• Aucun résultat trouvé

L’humanoïde dans la publicité : appropriation et réécriture des imaginaires de la technique au service des stratégies de marque

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "L’humanoïde dans la publicité : appropriation et réécriture des imaginaires de la technique au service des stratégies de marque"

Copied!
107
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: dumas-03259627

https://dumas.ccsd.cnrs.fr/dumas-03259627

Submitted on 14 Jun 2021

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Copyright

L’humanoïde dans la publicité : appropriation et

réécriture des imaginaires de la technique au service des

stratégies de marque

Quentin Le Joly

To cite this version:

Quentin Le Joly. L’humanoïde dans la publicité : appropriation et réécriture des imaginaires de la technique au service des stratégies de marque. Sciences de l’information et de la communication. 2020. �dumas-03259627�

(2)

École des hautes études en sciences de l'information et de la communication – Sorbonne Université

77, rue de Villiers 92200 Neuilly-sur-Seine I tél. : +33 (0)1 46 43 76 10 I fax : +33 (0)1 47 45 66 04 I celsa.fr

Mémoire de Master 2

Mention : Information et communication Spécialité : Communication Marque Option : Marque, innovation et création

L’humanoïde dans la publicité

Appropriation et réécriture des imaginaires de la technique

au service des stratégies de marque

Responsable de la mention information et communication Professeure Karine Berthelot-Guiet

Tuteur universitaire : Sophie Corbillé

Nom, prénom : LE JOLY Quentin Promotion : 2019-2020

Soutenu le : 14/09/2020 Mention du mémoire : Bien

(3)

! H! !

(4)

!

"#$#%&'#$#()*!

!

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

!

(5)

! L! !

!"#$%&'%(&)"*+,-%(!

!"#$%&'(#!%"!""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!!) (*+,!#$-).)/)0-1)-0-2-"#1)&-)03!"#-$#-4#'+0!#-)/)+)0+)($%!1--)&3'")!2+5!"+!$-)#-(*"!6'-)-#) 1(!-"(-78!(#!%""-0)))99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999).:)

!!"#$"!"%&'(&")*!+$"#$%%"&%)(,-$.$+"&%/($%&&$0&.!$1"0+%2*0&%(0%$#*3$0*$!"%+".40')4$-"'+".40')4',"#(((((((((((((((((((((#)*# +(! !"#$%&'()*#$&)+%"'*%&',-$&).)/"'0"*')12.)/2)&"*'#"3(/$4(),"*5#"3(/$4($6"*'77777777777777777777777777777777'89' )(! :"'1$%;"1"/#',%00)#"'$%'<'6&)*'0"*'123()/"*'=''7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'8>' *(! ?/'0)*3$%&*'@3$/$1)+%"'216);2,"/#'77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'8A' ,(! B"*'@3&);2)/*'+%)'3&@"/#',"*'3$/0)#)$/*'0"',2'4"%&'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'8C' ++(! :2'&@23#%2,)*2#)$/'0"'3"*')12.)/2)&"*'2%'&".2&0'0"'/$%;"2%D'$6E"#*'#"3(/)+%"*''777777777777777777777777'8F' )(! :"*'$&.2/)*2#)$/*'4%6,)+%"*'"#',2'4&$0%3#)$/'0-%/'0)*3$%&*'#"3(/$4(),"'*%&',-)/#",,)."/3"' 2&#)G)3)",,"'''777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'8H' *(! ?/'0)*3$%&*'1@0)2#)+%"'4$,I4($/)+%"'*%&',-)1423#'0"*'#"3(/$,$.)"*'777777777777777777777777777777777777'9J' ,(! K44&$4&)2#)$/'0"'3"*'0)*3$%&*'42&',"*'12&+%"*'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'9A' %"(5$"#"%&'(&")*!+$"#$%2"&%)(,-$.$+"&%/($%(+$-$&"0+%(0"%6$3(!"%)*!+$.(-$"!"#"0+%&$30$6$*0+"%"+%2"0&"#((((((((((((((((((((((#*-# +(! L/#&"'1I#("'"#')12.)/2)&"'M'N',-$&).)/"'0"',2'G).%&"'0"',-(%12/$O0"PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP9Q' )(! :2'G).%&"'1I#()+%"'0%'R$,"1''7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'9Q' *(! :-244&$4&)2#)$/'0"'3"'1I#("'42&',2'*3)"/3"SG)3#)$/'77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'9F' ,(! ?/')12.)/2)&"'+%)'320&"',"*'4%6,)3)#@*'777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'9T' ++(! UI#("'"#'4%6,)3)#@'M',-)/*3&)4#)$/'0"*'4%6,)3)#@*'02/*',"*'1I#("*'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'>8' )(! :"*'1I#("*'3$/#"14$&2)/*'0"',2'#"3(/)+%"'"#',"%&'%*2."'4%6,)3)#2)&"'''7777777777777777777777777777777777'>8' *(! :2'1)*"'"/'*3V/"'0"',2'4"%&'N'#&2;"&*',2'G).%&"'0"',-(%12/$O0"'777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'>>' .(! :2'1)*"'"/'*3V/"'0"',2'3&@2#)$/'N'#&2;"&*',2'G).%&"'0%'3&@2#"%&'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'>A' (*+,!#$-):)/)03+,,$%,$!+#!%")&-1)!2+5!"+!$-1),+$)0-1),';0!(!#+!$-1))9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999)<=)

!!"#$"!"%&'(&")*!+$"#$%/7)'-'3$"%2"%&$30$6$.*+$'0%2"%-*%6$3(!"%2"%-&4(#*0'82"%2*0&%-"&%)(,-$.$+"&#((((((((((((((((((((((((((#,0# +(! ?/'3$/#"D#"'M',-)//$;2#)$/'3$11"'1$#'0-$&0&"''7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'>H' )(! <'W//$;2#)$/')*'#("'/"X'Y&$.&V*'=''777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'>H' *(! :-)//$;2#)$/'"#',"'*$,%#)$//)*1"'#"3(/$,$.)+%"''777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'A9' ++(! :-%*2."'0"',2'G).%&"'0"',-(%12/$O0"'M''%/"'&@4$/*"'2%'1$#'0-$&0&"'+%-"*#',-)//$;2#)$/''77777777777777'A>' )(! :-(%12/$O0"'3$11"'*)./"'0%'G%#%&'''77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'A>' -(! :-(%12/$O0"'3$11"'2/#(&$4$1$&4()*2#)$/'0-%/"'#"3(/)+%"'M',-)/#",,)."/3"'2&#)G)3)",,"'7777777'AQ' %"(5$"#"%&'(&")*!+$"#$%%")*&&"!%-&"5$&+*0+%"+%)!')'&"!%(0%$#*3$0*$!"%'!$3$0*-#(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((#-1# +(! :2'&@@3&)#%&"'0"*')12.)/2)&"*'#"3(/)+%"*'"#'*3)"/3"SG)3#)$//",*'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'QJ'

(6)

! V! )(! ?/'&$6$#'+%)'233$142./"',-(%12)/'M'%/'&$6$#'+%)'/"'G2)#'42*'4"%&''77777777777777777777777777777777777777'Q8' *(! ?/'&$6$#'(%12/$O0"'+%)'/"'*2)#'42*'M',-(%12)/'*%&42**"',"'&$6$#''77777777777777777777777777777777777777777'QA' ++(! K%'*"&;)3"'0-%/'0)*3$%&*'0"'12&+%"'M',"'&".)*#&"'0%';&2)'7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777'QC' (%"(0'1!%"!"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!!"# ;!;0!%5$+,*!-!""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!!$# +""-4-1!"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!!%# $-1'2-!"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!&"!) ! ! ! !

(7)

! W!

!"#$%&'(#)%"*

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

!

^)! $%7%(! 3-0')%].*! */(! -)! _!'-(%0'(*! N! 8&1-$*! 3-0'&)*! 4-&C! '-! 0%F*)! .`-)! 0+,')&/0*! &)(+$&*-$C!$*#$%.-&(!,*$('&)/!0%-5*0*)(/!.`-)!Y($*!3-0'&)!

!aR!b2!*/(!/-$(%-(!2'!,$+'(-$*!$%7%(&4-*! .*!/,&*),*<8&,(&%)!#'$!*T,*22*),*R!b)($%.-&(!#'$!.*/!'-(*-$/!(*2/!4-*!93&2&#!:R!c&,d!.')/!,(/$

768'-98(/$ ':;(6*<&=/$ 8($ >-?*-6$ @=()*'&A?($B$ %-! *),%$*! b/'',! "/&0%5R! b2! */(! #'$8%&/! '##*2+!

_!').$%].*!a!%-!*),%$*!_!1F)%].*!a!?!.+,$&5')(!$*/#*,(&5*0*)(!-)!$%7%(!.O'##'$*),*!3-0'&)*! .-!1*)$*!0'/,-2&)!*(!.-!1*)$*!8+0&)&)R!b2!*/(!#'$'.%T'2*0*)(!($Q/!,%))-C!#$+/*)(!.')/!-)!1$').! )%07$*!.Oe-5$*/!,-2(-$*22*/!*(!.')/!2O&0'1&)'&$*!.*!(%-/!0'&/!#%-$(')(!&2!)O'!#'/!%-!#*-!.*! $+'2&(+!0'(+$&*22*R!6'$*/!/%)(!,*-T!4-&!%)(!$*),%)($+!-)!$%7%(!3-0')%].*!*(!$'$*/!/%)(!,*-T!4-&! 5%)(! *)! $*),%)($*$! -)R! b2! */(! .%),! /-$(%-(! -)! %7U*(! &0'1&)'&$*! &//-! .O-)! 1*)$*! 2&((+$'&$*! *(! ,&)+0'(%1$'#3&4-*!#'$(&,-2&*$!?!2'!/,&*),*<8&,(&%)R!c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

(8)

! f! N!2'!0Y0*!8&1-$*!*(!U%-*)(!/-$!,*((*!0Y0*!/*)/'(&%)!.O')1%&//*R!g!2O&)5*$/*C!.*/!#-72&,&(+/!(*22*/! 4-*!52'&6*C$01/2('/34$%-!*),%$*!7''-F$%1)/1!-(&2&/*)(!2'!8&1-$*!.*!2O3-0')%].*!/-$!-)!5*$/')(! 7*'-,%-#!#2-/!#%/&(&8C!*-#3%$&4-*R!\)!#*-(!F!5%&$!-)!1*)(&2!#*(&(!$%7%(!4-&!'&.*!2*/!h%00*/C! 4-&!2*-$!(*).!2'!0'&)R!@&!(%-(*/!,*/!#-72&,&(+/!(&*))*)(!-)!.&/,%-$/!.&88+$*)(C!,%00*)(!*T#2&4-*$! 2O-(&2&/'(&%)!.O-)*!0Y0*!8&1-$*!X!A%00*)(!2'!0&/*!*)!/,Q)*!.O-)!$%7%(!3-0')%].*!#*-(<*22*! #$%.-&$*!.*/!.&/,%-$/!.&88+$*)(/!X!9%-$4-%&!-(&2&/*)(<*22*/!,*(!%7U*(!$%7%(&4-*!4-&!$*//*072*!#'$! /*/!,'$',(+$&/(&4-*/!N!-)!3-0'&)!X!i&)'2*0*)(!)%-/!)%-/!/%00*/!.*0').+!.*!4-%&!2*!$%7%(! 3-0')%].*!*/(<&2!2*!/&1)*!X!! ! A*/!$+82*T&%)/!)%-/!%)(!0*)+!N!4-*/(&%))*$!#2-/!2'$1*0*)(!2*/!&0'1&)'&$*/!.*!2'!(*,3)&4-*C!2*-$! &07$&,'(&%)!'5*,!2*/!&0'1&)'&$*/!.*!2'!/,&*),*<8&,(&%)!0'&/!+1'2*0*)(!2*!,%)(*T(*!',(-*2!4-&! #$j)*!2O&))%5'(&%)!,%00*!5'2*-$!.*!0%.*$)&(+R!g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

D*! .&/,%-$/! #$%.-&(! #'$! 2*/! #-72&,&(+/! -(&2&/')(! 2'! 8&1-$*! .*! 2O3-0')%].*! */(! &)(*$(*T(-*2R! b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

(9)

! k!

A+-.-$#)-27!/(!)#!+(63(+63(!!

