HAL Id: hal-00115561
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00115561
Submitted on 21 Nov 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Four residues of the extracellular N-terminal domain of the NR2A subunit control high-affinity Zn2+ binding to
NMDA receptors.
A. Fayyazuddin, A. Villarroel, A. Le Goff, J. Lerma, J. Neyton
To cite this version:
A. Fayyazuddin, A. Villarroel, A. Le Goff, J. Lerma, J. Neyton. Four residues of the extracellular N-terminal domain of the NR2A subunit control high-affinity Zn2+ binding to NMDA receptors..
Neuron, Elsevier, 2000, 25 (3), pp.683-94. �hal-00115561�
!1'.#''<;+- "=%1%?>A@B1C:%1'&1;D-E)EFHG7I ! J-K
LNMPORQ"SUTWVXVTYZ\[[]OR^
`_
LNacbTQedfgOhaRaiTQ<Qjdkahl
_
LN^m^knkNod$pqp
`_r
Z\T^nkQ<MTl*T^[
r
TstuZ\kXvwxk=Vuyd^
nTWzdQeTWydORQekN[kw*kWZQed]zO{d$aid|Oik
}
sdaikw*d$QMTaik~]ZQ<O{kWZQek
w P~gX
Q&Z\kN[ahM
mKTQOv
SQjT^sk
T`^[
l<^v%y%OyqZydxT&eT`a
d^vjk&ed~Zk`Q<OidQ'[k<^ub$kuv&y%OR|TsOid^kuv'Oik`^uy%ORpqOisTuv
l
m
l
T[]Q<O{[
~TOh^
]X ¢¡£¡¤¦¥§9¨POR|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^]|4vOykOR^Nw¬«PL3Qeksk]ydQv
g¥%®*¯°]±³²´m§u|aZyT`MTWykQeksk]yd$Q
_
YOh^s
_
n'<fNµ
_
OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^
¶ °]±³±=¥´h·°]²X 4¸¡{¹°]±u§9«PQ=º
r
TstuZ\kuv.wxkWVXyd^
nT=zdQeTWydORQekN[kw*kWZQed]zOidaid|Oik
_ } sdaikw*d$QMTaik~]ZQ<O{kWZQek
_
Q&Z\kN[PaRM _
mKTQOv'»2SQeT`^sk
¼
ka%§m½½ *½
l
½P¾]
S2TW¿U§]½½ *½
l
½B
}
MTOha%§ ^k=Vuyd^ÀDzOidaid$|O{k]ºck^v-ºÁpqQ
w¬«PL3Qeksk`]yd$Qv(TQekNTaRa{d.v%ykQ<OisT`aRaVPOR^]©mOzOyk[PzmVgª'^mlO{d$^vOR^Tb$d$ayT`|k»&OR^[kk^[k`^uyUMT^m^kQ=º
¼
©kNTTQek^XyKTpqpqOR^]OcyqVp%dQ"ª'^dp.y%©k©kWyk`Qed$M kQ<Oisw¬«PL3Qeksk]ydQvO¦v'[kWykQ<MPOR^k[gzmVgy%©kgv&Zz]yqVmkNdp
w
l
v&ZzmZ^]OyKkW¿Qekuvvjk[Ocy%©Nw
l
L»<sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|Qeksk`]yd$QvUzkOR^m|y%©kMdv&y'vek`^v<Ocy%Obk &j
l
^X'T^[
w
l
»<sd^uyTOh^]OR^m|BQjksk]ydQv"z$kOR^]|y%©kaikTuv%yvjk^vOy%Ob$k &e½$-º9*v<OR^m|*s©]ORM kQeTuv'sd$^v&y%Q&Z\sWyk[
pqQed$My%©kuveky dgw
l
v&Zz]yqVmkuv
_
kgv<©d y%©TWyy%©kwx» yk`Q<MOR^Ta]n'<fNµK»&ahOkN[d$M TOR^dpy%©kw
l L
v&Zz]Z^mOyKsd^uy%Qedav"y%©k©]OR|©»<TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^POR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^\º9ZyTWy%Oid^v'TWyUp%d]ZQQekuvOi[uZ\kuvOR^y%©]Ov'[dMTOh^MTQk[]aV
Qek[uZ\skª'^T`pqpqOR^]OyqV zmVgZydm»&p%dai[POy%©d]ZyKTpqp%ksWy%Oh^]|*kOy%©kQQeksk`]yd$Q'Ts=y%ObTWy%O{d$^gzmV|acZyTMTWykNT^[
|aVsOR^kNdQOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^gz]V kW¿]y%QjTskaRacZaiTQQed]yd$^v'T^[wO "!Oid^vOR^[]OisTWy%Oh^]|y%©TWyy%©kuvekQekXv<Oi[uZ\kuvKMd.v%yUaROkaV
TQ&y%OisOhTWykOR^©mOR|©»<T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|º
9)B5¬G ¬)
©T^]^ka|TWy%OR^m|
_
Ta{d$^m|POy%©O{d$^mOisgveka{ksWy%ObOyqV
_
sd^v%y%OyqZykuv'd^kNdpy%©ky dBpZ^[TMk^XyTa
Qed$k`Q&y%Oikuv"y%©TWyK[kpqOR^ky%©k©uVvOid$a{d$|OisTaQedaikNd$pUT^POid$^ s©T^m^ka£ºu&yUOvUy%©kQek`p%d$Qek^dy'v%ZQ<Q<OvOR^]|y%©T=y2y%©k
|TWy%OR^]|QedkQ&y%O{kuv'dp2O{d$^s`©T^m^kav(TQekNdpyk^gy%©kyT`Q<|kWyKd$pUTahaid.v%ykQ<OisM d[uZaiT=yd$Qv-ºw¬«PL3Qeksk`]yd$Qv
_
MkMgz$kQv'dpy%©kOid^d]y%QedOis|aZyTMT=ykQeksk]ydQp%TMOhaVgy%©TWyU©TWb$kzkk`^ORMaRO{sTWyk[OR^^kWZQed^Ta
[kWbka{d$Mk`^uyKT^[xv%V]^T]y%OisaiTXv&y%OisOcyqVTuvkahaTuvTWy%©d$aid|OisT`a[]OvedQe[kQv
_
sd$^v&y%OyqZykNTyqVmOisT`akW¿TMPaikNd$p
©kTWbORaVPMd[uZaiTWyk[s©T^]^kav=º
¼
©kORQ'TsWy%ObT=y%Oid$^PQektuZORQekXv"y%©kQekXvek^skNd$py dxsd»<T|d^]O¦v&yev
_
|aZyTM TWykNT^[
|aVsOR^k
_
T^[gy%©kORQ|T=y%OR^]|Ov'T`pqp%ksWyk[gz]V*vek=bkQeT`akW¿]y%QeTskaRaZa{TQ'T|k^XyevOR^s`aZ\[]OR^]|Qed]yd^v
_
vek=bkQeT`a[]ObTa{k^uy
sTWy%Oid^v'T`^[d$acVT`MOR^kXv©mOis©TsWyU^d^»<sdMkWy%Ocy%ObkacVPOy%©QekXv<ksWyydy%©kNT|d^]Ov%yev &Qek=bOik k[OR^
sWµ TOR^ T^[gT=Vk`Q
_
¾¾] X«POR^]|aik[]OR^kNkWyKTa£º
_
¾¾¾=ºSUdQ'kTs©dpy%©kuvjkMd[uZaiTWydQv"y%©k`QekMgZv&yKkW¿Ov&yKT
zOR^[]OR^]|4v<OcykNT^[gy%QeT^ve[uZ\sWy%O{d$^M Ts©]Oh^kQ&VPaROR^ OR^]|y%©kzOR^[]OR^]|4v<Ocykyd y%©k<|T=yk=º9¨ dkWb$kQ
_
y%©k
Md$a{ksWZaiTQv%y%Q&Z\sWyqZQekXv"Z^[kQaVmOR^]|y%©kzOR^[]Oh^]|*d$py%©kuvekMd[uZaiTWydQv
_
y%©kORQaROR^ Oy%©y%©k|TWy%OR^m|
Mks©T^]OvM
_
Tuv kaRaTuv"y%©k|TWy%OR^m|BM ks©T`^]OvM Oyevekahp
_
Qek`MTOR^ddQ<aVZ^[kQv%ydd[º3k©TWbkz$k|]Z^gyd
aidd*TWyy%©kgv%y%Q&Z\sWyqZQeTa[k=ykQ<MOR^T^uyev(d$pUd^kgv&Z\s`©Md[uZaiTWy%Oid^
_
y%©kb$d$ayT`|k»&OR^[kk^[k`^uyUOR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^z]V
