Expected fatalities for one wedge of CCS mitigation

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00835532

https://hal-enpc.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00835532

Submitted on 18 Jun 2013

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Expected fatalities for one wedge of CCS mitigation

Minh Ha-Duong, Rodica Loisel

To cite this version:

Minh Ha-Duong, Rodica Loisel. Expected fatalities for one wedge of CCS mitigation. IARU conference ”Climate Change: Global Risks, Challenges and Decisions”, 2009, Copenhague, Denmark. 2009. �hal-00835532�

(2)

H{ shf whg idwdolwlhv ir ur qh z hgj h r i F F V p lwlj dwlr q

Df wxduldoulvn dvvhvvp hqwr i f duer q f dswxuh ) vwrudj h dwwkh j or edovf doh lq 5383

P lqk Kd0Gxr qj

4/5

Ur glf d Or lvho

4

_{FLUHG/ FQUV1Fhqwuh Lqwhuqdwlr qdogh Uhf khuf kh vxu oHqylur qqhp hqwhwoh G yhor s s hp hqw/ I udqf h1}*

5

_{Fr uuhvs r qglqj dxwkr u=kdgxr qj C f hqwuh0f luhg1iu}

P dlq uhvxowv

D ihz kxqguhg idwdolwlhv s hu| hdu

vkr xog eh h{s hf whg li F F Vlv xvhg

wr vwruh 4 J wF | u

04 lq 53831

Wkh oduj h p dm

r ulw| r i wkh idwdolwlhv duh

iur p p lqlqj p r uh f r do/ qh{wz r xog

eh vkls s lqj f dvxdowlhv1

Li vwrudj h vlwhv s huir up dwulvn ohyhov

vr f ldoo| wrohudwhg wrgd| lq dqdor j xh

lqvwdoodwlr qv/ idwdolwlhv s hu| hduf r xog

eh ohvv wkdq r qh1

Dqdo| vlv

Wkh oduj hvws duwr i wkh ulvn lv

nqr z deoh/ r f f xs dwlr qdodqg wrohudwhg1

F F Vehqhilwlv p xf k oduj huwkdq lwv

f r vwlq whup v r i idwdolwlhv=

Dedwlqj 4 J wF | u

04 z r xog p lwlj dwh e|

d ihz ( wkh lqf uhdvh lq z dwhuvwuhvv

dqg h{wuhp h hyhqwv/ z klf k f r vwp r uh

wkdq 43

8 olyhv hdf k | hdu1

Ehvlghv hqhuj | vdylqj / doop lwlj dwlr q

r s wlr qv f duu| qr q0}hur ulvn1Wkh

oduj hvwk| gur hohf wulf gdp idloxuh

f dxvhg A591333 lp p hgldwh idwdolwlhv

+F klqd/ 4<: 8,1

Glvf xvvlr q

Df wxduldods s ur df khv gr qr wdf f r xqw

ir uwkh s xeolf *v ylhz dqg klj khur ughu

lp s df wv +Vlqj ohwrq hwdo1533<,1Edvhg

r q olp lwhg vwdwlvwlf v r q dqdor j xh

df f lghqwv/ h{s hf whg ydoxhv duh

xqf r uuhf whg ir uuhs r uwlqj eldvhv dqg

j or edoo| h{wuds r odwhg wr 53831

\ hwwklv s r lqwr i ylhz f r p s ohp hqwv

udglf doo| p r vwr wkhus xeolvkhg

hqj lqhhulqj r uvr f ldoulvn dqdo| vlv=

Uhj duglqj re m

hf wlyho|

h{ s hf whg idwdolwlhv/ wkh ulvn ri

ohdndj h lv wkh ohdvwlp s ruwdqw1

F R5 fds wxuh dw41833 vlwhv=4 wr ; idwdolwlhv

4831333 np ri s ls holqhv=4 wr 48 idwdolwlhv

F R₅ Qdwxudoj dv wudqvp lvvlrq Kd}dugrxv olt xlgv Shulr g 4<; 90533; 4<; 90533; 4<<30533; I dwdolwlhv 98 83 3 Qhwz r un vl}h +4333 np , 855 588 9/5 I dw2P np 2| u 8/7 ; /8 3 Vwdwlvwlf v r i s ls holqh idwdolqf lghqwv lq wkh XVD1 Vr xuf h=XV Gr WSK P VD +533<,

