Une clinique par les formes ?

Texte intégral

(1)Une clinique par les formes ? Olivier Orain. To cite this version: Olivier Orain. Une clinique par les formes ?. 2006. �halshs-00114911�. HAL Id: halshs-00114911 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00114911 Preprint submitted on 19 Nov 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3) !#"%$'&()+*-,./&102+*43 !5 687:9;=<?>A@CBEDGFIHKJML#NO@QP=F@QJML#NORQFJSJT<?L=>VUW6XL?>AYZ9VF\[F\HO]^LJ<`_a@b>VYc<6X71Bb7Ode@fL#L`Yhga@f>Yc71@Q9iL#N1LjBQF d<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fL71JSY

(4) L\HX_TL\Hk7OHX_a9i7KH8_M7OH19lL`JambL\HkNORQFnT7:JTN1L`9oBCF!YZgTp=>iL/NORqHKJML!9i<\[K7:BrH1YZ@f7:Js>i;`@fLJSYZ@ftu@fv H:LN1LwBQF d<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fL4tu9VFJTxF@b>iLU/7:_T<`9<=L4NOFJT>yBfL=>XFJSJT<?L=>{z?|}e~eiz=|ee~eu

(5) RQ@bN1<?LANORrH1JTL(9 HK_SYHK9iLAtc71JMNOF68L`JaYZFBbL JaRC@Q6_aBC@fv H:L_aF?>+_M7OH19oF\H1YZFJaY'H1JTL_T7S>V@QYZ@b71JkFnM>i71BqHKYZ@b>VYcLUav H1@aN1<nT7KH:;`gTL`9F@CY>HK9BfL!N1<JS@aN1LwYc7OH1YcL!L?>V_Mp?;=L N1L!;?7:JaYZ@CJ1H1@QYc<!LJSYZ9iLBCF+d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fLw;BCF?>i>V@fv HaLL`Y>iL?>9iL6_aBQF?x`FJaYcL=>\ +L`9YZF@CJTL=>_TL`9V6%FJMLJT;=L?>>i71JSYF?>i>iL`P <\[O@fN1LJSYcL?>VUYcLBf>H1J{9iL?;=7OH19i>BCF9cdLN1L=>_S9VFYZ@fv H:L=>@b;?71JM7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L=>/7KHk@f;?7:Ja@b>VFJaYcL=>Z7KHkBQRQFJM;9VF\dLEN1L BQF9L=;gML9i;gML%NOFJM>/N1L?>!;`F?NO9iL?>w9i<\de@f7:JaF\HO]aaRQF\H1YZ9iL?>VUL`J{9iL\[FJM;gMLUBbLW>i71JSY+687:@QJT>ULY+JaRCF_a_SF9F@b>i>iL`JaY v HKRCF_a9ip?>H1JTLBf7:J1dHaLXtZF6@QBQ@CF9V@QYc<F\[KL=;BfL?>ENO@btctc<`9iLJaYc>E;=719V_1Ha>/<`YH:NO@b<?>\SRqHKJML%N1L=>!_SBrHa>/tc7:9VYcL?>!687:J >iL`JT>!L?>Yl;=LWv H:LEmCRQF_S_TLBCBfL`9F@'tZF\H1YcLN1L6@fL)H]XBQFq) e Z¡q¢¤£C¥¦) § BCRrH1J{N1L?>w71nambL?;`YZ@ftc>wN1LE;?LYcL\]OYcL <YZFJSYN1LEmrHa>VYZ@ftu@fL`9¨L`YlNORbL\]_SBQ@b;@QYcL`9¨;=LYZYcLWL)]_a9iL=>i>V@f7:J15wHsN1L6XL\H19VFJaYZUMBfLYZgMp6XLNHs©<?7:_T7:@QJaYª~e~«§ BfL=>Xtc7:96XL?>§ @CJ1[@CYcLh_aF9VYZ@f;)HKBC@fp`9L`68L`JaYE{;?L`Y¬L)]KL9i;`@f;?LÙNOFJT>BCFh68L=> HK9iL{7K®BCRf71J¯FsF?t tZF@C9LyBbLk_SBrHa> >i7KH[KL`JaYlHKJML;`BQ@QJS@fv H:Lt 71JTN1L`68L`JaY6X719V_SgT71Bb7Ode@fv HaL +716_aYcLYcLJ1HkNHktc719V6FYNH_a9i<?>iL`JaYL\]KL`9i;@f;=LU1@CBaL\°1Y<`Yc<!NO@ftctu@f;`@QBfL!N1L!;=71JM;@QBC@fL`9oL\]O_T7a>±<w_a9V@QJM;@Q_S@fL`B LY+9V@f;`gTL=>i>iLWN1L=>!L\]KL`6%_SBfL?>UFBf7:9>w6X²6XLWv HKRC@QBL=>VYvHaL?>YZ@f71JAN1LEBQFd<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fL_S9@b>iLENOFJT>w>VF!deBb71naFBC@QYc< XL\[FJSY%tZF@C9L³H1J´;`gT71@q]UwmQRQF@w_a9i<=tc<9i<h6XLYZYZ9iLhBCRQF?;=;?LJSYW> HK9BfL(NO@f>i;=7OH19>YZgM<?7:9@bvHaLU9L`_T7:9YZFJSYE³N1L=> YZ9VF\[F\HO]WHKBCYc<9V@fL)HK9i>N1L=>+_a9i7:Yc7a;?7:BfL=>NORQF?NO6@QJS@f>VYZ9VFYZ@f7:JsN1LBQF!_a9iL)H[KL<BCFnT719i<=>\e5!_a9ip?>lF\[K71@C9lL)]_aBC@f;`@QYc<µLY mrHa>VYZ@btZ@f<¶;?L`YZYcLF_a_MLBCBQFYZ@f7:JaUymfL6RfL`6%_SBf7:@fL·L)]_aBb719iL9¸BbL?>#NO@btctc<`9iLJaYcL=>¸6X7aNOFBQ@CYc<?>¸NORrH1JTL;`BQ@CJa@fv HaL d<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fv HaLw_aF9BfL=>

(6) t 719V68L=>VUOF\[FJaYN1L_T7S>iL9BCFv H:L=>VYZ@f7:J8N1L=>_a9i7:naBfp`68L=>

(7) <`_a@f>Yc<6X71Bf7Kde@fv H:L=>

(8) v H:Lw;?L`BQF >i7KHKBbp\[KL ¹»º®¼±½-¾¶¿¼±ÀÁÀ\Â/ÃWºIÄºÁÆÅEÇÈÅ/ÉO½ÊWËÀº @r[KL`9>>i71JSY!BfL?>¬687SN1pBfL=>W>i;`@fLJSYZ@ftu@fv H:L=>WvHaLXBbL?>d<=7Ode9VF_agTL=>E71JaYZUH1J4687:68L`JaY!7OH{H1J4F\HKYZ9iLÙ <_M7OHa>i<?>UF\Hkde9i<WN1LW;=71JaYZF?;`Yc>wF?>i>V@bNH:>!7KH³N1LEmbL\HO]sN1LW> H1_a9i<6FYZ@fLW;`@Q9i;?7:JT>VYZFJM;@bLBf>)TÌVBf>!>±LW>i71JSY[K7OH1BrHa> Yc7OH19+!Yc7OH19+JaFYH19FBC@f>VYcL=>VUa6X71JM7Ode9VF_agML?>+<9 HaNO@QYc>VU1gM71668L=>oN1Lw_SF@QBCBQF?>i>iLÙ1687SN1<BC@f>VFYcL)HK9i>+7OH%F?;`YcL\H19i>oN1L=> >i;`@fLJM;?L=>4>i7a;`@QFBfL=>Í ÎJÏ9iL\[OFJT;gMLUWBCRQFJSFBf7Ode@bL¸68<=NO@f;`FBfLUE_M7OH19Ð²YZ9iLI9VF9LÙEF4H1JÑ;`F9VF?;Ycp9iLI6X71@QJM> ga@b>VYc719V@b;@f>±<!Ò71JABQFE[171@QYw<6XL9 dL9/>V_M719VF?NO@fv H:L`68L`JaYNOFJM>/v H:L`Bfv H:L=>wYcL\]YcL=>!<_SF9>wYc7KHKY+F\HhBf71J:dÓNHyÔÔÕ >V@bp?;BbLeÎBCBfLwFHKJ9iÖ1BbLNORCF99V@bp9iL?u_aBQFJXNOFJT>BQRCF?;YHaLB1> H:;=;?p=>

(9) NHE×Øib£?¡VÙZÚbaÚZ¢Z¢bÚ¡i¢f£=ÛeÜe@171JBQFwN1<?;BC@QJMLL`J BQF_a9iLJSFJaYF\Hs>i<9V@fL)H]OUÝ;=71668LE<=;BQF@C9VF\dL_T7:YcLJaYZ@bLBM> HK9N1L=>+_a9VFYZ@fv HaL?>L=tctcL=;YZ@q[KL?>VUSBfL9<=> H1BQYZFYJaRbL?>VY_SF?> ÞMßZàá?âãâ+äZåuærçéè=êëVìOí î ïQðiñ ìïQëbòòVóôMõZðiòVëá)öeõ÷øQó±ùëC÷aú ìOïr÷øQúCôMõí õ û\ïQüióiëC÷aëbøcì1ùîVøqïQüióiëC÷aò=ý úbþQùïQøQóiùë1òVîVðV÷1írîOû)úbõ ûùî ì1ÿVïQëZàùîðî ïr÷ë1îó÷bïbþrírëQè äZå å æQä æ ç åcäæ !#"$ åuæQä &%'( æ è )Kå äæ è ç?+æ * ä æ , )Kå äæ .- è /001\è 2034eã.

