• Aucun résultat trouvé

Mobilisation des connaissances scientifiques et dispositifs participatifs

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Mobilisation des connaissances scientifiques et dispositifs participatifs"

Copied!
23
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-01190312

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01190312

Submitted on 3 Jun 2020

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Mobilisation des connaissances scientifiques et dispositifs participatifs

Pauline Landel

To cite this version:

Pauline Landel. Mobilisation des connaissances scientifiques et dispositifs participatifs. Congrès du GIS Participation du public, Décision, Démocratie participative, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (EHESS). Paris, FRA., Oct 2011, Paris, France. �hal-01190312�

(2)

8

$.5!.!.!

$#!"#$!#!"$!!##$$#!#

!##&!"! " " !"-

""-8:#!9788

##$##!#$!"""#"!##"$!"#"

""""# $""/#$ $"#$&#

/&#"# $".#!&!"#"/$"$!$("##!#$!#"$!$

#$"-$/&#" $"""$!"!.#

&"!#"#!" $2'"##"$!!$!##"!

"""-%"#""#$!#$!"!$#"0!#1#/0#1.

""!&#"#!!#!""!#!/&$#"#"""$"!/##"

!"""!" $/"#!#$&"#!&!""-#/$#"

###""!#"#$!"/!"""#"!##"#!##/$'"# $"#

# $"."#!#/!##!#"$'!!""#

""""$!/(""""#"-#/!"#!""$!"$' /#$!".$# $-"#!#/#!#!!"#("

""" $"#""-##!#$!&#!#&$!"#

/#3&$!$&-!#4-/("!"!!#"!#"#""

" $""#"!""#$!"$&#/$&## $.

# ' # "

% &% & # " $ # "

# ( " )"

#

(3)

C

.%!''%7

(-(+'-; 7<BE+.%.+'+FDAAD+!,7

&(+-!)+-!!)-!/,-)%.,')%.,!'/(*.)(.+%)+!,!,!('',%, (!0 - '(%(!*.,-,!'-!!*.,7%%,-!-)+%- (+!=,!')(%!-!*.5) !%(,() !)(%!-!*.

'(+&-!/>5(&&',%)+-!*.-%,!,(.+,)(%!-!*.,7(.++-!',.-.+,5%%)+&--+!- '-8&%!(++%+-+&(+-!*.,!,!(',!',!*.%.+9!!-:58,-<<!+

%.+)!-+,(.+%,)+(%&,!'-!!,)+%8-!(').%!*.7%%)+&--+!-'(.-+

&!.0&"-+!,+%,+!,*.,8!++/+,!!%!-%!,.0 (!0- '(%(!*.,5'&%!(+'-%)+!,' (&)-,!'-+-,')+,'5'+'-!,,'-.'&!%%.+&"-+!,%8!'+-!-.)+%

&(!%!,-!('%/+!-,(''!,,',0!,-'-,5-'/(+!,'-%8&+',(%.-!(', '(./%%,-%-+'-!/,7

)%.,')%.,8'%1,,)(,!-!/,',!')(%!-!*.,8-- '-('(,+/+%

('-!(''&'-,!,)(,!-!,)+-!!)-!,)++))(+-,($-!,7,'%1,,,('-'-+,,.+

%,$.0,-.+,',%8(+'!,-!('-%-'.,-,5,.+%8'%1,+!-!*.%

+)+,'--!(',!'-+-,',%!,.,,!('-%!,!('-5(')%.,+'-5,.+%,

!+'-,'$.0)(./(!+')+,'=)+0&)% CAAG55CAAD>7%%,

&('-+'-%!/+,!-,)+-!*.,-,(-+!',*.!0!,-'-++!+%8/!'*.+/-

%8!'$('-!('%)+-!!)-!('7

--'-+)+%,-.+,,&%)''-(&)(+-+.''%&(+-'*.!('+'%8'%1, .('-'.&&%!,!('5-%( +'%%<!)++))(+-.0($-!,&(+-!

-8!!-7'-5.',*.,-!(',(+,)+%,-,,.+%&(+-!)+-!!)-!/

.$(.+8 .!,-,/(!+,!5-',*.%%,('!-!(',5%%).--!/&'-+)('+.0!,

*.8('%.!,,!'5-')+-!.%!+'*.!('+'%, (!0,!'-!!*.,-- '(%(!*.,7 8'%1,,)+(.+,%&(+-!)+-!!)-!/))(+-/!&&'-,%&'-, +)(',7!,!%,&%',,!+)+!%%.+,,8-- +%8'%1,%+!-!('.('-'.

&&,!,!(',!,,.,,!,)(,!-!,%&(+-!)+-!!)-!/7 %0!,-.,,!5'-5.'

!/+,!-,)+-!*.,-,(-+!',&(!%!,-!(',(''!,,',',%,!,)(,!-!, )+-!!)-!,7--+%0!(',/%())'(-&&'-.-(.+,))+( ,('!-!/,%8-!(' ).%!*.-%8'%1,%+!-!('-!+.%-!(',!,=)+0&)% 5CABA6 5CAAC>7%%).--+'+! !)+.''%1,'-+,.+%8,-%&(!%!,-!(', (''!,,',,!'-!!*.,',%,!,)(,!-!,)+-!!)-!,%!,%!,!('- '!*.-

- '(%(!*.7)+-!+8.'-.,',%(&!'./%())&'-+!(%5('&('-++

*.-%!+,.+%,(''!,,',)+&-/(!%++-!','$.0)(%!-!*.,,.+%, ('!-!(',8.' (!0%(!,&(+-!*.-!'-+&,!,!('- '(%(!*.7 8+-!%,-(',-+.!-'-+(!,)(!'-,7(.-8(+5.'--%8+-&('-++'*.(!%*.,-!(', (''!,,',!&)(+-',%,+%0!(',-.%%,,.+%&(+-!)+-!!)-!/7',.!-5)+-!+

.,8.'!''(/-!('- '(%(!*.'+!.%-.+5$&('-++!(&&'---*.,-!(', (''!,,',,-.,,!.')+(.)-!(')(.+%,-.+,5-(&&'-5',%)+-!*.5!%,-

(4)

@

%#(( 4")'*"+'()#)'"(1%#')(%''")()#'(4)*'(1(*' '$ *%')%)"( !# ()#"(#""(("(%#*' (#"3))" -(%'!))'1

"(*")'#(!)!%(1+# '("*,%# )&*( ())&*()#"(#""(("() '* )#"('%%#')(#'"%'(""( + #%%!")4*")"# #3(

"*,%# )&*(#"'"")4*"%') !((%#()#"#""(("( (%#*'

%'!))'*")!#')&*)((#"(5(6(*' (#,)"# #&*(2) 4*)'%') (#"(&*"(*'"#"!"))* 4))'* ' '!#""(("(3

'")()#'( !#')) 4)#"%* &*%#(") &*()#"(!#-"(

#"'!#')&*!")((#"(! *'&* )1)#'")%#*'' &*()#"

(#""(("(1"%'#%#(")'")(!# )( *'!# ()#""( 4)#"%* &*3 4#'1*"%" ))')*'((") !")"#'!))') % 1*'"#*+ !"))*

#")"**)"(*"(-()!!#')&*#") )!)'%#(')(*' ')#"3 (($)(1 ()(*)#*' "#)#"!#')%')%)+"#*''((")')"((#*'(1

%'#("#'!)(1(*' 4 #')#"4*"!#'))"&*#") #")#"(') 4 )

")' ((+#'(3""14*)'(%%'#(+ #%%")*#")'' 4( #" &*

'")#"7''()#"((+#'(1)"#)!!") &*()#" 4((#""(("(

(")&*( (1()*"#")#"!%#')")%#*''%#"'*,#)(!#')) 4)((#"(3

%$ !"

%*( ! *(""(>DC=1#"#('+*"'"#*+*()(*)#*' 4

!#') ')+1"("((# ()"% #(#%%# )&*"#'!)+3()(#")

"%')"#*'' ))')*'(*' !#')%')%)+1"&* (*,"#)#"(

')#")%')%)#"'"+#")*((%'#(()#'(%# )&*('")(1#!!

(#* " 4') (-")()9?==B:3

"(()(1')"(*)*'((4#'")"' ')#"5

"##

#"691?=>>1%3CA: ')#"

%'!))')'*' %')(''*'()* (#*!#' ("( ((#"(3

#*' "9?=>>:1 #"(')#"'(#"" )%')"")(%'# !(&*

%'!) ')#"*"#")#"%()!&*(*%% !")'3 %'!) %'#*)#"

#""(("(1''"(14#%"#"("#*+ (1+#'4""#+)#"(&* 4#""4*')%*%'#*'

*)'!")3

()#'( ')#"!))")"( 4")(*' 56#!!

4%% ");9#%3)31?==B:1&*'#"') )!)%# )&*3)) +')*()'")%' &* )()(3 8"4()%("%' &* )('*!")(

"(!(%' (%'#*'(&*#'"(") ((*((#"(3(%'#*'(#+")%'!))' #"'#"))#"4(")'("+*(#") #!%#')!")()%"(%')'4*,

(5)

C

" )++8" +A7*%$+""*(, ')#++$+,$% /'",*) *%$$"(,*8 "$80. +'*

*,** %$7

9 *%$$":$ + ))$$ "8 " *%$*,# )*=%$')") +* $%$

8),#$+*9)+ %$$"*:>5$ "8 ")#** $%-" *%$*+ $ $*")% +'," 7*

+%) $*"#%)+ " )+ . $ **$+") *%$*+*%##"8$#,+,"

8),#$+*= +"75B@AA>7**,)') $ '(, #+"8$+*,)"8%)$ *+ %$

+$5"" )+ %$')#++) +*% /'",*9""

" &=5AFFF5'7DE><*$*(,"

(,*+ %$,%$+$,*'),.**% +%)7)+)) *%$$"" * %$ $"*+

,** $ 5%##")''"" =%'7 +75'7ED>5')*%$)8'+ " +'%,)"8$*#"

*')+ '$+*7$**5"*),#$+*% .$+. *)%$. $)')"#%$*+)+ %$",) ." +=+,""%,#%)">7$),#$+) *%$$"*+"%)*", (, )#'%)+"8* %$"'",*

