Une vie pour l'érudition : Charles Urbain (1852-1931)

HAL Id: halshs-01119257

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01119257

Submitted on 14 Mar 2021

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain (1852-1931)

Christian Sorrel

To cite this version:

Christian Sorrel. Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain (1852-1931). Revue Bossuet, 2013, pp.41-

55. �halshs-01119257�

5N

U NE VIE POUR L ’ ERUDITION : C HARLES U RBAIN (1852-1931)

E 9-,,"'/( )"( ??

,%V.$'b G( B+',/( ,-",( .'( /%/*'( _"'( $+)##&( M%./-*

B)**%V*'H( !*-`',,'"*( R( $+@0,/%/"/( .)/a-$%_"'( 7'( I)*%,H( &2-_"'( 7)0,( $) Revue d’histoire de l’Église de FranceH(7V,(,)(F-*/('0(NZ]NH($)(.)*[

*%V*'(,.%'0/%`%_"'(7"(.a)0-%0'(Ba)*$',(<*#)%0H()!*V,($"%()2-%*(.-0,)[

.*&("0()*/%.$'(0&.*-$-D%_"'

b(Ba)*$',(<*#)%0H(&7%/'"*()"L(.t/&,(7"(,"$[

!%.%'0(="DV0'(C'2',_"'(7'($)(.-**',!-07)0.'('/(7',(v"2*',(-*)/-%*', 7'( $+&2g_"'( 7'( K')"LH( ',/( 7&`%0%/%2'F'0/( %7'0/%`%&( R( .'$"%( )"_"'$( %$

)2)%/(.-0,).*&(!*V,(7'($)(F-%/%&(7'(,)(2%'('/($+-"#$%('02'$-!!'(7V,($-*, ,)(`%D"*'(7%,.*V/'b(@$(*',/'(7%``%.%$'()"8-"*7+a"%H(.-F!/'(/'0"(7'($+&/)/

7'( $)( 7-."F'0/)/%-0H( 7'( $)( F'//*'( '0( !$'%0'( $"F%V*'( '/( $'( !*&,'0/

)*/%.$'(0'(!'"/()!!-*/'*(_"'(_"'$_"',(8)$-0,b(@$,(,-0/(-*7-00&,()"/-"*

7'($+&2&0'F'0/(%0)//'07"(_"%(`)%/(7'(Ba)*$',(<*#)%0H(7'(NZQN(R(NZQ]H

$'(2%.)%*'(D&0&*)$(7'(K

C).*-%LH(&2g_"'(7'(>)*'0/)%,'H("0(&2&0'F'0/

_"%()!!)*)d/(.-FF'("0'(!)*'0/aV,'(7)0,("0'(2%'(7-00&'(R($+&*"7%/%-0H F)%,(_"%(-"2*'(7',(!'*,!'./%2',(,"*($'(!)*.-"*,('/($',(.-02%./%-0,(7' .'$"%('0(_"%(M%./-*(B)**%V*'(2-J)%/($+"0(E 7',(a-FF',($',(!$",(*'!*&[

,'0/)/%`,(7'($+&$%/'(%0/'$$'./"'$$'(7"(.$'*D& G(`*)0U)%,

b

Un prêtre intellectuel

C-"%,(Ba)*$',(<*#)%0(',/(0&($'(NZ(-./-#*'(NYOP(7)0,("0'(.-FF"0'

*"*)$'( 7"( 0-*7( 7"( 7&!)*/'F'0/( 7'( $)( e)"/'[K)*0'H( o-"$'2)0/[$'[

Baf/')"H(_"%(.-F!/'()$-*,(,'!/(.'0/(,-%L)0/'[7%L(a)#%/)0/,

b(@$()!!)*[

/%'0/( R( "0'( `)F%$$'( F-7',/'H( .-FF'( $'( ,"DDV*'( $)( !*-`',,%-0( 7'( ,-0

!V*'H(E(`-07'"*('0(."%2*'(GH('/($+-0(0'(,)%/(*%'0(7'(,',(!*'F%V*',()00&', 8",_"+R(,-0('0/*&'()"(!'/%/(,&F%0)%*'(7'(C)0D*',(R($+fD'(7'(_")/-*h' )0,H('0(.$),,'(7'(/*-%,%VF'

b(:0(!'"/(.'!'07)0/(,"!!-,'*H(7+)!*V,("0

Nb(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'b(Kb $'(.a)0-%0'(<*#)%0 G('/(E 9-,,"'/()"(??

,%V.$'b(C', /*)2)"L(7'($+)##&(<*#)%0(*'$)/%`,(R(9-,,"'/(W',,)%(#%#$%-D*)!a%_"'\ GH(7)0,(Revue d’his- toire de l’Église de FranceH(/b ?M@@H(04 kjH(NZ]NH(!b 5N5[5Nj('/(04 kkH(NZ]NH(!b 5j5[5Ykb C'( !*'F%'*( )*/%.$'( ',/( *'!*%,( 7)0,( La Semaine religieuse de ParisH( /b BCM@H( 04 5QOQH PP )-u/(NZ]NH(!b PN][PNOb

Pb(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'bbb GH(locb(citbH(!b(5N5b

]b(6*.a%2',(7&!)*/'F'0/)$',(7'($)(e)"/'[K)*0'H(NOY K NkY(W*'.'0,'F'0/(7'(NYON\

'/(N = NkYÄNQ(W&/)/(.%2%$\b

5b( =0( NYOZH( $-*,( 7'( $)( 0)%,,)0.'( 7'( ,-0( ,'.-07( `%$,H( B$)"7'(6$!a-0,'( <*#)%0( ',/

F&.)0%.%'0('/(,-0(&!-",'(S$%,)#'/a(^-,&!a%0'(,)0,(!*-`',,%-0b(@$(,%D0'($'(*'D%,/*'(7',

5P Christian Sorrel

,.a&F)(.$),,%_"'H($+)//'0/%-0(7"(."*&(7'($)(!)*-%,,'(!-"*("0(D)*U-0(_"%

F)0%`',/'( 7',( )!/%/"7',( %0/'$$'./"'$$',( '/( 0+'L.$"/( !),( 7'( ,'( /-"*0'*

2'*,( $'( ,).'*7-.'b( C'( !'/%/( ,&F%0)%*'H( 7-0/( $+-#8'./%`( $&D)$H( .-0`%*F&

!)*($)($-%(T)$$-"LH(*',/'($'(*'.*"/'F'0/(7"(.$'*D&H(.-0,/%/"'(7V,($-*,($' .)7*'()7&_")/(!-"*(`)U-00'*($+)7-$',.'0/('/($'(!*&!)*'*(R(%0/&*%-*%,'*

$+a)#%/",(,).'*7-/)$

b(C)(/f.a'(0'(,'F#$'(!),()%,&'(,%($+-0('0(.*-%/("0'

*'F)*_"'(7"(,"!&*%'"*H($+)##&(K)0-%, i(E @$()(7',(/)$'0/,H("0'(#-00' .-07"%/'H(F)%,(_"'$$'('L.'0/*%.%/& x G(M%./-*(B)**%V*'H(_"%(*)!!-*/'($'

!*-!-,H($'(.-FF'0/'()%0,% i(E @$(`)"/()2-%*(.-00"($'(.$'*D&(7"(;'.-07

=F!%*'H( ,-0( )F-"*( 7"( .-02'0/%-00'$H( 7"( /-"/( *'!-,H( !-"*( ,)%,%*( .' _"+"0'(/'$$'('L!*',,%-0(7)0,($)(#-".a'(7+"0(&7".)/'"*(7'(.'(/'F!,[$R

!-"2)%/( ,%D0%`%'*( !)*`-%,( 7+'L.'!/%-00'$H( 2-%*'( 7'( !*',/%D%'"L

b G( @$

0+',/( !),( .'*/)%0( /-"/'`-%,( _"'( $',( &7".)/'"*,( 7"( 7%-.V,'( 7'( C)0D*', )%'0/(&/&()",,%(&/*-%/,(_"+%$($'(,"DDV*'(7)0,($)(F',"*'(-q(%$,()..'!/'0/

7'( !*&,'0/'*( $'"*,( F'%$$'"*,( &$V2',( )"( #)..)$)"*&)/H( F)$D*&( $',( *&/%[

.'0.',( 7'( $+SD$%,'( .)/a-$%_"'( !-"*( "0( D*)7'( 8"D&( ,-"2'0/( %0"/%$'( '/

7)0D'*'"Lb(@0"/%$'H(.)*(%$('L.V7'($',(#',-%0,(7"(F%0%,/V*'(-*7%0)%*'('/

0+',/( !),( %07%,!'0,)#$'( !-"*( )..&7'*( )"L( !-,/',( ,"!&*%'"*,b o)0D'*'"LH(.)*(%$(!*-7"%/($+-*D"'%$('/(&$-%D0'(7"(,).'*7-.'b(=0(NYjZH Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( ',/( !-"*/)0/( '02-J&( $'( .-0_"&*%*( '0( ;-*#-00'H( -q( %$

*'U-%/($',(`&$%.%/)/%-0,(7"(8"*JH()$-*,(_"'(,',(.-07%,.%!$',(,'(,-"F'//'0/

)"(8"D'F'0/(7',("0%2'*,%/&,(7'(o%8-0(-"(7'(CJ-0b

C'(,"..V,(0'(7&/-"*0'(!),($'(8'"0'(a-FF'(7"(D*)07(,&F%0)%*'('/(%$

',/(-*7-00&(!*g/*'($'(PZ(8"%0(NYkOb(K

c"'**%0($'(0-FF'()",,%/t/(!*-[

`',,'"*( )"( !'/%/( ,&F%0)%*'( 7'( C)0D*',( -qH( /-"8-"*,( !),,%-00&( !)*( $',

&/"7',H( %$( !*&!)*'( $)( $%.'0.'( V,( $'//*',b( K)%,( ,%( $'( #)..)$)"*&)/( J( ',/

)..'!/&(!-"*($',(&$V2',H(%$(0+'0(',/(!),(7'(FgF'(7',(D*)7',(,"!&*%'"*,

!-"*($',('0,'%D0)0/,H('/(%$(7-%/($'(`)%*'('0(,'.*'/

b(:0(7'2%0'("0'(%0,)[

/%,`)./%-0H( 7-"#$&'( 7'( $)( .*)%0/'( 7+g/*'( )``'./&( "0( 8-"*( '0( !)*-%,,'( '/

7+)``*-0/'*( $)( E *',!-0,)#%$%/&( 7"( .-0`',,%-00)$H( z_"%{( $+'``*)J' G

b oV,( $)( *'0/*&'( ,"%2)0/'H( %$( *'8-%0/( .-FF'( !*-`',,'"*( 7'( *a&/-*%_"'

0)%,,)0.',H(.-FF'(,-0(!V*'(^)._"',(I)"$H(8)*7%0%'*b(=0(NYOPH($'(,'.-07(/&F-%0(',/("0

%0,/%/"/'"*(!*%F)%*'H(C-"%,(S/%'00'(o".$-,H(.'(_"%(!'"/(,"DD&*'*($)(!*&,'0.'(7+"0(%0/&*g/

!-"*($+&7".)/%-0(7)0,($'(*&,')"(7'(,-.%)#%$%/&(7'($)(`)F%$$'b

Ob(Cb ;'.-07JH(E I$).'('/(*t$'(7',(!'/%/,(,&F%0)%*',(7)0,($+'0,'%D0'F'0/(,'.-07)%*' '0(T*)0.'()"(?@?

