQtjORg
r
XV68
r r r r r
ORh?dp?acO`h?X2O Ìgbk?dpjuEgbp4©O t?g
XblORh?gbw?a2h zeg2p
r dt?QS0ORh?XbOdp'ORh?d
r
eX
r
QORh?Q
r
Qeg2p?t
r
O`X2O`QZTQZpvO0uEgbw?lt p?g2O0kKQ
w?ORORQS`SRQtkKQeXbw
r
QNdOnd
r lQ r`r
Qegbp?g2TcdeZXbl9ORh?Xbp0O`h?QfÊ?S
r
OEdpgbSRt?QSnO`geg2pv|2QVORh?Q
r
XbTcQ
dp?MPgbSRTcXbORdgbp
zEk9QldQ|2Q¦MPw?S`ORh?QS ORh?XbO)ORgcTcX2}bQ¦ORh?d
r
ORS`X2p
r dORdgbp4xbgbp?Q¦p?QQt?p4©O)ORXb}2Q¦dpvO`gXbeZegbw?pvO
ORh?Q7unXV=X2S`V=uEgbw?ltX
r`r
QpvOORg0ORh?Q7QTkKQt?t?Qt
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r
pYg2SfeZXbSRQ7u h?QO`h?QSORh?Q
r Q
uEgbw?ltDh?X|2QORh?Q
r
XbTcQcTcQXbp?dp?ajMPgbSUh?QS
gjzfO`QZpYtGORgjXba2S`QQcu dORhDÌQeX2pYX2ORdORh?XbO
SRQlw?eORXbp?eQ)ORgNTcXb}2Q)ORh?Q)ORS`X2p
r dO`dg2ph?QS`QneXbpgveew?S4gbp?lV7dMYORh?Q
r
WKQXb}2QSx(u h?Qpw?O`ORQSRq
dp?a7ORh?QÊ?S
rO r
QpBO`Qp?eQyxg|2QS`ORlV r w?a2abQ
rO r
ORh?XbOXbSRVTcXVkKQ
r
Qp
r dORd|bQORg
r
gbTcQORh?dp?a
ld}2Q7O`h?Q7MPg2S`TgbM4ORh?Q7ung2S`t
r w r
QZt'ËX-OH¦|
r
OOHU>tYd
r
O`dp?eORdgbpd
r
Xbl
r
gXbO
r
ORXb}2Q
h?QSRQyxeZM
IKÎ
z p£ORh?d
rr
dORw?X2O`dg2p4xSRQ
r
g2S`O7ORgX2lORQS`p?XbORd|2Q0WKg
r`r
dkYlQungbSRlt
rr QS`|2Q
r
X r
XcunXV0gbMSRQW?S`Q
r
QZpvO`dp?acu h?X2O2©
r
abg2dp?ag2pjdpjXbSRV©
r
h?QXbt4xBX2p?tjO`h?d
r dr eg2p
r dr ORQpvO
u dORh¤u h?X2OczORhYQZp¤O`X2}bQ=ORgDkKQjXGSRQW?S`Q
r
QpBO`X2ORdgbp?Xbl)W9QS
r
WKQeORd|bQjg2p¤ORh?Q
r
QTcX2pvORde r
g2Mk9QZldQZM
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r2
z ONd
r
p?gbOfgbkv|vdg2w
r
u)hYQZO`h?QSNORh?d
r
WYSRg|vdt?Q
r w r u dORhX
r
QTcXbpvORde
W?SRdpYeZdWYlQfdpORh?QNÊ?S
r
OnW?lXbeQË
r
w?eih0X
r
8e~h?Qei}cu h?QORh?QSnO`h?Q
r
QpvORQp?eQfd
r
ORS`w?QfdpX2ll9gbM
ORh?QUkKQldQMPqung2S`lt r
gbMORh?QUX2abQpBO k9QMPgbSRQUTcX2}vdp?acO`h?Q
r
w?k
r
ORdO`w?ORdgbp4©Î
ª7«y¬£®²¯¾°y®²±³~°?®´±\®²¯7±y´Y°7µ+®²¯ °y®]±³i°y®´±K¬v°7¬v¬±¿C0¼ ¿ 2ĺ9Ķ4·9¶i½v¿v¸º10Ã9¼¾Ä
Æ·9ļ »R¼¾·9¶4Ä!»R·¦º9¸ZÃ_º9Åy»R¼¾·9¶ ÀK¬Á¯(¯j0P¼ ¶4365¼ Ä»R¼ Å¿[0¼ ¿ 2ÄÇ z p'h?d
r
tYd
r
ew
r`r dg2p'gbM
ORh?Qlgba2deXbl4g2TcpYd
r
edQp?eQW?S`g2k?lQZTGx
w?k?w?e
r Ë Ï m'm
Ï
xK!