kW¿]y%QeTskaRaZa{TQ"ª'^]lOid^v'T^[©TWb$kOi[k^uy%OhpqOik[xvekWb$kQeTaQjkuv<Oi[uZ\kXv"y%©TWyKTQjkNsaidvekaVPQeka{TWyk[gyd ª'^gzOR^[]Oh^]|
_
y%©k
pqORQv&y'v%ykOR^gy%©kª'^POR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^M ks©T`^]OvM4º
w¬«PL3Qeksk`]yd$Qv(TQek©k=ykQedMkQv'sd$^v<Ov%y%OR^]|*dp.y dx[]Ohpqp%kQek^Xyv%Zz]Z^mOyev
_
w T^[w
l
y%©TWy
v<©T`QekNTNsdMMd^MkMgzQeT^kyd$daid|]VPOy%©Tahady%©kQOid^d]y%Qed$O{s|aZyTMTWykQjksk]ydQv&ZzmZ^]Oyev-º
}
Ts©
v&Zz]Z^mOyKsd^uyTOR^v"y%©]Qjkky%QeT^v<MkMzQeT^kgvek|M k^uyev
¼ _ ¼
½T^[
¼
_
TK»&aiddBQjk|Oid^ <sTahaik[
¼ l
TssdQe[]OR^]|ydy%©kNdQ<OR|OR^TaRaVPQedd.vjk[gyd$daid|]V'T`^[TNsWVXyd$a{Tuv<MO{sN»qykQ<MOR^XZv ?vjkk«Oh^]|aik[]Oh^k
kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾¾-º
¼
©kNkW¿my%QeTsk`aRaZaiTQ'[dMTOh^v'TQjkMT[kz]Vy%©ka{TQ<|kw*»ykQ<MOh^TaQek`|Oid$^ "mTT Qeksk[]OR^m|
¼ T`^[gz]V Tgv<MT`aRaikQaidd " mTT "zk=ykk`^
¼ ½T^[
¼ ºXL pqOhQv&yUTQ&yKdpy%©kw*» ykQ<MOh^uZv y%©k
pqORQv&yK½mTMOh^dxTsOi[v©Tuv'T kT 4vektuZ\k^skgvORMORa{TQ<OyqV Ocy%©TzTs=ykQ<OiTak`Q<ORaiTuvMOisQed]ykOR^ sTaRaik[
n'<fµ &p%dQ"nkWZ\sOR^k
_
³vedaikWZ\sOR^k
_
fTahOR^kµOR^[]OR^]|UQed]ykOR^¨ TQeTNk=yT`aqº
_
¾¾½XTuv%Z dxkWyKTa£º
_
¾¾¾=º
¼
©kQekuv&yKdpy%©kw*» ykQ<MOh^TaTa{d$^m|POy%©TdQ&y%Oid^dpy%©kaidd$z$kWykk^
¼
½T^[
¼ 4v<©d*vvjktuZ\k^sk
v<ORMOhaiTQ<OyqVydxd]y%©k`Q"zTsWyk`Q<OiTaTMPOR^d*TsOi[gzOh^[]OR^m|BQjdykOh^vv%Z\s©Tuvµ %p%d$Q|aZyT`MOR^kzOR^[]Oh^]|Qed]ykOR^
T^[gn'Lµ nVv<Oh^k
_
LNQ<|OR^mOR^k
_
NQ<^]Oy%©mOR^kµOR^[]OR^]|UQed]ykOR^w*T T^mOv<©mOkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾¨ TQeTNk=yT`aqº
_
¾¾½~]ykQ<^»µ Ts©k=yT`aqº ¾¾]=º ¼ ©]Ovvjksd^[kW¿my%QeTskahaZaiTQ'[dMTOR^P©Tuv"z$kk^xv©d^ydBMT kZy%©k
T|d$^mOv&yzOR^[]OR^m|4v<OykPOy%©xvksORpqOis`OyqVp%dQ|aVsOR^kOR^gy%©kw v&ZzmZ^]Oyev'T`^[p%d$Q|acZyTMTWykOR^y%©kw
l
v&Zz]Z^mOyev ?vjkk«POR^]|aik[]OR^kNkWyKTa£º
_
¾¾¾=º
} ¿]y%QjTskaRacZaiTQ"ª'^OR^[uZ\skuv"y d yqVmkuv(d$pOR^m©]OzOyd$Q%Vkpqp%ksWyev'd^Nw «L3Qeksk]ydQv
_
TbdayT|k»
[kk^[k`^uyKs©T`^]^k`a]zaids MgZ\s©ahOky%©kNd^kQed[uZ\sk[gzmVgA| "!Oid^v
_
T^[TbdayT|k»&Oh^[kk^[k^uy
OR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^»"©kQekd^Qek`p%kQ<Qek[gyd*Tuv <OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^ '»[uZ\kydxTN[ks`QekTuvjkOR^gy%©kNdk^Qjdz$TWzORahOyqVdpy%©k
Qeksk]ydQ's©T^]^ka <©]Q<O¦v&y%OR^kNT^[©dO
_
¾¾unk|k`^[]QekNT^[ 3kuv%yqzQedd
_
¾¾=ºUQekWbOidZvv&yqZ\[]Oikuv(d$^
QeksdMgzOh^T^Xy"Qjksk]ydQvv©dk[gy%©TWybdayT|k»&Oh^[kk^[k^uyª'^Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^OvKQ<ORMTQORaV [kWykQ<MOh^k[gz]Vy%©k
yqV]kNdpw
l
v&ZzmZ^]OyUQekXvek^Xy CORaRahOiTMxv
_
¾¾©k^k=yT`aqº
_
¾¾ XKTd$a{kWyqy%OkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ ¼ QeTWVm^k`aROv'kWy
Taqº
_
¾¾ -º9 ksk`]yd$Qv(sd$^XyTOR^mOR^]|w
l L v%Zz]Z^]Ocyev©TWb$kNT©]OR|©*vek^v<Oy%ObOyqVyd ª'^ &j
l
^X'T^[Py%©k
OR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^O¦vTQ&y%OiT`a
_
T`aRaidOR^m| l
d$py%©kNs`©T^m^kavUydBQekM TOR^Ts=y%ObkNTWy'vjTWyqZQeTWy%OR^m|ª'^sd^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^v
_
©kQekTuvUy%©kQeksk]yd$Q³v'sd^uyTOR^mOR^]|*d]y%©kQw
l
v&Zz]Z^mOyev
l µ _ l dQ
l « ©TWb$kNTaid kQvjk^vOy%ObOcyqVgydª'^
&eUQeT^m|OR^]|zk=ykk`^ºR p%dQw
l µ T^[½$ p%dQw
l 'T^[gy%©kOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^Ov'sdMaik=ykNTWy
©]OR|©sd$^sk^uy%QjTWy%Oid^v'dpª'^ºXLv'TNsd^vektuZ\k^skNdpy%©kOhQ©]OR|©gª'^*vek^v<Oy%ObOyqV
_
w
l
L»<sd^uyTOh^]OR^m|BQjksk]ydQv
TQekNkW¿ksWyk[gyd z$kyd$^mOisTahaVOh^]©]OczOyk[gzmVgy%©kaid aikWb$kav'dpª'^ Zv&Z\T`aRaV TWzd]bkgm^u p%dZ^[Tuv
sd$^XyTMOR^T^uyevKOR^xv&yT`^[TQe[xvjd$aZy%O{d$^vOR^Mdv&yUaiT=zdQeTWydQ<Oikuv-ºu<^[kk[
_
TaROisTWy%Oid^d$p©kTWb]VPMkWyT`as©ka{TWyd$Q³v
dyk^Xy%OiTWykuv.w »w
l L Qjksk]ydQv
_
Qekuv%ZMTWzaVgzmVQjkMd]bOR^m| y%©kNsd^uyTMOh^TWy%OR^m|ª'^ KTdaikWyqy%OkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ =º
^s©T`QeTsWykQORYOR^m| y%©kMks©T^]O¦v<M dp.ª'^POR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^
_
T^PORMdQ&yT^uy'v%ykOv"ydBa{dsT=ykQeksOvjkaV
©kQeky%©kOh^]©]OczOy%OR^m|ª'^ "!Oid$^v"zOh^[d$^y%©kw¬«PL Qjksk]ydQ=ºX<^gy%©]O¦vv&yqZ\[uV kNsd$^sk^uy%QjTWyk[d$^y%©k
©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|4v<Oykp%d]Z^[xv<ksORpqOisT`aRaVPOR^Nw
l
L»sd$^XyTOR^mOR^]|Qeksk]yd$Q³v=ºmoOb$k^gy%©TWyy%©]Ov
OR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^gzmVgª'^*v<©d k[^d vjk^vOy%ObOyqVgydbdayT|k
