On Magid's approach to the inverse problem in differential Galois theory.

HAL Id: hal-00129562

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00129562

Preprint submitted on 8 Feb 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

On Magid’s approach to the inverse problem in differential Galois theory.

Jerry Kovacic, Claude Mitschi, Michael F. Singer

To cite this version:

Jerry Kovacic, Claude Mitschi, Michael F. Singer. On Magid’s approach to the inverse problem in differential Galois theory.. 1996. �hal-00129562�

&*,+-.0/'112

354607)8:9;=<?>@48 AB;C>@6D8 AE>F;6HGJI7)BKL;=BM7<N;O;C>@B';C>@6QPR;)B@>F7=8 B6RKS8:BS;=TUI7=I6RU0VXW=Y Z[3548 A\<N;O;C>FB;C>@6

7=] ]:T'K6RK^>@;_7_PC;=TBF>@6CU`6aGb7)9MI']:6dceKT6f>@;^gh;ji'7)PR8 PRk5>@;l>@46m<N;=] ]:;jno8 Bp_3546R;=Uq6R9 cr354'6R;=Uq6R9ts=ZuCv^;=<

Vwv=Y:kqx

y{z@|~}Mj€FFFC€F}h‚,ƒ„z…‡†oˆ‰ƒ„…RŠ„‹NŠŒHLŽ 8 6?chk …R‘“’•”–z@|~—)`€FFRR€F—C‚™˜›š œ † cžEk ƒ„z

”‹N‘“z„…RŸ” ¡‹N‘“’zr¢bz`‘“’z`‘“|ŒR£Oz`Ÿ¤†¡¥^¦¡‹H|–§¨}h©œ ª

ªa«

”–z@|{}¬œ­}h©_® u¯ —R°®±}o°hƒ„zm|–§z

²

ŒRŸ³ŸCz`Š¢bŒR‘“’R‹N‘µ´m’z`Ÿ³‹N£O…|ž‹HŒR‘¶ŒH\š V· © Y ¥y{z@|J¸¬ƒ„zo…~¹_…Rº@‹N¹_…”=}L»hŠ*|r…ƒ@”–z5‹H’z„…”¼ŒH\š V· © Y

…R‘“’¶”–z@|Q½ ƒ„z¨|–§zhHŸC…

²

|–‹HŒR‘‡¾\z@”–’ŒHlš VX © YÀ¿ ¸¡¥ÂÁ§z`‘•½ÄÃŚƋNŠd…_Nj

²

…RŸC’Rˆ)Èbz`Š„Š„‹HŒ|

z`ºO|rz`‘µŠ„‹HŒR‘ÊÉˋH|–§ ¡c ½ ¿ š kÌ͏oÎ É˧z`ŸRz PC;K'8:9oÏ5cr¡c ½ ¿ š kÌÐu 

Ñ`‘D¢b…RŸ)|–‹

²`Ò

”–…RŸ Î ‹Ó  §…RŠÔ‘“Œf…”´Oz@ƒ`ŸC…R‹

² Š Ò

ƒ´@ŸRŒ

Ò

¢ŠDŒH

²

Œ@’R‹N¹_z`‘µŠ„‹HŒR‘!Õ Î |–§z`‘ ¡c ½ ¿ š k œ

 …R‘“’š c © k Ã,šÖ‹NŠl…Ç‹

²

…RŸC’Rˆ)Èbz`Š„Š„‹HŒ|z`ºO|rz`‘µŠ„‹HŒR‘ÊÉˋH|ž§ ¡c š cr © kj¿ š k œ  ¥

3548 AoAe>@7C>F6R9m6RBF>M8 Af8:B'PR;=UqU`6RPa>M7=A\>@4'6×<N;=] ]:;jno8 Bp^6HGJ7=9mI] 6RAhA`4;jntVXØ)Y:ZMÙ0;C>F6Ú>@4'7C>m3546C;=U`6C9›s=Z v