Ï
$ÍÎhYX
r
QTcW?h?X
r dQtX=t?d
r
ORdp?eq
ORdgbpjk9QO uEQQp qkKQldQM
r
X2pYtjmqkKQldQM
ra q²k9QldQM
r
g2Sp?gbSRTX2ldQtkKQldQM
r
X2S`Q7kKQldQM
r
ld}2QlV0ORgckKQ¦X
r
eZS`dkKQt=u dO`h=SRQ
r
WKQeO ORgO`h?Q¦p?g2p?q |bQZS`k?Xbl{kKQh?X|vdgbS)gbMXbp=X2abQpBO2xbu h?dlQ
mq²k9QldQM
r
g2SUldp?a2w?d
r
ORde r kKQldQM
r
XbSRQkKQldQM
r X r
eS`dkKQtDORgORh?QX2abQpvO\[PgbpDa2S`g2w?p?t
r
gbM
h?d
r
W?wYk?lde¦X
r`r QS`ORdgbp
rs
z¦X2abSRQQu dO`hDORhYQdTcWKgbSRO`X2p?eQ0g2M)ORh?QtYd
r
O`dp?eORdgbp4x{V2QO7XTcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?Xbl
ORh?QgbSRV¦g2Myk9QldQM
r
ORX2O`QZTQpBO
r
Tw
r
OQ¥vw?X2llV¦X2eegbw?pvOMPgbSdp?MPQS`Qp?eQ
r
egbp?eQZS`p?dp?afkKQldQM
r
ORh?XbOEXbSRQfX
r
eSRdk9QZtg2pORh?Qfk?X
r dr
g2Mg|bQSROnkKQh?X|vdgbSEXbp?tkKQldQM
r
O`h?X2OnX2S`QfX
r
eS`dkKQt0gbp
ORh?QUk?X
r dr
gbMW?w?k?ldeUX
rRr QSRO`dg2p
r2
¯ °y«y¬+®²¯¾°?®]±³i°y®´±¤¯ ´a+0¬+¯ ´ÁÍ°´µY¬±y¬Á͵E.²®bµ?°y®´±´°y«y¬ Ã9¿¸¿0ÀK¬Á¯(¯Ã9¿
Ã9¼¾Åv»R·'®]¯ °y®²±³~°y®´± ¢ hYd
rnr w?aba2Q
r
ORdgbpuEX
r
TX2t?QNdpeg2pv|bQS
r
X2O`dg2pkvV
9
W9QeORg2S
¢
h?Q MPXbeOORh?X2Ogveew?SRS`Qp?eQ
r
g2M9W?S`g2WKQSp?XbTcQ
r
gbw?O
r dt?Q ORhYQ
r
eZgbWKQg2M9XUkKQldQM9g2W9QSRXbORg2S
X2S`QnMPS`QQlV r wYk
r
O`dORw?ORXbk?lQnTcXVUkKQnabQp?QSRXbldQtORgNMPw?ll
r
QZpvO`QZpYeZQ
r2
¢
h?Qp4x(XfO`SRXbp
r
lX2ORdgbp
g2MË
Ï
ÎX2k9g|bQ¦egbw?ltjkKQC8
ËU&9Î7oM)O`h?QW?S`g2W9g
r dORdgbp£ORh?X2O7dM)Ìgbk?dp£eg2TcW9QORQ
r
x{h?Qu dllEu dp4x{XbSRVGkKQldQ|2Q
r
ORh?XbO dO h?g2lt
r2
¢
h?QW?SRgbWKg
r dORdg2p ORh?XbO0dM¦Ìg2k?dp'egbTcWKQORQ
r
xh?Qu dllu dpxd
r
O`h?Q
r
X2TcQX
r
ORh?Q
W?SRgbWKg
r dORdg2pjQvW?S`Q r`r
QtjkBVORh?QUQTkKQt?t?Qt
r
O`X2O`QZTQZpvO dp+Ë"#bÎ
¢
h?QS`QMPg2S`QUdO d
r
Q¥vw?d|XblQpBO O`g
r
XV8
ËUk9ÎUoEMnO`h?QW?SRgbWKg
r dO`dg2pDO`h?X2O7X2pvV2gbp?Qu h?gt?gvQ
r
p?gbOUegbTcWKQORQgbSUlg r Q r u dllt?g
r
gbTcQORh?dpYacORh?XbO Ìg2k?dpjung2p4©O tYg9xBX2S`V0k9QldQ|2Q
r
O`h?X2O dO h?gblt
r2
u h?deihjTcXVkKQUXceg2S`SRQeO W?X2S`X2WYh?SRX
r
QUgbMË"#2Î
r r r
VPH%H
r
h?gbw?ltSRXbORh?QSfkKQ7eX
r
h?Qtgbw?OX
r
XabQZpvw?dpYQ
r
QTcXbpvORde7X2Tk?dq
a2w?dO V0gbMk9QZldQZM
r
QZpvO`QZpYeZQ
r2
L VP%=4UH4H %OHU 0egbw?lt=ORh?Qp=k9Q¦t?QÊ?p?Qt