,%V.$' GH(7)0,( Revue d’histoire de l’Église de FranceH(/b jjH(NZYQH

!b P5][POZ s Bb ;-**'$H(E C)(`-*F)/%-0(7"(.$'*D&(.)/a-$%_"'('0(T*)0.'(7'(NYQQ(R(NZN5 GH 7)0,(eb T*&.a'/(W7%*b\H(Religion et culture de 1800 à 1914. Allemagne, France, Italie, Royaume-UniH(I)*%,H(S7%/%-0,(7"(>'F!,H(PQQNH(!b PY[5jb

jb(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'bbb GH(locb(citbH(!b(5N5b

kb(@$(`)"/()//'07*'($)($-%(7'(NYYP(!-"*(2-%*(,'(F"$/%!$%'*(7)0,($',(*)0D,(7"(.$'*D&($', D*)7',("0%2'*,%/)%*',(7&,-*F)%,(0&.',,)%*',(!-"*('0,'%D0'*(7)0,($',(.-$$VD',($%#*',b

Yb(Quinzaine religieuse de la TarentaiseH(N

8"%$$'/(NZ]Nb

5]

Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

$+&.-$'(;)%0/[>a-F),[7+6_"%0(R(:"$$%0,H()"L(!-*/',(7'(CJ-0H(,)0,(_"'

$+-0(!"%,,'(7%*'(.-FF'0/(%$()(&/&(.-07"%/(2'*,(.'($%'"b(C+&/)#$%,,'F'0/H

`-07&('0(NY]](!)*(/*-%,(!*g/*',(,&."$%'*,(7)0,(E "0'(!'0,&'(R($)(`-%, .)/a-$%_"'('/($%#&*)$' G(WCb[Xb B)!/%'*\H(',/(7'2'0"('0(NYOP($'(#'*.')"

7"( >%'*,( :*7*'( '0,'%D0)0/( 7'( ;)%0/[o-F%0%_"'H( .*&&( !)*( $'( !V*' C).-*7)%*'(!-"*(`)U-00'*(7',(.a*&/%'0,(.-0,.%'0/,(7'($'"*,(*',!-0,)[

#%$%/&,(D*f.'(R("0'(!&7)D-D%'(7'($)($%#'*/&('/(7'($+%0%/%)/%2'

b(K)%,($'

*'.*"/'F'0/($%F%/&(7'($)(#*)0.a'('0,'%D0)0/'H(F-%0,()//*)./%2'(_"'($' E D*)07(-*7*' GH(!"%,($',(7%``%."$/&,($%&',(R($+-``'0,%2'()0/%[.-0D*&D)[

0%,/'(7"(F%0%,/*'(T'**J(%F!-,'0/($+)!!'$()"L(!*g/*',(,&."$%'*,('/()"L

$).,(!-"*('0.)7*'*($',(&$V2',

b

Ba)*$',(<*#)%0(*',/'(7%L()0,(R(:"$$%0,('/(!'"/(J(."$/%2'*(,)(!),,%-0 7',( #'$$',[$'//*',H( R( $+a-00'"*( 7)0,( $+&/)#$%,,'F'0/ i( E C',( $'//*', ,'"$',H(R($+'L.$",%-0(7',(,.%'0.',(_"%(0'(2-",(!)*$'0/(_"'(7'($)(0)/"[

*'H( 2-",( F'//'0/( )"L( !*%,',( )2'.( 2-/*'( !*-!*'( .-0,.%'0.'H( 2-",( `-0/

.-00)d/*'(R(2-",[FgF'('/(2-",()%7'0/(R(2-",(2)%0.*' GH(*)!!'$$'($+).)[

7&F%.%'0( `*)0U)%,( M%./-*( 7'( C)!*)7'( 7)0,( "0( 7%,.-"*,( 7'( !*%L( '0 NYYQ

b( C'( !*-`',,'"*( '0( ',/( .-02)%0."( '/( %02%/'( E $',( 8'"0',( D'0,( R

$%*'($',(.$),,%_"',('/(R(!*'07*'("0'(.-00)%,,)0.'(7%*'./'(7'(0-,(D*)07,

&.*%2)%0, GH(.-FF'(%$($+'L!$%_"'(7)0,($)(!*&`).'(7'($+"0(7',(F)0"'$,

!-"*($)(.$),,'(7'(*a&/-*%_"'(_"+%$(!"#$%'(R(!)*/%*(7'(NYYQ('/(_"+%$(*&&7%[

/'(7'(0-F#*'",',(`-%,(!-"*(,"%2*'($',(.a)0D'F'0/,(7'(!*-D*)FF'

i E ;)0,($)($'./"*'(z~{H(/-"/(/*)2)%$(.-FF'($'(0t/*'(,'*)%/(%0"/%$'H(7)0[

D'*'"L( FgF'b( @$( a)#%/"'*)%/( $',( &$V2',( R( ,'( !)J'*( 7'( `-*F"$',H( 7'

!a*),',( /-"/',( `)%/',( _"%( 0'( $)%,,'*)%'0/( 7)0,( $'"*( ',!*%/( _"'( 7', 0-/%-0,(2)D"',(,)0,()"."0'(%F!*',,%-0(!'*,-00'$$'

b G

=0( NYYj( !-"*/)0/H( Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( _"%//'( ,-0( !-,/'b( C)( *'0.-0/*' 7+"0( 8'"0'( F'F#*'( 7"( >%'*,( :*7*'( '0,'%D0)0/( )``'./&( R( :"$$%0,( '0

Zb(z>b[ob X'J0%'*{H(L’École Saint-Thomas-d’Aquin à Oullins de 1833-1836 à 1886 par un ancien élèveH( CJ-0H( C%#*b( M%//'( '/( I'**",,'$H( NYZ5H( P]j !b s ^b[ob C'2',_"'H E C).-*7)%*'( R( :"$$%0, GH( 7)0,( cb 9&7-"'$$'( W7%*b\H( Lacordaire, son pays, ses amis et la liberté des ordres religieux en FranceH( I)*%,H( B'*`H( NZZNH( !b NkO[NYO s cb[cb K-0/,'**'/H(E =0,'%D0)0/(!)*.'(_"'(!*g.a'"*b(e'0*%[o-F%0%_"'(C).-*7)%*' GH Mémoire dominicaineH(04 ]H(NZZ]H(!b 5P[5jb(

NQb( C',( )*.a%2',( 7"( >%'*,( :*7*'( '0,'%D0)0/H( .-0,'*2&',( )"( .-"2'0/( 7'( >-"$-",'H 0+)!!-*/'0/()"."0(*'0,'%D0'F'0/(,"*($+)##&(<*#)%0(W.-FF"0%.)/%-0(7"(`*V*'(6"D",/%0 C)``)JH(PQNQ\b

NNb(Mb 7'(C)!*)7'H(Allocution aux élèves de l’école Saint-Thomas-d’Aquin pronon- cée le 2 août 1880 à Oullins (Rhône)H(I)*%,H(^"$',(c'*2)%,H(NYYQH(!b Yb

NPb(Précis d’un cours de littérature W2-$b N(Principes généraux et poétique s 2-$b P Genres en prose\('/(Études historiques et critiques sur les classiques français du bac- calauréat W'0(.-$$)#-*)/%-0()2'.(Kb ^)F'J\b

N]b(Études historiques…H(op. cit.H(Z

&7bH(CJ-0H(=b(M%//'H(NYZNH(!b

b

55 Christian Sorrel

)-u/( NYY]H( C".%'0( C).*-%LH( )"_"'$( %$( ,'( $%'( 2%/'H( 0+',/( !'"/[g/*'( !),

&/*)0DV*'( R( ,)( 7&.%,%-0b( B'$"%[.%H( '0( .-0`$%/( )2'.( $',( )"/-*%/&,( 7'( $) .-0D*&D)/%-0( '/( 7&,%*'"L( 7'( ,'( .-0,).*'*( R( $)( *'.a'*.a'H( -#/%'0/( '0 '``'/(,)(,&."$)*%,)/%-0('0(NYY5b(@$(,+%0,/)$$'(R(I)*%,(.-FF'(!*g/*'($%#*'H

"0(,/)/"/(.-"*)0/(7)0,($)(.)!%/)$'(_"%()//%*'(7',(.$'*.,()F#%/%'"L('/($'"*

-``*'H( a-*,( 7"( .)7*'( .-0.-*7)/)%*'H( 7',( *',,-"*.',( 2)*%&', i( !*&7%.)[

/%-0,H( !*&.'!/-*)/,H( .-$$)#-*)/%-0,( )"L( 8-"*0)"L( '/( )"L( *'2"',

b Ba)*$',(<*#)%0(`*)0.a%/($'(!),(7'"L()0,(!$",(/)*7('/(7'F)07'(,',(*',[

,-"*.',()"L($'U-0,b(@$(!'"/()%0,%(`*&_"'0/'*($+S.-$'(!*)/%_"'(7',(a)"/',

&/"7',( '/( $)( 9%#$%-/aV_"'( 0)/%-0)$'( !-"*( !*&!)*'*( "0( 7-./-*)/( V,

$'//*',H(R($+a'"*'(-q($'(7&#)/(,"*($',(E a)"/',(&/"7', G('..$&,%),/%_"',H )F-*.&( 7V,( $'( 7&#"/( 7"( ,%V.$'( '/( )F!$%`%&( !)*( $)( .-08-0./"*'H( %0.%/'

!$",%'"*,( 7'( ,',( .-0`*V*',( R( )``*-0/'*( $',( 8"*J,( 7'( $+S/)/( '0( ',!&*)0/

7&F'0/%*( $',( )..",)/%-0,( 7+%0."$/"*'( !-*/&',( .-0/*'( $'( .$'*D&( 7' T*)0.'

b

C+)##&( <*#)%0H( E F-%0,( a%,/-*%'0( _"+&*"7%/( '/( D*)FF)%*%'0 G

H .a-%,%/(7'(.-0,).*'*(,)(/aV,'(`*)0U)%,'(R(1%.-$),(B-'``'/')"H(7-F%0%[

.)%0('/(&2g_"'H(_"%()(8-"&("0(*t$'(!-$%/%_"'()"(7&#"/(7"(?M@@

,%V.$'H F)%,(_"%(',/(,"*/-"/(.-0,%7&*&(.-FF'($+"0(7',(!V*',(7'($)(!*-,'(`*)0[

U)%,'H(*'.-00"(!)*(M)"D'$),(!-"*(,-0(F)d/*'

b(62'.(F%0"/%'H(%$(*'/*).' ,-0(!)*.-"*,(!"%,()0)$J,'(,',(v"2*',(7-0/($'(,/J$'H(*&D$&(,"*($+",)D'(7'

