HAL Id: inria-00069883
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00069883
Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
Parallel computations of one-phase and two-phase flows using the MecaGRID
Stephen Wornom
To cite this version:
Stephen Wornom. Parallel computations of one-phase and two-phase flows using the MecaGRID.
[Technical Report] RT-0297, INRIA. 2004, pp.51. �inria-00069883�
a p p o r t
t e c h n i q u e
Thème NUM
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Parallel computations of one-phase and two-phase flows using the MecaGRID
Stephen Wornom
N° 0297
August 2004
12# &34 /658709;:
<%=?>A@CBC>EDGFHJIKDCH;LNM
OQPSRT6UVXW,Y[Z]\_^a`cbdRT6Ue`/f_gST6heikjmlEgSUe`
noidprqcUsbX\_TutA`vP
wtrx"x*pAivbQbkUKyzPSfSjmlEgSU{fJ|}A~EZXgS g"`vb~r}A}rZ]ax"t Ue`
,A_"CJ BC>@CIK>AK>AD=$IK>A@!H;I=>JLDC>E=?BC>J@C@_*=KHJDG=KH ¡IK¢¤£¥H;L@C¦=?DC§
HJ¨!=ª©«H¬o¦C¢NeL¦C*=?H;DAH¢>EE® BC>¯CIKe=AH¢>J°±²³u´µs¶«°;KL·¦C*=K>E«J>EIeH¢¸%Do*LN
¬oHa©¨cH;I$>r=K>EIeDoJ{JD¢¹D=?>AIKDo*,DCH;D%µªIK>EJA=KD§¬oHa©E® BC>ºK>AEH;D¢»AH¢>J°Q±$²¼½s¶¥°
KL·¦C*=?>A¾=ª©¥H"µª@CBo*K>AH;L@CIK>AKK¿C>À¬oHa©E® BC>©«H;IeÁ+>rC*LNDC>A¾=?BC>J@C@CE*=?H;D
HJ¨=?B>EK>EH%¢C>E>>EA¦=?DC§ÀH;DÂ@oJI?*>E@CIeHA>EKeH;IK$¦CKDC§=KBC>¾ÃG>EKKJ§;>ºÄJKeD§À½ªDµ
=?>EI¨vJE>ÅdÃÂÄ{½ÆH;DÂ=?B>ºÃ¤>A_ ³½s¼Ç=KBo*=EH;DDC>E=?=?B>·E¦C=?>EIeHJ¨½sȳ½ª±É<H;@CBC
±$D=?@!HJE°u²{AH;>¤¢C>EäDC>EÊ¢C>ÂÄJIK"=<%H;@CBC+±D=K@ËH;A°JDC¢0=?BC>G½sÌ< ½ºD
ÃÂJIKe>E>J®Íä>A=KBCH%¢CN=KH+HJ@=?LÎA>G=KBC>ÏÃG>E_; ³½s¼ÐJ@@C_"=?H;DCNJEAH;¦CD=?DC§»¨cH;I
=?BC>À¢CÒÑ!>EIK>AD=@CIKH%E>AKKHJINe@!>A>E¢CN*=·=?BC>À¢CÒÑ!>EIK>AD=Êe=K>ENJDC¢Ó¢CÒÑ!>EIK>AD=N³±Ã eÎA>E
JIK>@CIK>AK>ED=K>E¢Q® BC> ¡HJ¿C¦C¥±JDCE>¡eHJ¨Ô=ª©¥JIK>¥¦K>E¢À¨cH;I=?B> Ie¢J@C@CE*=?H;DCA®
<¦C§;§;>Ae=KH;D¨cHJI6¨c¦=?¦CIe>IK>Ee>_JIeÕBÏJIe>§;ÖJ>ED
פØÙÚeÛ¾Ü "ÝJ Ie¢&£¥H;L@C¦=KDC§° H;¿C¦E°ÃÂÄ{½£6Þuµ ß°$AH;L@C¦=Õ"=?H;DoJ¬o¦¢
¢¸%DoJLAE°o=ª©«H*µª@CBCJK>¬oHa©
àËáÒâãáåä!ærçªèªèzé/ãêªëKìíïî?ícðñ_ëKòvóôêªõôícðvæÕö÷aørùªúKæÕèªûªùªèªçüeêªýKþ?óÿ ä
ìóôýêªõôóôðvæÿ
òcí
'$$#u /
£¥>ÊI?J@@!H;I==?¦C¢>J@C@CE*=?H;D ¢¦ _JE¦«e¦CI¾§;Ie>Ê¢C>¢>E¦+H*µ
§;A>A¢C>ÃEEJDC%¦>¢C>E¬o¦C¢C>EA®/>Ê@CIe>EL>EIE°,±²³u´µs¶¥°Q=KI?JÒ=?>N¢EAH;¦C>EL>ED=?
LNHJDCH;@CBo*K%¦>E¢*>EIKH%¢¸%DoJL¦C>E«>%=?>AIKDC>>A=D=K>EIeDC>J®/>uK>AEH;D¢H;§;E>EoKL·¦>
¢C>EEEHJ¦C>AL>ED=?¢C@CBoJe¦C>AE®£¥>=?IKaÖ*JX>JLD>¾J@C@_*=KHJDÏ¢C>·A>EH;§;E>E
¦=??*D=ÊäĽK¦Iº>AºDC=ÕJ*=?H;DCº¢C>GÃG>E_; ³½s¼·°{EHJDCDC>E=ÕJD=>EºA¦C=?>AIK¢C>
½sÈ$³½ª± <H;@CB"µz±$D=?@ËH;E°¢C>¡²{EH;>¢C>EäDC>A¢>Ä,JIe!<HJ@CBC"µª±D=K@ËH;A°
>A=¢C>N½sÌ< ½"¤ÃÂJIeK>A>*®ÀÄ{¦K>E¦CIe¾L#A=?BH¢C>AÖ%?JD=GH;@=?LNK>AIA>E·J@C@Crµ
*=?H;DCÃG>E_; ³½s¼(@oJI¾Ï@CIKK>>AD EH;L@=K>À¢C>EºÖ%=K>EeK>E¢C>À@IKH%E>EeK>A¦CIK>A=¢>E
L$ALH;Ie>E6¢e@!H;D¿C>E¥K¦CI«>A¥¢CÒÑ%AIK>AD=K6KÒ=?>A6KHJD=¥@CIKHJ@!H&E>AE®/>$H;§;E>EË¢C>$§JIK>
¢C> ¡H;¿¦C±$ JDE>u>E={¦=K'u¢oJDC{A>EJ@@C_"=?H;DCÃÂÄ{½Õ®(/>6IKJ@C@ËH;Ie=,K>6=K>EIKLDC>
aÖJ>E¢C>Ee¦C§;§;>Ae=?H;DC¢DÖJ>Ee=K§;*=?H;DC¨c¦=?¦CIe>EA®
) Ü S Ú (* ¡IK>¢C>G_JE¦Cv°u ¡H;¿C¦CA°uÃÂÄ{½£6Þµs ß%°uÃA_JDC¦C>¢>E¬o¦C¢C>E