")7

$+"" $ + %$*),#$+*9) *%$$"*:*,)+,!%,)8, (,"(,* ,"+*

')+ (,*,/(,"*"*+*+,"**,)"#%)+ " )+ .*8++""$+7$*")

+%) (," # +')++$%+ %$(, *+9) *%$$":5,$+*,) +*,)"(,*+ %$"

$+,)*),#$+*= +"75%'7 +7>7% .$+; "*+),$ (,#$+%$**,)*

%*).+ %$*#' ) (,*4, $"#% " *+ %$*0#%"*5+#% $*.% )) +*

=>5*+;""*%, +"%###%0$8/')** %$** "+%,*+'%,.$+#'%)+)

"%$. + %$=B@@D>4##5") +)$%)#+ # *'"+* )$+*),#$+*

'%)+*')"*+,)*5+"))%$*$*,*%##%!+ 5*,)+$+"8%*).+ %$*

)''%)+*'%,.% )"8&,.)$*"* *,** %$*7%##$+)$+ )(,"*),#$+**+,)*

"*'",*', **$+*$.%$+'**8 #'%*)4%##$+ $ ),$ $%##,$"#,"+ '" +*

'% $+*.,$')*$$*" *,** %$4$(, %$)$"*%$$ **$*5"*(,*+ %$*

'%)+$+*,)"* ,"+*8%)$ *)",)%$)%$++ %$$*"* *,** %$*"#%)+

" )+ .7)$) =%'7 +7>')" $* )$)"') %) +,+%$+) +% )') )''%)+"8 #')+ " *,** %$7*+).,/"*'",*)$+*$ =%'7 +7>

.%(,$+"$** +8,$9*0*+#" )+ :5$*"(,"*) +%)$ *"%#'"#$+) +

$+)"* )$+*" ,/" )+ %$+"* )$+*%$$ **$*(,8 "*')%, *$+78,+,)

$%$,** "$** +)" ),/#%0$*$** )*,%$+ %$$#$+*0*+#6*

#%0$*.$$+"8++="% *" )+8/')** %$5 $*+ +,+ %$*')#++$+"+>+*#%0$*

')#++$+" )"**')*'%" + (,'," (,,/%)#*'",*#)$+*+ $%)#""*

*,** %$#)$+,'," 7$',+'$*)(,"(,*+ %$*#%0$*% +,** +)%)

$** #$* %$#+) ""7$ $5$ .%(,"(,*+ %$,%$+$,*

A ++ %$*, .$+ $ +"8" +$*"#%)+ " )+ .%##,$ "),"+,)69

# # %"

#'$(' (' % %("

# % # %#'$(

%

"% "

7:= +"75B@AA5'7D@>7

(6)

K

%0200%,+01 %0%,+0%0020) )% /1%,+;/))-+0),*-) *+1/%1 +1/%"" /+10 $))0 )% /1%,+C0-$/0-,)%1%.2-2)%.20-$/0?5-/00%,+%1,6++4,%/

%+1%*D-/,2%0+1%"" /+10-/,2%10 -%01 *%.20>)) 4,.2%+0%)+ 00%1 ?%+)2/)0 101%0-,0%1%"0 )% /1%"0),25;-,1+1%))*+1-,/12/0@ "%%10 -%01 *%.20A+0 )2/",+?,//1/ #)/)0-/,)*0;+00%0-,0%1%"0 )% /1%"0-)20)/#0;-,/12/0 0 10-,)%1%.201 ,+,*%.20@*/,A>

0.201%,+0/01+1,24/10;1/* %+1+-/1%/1%+0/%1%.2002/))%11 /12/

+,/*1%4) *,/1%.2 )% /1%4;,+0% / -/",%0,**-2+)%++)60/)0 --)%1%,+01-/,)*0,+/10) )% /1%,+;,**)+,1+1E C,->%1>D;+0)2//42).201%,+>11)%11 /12//)%).201%,+)-/1%%-1%,+25 1002/)0%"" /+10",/*0 *,/1%>))-/*1/ "%+%/0-/%+%-0

*,/1%.20-,2/)%0200%,+-2)%.2;1+,1**+1)-/%+%-?2+ #)%1 ",/*))+1/)0 -/1%%-+10;)2/0/#2*+101,-%+%,+0>))+?,/-++1-0).201%,+)?""%%1

?2+1)0601* )% /1%";+,1**+1-/.2.2?))+1/%1-0).201%,+0 %0%,+0 1)2/,+1+2>0-/,0020,+/10)-/%0 %0%,+;)0*,6+0*1 /%)0-/*11+1

#/+1%/).2)%1 ) %0%,+1)? #)%1 +1/)012/0;0,+10,+0% /1%,+0.2%/01+1 +$,/011)%11 /12/00+1%))*+1+,/*1%4>+21/,/-20;21,2/0+,1%,+0 *,/1%-/1%%-1%411$+%.2;+)60,2%*#%+)0",/*0#,24/+*+1)0-)20

""%0-,2/-/*11/2+*%))2/-/1%%-1%,+1*%))2/0 %0%,+0>

!

?21/0 10;21,2/)+,1%,+ *,/1%-/1%%-1%4;-/+++112,+151# + /) +0).2))0 *,/1%0,%4+1 4,)2/2(,2/?$2%=2+,+151/%000601*0

/-/ 0+11%"0C;,->%1>D;,3)00-$/0?1%,+-2)%.20,+1-)20+-)20,*-)50 1$ 1 /,#+0;4,%/%""%%)*+1#,24/+)0CE ;IGGHD;,3+,2425+(251 -/,)*002/#%00+1;+,1**+1+4%/,++*+125;.2%+ 00%1+1+,24))0*,)%1 0 -/,21%,+0 %0%,+0C;IGGHD>-/1%/,+011;1,212+)%11 /12//+0

%+0%)0%0-,0%1%"0%++,4+10.2%-/,)%"/+1+0)00-0?1%,+-2)%.2;1,2021,2/)?%

0),+).2))2+-)20)/#-/1%%-1%,+012/02/+/%1)0 %0%,+0

@*%))2/0A1-)20""%0"25+,2425-/,)*0>0 120*,+1/+14+11,21 )?51/!*%4/0%1 0%0-,0%1%"0;.2%-24+1/)4/?--/,$0%"" /+10) *,/1%

C-/5*-);HNLG;,2HNMK;4)?% *,/1%",/1<,2)+,1%,+

*,/1%%/1;;HNNM<,2+,/) *,/1%00,%1%4 HNNJD<1 .2%+0)?1%,+-2)%.20 )%++10,20%4/00",/*0%++,4+10;-,2/02%4+1%"" /+10 ,(1%"0#,24/+*+1,2#,24/++C-/5*-);+/+;),**%00%,+ 1 -2)%;;IGGI<,2)0,+" /+0%1,6+0;1)>;IGGG<,2+,/;2/ 0%);)0 5- /%+02#10*2+%%-25-/1%%-1%"0;IGGHD>

+-21/- //1/,%016-0?,(1%"0,2?""100%0-,0%1%"0-/1%%-1%"0;.2%,+/++11,20 2+* )%,/1%,+)#,24/+%)%1 )?1%,+-2)%.21)?""%%1 0 %0%,+0>

+-/*%/,(1%",2""101)2%?2+/#%+) #%1%*%1 ,2/ %%)%1 )?1%,+)?11;

+00,+1510,3))0B%0,+1/*%00+20,2 #/ 0>+/+;,&

(7)

J

?*,9%09@ )1(.%)/%'/%""%1'0 /-1;%',,'''/"*.(/'//%-1/'.,. /)00%*) ,*'%0%-18-1%*)0(*%)/' #%0%(%0 0/*)0(*%)/""%/)/)*//*% 0 /*)0(,*.%)/9'

%)2*-1';%),%0 .*%//)0%(,*/.//*'10%*)/<,.'$10=81/'*)'1%',.0

*)"%)/%0*4)/)/'*.,/;%)0.( %%./?,.0%/,*'%0%-1/8/4)%0/83,.0/:@0)/

';0091. /%'8';%)/.%,0%*),.%)%,/ (*.0%%.00,.0%%,0%2)/'*)/0%010%*)

%0*4))ELKK"%0,.0%;1),.*//1/. 0'%//()0' (*.0%"*.('',./' , .%*%001.?ELJH>ELKI@?8FDDH@9/'*%/%)/0%01)0%"" .)0/%/,*/%0%"/

,.0%%,0%"/,*1.'#/0%*)/,*'%0%-1/,1'%-1/*1'/1#0/(1)%%,13//)0/1.1) ,.%)%,,.0#1,*12*%.)0.';000'/*% 0 %2%'8"%) ,//.1) 00/.'0%*)/

(.-1 /,.';)0#*)%/(0'( "%)/1%0'%001.9%/*(('(*)0.2

8,.0#1,*12*%./0'%(%0 )/',.0%-180'/%/,*/%0%"//.2)0/1.0*10"%.

2*'1.'/.'0%*)/)0.'/*% 0 %2%'0';008%(%)1.'/'%2#/80) "%)%0%2

(*%'%/.',*,1'0%*)10*1.1,.*&0,*'%0%-1,*.0 ,.';009(!().)8';%(,*.0) .*%//)0*. 1)%(, .0%",.0%%,0%")/';0%*),1'%-1);(,!$,/-1'/

%/,*/%0%"/,.0%%,0%"//*)00./..()0*0 /,*12*%./ %/%*)80-1;%'/*)/0%01)0,'1/

/*12)0<" =?8

*,9%098,9FG@9%)/%8''%00 .01.(*)0.-1'/. '%/0%*)/)0.(/ (*.0%/0%*)/

%/%*)/./0)0'%(%0 /9%/,.%''1./8',.0%%,0%*)/.2)0*((' #%0%(0%*)';0%*) ,10"%'%0.'#*12.)()00.).';0%*),'1/""%)"*)0%*)/*&0%"/,*1./1%2%/,.

