Test du score pour l'exploration de modèles complexes: Application à la modélisation dynamique du VIH.

Texte intégral

(1)Test du score pour l’exploration de modèles complexes: Application à la modélisation dynamique du VIH. Julia Drylewicz, Daniel Commenges, Rodolphe Thiébaut. To cite this version: Julia Drylewicz, Daniel Commenges, Rodolphe Thiébaut. Test du score pour l’exploration de modèles complexes: Application à la modélisation dynamique du VIH.. 41èmes Journées de Statistique, SFdS, Bordeaux, 2009, Bordeaux, France, France. �inria-00386586�. HAL Id: inria-00386586 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00386586 Submitted on 22 May 2009. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5) !

(6) " # $%

(7) #&'.

(8) ($)''+*,-../0 12#!

(9) " 3 4 $%

(10) #5./! !

(11) " 67"8($%!9 :<;(= >@?BADCDEFHGJIKAML0N4CDO0P@QRFETSBCDL0AVUWYX.XZL0SB[YL!\^]%_^WK`BWYAMaBbBL/cdbBCMe!fgE@?ih jlknmBoqp4rts2uwvyxBz|{ }~g}2K}/p4}l lg} lg}HoVKD@}2}q4@D!g}l uw~g@}V /m}@D}~ JK}@T @s¡!¢¤£¥R}/¦Vlm§@¨@~@sª©©i«izT£¬JK}@T l}K}JTs J@~¤ l} 1® ¯K°<±w²¯´³7FETSB\AµEX.Wi`¶e!ADCM\EThCDWYS#`BL0\.\IK\Jh·0XZL0\fBCDWYAMWY[YCM¸K?¶L!\!Q`BL!\X.Wi`B·0ADL0\¬`BL|aBAM?B\¬L!S a¶AD?B\dO0WYXZa¶ADL¹iL0\d\WYSh^`Be0º@L!AMWYaBae!\!» ¼¾½¿L0\JhCDXZEThCMWYS`BL0\4agE@GETXZ·hGL0\d`BL/hL0AXZWK`B·0ADLCMXZaBAMCD¸y?BLn`BL!\ hL!X.aB\H`¶LO<ETADO!?¶AD\âgE@GJÀÁW@CD\4ADWYS¶[Y\!»^ÂnS[YGE@S¶`SBWYXfBGL`BLX.WK`B·!AML!\^L!\JhÃL¹iaBAMWYGL0GnCMSBO!AM?gE@Shn`BL!\ LÄ¤Lh\HE@ADe!EThWYCMGL0\nETCDSB\JCw¸y?BL2`BL!\^ºTE@GCDE@fBADL0\4L¹iaBADCMO<EThCMº@L!\^\?BGÂDL0\n`BC¨Ä¤e0GL0Syh\HagETGE@X.·0hGL!\0»^¼VL'hL0\Jh `¶?.\JO!WYGJLda§L0?¶h<Q`BE@SB\ÅO0LdO!WYShL¥¹KhL@QKÆ0hGLÇ?ihCDAMLaWY?BGÅCMSBO!AM?BGL`BLÇSBWY?iºYL!AMADL0\Åº@ETGCµETfBADL0\`gE@S¶\¾ADLX.WKìÈ ·0ADLT» UL!aL!SB`gETSyh!QÅA½ÉbIKa§W@hbB·!\JLSy?BAMADL`B?hL!\Jha§L0?¶h2Æ0hGJLO0WYXZa¶ADL¹iLTQÊ`B?ÃtADE aBGJe!\JL!SBO0L1`½ÉL0Ä§L0h\ ETADe<EhWYCMGL!\V`gETSB\ÊAML X.WK`B·!AML¾L0hÅCMA\L a§L0?¶he0[E@AML!X.L!Shw¸K?¶LAµE4XZEThGJCDO!Lq`½ÉCDSiÀÁWYGXZEThCMWYS/SBLªaB?BCM\\L agE@\ ÆhGJLÔ!E@ADO0?BADe0L4L0hª¸y?½¿?¶SBLHETaBaBGW<¹iCDXZEThCDWYS¬fBE@\e0Ln\J?BGqADL!\q\JO!WYGJL!\ª\WYC¨hqSBe!O0L!\\E@CDGJL@»qË^WY?B\qaBGW@a§WY\JWYSB\ A½¿?ihCDAMCD\EThCMWYS`BLO!L0\^hL!