B%($*! $*,3*$,3*! #%$(*! .%),! /-$! 2O-/'1*! .*! 2'! 8&1-$*! .*! 2O3-0')%].*! .')/! 2'! #-72&,&(+R! DO3-0')%].*!*/(!-)!'$(*8',(C!-)!%7U*(!4-&!*/(!($Q/!+(-.&+!.*!0')&Q$*!1+)+$'2*!,'$!&2!(%-,3*!N!,*! 4-O%)!)%00*!Y($*!_!2*/!)%-5*22*/!(*,3)%2%1&*/!aR!D'!.&/,&#2&)*!#3'$*!4-&!/O&)(+$*//*!N!,*(!%7U*(! */(!7&*)!+5&.*00*)(!2'!$%7%(&4-*R!P)!*88*(C!,O*/(!*)!/%&(!2'!$%7%(&4-*!4-&!,%)/($-&(!*(!0*(!*)!5&*! .*!_!5$'&/!a!3-0')%].*/R!Z'&/!2*/!/,&*),*/!3-0'&)*/!*(!/%,&'2*/!/O&)(+$*//*)(!+1'2*0*)(!N!,*(! %7U*(!.O+(-.*R!"&)/&C!2*!,3*$,3*-$!E%88$*F!;*,d*$!.')/!-)!%-5$'1*!#-72&+!*)!HIJV!#%/*!2*/!7'/*/! .O-)!#$%U*(!_!.O')(3$%#%2%1&*!.*/!,$+'(-$*/!'$(&8&,&*22*/!"aR!b2!/O&)(+$*//*!N!,%0#$*).$*!2*!2&*)! *)($*!h%00*/!*(!0',3&)*/!N!'##'$*),*!3-0'&)*!.')/!-)*!#*$/#*,(&5*!')(3$%#%2%1&4-*R!b2!/*! 4-*/(&%))*!/-$!2O&)(+$Y(!#%$(+!N!,*/!,$+'(-$*/!#'$!2*/!,3*$,3*-$/!*)!$%7%(&4-*/!?!#%-$4-%&!.%),! ,3*$,3*)(<&2/!N!,$+*$!-)!Y($*!'$(&8&,&*2!4-&!)%-/!$*//*072*!X!A*(!%7U*(!.*!$*,3*$,3*!/*!($%-5*! +1'2*0*)(!*)!/,&*),*!.*!2O&)8%$0'(&%)!*(!.*!2'!,%00-)&,'(&%)R!A2%(&2.*!A3*5*(C!,3*$,3*-/*!*)! @bA!'-!=$&#&,C!/O&)(+$*//*C!#'$!*T*0#2*C!'-!#$%,*//-/!.O+,$&(-$*!.*/!0',3&)*/!,%)5*$/'(&%))*2/! .')/!2*!,'.$*!.*/!&)(*$',(&%)/!3%00*<0',3&)*R#!P22*!&)(*$$%1*!.%),!-)!%7U*(!*)!#'$(&*!#$%,3*! .-!)%($*!?!2*/!$%7%(/R!92-/!$+,*00*)(C!-)*!+(-.&')(*!.-!APD@"C!9'-2&)*!;'$%)$!/O*/(!&)(*$$%1+C! /-$!2*!,'$',(Q$*!0'$,3').!.O-)!3-0')%].*!#'$(&,-2&*$!?!l2&20*4-&2'R!Z&4-*2'!@%-/'C!.*!/%)! _!5$'&!a!)%0C!*/(!-)*!&)82-*),*-/*!5&$(-*22*!4-&!,%0#(*!'-U%-$.O3-&!HCf!0&22&%)/!.O'7%))+/R!g! #'$(&$!.O-)*!+(-.*!/+0&%2%1&4-*!.*!/%)!,%0#(*!b)/('1$'0!*22*!0%)($*!,%00*)(!2O-(&2&/'(&%)! .O-)! &)82-*),*-$! 3-0')%].*! #*$0*(! '-T! 0'$4-*/! .*! ,$+*$! -)*! $*2'(&%)! 0'$,3').*! '5*,! /*/! '7%))+/!*(!'&)/&!$*)%-5*2*$!2*-$/!/($'(+1&*/!.O&)82-*),*R!!

DO%$&1&)'2&(+!.*!)%($*!$*,3*$,3*!(&*)(!.')/!2'!5%2%)(+!.O&)(*$$%1*$!-)!%7U*(!#'$(&,-2&*$!.')/!-)! ,%)(*T(*! #-72&,&('&$*R! g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`&(D(.0!C%%D<EEFFFGM&(D(.G>&E-%(*(,'%#-&E.*)%(*+#a.C#S#%G! $

! P'&)$0! L! ZVWXb\G! 5+) 10/+./&+2) "+2#/&0..+2) $-,.) &.%,6#&.) 1"+47,+) %,6#&.) $#.4) 2+4) 4/"#/83&+4) $-&.92,+.:+) $+4)

(10)

! K!

"7*#+63(!*7230/0)0.-&'(!!

9%-$!$+#%).$*!*(!5'2&.*$!)%/!3F#%(3Q/*/!.*!.+#'$(!)%-/!)%-/!/%00*/!'##-F+/!/-$!-)*!')'2F/*! /+0&%2%1&4-*!#%$(')(!/-$!-)!,%$#-/!#-72&,&('&$*!#'$(&,-2&*$R!g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c*! ,*!8'&(!)%-/!+,'$(%)/!2*/!#-72&,&(+/!4-&!0*((*)(!*)!/,Q)*!2*!$%7%(!3-0')%].*!,%00*!-)!+2+0*)(! .-!.+,%$%R!! c*/!,$&(Q$*/!(*2/!4-*!2*!0+.&'!-(&2&/+!m'88&,3*C!0+.&'!'-.&%5&/-*2/C!$+/*'-T!/%,&'-TC!82F*$/C!*(,n! %-!*),%$*!2*!#'F/!.*!.&88-/&%)!.*!2'!#-72&,&(+C!)O%)(!#'/!+(+!#$&/!*)!,%0#(*!.')/!2'!$+'2&/'(&%)! .*!,*!,%$#-/R!c+UN!,'$!)%($*!0+0%&$*!4-*/(&%))*!2'!8&1-$*!.*!2O3-0')%].*!.')/!2'!#-72&,&(+!*(! )*! 4-*/(&%))*! #'/! 2O3-0')%].*! ,%00*! -)*! 0+.&'(&%)! 0'$,3').*&R! cO'-($*! #'$(C! )%/! .*-T!

,$&(Q$*/!#$&),&#'-T!&).-&/*)(!-)!5%2-0*!.*!#-72&,&(+!#%-$!2*!0%&)/!$+.-&(*R!"&)/&!*)!+2'$1&//')(! N!#2-/&*-$/!#'F/!2'!$*,3*$,3*!)%-/!'5%)/!$+'2&/+!2*!,%$#-/!.*!)%($*!0+0%&$*R!D'!1$').*!0'U%$&(+! .*! ,*22*/<,&! /%)(! .&88-/+*/! *)! i$'),*! *(! .%),! #$%.-&(*/! *)! 2')1-*! 8$')S'&/*R! b2! /O'1&(! .*/! #-72&,&(+/! .O!"#$ %&'()*C$ .*! 2'! 5-)&@*@$ 51&6*<G&6)(6*<8(<H1?=C! .*! #*$ ,-.&/*&)/C! +5D$ E1FFC!

"-;1=&16$ *($ 01/2('/34I$ D*/! .*-T! #-72&,&(+/! 52'&6*$ %)(! +(+! #$%.-&(*/! *)! 2')1-*! ')12'&/*/! *(!

.&88-/+*/!'-T!o('(/<^)&/!.')/!2*!,'.$*!.O-)*!,'0#'1)*!2&+*!'-!@-#*$;%p2R!D'!#-72&,&(+!J&*1)K&! ! % !6)%#!<!P(#$!c-#!$)-,!&#.)-&()$,0!+'$,!*#!"C'D(%&#!V0!"0!((0!X!1!BUC-H'$)R+#!.)HH#!,(M$#!+-!>-%-&!?0!d!c-#*c-#,! #/#HD*#,!+#!.#!%OD#!+#!D-e*(.(%=,!c-(!D#&H#%%#$%!+#!&#$>)&.#&!$)%&#!'&M-H#$%'%()$!H'(,!c-(!$#!,)$%!D',!-%(*(,=#! +'$,!-$#!+=H'&.C#!'$'*O%(c-#G! & !6)%#!<!f!*U(H'M#!+-!H=H)(&#!+#!L'-*($#!P'&)$!c-(!,U($%=&#,,#!d!*'!H=+('%()$!H'&.C'$+#!($+-(%#!D'&!*U-%(*(,'%()$! +U-$!($>*-#$.#-&!C-H'$)R+#G!!

(11)

! JI! '!+1'2*0*)(!+(+!#$%.-&(*!*)!2')1-*!')12'&/*R!P)8&)C!2'!#-72&,&(+!.O7''-F$%1)/1!*/(!#$%.-&(*!*)! 2')1-*!*/#'1)%2*!*(!.&88-/+*!*)!P/#'1)*R!!

!

B0%-2-0$$(*($2!2370+-&'(!

P)! ,*! 4-&! ,%),*$)*! 2*! #%/&(&%))*0*)(! (3+%$&4-*! )%-/! -(&2&/*$%)/! .*/! ,%),*#(/! *(! )%(&%)/! .*! .&88+$*)(*/! .&/,&#2&)*/!?! .*! 2'! /%,&%2%1&*! *)! #'//')(! #'$! 2O+,%)%0&*! *(! 7&*)! +5&.*00*)(! 2*/! /,&*),*/!.*!2O&)8%$0'(&%)!*(!.*!2'!,%00-)&,'(&%)R!!

D*!#$&),&#'2!,%),*#(!-(&2&/+!.')/!,*!0+0%&$*!*/(!,*2-&!.O&0'1&)'&$*R!@&!2O%)!/O',,%$.*!N!.&$*!4-*! 2O&0'1&)'&$*!*/(!*)(*).-!&,&!,%00*!&0'1&)'&$*!/%,&'2C!&2!#*-(!Y($*!)+,*//'&$*!.O*)!*/4-&//*$!2*/! ,%)(%-$/R! DO&0'1&)'&$*! *)(*).-! ,%00*! &0'1&)'&$*! /%,&'2! ,%$$*/#%).! N! _!2O*)/*072*! .*/! $*#$+/*)('(&%)/! &0'1&)'&$*/! #$%#$*/! N! -)! 1$%-#*! /%,&'2!?! 2*/! 0F(3*/C! 2*/! ,$%F'),*/C! 2*/! -(%#&*/'!aR!9'($&,*!i2&,3F!'!2%)1-*0*)(!+,$&(!/-$!,*!4-O+('&(!2O&0'1&)'&$*!*(!)%('00*)(!,*2-&!

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d*(&)1!(%-(!,%00*!2'!#-72&,&(+R!D*/!2&((+$'(*-$/!/%)(!2*/! $%0'),&*$/C!5-21'$&/'(*-$/C!U%-$)'2&/(*/!4-&!5%)(!#'$!2*-$/!+,$&(/!(%-,3')(!-)!1$').!)%07$*!.*! 1*)/!#'$(&,&#*$!N!2'!.&88-/&%)!.O-)!&0'1&)'&$*R!P)8&)!2*/!',(*-$/!&)/(&(-(&%))*2/!(*2/!4-*!2*/!o('(/C! '//*072+*/!*(!%$1')*/!#-72&,/R!A*/!.*$)&*$/!N!($'5*$/!2*/!2%&/C!.+,$*(/!*(!$'##%$(/!#$%.-&(/!5%)(! +1'2*0*)(! #'$(&,&#*$! N! 2O&0'1&)'&$*! /%,&'2! .O-)*! (*,3)&4-*R! A*/! .&/,%-$/! )*! /%)(! #'/! )+,*//'&$*0*)(!,%3+$*)(/!*(!/*072'72*/R!AO*/(!7&*)!2*-$!/F)(3Q/*!4-&!,$+*!2O&0'1&)'&$*!/%,&'2! .O-)*!(*,3)&4-*!#'$(&,-2&Q$*R!!

g! ($'5*$/! ,*! 0+0%&$*! .*! $*,3*$,3*! )%-/! *//'&*$%)/! .*! 0%)($*$! ,%00*)(! 2*! .&/,%-$/! .*/! ,%),*#(*-$/! *(! .%),! 2O&0'1&)'&$*! 4-O&2/! .&88-/*)(! /O&)/,$&(! N! 2'! 8%&/! .')/! 2*/! &0'1&)'&$*/! .*/!