D%¦L$AIK¦C>J°+EAH;¦C>EL>ED=L·¦CÒ=?嵪@CBCJK>
#
9;u'Ës«
BC>G¢C>AÖJ>EH;@CL>ED=H*¨¡ ¡IK¢ £¥H;L@C¦=?DC§»¿!>A§JDÓD0=KBC>LN¢%$&'&'(JA® BC>¢C>_
=KHÀLÊ*ÁJ>N_ÖJ*J¿C>º¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=EHJLN@¦=?DC§IK>AKH;¦CIeE>AE°¢o*=?Ie>EeH;¦CIKA>EA°*DC¢ HJ=?BC>AI
EH;L@C¦=K>EIsµªIK>A"=?>E¢Â>@!>AIe=Ke>¾H;DÏNEH;L@C¦=Õ*=KH;DCJ Ie¢¤DÏHJIK¢C>AI=KHIK>EJÎA>·KA>ADµ
=?Ò¯oÊ@IKH*)>AA=?=?BC*=©¥H;¦¢ H*=?BC>AIe©K>N¿!>NL@ËH;Ke¿>ÊH;IDCHJ=@CI?*A=?_*«"=·KDC§;>
EH;L@C¦=KD§»e=K>J® ´¡D>ÀEH;¦C¢Ó>EDÖ%eHJDQ°«¨cH;I·>JL@C>J°=?BCH;¦?JDC¢ºHJ¨$eE>ED=?e=KÊD
LÊ*D¸»¢CÒÑ!>EIK>AD=ºH%_"=?H;DC·D=KBC>Ê©«H;IK¢ @ËHHJDC§¤=KBC>EI·Ie>EeH;¦CIKA>E·=KH¹JDo*¸%K=KBC>
¢o*=ÕHJ¨¥GLN!)HJI>r@!>AIKLN>AD=º*==?B>²{¦CIeH;@!>EJD»BC§JB>ED>EIK§*¸ @CB¸eA¾J¿!HJI?*=KH;Ie¸
D£6²³È°<%©Ò=?ÎE>AIKJDC¢»Å
BC>¡²{¦CIKHJ@!>EJDÀ¼*=?º ¡IK¢H;I«²¼¡ ,+KÆr®±DCHJ=KBC>EI«KE>ADoJIeH
©¥H;¦¢ÀDÖ;H;ÒÖ;>¡=?B>EH;¦@CDC§ºHJ¨AH¢>E6¢C>Ö;>AH;@Ë>E¢¤*=¥¢CÑ!>EIe>ED=ue=K>Eu>_*ÕB©Ò=?BÀe@!>rµ
EÒ¯o>@!>AIe=Ke>EE®
Ie¢¤£¥H;L@C¦=?DC§º¢C.-NE¦CÒ=ÕBoJ>ADC§;>¿!>A_J¦K>¡=?BC>¡D>E>E¢>E¢=?>EÕBDCH;H;§J¸©¥J
DCHJ=ºDCÒ=?JÒ¸ _Ö*J*¿C>*®Ä{IeH;§;IK>AKºAH;D=?D%¦>ENJ¾=?>AÕBCDCH;H;§J¸L@CIeHaÖ;>ENJD¢0LH;Ie>
¢C>AÖJ>EH;@!>AIK©¥HJIKÁ$HJD=KBC>{@CIeH*)>E=_® B>©¢C>rµªK@IK>_*¢·JAE>A@=ÕJDE>HJ¨C Ie¢¡AH;L@C¦=?DC§
©6J¥>AÖ%¢>ED=*=¥=KBC> H;¿C¦¥FHJIK¢ß/('('0¾£¥H;D¨c>EIe>EDCA>*=K=K>EDC¢>E¢¿¸LH;IK>=?BoJD1*('(
Ie¢ >ADC§;DC>E>AIKIK>A@CIK>AK>ED=KDC§ ß'1ÂEHJ¦CD=?IK>E32Ï=ª©¥H*µd¨cH;¢ DCAIK>EJK>À¨cIKHJL =?B>À?JL>
EH;D¨c>AIK>ADCE>BC>E¢GDÂß/('(ß%®
BC>ä>EE ³½s¼ @CIKH!)>EA==ÕJI=?>A¢¤DÀ=?BC>¨vJß/(/(ß·ue@!HJDCK>AIK>E¢¤¿¸=?BC>¶oIe>EDCÕB
äD=?Ie¸0HJ¨³>AK>EJIKÕBÍ=KBCIKH;¦§;B0=KBC>±£¥½dµs Ie¢ @CIKHJ§;I?JL
ç ® BC>Â@C¦IK@ËH;K>GHJ¨$=KBC>
ä>EE ³½s¼ @CIKH*)>AA=u=KHÊ@CIeHaÖ¢C>=?BC>Ä{IKHaÖ%DCE>rµª±$@Ë>Eµs£54J=?>¢±$ÎE¦I¾ÅvÄ!±£¥±¡ÆuIK>rµ
§;HJD[©Ò=?B. L>_JD=KHÓLÊ*ÁJ> *IK§;>¹@o*I?J>A¡EH;L@C¦=Õ*=KH;DGD8¬o¦C¢ L>AÕBoJDCE
¦CKDC§¹B¦CDC¢CIe>E¢CºH*¨@CIKH%E>AKKHJIKE® BCº@ËH;Ke¿C=ª¸_JD ¿Ë>Ie>_JÎA>E¢Ó¿¸AIK>E*=?DC§
JIe§;>GEH;L@C¦=?*=?H;Do* ¡IK¢ AH;L@CIKK>A¢8HJ¨¡E¦C=?>EIeÀ*=N=?BC>¤¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=Àe=K>ED =KBC>
Ä!±£¥±.IK>E§JH;D® BC>$DCÒ=?Jo@CBo*K>$H*¨=?B>ä>A_ ³½s¼ ¿CIeDC§J=KH;§;>A=KBC>EI{=KBC>A¦e=?>AIK
*=½sÈ$³½ª±2<H;@CBC±$D=?@!HJE°Ë£6²Ã²¶ Åk£¥>ED=?Ie>¢>LK>>ED¨cH;IKL>¢C>ALN*= EIeJ¦%
¢C>¡²{EH;>¡¢C>AäD>E¢C>¡ÄJIKµs<H;@CBCº±$D=?@ËH;ÕÆr°ïJDC¢=KBC>¡½sÌ< ½$Åv½ªDe=?Ò=?¦=ÌDCåµ
Ö;>EIeKÒ=ÕJIK>·¢C>E<¸=6ALN>A BC>EIeLN¦C>E¡>=½ªDC¢¦Ce=KIK>EÕÆ$D ÃÂJIeK>E>·µ¥K>A> ¦*IK¢
798!:
®Ï½ªD=KBC>@CIe>ELDoJI¸ e=?J§;>H*¨u¢C>AÖJ>EH;@CL>ED=NHJ¨u=KBC>ä>A_ ³½s¼ @IKH*)>AA=_°=KBC>
ÒµzE¦Ce=K>EIHJ¨Q½sȳ½ª±.³BCH;DC>±$@!>A©¥JDE¦C¢C>E¢D=?BC>@ËHH;HJ¨QLNJÕBCDC>A6_Ö*JJ¿C>
=?Hº=?BC>·Ã¤>A_ ³½s¼ EHJLNL¦CDCÒ=ª¸;®u²JÕBG@oJI=?DC>AIBoJ=?BC>AIHa©D¤¢Ñ!>EIe>ED=eE>EDCJIKH;
J=?HBCHa© =KBC>A¸·©¥H;¦¢Ê¦CK>u=?B>DCAIK>_*K>E¢Ê_J@CJ¿CÒ=ª¸º@CIeHSÖ%¢C>E¢Ê¿¸¾=?BC>ä>A_ ³½s¼·®
²Ö;>ED =?BCH;¦§;B8 ¡IK¢Í£¥HJLN@¦=?DC§ Bo*N¿Ë>E>ADͦCDC¢>EIN¢C>AÖJ>EH;@CL>ED=¨cH;INJLH;e=