(10) .

(11) N1<J:H:<NORQ@CJaYc<9i²`YZUa/;?7:JTNO@CYZ@f71JhN1L!_S9L`JTNO9iLwdeF9iN1L!F\HO]W×O¥¢Z¡iØi O¤Ù¤ÚVZ¢¤Úb O¤ÙØ £=£b¡rÛÙT;?7:6%6XL!JM7OHa>D ;?7:J1[@bL F?;=vHaL?> l7OHO[KL`9L=>i>i L c. <?N1L=;@QJM>+;?7166XLd<=7Ode9VF_agML?>+>i71JSY;=71JMtZ9i71JSYc<?>H1JTL!NO@CFBfL=;YZ@fv HaL>V@C6%@CBQF@C9LwNH%;F?>LYN1L=>9ip\deBfL=> d<JM<9VFBfL=>VU+F\[KL?;ÓH1JTLy@Q9V9i<?NHa;YZ@Cna@QBC@QYc<l¥¢Z

(12) ¡ b +£ÚbN1L?>¬@QJTNO@q[@fNHa>W;=71JT>@fN1<9i<=>\FJT>EnM71JIJT716na9iLyN1L >i;`@fLJM;?L=>%7K-YZ9@b716_agMLkBCRQ@CJTNO@r[O@fNH1FBQ@f>68Ly6X<YZgT7SN171Bb7Ode@fv H:LÙLJ¸68L`YZYZFJaYX_aF9VY/;?L`9YZF@CJTL=>Wtc7:96XL?>N1L _T>D ;gM71Bb7Ode@fLE;BC@QJS@fv H:LÙÝ7:JhF99V@q[KL;?LEtuF\H]X_aF9VF?N17O]1Lv HaL/BbL?>w> H1mfLYc>wLJMvHa²Yc<=>JMLBfLE>i71JSY

(13) _SF?>LJyYZFJaY v HKRC@QBf>+>i7:JaYN1L?>¥Z¢¤Ù ¡i=?¤ÙUa;?7:JTx)H:L=>o;=71668LwF\DFJaYHKJMLwÚ ¢bÚ Tw_a9iL`JTNO9iL!LJk;=716_aYcLwLJYZFJaYv H:LYcLBCBfL ÎJµ9iL\[FJM;gTLÙ¨L`JG6X<?N1L=;@CJTLA;?7166XLÐL`J#d<?7Kde9F_Sga@bLUwÐN1L?>ÓJa@r[1LF\HO]®_aF?>±>VFnaBbL6XLJaYNO@ftct <9iLJSYc>VUwBQF v H:L=>VYZ@f7:J^N1L4BCF4_TL`9>±71JaJSFBQ@b>VFYZ@f7:J·_a9iL`JTN¯H1JTL4Yc7KHK9VJ:HK9iL4_SF9VYZ@f;\H1BQ@bp9iL6XLJSYk;9 Ha;@QFBbLUEvH1@;=71JTtu@QJML4 BQRb71JSYc71Bf7Kde@fLÒ;RfL=>VY!<\[@bN1LJaY!v HKFJMNÐ7:J4F%F?t tZF@Q9iLXN1L?>E²YZ9iL=>/g:HK6F@QJM>6%FBCF?N1L?>VU

(14) x`F%BCRfL?>YF\H1YZFJaYw_T7KHK9 Yc7OHa>/;=L\HO]³v HK@;?7:JTx=71@r[1LJaYlHKJ(× ¤Ú¢Z: Z¡rO¢¤£C¥¦ÛÙN1L F\H1B !@fNOFBN1LWBCF oBCF?;gMLE o7OdL`9 +9cH1JTL`YZU7OH H1JTLwd<=7Ode9VF_aga@b;@CYc<!_a9i7SNH:;`YZ9@b;?LN1Lw×aO Z¡ÙZÚ¢¤ Ú ¢Z¤Ù1Û!9VF?tct L?>VYZ@CJa@bLJaJML?>7KHÓNORO×w¤Ù ¥£=¤¤Ù V Z=Ù1ÛwBCF¨tuF?x?7:JkN1L ©¬HD#@ <=7M!ÎJÏNORQF\H1YZ9iL?>(YcL9V68L=>VU/_M7OH19{N1L?>h9VF@f>±71JT>(;?716_aBbL\]KL=>VU/BCF4_aBqHK_SF9YkN1L=>yd<?7Kd 9VF_SgTL?>U tHa>i>iL`JaYcu@QBf>!<`_a@b>VYc<6X71Bb7Ode@fv H:L`68L`JaY+JT7:6%@CJaFBC@f>VYcL=>VUtc7:JaY+BfL¬_aF9V@v H:LEBbL\H19¨7:nambLYd<JT<`9V@fv H:L¤Ú'_SF9VYZ@f;\H1BQ@bL9 § 6@QBC@fL\H1UO9<)de@f71JSUKL=>V_aF?;=L7KHWYcL9V9V@QYc71@C9iL+§ FlHKJMLJSFYHK9iLØifÙ ¢ ¤ÚTLY9<=LBCBfL 7KHK9{>VF@b>V@Q9yH1JTL4_ML9i>i7:JaJTLI7OH·>VF4_aFYZgM71Bb7Ode@fLÙ/BfL=>hBf7:@f>yd<`JT<9VFBbL?>y_TL`96XLYZYZFJSY8NORbL\]_SBQ@bvHaL9yBQF _aBqHK_SF9VY-N1L?>¸6X<?;`FJa@f>68L=>¸BQR H[9iL JTL>i7:JaYA_aF?>¸> HatctZ@b>VFJaYcL=>\%+L9VYcL?>UkLBQBbL?>¸>i7:JaYAFnT>i7:BrH168L`JaY JT<=;?L=>i>VF@Q9iL=>L`Js6X<?N1L=;@CJTLUL`Y

(15) BfLE>i7:JaY+<\deFBfL`68L`JaYoN1L)[KLJ:H:L=>_M7OH19+H1JTL!nM71JSJTL!_SF9VYZ@fL/N1LBQFwd<?7Kde9F_Sga@bL ;?7:JaYcL`6%_M719VF@QJMLXtHa>i>iL`JaYccL`BQBbL?>!L\]OYZ9F? d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L=>Z\ F@f>w@CBL?>Yl<)deFBfL6XLJSY

(16) JM<?;?L=>i>VF@C9LEN1L_a9VFYZ@bvHaL9 BQFW;`BQ@QJS@fv H:LÙ;RbL?>VYcu?cNO@C9LLJ{_S9L`6%@bp9iLWL)]_aBC@f;FYZ@b71JhH1JÐL)]F68L`J{_TL`9V68L`YZYZFJaYN1LE9VF_a_M719VYcL9wBfLE;F?>N1L=> > De>VYcp6XL?>YZF\]@CJT716@fv HaL?>VUaN1Lw6XL?> H19iL9BfL?>+<=;F9VYc>+<\[KL`JaYHaLBf>F\HO]JM719V68L=>

