Strategies for RANS/VMS-LES coupling

HAL Id: inria-00088040

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00088040v2

Submitted on 1 Aug 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Strategies for RANS/VMS-LES coupling

Gennaro Pagano, Simone Camarri, Maria Vittoria Salvetti, Bruno Koobus, Alain Dervieux

To cite this version:

Gennaro Pagano, Simone Camarri, Maria Vittoria Salvetti, Bruno Koobus, Alain Dervieux. Strategies for RANS/VMS-LES coupling. [Research Report] RR-5954, INRIA. 2006, pp.43. �inria-00088040v2�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

ISRNINRIA/RR--5954--FR+ENG

Thème NUM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Strategies for RANS/VMS-LES coupling

Gennaro Pagano, Simone Camarri, Maria Vittoria Salvetti, Bruno Koobus, Alain Dervieux

N° 5954

July 2006

24365587:9<;>=?7:@A7:5B;

∗^{CED FHG ;I5B34JK7 G 7:9L9 F}†^{CNM 7O9 F7QP FHR<R ;I9 F7 D 7OSHTI3 RLRLF}‡^{CEU 9<V5;}

W ;;IXVY

§^{CZ S[7 F}5]\369<T

F

36V ^

¶

_a`cb0dKefg?hjilknmporqsb0dKe<otnucdKv<wyx{z|uce<o

}Ews~€reqknd‚6oƒ`

„€…c…:~†wyqˆ‡pewyeL‰Š`ce0wŠ‰Š`ce‹t:ŒŽŽŽil6uc‘m.’€“6“†”i–•6—…%†˜†e<o

™›šBœ<0žŸc ††¡'¢ tce<£¤`nmn¥cwsx‘‡'„ ¢ f?k%¦€§©¨ªk'†…c…cws~66‰Š`«x{o…cws~†…:~6oye<‡A¬._a`ce®­†e<m°¯±e<€qyucwse‚~€¯aqs`cx‘o²€…p³

…%wy~|†‰Š`®x{oa#¥c‘e0tO‡px´t%˜²¥:eqr£+e0e<t›qr£+~#eL‡c‡pm|³[µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qsx´eLo0·n~6tce?˜6x´µ6e0t®¥nmKqs`ce

k−ε^{„ ¢} f?k.dK~n‡ce0A€t%‡

qs`ceˆ~†qy`ce<wN¥nm#qs`ce¸kpdK†˜†~6wyx‘t%oy­|m#¹?h«k|³º§©¨+k°»±µ€wsx{qyx‘~†tO€cd²uc¶qsx‘os‰0†´e?§©¨ªkc¼N‰‘~6oyucwse†¬_a`ceˆ¥c‘e0t%‡cx´tc˜

x{o#oyeq²¥|m½¾…%†ws†dKeqye<w

θ^¿ ¹?hÀk|³Á§¨ªk'dK~p‡pe›x{o#6‰Âqsx´µ6e®£`ce0t

θ = 0^{·„ ¢} f?k½dK~p‡pe®x´¯

θ = 1^·

`nmn¥cwsx‘‡dK~p‡pe¯±~6w

0< θ <1¬ª_a`%e…cws~†…:~6oye<‡.`|mn¥cwsx{‡.dK~p‡pe<`%6o¥Oe<e0t4†…c…c‘x´eL‡›qs~‚qy`%etnucdKe0wsx‘‰<€

oyx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t~†¯Aqy`ceˆÃ%~£Ä€ws~†uct%‡Kosz|u%€wseˆ‰mn‘x´tO‡pe0w+q

ReL= 22000¬B_a`cwye<eˆ‡px´Å:e<wye<t6q+…%€wŠ€dKe0qye0wŠo

»Æ¥%†oye<‡›~†t.µ|x{os‰~6oyx´qrmwŠqsx´~O·|qyx‘dewŠqsx´~€t%‡.´e<tc˜€qs`›wŠqsx´~n¼N†wyeqye<oƒqyeL‡A¬E_a`ce¸wyeLoƒu%¶qŠoª~6¥pqs†x´t%e<‡®£x´qy`

qs`cx{otce<£¤`nmn¥cwsx‘‡½†…c…cws~66‰Š`Q†wye®‰0~†dK…%€wse<‡Q£x´qy`'qs`c~6oye®~†¥cqs€x‘tceL‡'u%oƒx‘tc˜°qs`ce›§ f?k'€…%…cwy~|†‰Š`À¯±~†w

qr£+~‡px´Å:e<wye<t|qE˜†wsx‘‡wse<oy~†‘upqyx‘~†t%o<dž‰0~†dK…%€wsx{oƒ~6t%o£x¶qs`‚eÈp…:e0wsx´dKe0t|qŠ€%‡c€qsx‘tKqy`ce´x´qƒqse0wŠqyu%wyeˆ†wye€{oy~

…%wy~µnx{‡pe<‡A¬_a`ceoƒe<t%oyx¶qsx´µnx´qrm.~†¯Bqs`ce#dK~p‡pe<qs~›oƒ~6dKe#oƒe0qƒqsx´tc˜›…%€wŠ€dKeqse0wŠo»Éqs`ce#x‘tpÃ%~£(µ€‘uce~†¯8qy`ce

qsucws¥cuc‘e0t|q+­nx‘tceqsx‘‰?e0t%e0ws˜†m†·

k0

†t%‡‚qs`ce…%€wŠ€dKe0qye0w

δx‘t›qs`ce¸†…c…cws~ŽÈpx´d‚qse£a€‘%qswyeLqsde<t|qŠ¼Nx‘oa€{oy~

†t%€‘mpoƒeL‡A¬

Ê°Ë|ÌIÍsÎ#Ï žÐBœ†¡ Ñ mn¥cwsx‘‡Ò„ ¢ f¸k%¦§¨ªkÒ_u%wy¥cu%´e<t%‰e°h°~p‡pe<‘o<·N¹E†wyx{qsx´~6t%€ah°uc´qyx{oy‰<€‘e ¢ …c…cws~66‰Š`

»Æ¹?h«k%¼Â·O§x´dKx´qyeL‡fucdKe0wsx‘‰<€kp‰<€‘e<o»H§f?k%¼Â·:Óª~6d…%´e0ÈÔ¸e0~6de0qywsx´eLo0·cgt%oƒqywsu%‰ÂqsucwyeL‡Ô¸wsx{‡co0¬

∗ÕBÖØ׎Ù{ÚcÛÉ܎ÝÂÞrÝÂ܎ÞrßÆÖáàˆâ©ÞrßÆãÂä[×àŠårÖáàŠÙØÞÂæçÖáà+è©àŠßÆéŽäHãŽæêÂëLìƒíÂëî%ÖØäÁàˆï‘Û{ð[àŠÙñò

†ÕBÖØ׎Ù{ÚcÛÉ܎ÝÂÞrÝÂ܎ÞrßÆÖáàˆâ©ÞrßÆãÂä[×àŠårÖáàŠÙØÞÂæçÖáà+è©àŠßÆéŽäHãŽæêÂëLìƒíÂëî%ÖØäÁàˆï‘Û{ð[àŠÙñò

‡ÕBÖØ׎Ù{ÚcÛÉ܎ÝÂÞrÝÂ܎ÞrßÆÖáàˆâ©ÞrßÆãÂä[×àŠårÖáàŠÙØÞÂæçÖáà+è©àŠßÆéŽäHãŽæêÂëLìƒíÂëî%ÖØäÁàˆï‘Û{ð[àŠÙñò

§ÕBÞr×LðóàsðHôŽõröˆàsðHÖØ÷<éŽÞräƒæø ÜLÖù6ÚOóãÂÜð[׀ÞrÙØÙØÖØÞrßÛÆÛÁæ†è©èBÚúÂêLìÂæ€ûŠüúÂýÂêóãÂÜð[׀ÞrÙØÙØÖØÞr߃æLþß[àŠÜŽÿrÞÂæ†àŠÜÛÛÉâ

¶Û©ÛÉâªæ€íÂúÂúŠü©ãÂéLðHގÞrä néLÿƒÖØãÂÙØÞräƒæAîpڀýÂûLæúÂëÂýÂúÂí<ãÂ×LôŽÖáàÉâBÜðHÖØ׆ãÂÙØÖØäƒæŽþßHàŠÜŽÿrÞ

œ ¡ gˆt%e+t%~†ucµ6e0‘´e+€…c…cws~p‰Š`ce+`|mn¥cwsx{‡peª„ ¢ f?k%¦€§©¨ªk»H„ ¢ f¸k

¿

„e0mntc~6‘‡%o ¢ µ†e<ws†˜†eL‡fŽµnx´e<wƒ³

knqy~†­6e<o¦f?Žµ|x‘e0wy³rk|qy~6­†e<o8Žµ6e<‰dK~m6e0tctce¸‡pe„e0mntc~6‘‡co¸Çp§©¨+k

¿

§†wy˜6eˆ¨N‡c‡pmknx´d²uc{qyx‘~†tI¦€knx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t

‡ce˜†wŠ€tO‡pe<oNknqywsu%‰ÂqsucwyeLos¼Ee<oƒq+†…c…c‘x‘z|ucv<e{oyx´d²uc‘€qyx‘~†t®tnucdKv<wyx{z|uce‡pe?v<‰0~†uc‘e0dKe0t|qª†upqy~6ucwª‡uct

‰0mn´x‘t%‡pwse²‰<€wswyv6¬§e‡cx‘oy…O~|oƒx´qyx´¯ª…%wyx‘t%‰x‘…%†B‡peK‰e0qƒqseK†…c…cws~p‰Š`ce#eLorq‘®¯±u%oyx´~6tÀe<t6qswye‡pe0ucÈ4µ|x{os‰~6oyx´qyv<o

qsucws¥cuc‘e0t|qyeLo0·u%tce‡p~†tct%v0e+…%€wB´e+dK~p‡pb0‘e+„ ¢ f?k

k−ε^e0q€upqswyeª…%€wuctceª¯±~†wsd#u%‘€qyx‘~†t¹¸h«k|³º§©¨ªk

»Æ¹?h«k

¿

¹E€wsx‘€qyx‘~†t%†Ah°uc´qyx{oy‰<€‘eL¼ª¥%†oyv0eoyucw‘²¯±e<wydKeqsucwse§¨ªk‡peknd‚€˜6~†wsx´t%oy­nm†¬§#¯±u%oyx´~6t.e<t6qswye