X r X [PabQp?QSRXbldQtjOHP¦SRQX2tYdp?a2scgbMkKQldQM
r
ORXbORQTcQpvO
r2
¢
h?QS`Q)d
r
X¦eg2S`SRQeOdpvORw?dORdgbpk9Qh?dp?tcORh?d
rr w?aba2Q
r
ORdgbpE89dO r w?aba2Q
rO r
O`g¦X2p?XblVvQ)kKQq
ldQM
r
ORXbORQTcQpvO
r
gbMKO`h?Q MPgbSRT k9QldQ|2Q
r
ORh?XbOaAE©(X
r
QBWYSRQ
r`r dpYa¦X
r
WKQedÊ?eËPSRQW?S`Q
r
Qp?q
ORXbORdg2p?XblÍÎ4kKQldQMSRQlXbORdgbpk9QZO unQQpXbpXba2QpvOfX2p?tX0W?SRgbWKg
rdORdgbp
¢ h?d
r
eg2S`SRQ
r
W9g2p?t
r
ORgcORhYQ¦S`QX2t?dp?acXbt?|bgBeXbORQtjkvV0gbpBO`X2abw?Q¦h?dT
r
QlM
)V¦egbpBO`SRX
r
OORgfO`h?QEORh?Q
r dr gbM
r
QTcXbpvORdeEXbTk?da2w?dO VvxTV¦elXbdT¡dp7ORh?QnW?X2W9QSd
r
ORh?XbO
ORh?Qt?d
r
O`dp?eORdg2p0d
r
VPGOH 4U>H ydpORhYQÊ?S
r
OEW?lX2eQ
z r
W9QZXb}Tcg
r
ORlVg2M{S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2q
ORdgbp?X2lE|2QS
r w r
TcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblJN4>U)`x VPH4U>`x GHNU`x%N>
g2S %S VP
zX2l
r g r
WKQXb}jgbMS`QW?SRQ
r
QpBO`X2O`dg2p?Xbl ><H²x?u h?QpzunX2pvONORgegbpvORSRX
r O
u h?X2OfO`h?QX
r
eSRdk9QSfQp?t?gbS
r Q r
x?X2pYtu h?X2OfO`h?Q7X
r
eSRdk9QZQd
r
TcQX2pvOfO`g0Qp?t?gbS
r Q z pTV
t?d
r
ew
rRr
dgbpcgbM9|vd
r
w?X2lYX
r
eS`dW?ORdgbp
r
xz4a2g
r
gUM]X2SX
r
O`g
r
W9QX2}g2M9X7TcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?Xbl
|2QS
r w r
X=SRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2l OHU gbSNdpvO`QZS`W?S`QZO`X2O`dg2pgbM|vd
r dg2p
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r2
¢
h?d
r dr
W?SRgbk?X2kYlVDXbp+w?p?h?XbW?WvVDQvORQp
r dgbp4xkKQeX2w
r
Q=z7t?gGp?g2OTQZXbp+ORg
r
XVDO`h?X2OO`h?Q
r
Qp?q
ORQp?eQ
r
ORh?QT
r
Ql|bQ
r
X2S`Q
r
QTcXbpBO`deX2llV=X2Tk?dabw?g2w
r
xvk?w?OX2abX2dpjORhYX2OORh?QV=X2S`Q
r
w?kPQeO
ORgct?d99QSRQpvO
r
QZTX2pvORdeUX2W?WYSRgbX2eih?Q
r
)Q
r dt?Q
r
zX2T p?gbO
r
wYSRQnu h?QORh?QSunQE}bQQZWabgvgBtORS`X2ei}¦gbM?ORh?Q
r
VBpvO`X2eORdent?d
r
ORdp?eORdgbp
kKQO unQQZp OXbp?tOHO>£dMuEQGO`X2l} g2Ma2Qp?QS`X2ldQtOH
z r
p?g2OjORh?Q
r
g2q
eX2llQta2Qp?QS`X2ldQtOHSRQXbt?dp?a¤h?QSRQDPw
r
OjX+unXV gbMt?Q
r
eS`dk?dp?a¤ORh?Q
r
QTcXbpvORde
dpvORQSRW?S`QORXbORdg2p\uEQ0abd|2Q0dp£ORhYQTQORX2lXbp?a2wYX2abQgbM)XW?lXbdp O*O>=S`QX2t?dp?ag2M ORh?Q
r