_
d]ZQv&yTQ&y%Oh^]|©uVmd]y%©kuvOv Tuv"y%©T=y2y%©k©]OR|© TpqpqOR^]OcyqV
ª'^OR^]©mOzOcyd$Q&V*v<Ocykgv<©d]Zai[gzka{dsT=yk[OR^gy%©kNk=¿]y%QeTskaRaZaiT`Q'[d$MT`OR^v'dpy%©kw
l L v%Zz]Z^mOy³º kzk`|T^gz]V
QedZ|©maVPaidsTWy%OR^]|y%©mOvv<OcykOy%©mOR^gy%©kw
l L kW¿]y%QjTskaRacZaiTQ'[dMTOR^v"Zv<OR^m|Qeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|*s©]OhMkQ<Ois
w
l
v&ZzmZ^]OyevM T[kpqQedM3w
l L T^[Nw
l _
sdkW¿Qjkuvvjk[Oy%© w OR^N¥°<·]´dds=VuykXv=º
kTuv%ZQekMk`^uyev
_
Z^[k`Q"yd*kaiksWy%Qjd[kb$d$ayT`|kNsaiTM
_
dp.y%©kª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^OR^gb$TQ<Oid]Zv's©mORMkQeTXv'TaRaid k[
y%©kOi[k^Xy%ORpqOisT=y%Oid$^ d$pUT^Nw*» ykQMOR^T`aQek|Oid^dp"T=zd]Zy½mTMPOR^d*TsOi[v
_
TuvUzkOR^m|^kskXvveT`Q&Vp%dQ©]Oh|©
TpqpqOR^]OcyqVgª'^gzOR^[]Oh^]|ºX<^uykQjkuv&y%OR^m|aV
_
y%©mOvQek`|Oid$^ sd$Oh^sOi[kXvOcy%©gy%©kn'<fNµK»&aROkQek`|Oid$^\ºw*kW¿my
_
ZvOR^]|*T
d$OR^XyUMgZyTWy%Oid^xv&y%QjTWyk|]V
_
kOi[k^Xy%ORpqOik[p%d]ZQQekuvOi[uZ\kuvOR^y%©]Ovw*»ykQMOR^T`a[d$MT`OR^gy%©T=y"M TWVQjkQekuvjk^uy
_
TWy
aikTuv%y"Oh^TQ&y
_
y%©kMdaiks=ZaiTQ'[kWykQMOR^T`^uyev'dpy%©k©]Oh|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^zOR^[]OR^]|4v<Ocyk]º9ZyTWy%Oid^v'T=y2y%©kuvek
Qekuv<O{[uZ\kuvMTQ k[]aV [ksQekTXvek mp%d$ai["y%©kNTTQek`^uyKTpqpqOR^mOyqVp%dQ"ª'^dpw
l
L»<sd^uyT`OR^]OR^m|Qeksk]ydQv
T^[gy%©k=VxvksORpqOisTaRaVyTQ<|kWyy%©k©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^§u^kOy%©kQ"y%©kNTT`Qek^uyKTpqpqOh^]Oy%OikXvp%d$Q'k`Oy%©kQ
T|d$^mOv&y
_
^dQ'd]y%©kQ"yqVmkuv'dp|TWy%OR^m|BM d[uZaiT=y%Oid$^*v&Z\s©TXv"y%©dvekzmVQed]yd^v'dQ^]Ois kaTQekNTpqp%ksWyk[º0©mORaik
y%©]Ov dQ TuvKOR^Qed|Qekuv³v
_
T^d]y%©kQv%yqZ\[uVQjd$dvek[gy%©TWyydQekuv<O{[uZ\kuvOR^gy%©kwx»qykQ<MOR^Tadp.y%©kw
l L
v&Zz]Z^mOy &OR^saZ\[]OR^m|xd^kNdpy%©kQekXv<Oi[uZ\kuv([]OvesWZv³vek[OR^y%©]OvQjkd$Q%y"MTWV sd$^v&y%OyqZykT`Q&yKd$py%©kª'^zOR^[]OR^]|
v<Oyk <©d$OT^[gn'OR]yd$^
_
¾¾¾-º
5
!"!#!$%&')(+*,-# $.0/.0. 12!3- 0454
6!78$&9 ;:=<5>@?AB$&C,". 9!.7@D@E453'F
oNOb$k^gy%©kgv%Zz]Z^mOy'v<ksOhpqOisOyqV T^[gb$d$ayT`|k»&OR^[kk^[k`^skNdpy%©kª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^
_
kQjkuv&y%Q<O{sWyk[dZQ
vekTQjs©p%dQ"y%©k©]Oh|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^zOR^[]OR^]|4v<Ocykyd y%©kNk=¿]y%QeTskaRaZaiT`QQek|Oid^dp.y%©kw
l L v&ZzmZ^]Oy³ºX<^dQe[kQ
ydBaidsTWykP©]Ois`©TQ&yKdp.y%©mOvaiT`Q<|kQek|Oid^ mTT OvKMd.v%yUaROkaVydxsd$^XyTOR^gy%©k©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^
zOR^[]OR^]|4v<Ocyk
_
kMkTXv&ZQek[gª'^xvjk^vOy%ObOyqVdpQeksk`]yd$Qv(sd$^v<Ov%y%OR^]|*dpw v&ZzmZ^]Oyev'sdkW¿Qekuv³vek[POy%©
s©]ORM kQ<Oisgv%Zz]Z^]OcyevMT[kzmVxv"TOh^]|*[]ORpqp%kQek`^uyUQek|Oid^vUzkWy kk^gy%©kMdv&y'vek^v<Oy%Ocbkgv&ZzmZ^]Oy
_
w
l L _
T^[gy%©ka{kTuv&y'vjk^vOy%ObkNd^k
_
w
l
ºSOR|º sdMTQekXv"ª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^dz\vekQ%bk[POy%©PORai[gyqVmkw
l L d$Q
w
l
0v&Zz]Z^mOyevPOy%©gy%©TWyKdz\vekQ&b$k[Ocy%©s©]OhMkQeTuvKOR^P©]Ois©y%©kQek|O{d$^Nw*» ykQMOR^T`a]yd ¼ pqQedM d$^k
v&Zz]Z^mOyU©TuvUzkk^PQekaiTsk[gz]Vy%©k©dMdaid|dZvQjk|Oid^pqQedMy%©kNd]y%©kQv%Zz]yqVmk]ºXLyTgv%ykT[uVbdayT|kNdp
»<Mf
_
T^T`aROisTWy%O{d$^dpm^u zmZpqp%kQek[gª'^ ?vjkk } ¿kQ<OhMk^uyT`a]"Qjdsk[uZQekuv
_
TNsd^sk^uy%QeT=y%Oid$^ydd
aid ydBQed[uZ\skNTb$d$ayT`|k»<[kk^[k^uyzaids xdpw «L3Qeksk]ydQv KTdaikWyqy%OkWyKTa£º
_
¾¾ _
OR^[uZ\skuv'T
v&y%Qed^]|OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^
l 'dpy%©kQekuvd$^vekNkWb$d k[PzmVxvjTWyqZQeTWy%Oh^]|*[d.vjkuv'dp|aZyTMTWykNT`^[|aVsOR^k
$ kTs©OR^ ORa{[»yqVmkw
l
L»<sd^uyT`OR^]OR^m|Qeksk]ydQv qSOR|º L =ºµV sd^uy%QeTXv&y
_
ORa{[» yqVmkw
l
»
sd$^XyTOR^mOR^]|Qeksk]yd$Q³v'TQekz$TQekaVPOR^m©]OzOyk[TWyy%©]Ov(sd$^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^ SOh|º L l
-º ¼ ©kª'^xvjk^vOy%ObOyqVdpy%©k
Qeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|*s©]OhMkQ<Oisgv%Zz]Z^mOyev'[kk^[v'd^gy%©kN[d^dQ'd$py%©kQek» ¼ w*»ykQ<MOh^TaQek`|Oid$^\º
¼ ©XZvQeksk`]yd$Qv(sd$^XyTOR^mOR^]|*s©mORMkQeTXvOcy%©gy%©kw*» ykQ<MPOR^Tadpw
l
HGRw
l
JI£L ?m]
_
SOR|º L½KTQekNd^]aV
v<aROR|©Xy%aV
_
Ohp"T=yT`aRa
_
OR^]©mOzOyk[PzmVxm^X ª'^P©kQekTuvQeksk]yd$Q³v'sd^uyTOR^mOR^]|*s©mORMkQjTuvPOy%©gy%©kw*» ykQMOR^T`ad$p
w
l
LGRw
l
LI ?m½
_
SOR|º LN;KTQekgv%y%Qed$^m|aVPOR^]©mOzOyk[ ", =º
S\ZaRa]ª'^[dvek»&Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^sWZQ%bkuv qSOR|º µ kQjkNdzmyTOR^k[ p%dQ"y%©kXvekp%d]ZQw
l
