HAL Id: inria-00074341
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074341
Submitted on 24 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Tolerating Node Failures in Cache Only Memory Architectures
Michel Banâtre, Alain Gefflaut, Christine Morin
To cite this version:
Michel Banâtre, Alain Gefflaut, Christine Morin. Tolerating Node Failures in Cache Only Memory Architectures. [Research Report] RR-2335, INRIA. 1994. �inria-00074341�
ISSN 0249-6399
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Tolerating Node Failures in Cache Only Memory Architectures
Michel Banˆatre, Alain Gefflaut, Christine Morin
N˚ 2335
Aoˆut 1994
PROGRAMME 1
(
) *& +," "!%'- ./0
13254768:9<;=?>A@=?BCD8E:FGH9I=?2J>3KL8NMO=?P/BQERFTS*6/C2IUB2V>8L1XW?C2V>*E
Y[Z]\7^DZ`_abacdfe gfZihkjmlonpchqnprmZ]cs-tu_Zi_vwvJxcvwcys{zN|}_7s~cysfNcAN\Dmccys{zmZcys~c_rm
cn.sI msIn'xcabcsNls~n]Zplw|r"cs
Y-Zp\7Ic'n<R\7volN\DZ
._tmtu\DZpnNcZpch`jmcZihkjmc77D0e g.\rndDe 7tu_^Dcs
Q{m7R ¡*¢"£f¤I¦¥§I¨R©ª /«7¬®¯¡©`°±²~¢²]§~¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²I©q£i·[¥²~©¸¥y«³µ«D´~©`²I©q£V´V³µ«R¹b§~¬o¥£~£
±º-¬o¥²I¹©A£I§`¥{¬µ©A£V¨:¥y²I©q»°©`°±²I°¶7¬µ´V³µ¼R²I±R§p©q£I£V±²]£`½A¾[¨R©`b©p¿R´I©`«:»À´I¨R©A§p±«:§p©`¼R´p£"±º§`¥§~¨R©
°©`°ª±²V³µ©q£.¥«:»£V¨:¥y²I©q»Á³®²~´I¶:¥{¬°©`°±²IÂD¶:£Ã³µ«R¹*´I¨R©¸¬®±R§`¥{¬Q°©`°ª±²V³µ©q£±º¦´~¨R©«R±R»7©q£.¥£
¬o¥²I¹©A§`¥§~¨R©q£º±².¥£Ã³µ«R¹¬µ©0£5¨:¥²I©q»¯¥»R»7²~©q£I£"£V¼:¥§p©½Ä¶R©´~±´I¨R©p³µ²"¬o¥²I¹©ª«D¶R°<Â:©`²f±º[§p±°Å
¼N±«R©`«D´p£`ÆR´I¨R©q£V©"¥²]§~¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²I©q£¥²I©¼:¥²I´V³o§p¶7¬o¥²V¬µ*£V¶:£I§p©`¼R´5³®Â7¬µ©f´I±<¨:¥²]»7Ç/¥²I©-ºÈ¥{³É¬µ¶R²I©q£¥«:»A£5±