! ' !:$.O.*)Dg+('!3$(S#&,'*(,0!1!h45`h65h@:!i7"h5B!?0!:$.O.*)Dg+('!3$(S#&,'*(,0! C%%D,<EEFFFG-$(S#&,'*(,G>&E#$.O.*)D#+(#E(H'M($'(&#a,).('*EG! (! L'%&(.#!K*(.CO0!1!B'!D*'.#!+#!*U(H'M($'(&#!+'$,!*U'.%()$!%#.C$(c-#!?0!*+4+#,=!$)!XWb0!$" !Y!ZVWWX\<!YV^jJG! !!

(12)

! JJ! 2&((+$'(*-$/!(%-(!,%00*!.*/!%$1')&/'(&%)/!#-72&4-*/!(%-(!*)!#'$(&,&#')(!N!/'!$++,$&(-$*!*(!.%),! *)!2O'.'#(')(!N!,*!4-O&2/!5*-2*)(!0*(($*!*)!'5')(!%-!#'/R

(13)

! JH!

!"#$%&'()*)+),(-)./.0(1&-)2()/3%1&('&(4&5#/%&.)6)7)/#)8'9%-.()

2351)%0#:%1#%'()&(8"1%;5()(&)-8%(18(+<%8&%911(/)

B+(*->+(!%0'%85#+2-(!C!

"(%!5'1)-6-27%!&'-!%:-$%6+-D($2!/#$%!'$!-*#.-$#-+(!2(63$053-)(E2(63$05301(!

c')/! ,*((*! #$*0&Q$*! /%-/<#'$(&*C! )%-/! *//'&*$%)/! .*! 0%)($*$! *)! 4-%&! 2*/! #$%.-,(&%)/! #-72&,&('&$*/!.*!)%($*!,%$#-/!/O&)/,$&5*)(!.')/!-)!,%)(*T(*C!-)*!+#%4-*!-)!(*0#/!#'$(&,-2&*$!%q! 2*/!&0'1&)'&$*/!2&+/!N!2'!(*,3)&4-*!/%)(!'07&5'2*)(/R!b2/!/%)(!N!2'!8%&/!/%-$,*!.*!8')('/0*!,3*r! ,*$('&)/! *(! /%-$,*! .*! ,$'&)(*! ,3*r! .O'-($*/R! Z&,3*2! 9-*,3! )%-/! '88&$0*! 4-*! 2*/! _!(*).'),*/! )'(-$*22*/! *)5*$/! 2'! (*,3)%2%1&*! (*).*)(! N! /*! .&/($&7-*$! /-$! .*-T! *T($Y0*/!?! _!(*,3)%#3%7&*M(*,3)%#3&2&*!a)R!"&)/&!)%-/!*//'&*$%)/!.*!0%)($*$!&,&!*)!4-%&!2O'07&5'2*),*!.*!

#*$,*#(&%)!.*!2'!(*,3)&4-*!'!(%-U%-$/!+(+!-)*!$+'2&(+C!7&*)!4-*!2*/!%7U*(/!(*,3)&4-*/!/%-$,*/!.*! 8')('/0*/! %-! .*! ,$'&)(*/! )*! /%&*)(! #'/! 2*/! 0Y0*/R! "-($*0*)(! .&(! )%-/! 5*$$%)/! .*! 4-*22*/! 0')&Q$*/! 2*/! .&/,%-$/! 0+.&'(&4-*/C! #%2&(&4-*/! *(! +,%)%0&4-*/! &//-*/! .O+#%4-*/! .&88+$*)(*/! ,%)/($-&/*)(!.*/!$+,&(/!,%)($'.&,(%&$*/!.*!2'!(*,3)&4-*R!AO*/(!-)*!8'S%)!#%-$!)%-/!.*!$*#2',*$! 2*/!.&/,%-$/!#-72&,&('&$*/!.*!)%($*!,%$#-/!.')/!-)*!#*$/#*,(&5*!3&/(%$&4-*R!!

&R! 6*(%-$! 3&/(%$&4-*! /-$! 2O%$&1&)*! .*/! &0'1&)'&$*/! (*,3)%#3&2*/M(*,3)%#3%7*/!

D'!#*-$!.-!$*0#2',*0*)(!.*!2Oh%00*!#'$!2'!0',3&)*!)O*/(!#'/!-)*!4-*/(&%)!0%.*$)*R!!c-! 0%&)/C!2'!0%.*$)&(+!.*!,*((*!4-*/(&%)!*/(!$*2'(&5*R!c+UNC!P))&-/C!#%Q(*!2'(&)!.-!H*+,!'5R!EAC!'2%$/!

,%)/&.+$+! ,%00*! _!2*! #Q$*! .*! 2'! #%+/&*! 2'(&)*!!-! aC! .&/'&(! .*! 2'! 0',3&)*! 4-O*22*! +('&(! _!-)*!

0*)',*!&00*)/*!a!#%-$!2*/!#*-#2*/R!Z'&/!,O*/(!/-$(%-(!'-!$*1'$.!.*!2'!#$*0&Q$*!$+5%2-(&%)! &).-/($&*22*!4-*!/O*/(!,%)/(&(-+!2*/!#$*0&Q$*/!,$&(&4-*/!8'&(*/!'-T!0',3&)*/!/-$!2*-$!#%(*)(&*2! .*/($-,(*-$R! AO*/(! +1'2*0*)(! N! ,*((*! +#%4-*! 4-*! /O*/(! 8%$0+! 2'! ,$'&)(*! .O-)*! (*,3)&4-*! .*/($-,($&,*! .*! 2Oh%00*! *(! 4-*! 2*! 0F(3*! .-! =%2*0! '! +(+! ,%00*! )%-/! 2*! 5*$$%)/! .')/! 2'! ! ( !4(.C#*!L-#.C0!1!L)-&c-)(!*U#/%&kH#;l!A#.C$)DC(*(#!#%!%#.C$)DC)e(#!+'$,!*#,!&=.(%,!>-%-&)*)M(c-#,!?0!($!>&4+4)+.) "8:&/)$+)2#)/+:%.&7,+;)"+3#"$4):"0&484!Z5&.C(S#,!.)$%#HD)&'($#,0!VWXX\0!DGjWG! !-!!"#$%& ?..&,4!ZL&)D#&.#0!hhh0!J0![\G!">G!#2/+")@06+",4!Z2)&'.#0!A1B/"+40!hh0!X0!YW\! !

(14)

! Js! .*-T&Q0*!#'$(&*!-)*!8'S%)!.*!,$&/('22&/*$!2O*)/*072*!.*!,*(!&0'1&)'&$*!'-T!$*1'$./!.*/!)%-5*22*/! (*,3)%2%1&*/R!! @*2%)!2O3&/(%$&*)!+,%)%0&4-*!i$')S%&/!A'$%)C!2*!0%).*!'!,%))-!($%&/!$+5%2-(&%)/!&).-/($&*22*/R! !!!^)*!$+5%2-(&%)!&).-/($&*22*!)O*/(!#'/!2'!/&0#2*!&)5*)(&%)!.O-)*!)%-5*22*!(*,3)&4-*!%-!.O-)! )%-5*2!%7U*(!(*,3)&4-*R!b2!/O'1&(!/-$(%-(!.O-)!,3')1*0*)(!.*!#'$'.&10*!.')/!2'!8'S%)!.*!8'&$*! /%,&+(+R!"&)/&!2'!#$%.-,(&%)C!2'!,%)/%00'(&%)!*(!2O+,3')1*!.*!7&*)/!/*!$+&)5*)(*)(R!c*!,*!8'&(! 2*/!$*2'(&%)/!)*!/%)(!#2-/!2*/!0Y0*/!*(!2*!0%).*!,3')1*R!!

DO'07&5'2*),*! .')/! 2'! #*$,*#(&%)! .*! 2'! (*,3)&4-*C! 2'! #*-$! .')/! 2'! 0',3&)*C! 2*! /*)(&0*)(! (*,3)%#3%7*!*(!(*,3)%#3&2*!*(!2'!8'S%)!.%)(!%)!2*!#*$S%&(!'-U%-$.O3-&!#*-(!Y($*!$*0%)(+!N!2'! #$*0&Q$*!$+5%2-(&%)!&).-/($&*22*R!A*22*<,&!.+7-(*!'-!,%-$/!.-!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*!*)!")12*(*$$*R!P22*! */(!2*!8$-&(!.*!2O'5'),+*!/,&*)(&8&4-*!*(!(*,3)&4-*!'&)/&!4-*!U-$&.&4-*!.*!,3*$,3*-$/C!&)5*)(*-$/! *(!/#+,&'2&/(*/R!P22*!/*!,'$',(+$&/*!N!($'5*$/!2*!.+5*2%##*0*)(!#'$!E'0*/!u'((!.*!2'!0',3&)*!N! 5'#*-$R!A*22*<,&!5'!'5%&$!-)!&0#',(!/-$!2'!0%7&2&(+!'5*,!2'!0&/*!*)!#2',*!.*!2%,%0%(&5*!N!5'#*-$! %-!*),%$*!.*/!7'(*'-T!N!5'#*-$R!c')/!-)!'-($*!/*,(*-$C!,*2-&!.-!(*T(&2*C!2'!$+5%2-(&%)!&).-/($&*22*! '!5-!+0*$1*$!.&88+$*)(/!%-(&2/!(*,3)&4-*/!#*$0*((')(!.*!$+.-&$*!2*/!,%v(/!.*!0'&)/!.Oe-5$*/!*(! '&)/&!0'T&0&/*$!2*!#$%8&(!#%//&72*R!! JR! D*!0%-5*0*)(!2-..&(*!%-!_!7$&/!.*/!0',3&)*/!a! D%&)!.*!,*!4-*!2O%)!#*-(!,%)/&.+$*$!Y($*!.*/!0',3&)*/!&)(*22&1*)(*/C!2*/!0',3&)*/!.*/!(&//*-$/C! %-5$&*$/!')12'&/!.-!.+7-(!.-!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*!%)(!+(+!2*/!#$*0&Q$*/!N!8'&$*!2O%7U*(!.O-)*!,$'&)(*! .O-)! $*0#2',*0*)(! .*/! h%00*/! #'$! 2*/! 0',3&)*/R! 92-/! 4-O-)*! #*-$C! 2'! 0+,')&/'(&%)! .*/! 0+(&*$/! .-! (*T(&2*! '! 5-! 2'&//*$! #'$'w($*! -)! 0%-5*0*)(! /%,&'2! ,%)(*/('('&$*!?! ,*2-&! .*/! .&(/! _!2-..&(*/!aR!D*!2-.&/0*!*/(!-)!0%-5*0*)(!_!.O%-5$&*$/!.-!(*T(&2*!')12'&/!0*)+/!#'$!B*.!D-..C! 4-&! .*! JkJJ! N! JkJs! #-&/! .*! )%-5*'-! *)! JkJWC! /O%$1')&/Q$*)(! #%-$! .+($-&$*! 2*/! 0',3&)*/C! ',,-/+*/!.*!#$%5%4-*$!2*!,3j0'1*!!"aR!D*!0%-5*0*)(!/O*/(!8%$0+!N!#'$(&$!.*!2O&)($%.-,(&%)! .')/!2*/!-/&)*/!.*!(*T(&2*/!')12'&/*/!.*!0',3&)*!5&/')(!N!$+.-&$*!2*/!,%v(/!*)!-(&2&/')(!_!.*!2'! 0'&)!.Oe-5$*!0%&)/!4-'2&8&+*C!.*/!'##$*)(&/C!.*/!($'5'&22*-$/!4-&!)O'5'&*)(!#'/!*88*,(-+!2*-$! ! !! !i'e($#!9#*'$M*'+#0!1!1h$%#&$#%0!.U#,%!*'!%&)(,(TH#!&=S)*-%()$!($+-,%&(#**#?!?0!5?=1"+44(9"0!Vj!'S&(*!VWWW0!,#.%G! '&.C(S#0!EEFFFG*#/D&#,,G>&E($>)&H'%()$,E($%#&$#%a.a#,%a*'a%&)(,(#H#a&#S)*-%()$a($+-,%&(#**#m[Jj[VXGC%H*G! !) !n+(%()$,!B'&)-,,#0!1!9=>($(%()$,;<!*-++(%#!a!9(.%()$$'(&#!+#!>&'$o'(,!B'&)-,,#!?0! C%%D,<EEFFFG*'&)-,,#G>&E+(.%()$$'(&#,E>&'$.'(,E*-++(%#E_]WWJG!