\h\H`¶?t\JO!WYGJL2`gETSB\nAML'O!WYShL¥¹KhL`¶LADE.X.WK`Be!AMCD\EhCDW@S`¶IKSgE@X.CD¸y?BL`B?8ÌÍÏÎ ÃagE@GhCDGq`BL^\JIK\h·!X.L!\`½¿e0¸y?gEThCMWYSB\ª`BCMÄ§e!GJL!ShCML!AMADL!\0»ÅË^WY?B\S¶WY?B\ªCDShe0GL!\J\WYS¶\dE@?i¹.\hlEThCD\JhCD¸y?BL0\ `B? hL!\hH`B?t\O0WYGLa§W@?BGdhL!\hL0GnA½¿LÄ¤Lhn`¶LºTE@GJCµE@fBAML!\dL¥¹¶a¶ADCDO!EThC¨ºYL0\^LhHADE¬º@ETGCµETSBO!L/`½ÉL0Ä§L0h\E@AMe<EThWYCDGJL!\0» ÐwWY?BGOlbgETO!?BS7`BL|O!L0\¬hL0\Jh\SBW@?B\e0h?B`BCDW@SB\¬ADL0?BG¬L0GGL0?BG`BL1hIKaLÑ8E@CDSB\JÇy?BL8ADL0?BGa¶?BCD\J\E@SBO0L@» Ë^WY?B\4E@a¶aBADCM¸K?¶WYSB\ÇO0L!\dhL0\Jh\4ET?i¹|agETGE@X.·0hGL!\d`¤½¿?BS8X.Wi`¶·!ADLn`BL/A½ÉCDShL!GETO0hCMWYS1L0SyhGL/AMLHÌÍÏÎ´Lh4ADL \IK\Jh·0XZLCMXZX¬?¶SBCMhE@CDGJLL0\JhCDX.e!\/\?¶G/?BSÒJL!? `BL`BWYS¶SBe!L0\`¶LagEThCML!Sh\/CMS¶ÀÁL!Ohe0\/agE@GAMLÌÍÏÎ)CM\\? `¶LADEUWYADADE@fWYGEThCDWYS1UÓ/ÔBUÓHFÕd» ÖØ×gÙÚ°ÛÜÁ¯i°Z³/cÊL0\Jh4`B?8\O0WYGLTQBbBWYX.WY[Ye0SBe!C¨heTQ¶L0Ä§L0h\4E@ADe!EThW@CDGL0\!QK`BCD\hGJCDfB?¶hCDWYSE@\JIKX.a¶hWThCD¸y?BLTQ X.WK`B·!AML`¶IKSgE@X.CD¸y?BL Ý1Þ °0ÙßÚàgÛ@Ù³cwWáX.Wi`¶L!AªfBCDWYAMWY[YCMO\JIK\JhL!X.\!QqXZW@GL1ETSB`X.WYGLZO!WYX.aBADL¥¹âXZWK`BL!AM\ETGL`¶L0ºYL0A¨È W@a§L0`»¾ÐETGE@X.L0hL!G\L!\JhCDXZEThCMWYS¬W@ÀR\J?BOlb.XZWK`BL!AM\O!E@Sf§LÇº@L!GJIhCDX.LÈãO!WYS¶\?BX.CDSB[¶»äÓåADW@hW@ÀXZWK`BL!AM\ CMSBO!AM?B`BCMSB[GE@SB`BWYX-LÄ¤L0O0h\4ETSB`|L¹iaBADE@SgEThWYGJIºTE@GCDE@fBAML!\ªXE<I.f§LHL¹iaBADW@GL!`¤»¾ÍS1hbBCM\O!W@SyhL¹Kh<QihbBL \JO!WYGJL^hL!\h\ªO<E@S.f§L4?B\JL0ÀÁ?BARCMS.W@G`BL0GqhW2CMSBO!AM?B`BLdSBLNæºTE@GCDE@fBAML!\¾CDShbBL4XZWK`BL!A»Î^WNLºYL!G0QihbBLnSy?BAMA bIKaW@hbBL0\CM\ O!E@SZfLdO!W@XZaBAML¹¬`B?BL4hW'GE@S¶`BWYX)LÄ¤L0O0h\ E@SB`C¨hqXE<I¬bBE@aBaL!ShbgEThqhbBL4CDS¶ÀÁWYGJXEhCDW@S XZEThGC¨¹|O<E@SBS¶W@hfLO0WYXZa¶?¶hL0È@SBÈTSáE@aBa¶GW<¹iCDXZEThCMWYStfBE@\L0`áWYShbBL\JO!WYGJL!\CM\nSBL0O!L0\\ETGJIY»nçL a¶GWYaWY\LnhW?B\JL/\O!W@GLhL0\Jh\dCDShbBLO!W@SyhL¹Kh4W@ÀÊÎnÍãÌ´`¶IKSgE@X.CDO!\XZWK`BL!AM\!»çâLL¥¹BETXZCMSBLnhbBL/\O0WYGL hL!\h2\hlEThCD\hCDO0\HÀÁWYGhL!\JhCDSB[|hbBLL0Ä§L!Oh2WTÀL¥¹¶a¶AµE@SgEhWYGIºTE@GCDE@fBAML!\/E@S¶` hbBL¬ºTE@GCDE@SBO0LW@ÀGE@SB`BW@X LÄ¤L0O0h\4E@SB`N L\Jh?B`¶I.hbBLnhIiaLÍqL!GJGWYGE@SB`hbBLH\hlEThCD\hCDO!E@Aa§WN L!GÇW@À¤hbBCM\\O0WYGLnhL!\hd\JhEThCM\JhCDO!\0» çâLZE@aBaBAÏhb¶LZ\JO!WYGJL.hL!\Jh\hW hbBL.L!\JhCDXZEThL0\/WYf¶hE@CDSBL0`#ÀÁGJWYX+E8GL!E@A¾`gEThE@\Lh2WTÀdÎnÍãÌèCMS¶ÀÁL!OhL!` aBEThCML!Sh\dÀÁGW@Xéhb¶LUÓÔBUÓFHÕêUW@ADAµETf§WYGEThCMWYS» Ñ.