ºÈ¥¶7¬µ´.´I±y¬®©`²p¥«:§p©<°©q§I¨:¥y«7³Ê£5°A£"¨:¥{Á©f´I±Â:©f³µ«D´~²I±Ë»7¶:§p©q»À´I±©`«:£V¶R²I©A¥¨7³µ¹¨¯¥{Á'¥'³Ì¬o¥Â7³É¬É³µ´V½ÍÈ«
´I¨7³o£T¼:¥¼:©`²qÆmÇ-©<¼R²I±¼N±D£V©¥«³µ°¼7¬µ©`°©`«7´]¥´V³µ±«¯±yºQÂ:¥§IÎ7Ç/¥²]»Ï©`²I²I±²²I©q§p±Á©`²Iϳ®«¯¥/ ¡¢
Ç/¨7³o§~¨Ð°<³µ«7³µ°<³µÑ`©q£¼:©`²Vº±²I°A¥y«:§p©b»7©`¹²]¥»R¥´V³µ±«Ð¥«:»%²I©qÒ¶7³®²~©q£ª¬Ì³µ´I´5¬®©À¨:¥²]»7Ç/¥²I©°±Ë»³ÉÓ§`¥Å
´V³µ±«:£k½L¾-¨7³o£<³µ°¼7¬µ©`°©`«7´]¥´5³®±«L¶:£V©q£ª´I¨R©º©q¥´I¶R²I©q£f±º.¥H/ ¡¢3´I±³®°ª¼7¬®©`°ª©`«D´*¥¯£5´]¥Â7¬µ©
£V´~±²]¥¹©¥Â:£V´I²]¥§p´V³µ±«¶:£Ã³µ«R¹´I¨R©"£V´]¥y«:»R¥²]»<°©`°ª±²V³µ©q£Ô±ºu´I¨R©¥y²]§I¨7³µ´I©q§p´~¶R²I©½QÕ-©q§p±Á©`²I»R¥´]¥
¥²~©²I©`¼7¬É³Ê§`¥y´I©q»Ö¥«:»H°<³É¿Ë©q»×Ç-³µ´I¨Ø§p¶R²~²I©`«D´»R¥´]¥Ï³µ«L«R±R»7©*°©`°±²V³µ©q£<Â:±´~¨L±ºÇ¨7³Ê§~¨Ø¥y²I©
°A¥y«:¥¹©q»ª³µ«b¥<´~²]¥«:£V¼:¥²~©`«D´-Ç/¥{A¶:£Ã³µ«R¹¥«©p¿R´I©`«:»7©q»*§p±¨R©`²~©`«:§p©.¼R²I±´~±Ë§p±¬È½
ÙÏÚDÛuÜVÝ<Þßà?áâ
£I§`¥{¬o¥Â7³É¬É³®´VÆ?°<¶7¬µ´V³µ¼R²I±Ë§p©q£~£V±²¥y²]§I¨7³µ´I©q§p´~¶R²I©Æu£V¨:¥²I©q»ã°©`°±²IÆu¥{Á¥{³É¬Ê¥yÂ7³Ì¬É³µ´VÆ
Â:¥§~Î7Ç[¥y²]»©`²I²I±²-²I©q§p±Á©`²~Æ:£Ã³µ°<¶7¬Ê¥y´V³µ±«
äåæ
ç5èIéê
æ
çëÔìoèIíÃî`ï
ðñòfóõô{öÈ÷øöÈòIùÃòIúûÈò]üýÉúûÈñýÉù/ø7þ`ø7òIöýÉù/ø7þ`öÈûÃýµþ`ÿÉÿúDüò]üûÈñò mð%öÈòIùÃò]þ`öÈñVô{úûÈöJþVû
ú7òIö! #"$"%"%&"VðñýÌùNøDþ`ø7òIöuóýÉÿÉÿþ`ÿÉùÈô-þ`øø7ò]þköuýÉú/ûÈñòøöÈôVòIò]üyýÌú'qùuô)(øDòIö*?ô,+
øûÈýÉú'-#./*þ`ùÈñýÌú'qûÈô{ú0 *.1ô$2{ò37òIö45$+3!6.7$8
9$:
Dþ`úDþkûÈöÃò$;
:
'qò<þû3;
:
.ô{öÈýÉú=;$>QýÉöÃýÌùVþoö
Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes
IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – T´el´ecopie : (33) 99 84 71 71
# ( + - ã ' R ' % . LL
ÚËáÚbâ