O`X2O`QZTQZpvOjdp ORh?QGgbk{]QeORq²lX2p?abw?X2abQ
g2p
r dt?QSjORh?Q USRXbORQSRqÉ QdT QvX2TW?lQ L
p?X2O`w?SRXblunXVORgeZgbpvORQ
r
OUORh?QQ¥vw?d|X2lQp?eQkKQO unQQp ËÏ
ÎEXbp?t Ë"#bÎEXbkKg|bQd
r
ORgjXbSRabw?Q
ORh?XbO\Ë
Ï
ÎUXbp?t Ë"#bÎUdp?t?QQt&hYX|2QGX2Tk?dabw?g2w
r
SRQXbt?dp?a
r
p?t?QS=X
r
ORXbp?t?X2S`tO
SRQXbt?dp?a9xË
Ï
ÎkKQegbTcQ
r 8
Ë2Î oEMÌg2k?dp4xBXbSRVkKQldQ|bQ
r
ORh?XbO dMh?Q¦egbTcWKQO`Q
r
xBh?QUu dll{u dp
Xbp?t+Ë"#2Îk9Qeg2TcQ
r 8
Ë 9ÎnoMX2pvVbg2p?QNu h?gQZdORh?QSnt?gvQ
r
p?g2Oneg2TcW9QORQfgbSnlg r Q r
x2XbSRVkKQldQ|2Q
r
O`h?QVcu dll
t?g
r
g2TcQO`h?dp?acÌgbk?dpjuEgbp4©O t?g
z O=d
r
elQXbSORhYX2Ow?pYt?QSORhYQ
r
QS`QZXbt?dp?a
r
x)X\t?d99QSRQpvO£ËS`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORXbORdg2p?XblÍΦk9QldQM
eg2pvORQpvOfd
r X r
eS`dkKQtORg0X2S`V=dpQX2eiheX
r Q
7
lQX2S`lVyxyORh?d
r dr
pYg2OfORh?Q
r
XbTcQ7S`QX2t?dp?a
X r
O`h?QUg2p?Q7eg2S`SRQ
r
WKgbp?t?dp?aORgGË&{ÎXbp?t+Ëk{Î
znelXbdT§O`h?X2OORh?QUgbp?QUeg2S`SRQ
r
W9g2p?t?dp?aORg
kKgbORh+Ë&9ÎXbp?t+Ëk{Îd
r
Pw
r
O X
r
ORXbp?t?XbSRtYOPOHU>7S`QX2t?dp?a
( 0§ ¦f 9
g
r
O SRQXbt?QS
r
u dllW?SRgbk?X2kYlV0h?X|bQ¦h?X2tjORh?QUMPQQldp?acORh?XbO)O`h?Q
r
QeORdg2pjg2MORh?QUg2S`da2dp?Xbl
W?X2W9QSUu hYQZS`QzNtYd
r
ew
r`r t?d
r
ORS`dk?w?ORdgbpDgbM)}Bp?gu lQt?a2QgbWKQS`X2ORgbS
r
g|2QS7eg2p?]w?p?eORdgbpDd
r
ORh?QunQZXb}jW?X2S`Ofg2MT7VjXbSRabw?TcQpvO
z Xba2S`QQ7O`h?X2ONORh?QX2S`a2w?TcQpvOfd
r
p?gbOfX
r
elQX2SNX
r dO
r
hYg2w?ltkKQyx2XblORh?gbw?a2hzM]QZQl9dp?eldp?QtORgh?g2lt0gbp0ORgTVeZgbp?elw r dg2p
r
É QSRQfXbSRQNXMPQu
r
W9QedÊ?e¦gbkPQeORdgbp
r
ORg
r
O`X2S`O u)dORhj8
Ï ¢ h?QNW?X2S`X2llQZl9k9QO uEQQp}vp?gu dp?aX2p?t
r
QQdp?ad
r
W?w?ldp?aW8M]SRgbT ORh?QNSRQW?S`Q
r
Qp?q
ORXbORdg2p?Xbl9WKQS
r
W9QeORd|2QNORXb}2QpkvV
SRQO
r
}bQyx
r
QQZdpYad
r
XORSRXbp
r
W?X2S`QpvOnX2ORO`dORw?t?Qyx2u h?QS`QX
r
r r r r
}vp?gu lQt?a2Q7g2Sk9QZldQZM4egbpBO`QpBO
r
xvdO r QZQT
r
ORh?XbO k9QldQMd
r
p?g2OXORS`X2p
r
W?XbSRQpvO XbORORdORw?t?Q
¢
h?QSRQMPgbSRQyxBh?gueg2w?lt
r
w?eihjXcW?X2S`X2llQlkKQUdllw?Tcdp?X2ORdpYa
# ¢ h?Q
r
g2qeX2llQt\TcQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORXbORdg2pYX2lEXbp?XblV r dr