¢C>EEJ¢C>J°%=?BC>ÕBoJ>ADC§;>A6DÖJH;ÖJ>E¢ÀDEIe>_*=KD§·EHJLN@¦=Õ*=KHJDoJ Ie¢C«JIe>$LNJD¸ÊJDC¢
=?H%¢o_¸ÂDC>EJI@C¦C§*µªJDC¢µz@Ca¸¤KH*¨Ô=ª©6JIe>º>e=?¡HJDC¸¤¨cH;I$e@!>AEJ,=ª¸%@Ë>E¡HJ¨« ¡IK¢»£¥H;L¾µ
;
þsììý<==?>@>@>ïøívë
îÕÿdìÿA óôîEøê A
B
@C¦=?DC§ÊÁJ>º¼>EKÁ=KH;@»£¥H;L@C¦=KDC§JDC¢¹²{D=?>AIK@CIee> Ie¢©BCÕB JIe>·KL@C¯o>A¢¹¿¸
¿!>ADC§+H%_"=?>E¢ *=+KDC§;>Âe=K>¤©Ò=?B H%_JDC>=ª©¥HJIKÁÀJDC¢ H%_**¢CLDCe=KI?*=KH;IKA®
ĦC§*µªJDC¢µz@Ca¸¤KH*¨Ô=ª©6JIe>º¢CH%>EDCH*=¸;>=¡>e=¡¨cH;I$©BC*=JIe>¾ÁDCHa©D+*Ie=K¦oJ{´Isµ
§JDCÎ_*=KHJDCGŴƾ ¡IK¢CºÁ*>=KBC>Gä>A_ ³½s¼®´JIK>ÀDCe=K=K¦=?H;DCºHJIº§;IKH;¦@C
=?Bo*=JIe>=KHJ=Õ*Ò¸D¢C>E@Ë>EDC¢>ED=¡>ED=K=K>AE®ÞHa©«>AÖ;>AIE°Q Ie¢¤KHJ¨Ô=ª©¥JIK>Á*>=?B>º ¡H;¿¦C
±$JDCA>¾KHJ¨Ô=ª©¥JIe>ÅvB=K=K@"©u©u©®§;HJ¿C¦CE®H;Ie§Æ$$K¦ -NE>ED=K¸Â¢C>AÖJ>EH;@!>A¢»=KH@Ë>EIeLNÒ=
=?BC>AIK>E*=?H;D HJ¨´ Ie¢¾HaÖ;>EI $Aµß¤LH;D=KB @!>AIKH¢ ¦CD¢C>EI¾@IKH;@Ë>EI¾AH;DC¢CÒ=?H;DCA®
BC>u@CIKHJ@!>AI{EH;DC¢=KH;DJIK>uH;D¾=KBC>uB¦CLNJDK¢C>I?*=KBC>EI=?BoJDº=KBC>uKHJ¨Ô=ª©¥JIe>uK¢C>JDC¢
_JDG¿!>=KBC>LH;e=¢C.-NE¦CÒ==KHIK>EeH;ÒÖ;>>AÖ;>ADÏJLH;D§Ê@o*Ie=?D>EIKA®
´ ¡IK¢CNJIK>À¢C.-NE¦CÒ=N¨cH;I¾LNJD¸ÓIK>EJKH;DE®0¶,IKe=E°=KBC>EH;L@C¦=?DC§+Ie>EeH;¦CIKA>E
JIK>H%_*=K>E¢*=u¢Ñ!>EIe>ED=De=?Ò=?¦=?H;DCu¦Ce¦oJ¸D¢CÒÑ>AIK>AD=§J>EH;§;IKJ@CBC_*HE*=?H;DCA®
BC>¤DC=?Ò=?¦=KH;DJIe>DC¢>E@Ë>EDC¢C>AD=HJ¨>_JÕB HJ=?B>EIE°«Bo_Ö%DC§ =?B>EINHa©D @CIKH;IKÒ=?>EA°
e¸%e=K>EL J¢CLDC=?IK*=?H;IeE°«¿o*=?ÕB e¸%e=K>ELE° ¦C>A¦C>G@CIKH;IKÒ=?>EA°¥e>EE¦IKÒ=ª¸ @IKH%E>E¢¦CIK>AE°
BoJIK¢©6JIe>JDC¢¦CK>AIEH;DC=?Ò=?¦C>ADCA¸J®u£¥Bo*DC§;>E*=*D¸@oJIe=KA¦CJI´2KÒ=?>JIe>¡LNJ¢C>
D¤¾=?LN>A¸LNJDDC>EIJ6=KBC>ÕBoJDC§;>A$*IK>¦CDC¢C>AIEH;D=?IeH;/HJ¨,ºH%_J e¸%e=K>EL J¢CLDµ
=?I?"=?H;IA® BC>LÊJ)H;IIK>_*KH;DN©B¸NAIK>_"=?DC§´ ¡IK¢C¢C.-NE¦CÒ=¥=?BC>J¿Ce>EDCA>$HJ¨
¡IK¢ÏJ¢CLDCe=?IK*=?HJI=KH@CJDQ°Ë>E=ÕJ¿CKB¹¿Ë>EDCÕBCLNJIeÁE°/JD¢ÂEH%H;Ie¢CDC*=?>=?BC>H%_*
e¸%e=K>ELJ¢CLD=?I?"=?H;IeÅX<±$?Æ®«<>A>FH;IeDCH;L
7
$
:
¨cH;I«¨c¦CIe=KBC>EI6¢eE¦CeKH;DÂHJ¨/=KBC>
ÕBoJ>ADC§;>E>EDEH;¦CD=K>EIK>A¢ÏDGAIK>E*=?DC§=?BC>ä>A_ ³½s¼®
34 /!u5Í7 9J: /%«! /
BC>¡EHJLN@¦=?>AI6IK>AKH;¦CIeE>A6¨cH;I=KBC>ä>A_ ³½s¼ JIK>=?BC>A¦e=?>AIK*=«=?BC>$¢CÑ!>EIe>ED=
LN>AL·¿Ë>EIeHJ¨=?B>ÃG>E_; ³½s¼ =KH¤¿Ë>ºEHJL·¿CDC>E¢+=?HÀ¨c¦CDC=?H;D*¡H;DC>*IK§;>@oJIKJ>A
EH;L@C¦=K>EI§JÖ%DC§Ã¤>A_ ³½s¼Í¦K>EIe,=?B>6_J@CJ¿CÒ=ª¸=KH$@Ë>EI¨cH;IKL EHJLN@¦=Õ*=KHJDC,=?BC*=
JIK>DCHJ=@ËH;Ke¿>$*=«JD¸LN>AL·¿Ë>EI«KÒ=?>·Åc=?B>LN"L·¦CL @CIeHA>EKeH;IK«_Ö*JJ¿C>*=«JD¸
LN>AL·¿Ë>EIKÒ=?>D+=KBC>@IK>Ee>ED=Nä>A_ ³½s¼EHJD¯o§;¦CIK*=?H;D+
8
(Â*=½sȳ½ª± <H;@CBC
±$D=?@!HJÕÆr®
£¥¦e=?>AIKBCaÖJ>Ï>EÒ=?B>EI@¦C¿C¤H;IÊ@IKÒÖJ"=?>G½sÄ *¢C¢CIK>AKe>EE® *¿C> $ÂeBCHa©=?BC*=
8
&@CIKH%E>AKKHJIK¥©«H;¦C¢¿Ë>$_Ö*JJ¿>¨/¿ËHJ=KB@CIeÖ**=K>$JD¢@C¦C¿½sÄ J¢C¢IK>EeK>A6©¥>AIK>
DCA¦¢C>E¢Q® BC>¹HEJJIe>_ DC>=ª©¥H;IeÁ ű$ÈÆe@!>A>E¢[ÀD §¿=KÀ@!>AIÀK>EAH;DC¢
Åd ¡¿C@CÕÆr®{@JÈ =KBC>D¦CL·¿Ë>EIHJ¨@CIKH%E>AKKHJIK@!>AIÈH¢>J®
±6=¡=?BC>@CIe>Ee>ED==?LN>*°¦CK>AIK*==KBC>DC¢Ö%¢C¦oJ{L>EL¿!>AIKÒ=?>ELN_¸¹>@Ë>EIe>ADCE>
H;D§»©¥JÒ=N=KL>AN©BC>AD LH;Ie>=KBoJD"µ$ @IKH%E>EeKH;Ie*IK>IK> %¦>Ee=K>E¢Q®Í¼$>E@Ë>EDC¢DC§
