Testing communicating systems : a model, a methodology and a tool

HAL Id: hal-00408493

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00408493

Preprint submitted on 30 Jul 2009

HAL

is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Testing communicating systems : a model, a methodology and a tool

Ismail Berrada, Richard Castanet, Patrick Felix

To cite this version:

Ismail Berrada, Richard Castanet, Patrick Felix. Testing communicating systems : a model, a method-

ology and a tool. 2005. �hal-00408493�

&',(-)-..*- (/-)

?

0214357698 :;=<><>5@?A5 BCEDGFH57<G?JI5+1LK>57MH;K NO5PK><4CEDGQSRUT=8VCXW

Y[Z]\U^`_acbUd^e.afg^ihkjkl]lf$monqpsr>t2uvnxw2y\Uz=tL{@r|Z=}@~€

kk‚ lshƒ„Z=…Xr>mo†Gr!†Gr|{+r>~A‡@ˆ@tLZkm@†Gr

‰Š

r4tvtLZ]{oZ

|†|Z=u‹wLZkmor4w

|^Œr>…Xnx~Žk…XZ

Š

t2n‘

Œt

’“„”G•G–—Ž˜k•]™ ƒcš@nquœ›oZk›r>t

Œ

z]…q…qz|žŸuœw žcz`¡-Zknqm¢…Xnqm@rGuz

Œ

t2rGuvr|Z=t2†Lš[]ƒcšorœ£ot2u‹w…qnqmorUnXu

t2rG…XZw2r|{!w2zŸw2šorœu‹w2}Ž{7¤¥z

Œ

¡.z7{+rG…qu

Œ

z=t„w2šor{@r>uv†>t2nq›@w2nqz]m¢z

Œ

u‹¤+u‹w2rG¡.uGˆoz=t„w2šonqu¦…qnqmork‡

žUr§nqmPwvt2z7{@}@†Gr¥w2šor!¡.z7{@r>…[z

Œ¢¨œ©=ª«ª«¬7­@®°¯2±k²‘®E­7³-´oµ=¶L² ·4ª§¶¸

bOeo¹4‡@žŸšonq†LšS{@r>£omorGu

Z-uvr>wz

Œ

†Gzk¡.¡.z]mºt2rGuvzk}@t2†Gr>uG‡¦Z-uvr>wz

Œ

r>m7w2nxw2nqrGuG‡HZ=mŽ{SZ-w2zk›z]…qz]»=¤€z

Œ

†Gz]¡.¡§}@a

m@nX†GZ=w2nqz]mH ƒcšoruvrG†GzkmŽ{%…qnqmor

Œ

zP†G}@uvrGu«zkm¼w2r>u‹w2nXm@»¡.r>w2šoz7{+z]…qz]»knqrGu.Z]{@Zk›+w2r|{w2z

›+t2zkw2zP†Gzk…cw2rGu‹w2nqmo»@ˆozkt¢w2šonqu¢…Xnqm@r]‡„žcr-»knXp]rZ

Œ

zkt2¡-Zk…c{@r>£omonxw2nqz]mJz

Œ

Z»krGmor>t2nq†

»krGmor>tLZw2nqz]mZk…q»]z=t2nxw2šo¡

¸¾½½¥¿

¹4]Àr`{@rG¡.zkmou‹wvtLZ=w2rcw2šoZ=wœw2šor$bOe«¡.z7{@r>…+žŸnxw2š-Z

½½¥¿

uv}@›o›z=tvw2uOp]Zt2nXzk}ou¹Uw2rGu‹w`Zt2†4š@nxw2rG†>w2}@t2r>uG‡AÁ]¹w2r>u‹w`w ¤+›rGuGÂ+†Gz]m

Œ

zkt2¡-Z=mo†Grk‡

nqmPw2r>t2z]›r4tLZ

Š

nq…qnxw9¤P‡ArG¡

Š

r|{o{+r|{H‡o†Gz]¡.›zkmorGmPw`w2rGu‹w2nqmo»+‡HZkmŽ{  ¹Ÿw2rGu‹w!Z=›o›+t2zsZk†Lšor>uGÂ