$)(.-"*H(E 0+',/(!),(,)0,(F&*%/' GH(F)$D*&(7',(7&`)"/,()7F%,(!)*(,',($)"[

7)/'"*,('"L[FgF', i

6"( /'F!,( 7'( B-'``'/')"H( .'( _"+%$( `)$$)%/( 7-00'*( )"L( T*)0U)%,H( .' 0+&/)%'0/( !),( 7'( .',( .a'`,[7+v"2*'( _"%H( !)*( $'"*( !'*`'./%-0( FgF'H 7&.-"*)D'0/($',(%F%/)/'"*,H(F)%,(!$"/t/($'(F-7V$'(7+"0(,/J$'H(!-"*()%0,%

7%*'H(%F!'*,-00'$('/H(R(.'//'(.-07%/%-0(,'"$'F'0/H(.)!)#$'(7'(7'2'0%*($)

$)0D"'(7'(/-"/("0(!'"!$' s 7+"0(,/J$'(F-%0,(7%,/%0D"&H(F)%,(!$",()..',[

,%#$'H(7+"0'($)0D"'(.$)%*'('/(&$&D)0/'H()#-07)0/'('/(`).%$'H(_"'(/-",($', D'0,(#%'0(&$'2&,(!"%,,'0/(,+)!!*-!*%'*b(K)%,H(!-"*(!*-7"%*'(.'(F-7V$'H '/(.*&'*()%0,%($)($)0D"'(7'(/-",H(%$(`)$$)%/H(0-0(!),($',(7-0,(7"(D&0%'H(F)%,

"0( a'"*'"L( '0,'F#$'( 7'( _")$%/&,( F-J'00',H( F-%0,( .-FF"0( _"+-0( 0' ,"!!-,'H('/(_"%(`"/(!)*('L.'$$'0.'($'(!)*/)D'(7'(B-'``'/')"b

N5b(Bb ;-**'$H(Libéralisme et modernisme. M

Lacroix (1855-1922). Enquête sur un suspectH(I)*%,H(B'*`H(PQQ]H(!b 5k[YNb

NOb(Sb I-"$)/H(E C',(%0,"``%,)0.',(7'($)(a)"/'(."$/"*'(.)/a-$%_"' GH(7)0,(Liberté, laï- cité. La guerre des deux France et le principe de la modernitéH(I)*%,H(B'*`[B"8),H(NZYYH

!b ]]O[]jZb

Njb(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'bbb GH(locb(citbH(!b(5N5b

Nkb( Nicolas Coeffeteau, dominicain, évêque de Marseille, un des fondateurs de la

prose française (1574-1623)H(CJ-0H(=b M%//'H(NYZ5H(5NO !b

5O Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

T-*/(7'(.'(/*)2)%$H(.-F!$&/&(!)*("0'(7%,,'*/)/%-0(!a%$-,-!a%_"'(!-"*

$)(/aV,'($)/%0'(7-0/($)(!$).'(7&.$%0'(8",_"+R(,)(,"!!*',,%-0('0(NZQP

H Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( ',/( !*-.$)F&( 7-./'"*( V,( $'//*',( '0( ;-*#-00'( $' PP( 7&.'F#*'( NYZ]

b( @$( 0'( F-7%`%'( !),( !-"*( )"/)0/( ,)( 2%'( 7%,.*V/'H FgF'( ,+%$( '02%,)D'( 7'( !*&!)*'*( $+)D*&D)/%-0

H( '/( ,'( .-0,).*'( R( ,',

&$V2',('/(R(,',()./%2%/&,(&7%/-*%)$',H(_"%(.-F!$V/'0/($',(*'2'0",(7'(,',

$'U-0,b(@$(.-$$)#-*'()"(Bulletin du bibliophile '/(R($)(Revue d’histoire littéraire de la France '/( .+',/( 7)0,( .'( .)7*'( _"+%$( ,+%0/&*',,'( R 9-,,"'/H( .-0/*'( _"%( %$( 0-"**%/( )"( 7&!)*/( 7',( !*&2'0/%-0,( '/( )"_"'$( %$

!*&`V*'(T&0'$-0(7-0/(%$(,'(`)%/($+)2-.)/(`).'(R(C&-0(B*-",$&H(!*-`',,'"*

7+&$-_"'0.'( `*)0U)%,'( '0( ;-*#-00'H( '/( R( 7%2'*,( .'0,'"*,

b( @$( .*-%,' '0,"%/'($'(`'*()2'.($+)##&(>a&-7-*'(o'$F-0/H(!*-`',,'"*()"L(T)."$/&, .)/a-$%_"',(7'(CJ-0H(_"%(2'"/($)2'*(9-,,"'/(7'(/-"/'()..",)/%-0(.-F[

!*-F'//)0/'( !-"*( ,)( F&F-%*'( )"( !-%0/( 7'( 0%'*( $+)"/a'0/%.%/&( 7'( !$"[

,%'"*,(F)0",.*%/, i($+)##&(<*#)%0(7&`'07($'"*(2)$'"*('/(%0,%,/'(,"*($',

&$&F'0/,(7'(!*-L%F%/&('0/*'($+&2g_"'(7'(K')"L('/($',(8)0,&0%,/',

b(@$

7'2%'0/()%0,%(*)!%7'F'0/("0(#-0(.-00)%,,'"*(7"(!*&$)/('/(%$(0+',/(7-0.

!),( &/-00)0/( _"+="DV0'( C'2',_"'H( !*-`',,'"*( )"( ,&F%0)%*'( ;)%0/[

;"$!%.'H($"%(7'F)07'(,-0()%7'(!-"*($)0.'*($)(Revue BossuetH(_"%(!"#$%' a"%/(2-$"F',(7'(7-."F'0/,(%0&7%/,('0/*'(NZQQ('/(NZNN

b

C+)##&(<*#)%0(.-0`%'("0'(!)*/%'(7'(,',(&/"7',(R($)(Revue du clergé français 7-0/(%$(',/("0(.-$$)#-*)/'"*(7'!"%,(,)(.*&)/%-0('0(NYZ5(!)*(,-0 )F%(C).*-%L

H(_"%('0/'07(F'//*'($'(.$'*D&(7',(!)*-%,,',('/(7',(,&F%[

0)%*',()"(.-"*)0/(7',(-*%'0/)/%-0,(0-"2'$$',(7'($)(,.%'0.'('/(7'($)(.%/&

'/($"%(!*-."*'*(7',(F-J'0,(7+)./%-0(!),/-*)$'(.-0`-*F',()"L(-!/%-0,

NYb( De Concursu divino scholastici quid senserint. Philosophicam disputationem Facultati litterarum Parisiensi proponebat Carolus UrbainH(CJ-0H(=b M%//'H(NYZ5H(NON !b Ba)*$',(<*#)%0()#-*7'(7)0,(.'//'(&/"7'($)(_"',/%-0(7'($+%0/'*2'0/%-0(7'(o%'"(7)0,(.a)[

."0'(7',()./%-0,(7',(.*&)/"*',('/(7'(,-0(.-0.-"*,()"L(-!&*)/%-0,(7',()D'0/,(!aJ,%_"',b NZb(6b c"%D"'H(La Faculté des lettres de l’Université de Paris depuis sa fondation (17 mars 1808) jusqu’au 1

janvier 1935H(I)*%,H(C%#b(T&$%L(6$.)0H(NZ]OH(!b(ZY[NQZb

PQb(6*.a%2',(0)/%-0)$',H(TNZ PYNNH(7-,,%'*(<*#)%0H('0_"g/'(7'($)(!*&`'./"*'(7'(!-$%[

.'(7'(I)*%,H(NY(8"%$$'/(NZQNb(6!*V,(NZQPH($'(D-"2'*0'F'0/(B-F#',(`'*F'*)($'(.-0.-"*, )"L('..$&,%),/%_"',b

PNb( Revue d’histoire littéraire de la FranceH( /b @@H( NYZOH( !b Pjk[PkZ s /b @@@H( NYZjH

!b 5QZ[5]5b(C&-0(B*-",$&()2)%/(!"#$%&('0(NYZ5[NYZO(7'"L(2-$"F',(%0/%/"$&,(Fénelon et Bossuet. Études morales et littérairesb

PPb(Revue du clergé françaisH(/b @?H(NYZkH(!b ]5N[]5] s(/b ??H(NYZZH(!b NN][N]](WE o"

8)0,&0%,F'( 7'( 9-,,"'/ G\( '/( 55Z[5Y] s( /b ??@H( NZQQH( !b 55Z[5jZ( '/( jPj[j5O s /b ??@@H NZQQH(!b jk[Yk s /b ??MH(NZQNH(!b ]jN[]ZP(WE 9-,,"'/()!-$-D%,/'(7"(Ib }"',0'$ G\b

P]b( ^b B)**'J*'H( E 1&.*-$-D%'b( Kb( ="DV0'( C'2',_"' GH( 7)0,( Revue d’histoire de l’Église de FranceH(/b ???H(04 NNkH(NZ55H(!b PQQ[PQNb

P5b(C+)##&(C).*-%LH(7-./'"*(V,($'//*',(7'!"%,(NYZN()2'.("0'(/aV,'(,"*($+&!%,.-!)/(7'

X%.a'$%'"(R(C"U-0H(',/(7&,-*F)%,()"Ft0%'*(7"($J.&'(K%.a'$'/(R(M)02',b

5j Christian Sorrel

!-$%/%_"',('/(,-.%)$',(7'(C&-0 ?@@@

b(@$(,%VD'(7V,($'(7&#"/()"(.-F%/&

7'(7%*'./%-0('/()"(.-F%/&(7'(*&7)./%-0('/(),,"*'($)(.a*-0%_"'($%//&*)%*' -q( %$( *'07( .-F!/'( 7',( !"#$%.)/%-0,( *&.'0/',( )2'.( `%0',,'H( '0( ",)0/

7+"0'(D*%$$'(7'($'./"*'(.)/a-$%_"'H(F)%,(,)0,(.&7'*()"(7-DF)/%,F'b(@$

'0(!*-`%/'(!-"*(D$%,,'*(_"'$_"',(!-%0/',b(@.%H(%$(&!%0D$'(E 0-,(a)#%/"7', 7+%0/*)0,%D')0.'( '/( 0-/*'( !'*!&/"'$( ,-".%( 7'( $)( $-D%_"'( '/( 7',( !*%0[

.%!', G

b(CRH(/-"/('0(,'(7&`'07)0/(7'(E F&7%*'(7'($)(/a&-$-D%'(,.-$),[

/%_"' G(!*t0&'(!)*(C&-0 ?@@@H(%$(*'.-FF)07'($+&/"7'(7'($)(!)/*-$-D%'H _"%(!*-!-,'*)%/("0'(E /a&-$-D%'(2%2)0/' G()"L(&/"7%)0/,(7',("0%2'*,%[