z¦abd|bQ0g2M
r
QQZdp?a
r
ORXbORQTcQpvO
r
dpvORQSRW?S`QO
r [r QQ
r
X2pLNsUX
r [r QQ
r
XbpL X r
XbpLfs%8(dpvORwYdORd|2QlVyxORh?d
r dr
p?gbOXUORS`X2p
r
W?XbSRq
QpBOS`QZXbt?dp?a{xBXbp?tjVbQO znelXbdT§dpORh?QUWYX2WKQSORhYX2Ow?p?dMPgbSRT
r
wYk
r
O`dORw?ORdg2pjgbM4lg2abdeX2llV
Q¥BwYd|X2lQpvONW?S`QZtYdeX2ORQ
r dr
XbeZeQW?O`X2k?lQ ¢ h?d
r¦r QQT
r
ORgkKQa=ORh?Q¥vw?Q
r
ORdgbpkKQeX2w
r
QdO
TcXVk9QcORh?XbOUORg
r
QQX2pDL_X
r
X2pDL_d
r
p?g2OUORh?Q
r
XbTcQcX
r
ORg
r
QQcX2pDLf!X
r
X2pDLfx
Q|2QpGO`h?g2w?abhGL X2p?tDLf!t?gjQBW?S`Q
r`r ORh?Q
r
X2TcQW?SRgbWKQSRO Vyx
r
gjlgbp?ajX
r
L_Xbp?tG!t?g
QBWYSRQ
r`r t?d
r
ORdp?eO W?S`g2W9QSRORdQ
r2
&
z O=TcXV'k9QO`h?X2O=t?d
r
ORS`dk?w?ORdg2p g2M
r
QQdp?a+g|bQS=eg2p?]w?p?eORdgbp&d
r
p?gbOQ|bQp&X
eg2S`SRQeOS`QZWYSRQ
r
QpBO`X2ORdg2p?Xbl?W?SRdp?edW?lQËX
r
w?a2abQ
r
O`dg2pcTcXbt?Q ORg¦TcQ kvV
¢ dlldX2T
r
gbpcdp
eg2pv|2QS
r
X2ORdgbp4Î"8{MPgbSdp r
ORXbp?eQ)zTcXV
r
gbh?pcX2p?tcXbSRVX2p?t
w r
Xbpceg2Tcdp?aUu dORh?gbw?O
r
QQdp?ajQdO`h?QS
gbh?pDeZgbTcdp?ajgbSUX2S`VegbTcdp?ajg2S
w r
XbpGegbTcdp?a
¢ h?d
r dr WKQS`h?X2W
r
u h?X2OEz4h?X2tdp0Tcdp?tdpTVt?d
r
ew
r`r
dgbpg2M U
L r dlldXbT
r
g2pW9g2dpvORQtgbw?OORg
TcQyxbO`h?d
r dr eZlg r
Q¦ORgd
rRr w?Q
r dpjORh?Q
r
QTcX2pvORde r
g2MW?lw?S`X2l
r
MPgbS
r
O`X2ORQTcQpvO
r ld}2QC8[
gbh?p
X2p?tXbSRVcldMPORQtORh?QfWYdX2p?g{x2V2QOnp?QdORh?QSnt?dt
g2h?pldMPOnO`h?QfW?dXbp?g9x2p?gbSnt?dtX2S`VcldM]O
ORh?QUW?dX2p?gbs
zNu dllp?g2OUXbORORQTW?OUORgjt?QXblu dO`hDORh?Q
r
Qcgbk{]QeORdg2p
r
h?QSRQXbp?tDzflQX|bQcO`h?QTÈMPg2S
t?d
r
ew
rRr dgbp
z r
h?Xbllt?QXblu dORhDXjTg2S`QcM]w?p?t?XbTcQpBO`X2lgbkPQeORdg2p£ORh?X2O7uEX
r
TcX2t?QORg
TcQkBV
Y
WKQeORgbS:8 =(ZCFZ H4eGHEGHe4ZCVP44IHV )U I<HU FHS G
GH%N> LU 4HaL>HN>aVP=4UH 'NU>% \G=4bEOH
QKPGH)Pc% MLcGF%Z PO>=NUSOcU2>\
z¦S`QZeXbllEORh?XbO7ORh?Q0W?w?lQ0d
r
O`h?Q0MPX2eO7O`h?X2OORh?Q0eg2Tk?dp?XbORdgbpDgbM)W?S`dp?edW?lQDËÌUÎ
X2p?t+Ë
z ¢
ÎQpBO`X2dlr elg r
w?S`Q¦gbM}BpYgu lQt?a2QUw?p?t?QS lgba2deXbl{egbp
r
Q¥BwYQZpYeZQ
eih?QTcXbORdeX2llV68MPSRgbTS`w?lQcË
z ¢
Î"8'? A
?BAf?¦xXbp?tGËP̦Î<8:A
?BA ?¦xBunQ¦abQO ORh?QUMPg2llgu dp?act?QSRd|2QtjSRw?lQ=Ë
m Î"8
A !#"_?BA
?