;=<ÔVXv=Y¼8 A8 BPC;=U`Uq6RPH>~7=An~6C]:]A`8 BPR6>@46Ú8:K'6R7=] AI'U`6RAq6RBF>@6CK^8:Bh>@46CA`606aGJ7=9mI]:6CA\47ji6~46R8 p=4F>0]:7=Uqp=6RU>@4'7=B

uCZ

Û~ÜÞÝ'ßà“árâäã¼å Ž 6H>¨Ææ6 †èçé†hê T'BK6RUm7=K'K8X>F8:;)BZéëì<n06mno8 A`4 ê n06í9m7jîéPR;)BA`8 K6RUSÖ>F;‡æ6^7

A`T'æp=U`;)TIí;)<{ï Ž crv=k5æFîJx

cð €Fñ kòó

u ð ñ

ô u ô

ô ô u

3546MU`8 Bp_;=<\Uq6Rp=T] 7=Uh<NTBPa>@8 ;=BA¤;=Bõ8 A † VXoY œõ† Vö €F÷ Ybno46CU`6hö 7=B'K ÷ 7=U`6~>F46SPC;;)U`K8 B7C>F6

<NTBPa>@8 ;=BAqxDöøcrð €Fñ k œ ð_7)BK ÷ crð €Rñ k œ­ñ ZlëÀ>×8:A0B;C>@4'8:Bp!9m;=Uq6Ú>@4'7=BS>@4'6×U`8 BpL;=<ËI;=]wîJB;=9m8:7)]:Af8 B

>@4'6L8:B'K6H>F6RU`9m8 B7C>F6RA~ö 7=B'K ÷ Zù3546 Ž 8 6L7=] p=6CæU`7Ê;)<5U`8 p=4F>`ú„8 BFi7=U`8 7=BF>^K6CU`8wi'7‰>@8 ;=BA^ce;„i6RU † k×47)A

ûrüCýµþÿÿ\ü ¨ýý !#"

$&%

'()*,+-/.01 -1 3254 76894:(<;*Lþ=4#1>6?()='(<6A@*-(<'CB4#'::*C_ÿ9.DE)5F3*G.076

HI'14'JKF#"LM-4'NO#*:PfÿQ+-RS-41

T

U#:: lÿQ4#:#V<()44#W?(<=#':()YX#HIZ4#::89[Q2\4: 894#()1']^_]R`"#a#b>#.04V)()P Q\ÿca>F#db#ef"#abK

gji gjl

m 6n'B6 —)œ uf7=BK —#oڜ ØREZD3546RAq67=Uq6h8:B š 7=BK_7=U`6h] 8:B'6R7=Uq]Xî‡8 BK6CIJ6CBK6RBF>×;„i6RU † Z Ž 6a> } æ6

7mK6RUq8Xi7C>F8:;)Bí;=B š V· © Y œ š ®qp_† V·hYK6n'B6RKí7=A5<N;=] ]:;jnoA`x

}М r

r  ® uÔ¯™u ® s

s ö

¯•ØC ® s

s ÷

t

;=BAq8:K6CU>F46h8:K'6R7=]0u œ cž ® u » u ® ö €  o ® u » u ®•÷ k5;=< š VXoY ZQ3546RB

} cž ® u » u ® ö k œ u ® u » u ® u œ ô

7=BK

} cž

o ® u » u ® ÷ k œ ØC ® u » ØR ® u œ ô

354?TAvul8:A7 } ú„K'8fw6RUq6RBF>@8 7=]b8 K6C7=]J;)< š VXoY Z[ÙÚ;C>@6>@47C>~8:<'n06~8 K6RBF>F8:<Óî š VXoY=no8w>@4 š Vö €F÷ Y>@4'6RB

u œ cžö »  €F÷±»  o

k`Z

Ù0;jntPC;=BAq8:K6CUh>F46^A`Tæ'Ar>@8w>@T*>@8 ;=B 4';=9m;=9m;=U`I4'8:Aq9yx xö òó  €F÷ òó  o