/&,(.)/a-$%_"',('/(7',(,&F%0)%*',('/($',(E *'!-,'*)%/(7',()#,/*)./%-0,('/

7',()*%7%/&,(,.-$),/%_"', G

b

@$(7&2'$-!!'(,',(.-02%./%-0,(7)0,(7'"L()*/%.$',(,"*/-"/b(C'(!*'F%'*H

%0/&D*&(R($)(.a*-0%_"'($%//&*)%*'('0(NYZOH(%02%/'($'(.$'*D&(R()7a&*'*()"L ,-.%&/&,(,)2)0/',('/(R(7-00'*("0'("/%$%/&(!*)/%_"'(R("0'(E 7%,/*)./%-0 G

$&D%/%F'( '0( )2)0U)0/( $'( /aVF'( 7'( $+E )!-,/-$)/( !)*( $)( ,.%'0.' G( _"%

*'2g/("0'(%F!-*/)0.'(.*-%,,)0/'()"(.-"*,(7'($)(7&.'00%'(NYZQ

i

C)( !*&,'0.'( 7',( '..$&,%),/%_"',( 7)0,( .',( .-FF"0)"/&,( %0/'$$%D'0/',

`'*)%/(/-F#'*(!'"(R(!'"($',(!*&8"D&,()#,"*7',('/($',(!*&2'0/%-0,('0*).%[

0&',( _"%( ,+-!!-,'0/( ,%( F)$a'"*'",'F'0/( R( $+'L'*.%.'( 7"( F%0%,/V*'

&2)0D&$%_"'(z~{b(C'(!*g/*'(,'(`'*)%/("0'(!$",(8",/'(%7&'(7'($+&/)/(7+',[

!*%/('/(7',(#',-%0,(,!%*%/"'$,(-"(F-*)"L(7'(,',(.-0/'F!-*)%0,(z~{b(C',

$)_"',H(R($'"*(/-"*H(,+%$,(-0/(!"()!!*&.%'*(R($'"*(8",/'(2)$'"*($',(!*g/*', 7'2'0",($'"*,(.-0`*V*',H(,'*-0/(!$",(7%,!-,&,(R($'"*(-"2*%*($'"*(.v"*('/

$'"*(.-0,.%'0.'b(}")07($'(!'"!$'(0-",()"*)(2",(),,-.%&,()"L(!*%0.',(7'

$)(,.%'0.'H(-0(0'($"%(`'*)(!$",(.*-%*'(_"'(0-",(,-FF',($',('00'F%,(8"*&, 7',($"F%V*',('/(%$(,'(7&`%'*)(F-%0,(7'(0-",($-*,_"'(0-",($"%(!*g.a'*-0,

$+S2)0D%$'b

C'( ,'.-07( )*/%.$'H( !"#$%&( '0( NYZjH( ',/( !$",( )F!$'b( @$( ,+)//).a'( R 7&`%0%*($+)//%/"7'(7"(.$'*D&(`).'(R(E $+',!*%/(,.%'0/%`%_"' G('/(!*'07("0

*'$%'`( ,%0D"$%'*( )!*V,( $',( 7&.$)*)/%-0,( 7'( T'*7%0)07( 9*"0'/%V*'( ,"*( $) E `)%$$%/' G(7'($)(,.%'0.'H(2"'(.-FF'("0'(.a)0.'(!-"*($'(.)/a-$%.%,F'b C'(7%*'./'"*(7'($)(Revue des Deux Mondes ,'F#$'('0('``'/(7-00'*(*)%[

,-0(R(.'"L(_"%(7&0-0.'0/($+%0`%$/*)/%-0(!'*2'*,'(7',(F&/a-7',(!*-`)0', 7)0,($+SD$%,'H(0-0(,)0,(&.a-(R(X-F'H('/('F#)**),,'0/($',(7&`'0,'"*, 7+"0'( )..$%F)/)/%-0( 7'( $+'``-*/( ,.%'0/%`%_"'( '0( ,-0( ,'%0

b( o)0,( .'

POb(Bb ;-**'$H(Libéralisme et modernisme…H(op. cit.H(!b Y][N]]b Pjb(Revue du clergé françaisH(/b @@H(NYZOH(!b ]j[5]b

Pkb(IbidbH(/b @@@H(NYZOH(!b 5j[O]b

PYb(E Ba*-0%_"'($%//&*)%*' 3(C'(.$'*D&('/($',(,-.%&/&,(,)2)0/', GH(ibidbH(/b @H(NYZ5[NYZOH

!b 5]Z[55jb

PZb(E C+',!*%/(,.%'0/%`%_"'('/($'(.$'*D& GH(ibidbH(/b M@H(NYZjH(!b O[]Qb

5k Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

.-0/'L/'H( $+)##&( <*#)%0( 7&!$-*'( $)( E /'07)0.'( `f.a'",' G( 7'( ,', .-0`*V*',( R( E )!!$%_"'*( R( /-"/',( $',( #*)0.a',( 7',( .-00)%,,)0.', a"F)%0',( $'( !*%0.%!'( 7+)"/-*%/& Gb( @$( '0( )7F'/( $)( $&D%/%F%/&( !-"*

E $+&/"7'(7',(2&*%/&,(*&2&$&', Gb(K)%,(%$(*'`",'(R(&/'07*'(E )"L(,.%'0.',

!*-`)0',($)(F&/a-7'(/a&-$-D%_"' G('/(*&.",'($)(!*-!'0,%-0(7',(/a&-$-[

D%'0,(R($%F%/'*H(7)0,($'"*(7-F)%0'(!*-!*'H($'(.a)F!(7',(-!%0%-0,($%#*',

!-"*(&$)*D%*(.'$"%(7'($+)"/-*%/&(7-DF)/%_"'(7'($+SD$%,'('0(,).*)$%,)0/

$',(.-0.$",%-0,(7',(&.-$',H('0()#",)0/(7'($+)*D"F'0/(7"(.-0,'0/'F'0/

7',(/a&-$-D%'0,('/('0(*'8'/)0/($',(E `)%/, G($',(F%'"L(&/)#$%, i

@$(,+'0(`)"/(_"'($+)"/-*%/&(,-%/(/-"/('/(_"'($'($%#*'('L)F'0(0+)%/(!),($%'"(7' ,+'L'*.'*(z~{b(C)(2&*%`%.)/%-0(7"(,'0,('/(7'($+)"/a'0/%.%/&(7',(/'L/',(7-%/

g/*'(`)%/'(!)*(.a)."0(7'(0-",('/(%$(0'(`)"/(!),(,'($+%0/'*7%*'(!)*(,"%/'(7+"0' .-0`",%-0(,"!'*,/%/%'",'('0/*'($'(7-DF'('/(,)(7&F-0,/*)/%-0(z~{b(;%(0-", .*-J-0,(2&*%/)#$'F'0/H(,%(0-/*'(`-%(',/(,-$%7'F'0/(),,%,'H('$$'(0+)(*%'0(R

*'7-"/'*(7',(!*-D*V,(7'($)(,.%'0.'(z~{b(C-%0(7'(0-",(F'//*'('0(7&`%)0.' .-0/*'( $',( 7&.-"2'*/',( z7',( ,.%'0.',( 7'( $)( 0)/"*'{H( ).."'%$$-0,[$',( )2'.

,JF!)/a%'(z~{b(1-/*'(7'2-%*(',/(7'(0-",(),,"*'*(_"'(.',(`)%/,(-0/(&/&(#%'0 '/(7uF'0/(.-0,/)/&,('/H(,+%$,(,-0/('0(-!!-,%/%-0()2'.("0'(%0/'*!*&/)/%-0(/*)[

7%/%-00'$$'(7"(7-DF'(W8'(0'(7%,(!),()2'.($'(7-DF'H(.)*(%$(0'(!'"/(J()2-%*

7'(`)%/(,.%'0/%`%_"'('0(-!!-,%/%-0()2'.("0(7-DF'\H(%$(0'(`)"/(!),(a&,%/'*(R

$)( F-7%`%'*b( o%'"( )( D)*)0/%( $+%0`)%$$%#%$%/&( R( $+SD$%,'( !*-.$)F)0/( ,', 7-DF',H( F)%,( 0-0( )"L( /a&-$-D%'0,( _"%( $',( 'L!$%_"'0/b( >)0/( _"+'$$',( 0' ,-0/(!),(.-0`%*F&',(!)*("0(8"D'F'0/(7'($+SD$%,'H($',(%0/'*!*&/)/%-0,(7', /a&-$-D%'0,(*',/'0/(.-08'./"*)$',('/(aJ!-/a&/%_"',H('/('$$',(7-%2'0/(.&7'*

7'2)0/($',(`)%/,(!-,%/%`,b

<0'(`-%,(!-,&',(.',(*VD$',H($+)##&(<*#)%0('0(/%*'(7',(.-0,&_"'0.',

!-"*(7'"L(7%,.%!$%0',(_"%(F-#%$%,'0/($'(.$'*D&(7"(/'F!,H($)(!a%$-,-!a%' '/($+a%,/-%*'b(r(!*-!-,(7'($)(!*'F%V*'H(%$(*'D*'//'($)(/'07)0.'(R(E )#7%[

_"'*( ,-0( 8"D'F'0/( !*-!*'( '0/*'( $',( F)%0,( 7+"0( 7-./'"*H( `u/[%$( ,)%0/

6"D",/%0(-"(,)%0/(>a-F), G i(E B'(,'*)%/(,+)#",'*(&/*)0D'F'0/(_"'(7'

!'0,'*H( .-FF'( _"'$_"',["0,( $'( `-0/( .a'h( 0-",H( _"+%$( 0+',/( !'*F%,( 7' ,+&.)*/'*('0(*%'0(7',(%7&',(7'($+60D'(7'($+S.-$'b(1-0H(C&-0 ?@@@(0+)

!),(2-"$"('0.a)d0'*($)(!'0,&'(a"F)%0'(R($)(Somme /*)0,`-*F&'('0("0' ,-*/'(7'(.%0_"%VF'(S2)0D%$'(z~{b(1-0H($)(!a%$-,-!a%'(z~{H(.+',/()2)0/

/-"/( "0( '``-*/( !'*,-00'$( !-"*( $)( 7&.-"2'*/'( !*-D*',,%2'( 7'( $)( 2&*%/&

7)0,($+-*7*'(0)/"*'$b G(o)0,($'(7-F)%0'(7'($+a%,/-%*'H($)(.*%/%_"'(',/(/-"/

)",,%(0&.',,)%*'('/(`)%/(!$",('0.-*'(7&`)"/(.-FF'($'(F-0/*'0/($',(M%', 7'(,)%0/,(-"($',(/*)7%/%-0,($-.)$',H(0-"**%',(7'(,"*0)/"*'$b(r($+'0.-0/*' 7',( /aV,',( !*-2%7'0/%)$%,/',( 7'( $)( Revue des questions historiquesH Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( )``%*F'( _"'H( ,%( o%'"( ',/( $'( F)d/*'( 7'( $+a%,/-%*'H( E %$

F)0%`',/'(),,'h(*)*'F'0/(,)(!"%,,)0.'('0(7&*-D')0/()"L($-%,(7'($)(0)[

/"*' Gb(C'(.a'*.a'"*(7-%/(7-0.(!*%2%$&D%'*($'(`)./'"*('L!$%.)/%`(a"F)%0

'/(7%*'($)(2&*%/&H(,-"2'0/(`)$,%`%&'(!)*(!%&/&(-"(!)*/%(!*%,(7-./*%0)$H('0(0'