(15)

! JL! '##$*)(&//'1*!*(!.*/!8*00*/!!#

a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h%00*! '2%$/! 4-*! 2'! 0',3&)*!'-(%0'(&/*!-)!1*/(*!*(!.*!,*!8'&(!2*!$*0#2',*!$R!AO*/(!*)!,*!/*)/!4-*!2O%)!)*!#*-(!#'/!

5$'&0*)(!#'$2*$!.O-)*!,$'&)(*C!.O-)*!#*-$!.*!2O%-(&2!#-&/4-*!,*2-&<,&!',,%0#'1)*!2*!1*/(*R!P)! .O'-($*/! (*$0*/C! 2O%-(&2! 5&*).$'&(! ',,%0#'1)*$! 2O3-0'&)! '2%$/! 4-*! 2'! 0',3&)*! 5&*).$'&(! 2*! $*0#2',*$R!A*!4-&!*T#2&4-*!,*/!#$*0&Q$*/!8%$0*/!.*!$*U*(!.*/!(*,3)&4-*/!.O'-(%0'(&/'(&%)/R!!

HR! ^)!.&/,%-$/!+,%)%0&4-*!'07&5'2*)(!!

"-<.*2N! .*/! 0%-5*0*)(/! /%,&'-TC! 2*/! #*)/*-$/! *(! #3&2%/%#3*/! +,%)%0&4-*/! %)(! (*)-! -)! .&/,%-$/!'07&5'2*)(!4-')(!N!2O&)(+$Y(!*(!2'!#%$(+*!.*/!0',3&)*/!/-$!2'!/%,&+(+R!!

D*/!+,%)%0&/(*/!,2'//&4-*/!5%F'&*)(!.')/!2*!.+5*2%##*0*)(!*(!2O-(&2&/'(&%)!.*/!0',3&)*/!#'$! 2*/! #$%#$&+('&$*/! .O-/&)*/! ,%00*! #%-$! 2*/! #$%#$&+('&$*/! '1$&,%2*/! -)*! 8'S%)! .O',,$%w($*! 2'! $&,3*//*!#$%.-&(*!/')/!4-*!,*2'!'&(!-)!&0#',(!/-$!2O*0#2%&R!@')/!'5%&$!N!8'&$*!-)!#'$,%-$/!%-!-)! +('(!.*/!2&*-T!.*/!,%))'&//'),*/!*(!/'5%&$/!N!,*!/-U*(!N!,*((*!+#%4-*C!%)!#*-(!.&$*!4-O'-!(%-(! .+7-(!.*/!'))+*/!JkII!&2!F!'5'&(!-)!,*$('&)!,%)/*)/-/!'-#$Q/!.*/!+,%)%0&/(*/!,2'//&4-*/!?!2*/! 0',3&)*/! #*$0*((*)(! .O'-10*)(*$C! .O',,$%w($*! 2*! 7&*)<Y($*! 1+)+$'2! #'$! .&5*$/! 0+,')&/0*/! +,%)%0&4-*/R! AO*/(! )%('00*)(! 2*/! .&/,%-$/! .O".'0! @0&(3C! 8%).'(*-$! 2O+,%2*! 2&7+$'2*! ,2'//&4-*C!(%-(!,%00*!,*-T!.*!E*')<;'#(&/(*!@'F!.')/!/%)!+'1&*@$8L@)-6->&($2-=&*&A?(!mJkIsn! %-!*),%$*!.*!E%3)!@(-'$(!Z&22!4-&!.')/!/%)!%-5$'1*!M->>(')($%(N(68(8!mJkIkn!.+,2'$*!_!D'! 8'S%)!.%)(!2'!#$%.-,(&%)!/O',,+2Q$*!*(!/O',,$%&(!1$x,*!'-T!&)5*)(&%)/!*(!N!2O'0+2&%$'(&%)!.*/! 0',3&)*/C!)*!8'&(!'-,-)!.%-(*!%aR!"&)/&C!2'!#*)/+*!4-&!5*-(!4-*!2'!(*,3)&4-*!/%&(!-)*!0')&Q$*! ! !" !p#S($!P($>(#*+0!1!B-++(%#,!#%!*-++(,H#!?0!C,6,2/+4!$q!Vj0!$" !V!ZVWW[\<!XYb^jXG! !# !6)%#,!<!7$!D)-&&'(%!.&(%(c-#&!.#%%#!D),(%()$!#$!'S'$o'$%!c-#!*'!H'.C($#!.&=#!=M'*#H#$%!+#!$)-S#'-/!M#,%#,0!+#,! M#,%#,!c-(!S(,#$%!d!*'!.'+&#&0!*'!.)$%&r*#&!#%!c-U(*!,U'M(&'(%!+#!.#%%#!H'$(T&#!+U-$!)-%(*G!h*!O!'!#$.)&#!+#,!+=e'%,!D)-&! .)$,(+=&#&!*'!+(>>=&#$.#!#$%&#!*'!H'.C($#!#%!*U)-%(*!d!.#!$(S#'-G!4'(,!D)-&!,(HD*(>(#&!$)%&#!D&)D),!$)-,!%(#$+&)$,! D)-&!.)$.*-,()$!.#**#!+#!p'&*!4'&/!<!1!d!D'&%(&!+-!H)H#$%!)s!*#!>'(%!+#!H'$(#&!*U)-%(*!#,%!%&'$,>=&=!+U-$!k%&#!C-H'($! d!-$!H=.'$(,H#0!-$#!H'.C($#!'!D&(,!*'!D*'.#!+U-$!,(HD*#!)-%(*!?G!A(H!h$M)*+0!1!BU7-%(*0!*U#,D&(%!#%!*'!H'.C($#;<! 3$#! #/.-&,()$! +'$,! *'! DC(*),)DC(#! +#! *'! 1;%#.C$)*)M(#;?!?0! C+:%.&7,+4) D) E,2/,"+() *+',+) 4+6+4/"&+22+)

$-#./%"010203&+)$+4)/+:%.&7,+40!$"

!Y_^YY!ZJW!t-($!VWXW\<!VbX^JXX0!C%%D,<EE+)(G)&MEXWG_WWWE%.GYWW_G!!

!%

! 7&(M($'*! <! u2)F! H-.C! %C#! D&)+-.%()$! )>! .)HH)+(%(#,! (,! '..#*#&'%#+! '$+! ($.&#',#+! eO! %C#! ($S#$%()$! '$+! (HD&)S#H#$%! )>! H'.C($#,0! &#c-(&#,! $)! (**-,%&'%()$Gv! &.! N'H#,! 4(**0! ")HH#&.#! 9#>#$+#+G! 5$! 5$,F#&! %)! %C#!

(16)

! JV! .O'0+2&%$*$!2'!#$%.-,(&5&(+C!2*/!1'&)/!*(!2'!4-')(&(+!.*!7&*)/!#$%.-&(/!.+,%-2')(!'&)/&!/-$!-)!7&*)< Y($*!'0+2&%$+!*/(!2'$1*0*)(!.&88-/+*!#'$!2*/!+,%)%0&/(*/!,2'//&4-*/!.*!2'!8&)!.-!t[bbbQ0*!*(!2*! .+7-(!.-!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*R!!

D*! #$*0&*$! 1$').! +,%)%0&/(*! ,2'//&4-*! N! $*0*(($*! *)! 4-*/(&%)! ,*(! +('(! .-! /'5%&$! */(! c'5&.! 6&,'$.%!.')/!/%)!%-5$'1*!H'&6)&2(/$8($=L@)-6->&($2-=&*&A?($(*$8(/$&>2O*/!+.&(+!*)!JkHJR!b2!/OF! #$%#%/*!.O+(-.&*$!_!2O&)82-*),*!4-*!2*/!0',3&)*/!*T*$,*)(!/-$!2*/!&)(+$Y(/!.*/!.&88+$*)(*/!,2'//*/! .*!2'!/%,&+(+!a!&!*(!#'$!2'!0Y0*!%,,'/&%)!.*!0%)($*$!*)!4-%&!2O-(&2&/'(&%)!.*/!0',3&)*/!#'$!2*/!

#$%#$&+('&$*/!'0Q)*)(!2*/!%-5$&*$/!*(!($'5'&22*-$/!N!-)*!8%$0*!.*!,3j0'1*R!c')/!/%)!,3'#&($*! /-$!2*/!_!0',3&)*/!a!c'5&.!6&,'$.%!$*5&*)(!/-$!2'!8'S%)!.%)(!,*/!.*$)&Q$*/!#*-5*)(!'##%$(*$!.-! ,3j0'1*!'-T!h%00*/R!D*!,3j0'1*!+5%4-+!#'$!6&,'$.%!/*!$'##$%,3*!'2%$/!8%$(*0*)(!.*!,*2-&! .*! Z'$T! 7&*)! #2-/! ('$.!?! _!2O',,$%&//*0*)(! .-! ,'#&('2! #'$! 2*/! 0',3&)*/! */(! .&$*,(*0*)(! #$%#%$(&%))*2! '-! )%07$*! .O%-5$&*$/! .%)(! 2*/! 0%F*)/! .O*T&/(*),*! '-$%)(! +(+! .+($-&(/! #'$! ,*/! 0',3&)*/!'!aR!"-($*0*)(!.&(C!/*2%)!2'!5&/&%)!.*!Z'$TC!#2-/!2*/!0',3&)*/!(*).*)(!N!'-10*)(*$!*(! N!',,$%w($*!2*!,'#&('2!.*/!#$%#$&+('&$*/!#2-/!2*/!*0#2%&/!(*).*)(!N!7'&//*$!,*!4-&!&)82-*!/-$!2*! )&5*'-!+,%)%0&4-*!.*/!%-5$&*$/!*(!.%),!/-$!2*-$/!_!0%F*)/!.O*T&/(*),*!aR!! "&)/&C!/O*)($*,$%&/*)(!#2-/&*-$/!.&/,%-$/!'-!/*&)!.*!2'!,%00-)'-(+!/,&*)(&8&4-*!+,%)%0&4-*!.-! tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*!#%$(')(!/-$!2O&)(+$Y(!.*/!0',3&)*/!'-!/*&)!.*!2'!/%,&+(+R!A*$('&)/!.&/,%-$/!8%)(! .*/!0',3&)*/!2'!/%-$,*!.-!7%)3*-$!.*/!h%00*/!*(!.*!2'!/%,&+(+!*)!1+)+$'2*R!D*/!'-($*/!4-')(! N!*-TC!,$&(&4-*)(!2O'//*$5&//*0*)(!#%//&72*!.v!'-T!0',3&)*/!'&)/&!4-*!2O&0#',(!#%(*)(&*22*0*)(! 8%$(! .*! ,*22*/<,&! /-$! 2*/! *0#2%&/R! AO*/(! *)! ,*! /*)/! 4-*! )%-/! )%-/! /%00*/! &)(+$*//+/! N! ,*((*! +#%4-*R!P22*!*/(!/*2%)!)%-/C!,*22*!4-&!5%&(!+0*$1*$!2*/!#$*0&*$/!.&/,%-$/!&)/(&(-')(!&)/(&(-*!2'! #*-$!.*!$*0#2',*0*)(!.*/!h%00*/!#'$!2'!(*,3)&4-*R!! sR! c*/!+,$&5'&)/!4-&!,$+*)(!2*/!,%).&(&%)/!.*!2'!#*-$! A%00*!)%-/!*)!'5%)/!.+UN!.&/,-(+!'-#'$'5')(C!9'($&,*!i2&,3F!,%)/&.Q$*!4-O&2!*T&/(*!($%&/!(F#*/! .O&0'1&)'&$*/!(!2%$/4-O&2!/O'1&(!.O+(-.&*$!2'!(*,3)&4-*R!A*2-&!.*/!,%),*#(*-$/C!.*/!%$1')&/'(&%)/! ! 5&M-H#$%,!eO!FC(.C!4&G!iD#$.#0!4&G!")ee#%%0!'$+!7%C#&,0!C'S#!'%%#HD%#+!%)!L&)S#!%C'%!")HH#&.#!(,!$)%!'!,)-&.#! )>!6'%()$'*!w#'*%C!xX]W]y!.)$,-*%=!d!*U'+&#,,#!,-(S'$%#!<!C%%D,<EE)**G*(e#&%O>-$+G)&ME%(%*#,EX[[]z4(**mW]j_m_V! !&* 9'S(+!@(.'&+)0!1!9#,!H'.C($#,!ZX]VX\!?0!*+',+)9"#.F#&4+)$-8:0.06&+!_0!$" !J!ZXb]b\<!XVb^_X0! C%%D,<EE+)(G)&MEXWGJ_W[E&>#.)GXb]bGXVV[G!! !'* `#$#S(TS#!i.CH=+#&0!1!B#,!#>>#%,!+-!D&)M&T,;<!@(.'&+)0!*#,!H'.C($#,!#%!*U#HD*)(!?0!*+',+)9"#.F#&4+) $-8:0.06&+!_0!$" !J!ZXb]b\<!X_J^YY0!C%%D,<EE+)(G)&MEXWGJ_W[E&>#.)GXb]bGXVVjG! !(. L'%&(.#!K*(.CO0!5-&..0'#/&0.)/+:%.&7,+0!B'!9=.)-S#&%#0!i.(#$.#,!#%!i).(=%=0!DG]b!