'/*),01./,*'%0%-1/,1'%-1/9)0.*12%)/%)*(.133(,'/#).;""0/8 '%) /)/''%00 .01. 01%)0'/,*'%0%-1/0,.*&0/ 2'*,,()0*1.$.$

,.0%%,0%29)/1).0%'/4)0$/0.%0)0,'1//, %"%-1()01*(%)1

2'*,,()0#.%*'0.1.'8A?ELLI@.,,'')0%)/%-1'/( 0$*/

,.0%%,0%2//*)0,' %/%0 /,.'/*),01.//,.*#.((/?0#)/';

)*0(()0@9)%)'1)0'/ ) "%%%./8/( 0$*/,.(00)0)""0.*)).' ' #%0%(%0 /,*'%0%-1/ 2'*,,()0,*12)0!0.,.1/,.'/,*,1'0%*)/*((

2))0<';30 .%1.=0),.))0,/)*(,0'//, %"%%0 /'*'/9)"*%/,'1/

.#%)' #%0%(%0 /;*(,#);1)#%);""%%0 ,1%/-1',.0%%,0%*)/01./,.(0 1//%,.*1%.*1"%.,0./ %/%*)/,'1/.,%()080(%13'/,0.13

*)030/0/*%)/';0%*)9,))08'/101./.)/)01//%;%(,*.0)0/'%(%0/

#).( 0$*/,.0%%,0%2/8-1%,12)0' #%0%(./ %/%*)//)/$)#.'/.,,*.0/

,*12*%.),'9)/'(&*.%0 //)""08'/,*,1'0%*)/'*'/);*)0,/8,.3(,'8'

*)0.+'/1.'/,$// %/%2//,.*//1/,.0%%,0%"/?)/'/'.$.$,.0%%,0%28 ,$// "%)%0%*)1,.*'(8;3,'*%00%*)1,.*1%0"%)%8,.3(,'@9/01./)/*)0

"%)'()0%)'1/)/'/%/,*/%0%"/-1;)0)0-1;%)"*.(01./8,.-1;%'/,,*.0)0/*)) /9 ,'1/8'/,.0%%,)0//*)0/*12)0.,. /)0)0//".)#/*(%))0/',*,1'0%*)9 *1')0/,.(%./*)/00/8*),10%)0%"%.1)13%(*&0%"*1""0'

,.0%%,0%*)8., . -1/%1))%(()0,.''%00 .01.8-1%/0'.$.$*)/)/1/900 .$.$*)/)/1/,10.*12.%./'*#%-1/2.% /9)/.0%)/*(%)/;0%*)

,1'%-18'10/0'. /*'10%*)2*%.',. 2)0%*)1*)"'%08*((?*,9%09@';)'4/,.

3(,')/'/1 0,1'%).)9;1)()%.# ) .'8'/%/,*/%0%"/,.0%%,0%"/

/*)0%)0.*1%0/,*1.# ..<

""

!=? 8FDDE8

(8)

G

,:GDA: '//.3)0'*./,.*1#.'!*13.)#'#09,.')!*#0#*))0.,.0#/,.))0/9*1 ,.1)*((1)#0#*).))0'/"*#4,1'#/,'1/,0'/:*(('./1()0

B @*,:#09,:FFGA9'/1//#/,*/#0# /< *&+

( ( %*&+ *&+ '( ) ( ( ' #($

:=:'')01*1000'*!#-19'/0"*.#/1)*131 ()!()0,1'# *)0'*?,.*10#*)/,*'#0#-1/,1'#-1/1)(*5),*1. .#-1./

"*#40/#/#*)/,'1/ #/9/*#0,.-1;'',.(0(#14'/,0.14()/

/#0*5)/9/*#0,.-1;'',.(0;*0)#.'/*10#)/.)#.//"*#4&.'#//:

)//)/9< *&+

( ' ( &

( $ =@ B9ECCE9,:FHA:

) #)91)0.*#/#(*&0# /#/,*/#0# /,.0##,0# /9'#00*1'."."; ##00 '!#0#(#090.#0,'1/,.0#1'#.()0'-1/0#*)'(*#'#/0#*)/*))#//)/-1#)*1/

#)0.//##:;#(,'#0#*)/,.0#/,.))0/,10) 0.).';0#*),'1/ #)

*(,'0)0'//3*#./';00,.'//3*#.//01./'*14*1/0*.#'/9*((

@DHHHA';(*)0.)//*))'5/'0.)/ *.(0#*)';0#*)';00).)9,1#/1) ,*/#0#*)010'#.3./'(1'0#,'#0#*).'0#*)/,.0).#'/)/';0#*),1'#-1://3*#./

/*)0((,. *#/'/1'.//*1.*!)#0#3*)0#/,*/';00,*1.!#.9)//*(#)/*2#'

*))$01) ##0*))#//)/9)///#010#*)//*13)0.#0/*((//#010#*)/

;#).0#01.#'@0':9ECCDA:)//9;/0??#.)/'/';00/0.*13 /)&14;0#*),1'#-1)*13140*(,'4/*(()/'*(#)';)3#.*))()0

*1';#))*30#*)0")*'*!#-19',.0##,0#*)/0'*.//#!)*(('(*5),*1.(*#'#/.

0,.*1#./*))#//)/)*13''/*1'0.)0#3/90*?*)/0.1#.//*'10#*)/.,*))0 14.#0./;1)3'*,,()01.'@9*,:#0:A:

,.0#./*)/00/0,*/01'09.0#)/101./,.*,*/)01)(*'(*.0#

0")#-1:)/'1.//#ECCD9#"'0':*)))01)/.#,0#*)(*'9 )/'-1'#'/0)0)0.'#.'/ 0/,*/#0# /-1;#'/*)0*/.3/)//#/,*/#0# /,.0##,0# / '#//0/0")#-1/0/#)0# #-1/91),.*&0(*.0#-1,'1/)*.(0# :,.0#.

';*/.30#*),")*()/,'1/),'1/)*(.14#/1//#*)/,1'#-1/'/#)9#'/

))0#)/#1)(*'(*.0#//1.';#';1)*?,.*10#*)/#/#*)/

/#)0# #-1/00")*'*!#-1/9)0./01.//3)0/0/#0*5)/!140+13.)0,*1.1)

#)*((1):0#'/.#000#)0,.';)!!()00# /<,.* )/=*).)/,.1) ."."/#)0# #-1*10")*'*!#-10>*1,.//*)/-1)/:0)!!()0,103*#.'#1 )/'/# .)0/(*()0/<0.10#*)=)(*)01'*.0*#.//#)0# #-1/@(#//1.

!)/#)0# #-1;1),.*'(0#-19 #)#0#*);1)-1/0#*))()093*#.;1)(0"*

."."A0)3'@0.10#*)/*&0/0./1'00/,.*1#0/,.'."."9,*1.'1.

10#'#/0#*),.',.0#-1A:#/';)!!()0,101//#3*#.'#1)/'/,"//*''0

(9)

G

&%%,7%,*(*,,&%+*+-#,,+#$&#+,%+++%,##$%,++-*#

%*#+,&%+8&*-$+0*+947+,::*8 ( " " " ""

" ' )" " ' " "* "

" " 69; ,#64B@@B4(6EC<6

$&##$&*,,%)-+*,*+(*-%(+,$&#&(*,-#*4.#&((

(*##-*+%++%#0++*$%,#%++,7%+,-**+%&-.-/$&+(*&-,&%

+&%%++%++%,)-+;(*/$(##8$&B9*,(*,#64AHHC<6#

*(&++-*#&/$,&&#&)-,,&*)-7-%%&%*%,&%++.&*+*-#%,%+

#+&*-$+0*+4+#&%#7(+,$&#&.#&(((*#+&&#&++%+

8%,*%,,&%%+,9; =4B@@D<6#+%)-4#&+(&-*#7%#0+, (&-*#+&%%+#++(&+,+#$&*,,%)-4&%%*&%% ,(+#7,*&%, (+,$)-++.&*+)-+&%,%+4-,#++%+#+,+6%%,(+*%%,*

#+&(%&%++,-*+,+&%%++%++%,)-+/(#,%,#-*+(*&-*+

.#,&%5%*%%,*&(%&%+5%*%%,*#+&%%++%++%,)-+

##+:$$+;%.-/(*-.+5&-*%%,*(*-.+(*&*$%&-7%%&-,7-%

,%&#&(*/$(#<6%+#+-$&#$&*,,%)-4,,(&+,-*%,

*%,,&%%+,(*$,,*,(#-+$&*,;##&-*,:*-,*,#7-,&*,++.&*+

8/(*,+9,(*$,,*,#(*+%&$(,++.&*+(&*,+(*#+,&0%+<,(#-+7,

;%#*++%,#$(+&%%++%+$&#+#+(&-*#7,&%<6

*4+#&%%&-+4+(&+,&%+(+,$&#&)-+(&+%,(*&#$67&*#7#7-%&:(*&-,&%

+&%%++%+,++&%+%,*,-*+-/%&**+(&%--%*#,/+,%,6

&$$#*((##,*%;B@@F<%+#++(*&-*+&:(*&-,&%+

&%%++%+(#+,+%+#&%,/,+(&#,)-+#-,,&%,*#(-.*,4&%%(-,

%*#++,-,&%+7%#,++,-*+#&:(*&-,&%68 &

& "& & "

%& #

& ($) ' &

"

&

69;(6AD<6-:#&%+,,4#%&%*%,,&%+&%%++%+,*-$%,+

%+%+#+&*-$+(-,&%-*%+#(*,)-$+)-*#+*((&*,+&*%

(*+%%+#+,+4,$,,*-(*$*(#%++.&*+*(*+%,%,+#+%,*,++

,-*+4,(+&*$%,#++.&*+)-(*$,,*%,-%,*,$%,$&*,)-,#

)-+,&%,%)-&%+*6%+#+,+,-#+#+#7&#&+,&%#7*-#,-*4

=;B@AA<&%,$&%,*&$$%,#+*$+(*.+"&-%,-%*'#(*$*(#%4

%&,$$%,%+#(*&-,&%&%%++%+4(&-*#-+&%7%%&.,&%+,%)-+,

%+,,-,&%%##+%&*.#-*+%,*,+6%++&%,&%+4,-/*++&-*+(&-.&*

&%,+(&+%,+,-*+4&%(-,#&*++$%*+#&:(*&-,&%.+,-*+(#-+

#+&-+(&%,+.-(#-+$*%-/+,*##$%,(&++#6%+-%-,**,#4.