(17) >VYZFJMNOF9iNOUKL`YN1L_S9i71JT7:JT;=L9'H1J NO@QF\deJM7a>VYZ@b;UW;RbL?>VYcu?cNO@Q9iL H1JTLIF?>i>V@qd JSFYZ@f7:JÑNH^;`F?>\wF¸;BC@QJa@bvHaL¸L\]K;=p?N1LILJ^;=LBCF-;?L-v H1@/9iLBbp\[KLIN1L BQRCFJaFBqD >iLÙoBCF?vHaLBCBfLh>V@qd JSFBfLhN1L?>_agM<JM716XpJTL=>VUL?t tcL?;`YH:LhN1L=>%7:_T<9VFYZ@b71JT>LYEN1L?>;?7:6%_SF9F@b>i71JM>VU+6%F@b> JaRC@QJM;BrH1YX_aF?>³@QJaYZ9V@CJT>ip=vHaL6XLJSYXBfLAdL=>VYcL-> DJaYZgM<YZ@fv HaL-;?7:JT>V@b>VYZFJaYXAdeBb71naFBC@f>iL`9{>i7OHa>yH1JTL(d<JM<9VFBQ@CYc< NORfL=>V_Tp=;?L{N17:JaJM<?L5¨@CJT>V@CUlv H1FJTN @b;gTL`B ¨@qd7KHK9i7KH]-L\]F6@QJMLyBQRQF_S_aBC@f;FnS@QBC@QYc<hNH4×o6X7aN1p`BfLhN1 L 7:J g KJMLJ LJ·Î@Q9iL!Òw@Q6F\dL?>{L`YX9<`FBQ@CYc<?> Û !¤U!BCFÐ_SF9YZ@bLA_a9i71_S9iL6XLJaYFJaFBqDéYZ@bvHaL4N1L4>i71JYZ9VF\[F@CB!@QJM;BrH1Y BQRCFJaFBqD >iLy6HKBCYZ@r[F9V@f<=LhLY/BCFs;`F9Yc7Kde9F_Sga@bLk@CJa@CYZ@QFBfLhN1L=>W9i<?>HKBCYZFYc>W>VYZFYZ@f>YZ@fv H:L=>\Fk;BC@QJa@bvHaLkL=>VY!9i<FBC@f>i<=L v HKFJMNh@QBD8FF?>i>V@rdeJSFYZ@f71J4NH³;`F?>w_aF9w9iLJ1[171@NHh9<=> H1BQYZFY+EBQFW;FYc<)d7:9V@fL×+687SN1pBfLN1L[K71J "g 1JTL`JÛ Rf719 deFJa@b>VFYZ@f7:JsN1LYDé_TL;?L`JaYZ9i$L #e_M<9V@Q_SgT<9V@bLUT;=LYZYcL×O¥¡ÚZ)Úf£rbÙZ£Úb¡±Ù ¥£Úbf£Û!vHa&L %a9VFJT ; '/5wH19@CF?;w9iL_Tp`9iL NOFJT>³BfLA[O@rdeJT7:naBfLABCFJ1dHaL?N17a;`@fL`)J (W9iLBbp\[KL4<)deFBfL6XLJSY%+ *é?WN1L4;?LAYDé_ML4NORf7:_T<9VFYZ@b71JXLA6FJa@fp`9iL <?v H1@r[FBbLJaYcLÙWBQFId<?7Kde9F_Sga@bL#;BCF?>i>V@fv HaL¸F¸_a9i7aNH1@QYyH1JTL#;`BQ@QJS@fv H:L d<?7:687:9V_agT7:Bf7Kd @bvHaLUWv HK@WN1<`_a@f>YZF@QY ,.-)ã0/ * ä èö ùõZòcï ûëC÷ëbø$1¤ëbùøqï û)ëC÷òVëíý îVðiî írõ ûïQëCè.2æ ( äè03 % åuæ ç $54 å76æQä98cè$:<;.;.;ã = ã?>æ@6 ä 5A è03)B 4éä 4 DC

(18) > ç+E 5F ç ç çGMæQä H æ C å76 L?M.N<W O õZò Cí ëC÷ëbø=ôTõZòVúCí ïr÷îVørïQõZð'ëbðeûúbõ û)ùî ì1ÿVïQëCè 4eã P"Q ã?R äæfå è.SUT ÷ø QôMëeúbþQõZðiõôSïQüióiëeëbøëC÷ ìKîVþCëQè)1å äæ è.V ç .C æ å è$:<;.W1ã. ä , å æ , c8 è åuç )I ä 4 J. 4 . ç è$Kúbõ ìKõïQð±ø.

(19) \; HaL?>YZF?>VUy[F\H] _TL`9i;gT<=>GL`Y-F\H1YZ9iL?>µ> HK9ituF?;?L?>µNORQF_SBQFJS@f>i>iL`68L`JaY-L`J BQRbL?>V_Mp?;=L·N1L9iL`BQ@fL=tc>#L`Y49iL_aBCFYc> d<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fv HaL6XLJaY>V@CYH:<=>\aÎBCBfLEFEF\Ha>i>V@_S9i7aNH1@QYHKJMLW;BC@QJS@fv H:L_aF\De>VF\dp9iLUM6X71@CJT>w<Yc7at tc<=L>±7OHa>BCRQFJ1deBbL YZF\]@CJT716@fv HaLÎYna@bLJXNORQF\H1YZ9iL?>

(20) L`JT;=719iL Áº#¿¼±ÀÁÀ\ÂÃº-Ê½

(21) ÉX¼±º=ÈÉ º F9V6@XBfL?>¸NO@q[KL9i>iL=>®>±719VYcL?>¸N1Lµ;BQ@CJa@bvHaLGL`J1[@b>VF\dLFnSBfL?>U%BCF¸d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fL¯F#_T7KHK94_SF9VYZ@f;\H1BQF9V@CYc< NORQF?t tcL=;YZ@f7:JaJML9/;?L`BQBbL?>/v H1@9iL?;=7OH19iLJaY%N1L?>9<`_TL`9Yc7:@Q9iL?>N1L O* ¡i¢ ¤Ù>VYZFJTNOF9iNO@f>±<?L?>U_SF9t 71@b>/;?7:JT>V@bN1<9i<?L=>. ?; 7:6%6XLµN1L?>A×>VYZ9 H:;`YHK9iL=>Û!ÒEBQFjd<=716X719V_agM71Bb7Ode@fLÙ%BCF¸d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fL¸F\de9VF@Q9iL#7KH^BbL?>A9iL?;`gTL9i;`gTL?>4>HK9 BQRCgaFnS@QYZFYX9 HK9VFBCU/6F@f>hF\Ha>i>V@!BCF ;`gT719i<`6%FYZ@bvHaLUw[K7:@Q9iL4;?L`9VYZF@QJT>hL=>i>VF@f>hNORCF_a_aBC@f;`FYZ@f71J·N1L(×+687SN1pBbL?>ÛÙ 9iL?>i>±719VYZ@f>i>±LJaYZU_T7KHK9E_aF9VYZ@bLXF\H4687:@QJT>U

(22) H1JTLhr)1¥£=¢¤Ù *¡i¢ ¤Ù 5/tZ@CJ®N1Lk;`BQF9V@ftu@fL`9BbLX_S97:_T7S>VUo7:J _T7KHK9V9VF@QYN1<?tu@QJS@Q9H1JTL t 719V6XL ;?7166XL»HKJML ×LJaYZ@CYc< [O@f> H1FBQ@b>VFnaBbLNO@b>i;9i<YZ@b>i<?LÛ{ÌVB4>VRQF\de@QY¯BQU4LY N1<BC@QnM<9i<6XLJSYZU¬NORqHKJML49i<?NHa;YZ@b71JyÒ¨7:J·_T7KHK9V9VF@QYk;=71JM>V@fN1<`9L`9{N1L?>{t 719V68L=>hJT7:J[@b> HaLBQBbL?>4b6Ha>V@f;`FBfL?>U >VYDBQ@f>YZ@fv H:L=>VUWLYc; !Yc7KHKYcL=tc7:@f>VUENOFJT>hBbL-;gSF6%_ vH1@/JM7OHa>h@QJSYc<9iL?>±>iLUBQF-tc7:9V68L 9L=>i>i7:9YZ@CYXF\HG[O@f> HaLB RQF?NOmfL=;YZ@bt×lNO@f>±;9i<YZ@b>i<?LÛ[@f>iLX> HOdd<`9iL9VU

(23) NOFJT>E;?LX;=71JSYZ@QJ1HOH16 vHaL>i71JSYBfL=>w×¢Z ¤£qfÚ ¤ÙT Z¡rO¢¤£C¥¦¤Ù1ÛÙ H1JTL 7:_T<`9FYZ@b71J NORQ@fN1L`JaYZ@btZ@f;`FYZ@f7:J >VFJM> BQF?v H:L`BQBbL ;?L`BQBbL?>i ;@®N1L`68L)HK9iL`9F@bLJSYG *¡±¢ ¤ÙU4_a9i<=;@f>±<6XLJaYÒ ;?7:JT>V@bN1<9iL9v HKRqHKJML!_SF9;=LBCBfL/L=>VY'×£=¢Z¢Z ZÛUMvH1RrH1JTLF\dd Bb716X<9VFYZ@f7:JsL=>VY