(17)

! JW! #-72&4-*/!*(!.*/!_!2&((+$'(*-$/!!) !aR!A*/!.*$)&*$/!/%)(!,*-T!4-&!#$%.-&/*)(!.*/!.&/,%-$/!8&,(&%))*2/! *(!4-&!,%)/($-&/*)(!2O&0'1&)'&$*!/%,&'2*!.O-)*!(*,3)&4-*R!"&)/&!2*/!.&/,%-$/!(*,3)%#3%7*/!/*! $*($%-5*)(!.')/!.*/!'$(&,2*/!0+.&'(&4-*/!'&)/&!4-*!.*/!$%0')/!.Q/!2*!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*R!g!,*!(&($*C! %)!#*-(!+5%4-*$!2O&)(+$Y(!#%$(+!#'$!.*/!#%Q(*/!*(!$%0'),&*$/!(*2/!4-*!>3%0'/!A'$2F2*!4-&!*)! JksK!,'$',(+$&/'&(!2*/!0',3&)*/!,%00*!-)!_!.+0%)!0+,')&4-*!a!,'#'72*!.*!_!$*0#2',*$!-)*! 0-2(&(-.*!.*!($'5'&22*-$/"-!aR!@'0-*2!;-((2*$C!+,$&5'&)!,+2Q7$*!#%-$!/%)!e-5$*!P$*p3%)!mJkfHn! */(!2O-)!.*!,*-T!4-&!,$&(&4-'!2*!#2-/!5&5*0*)(!.')/!2'!/%,&+(+!7$&('))&4-*!.-!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*!2*! $j2*! .*/! 0',3&)*/! .')/! )%($*! /%,&+(+R! 92-/! 4-*! .*! $*0#2',*$! 2*/! ($'5'&22*-$/! *(! %-5$&*$/C! 2*/! 0',3&)*/!(*).*)(!/*2%)!2-&!N!$*0#2',*$!2O3-0'&)!*)!(')(!4-O*/#Q,*!.%0&)')(*R!c')/!-)!'$(&,2*! .*!#$*//*!#-72&+!2*!Js!E-&)!JkWs!'-!/*&)!.-!U%-$)'2!+K($H'(//!*)!B%-5*22*<y+2').*C!&)(&(-2+! _!c'$p&)!'0%)1!(3*!0',3&)*/!aC!2O'-(*-$!$*#$*).!2*/!(3+%$&*/!.*!A3'$2*/!c'$p&)!/-$!2'!2%&!.*! 2'!/+2*,(&%)!)'(-$*22*!#%-$!2O'##2&4-*$!'-T!0',3&)*/R!b2!'##'$'w(!/*2%)!2-&!4-*!_!,*!)O*/(!4-O-)*! 4-*/(&%)!.*!(*0#/!'5')(!4-*!2*/!0',3&)*/!.+(&*))*)(!2*!#%-5%&$!*(!2O*T*$,*)(!/-$!2*!0%).*!*)(&*$! *(!#'$!*T(*)/&%)!/-$!2O*)/*072*!.*!2O3-0')&(+!"!aR!!"&)/&C!&2!.+,2'$*!4-*!2*!$j2*!.*!(%-(!h%00*! */(!.*!_!.+($-&$*!2*/!0',3&)*/!a!'8&)!4-*!,*22*/<,&!)*!2*/!$*0#2',*)(!#'/R!! ! \)!,%0#$*).!'2%$/!2*!$j2*!.*!,*/!_!2&((+$'(*-$/!a!?!&2/!#'$(&,&#*)(!N!2'!,&$,-2'(&%)!.O-)!$+,&(!?!,*2-&! .O-)*! (*,3)&4-*! .*/($-,($&,*! .%)(! %)! .%&(! '5%&$! #*-$R! P)! '&.')(! N! 8'&$*! ,&$,-2*$! ,*! (F#*! .*! .&/,%-$/C!&2/!#'$(&,&#*)(!.O-)*!,*$('&)*!0')&Q$*!N!2'!,%)/($-,(&%)!.O-)!&0'1&)'&$*!(*,3)%#3%7*R!!

&&R! D'! $+',(-'2&/'(&%)! .*! ,*/! &0'1&)'&$*/! '-! $*1'$.! .*! )%-5*'-T! %7U*(/! (*,3)&4-*/!!

D'!#*-$!.*/!h%00*/!.*!/*!8'&$*!$*0#2',*$!#'$!2*/!0',3&)*/!.-!tbtQ0*!/&Q,2*!*/(!(%-U%-$/! #$+/*)(*R!A*#*).')(C!,*((*!#*-$!)O'!#'/!,%00*!%7U*(!2*/!0',3&)*/!N!(&//*$!%-!2*/!0',3&)*!.*/! -/&)*/! N! ,3'$7%)! 0'&/! .*/! (*,3)&4-*/! ,%)(*0#%$'&)*/R! A*/! /*)(&0*)(/! (*,3)%#3&2*/! *(!

! !). '()*! "-. "5@B{B:0!AC)H',0!1!"C'&%(,H!?0!X]Jb0!($!AC)H',!"'&*O*#<!i#*#.%#+!w&(%($M,0!X]_W0!DG!XYXaVJVG!! uAC#!C-M#!+#H)$!)>!4#.C'$(,H!,H)Q#,!'$+!%C-$+#&,0!D'$%($M!',!C(,!M&#'%!%',Q0!($!'**!,#.%()$,!)>!:$M*(,C!*'$+|! .C'$M($M!C(,!,C'D#!*(Q#!'!S#&O!L&)%#-,|!'$+!($>'**(e*O0!'%!#S#&O!.C'$M#!)>!,C'D#0!)S#&,#%%($M!FC)*#!H-*%(%-+#,!)>! F)&QH#$0!',!(>!F(%C!%C#!F'S($M!)>!C(,!,C'+)F!>&)H!'>'&0!C-&*($M!%C#H!',-$+#&0!%C(,!F'O!'$+!%C'%0!($!%C#(&! .&)F+#+!H'&.C!'$+!.)-&,#!)>!F)&Q!)&!%&'>>(.|!,)!%C'%!%C#!F(,#,%!$)!*)$M#&!Q$)F,!C(,!FC#&#'e)-%,v! "!. }#&,()$!)&(M($'*#!<!1%C#!-D,C)%!(,!,(HD*O!'!c-#,%()$!)>!%(H#0!e-%!%C'%!%C#!%(H#!F(**!.)H#!FC#$!%C#!H'.C($#,!F(**! C)*+!%C#!&#'*!,-D&#H'.O!)S#&!%C#!F)&*+!'$+!(%,!($C'e(%'$%,!(,!FC'%!$)!D#&,)$!)>!'!%&-*O!DC(*),)DC(.!H($+!.'$!>)&!'! H)H#$%!c-#,%()$v!&.!.C%%D<EE$~#%.GS(.%)&('G'.G$~E%HE,.C)*'&*OE%#(aP-%K(&a%XaMXa%XaMXa%_ae)+OGC%H*!!

(18)

! Jf! (*,3)%#3%7*/! )O%)(! ,*//+! .O*T&/(*$! N! ($'5*$/! 2*! (*0#/R! >%-(! ,%00*! c'5&.! 6&,'$.%! N! /%)! +#%4-*C!#2-/&*-$/!+,%)%0&/(*/!#$+.&/*)(!2'!8&)!.*!2O*0#2%&C!2*!$*0#2',*0*)(!.*/!h%00*/!#'$! 2'!0',3&)*!*(!)%('00*)(!#'$!-)*!(*,3)&4-*!#'$(&,-2&Q$*!?!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!P)!HIJsC!2*! $'##%$(!.O+(-.*!.*!A'$2!;*)*.&d(!i$*F!*(!Z&,3'*2!\/7%$)*!.*!2O-)&5*$/&(+!.O\T8%$.!'!8'&(!-)! 1$').!7$-&(!.')/!2O*/#',*/!0+.&'(&4-*/!*(!/,&*)(&8&4-*/""R!g!,*((*!.'(*C!&2/!8'&/'&*)(!2'!#$+.&,(&%)! .*!5%&$!Lfz!.*/!*0#2%&/!'0+$&,'&)/!0*)',+/!#'$!2*!.+5*2%##*0*)(!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!!! \$!2*/!#-72&,&(+/!.*!)%($*!,%$#-/!($'&(*)(!.O-)*!,*$('&)*!8'S%)!.*!,*/!#$%72+0'(&4-*/C!.*!,*/! 4-*/(&%))*0*)(/!2&+/!N!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!*(!.%),!/O&)/,$&5*)(!.')/!,*(!&0'1&)'&$*R!! !

DO+#%4-*! .')/! 2'4-*22*! )%-/! )%-/! /&(-%)/! &)5&(*! N! #*)/*$! 2*/! (*,3)&4-*/! '-! #$&/0*! .O-)*! _!($%&/&Q0*! $+5%2-(&%)! &).-/($&*22*!a"#R! 9%-$! i$')S%&/! A'$%)C! 3&/(%$&*)! .*/! /,&*),*/! ,*((*!

($%&/&Q0*! $+5%2-(&%)! &).-/($&*22*! */(! -)! 8'&(! 3&/(%$&4-*! *(! .+0%)($+R! D*/! (*,3)%2%1&*/! .*! 2O&)8%$0'(&%)!*(!.*!2'!,%00-)&,'(&%)C!2*!.+5*2%##*0*)(!.*/!0&,$%#$%,*//*-$/!*(!8&)'2*0*)(! .*/! %$.&)'(*-$/! %)(! ,%).-&(! N! -)! ,3')1*0*)(! .*! #'$'.&10*!"$R! g! 2O&)(+$&*-$! 0Y0*! .*! ,*((*!

$+5%2-(&%)!%)!#%-$$'&(!+5%4-*$!#2-/&*-$/!(*,3)&4-*/!.&88+$*)(*/!4-&!%)(!+0*$1+!*(!4-&!%)(!/-&5&! /*2%)! [&,(%$! @,'$.&12&! -)! #$%,*//-/! .O&)/*$(&%)! /%,&'2*! $*2'(&5*0*)(! /&0&2'&$*R! "&)/&! /*2%)! 2O')(3$%#%2%1-*C!&2!*T&/(*!_!($%&/!(*0#/!.*!2O&)/*$(&%)!/%,&'2*!.*/!(*,3)&4-*/"%!aR!!D*!#$*0&*$!*/(!

,*2-&!.*/!_!.&/,%-$/!#$%#3+(&4-*/!a"&!4-*!2O%)!#*-(!,'$',(+$&/*$!,%00*!+(')(!$*0#2&/!.O&0'1*/C!