‘e<oB‡pe<upÈd~p‡pb<´eLo©eLorq‰~†t|qswy~6´v<eE…%€w ´eª…%€wŠ€dKb0qywse

θ ^¿ ¹¸h«k|³º§©¨ªke<oƒqB€…%…c´x{z|ucvN~

θ= 0^{·„ ¢ f?k}

~ θ= 1·peqˆuct¾dK~p‡pex´t|qse0wsdvL‡px{€x‘wye¸…O~6ucw

0< θ <1¬E_ wy~6x‘o+…%†ws€dKb0qywŠ€˜†eLoª‡cx¶ÅIv0wse0t|qso#»±¥%6oƒvLo oyucw‘ewŠ€…%…O~6wƒq‡peKµnx‘os‰~|oƒx´qyv6·A´eKwŠ€…c…:~†wyq¸‡peqse0dK…%oe0q‘eKws†…c…:~†wyq¸‡peK‘~†tc˜6uce0ucw¼?oƒ~6t6qe0Èp†dKx´tcvLo0¬

§e<owsv<oyuc´qs€qso~†¥cqye0tnu%o#Žµ†e<‰‰e0qƒqse®tc~†u%µ†e0‘‘eK†…c…cws~p‰Š`ceK`|mn¥cwsx{‡pe®oƒ~6t|q‰0~†dK…%†wyvLo‰0e0upÈQ~†¥pqse0tnu%o

e<tÄupqyx‘‘x‘os€t|q›†…c…cws~p‰Š`ce°§f?k »Æ§©x‘dKx¶qse<‡ÄfucdKe0wsx‘‰<€¸kc‰0€‘eL¼…:~†u%w.‡pe<upÈÒwsv<oy~†‘upqsx´~6t%o‚‡px´Å:v<wye<t6qse<o

‡ce˜6wyx‘‘´e6LJpe<o‰0~†dK…%€wŠ€x{oy~†t%o¸Žµ†eL‰‘e<o‡p~6tctcv0eLo¸eÈp…Ov<wyx‘dKe0t|qs†´eLooƒ~6t6qv0˜|€‘e0dKe0t|q…cws~†…:~6oyv0e<o<¬§

oye0tOoƒx‘¥cx‘´x´qyv«‡cuÄd~p‡pb<´e½z|uce0{z|uce<o›…%€wŠ€dKbqswyeLo‚‡pe«wsv0˜6‘†˜†e½»±‘e4tcx‘µ†eL€u

k0

‡€…c…:~†wyq.‡v0t%e0ws˜†x‘e

‰0x´t%vqyx{z|uceqyu%wy¥cu%´e<t6qseeq‘e…%€wŠ€dKbqswye

δ‡c€t%oa‘eqywŠ€x´qye<dKe0t|q€…c…%wy~ŽÈpx‘dK€qyx´¯ ‡peLoˆ‰~6u%‰Š`ce<o+‘x´dKx´qyeLos¼ eLorqv<˜6€‘e0dKe<t6qˆ†t%€‘mpoƒv<e†¬

Ï Lœ Í   œ#¡ _ucws¥cuc‘e0tO‰e†· Ñ mn¥cwsx‘‡peLo„ ¢ f¸k%¦§¨ªkI·€¹E†wyx{qsx´~6t%€ph°uc´qyx{os‰0€‘e†·6§©x‘dx´qyeL‡²fucdKe0wsx‘‰<€

kc‰0€‘e<o<·p˜†v<~†dKvqswyx‘e<oa‰0~†dK…c‘eÈpe<o<·pd‚€x‘´{€˜6e<o+tc~†tc³Áoƒqywsu%‰Âqsucwsv<o

1² ,.)N 1

_a`%e!x‘wyeL‰Âq?fucdKe0wsx‘‰<€ kpx´d²uc‘€qyx‘~†t½»!¸f?k%¼~€¯qs`ce#fŽµnx‘e0wy³ºknqy~†­6e<o+e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%oˆx‘oa¯±eL†oyx´¥%´e~6tc´m›¯±~†w

‘~£ „e0mntc~6‘‡cot|u%d#¥:e0wŠo®»

Re¼‡puceKqs~°qy`ce›tce<‰0e<osoy†wym«‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t%€Ewse<oy~†u%ws‰0e<o<·©£`cx{‰Š`'†´wse<6‡pm

¥:e<‰0~†dKea…cws~†`cx‘¥cx´qyx‘µ†e0‘m{€ws˜†e+¯±~†w

Re'10⁴¬#"c~†wqs`cx{o8wyeL†oy~†t©·€qyucws¥cuc‘e0t%‰0ead~p‡pe<´x‘tc˜x{o8tce<‰0e<osoy†wym oƒqye<…¯±~†wqs`cetnucdKe0wsx‘‰<€oyx´d²uc{qyx‘~†t~€¯Ã%~£ˆoa~†¯Be<tc˜†x‘tce<e0wsx´tc˜Kx‘t|qye0wse<oƒq<¬$ºtqy`cx{o‰0~†t|qye0È|qL·pqy`%ed~|orq

£x{‡pe<´mu%oye<‡®†…c…cws~6†‰Š`¯±~6wEqy`%e?oyx´d²uc‘€qyx‘~†t‚~†¯I`%x´˜6`p³Á„ˆe0mntc~†{‡coNt|u%d#¥:e0wEqsucws¥cuc‘e0t|qNÃ%~£ˆoNx‘oEqy`ce?~†tce

¥O†oye<‡.~†t.qy`ce„e<mntc~†{‡coƒ³¢ µ†e<ws†˜†e<‡‚f?Žµnx´e<wƒ³rk|qy~6­†eLoNeLz6uOqyx‘~†tOo»Æ„ ¢ f?kc¼¬%$ºtqy`ce„ ¢ f?k†…c…cws~6†‰Š`·

qsx´dKeŽµ†e<ws†˜†x‘tc˜x{o+†…c…c‘x´eL‡‚qs~²qs`cefŽµnx´e<wƒ³rk|qs~†­†eLoEeLz6uOqyx‘~†tOo+†t%‡®~6tc‘mKqy`ce¸qyx‘dKe³ºŽµ†e<ws†˜†e<‡²Ã%~£ x‘o

oyx‘d#uc{qse<‡A¬&$ºt‚qy`%x‘oN£+Žmtc~€qsx‘‰0e<†¥c´eˆoyx‘d…%´x('O‰0€qyx‘~†t‚~†¯:qs`ce…%wy~6¥c´e<d x{oE~6¥pqs†x´tceL‡A·n‰~†dK…cucqsqsx´~6t%€

‰0~6oƒqsoª€wse‡pwŠ†oƒqyx{‰0€‘‘m#wse<‡pu%‰0e<‡‚†t%‡‚¥:e<‰~6dKe?€‘dK~6oƒqNx‘t%‡pe0…:e0tO‡pe0t|qª~†¯Aqy`ce¸„e0mntc~6‘‡%oEtnucd#¥:e0w+£`ce<t

qs`cx{oªx{ooyu*)®‰x‘e0t|qy‘m‚‘†wy˜6e†¬

Ñ

~£+e0µ6e0wL·|„

¢

f?k›dK~n‡ce0{oªuOoƒu%†´‘m‚`%Žµ6e?‡px()®‰uc´qyx‘e<oax‘t.…%wy~µnx{‡px´t%˜²†‰<‰up³

wŠqse?…%wyeL‡px‘‰qyx‘~†t%oª¯±~6wªÃO~£ˆoN£x´qy`d‚†osoƒx‘µ†eoƒe<…%€wŠqsx´~6t%o<·6†oª¯±~6w+x‘t%oƒqs†t%‰e¸¯±~†w+qs`ce¸Ã%~£ €ws~†u%t%‡‚¥c‘upÅ

¥:~p‡px‘e<o<·O¯±~6w?£`%x‘‰Š`«qy`ce<m4€wseqy~n~.‡cx‘osoƒx‘…%€qyx‘µ†eqs~.…%wy~6…Oe<wy‘moyx‘d#uc{qse²—!¤…c`%e0tc~6de<t%c·Imnx‘e0{‡px´t%˜®qy~

oyx‘˜†tcx('O‰0†t|qa‡px{os‰wse0…%†t%‰x‘e<oa£x´qy`¾wse<oy…OeL‰Âqaqy~qy`%eeÈp…Oe<wyx‘dKe0t|qs†AwyeLoƒu%¶qŠo0¬

¢ t €´qye<wyt%€qyx‘µ†e®†…c…cws~6†‰Š`Qx{oqy`%e.§†wy˜6e³Á¨N‡c‡pmÀoƒx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t]»Æ§¨ªkc¼Â·Bx‘t £`cx{‰Š` 4oƒ…Oqyx{€+'%¶qse0w

x{o#†…c…c‘x´eL‡Qqy~°qs`ce›eLz|u%qsx´~6t%ox‘t½~†wŠ‡pe0wqy~4˜6eq#wsx‘‡'~†¯oƒd‚†´´³Áos‰0†´eqsucwy¥%uc´e<t|q#Ã%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o#£`cx{‰Š`

†wyeqy`nu%oadK~p‡pe0‘e<‡©·c€t%‡®qy`cewse0d‚€x‘tcx‘tc˜#ÃO~£ oy‰<€‘e<oa€wse?‡cx´wse<‰qy‘m®oƒx‘d#uc{qse<‡A¬Nkpx´t%‰0eqs`ce‡pmnt%€dKx{‰0o

~†¯+{€ws˜†eKos‰0€‘e<ox{o‡px‘wyeL‰Âqs´mQoƒx‘d#uc{qse<‡'€tO‡4qs`cwye<e³º‡px‘de<t%oyx´~6t%€‘x¶qrmÀ€t%‡Àuct%oƒqyeL†‡px‘tce<oso~†¯Nqy`%e‚Ã%~£

†wye.t%qsucwŠ€‘´mQqs†­†e<t x´t|qs~Q6‰0‰~6uct|q<·qs`ce°§©¨ªk €…c…cws~66‰Š`½x‘o˜6e0tce<ws†´‘mÀdK~6wye¾†‰<‰ucwŠqse†·¥cupq®€{oy~

‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t%€‘´m¸dK~†wseEeÈp…:e0t%oyx‘µ†e†·Lqs`%€t#qy`ce+„ ¢ f¸k~†t%e†¬ h4~†wse0~µ†e<w<·0qy`ce+‰~|orqB~€¯%§©¨+koyx´d²uc‘€qyx‘~†t%o

x‘t%‰0wyeL†oye<oB†oBqy`%eaÃ%~£ „e<m|t%~†{‡cotnucd#¥:e0w8x{ox´tO‰wse<†oye<‡©¬,$ºt%‡pe<e<‡A·€qy`ce˜6wyx{‡#`O†o qy~¥:e-'%tcee0t%~†uc˜6`qy~

wse<oy~†‘µ†eˆ#oƒx‘˜†tcx('O‰<€t|qN…%†wƒqN~†¯Aqy`ceqyucws¥cuc‘e0t|qaoy‰<€‘e<o<·6€tO‡®oƒ…Oqyx{€OwyeLoƒ~6´ucqyx‘~†tK¥OeL‰~6deLoE…%†wƒqsx‘‰0uc{€ws´m

‰0wyx´qyx{‰0†Ax´tqs`cetce<†wƒ³Á£+†´Iwse0˜6x´~6t%o0¬

¢

t%e0£(‰{†osoa~€¯8dK~n‡ce0{o`%†oˆ¥Oe<e0t¾wyeL‰e<t6qs´m.…cws~†…:~6oye<‡.x´tqy`%e´x´qye<ws€qyucwsex´t°£`%x‘‰Š`°„

¢

f?k¾€tO‡

§¨ªk€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`ceLoª†wye‰~6d#¥cx‘tceL‡®qs~†˜†e0qy`ce<wx´t¾~6ws‡pe<w+qy~‚~†¥cqs€x‘t¾oƒx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t%o†o6‰0‰0ucws€qye†oax‘tqy`ce

§¨ªkÀ‰0†oye¥cupqqwyeL†oy~†t%†¥c‘e²‰~6dK…cupqs€qyx‘~†t%†8‰~6oƒqso<¬ ¢ d~6tc˜¾‡px¶ÅIe0wse0t|qoƒqywŠqye<˜†x‘e<o?~€¯a‰~†d²¥cx‘tcx´t%˜

qs`ce‚qr£+~4€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`ceLo0·©£+e®‰~6t%oyx‘‡pe<w`ce<wyeKqs`ce.0/(123 4527698:;=<4:>1?6@·Bx‘t½£`cx‘‰Š` „ ¢ f?k'†t%‡½§©¨+k'€wse

¥%´e<t%‡pe<‡²qs~†˜†e0qy`ce<wx´t‚‰~6t6qsx´tnuc~6u%o£aŽmqy`cws~†uc˜6`c~†ucqBqs`ceˆ‰~6dK…cupqs€qyx‘~†t%†c‡p~†d‚†x´t©¬B_a`cx{oE€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`

‘e<6‡co+qy~qs`ceoƒ~†³Á‰<€‘´eL‡9A*25BC10D80<4/,EGFH 10/I8¬

¢ d~6tc˜‚qs`ceJA*2%5B410D8<@/,EGFK L1/M8‡ce<os‰wsx´¥:e<‡x‘t°qy`ce#´x´qye<ws€qyucwse†·pqs`ceN!?eqŠ†‰Š`ceL‡¾¨N‡c‡pm°knx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t

»!¨+kc¼`%6owyeL‰e<x´µ6e<‡°qs`ce®{€ws˜†eLorqqyqye0t|qsx´~6t©¬®_a`cx{o€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`©·O'Owsoƒq‡pe<os‰wsx´¥:e<‡Qx‘t½„e¯r¬«»QP’6’HR±¼Â·Bx‘o

¥O†oye<‡~†tqy`%e~†tce0³[eLz|u%qsx´~6t¾kn…O€{€wyqƒ³¢ ‘´d‚€wŠ†o„ ¢ f?kdK~p‡pe<H·Ox´t°£`cx{‰Š`¾qy`%e´e<tc˜€qs`°oy‰<€‘e~€¯qy`ce

qsucws¥cuc‘e0t|q?­nx‘tceqsx‘‰²e0tce<wy˜6m.‡peLorqswyuO‰Âqyx‘~†t4qye0wsdx‘o?dK~p‡pxS'Oe<‡°qs~›¥:eqs`ce²dKx‘tcx‘d#ucd!~6tce#¥:eqr£+e0e<t°qy`ce

‡cx‘oƒqs†t%‰e›qy~4qs`ce›£a€‘a€t%‡ «´e<tc˜€qs` …cws~†…:~†wyqyx‘~†t%†Eqs~4qy`%e›‘~n‰<€+˜†wsx‘‡'wse<oy~†‘upqsx´~6t©¬À_a`nu%o<·8x´t qy`ce

t%e<€wy³Á£+†´pwse0˜6x´~6t†t%‡K£x¶qs`®„ ¢ f¸k|³Á´x‘­†eˆ˜6wyx{‡coqs`ce?kn…O€{€wyqƒ³¢ ‘´d‚€wŠ†o8„ ¢ f?kdK~p‡pe<%x{oEu%oye<‡A·|£`cx‘´e

¯Æ†wE¯±ws~†d¤qy`%e£a€‘cqy`%e¸oyx´d²uc{qyx‘~†t®oy£x´qs‰Š`ceLoEqs~qy`ce§©¨+kKdK~n‡ce£x´qy`.~†tce0³[eLz6uOqyx‘~†t›k%Ôk‚‰‘~6oyucwse

»[kcÔk

¿

oyuc¥p³Á˜†wsx{‡.os‰0†´eŽ¼Â¬

¢ tc~€qs`ce0wK`nmn¥cwyx{‡ †…c…cws~6†‰Š`·qs`ce§x´dKx´qyeL‡ fˆu%de<wyx{‰0†akc‰0€‘eÀ»H§f¸kc¼²~†tce6·8`%†o²¥Oe<e0t>wyeL‰e0t|qs´m

…%wy~6…O~|oƒeL‡Kx´t›„ˆe¯r¬TPVUR[¬#$ºt›qy`cx{oª†…c…cws~66‰Š`©·€qs`ce¥c‘e0tO‡px´t%˜#…%†ws†de0qye<wª‡pe<…Oe<t%‡coª~†t‚qs`ce?µ†´uceLoN~†¯Aqy`ce

eL‡c‡pm|³Áµ|x{os‰~6oyx´qrm˜†x‘µ†e0tK¥nm²„

¢

f?k‚d~p‡pe<H·

µt

·|†t%‡~€¯:qy`ce?k%Ôkµ|x{os‰~6oyx´qrm˜†x‘µ†e<t¥nm§©¨ªkK‰0´~|oƒucwse†·

µs

¬$ºt°…cws6‰Âqsx‘‰0e†·cqs`ce#dKx‘tcx‘d#ucd~€¯8qs`ceqr£+~®e<‡%‡pm|³[µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qsx´eLox‘ou%oye<‡A¬ˆ_a`cx{o¸oƒ`c~6uc{‡¾e0t%oyucwseqy`%€q<·

£`%e0wseaqy`ce?˜†wsx‘‡x{oW'%tcee0tc~6uc˜†`Kqs~wyeLoƒ~6´µ6eoƒx‘˜†tcx('O‰<€t|qN…%†wƒqE~†¯:qs`ceˆqsucws¥cuc‘e0t%‰0eoy‰<€‘e<o<·qy`%edK~p‡pe0

£+~†ws­pox‘t qy`%e§¨ªk½dK~p‡pe†·8£`%x´‘e›e<‘oye0£`ce<wye›qy`ce„ ¢ f¸k ‰0´~|oƒu%wye®x{o²wyeL‰~µ†e<wyeL‡A¬ ¢ t>eÈc€dK…c‘e›~†¯

µ†´x{‡cqsx´~6t.~†¯qs`cx‘oˆ`|mn¥cwsx{‡›dK~p‡pe0©¯±~†waqy`%eoƒx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t.~†¯ ¥c‘upÅ:³[¥:~p‡pm.Ã%~£ˆo+x‘o˜6x´µ6e0t.x´t°„e0¯r¬P CR[¬

$ºt‚qs`ce…%wyeLoƒe<t6qª£ª~6wy­I·†t%e0£]oƒqywŠqye<˜†m²x‘oN…cwy~6…O~|oƒeL‡²¯±~†wN¥%´e<t%‡px‘tc˜²„ ¢ f?k‚†t%‡‚§©¨+k‚€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`ceLo

x‘t «`|mn¥cwsx{‡½dK~n‡ce0[¬À_ ~4qy`%x‘o²…cucws…O~|oƒe6·E†o#…cwy~6…O~|oƒeL‡'x´t҄e¯r¬ PVU<—CRÁ·qy`ce.Ã%~£ µ€wsx‘†¥c‘e<o#†wye.‡pe³

‰0~†dK…:~6oye<‡4x‘t½¾„ ¢ f¸k«…O€wyqK»ÆxH¬e†¬Kqs`ce‚Žµ†e0wŠ€˜6e<‡¾ÃO~£ '%e0{‡%¼· ¾‰~6wywse<‰qyx‘~†t«…O€wyq?qs`%qqŠ€­†eLo¸x´t|qy~

6‰0‰0~†uct|qqs`ceqyucws¥cuc‘e0t|q{€ws˜†e³ºos‰0€‘eÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o<·†t%‡«›qy`cx‘wŠ‡«…%†wƒqd‚†‡pe~€¯Nqy`ceKuctcwse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡°~†w

k%ÔkÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o<¬ _a`%eª¥%6oƒx{‰ªx‘‡peLˆ~†¯cqy`ce+…cws~†…:~6oye<‡†…c…cws~66‰Š`x‘o qy~¸oƒ~6´µ6eEqs`ce+„ ¢ f?k#e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o x‘t

qs`ce¸£`c~†‘e¸‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t%€I‡p~†d‚†x´t€t%‡®qy~K‰~†wswse<‰Âqªqy`ce¸~†¥cqs€x‘tceL‡›Žµ†e<ws†˜†eL‡Ã%~£ '%e0{‡.¥|m‚6‡c‡px‘tc˜%·

£`%e0wse®qy`%e.˜6wyx{‡½x{o²6‡pe<z|u%€qye0‘m'wye0'%tceL‡A·qy`cewse0d‚€x‘tcx‘tc˜«wse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡QÃ%u%‰Âqsu%qsx´~6t%o<¬Q_a`cee<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o

˜6~µ†e<wytcx‘tc˜qs`ce?wse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡²Ã%u%‰Âqsu%qsx´~6t%oa€wse‡pe<wyx‘µ†eL‡K¯±wy~6d¤qy`ce¸„ ¢ f¸k›†t%‡®§©¨+k‚e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o<¬&$ºt%orqse<6‡