›oZkuvuvnqpsr§ZkmŽ{SZ=†>w2nqpsrw2rGu‹w2nqmo»@Hƒcš@r!›ŽZk›r4t¥›@t2r>uvrGmPw2uZ=…Xuvz-w2šor¢¡-Zknqm†LšŽZtLZk†>w2r>tva

nqu‹w2nq†Gu!z

Œ

w2šor«ƒ

½

e@ÃÄw2zPz]…

¸

ƒ¦rGu‹w

½

r>mor>tLZw2nXzkm[‡¦e+nq¡§}o…XZ=w2nqz]mH‡HZkmo{à ¡«}@…ÅZw2nqz]m¹4

ƒ ½

e+ÃnXu¡-Z]{@r4a }@›z

Œ

Zw2rGu‹w$†|Zkuvr§»]rGm@r>tLZ=w2z=t|‡

Š

Z=uvr|{ºz]mw2šor§bOeº¡.z7{@r>…„Zkmo{

nq¡.›o…qrG¡.r>m7w2nqm@»¥Z

½½¥¿

‡sZ¥»ktLZ=›ošonq†`uvnq¡«}o…XZw2zktœz

Œ

w2šorOr4~@r>†G}@w2nqz]m.z

Œ

Z¥uvr|ÆP}orGm@†Gr

»krGmor>tLZw2r|{

Š

¤ºƒ

½

e@ÃO‡HZkmo{€Zt2r|Z=…xa¾w2nq¡.r¢rG¡«}@…XZ=w2zktz

Œ

†Gz]¡.¡§}om@nX†GZ=w2nqmo»uv›r>†Gnxa

£o†|Z=w2nqz]m@uG¦_ mnxw2u!†G}+tvt2rGmPwpsr>t2uvnqz]mH‡„ƒ

½

e+ÃÇuv}@›o›z=tvw2u¥w2šor«›oZkuvuvnqpsr-Z=mŽ{€Zk†>w2nqpsr

w2rGu‹w2nqm@»¥z

Œ

zkmorOz=tuvr>psr>tLZk…+†Gzk¡.›z]mor>m7w2u[žŸnqw2š{oZ=wLZ$Zkmo{¢w2rG¡.›z=tLZk…+†Gz]m@u‹wvtLZknqmPw2uG

È ÉoÊ`˝ÌAÍΧϢЦËAÑ2Í`Ê

NŸ<4Ò+K4ҝDÒ@8§14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+MH157<>;¼ÕH14;k?ÖK4Ò×?A;=Ø+;k8ÅÒ@ÓÖÓA<>Ҏ?AÕHD|KG15+MH?Ù14;=<>ØoCED;]1=ÚۜÒ×;=MH14ÕA<>;

DÒ+<><>;kD|K>MA;k1>1ŸÒ+ÜU14ÕHDGF€ÓH<4ҝ?ÕHDK>1«Ý°CV3ºÓA8Å;k3º;=MoK>57K4CVÒ+MH1GÞ|ߎK>;k1LK4CVMAàHßoK4FH;«ÓH<4ҝD;]141$Ò7ÜUDGFA;kDGQŽCVMAà

K4FH57K514á12K>;=3âÓ¦Ò@1>14;k1>1L;]1«5%14;K.Ò7Ü¥?;k14CV<4;]?ãÓA<>Ò+Ó¦;=<4K4CV;k15+MH?[äsÒ@<å[;kFH5s؎CÅÒ@<>1k߄CV1Ò@MA;ºÒ7Ü

K4FA;.3ºÒ@1LKÕH14;k?ØP578VCV?A57K4CVÒ+MK4;]DGFAMACEæ@ÕH;k1kÚ

ۜ;]12K>CÅMAà.ÓH<4ҝD;]141ŸCV15FH57<G?ºçÒ+<>Q-K4F[5PK`CE1Ÿ8VÒ+MAà[ß+<>;=Ó¦;K>CXK>CÅØ@;¢57MH?ºçFHCVDGF<>;=ÓA<>;k14;=MoKG1O5

Ó[Ò+K4;=MoK>CV5+814Ò+ÕA<GD;Ò7ÜO;k<4<>Ò+<G1=ÚAÛ¥FH;.ÕH1L;Ò7ÜcÜ°Ò+<>3578œ14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+MH1!ÓA<4ÒP؎CE?;k114ÕAÓAÓ¦Ò+<4K!Ü°Ò@<