(24) 719 deFJa@b>i<?LLJX×£¢Z Z¡¤Ù1ÛUMvHaL!YcL`B gaF\H1Y'_aBQFYcL`F\H8L?>YMHKJ× c£u¥Z¢Z¦ ÛUO@Q6_aBC@fv H:LwNORQ@b>i71BbL9'H1JTLl×¥¡i¢¤Úb¡iw"Ø ¤Ù ¥£=Û/;=71668Lw71JF\HK9VF@CYNO@QYNOFJM> BQF¬d<=7Ode9VF_agS@fLN1L?>!FJSJT<=L?>Wz=| e~!F\H{JM716UmqH:>VYcL`68L`JaYZUNORrH1JTLWt 719V6XLUL`YoF\H{N1<YZ9V@Q6XLJSYNORrH1JTLE@CJTtZ@CJa@CYc< NORQF\H1YZ9iL?>NO@b>i;9i<`YZ@f>VFYZ@b71JT>_M7a>i>V@CnaBbL?>\CQ$ 7KHK9F\HKYZFJSYZUa;?L?>+t 719V68L=>JTL!>i7:JaY'_aF?>9VFnaFYZYZFnaBbL?>+tc7:9i;?<6XLJSY>HK9 BQRC@fN1<=L·N1L6X7aN1p`BfLÙkNOFJT>IBQFµ68L=> H19L7K LBCBfL=>®>±71JaY4>i7KH[KL`JaYA@QJMN1<_TL`JTNOFJSYcL?>¸NORrH1JTLv H:L`Bf;=71JTv HaL >V@qd JS@ftu@f;FYZ@b71JhH1Ja@q[K7av HaL!Ò1H1Jh×+_aF\D >F\dLN1LEnT7S;F\dL

(25) ÛEJML[K<`ga@f;)HKBbLEF\Ha;\H1JÐ>iLJM>>±7a;@CFBQU<?;=71JM716@fv H:LE7OH ;\H1BQYH19iLBh·_S9V@f719V@CUs_SF?>¸_aBqH:>¯vH1RrH1JTL¶>VYZ9 H:;`YHK9iLF\H19i<?7:BQF@Q9iL¶7OH vH1RrH1J YD_TL·NORCgaFnS@QYZFY49 HK9VFByBQF XL6FJ1dL?7:J ¤¡iÚ¢¤£=¢¡ U

(26) BfL=>E6X7aN1pBbL?>WL`J1deF\dLJSYwHKJMLk>V@qd JS@ftu@f;FYZ@b71JIYZ9p=>E_a9i<=;@f>±L{v H:LÓBQRf7:J-_MLJT>±LX ;?L)H]GN1L³[K71J g KJMLJ7OHGga9V@f>YZFBQBfL`9ZkvHaL(BQFÐt 719V68L(ÐL`BQBfLA>iL)HKBbL{JMLÐ>VF\H19VF@QYZU!>VF\Hat%;`F?>kNORfL=>V_Tp=;?LÙ _a9iL`JTNO9iL%L`J ;`gaF9 dLMÎJA9L)[FJT;`gTLÙ;=L9VYZF@QJML?>/;`BQ@CJa@fv HaL?>!6X719V_SgT71Bb7Ode@fv HaL?>!9iL`_a9iLJSJTLJSYEBfL)HK9!;?7:6%_SYcL N1L?>Xt 719V6XL?>Xv H:L{N1L=>687SN1pBbL?>JT7:687:YZgT<`YZ@fv H:L=>X71JaYW;=71JaYZ9V@Cn1Ha<hh_a9i7aNH1@Q9iLUwLJG7:_T<9VFJSY/H1JTLh>i7:9VYcL NORf<`_1H19VFYZ@f71J¶_aF9h9VF_a_M719VY%ABQRbLJSYZ9L`_a9V@f>±LA@QJa@CYZ@QFBbLÌVB/L`Jµ[FÐF@CJT>V@/NOFJM>yBfL?>yYZ9VF@QYcL`68L`JaYc>y6HKBCYZ@r[F9V@f<=> N171JSJaFJSYBC@fL\HW+H1JTL@QJSYcL9V_a9i<`YZFYZ@f71JyÒe;?LBCBfL=c;@H1YZ@QBQ@b>iLwLJd<`JT<`9FBH1JTLw;BQ@CJa@bvHaL6X719V_SgT71Bb7Ode@fv HaL/bmbL_MLJT>±L JT7:YZF6%6XLJSYF\HÐN1L9VJa@bL9/;`gaF_a@CYZ9iL%N1LBQ

(27) R 8ÚQ£Ù¨Ø o¢¤£==¤ oL?;`BrHa>!;?7:JT>VF?;`9<¬F\H]X[@CBQBbL?>VUv H1@>iLE9i<?t p9iLEF\HO] YZ9i71@b>+687SN1pBbL?>;`FJT71JS@fv H:L=>NORf7:9 d FJS@f>VFYZ@b71Jy@QJaYZ9VF? HK9VnaF@CJTLÙaBQRCF\HK9i<=71BQF@C9iLUaBbL/>iL=;Yc7:9@bLBMLYBfL6WH1BQYZ@C_T7:BQF@Q9iL±\ ÎY/>VRC@QBDsFk;BC@QJS@fv H:LÙo;RbL?>VY!_S9i<?;@b>i<6XLJSY!_aF9i;?LyvH1RQ@CBoL)]@f>VYcLyN1L?>E9i<`_TL9VYc7:@Q9iL?>EN1LXtc7:9V68L=>+ÒBQRbLJSYZ9L`_a9V@f>±L JaRbL?>VY_aF?>@CJTNHa;YZ@q[KLU1LBCBfLw71_Tp`9iLNOFJM>'H1J8;=71JaYcL)]YcLnaFBQ@b>i<_aF9

(28) N1L?>_a9i<?;=<?N1L`JaYc>

(29) ;=7aNO@btZ@f<=>\ Fjv HaL?>VYZ@b71JN1L=>4> D >VYcp`68L=>4;BCF?>i>V@ftu@f;`FYc71@Q9iL=>4LY{N1L?>AYZFnSBfL?>(YDé_M71Bb7Ode@fv H:L=>ÐL=>VYsL=>i>iL`JaYZ@fL`BQBbL!Ò!BfL=> ;BC@QJS@fv H:L=>wBfL?>w_SBrHa>w_TL`9t 719V6FJaYcL?>!>±71JaY;=LBQBbL?>!v HK@_a9i<?;`@f>i<`68L`JaY71JSY

(30) _a9i7SNHK@CYoN1L?>_aBCFJT;`gTL?>_a9i<=>iLJSYZFJaY.

(31) BfL=>{tc7:9V68L=>{N1L46FJa@bp9iL49VF@f>±71JaJM<?LÒ¨v HK@JaRCF4_aF?>h4BCRfL?>_a9V@QYk;=L?>h6FJ1HaLBb>sN1L=>yFJaJT<=L?>Az?| ~eiz?|e~ ;?7:JaYcL`JaFJaYNOFJM>wBfLEYcL)]YcLW7OH{>i7OHa>!tc7:9V68LWNORbLJM;F9VY+BfL?>F9i;gM<YDé_ML?>wN1LBQF!d<=716X719V_agM71Bf7Kde@fL XL[K71@CYc 71JA_aF?>UF\[KL=;WBCFd<`JT<`9FBC@f>VFYZ@b71J-L`Y+_aF9itc7:@f>wBQF[eH1BrdeF9V@f>FYZ@f71JO!N1LEBQRCFJaFBrDe>iLW>V_SFYZ@QFBbLU>iL¬9L`_a9i7aNH1@Q9iLWN1L=> _agM<JM716XpJTL=>!FJSFBf7OdHaL?> ÎJAYcL9V6XL?> 'H1gaJS@fLJM>VU@CBMDW[FWN1LEBCRQF_a_S9iLJaYZ@b>i>VF\dLWL`YlN1L¬BQFW>VYZFJTNOF9iNO@b>VFYZ@f7:J N1L×aO Z? Z¢¤£rbÙZ£Úb¡±)Ù