~†¯BuOoƒx‘tc˜®0~6t%€ €…c…cws~66‰Š`©·px‘t°£`cx‘‰Š`¾wse0˜6x´~6t%o+qy~‚¥:eqywse<€qyeL‡.¥nm‚„ ¢ f¸k¾~†wˆ§¨ªk¾€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`¾€wse

€³[…%wyx‘~†wsx‡pe0'%tce<‡©·I6oˆx‘t«„e0¯r¬ PVU<—CRÁ·I9A*2%5B410D8<@/%`nmn¥cwsx‘‡¾dK~p‡pe0Bx{o…cws~†…:~6oye<‡¾`%e0wse†¬_ ~®qs`cx‘o¸€x‘d¾·:

¥%´e<t%‡px‘tc˜‚¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t°x{ox‘t6qswy~p‡puO‰e<‡©·

θ·O£`cx‘‰Š`4oydK~n~€qy`%´m.µŽ†wyx‘e<oˆ¥Oe0qr£ªe<e0t°“®€tO‡.U6¬+_a`%e#‰~6wywse<‰qyx‘~†t qse0wsd £`cx{‰Š`²x{o8†‡%‡pe<‡#qy~¸qy`%eˆŽµ†e0wŠ€˜6e<‡¸Ã%~£ '%e0{‡²x‘oBqs`|uOoE‡c€dK…:e<‡²¥nm#?¯Æ†‰Âqs~†w

(1−θ)·€~6¥pqs†x´t%x´tc˜

dK~p‡pe<%£`cx{‰Š`®‰~6x´t%‰0x‘‡ce<o8£x´qy`Kqs`ce„

¢

f?k‚†…c…cws~6†‰Š`£`ce<t

θ= 1€t%‡Kwse<‰0~µ†e<wso qy`%e§©¨ªk®€…c…cws~66‰Š`

x‘tÀqy`ceK‘x´dKx´q~†¯

θ→ 0¬²_a`%wye<e‡px´ÅIe0wse0t|q‡pe'%t%x¶qsx´~6t%o¸~€¯Nqs`ceK¥c‘e0t%‡px‘tc˜.¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t

θ €wse…cwy~6…O~|oƒeL‡A·

¥O†oye<‡‚~6t®qy`%e?wŠqsx´~|oN¥:eqr£+e0e<tÀ»±xɼEqy`ce¸qr£+~#e<‡%‡pm‚µnx‘os‰~|oƒx´qyx‘e<o<·:»Æx´xɼNqr£ª~‰Š`%€wŠ†‰qye<wyx{orqsx‘‰ˆ´e<tc˜€qs`.os‰0€‘e<o

†t%‡»±x‘x´xɼBqr£+~‰Š`O€wŠ†‰Âqse0wsx‘oƒqyx{‰8qsx´dKeˆos‰0†´eLo˜†x‘µ†e0t¥nmqy`%eˆ„ ¢ f¸kK€t%‡#qy`ceˆ§¨ªk²dK~n‡ce0{o0·6wyeLoƒ…:e<‰qyx‘µ†e0‘m†¬

_a`%e¸„ ¢ f?k®d~p‡pe<Iu%oƒeL‡®x‘t®qs`ce…cwy~6…O~|oƒeL‡K`nm|¥%wyx{‡®dK~p‡pe0Ix{oªqy`ceorqŠ€t%‡%€wŠ‡

k−εd~p‡pe<A„e¯r¬TPVUCR[·

£`%x´‘e¯±~†wqy`%e®§©¨ªkÀ…%†wƒqqy`%e‚¹E€wsx‘€qyx‘~†t%†h4uc¶qsx¶³rkp‰<€‘e®€…c…cws~66‰Š` »±¹¸h«kc¼„ˆe¯r¬ PVUURNx{o†‡c~†…pqse<‡A¬

_a`%e.¹¸h«k †…c…cws~66‰Š` ‰0†t ¥:e¾‰0~†dK…%†wyeL‡½x´t>qye<wyd‚o~€¯†‰<‰ucwŠ†‰0m«qs~Àqs`ce°‡pmnt%€dKx{‰kpdK†˜†~6wyx‘t%oy­|m

dK~p‡pe<H·:¥cupqx¶qŠo?‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t%€B‰~6oƒqx{o?‡ce'%tcx´qye<´m°‘~£+e0w†t%‡4‰~6dK…%€wŠ€¥c‘eqy~›qy`%€q?~†¯8qy`ceoƒx‘dK…c´e

kpdK†˜†~6wyx‘t%oy­|mKdK~p‡pe0[·%6ooƒ`c~£tx‘t¾„ˆe¯r¬TPVUL’HRÁ¬

_a`cea…cws~†…:~6oye<‡#dK~n‡ce0p`%6o ¥:e0e<t²x‘dK…c‘e0dKe0t|qyeL‡#x‘tK?tnucdKe<wyx{‰0†noy~†‘µ†e<w+»¢ ¨N„¼¯±~†wBqs`cefŽµnx´e<wƒ³

knqy~†­6e<o+e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%oax‘t.qy`ce‰<†oye?~†¯B‰~6dK…cwyeLoyoyx‘¥c´e¸Ã%~£ˆoa†t%‡›…:e0wy¯±e<‰qfˆe<£aqy~†t%x‘†t.˜|†oye<o<·|¥O†oye<‡®~6t

dKx´Èpe<‡ '%t%x¶qse³Áe0‘e0dKe0t|q¦C'%tcx´qye0³[µ6~†‘ucdKe?os‰Š`ce0dKeˆ¯±~6wyd²uc{qyeL‡K¯±~†w+uct%oƒqywsu%‰qyucwse<‡‚˜6wyx{‡coªd‚†‡pe?~€¯©qseqywŠ³

`%e<‡pwŠ€ce<´e<dKe0t|qso<¬W" x‘tcx´qye?e0‘e0dKe0t|qso?»±} Uqrmn…OeŽ¼8€t%‡G'%tcx´qyeˆµ6~†‘ucdKe<oN†wyeuOoƒeL‡qy~qswyeLqEqs`ce?‡px´ÅIu%oƒx‘µ†e

†t%‡›‰0~†tnµ†eL‰Âqsx´µ6eˆÃ%upÈpeLo0·pwse<oy…OeL‰Âqsx´µ6e0‘m†¬NÓª~†t%‰0e0wstcx‘tc˜qs`ce¹?h«k.€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`©·6qy`ceµ6e0wŠoƒx‘~†t®…%wy~6…O~|oƒeL‡®x‘t

„ˆe¯r¬-P(UŽ’HRc¯±~6wN‰~6d…%wyeLoyoyx´¥%´e+Ã%~£ˆo8†t%‡²¯±~†w8qs`ce…%€wyqyx{‰u%‘†w8t|u%de<wyx{‰0†pdKeqy`%~n‡Ke<dK…c´~m6e<‡²x´t

¢

¨N„

`O†oa¥:e0e0t¾u%oye<‡.`ce<wye6¬

¢ ‘oy~®qs`ce²§ f?k°†…c…cws~6†‰Š`¾`%6o¥:e0e<t4x‘d…%´e<de<t|qye<‡4x´t ¢ ¨N„¤†o?‡pe<os‰wsx‘¥OeL‡¾x´tQ‡peqŠ€x‘‘ox´t«„ˆe¯r¬

PKRÁ·cu%oyx´t%˜#qs`ceorqŠ€t%‡%€wŠ‡

k−ε dK~n‡ce0©€tO‡®qs`ceknd‚€˜†~6wyx‘tc­nm›kcÔk›dK~n‡ce0©†oªqs`ce„ ¢ f¸k€t%‡.§©¨ªk …O€wyq<·pwse<oy…OeL‰Âqyx‘µ†e<´m6¬

_a`ce¸‰0†…%€¥cx‘‘x¶qsx´eLoE~€¯A¥:~€qs`‚qy`ce¸§f¸k‚€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`‚€t%‡qs`ce…%wy~6…O~|oƒeL‡K`|mn¥cwsx{‡‚€…c…cws~66‰Š`²`OŽµ†eˆ¥:e0e<t

†…c…cwŠ€x{oƒeL‡x´tqy`ceaoƒx‘d#u%‘€qyx‘~†t~†¯pqy`ceªÃ%~£½€ws~†uctO‡osz6uO€wseN‰mn‘x´t%‡ce0wqB?„e0mntc~6‘‡%otnucd²¥Oe<w<·¥%6oƒeL‡

~6t«qs`ce¯Æ€wy³'Oe0{‡«µ6e0‘~n‰0x¶qrm4†t%‡À~†tÀqy`ce®oyx‘‡ce‘e0t%˜€qy`'~†¯Nqy`%eK‰0mn´x‘t%‡pe<w<·©eLz|u%€qs~

Re= 22000^¬"c~6w

qs`cx{oªµ†´uce¸~€¯qy`ce„e0mntc~6‘‡%oªtnucd²¥Oe<w<·poye0µ6e0wŠ€%e0Èp…Oe<wyx‘dKe0t|qs†I†t%‡®tnucdKe<wyx{‰0†Owse<oyuc´qso+€wse?Žµ€x‘‘†¥c‘e

x‘t.qy`ce‘x¶qse0wŠqsucwyeK»Æoye0e6·n¯±~†wx‘t%oƒqs€tO‰e†·c„ˆe¯r¬TPVU<”CRÁ·(P—CRÁ·(PؒCR±¼Â¬+!?x´Å:e<wye<t6qoyx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t%o+`%Žµ†e¸¥Oe<e0t¾‰0†wywsx´eL‡

~6upq‚¥nm½µŽ†wymnx‘tc˜Àqy`ce¾˜†wsx{‡ wse'%tce<dKe0t|q<·Nqy`ce¾x‘tpÃ%~£ µ€‘uce¾~€¯qy`ce¾qsucwy¥%uc´e<t|qK­nx‘tceqsx‘‰e<tce0ws˜†m½€tO‡

qs`ce²¯±wye<e#…%†ws†de0qye<w

δ x‘t4qy`%e†…c…cws~ŽÈnx‘d‚qse£+†´ qywse<€qydKe0t|q¸u%oƒeL‡°x‘t ¢ ¨ª„²·I£`cx{‰Š`4x{o¥O†oye<‡°~6t qs`ce#„e<x‘‰Š`O€wŠ‡nq£a€‘¶³Á‘Ž£(„e0¯r¬ P(UL“CR[¬T$ºt4qy`ce‰0†oye~€¯qs`ce#…cws~†…:~6oye<‡dK~p‡pe0[·I€‘©qy`%eqy`%wye<e#‡px´Å:e<wye<t6q

…%wy~6…O~|oy†‘o¯±~†wBqy`%e+¥%´e<t%‡px‘tc˜¸¯±uct%‰Âqsx´~6t

θ`%Žµ6eN¥:e0e0t²qyeLorqse<‡A¬NÓª~6d…O€wsx‘oy~†t%o£x¶qs`²e0Èp…Oe<wyx‘dKe0t|qs†n‡%qs

†t%‡.t|u%de<wyx{‰0†AwyeLoƒu%¶qŠoax´tqy`%e´x´qye<ws€qyucwse¸†wye†‘oy~²…%wy~µnx{‡pe<‡A¬

B ?$'&(l)+,.-/01.