;jiµ6RU š Z ëìB ;‰>@46CU

n0;=U`KA ê x•x š V·hY œšé®ø† VXoY“ó š 8 Afp=8wiµ6RBdæFî c:z °J®|{?° kDòó c:z °:{O° cž €  o

kqk`ZC}hB6lPC7=B A`4;jn

>@4'7C>f>@48 Ao8:Ah7 } >F;

r ¿ r  K8~wJ6CU`6CB@>F8:7)]4';=9m;=9m;=U`I4'8:Aq9¬no4;=A`6c)6CU`B6C]8:A5uZ/€8:B'PR6~>@46M8 9M7)p=6l;=<

x±8 A~7An6C]:K c

‹H¥Nz@¥

Î š k ê

u!8 A~7L9m7CGJ8:9m7=]{8:K'6R7=]

ê

7=BKM>@46CU`6R<N;)U`6×7L9m7CGJ8 9m7=] K8~w6RU`6CBF>@8 7=]Ô8 K6R7=] Z‚[T*>

½ œ š VXoY:¿Kuù8 A¡8 A`;=9m;=UqI48 PM>@; š Z 3546¨ïo7=] ;=8:AMp=Uq;=TI Sc½ ¿ š kM8 Ao>F46_8:K6CBF>@8w>ìî ê no48 P„4±8:AM;=<

PR;OK8 9m6RBAq8:;=BíØS8 BíoZWƒ 6hB;‰>@6[>@47‰>7)U`æ8w>@Uq7=UrîdPC;K'8:9m6RB'A`8 ;=B¨PC7=B¨æ6h7=P„48 6Hiµ6CKÊæFî‡TA`8 Bp¡ œ,†

‚

7=BK_6R] 6R9m6CB@>FA —C°Þœ…„ 

°Y†µ

€„œ u €FFRR€‡ Z

ˆ

B7)]Xî7‰R8 BpÚ>F48 A6aGb7)9MI']:6Ú<NTUr>F46RUA`4;jnoAEno46RUq6>@4'6Ú7=Uqp=T9m6RBF>~8:Bf>@46DIUq;;=<J;=<b354'6R;=Uq6R9Ðs=Z v¤8 A

B;C>i7=]:8 KZIƒÂ8w>@4LB';C>@7C>F8:;)BA[7=AæJ6C<N;=U`6

ê

] 6H>\Š

œ

€'IJ6CP

† VEY

œ ˆ 

p

7=A\8 B¤>F46~IUq;;=<b;=<3546R;)U`6R9Ös=Z v

8 B¨Vwv=Y“c>@46 —C° 46RUq6D4'7„i6ÚB';oK'6RB;=9m8 B7C>F;=U`Aqk`Z53546CB‹Š ç  œ €I6RP † V € ö €F÷ Y7)BKh>F4658 U`U`6CKTPC8:æ] 6

i7=U`8 6H>ìî K6nB'6RK‡æ@î¨>@46l8 K6R7)]Wuí8 A\>@46mUq7C>@8 ;=B7=]{PRTUeiµ6cŒ œ €IJ6CP † V € ö €F÷ Y:¿µcžö »  €F÷™»  o k`Z

3546hp=6CB6RUq8:PhI;=8:BF>5€I6RP

š

;=<UŠ cr7=A5æ6R<N;=Uq6

ꚙœ †

c–Ek`k5æ6RPC;=9m6RAQ7=B

š

újIJ;)8:BF>h;=<Š

ç

éiJ8:7f>@4'6

B7C>FTU`7)]“4';=9m;=9m;=U`I4'8:Aq9 † V € ö €F÷ Ybó † V € ö €F÷ Y:¿µc–ö €F÷ k`YJó š ZfëÀ>6HG?>@6CBKA>F;¡7=B š újIJ;)8:BF>¤;=<

Š ç  no48 P„4S8 A ‘“Œ| 7=B š ú„I;=8:BF>D;=<Œ ê A`8 BPC6Ë>F4658 K6R7=]Žuh8 AB';C>QPR;)B@>F7=8 B6RKM8:Bf>@4'6`)6RUqB6R]“c–ö €F÷ kÔ;=<