(32) Ù ¡r)¤Ù:Û v H1@T;?7:JaYZ9V@Qn:H:L`JaYgSF\HKYcL`68L`JaY/>VYZ9 Ha;YH19L`9HKJy_aF9VF?NO@rde6XL/>i;`@fLJSYZ@ftu@fv H:L

(33) L?>L`JaYZ9iL_S9@b>iL?>l687:@QJT>tc719V6FBQ@b>i<?L=>VU1JT7:YZF6%6XLJSYBCF¨;`BQ@QJS@fv H:Lw_SF\D >VF\dp`9L!;`BQF?>i>@fv H:LÙ1JaRf7:JaY'_aF?>BQFw6X²6XL _TL`9itc719V6FYZ@r[@CYc<#JS@WBfLj68²`68L#;`9i<?NO@QY{>i;`@fL`JaYZ@ftu@fv H:L RfL=>VY{NORQF@QBCBfL)HK9i>A_T7KHK9iv H:7:@%;?L`9VYZF@QJT>(d<=7Ode9VF_agTL=> _ag:D >V@b;@bLJT>UYcL`B eLFJM %a9VFJMx?71@b> @f;gSF9i N ¤U!71JSYE[K7OH1BrHG7:_T<9iL`9HKJ;?7SNOF\dL(nTL`F\H:;=7OH1_G_SBrHa>X>VYZ9V@f;`Y¬N1L=> tc7:9V68L=>k_SF\D >VF\dp`9L=>\ Jµ[K71@CY%nS@fLJ4;?L(Ja@q[KLF\H#Ðv HaLBw_T71@CJaYWBCRQFJSFBf7Ode@bL{F\[KL=;{BCF{6X<?N1L?;`@QJML{9iL?>YcL 71_M<9VFYc71@C9iL!Òs;=LBCBfL? ;@ÐL=>VY#LBCBfL F\Ha>i>V@hH1JTL^d 9VFJMN1L·_S9i7aNHa;YZ9V@f;=L^N1L¶9i<_ML9VYc71@C9iL?>VU{LJ BCRf7a;=;\H19V9L`JT;=L JT7S>i7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L=>VUO@QJaYZ@C68L`68L`JaYBC@f<=>+H1JTL@Q6F\dL9V@fL> H1_a_M719VY6HKBCYZ@Q_aBbL ÎJ(d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fLÙ@CBDXF%N1L?>;BC@QJa@bvHaL?>Wtc719V6XLH1Ja@fv HaLXbYcLB7:nambLYd<?7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L>iL[K7:@QY+F?>i>V@qd JML9 YcLBCBfLtc719V6XL!@CJaYcL9V_S9<`YZFYZ@r[KL±LY@CB1DF/N1L=>;BC@QJS@fv H:L=>

(34) _SF9

(35) F\de9i<\deFYZ@f7:JeFJT>+>i7:JX_a9i71mbLYZU1BQF!;gM719i<6FYZ@fv HaL L?>Y¨L`6%nSBf<6FYZ@fv HaLXN1LX;?LYZYcLX>±L?;?7:JTN1LX;`FYc<\d719V@fL ÎJ-L?t tcL`YZUJT7OHa>ENO@QY o9 H1JTLYZU'@QB>VRCF\d @CYNORQ@bN1LJSYZ@ftZ@bL9 _T7KHK9¯H1J > D >Ycp6XL·9i<)d @b71JSFB³N17:JaJM<U{vHaLBb>G>±71JaYIBfL=> ×w¦ ¡i¢ ¤Ù¬¥Z¢¤Úb=Z)ÚÙ1ÛÙsF\[1L?;¶BQRCF_a_1H1@{N1L¶BQF JT7:68L`JT;`BQFYH19Lytc7KHK9VJa@bLX_SF9BCFXYZFnaBbLkN1L?>;gT7:9ip6XL?>\ÌVB

(36) 6XLk>iL`6%nSBfLÓF\H N1L`68L)HK9VFJaY/v HaLBQRQ@bN1<?LXNORqHKJML × ¡iØ ¤rbÙZ£Úb¡± O¢¤£C¥¦Û YcLBCBfL vHaL BCF 9iL\[KL`JTNO@bvHaLJSY >iL?> F?N1L`_aYcL=>2L?>VY @QJSF?;?;=L_aYZFnSBfLÙ [K71@C9iL D @QJM;?7:6%_S9<`gTL`JT>V@CnaBfLÙNOFJT>lHKJML!_TL`9i>V_TL=;YZ@r[1L!g1D_T7:YZgT<YZ@b;?7ScN1<?NHa;YZ@q[KL/7:9VYZgT7aN17K]KLOÎJk9iL)[FJT;`gTLUMLBCBfL/L=>VY _TL`JT>VFnSBfL _a9i<?;`@f>i<`68L`JaYkLJ¶YZFJaYXvHaL4;BC@QJS@fv H:LA_SF9kBfL=>htc719V6XL?>lÒ;?LBCBfL=>ic;`@QU/NORfL`6%nSBf<=L4719iN171JSJT<?L=>hLY 9VFYZ@f7:JaFBQ@b>i<?L=>VU>i71JSY@Q668<=NO@QFYcL`68L`JaYNO@b>V_T7:Ja@QnSBfL=>/LYwtc7OH19VJa@b>i>iLJSY+H1J 7KHKYZ@CB@CJaYZ9V@QJM>ip?v H:LN1LNO@QF\deJT7S>VYZ@f; +LEvH1@MJTL[KL\H1Y

(37) _SF?>NO@C9iLv HaL;=LEN1L9VJa@bL9L=>VY

(38) @C6%6X<?NO@CFYo7OHkJML9L=vH1@fL`9VYF\H:;)HKJML!FJaFBqDéYZ@bvHaL!_S9<`FBQFnSBfLÒ BfL=>/N1<`naFYc>/N1L=>!FJSJT<?L=>Wz?||e~k7:JaYnS@fLJA6X71JaYZ9i<%v H:L`B_M71@QJSY o9 H1JTL`Y<YZF@CYFYZYZF?;gM<WWBCRQ@bN1<?LWNORqHKJML 6 F

(39) fYZ9V@f>iLBQ@C6%@CJaF@C9LwN1L?>@QJMtc719V6FYZ@f7:JT>

(40) NO@b>V_T7:Ja@CnaBfL=>F\[FJSYYc7OH1YcLwN1<6F9;`gTLw;gM719i<6FYZ@fv H:L FJT>yH1J·Yc7KHKYXF\H1YZ9iLAH1Ja@r[1L9i>VU©Ó@ <=7µF L=>iv HK@b>i>i<4N1L?>h7:_T<9VFYZ@b71JT>hv HK@/>±LA9F_S_a9i7a;`gTL`JaY >V@CJ1dHKBC@fp`9L`68L`JaYN1LwBQFwYcLJSYZFYZ@r[KLwnS9cH1JT<`YZ@fL`JaJTLÙ1na@bLJkv HKRbLBQBbL?>+>VRCF_a_aBC@fv H:L`JaY'N1L?>9iL_a9i<=>iLJSYZFYZ@f71JM>

(41) L`YJT7:J WN1L?>!L`JaYZ@QYc<=>w_a9i<?>±LJaYc<=L?>!;=71668LWN1L=>w9i<FBQ@CYc<?>!7:namfL=;YZ@q[KL?>\S%FJM> ¨¤Ù+ÚZ¢Z¢bÚ¡c¢Z¤ÙØ¡ÚbØiZ UM_aBqH:>@fL\H19i> F9VYZ@f;`BfL?>w>VRCF?;gTp)[KLJSYo> H19N1L=>9iL_S9i<?>iL`JaYZFYZ@f7:JT>w> DéJSYZgT<`YZ@fv H:L=>6X²BCFJaY×w¤Ù ¥£=¤Ø ZÛWb M SN1<?tZ@CJa@b>+_aF9+BfL=> ;@C9i;\H1BQFYZ@f7:JT>WN1L=>E@QJMNO@r[@bNH:>uWLYw×¤Ù ¥£= V ZÛhb '_S9L`JaFJSY¨L`J-;?716_aYcLBbL?>Etc7:9V68L=>>Dé6nT71BC@fv H:L=>EN1L BQRCF_a_SF9YcL`JaFJM;?LEYcL`99V@CYc719V@QFBbLi\aFJT>wBbL\H19¨L=tctc7:9VYoNORQF9VYZ@b;\H1BQFYZ@f7:J{N1L>±;gTp`68L=>FJSFBrDYZ@fv H:L=>VU;?L?>YcLJSYZFYZ@r[KL=> de9VF_aga@bvHaL?>h>i7:JaYYDé_S@fv H:L`68L`JaYHKJMLÐt 719V68LAN1LA;BQ@CJa@bvHaLÐNHG>iL`JaYZ@C68L`JaYWYcL`99V@CYc719V@QFBCUBCF?vHaLBCBfL(F{_T7KHK9 ß à`á.E .C å çéè$3 ) å 8 êî÷øCùóiþCøQóiùë1òVëC÷aùú1õí óiøqïQõZðV÷1÷þrïQëbðiøqïàiïQüió±ëQ÷bè äZå ã 2Kã ä , ã äæ@6\ærç å H :<; /èä ,, ã :<; 0"!è)1å äæ è5Q å C+C å äæ çè03 "$ å C 4 8cè$:<;.W1\è 4 , ã4eã /25W ! /3 0 /33 ! /3.Wã #Mß à`áiç å C+C ç ç¨å ä æ 3 2 $ ç æ ç '54 ç åuç56?å76 æ ç æ æ&% ç6 , 6ä å 4 æ H 4 A C 4 4 , +C æ æ 4 å å76 "' 8cè åZç I ã)(æ å è æQä ã è+Këbõ û)ùî ì1ÿVïQë+* ÷ ,Eëbøí îVðbûîCû)ë+* ÷ ,$-'ïQðiøCëfù àîVþQë N