57՝K>Ò+35PK>CÅMAàK4FACE1ÓA<>ҎD=;k1>1=ڎè§CXé„;=<>;=MoK¥3ҝ?;k8V1«Ý¾ROêëìߝí`ROêëÄß[I$í`ROêëÄߝîÛ!ê„ߎ04ï«îÛ!ê„ß

Û¥04ï!ðßÅÚVÚÅÚxÞ«57MH?ñ8E57MAà@ÕH57à@;k1Ý êè«îŸßœîœÒ7K>Ò@1kߦ02Rߜò§ë¼îŸßVÚVÚÅÚxÞ«FH5sØ+;å¦;=;=MóÓA<>Ò+Ó¦Ò@14;k?¼K4ÒJ?;ô

14D=<4CVå[;ÓA<4Ò+K4ҝDÒ@8V15+MH?K4FH;?;k14CV<4;]?%å[;kFH5s؎CÅÒ@<>15+å[Ò@՝K!K4FH;=3õCÅM¼5Ü°Ò+<>3º5+8 ç¥5sá+ÚHè§ÕA;.K>Ò

K4FA;MH5PK>ÕA<>;öÒ+Ü`ÓA<>Ò7K4ҝD=Ò+8E1GäsÜ°ÕAMHD|K>CÅÒ@MH1!å¦;=CVMAàK4;]12K>;k?ßØP57<>CVÒ+ÕH1¢K4;]12K«K2áŽÓ[;]1«5+<4;ö<4;]æoÕACÅ<>;k? Ú

RAÒ+<;WA5+3ÓH8Å;@ßUCVM×D=Ò+MÜ°Ò@<435+MHD;K>;k1LK4CVMAàHßO5ñ1LCVMAà+8V;€CV3ºÓA8V;=3º;=MoK>57K4CVÒ+M×CV1ºDÒ@3ºÓH57<>;k?óK>Ò

<4;k8Å;kØs5+MoK$12KG57MH?H57<G?A1=Ú@0vM€CVMoK4;=<>Ò+Ó¦;=<G57åHCÅ8VCXK2áK4;]12K>CÅMAà[ß+K2çÒÒ@<`3ºÒ+<>;!CV3ºÓA8Å;k3º;=MoK>57K4CVÒ+MH157<>;

K4;k1LK4;]?¼?CV<4;]D|K>8ÅáJ57ào57CVMH1LK¢;k5@DGFJÒ7K4FH;=<]ßHçCÅK4FJK>FA;1LK>5+MH?A5+<>?%ÕH14;k?¼ÓA<4CV357<>CÅ8Vá5@1§5S<4;=Ü°;=<4ô

;=MHD=;K4Òã5@?s÷2ÕH?CED=57K4;SÓH<4Ò@åA8Å;k3157M[?CÅMHD=Ò+3ºÓH57K4CVåACÅ8VCÅK4CV;k1kß57M[?Ä1L;]DÒ+M[?A57<>CÅ8Váñ5@1-5Jà@ÕACV?A;

? ƒcšonqu§t2r>uvr|Z=t2†LšñšoZku

Š

rGrGm¼uv}o›@›zktvw2r|{

Š

¤€w2šoröˆ@t2rGm@†4š%^`d¥ƒOY›+t2z=ø9rG†>w

¿

psy>tvt2zPrGu«ZkmŽ{w2š@r

gºZ=t2nqr§bU}@t2nqr^œƒcdùƒ ^`ú¥ƒ gbU^œƒcdÖhkl]h7|Á7¹4

DÒ+3º3öÕAMACED=5PK>CÅMHàK4FA<>Ò+ÕHà+F¼CÅK>1§;=MŽØŽCÅ<>Ò+MH3;kMoKkÚ[Û¥FH;ç¥5sáŽ1K4ÒSK>;k1LKD=Ò+3º3ÕHMACVDk5PK>CÅMAà1Lá1Lô

K4;=31Dk57Må[;-D=8V5@1414CXÔ[;k?SCVMoK4ÒK2çÒöåH5@1LCED«à+<>Ò+ÕAÓ[1=ڎۥFA;.3ºÒ@1LKMH5PK>ÕA<>5+8„ç5sá@ßoM[573º;=8VáK4FH;

