HAL Id: halshs-00159575
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00159575
Submitted on 3 Jul 2007HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Efficiency of Uniform Standards for Transboundary
Pollution Problems : a note
Basak Bayramoglu, Jean-François Jacques
To cite this version:
Basak Bayramoglu, Jean-François Jacques. Efficiency of Uniform Standards for Transboundary Pol-lution Problems : a note. 2007. �halshs-00159575�
Documents de Travail du
Centre d’Economie de la Sorbonne
Maison des Sciences Économiques, 106-112 boulevard de L'Hôpital, 75647 Paris Cedex 13
http://ces.univ-paris1.fr/cesdp/CES-docs.htm
ISSN : 1955-611X
Efficiency of Uniform Standards for Transboundary Pollution Problems : a note
Basak BAYRAMOGLU, Jean-François JACQUES
!
! " # $ $ %& ' $ ()*+* ,($ - ! . / # , ++ )& %& &%$ / #
0! 1 2/ 3 4 !5 6$ 7 4 $ / / 8 . 2 1$ (), 9 ! . /# , ++ ,) ++ 9,$ /# : 3 4 !5 ! ; < / / 0 0 = // 5 /45 / ! ; / 2 5 / = 4 / $ 7 5 / / ! > $ < 0 4 4 5 4 / / $ ? /1 %,,+ $ 4 //1 8 1 @ 4$ " A 4 4 // / $ 4 4 5 B $ 4 %,,+ $ 4 //1 @ // 0 5 /45 / 22 ! " 1 4 / 1 5 !
"" " # # $ % &#' ($ " ) " '* )+ ' ' ($ '' ) # ) " ($ , " +- $ ) ) & $ . & / " , ' )+& " ' # # " $ , " 0 ) # " " & " ) " ($ # $, " " $, "+ 1" 2 +)$ ) 3+ && " ' $ +& / * %#' " ) + $'" " " $, - ) '*4 # "42 ) 1$" 5% ) ' " 4 ' - ) )+# ''$" / 3 " '* " )$ " ) 1$" 5% &#' ($ $ , % "+ ' ' ) ' . " ) $" ) )+# ''$"1 / 6 # ) " ($ # $, " - - ' ' " , & " - " $ ) ) & ) 3+ + 5 ) # 5" ) ) & " )*+ 4 '' ) ' )+# ''$" / , 4 $ ) # )+# ''$ # $ ' ) $% " ) # ' $" 5% ) '* , "1 & "/ " # "
' " &# + # $ " 3 " # ) " . " & +" / 7 $ & " ($ ' , $ ) 1$" 5% ) " 1" $8 && " +' ,+ ) / 0 # ''$" " . " ' 2 9 $% #+ " . +- " & " . " $" 5% /1 :4 " # # % &#' ;4 4 " ) " "4 ) "4 " & ' $ " ; '' - " " - & " $ . & " ) )/ <" 4 ; "4 " " "' ) " ' $ " & 4 , " " )$ - "4 & ) 3 "' ) " $ . & ; / :4 $'" ' "4 % " . 5% ) " "4 = " & " " 4 ' - / <) " ' $ " $') = = "" 3 = - - - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ) " %#' " - "$ " ' "4 = " & " " , " / # 5 '' . "4 $ " = " . = "4 ) # . "4 5% ) " . , "& "/ < "$ " &# " ) = & " " . . "4 3 "/ > 4 ; "4 " "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " &$ " = $8 "' 4 -4 "4 / 0 " = $ ) # ''$" # " , - & = - - " ) ) " . 5% ) "/ 0 ? ! /
$ #$ # "4 " " 4 '' - "4 "$ " , -$& " "4 $ . $ . & " ) ) / :4 -$& " ) . ) "4 $ . $ . & '$" = $ "4 $ " & ' / :4 ) "4 " = $ "4 $ " 4 , & ' ; '' - " # . ' -' = ' , & " ) & ' = " & " " "4 # . ) ' , ' . "4 = " & " " ) ) ; '' = "4 & / @ " = "" " - " " - & " $ . & " ) ) "4 "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) / < "4 " ; & ' "4 . '' ; - ($ " 0 ;4 " ) "4 % " . 5% ) " .