LNeZegbSRt?dpYaORg
4
WKQeORgbS2x?ORh?QORh?Q
r dr
t?QMPQp?t?QtdpTVjW?XbWKQSNd
r
p?g2ONX
r
S`X2t?deZXbl
X r dO g2w?abhvO ORgckKQ
z pjW?X2S`ORdew?lXbSxBznu SRdORQC8
ORh?QW?SRdp?edW?lQg2Mnelg r
w?S`QcgbME}vp?gu lQZtYa2QcwYp?t?QSUlg2abdeX2leZgbp
r
Q¥vw?Qp?eQ
dr dS`SRQXbldr
O`de QKGG=*QK24= fj%H R*H
VP=4UH H%N4>=% =ËW
Ï
#2Î
)w?Ong2p?eQfgbp?QfX2eeQW?O
r
ORh?Qft?d
r
O`dp?eORdg2pkKQO unQZQp0TQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblKXbp?t0SRQW?q
SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblÍx?
4
W9QeZO`g2S¦X
r } r 8)u hBV
r
h?g2w?ltO`h?d
r
W?S`dp?edW?lQkKQTcgbSRQW?S`g2k?lQTcXbORde
MPS`g2TXcTQORX2S`QW?SRQ
r
QpvORX2O`dg2p?XblW9g2dpvOg2M4|vdQuORh?XbpjO`h?QUW?S`dp?edW?lQUgbM
r
w?k
r
ORdO`w?ORdgbpjgbM
lg2abdeX2llVQZ¥vw?d|X2lQpvO
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r ¢
h?QtYdlQTcTcX=d
r
ORh?QpGSRQew?S`SRQpvO:8 QdORh?QS¦ORg
r
h?gu
u dORh?gbw?Ow
r dp?afORh?QEXbp?X2lgba2V¦u dO`hWU UORh?XbO Ë z ¢
Îvd
r dp?t?QQtMPX2lldk?lQyxZgbSORgXbeeQW?O
Ë m Î
mQO w
r lgvg2}X2abX2dpjXbO QX2eih=hYg2S`p=gbMORh?QUt?dlQTcTcX
X{Î
¢
h?QÊ?S
r O r w?a2abQ
r
O`dg2p&d
r
ORg\Ê?p?t&X2p?gbORh?QSW?lXbw
r
dk?lQunXV¤gbM¦S`QX2t?dp?a\k9QldQM
r
O`X2O`QZTQZpvO
r
xdpX2abSRQQTcQpvOu dORh7g2pvORXba2w?Qq
eg2O`O
r
QTcXbpBO`de
r
B
W9QeZO`g2Sh?QS`QEg'99QS
r
ORgcXbp?X2lV r Q¦X
r
O`X2ORQTcQpvO gbMORh?QUMPg2S`T28
r
X r
Ë9Î kKQldQ|bQ
r X r
QpvORQp?eQUORh?XbO d
r lgba2deXbllV0Q¥vw?d|XblQpvO ORgLA
p?t?QSORh?d
r
Xbp?XblV r dr x r wYk
r
O`dORw?ORdgbpcg2MKlgba2deXbllV7Q¥vw?d|XblQpBO
r
QpvORQp?eQ
r dr
XUeZgbSRS`QeO
W?SRdpYeZdWYlQyx(k?w?Ot?d
r
ORS`dk?w?O`dg2pcg|2QSegbp?Pw?p?eO`dg2pcd
r
p?gbO
¢ h?d
r
X2p?XblV r dr a2d|bQ
r X r w?dORXbk?lQ
dpvORQSRW?S`QORXbORdg2pgbM cXbp?t7dO r WKg
r`r
dkYlQEung2S`lt r
QTcXbpBO`de r xXbp?t
B
W9QeZO`g2S