5+D|K>CÅØ@;!K>;k1LK4CVMAà5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGF 9ßoDÒ+M[1LCE12KG1`CVMDk57<><4áŽCVMAà-Ò@՝K$K>FA;§K4;k1LK?;=<>CÅØP57K4CVÒ+M€1LK>5+<LK4ô

CÅMAàºÜ°<>Ò+3 1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ¦D=5PK>CÅÒ@MH1kÚHð!MAÒ+K4FA;k<!Ó¦Ò@1>1LCVåACV8ÅCÅK2á€CE1¥K4FH;.ÓH5+1>1LCVØ+;«K>;k1LK4CVMAàS57ÓAÓH<4Òo5+DGF ‹Ú

Û¥FA;5+åH14;=MHD=;öÒ+Ü`Ò+åH14;=<>ØP5PK>CÅÒ@MH1§5+8Å8VÒPç!1§Ò+MA8VáK4FA;ºØP578VCV?H5PK4CVÒ+MñÒ7ܟK><>5@D;]1=߄57MH?¼K4FŽÕH1«K>FACV1

57ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGFñDGFA;]DGQ1«K4FH57Kö5K4<G5+D=;Ò+Ü!57MCÅ3ºÓA8V;=3º;kM@KG5PK>CÅÒ@MóCE1-5%ØP578VCE?ñ;=W;kDÕAK4CVÒ+MÒ7Ü¥K4FH;

1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@M Ú

RA<>Ò+3 Ò@ÕA<cÓ[Ò@CÅMoKŸÒ7܄؎CÅ;kç.ßsK4FACE1Ÿ?CVØ+;k<>14CÅK2á.Ò7ܦK2áoÓ¦;k1kßP3ºÒ?;=8E1Ÿ57M[?ö5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5+DGFH;k1Ó[Ò@CÅMoK>1

Ò+MA8VáK4ÒK4FA;1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[D=CXK2áJÒ+ܟ<4;]æoÕACÅ<>;=3º;kM@KG1=Ú¦0vMH?;k;k?ߦK>FA;?ACXé„;=<>;=MoK¢K2áŽÓ¦;k1«Ò7ÜOK>;k1LK5+<4;ö5

DÒ+M[1L;]æ@ÕH;=MHD=;$Ò+ÜAK4FA;D=Ò+3ºÓ[Òo1LCÅK4CVÒ+MöÒ7Ü[K4FA;14áŽ1LK4;k31œK>Òå[;K4;]12K>;k?7DÒ@MÜ°Ò+<>357MHD=;ŸK4;]12K>CÅMHà

DÒ+M[1LCE?;=<G1§Ò+MA8Vá%Ò+MA;ö;=MoK4CÅK2áJçFACV8Å;CÅMoK>;=<>Ò+Ó¦;=<G57åACV8ÅCÅK2á%57MH?ã;=3å¦;k?H?;k?¼K4;k1LK4CVMAà%DÒ@MH1LCE?;k<

1L;kØ+;=<G578„DÒ@3º3ÕAMACED=57K4CVMAàºDÒ+3ºÓ¦Ò+MA;kMoK>1¥CVM@K>;=<G5+DK4CVMAà5@D=D=Ò+<G?CÅMHà-K4Òº5öK4;]12K!57<GDGFACÅK4;]D|K4ÕH<4;@Ú

Û¥FA;öD=Ò+MH14CV?A;=<>;k?%3ºÒ?;=8UCV1`÷2ÕH1LK4CÅÔH;k?ãåŽáMH;=;k?H1¢Ò+Ü`1Lá1LK4;=3õ?;]14D=<4CVӝK4CVÒ+M¦14á12K>;=31!FH5sØ@;

å[;kFH5s؎CÅÒ@<>1U57MH?öD=5+MFH5+MH?8V;?A57K>5«57MH?-K4;k3Ó¦Ò+<G578D=Ò+MH1LK4<G57CVMoK>1kÚÖCÅK4F;=CÅK4FA;k<cK4FA;ÓH5@1414CÅØ@;