H;D=?B>Ê©«H;IKÁ»H;J¢Q°,=KBC>Ê©¥JÒ=·=?L>EºLN_¸»>%=?>ADC¢ ¨cIKH;L e>AÖ;>AI?J¥BCH;¦CIe·=?H¤©¥>A>EÁï®
´¡D>EH;¦¢ÀLNJ§;DC>$=?BC*=6©Ò=?B
8 &@CIKH%E>AKKHJIK_Ö*JJ¿C>J°EH;L@C¦=Õ*=KH;DuIK> ¦CIKDC§
\_jbkU yg"`vbkUi cnJ nïW` w,Y ÕVXpSU XV x ÕV
cVwc¹x*UK` jmyg"`vbkUiK xSgjy ~S }ô " }A} }e}A}
cVwc¹x*UK` jmyg"`vbkUiª~ xSgjy ~}} } " }A} }}A} ~
cVwc¹`kpxSPSjmt cVwcx xSgjy " } }} }e}A} ~
cVwc¹`kpxSPSjmt cVXwcf"jf"t xSgjy " ~ ~} }A} }}A} ~
cW\SO T " Py g"`vbkUei xSikj"!ÕtÕbdU " } ~} }A} }e}A}
$#ËY%#'& `dtridU ()Ôyg"`cbdUi xSikj"!ÕtÕbdU " } }} }e}A} ~
O%pbdt*nïWX` xSg+xSidj _Õ
Ot,U6-ïOprbdt%YUeyetw/.Ïx"ikpaysUK`k`kpiz`10ÒxSgjmy2+Ïx"ikj"!ÕtÕbkU43
0ßSµ
À@CIKH%E>AKKHJIKÊÅv>Ee=KBoJD $(À@!>AIKA>ED=HJ¨«=KBC>N_ÖJ*J¿C>º@CIKH%E>AKeH;IK?Æ¡©«H;¦C¢+DHJ=
IK> ¦CIK>$H;D§©¥J=¥@!>AIKH¢¥¦CeDC§=?BC>ä>EE ³½s¼·®± Ie>EE>AD=u>JL@C>>@Ë>EIe>ADCE>A¢
¿¸·=?BC>J¦=KBCH;I©¥J«Ie> ¦C>Ae=¨cH;I ¡@CIKH%E>AKeH;IKH;D=?BC>½sÈ$³½ª±8E¦C=?>EI=?H>ÖJ*¦o"=?>
@!>AIe¨cH;IeLÊ*DCE>=KBo*=ºIe>ELNJDC>E¢ÓD =?BC> %¦>E¦C>=KBCIK>A>À¢o_¸º¿Ë>A¨cHJIK>HJ¿=ÕJDCDC§Ï=?B>
@CIKH%E>AKKHJIKE® B>Â?*LN>GIK¦D ©¥JÊe¦C¿CLÒ=K=?>A¢Í=?H =?BC>Âä>A_ ³½s¼ ©BC>EIe> @CIeH*µ
E>EeKH;Ie©«>EIe>LNL>A¢C"=?>EÒ¸+_ÖJ*J¿C>@!>AIKL=e=?DC§Â@Ë>EI¨cH;IKLNJDE>N>AÖ*J¦o*=?H;D+HJ¨«=KBC>
D=?>AIµzE¦Ce=K>EIK¦Ce>E¢ÂD=?BC>IK¦DQ®
½ªDÊ=KBC>$e¦CLLN>AIuß/(/('0½sȳ½ª±[=?B>$³BCH;DC>rµª±@Ë>E«E¦Ce=K>EI¥¦DC¢C>EI©¥>AD=JD¦@C§;I?*¢C>
J=?DC§$e>AÖJ>EI?*LH;D=?BJDC¢¿!>A_JL>¥JD·DoJ=?ÒÖ;>¥L>AL·¿Ë>EI,H*¨C=?BC>¥Ã¤>A_ ³½s¼®
BC
¦C@C§;IKJ¢C>6{DCHa©0EH;L@C>A=K>*DC¢º=Dº=?BC>¥D=?>AIK>Ae=HJ¨o=?B>ä>EE ³½s¼Í=?Bo"=½sÈ$³½ª±
³BCHJDC>µz±$@!>Au¿!>¡D=?>E§JI?*=K>E¢GJJDGJ=?ÒÖ;>L>EL·¿Ë>EIJ¥=K6=ª©¥HNE¦Ce=K>EIeBCaÖJ>¡=?BCIe>E>
=?LN>AJLÊ*D¸G_Ö*J*¿C>@CIeHA>EeKH;Ie=KBoJD=?BC>HJ=KBC>EIu=KBCIK>A>L>AL·¿Ë>EIKEHJL·¿CDC>E¢$5
6798 :
;kÝ Ü =< /a; Ü?> X; >@ <;BAC ØDCE oÝXÝX Ø _ Ø
*¿C>+ß KBHS©À©Bo"=À=?BC>+ä>A_ ³½s¼ AH;D¯o§;¦I?*=KH;D8©«H;¦C¢ Ie>Ee>EL·¿>»¦CKDC§
H;DCÒ¸=?B>A¦e=?>AIKu©Ò=?BG@C¦C¿C½sÄ J¢C¢CIe>EKe>E¾Å
@IKH%E>EeKH;IeÕÆr®¥<%BCHa©D¤D J¿> 0
=?BC>N@CIK>AK>AD=ä>EE ³½s¼]AH;D¯o§;¦I?*=KH;D»=?Bo"=·¦Ce>E¾@IKÒÖJ"=?>N½sÄ *¢C¢CIK>AKe>EE® BC>
E¦Ce=K>EIKX*=£6²Ã²¶GJDC¢¡=?B>{½sÌ< ½!Bo_Ö;>@CIKÒÖ**=?>{½sĤJ¢C¢CIe>EeK>E©BCÕBD>EE>AKe=?*=?>A¢
=?BC>ºAIK>_"=?H;D HJ¨« Ie=?¦CJ{Ä{IKÒÖ**=?>È>A=ª©«H;IKÁÓÅ ¡ÄÈÆ$HJI$=?¦CDDC>E,=KH@oJK¡L>AK?*§;>E
¿!>=ª©¥>A>ED=KBC>¢CÑ!>EIe>ED=E¦Ce=K>EIKA® BC>N½sÈ$³½ª± E¦Ce=K>EIeBo_ÖJ>@C¦C¿½sÄ J¢C¢CIe>EKe>E
¿C¦==?BC> ÄÈ =KIK>_"=?6=?B>EL JuÒ¨,=KBC>A¸©«>EIe>@IKÒÖJ"=?>J®
BC>LÊSL·¦L D¦CL¿!>AIH*¨@CIeHA>EeKH;Ie,_Ö*J J¿>«*=/=?B>6£6²Ã²¶Â*DC¢¡=?BC>½sÌ< ½
&ßÅv>EJÕBGKÒ=?>¦CK>A=ª©«HÊ@IKH%E>EeKH;Ie¨cHJIue¸%e=K>EL(LNJDoJ§J>EL>ED=rÆr®
BC>¹³JDC¢CHJL4±uEE>AKGä>ALH;Ie¸ Åk³±¡ÃÏƺ=?BC>=?H*=ÕJ³±¡Ã _Ö*JJ¿>G=?H+=KBC>
ÈH%¢C>=KB%¦E°C*@C@CIKH_LÊ"=?>EÒ¸ $ ;ß6_Ö*JJ¿>$=KH·>EJÕBG£6ÄÌ&HJ¨/=?B>ÈH%¢C>¨cH;I¥ÈH¢>E
\ajbdU y g*`cbdUi cn;Ïbc^_xJU nïW` w,Y ÕVXpSU XV¹`kx*UeU
cVXwc¹xJUe` jmyg"`cbdUiK xSgjmy ~S " }A} }}A}1"x"`
cVXwc¹xJUe` jmyg"`cbdUiª~ xSgjmy ~}} " }A} }}A}1"x"`
cVXwc¹`kpx"PSjt cVXwcfSjf"t xSgjmy " ~ ~ }A} }}A}1"x"`