5Y Christian Sorrel

.-0`-07)0/(!),($+SD$%,'H(7-/&'(E 7'($)(!*-F',,'(7+"0'(%0)$/&*)#$'(,)%0[

/'/& GH('/(,',(F%0%,/*',H(,"8'/,(R(7',(7&`)%$$)0.',(E ,)0,(_"'(,-0()"/-*%[

/&(7-%2'(,-"``*%*(7'($'"*(%07%D0%/& Gb(@$(7-%/()$$'*()"L(,-"*.',('/(*'0-0[

.'*(R("0(,/J$'(*-0`$)0/H('F!*"0/&(R($+)0.%'00'(&$-_"'0.'(7'($)(.a)%*'b K)%,(%$(7-%/()",,%(/%*'*($',(.-0,&_"'0.',(7'(.'//'(_"g/'(7'($)(2&*%/&H($%&' R($+',!*%/(,.%'0/%`%_"'H(!-"*($+)!-,/-$)/H(_"+%$(,+)D%,,'(7'($)(!*&7%.)/%-0 -"(7"(."$/' i(E =0(.',(8-"*,(-q($',(`%7V$',('0(,%(D*)07(0-F#*'(.-"*'0/

)"L( !*)/%_"',( -"( )"L( 7&2-/%-0,( 0-"2'$$',( '/( ,'( `-0/( /)0/( 7+%7&',

`)",,',H(0'(.*-J'h[2-",(!),(_"+%$(,'*)%/(R(!*-!-,(7'($',(*)F'0'*(R("0' F&7%/)/%-0(!$",()!!*-`-07%'(7'($+S2)0D%$' | G

C',(%7&',(_"'($+)##&(<*#)%0(7&2'$-!!'(7)0,(.'/()*/%.$'(0'(,-0/(!),

%,-$&',('/(0'(.)*)./&*%,'0/(!),("0(,'"$(.-"*)0/(7)0,("0'(7&.'00%'(F)*[

_"&'( !)*( 7',( 7&#)/,( )*7'0/,( )"/-"*( 7'( $)( ,.%'0.'H( 7"( *)$$%'F'0/( R( $) X&!"#$%_"'H( 7'( $)( _"',/%-0( ,-.%)$'( -"( 7'( $)( 7&F-.*)/%'( .a*&/%'00'b K)%,('$$',($'(,%/"'0/(!$"/t/(7"(.t/&(7',(a&*%/%'*,(7"(.)/a-$%.%,F'($%#&[

*)$H(,-".%'"L(7'(*&!-07*'()"L(7&`%,(7"(F-07'(F-7'*0'H(FgF'(,+%$(',/

7%``%.%$'(7+g/*'(!$",(!*&.%,(7)0,($)(F',"*'(-q(%$(,+)#,/%'0/(7'(/-"/()"/*' '0D)D'F'0/('/(0'(!)*/%.%!'(!),H(!)*('L'F!$'H()"L(.-0D*V,('..$&,%),[

/%_"',(7'(X'%F,('/(7'(9-"*D',H($%'"L(7'(.-0`*-0/)/%-0(7',(/aV,',(0-"[

2'$$',b(=$$',()%7'0/()",,%(R(.-F!*'07*'(,-0(.a-%L(a priori &/-00)0/(7' 7'2'0%*H(R(!*',_"'(.%0_")0/'()0,H($'(2%.)%*'(D&0&*)$(7+"0(!'/%/(7%-.V,'

&$-%D0&(7'(I)*%,H()$-*,(_"+%$(0+)(8)F)%,('L'*.&(7'(*',!-0,)#%$%/&()7F%[

0%,/*)/%2'(-"(!),/-*)$'b(C)(`%7&$%/&(7'(,-0()F%(C).*-%LH(7-0/(%$(!)*/)D'

$+)F#%/%-0(%0/'$$'./"'$$'H($"%(-``*'('0('``'/("0(/'**)%0(7'(F)0v"2*'

b K)%,($'(*g2'(,'*)(7'(.-"*/'(7"*&'b

La tentation de l’action et le repli sur l’érudition

C'( P5( 8"%0( NZQNH( $'( `-07)/'"*( 7'( $)( Revue du clergé français ',/

,).*&(&2g_"'(R(I),,J(7'2)0/("0(!)*/'**'(7+)##&,(7&F-.*)/',('/(7+%0[

/'$$'./"'$,($%#&*)"L(_"%(7-00'(R($)(.&*&F-0%'($'(.)*)./V*'(7+"0'(F)0%[

`',/)/%-0b(C+)##&(<*#)%0('0()2)%/(`%L&(!)*()2)0.'($)(,%D0%`%.)/%-0('0 ,)$")0/(7)0,( La Justice sociale 7'($+)##&(1)"7'/H(,-",(.-"2'*/(7+"0

!,'"7-0JF'H( $)( 0-F%0)/%-0( 7'( ,-0( )F%( R( $)( /g/'( 7"( !'/%/( 7%-.V,' ,)2-J)*7(7'(>)*'0/)%,'H($'(,'"$(_"'(X-F'()2)%/(.-0,'0/%(R($"%()..-*[

7'*( !-"*( 0'( !),( #$-_"'*( $)( 0&D-.%)/%-0( )2'.( $'( D-"2'*0'F'0/

Ç)$7'.Å[X-",,')"H(7&.%7&(R(`)%*'('0/*'*(.'(!*g/*'(*&!"#$%.)%0(7)0,($' .-*!,(&!%,.-!)$

i

]Qb M%./-*(B)**%V*'(!)*$'(7'(E ,)(.)F!)D0'('0(>)*'0/)%,' Gb(:0(!'"/(0-/'*()",,%(_"' K

C).*-%LH(`-*/(7"(,-"/%'0(7"(!-"2-%*H(',!&*)%/("0(/*)0,`'*/(*)!%7'(2'*,("0(7%-.V,'(!$",

%F!-*/)0/(-q($+)##&(<*#)%0($+)"*)%/(,"%2%b(=/(%$(0'(`)"/(!'"/[g/*'(!),(0&D$%D'*($+)//*)%/(7+"0

*'2'0"(`%L'b

5Z Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

C'(0-"2'$(&2g_"'(,+',/(*'07"(.-F!/'(7',(0&.',,%/&,('/(7',(#',-%0, 7'( ,-0( /'F!, s %$( 0+',/( !),( 7'( .'"L( _"%( .*-%'0/( _"'( $',( %07&!'07)0/, ,-%'0/( 7',( *&2-$/&,H( 0%( _"'( $)( ,.%'0.'( '/( $+)F-"*( 7'( $+&/"7'( ,-%'0/

%0.-F!)/%#$',()2'.($)(2*)%'(!%&/& s %$(0'(.*-%/(!),(7)2)0/)D'(_"'($'(/*)[

2)%$(%0/'$$'./"'$(*'07'(F-%0,(!*-!*'(R($+)7F%0%,/*)/%-0(7',(!)*-%,,',b(@$

/*)2)%$$'*)( 7'( /-"/',( ,',( `-*.',( R( *)!!*-.a'*( $',( $)_"',( 7"( !*g/*'H( R .-0.%$%'*($)(*)%,-0('/($)(`-%H($+SD$%,'('/($)(,-.%&/&(F-7'*0'b

62)0/( ,-0( 7&!)*/( 7'( I)*%,H( K

C).*-%L( !*-!-,'( )"( 7%*'./'"*( 7', B"$/',($'(0-F(7'(,',(2%.)%*',(D&0&*)"Lb(@$(-!/'H(.-FF'(0-F#*'(7'(,', .-$$VD"',H(!-"*("0'(.-F!$&F'0/)*%/&('0/*'("0(a-FF'(7'(/'**)%0H($+)0[

.%'0(2%.)%*'(D&0&*)$(^-,'!a[SF%$'(9-**'$H('/("0(a-FF'($%D'H(Ba)*$',

<*#)%0H( 7-0/( %$( )//',/'( $)( E D*)07'( F-7&*)/%-0( 7)0,( $',( %7&', G( '/( $) .)!).%/&(R(E D)D0'*(/-"/',($',(,JF!)/a%',(!)*(,-0($%#&*)$%,F'H($)(7-"[

.'"*( 7'( ,',( F)0%V*',( '/( ,)( !)*`)%/'( .-"*/-%,%'( R( $+&D)*7( 7'( /-",( .'"L _"%($+)!!*-.a'0/ G

b(C+'0_"g/'()7F%0%,/*)/%2'(,"*($'(.)07%7)/(0'(*&2V[

$'( )"."0( !*-#$VF'b( E @$( ',/( .-0,%7&*&( .-FF'( ,'( /'0)0/( /-"/( R( `)%/( R

$+&.)*/(7',()D%/)/%-0,(7',(!)*/%,H(,'(*'0`'*F)0/(7)0,(,',(/*)2)"L($%//&[

*)%*',(-"(!*-`',,%-00'$, GH(0-/'($'(7&$&D"&(7'($)(!*&`'./"*'(7'(!-$%.' 7'(I)*%,

b(E B+',/("0(!*g/*'(7'(D*)07'(2)$'"*H(!$",(a-FF'(7'(.)#%0'/

!'"/[g/*'( _"+a-FF'( 7+)./%-0 GH( *'F)*_"'( $+&2g_"'( 7'( C)0D*',H K

e'*,.a'*H( ,-0( -*7%0)%*'H( _"%( $'( .-00)d/( F)$

b( X%'0( 0'( ,+-!!-,' 7V,( $-*,( R( $)( !*-F-/%-0( 7'( $+)##&( <*#)%0H( _"%( *'F'*.%'( )",,%/t/( $' 7%*'./'"*(7',(B"$/', i(E ^'(F+'``-*.'*)%(7'(8",/%`%'*(2-/*'(.-0`%)0.'('0 ,'.-07)0/(7'(F-0(F%'"L(F-0(&2g_"'()2'.(_"%H(2-",($'(,)2'h(7&8RH(8' ,"%,( 7'!"%,( $-0D/'F!,( '0( !)*`)%/'( .-FF"0%-0( 7'( 2"',( '/( 7'( ,'0/%[

F'0/,

b G

=0()-u/(NZQNH($'(0-"2')"(2%.)%*'(D&0&*)$(*'8-%0/(K-u/%'*,H("0'(,-",[

!*&`'./"*'(7'(7'"L(F%$$'(,%L(.'0/,(fF',()"(.v"*(7+"0(7%-.V,'(F-0/)[

D0)*7(7'(.%0_")0/'[.%0_(F%$$'(a)#%/)0/,(7-0/($'(.$'*D&H(_"%(!),,'(!-"*

%0D-"2'*0)#$'H( )( *'U"( )2'.( !*"7'0.'H( ,%0-0( *&,'*2'H( K

C).*-%LH( "0

!'"(,",!'./(R(,',(J'"Lb(@$(,'(F'/()"(/*)2)%$H(7-00'(7',(E ,'*F-0,(7&$%[

.%'"L G()!!*&.%&,(!)*($',(0-/)#$',(_"%(`*&_"'0/'0/($)(,/)/%-0(/a'*F)$'(7'