_a`%ef?Žµ|x‘e0wy³rk|qy~6­†e<oe<z|u%qsx´~6t%o#¯±~†wK‰~†dK…cwse<osoyx´¥c‘e®ÃO~£ˆo#~†¯#»Æ‰0†´~6wyx{‰0†´‘m'€t%‡ qy`ce<wyd‚€‘‘mp¼#…:e0wy¯±e<‰Âq

fe0£aqs~†tcx{€t‚˜|†oye<oN†wye?‰~†tOoƒx{‡pe0wse<‡K`%e0wse†·|£wyx´qƒqse0t®x‘t›‰~6t%oye0wsµŽ€qyx‘µ†ea¯±~6wyd x‘t‚qy`ce¯±~†‘´~£x‘tc˜µ†wyx{€¥c‘e<o

»Æu%oyx´tc˜«¨Ex´tOorqse0x‘t tc~†qsqsx´~6tO¼

¿

‡pe<t%oyx¶qrmÄ»

ρ¼Â·8dK~6de<t|qyucd »

ρui

· i = 1,2,3¼†t%‡'qs~€qs†Ne<tce0ws˜†mQ…Oe<w u%tcx¶qˆµ6~†‘ucdKe‚»

E=ρe+ 1/2ρuiui

· e¥:e0x‘tc˜qy`cex‘t|qye0wst%†Ae0tce<wy˜6mp¼¬

¢ ox´t°„e0¯r¬TP(UL—CRÁ·pqy`ce¯±~6´‘~£x‘tc˜‡ce<‰~6dK…O~|oƒx´qyx‘~†t~€¯Bqy`ceÃO~£ µ€wsx‘†¥c‘e<o+x‘o6‡p~†…cqye<‡

¿

wi=< wi>

| {z }

RAN S

+ wi^c

|{z}

correction

+wiSGS

£`%e0wse

< wi>€wse¸qy`ceÃ%~£ µ€wsx{€¥c‘e<oax‘t4„ ¢ f¸kI·%~6¥pqs†x´t%e<‡.¥|m€…c…%´mnx‘tc˜®€t°Žµ†e<ws†˜†x‘tc˜#~6…Oe<ws€qy~6w qs~qy`ce?fŽµnx´e<wƒ³rk|qs~†­†eLoBe<z|u%qsx´~6t%o<·

w^c_i €wseaqy`cewye<dK†x´t%x´tc˜wse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡Ã%uO‰ÂqyuOqyx‘~†tOoˆ»±x[¬e6¬

< wi>+w^c_i

†wye?qy`%eÃ%~£ µ€wsx{€¥c‘e<o+x‘t¾§¨ªkc¼†t%‡

wiSGS †wye?qy`%euctcwse<oy~†‘µ†e<‡›~†wkcÔk›Ã%uO‰ÂqyuOqyx‘~†tOo0¬

$Á¯£ªe£wsx´qye¸qy`cef?Žµnx´e<wƒ³rk|qy~6­†eLoNeLz6uOqyx‘~†tOoax´t.qy`ce¯±~6´‘~£x‘tc˜‚‰~†dK…%6‰Âqˆ‰~6t%oye0wsµŽ€qyx‘µ†e¯±~†wsd

¿

∂W

∂t +∇ ·F(W) = 0

x‘t‚£`cx{‰Š`

F wye<…cwse<oye0t|qso¥:~€qs`‚qy`ce?µnx‘os‰~6u%oE€tO‡qy`ce¸‰~†tnµ6e<‰Âqsx´µ6e+Ã%upÈpe<o<·†¯±~6wEqs`ceŽµ†e<ws†˜†eL‡Ã%~£

hWi

£+e˜†e0q

¿

∂hWi

∂t +∇ ·F(hWi) =−τ^{RAN S}(hWi) ^»QUL¼

£`%e0wse

τ^{RAN S}(hWi)x‘oqy`ce‰0´~|oƒucwse?qye0wsd˜6x´µ6e0t.¥|mK„ ¢ f¸k®qsucws¥cuc‘e0t%‰0ed~p‡pe<H¬

¢

oª£+e0‘I­ntc~£t©·|¥|m®†…c…c‘mnx´tc˜ '%´qye<wyx‘tc˜~†…:e0wŠqs~†wEqs~qs`cefŽµnx´e<wƒ³rk|qs~†­†eLo8e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o<·6qy`ce§©¨ªk

eLz|u%qsx´~6t%oa€wse¸~6¥pqs†x´t%e<‡A·p£`cx{‰Š`©·cx‘tqy`ce…%wye<µ|x‘~†uOoƒ‘m‚x´t|qswy~p‡pu%‰0e<‡.tc~€qŠqsx´~6t%o0·c‰<€t¥Oe£wsx´qƒqye<t

¿

∂hWi+W^c

∂t +∇ ·F(hWi+W^c) =−τ^LES(hWi+W^c) ^»H’†¼

£`%e0wse

τ^LES x{o+qy`ce#k%Ôk®qse0wsd¾¬

¢ t½e<z|u%qsx´~6tQ¯±~†wqs`ce®wse<oy~†‘µ†e<‡«Ã%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o

W^c ‰0†tÀqs`nu%o¥:e›‡pe<wyx‘µ†eL‡À6o¯±~†‘´~£ˆo›»Æoye0e®€{oy~

„ˆe¯r¬TPVU<—CR±¼

¿

∂W^c

∂t +∇ ·F(hWi+W^c) − ∇ ·F(hWi) =τ^{RAN S}(hWi)−τ^LES(hWi+W^c) ^»Æ—6¼

_a`ce›¥%†oyx‘‰x{‡pe<¾~†¯aqy`ce‚…cws~†…:~6oye<‡Q`nmn¥cwsx‘‡ÀdK~n‡ce0Nx{oqs~4oƒ~6´µ6e¨ªzO¬'»UŽ¼¸x´t'qs`ce‚£`c~6´e®‡p~6d‚€x‘t

†t%‡½qs~Q‰0~†wswyeL‰Âq²qy`ce¾~†¥cqs€x‘tceL‡ Žµ†e<ws†˜†eL‡«ÃO~£ ¥nm †‡c‡px‘tc˜Àqy`cewse0d‚€x‘tcx‘tc˜Àwse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡QÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o

»H‰~6d…%upqyeL‡‚qy`%wy~6uc˜†`.¨Nz:¬ˆ»Æ—6¼y¼Â·p£`ce<wye<µ†e<wEqy`%e¸˜6wyx{‡®wse<oy~†‘upqsx´~6t®x‘oa6‡pe<z|u%€qyeˆ¯±~6w²§¨ªkI¬*$ºt%oƒqyeL†‡®~†¯

uOoƒx‘tc˜ 0~†tO€p€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`#6ox´t‚„e0¯r¬PVU<—CRÁ·†x‘t£`cx‘‰Š`qs`ceawye<˜†x‘~†t%oB£`ce<wye+qy`%ea6‡c‡px´qyx‘~†t%†nÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o

qs`%qad#uOorqa¥Oe‰~6dK…cupqyeL‡›†wye¸³Á…cwyx‘~†wsxO‡ce'%tceL‡A·p£+e£x{oƒ`›qy~K‰~†tOorqswyu%‰q+ A*2%5B41D80<@/†`nmn¥cwyx{‡®dK~p‡pe<H¬

_ ~²qy`cx{o€x‘d¾·p£ªex‘t6qswy~p‡puO‰e 0/(102 45276DA*2 :;F42O·

θ·%oydK~|~†qy`c‘m‚µ€wsmnx´tc˜¥:eqr£+e0e0t

0^†t%‡ 1^¬Ä`ce0t θ = 1^·tc~ ‰0~†wswyeL‰Âqyx‘~†t>qy~

hWi x{o›‰~6dK…cupqyeL‡]€tO‡A·aqy`nu%o<·aqy`ceQ„ ¢ f¸kā€…%…cwy~|†‰Š`Òx‘o›wyeL‰~µ6e0wse<‡A¬

Óª~6tnµ†e0wŠoye0‘m†·:£`ce0wse0µ6e0w

θ <1·©†‡%‡px¶qsx´~6t%€8wse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡Ã%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o†wyeK‰~6d…%upqyeL‡AÇx‘t«qs`ceK´x‘dKx¶q~†¯

θ→ 0£+e£+†t6q?qy~wyeL‰~µ6e0w?›¯±uc‘E§©¨ªkÀ€…%…cwy~|†‰Š`©¬_a`ceK‡pe0'%tcx´qyx‘~†tQ~€¯Eqs`ceK¥c´e<t%‡px‘tc˜.¯±uct%‰Âqsx´~6tÀx{o

‡cx‘os‰u%osoye<‡x´t°‡pe0qs†x´{ox‘t«kne<‰†¬+’p¬VU€¬a_a`nu%o0·%£`ce0wse0µ6e0w

θ <1·c£+e€{oy~Koy~†‘µ†eqs`ce¯±~†‘‘~£x´tc˜‚eLz|u%qsx´~6t

¯±~6waqy`ceÃOu%‰Âqsu%qsx´~6t%o

¿

∂W^c

∂t + ∇ ·F(hWi+W^c) − ∇ ·F(hWi) = (1−θ)

τ^{RAN S}(hWi)−τ^LES(hWi+W^c)

»±•|¼

f~€qseqy`%€q¯±~†w

θ→1^{qs`ce#„ ¢} f?k‘x´dKx´qˆx‘o†‰Âqsu%€‘‘m›wse<‰~µ6e0wse<‡AÇnx‘t%‡pe<e<‡A·p¯±~6w

θ= 1qs`cewsx´˜6`6qy³[`O€t%‡

oyx{‡peK~€¯a¨Nz:¬4»±•|¼¸µ†tcx‘oy`ceLo€t%‡A· `ce0tO‰e†·B.qywsx´µnx{€Eoy~†‘upqyx‘~†tQx‘o