(12) ×ßw°³ ÔiO!WYGJL¬hL0\Jh<Qäb¶WYXZW@[YL!SBL0CMhI@QGE@S¶`BWYX. SBE@XZCMO<E@A§XZWK`BL0A. L0Ä§L!O0h\!QwE@\IiX.a¶hW@hCMO¬`BCD\hGJCDfB?¶hCDWYS¤Q§`¶IÈ.

(13) "! #$&%' ()! %' +* . ,.-/,. 0)13254&687:9;1=<84.<>9;?;<8@:A.?CBD1E25?GFIHJ1. QyWYSZO!WYSB\JCD`B·0GL^?BSX.WK`B·!AML^¸y?BC`BWYS¶SBLnADE`¶CD\JhGCMfB?¶hCMWYS`B?.ºYL!OhL0?BG ÐwWY?BGª?BS1\J?ÒJL0h `¤½¿WYf¶\L!GºTEThCMWYSB\ iYK i == 1,(Y...,, jnL = 1, . . . , n ) L0S#hL!GJXZL`BLagETGE@X.·0hGL!\/CMSB`BC¨ºiCM`B?BL0AD\ ξ = (ξ , l = Q@L!?K¹KÈãXZÆ0XZL0\ÅX.Wi`Be0ADCM\e!\ÊagE@G \WY?¶\¾AµE^ÀÁW@GX.LADCMSBe<ETCDGLNM Q 1, . . . , p) WPO φ L0\Jh/A½¿CMShL!GJO!L0a¶h<Q ω L!\hA½Ée!O!E@GJhÈãhξ˜IKa=L`BψL2(ξA½ÉL0)Ä§L0hHE@ADe!EThWYCMGLTQ z L0\Jh?¶SºYξ˜L0O0=hL0?BφG+ω `BLºTuE@G+zCDE@fBβADL0\ L¥¹iaBADCMO<EThCMºYL0\ZaWY?BG.ADL lÈCM·!X.L|agE@GETXZ·hGLT» ¼äL!\ β \JWYSh1AML!\.L0Ä§L0h\#Q¶¹iL!\1LhW@S \?¶aBa§W@\L u ∼ QgRW O u = (u , l = 1, . . . , p) L0\JhÂDLº@L!OhL!?¶GnCMSB`BCMºKCM`B?BL!A¤`BL!\4L0Ä§L0h\Ê@ADe!EThWYCMGL0\!».SS8SBW@hL N (0, I ) ADL0\dagE@GE@XZ·hGJL!\4`B?8XZWK`B·0ADL@Q¶AD?BC ÈX.Æ!X.LnSBWThe (P θ )θ » θ = (φ , ω , β , l = 1, . . . , p) ÐwWY?BGd?BS8\?ÚÒJL0h i Q¶AµE2ºKGETCD\L0X¬fBADE@SBO!LH`BL!\dWYf¶\L!GºTEThCMWYSB\ÇO0WYSB`BC¨hCDW@SBSBL!AMADL0XZL0SyhE@?i¹1L0Ä§L0h\4E@ADe!EÈ hWYCDGJL!\¬L0\JhSBWThe!L Lθ (Y |u) Qq¸y?gE@S¶` u aBGJL!SBÀDEtºTE@ADL0?BG u »¼VEáADW@[@ºKGE@CM\L!XfBAµE@S¶O!LaWY?BGADL \J?ÒJL0h i L!\hnE@ADWYGJT\ M Z i. ij. i. i. i l. l. i l. l. i l. i l. l. i l l. i l. l. i. l. i. p l. l. i l. l. ∈Θ. Yi |ui. i. i. Lθ i = log. U. Lθ Yi |ui (Yi |u)φ(u)du. WPO φ L0\JhÂµE¬`BL0SB\C¨he'`½É?BSBLADWYC§SBWYGJXE@AMLX¬?BA¨hC¨º@ETGCDe0L ,.-WV. i l l. p. N (0, Ip ). »qË^WY?B\4SBW@hWYSB\. L=. n P Lθ i. ». i=1. XY1:Z[H\68]"Z_^`4aBD1cb4.]dBfeA.Bg?;A.h89;1i1`F&bj9;?;^ÀkHJ?Ce.1. Ë^WY?B\ºYW@?BADWYS¶\ hL!\hL!G A½¿LÄ¤Lh a§WY\J\CMfBADL(`½É?BSBL(ºTE@GJCµE@fBAMLL¹iaBAMCDO!EThC¨ºYL z \?¶G#AML(agE@GE@XZ·hGJL ξ »q¼¾½¿bIKa§WThbB·0\LSK?¶ADADL H L!\J&h l β = 0lH¸y?BCä`B'e QgSBCMh4?¶St\JWY?B\ÈãXZWK`B·0ADL (P θ )θ QgWRO K l =L!\1,h2..., pL AML\WY?¶\ÈL0SB\L0X¬fBAMLZ`BL Θ hL0A¾¸K?¶L β = 0 »¼äL.\JO!WYGJL`BL β Q U (θ) QVL!\Jh | »UW@XZX.L Θ P Q¾L!S7E@aBaBAMCD¸y?gE@ShADLhbBe!WYGJ·!X.L|ADCMXZC¨hLO!L0SyhGE@AQ¾WYS(WYf¶hCDL0Syh¬¸K?¶L \?¶CMh √ U U = ET\JIKXZaihW@hCD¸y?BL!X.L!Sh?BSBLAMWYC¾SBWYGJXETADL@m» SSS¶W@hL θˆ A½ÉL!\hCMXEThL!?BG'`B?XE¹iCMX¬?BX+`BL.ºiGE@CD\JL!XÈ f¶AµE@SBO0LZ`¶L θ aWY?BG (P θ )θ »tÔiC H L!\Jh2ºKGE@CML@QO0L0hL!\JhCDXZEThL0?BG'L!\h¬O!W@SB\CM\JhlETSyha§W@?BG θ L0h L0S E@aBaBAMCD¸y?gE@ShÇAMdL lO0WYShCMSK?¶WY?B\ÇXZE@aBaBCMSB[2hbBL!W@GL!nX llQiWYS8E¬AµE2XZÆ0XZL`¶CD\JhGCMfB?¶hCMWYS1ET\JIKXZaihW@hCD¸y?BL aWY?BGdADE\JhlEhCD\hCM¸K?¶L/`B? hL!\hn`¶?t\JO!WYGJL#M ˆ ) U (θ S=q K ÑY»¨Ñ L i l. 0. l. 0. · βl. l. n. i=1. i l. l. i βl. · βl. ∂L ∂βl θ Uβl (θ∗ ). ∈Θ0. var Uβ· (θ∗ ) l. 0. ∗. ∈Θ0. 0. ∗. · βl. WPO. ˆ0) var d Uβ· l (θ. 0. ˆ0) var d Uβ· l (θ. L!\h^?BStL0\JhCDXZEThL0?BGdO!WYS¶\CD\hlE@Sh^`BL o. ˆ0) var Uβ· l (θ. ».