(10)

I

?(*:#.:@ #.#'-#%;'%3--.%-,('-#'.,'.#('%-(0-;%(,'.%--.',- 1(%('.#,-/,%-'&.#,*,(/.#('!,#(%:'--#-*(-#.# -8%%(-,1+/%-

&&,---('.-(/1'.&(#'-'(&,/28.+/;#%--('..,-,,&'.#--/-;%(%-(/

,*,-'.'.--#'.,.--*.#.-*,(/./,-.--%,#-!,#(%-:#'+/%-.%- ,('--(#'.'*,#'#*(/1,.-.(/-%-./,-8/2+/#3*,.##*'.',%#.-('.%- ./,-%-*%/-(.-',--(/,- #''#,-8"/&#'-8-(#%-.(!'#.#1-8('%- #,&-

*,#1-.%-!,'-#'.,'.#('%-'1#,(''&'.%#-.-+/#*,(/#-'.%-(''#--'- +/;#%-**(,.'.'-%-.-:

#'-#8*,%'.&(,.#."'#+/8'>/%?ECCE@ #,&+/%&(%

(,/&-"3,#-(0.(/-%-./,--('.!/21'.%.'.#'.*-:%(,,-*('/' ,/.#('/,%.,(*#&*(,.'.,#%'*,'*-*%#'&'.'(&*.%;2#-.';#'!%#.- ('(&#+/-8*(%#.#+/-(//%./,%%-:%';-.('*-"/,#-.#+/*(/,(&*,',/(/*

(,/&-"3,#-(0%-(''#--'--('.*,(/#.-.#,/%'.-%('-,**(,.- (,#'!/28 (&&*,2&*%'-%- (,/&-"3,#-%#-/2.--/,%-','?#:8*:DIF@8(/

/,-#%(0%*(#--./,-#'/-.,#%-'--#'-.'-./*,--*(/1(#,-*/%#--.

*,.#/%#,&'. (,.?.%:8ECDD@:

&(%-.8' #'(&*.8--/,/' #'#.#('*,(/,%%&(,.#8'-%+/%%

% #'#.#('*,(/,-*,&..'.%;!%#.;-/.'.,*,.##*'.-- (,/&-

"3,#--/ #,#.!,'.#,/' ('.#(''&'.&(,.#+/8/',*,-'..#('+/#.%-

*(#'.-1/.-(''#--'-:*,.#,.. #'#.#('8%%#..,./,*(-#.#1-/,%

&(,.#."'#+/,-.#'-#'.,-/,%;'%3--$/2;./,-8.-/,/',#.#+/-

*,(/,-.,!%-,*,-'..#('%;)/1,'-%-#-*(-#.# -*,.##*.# -8+/#'-('.*- --4#'%/-#1-:,8(&&%,**%%'.A?ECCD8*:HG@8<

=.

$(/.8'+/#(','%-(''#--'-9<

!

! =?8(*:#.:8*:DIF@E:

'-('.2.8%"(#2&."((%(!#+/;/'-3&.,#--1(#,-('.#'./''!%&(,.

#&*(,.'.-/,%+/-.#('%;'%3--(''#--'-#,/%'.'-%-.-.%/,1%##.:

#-'.8/'.%%&."((%(!#%#--/'*,.#/.-/,%&(,.#-.#('.%; ##.

%#-#('' ('.#('-($.# -;.#('*/%#+/:#'-#8*(/,./#,% ('.#(''&'.- (,/&-"3,#-.%&(,.#*,.##*.#18('*,(*(-,'.,,%.%&(,.#

."'#+/-/,8'.,/.,-8%+/-.#('%<"#,,"#-.#('-(''#--'-=8-%('

%;2*,--#('.%:?ECCI@:#*,&..,8-%(''(/-8;**(,.,/'%#,!

(&*%&'.#,-/,%-,**(,.- (,.*(/1(#,'.,%-./,-- (,/&-8-/,% (' E%-.('##'(.,+/8-'-(/.8.%:''#'.*-+/;#%2#-./'".,(!'#.-1(#,- '-%;-(%/:#-%/,&(%&(,.#."'#+/'%*,'*-'(&*.,8+/#-.'.,%

*(/,/2(&&#%-%,**%%'.'-/',.#%',*('-:!!,#? .%:8ECCE@8;-.%

('-.,/.#(';#'.#.-8(%%.# -8.'(.&&'.*(/,*,&..,%,*,-'..#('-&#'(,#.-'-%- .--#'.# #+/-.."'(%(!#+/-:

(11)

>=

'&,$+,+,!&")-+,$%'"$"+,"'&+'&&"++&+*'-.*&,+&#-/('$",")-+6

$(*%,,*'-!*+-*-&&$0++0&%")-+* -$,"'&-* "%

'&&"++&+,-$6,*%* "%'&&"++&++" &$8.'$-,"'&$8&+%$+

* $+4+"+('+","+,+)-"+"+('&"$+;*++'-*+' &",".+4'%(,&+7<)-"

,*%"&&,$'&'&,+'&,(*'-",+$+'&&"++&+('-*"*&,+,0(+8'#,"4,

*&-+++"$+-/+*."+$8,,,".*+,0(+8,-*+6&* "%'&&"++&++, '&$(*'-","&+,",-,"'&&$$%","'&'&$",+(*'(*+$"+-('-.'"*%"+-++"$(*'-",

"&+,",-,"'&&$'%(*'%"+&,*+0&%")-+'&'%")-+,+'",$+)-"!((&,$8,,6

* "%+($'"+-*$+"+('+","+' &","+,%,*"$+!*",+4,+'&'&,"'&&%&,

*.$$(",$8,,,".*+,0(+8,-*+'&.'"*+'*%+8"&,*.&,"'&

)-,+$-*+'#,"+,$+&*6'-*$++*."+$8,,4*,"&+'&,"'&+-

* "%'&&"++&+(-.&,.'"*+"&$",+(*"&"($%&,('$",")-+)-"."+&,-

*&'*%&,-('-.'"*;."(*/%($$++,,"+,")-+4$+*&+%&,+7<48-,*+'&*&&,

$+*$,"'&+'&,"$+,(*,"(*&&,.8-,*+,-*+;(*/%($ *&,"*$)-$",+

'&&"++&+%'"$"++&+*,"&+'%"&+*$.&,$8"&,*.&,"'&(-$")-<48-,*+

&'*'**+('&&,+'&,"'&+)-"+'&,(-(-.&-+-'%"&* $"&;* -$*

$8+-/'&&"++&+-&".-+'",$<6

"&+"4-&%,!''$' "++-*$"*&","'&+'&&"++&+(*%,,*+$'&&'-+

8,-"*$+,+$%-$,"($","'&+"+('+","+(*,""(,"+-,"$"++('-*$%'"$"+,"'&+

'&&"++&+4+-*$8.'$-,"'&-* "%'&&"++&+8-&(*,,+-*$&,-*9.$"",+

"+"'&+*$,".++,+,!&'$' ")-+;&'&,"'&+*",*+%'*,")-+, 8"",(**(('*,-/'#,"+8,"'&(-$")-<6

"!

'-*'**,,&',"'&"*&,","'&+'&&"++&+4'&(-,.')-*-&,*'"+"%'*(-+

$",,*,-*4)-"+.$'((-#'-*8!-"&',%%&,&&$0+('$",")-+(-$")-+4&+$+

,+-,'-*+((*'!+",+ ! '-&'*

6+,+++'&,,'+&+"&('$",")-& $'+/'&&4;,$64

?==A<4%"+"$++'&,.$'((+-++"&*&;,$64'(6",6<6'*(-+'%(*&-++"

+&$0+++'"'$' "++"&+4,$$)-.$'((+&',%%&,(*"**

;?==><4'-(***0 ,+$;?==@<6

$",,*,-*-,'-*+((*'!+ (*,8-&'&+,,+"%"$"*$-"+

,!'*""&+$%'*,",!&")-4+-*$'%($/"","'&+(*'$%+8,"'&(-$")-, +-*$""-$,(*.'"*$+"%(,+*,"&+"+"'&+'-"&&'.,"'&+,!&'$' ")-+6"+

$$$+"*%&,$8"&,*,4('-*$+,-*+$"+"'&4('-.'"*+8((-0*+-*+

'&&"++&+$+($-+"$+('++"$+4(*%"8-,*+'*%+%'"$"+,"'&+'&&"++&+6

"&+",$6;'(6",6<(*,&,:"$+-'&+,,)-$ &++'%"&+'%%

$8-,"'&4$+('$",")-++'"$+4$8 *"-$,-*4$+-*",$"%&,"*4'&,($-+&($-++'"&

+8((-0*+-*+'&&"++&++"&,"")-+40'%(*"++'&&"++&+"++-+++"&+

+'"$+6'-*-/4$+,-$'%($/",+(*'$%+-/)-$+$+ '-.*&%&,+'&,4 ,-++"-&(*,-('"++"'$' "+6&+'&,/,4$+,-*+'&,,&&+,'-*&*

.*+8-,*+,0(+$' ")-+%'"$"+,"'&+'&&"++&+,"+"'&)-$$+ -"+

(*$*'0&5"$++,'-*&&,&',%%&,.*+$'$$'*,"'&4('-*"&,""*$+(*'$%+4%"+

(12)

EE

0.."2-.&.)(("..(.."(/"",0.8+)0-.2)"-<,0"'-!=//-'"(-&.+)&"/",0.

&.+&0.'';/-".:+0".&"(.((.EIID8.&) ",0..2&)++(/(.

;0/-.)'"(.;/")(+0&",0/(.;0/-.0&/0-.+)&"/",0.82()/''(/&.

3+-"(.(.&-.+)&"/",0.(2"-)(('(/&.8+- 3'+&(-",000? /&:8)+:"/:@:

./.0/)0-.++-)!..)(/-"!.+)0-+&0."0-.-".)(.:&.)0-("..(/;)-.

&'(/.-&3")(/.)0/"&.;(&4.+)0-/0"-&)(/(0) ("/"././".")(.

/+)0-!"--!".-&.)(("..(.".+)("&.+)0-&;/")(:&'"(?+-3'+&

/&:8FDDG@03+)&"/",0. -">(2"-)(('(/&.8. -"&&.;(&4..)(/"(."

".0/.+)0-+)02)"-/&"-&.')4(."-("-&."-(/.("203+-02.

)(("..(.".+)("&.8"(.",0&0-0/"&"//&0-""&"/()(/")(.)%/".&

+-/",0:(.&)'"(&;/")(+0&",08)(+0/+-3'+&&"(-&""&"/;0(

)(("..(.&)(/-)"..+/.? A8FDEE@:()(("..(./;)-"&."