K4;k1LK4CVMAàiÒ+<€K4FA;5+DK4CVØ+;¼K>;k1LK4CVMAàHߥç;ñ5+<4;óDÒ+MAÜ°<4Ò@M@K>;k?ùçCÅK4F K4FA;145+3º;ñÓA<>Ò+åH8Å;k3$K4FH;

5+D=D=;k1>1LCVåACV8ÅCÅK2áÓA<>Ò+åA8V;=3 Ò7ÜO12KG5PK4;]1¥Ò+<¥K><>5+MH1LCÅK4CVÒ+M[1=Ú

Û¥FoÕ[1=ß[K4FA;º57CV3 Ò7ÜOK>FACE1§Ó[57Ó¦;=<«CV1«MAÒ+K§K>ҀCVM@K><4ҝ?Õ[D;ö5MA;kç K4;k1LKà+;=MH;=<G5PK4CVÒ+M%K>;kDGFô

MACVæoÕA;@ߜåAÕAKö<G5PK4FH;=<K4Òñ1LFAÒPç K4F[5PKCÅKöCE1-Ó¦Ò@1>1LCVåA8V;ºK4ÒJK><4;]5PK.K>FA;?CÅé„;=<>;=MoK-K2áŽÓ[;]1SݾD=Ò+Mô

Ü°Ò+<>3º5+MHD;@ß@CVMoK4;k<4Ò@Ó[;k<>5+åACÅ8VCÅK2á+ßo;=3å¦;k?H?;k?ßAD=Ò+3ºÓ¦Ò+MA;kM@K|Þ`5+MH?€5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGFA;k1§Ý°ÓH5@1414CÅØ@;§5+MH?

5+D|K>CÅØ@;]ޟÒ7ÜK4;]12K>CÅMHàCVM€5-ÕAMHCXÔH;]?357MAMH;=<]ڝï§ÕA<$357CVM€DÒ@M@K><4CVåA՝K>CÅÒ@MH157<>;K4FA;¢Ü°Ò+8V8ÅÒPçCVMAà

RCV<G12K]ߦç;CÅMoK4<>ҝ?ÕHD=;K>FA;º3ҝ?;k8OÒ7Ü$D=Ò+3º3ÕHMACVDk5PK>CÅMAà%14áŽ1LK4;k31݋I¥êAÞ|Ú Û¥FHCV13ºÒ?;=8

?;ÔHMH;k1Ý°C‘Þc5«1L;=KcÒ+ܦD=Ò+3º3ÕAMHCVDk5PK4CVMAà;=MoK>CXK>CÅ;]1ݾDÒ@3ºÓ[Ò@MA;=MoK>1GÞ|ßAݾCÅC‘Þc5«1L;=KcÒ+ܦD=Ò+3º3ºÒ+M<4;=ô

1LÒ@ÕA<>D=;k1«Ý°ØP57<>CE57åA8V;k157MH?€ÓH57<G573º;=K4;=<G1Gޟ14FH57<>;k?åŽáºK>FA;k14;;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1kߝ57MH?ñÝ°CVCÅC‘Þ5-K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+á

Ò7Ü DÒ@33öÕAMACED=57K4CVÒ+M ß7CVMH14ÓACV<4;]?ºåoáAß 9ßPçFACEDGFS14Ó[;]DCÅÔH;k1ŸK4FA;¢?ACXé„;=<>;=MoK`Ó¦Ò@1>1LCVåA8V;¢14áoMAô

DGFA<4Ò@MACk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1¥CVM¼5à+8VÒ+åH5+8 12KG5PK>;-Ò7ÜcK4FH;1Lá1LK4;k3Úñ;FH5sØ+;-DGFAÒo1L;kMK4ÒS3ºÒ?;=8;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1

åoá€;WŽK4;kMH?;k?K>CÅ3º;k?%5+՝K4Ò@3º57K>5åA՝K!Ò+K4FA;k<3ºÒŽ?A;=8E1¥3º5sá€å[;.ÕH14;k? Ú

êŽ;kD=Ò+MH?ߝç;.?;=3ºÒ@MH12K><>57K4;«K4F[5PKK4FH;öI¥ê€3ºÒ?;k8 CV1¢5öà@;=MA;k<4CED«3ºÒŽ?A;=8Ü°Ò@<¥K4;k1LK4CVMAàCVM