† V € ö €F÷ Yó š Z}oBí]:8 B6oØ=Wm;=<5Vwv=Yê 7=Bí8 9mI] 8:PC8X>7=A`AqT9mI>@8 ;=BÊ8 AD9M7)K6Q>F47C>LcrT'A`8 Bpo>F46hB;C>@7‰>@8 ;=B

;=<ÚVwv=Y:klc €‘ k~8 Af7!IJ;=8 BF>m;=<MŒ ’ ê >F47C>m8 A ê c”“ €‘ k~8 Af7!IJ;)8:BF>M;=<•ŒÖc š k~<N;=U07=]:]“ ˜ š ZSëìB¡>F46l7=æ;„i6

6HGJ7=9mI] 6 c”“ €‘ k œ c–“ € ô € ô kh7=BK—Œèc š k œ™˜ c”“ € “ € “ o k € “ ˜ š5š 7=BK¶A`;mn~6SA`6R6h>@47‰>¤>F48:Ao8 AB;C>o>@4'6

PR7)A`6RZ

}hB6hPR7=B_7=] A`;MPR;=BAe>@UqTPH>¤7MPR;=TBF>F6RU`6aGJ7=9mI]:6¤<N;=U57mU`6CKTPH>F8Xi6p=Uq;=TIZ

Û~ÜÞÝ'ßà“ár◛ å Ž 6H>M œ ï Ž c‡ k`Z Ž 6a>œ °)ž æ60>@46lPC;;)U`K8 B7C>F6×<NTBPa>@8 ;=BAf;=B ïoZ 354?TA`œ °)ž c”Ÿk œ Ÿ ° ž

no46CB6Hi6RU¡Ÿ ˜ ï Ž c‡ kqZ 3546_U`8 Bp‡;=<0Uq6Rp=T']:7=Um<NTB'PH>@8 ;=BA † V·hY58 A † Vœ ° ž³€



¢J£¥¤§¦

Y:Zø3546_K6RUq8Xi7C>F8:;)BA

}h° ž\œ ¨ œ ž ¨ g

g

¦©)ª

<N;=U`9è7Sæ7)A`8 AD;)< Ž 8 6chk¤c

² ZoV uCYê IZ5v=ØK«=kqZ ˆ AQæ6R<N;=Uq6 ê ] 6H> š œ,† cžEkqZ

}hB6[no8:Aq46RA>@;,nBK —=ìj€FRFR€F—C‚R‚טš 7=BK,¬ ìj€FFRC€ ¬ ‚R‚l˜ùš AqTP„4M>F47C>Fx

uCkÔ>@46 —C° ž 7=Uq6f]:8 B6R7)U`]wî‡8:BK'6RI6RBK6CBF>l;jiµ6CU †hê

v=kQ8:< }œ ª

ªa«

® uÔ¯

° ž

—R° ž ®±}o°)ž >@46CB ¸ 8:AQ7 } ú„Ae>@7=æ']:6h8 K6R7=] Z

ƒ•65no8 ] ]'>@46CBí47ji6¤7MPR;=T'B@>F6RUq6HGJ7=9mI] 6D>@;~>F46[>@46C;=U`6C9MZ

Ž 6R7jiµ6oPR;=B'K8X>F8:;)B u~7=A`8 K6h<N;=U >F46h9M;)9M6CBF>@Z

t

;=BK8w>@8 ;=B_ØS8 AQA`7C>F8:An6RKíA`;M]:;=B'pM7)ADK'6H>c”¬µk58:AQB;‰>

ô Z53548 AD8:AQ6­?T8wi7=] 6RBF>Ú>F;SAq7jîb8 Bpf>@47‰>q¬

˜  © Z t

;=B'K8X>F8:;)B¨vm8:AQ9m;=Uq6o8 BF>@6CU`6RAe>@8 Bp=Z

} c”¬®#¯ ® u » u ® œ®#¯*k œ ¬K°

®#¯

® u »

° ž

—R° žÔ®•}o°)ž œ®#¯

œ ¬ °

®#¯

® u »