r
w?aba2Q
r
ORQt
ORh?XbO4O`gNX
r`r
QS`OfËPTcQORXbSRQW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdgbp?X2llVÎYORh?XbO4XbpXba2QpvOkKQldQ|2Q
r
O`h?X2OaA0uEgbw?ltcORh?Qp
X2Tcgbw?pvO0O`g£X
r
eSRdk?dp?a\X
r
WKQedÊ?e'ËS`QW?S`Q
r
QpvORXbORdg2pYX2lÍΦkKQldQM
S`QlX2ORdgbp k9QO uEQQp Xbp
X2abQpBO Xbp?tjX
r
QpBO`Qp?eQ
zfSRQW?lVORh?XbO
r
w?e~hGXbpXbp?X2lV r dr
TX2OReih?Q
r dpYt?QQZtGO`h?QW?S`Qt?deORdgbp
r
gbMEg2pvORXba2w?Qq
eg2O`O
r
QTcX2pvO`de r
xZk?w?Op?gu£h?X
r
X|bQSRVNt?d99QSRQpvOYX|2gbw?S
r
dp?eQdOW9g
r
ORw?lX2ORQ
r
XS`QZlX2ORdgbp
kKQO unQQZp\X2p\Xba2QpvO7Xbp?t\X
r
QpvORQp?eQyxXbp?t£pYglgbp?abQZSXS`QlX2O`dg2p\kKQO unQQZp\X2p\Xba2QpvO
X2p?tXW?S`g2W9g
r dORdgbp
oEp?Qu)dllh?X|2QO`g
r
WKQedMPVju hYX2ONORh?QkKQldQM
S`QlX2O`dg2pX2Tg2w?pvO
r
ORgcdpjgbSRt?QS ORgX|2gbdtjORh?QUORSRXbt?dORdgbp?Xbl{W?S`g2k?lQZT
r
gbM
r
QpvORQpvORdXbldr T
k4Î gu\MPgbSORhYQ
r
Qeg2p?thYg2S`pE8KzS`QTcX2S`}¦O`h?X2OO`h?QnX2p?XblV r d
r4r w?a2abQ
r
ORQtkvV¦
v
W9QZeq
ORgbS t?gvQ
r
p?gbO VvdQltjXt?dSRQeOp?X2O`w?SRXbllX2pYa2w?Xba2QUegbw?pvORQSRQvX2TW?lQUORgORh?QUW?S`dp?edW?lQUgbM
t?d
r
ORSRdkYw?ORdgbpg|bQSNeg2p?]w?p?eORdg2p
z pO`h?d
r
S`Q
r
W9QZeONdONd
r
]w
r
ONXbp?g2ORhYQZSNunXVg2MTcXb}Bdp?a
r
Qp
r
Q g2M9g2pvORXba2w?Qq
eg2O`O
r
QTX2pvORde
r2{¨
QOdM9ORh?Q W?SRdp?edW?lQ)gbMKt?d
r
ORS`dk?w?ORdgbpcg2MK}vp?gu lq
Qt?a2Qng|2QSegbp?Pw?p?eO`dg2pSRQXbllV¦d
r
Xfk?X
rdeEW?S`dp?edW?lQna2g|bQSRp?dp?af}vp?gu)lQZtYa2QEX
r
eSRdW?O`dg2p
r x
ORh?QpGgbp?Qcu dllXbW?W?X2S`QpvORlVkKQcegbTcTcdORO`QZtDORgjORh?QcW?S`dp?edW?lQË
m ÎgbMEelg r
w?SRQcw?p?tYQZS
lg2abdeX2l4eg2p
r
Q¥vw?Qp?eQ
r
g=lg2p?aX
r
gbp?QX2eeQW?O
r
Ë̦Î
4
gbw?lt?p4©ONO`h?QeX
r
QzTcXb}2QMPg2S
XWYSRXba2TcXbORdeS`Q
r
O`SRdeORdgbpgbMW?S`dp?edW?lQËP̦ÎORh?Qpk9QTcXbt?QX2abX2dp r OË
m ÎNXVvkKQyx
r
XV
r
?