(42) ùë ì1ùúC÷ëbðiøCîVørïQõZð NïQðiøQëbùò ïr÷þrï ìOí ïQðiîVùbïQøQúCè - ç æ ç=æ+* ä æ åuæQä . ä /0/ è2±1 æ çéè21 æ è$:<;.;.;\è 4 ã :3 : ! :<W.;ã 4 I ã J æ , è æQä ã è\êëQ÷OøQëbùùbïQøCõïQùëC÷òVóüió±õZørïQò ïQëbðVè)Kå äæ è.2 4 5 å ä C å åuçè$:<;.;ã.

(43) ?L t tZ@b;F?;?L¬_aF9VYZ@f;)HKBC@fp9iLWN1L9VF6XLJTL`9N1L?>wLJMvHa²YcL=>Etc7:9YcLE;=71JT>±71JaFJM;?LELYZgSJT7Kd 9VF_Sga@fv HaL![1L9i>+H1Jh9iLJTNH YDé_S@fv H:L`68L`JaYd<?7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L ÜeRC@QB'DkFX;BC@QJa@bvHaLU

(44) ;`RfL=>VY_SF9i;?LXv HKRC@QB'DkFFBf719i>9<=L6_aBb71@NORrH1JÐ9i<_ML9VYc71@C9iL d<?7Sde9VF_aga@bvHaLUSH1YZ@QBC@f>VFJSYoN1L?>l×lq fÚ¤Ù1ÛÙÝN1L=>+×w¤Ù ¥£=¤¤Ù:ÛUN1L?>l× TÚZÙ¡iÙ1ÛUN1L?>×£ ¤ÙØØ V¤b¡ ¥¥ Z)ÚeÛÙ BfLYc7OH1Yg1Dna9V@fN1<F\[KL?;N1L?>> D6%nM71BbL?>!v H:LBQRb71Jk_ML\H1Y

(45) > H1_a_T7S>iL9+9i<_ML9VYc719V@CFnaBfL=> ¤\OÎY

(46) ;RbL?>VYZU:HKJML/t 71@f>N1L _aBqH:>UMHKJMLW;BC@QJS@fv H:LE_SF9BfL=>t 719V6XL?>\1ÎJh6X²6XL/YcL`6%_M>VU71JhFYZYcL@CJaYF\[KL?;E;?LEN1L`9JS@fL`9L\]KL`6%_SBfLH1J³>YZF?N1L 7OhBQFEJTL)HKYZ9VFBC@QYc<EF\]@b71Bb7Ode@fv H:LN1L\[@bLJaYNO@btctZ@b;@CBfLSÎJÐNORQF\H1YZ9iL?>YcL9V6XL?>VUM@QB>VRCF\de@QYoN1LE>iLEN1L`6%FJMN1L9mqH:>iv H1RQ v H:L`B_M71@QJSYMH1JTLw;BQ@CJa@bvHaL_SF9BfL=>

(47) tc7:9V68L=>

(48) L?>YYcLJSFnaBfL . ¹»À ¿Ã À\ÈÁ ÇÊÀ Ç . . . . È¼±ÈÅEÀ\Â/Ãº. + 716_aYcLYcL`J1H N1LBCF%nS9@bp\[KL`Yc<XN1L%;=L%v H1@_S9<=;?p=N1LU'@QB'6%RbL?>VYNO@btctu@f;@CBfLNORfL)]_aBC@f;@CYcL9!BCRfLJM>iL6naBbL%N1L=> 9i<?>iL`9 [KL?>wvHaL6%RC@QJM>V_a@C9LBCF/_a9VFYZ@bvHaLF@QJT>@TN1<?;`9V@QYcL1ÌVBTtuF\HKY

(49) <)deFBfL6XLJSY_a9i<?;`@f>iL`9vH1RQ@CBaJaRbL?>VY_SF?>v H:L=>VYZ@f7:J N1LX9i<=NHK@C9LÓBQRbLJT>±L6naBfLyN1L?>_a9VFYZ@bvHaL?>ENH{d<?7Kde9F_SgTLX;?L`YZYcLHKJS@fv H:LX7:_T<9VFYZ@b71JMFX;BQ@CJa@bvHaLXL?>VYH1J 6X716XLJaYZU¬;=L9VYZF@QJM><)deF9N1>FJaFBb7OdHaL/BQFJT716@QJSFYZ@f7:JaUM6%F@b>JMLE>VRrDW9i<?NH1@f>VFJSY

(50) _SF?>+ÒaLBCBfL_a9i<?>HK_S_T7a>±L N1L?>lFJaFBrDe>iL?>UTN1L?>l@QJ1[1L?>VYZ@qd FYZ@b71JM>VUTv HK@SJTLN1<nT7KH:;`gTL`JaY_aF?>tZFYZFBfL`68L`JaY

(51) > H19HKJMLwF?>i>V@qd JSFYZ@f7:JaU1FBf7:9i>ov H1RQ BQRC@QJ:[KL9i>iL BQF·N1<?>@rdeJaFYZ@b71J _ML\H1Y-²YZ9iLµH1J _1H19-_S9i<FBQFnSBfL WÎYÐnS@fL`J NORQF\H1YZ9L=>¸N1<6F9;`gTL=>®L)]@f>YcLJaYÒ >V@C6WH1BQFYZ@b71JaUM6X7aN1<`BQ@f>FYZ@f71JSUS×lN1L?>±;9V@Q_SYZ@f71Jh<_SF@f>i>iLÛ/N1LYDé_TL@QJSYcL9VF?;YZ@b71Ja@b>VYcL/v H1@a_a9i<=;@f>±<6XLJaY9i<=;\Ha>iL!BbL 9iL?;=7OH19>EH1JTL;BQ@CJa@bvHaLULYc; TÎJ4>i7:6%6XLULBCBfLL?>VY+H1JTL71_M<9VFYZ@f7:J{_aF9V6@NORQF\H1YZ9iL?>\MÜe@C6%_SBfL6XLJSYZU>i7:J ;F9VF?;`Ycp9iLJT7:J-;?71J:[KLJSYZ@f7:JaJTL`B

(52) NORrH1JÐ_M71@CJaYN1L¬[eHaL%<`_a@f>Yc<6X71Bf7Kde@fv H:LLJAF%tZF@CY+H1JÐFJ:d BbLWF\[1L\HOd BbL%N1L=> 9i<?tuBfL\]O@f71JM>