sd^v&y%Q%Z\sWyevOR^T
vekQ<O{kuv'dp"k=¿kQ<OhMk^uyevKkQ<p%dQ<Mk[POy%©» LI
mMf3bdayT|kQeT`Mv ?vjkk } ¿kQ<ORM k^uyTa]UQedsk[uZQjkuv=º
¼ ©kNsWZQ<Qek^Xy TuvKMkTuv%ZQek[TWy
m MPf ydxT=bdOi[sd$^XyTMOR^TWy%Oid^dp.y%©kbdayT|k»%OR^[kk`^[k^Xy"Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^
z]Vy%©kbdayT|k»<[kk^[k^uyª'^gzaids BOh^gy%©k $8» M sd^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^QeT`^]|k]º } ¿kQ<ORM k^uyTa[T=yTkQjk
pqOyqyk[gz]V T Ois`©TkahOvOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^pZ^sWy%O{d$^ evekk } ¿kQORMk^XyTa]UQedsk[uZQekuv =º ¼ ©kNs=ZQ&bkNd]z]yTOh^k[POy%©
w
l
LI% ?m½'s`©]ORMk`QeTNsd^uyTOR^mOR^]|Qeksk]ydQvQekuvjkMgzaikuv"y%©TWyKd$pQeksk]yd$Q³v'sd^uyTOR^mOR^]|w
l L gy'v&ZzmZ^]Oyev
OR^gy%©T=y2y%©ke p%d$Q"z$dy%©PQeksk]ydQvO¦vOR^gy%©k B» ^X QeT^m|kMGq ^u p%dQw
l
LI em½'T^[ ^u
p%d$Qw
l L gyNKT^[gy%©kWV*veTWyqZQjTWykNTWy MTW¿ORMgZM OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^º ^gy%©kNdy%©kQ©T`^[
_
Qeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|
l l l
l ½ p%dQw
l
=KTuv kaRaTuvKMTW¿OhMTaOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^ <saidvekyd OR^gz$dy%©sTuvekuv =º ¼ ©kuvekQekXv&Zayevv©d
y%©TWyU©]Oh|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^POR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^QjktuZORQekuvUy%©kQekuvjk^skNd$py%©kQjk|Oid^Qeksk[]OR^]| ¼ pqQedM3w
l
Lº
w*kW¿my
_
ZvOR^]|*Tgvek=ydpw
l
LI{w
l
s©]ORM kQeTuv evekk } ¿kQORMk^XyTa]UQedsk[uZQekuvp%dQ'TQeks`Ovek
[kpqOR^]Ocy%Oid$^ d$py%©kNs`©]ORMk`QeTuv
_
kNTWyqykM]yk[PydaidsTaRORY9ky%©k©]Oh|©»<TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOykydxTgvMTaRa{kQ
Qek|Oid^dp.y%©kw
l
Lw*» ykQ<MOh^TaqºµQ<OikpqacV
_
y%©kw*» ykQMOR^T`aQek|Oid^dpw
l
v&Zz]Z^mOyev Tuvv%Zz[]ObOi[k[OR^uyd
v<O¿Qjk|Oid^v^XZMgzkQjk[Nw »w*T^[kTs©dp.y%©kuvekQjk|Oid^v TuvQek`aiTsk[OR^ w
l
L0z]Vy%©k©d$Mdaid|dZv
pqQeT|Mk^XyKd$pw
l
NºXLNaRadp.y%©kuvekNsd$^v&y%Q&Z\sWyev
_
k=¿sk]y\w
l
L (w _
Qekuv%Zayk[OR^pZ^sWy%Oid^TaXw
l
v%Zz]Z^mOyev
TuvOR^[]OisTWyk[gzmVgy%©kNTMaROyqZ\[kNdpy%©k|aZyT`MTWykQekuvd$^vekuvKQeksdQe[k[OR^ddsWVXykuv ?vjkk } ¿kQ<ORM k^uyTa
"Qjdsk[uZQekuv-º ¼ d v%yqZ\[uVgy%©kdyk^Xy%OiTaORMPaROisTWy%O{d$^dpy%©kw Qek|Oid^OR^gy%©k©]OR|©»<TpqpqOR^mOyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^]|4vOyk
_
y%©]OvQjk|Oid^TXvv<aROcy"Oh^uyd y d vMTaRa{kQpqQeT|Mk`^uyev w TNT^[w zP©]O{s© kQekN[kaik=yk[d$^kNTWyKTy%ORMkOR^
w
l L _
OR^v%ykT[d$pz$kOR^]|Qek`aiTsk[gzmVgy%©k©dMd$a{d$|d]Zvw
l pqQeT|M k^uyev
_
aikT[]OR^]|ydy%©kpZ^s=y%Oid$^Ta
sd$^v&y%Q&Z\s=yevw
l
L
∆
w T 'T^[Nw l L∆
w zQekuvksWy%Ob$kaV\ºª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^ TuvKMkTuv%ZQek[TWy
m MPfp%dQ
kTs©dpy%©kNs©mORMkQOisNsd^v&y%Q%Z\sWyev'T^[Py%©kebTacZ\kuv kQekNd]z]yTOR^k[pqQedMy%©kN[dvek»&Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^sWZQ%bkuv-º
¼ ©kQekuv&ZacyevpqQedMy%©kuvjkNkW¿kQORMk^Xyev'TQekaid]yqyk[OR^gS.OR|º
l º ¼ ©kydBQjd*vaid]yy%©kQekuv%Zayev'd]z]yTOh^k[POy%©
y%©kNsd^v%y%Q&Z\sWyev'dpSOR|º º9« TWyTpqQedM s©mORMkQeTXvOR^P©]Ois`©d$^kNd$py%©kgvek|Mk`^uyevw »w* ©T[gzkk`^QekaiTsk[
z]Vy%©k©dMdaid|dZvQjk|Oid^d$pw
l dQ'[kaikWyk[BT`ayd$|k=y%©kQ'TQjkgv<©dP^OR^Qed*v'»
l
T^[Nw
l
L
_
y%©k
TQek^XyTaXw
l
L3pqQedM ©mOis©kTs©dpy%©kuvjkNs©]ORM kQeTuv Tuv'sd$^v&y%Q&Z\sWyk[ O¦vv<©dP^OR^Qjd ºw
l
LW©T[T^
eKd$p
l
¾^u P©]O{s©Ov"b$kQ&V saidvekydy%©kedpw
l L gy³ºX<^sd$^Xy%QeTuv&y
_
s©mORMkQeTXvOR^ub$d$acbOR^m|gw _ w l
T^[Nw*½ Qjk|Oid^v'TahaQekuvek`^uyKTMTQk[]aVOh^sQekTuvek[ &M d$Qeky%©T^xmp%dai["ª'^eº ¼ ©kª'^e?v'dp
s©]ORM kQeTuvOh^ubdabOR^]|Qek|O{d$^vMdQekQed]¿ORMT`a]yd ¼ TQekNkOcy%©kQ'd^]aVPMd[kQeTWyk`aVOh^sQekTuvek[ zmV p%dai[
OR^gy%©kNsTuvekNdpwx
_
^d]y'v<OR|^mORpqOisT`^uy%aV Tpqp%ksWyk[ ¦w _
dQ'kWbk^ [ksQekTXvek[ zmVxp%dai[OR^gy%©kNsTuvekNdpwB=º
¼ T k^yd$|kWy%©kQ"y%©kXvekQekuv%Zayevv%Z||kuv&yy%©T=y2y%©k©]OR|© TpqpqOR^]OcyqVgª'^gzOR^[]Oh^]|4v<OykM TWVgz$kaidsTWyk[OR^
y%©kw »wx½Qek`|Oid$^v=º ¼ ©mOvOi[kTOvv&ZdQ&yk[gzmVgy%©kNdz\vekQ&b$TWy%Oid^gy%©T=y2y%©kgv&ZzmZ^]Oy\w
l
&Lw »&
_
p%d$Q<M k[gz]VPQekaiTskMk^Xydpvek|M k^uyevw »wOR^Nw
l
¬z]Vy%©k©d$M d$aid|d]ZvQek|Oid^dpw
l L _
Ov©]Oh|©]aV
vek^v<Oy%Ob$kyd ª'^ qSOR|º
l _
Qjd ½=ºu^uykQekXv&y%OR^m|aV
_
y%©kQek|Oid^sd^vOv&y%OR^m|*d$py%©kgvjk|Mk^Xyevw »wx½©Tuv"zkk^
v<©dP^gyd v©TQekgvjktuZ\k^skgv<ORMPORaiTQ<OcyqVPOy%©d^kyqVmkNdp.z$TsWykQOiTakQ<OhaiTuv<MPOisQed]ykOR^
_
y%©knk=Z\sOR^k»