]Nb Bb C)*)"$LH( E K

C).*-%LH( &2g_"'( 7'( >)*'0/)%,' GH( 7)0,( La Justice socialeH Pk()2*%$(NZQNb(C+)//*%#"/%-0(7'($+)*/%.$'(*'!-,'(,"*("0'($'//*'(7'(K

C).*-%L(R($+)##&

C'F%*'H(Pk()2*%$(NZQN(W6*.a%2',(C'F%*'H(e)h'#*-".Å\b

]Pb 6*.a%2',(0)/%-0)$',H(TNZ PYNNH(7-,,%'*(<*#)%0H($'//*'(7'(K

C).*-%L(R(Ba)*$', o"F)JH(Pk(8"%0(NZQNb

]]b IbidbH(*)!!-*/(7+'0_"g/'H(NY(8"%$$'/(NZQNb(C+)##&(<*#)%0(.&$V#*'($)(F',,'(R($+&D$%[

,'(;)%0/[I%'**'(7'(Ba)%$$-/b

]5b IbidbH($'//*'(7'(K

e'*,.a'*(R(Ba)*$',(o"F)JH(PN(8"%$$'/(NZQNb

]Ob IbidbH($'//*'(7'($+)##&(<*#)%0(R(Ba)*$',(o"F)JH(PN()-u/(NZQNb

OQ Christian Sorrel

9*%7',[$',[9)%0,

H( !f$'( *'`$'/( 7'( $)( 2%'( F-07)%0'( !)*%,%'00'H( '/( )%7' ,-0(&2g_"'(R(F'//*'('0(`-*F'(.'*/)%0,(7'(,',(/'L/',

b(K)%,(%$(,+-.."!' '0(!*%-*%/&(7"(!'/%/(,&F%0)%*'(7-0/(K

C).*-%L(2'"/(`)%*'("0(&/)#$%,,'[

F'0/(F-7V$'H(7+)"/)0/(_"+%$()00-0.'(7V,(,-0()**%2&'(_"+%$('L%D'*)(7', .)07%7)/,()"(,).'*7-.'($'(#)..)$)"*&)/(-"($'"*(%F!-,'*)H(R(7&`)"/H("0 'L)F'0(7+'0/*&'H(.'(_"%(0'(F)0_"'(!),(7'(!*-2-_"'*("0'(!-$&F%_"'(7'

!*',,'('/("0'(7'F)07'(7+'L!$%.)/%-0(7'($)(."*%'(*-F)%0'

b(@$(7-00'($)

!*%-*%/&()"(*'0`-*.'F'0/(7"(.-0/*t$'(7',(.-00)%,,)0.',('0(&/'07)0/($', 'L)F'0,(&.*%/,(/*%F',/*%'$,()"L(F)/%V*',(,'.-07)%*',(Wa%,/-%*'H(D&-D*)[

!a%'H($)0D"',(2%2)0/',H(,.%'0.',\H('0(%0,/%/")0/(7',(.-$$',(#%F'0,"'$$', '0(.$),,'(7'(*a&/-*%_"'('/(7'(!a%$-,-!a%'('/('0(7&.%7)0/($)(!*-.$)F)/%-0

!"#$%_"'(7',(0-/',('/($+'02-%(7'(#"$$'/%0,()"L(!)*'0/,

b

C+'08'"(',/(7'(/)%$$'(R($+a'"*'(-q($',()72'*,)%*',(7'($+SD$%,'(7&0-0[

.'0/($)(.-0."**'0.'(7&$-J)$'(_"'($',(!'/%/,(,&F%0)%*',(`-0/(,"#%*()"L

$J.&',('/()"L(.-$$VD',(!"#$%.,(,-",($'(*&D%F'(7'($)($-%(T)$$-"LH(_"%($', 'L'F!/'(7'($)(,"*2'%$$)0.'(7'($+<0%2'*,%/&b(=0('``'/H(%$,(0+).."'%$$'0/

!),(,'"$'F'0/($',(`"/"*,(.$'*.,H(F)%,()",,%(7',(8'"0',(D'0,(7'(F%$%'"

F-7',/'(_"%(,'(!*&!)*'0/(R(7',(.)**%V*',(.%2%$',('/(,-0/()//%*&,(!)*($' F-%07*'( .-u/( 7',( &/"7',b( C'( P5( )-u/( NZQPH( $+)##&( <*#)%0( !*'07( $) 7&`'0,'(7'($+%0,/%/"/%-0(7)0,($'(7%,.-"*,(_"+%$(!*-0-0.'(R($+-..),%-0(7'

$)(7%,/*%#"/%-0(7',(!*%L('0(F'//)0/('0()2)0/(,)(F%,,%-0(,!&.%`%_"'H(F)%, '0(,'(*'`",)0/(R($+J('0`'*F'*H(.-FF'($'(`-0/(.'*/)%0,(&2g_"',(!)*(!*"[

7'0.'(-"(!)*(,-".%(7'(."$/%2'*($',(2-.)/%-0,('0(2),'(.$-,

i

zC',( !'/%/,( ,&F%0)%*',{( *'F!$%,,'0/( "0'( /f.a'( 7-0/( $+<0%2'*,%/&( ,'

*'.-00)d/(%0.)!)#$'H(!)*.'(_"+'$$'(0+)(!),("0(.)*)./V*'(.-0`',,%-00'$ s

%$,(,-0/(%0,/%/"&,()2)0/(/-"/('/(7%*'./'F'0/(!-"*($'(*'.*"/'F'0/(7"(.$'*[

D& s '/(/)0/(_"+-0(0+)"*)(!),(7&.a%*&($'(.-0.-*7)/H(0%(,&!)*&($+SD$%,'(7'

$+S/)/H(%$(`)"7*)(#%'0()2-"'*(_"'(0-",(),,"*-0,("0(,'*2%.'(!"#$%.H(.'$"%

7"(."$/'(.)/a-$%_"'(z~{b(zK)%,{(8'(0'(.*)%0,(!),(7'(7%*'(_"+R($+a'"*'(!*&[

,'0/'H( $)( #-00'( `-*F)/%-0( 7"( .$'*D&( *&.$)F'( _"'( $',( `"/"*,( !*g/*',H 7"*)0/($'(/'F!,(7'($'"*,(&/"7',(.$),,%_"',H(,-%'0/(F%,('0(.-0/)./()2'.

]jb 6*.a%2',( !*%2&',H( F)0",.*%/( 7'( c'-*D',( 7'( T-0.$)*'( ,"*( $+&!%,.-!)/( 7' K

C).*-%Lb

]kb( 9%#$%-/aV_"'( 0)/%-0)$'( 7'( T*)0.'H( 1-"2'$$',( )._"%,%/%-0,( `*)0U)%,',( P5 5QNH

!)!%'*,(C).*-%LH(`4(ZZ[NQQH($'//*'(7'(Kb(K-0%'*(R(K

C).*-%LH(NQ(F)*,(zNZQ]{b ]Yb(Bb ;-**'$H(Libéralisme et modernisme…H(opb(citbH(!b NjZ[Nkjb

]Zb(6*.a%2',(7"(7%-.V,'(7'(>)*'0/)%,'H(N e N]H(*'D%,/*'(7',(7&$%#&*)/%-0,(7',(!*-`',[

,'"*,H(NYk][NZQjb(<0'(!)*/%'(7'(.',(F',"*',('0/*'('0(2%D"'"*(8",/'()!*V,(,-0(7&!)*/(7' K-u/%'*,b

5Qb(E o%,.-"*,(7'(Kb(<*#)%0(,"*($',(!'/%/,(,&F%0)%*', GH(7)0,(Bulletin religieux du

diocèse de TarentaiseH()-u/(NZQPb(C'(/'L/'(',/(*'!*%,(,-",($'(/%/*'(E C)(.-07%/%-0(7',(!'/%/,

,&F%0)%*', G(7)0,(Revue du clergé françaisH(/b ???@@H(NZQPH(!b Zk[NNQb

ON Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

7',(8'"0',(D'0,(7',/%0&,(R(2%2*'(7)0,(7',(.)**%V*',($)_"',(z~{b(:0(.-"*/

*%,_"'H('0(.'/(%,-$'F'0/H(7+)D%*(,-",($+'F!%*'(/*-!()#,-$"(7'(.'*/)%0',

!*&-.."!)/%-0,(!*-`',,%-00'$$',H(`-*/(*',!'./)#$',(,)0,(7-"/'H(F)%,(_"%H ,%($+-0(0+J(!*'07(D)*7'H(.*'",'0/(!'"(R(!'"("0()#dF'('0/*'($'(.$'*D&('/

,',(.-0/'F!-*)%0,H(,"*($',_"'$,(7V,($-*,(,-0()./%-0(',/H(!-"*()%0,%(7%*'H 0"$$'H( !)*.'( _"+%$( 0'( !)*$'( !$",( $)( FgF'( $)0D"'( '/( 0'( .-F!*'07( !$",

$'"*,( ,'0/%F'0/,( z~{b( K)%,( %$( J( )( !$",( z~{b( Ba'*.a'*( R( 7&Fg$'*( 7)0,

$'"*,( &$V2',( $',( F)*_"',( 7'( .'//'( 2-.)/%-0( FJ,/&*%'",'H( .+',/( $R( %0[

.-0/',/)#$'F'0/($)(/f.a'(!*%0.%!)$'(7',(F)d/*',(7'(0-,(!'/%/,(,&F%0)%*', z~{b(:*H(.*-J'h[2-",(_"'($'"*(.a-%L(,'*)(2*)%F'0/($%#*'(,%H('0$'2&,(7V,

$'"*(!$",(/'07*'('0`)0.'(R($'"*,(`)F%$$',H(%$,(,-0/(/'0",(%.%(7)0,($+%D0-[

*)0.'()#,-$"'(7"(F-07'H(R($+&.)*/(7'(/-"/'(%0`$"'0.'(&/*)0DV*'('/H(!-"*

)%0,%(7%*'H(7'(/-"/(,-"``$'(7"(7'a-*, |(z~{(=/(.'(0+',/(!),(/-"/('0.-*'H K',,%'"*,b(KgF'()!*V,(,-0('0/*&'()"(D*)07(,&F%0)%*'H($)(*&,-$"/%-0(7"

8'"0'( $&2%/'( 0+',/( !),( %**&2-.)#$'F'0/( `%L&'( z~{b(6`%0( 7'( *),,"*'*( ,) .-0,.%'0.'(-"(FgF'(!-"*($"%(&!)*D0'*($)(/'0/)/%-0(7'(0'(!'*,&2&*'*(7)0,

$+&/)/('..$&,%),/%_"'(,)0,()"/*'(2-.)/%-0(_"'($)(!'"*(7'(F-"*%*(7'(`)%FH z~{(0-",(2-"$-0,(_"+)"(/'*F'(7'(,',(&/"7',(.$),,%_"',H(%$()%/(!"(.-0_"&[

*%*($'(7%!$tF'(7'(#).a'$%'*(_"%H(7)0,($+&/)/()./"'$(7'(0-/*'(,-.%&/&H(7-00' )..V,(R(/-"/',($',(.)**%V*',($%#&*)$',b