(53) NO@b>i;@C_aBQ@CJaF@C9L=>\ 6X71J#>iLJM>VU

(54) BCFX_a9iL6@fp`9iLkNO@ft tZ@b;\H1BQYc<kv HaLk>i7KHKBbp\[KLy;?LYZYcLy71_M<9VFYZ@f7:J-9i<?>V@bN1LkNOFJM>EBfLÓ_aF?>i>VF\dLyN1L BQRCFJaFBqD >iLIF\H^NO@QF\deJM7a>VYZ@b;®NORC@fN1L`JaYZ@QYc< 7OH19Ð;?L`9VYZF@QJTL=>ÐL`JaYZ@CYc<?>yd<?7:687:9V_agT7:Bf7Kd @bvHaL?>U/BQF49i<=>iL9 [KL _TL\H1Y >iL`6%nSBfL9AFnT>HK9iN1L 7OH19VYZFJaYZUWBbL?>4;gSFJ1dL6XLJSYc>AYZgT<=719V@fv H:L=>A_TL)H[KL`JaYy9L`JTNO9iL¸;?L`9YZF@CJT>ANO@QF\deJT7S>VYZ@f;=> tZFBCBQF?;`@fL\HO]UJT71YZF66XLJaYkL`J^;=L-v HK@E;?71JM;?L`9JML4BbL?>h> H19tuF?;?L=>sNORb<9i7a>@f71JYcL`BQBbL?>hvHaL4;?7:JTx)H:L=>sNOFJM>yBQF YZgT<=719V@fLINOF\[@f>@fLJSJTL F@f>{;`RfL=>VYk> H19Yc7KHKYX_M7OH19hBfL?>(tc719V6XL?>{>_aFYZ@QFBbL?>{N1L BQFA[@bL4LJ·>i7S;@b<Yc<4v H:LABbL _a9i7:naBfp`68L!>±Lw_T7a>±LeÎJXL?t tcLYZUOJT7:YZF6%6XLJSYNOFJT>BfLw;F?>NORrH1JTL_a9i7a;=<?NH19Lw;?7KHK_SBQFJSYFJaFBqD >iL6WH1BQYZ@q[F9V@f<=L LY@CJaYcL`9_S9i<YZFYZ@f7:Js;`BQ@QJS@fv H:LÙa@CB1DFwH1Js;=71JSYZ9F?>YcLwFn1D >±>VFBaLJSYZ9LwBCF9V@qdéHaL\H19oN1L=>+71_T<`9VFYZ@f71JM>FJaFBrDYZ@fv H:L=>+LY BfL(tc71JM;YZ@b71JaJML6XLJSYFJSFBf7Kd @bvHaL{v HK@F68p`JTLhhF?tctu@Q9V6XL9_aF9XL\]KL`6%_SBfL{v H:L³BQF F6_aFkF9 dLJSYZ@QJMLsL=>VY 719 deFJa@b>i<?LLJyFJaJTL`F\H]XN1Lw[K7:J g KJMLJe5!Bf719i>v HaL!BQF!6X7aN1<`BQ@b>VFYZ@f7:JXg1Dé_M71YZgM<YZ@f;=7a N1<?NHa;YZ@r[1Lw9<)dHKBbLwBQF naF?>±L·L6_a@C9V@fv H:L¶LY4BfL=>¸YDé_ML?>#N1LtuFBf>V@btZ@b;FYZ@f7:J LJ:[@f>VF\dL`FnaBfL=>VUXBQF;BC@QJS@fv H:LL=>VYÐBbLµ_a9i71Yc7:YDé_MLN1L BQRb71_M<9VFYZ@f7:J4@QJaYcL`9V_a9i<YZFYZ@q[KLX>VFJT>¨[K<9V@btZ@f;`FYZ@f7:J L)]_T<`9@C68L`JaYZFBbL!ÒMBQRCFJaFBf7Kde@fLFE[FBfL)HK9/N1L¬[FBC@fNOFYZ@f7:J BQF NO@ft tc<`9L`JT;=LXN1LX;?LXv HK@

(55) >iL_SF?>i>iLXL`J468<=N1L?;@CJTLÙ@CBJSRrDXFW_aF?>N1L *OZZØ £= (_T7S>i>V@CnaBfLÙ7KH{FBf719i>NOFJT>/N1L=> ;?7:JTNO@CYZ@f71JM>WL\]1;?L_SYZ@f7:JaJTL`BQBbL?>VU+N1Lk>i7:9YcLyvHaLXBCRf7:J-JTLÓ_TL)HKYw_aF?>F\[K7:@Q9!H1JTLdeF9VFJaYZ@bLHKBCYZ@Q6XLXvH1FJaYwBQF _TL`9VYZ@QJTL`JT;=L%NHÐNO@QF\deJM7a>VYZ@b;M%FJM>!BfL;F?>N1L?>;BQ@CJa@bvHaL?>_aF9!F\de9i<\deFYZ@f7:JaUMH1J{F\H1YZ9L<?;\HaL@CB>iLE_S9i<?>iL`JaYcLÒ ;?7:6%6XLJSY>RQF?>i> H19iL9+vHaLwBfL=>ot 719V6XL?>+7OH8;`gT7:9p`68L=>+7OH8>VYZ9 Ha;YH19iL?>

(56) v HaLBCRf71J6XLYL`J%F\[FJSY>i7:JaYnS@fLJBfL=> . . .

(57) _aBqH:>_TL`9VYZ@QJTL`JaYcL=>VULY/BbL?>>iL\H1BfL=>W_ML9VYZ@QJMLJSYcL?> 9U+_S9<=;@b>i<6XLJSYZUo_M7OH19E_aF?>VYZ@b;gTL`9EH1@QJMLU

(58) @CBDhFHKJML @QJM>i;9 H1YZFna@CBQ@QYc<XN1LBCRr× ¤Ú¢ZaO Z¡r¢¤£C¥¦`Û_aF9EN1L?>6X7OD L`JT>FJaFBqDéYZ@bvHaL?>\M

(59) L?>¨d<?7Ode9VF_agML?>;BQF?>±>V@fv H:L=>/7:JaY L?>±>VF\D <N1L%;=716naBbL9!BfL¬d7OHatctu9LLJA6HKBCYZ@Q_aBC@QFJSYBfL=>!vHaL?>VYZ@b71JSJaF@Q9iL=>VUF\Hs9V@b>ivHaLWN1LEBCRfL`JT;\De;Bb71_T<=NO@f>V6XLEBbL _aBqH:>l[F@CJ. eL/JML/> H1@f>l_aF?>;=L9VYZF@QJhvHaL!BCF/;gT7:9i<6FYZ@fv H:L>i71@CY_aBrHa>+F\[FJM;?<=L/> H19;?L!YcL`9V9F@CJO8<`687:JaYZ9iL9 v HKRqHKJ7:nambLYyd<?7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:LjF4H1JÑ;=L9VYZF@QJ JM716na9iL¸N1L®;`F9VF?;Yc<9V@b>VYZ@fv H:L=>Ð>_aFYZ@QFBbL?>AL?>VYhN1<?t LJTNOFnSBfL 9i<YcL`JTNO9iLAvHaLÐ;=L?>y;F9VF?;Yc<`9@b>VYZ@fv HaL?>X>i7:JaYWb¤ÙE;F9VF?;`Yc<9V@f>VYZ@bvHaL?>XN1L³BQRf7:nambLYE9iLBfp)[KLU@QB6XL{>iL`6%nSBfLUwN1L BQRC@QJMN1<6X71JaYZ9VFnSBfL+XLÐ> H19i;9i 7

(60) bYZUF\H#9V@f>±vHaLÐN1LA>i;`FJTNOFBQ@b>iL9k;=L9VYZF@QJM>VUwmQRQF\H19VF@f>YcL`JTNOFJT;=Lh{;?7:JT>V@bN1<9iL9 BQRb71JSYc71Bf7Kde@fLd<?7Kd 9VF_Sga@fv HaL!;?7166XLHKJF?;YcLwN1Lt 71@17OH%;?7:6%6XLlHKJ_aF9V@ J%_ML\H1YF\H:>±>V@_MLJM>iL9

(61) v HKRC@QBOJaRqD FW_SF?>/NORr×²YZ9iL¬d<=7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:LÛU>VFJT>[KL`9i>iL9w_T7KHK9wF\HKYZFJSYNOFJT>wBQFE_M7a>VYZ6X7aN1L`9JS@QYc< 15H{N1L6XL\H19VFJaYZUBbL N1<nSFYFtuF@QY9VF\dLL`JaYZ9iLJT7OHO[KL`F\H]d<=7Ode9VF_agML?>

(62) NH19VFJaYBbL?>FJaJT<=L?>z?|e}e~MÍ JTLF\H1YZ9iLXNO@ft tZ@f;)HKBCYc<9i<?>V@bN1LXNOFJT>BfL_SF9YZ@bZ_S9@b>×ltc7:9V6%@b>VYcL