W^c = 0^{¬ ¢} owse<z|ucx‘wyeL‡A·A¯±~6w

θ = 0

¨ªzO¬Ä»Æ•|¼¥:e<‰0~†dKe<ox{‡pe0t|qsx‘‰<€ªqy~«¨ªzO¬Ä»H—6¼²€t%‡'qs`cewye<dK†x´t%x´tc˜ÀwyeLoƒ~6´µ6e<‡ÀÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%oK†wye›6‡c‡peL‡

qs~¾qy`ce.Žµ†e0wŠ€˜6e<‡4Ã%~£ÇBqy`ce®dK~p‡pe<H·Bqy`nu%o<·B£ª~6wy­pox‘t §©¨ªkQdK~p‡pe†¬"c~6w

θ ˜†~6x´t%˜¾¯±wy~6d UKqy~À“c·BxH¬e†¬

£`%e0t©·%¯±~†‘´~£x‘tc˜qy`ce²‡pe'%t%x¶qsx´~6t°~€¯qy`ce#¥c´e<t%‡px‘tc˜‚¯±uctO‰Âqyx‘~†t »Hoƒe<e#kne<‰†¬a’c¬(UL¼Â·Oqy`ce˜6wyx{‡wyeLoƒ~6´ucqyx‘~†tx‘o

x‘t|qye<wydKe<‡cx‘€qye¥:eqr£+e0e<t›~6tce?6‡pe<z|u%€qye?¯±~†wa„

¢

f¸k›†t%‡‚~†t%e¸6‡pe<z|u%€qyeˆ¯±~6w+§¨ªkI·nqs`ce?wsx‘˜†`|qy`%†t%‡coyx‘‡ce

qse0wsd x‘t®¨Nz:¬ˆ»Æ•6¼8x{oª‡%€dK…OeL‡Kqy`%wy~6uc˜†`‚d²uc¶qsx´…%´x{‰0€qyx‘~†t®¥nm

(1−θ)^{¬ ¢} ¶qs`c~†u%˜†`®x´q+‰0~†uc{‡®oye0e0d¤wŠqy`%e0w

†wy¥%x¶qsws†wym#¯±wy~6d¤#…c`nmnoyx{‰0€O…O~6x´t|q+~€¯Aµnx´e<£·6qs`cx{oNx{oª†x´dKeL‡qy~#~6¥pqs†x´t.oƒdK~n~€qs`‚qywŠ€tOoƒx´qyx‘~†t‚¥:eqr£+e0e<t

„ ¢ f?k¾†t%‡°§©¨+kI¬:h4~†wseoƒ…:e<‰0xS'O‰<€‘´m6·%£+e£x‘oy`¾qy~›~†¥pqŠ€x‘t¾®…cwy~6˜†wse<osoƒx‘µ†e†‡%‡px¶qsx´~6t¾~€¯Ã%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o

£`%e0tqy`cea˜6wyx{‡#wse<oy~†‘upqsx´~6t²x‘t%‰wse<6oƒeLo€t%‡#qy`cedK~p‡pe<%oƒ£x´qs‰Š`%e<oB¯±ws~†d‹qs`ceˆ„ ¢ f¸k#qy~qy`%eˆ§©¨ªk²dK~p‡pe†·

x‘t~†wŠ‡pe0w+qy~Kqswym®qy~K~µ†e<ws‰0~†dKeˆqs`ce£ªe<´A­ntc~£t…cws~†¥c‘e0d‚o+~€¯eÈpx{orqsx´t%˜u%tcx´µ6e0wŠoy†I`|mn¥cwsx{‡®dK~p‡pe0{ox‘t

qs`ceqsws†t%oƒx´qyx‘~†t¯±ws~†d„ ¢ f¸k.qy~›§¨ªkI·O6o0·c¯±~†wˆx‘t%oƒqs€tO‰e†·%qy`ceƒ˜†wŠŽm <~†tceLox´t9!?¨ªk¾~6waqy`cet%e0e<‡¾~†¯

6‡c‡px´qyx‘~†t~€¯8oƒmnt|qy`%eqyx{‰?qyucws¥cuc‘e0tO‰ex‘t¾§ f?k„e0¯r¬TP(URÁ¬

knu%dd‚†wyx0x‘tc˜%·Iqs`ceKx´t%˜†wse<‡px‘e0t|qso¸~†¯Eqy`ceK…cws~†…:~6oye<‡À€…c…%wy~|†‰Š`«†wye

¿

„ ¢ f¸k«‰0´~|oƒucwsed~p‡pe<H·©

k%Ôk›dK~p‡pe<I¯±~†w§¨ªk€t%‡›qy`ce‡ce'%tcx´qyx‘~†t¾~†¯qy`%e¥c´e<t%‡px‘tc˜K¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t©¬

¢ oB¯Æ€wBqy`ce‰0´~|oƒucwse+~€¯%qs`ce„ ¢ f¸keLz|u%qsx´~6t%oBx‘o8‰0~†t%‰0e0wstce<‡A·x‘t²qy`cea…cwse<oye0t|q8orqsu%‡pm†·€qy`ceoƒqs€tO‡c€wŠ‡

k−εdK~p‡pe<:„e0¯r¬-P(U HRIx‘oªu%oye<‡A·nx‘t®£`cx{‰Š`‚qy`ce¸„e0mntc~6‘‡%oªoƒqywse<oso8qse0t%oy~†wªx‘oªdK~n‡ce0‘e<‡‚¥nmKx´t|qswy~p‡pu%‰0x´t%˜

#qyu%wy¥cu%´e<t6qae<‡%‡pm|³[µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qrm

µt

·c‡pe'Otce<‡†o+¯±u%t%‰Âqsx´~6t.~†¯©qy`ce¸qsucwy¥%uc´e<t|qa­nx‘tceqsx‘‰?e0t%e0ws˜†m

k ^{†t%‡®~†¯}

qs`ceqyu%wy¥cu%´e<t6q‡cx‘osoƒx‘…%€qyx‘~†t›wŠqse~€¯e0tce<wy˜6m†·

ε·%†o+¯±~6´‘~£ˆo

¿

µt=Cµk² ε

»†¼

£`%e0wse

Cµ

x{oª²dK~n‡ce0I…%€wŠ€dKe0qye0wL·6oyeqa`ce<wye?e<z|u%€:qs~qy`%e¸‰0‘6oyoyx‘‰<€:µ€‘uce~†¯

0.09^†t%‡ k^†t%‡ ε ^†wye

~6¥pqs†x´t%e<‡›¯±wy~6d qy`ce‰0~†wswyeLoƒ…:~†tO‡px´t%˜²dK~p‡pe0‘e<‡›qywŠ€tOoƒ…:~†wyqe<z|u%qsx´~6t%o»Æoye0e„e0¯r¬TP(U HR±¼Â¬

"%~†w¸qy`ce‚§¨ªk4dK~p‡pe6·©£ªe£x{oƒ`«qy~wyeL‰~µ†e<wˆqs`ceK¹E€wsx‘€qyx‘~†t%†Bh°u%¶qsx¶³rkp‰0†´eK€…%…cwy~|†‰Š`«„ˆe¯r¬ PVUUR[·

x‘t¾£`cx{‰Š`›qs`ceÃ%~£ µ†wyx{€¥c‘e<oa†wye‡peL‰~†dK…:~6oye<‡†o+¯±~6´‘~£ˆo

¿

wi= wi

|{z}

LRS

+ w⁰_i

|{z}

SRS

+wiSGS ^»Æ”6¼

£`%e0wse

wi

€wseqs`ce‘†wy˜6ewyeLoƒ~6´µ6e<‡°os‰0†´eLo#»Æ§ „kc¼·

w⁰_i †wyeqs`ceKoƒd‚€‘wyeLoƒ~6´µ6e<‡°os‰0†´eLo#»Hkc„kc¼Â¬©_a`%x‘o

‡ce<‰~6dK…O~|oƒx´qyx‘~†tx‘oN~†¥pqŠ€x‘tce<‡²¥nm#µ€wsx{qyx‘~†tO€p…cws~€reL‰Âqyx‘~†tx‘tKqy`ceˆ§ „kK€t%‡‚kp„?kKoƒ…%6‰eLowyeLoƒ…:e<‰qyx‘µ†e0‘m†¬

$ºt qy`ce…cwse<oye0t|q²oƒqyu%‡pm6·8£ªe›¯±~†‘´~£ qs`ce›¹¸h«k †…c…cws~66‰Š`Q…%wy~6…O~|oƒeL‡'x´t „ˆe¯r¬ P(UŽ’HRa¯±~†wqs`ce¾oƒx‘d#uc{³

qsx´~6t®~€¯‰0~†dK…cwse<osoƒx‘¥c‘eaqyucws¥cuc‘e0t|qªÃ%~£ˆo8qs`cwy~6uc˜†`®'%tcx´qye?µ†~†‘ucdKeŽ¦C'%tcx´qyeˆe<´e<dKe0t|q+‡px{os‰wseqyx<€qyx‘~†t‚~6t

u%t%orqswyuO‰Âqyu%wyeL‡®qseqywŠ€`%e<‡pwŠ€I˜†wsx{‡co0¬

$Á¯

χl

€wseˆqy`%e

N '%tcx´qye0³[µ6~†‘ucdKe?¥O†oyx‘oª¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t%oa†t%‡

φl

qy`ce

N '%tcx´qye³Áe0‘e0dKe<t6q¥%6oƒx{oª¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t%o

6oyoy~p‰x{qse<‡Kqs~²qs`ceu%oye<‡.˜†wsx‘‡A·|qs`ceԁ€‘e0ws­|x‘t.†…c…cws~ŽÈpx´d‚qsx´~6t‚~€¯ qy`cefŽµnx‘e0wy³ºknqy~†­6e<oªe<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o+‰0†t

¥:e£wsx¶qyqye0t¾†o+¯±~6´‘~£ˆo

¿

∂W

∂t , χl

+ (∇ ·Fc(W), χl) + (∇ ·Fv(W), φl) = 0 l= 1, N ^{» €¼}

£`%e0wse

(·,·) ‡pe0tc~†qye<oqy`%e

L² os‰0†‘†wˆ…cws~n‡cu%‰ÂqL·

Fc(W) €wseqy`%e‰0~†tnµ†eL‰Âqyx‘µ†eÃOupÈneLo0·A‡px{os‰wseqyx0eL‡°¥nm 'Otcx¶qseµ†~6´ucdKeLo+†t%‡