.*!#$%0*//*/!*(!.*!.&/,%-$/R!D*!.*-T&Q0*!+(')(!,*2-&!.*!2'!.&88-/&%)!*(!.*/!#$*0&*$/!-/'1*/R!D*! .*$)&*$!+(')(!,*2-&!.')/!2*4-*2!2*/!-/'1*/!/%)(!/('7&2&/+/R!DO-/'1*!*(!2O*T#+$&*),*!.*/!(*,3)&4-*/! 0%)($*)(! 4-*! 2*/! #$%0*//*/! .O')(')(! )*! /%)(! #'/! $*0#2&*/R! b2! F! '! '2%$/! -)! /*)(&0*)(! .*! .+/&22-/&%)R! "-($*0*)(! .&(! 2'! (*,3)&4-*! )O'-$'&(! #'/! $*0#2&! /'! #$%0*//*R! 9&*$$*! Z-//%! *)! $*#$*)')(!2*/!&.+*/!.*![&,(%$!@,'$.&12&!0%)($*!4-*!2O%)!$*($%-5*!,*/!s!(*0#/!.')/!2*/!.&/,%-$/! ! )) !"'&*!P#$#+(Q%!K&#O!#%!4(.C'#*!7,e)&$#0!1!A2:!K3A3@:!7K!:4LB7{4:6A<!27wi3i":LAhPB:!5@:! N7Pi!A7"74L3A:@hi5Ah76l!?!Z7/>)&+!3$(S#&,(%O!:$M($##&($M!i.(#$.#,!9#D'&%H#$%0!Xj!,#D%#He&#!VWXJ\G! "#! !"#$%&'()*#"&$+),)-"&'('./0)"12&345'&$)'$64(5"'0330)05)$&420330)17&$&/'0)8+)!"#$"%&')$9)::;+)$$ )<) =;>>>?@);ABCDE! "$ !(%)*! "%. }(.%)&!i.'&+(M*(0!)DG!.(%G0!DGJXaJ_!#%!1!6)-S#**#,!%#.C$)*)M(#,!<!*U(H'M($'(&#!+-!D&)M&T,?0!($!BU(H'M($'(&#!+#,! %#.C$(c-#,!+#!D)($%#G!5-!+)(M%!#%!d!*U(*0!,)-,!*'!&#,D)$,'e(*(%=!+U5*'($!`&',!#%!i)DC(#!L)(&)%a9#*D#.C0! BU2'&H'%%'$0!L'&(,0!Xb]b0!DGbjaXX_! %& !4-,,)!L(#&&#G!!3,'M#,!#%!(H'M($'(&#,!+#,!Ah"G!BU=S)*-%()$!+#,!.-*%-&#,!$-H=&(c-#,0!K{L!=+(%()$,0!DDGVWXaVXW0! VWWbG!C'*aWW_jb[W[!

(19)

! Jk! '-(%-$! .O&)(*$)*("'

R! D*! .+7-(! .*/! '))+*/! JKKI! +(')(! 2'! #+$&%.*! .*/! #$%0*//*/! .O-)! &)(*$)*(! '0+$&,'&)!4-&!.%&(!Y($*!-(&2&/+!'8&)!.O*)($*$!.')/!2'!)%-5*22*!+,%)%0&*!4-*!,*((*!0Y0*!(*,3)&4-*! .+5*2%##*$'R!D*/!'))+*/!JKKW!U-/4-ON!HIII!5%&*)(!2*/!#$*0&*$/!-/'1*/!.O&)(*$)*(R!P)8&)!'#$Q/! 2O+,2'(*0*)(!.*!2'!7-22*!8&)'),&Q$*!*)!0'$/!HIIIC!2*/!.+/&22-/&%)/!'##'$'&//*)(!*(!_!2*!$+'2&/0*! /O&)/('22*!aR!DO&)(*$)*(!)O*/(!#'/!2'!(*,3)&4-*!4-&!7%-2*5*$/*$'!$'#&.*0*)(!*(!$'.&,'2*0*)(!)%/! 5&*/R! B%-/! #*)/%)/! 4-*! 2'! (*,3)&4-*! 0%.*$)*! 4-&! */(! '-! ,e-$! .*/! *)U*-T! *(! .&/,%-$/! #$%#3+(&4-*/!*/(!,*22*!4-*!2O%)!)%00*!?!&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!!

!

b2!/O'1&(!&,&!.*!0%)($*$!,%00*)(!2*/!.&/,%-$/!/-$!,*((*!(*,3)&4-*!#*-5*)(!Y($*!,%)/&.+$+/!,%00*! #'$(&,&#')(! N! 2'! #$*0&Q$*! #3'/*! .O&)/*$(&%)! /%,&'2*! .+,$&(*! #'$! [&,(%$! @,'$.1&2&C! ,*22*! .*/! #$%0*//*/! *(! 8')('/0*/R! g! ,*! (&($*C! #2-/&*-$/! .&/,%-$/! ,%*T&/(*)(R! A*! 4-*! )%-/! '&0*$&%)/! 0%)($*$! &,&! ,O*/(! .*! 4-*22*! 0')&Q$*! 2*/! .&/,%-$/! /-$! 2'! (*,3)&4-*! 0%.*$)*! /%)(! (%-U%-$/! #%/&(&%))+/! /-$! 2*! 0Y0*! 'T*! (*,3)%#3&2*M(*,3)%#3%7*R! "T*! .%)(! %)! #%-$$'! .+0%)($*$! 2'! #*$0')*),*!'5*,!2*/!*T*0#2*/!4-&!/-&5*)(R!!!!

JR! D*/! %$1')&/'(&%)/! #-72&4-*/!*(! 2'! #$%.-,(&%)! .O-)! .&/,%-$/! (*,3)%#3&2*!/-$!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*! D*!Hf!0'$/!HIJfC!'!+(+!#$+/*)(+!'-!9$+/&.*)(!.*!2'!6+#-72&4-*!i$')S%&/!h%22').*!2*!$'##%$(! i$'),*!b"R!o('&*)(!+1'2*0*)(!#$+/*)(/C!2*!0&)&/($*!.*!2`o,%)%0&*!*(!.*/!i&)'),*/C!2*!/*,$+('&$*! .`o('(!,3'$1+!.*!2`P)/*&1)*0*)(!/-#+$&*-$!*(!.*!2'!6*,3*$,3*C!*(!2*!/*,$+('&$*!.`o('(!,3'$1+!.*! 2`b).-/($&*C!.-!B-0+$&4-*!*(!.*!2`b))%5'(&%)R!A*!$'##%$(!*/(!&//-!.O-)!($'5'&2!0*)+!.-!HI!U')5&*$! '-!Jf!0'$/!HIJf!#'$!Jf!1$%-#*/!.*!($'5'&2!*(!5&/*!N!_!#$%#%/*$!.*/!',(&%)/!.*!#%2&(&4-*!#-72&4-*! 5&/')(!N!.+5*2%##*$!2`&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!*)!i$'),*!"(!aR!^)!')!#2-/!('$.!($Q/!*T',(*0*)(C!2*! Hk!0'$/!HIJkC!2*!0'(3+0'(&,&*)C!*(!'2%$/C!.+#-(+!.*!2OP//%))*!A+.$&,![&22')&!$*).!#-72&,!2*! $'##%$(! _!.%))*$! -)! /*)/! N! 2`&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*!?! #%-$! -)*! /($'(+1&*! )'(&%)'2*! *(!

!

)'

!'()*&

%'

!!1!@'DD)&%!i%&'%=M(#!K&'$.#!hG5G0!D)-&!*#!+=S#*)DD#H#$%!+#,!%#.C$)*)M(#,!+U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?!Z4($(,%T&#! +#! *U#$,#(M$#H#$%! ,-D=&(#-&0! +#! *'! &#.C#&.C#! #%! +#! *U($$)S'%()$0! XV! H'(! VWXj\0! EEFFFG#$,#(M$#H#$%,-Da &#.C#&.C#GM)-SG>&E.(+XX_jJbE&'DD)&%a,%&'%#M(#a>&'$.#a(G'GaD)-&a*#a+#S#*)DD#H#$%a+#,a%#.C$)*)M(#,a+a

(20)

! JK! *-$%#+*))*!a")

!,%00').+!#'$!2*/!)%-5*'-T!#$*0&*$!0&)&/($*!o.%-'$.!93&2&##*!*(!#$+/&.*)(!.*! 2'! 6+#-72&4-*! P00')-*2! Z',$%)R! "&)/&! .')/! ,*((*! /*,%).*! 0%&(&+! .*/! '))+*/! HIJIC! 2*/! $'##%$(/!&//-/!.*/!%$1')&/'(&%)/!#-72&4-*/!4-&!#%$(*)(!/-$!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!#$%2&8Q$*)(R!!! @&!2*/!%$1')&/'(&%)/!#-72&4-*/!#$%.-&/*)(!.*/!$'##%$(/C!&2/!#$%.-&/*)(!+1'2*0*)(!-)!.&/,%-$/R!b,&! 2*!.&/,%-$/!/-$!2'!(*,3)&4-*!*/(!.*!2O%$.$*!.*!2'!#$%#3+(&*R!"&)/&!2*!$'##%$(!i$'),*!b"!.*!HIJf! '88&$0*! 4-*!_!2*! 0'$,3+! .*! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! #%-$! 2*/! '##2&,'(&%)/! *)! *)($*#$&/*! */(! */(&0+!N!#2-/!.*!sW!0&22&'$./!.*!.%22'$/!.O&,&!N!HIHV!*)!b"!,%)($*!WLs!0&22&%)/!.*!.%22'$/!*)! HIJW#-!aR!D*!$'##%$(!/*!,%)/($-&(!'-(%-$!.*!2O&.+*!4-*!2Ob"!5'!'5%&$!-)*!#2',*!0'U*-$*!.')/!

2O+,%)%0&*!N!0%F*)!(*$0*/R!"&)/&!&2!&)5&(*!2'!i$'),*!N!8'&$*!#'$(&*!.*!,*!,3*0&)C!.*!#'$(&,&#*$! N! ,*((*! )%-5*22*! +,%)%0&*R#!! D*! $'##%$(! [&22')&! 4-')(! N! 2-&! #$+,&/*! 4-*! _!2O&)(*22&1*),*!

'$(&8&,&*22*! */(! *)($+*C! .*#-&/! 4-*24-*/! '))+*/C! .')/! -)*! )%-5*22*! Q$*C! 4-&! .%))*! 2&*-! N! .*! )%07$*-T! */#%&$/R!a! "&)/&! ,*/! $'##%$(/! #$%.-&/*)(! -)! .&/,%-$/! .')/! 2*4-*2! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*!'!-)!$j2*!,*)($'2!.')/!2*!8-(-$!.*/!/%,&+(+/!3-0'&)*/R!A*((*!(*,3)&4-*!'##'$'w(!,%00*! &)+5&('72*!#'$!2*!.+5*2%##*0*)(!*T(*$)*!.*!,*22*<,&!.')/!.O'-($*/!#'F/R!b2!*/(!.%),!)+,*//'&$*! .*!#$*).$*!2*!,3*0&)!.*!2Ob"R!! A*!.&/,%-$/!*/(!.O'-(')(!#2-/!'0#2&8&+!#'$!.*/!,%00&//&%)/!/+)'(%$&'2*/!4-&!/*!#$%#%/*)(C!*22*/C! .*!$+82+,3&$!'-T!',(&%)/!N!.+5*2%##*$!#%-$!$+#%).$*!'-T!&0#+$'(&8/!.*!,*/!$'##%$(/R!"&)/&!*)! %,(%7$*!HIJf!2'!,%00&//&%)!.*/!'88'&$*/!*-$%#+*))*/!.-!@+)'(!N!,$+*!-)!1$%-#*!.*!($'5'&2!5&/')(! N! _!'//-$*$! 2*! /-&5&! .*! ,*! /-U*(! {2Ob"|! *//*)(&*2!#"!aR! A*((*! ,%00&//&%)! .+.&+*! N! 2O+(-.*! .-!

.+5*2%##*0*)(!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!#$%#%/*!.')/!/%)!$'##%$(!.*!_!#$+#'$*$!2'!4-'($&Q0*! $+5%2-(&%)!&).-/($&*22*!aR!"-($*0*)(!.&(!2Ob"!/*$'&(!-)*!(*,3)&4-*!4-&!.*!#'$!/%)!.+5*2%##*0*)(! *(! /%)! -(&2&/'(&%)! 0'//&5*! &0#2&4-*$'&(! -)! ,3')1*0*)(! .*! #'$'.&10*! /%,&'2C! +,%)%0&4-*C! #%2&(&4-*R! \)! 2*! ,%0#$*).C! ,*! .&/,%-$/! 5&/*! N! &)/(&(-*$! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! ,%00*! (*,3)&4-*! 0'U*-$*! .-! ttbQ0*! /&Q,2*R! "&)/&! 2*/! .&88+$*)(/! $'##%$(/! +(-.&+/! #$+/*)(*)(! -)! .&/,%-$/! (*,3)%#3&2*! 4-&! &0#2&4-*! -)! &0'1&)'&$*! .')/! 2*4-*2! 2'! (*,3)&4-*! .O&)(*22&1*),*!