cVXwc¹`kpx"PSjt cVXwcx xSgjmy " }} }e}A}1"x"`
Oprbzt,*nïW`
Ot,U~-oY¡Ueyt)w/. y g"`vbkUeid`/ypT6xJpA`kUpx"gjycntaikUK`k`kUe`
\_jbkU y g*`cbdUi cn;Ïbc^_x*U nïWX` wY rVpaU %V¹`vxJUU
$#!Y%#'& `dtridU ()y g*`cbdUi xSidj!ÕtÕbdU E~ }ôr} }e}} 1Sx"`
cVwc¹`vpAxSPSjmt cVXwcx xSgjmy
"
}ôr} }e}} 1Sx"`
cVwc¹`vpAxSPSjmt cVXwcfSjf"t xSgjmy
" ~ ~ }} }}} 1Sx"`
cW\aO T "
PÔyg"`vbkUei xSidj!ÕtÕbdU
" } ~ }} }e}} 1Sx"`
Oprbzt, A~
Ot,U "
-?!gSidikUefEbY¡Ueyt)w/.¹yspAf
AgSidtrbkjpf$yspT6xJpA`kUp,CxSidj!ÕtÕbdUcntaidUe`d`vUK`
©=KB¿C嵪@CIeHA>EKeH;IKA®ÈHJ=K>=KBo*=©=KB=?BC>>E>A@=?H;DÀHJ¨=?BC>½sÌ< ½Õ°Jï=KBC>$A¦e=?>AIK
Bo_Ö;>=ª©¥H£6ÄÌJÈH¢>J® B¦C=?B>½sȳ½ª±µªDCDo¤ÅvH;IKL@CÒ¸DCDCÆuJDC¢=?BC>½sÌ< ½
E¦Ce=K>EIK¿ËHJ=?B Bo_ÖJ>ß Þκ@CIeHA>EeKH;IeE°DCDo©=KB $ JßÀ ³±¡Ã ;£6ÄÌJD¢ =KBC>
½sÌ< ½©=KB $ ;£6ÄÌ®
BC> ¡ÄÈ >Ae=Õ*¿CKB>EIKH;¦=?>E=?BCIeH;¦C§;B =KBC>G Ie¢ JDC¢ =?¦DCDC>E¿!>=ª©¥>A>EDÓ¨cIKH;D%µ
=?>ED¢CÀD8HJIK¢C>AI=?H @CIeHaÖ¢C>¹AH;DCDC>AA=?ÒÖ%=ª¸[¿Ë>A=ª©«>E>AD.=KBC>¨cIeH;D=?>ED¢.DH¢C>A2J=KBC>
¨cIKH;D=?>ADC¢CBo_Ö;>@C¦¿C½sÄ J¢C¢IK>EeE®¤²JÕB @oJI·H*¨6¨cIKH;D=K>EDC¢CEH;DDC>E=?>E¢ Ö%Ï
=?¦CDCD>ED©BCÕBEIe¸%@=K>E¢GJDC¢À>ADC_*@CK¦C*=K>E¢@oJÕÁ*>A=?*IK>$=KI?JDCeL=e=?>E¢® B>@oJÕÁ;µ
>A=?$JIK>EHJLN@IK>EeK>A¢ =KHÊL@CIKHaÖJ>·=?BC>¬oHa© I?*=K>=KBCIKHJ¦C§;B¤=KBC>=K¦CDCDC>Ak®
BC>¡ÄÈ
EH;L@C>A=K>E¢º¿¸=KBC>uJ¢¢C=KHJD¾HJ¨ïIKHJ¦=?>AKH$=KBo*=,>_JÕBº@CIeHA>EeKH;IEJD¾e>EDC¢N@CJÕÁJ>={=?H
JD¸ºHJ=?B>EI@CIKH%E>AKeH;IH;DN=KBC> Ie¢NJD¢Êe>E>>_JÕB¨cIKH;D=K>EDC¢J¢>A¨vJ¦CÒ=§*=K>A©¥a¸·¨cH;I
>%=?>AIKDoJ*¢C¢CIK>AKe>EºÅck®>J®DCH*=H;DG=KBC>?JL> /±È$Æ®C± @oJÕÁ*>A=K>AD=¨cIKHJL JD½sÈ$³½ª±
@CIKH%E>AKKHJI=?HG£6²Ã²¶.@CIeHA>EeKH;I¡¯oIK=K>ED=¡=KH=KBC>º½sÈ$³½ª±¨cIKHJD=K>EDC¢ ©BC>AIK>
K@Ë>EEJïIKHJ¦=?>A«Bo_ÖJ>$¿Ë>E>EDK>A=«¦C@N=?HK>ED¢=DÊ=KBC>$*@C@CIKHJ@CIK*=?>=?¦DCDC>Ev® BC> ¡ÄÈ
¨c¦CDCA=KHJDCJ¨*@CIeHA>EKeH;IK©¥>AIK>¾H;DÂÊF¹±$È Åc©¢C>·JIK>EDC>A=ª©«H;IeÁÆuµ6e>E>ºÈÖJ>A=
7
$'$
:
®¶§;¦IK> 0ÅQ¨cIKH;L ÈÖJ>A=
7
$'$
:
ÆeBCHa©ueÕBC>ELN*=K$HJ¨Q=?B> ¡ÄÈ[¨cH;I{=?BC>@CIK>AK>ED=
ä>EE ³½s¼ÇAH;D¯o§;¦I?*=KH;D®¶oH;IJ¢C¢CÒ=?H;DoJ=?>AÕBCDC_J¢C>A=?JHJDÂ=?BC>¾Ã¤>EE ³½s¼
=?BC>IK>EJ¢C>AIIK>¨c>EIKIe>E¢=?HNÈÒÖ;>=$Ie>E@ËH;Ie=E®
INTERNET
INRIA frontend CEMEF frontend
IUSTI frontend
nina
pf
bi−processors nodes mono−processors nodes
IUSTI CEMEF
CIPE tunnels INRIA
&j AgSikU6-Ë\ayzPSUTutrbkjmypoY¡Ueyt)w/.nËV
! "# .-/) /C
798 Ø ;v; * *@ïÜ ;c
BC>¯oIK=Á*>EIeDC>EEH;DK¢C>EIe>E¢ D»=KBC=?¦C¢¸ =?BC>eHJ¨Ô=ª©6*IK>N±²³u´¢C>Ö;>AH;@Ë>E¢
*==?BC>ÌDÖJ>EIKe=ª¸¤HJ¨£¥H;H;I?J¢HN©Ò=?BG=?BC>EHJJ¿ËH;I?*=KHJD¤HJ¨½sÈ$³½ª± µK>E>·¼$>EIÖ%>A¦
70 :
°H;D§JDC¢ ¦CJIe¢
7$ :
°%¶ïJIKBo"=
71 :
°%JDC¢ÃÂJI=?DJD¢ ¡¦CJIK¢
7& :
¨cH;I{¢C>=ÕJA®
±²³u´ Ie>E>A¥H;DÊJDN¦CDCe=K>_J¢¸N=KBCIK>A>µd¯o>E¢LH%¢C>EïEHJDCKe=KDC§·HJ¨Qe=KIK¦C=?¦CIKJïLH¢C>A
Åv±²³u´µs<CÆ°*¬o¦C¢ºLH¢>EÅv±²³u´µª¶{Æ°*JDC¢º@CK>A¦C¢CH*µz>EJe=KA=ª¸·LNH%¢C>A/Åv±$²³u´µs²Æ
¨cH;I{=?BC>¢¸%DoJL_Jï¬o¦C¢L>AKBQ®{½z=«¦Ce>A¨c¦Cï¨cH;I=KBC>e> ¦C>AË=KH§;ÒÖ;>$¨c>©8> ¦o"=?H;DC
¢C>EeEIK¿CDC§Ê=KBC>EH;¦@C>A¢¤LH%¢C>E
!