&&./&+&0.2&"+).."&8;./>>"-+&0.&&./)--))-+-.)((.'+"-",0.

2-"".8/;0('("-,0"3+&""/&.&"'"/..2&""/:(.&.;0()(("..(

."(/"",08"&.; "/+-3'+&;3+&""/-&.!)"3'/!))&) ",0."/./&0-.&"'"/.(

/-'.-+-.(//"2"/)0-)0./...-.0&//.:(03"'-"/-&""&"/;0(

)(("..()(-(.+-/"((+--++)-/0(,0./")(&+-/",0:-3'+&8(.&

.;0("(()2/")(/!()&) ",08&.)(("..(.)"2(//-+-/"((/..&)(&.)%/".

;/")(+0&",0+)0-.0"2".)0&;)%/(/?+-02.;"(()0"/."&;)(20/)((#/-&./.

.0-&.(/+0&",0+-3'+&@:("(8&.)(("..(.)"2(//-,0/.03)(/3/.

;++&"/")(/03+0&".)(-(.?+-3'+&8(.&.;0("(()2/")(/!(",0(

-"0&/0-8&.)(("..(..0-&.+-)-'(.&;"(()2/")()"2(//-,0/.(

)(/")(&"2-."/..4./'.+-)0/")( -")&3"./(/./.0-&.,0&.&"0.")(

&;"(()2/")(0-./.@:

"(."8&./.0/)0-.++-)!..)(/0.."+-"&&0-.0()(+).-&,0./")(.

')4(.)(/".+).(/&./0-.+)0-2)"-..)(("..(.0/"&".&./"&.+)0-&

".")(:&.+-'//(/-&(-&./..0-&.2(/ .".+).-;0(.4./'

-!-!/')"&"./")(.)(("..(.,0".)"/.."&/0/"&".&+-&./0-.+0&".

/&. )02-('(/.:(.&)(/3/0)40'("+-3'+&? /&:8)+:"/:@8&.

0/0-.-++&&(/&;3"./(!"./)-",0;0(.4./';<"( ("-".)"&=3"./(/+0".&"(

0B."&8(.&)'"(.+)&"/",0..)"&.:&.3+&",0(/)''(/.4./'/'".

'&0-(/&.((".EIHD>EIID8)1&;")&) "0+)02)"-+)&"/",0(+&)(0"/0!)"3

;)02-"-&+-)0/")()(("..(.+&0."0-./4+.;/0-.?/&.&. +-3'+&@:

.0/0-.')(/-(/)''(/80%)0-;!0"8&. )02-('(/.)(//(("-2)&0-&.

-&/")(.(/--!-!//")(+0&",02-.0(')&-/")(&"/&"'"/:&.).-2(/,0

&/((./+&0/*/+-"2"& "-&.--( '(/."(./"/0/")((&.,0"+-'//-"(/03"("2"0.

.-++-)!-0'"03;0(+-)..0.".")(-/")((&&?&-/")(&"//(/"("(

)(/")(.)%/".&;)- ("./")()(/"/+-/"&;"("2"08/()((.&;.)&0@:&."/(/.

--( '(/.)''&-/")( -)0+./;)- ("./")(..+"&"./.+)0- --&.".")(.

-)0/"(9)0&;0/"&"./")(+-)0-.2-."&.+)0-2)-".-&+-".()'+/

;"()-'/")(./;- 0'(/.+-/"((/.9&'"&&0-0/"&"./")(;)0/"&./!()&) ",0.+)0- '&")--&;(&4./&".")(9)0()-&;0 '(//")(&,0(/"/.2)"-..0-&;""/

(13)

CD

-%.,'.!1-*(%!.!+/-8!'-!7%-.-/.(/,-**,( -(,'./'/.,,,-/,%-

&(3'-;,/!,%:!',.!./<'-%!-!('8*(-./%.':-.*%/-%/!-%('%+/%%

+/'.!.(/%,*,-'..!1!.-./,-*,.!!*'.--.+/!(&*.8:!'.,,(.!('*(,.-/,

%-&(3'-7*(/,%*,.!+/7-:**/3,-/,%-(''!--'-%-*%/-!%-*(--!%- '1(!.('+/%-.-/.(/,-**,( --('.*%/-,! -+/+/,.!'-

**%!.!('-*(%!.!+/--&. (-(/,.!'-,!.!+/-*/1'.!,,(!,8*,!'!*%

,*,( +/!%/,-.(/,&&'.!.-.+/:%%--!'!!,!'./',.(/,/&(%,.!(''%%

!-!('.+/:%%-/,!'.-.-'.!-'.,&-*(%!.!-.!('-.-8*,- '%3-7-,!.!+/-''(/--&%'.*-.,$/-.!!-8',%!.7(&&('%:1(+/7-

**,( --1%(**'.'!'1(+/'./'&(%!-!('*%/-*,( %/!%,.!('%!.

%!&!.8(&*,!-'&!'7(0%-&. (---('.1%(**-,*!&'.-,'!,- ''-7//'/./,'!.%*,(&(.!(':/'!-!(''.!,&'..-3-.&.!+/&'.(' -/,%-&!%%/,-(''!--'--!'.!!+/-*(--!%-8:(,*,+/%':-.*-.(/$(/,- ,'/*(--!%*,%-('!.!('-%*,.!+/7.'-/!.*,+/':-.&&*--(/ !.%

'---!./.!('-(0!%/./--!(&*(-,1%--!'/%,!.---7-*.!'.-888*%!(3, -.*%/.).7(&&%,**%%'.. ,!'.%8>(*8!.8?7*(/,;

<>.%87CFFE?8-/./,--('./''!&-*(/,,(''".,+/:/'!-!(''-

%*,.!+/-*,'-/,%-:/''-&%(''!--'-!,'.-7.+/:%%-.!'%/'

*,:/.,-./,-2.,!/,-'(,8'-%(&!'%*(%!.!+/7',.%8

>(*8!.8?,**%%'.!'-!+/:!%-,!./2!,+/%:('1!.'-/'-(!./!*,%-!'7 (&&%:!,& ,%- >CFFB?7.+/%:('(-,1*%/.).%*,(&!''/*(%!.!+/7

!'!(&&%:,./*(--!%7(//(&&/'&'.*.%7*%/.).+//,.!(''%8!'-!7-!%-

**,( --('./--*(%!.!-,%-.-7!%-&%+/',:.-(!..,

*%/.)...,!//2./,-3'.!'.,.!'1(+/,/';,!-('-!'.!!+/-(%/<(&&

,/&'.:/.(,!.-,1'.%/,-*,(*,-!'.,.-'-%-.-8(/,%-/./,-'%3-'.%-

**,( -7-&. (-('.*%/.)./'!'.,.*(/,,*'-,%-,%.!('-'.,(''!--'- -!'.!!+/-..!('*/%!+/7&!-!%-.%!,+/:!%,1!'.'-/!./*(%!.!+/:(,'!-,%

(&*%&'.,!.-!,'.-.3*-(''!--'-'-%..%!-!('8

!'-!7%:*!-.&(%(!-/,%+/%%-('.('--**,( --,**,( =.=%%%%

1%(***,!,, >(*8!.8?(/*,,,3 .-%>(*8!.8?8%

!,'%-(!(%(!--!'---/,/'-3&.,!--1(!,-7-'%3-- ,(''!--'.%-*!!!.-!,'.-(''!--'-7.,(''!--'.'*,.!/%!,%

*,.!/%,!.%&. (-!'.!!+/.-(''!--'-+/:%%*,(/!.8 %':-.*%/-+/-.!('

!,+/:/'(''!--'-!'.!!+/-./'*,/1'-%:-(%/7.+/%*,(,--!'.!!+/1!-

!,;%1,!<7&!-,(''".,''&(!'-+/%&. (-!'.!!+/*,&.!, ,.!'- (---/,%,%7'2*%!!.'.%-%!&!.--(''!--'-+/:%%*,(/!.8- -(!(%(!-7.(/.'!'.,'.%-,-/%..-.,1/2'.,!/,-&('.,'.%:!'%/'-./,- 2.,!/,->-(!(=('(&!+/-7/%./,%-7!(%(!+/-9?-/,%-*,(/.!('--!'.!!+/-7

*,&..'.!'-!,/.,%,%.!1!-&-(%//+/%*/1'.('/!,,.!'-!'.,*,..!('- -. (,!-;'('!,'!.!(''!-.-<>*(/,,*,',%.,&$!. @7 (*8!.8?8

(14)

<>

%')'(%"()*)(%() ""&*(2()(*)"*'(%%'"(%*,!)"!

"*'!'( !)(%"*'''*- ".!("!')(5() "()"!(

"!!((!((!)&*(%"*'("!%*&*4 (%' ))!)!('%")('(

&*()"!(&*("!)2" "!5,"&*2("*,!)!"'(('(5)*((%")""*(2)

%"*')!)*$*'(%'"*%)"!((%"*,"'(%*()(%'" )&*((("!

(()*)"!(5!'))*4!%')*'2(%*,!)&*()"!!''#((!!*- )*'(%',(2"*'!((*'("!!((!(("*,!)!)'*-!('()((*'(

!"*,()!""()*'( %)(8,"'%'- %2=;;=2%"*'5!.(

5*)()"!(!" '%')"'5)"!%'('"*%(5!)')("!" &*(*

!,**'"%!94(%*,!)*((%' ))'5!.('(.! &*( "()"!(

"!!((!(&*"!*(!) ))'!,!)"*,"'')!(!*-"*)'!),(!((

(%'())5)"!%*&*4

!(5!( 5))))')*'&*!"*(,"!(%'(!)2"!,")"!&*&*()"!

("!!((!()!)*!%'!)("!("'%*((*'5)"!%*&*2)&*&*()"!

!)*'("!!((!(())')' !)45 '( "!)'' !)!!)&*5

%')'5"(',)"!(2"!%*),"'" !)))&*()"!("!!((!(-())"*)*)!)