vedaikWZ\sOh^k»&fPTaROh^k» µOR^[]OR^]|»q"QjdykOh^ n'<fNµ g¨ TQeTNkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾½u Tuv&Z d*kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾¾=º kPORaRa
©kQekd$^sTaRa]y%©]O¦vQek|Oid^gy%©kn'<fµK»&aROkN[d$MT`OR^º
l
m p%dai[
_
y%©kª'^Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^ Tuv^dyKTWz$d$aRO¦v<©k[BT`^[gy%©kQekXv&Zay%OR^m|Qeksk]ydQv kQekgv%y%ORaRavjk^vOy%Obkyd
MOisQedMdaiTQ'sd^sk^uy%QeT=y%Oid$^v'dp.ª'^\ºN^kdvvOzOhaROyqVPOv"y%©T=y2y%©kn'<fNµK»&ahOkN[d$M TOR^vKOR^Nw
l L T^[
w
l
sd$^XyTOR^T`MOR^d*TsOi[QekXv<Oi[uZ\kuvUy%©TWyKsd^uy%Q<Ocz]ZykydxT©mOR|©TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOykOR^Nw
l L T^[T
aid TpqpqOR^mOyqVxvOykOR^Nw
l vjd y%©TWyUQekaiTskMk^XydppqQeT|Mk`^uyevOR^ w
l L Ocy%©©dMdaid$|d]ZvpqQeT`|Mk^uyev(d$p
w
l
0v POys©kXv"y%©kgvjk^vOy%ObOcyqVdpy%©kQekuv%Zay%OR^m|BQjksk]ydQ"ydxT^ w
l
»&aROkgvjk^vOy%ObOyqV\ºuL v&y%Qjd$^m|
TQ<|]ZMk^XyKT|TOR^v&yy%©]OvKd.v³v<OzORaROyqVPOv"y%©TWyUQeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|y%©kNsd^v%y%Q&Z\sWy\w
l
L
∆
w »<½&y%Q SOh|º l _Qed OR^P©]Ois`©gy%©kpZaRa]n'fµK»&aROkN[dMTOh^©TuvUzkk^ [kaikWyk[xv%y%ORaRaQekWyT`OR^Tª'^e"OR^y%©kaid
MOisQedMdaiTQQeT`^]|k]º3k kQekT`Q&y%OisWZaiT`Q<aV dQ<Q<Oik[Py%©TWy'v&Z\s© TaiTQ<|kN[ka{kWy%Oid^OR^T^ w
l
v&ZzmZ^]Oy PORaRa
Qed[uZ\skNT^d^pZ^sWy%O{d$^Tav&ZzmZ^]OyKT^[Py%©TWyy%©k©k^d]yqVmkNdz\vekQ&b$k[Ocy%©gy%©]Ov([kaikWy%Oid^sd^v%y%Q&Z\sWyUMOR|©Xy
sd$QQekuv<d^[gydy%©TWyKdp <©d$M d$Mk`Q<Oisw Qeksk]ydQv ?vjkk } ¿kQ<ORM k^uyTa]UQedsk[uZQjkuv=º¨ d kWbk`Q
sd$Oh^eks=y%Oid$^POR^uyd*ddsWVXykuv'dpw Ocy%©Nw
l
L
∆
w »½&y%QaikT[vUydBaiTQ|k|aZyTMTWykQjkuv<d^vjkuv L TWy»<Mf
_
v<OhMORaiTQ"ydy%©dvekQeksd$Qj[k[Oy%© ORa{[PyqVmkw
l
LOR^[]OisTWy%OR^]|y%©TWyy%©]Ovw
l
sd$^v&y%Q&Z\s=y"O¦v
pZ^sWy%Oid^T`aqº
< 'N0B.*,45.04 / BN!#!%&.-)(+12!3'
¼
©kQjkuv&ZayevKpqQed$M s`©]ORMk`Q<OisQeksk]yd$Q³v'[kuves`Q<Ozk[BT=zd]bkgv&Z||kXv&yk[gy%©kQjkuvek^skNdp2M T&edQ
[kWykQ<MOh^T^Xyev'd$py%©k©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|4v<OykPOy%©]Oh^gy%©kNkW¿my%QeTsk`aRaZaiTQ"n'fµK»&aROkN[dMTOh^OR^gy%©kwx»
ykQ<MOR^Tadpw
l
LºZQ^k=¿]y'v&y%QeT=yk|]V Tuv"ydZvekdOR^uyUMgZyT=y%Oid$^v"yd y%Q%VgydOi[k^uy%OhpVOR^[]ObO{[uZ\TaTMOR^d
TsOi[QekuvOi[uZ\kuv"y%©TWyUMTWVzkORMPd$Q&yT`^uyUp%d$Q©mOR|©TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^ºX<^Mdv&yUQed]ykOR^v
_
©kTWbmVM kWyTaOid^v
TQekZv&Z\T`aRaV sddQe[]OR^TWyk[gz]VP^]Ocy%Qed$|k`^
_
v&ZaRpZQ
_
dQ'd¿mV]|k`^TWydMxvp%d]Z^[OR^xvOi[kNs©T`OR^v'dp©]Ov%y%Oi[]OR^k
_
sWVv&ykOR^k
_
Tuv<TQ%yTWykNT^[|aZyT`MTWykQekuvOi[uZ\kuv oaZv kQ
_
¾¾ MT OR^m|y%©kuvjkQekuv<O{[uZ\kuvaid|OisTa]yT`Q<|kWyevp%dQ
MgZyT|k^kuv<Ov-º9µ Tuvjk[d$^ T^T^TaVv<Ov(d$p]ZzahOv<©k[Nw
l
vektuZ\k`^skNTahOR|^]Mk`^uyev &³v<©]OhOkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾½
_
TpqORQ³v&y
vekQ<O{kuv'dp2MZyTWy%Oid^v kQekMT[kNTWyUd.vOy%Oid^v"y%©TWy kQjkNdss=ZOik[gz]V T]ZyTWy%Ob$kª'^aROR|T^[º %Oqºck]º9¨
_ _ «
d$Q
}
OR^Nw
l L _
zmZy2y%©TWy k`Qek^d]yKsd$^vekQ%bk[ <kWb$k^OR^ TzQedT[[k|k^kQeTWyk TWV
_
O£ºkmº]TuvKd$aiT`Q'd$Q
s©TQ|k[OR^gy%©k©dMd$a{d$|d]Zvw
l dv<Oy%Oid^ S.OR|ºc½
_
y%Q<O{T^]|aikXv=º3kNT`aved*sd$^v<Oi[k`Qek[gy%©kdvvOzORahOyqVgy%©TWy
y%©k©]Oh|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^zOR^[]OR^]|4v<OcykMTWV sd$^XyTOR^Qjkuv<Oi[uZ\kXv"y%©TWyKTQjkNsd$^vekQ%bk[gzk=ykk`^Nw
l L T^[w
l
z]Zy
_
zksT=ZvekNdp"[]Ohpqp%kQek^skuvOR^y%©kaidsTak^XbORQjd$^mMk^uy
_
MTWVP^d]y'vekQ%bky%©]O¦vpZ^sWy%O{d$^Oh^Nw
l _ d$Q
_
zksT=ZvekNdp.y%©kNTWzvjk^skNd$pUd]y%©kQTQ%y%^kQv
_
M TWV^dyz$kgv&ZpqpqOisO{k^uyydBM T kNT©]OR|© TpqpqOR^]OcyqVgzOR^[]OR^m|4v<OykOR^
w
l
Nº ¼ ©k`Qekp%dQek Tgveksd^[xvjkQ<Oikuv(d$pMgZyTWy%O{d$^vTXv'sTQ<QOik[dZyydQekaiTskgvedMkNsd^vek`Q&bk[ « T^[
} QekuvOi[uZ\kuv qSOR|ºc½
_
[]O{TMd^[v-ºu<^y%©]OvvjkQ<OikXv
_
kNTa¦vedBMZyTWyk[xvedMkdv<Oy%Ob$kaV s©T`Q<|k[QekuvOi[uZ\kuv T^[
P©]O{s©
_
OR^T[[]Ocy%Oid$^ydxTdvv<Oczaik zmZyK[]ORpqpqOisWZayydykuv&y"OR^mpqaZ\k^skNd$^y%©kª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|4v<OykN½u« v&y%Q&Z\sWyqZQjk
_
MTWV Taved*kW¿k`Q&yKkaiksWy%Qjd.v%yTWy%OisQek]Za¦v<Oid^d^gy%©kª'^ !'sT=y%Oid$^\º
ZyT^uyevkQjkgvesQekk^k[gzmVMkTuv&ZQ<Oh^]|y%©kaik=bkadpOR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^T=y2y d ª'^ sd$^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^vW§$m^u
_
TNsd$^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^½p%d$a{[ ©mOR|©k`Q"y%©T^gy%©keKd$pw