, "& " "4 = " & " " 4 ' - &#' " & . "4 &# . $ . & ) ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ;4 "4 # = ' " . ) # & " 4 & "4 $ " A < ) " )) "4 ($ " ; ) #" - " " - & & ) ' ) & # " $' ' "4 7 4 = -
-'$" B7 4 B C? DD ($ ' = $&/
> ) 5 E $' F < " " ' , & " ' - & " B4 ." < D = "4 )$ " . $ " & " 4 # " - . "4 & . = / $ . & $' & "4 " "4 # " - "4 & . '' $ " / :4 " # . $' '$) ) "4 # , . "4
" ' G " ' $= " "4 " 6 #' " "4 H ;4 4 # 5 ) & )$ " . ) 4 ' = # " = ) CIJ
& ' , ' " = &#' 4 ) = CCI B $ B DD / 6 3 " " ) $' & "4 " "4 # " - ) 3 " . ) 3 " $ " / :4 %
&#' . - & " ; "4 ) 3 " " ) " ) ) "4 K " G " ' ' & " 4 - B CC!D ) "4 ' G " ' $ "4 )$ " . $'#4$ & B CCLD/ 7 & '' $ . & $' ' M % =' ' 8 " "4 ) 3 " " ) $ ' "4 $ " & ' B@ " ) B JD #/ D / > = , 4 ; , . ($ " $ . $ . & $' < B@ ' B CC D #/JLN @ " ) B JD #/ D / 4 1 C 4 4 > " ! . 4/ 5 > " / 2 4 / 1 5 5 < - / . 1 D $ / / D&( 0 / 6 2 // %,, ! " 4/ / 0 / D&) < 22 5 / 4 5 D&, / / 1 *, 4 1 DD*! >5 C 2 / 4/ $ 5 / < // / 5 2 2 / : / DD% $ 4! +% ! 6 E / / 2 4/ 2 5 5 # 5 2 ; / DD% $ 2 5 5 / 4 / O
'"4 $-4 $ ' "4 " ' , "4 ' ; ''$ " " " = ; '' ; % &#' 0 "4 E 4 4' ) F/ :4 ''$ " " . & "" B OD/ :4 4 4 = # ''$" ) = '" CO / :4 =$' . 4' ) & - " ) & ) / :4 7 "4 ' ) "$ " ) ) ; " & . "4 "4 # " " ) "4 ; "4 ' , " &/ < C! & ) ; "H ' ) - ) "4 " "4 )$ " ; $') = 4 , ) = ;4 4 ; $') " "4 '" " "4 " . & '' / <" ; ) ) ) " #' " "4 " . "4 , "& " " . $ $ " B & ; "H ' ) ) "4 7 "4 ' ) D/ '"4 $-4 "4 . & "4 $ " ; " ) "' 3 " ) = "4 # ''$" "4 " " ' = " & " ' , ' 4 , $" ' " . & ' . E ($ " F ) E ' ) " F ) 5 ) = 6 # #' " . " # ''$" B ($ ) B C!!DD ($ " ) = "" B O #/ O D/
"4 % &#' 4 ; "4 5% ) " . , "& " , & " ' # " " = ) " & " . " . "4 # " $ " / # 5 '' "4 ' , ' . "4 5% ) " 3 " "4 - . & # " $'" - . & , ' < * / <" # =' " 9$ " . "4 % " . $ 4 " ' " . "4 . ; " # ''$" = )$ " ' - $'"$ ' " , " / " # ''$" - 5 & $ " &$ " " '' # ' #' " . "4 ' - . " ) 4 - / :4 " '' " . $ 4 #' " # " 5% ) " . "4 5 &/ <. "4 ' , ' . "4 " 4 -4 " ; $') = " ' . & ' $ " "4 " ' . "4 $ " , " ) # . "4 5% ) " ) "4 "4 $ " &# " " = ) # & " / < "4 "$) ; " $ " & ) ' ;4 4 ' H "4 3 " . "4 # . 5% ) " , & " ' # " " / > ) "; " # . " "$" ' - & " " & " - " " = $ ) # ''$" # =' & "; $ " / " ; ) "4 ;4 "4 $ " $ ) " "4 & = " & " . . " ) = "4 # . "4 5% ) " . , "& " "4 = " & "/ :4 ;4 " ; '' "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . / "4 $ " ) " ' "4 ) . ) # & " 4 & / )' ; "$) "4 ;4 ' . "4 $ " $ ) " = " & " 3 " ) # . "4 5% ) " ) "4 "4 $ " &# " " ; "4 " . / :4 ;4 " ; '' "4 - & " 8 . 1 DD+ $ %,,9 $ F5 / 4 G 2 // 2 D9, $ 2 5 2 1 4 / = 1 8 C DDD $ 1 2 4 / . 1/ %,,) 2 5 1 5 $ 4 5 = 1 2/ %,,) ! L