%"*'()*'(2 (&*!(%')&*'"*'(*%')%)'!,"(%'"*%)"!(

)'('!)(4

)""""',(" %'!' "()"!("!!((!(!((%'"((*(

5)"!%*&*(*,"%% !)5*!!!",)"!)!""&*2)'#((%"()(

%')%)(!( "()"!"!!((!((%"*'5)"!)("!%*&*(4 ()*()*(8!&*(*)*'(!("*'92!(" !'"4(

!!",)"!(%%"')!)(,!)(8(("!(" )"!5((!%'- %9 (("!)

")("!)'",'(((!)&*(2(*-'(&*(5'','()"!)(%*,!))'

%"')*((2!") !)*-'(&*(!,'"!! !)*-(5*)()"!5'(8,"'!'7 (("*(94((,"%%!)%!!))'('% !)!'!2)"*,'!)((*'()(

8<6>((*'(*),(!=;;@9&*5!!",)"!!%*))'"!('" !")&*4 7()%"')%'('"*%(%'"*)*'((' !)5*!"!)"!! !)%')%)2) ("!)%'"(")(%")&*(%*&*(4(("!)"!%"')*((5!*-5)"!%*&*

(*-"!)"!(5*!%'(("! "')&*)*,"%% !)5*!

)!""%")!) !)%"')*('(&*(4

()*()*5*!,"%% !))!""&*5 %*'3*(!&*(*)*'(!(

"*'894(("!)()!&*('!(*)*'(8'(2""7%'")!*-9"!((*' 5'')*"*'(("!%'!%*!"*,')*'%' !!)(("(45!( ('"*,'*!

%')&*()'('2!)5*!''))"))"*)')"*'! !)*("8( (')9*(&*5(

%')&*()',(*%'8)!&*(*)*'(( %(94()!&*(!"!)&*5"!%%

*((5'*)*'"!(',)"!892&*()%'(!)%'((%')!("*%'" ")*'(" *!

!!",)"!%"*'*!(.() %'"*)"!'"%' ))!)%'(',)"!(("(8!") !)!((

"!)-)(5'"("!2" *-))(!("**'("+()!&*("!)),"%%(94((

,"%%!)'% !)!'!)"*,'!)*"*'5*%*(5*!)'(((*'(*),(8"*'3 %!'"'()=;;?6=;;@94( '!)" *!!*5 %"')!'(%'" ))!)

(15)

?B

(!("!" &*(;'*)"!("+)(!(") !6$*,'3* !))"!((*'(

*),(<)!,'"!! !)*-; !*)"!')"!)%"*)"!(("(4 !*)"!( (("!(

/)(''<5(("!)")( (*'(6)"!%*&*3!") !)!('6*!

'),*'"%!!(*'(!)')(3&*!)!)"*,')*'(("('"(5%!!)36-()!

(!(()6")"!)'",'((!(*!"!)-)6!'))*(*'( "()%")&*('"(

))'!$*,'*-!*-*,"%% !)*'5()*((!)&*()*( "!)'!)!

)&*'*(()*(!("*'%!"') !)("!)"!("(*'%%)"!)

6" %! !)-()!)5!"!)"!(')'(3(%*,!)'"*,''(!*- *'(!)' (

"!" &*(;((('! !)()%'" ((,"* (%'"*)"!!(*!"!)-)

"!*''!!)'!)"!('*)'( !)' "!<3("*-;(%')"!(%))(

-%"))"!(!(*!"!)-)'("!" &*&*)"*( !('"((%*(%*,'(<)

!,'"!! !)*-;*('*(%'"*)(%()()'()%'" (%"*)"!(("(3,"' (!)%*&*<5

!*)'')'()&*(()&*6((,"%%!)%'!% !)("!(.! &*(

7"))" 9*%83*(!'"*% !)(%'"*)*'(3&*',!&*!)*!"!)"!! !)%')%)5 '*'(3*!)'(' (%',(!(,"%% !)7%')%)8()!&*()*(!

('"*% !)(%'"*)*'() "!)'!(%*(*'((!)"!*-;%'- %*'( 3

@>>A4)!'!3@>>D<5!)3')!(%%)"!()!""*(!("*'%*,!)

"*'(*'*!*('*')!(!)'!)(;%()(3,')(( !(%)(<5'

"!(&*!)3(' (!(*%'(('('"("!)*!!)')"!" &* %"')!)*

,"%% !)')!(!!",)"!()!""&*()("!)"!%"*',".*(("!!((!(!

(!(5

!!3(%'"((*(6"')"!%")&*(%*&*(("!)!"*'((*'()!&*(3!%')*'!(

' (*'('":!,'"!! !)(%"*'"!(',)"!(("()'*)"!( (("!(/

)(''!((()*'(%'"*)(5*(!' !)3!(*!"!)-)'("!" &*3("

)!,'"!! !)*()*''"3(%"*,"'(%*(("!)''!"*,*- "(

%'"*)"!),"%% !)'"(5!("!)-)3(%"(&*()"!*'#6))!((

.! &*(6!!",)"!()!(' "!!((!(*,"%% !)'"5 )" (!$*,'6"'"!(()!'()"!6!&*)(;"* !)'() )''!<5(''("* !)'(,(!)!)'("!)'",'(((!)&*()(

'(&*(%")!)((*,"%% !))!""5(,(!)*((!)'(!*- ,"'('()"!(!)' (%")&*(%*&*(3!)'()*'(%"')*'(*

,"%% !))!""3!") !)*%'((%"*,"'(%*(3)()*'(

%'"*)*'("!!((!( !)!)()(%*()("!)'",'((5("!)"!%"') (*'("* !)((!)&*(;')(%*(!((',*((!)&*(" ))*'3 -%')(("),(6!())*)"!(''%*&*3)*(" !(%'(!(

6)))( !()'()'((%'(")((!)&*())!!(<3 (*((

(*'("* !)("*'!()&*(;')(%'"*)(%'%'(((%("*%'("*'!*- 6((")"!(%'"*)*'(<"*(*'"* !))"! !()'),%'"*)%'("'!()"!(

%*&*(;!)'!)"!()!)"!(<5(!.(("* !)'("!)%' ((('(

"!)'",'((!)((!)&* !)3!(&**')') !)%'()*'(*

,"%% !))!"")(%"*,"'(%*(5

' !)(!.((3(!)')!("!))'((!'!;!E?C<*%'(6)*'(

()"!!(!'("!*'!,6)"!%*&*,"%% !)'")

(16)

69

'!!%%/$-$%#%$%%%&$&!#$$#$!$$

$$#'$!&$%#&(#$#%%$#3'#%$4;95-$&(

&($#'%$$$%0!%%$!#$$&$!#&%#&

%%"&/$%#%$%&$$%#$$&!#$$$0%%%$%%&%$

%"&$!&$%!#'$##%'!!%#-#$!$$0%&$&

!#%$'!!%%"&-%!#%!%$&(%$$&(#%%$%

!%"&$!&"&$#$4;:5/-$%&#$$#$%$#$!#%$!#%$

$!#$$&$0#%$!%"&$!&"&$%%&$$%##$4;85/$%#%$

'$%!$#0)$$$&#$$%&#$%&#$%#%$-$%#$

$!$%$$%#&%&#$$$"&$$$%$#$4#%%$-$%%&%$-#$&(0%&#$5-

%%!&#$#$$$$$&#%/

($%&#$!#$%%#!%'#$%$$%&%$-$!#%"&$%$

&(%#$$%$$$$/!##)$$%#%$&$$

%##%#%$#$&(0%&#$!#&$%-$%%%$

$$$$&#%/

&3%%'#$%-!&!##$!##$#&!%$%#%#$

#$$)!%$$-##&!#$%&#$!##!!#%!#%"&"&&$

%#$$/$##&!%$!#%%%$%%#&#$#%$%#$%

%$$%$$$$$0%!&"&&'!!%0&

%%%#$$#$"&$0##'#$%%$%!#%&$/$%!#%&#

!&#&%0##$#%$%$$$$&!#%!%$$#%$%#$-

&%&#$"&$$0#%8&(3%)!$-"&0!#$%$!#%$&'%/

$#$&%%$!#$%$$%%&%$%$#$&%%$%##$-$$&$0&

!##!$%###/

$&!##%)!-$%&#$0!!&%$&#&%#"&%!#%!%

0#%%#$!#%$4#&%&#$%%&#$&'!!%.$#$

#$-$&$$$%%&%$!&"&$%##!&"&5%$#$!#'$7/$'%$

%"&$!&'%%#!#&%$0%%'$#&%&#$-$$%$$#'$

##%'!!%$#$!#'$"&#!#%$&%$'%$-$%$%%-

$'%%$&$%&!#$$!#%$/&#$#$$$$!&#0%-

!#%%##&%&#$%#$!#'$$%%#/$#$!#'$

$%!#$%$!#$%&#$$!&$!##%$!&#!#&#$$$$&%$

&'!!%0'%-#$$$%$%#%$&$%&##$&$$

$$$$!#&%&#$/$$%%$%%!&$!#$$1#%$&%##2%

#$0'%/&#"&!#%$%-&%$$!$%$!#%!%$&

$$"&$$'!!%$'%$/$$$!$%$-$#&%&#$$%$$%#

& &#$!#$$&$0'%%$/ $$&#$$&#$$$$%

#$$&#$$%$#$!#'$/#(!-0$%%&%0#&%&#&#-%

7$#$!#'$$%$!#%&#$"&$%4#%$%&#$$&#$0%#%$%0&%$5

%'4%$-&$%#$0#3%#-$%#&%&#$5$#$!#&%#/

(17)

;>

3$'&'$ %$)& /%&&'"$ '&'$/%'%%' %3%&$&

($&%$%"$)%)'%%3&$&%7$%&%%8% && $%

$&$%2 "$&"& %$'&'$%"'& $%&$) #' &&

%" %&%$%"$%&$&%"$)%2%&& '$& /$!%%$)%"'%

$$& %%&$" $'*% %&%%"$&$&%&$

$'&'$%&$%"$)%/&$)&$% '& %"$ %$ &$%"$'*#'