#"%$'&)(
*+"-,/.0(
1
1
2
1
3 3
ÅM$SÆ
©BC>EIe> ¢C>Ee§JDo*=?>A=?L>J°
=KBC>·@ËH;e=KH;D¹H*¨LHaÖDC§¬C¦C¢¹§JIK¢Ï@!HJD=_° =KBC>
¬o¦C¢ e=?*=?>NÖ;>E=?H;IA°
Ie>Ee¦C=K·¨cIKHJL =KBC>ʯCDC=K>µz>E>EL>ED= SÖ;H;¦CL>À¢CKEIe>A=KÎE*=?H;D HJ¨
=?BC>¬o¦C¢¾> ¦o"=?H;DCE°
=?BC>Ö;>E=?H;IHJ¨oAH;DÖ;>E=?ÒÖ;>u± X²Â¬C¦>EE® X=?BC>Ö;>AA=?HJI,HJ¨
¢CÑ!¦CeÖJ>¬o¦>AE° =?BC>e=KIK¦C=?¦CIKJï¢Ce@CJE>ALN>AD=6Ö;>AA=?HJIE° "
$4&)(
¢C>EDHJ=?>A«=?B>ÖJ>EA=KH;I
HJ¨6D=?>EIeDoJ{¨cH;IeE>ED+=KBC>Ê=?Ie¦CA=K¦CIK>*°JDC¢ "
,/.0(
=KBC>NÖJ>E=?H;IHJ¨6>r%=?>EIeDoJ{¨cH;IeE>EA®
=?BC>¯oDCÒ=?>µz>E>EL>ED=¡LNJeLN*=?IeÒ¤HJ¨,=?BC>e=?Ie¦CA=K¦CIK>*°
1
° 1
2 JD¢
1
3 JIe>¯o=?Ò=?H;¦C
LÊ*KE°J¢oJL@CDC§¡JDC¢·e=?ÒÑ!DC>Ee{LÊ"=?IKE>A{JeKH%E*=?>A¢·©=KB¾=?BC>«LHSÖ%DC§¬o¦C¢¾§;Ie¢¾JDC¢
3
=?IKJDCe¨c>AILN*=?IeÒ·=?Bo"=¢C>AKEIe¿Ë>E{=KBC>uJ=?H;DºHJ¨o=?B>uLNH*=?H;DºHJ¨o=?B>6e=KIK¦C=?¦CIKJ
K¢C>HJ¨=KBC>¡¬o¦C¢*=?IK¦A=?¦IK>·D=?>AIe¨vJA>HJDG=KBC>¬o¦C¢Â¢¸%Do*LNL>EKB®
±$DL@CA=«¯oDCÒ=?>µz>E>EL>ED=u=KL>$eÕBC>EL>¥¦K>E¢Ê¨cH;I=KBC>$=?Ie¦CA=K¦CI?JËLH¢>E!JDC¢
JDºL@CEÒ==KL>rµªe=?J§;§;>AIK>A¢ÊeÕBC>EL>¨cH;I,=?B>ue=?Ie¦CA=K¦CIK>*®{± Ö;>AIe=K>µªA>ED=?>AIK>E¢¦C@©DC¢
¯oDCÒ=?>µdÖ;H;¦CL>KÕBC>ALN>¥>EL@CHa¸;>A¢¾©BC>ED±²³u´µs¶À¦Ce>E¢D=?BC>¬o¦C¢µzH;DCÒ¸¡LH¢C>*®
ȦCL>EIeEJHJ@=?H;DC¥J¢C¢CIe>EK¥K>EAH;DC¢µzH;IK¢>EI6*EE¦I?J¸¿ËHJ=?BDe@oJA>JDC¢Ê=?LN>µe>E>
¼$>EIÖ>E¦% 70 : ° H;DC§·JDC¢¤ ¦*IK¢ 7$ : °¶ïJIKBo"= 71 : °CJDC¢GÃÂJI=?DGJDC¢G ¡¦CJIK¢ 7& : ®
BC>§;HJHJ¨,=KBCe=K¦C¢¸À©«>EIe> $aÆ£¥Ie>_*=KHJD¤HJ¨=?BC>ä>A_ ¡IK¢Q°!ß;Æ<%=K¦C¢CDC§N=KBC>
>3-NE>EDC¸ÀHJ¨Q=KBC>H;D>µª@BoJK>$±²³u´µs¶AH¢>¦CKDC§¾=KBC>ä>A_ ³½s¼°CJDC¢ 0Æ«¼$>Ö;>AÒµ
H;@CDC§ÏJD¢ >JLDCD§Â=?BC>Ê>3-NE>EDA¸ H*¨¤=?BIK>E>rµª¢CL>EDCeHJDoJ«=ª©«H*µz@CBoJe>ÊÖ;>AIKeH;D
HJ¨=?BC>¾±$²³u´µs¶ÍEH%¢C>¾¨cH;I Ie¢ *@C@CE*=?H;DCA® BC>ºIe>EK¦=KH*¨=KBC>Ee>º>@Ë>EIKL>ED=?
JIK>¡Ie>E@ËH;Ie=K>E¢GD=?BC>e>EA=KHJDC=KBo*=u¨cH;HS©®
5 6 /0% 87:9 5;9Í7 : )+ / ) 1
BC>ϱ ¡±³¼ =?>Ae=_Je>ÏEH;L@C¦=?>EÊ=?BCIe>E>µz¢CLN>ADCKH;Do*$¬oHa© JIKHJ¦CDC¢8»e©«>E@=
©DC§Ê*=HS© ÃÂJÕB¤D%¦L·¿Ë>EIµe>E>=<«*=?>A
7
$J1
: ® BC>LN>AKBϦK>E¢¤BC>EIe>AH;D=ÕJDC$ß;ß
Ö;>EI=?E>AE®
BC>¾ÃG>E_; ³½s¼ ¢C>Ee§JDC>E¢¨cH;IuJIK§;>¡@IKH;¿C>ELEH;D=?JDDC§=?BH;¦C?*DC¢C
H;ILH;DCHJ¨,Ö;>EI=?E>A$=?B¦C$=KBC$L>EeB¹IK>E*=KÖJ>EÒ¸ÂeLÊ*X¨cH;I ¡IK¢ÂEJE¦C*=?H;DCA®
ÞHa©¥>Ö;>AIE°Ë=©/§;ÒÖ;>JDG¢C>EÊHJ¨,BCHa© eLÊ*L>EeBC>E@!>AIe¨cH;IeL H;D¤=KBC>ä>EE ³½s¼
JDC¢@Ë>EIeL=6EHJLN@CJIKKH;D¿!>=ª©¥>A>ED=?B>$@Ë>EIe¨cHJIKLNJDCA>HJ¨=?BC>L@CA=6JDC¢Ê>@CA=
KH;ÒÖ;>AI¥H;@=KHJDC«D=KBC>±$²³u´µs¶+AH¢>J® BC>L@CEÒ=6IK¦DC¥Ie> ¦CIK>E¢ $aß =KL>e=K>E@C
=?HHJ¿=ÕJDÍ+IK>Ee¢¦oJEH;DÖ;>AIK§;>ADCE>¹H*¨_®.ÌKDC§=?B>Â>@CEÒ=ÀKÕBC>AL>Ï©¥H;¦¢
IK> ¦CIK>K>Ö;>AI?J=?BCHJ¦C?JD¢CH*¨=KL>e=?>A@CJDC¢¤ÖJ>EIe¸GJIK§J>·£6ÄÌ =?L>=KH*ÕBC>Ö;>
=?BC>KJL>¡>Ö;>A/HJ¨EH;DÖJ>EIK§J>EDCA>J® B>¡>@CA=eH;ÖJ>EI¦Ce>E *µze=Õ*§;>³¦CDC§;>rµ ¡¦=e=Õ
=?LN>eÕBC>EL>J® BCÊ=?IKDC§;>AD=AH;DÖ;>EIe§;>EDE>ÂDCHJ=NDC>AE>Ee?JI¸Ó=?H >E=ÕJ¿CKB8 ¡IK¢
@!>AIe¨cH;IeLÊ*DCE>*®¶oH;I·=KBC>G ¡IK¢ @!>AIe¨cH;IeLÊ*DCE>=?¦C¢¸;°IKH;¦C§JBC¸> ¦CÒÖ*J>AD=N=KL>A¾¨cH;I
¿!HJ=KBN=KBC>>@CA=6JDC¢NL@CEÒ=¥L>A=KBCH%¢C©«>EIe>$¦Ce>E¢ÏÅvH;D=?BC>H;Ie¢C>EIHJ¨ $J1/(¡K>AEH;DC¢E°
ß'1 >@CA=KHJÖJ>EIu=?L>=?>E@ÕÆ®
<BCHa©DÓD0¶,§;¦CIe>ß·=?BC>ÀDH;Dµ ¡H;¿C¦C¾e@!>A>E¢C¦@0ÖJ>EIKe¦Cº=?BC>D%¦L·¿Ë>EIHJ¨@CIeH*µ
E>EeKH;IeH;D=?BC>¡½sȳ½ª±µªDCDoJDC¢½sȳ½ª±µª@¨XE¦C=?>EIe*=u½sÈ$³½ª± <H;@BCº±D=K@ËH;A®