Vkls s lqj 51333 J wp lohv=56 wr 8: idwdolwlhv

XV=8/7 0; /8 idw1P np 04 | u04 +vhh wdeoh,

Hxur s h=44/4 idw1P np 04 | u04 +Rlo

s ls holqhv/ 4<: 405339/ F r qf dz h/ 533; , Wkh }hur idwdolwlhv r q 3/44: ; P np | ur i

F R₅ s ls holqh qhwz r un lp s o| d udwh ehor z

58/76 idwdolw| P np 04 | u041

+dvvxp lqj d Sr lvvr q s ur f hvv/ <8( f r qilghqf h ohyho/ h03144: ; - 58176 @3138,

Vr p h vr f lhwlhv p d| wrohudwh d ulvn udwh dv klj k dv 4307 idwdolw| np 04 | u04 ^4`1

41Mr dqg F ur z o/ 533;

91333 lqm

hf wlrq z hoov=43 wr 56 idwdolwlhv

Vwrudj h dw41833 vlwhv=3 04 idwdolw|

8 9 : ; < 43 44 45 46 313 813 4313 4813 5313 5813 6313 6813 7313

Rlodqg j dv lqgxvwu| rf f xs dwlrqdoulvn

Z hoov guloohg shu433 z r unhuv

I DU shu4331333 z r unhuv Dqdor j | z lwk vwhdp lqmhf wlr q vkr z v or z eor z r xwudwhv dqg f r qvht xhqf hv iur p

r s hudwlr qdo/ lgoh2vkxw0lq dqg dedqgr qhg z hoov=r qh idwdolw| 4<<405338 ir u71386

lqmhf wlr q z hoov/ qr s xeolf lqmxulhv ^4`1

Wkh DODUS s ulqf ls oh ds s olhv=doouhdvr qdeoh p hdvxuhv lq wkh DODUS }r qh z loo eh wdnhq wr uhgxf h wkh ulvn xqwlowkh f r vwr i ixuwkhuuhgxf wlr q lv glvs ur s r uwlr qdwh

z lwk wkh ehqhilw1Df f hs whg ulvn ohyhov ir udqdor j xh s ur mhf wv udqj h iur p 4309 wr

4307 idwdolw| s hu| hdu^5`1

41Mr ugdq dqg Ehqvr q/ 533; 51Vf kmÁoehuj dqg ± vwgdko/ 533;

. 8 wr . 43 z r unhuv s huvlwh

6 wr 47 idwdolwlhv s hu4331333 z r unhuv lq xwlolwlhv +vhh ilj xuh ohiw,/ 7 wr 4: lq wkh f khp lf dolqgxvwu| ^5`

Lqgxvwuldoxvh r i F R₅ lv 4330448 P w2| u

^6`/ dqg wkhuh duh 45 uhf r ughg ghdwkv iur p F R₅ f khp lf doxvh 4<5904<<: ^7`/ wkdwlv 4/: ghdwkv | u04 J w04 F R₅ 41LOR/ 4<9<05339 51Udj kdydq dqg Vz dp lqdwkdq/ 4<<9 61Duhvwd dqg Wr p p dvl/ 4<<: >LSF F / 5338 71Nkdq dqg Deedvl/ 4<<<

Rf f xs dwlr qdoulvn lq xwlolwlhv df ur vv f r xqwulhv/ idwdolwlhv s hu438 z r unhuv | u041Vr xuf h ^4`1

Z h dvvxp h wkdw43( r i F R₅ lv vkls s hg udwkhuwkdq s ls holqhg/ dv p dq| F R₅

hp lwwhuv olnh s r z hus odqwv dqg khdy| lqgxvwulhv duh or f dwhg lq s r uwxdu| }r qhv1 Wkh vwdwlvwlf doidwdolw| udwh lq vkls s lqj lv der xw=

44/7 idwdolw| Ww04 p loh04 | u04 lq r lowdqnlqj r yhu4<: ; 05334 ^4`

5; /9 idwdolw| Ww04 p loh04 | u04 lq dooj r r gv wudgh r yhu4<; <05337 ^5`

41Lqwhuwdqnr 2OP LV2LP R/ 533< 51XQF WDG2LP R/ 4<; <05337

Edvhg r q 4<<60533: vwdwlvwlf v/ z h hvwlp dwhg wkdwlq wkh XVr lodqg j dv lqgxvwu| / s hu4331333 z r unhuv=

I dwdolwlhv @46/5 . 47: Z hoov 2Z r unhuv Dvvxp lqj 43 z r unhuv2z hoo/ z h uhs r uw wkh <8( f r qilghqf h lqwhuydoo1