(14) ä¼ L!\ª\O0WYGL0\ U (θˆ ) \W@Syh O<ETADO!?¶ADe!\¾ÀE@O0CDAML!X.L!ShqÃ'agE@GJhCDG¾`BL0\ \JO!WYGJL!\ WYf¶hL0Sy?B\ `¶?BGE@Sh AµE/aBGJWiO0eÈ `¶?BGL.`½ÉWYa¶hCMXZCM\EThCDWYS¤» SSE U (θˆ ) = z U (θˆ ) a¶?BCD\J¸K?¶LA½¿E@AM[YWYGC¨hbBX.L2E O!E@ADO0?BADeADL[@GE@`BC È L0Sh¬`BL.AµE8ADWY[TºiGE@CD\JL!X¬f¶AµE@SBO0L.Ã OlbgET¸K?¶L1CMhe!GEhCDW@SQVADL!\ U (θˆ )(i = 1, . . . , n) \WYShADL!\'ºTE@ADL0?BG\ W@f¶hL0SK?¶L!\nÃ.ADE¬`BL!GJSBCD·0GL'CMhe!GEhCDW@S» ¼VEºTE@GJCµE@S¶O!L4`B?\JO!WYGJL U (θˆ ) \W@?B\ H a§L0?¶hÆhGJLHE@\IKXZa¶hW@hCM¸y?BL!X.L!Sh `Be0hL!GX.CDS¶e!L^Ã2agETGJhCMG `¶L#ADEXEhGCMO!Lá`¤½¿CMS¶ÀÁWYGXZEThCDWYS K UW<¹ L0htÎnCMS yADLIYQÑ L » FE@SB\8AML!\8XZWK`B·0ADL!\O!WYX.aBADL¥¹iL!\!QHAµE Î^L!\J\CDL0SBSBL^SBL4a§L0?¶hªagE@\¾hW@?ÒJWY?BGJ\ªÆhGJLÔ!E@ADO0?BADe0LdL0hª?BS.L!\hCDXZEThL!?BG¾`BL4ADE/ºTE@GJCµE@S¶O!Ld`B?.\O0WYGL4aL!?¶h ÆhGJL?ihCDAMCD\Je K ?BL!`ÚÒdLhHETA»¨Q o

(15)