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
$&#" . # , " - ) . "4 5% ) " . , "& " "4 = " & " ) . "4 = " & " " B D
:4 -' = ' = " & " "4 $& . "4 ) , )$ ' = " & " 3 " . $ " ) # " , ' P ) P
/
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
$&#" ; $& "4 " "4 4 , "4 & - " " # ; / ; . $ "4 &#' 7 4 = - - '$" ; "4 ) " ' - " " # ; /
> ) 5 "4 P P P P P = $ P = $&#" / :4 & "4 " "4 $ " 4 , "4 & # "
- )$ " " . "4 & . = ;4 4 ($ ' . "4 $ " /
:4 7 4 = - - '$" ; "" "4 . '' ; - ; ;4 = "4 $ " &#' & " = " & " 3 "0
B B D R T B D D B B D R T B D D BOD B D P B D BLD ;4 P ! <. ; " "4 ' ; '. .$ " O "4 5 " ) ) " ; "4 # " " "4 $ . & " ) ) ; "" 0 P B D R T B D B D B D P B?D B D P B D ;4 P :4 '$" . "4 ($ " - , $ "4 ' , ' . "4 " " ' = " & " $ ) "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . :4 ' $' " "4 $" ' " ' , ' . 4 $ " 0 P B D R T B D BJD > ; "$ " "4 ' . "4 $ ' " ' " ;4 . "4 $ " $ ) " = " & " 3 " ) # . "4 5% ) " .
, "& " ) "4 "4 $ " & " . # & " /
"
#
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
"
$%
:4 5 " ) ) " $ ) "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . ) "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . "4 . '' ; -0 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . 0 B D P B D - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . 0 B D P B D C-$ 0 &# . "4 = " & " ' , '
> ''$ " " -$ "4 = " & " ' , ' $ ) "4 "; -& " /
> $& $# "4 &# . "4 = " & " ' , ' "4 . '' ; - # # " /
! ! !
! "
# ! $
G # " "4 " "4 $ " = " & " - "4 ;4 "4 = "4 & = " & " 3 " B"4 $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . D "4 ;4 ' $ " = " ) $ " &# " " . "4 3 " B"4 ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . D/ :4 5 ) - $') =
%#' ) = "4 , % " . "4 , =' = " & " " .$ " /
< "4 %" " ; . $ "4 &# . "4 ; '. ' , ' $ ) ) 3 " " "$" ' - & " /
&
'
:4 ) , )$ ' ; '. ' , ' . "4 $ " "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . B D ) "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . B6:D "4 . '' ; -0 - & " 0 P B D R T B D - & " 6:0 P B D R T B D R P B D R TG # " $& $# "4 & $'" - "4 &# . "4 ) , )$ ' ; '. ' , ' "4 "; - & " / :4 # . . "4 # # " # , ) ) ## ) % / ! " ! % & :4 ' , ' . ) , )$ ' ; '. "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . $') % ) "4 " "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . . "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " B D $8 "' 4 -4/ >