Fv(W)€wseqs`ceµnx‘os‰~6u%oªÃ%upÈpe<o<·%‡px{oy‰0wye0qyx0e<‡.¥nmG'%tcx´qyee<´e<dKe0t|qso<¬#$ºt~6ws‡ce0w+qy~

~6¥pqs†x´tKqs`ce¹¸h«kKÃO~£ ‡ce<‰~6dK…O~|oƒx´qyx‘~†t‚x‘t®¨Nz:¬ˆ»Æ”6¼Â·|qy`ce'%tcx´qye‡px‘de<t%oyx´~6t%€:oƒ…%6‰eLo

VF V

€t%‡

VF E

·

wse<oy…:e<‰Âqsx´µ6e0‘m®oƒ…O€tctceL‡¥|m

χl

€t%‡

φl

·%‰0†t.¥:ex‘t.qsucwst¾‡ce<‰~6dK…O~|oƒeL‡.6o+¯±~†‘´~£ˆoa„e0¯r¬TP(UŽ’HR

¿

VF V =VF V

MV_{F V}⁰ ; VF E =VF E

MV_{F E}^{0 » ¼}

x‘t#£`%x‘‰Š` L‡pe<tc~€qse<oqy`ce‡px‘wse<‰Âqoƒu%d €t%‡

VF V

€tO‡

V_{F V}⁰ †wyeNqy`ce'%tcx´qye+µ†~6´ucdKe+oƒ…%6‰eLo 6oyoy~p‰x{qyeL‡

qs~®qs`ce#{€ws˜†eLorq?†t%‡°oydK†´‘e<oƒq?wse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡¾oy‰<€‘e<o<·:oy…%€t%tce<‡¾¥nmqy`ce²¥%†oyx{oˆ¯±uctO‰Âqyx‘~†tOo

χl

€t%‡

χ⁰_l^Ç VF E

†t%‡

V_{F E}^{0 €wseqy`ce} '%tcx´qye²e0‘e0dKe0t|q€t%†´~6˜†~†uOo0¬T$ºt«„ˆe¯r¬NPVUL’CR8®…cwy~†re<‰qy~†w~†…:e0wŠqy~6w

P x‘t°qy`ceK§„?k oy…%6‰ex‘o‡ce'%tceL‡¥|m.oƒ…%€qyx{€©Žµ6e0wŠ€˜†e?~†td‚†‰ws~K‰e0‘{ox´t.qy`%e¯±~†‘´~£x‘tc˜K£+Žm

¿

W =P(W) =X

k







V ol(Ck) X

jI_k

V ol(Cj) X

jI_k

χj







| {z }

χ_k

W_k ^»6¼

¯±~6waqy`ce‰0~†tnµ†eL‰Âqsx´µ6eqse0wsdKo<·c‡px{oy‰0wye0qyx0eL‡›¥nmG'%t%x¶qseµ†~†‘ucdKe<o<·c€tO‡

¿

W =P(W) =X

k







V ol(Ck) X

jIk

V ol(Cj) X

jIk

φj







| {z }

φ_k

W_k

»QU<“6¼

¯±~6wqs`ceK‡px¶ÅIu%oyx´µ6eqse0wsdKo<·A‡px{oy‰0wye0qyx0e<‡4¥|m'Otcx¶qse²µ6~†‘ucdKe<o<¬ $ºt«¥O~†qy`«¨ªz|o<¬‚»|¼†t%‡ » UL“†¼Â·

Cj

x{o?qy`ce

'Otcx¶qse?µ6~†‘ucdKe¸‰0e0‘A€ws~†uct%‡‚qy`ce¸tc~p‡pe

j^· V ol(Cj)‡pe<tc~€qse<o+x¶qŠo+µ†~†‘ucdKe€t%‡

Ik ={j/Cj∈Cm(k)}^· Cm(k)

¥:e0x‘tc˜¸qy`cead‚†‰0wy~†³Á‰0e0‘|‰0~†t|qs†x´tcx‘tc˜?qy`ce‰0e0‘

Ck

¬B_a`%e+d‚6‰ws~€³º‰e0‘{o€wse+~†¥pqŠ€x‘tce<‡²¥nm#…%wy~p‰eLoyo

­ntc~£t6o †˜†˜6´~6de<ws€qyx‘~†t„e¯r¬PVU0•4RÁ¬B_a`%eN¥%6oƒx{o©¯±u%t%‰Âqsx´~6t%o©¯±~6wqs`cekp„koy…%†‰0eª†wyeN‰0´eL€ws´m¸~†¥cqs€x‘tceL‡

6o+¯±~†‘´~£ˆo

¿ χ⁰_l=χl−χ_l ^†t%‡ φ⁰_l=φl−φ_l^¬

"Bx‘t%€‘´m6·Žx´tqs`ceN¹¸h«k†…c…cws~6†‰Š`¸qs`ce+kcÔk¸dK~p‡pe<6x{o 6‡c‡peL‡~†tc‘mqs~qy`%eªoydK†´‘e<oƒqwse<oy~†‘µ†eL‡¸os‰0†´eLo0¬

¢ oˆx‘t«„e0¯r¬ P(UŽ’HR[·Oqy`%e²knd‚€˜6~†wsx´t%oy­nm›dK~p‡pe0 x‘ou%oye<‡A·I€t%‡©·%`ce<t%‰e6·%qs`cekcÔk.qse0wsd‚o€wse‡px{oy‰0wye0qyx0eL‡

†t%€‘~†˜6~†u%oy‘m²qs~qy`ceµnx{oy‰0~†u%o+Ã%ucÈneLo0¬8_a`nu%o<·pqy`%e#ԁ€‘e0ws­|x‘t›…%wy~†re<‰Âqsx´~6t.~†¯ ¨Nz:¬»[’€¼+¥:e<‰~6dKe<o

¿

∂hWi+W^c

∂t , χl

+ (∇ ·Fc(hWi+W^c), χl) + (∇ ·Fv(hWi+W^c), φl) =− τ^LES(W⁰), φ⁰_l

l= 1, N

»QUUL¼

x‘t4£`cx{‰Š`

τLES

x‘o?dK~n‡ce0‘e<‡4¥nm¾x‘t6qswy~p‡puO‰x‘tc˜›.k%Ôk°e<‡%‡pm|³[µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qrm

µs

¬¸_a`ceKknd‚€˜6~†wsx´t%oy­nm¾k%Ôk

dK~p‡pe<©„e¯r¬ Pؒ*URx‘o6‡p~†…cqye<‡.`ce<wye6Çnqy`nu%o<·c£ªe`%Žµ6e

¿

µs=ρ⁰Cs∆²q

S_ij⁰ S_ij^{0 »QUL’†¼}

£`%e0wse

Cs

x{oNqs`ce¸d~p‡pe<Ix´tc…%upq+…O€wŠ€dKeqse0wL·

S_ij⁰ x{oEqs`ceorqsws†x´tp³ÁwŠqyeˆqye0tOoƒ~6w¸»H‰~†dK…cucqye<‡›x´t®qy`ce¸¹?h«k

†…c…cws~66‰Š`6oˆK¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t°~†¯

W⁰

€t%‡

∆ x{o‚‘e0tc˜†qy`°£`cx{‰Š`4oy`c~†uc{‡¥Oe²wye<…cwse<oye0t|qs€qyx‘µ†e~€¯qy`%e#oƒx0e

~†¯qs`cewyeLoƒ~6´µ6e<‡‚qsucws¥cuc‘e0t|qˆoy‰<€‘e<o<¬ Ñ e0wse†·

∆`O†o+¥Oe<e0t°oye0‘e<‰Âqse<‡†o

V ol(i)^1/3 »Éqs`%qx{o+qy`ceµ6~†‘ucdKe

~†¯qs`cex¶³[qy`qseqywŠ€`%e<‡pwŠ€Ie0‘e0dKe<t6q¼a€t%‡

Cs

`%†oa¥:e0e<t¾oyeqˆeLz|u%€Iqs~K“%¬(U6¬

"Bx‘t%€‘´m6·cqs`ce²Ô€‘e0ws­nx´t¾…cws~€reL‰Âqsx´~6t.~†¯¨ªz|o<¬»UL¼ˆ€t%‡'»±•n¼+¯±~†wˆqy`ce#‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t~†¯

hWi^{€t%‡~†¯}

qs`ce†‡%‡px¶qsx´~6t%€IÃOu%‰Âqsu%qsx´~6t%oax´tqs`ce…cws~†…:~6oye<‡®`nmn¥cwsx‘‡.dK~p‡pe0©¥:e<‰0~†dKewyeLoƒ…:e<‰qyx‘µ†e<´m

¿

∂hWi

∂t , χl

+ (∇ ·Fc(hWi), χl) + (∇ ·Fv(hWi), φl) =

− τ^{RAN S}(hWi), φl

l= 1, N

»QU<—6¼

∂W^c

∂t , χl

+ (∇ ·Fc(hWi+W^c), χl)−(∇ ·Fc(hWi), χl) + (∇ ·Fv(W^c), φl) = (1−θ)

τ^{RAN S}(hWi), φl

− τ^LES(W⁰), φ⁰_l

l= 1, N

»QU0•|¼

"!#%$&'(

¢ oK…O~|oyoyx‘¥c´e‰Š`c~6x‘‰0e¯±~6w

θ·pqs`ce¸¯±~†‘´~£x‘tc˜¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t¾x{oau%oƒeL‡x´tqy`%e…cwyeLoƒe<t|qoƒqyuO‡pm

¿

θ=F(ξ) =tanh(ξ²) ^»QU†¼

£`%e0wse

ξ <sup>x‘o+qs`ce /V123 452</sup> 6*)%<4=<@E 10:?10·c£`cx{‰Š`¾oƒ`c~6uc{‡®x‘t%‡px{‰0qse£`ceqs`ce0waqs`ce˜†wsx‘‡›wyeLoƒ~6´ucqyx‘~†t›x{o'%tce e<tc~†u%˜†`.qy~KwyeLoƒ~6´µ6e¸Koyx´˜6tcx('O‰0†t6q…%†wƒq~†¯ qs`ceqyucws¥cuc‘e0tO‰eÃ%u%‰qyu%€qyx‘~†t%o<·px[¬e6¬qy~‚~†¥cqs€x‘t¾§¨ªk|³Á´x‘­†e

oyx‘d#uc{qsx´~6t©¬_a`ceN‰Š`%~†x{‰e8~€¯nqs`ce 0/(123 45276() <@=<4EG10:?10Ax‘o‰‘e<€ws‘m?­6e0m…:~†x‘t|q©¯±~†w©qy`ceN‡ce'%tcx´qyx‘~†t#~€¯nqy`ce