(16) L M i βl. 0. i βl. 0. i l. i φl. 0. i φl. · βl. 0. 0. ˆ0) = var d Uβ· l (θ. ,.-. 0. XY1:Z[H\68]"Z_^`4aBD136d4 254.@:<d@:?CHJ@. n X. 2. ˆ0) Uβi l (θ. i=1. ^Ë WY?B\dºYW@?BADWYS¶\ÇhL!\hL0GÂDE¬aBGe0\L0SBO!L`½É?BStLÄ¤LhÊ@ADe!EThW@CDGLn\?BG4AMLagE@GE@XZ·hGJL l »q¼¾½ÉbIiaW@hbB·!\JL2Sy?BAMADL L!\Jh l ω = 0l»1Õ¾SS¶WY?B\fgE@\ETSyh2\?¶G2ADE8ÀÁWYGJXZL[@e!SBe0GE@AMLZ`B?#hL0\Jh2`B?\JO!WYGJLZ`½ÉbBWYX.WY[Ye0SBe!C¨he H `¶e0ºYL0ADWYa¶a§e/agETG4UWYX.XZL0SB[YL!\L0h^>YE@O0¸yXZCMSiÈ E@`B`gE K Ñ L QKAµE\hlEThCD\hCD¸y?BLH`B?1hL0\Jh4`B?8\O0WYGL/\JWY?B\ L!\Jh T = U W U−tr(Iˆ W ) QTPW O U L!\hAML¾ºYL!OhL0?BGÅ`BL0\ U = H | E<º@L!O ε = ω u Q Iˆ L!\hADEXZEThGJCDO0Ld`½¿e0ADe0XZL0Syh\ − 0 L h ! L \ h D A ' E Z X T E h G D C 0 O 4 L B ` n L 0 O Y W G J G e!ADEÈ (θˆ ) W hCDWYS8`BL u X.WYCDSB\AµEXEhGCMO!LCM`BL!ShCMheT» ¼äL!\/\JO!WYGJL!\ U \JWYSh'O<E@AMO!?BAMe!\/E<º@L!O M »FETSB\/ADL¬O!E@\/RW O | | = ET?BO!?BS7L0Ä§L0h.ETADe<EhWYCMGLS¤½¿L0\Jh.aBGe0\L0SyhZ\W@?B\ H QªADEáXEhGCMO!L Iˆ L0\Jh.`BCµET[YWYSgE@AMLLh Tr(Iˆ W ) = »7FE@SB\ADL0\O<E@\O!W@XZaBAML¹iL!\ K aBGe0\L!S¶O!L `½¿LÄ¤Lh\ZE@ADe!EThW@CDGL0\¬\W@?B\ H L Q SBW@?B\`BL0º@WYSB\O!E@ADO0?BADL0G 0 ADE`Be!GJCMºYe0Lt\JL!O0WYSB`BL `BL8AµEADW@[@ºKGE@CM\L!XfBAµE@S¶O!L O<E@AMO!?BAd¸y?BCdaL!?ih\0½ E<ºYe0GL0GZO0WYXZa¶ADCD¸y?Be|Lh.¸K?¤½¿WYS \JWY?BbgETCMhL0GE@C¨h4e0ºKCMhL!G0»4UL!aL!SB`BE@Sh<QADL/hL0GX.LCMS¶ÀÁWYGJXEThCMÀV`gETSB\HA½¿L¥¹¶a¶GL!\J\CMWYSt`¶LAµE\hlEThCD\JhCD¸y?BL'`BL hL!\hqL!\Jh U W U XETCD\\JWYSL!\Ja§e0GE@S¶O!L4S½ÉL!\JhqaBE@\ÅSy?BADAMLÇ`gE@S¶\ÅADLÇO!E@\¾O!W@XZaBAML¹iL@»ËnWY?¶\ÅaBGW@a§WY\JWYSB\ `¶L[YE@G`BL0G4O!L/hL0GX.L/L0h^SBWY?B\4O!E@ADO0?BADL0GWYSB\dO0L0hJhL'L!\Ja§e0GE@SBO0L2aBE@G4\CDX?BAµEThCDWYS¶\ M X PW O T = X U U T =U W U= T 0. l. 0. WPC. T. i l l. ij. ∗. ∂ 2 log L ∂εij ∂εi0 j 0. ε. i l. ∂L(εij ,j=1,...,ni ;i=1,...,n) (θˆ0 ) ∂εij. ij l. ∗. . ∗. 0. ∂L(εij ,j=1,...,ni ;i=1,...,n) (θˆ0 ) ∂εij. ij l. 0. ∂L ∂φl (θˆ0 ). ε. ε. ∗. 0. T. ∗. n. T. ∗. i. ij 0 l. j,j 0 ≤ni j 0 6=j. i=1. ¼VE\JhEThCM\JhCD¸y?BL/`BL/hL0\JhnL!\hHETADWYGJ\jM. ij l. i. b H0 [T ] T −E SH = p var d H0 T. PW O Eb [T ] Lh var \JWYShÇ`BL0\dL!\JhCDXZEThL0?BG\ª`BLA½¿L0\ae!GE@SBO!LHL0hÇ`¶LAµE'º@ETGCµETSBO!Ln`BL T \W@?B\ H » d T ULhhL1\JhEThCM\JhCM¸y?BL\J?BCMh¬E@\JIKX.a¶hW@hCD¸y?BL0XZL0Syh?BSBL1AMWYCqSBWYGJXE@AMLO!L!ShGe!L|GJe!`B?¶CMhLT»ÐÊW@?BGWYfihL!S¶CDG O0L!\.L!\hCDXZEThL!?BGJ\!QªSBWY?B\Ge!E@ADCM\WYS¶\?BS fWKW@h\hGETa7aBE@GE@X.e0hGCM¸K?¶LM S¶WY?B\\CMX¬?BADW@SB\ K ÒJL0?i¹`BL `¶WYSBSBe0L!\¬`BL n CMSB`BCMºKCM`B?B\\WY?B\ P θ aWY?BGOlbBE@¸y?BL1GL0aBADCM¸y?BLZS¶WY?B\O!E@ADO0?BADW@SB\2AML!\\JhEThCM\JhCM¸y?BL!\ L0h^SBW@\^L0\JhCDXZEThL0?BG\d\JWYShnADEXZWIYL0SBSBL'L0hÂDEºTE@GJCµE@S¶O!L/L!X.aBCMGCD¸y?BLH`BL'O!L!\4ºTE@ADL0?BG\0» T H0. H0. ˆ. 0. (k). . 0.