; . & "4 # ) - " "4 " "4 &#' & " " . "4 = " & " = "4 "; $ " B"4 # ' " D $') = %#' ) = "4 . " "4 " "4 "$ " ' "4 = " & " " 4 ' - ) -/ :4 , 5 ) . "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " ' ;N "4 = " & " ) $" "4 - . ) - "$ " ' / :4 ' . ; '. 5 & "4 $'"/ < ## ) % ; %4 = " ($ ) " % &#' "4 ' , ' "4 5% ) " . ;4 4 "4 ) , )$ ' ; '. . "4 $ " $ ) "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . 4 -4 "4 "4 $ ) "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . / :4 " 4 ; "4 " " "' ) " ' $ " 4 , " " )$ - "4 & ) 3 "' ) " $ . & ; / :4 %#' "
. "4 $'" & . & "4 $&#" . 5% ) " "4 = " & " " 4 ' - ;4 4 &#' ' ' , % " . "4 = " & " " .$ " / <) " ' $ " $') = = "" 3 = - - - & " ) 3 "
= " & " " , " / # 5 '' . "4 $ " = " . = "4 ) # . "4 5% ) " . , "& "/ < "$ " &# " ) = & " " . . "4 3 "/ > 4 ; "4 " "4 ' , ' . "4 5% ) " &$ " = $8 "' 4 -4 "4 / <" &# " " " " 4 "4 " ; ) - && " 7 4 ($ ' = $& ;4 $ " $ ) " = " & " 3 " ) # . "4 5% ) "/ :4 &#' "' ($ $8 "' 4 -4 ' , ' . 5% ) "/ <" &$ " ' = $8 "' ' ; " "4 - " " " - " $ -$ " " , " =$" &$ " = $8 "' 4 -4 "4 " ' . "4 $ " , " / < ## ) % ; ) 5 "4 ' , ' . ($ ) " = 5" ) " .$ " / "4 # , '$ . 5% ) " "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . ) & " " & . ) , )$ ' ; '. "4 && " 7 4 ($ ' = $& ) "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . / $& ' ''$ " " # , ) ) ## ) % /
(
:4 " ' H "4 ; '. &# = "; "4 - & " $ . & , $ ) 3 " " ) " ) ) " " ' " = $ ) # ''$" # =' & "; $ " / $ 5 ) - 4 ; "4 " ) 3 " " ) -& " = # . ) = ) " ' $ " " $ . & ;4 "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " . , "& " "4 = " & " " 4 ' - $8 "' 4 -4/ :4 $'" 4 -4' -4" "4 . " "4 " "4 -$& " . & ' " . $ " " ) . ) "4 $ . $ . & " ) ) " " ' , & " ' -& " " '; ## # " # '' ;4 " " $ " "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " $'" - . & "4 " '' " . = " & " " 4 ' - /)
Q S * + , B OD0 , & " ) " " ." :4 " " - . , & " ' : " - %. ) , " G / Q S * - + * + . / + . 0 B ?D0 ' ! & ; - # # 4 ) 4 4 < Q ?/ ?S , "+ G <U 6 $#4 /QOS * - + + # + . . B CCCD0
! ! # ) $ ' . & , '/O 7 / O! ?!/
QLS + * + - + , B ?D 0 (
! $ ' . , & " ' & ) - & " , '/ LC ? OL/
Q?S 0 + B D0 ) ! * " & :4 ) < " " ' , & " ' # " ); '- / QJS 1 + * B JD0 + , # ; - # # / Q!S 1 + B CC D0 ! $ # $ ' . , & " ' & ) - & " , '/ ?? ! / QIS 1 + B CC D0 - ! ! # , & " ' ) $ & , '/ L ?C/ QCS + * $ + % -+ . $ B CCLD0 . # ' - ' & , '/ !! IL/ Q S + . 0 B C? D0 # & " , '/ I ?? J / Q S , + B CJ D0 :4 " " - . M "# @ , ) , " G &= )- / Q S ' + 1 B CC D0 * % '/ /@ # ) / " & B ) /D - " ) , & " ' < $ 0 $ # G # " , G ) - . & 7 ; -- . - ? ! $ CC ' 0 ) , , " G 4/ / O