C)(.-0,&_"'0.'(7'(.'//'(.-02%./%-0(',/(&2%7'0/'(!-"*($+)##&(<*#)%0 _"%(%02%/'(,',()"7%/'"*,H(7)0,($)($%D0'(7',(!*-F-/'"*,(7'($)($-%(T)$$-"LH R(0'(!),(.&7'*()"L(%$$",%-0,(7'($)(/aV,'(%0/*)0,%D')0/'(_"%(7&`'07($+%0[

7&!'07)0.'( )#,-$"'( 7'( $+SD$%,'( '/( R( )7F'//*'( "0'( aJ!-/aV,'( *&)$%,/' )"(*'D)*7(7'($+&/)/(,-.%)$('/(!-$%/%_"'('/(7'($+%0/&*g/(7'($+SD$%,' i

;%($+-0(!*&/'07)%/(0-",(*&7"%*'(R("0'(&7".)/%-0(!"*'F'0/(.$&*%.)$' z~{H()$-*,H(K',,%'"*,H(%$(`)"7*)%/(*&,-$"F'0/(*'0-0.'*()"L()2)0/)D', ,!&.%)"L(_"'(8",_"+%.%(0-",(*'.-00)d/($+S/)/('/H(!)*/)D')0/($'(,-*/(7', )"/*',(&/)#$%,,'F'0/,($%#*',H(*&.$)F'*($+&D)$%/&(7)0,($)($%#'*/&b(K%'"L 2)"7*)%/(.'0/(`-%,()..'!/'*($)(,"*2'%$$)0.'(7'($+<0%2'*,%/&('/(0-",(,-"[

F'//*'()"L(.-07%/%-0,(%F!-,&',(!)*($+S/)/()"(*'.*"/'F'0/(7',(!*-`',[

,'"*,( $%#*',( _"'( 7'( 0+)2-%*( !$",( $'( 7*-%/( 7+).."'%$$%*( %07%,/%0./'F'0/

7)0,(0-,(!'/%/,(,&F%0)%*',(/-",($',(8'"0',(D'0,(_"%(,+J(!*&,'0/'*)%'0/

-"(7+g/*'(.-07)F0&,(R(0'($'"*(7%,/*%#"'*(_"+"0('0,'%D0'F'0/(_"%($',

&.)*/'*)%/( 7'( !$'%0( 7*-%/( 7',( .)**%V*',( .%2%$',( -"( 7',( `-0./%-0,

!"#$%_"',(z~{b(K%'"L(2)"/($+&D)$%/&()2'.(,',(.a)*D',H(F)%,()",,%(,', )2)0/)D',H(_"'(7',(!*%2%$VD',(_"%(,'*)%'0/("0'(.)",'(7+%F!"%,,)0.'('/

7'(,/&*%$%/&b

B'//'(!*&-.."!)/%-0(7'(.-0`*-0/)/%-0()2'.($)(,-.%&/&(',/(&D)$'F'0/

!*&,'0/'( 7)0,( $'( .-FF'0/)%*'( 7',( .-0`&*'0.',( '..$&,%),/%_"',( _"'

K

C).*-%L()(.a)*D&($+)##&(<*#)%0(7'(*&0-2'*H()$-*,(_"+%$(0'(,'F#$'

D"V*'( %0/'*2'0%*( )"( D*)07( ,&F%0)%*'H( /'**)%0( 7'( !*&7%$'./%-0( 7'

OP Christian Sorrel

$+&2g_"'

b( @$( 7&!$-*'H( '0( !*-`',,'"*( 'L%D')0/H( $',( )#,/'0/%-0,H( $', .-!%',( E -q( $)( !)"2*'/&( 7'( $)( !'0,&'( 0+)( 7+&D)$'( _"'( $)( #)0)$%/&( 7'

$+'L!*',,%-0 GH( $'( E !$)D%)/( &a-0/& GH( $',( *&!-0,',( 2)D"',( '/( $'( a-*, ,"8'/b( K)%,( .'( _"+%$( *'D*'//'( ,"*/-"/H( R( !*-!-,( 7+"0'( _"',/%-0( ,"*( $)

!-,,%#%$%/&(!-"*($',(!*g/*',('/($',(`%7V$',(&.$)%*&,(7'($%*'(E $)($%//&*)/"*' F-07)%0'('/(,&."$%V*' GH(.+',/($)(!*-!'0,%-0(7"(.$'*D&(R("0'(E %0/*)0[

,%D')0.' G(7-0/(%$(,'(7'F)07'(,%($)(,-"*.'(0+',/(!),(E 7)0,("0'(%0."[

*%-,%/&(D&0&*)$'(7'(/-"/'($'./"*'(,&*%'",' Gb

o'(/'$,(!*-!-,H(%F!*%F&,(,"*(-*7*'(7'($+&2g_"'H(0'(,-0/(!),(7'(0)/"[

*'(R()!)%,'*($',(*'$)/%-0,(7'($+)##&(<*#)%0()2'.(,',(,"#-*7-00&,(_"%($'

*'D)*7'0/( 3 ,%/")/%-0( #)0)$' 3( E .-FF'( "0( %0/*", Gb( K)%,( %$( ,'F#$'

&D)$'F'0/(g/*'(7&U"(!)*($+)//%/"7'(7'(K

C).*-%LH(,)(!*-L%F%/&()2'.($'

!-"2-%*H( ,',( '**'"*,( 7'( D-"2'*0'F'0/H( ,-0( 'L!-,%/%-0( F&7%)/%_"'( '/

,',(.-0`$%/,(2%-$'0/,()2'.(!$",%'"*,(!*g/*',H(7"(F-%0,(,%($+'0('0(.*-%/($' /&F-%D0)D'(7'($+"0(7',()72'*,)%*',(7"(!*&$)/H($'(#)0_"%'*(c'-*D',(7' T-0.$)*'H(_"%(/*-"2'(E "0(*&'$()D*&F'0/ G(R($)(.-F!)D0%'(7"(2%.)%*' D&0&*)$

b( B'$"%[.%( 0'( F)0_"'( !-"*/)0/( !),( 7'( F'//*'( ,',( .-00)%,[

,)0.',(a%,/-*%_"',()"(,'*2%.'(7'(K

C).*-%L(!-"*(8",/%`%'*(,-0(*'`", 7'(,%D0'*($)(!&/%/%-0(7'($+&!%,.-!)/(.-0/*'($)(!-$%/%_"'()0/%[.-0D*&D)[

0%,/'(7"(F%0%,/V*'(B-F#',b(@$(,"DDV*'('0('``'/(,-",(!,'"7-0JF'H(7)0,

"0'( &/"7'( )"L( )*D"F'0/,( "0( !'"( ,!&.%'"LH( _"'( $)( !$"*)$%/&( 7',( 2-%L 0+',/( !),( "0( .*%/V*'( 7'( 2&*%/&H( .-FF'( $'( F-0/*'( $+)7-!/%-0( !)*

$+6,,'F#$&'(7"(.$'*D&(7'(NjYP(7'($)(o&.$)*)/%-0(7',(_")/*'()*/%.$',H('/

)``%*F'(_"'(X-F'()(7&,)2-"&(!)*()2)0.'($)(!*-.&7"*'("/%$%,&'('0(NZQP '0(.-07)F0)0/('0(NYOP($)(7&F)*.a'(7'(K

o"!)0$-"!(.-$$'./)0/(7', ,%D0)/"*',( .-0/*'( L’Universb( <0( &2g_"'H( .-0.$"/[%$H( 0+)( !),( R( !$%'*

7'2)0/( 7',( E %07%2%7")$%/&,( .-0,%7&*)#$',( !'"/[g/*'H( F)%,( R( .-"!( ,u*

,)0,( F)07)/H( '/( .'$)( ,-",( $+%0`$"'0.'( -.."$/'( 7+)D'0/,( %0.-00",( '/

%**',!-0,)#$', G

b(<0()0(!$",(/)*7(.'!'07)0/H('0()-u/(NZQ]H(%$(*'0-0[

.'(R(,-0(!-,/'H(-``%.%'$$'F'0/(!-"*(*)%,-0(7'(,)0/&H(/-"/('0(*',/)0/("0

`)F%$%'*(7'(K

C).*-%L

b

5Nb(Diocèse de Tarentaise – Conférences ecclésiastiques I. Ordonnance épiscopale II. Rapport sur les travaux de l’année 1902H(Ba)F#&*JH(@F!b(,)2-%,%'00'H(NZQ]H(]N !b

5Pb( 6*.a%2',( !*%2&',H( F)0",.*%/( 7'( c'-*D',( 7'( T-0.$)*'( ,"*( $+&!%,.-!)/( 7' K

C).*-%Lb

5]b(Bb K)0,"'/H(E C',(B%0_ GH(7)0,( Bulletin religieux du diocèse de TarentaiseH NO(0-2'F#*'(NZQPb(K

C).*-%L('02-%'(.'(/'L/'(R($)(!*',,'(!)*%,%'00'('/(R(/-",($',

&2g_"',(`*)0U)%,b

55b(I)*(/',/)F'0/H(K

C).*-%L($'(.a)*D'(7'(E /*%'*(,',(!)!%'*, G('/(7'(E .a'*.a'*H(!-"*

&.*%*'(,)(2%'H("0(a-FF'(7'(/)$'0/ GH('0($+-.."**'0.'($+)##&(1)"7'/H(9%#$%-/aV_"'(0)/%-[

0)$'(7'(T*)0.'H(1-"2'$$',()._"%,%/%-0,(`*)0U)%,',(P5 5QjH(!)!%'*,(C).*-%LH(`4 kN]H($'//*'

7'($+)##&(<*#)%0H(NO(F)*,(NZPPb

O]

Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( *'D)D0'( )",,%/t/( I)*%,( '/( *'!*'07( ,',( )./%2%/&,( 7'

!*-`',,'"*($%#*'('/(,',(/*)2)"L($%//&*)%*',(_"+%$(0+)2)%/(8)F)%,()#)07-0[

0&,(7"*)0/(,-0(,&8-"*(R(K-u/%'*,

b(@$(*&2%,'(,',(F)0"'$,(!-"*($)(.$),[

,'(7'(*a&/-*%_"'H(),,"*'($)(E .a*-0%_"'(7+a%,/-%*'($%//&*)%*'('/(7+&*"7%[

/%-0 G(7'($)(Revue du clergé français 8",_"+R(,)(7%,!)*%/%-0('0(NZPQ('/

*'0-"'()2'.($)(!-$&F%_"'(R(!*-!-,(7"(!*&/'07"(F)*%)D'(7'(9-,,"'/('/

7'(K

7'(K)"$&-0(_"%(!*'07("0'()F!$'"*(%0)//'07"'(7'(NZQj(R(NZQY '/($+'0/*)d0'(2'*,(7',('L.V,

b(K)%,(%$(,'(.-0,).*'(7&,-*F)%,(,"*/-"/(R

$+&7%/%-0(.*%/%_"'(7'($)(.-**',!-07)0.'(7'(9-,,"'/(WNZQZ[NZPO\H(7-0/

$+)00-/)/%-0( ',/( $)*D'F'0/( $'( `*"%/( 7'( ,',( *'.a'*.a',H( '/( 7',( v"2*', -*)/-%*',(WNZN5[NZPO\H()"L_"'$$',(,+)8-"/'0/(7',(-"2*)D',(.-FF'($', Maximes et réflexions sur la comédieb

B'(*'!$%(,"*($+&*"7%/%-0H('0(.-a&*'0.'()2'.($',(!*'F%V*',()./%2%/&,(7'

$+)##&(<*#)%0H(_"%(!*&`V*'(E $)(F%0%)/"*' G()"L(E D*)07',(`*',_"',(a%,[

/-*%_"', G

H( ',/( ,)0,( 7-"/'( )..&$&*&( !)*( $',( 7&#-%*',( &!*-"2&,( '0

>)*'0/)%,'H(F)%,()",,%(!)*($+-``'0,%2'(*-F)%0'(.-0/*'($'(F-7'*0%,F'(_"%

,'(7&!$-%'()"(7&#"/(7"(??