(17) ! % ' I "%

(18) T'. VI-/,. 4&6d7:9;1c6I<8A 25?I]81. ^Ë WY?B\2O!WYSB\JCD`Be0GWYS¶\¬?BSX.Wi`¶·!ADLO0AµE@\J\CD¸y?BLZ`½Ée!¸y?gEThCDWYSB\2`BCMÄ§L!GJL!ShCML!AMADL!\WYGJ`BCDSgETCDGL0\ K ÐÊL0GL0AD\W@SL0h ETA»4Ñ L a§WY?¶GdAµE`¶IKSgE@X.CD¸y?BL'`BL0\nO0WYSBO!L0ShGEhCDW@SB\4`BL!\4ºKCDGCMWYSB\dLhH`BL0\nAÏKXZaBb¶WiOIKhL!\4cØUÇF aWY?BGd?¶St\J?ÒJL0h i `gE@SB\4AML/O!WYShL¥¹KhL`¶LA½¿CMS¶ÀÁL!OhCMWYS1agE@GdAMLÌÍÏÎ»gÍAäCDSBO0AD?¶hdhGWYCM\ÇO!WYX.agE@GhCMXZL0Syh\TM ADL0\ÇO!L0ADAD?¶ADL!\O!CDf¶ADL!8\ MÅAMIKX.aBbBWKO0IyhL0\dcÚÇF L Q I K AML!\ÇO0L!AMAD?BAML!\ÇCMS¶ÀÁL!Ohe!L0\ L Lh V K ADL!\ÇºKCMGCDW@SB\ T K O0CDGJO!?BADE@Sh\ L »q¼äLX.WK`B·!AMLa§L0?¶h^\!½Ée!O0GCDGJL'\WY?B\4ADEÀÁW@GX.L\?BC¨ºTE@ShL M i. i.   . dT i dt dI i dt dV i dt. i. = λi − γV i T i − µiT T i = γV i T i − µiI I i = π i I i − µV V i. ¼äL0\dO!L!AMAD?BAML!\ O!CDf¶ADL!\L!ShGJL!Sh^`gE@SB\ÇAML\ETSB[O!CMGO!?¶AµE@Sh4Ã¬?BS1hE@?i¹ Q¶L!AMADL0\Ça§L0?¶ºYL0ShnÆhGJL/CDS¶ÀÁL0O0he0L!\ aBE@G?BSáºKCDGJCDWYSÃ?BSáhE@?i¹ γ Lh/X.L!?BGJL!Sh'E@?hE@?i¹ µ »'¼äL!\'UÇF λ8CMS¶ÀÁL!Ohe!\HXZL0?BGL0Syh/Ã?BSáhlET?i¹ L0h.aBGJWi`¶?BCD\JL!Sh`¶LtSBW@?¶ºYL!E@?i¹ºKCDGJCDWYSB\.E@?hlET?i¹ π »æ¼äL!\ºKCDGCMWYSB\X.L!?BGJL!ShE@?7hE@?i¹ µ L0h µ aL!?iºYL!ShHE@ADW@G\ÇCMS¶ÀÁL!OhL!Gd`¤½ E@?ihGL0\4O!L!AMAD?BAML!\dO0CDfBAML!\!»ÅËnWY?B\4\J?BaBaWY\WYS¶\n¸y?BL L0h \JWYShÔ!WYSB\hlE@Sh Lh'O!WYX.X¬?BS Ã1hWY?B\/ADL0\\?ÚÒJL0h\0»¼äL!\/agE@GE@X.·0hGJL!\/CMSB`BCMºKCM`B?BL!AM\H\JWYSh ξ =γ(λ ,µµ , π , µ ) γ L0h \WYSh2\?Ba¶a§WY\Je!\¬O0WYSBSy?B\0»8¼VL0\ \WYSh2ADL!\'WYf¶\L!GºTEThCMWYSB\fBG?BC¨he0L!\`BL Lh »|Ë^WY?B\ µ a¶GL!S¶WYSB\ ξ˜ = log(ξ ) aWY?BGdhWY?¶h lYaWY?BG4E@\J\?BGJL!GÂµE¬aWY\C¨hC¨ºiC¨he`¶L!\4agE@GE@XZT·hGJ+L!\!I» V i. i T i. i I. V. i. V. i. i. i. i l. V i I. i. i. i T i. i l. VI-WV. I?/2E]d9;AaHJ?;4.<8Z. VI-. b8bj9;?;^ÀkHJ?;4.<. Ë^WY?B\/E<º@WYSB\/O<ETADO!?¶ADeAML!\L0GGJL!?BGJ\`BL¬hIKa§LÑE@CDSB\JCÊ¸y?BLAML!\naB?BCD\J\E@S¶O!L!\/`¶L!\/`BL0?i¹áhL!\Jh\/L!SáÀÁWYS¶OÈ hCDWYSt`BL¬A½¿LÄ¤Lh`BL¬ADE.ºTE@GJCµE@fBAML2L¥¹iaBADCMO<EThCMºYL K fBCMSgE@CMGLWY?áO!W@SyhCDSy?BL L L0hH`BL¬AµEºTE@GCDE@SBO!L2`BL!\/LÄ¤Lh\ ETADe<EhWYCMGL!\0»^¼VL0\L!GJGL0?BG\`¶LhIKa§L1Ñ2e0hE@CDL0SyhH`BL¬A½¿WYGJ`BGL`BL2AµE.hE@CDAMADL'SBWYX.CDSBE@ADL/`BL0\HhL0\Jh\ K