! "
> # , ) 4 "4 ) , )$ ' ; '. &# = "; "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . B D ) "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . B6:D B; "4 P D/ , "4 , '$ . " . "4 ) 3 = "; - & " 6: ) -& " " & . ) , )$ ' ; '. . 4 $ " ; "" 0 P B D B D B D R B D R B D ) B D " $ $ .$ " Q S Q S Q S B D B D B D R B D 5 " / ($ "' . $8 "' ' - , '$ . - " "4 "4 '$) "4 " "4 $ " # . "4 - & " ) 3 " " ) " ) ) ; "4 " . " "4 - & " $ . & " ) ) ; "4 $" " . . "4 ' , ' . 5% ) " . , "& " $8 "' 4 -4/! # $
% &
&
'
> ' . # 5 ' , ' . "4 5% ) " ;4 4 " 5 "4 ) " / " " &$ " = $8 "' 4 -4 $ 4 "4 " $ " = " " "4 7 4 ($ ' = $&/ )' " &$ " = 4 -4 $-4 " =" "4 $# " " & . ) , )$ ' ; '. . "4 ) 3 " " ) - & " ; "4 " . B6:D , "4 $ . & - & " ; "4 $" " . B D/ " " &$ " = ' ;$-4 $ 4 "4 " "4 $ " 4 , 4 -4 $" ' " ' , ' "4 - & " 6: &# ) " "4 " "4 7 4 ($ ' = $&/ > 5 " ' H "4 ) " ;4 4 &#' "4 " "4 ;4 $ " = " " "4 7 4 ($ ' = $& 7 4 ($ ' = $&/ " "4 7 4 ($ ' = $& ;4 $ " = " "4 $" ' " ' , ' . "4 $ " . '' ; 0 P P P T L
;4 P P : = 7 4 ($ ' = $& 4 $ ' " ' ) , " &$ " = # 5" =' / $## "4 " $ " ) , " ) = " "4 5 " ) ) " . $ " "4 = & B D P B D/ :4 $" ' " ' , ' . "4 $ " ;4 ' $ " = " 0 P B D R T B D P B D R T # " "4 ; '. ' , ' . "4 $ " B N D "4 " =' = ' ;0 $ " ) " = " $ " = " $ " 0 B D R T B DN $ " 0 B D R T $ " ) " = " $ " 0 TN $ " 0 T :4 ) " ;4 4 &#' "4 " "4 ;4 $ " = " 7 4 ($ ' = $& "4 . '' ; -0 B D R T B D T B D B D B D > ; % & "4 ) " $ ) ;4 4 "4 $ " 4 , 4 -4 $" ' " ' , ' "4 - & " 6: &# ) " "4 " "4 - & "
) " "4 " "4 7 4 ($ ' = $&/ , '$ " "4 $" ' " ' , ' . "4 $ " "4 - & " 6: $ - ($ " L ;4 4 - , $ "4 %# . "4 " . / > =" 0 P P B D R T B D ; "4 B D P B D :4 $" ' " ' , ' . "4 $ " "4 - & " ($ ' " 0 P P B D R T B D ; "4 B D P B D :4 $# " ) " . ) , )$ ' ; '. . "4 $ " "4 - & " 6: "4 - & " ; "" 0 B D B D B D R B D B D ?
:4 $# " ) " . ) , )$ ' ; '. . "4 $ " "4 - & " 6: "4 && " 7 4 ($ ' = $& ; "" 0
B D B D B "D = $ P T > $ ($ ) " = 5" ) " .$ " 0 B D P ; "4 B D P ;4 ) # " , / > ; ) 5 "4 = " & " ' , ' " ) ; "4 "4 .$ " ' . & / $ - / % B D P B D P P R 2 # B D P B D P P R 3 B D P B D P P R > ' . "4 ;4 "4 % " "4 # 5 , '$ . 5% ) " . ;4 4 ) " ) O &$'" $ ' , 5 )/ > '' ; "4 # & " ) " , = "; ) " , ' . > = , 4 -4 $&= . ;4 "4 "4 ) " , 5 )/ % &#' ; "4 P P P "4 "4 ) " , 5 )/ $ ) " ) " ) ) " O
:4 & "4 " 5 ) "$ " ;4 "4 - & " 6: ) & " " & . ) , )$ ' ; '. "4 && " 7 4 ($ ' = $& B $ " = " D ) "4 - & " . "4 , '$ . "4 # & " ) )/