°)ž

¨

—R° žÔ® œ ž ¨ s

œ±®¯

s œ °¨

œ ¬ °®#¯ ® u » ž — ® žÔ® œ ž ¯

² ¬ °

®#¯

® u » ž — ® ž ¬ ž ¯ ® u ce9M;OK ¸ k 

€;¶8X>¨A`T´³mPC6RA>@;µnBK 79m7C>@Uq8XG¶¬

œ

c”¬®#¯*kSAqTP„4>@4'7C>‹¬ °®#¯

œ ž — ® ž ¬ ž ¯ ê

;=U

ê

8:B 9m7C>@Uq8XG <N;=Uq9

ê

—!œ ¬ °¬

†µ

Z

ëìBé;=U`K6CU>@47‰>d7=] ]>@46 PC;=BK8w>@8 ;=BA!æ6 A`7‰>@8 An6CK ce8:BPC]:T'K8:B'p PC;=BK8w>@8 ;=BäuCk

ê

n06‡B'6R6RKù>F;·nBK

6HGJ7=9mI] 6RA_;=<v¬ ˜  © AqTP„4 >F47C>!>F46 PR;O;=U`K'8:B7‰>@6RA^;=<h8w>@A^] ;=p=7=Uq8X>F49m8:P K6CU`8wi7C>@8wiµ6‡7=U`6 ] 8 B6R7=Uq]Xî

8 BK6RI6RB'K6RBF>l;ji6RU † Z¸ƒ•6hB;jnK;f>@48 AQ<N;=U5ï Ž crØ=kqZ Ž 6a>

ð œ Ø±¹

ñ œ

رº

» œ ر¼

r œ Ø «

no46CU`6!>@46G½

€¾J€¿l€

Í7=U`6dI;=A`8w>@8wiµ6d8 B@>F6Rp=6CU`A_P„4;=Aq6RB Aq;d>F47C>!no8w>@4À½™Á

¾ Á ¿

Áĝ ce8:Bø<N7=Pa>

ð œ Ø €Fñ\œ Ø o € » œ Ø € r œ ØÃ[no8:] ]n~;=U?k`Z Ž 6H>¬ œ c–¬®¯k œ



«Ä



«Å



«±Æ



«Ç

ƒ 6[>F46RB_47jiµ65>@47‰>q¬

°¬

†µ

œ 

« Ä 

« Å



« Æ 

« Ç ° 

«Ç

» 

« Å

» 

« Æ 

«Ä

ÈÉKÊ ÉKËÉ ª



Ê ÉKË

» 

ÈÉ ª

3“;‡Aq4;jn¬>F47C>×>F46^6RBF>@Uq8:6CAM;)<Ë>F48 AM9m7C>FU`8wG±7=Uq6!]:8 B6C7=U`]wîé8 BK6RI6RB'K6RBF>¨;„i6RU~>@4'6!PR;=BAe>@7=BF>FA ê 8w>^8 A

6RB';=Tp=4l>@;mA`4';„n >@47C>5>F46h6RBF>@Uq8:6CAÚ;)<>@4'6o<N;)]:]wn~;)8:Bpm9m7C>FU`8wGd7=U`6h] 8:B'6R7=Uq]Xî‡8 BK6CIJ6CBK6RBF>



« Ä 

« Å



«±Æ



«Ç

° 

«Ç

» 

« Å

» 

«±Æ



« Ä œ † È

« ÄÌKÍ

† Ê

« ŖÌÎÍ

† Ë

« Æ ÌÎÍ

† ª

« Ç ÌKÍ



«Ç

» 

« Å

» 

«±Æ



« Ä

œ † È

«ÄÌ Ç ÌKÍ

¯ Ê

« ÆÌ>ŖÌKÍ

È

«ÄÌOŖÌÎÍ

» Ê

«ÄÌOŖÌÎÍ

† Ë

« ÆÌ ÇÌKÍ

¯ ª

« ÆÌ ÇÌKÍ

Ë

«Å–Ì ÆÌÎÍ

» ª

«ÄÌ Ç ÌÎÍ

AqA`T9m65n~6o47jiµ6o7mU`6C]:7C>F8:;)B ô œ

Ï c » ð



È#É ª É  ¯ ñ



ËÉKÊ É



k¯ÑÐ!c

ð



ÈÉKÊ É

 » ñ



ÈÉKÊ É



k¯ † c » »