l L gy»<sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|Qeksk`]yd$Qv(T^[xm^u
_ T
veTWyqZQeT=y%OR^]|*sd^sk`^uy%QeTWy%O{d$^p%dQ"y%©kXvekQeksk]yd$Q³v ¼ TWzaik =º kNTQ&zOy%QeTQORaV sd$^v<Oi[k`Qek[Tuv v%y%Qed$^m|aV
Tpqp%ksWyk[gy%©d.vjkMgZyT^uyevUy%©TWyU©T[ QjkaiTWy%Ob$kNsWZQ<Qek`^uyKTMaROcyqZ\[kuv"y%©T=y kQeka{TQ<|kQ"zmVMdQeky%©T^
l
»&p%dai[pqQedM
y%©kQeka{TWy%ObkNs=ZQ<Qek^Xyev'd$p PORai[gyqVmkQeksk`]yd$Qv zdai[T^[gz$d¿$k[d$Q"Z^[kQ<aROR|^k[OR^gSOh|º½T^[ ¼ TWzaik
_
Qekuv<ksWy%Obk`aV =º& d[k`QeTWykaV 'Tpqp%ks=yk[MgZyT^uyevkQjkN[kpqOR^k[BTXv"y%©dveky%©TWyU©T[Qeka{TWy%ObkNs=ZQ<Qek^XyevaiTQ<|k`Q
d$QvMTaRaik`Q"y%©T^PORai[gyqVmkz]VPMdQeky%©T`^ ºl
m»&p%d$a{[BT`^[aikuv³v"y%©T^
l
»&p%d$a{[ ev<ORMacVgz$d$ai[OR^SOR|ºc½T^[ ¼ TWzaik
=º py%©kdv<Oy%O{d$^vMgZyTWyk[
_
P©]Ois© TaRa|TWb$kpZ^sWy%Oid^T`aQeksk]ydQv
_
d]ZQvesQjkk^]Oh^]|4v&y%QeT=yk|]V[k=yksWyk[
MZyTWy%Oid^v ¨P
l L _
¨L
_ « XL _ ¨ l
~
_ « l L _ } l
_ l
½½u
_ l
o _ } l
~
_
¨ ½XL T^[
½ ~ Qjkuv&Zay%Oh^]|OR^TgvOR|^]ORpqO{sT^uyUMd[]ORpqOisTWy%Oid^d$py%©kª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^ Oy%©Pp%dZQMgZyT`^uyev
_
¨PL _ ¨ l
~
_
l
½½u3T^[ } l
~
_
y%©TWyKsd]Zai[gzkNsa{TuvvORpqOik[Tuv v%y%Qed^]|aV 'Tpqp%ksWyk[º]dMaikWykª'^Oh^]©]OczOy%Oid^sWZQ%bkuv
kQjkNsd$^v&y%Q&Z\s=yk[p%d$Q"y%©kuvek MgZyT^Xyev ?vjkkSOR|ºp%d$Q"¨PL _ ¨ l
~
_ l
½½u3T^[ } l
~'T^[Py%©k
TQeTMk=ykQv'dpy%©kpqOyevk`Q<p%d$QMk[Ocy%©ktuZ\TWy%Oid^ ?vjkk } ¿kQ<ORM k^uyTa]UQedsk[uZQjkuv'TQjk|Obk^POR^ ¼ TWzaik
<=º ¼ ©kQekuv&ZacyevpqQedMy%©kOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^sWZQ&b$kuv'sd^]pqORQM dZQ'kMPORQ<OisT`atuZ\T^uy%ORpqO{sTWy%Oid^§9y%©kMgZyTWy%Oid^vU¨
l L _
« XL
_ « l L _ } l
_
¨½XL T^[ ½ ~BMd[kQeT=ykaVPOR^sQjkTuveky%©kª'^e2z]V
l
yd
l
p%dai[©mORaik
y%©k
l
o MgZyT=y%Oid$^PQekuv&ZacyevOR^TN½p%dai[g²¥±=¥`¸´=¥NOR^gª'^Pe³º ¼ ©kMZyTWy%Oid^v"¨PL _ ¨ l
~
_ l
½½u
T^[ } l
~B©TWbkNTMdQekN[]QeTXv&y%OisNkpqp%ksWyKd$^gy%©kª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^§9¨PL [ksQekTXvekuv"y%©kNTTQek`^uyª'^TpqpqOR^mOyqV
z]V p%dai[
_ ¨ l
~z]V*
l
p%d$a{[
_ l
½½uz]V
l
p%d$ai[T^[ } l
~z]VP
l
p%d$ai[
_
QekuvksWy%Ob$kaV\º
8-# N 1 $93..# 4 /'N0')( 9!.".4 )N # 1 .!3.-
ZQMgZyT|k`^kuvOvvesT^Qekuv%Zayk[OR^gy%©kOi[k^Xy%ORpqOisTWy%O{d$^dpQekuv<O{[uZ\kuv
_
¨
_ ¨ l _ l
½½T^[
} l
_
©d.vjkMgZyTWy%Oid^Qedp%d]Z^[]aV Tpqp%ksWyevUy%©kNTTQjk^uyKTpqpqOR^mOyqV d$py%©kOh^]©]OczOydQ&Vª'^gzOR^[]OR^]|4vOyk]º
¼
©k
^TWyqZQekNdpy%©kuvjkQekuvOi[uZ\kuv <k=¿sk]yUp%dQ"y%©kaVvOR^k
_
z]Zy'vjkkN[]Oves=Zvv<O{d$^ _
TXvk`aRaTuv"y%©kNTMaROyqZ\[kNdpy%©k
MgZyTWy%Oid^»&Oh^[uZ\sk[xv©]ORpyevOh^gª'^e z$kWykk^
T^[xmp%dai[v&ZdQ&yy%©kOi[kTy%©TWyy%©k=VMT=V[]ORQjksWy%aV
TQ&y%OisOhTWykOR^gy%©k©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|4v<Oyk]º¨ d kWbk`Q
_
Tgv%y%Qed^]|*kpqp%ksWyKdpUTMgZyTWy%Oid^d^gy%©ke Ov
^d]yTQjddpy%©TWyy%©kQjkuv<Oi[uZ\kT`Q&y%OisORT=ykuvOR^gy%©kzOR^[]OR^]|Qedskuv³v=ºX<^[kk[
_
MZyTWy%Oid^v"y%©TWyKTpqp%ksWyy%©k
zOR^[]OR^]|MT=VQeksORQedsTaRacVTpqp%ksWyy%©kaROR|T`^[gzOR^[]OR^]|*ktuZOhaROzQOZM <d$a{tuZ©d]Z^
_
¾¾ =ºZ\T^Xy%OyTWy%Ob$kaV
_
y%©kNkpqp%ks=yev'd$pv%Z\s© <QekM dykMgZyT=y%Oid$^v'sT^zkaiTQ|k]º
¼ dBMgZyTWy%O{d$^vOR^gy%©k»%aiddQek|Oid^ ¼ l
'dpy%©kw v%Zz]Z^mOy
_ m¾T^[Nw4m¾m
_
sd$^v&y%OyqZykyqVmOisTakW¿T`Maikuv'dpv&Z\s© <QekMd]ykMgZyTWy%Oid^vOy%©PQek|TQe[gydy%©k©]Oh|©»<TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^gzOh^[]OR^m|
v<Oyk]º`w » m¾©TXv"zkk`^aidsTWyk[OR^gy%©kOR^]^kQ"bkXv&y%OzmZaikNd$py%©kNs©T^m^ka Z^kQ'kWyKTa£º
_
¾¾'T^[w »
w m¾OvT`Q&yKd$py%©kgvjkaiks=y%ObOyqVPpqORayk`Q
_
[kkOR^gy%©kdQek
_
P©kQekzaids OR^]|A| !Oid^vUzOR^[ evekk«POR^]|a{k[]OR^k
kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾¾-º ¼ ©kaidsTWy%O{d$^v'd$py%©kuvekQekXv<Oi[uZ\kuvKMT kOybk`Q&VOhMQed]zTWzaiky%©TWyy%©kWVT`Q&y%OisORT=ykOR^gy%©k
©]OR|©»<TpqpqOR^mOyqVgª'^POR^]©mOzOydQ&V*v<Oyk
_
P©]Ois`©
_
|Obk^y%©kaiTs xdpbdayT|k»[kk^[k`^skNdpy%©kª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^
_
MgZv&yzkNd]Zyev<O{[ky%©ky%QeT^v<Mk`MgzQeT`^kpqOika{[ºu<^[kk[
_
y%©kMgZyT=y%Oid$^ w
l
L»w4m¾
_
P©]O{s©OR^Xy%Qed[uZ\skuv'T
d.vOy%ObkNs`©TQ<|kOh^gy%©kgvjkaiksWy%OcbOyqVPpqORaykQ %Oqºck]ºuOh^gy%©kNsa{d.vjkbOisOh^]OyqV d$pw »w m¾ _
pZaRacVQek=bk^Xyev'TsskXvv
yd y%©kdQekp%dQ'[]ObT`aik^uyKsT=y%Oid$^v
_
z]ZyUaikT=bkuv"Z^Tpqp%ksWyk[Py%©k©]OR|©»<TpqpqOR^mOyqVª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^ ?vekkKTdaikWyqy%Ok=y