©q£¥²]§~¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²I©q£/ ¡¢ ¤I¦¥§~¨R©< /«7¬µ*¡©`°±²I¢²]§~¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²I©q£p·-£V±«7´¦¶R«R©
§~¬o¥£I£5©<³µ«D´©`²I©q£I£I¥y«D´I©<»7©q£"¥²]§~¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²I©q£°<¶7¬µ´V³µ¼R²I±R§p©q£I£V©`¶R²]£T©p¿Ë´I©`«:£J³®Â7¬µ©q£¥ª°©`°±y³®²~©¼:¥y²I´]¥Å
¹©`©½ ¬Ì¬µ©q£ ©`´~©`«:»7©`«D´Ô¬µ©q£/§p±«:§p©`¼R´]£-»7©"°!©`°±³µ²I©q£Ô§`¥§I¨R©"©`´/»7©°!©`°ª±³µ²I©Á³µ²I´I¶R©p¬É¬µ©.¼:¥²~´]¥¹©`©
¼:¥² ¬#"¶R´V³É¬É³Ê£~¥´V³µ±«b»7©q£ °!©`°ª±³µ²I©q£?¬µ±R§`¥{¬µ©q£¦»7©q£Ô«$"¶:»R£-§p±°°ª©§`¥§~¨R©q£¦»7©¹²]¥y«:»7©/´]¥{³É¬É¬µ©.»%"¶R«
©q£V¼:¥§p©A»%"¥»7²I©q£~£I¥¹©<¼:¥²I´p¥¹©"¶R«7³oÒ¶R©½ÔQ±°¼R´I©<´I©`«7¶¯»7©<¬µ©`¶R².¹²p¥«:»«R±°<ÂR²I©»7©A§p±°¼N±Å
£I¥y«D´]£kÆ §p©q£ª¥²]§~¨7³®´~©q§p´I¶R²I©q££V±«7´¼:¥y²I´V³o§p¶7¬É³&©`²I©`°©`«7´0£5¶('J©`´I´~©q£¥y¶7¿×»)©pº¥{³É¬É¬o¥«:§p©q£ª°A¥´©`²V³µ©p¬Ì¬µ©q£
²I©`«:»R¥y«D´<«*©q§p©q£~£I¥{³µ²I©ª¬&"³®«7´I²I±R»7¶:§p´V³µ±«Ö»7©A°!©q§`¥«7³o£V°©q£<»7©´I±¬+©`²]¥y«:§p©0¥¶7¿ºÈ¥¶R´I©q£f¼:±¶R²¹7¥Å
²]¥y«D´V³µ²<¶R«R©¨:¥¶R´I©»³Ê£5¼:±«7³µÂ7³É¬µ³µ´©½ÔÄ"¥«:£<§p©`´¸¥y²I´V³o§~¬µ©Æõ«R±¶:£.¼R²~±¼:±D£5±«:£T¬Ê¥°<³o£V©©`«,$"¶RÁD²I©
»%"¶R«Ö°!©q§`¥«7³o£V°©¯»7©²I©`´I±¶R²¥²I²5³&©`²I©b»R¥y«:£¶R«R©ã¥y²]§I¨7³µ´I©q§p´~¶R²I©H/ ¡¢ Ò¶7³.°<³µ«7³µ°<³o£V©À¬o¥
»)©`¹²]¥»R¥´5³®±«L»7©q£<¼:©`²Vº±²I°¥«:§p©q£©`´ª²I©qÒ¶7³µ©`²I´¼:©`¶Ð»7©°±R»³ÉÓ§`¥´V³µ±«:£°A¥y´-©`²V³µ©p¬É¬µ©q£`½-Q©`´~´I©
°<³o£V©©`«!$"¶RÁD²~©´V³µ²I©¼R²I±Ó:´A»7©q£ª§`¥²]¥´©`²V³o£V´V³oÒ¶R©q£"³µ«R¨*©`²I©`«D´~©q£¥¶7¿L¥²]§~¨7³®´~©q§p´I¶R²I©q£/ ¡¢
¼N±¶R²A±.}²5³®²<¶R«R©*¥Â:£5´I²]¥§p´V³µ±«L»7©°!©`°±³µ²I©£V´]¥yÂ7¬®©©`«%¶R´V³É¬É³Ê£~¥«D´ª¬µ©q£<°!©`°±³µ²I©q£<£V´]¥«:»R¥y²]»
»7©¬#"¥²p§I¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²~©½