²{ÖJ>ED&=KBCH;¦C§JB.=KBC>+L>AKB ¤eLNJv°ÓIK>_*KH;Do*¿C>+K@Ë>E>A¢C¦C@ ¤HJ¿=ÕJDC>A¢ ©Ò=?B Sµ
@CIKH%E>AKKHJIK·Åkº¨vJA=KH;IHJ¨{J@@CIKH_LN*=K>EÒ¸ 8 Æ®6ÃÂJÕBÂAH;D=?H;¦IK*=ÎE>EIeHDCE¢C>ADCE>¨cH;I
=?BC>± ±$³¼ LN>AKBÀ*IK>$eBCHa©DDÀ¶,§;¦CIK>%0®
BC>Ö%>A©.§;ÒÖ;>E«=?BC>¨vJK>$L@CIK>AKeH;D
=?Bo*=u=KBC>¡©D§Ê*=JD¤JDC§;>¡HJ¨,*=K=?JÕÁï®
&j gSidU~-ËY¡n Q`vxJUU agSxpfbkP"U cVXwc y g*`cbdUiz`!g*`vjfS 6bkP"U{jT6xjyjbX`kp"!Uei
&j gSidU " -oXw./jf" ¥T6UK`vP -ËYtyzPyspfEbdpgSiz`
½ªD =?BC>ÀDC>r%=Êe>E=?H;DCE°=?BC>GÃG>E_; ³½s¼(@!>AIe¨cH;IeLÊ*DCE>À>JLD>E¢Ó¨cH;I Ï@CIeH*µ
E>EeKH;Ie*DC¢ AH;L·¿Do"=?H;DCNHJ¨ ¹@CIeHA>EKeH;IKNDÖJH;ÒÖDC§=KBC>¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=ä>EE ³½s¼
E¦Ce=K>EIKA®
798 : * Ü
X A Ø
"X
>Ü?>/Ú : * Ü X < Ø
Ü
> Ø
<BCHa©DÂD J¿C> ÊNAH;L@oJIKKHJD¿Ë>A=ª©«>E>EDÂDCH;Dµs H;¿C¦CJD¢Ï ¡HJ¿C¦C@!>AIe¨cH;Isµ
LÊ*DCE>6¨cH;IX=?BC>u± ¡±³¼Íe©«>E@=©DC§=K>Ee=EJK>u¦KDC§¡=?BC>u½sȳ½ª±µªDCDoE¦C=?>EIA® "µ
¿C> ·eBCHa©¥=?BC> H;¿C¦«@Ë>EI¨cH;IKLNJDCA>=KH¾¿!>K§;B=?Ò¸¿Ë>A=e=?>EI=?Bo*DÊ=?B>$DCH;D%µ ¡H;¿¦C
@!>AIe¨cH;IeLÊ*DCE>*® BC>ÀDCH;D%µ ¡H;¿¦CºÃÂÄ{½¦Ce>E¾=?B>ÃÂÄ{½£6Þ]@ ÕB ¢C>Ö%A>©BC>EIe>_J
=?BC> ¡H;¿¦C«ÃÂÄ{½¦CK>A«=KBC>§;HJ¿C¦CÕߢC>AÖ%E>*®
BC>eLNJï¢CÒÑ!>EIK>ADCE>A¥DÊ@Ë>EI¨cH;IKLNJDE>
JIK>¤¢C¦C>Â=KHK§;B=?Ҹ͢CÒÑ>AIK>AD=EH;D¯C§;¦CIK>¤H;@=KH;DE® ¡HJ¿oJD=K>EIµzEH;LL¦CDC_*=KH;D
HAE¦CIeE°¨cHJI>rJL@C>*°©BC>AD=?B>ÊLN"L·¦CL°LDCL¦CL°H;IK¦L H*¨¥=?B>NÖ*J¦C>EHJ¨
¤Ö*JIKJ¿C>ÀJIe>EH;L@C¦=?>E¢ÓHaÖ;>AIJ«=?B>@CIKH%E>AKeH;IKA® /H%_JD=K>EIµzEH;LL¦CDC_*=KH;D
HAE¦CIe©B>ED»LN>AKKJ§;>EJIe>º@oJKe>E¢»¿!>=ª©¥>A>ED»=ª©¥HG@CIKH%E>AKeH;IKA® BC>º=?HJ=?JEHJLN@¦µ
=Õ*=KH;D=KL>¡DCE¦C¢C>A=KBC>¡D=K>EI *D=KI?"µzEH;LL·¦DCE*=?H;D=?L>E¿C¦=DCH*=uK>=?¦C@=?L>E
ÅvIK>EJ¢CDC§¢C*=Õ°¥LN>AKBC>AE°DC=K *Î_*=KHJDQ°¡®®®>A=?_Æ® BC>G=?LN>AeBCHa©D8D Ju=?J¿C>E
JIK>DÂK>EAH;DC¢CJDC¢Â=KBC>·LN"L·¦CL Ö*J¦>E$¨cH;IJ/=?BC>@CIKH%E>AKKHJIKE® L>A$=?HÊ?_Ö;>
D=?>AIKL>E¢ *=K>¡KH;¦=KH;DuJIK>DCHJ=«=ÕJÁ*>EDÀD=KHºJAEH;¦CD=E® BC>£¥H;LL·¦DCE*=?H;DSFH;IeÁ
I?*=KH¤·=KBC>e¦CL H*¨6=?BC>H%_J«JDC¢§;HJ¿oJEH;LL¦CDC_*=KH;D =KL>¢CÒÖ%¢>E¢ ¿¸+=KBC>
=?HJ=?JQEHJLN@¦=Õ*=KHJDoJ=KL>µEH;LL¦CDC_*=KH;D=?L>ÊÅcF+H;IKÁÆ
ú ® BC>LDCL·¦L JDC¢
aÖJ>EIKJ§;>£¥H;LL·¦CDE*=?H;D"F+H;IeÁÀI?*=KH;JIe>¡L·¦CÕB¤KLNJ>AIE®
BC>ÏDCHJDµ ¡HJ¿C¦CÊJDC¢8 ¡H;¿C¦CNEH;L@C¦=Õ*=KH;DCJ=KL>AJIe>ÏJ@C@IKH_LN*=K>EÒ¸0=KBC>
?JL>H;D=KBC>DCDo¾A¦C=?>AIE®{F[=KBCH;¦=¥=?>E=?DC§º>_*ÕBGDC¢CÒÖ%¢¦oJQA¦C=?>AIE°©«>¡B¸@ËHJ=KBµ
>EKÎE>=?BC*==?BC>DCH;D%µ ¡H;¿¦CJDC¢ H;¿C¦=KL>A©¿Ë>NJ@C@CIeHaLN*=?>A¸¹=KBC>?JL>
H;DÀ=?BC>HJ=KBC>EIE¦C=?>EIe$*©«>Ev®
w/g"fbc^_xJU f"pf/1pSg"` 1p"g"`
VtrT6U{p,Cyg"`cbdUi cVXwcÏfSjf*t cVXwcÏfSjf*t
noidpaysUK`k`kpi/`kx*UeU ~ ~
XV¹`kx*UeU 1Sx"` 1Sx"`
yetyzPSU a?~ a?~
w,Y nËW r~ r~
#aUKysgabzt,U`vj"U ~ " uY% ~ " 6Y%
VXgST JUipxSidpaysUK`k`kpiz`
Oprbzt,yspAT6xSgabdtrbkjpf"t;bkjT6U e} "
%p_yet,jfEbkUi ÔyspT6T bkjT6U ?ô " ô~
1p"tjfEbdUi ypT6T bdjT6U } ô
!pAT¥T«gSfSjmytrbkjpf pAi( } }"
OtU, -'1pSg"`!AUiz`vg"`fSpAf/1pSg"`QxJUi ÒpidT6tf"ysU,jT¥xjmysjbx*Uei9ÒpAikTutf"ysU
76 C)>
Ý ;BA;vÝ *«(*XA
Ø < Ø
Ü
> Ø
<BCHa©D D J¿C> 1JIe>·=?B> H;¿C¦@!>AIe¨cH;IeLNJDCE>A¡H;DÂ=KBC>º¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=DC¢CÒÖ%¢C¦CJ