ËÉ ª É  ¯ r



ËÉ ª É 

k¯ } c »



Ê ÉKËÉ

 » r



ÈÉ ª É  k

<N;=UA`;=9m6fPR;)BAr>F7=BF>@A

Ï € Ð €F†Ú€R} Z€8 BPC6

r ¯ »

¯øu`Ò

r

¯ùðQ¯±uÒ

» ¯ ñ ¯øu`ҙð[¯ ñ ¯øulc>@46CA`6f7=Uq6

ØCúj7=K8 Pf6HGJI7=BAq8:;)BA`kn~6h9T'Ar>47jiµ65>@47C>

† c r » » k œ ô

Ï c » ðkE¯ } c» r k œ ô

Ï c ñ k“¯ } c » k œ ô

ÐLcð »±ñ k œ ô

€8 BPR6

r Ò »

7)BK ñ Ò ð ê n06047ji6>@4'7C> †™œ Ð œ ô Z9€8 BPC60ð

» Ò ñ r

n06047ji6>@4'7C> » ð » ¯ ñ

rÔÓ

œ ô Aq;

Ï œ} œ ô Z×354'6RU`6C<N;=U`60>F46×6CB@>FU`8 6RAf;=<Õ¬

°¬

†µ

7=Uq6×] 8:B6C7=U`]wî8:BK'6RI6RBK6CBF>@Z ˆ A`8 9m8:] 7=U~8 K6R7!Aq4;=T] K

n0;=UL<N;)U5ï Ž c‡ k €‡ ÒøØS7=A n06R] ] Z

V uCY\ÖZ×ÚZÞgh;=] P„48 BÙØ ‹)Ú0z`ŸRz`‘“|–‹H…”EÛo”´Oz@ƒ`ŸC…L…R‘“’ÜÛo”´Oz@ƒ`ŸC…R‹

²‚Ý

ŸCŒ

Ò

¢Š„ê ˆ PC7=K6R9m8 PÜÞUq6RA`A ê u#«=s=v=Z

VwØ=Y\ßZgh;„i7=PC8:P ê0àˆì¹_…R‹H”

²

ŒR¹l¹

Ò

‘µ‹

²

…|–‹HŒR‘ |rŒCÛ¥Õáù…R´@‹H’ Ώ⠥_á|–Š

²

§‹ Î áù¥)ãQ¥_䵋N‘µ´Oz`Ÿ Î z@|r¥Ë…”–¥å 7)U`P„4

Ø ê u#«>«Kæ=Z

Vwv=Y ˆ Z å 7=p)8:K ê{y{z

² |Ò

ŸCz`ŠLŒR‘ Ø ‹)Ú0z`ŸCz`‘“|ž‹H…”

Ý

…”–ŒR‹NŠ Á§z„ŒRŸ³ ê s êçޑµ‹N£Oz`Ÿ³Š„‹H|– Ly{z

² |Ò

ŸCz5ä“z`Ÿ³‹Hz`Š„ê´è ;=] Z{s ê

ˆ

9m6RUq8:PC7=B å 7C>@4'6R9m7C>@8 PR7)]U€';PC8:6a>ìî ê u#«K«)W=Z

VwW=Y t Z å 8w>@A`P„4'8 ê´å ZféÔZ΀'8:Bp)6RU ê ⠌R‘µ‘“z

²

|z„’f”‹N‘“z„…RŸ´@ŸCŒ

Ò

¢ŠÚ…RŠÚ’R‹)Ú0z`ŸCz`‘“|ž‹H…”

Ý

…”–ŒR‹NŠ´@ŸCŒ

Ò

¢Š0ŒR£Oz`Ÿ† cžEk ê

>@;m7=II6R7)U58:B—ê Œ Ò

Ÿ³‘“…”ŒHvÛo”´Oz@ƒ`ŸC… Z