©q£/»7±«R«*©`©q£-»7©"²-©q§p¶R¼*©`²]¥´V³µ±«A£5±«D´-²©`¼7¬É³ÊÒ¶*©`©q£[©`´[§p±«:£V©`²IÁ/©`©q£-¥{Á©q§-¬µ©q£
»7±«R«*©`©q£<§p±¶R²]¥«7´I©q£.»R¥y«:£"¬µ©q£f°!©`°±³µ²I©q£.»7©q£f«$"¶:»R£`½
©q£<»7©`¶7¿´VD¼N©q£.»7©»7±«R«0©`©q£<£V±«7´
¹©`²©q£Ô»7©"ºÈ¥21§p±«´I²p¥«:£V¼:¥²I©`«7´I©¼:¥²/¶R«¼R²I±´I±R§p±¬µ©.»7©§p±¨*©`²I©`«:§p©3©`´~©`«:»7¶u½
4 Þ65qá`Ü87:9(Úâ
©p¿Ë´~©`«:£Ã³µÂ7³Ì¬É³µ´©Æ¥²p§I¨7³µ´I©q§p´I¶R²~©.°<¶7¬µ´V³µ¼R²I±Ë§p©q£~£V©`¶R²qÆR°!©`°±³µ²I©¼:¥²I´]¥y¹;©`©Æ7»³Ê£5¼:±«7³µÅ
9 :
¯-H%L .'
:h_v_|vwc¯Rju_Z]c<;Hca\7Z] =;Hrmvwn]lwtmZ]\:h{cspsI\7Zis/>Im;?;A@_Z]cn]jm\7r^7j:nªn]\H|ucb_ã^D\R\:
s~\Dvwrmn]lw\7*np\¸_7h`jmlwcCB:lw^fn]jmc"npcZi_EDu\Dtus-h{\Datmrmn]lwm^.tu\FcZ-ccNc|: ^7Zi_u*hkj}_vwvocm^Dc
_tmtvwlh'_nplo\7uss~ruh`jb_7s"h{volwa¯_npcab\:Ncvwlom^<\DZj:rma¯_cf^Dcm\7abcGHjmcsIc<_Z`h`jmlwn]ch{n]rmZpcs
h{\7}s~lsIn\I_Hs~c'nª\Ih{\7abtmrmn`_nplo\7Lm\:NcsAh{\7:n`_lwmlom^HtmZ]\:h{cs]s~\7Zis{z¦h_7h`jmcs_}%acCJ
a\7Z]lwcsqzuh{\7mch{n]cH|N _jmlo^7jJÈ|u_}F"lNn]j%vo\F v_npcuhq Hlw:npc'Z`h{\Dmmch{n]lw\DÀcn6F\7Z!KLG
:h_v_|lwvwlonI RzR_7h`jmlocCBRc|: npjmcs]h_v_|mvocfloNn]cZ`hq\7mmcyh{nplo\7mcn6F\7ZK*_unpjmcNls~npZ]lw|mr5J
npc*a¯_loac'a\7Z] Rz7_vwvo\MF.s"_v_Zp^7c:rma*| c'Z-\MI¦tmZp\:hqcspsI\7Z`sn]\|ucªr}s~cNF"lonpj¯_^D\R\:
c7Oãh{lwc}h{ G-Rju_ZpcÐaca\DZp HtZp\BNlNcs_PDuc:lw|mvoc¯_} tu\FcZ6IÈrmv.h{\7abtmrmnplom^Hc'B:lJ
Zp\Dmac:nCGHQF\3BD_Z]l_nplw\Dus\MIQn]jmcsIc<_Z`h`jmlwn]ch{nprZpcsÔj}_EBRc.cac'Zp^7cyLRS_7h`jmcS/\7jmc'Zpc:n
Tf\7<U.mlVIÈ\DZpaW;Hcab\7Zp bg<hhqcspsa¯_DhkjlwmcsX>YS+S TZUZ;g@4[Êd7zd'\VzF"jmlhkjs~ni_nplh_vovw
NlB:l:c"npjmc"a¯_lwac'a\7Z] <_a\7m^n]jmc"m\:Ncs/\MI npjmc._Z`h`jmlwn]ch{nprZpcRzD_uS_7h`jmc].mvw