Taqº
_
¾¾ -º9« kuv<Ocyky%©kORQQjdz$TWzaikN[]O¦v&yT^skpqQedMy%©kª'^gzOR^[]OR^m|4v<Oyk
_
y%©kMZyT^uyevw » m¾ T^[
w »w4m¾m
_
sdkW¿Qekuvvjk[Ocy%©Nw
l L yzd]y%©xv&y%Qed^]|acV[ks`QekTuvjkª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^\º ¼ ©kNT`MaROyqZ\[kuv(d$py%©k
QekaiTWy%OcbkNsWZQ<Qjk^uyUMkTXv&ZQek[TWyK»<Mf OR^gy%©kQekuvek`^skNdpUº{ ª'^OR^gy%©kzTWy%© <ºc¾
l
ºc]
_
^xT`^[
º{ ºc
_
^,½
_
QekuvksWy%Ob$kaV 'TQekNsd$MT`QeTWza{kyd y%©T=ydpy%©kv%y%Qed$^m| MgZyT^uyev ?vekk ¼ TWzaik=ºX<^p%Ts=y
_
MgZyTWy%Oid^v'T=y"dv<Ocy%Oid$^ w »w4m¾©TWb$kNTaRQekT[uVgz$kk^xv©d^gyd©TWb$kaikOy%Qjd$OisNk`pqp%ksWyev'd^|TWy%OR^m|
~s©]^k||k^uzmZQ<|kQ'T^[Lves©kQ
_
¾¾ _
vkQ<MOh^kd]yk^uy%OiT=y%Oid$^ T^[Qed]yd$^POR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^ Tuv<©mOT`|OkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ ¼ QeTWVm^k`aROv'kWyKTa£º
_
¾¾ Xª'©k^m|xk=yT`aqº
_
¾¾¾'T^[gª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^ ¼ QjTWVm^kaRO¦v'kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ =º
¨ d sT^ d$^kN[]Ov&y%OR^m|]ZOv<© TMgZyTWy%Oid^OR^gy%©kª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOykpqQedM T<QekMd]yk'd^k&Nk`Mdyk
MgZyTWy%Oid^vv©d]Zai[^d^»?vksORpqO{sTaRaV Tpqp%ks=y2y%©kzOR^[]OR^]|*dpUdy%©kQaROR|T^[v'TsWy%Oh^]|*d$^P|TWy%OR^]|
_
P©kQekTuv'T
MgZyTWy%Oid^dp.y%©kª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOyk©TXv'TMgZ\s©©mOR|©k`QQedz$TWzOhaROyqV d$pv<ksORpqOisT`aRaV Tpqp%ksWy%OR^m|ª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^
<kW¿sk]y
_
dpUsd]ZQvek
_
ORpy%©kMZyTWyk[QekuvOi[uZ\kNTavjdBTQ&y%O{sORTWykuvKOR^gy%©k|T=y%OR^]|Mks`©T^mOv<M -ºu<^ d$Qe[k`Q"yd ykuv%y
y%©kgv<ksORpqOisOcyqVp%dQ"ª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^d$py%©kp%dZQ v%y%Qed$^m| MgZyTWy%Oid^v'T`^[d$pvjkWbkQjTa <Md[kQeTWykMgZyT=y%Oid$^v
y%©TWyU©T[Pz$kk^O{[k^uy%ORpqO{k[
_
kNsdMTQek[Py%©kNkpqp%ksWyev(d$py%©kXvekMgZyTWy%O{d$^vOcy%©gy%©dvekNdpyd <QekMd]yk
MgZyTWy%Oid^v ¦w » m¾ T`^[Nw »w4m¾m 'd$^*vekWb$kQeTa|TWy%Oh^]|Md[uZaiTWy%Oid^v'dpw «L3Qeksk]ydQv`§uO
y%©kNTsWy%OcbTWy%Oid^gzmVgy%©kyd*T|d$^mOv&yevK|aZyTMTWykNT`^[|aVsOR^k ]OhO"y%©kOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^gz]V kW¿my%QeTskahaZaiTQQed]yd^v
T^[ORORO"y%©kbdayT|k»&OR^[k`k^[k^XyUOR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^gzmVk=¿]y%QeTskaRaZaiT`QwBO "!Oid^v-º
« dvek»&Qjkuv<d^vjkNsWZQ&bkXvp%d$Q|acZyTMTWykNT^[|aVsOR^k kQekNd]z]yT`OR^k[gZ^[kQ"ª'^»&pqQjkkNsd^[]Oy%Oid^vKp%d$Q
Qeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|w yKT^[Nw
l L y'v&ZzmZ^]Oyev
_
Qeksk]ydQv'sd^uyTOh^]OR^m|gw gyKT^[d$^kNd$py%©k
w
l
L3MgZyT^Xyev"¨L ¨ l
~
l
½½u l
o T^[ } l
~ T^[ Qjksk]ydQv'sd^uyT`OR^]OR^m|*kOy%©k`Qw »
m¾d$Qw »w4m¾m T^[Nw
l L y³º ¼ TWza{k<<v<©d*v"y%©kTQeTMk=ykQv'dpUktuZ\TWy%Oid^½gZvek[gydpqOyy%©k
sWZQ&bkXv ?vekk } ¿kQ<ORMk`^uyTa]UQedsk[uZQekXv=ºXL sd$MPTQ<Ovjd$^POy%©PORai[gyqVmkgv<©d*v^d v<Oh|^]ORpqOisT^uybT`Q<OiTWy%Oid^OR^
y%©kpqOyqy%OR^m|TQeTMk=ykQv'dpy%©kpqOb$kw
l
L3MgZyT^Xyev=ºX<^sd^uy%QeTXv&yy%©ky d <Qek`Mdyk 2w MgZyT^uyevK©TWb$kNT
»&p%d$a{[ |QjkTWykQ'TpqpqOh^]OyqVPp%d$Q"z$dy%©P|aVsOR^kNT`^[|aZyTMT=ykQekaiTWy%OcbkydPORai[»qyqV]kmº
} ¿]y%QjTskaRacZaiTQQed]yd$^vOR^gy%©k©uVv<O{d$aid|OisT`asd$^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^QeT^m|k <TQed]Z^[]¨ ©TWb$kzkk^
v<©dP^gydBOR^m©]OzOy\w «L3Qeksk]ydQv"bO{TNTN[ksQekTXvekOR^gy%©kORQ'dk^Qed]zT=zORaROcyqV ¼ QeTWVm^kaROv'T`^[ZaRai»<T^[uV
_
¾¾=º9 kuvOi[uZ\kuvpqQjd$M []ORpqp%k`Qek^uyUTQ%yev'd$py%©kNkW¿]y%QeTskaRaZa{TQ'[d$M TOR^v(d$pw v%Zz]Z^]Ocyev'TkTQ"ydzk
OR^ub$d$ab$k[OR^gy%©mOvMd[uZaiTWy%Oid^ ?vjkk«POR^]|aik[]OR^kNkWyKTa£º
_
¾¾¾=ºUQedyd^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^sWZQ&b$kuv'd]z]yTOh^k[pqQedM
Qeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|*kTs© d$py%©kv%y%Qed^]| w
l
L3MgZyT^Xyev ¨PL _ ¨ l
~
_ l
½½u T^[ } l
~k`Qek
^d]y"MZ\s©[]ORpqp%kQjk^uy
_
ORpUTWyKTaRa
_
pqQedMy%©dvekNdp ORa{[PyqVmkQeksk]ydQv SOh|º$XL=ºX<^sd$^Xy%QeTuv&y
_
w »m¾
T^[Nw »¦w m¾m MgZyTWy%Oid^vKOR^[uZ\sk[BTgvOR|^]OhpqOisT^Xy"Oh^sQekTuvekOR^PQedyd^e T^[Bp%dai[
_
QekuvksWy%Ob$kaV
_
SOR|ºXL=º ¼ ©]QjkkNd$py%©kykuv&yk[ <Md[kQeT=ykw
l
L3MgZyT^Xyev ¨P
l L _ « l L T^[ ½ ~v<©d k[Qed]yd$^
OR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^s=ZQ&bkuvUy%©TWy kQekOR^[]Ov&y%OR^m|]ZOv<©TWza{kpqQed$My%©TWyKd$p PORai[gyqVmkQeksk`]yd$Qv &^d]y'v<©dP^=º¨d kWbkQ
_
y%©kMgZyTWy%O{d$^Nw