,%V.$'('/(,'F#$'(7%,_")$%`%'*($',('``-*/,(7' 7%)$-D"'()2'.($)(,.%'0.'(.-0/'F!-*)%0'b(r(2*)%(7%*'H(,-0()//%/"7'(`).'(R

$)( .*%,'( ',/( F)$( .-00"'( '/( $+)*/%.$'( 0&.*-$-D%_"'( 7'( $)( Quinzaine reli- gieuse de la Tarentaise 0+)%7'(!),(R($)(.$)*%`%'*('0()``%*F)0/(_"+E %$(0' .&7)(!),()"L(2'0/,(-!!-,&,(_"%(8'/)%'0/(7',(!*g/*',(7)0,($+%0/&D*%,F'(-"

$)(*&2-$/' G('/(_"+%$(`"/(E "0(!'"(c%#'$%0(!-"*($',(c"'$`',('/(c"'$`'(!-"*

$',(c%#'$%0, G

b(<0'(!a*),'(7)0,($)_"'$$'(%$(,'(7&.$)*'(E .-02)%0."(_"'

$',(!)*/%."$%'*,(0'(!'"2'0/(*&",,%*(R(*&`-*F'*(.'(_"%(7)0,($+SD$%,'()"*)%/

#',-%0(7'(.-**'./%-0 GH(F)%,(_"+SF%$'(c-%.a-/(.%/'(,)0,(*&`&*'0.'H(,"D[

DV*'('0(*'2)0.a'("0(7&.-"*)D'F'0/H(,%0-0("0'(*&2-$/'(.-0/'0"'

b(C)

!"#$%.)/%-0( '0( !$'%0'( &!*'"2'( 7'( $)( ;&!)*)/%-0H( ,)0,( 0-F( 7+)"/'"*( '/

,)0,(.-FF'0/)%*'

H(7'(7-."F'0/,(&$-_"'0/,(,"*($'(.-0`$%/('0/*'($'(!)!' I%' @?('/($+)*.a'2g_"'(7'(I)*%,(o)*#-J(,'F#$'()$$'*(7)0,(.'(,'0,('/(0' F)0_"'(!),(7'(*&8-"%*(K

C).*-%LH('0(.-0`$%/()2'.($)(."*%'(*-F)%0'('/

#%'0/t/(.-0/*)%0/(7'(,'(7&F'//*'(7'(,-0(,%VD'(&!%,.-!)$

b

5Ob( =0( /&F-%D0'0/( ,',( )*/%.$',( ,"*( E <0( !*-,&$J/'( 7'( 9-,,"'/ i( ^b[9b( Ç%0,$-n G WRevue du clergé françaisH(/b ???@@H(NZQP\('/(E 9-,,"'/('/($',(,'.*'/,(7'(T&0'$-0 G(WLa QuinzaineH(N

)-u/(NZQ]\b

5jb(M%./-*(B)**%V*'(!*&,'0/'($)(!-$&F%_"'('0(7&/)%$(7)0,(E 9-,,"'/()"(??

,%V.$'bbb GH loc. cit.H(!b 5k5[5YPb

5kb(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'bbb GH(locb(citbH(!b(5NOb

5Yb(Quinzaine religieuse de la TarentaiseH(N

8"%$$'/(NZ]Nb

5Zb(Sb c-%.a-/H(Henri Bremond, historien de la « faim de Dieu »H(c*'0-#$'H(^&*tF' K%$$-0H(PQQjH(!b PQZb

OQb(E K

o)*#-J('/($'(;)%0/[;%VD'b(o-."F'0/,(%0&7%/, GH(7)0,(Revue d’histoire et de littérature religieusesH(/b ?@@H(NZQkH(!b P5Q[PYkb

ONb( @$( 7'F)07'( )"( !"#$%.%,/'(6$#'*/( e-"/%0( 7'( *&7%D'*( "0( .-F!/'( *'07"( !-"*( Le

Temps i(E :0(J(F-0/*'*)%/(7+)#-*7(_"+%$(J()(_")*)0/'()0,H($',(!*-.&7&,(7'($)(0-0.%)/"*'

O5 Christian Sorrel

C',(7'*0%V*',()00&',(7'($)(2%'(7'($+)##&(<*#)%0(,-0/(F)*_"&',(!)*

7',(7%``%."$/&,(`%0)0.%V*',(.*-%,,)0/',b(C',($'U-0,(,'(`-0/(*)*',('/($',

*'2'0",( &7%/-*%)"L( `*)D%$',b( ;',( )F%,( ',,)%'0/( 7'( $+)%7'*( '0( $"%( -#/'[

0)0/($)(.*-%L(7'($)($&D%-0(7+a-00'"*('0(NZPO('/(,"*/-"/('0(,-$$%.%/)0/

$+%0/'*2'0/%-0(7"(.)*7%0)$(o"#-%,H()*.a'2g_"'(7'(I)*%,H(_"%($'(0-FF' '0( NZPk( .a)0-%0'( !*&#'07&( 7'( 1-/*'[o)F'H( )$-*,( _"+%$( 0+',/( !),

%0.)*7%0&(7)0,($'(7%-.V,'

b(6``)%#$%(!)*($)(/"#'*."$-,'H(%$(F'"*/($'(NN 8"%0(NZ]N('/(,',(`"0&*)%$$',(,-0/(.&$&#*&',(R($)(.)/a&7*)$'('0(!*&,'0.' 7'(K

T%$$-0H(&2g_"'(7'(C)0D*',H(_"%(7-00'($+)#,-"/'

b

Ba)*$',( <*#)%0( 0+)( !),( $%2*&( /-",( ,',( ,'.*'/,b( T%D"*'( 7'( E !*g/*'

$%#*' G(R($+a'"*'(-q($+)#-07)0.'(7',(2-.)/%-0,(,).'*7-/)$',(*'07(!-,[

,%#$'("0'(`-*F'(7'(,).'*7-.'(2&."('0(!*%2&H(`%D"*'(7'(E !*g/*'(,)2)0/ G /'0/&("0(F-F'0/(!)*($+)./%-0('/(7&U"(*)!%7'F'0/H(%$($)%,,'(7'2%0'*("0

*)!!-*/(.*%/%_"'(R($+%0,/%/"/%-0('..$&,%)$'('/('L!*%F'("0'('L%D'0.'(`-*/' 7'( 2-%*( &2-$"'*( $+)//%/"7'( 7',( .)/a-$%_"',( 7)0,( $)( 2%'( %0/'$$'./"'$$'H .-FF'( !$",%'"*,( 7'( ,',( .-0/'F!-*)%0,( 2%./%F',( 7'( $+)0/%[F-7'*0%,[

F'b(@$(7'F'"*'(R(8)F)%,($+&7%/'"*(7'(9-,,"'/H(_"+%$(0+)%F)%/(D"V*'()"

7&!)*/( '/( _"%( $"%( )( !'*F%,( 7'( E *&)$%,'*( '0( /-"/'( %07&!'07)0.'H( *'$%[

D%'",'F'0/H(,)(2-.)/%-0(7+&*"7%/ G('0(E a-FF'(.)07%7'H(7'(.-FF'*[

.'(,u*H(-#$%D')0/('/(F-7',/'H(0)/"*'$$'F'0/(!%'"LH(7'(Fv"*,(7-".',H

*&,%D0&(!)*()2)0.'(R("0'('L%,/'0.'(,)0,(&.$)/ G

b

B

;

Christian Sorrel est professeur d’histoire contemporaine à l’universi- té de Lyon (Lyon 2) et membre correspondant du Comité pontifical des sciences historiques. Spécialiste de l’histoire du catholicisme français, il a travaillé notamment sur les crises du début du 20

siècle (politique anti- congréganiste, séparation de l’Église et de l’État, modernisme) et les

7'(I)*%,(&/)%'0/(%7'0/%_"',(R(.'"L(7'(F)%0/'0)0/('/(7'(K-0/)D0%0%('/('0,"%/'(_"'($+)*[

.a'2g_"'(o)*#-J(/'0)%/()"(;)%0/[;%VD'("0($)0D)D'(_"'($+&!%,.-!)/()./"'$(`'*)%/(#%'0(7'

!*'07*'(!-"*(F-7V$' GH(9%#$%-/aV_"'(0)/%-0)$'(7'(T*)0.'H(1-"2'$$',()._"%,%/%-0,(`*)0[

U)%,',(Nk kNPH(!)!%'*,(e-"/%0H(`4 ]YQH($'//*'(7'(K

C).*-%LH(NN(F)%(NZQOb

OPb(:0(!'"/(*'F)*_"'*(_"'(K

o"#-%,H(,-".%'"L(7'(!).%`%.)/%-0H()2)%/(`)%/()..-*7'*

'0(NZPN("0(/%/*'(&!%,.-!)$(R(K

C).*-%L(_"%('0()2)%/(&/&(!*%2&($-*,(7'(,)(7&F%,,%-0(7"

,%VD'(7'(>)*'0/)%,'b

O]b(Mb B)**%V*'H(E 1&.*-$-D%'~ GH(locb(citbH(!b(5Njb

O5b(IbidbH(! 5Njb

OO Une vie pour l’érudition : Charles Urbain

réponses apportées par l’Église. Il a publié notamment C)( X&!"#$%_"' .-0/*'($',(.-0D*&D)/%-0,b(e%,/-%*'(7+"0'(!),,%-0(`*)0U)%,'(WNYZZ[NZN5\, Cerf, 2003 ; C%#&*)$%,F'( '/( F-7'*0%,F'b( K

C).*-%L( WNYOO[NZPP\b

=0_"g/'(,"*("0(,",!'./, Cerf, 2003 ; C'(>'F!,(7',(.-0D*V,(.)/a-$%_"',b

9%#$%-D*)!a%'(*)%,-00&'(7',()./',(7'(.-0D*V,(/'0",('0(T*)0.'(7'(NYkQ(R

0-,(8-"*,, Brepols, 2010. Il s’oriente aujourd’hui vers l’histoire de la par-

ticipation française au concile Vatican II.