;Hca\DZp *gfZihkjmlonpchqnprmZ]csQ>YS+]4;g<s8@X[µd{mzõdC^\_F"jmlh`jhq\7BRcZpn/npjcªtucZm\:Ncacab\7Zp
lw:np\ _v_Zp^7cbh_Dhkjmc\I"n]jmcsIju_Z]cL_7mNZ]cspssItu_7h{cËzÔh'_vwvoc_Øg"npnpZi_7h{n]lw\D<;Hca\7Z]
>VgZ;A@`G
afrcªn]\npjclwZ"louh{Zpcy_7s~lom^*Nrma*|ucZ\Ih{\Datu\7mc:n`s|u\Dnpj$S+S%JTZUZ;g a¯_7h`jmlomcs
_uS+]4;g<sÔju_CBRcRz:cs~tmlonpc._lwatu\7Z]n`_NnQlwuhqZpc_Ds~c"lwAju_ZiF"_Zpc.Zpcvol_|mlwvolwnI Rz_XBRcZp
jmlw^Dj tmZ]\7|u_|mlwvolwnI Ön]\cNtucZ]lwc}h{cju_Z`F_ZpcbIJ_lovwrmZ]cs7G%H\7vocZ`_nplw^m\:NccIJ_lwvormZpcsls
npjmc'Zpc7IÈ\DZpc+BRcZ] ªloatu\7Z]n`_:ndIÈ\DZ/_ZihkjmlonpchqnprmZ]cs r}s~c3IÈ\7Z-vo\7m^Z]rmmmlom^Ah{\7atrmn`_nplw\Dus7G
eu_rmvon<np\DvwcZi_uh{c|uchq\7acs"npjca¯_}m_n]\7Zp Z`_npjmcZnpju_%\Dtmnplo\7u_vfIÈ\DZ<v_Zp^Dc*sph_vwc
s~ju_Zpc¯aca\DZp AarmvonplotmZp\:h{cysps~\DZ"_Z`h`jmlwn]ch{nprZpcsG
gVnpjls<tu_tucZ'zhFc*tmZp\Dt \Ës~c¯_¯mcCF s~\7vormnplo\7Lnp\ h{\Dt ciF"lwnpjLa*rmvwn]lwtmvoc<npZi_usIlwc:n
_usIlwm^Dvwct c'Zpa¯_mc:nm\:NcQIJ_lovwrmZ]cslw_S+]Z;g"G]frZ/_tmtZp\R_Dhkjr}s~csQ_f|u_DhKF"_Z`
cZpZ]\7Z<Z]ch{\BRcZ] ¯sph`jmcac/[ÊdMjk\dF"jcZpcn]jmcZ]ctmvwlh_n]lw\DHach`ju_mlsIas/\MI_cS+]4;g3_Zpc
rus~cynp\cusIrmZpc.npjc<h{\Dus~c'ZBD_n]lw\7ã_uZ]ctmvolh_nplw\D\MIQZ]ch{\BRcZp Am_n`_lw*npjmcgZ;s-\MI
npjmcA_Z`h`jmlwn]ch{nprZpcGH\lwatmvoca*cNnQnpjls{zu_¯cNn]cuNcyh{\7jcZpc}h{c<tmZ]\7np\:hq\7va¯_u_^Dcs
npZi_usItu_Z]cNn]vw |u\7n]jh{rZpZpc'NnQ_uZpchq\MBRc'Zp m_ni_GHjmlsÔsI\7vormnplo\7*_CBR\7lms n]jmccclIÈ\DZ
s~tuch{lmõh"ju_ZiF"_Zpc_ualwlwalncs?tucZ6IÈ\7Z]a¯_uhqc"Nc^DZ`_Dm_n]lw\7b|N rusIlwm^n]jmc"aca\oJ