(19) »

(20) L » ¼äL0?BG\ÊaB?BCD\J\E@S¶O!L!\ÅE@?B[YX.L!ShlETCDL!ShÊE<ºYL0OÇA½ÉL0Ä§L0hÊ`BLªAµEdº@ETGCµETfBADLqL¹iaBAMCDO!EThC¨ºYLqL0hAµEdº@ETGCµETSBO!Lq`BL A½ÉL0Ä§L0h ETADe<EhWYCMGLLhdhL!S¶`gE@CDL0Sh^º@L!GJ\2ÑY» Ë^WY?B\8E<ºYW@SB\ E@aBaBAMCD¸y?BeáO0L!\|hL0\Jh\ E@?K¹åagE@GE@X.·0hGJL!\|L0\JhCMXZe0\|`B? XZWK`B·0ADLa¶Ge!\JL!She#L!S \JL!O0hCDWYS o »MÑ1\J?BG¬?BStÒJL0?(`BL1`BW@SBSBe!L0\`BL iÑagEThCDL0Syh\¬CDSiÀÁL!O0he!\¬aBE@GAMLZÌÍÏÎéCD\\J?(`BL1ADEáUWYAMAµE@fWYGEhCDW@S UÓÔBUÓFHÕ4»ª¼äL|X.Wi`B·0ADLZCDSBO0AD?gE@C¨h`¶L!\L0Ä§L0h\ZETADe<EhWYCMGL!\2\?BGAML!\agETGE@X.·0hGL!\ λ Lh µ »Ë^WY?B\ E<º@WYSB\¾hL0\JheÂ½ÉL0Ä§L0hÅ`BL!\qºTE@GCDE@fBADL0\ª}Ji}4Lh K}4\?BG¾AML!\¾`BC¨Ä¤e0GL0Syh\qagE@GETXZ·hGL0\!»¾¼VEHºTE@GJCµE@fBAML K}Ê ehedaBGJCD\JLÇL!S¬ºTE@GJCµE@fBAML O0WYShCMSK?¶LdL0h¾L0S¬º@ETGCµETfBADL fBCDSgETCDGLT»VÓH?BO0?BSL0Ä§L0hq`BLÇADEnºTE@GCDE@fBAML4}Ji}ÇS½ Eehe X.CD\4L0Se0ºKCD`BL0SBO!LTQ¤`BL2XZÆ0XZLaWY?BGÂµE.ºTE@GJCµE@f¶ADL K}2aBGCM\LL0SáO!W@SyhCDSy?BLT»HË^WY?B\E<º@WYSB\HhGWY?¶º@e?BS LÄ¤LhH`¶LA½ K}/aBGCM\^L0S ºTE@GJCµE@f¶ADLfBCMSgE@CMGL/O!WK`Be0LZÑ'aWY?BG4ADL0\âBEThCML!Sh!\ @[Ye0\ E@SB\ L0h

(21) aWY?BG AML!\¾aBAM?B\§ÒJL!?¶SBL!\ K

(22) E@SB\¾L!\hªADL ÈCD·0XZL a§L0GO0L!ShCMADL L \J?BG¾ADLagE@GETXZ·hGL µ K KS≥=50−1.99L Q#a "

(23) »

(24) L » i. . I. i I.