K4FA;1L;kMH1L;ŸK4FH57KÝ°C‘ÞœCXKUÒ7é„;=<G1 3º;kDGFH5+MACE1L31Ü°Ò@<œ3ºÒ?;=8VCVMAà§?CÅé„;=<>;=MoKœK2áŽÓ¦;k1 Ò+ÜHDÒ@33öÕAMACED=57ô

K4CVÒ+MH1c57M[?.K4;]12KO57<GDGFACÅK4;]D|K4ÕH<4;]1=ßs57MH?Ý°CVCEޜCÅKO5+8Å8VÒPç!1œK4FA;Ó[Òo1414CVåACÅ8VCÅK2á.Ò7Ü[5+ÓAÓA8VáoCVMAà¢K4FA;1>573º;

à+;=MH;=<>CVDà+;kMA;=<G5PK>CÅÒ@Mó5+8Åà@Ò+<>CXK>FA3Ýð«Þ.çCÅK4FÄ?CÅé¦;k<4;kMoK.K4;k1LK.K2áŽÓ[;]1-57M[?ó5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGFA;k1kÚ

ð¢1ç;öçCV8Å8Ÿ14;=;@ߦK4FA;]1L;º<>;k14ÕA8XKG1«FH5sØ+;5D=Ò+MH14;kæoÕA;kMHD;Ò+MãK4FA;D8E5+1>14CVDk578K4;k1LK-5+DK4CVØoCÅK4CV;k1

CÅM%K>FA;-1L;kMH14;K4FH57K!K4FA;ö1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@M3ºÒ?;k8ÅCVMAàS57M[?€K>FA;-ÕH14;.Ò7ÜO5K4;]12K«57ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGF5+MH?

5K>;k1LK¢57<GDGFACÅK4;kDK4ÕA<>;57<>;«MHÒ7K¥K2ç$Ò14;=ÓH5+<>57K4;12K>;=ÓH1kÚ

RCVMH5+8Å8Vá+ßoåŽáÓH<4;]1L;kM@K>CÅMHà.K4FA;Û.êŽíÇK4ҎÒ+8cݾÛ;k1LK«;kMA;=<G5PK>CÅÒ@M ßoêCÅ3öÕA8V57K4CVÒ+M€5+MH?Sí`3öô

ÕA8V57K4CVÒ+M[ÞßAç;14FAÒPç K4FH57K¥Ò@ÕA<¥Ü°<G573º;=çÒ+<>QCV1¥Õ[145+åA8Å;CVM%ÓA<>5@D|K>CVDk578„K4ҎÒ@8V1kÚAÛ.êŽíùCÅ3ºÓA8V;ô

3;kMoK>1Ÿ5+MÒ@Mô9K4FA;=ôHáð-ßo57MH?º14ÕAÓAÓ¦Ò+<4K>1cK>FA;!ÓH5@1414CÅØ@;57MH?º5+DK4CVØ+;K4;]12K>CÅMHà€Ý°çCÅK4FºK>;k1LK

ÓAÕA<>Ó[Òo1L;sÞ`Ò+ÜUÒ@MA;Ò+<!14;=Ø@;=<G578„DÒ+3ºÓ¦Ò+MA;kMoK>1¥çCÅK4FJ?A5PKG5º57MH?K4;k3ºÓ[Ò@<>5+8 DÒ+M[12K><>5+CÅMoK>1kÚ

Û¥FA;öÓ[57Ó¦;=<CV1Ò@<4ào57MAC=;]?J5+1§Ü°Ò+8V8VÒPç!1=Ú êŽ;]D|K4CVÒ+M €CÅMoK4<>ҝ?ÕHD=;k1§K4FA;SI¥êã3ҝ?;k8 Ú Û¥FH;

à+;=MH;=<>CVDDGFH5+<>5@D|K>;=<Ò7Ü¥K4FHCV1.3ºÒ?;k8$57M[?CXKG1-1LÕHCXKG57åACV8ÅCÅK2áñÜ°Ò+<-ÓA<>Ò7K>ҝDÒ+8cK>;k1LK4CVMAàã5+<4;?CE12ô