l
L» l
o OR^[uZ\sk[T
l
p%d$a{[B[ksQekTuvjkOR^Qed]yd^e SOR|ºXL=º
} ¿]y%QjTskaRacZaiTQwO !O{d$^v
_
OR^T[[]Oy%O{d$^gydOR^[uZ\s`OR^]|*TbdayT|k»<[kk^[k^uyza{ds b$kQ&V*v<ORMOhaiTQ"yd y%©TWy
d$p | _
TavjdBOR^m©]OzOyUOR^Tb$d$ayT`|k»&OR^[kk^[k`^uyUMT^m^kQvjkWbkQjTaQeksdMgzOR^T^Xy\w «L3Qeksk]yd$Qv%Zz]yqVmkuv
y%©dvekNsd^uyT`OR^]OR^m|w
l L _ w
l µ d$Qw
l « v&ZzmZ^]Oyev uKTdaikWyqy%OT`^[Nwxk=Vuyd^
_
MT^XZvesQOR]yUOR^QekT`QeTWy%Oid^=º
Lvp%d$QQjdyd^v
_
wOOR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^ sWZQ&bkXv'd$pQeksk]ydQv'sd^uyTOh^]OR^m| y%©kv&y%Qed^]| w
l L MZyT^uyev'[]O{[ ^dy
v<OR|^mORpqOisT^Xy%aV []ORpqp%kQpqQedMy%©TWyKdp ORa{[PyqVmkQeksk]ydQv=Gp%dQw
l
LȬPL T^[Nw
l
LȬ l
~
_
d$^maV d$^k
sd$^sk^Xy%QeTWy%Oid^dp2^mOis ka Tuv"ykXv&yk[ $ 'T^[gy%©kQekaiTWy%OcbkNsWZQ<Qjk^uyev kQekNs`aid.vjkyd y%©TWyKd$p PORai[gyqVmk
Qeksk]ydQvW§]º
l
ºc½
_
^¢½ p%dQ"¨PLºR ºc]
_
^¢½p%d$Q"¨
l
~ ºR
l
ºc
_ ^ Dp%dQORa{[
yqV]k0Kºu^sd^uy%QeTuv%yKT|TOR^
_
z$dy%©Nw » m¾ T^[Nw »w4m¾m MZyTWy%Oid^vOR^[uZ\sk[Tgp%d$a{[ Oh^sQekTuvekOR^
wBOeº ¼ ©k<Md[kQeTWyk 2w
l
L3MgZyT^uy
l
o[]O{[ ^dyKTpqp%ksWy\wBOvjk^vOy%ObOcyqV POy%© wBO
_
y%©k
QekaiTWy%OcbkNsWZQ<Qjk^uy Tuv'ºR º _
^ =º
UQek=bOid]Zvv&yqZ\[]O{kuv CORaRaROiT`Mxv
_
¾¾©k^kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ uKTdaikWyqy%Ok=yT`aqº
_
¾¾ ¼ QjTWVm^kaRO¦v'kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ ©TWb$kgv<©dP^gy%©TWyy%©kbdayT|k»&Oh^[kk^[k^uyUOR^m©]OzOy%Oid^dpw¬«PL3Qeksk`]yd$QvUz]V kW¿]y%QeTskaRaZa{TQ"ª'^
[kk^[v(d$^gy%©kgv&ZzmyqV]kNdpy%©kw
l
v%Zz]Z^mOyUQekuvek`^uy
_
Oy%©PQeksk]ydQv'sd$^XyTOR^]Oh^]|w
l L v&ZzmZ^]OyevK©TWbOR^]|
TQekMTQTWzaVP©]Oh|©TTQek`^uyKTpqpqOR^mOyqVp%dQ"ª'^ &j T`QedZ^[
l
^X=º ¼ ©]Ov dQ*TORMk[TWyUOi[k`^uy%ORpVmOR^m| y%©k
Md$a{ksWZaiTQ'[k=ykQ<MOR^T^uyev(d$py%©k©mOR|©TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOyk]ºmoOcbk^gy%©kbdayT|k»%OR^[kk`^[k^skNT^[gy%©k
v&Zz]Z^mOy'v<ks`ORpqOisOyqV dp.y%©kª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^
_
k©XV]d]y%©kXv<ORYXk[Py%©TWyy%©k©mOR|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVª'^gzOR^[]OR^]|4vOykgv<©dZai[
zkaidsTWyk[OR^ T^kW¿my%QeTskahaZaiTQ'[dMTOR^ d$py%©kw
l L v&Zz]Z^mOy
_
T^[OR^[kk[p%dZ^[gy%©TWyy%©kQjkuvek^skNdp.y%©k
n'<fµK»&aROkN[d$MT`OR^dpw
l
L3OvQektuZOhQek[T^[xv%ZpqpqOisOik^Xyydxsd^]p%kQ©mOR|©TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^gyd
Qeksk]ydQv'k=¿Qekuv³v<OR^m|*s©]ORM kQ<Oisw
l
LIiw
l
0v&ZzmZ^]Oyev-º ¼ ©]O¦v
_
sd$MzOR^k[Oy%©y%©kp%TsWyy%©TWyK[kaikWy%Oid^dp
y%©]Ov'[dMTOh^[dkXv^d]yUQekWbk`^uyKkW¿QjkuvvOid$^ d$ppZ^s=y%Oid$^TaQeksk]yd$Q³v ?vekkSOR|º
l _
v%y%Qek^m|]y%©k^v"y%©k
Qed$dveT`a]y%©TWyy%©kw*»ykQMOR^T`aQek|Oid^Qeksk[]OR^]|y%©kNT|d$^mOv&yzOR^[]OR^m|*[d$MT`OR^sd^v%y%OyqZykuv'TMd[uZaiTQ
[d$MT`OR^OR^Xbdabk[OR^P|TWy%OR^]|Md[uZaiTWy%O{d$^ ©mQ'kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾] Q&Z*kWyKTaqº
_
¾¾ ]fORaRa{TQ<QedkakWyKTaqº
_
¾¾
Tuv%Z dxkWyKTaqº
_
¾¾¾=ºXL dOR^Xy"MZyT|k^kXv<OvvjsT^gy%©mQed]Z|©gy%©kn'<fNµK»&aROkN[dMTOR^ d$pw
l L Tahaid k[
Zv"ydBOi[k`^uy%ORpV*vekWb$kQeTaQjkuv<Oi[uZ\kXv"y%©TWy
_
P©k^MZyTWyk[
_
vekWb$kQekaV Tpqp%ks=yk[©]OR|©T`pqpqOR^]OyqVª'^OR^m©]OzOy%Oid^º ¼ ©k
TMaROyqZ\[kNT`^[xv<ks`ORpqOisOyqV dp.y%©kNkpqp%ksWyev(d$pOR^[]ObOi[uZ\T`ad$OR^XyUMgZyTWy%Oid^v'd^gy%©kª'^OR^]©mOzOcy%Oid$^Pp%TWbdQp%dZQ
Qekuv<O{[uZ\kuv
_
yd©]Ov%y%Oi[]OR^kuv ¨P*T^[g¨
l _
TacVvOR^k
l
½½'T^[T|aZyTM TWyk } l
'Tuv"zk`OR^]|*saidvek`aV
TuvvjdsO{TWyk[Ocy%©gy%©k©mOR|©TpqpqOR^mOyqVª'^OR^]©mOzOcyd$Q&V*v<Ocyk]ºuLN^dy%©kQv&yqZ\[uV
_
]ZzaRO¦v<©k[ P©]Ohaiky%©]OvdQ TXvOR^
Qed$|Qjkuvv ©d$OT`^[gn'OR]yd^
_
¾¾¾
_
T`aRQekT[uVPQedd.vjk[gy%©TWyKd^kNdpy%©kuvjkQekuv<O{[uZ\kuv
_
w
l
LȬP
_
yd$|kWy%©kQ
Oy%© w
l
L» ¨P
l
sd$^v&y%OyqZykT`Q&yKd$py%©k©mOR|©TpqpqOh^]OyqVª'^gzOh^[]OR^m| vOyk]ºXLv'[]OvjsWZvvjk[gzkaid qy%©]ORQe[xvjksWy%Oid^
d$p«POvesWZv³v<Oid^
_
kNT|QekkNd^gy%©mOvQedd.vjTap%dQw
l
LȬP
_
zmZyUQed$dvekNT`^d]y%©kQOR^XykQ<Qek=yTWy%Oid^p%d$Q"y%©k
Qed$a{kNd$pw
l
L»q¨
l º
78D@EM$9#M7"0/ 9 4 L( /45450454J M)(,/4 *,'9# $/ 12
!3'5( 45-4
} bk`^gy%©d]Z|©xvek=bkQeT`aMgZyTWy%Oid^vOh^gy%©kw
l L w*» ykQMOR^T`akQjkNTWzaikyd4v<©mORpyª'^TpqpqOR^mOyqVgzmV
vekWb$kQeTadQe[kQv(d$pMT|^mOyqZ\[k
_
^d^kNdpy%©kM kQekNTWzaikydxsd$Ma{kWykaV kaRORMPOR^TWykb$d$acyT|k»&OR^[kk^[k^uyª'^
OR^]©mOzOy%O{d$^\º ¼ ©kp%d]ZQMdv&yKkpqp%ksWy%OcbkMgZyTWy%O{d$^vk`QekNd$^maV TWzaikyd4v<©mORpyy%©kª'^e OR^Xyd y%©kaid $