WKQeORgbSxk?w?OM]SRgbTX
r
O`SRdeO
r
QTcXbpBO`de)W9g2dpvOgbMK|vdQuxXbpcX
r
eSRdk9QSu h?g¦w?O`ORQS
r
?BA
r
hYg2w?lt0XbpvVvuEXVcXbeeQW?OEORg
r
XVL?\X
rnr gvgbp0X
r
\d
r
Xlg2abdeX2l9eZgbp
r
Q¥vw?Qp?eQfg2MA
¢
h?QlXbORORQS7Tcg|bQ
r
QZQT
r
O`gjTcQwYp
r
XbORd
r
MPXbeORgbSRVX2pYtDdTcW?lXbw
r dk?lQh?gunQ|2QS:8NTV
dpvORw?dORdgbpd
r
SRQXbllV=O`h?X2OfgbpORh?Qk?X
r dr gbMNË
m ÎRxyk9QldQMeg2pvORQpvO
r
u dllkKQX
r
eS`dkKQtORg
X2pDXba2QpvOUkvVTcQXbp
r
g2MndpYMPQSRQp?eQ
r
ORh?XbOUdOUd
r
p?XbORw?S`X2lO`gjS`QPQeOx9egbpvORSRXbSRVO`gju h?XbO
dr
h?X2W?W9Qp?dp?adp\ORh?QeX
r
Q=g2MTcQSRQlgba2deXblnQ¥BwYd|X2lQp?eQ
¢
h?Q|BdQZu z7TcX2dpvORXbdp\d
r
r
O`dll4ORh?QM]g2llgu dp?a18ndONd
r
eQS`ORX2dpYlVjS`da2hvONORgdp?M]QSNMPS`g2T }vp?gu
r
GH ADX2p?t G
¦©x }vp?gu
r
ORh?XbOA'X2p?t }vp?gu
r
O`h?X2O ¦©
)w?OORh?Q
r
O`X2O`QZTQZpvO? A gbM
QW?d
r
ORQTcdeNlgba2deNO`h?X2O)d
r w r
QtORgt?QS`d|2QNW?S`dp?edW?lQ0Ë
m Î{MPS`g2T ËÌUÎ{Xbp?t£Ë
z ¢ Îh?X
r
X2pjXbT7k?da2w?gbw
r
S`QX2t?dp?a
z O
r
hYg2w?ltjORh?QpjS`QZXbtE8
}vp?gu
r
GHfËUAXbp?t ©
zEX2T XunX2S`Q¦ORh?X2O)O`h?d
r dr
Pw
r
O)X2p?gbORh?QS)unXVgbMt?Q
r
eSRdk?dp?aO`h?QNM]X2eO)ORh?XbO)dp=g2p?q
ORXba2w?Q
r
QTX2pvORde r xvORh?Q
r
QTX2pvORde7|X2lwYQUgbM[PO`h?X2OcËUAGX2p?t pYQZQtp?gbOkKQ7ORh?Q
r
XbTcQ
X r
O`h?X2ONg2M[]ORh?X2OeADX2pYtORh?XbO ¢ h?d
rNr ORdll4t?gvQ
r
p?g2ONabd|2Qw
r
X0pYX2ORw?S`X2l4lX2p?abw?Xba2Q
k?X
r dr
MPg2SORh?QUt?d
r
O`dp?eORdgbp
!Ï$ w?k?wYe
r Ë Ï mm
Ï
ÎRx4[`oEpmg2abdeX2loTp?d
r
edQp?eQs{x(dpZCP4H M:
Ï
&'&bq
Ï
&'k{x
W?W
k Ï qk
!#<$
w?e É 0
Ë Ï mm bÎRx[PÌfQZX
r
g2p?dp?aUX2k9g2w?OÌXbORdgbp?X2lÍxk?wYOp?g2Omgba2deXbllVjoETcp?d
r
edQpvOx
LfabQpBO
r
s{xHHZ[N NI4U>PH4O FVF%ZCU?xB|2gbl
2xB|
bxBW?W
'&&2q 'k
!&'$abSÈ^
Ë"#l'l%#2Î`x[PLNW?W?SRgveih?Q
r dTcW?ldedORQTcQpvOW?d
r
OTcd¥Bw?Q
r
QO§QvW?ldedORQq
TcQpvOW?d
r
OTcd¥vw?Q
r
t?w§W?S`g2k?lTcQt?QlÍ©gbTcp?d
r
edQp?eQ lg2abd¥BwYQZs{xTcX2pvw
r
eSRdW?Ox
p?d|bQS
r dO ^4XbSRd
r Ï L Ê?S
r O |bQS r dgbp dr
X|X2dlXbk?lQ gbp ORh?Q unQZk XbO 8
!"#$%'&(%)$*%+
!k'$
7
Xba2dpjÌ
x É XblWKQS`p
xbg
r Q r ¨
i-,X2S`t?d{
Ë Ï mm bÎRx
U BSZC/.e4HQ T
O4(xbz
¢
^S`Q
r`r