E¦Ce=K>EIKHJ¨=KBC>Nä>EE ³½s¼ JDC¢¹=KBC>ºEH;LL¦CDC_*=KH;D¹=KL>EIe>E*=?ÒÖ;>º=?H=KBC>ºDCDo
ÖJ*¦C>AE® BC>$EH;L@C¦=?*=?H;Do*I?"=?H;¥eBCHa©DÀD=KBC>$=?J¿C>E¥=KBo*=¥¨cHJHa©.JIK>¿oJK>A¢ÀH;D
=?BC>·=KHJ=Õ*AH;L@C¦=Õ"=?H;DoJ=?L>E¡IK>A"=?ÒÖ;>¾=?HÊ=?BC>¾½sȳ½ª±µªDCDoA¦e=?>AI2X²,JLDCDC§
J¿> 1H;DC>_*DLNJ§JDC>=?B>$¢C.-NE¦CÒ=ª¸DHJ@=?LÎADC§º Ie¢ÊEH;L@C¦=?*=?H;DC«¢C¦C>=?H
=?BC>¢Ñ!>EIe>ED=@CIKH%E>AKeH;IK6e@!>A>E¢CA°ï³±Ã+°EJÕBC>*°oJDC¢/±È K@Ë>E>E¢uH;D=?BC>$¢CÑ!>EIe>ED=
E¦Ce=K>EIKA®¶oH;I=KBC>u± ±$³¼Í©¥>A@=©D§¡_Je>6=?BC>ueÎA>uHJ¨ï=?BC>6>r>EE¦=ÕJ¿C>ß*0
Ã
Iþ?í GÿKóG!ëGGõôêeòvÿzõ%ÿ
î Aªõôê ÕÿzõòcêGGë
óôòkÿdìóôê
ìóG/ícð Gÿ ríê
îKóAíí
ìýêòvícððê ðkø Iþ?í íEê í,ì þKí
êGG!ë
óôòvÿdìóôê
=ê ÿdìóôêªðËð þKê?>
þKííQòcêG/ý?ëKìícî>%óìþìþ?íG/í
ìóôê
ícî ÿdìóôêªðËÿ í/ê
õÿ
ë?ýKýí ïícðìóGÿdìí
ÿ
îÿ íõÿ HAªí ìþÕÿ
ìþKíQÿzòÔì ë?ÿzõ!Czÿzõôë?ícðkø Iþ?í G/êªðì ícòcí ì Csí ðóôê
êEJìþ?íäJã
òcêî?íòcêG/ý?ëKìí!ìþ?ícðí ÿdìóôêªð
òvê ívòÔìõ ðící!ä÷J÷Jâá ø
wgSf$bc^ExJU 1pSg"` 1pSg"` 1p"g"` 1pSg"`
VtrT6Up,oyg"`vbkUi cVXwc fSjf*t cW\aO $#ËY%#'& cVXwcx
nïikpaysUK`k`kpiQ`kx*UeU ~ ~
XV¹`kx*UeU }} 1Sx"` e}A}¥Y%Sx"` e}}6Y Sx*` K}}6Y Sx"`
yetyzPSU SK~ SK~ ~ ~,
wXY nïW r~ ? 4 Õ
# _UKysgabzt,U{`vj"U ~ " 6Y% ~ " 6Y% ~ " 6Y% ~ " ¥Y%
VXgST JUi/px"ikpaysUK`k`kpiz`
Oprbzt,ypT6xSgabztÕbkjpf*t,JbkjT6U e } ~r}A}ô~ ~,r
%payt,;jfEbkUi ÔyspT6T bkjT6U A" E ,
1p*t,jfAbdUi ypT6T bkjT¥U " " }
!pAT6xSgabdtrbkjpf$idtrbkjp } ô ~
" " }
!pAT6TgSfSjmytrbkjpf pAi ( } }ô } }"
Ot,U-'1pSg"`/xJUi ÒpidTutrf"yUe`pfbkP"U{jfSj!_jag"t,yg"`cbdUiz`
JDC¢G>EK=?BCJDÀ=?BC>_Ö*JJ¿C>³±Ã *@CIeHA>EeKH;IeH;D=?B>¢Ñ!>EIe>ED=$A¦e=?>AIKA®
B¦C
H;DC>¡©¥HJ¦C¢G>@Ë>E==KBo*=u=?B>½sȳ½ª±µªDCDoJDC¢=?B>½sÌ$<
½¥A¦e=?>AIK=?HKBCHa© J¿!HJ¦=
=?BC>?JL>@!>AIe¨cH;IeLNJDCE>«J¿ËHJ=?BBo_Ö;>6ß ÞÎ@CIeHA>EKeH;IKA®
J¿C> 1uKBCHa©X=?BC>½sÌ<
½
E¦Ce=K>EI=KH¿Ë>e§;B=?Ò¸¤KHS©«>EI=?BoJDG=?BC>DCDoÊA¦C=?>AIE®±2@ËH;Ke¿>>@CJDo*=KH;D¤¨cH;I
=?BC¢CÒÑ!>EIK>ADCE>ÂLÊ_¸0=?BC>¤¢CÒÑ>AIK>EDE>ÏD /±È K@Ë>E>E¢E° $ ¡¿C@CʨcHJIÊDCDo+JDC¢ (®$
¿C@¤"=G=KBC>»½sÌ< ½Õ® /Á*>A©K>+H;DC>»LN§;B=G>@Ë>EA=¤=?BC>+£6²Ã²¶A¦e=?>AI¤=KH ¿Ë>
J@C@CIeHaLN*=?>A¸º=ª©E>JKHa©[J{=?BC>DCDoE¦Ce=K>EII?*=KBC>EI=KBoJDʨvJA=KH;IHJ¨/ß%®90=?BC*=
J§JD LÊ_¸ ¿Ë>ÊIe>E*=?>A¢»=KHG=KBC>N¢CÑ!>EIe>ED=±$ÈK@Ë>E>E¢ÀÅ$Ö;>AIKe¦C,(®$ ¿C@ÕÆ®´DC>
©¥H;¦¢»JKH>@Ë>E==KBo*==KBC>º½sÈ$³½ª±µz@¨«E¦Ce=K>EI¡©¥HJ¦C¢ ¿Ë>¨vJA=KH;IHJ¨=ª©«HGeHa©«>EI
=?BoJD DCDoÀDCe=K>_J¢ HJ¨¥¨vJA=KH;I¡HJ¨0®(®·½ªD §;>ADC>EIKJv°XÒ=¡¢C-NA¦C==KHÀ>AÖ*J¦o*=?>¾=KBC>
IK>E*=KÖJ>GL@!HJIe=Õ*DCE>ÀHJ¨=KBC>À¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=N_*ÕBC>KÎE>EA° /±È e@!>A>E¢CA°6JD¢ =?BC>G³±¡Ã
aÖ*JJ¿C>=KHN@IKH%E>EeKH;I@oJI=?E¦CJIeÒ¸¨cH;IºKLNJ/L>EeBQ®
7 : ;kÝ < Ø Ü > Ø +C Ù
<BCHa©D D J¿C>
JIe>»=KBC>+@Ë>EI¨cH;IKLNJDE>E¤H;D[=?BC>»¢CÒÑ>AIK>ED=ÂE¦Ce=K>EIK¤HJ¨·=KBC>
ä>EE ³½s¼.¨cHJI=?BC>± ±$³¼8=?>Ae=«_Je>¨cHJI¢Ñ!>EIe>ED=¥AH;L·¿Do"=?H;DC¥H*¨!=KBC>A¦e=?>AIK
¨cH;I¿!HJ=KB+=KBC>ÊL@CA=¾JDC¢+=KBC>N>@CA=·KH;ÒÖ;>AIK¾Ie>E*=?ÒÖ;>N=?H=?BC>NDCDoG=KL>EA®G¶ïHJI
¿!HJ=KB=KBC>«L@CA=JDC¢¾>r@EÒ=eH;ÖJ>EIe,=?BC>«@!>AIe¨cH;IeLNJDCE>¢C>A§;I?J¢>E,e§JDC¯C_JD=?Ò¸¨cH;I
D=?>AIµzE¦Ce=K>EIAH;L@C¦=Õ"=?H;DCE®½ªD=?>AI*D=?I?SµªE¦C=?>EI$EH;L@C¦=?*=?H;DCJIK>D¢CE*=?>A¢¹¿¸
*µ ¡=?B¦CA°¨cH;I>rC*LN@>*°DCDo"µzE>EL>¨/L>_JDC @IKH%E>EeKH;Ie¥H;DÊDCDo*DC¢ @CIKH%E>AKeH;IK
H;DÀ=?BC>£6²Ã²¶ A¦C=?>AIE®