Zplocs<_}HnpjmcloNn]cZ`h{\Dmmchqnplw\D¯mcn6F\DZK¯np\¯ju_uNvwcZ]ch{\BRcZ] tu\7lw:n<csIn`_|mvwls~jmac'NnkG
].npjmcZ¸_7s~tuchqn`sf\IpIJ_rmvwnnp\7vocZ`_uh{cRzõs~r}hkj_7sNcn]ch{nplo\7_uHcZ]Zp\DZh{\7mumcac'Nn._Zpc
\7rmnb\MIn]jmcs]h{\7tucH\InpjcHtu_t c'Z¯_uÐlwnpjmc¯Zpc'a¯_louNcZ"Fc_DspsIrmac _qIJ_rvwnJIÈZpc'c
mcn6F\DZK_}rIJ_lwvJVsInp\Dt m\:NcsG+afcn]ch{nplo\7\MIIJ_rmvonI Öm\:NcslsÏtmZ]\BNlNc n]jmZp\Drm^7j
nploacCJÈ\7rmnis\7 lw:npcZ!JÃ\:NcAh{\7aa*rmmlh_n]lw\Dus7G
Hjmc¯Z]ca¯_louNcZA\MIn]jmlst}_tucZ*ls\7Zp^Ë_mlnc_7s3IÈ\7vwvo\F.s7GRchqnplw\DNz/^7lBRcys_
\BRcZB:lwcCF \IQS+]4;g a¯_DhkjmlomcsGgVHËch{nplo\7 Nzu_CIÈnpcZ"loNn]Zp\:Nr}h{lwm^n]jmctmZplouh{lotmvwcs/\MI
\7rmZ0s~\Dvwrmn]lw\7 z Fc*Ncs]h{Zplo| c*jm\F3n]jmcbh{\7jmc'ZpcuhqctmZp\Dnp\:h{\Dvls<c:npc'uNcHn]\Àn]\7vocZ`_npc
m\:NcIJ_lwvormZpcsG:YÔcZYIÈ\DZpa¯_uh{ccCBD_vwr}_nplo\7Z]cs~rvwn`s-\D|mn`_lwmc|: *s~lwa*rmv_nplo\70_Zpc^7lBRc'
lw Ëch{nplo\7ÖPIÈ\DZ_ loatmvocac'Rn`_n]lw\D\MInpjmctZp\7n]\:h{\7v"loÖ_sIvw\Dnpnpcy%Zplom^$S+]4;g
s~loalwv_Zn]\*_sIlwm^DvwcZplom^:d*[ÊdC^\G Rcyh{nplo\7 h{\7}h{vwru:cs\7rmZ.tmZ]cs~c:n`_nplo\7hG
"! #$L'& ( ) & +," "!%'- .
S+S%J T4UZ;g3_Z`h`jmlwn]ch{nprZpcs._uAS+]4;g<s.ju_CBRcs~loalwv_Z"\DZp^R_mlny_nplo\7usGhHjmc |u\7npj
ju_CBRc¯_H:ls~n]Zplo|mrmnpcy×a¯_lwLaca\DZp _}Ö_Hs]h_v_|mvoclw:npcZih{\7mch{n]lw\7cn6F\7Z!KLG gV
h{\7:npZi_7sInfn]\cS+S%JTZUZ;g a¯_Dhkjmlomcsqz S+]4;g<s"h{\DBRcZ]nn]jmctucZ!JÃm\::caca*\7Zp loNn]\
_j:rm^7cAh_Dhkjmc\I/npjmc0s~ju_Zpc _7m:Zpcs]s<s~tu_Dh{c|: ¯_DmNlw^ni_^Rs.np\*vwlwcslw a¯_loacCJ
a\7Z] G:g hq\7usIcrcuh{c.\MIQn]jmls/lsn]ju_nnpjmcvw\:h_nplw\D¯\MI¦__n`_lonpcaXlon]jmc<a¯_Dhkjlwmc
lsnp\7ni_vovw ØNch{\DrmtmvwcyqIÈZp\Da lon`sªtjN s~lh_v_7NZpcs]s{z/_uÖ_m_n`_Hlwn]ca lsA_rmn]\7a¯_nplJ