…%wyeLoƒe<t6qª`|mn¥cwsx{‡Kd~p‡pe<H¬#$ºt‚qs`ce…%wyeLoƒe<t6q+orqsu%‡pm†·p‡px´ÅIe0wse0t|qª~6…pqyx‘~†t%oª€wseˆ…cws~†…:~6oye<‡‚†t%‡Kx´tnµ6e<oƒqyx‘˜6qse<‡A·

tO€dKe0‘m

¿

+ ξ =µs

µt

·p£`cx{‰Š`¾x‘o†‘oy~Ku%oye<‡†o¥c‘e0t%‡px‘tc˜‚…%†ws†dKeqye<wax´t°§f¸k„e¯r¬TPVURÁ·

+ ξ = ∆

lRAN S

· lRAN S

¥:e0x‘tc˜®²qrmn…cx{‰0€A‘e0t%˜€qy`¾x‘tqy`ce„ ¢ f?k€…%…cwy~|†‰Š`©·nx[¬e6¬

lRAN S=k^3/2

+ ξ = tLES

tRAN S

·

tLES

†t%‡

tRAN S

¥:e0x‘tc˜«‰Š`%†ws6‰Âqse0wsx‘oƒqyx{‰²qyx‘deLo~†¯+qs`ce›§¨ªk½€tO‡½„ ¢ f¸k½€…p³

…cws~6†‰Š`%e<o+wyeLoƒ…:e<‰qyx‘µ†e<´m6·

tLES= 1 qS_ij⁰ S_ij⁰

€t%‡

tRAN S=k

¬

#"

_ ~Žµ6~†x{‡¸qy`ce+oƒ~6´upqsx´~6t~€¯pqr£+~‡px´ÅIe0wse0t|qBoymporqse0d‚o~†¯c} !?¨Q†t%‡qy`%eª‰~6t%oye<z|uce0t|qx‘t%‰0wyeL†oyeE~€¯cwse<z|ucx‘wyeL‡

‰0~†dK…cupqŠqsx´~6t%€Awse<oy~†ucwŠ‰eLo0·|¨Nzno<¬ˆ» U<—6¼a€t%‡'»U<•6¼a‰0†t.¥:ewse<‰06orq+qy~6˜†e0qy`ce<wˆ†o+¯±~†‘‘~£ˆo

¿

∂W

∂t , χl

+ (∇ ·Fc(W), χl) + (∇ ·Fv(W), φl) =

−θ τ^{RAN S}(hWi), φl

−(1−θ) τ^LES(W⁰), φ⁰_l

l= 1, N

»QU<”6¼

Óª‘e<†wy‘m†· x¶¯~6tc´m«¨Nz:¬Q»QU<”†¼x{o#oy~†‘µ†eL‡A·

hWi x‘ot%~€q#Žµ€x‘‘†¥c‘eK€qe<6‰Š`Àqsx´dKe›oƒqye<…©¬._ £+~4‡px¶ÅIe0wse0t|q

~6…pqyx‘~†tOo†wye…:~6osoƒx‘¥c‘e

¿

e0x´qy`ce<wKqy~'u%oye¾†t>†…c…cws~ŽÈnx‘d‚qsx´~6t ~€¯

hWi ~†¥pqŠ€x‘tce<‡>¥nm Žµ†e0wŠ€˜6x´t%˜«€t%‡

oydK~n~€qy`%x´tc˜~†¯

W·†x‘tKqy`%eˆoƒ…cx‘wsx¶qE~†¯:¹¸h«kI·†~6wqy~oyx´dK…c‘m#uOoƒex‘tK¨Nz:¬a»QU<”†¼

τ^{RAN S}(W)¬8_a`ceˆoƒeL‰~6t%‡

~6…pqyx‘~†tx{o†‡p~6…pqyeL‡.x‘t.qy`ce…cwse<oye0t|qˆoƒqyu%‡pm†o '%wŠorqˆ†…c…cws~ŽÈnx‘d‚qsx´~6t©¬

$' -.-)

_a`%e®„e0mntc~6‘‡coƒ³ ¢ µ6e0wŠ€˜†eL‡4fŽµnx‘e0wy³ºknqy~†­6e<o¸e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%o¸¯±~6w#‰~6dK…cwyeLoyoyx‘¥c´eÃ%~£ˆo~†¯»Æ‰0†´~6wyx{‰0†´‘m4€tO‡

qs`ce0wsd‚€‘´mc¼…:e0wy¯±e<‰q.fˆe<£aqy~†t%x‘†tҘ|†oye<o‚†wye°‰~6t%oyx‘‡pe<wyeL‡ `%e0wse†·a£wyx´qƒqse0t x‘t]‰~†tOoƒe<wyµqsx´µ6e¯±~†wsd x‘t

qs`ce¯±~6´‘~£x‘tc˜®µ€wsx‘†¥c‘e<o

¿

‡pe<t%oyx¶qrm½»

ρ¼Â·IdK~†dKe<t6qsucd »

ρui

· i= 1,2,3¼a€t%‡°qy~€qŠ€Be0tce<wy˜6m›…:e0w¸uctcx´q µ6~†‘ucdKe‚»

E=ρe+ 1/2ρuiui

· e ¥:e0x‘tc˜qy`cex‘t|qye0wst%†Ae0tce<wy˜6mp¼¬

_a`ce+orqŠ€t%‡%€wŠ‡

k−εdK~p‡pe0n„e¯r¬PVUHRnx‘ou%oye<‡¯±~6w©qy`%eª‰‘~6oyucwse8~€¯pqs`ceª„ ¢ f?keLz|u%qsx´~6t%o0·Lx‘t£`cx{‰Š`

qs`ce„e<m|t%~†{‡coaorqswyeLoyo+qse0t%oy~†wx{oadK~n‡ce0‘e<‡¾†oª¯±~†‘‘~£ˆo0·p¥nm®x‘t|qyws~n‡cu%‰x‘tc˜‚²qyucws¥cuc‘e0t|qˆe<‡%‡pm|³[µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qrm6·

µt^¿

Rij 'µt

∂eui

∂xj

+∂uej

∂xi

−2 3

∂eul

∂xl

δij

| {z }

Pe_ij

−2

3ρkδij , ^{»QU €¼}

x‘t#£`%x‘‰Š`²qy`ceªqyx‘{‡pe‡pe0tc~†qyeLoqs`ceT"%ŽµnwseªŽµ†e<ws†˜†e6·0qs`ceª~µ6e0ws¥%€wqyx‘dKeaŽµ6e0wŠ€˜6x´tc˜O·

δij

x‘o qy`%ew†t%e<‰Š­†e<w

oymnd#¥:~†©†t%‡

k x‘oaqs`ceqyu%wy¥cu%´e<t6q?­|x‘tce0qyx{‰e0tce<wy˜6m†¬N_a`ceqsucws¥cuc‘e0t|qˆe<‡c‡cm6³Áµnx‘os‰~|oƒx´qrm

µt

x‘o‡pe'%t%e<‡°†o

²¯±uctO‰Âqyx‘~†t¾~†¯

k €t%‡.~€¯Bqy`%eqyucws¥cuc‘e0t|q‡px{oyoyx‘…%qsx´~6t.wŠqse¸~†¯ e<tce0ws˜†m6·

ε·c6oax´t¾¨Nz:¬ˆ»†¼Â¬

$ºtÀqy`ce®§ f?k«dK~n‡ce0qy`%eK„ˆe0mntc~†{‡cooƒqywse<osoqse0t%oy~†w˜6x´µ6e0t«¥nm°qs`ce‚„ ¢ f¸kQ‰‘~6oyucwye²x‘od²uc´qyx‘…c´x‘e<‡

¥nm À¥c‘e0t%‡px‘tc˜À¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t©¬Ò_a`|uOo0·8qs`ce°§f¸k½e<z|u%€qyx‘~†t%oK†wye.~†¥pqŠ€x‘tce<‡ ¯±wy~6d qy`ce¾„ ¢ f¸k>~†tceLo#¥nm

wse0…%‘6‰x‘tc˜#qs`ce„e<m|t%~†{‡coorqswyeLoyo+qse0t%oy~†w

Rij

·p˜†x‘µ†e0t¥nm®¨Nz:¬»QU ¼·c£x¶qs`qy`ceqse0t%oy~†w

Lij^¿

Lij =αRij=αµtPeij−2

3ρ(αk)δij , ^{»QU ¼}

£`%e0wse

αx‘o+qs`ce‡c€dK…cx‘tc˜K¯±uctO‰Âqyx‘~†t½»

0≤α≤1¼Â·cµ†wymnx‘tc˜²x‘t°oƒ…O†‰e†t%‡®qsx´dKe6¬

$ºtqy`%e§f?k.dK~p‡pe0…cwy~6…O~|oƒeL‡®x‘t°„e¯r¬TPVURÁ·pqy`%e‡%€dK…cx‘tc˜K¯±uct%‰qyx‘~†t¾x‘o‡ce'%tceL‡¾†o+¯±~†‘‘~£ˆo

¿

α= min µs

µt

,1

»QU 6¼

x‘t°£`cx{‰Š`

µs

x‘oˆqy`ceKkcÔk¾µnx{oy‰0~6oyx¶qrm.~†¥pqŠ€x‘tce<‡¯±ws~†d¨Nz:¬(UŽ’K£x¶qs`°qy`%e~†tc‘m¾‡px¶ÅIe0wse0tO‰eqs`%q¸`ce0wse

∆

`O†oª¥Oe<e0t.oye0‘e<‰qyeL‡A·|¯±~†w+e<†‰Š`®qyeqsws†`ce<‡cws†%e0‘e0dKe<t6qa~€¯qy`ce¸˜†wsx‘‡©·|6oEqs`ce?‘e0t%˜€qy`.~€¯©qs`ce¸´~6tc˜†eLorqNeL‡p˜†e

»Hoƒe<e„e¯r¬ P•4R±¼Â¬