!

)(

!!1!@'DD)&%!+#!"=+&(.!}(**'$(;<!+)$$#&!-$!,#$,!d!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!Zh5\!?!Z4($(,%T&#!+#!*U#$,#(M$#H#$%! ,-D=&(#-&0! +#! *'! &#.C#&.C#! #%! +#! *U($$)S'%()$0! V]! $)S#He&#! VWX]\0! EEFFFG#$,#(M$#H#$%,-Da &#.C#&.C#GM)-SG>&E.(+XV]YjjE&'DD)&%a+#a.#+&(.aS(**'$(a+)$$#&a-$a,#$,a'a*a($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#a('GC%H*G! "( !1!@'DD)&%!i%&'%=M(#!K&'$.#!hG5G0!D)-&!*#!+=S#*)DD#H#$%!+#,!%#.C$)*)M(#,!+U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?GDGX! "! !1!L#&H#%%&#!d!*'!K&'$.#!+#!%(&#&!D'&%(!+#!%)-%!*#!D)%#$%(#*!+#!.&)(,,'$.#!=.)$)H(c-#!#%!+#!D&)M&T,!,).('*!)>>#&%! D'&!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?!&.)&G&$)DGJ!! "%

!5$+&=! `'%%)*($! #%! '*G0! 1!@'DD)&%! +U($>)&H'%()$! >'(%! '-! $)H! +#! *'! .)HH(,()$! +#,! '>>'(&#,! #-&)D=#$$#,! ,-&! *'! ,%&'%=M(#!#-&)D=#$$#!D)-&!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?0!@'DD)&%!+U($>)&H'%()$!Zi=$'%0!JX!t'$S(#&!VWXb\GDGY!

(21)

! HI! '$(&8&,&*22*!/*$'&(!#%/&(&5*!*(!/F)%)F0*!.*!8-(-$R!cO'&22*-$/C!,*/!0Y0*/!$'##%$(/!$*2'(&5&/*)(!(%-/! 2'!,'#',&(+!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!N!.+($-&$*!.*/!*0#2%&/C!N!$*0#2',*$!2Oh%00*R!"&)/&!2*! $'##%$(!/+)'(%$&'2!&).&4-*!4-*!_!,*((*!&.+*!.*!2'!/-7/(&(-(&%)!.*!2O3%00*!#'$!2'!0',3&)*!.')/!2*! ($'5'&2!$*2Q5*!#2-/!.-!8')('/0*!4-*!.*!2'!$+'2&(+!%7/*$5+*R!a##!b2!&).&4-*!4-*!2*!($'5'&2!/*!5*$$'! 7&*)!+5&.*00*)(!($')/8%$0+!#'$!,*/!)%-5*22*/!(*,3)%2%1&*/!0'&/!4-*!2*!#$%#$*!.*!2Oh%00*!*/(! .*!#%-5%&$!/O'.'#(*$!*(!4-*!2O-(&2&/'(&%)!.*!,*/!0',3&)*/!&)(*22&1*)(*/!$*).$'&*)(!/-$(%-(!8'5*-$! N!2Oh%00*!*)!2*!2&7+$')(!.*!(x,3*/!$+#+(&(&5*/!?!_!2O3%00*!.*5$'!'##$*).$*!N!($'5'&22*$!'5*,!,*! )%-5*'-!(F#*!.*!0',3&)*/!#$aR!

\)! ,%0#$*).! 2*! #'$'22Q2*! 4-&! #*-(! Y($*! 8'&(! '5*,! 2*/! .&/,%-$/! #$%.-&(/! #'$! 2*/! +,%)%0&/(*/! ,2'//&4-*/R!DO&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!*/(!-)*!(*,3)&4-*!N!2'4-*22*!%)!'(($&7-*!.*/!5'2*-$/!2&+*/! '-!8-(-$!*)!(')(!4-*!,%),*#(&%)!.*!2O+,%)%0&*!*(!.*!2'!#$%/#+$&(+R!

HR! ^)! .&/,%-$/! 0+.&'(&4-*! #%2F#3%)&4-*! /-$! 2O&0#',(! .*/! (*,3)%2%1&*/!

D*/!.&/,%-$/!0+.&'(&4-*/!,&$,-2')(!/%)(!,*-T!4-&!/%)(!2*/!#2-/!N!0Y0*!.O'5%&$!-)!&0#',(!/-$! 2O&0'1&)'&$*!4-*!2O%)!',,%$.*!N!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!P)!*88*(C!2*/!0+.&'/!4-&!*)(%-$*)(!2'! (3+0'(&4-*! .*! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! /%)(! '07&5'2*)(/! .')/! 2*! /*)/! %q! 2Ob"! F! */(! /%&(! 8')('/0+*! /%&(! .+,$&+*R! b2! )%-/! */(! .&88&,&2*! '-! 5-! .*/! .%))+*/! 4-&! /%)(! N! )%($*! .&/#%/&(&%)! .O+('72&$! -)! ,%$#-/! 0+.&'(&4-*! *T3'-/(&8! #*$0*((')(! .*! 0*(($*! '-! U%-$! -)! /F/(Q0*! /($-,(-$+! '-(%-$!.*!.&/,%-$/!#%$(')(!/-$!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!b2!/O'1&$'!/-$(%-(!.*!0%)($*$!2*!,'$',(Q$*! ,%)($'.&,(%&$*! .*/! .&/,%-$/! 4-&! ,&$,-2*)(! .')/! 2O*/#',*! 0+.&'(&4-*R! ! c*! ,*((*! 0')&Q$*! )%-/! 0%)($*$%)/!4-O&2!*T&/(*!-)!.+7'(!'-(%-$!.*!2O-(&2&/'(&%)!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R!!

c')/!-)!#$*0&*$!(*0#/C!)%-/!%7/*$5%)/!4-*!2'!(3+0'(&4-*!.-!$*0#2',*0*)(!.*/!3-0'&)/!#'$! 2*/!0',3&)*/!'-!)&5*'-!.*!2O*0#2%&!*/(!/%-$,*!.O-)!1$').!)%07$*!.O'$(&,2*/R!A*/!'$(&,2*/!/%)(! &//-/! .*! 0'1'r&)*/! /#+,&'2&/+/! (*2/! 4-*! 5)&(6)(/$ (*$ 7;(6&'C! M12&*1=$ %-! *),%$*! D-'P(/R! D*! #$*0&*$! ($'&(')(! 2*! /-U*(! /*2%)! -)*! 2&1)*! +.&(%$&'2! _!(*,3)&4-*!aC! 2*/! /*,%)./! /*2%)! -)*! 2&1)*! +.&(%$&'2!+,%)%0&4-*R!Z'&/!&2!*T&/(*!+1'2*0*)(!.*/!U%-$)'-T!1+)+$'2&/(*/!#2-/!%-!0%&)/!%$&*)(+/! #%2&(&4-*0*)(! (*2/! 4-*! ,LQR2'(//C! ,($ S-68(! %-! *),%$*! ,&P@'1*&-6! *(! S1'&166(R! "&)/&C! 2'!

!

##

!`'%%)*($!#%!'*GDGY)

#$

(22)

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c*/($-,(&%)/! .`*0#2%&/C!#*$(*!.-!2&7$*<'$7&($*!?!2*/!0*)',*/!.*!2`&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!#%a!*)!U')5&*$!HIHIR!

A*(!'$(&,2*!/*!#$%#%/*!.*!$*5*)&$!*(!.O'0#2&8&*$!2*!0*//'1*!.O-)!2&5$*!+,$&(!#'$!A+.$&,!@'-5&'(!*(! Z'$&*! c'5&.C! (%-/! .*-T! &)1+)&*-$/!?! _!b)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*C! 2'! )%-5*22*! 7'$7'$&*R#&a! D*!

0*//'1*!*/(!8%$(!?!_!)%)C!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!)O*/(!#'/!&)+5&('72*C!,*!)O*/(!#'/!-)!#$%1$Q/! ,%00*!2*/!'-($*/!*(!*22*!)*!/O&)/,$&(!#'/!.')/!2'!}0'$,3*!.*!2Oh&/(%&$*}!2%1&4-*!*(!/%-3'&('72*#'a!

*(!/O'##2&4-*!N!'88&$0*$!4-*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!.+($-&$'!.*/!*0#2%&/C!#2-/&*-$/!,*)('&)*/! .*!0&22&%)/!'-T!o('(/<^)&/!*(!*)!A3&)*!*(!.*/!0&22&%)/!*)!i$'),*!*(!'-!6%F'-0*<^)&R!A*(!'$(&,2*! 8'&(!+,3%!N!.O'-($*/!4-&!_!'2*$(*)(!a!/-$!2*!.')1*$!4-*!$*#$+/*)(*!,*((*!(*,3)&4-*R!D*!/&(*!&)(*$)*(!

M=?P&)! .')/! -)! '$(&,2*! .-! K! /*#(*07$*! HIJK! $*#$*).! -)*! +(-.*! .Ob;Z! /*2%)! 2'4-*22*! JHI!

0&22&%)/!.*!($'5'&22*-$/!N!($'5*$/!2*!0%).*!5%)(!#*$.$*!2*-$!*0#2%&!.O&,&!($%&/!')/!N!,'-/*!.*! ,*((*!&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*R#(!"-T!o('(/<^)&/C!2*!/&(*!+K($"(R*$T(P!$*2'&*!2*/!#$+.&,(&%)/!.*! ='$F!:'/#'$%5C!$%&!.*/!+,3*,/!7'((-!*)!JKKf!#'$!2'!0',3&)*!c**#!;2-*!.Ob;ZR!A*!.*$)&*$! '88&$0*!4-*!KWz!.*!(%-/!2*/!*0#2%&/!5%)(!Y($*!$*0#2',+/!#'$!.*/!0',3&)*/R!! ! D*!.*-T&Q0*!(F#*!.*!.&/,%-$/!*/(!,*2-&!4-&!&)5&(*!N!$+82+,3&$!N!2'!4-*/(&%)!#2-/!4-ON!'##%$(*$! -)*! $+#%)/*! N! 2'! 4-*/(&%)! .-! $*0#2',*0*)(R! c')/! -)! '$(&,2*! 0%&)/! ,$&(&4-*! N! 2O+1'$.! .*!

!

")

!4'&()$!4#,,($'0!1!9#,%&-.%()$,!+U#HD*)(,0!D#&%#!+-!*(e&#a'&e(%&#;<!*#,!H#$'.#,!+#!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?0!

>#"&#..+0! VV! t'$S(#&! VWVW0! C%%D,<EEFFFGH'&('$$#G$#%E+#e'%%)$,E(+##,E+#,%&-.%()$,a+a#HD*)(,aD#&%#a+-a*(e&#a

'&e(%&#a*#,aH#$'.#,a+#a*a($%#**(M#$.#G!

#&

! 4'&(#! 9'S(+! #%! "=+&(.! i'-S('%0! H./+22&3+.:+) I"/&9&:&+22+J;) 2#) .0,'+22+) G#"G#"&+0! n+(%()$,! +-! @).C#&0! VWXb0! C%%D,<EEFFFG#+(%()$,+-&).C#&G>&E*(S&#E>(.C#E($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#abj]VV[]XWVJjYG!

#'

!4#,,($'0!1!9#,%&-.%()$,!+U#HD*)(,0!D#&%#!+-!*(e&#a'&e(%&#!?G!

"'

!P#$t'H($! P&-#*0! 1!i#*)$! hP40! *#,! &)e)%,! S)$%! &#HD*'.#&! XVW! H(**()$,! +#! %&'S'(**#-&,! +U(.(! %&)(,! '$,!?0!