% & %$% %)$&%&'$%3 )& 2'%%$%'*&6&+"/

)&% %%%%& & 3&$&%%'"" %% '%&$%

$'&'$%&%$%"$)%/ $&%&$&%'%&'$$ 2 4'$&5%

%+%&%"$ '& $ %&%'&$& "&&)&

#'%*" && %/)&& '& %$& )$ &2 & %$%

%&%%&%% %%%4#'$&5 &

"$ '& $ /&% %%%#'% &'&%%$&&" '$3 )& 23'&$%

&%"$ '& %%%7 %&%&%3 '&%3'&%& 3&$&%

#'%"$*"8"%%& $%& '% "/) $% & %$%"$$&%

&&% &$ '&%/$)&4'*"$ %52&"$ %#'&/%

&& &$$!' %$ "'%$3%& %& '*

%%%%&""'%%$2 %%&$'&'$%"'#'%% & %$%

% &%/&) '%&$$"%"$3'&$%%&$'&'$%"$'% "'%+#'%/

%%'%% "$&)%$ % '"$ " %%$&&"$%$%2%%%&$'&'$%/

%$"$$&% $!3*"$&&'$2%%&$&%/ &4&&'$5$)&

% ')&1 %$)&'% $&4"%%'$53 $& %&$$'&'$%&$%

"$)%2"$& '&$!&%"$ '& & %& %%%/&3%&"'%

$&&% %%%#'3)%$'&'$%2 $$%" & &&&6&+"1

3%&&'&3$'&'$'$/'% &"$)*$&% & % +" '$3$'&'$ %$)& '"$%%" ') $%"'%

$%&'$ "%/$'%%&%$'&'$%"$&#'&%% '$

& &&"$%$% %& &+&0

" $&& "$&)$ 3'%&$) ""&%

&)&%$ 6'%&$%&%&$'& 7<<$&%0"$%=

$%$3$%<:;:8/%"%%"$ & 3' ')' $ '& '$ & 34$'&'$

#'&&%)5%%'$) ""&%&#'%%%

'$/& & %3%&$& '"$%&$

%$ '$+6$'2

% &+"&"$&"& '%+%&'&)'*$$/

) ""&&% %'$& /%% &%"$&$&%&#'%&

%&#'%" '$) ""$&&%&$% )& %&%%&%"$&"&)%&" '$

'$$$% " &#'&$&$2')'3& /" '$%$'&'$%/%

%%%%&#'%% &'$%% '$&$&'$&%&)&" '$"$&

'$&)&7$%#'%%3&%') 3 )& & #'#'%

$)$& "$ $&82 %& &% %%%%&$&"$%+#'%

(18)

:;

3!!")'"!#%'!%&(&!&$(&&%('(%&"!'&&&%)&#(&3'' 8%%#($(/ %&3%('(%9$('&'!''#%"(&!'&"!!&&!&'

%%!&'!$(&('&&#"(%3'"!2&%('(%&!!'"&3(!"!&

'!$('#'&3*#% !''"!(!!)("/'#%"('"!#%%%

#($(%%!&!%$(&&(%3!!")'"!$(3&)"##!'/&&!(*'&&%&$(&2(

!)(&"!#"'$(/&&%)&!'%(*& !&'%&/%&#"!&&%'"!&

&(%&#"'$(&#($(&/&"!'!&&)"%(!&%'(*"!!&&!&)#(&(%&

'+#&3"('&8 &!#&%)&)%&"(%!%&&+!'&&&"!!&&!&

*&'!'&/!! !'3'(&/" !%##"%'&&+!'&/##&*#%'&92!&

'"(&&&/'$(&%&(''&#%")!!!'%%#($(&'%!'3(!'

&"!!&&!&&!'$(&2&7&%)!'!&('&(*'&$(#%!!!'#!&

&!&'!&#%'#')&#"()!''%'%#(&(%&'+#&3!'%'&&(#"'$(2!&' 7'+#/&&#"&'&#%'#'&!&"!'"!#&!)"$(&" &!&'%( !'&#"(%

"&'"!&"!!&&!&&!'$(&2&&%)!'3('%&('&/" #%* #

%&& %&#%"('(%&('"(%#%"(#'"!&&")%&'8&%)'"%

#%'#'")%&'9/"!!'%&#"&'"!&#"'$(&&#%'&#%!!'&8" '&

'!$(&"!&('&#%&&%)&& !&'%&9/"("!&'%(%("!&!&(&!)(

&"!8%(!"!&!'%*#%'&& !&'%&0!&'!&(%!3!)%"!! !'92&

&#"&'&#%'#'&&"!'!&" &!&'!&&(&&"!#"'$(/'!"!'!$(2

%%!'!"' !'''"'%!1

&'(%&&&(&&&%)&!'%(*& !&'%&3%('(%' 3!)%"!! !'/%& &&"!&% !''"!&(%&#%'$(&

%"&'!)%"!! !'&0

3!3''#"(%3!)%"!! !'0

& %&3%('(%0

&!&''('&'!$(&2

!&%'/((!&#"&'!"%%&#"!#!!''7'+#2

!'%"& '+#!'#%'#'" &!#+! $(&3!!")'"!

/ #$(!'(!%(#'(%)&77)&(&+&' )"## !'%"4 52

!&(!"!'*'%&( "%" "%!&'/% "!!&&!&"'&

%!"()%'&!!")'"!&&3"%%(!)("2 "&'"!&"!!&&!&&'

!&(!!'!$(!'%#%'!&/3&'77%!'%%('(%&2&%('(%&

#%"(&!'&!!")'"!&/&'&'!'(&!(%*#"''"!"((&!3(!%&(

3*#"''"!&/'(&!'(%&*#%!&2 &!" (!&*#%!&&'!&

&&#"&'&#%'#'&"!('&#%&#%'!&(*7 &8&&"'"!&#%"('(%&0 ('&'"!"%( &!'%!'0%'"!%)(&#%"&&"!!&#%* #92&#()!' "&%&&%)&"!&8#(&'&&(&(&'(%#%)9&"!(%&!'%'&/ &&

%'"!&)&&%)&&"!'%'%&&#%(! !3%3(!&+&' %%

')"## !'#%(" "( "%" "%!&''#%"(')&'2

#%'#'"!!&+! $(&"''" 6(#3!!")'"!"%%&#"!(&&(!&"!

%"!!&&!!''%#%'&%('(%&8/"#2'292&'!"

"+!#%"(%&&"('"!&'%!')&&/!"!'"!3"'&%!"()&#%%##"%' (*& "&#%"('"!!%&2

(19)

BC

,,$,$'-/*,",1(+++%,%$+(*%-,-*+/"%(($,"+$+"%-*

>++%,%$=*,$*-",-*%"+$/*%$$#$,5,-(*** 57?7

$$5+"%$-$)-,*#",1(5"(*,(,+,"+-"#%1$+(%+,%$+(*,$+(%-*

#%"+*"+%$$++$+%$,"+%$,+%$7%-*-$*,$$%#*8,-*+5$+"%$,0, 8-$*#%$$++$+%++-0$,*,+-#%"(*%-,%$*%"%#$$,5"

(*,(,+,"8-$)-%$/"%((*+$$%/,%$+",*$,/+7 #+$("+

+(%+,++,-$*(%$+"8+%"#$,,-0-",+*,$+,-*+/%*+-0

%$$++$++$,)-+7$+5"++(%+,+(*,(,+(-/$,,*+*+-0(*,$*,

$,*(*%-,-*+5/$,-""#$,$*+(*++1$,+"(*%++%$5%-%$("-+

$+,,-,%$$"+"*,%$8++%,%$+#",$,+%-"8$,*$++(*%!,+**

(*,(,//+*-*++$+,,-,%$+(-")-+7+++(%+,++%$,$+%##

-$(+""*(**((%*,8-,*+#%1$+("-+"+#%"+,%$+%$$++$+>%##(*

0#(""8+-0+*/+(-"+%$+"*%"?7"+$+%$,(+*$,+$-0<##+"

",+%$$++$+(*%-,+7

+*-",-*+/"%(($,"+$+"%-*9%:5,;%-+$,(*,"%$*,%$

1+$$5+%$,$+*+$++*+-08,-*+%**+(%$$,,",1(7

+)-,*-0<,1(+(*+$,$,%$+*+-",,+$,*#*++-*"+(*,)-+,"+#%1$+

%$,+(%+$,*$,+,%*+8,-*+(%-*#%"+*"+%$$++$++-*",$%"%

-+$+"%-*5,$(*,-"*+-*"8-+)-8"+%$,-(*,(,$+"#%"+,%$+

%$$++$+7 +*+-",,+%$,((*,*+$",+#%1$+(%-*"8+-0%$$++$+

$,*"+*$,+,-*+5/%##%$+)-$"#%"+,%$%$$++$+("-+%-

#%$+"++"%$"+*+-07"+#%$,*$,$+"+%+,"+)-*$%$,*$,"+,-*+(%-*

/%*$#$"+%$,%$+8-$,,8-$%0,$%"%)-+#%*,)-+>5+(%-*

"8$+#"+,-*++%$$++$+#,,$,!%-*"+*$,+$!-0(%*,+(*"

,$%"%?,+>)-0(",$,"+*$,+*+)-+"+"8$#$,$+"

/"%((#$,",$%"%?7

8$,,%$+*$,+-0,1(+,((*,*("-+-*+++%-#,,*"

+-++%$6

B? %-,8%*5"+,-*++(%+,%$$$,*##$,(**((%*,-(*,(,5,

#%"+$,*##$,,,$%,%$7$%$,%$"5$+)-+$,*,+/*$,+

)-8"+%$,$+"/"%((#$,",$%"%,+#%1$+$-0%$,"++(%+$,5

"+$#%"+$,(+"+%$$++$+"###$*5,"+#%"+$,+

%$$++$+*$,+$,-*+7*5"(-,(%+*+(*%"#+$+"#+

+(%+,%$%$$++$+"+(%-*"+(*,$+5$+)-$+"#+(",+

$!-0,%$,*%/*++(%-*",,"+%$(-")-7$(*,-"*5+"%$"+

*$,+%,*$+"+-(*,(,,+"%$"+*++%-*+$"+%$,+(%+$,"+

,-*+5%$(-,%-,*++,-,%$+%."+*#+(*/+!%-$,-$*&"$,*"$+

"8%"%+,%$"8*-",-*,+#+$,,$)-,(%",)-7,1(

%$"-+%$*$%*+%+*/,%$+!0+,$,+> @ 5%(7,7?7

(20)

FN

G@ "-*,"&&/,-7+/;/((&2-(.,-/,&-)(("--(-*,'"-'..,%)/,7

;-.+/&-*,)&'-;-.')"&"-.")()(("--(-0&"-(-&-

",(.-).,"(-/*,.""*.")(.0)",0/(.."./,()('(.&*,.