(63) ÛN1LWBCF%;BC@QJS@fv H:L¬d<?7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L ) +@fL`J YZ9i71_ >i7OHO[KLJSYZU/BbL-tZF@CYkNORQF\[K7:@Q9y@fN1LJSYZ@ftu@f<(H1JTL4tc7:9V68LÙwHKJYD_TLUwH1JTL4>YZ9cHa;YH19iLU/L`Yc; U/L=>VYX;?71JM>V@fN1<`9i< ;?7:6%6XLBQRQFnM7OH1YZ@f>i>±L6XLJaYwNORrH1JTL9L=;gML9i;gML 7OH19VYZFJaYZU>V@BQFd<?7Ode9VF_agS@fLW>±L[KL\H1YHKJMLW>i;`@fLJM;?LW>±7a;@CFBfLÙ _TL)HKYc LBCBfL{>VRCF9V9²`YcL9BQ L\H1YccLBCBfL{<=;gSF_a_TL`9%yH1JTLh@CJaYcL`99i7Kd FYZ@b71JG>HK9BQF4bBfL=>ZX>V@rdeJS@ftZ@b;FYZ@b71J>u8N1L³BQF tc7:9V68L ÎJkN1L?>YcL6_T>

(64) N1Lwtc7:JTNOFYZ@b71JhZz?|ee~V9U o9 H1JTL`Y@QJM>V@f>VYZF@CY> H19BfLwtZF@CYvHaLBfL?>;gM719ip6XL?>F\[F@fL`JaY H1J >V@qdeJa@ftu@QFJSYÐLYhH1J >V@rdeJa@btZ@b<& 7OH19VYZFJaYZUX;?716na@bLJ N1L#9iL=;gTL`9i;gTL=>A687:9V_agT7:Bf7Kd @bvHaL?>4<)[F?;\HaLJSYhBQF v H:L=>VYZ@f7:JkNH8>iLJM> 9VF\[F@CBQBCFJaY> HK9BQRbÌV9VBQFJTN1L!NOFJM>BCRQF9VYZ@f;`BfL_a9i<?;=<?N1L66XLJaY';@QYc<Ù @b;gTL`B !@rd7KHK9i7OHO]¬>±L N1L6FJTNOF@CYZUH1JA_TL\H{N1<?>VFn:H:>±<U;=LWvHaLEJM7OHa>wF_a_a9iL`JaF@QY+BCRf719 deFJa@b>VFYZ@f7:J{F\H19<=71BCF@Q9iLWN1LEBCRQF\de9V@f;\H1BQYH19iLEF\Ha N1LBCkN1Lk;=Lk>iL)HKB9<=> H1BQYZFY!6X719V_agM71Bf7Kde@fv H:L 5!@QBQBbL\H19i>VU

(65) 71J4FXNO@QY!LYwYZ9i71_-<?;`9V@QY!vHaLBfL=>t 719V6XL?>EN1LYDé_ML ;?L`JaYZ9i$L #e_M<9V@Q_SgT<`9@bLE<YZF@fL`JaY+N1L?>687SN1pBfL=>VUvH1@>V@rdeJS@ftZ@CF@fL`JaY

(66) BCFN17:6%@CJaFYZ@f7:J F@f>wN1L/v H:L`BQBbL/N1716@QJSFYZ@f7:J _aF9VBbL?ZYc 71J ·ÎY·;=71668L`JaY·N1<?tu@QJS@QYcc7:J BbL?>Ï;=LJaYZ9iL=> ¬HKFJMN BQF _S9<`6%@b>i>iL L=>VY#H1J NO@QF\deJM7a>VYZ@b; 6X719V_agM71Bf7Kde@fv H:LÙo_SF9VBfL9N1LX×+687SN1pBbL

(67) ÛyFnT7KHKYZ@CY/kF_S_aF\HO[9V@Q9%>@QJ1dH1BQ@bp9iL6XLJSY/BfLh>iL`JT>N1Lh;?LhN1L9VJa@bL9 YcL9V6XLUO[K7:@Q9iLwwBfLw_TL`9 [KL9VYZ@Q9VU1_:HK@b>ivHaL!71JBfLl[@bN1LN1LYc7OH1Y;?7:JaYcL`J1H%>i7a;`@QFB17OH%<?;=71JM716@fv H:L éXL;=L_M71@CJaY N1L[eHaLUMBQRbLJ1d7KH:L`68L`JaY

(68) F?;`YH:L`BM_T7OH19BbL?>wtZ9VF?;YZFBbL?>68LE>iL`6%nSBfLF?>i>iL`P@CJTv HK@b<YZFJSYZUTYZFJSY

(69) vH1Rf7:JkJSRQF\H19F!_SF?> F?;?;=716_aF\deJT<yBbLk_S9i7Ode9ip?>68<`YZgT7aN17:Bf7Kd @bvHaLy_aF9EH1JTLy9i<?tuBfL)]@f7:Jj>HK9%>±71J-@C6%_SF?;Y!FJSYZga9i71_M71Bf7Kde@fv H:LyLY >i7S;@QFB Í ÌJ1[KL`9>±L6XLJaYZU'H1JTLYZgM<?7:9@b;@bLJaJMLXN1LWBCRfL`J1[KL`9cdH19iL%N1L8L`Ja@b>iL HK6F@QJAJaRCF?;?;?7:9iN1L%v HKRqHKJA9iÖ1BbL YZ9ip?>wF\HO]@QBC@QF@C9LEL`YoN1L?>±;9V@Q_SYZ@ft/BCF!d<?7:68<`YZ9@bLEtZ9VF?;YZFBbLNOFJM>>F/9i<?tuBfL\]O@f71J{> H19BbL?>w> D >VYcp`68L=>N1L[@CBQBbL?>\ XL >iL`9F@CYcc;=L_SF?>'H1JTLFYZYZ@QYHaN1L9VF@f>±71JaJSFnaBbL ÜRQF\de@f>i>FJaY/N1Lk;=L9VYZF@QJML?>WL`JaYZ9iL_S9V@f>iL=>W;F9VYc7Ode9VF_agS@fv H:L=>VU

(70) BbLk>i;`gT<`6%F?una@QBCFJ®v HK@JT7KH:>WL=>VYw_a9i71_M7a>i<Ù gT<`9V@QYZ@fL`9_aF?>w>V@MBf7:@QJSYZF@QJ{N1LBQF;`F9VYcLN1LE> DJaYZgMp?>iLEtZF?x=71J @bL9V9iL©L?7:9 dLÙ>iL6naBbL;=71JM>VF?;9iL9+BbL!9iLYc7KHK9+ BQRC@fN1<`FBl7:JaYc7:Bf7Ode@bvHaLhN1LkBCFXd<?7Kde9F_Sga@bLs;`BQF?>i>@fv H:LÒ

(71) 71J¸9i<@QYcp`9iLXBQFk>HKnM>VYZFJT;=LkN1LXBCRf7:namfL`YZUo7:J®L?>±>VF@fLyN1L _a9i<=;@Q_S@QYcL`9o>i7:JX@fNO@f7S> DéJM;9VF?>V@bLUav HK@aL=>VYBbLw9i<?> H1BQYZFY_SF9VYZ@f;\H1BQ@bL9

(72) N1Lw;?7:6%nS@QJaF@b>i71JM>

(73) L`JaYZ9iLN1L=>'H1Ja@q[KL9i>VF\HO]Í 7KHK9VYZFJaYZU+vHaLktuF@Q9iLkN1Ly;?L=>W;F9VYcL?>> HK9i;`gaF9 d<?L? > !ÎBQBbL?>E>i71JSY@CJTtuFBf>V@btZ@QFnSBfL=>L`Y@CB

(74) L?>VY!NO@ft tZ@b;@QBbLXN1LBfL)HK9 @Q6F\de@QJML9'H1J8N1L=>VYZ@QJ_a9VFYZ@fv HaL 87KH:>F_a_a9iL`JaJTL`JaYc LBQBbL?>vHaLBbvHaL;`gT7S>iL L\HO[KL`JaYccL`BQBbL?>

(75) >±L\H1BfL6XLJSYtZF@C9iL 7at tZ@b;?LhN1LynaBQF?>±71J J¸_TL\H1YL`J#N17OH1YcL9VUNOFJT>BQFk6XL?>HK9iLh7OH-Bb7Od7a>LYnaBQF?>±71JT>71JaYwH1JTLyL?t tZ@f;`F?;@CYc<.

(76) _a9i7:_T719VYZ@b71JaJMLBCBfL!!BbL\H19>V@Q6_aBC@f;@CYc<OÎJsN1<=tZ@QJS@QYZ@q[KLUS9L`_a9i<?>±LJaYcL`9N1L?>t 719V68L=>N1<nM7OHa;gML!>i7OHO[KLJSY>HK9+N1L BQRC@QJMtc719V6XL 7:@QBCvH1@O_aBQF@bN1LUO68Lw>iL`6%nSBfL?uYcZ@CB_M7OH19JTLmQF6F@f>BbL\H19

(77) ;?7:JT;?<=N1L9

(78) NORCF\HKYc7:JT716@fL:Í.

(79)