E2,G&:(:060!b!,#D%#He&#!VWXb0!,#.%G!&)e)%(c-#0!C%%D,<EEFFFG.*-e(.G.)HE&)e)%(c-#E'.%-'*(%#a][]]V[a(eHa&)e)%,a

(23)

! HH! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! 2*! 0'1'r&)*! M12&*1=! &)5&(*! N! /*! 4-*/(&%))*$!?! _!DO&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! */(<*22*! .*/($-,($&,*! .O*0#2%&!X#)

aR! D*! .&/,%-$/! (*)-! */(! $*2'(&5*0*)(! /&0&2'&$*! #-&/4-O&2!*/(!'//*r!#*//&0&/(*!0'&/!$*/(*!.')/!2O&)(*$$%1'(&%)!*(!2'!)+,*//&(+!.*!,%0#$*).$*!4-*2! /*$'!2O&0#',(!.*!,*((*!(*,3)&4-*!/-$!2*!($'5'&2!*)!1+)+$'2R!b2!&)5&(*!'2%$/!N!$+82+,3&$!*(!#$%#%/*!.*! 5%&$!2*/!(*)')(/!*(!'7%-(&//')(/!.*!,*((*!(*,3)&4-*R!! ! cO-)!'-($*!,j(+C!,*$('&)/!U%-$)'-T!8%)(!,&$,-2*$!.*/!.&/,%-$/!4-&!(&*))*)(!N!$*2'(&5&/*$!2'!4-*/(&%)! .-!$*0#2',*0*)(!.*/!3-0'&)/!#'$!2*/!0',3&)*/!&)(*22&1*)(*/R!"&)/&C!.')/!/'!5*$/&%)!)-0+$&4-*C! 2*!U%-$)'2!,($S-68(!(&($*!_!D*!($'5'&2!)*!.&/#'$'w($'!#'/!N!,'-/*!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*$-a! %-!*),%$*!_!D*/!3-0'&)/!/%)(!*),%$*!2%&)!.O'5%&$!#*$.-!2*-$!#2',*!*)!*)($*#$&/*!$!aR!,($E-?'61=$ 8?$ "(*$ UE%"V! 4-')(! N! 2-&! (&($'&(! *)! '5$&2! HIHI!?! _!9%-$4-%&! 2'! $+5%2(*! .*/! 0',3&)*/! )*! )%-/!

0*)',*!#'/!*),%$*$"!X!a!A*/!'$(&,2*/!#%$(*)(!-)!.&/,%-$/!.')/!2*4-*2!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*C! ,*$(*/C!5'!0%.&8&*$!*(!($')/8%$0*$!2*!($'5'&2!0'&/!.')/!-)*!2%1&4-*!.*!2&7+$*$!2*/!($'5'&22*-$/! .')/!2*-$/!(x,3*/!2*/!#2-/!$+#+(&(&5*/!*(!'&)/&!2*-$!#*$0*(($*!.*!/O'(('$.*$!/-$!.*/!(x,3*/!%q!2*-$! &)(*22&1*),*!*/(!*//*)(&*22*R!! ! P)8&)C!-)*!'-($*!(3+0'(&4-*!*/(!/%-5*)(!+5%4-+*!?!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!#%-$$'&(!.+/%$0'&/! $*0#2',*$!2Oh%00*!.')/!,*!4-O&2!'!.*!#2-/!3-0'&)C!/'!,$+'(&5&(+R!D'!,$+'(&5&(+!*/(!2'!8',-2(+! 3-0'&)*!4-&!/*072'&(!U-/4-ON!0'&)(*)')(!+,3'##*$!'-T!.+7'(/!2&+/!N!2O'-(%0'(&/'(&%)R!P)!*88*(C! /&! 2*/! 0',3&)*/! #*-5*)(! '-(%0'(&/*$! .*/! (x,3*/! $+#+(&(&5*/C! ,%00*)(! -)*! 0',3&)*! #*-(<*22*! 8'&$*!#$*-5*!.*!,$+'(&5&(+!/',3')(!4-O&2!/O'1&(!.O-)*!',(&%)!4-&!/*072*!)%)!'-(%0'(&/'72*!,'$! $*2'(&5*!N!2O'$(&/(&4-*!*(!.%),!N!2'!#*)/+*!3-0'&)*!X!D*!.+7-(!.*!2'!#$*0&Q$*!0%&(&+!.*!2O'))+*! HIHI! '! ,%))-! -)*! ',(-'2&(+! 2&+*! N! ,*((*! (3+0'(&4-*R! 92-/&*-$/! U%-$)'-T! *(! /&(*/! &)(*$)*(! %)(!

! "* !`-(**'-H#!B#$'M'&+0!1!BU($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!#,%a#**#!+#,%&-.%&(.#!+U#HD*)(,;l!?0!E#1&/#2(9"0!JX!H'&,!VWVW0! ,#.%G! 4'$'M#H#$%0! C%%D,<EEFFFG.'D(%'*G>&ES)%&#a.'&&(#&#E*($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#a#,%a#**#a+#,%&-.%&(.#a+#HD*)(,a XJ[[V]bG! #( !5$+&#'!p)H*),O0!1!1;B#!%&'S'(*!$#!+(,D'&'€%&'!D',!d!.'-,#!+#!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#;?!?0!5+)>0.$+(9"0!Y!>=S&(#&! VWVW0! C%%D,<EEFFFG*#H)$+#G>&E(+##,E'&%(.*#EVWVWEWVEWYE*#a%&'S'(*a$#a+(,D'&'(%&'aD',a'a.'-,#a+#a*a($%#**(M#$.#a '&%(>(.(#**#m[WV]_JJmJVJVGC%H*G! #! !"O&(*!B#!4'%0!1!h$%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#;<!1;B#,!C-H'($,!,)$%!*)($!+U'S)(&!D#&+-!*#-&!D*'.#!#$!#$%&#D&(,#;?!?0!5+)

>0.$+(9"0! XY! $)S#He&#! VWXb0! C%%D,<EEFFFG*#H)$+#G>&E(+##,E'&%(.*#EVWXbEXXEXYE($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#a*#,a

C-H'($,a,)$%a*)($a+a'S)(&aD#&+-a*#-&aD*'.#a#$a#$%&#D&(,#m[WXbV[_mJVJVGC%H*G!

$)

! hM)&! P)M'.C#S0! 1!L)-&c-)(! *'! &=S)*%#! +#,! H'.C($#,! $#! $)-,! H#$'.#! D',! #$.)&#;l!?0! .)$,-*%=! *#! [! ,#D%#He&#! VWVW0! C%%D,<EEFFFGt)-&$'*+-$#%G.)HE,)*-%()$,E+,(EX_bWjWXaD)-&c-)(a*'a&#S)*%#a+#,aH'.C($#,a$#a$)-,aH#$'.#a D',a#$.)&#EG!

(24)

! Hs! .&/,-(+! .*! 2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*! 4-&! .%&(! (*$0&)*$! 2'! #'$(&(&%)! .*! 2'! JI*+,

! /F0#3%)&*! .*! 2O&22-/($*!0-/&,&*)!;**(3%5*)R!A*((*!JI*+,

!/F0#3%)&*!*/(!*)!*88*(!&)',3*5+*!%-!.-!0%&)/C!2*/! 3&/(%$&*)/! )O%)(! #-! $*($%-5*$! 2O*)(&Q$*(+! .*! ,*((*! /F0#3%)&*R! ^)*! +4-&#*! .*! ,3*$,3*-$/! '22*0')./!*(!'-($&,3&*)/!%)(!'2%$/!.+,&.+!.O-(&2&/*$!2*/!%-(&2/!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!#%-$! _!8&)&$!a! ,*((*! #'$(&(&%)R! D*! U%-$)'2! ,($ H1'&/&(6! (&($*! *)! U')5&*$!_!D'! JI*! /F0#3%)&*! .*! ;**(3%5*)!',3*5+*!1$x,*!N!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*$#!a!(%-(!,%00*!,($H-&6*!_!^)*!&)(*22&1*),*!

'$(&8&,&*22*!5'!(*$0&)*$!2'!JI*+,!/F0#3%)&*!.*!;**(3%5*)!$$aR!92-/!1+)+$'2*0*)(C!2*/!U%-$)'-T!N!

($'5*$/!2*!,'/!#'$(&,-2&*$!.O-)*!&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!4-&!,$+*!#-72&*)(!*(!.&88-/*)(!.*/!'$(&,2*/! #%$(')(!/-$!2'!#%//&7&2&(+!#%-$!-)*!b"!.*!8'&$*!#$*-5*!.*!,$+'(&5&(+R!P)!0'$/!HIHIC!2*!U%-$)'2!

W+XD! #-72&*! -)! '$(&,2*! #$+/*)(')(! "2(*$! s! -)! $%7%(! 3-0')%].*! ,3*8! .O%$,3*/($*R! b2/! /*!

.*0').*)(!/&!_!2Ob"!#*-(!$*0#2',*$!2'!/*)/&7&2&(+!3-0'&)*!$%aR!P)!0'&!HIJK!D*!Z%).*!'88&$0*!

4-*!_!2O&)(*22&1*),*!'$(&8&,&*22*!*/(!'-//&!,$+'(&5*!$&aR!!

! [%-/!2O'-$*r!,%0#$&/C!2*/!%$1')*/!.*!#$*//*/!%)(!(*).'),*/!N!8'&$*!,&$,-2*$!#2-/&*-$/!(F#*/!.*! .&/,%-$/!2&+/!N!2'!(*,3)&4-*R!A*/!.&88+$*),*/!*(!,*((*!,%*T&/(*),*!$+5Q2*)(!2O*T&/(*),*!.O-)!.+7'(R! A%00*!)%-/!2*!5*$$%)/!.')/!2'!.*$)&Q$*!#'$(&*!.*!,*!0+0%&$*C!,O*/(!2'!5%2%)(+!.*!#$*).$*!#'$(! N!,*!.+7'(!4-&!.%))*!N!5%&$!2*!#%/&(&%))*0*)(!.*/!0'$4-*/!.*!)%($*!,%$#-/R!!! sR! "##$%#$&'(&%)!.*!,*/!.&/,%-$/!#'$!2*/!0'$4-*/!! D*/!.&88+$*)(*/!0'$4-*/!.*!)%/!#-72&,&(+/!/O&)/,$&5*)(!.')/!,*!,%)(*T(*!?!,*2-&!.*!2O&)(*22&1*),*! '$(&8&,&*22*R! P22*/! .&/,-(*)(! (%-(*/! #2-/! %-! 0%&)/! *T#2&,&(*0*)(! .*! ,*((*! (*,3)&4-*! .*!

! #" !!"=,'&!4'&.C'*0!1!B'!XW#!,OHDC)$(#!+#!P##%C)S#$!'.C#S=#!M&.#!d!*U($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!?0!*#D'&(,(#$G>&0!Xb! t'$S(#&!VWVW0!,#.%G!E.-*%-&#a*)(,(&,EH-,(c-#E0!C%%D,<EEFFFG*#D'&(,(#$G>&E.-*%-&#a*)(,(&,EH-,(c-#E*'aXW#a,OHDC)$(#a +#ae##%C)S#$a'.C#S##aM&'.#a'a*a($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#aXbaWXaVWVWa]VJbVXYGDCDG! ## !%#!L)($%G>&0!1!3$#!($%#**(M#$.#!'&%(>(.(#**#!S'!%#&H($#&!*'!XW#!,OHDC)$(#!+#!P##%C)S#$!?0!B#!L)($%0!Xb!t'$S(#&! VWVW0! C%%D,<EEFFFG*#D)($%G>&EC(MCa%#.Ca($%#&$#%E-$#a($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#aS'a%#&H($#&a*'aXW#a,OHDC)$(#a+#a e##%C)S#$aXbaWXaVWVWaVJY]YYJm_jGDCDG! $%

! "=*($#! 9#Q).Q0! 1!3$! &)e)%! C-H'$)R+#! .C#>! +U)&.C#,%&#;<! *U($%#**(M#$.#! '&%(>(.(#**#! D#-%a#**#! &#HD*'.#&! *'! ,#$,(e(*(%=! C-H'($#;l!?0! 4-,(cJ0! XJ! H'&,! VWVW0! ,#.%G! h$>)0! C%%D,<EEFFFG&%e>Ge#EH-,(cJE'&%(.*#E+#%'(*m-$a&)e)%a C-H'$)(+#a.C#>a+a)&.C#,%&#a*a($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#aD#-%a#**#a&#HD*'.#&a*'a,#$,(e(*(%#aC-H'($#l(+‚XW_Y[JjJG!

#&

! 6)~C'! P)-t#H''0! 1!BU($%#**(M#$.#! '&%(>(.(#**#! #,%! '-,,(! .&='%(S#!?0! 5+) >0.$+(9"0! Vb! H'(! VWXb0! C%%D,<EEFFFG*#H)$+#G>&E,.(#$.#,E'&%(.*#EVWXbEWYEVbE*a($%#**(M#$.#a'&%(>(.(#**#a#,%a'-,,(a

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to