&;..9+/-.")(&0&"".-)(("--(-,)/*)(-(%/1*,)*,'(.

*)&"."+/--/,&-)(".")(-1"-.(.-*)/,*,'..,/(../(!)"1.!()&) "+/

'),."+/."9(.7)(0/+/&/1"'"&>.2**,-(.(

),,-*)(".,"(+/"1"-.(-&,&".9-./,---,0"-*/&"-"(.,,) - (;)(.*-&-')2(-'..,(*&&-2-.'A*,.""*."+/"&/,*,'..,".7

"(-"+/;/1*,.""(-70&)**,-"(()0.")(-('#.,"-(./'"/1&-,"-+/-9 ..-(;"(.,0(.")(7-)(.&-./,-*,"0-+/"-;'*,(.&+/-.")(

&""&".-)(("--(-9

H@ ,)(-+/(.7&-",'-*,"0--'&(."(.,&-*"&).-/0&)**'(.-

"(()0.")(-.!()&) "+/--/,&.,,"(7/*,-- ,"/&./,-9(-)(.1..&/"

&;-(&;..7/()(-+/(-.+/;/(,."(()',;./,--,.,)/0 1&/7(-!,(8&-)(-"&&,- ,")&--!',-; ,"/&./,-*,1'*&7)/

&-*")((",-0&)**(.-"(()0.")(-&.,(."0-?)''&-'"-",.**&"+/

&; ,"/&./,")&) "+/@9

-,-/&..-*,'..(.)(&/,-/,&*,."((&;!2*).!-'.!))&) "+/7*,-(.

(-..)''/(".")(7+/")(-",&-)(("--(--"(.""+/-)''/(,--)/, (.,&(-&,-.-."-")(-.!()&) "+/-9(.(.+/.&&-7&&--)(.&;)%.

,**),.-),.7(&;-(;/(, /&.")(*,&;../, "')(("--(-7)(*/.

)/.",--"./.")(-'"-("(0"-""&".,."(-(%/1?(0",)(('(./17-)"/1)/

)()'"+/-@.)(-&"'".-(.,'-'),."-.")(.;"".-*,)--/- ,".")(-*)&"."+/-*/&"+/-&"-/0&)**'(. ,")&9

,-.,"'/,7GEEM7<(-&-"&&)(/()(&)/,=7#(BGEL0,", GEEM7,"-7"("-.,&; ,"/&./,.&!9

97FNMJ7!#!7("0,-".2)&"),("

,--9

979797GEEG7<*)(-9 ,"=7KM7*9KF>

KJ9

97GEEG7<0)",..,9-.-&;"(-."./.")((&"-.")(&*,.""*.")(-/,&- ),'-&;.")()&&."0=7 FJ?JL@7*9LN>FEG9

97GEEM7<'),."&",."00-'),." )("-."+/6-.././)(&".(-

&-.!),"-.&-*,."+/-*,.""*.")()(.'*),"(-=7 7,"-7,---

"(-)9

97GEEF7 7,"-7"-)(-; ",9

979797GEEE7<(1'*&'),."*,.""*."08&:)(,(

".)2(-;-/,&-), ("-'- (."+/'(.')""-=7 JE

?I>J@7*9LLN>MFE9

(21)

MK

=;MKKL;?,)&2&13)&1.0,!1!+4,)4&*!+2,E312!+24!)F@;&+=;

=;==;=;==; =;==;

==;=;=/-$&$%%. %#% % $

%$;&, !+!&0,; =0*,+ =

=;=; =;MKKL;#$& #%/$$$&# #%

%"&/;0&1;!!3&)=

=;=;LTTP;G%2&1.02&&.2,060!1!0%:G; OL ELMF;.=LQQRCLQRQ=

=;MKKO;?,&! !&4&);.02&&.,!& +&<!/3!!12*,1#)+ ,:B;&+

=E &0=F; %$&)$ '%! $ * ;01;!1D +&4!01& !+20) !!+!73!);.=TPCLLK=

=;LTTT;$#0% !&"&;0&1;&0&0&!$"+"0)! ! 0,&2!2 !'30&1.03 !+!=

==;MKKN;A!1!0%+ !%+,),$6,)&&!1&+++,42&,+612!*1<!0,&))$!&+07&)B;

$# )NM;..=PRNCPSQ=

=;MKLK;A!112+ 0 14,),+2&0!1;&+1203*!+21*,+2+21 !1.,)&2&/3!1$0&,)!1!2 )&*!+2&0!1=+20!&+2!0+2&,+)&12&,+!2.0&42&12&,+B;&+ =;=;=;

=;=;$ $# $! %"&=$!)$$&#% &#

"&$% # -0&1;0!11!1 !&!+!,=

=;=;MKLL;A&##31&,+ >&++,42&,+12!%+&/3!1!2&+12&232&,++!))!1=!0-)! !1

#&0*!1 +1)>",),$&12&,+ !)>$0&3)230!B;,**3+&2&,+3,)),/3!A $% $

! %"&$!&"&$%$!#%"&$# $B;4&$+,+;LQCLRCLS*01MKLL=

=;MKKP;&2$%1"&&$%$ , $$%#$%#&% ;0&1;

",34!02!

=;MKKP;A!)&!02&,+!#,0!2%!!4,)32&,+=,50 1+2%&1,#!)&!02&4!!*,06&+

++'312,0) B; % #)-NNENF;.=NTRCOLT=

=; ==;MKKL;?!!.!+&+$ !*,06<++,42&,+1&+!*.,5!0! .02&&.2,06

$,4!0++!@; %$3 %)MTELF;.=PCOL=

C;MKKM;A.0,.,1 ! "*,02&!2!%+&/3!B; &'%$MLCMM;.=LTLCLTN=

C;=;MKKL;A.0,.,1 ! "*,02&!2!%+&/3!B; &'%$LS;.=RNC SK=

=H==;MKKM;A0,*!*,02&,4!0+*!+22,02&&.2,06,4!0++!@;&+

=H==E &0=F;#%!% #) '#. %$ %!% $;.) !+;

!1(!3+ 3 0&%=

=;=; =; =;=;=;LTTO;(

# &% (.)$ $# %! ##) %$;,+ ,+;

$!=

=;=; =;MKKO;?11!11&+$2%!3)&26,#!1!0%@;NMS;

.=NTCOL=

(22)

QP

?=QOOW=D12+1&,+1!.&12!*&/312.0,#11&,++))1+$0&3)230?8+*&/3132,30 12%+&/311+1),302)30!5)32&,++5&0,++*+2)E=)(/!'%"#""&

"!!&&!&S=.?QXPGRPO?

?=PXXS=&&"') "%+.*"% &""!" !&"")%!!=*%012=>

+&501&28,#11%31121011?

?=QOOP=B$,2&2&,+1&+.3)&.,)&8*(&+$>7,$+,3100&012,1311#3)&1.32 01,)32&,+C="(%!"("+QPFP=.?VPGXU?

?=QOOV=D+!$)&2!11,&)1=.3502!2!5),..*+230)?,3537+'37 32,301*, )1,++&11+1/3&1,312++2)A2&,+.3)&/30-""$("!'%!"!

&"%&!)") !'"%%'"%(&'!')=),0&+,.,)&1=+220&+=01&)=QQGQT,42QOOV?

?-?=G?= ?=?=?=?=

?=?=?=G?=?= ?=?= ?=

QOOX=D,30/3,&1A&+2!0110)+,2&,+A5&+1,)&8<E=)(%&"!QOO=.?WTRG WVR?

?=?=QOPP=B%/312&,+,#@5&+A&+2%*0$+,#5&+G1,0 5&+G60.,)&&1&+$0&3)230C=,**3+&2&,+3PQQL!*&+&0)!1&

%('(%!(%"+!.'"""! #%!&""+)('"!=

+-+=PVGPW!50&0QOPP?

?=PXXO= !$(%+!!.%"('' #''"!%&'!!#"'+=

6 5+=)+&501&28011?

?=QOPP=D,**+2.0,*,35,&0)!)&!02&,+!*,02&/3<0&,0&2!3!2 ,+20&2,&0130)&1311&,+E=&"!&"'$(&SQ=0&1=0111&+1,=.?WRGPPR?

?=QOPP=D812*&..0,%2,)&02&5*,08E=,+#!0+3,)),/3 +20+2&,+)D'"(%!!'%'.!-%'$(&-%&#')&0=0&1= =PUGPV'3&+QOPP?

?= ?= ?=?=?=?=?=

?=??=QOPP=D.))A&+2!0"2.02&3)&02)0-)3.,35,&0+1)!*,02&

!)&!02&5E=&"!&"'$(&SQ=0&1=0111&+1,=.?SVGWQ?

??=?= ???=QOOV=&!)!."*&%! #%")(

%)&=0&12,)=%,)&8011?

?=PXXW= "%'%'=0&1=,+,*&?

?K?=QOOV=B0&++,52&5=.02&&.2,08+)&02&5.0,301&+

.,)&8*(&+$)&02&5+##2&5<J=(%"#!"(%!""'&%SU=.?SSTGSVQ?

?=PXVO=%'#'"!! "%'"%+=*0&$+&501&28011?

??=??=??= ??= ??=PXXU=B5&+G 1&&+>%221+%221+A2C=RPQ=.?VPGVQ?

?=QOOQ=DA7.02&1>+*,.02&&.2&,+1$0,3.1A&+2!0"23.0,1131

!&1&,++),**3+32&0E=)(%!&!"'$(SHTQI=.?RVTGSOP?

(23)

DD

9797DBBG7' (7+%,7%,)(,:#%+9

97DBBC7;+-%%*-)+2.#-%(#%(+3%&%(%-%,8%'%-,(),,%%&%-%,%(.%&%(#

')+-%(,-%-.-%)(,<7!CE?C@7*9CGI>CHF9

97CIII7;&%+-%)(7(0$-&,6<7%(9?%+@7&

71")+71")+(%/+,%-2+,,9

979797:979799797 97 9797DBCC7;%)++%,))''%,,) (%%)(&

%),,#.+(8%),.'1*!+%(%<7%(979?%+9@7

$%%%7=9

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to