h_vovw alo^7Zi_npcy_uZpctmvolh_npclonpjc<aca\DZplocsIÈ\Dvwvo\MF"lom^n]jmc.aca\DZp Z]c7IÈcZ]cuh{c
tu_n]npcZ]¯\MI¦npjmcc:ch{rmn]c*_tmtmvolh_nplo\7hG5e}Z]\7a _ IJ_rmvon"np\DvwcZi_uh{ct \Dlw:n"\MI BNlocCFzRnpjmls
IÈc_n]rmZpch{\Dus~n]lwnprnpcs-_h{voc_Z[_7BD_:n`_^7c.\MI S+]Z;gsÔ\BRcZQS+S%JTZUZ;g _Z`h`jmlwn]ch{n]rmZpcs
s~louh{c"acab\7Zp .lwn]ca¯s?vo\:h_n]cÏlo*_ IJ_rvwnI m\::c<h_|uc"ZpcCJJ_vovw\:h_npc\D/IÈrm}h{nplo\7mlom^
m\:Ncs/npZi_usItu_Z]cNn]vw "F"lwnpj\7rmn/a\:Nlmõh_nplw\Dnp\npjclwZ-tjN s~lh_vu_DmNZ]cspsGHjls-lsÔn]jmc
Zpc_Ds~\DPF"j: Fcju_CBRcAhkj\Rs~c'Àn]\lwBRcs~n]lw^Ë_npc"S+]Z;gs7G
S+]4;g rusIru_vovw Ör}s~cHjlwcZi_Z`h`jmlh_v/\7Z]^R_mln_nplo\7 np\vo\:h_n]cHac'a\7Z] Hlwn]ca¯s<\7
_als]s7G(afloZpch{n]\7Z]lwcs._n<cy_7h`jvwcCBRcv\InpjmcjmlocZ`_Z`h`jN ba¯_loNni_lw lwIÈ\DZpa¯_nplo\7_|u\7rmn
aca\DZp lonpca h{\Dtmlwcysfvw\:h_npcHloL_¯s~rm|JÈjmlocZ`_Z`h`jN GRruh`jL_L\7Z]^R_mln_nplo\7LlsfrusIc
lw¯npjc3a4aZ; [Êdq\Q_u:d*[Êdk^\_Zihkjlwnpcyh{nprmZ]cs7G
"_Ds~lh'_vwvo Rzm_vwv%S+]4;g<sfrusIcnpjc*sp_abchq\7jmcZ]cuh{cAtmZp\Dnp\:h{\Dv GhHjls"tmZp\Dnp\:h{\Dvh'_
|ucÖsIlwatmvolVmucy n]\$IÈ\7rmZ¯|u_Ds~lhlwn]ca sIn`_npcsF"jmlhkjOh`ju_^7cL_7h'h{\7ZiNlwm^Ðn]\ Z]cRrmcs~nis
ZpchqclBRcIÈZp\Danpjcvo\:h_v-tZp\:h{cs]s~\DZ> 8! 76@`zu\7ZZIÈZ]\7aZ]ca\Dnpc\:Ncsª\BRcZ
npjmc.mcn6F\7ZKb>68! ( 76@8G eÔlw^DrmZpcdNctmlh{n`sÔn]jmcs~n`_um_Z`h{\DjmcZ]cuh{c"tmZ]\7n]\:h{\7v
rus~cyÀ|: n]jmcgZ;s/\MI_NS+]4;g_Zihkjlwnpcyh{nprmZ]cG
"!C Runpjmcvw\:h'_vQgZ;,N\Rcs"m\7n.hq\7:n`_lo _/BD_vol¯h{\DtN \I-n]jmclwn]ca?G
#
'5 8!RNnpjcªvo\:h_vQg4;$ju_Dsf_Zpcy_7JÈ\7mvo ¯h{\DtN \I-n]jmclwn]ca?G