(25) U L0AµE\CM[YSBC QgL/¸y?BL'ADL!\daBEThCML!Sh\!@[Ye0\4WYSh4?BSBL/hlE@?K¹8`BL'`Be!O0·!\^`BL!\4O0L!ADAM?BADL0\dCDS¶ÀÁL0O0he!L!\4aBAM?B\ÇÀE@CMfBADLTQ O0L'¸K?¶CwaWY?BGJGE@C¨hdGL ge0hL!G4?BSBL'X.WYCDS¶\df§WYS¶SBL/Ge0a§WYS¶\LCDX.X¬?BSBC¨hlE@CMGLÔlbBL!PO!L0\âBEThCML!Sh\0» Ë^WY?B\dE<ºYW@SB\Çe![YE@ADL0XZL0SyhE@aBa¶ADCD¸y?BeÂDL4hL0\Jhd`¤½¿bBW@XZWY[@e!SBe0CMhenÃ2O0L!\ÇL0\JhCDXZEThCMWYSB\!»ËnWY?¶\S½¿E<ºYWYSB\ X.CD\L!S.e0ºKCD`BL0SBO!LnE@?BO0?BS.SBWY?¶º@L!AgL0Ä§L0h E@AMe<EThWYCDGJjL M S = 1.42 K a "

(26) »MÑ L L0h S = 1.55 K #a "

(27) »MÑ o L Q GJL!\Ja§L0O0hC¨ºYL0XZL0SyhnaWY?BG π L0h µ » . H. H. T. . . +% ' . ^Ë WY?B\dE<º@WYSB\d`BeºYL!AMWYaBae/`BL!\ÇhL!\h\Ç`B?|\JO!WYGJL/`gE@SB\?BS|O!WYShL¹KhL'SBWYSKÈ\JhE@SB`gETG`»q¼äL!\\CDX?BAµEThCDWYS¶\ X.WYShGJL!Sh ¸K?¶LHO!L0\ hL!\Jh\ ÀÁWYS¶O0hCMWYSBSBL0ShfBCML!S»¾UL!\ hL!\h\aL!?iºYL!ShdÆhGJLn?¶hCDAMCD\e0\¾a§W@?BG GJe<E@AMCD\JL!Gq?BSBL L¥¹iaBADWYGEThCMWYS(GETaBCD`BL|`¤½¿?BS¶L8ÀETXZCMADADL.`BL8X.Wi`B·0ADL0\O!WYX.aBADL¥¹iL!\L!S7agE@GhCDO0?BADCML!G2a§WY?¶GADL!\X.WK`B·!AML!\ ìIiSBE@XZCM¸y?BL!\0» ?Chj9;?;4aBgA.b 8 ?;1. . Ñ ¾UW¹§QVÓ»§L0hÎ^CDSyADLIYQäF2» K Ñ L TH g}l QäcdbBL0WYGLhCDO!E@AÅ\hlEThCD\JhCDO0\!QVUbgETaBXETS ] ÎnE@ADAQB¼äWYSB`¶WYSQBagET[YL!\ o ÚÈ » o ?BL0`Ò0QR>¶»¨QBcdbBCMe!fgE@?ih<QB_'»¶LhnUWYX.XZL0SB[YL!\0QBF» K o

(28)

(29) L r<Yi-¦Ê } Dg!oq.@~~ T~@ @Rrâ!K} dj¶äQ CMWYXZLhGJCDO!\0Q QÑYÑ ÚÈlÑ o

(30) ¶» }~¤}J@ }.m l} }l4 2K}~¤} ÊUWYX.X.L!SB[YL0\!QgF2»gL0hH>YE@O!¸yX.CDSiÈ ET`B`gE¶Q¶Î2» Ñ . K L ^}7~ { }¨@}#pÇ@~K o }l |r#!K} Q4>@WY?BGJSgE@A^W@Àhb¶Lá_4WÚIYE@AnÔKhlEhCD\hCMO<E@A^ÔiWKO!CML0hI M ÔKL!GCML K L0hbBWK`BWYADW@[YCDO!E@A L Q iQÑ ÚÈÑ iÑY» ¶ÐÊL0GL!AM\WYS¤QÓ»@Ô§»MQYËnL!?¶XE@S¶SQYÓ»@Â2»¨Q E@G @WN4CMhP@Q »MQ¼äL0WYSgE@GJ`Qy>¶» »TLhqÎnWBQYF» Ñ ä@ ~@ l'~tKK.@~K~¤!K} Ç }~¤ ¬¥y ¥g}¡~ <}l ~gQRÔiO0CDL0SBO!LTQ o iÑYQÑ K o ÈÑ L ¶» . . . . . .

(31) . . . . . !. $ $. . . . . . #". &%. ". . . . ". '. ". . .

(32)