DÕH1>1L;]?ÖCVM 1L;]D|K>CÅÒ@M"!AÚêŽ;kDK4CVÒ+M"#×à+CVØ+;k1€1LÒ@3;ñ;=8V;=3º;=MoKG1€Ò+Ü.K4FA;ñCÅ3ºÓA8V;=3º;=MoKG5PK4CVÒ+M Ò7Ü

K4FA;JK>;k1LK€à+;kMA;=<G5PK>Ò+<K4ҎÒ@8§Û.êŽí!Ú¥êŽ;kDK4CVÒ+M%$ó<>;=Ó¦Ò+<4K>1ºÒ@ÕA<S;WÓ¦;=<>CÅ3º;kM@KG578!<>;k14ÕA8ÅK>1Ò@M

I¥êë¼ð«ä@Iè ÓA<>Ò7K>ҝDÒ+89ڜRUCVMH578V8Åá@ß ç;€DÒ@MHD8VÕH?;S5+MH?Ä?<G5sç 14Ò+3º;SÓ¦;=<G1LÓ¦;kDK4CVØ+;k1-CÅMì14;kDô

K4CVÒ+M'&AÚ

Û¥FA;§å¦;=F[5sØoCVÒ+<$Ò7ܜ5öDÒ+3º3öÕAMACED=5PK>CÅÒ@MSÓA<>Ò7K>ҎD=Ò+8¦D=57M€å[;?;k1>D<>CVå[;]?åŽá3º;]57MH1$Ò7Ü Ü°Ò@<435+8

3ҝ?;k8V114ÕHDGFã5@1§D=Ò+3º3ÕAMHCVDk5PK4CVMAà1Lá1LK4;=31ºÝ9I¥êHÞ|ڄ0vM¼K>FACV1«ÓH5+Ó[;k<kß

IR çCÅ8V8O?;=MAÒ+K4;öK4FA;

1L;=K!Ò7Ü<>;k5+8V1kßA57M[?

IR⁺ çCV8Å8?;=MAÒ+K4;«K4FH;-1L;=K!Ò7ÜÓ¦Ò@14CÅK4CVØ+;<4;]578E1=Ú

"!#$

% &('*)($+! -, % &. -$0/1! 2/0$3 ðÄD8VҝDGQ¢CE1 5ØP57<>CV5+åA8V;K>FH5PKU578V8ÅÒPç!1¦K>Ò<4;]DÒ+<G?¢K4FA;ŸÓ[5+1>145+à+;

Ò7܄K4CV3º;+Úo0‹K$D=5+Må[;¢14;K`K4Ò5-D=;=<4K>5+CÅMºØP578VÕA;¢5+MH?ºCÅM[1LÓ¦;kDK4;k?€5PK$5+Moáö3ºÒ+3º;=MoKŸK>Ò1L;k;!FAÒPç

3ÕHDGFJK>CÅ3º;öFH5+1¢ÓH5+1>1L;]?Ú¦0vMJK4FA;ð!8VÕA<4ô‹è§CÅ8V8U3ҝ?;k8 04 9ߦD8VҝDGQŽ1¢CÅM[D<>;k5+14;57K!K4FA;º1>573º;

<>57K4;+ßsK>FA;=á57<>;$<G57MHà+;k?öÒPØ+;k<

IR⁺ß+5+MH?-K>FA;Ò+MH8Åá5@1414CVà+MA3º;=MoKG1U5+8Å8VÒPç;k?5+<4;D=8ÅҝDGQ-<>;k14;KG1 Ò7ÜUK4FA;.Ü°Ò@<43

x:= 0ÚHRAÒ@<!51L;=K

C Ò+ÜcD=8ÅҝDGQ1kßA51L;=K

P Ò7ÜcÓH5+<>5+3;=K4;k<>1kßA57MH?%514;K

V ^Ò+Ü

Øs5+<4CE57åH8Å;]1=ßoK4FH;-1L;=K!Ò7ÜUD=8ÅҝDGQ€D=Ò+MH1LK4<G57CVMoK>1

Φ(C, P, V)CV1?A;ÔHMA;]?åoáSK4FA;.à@<>5+335+<

φ:=φ1 |φ2|φ1∧φ2, φ1:=x≤f(P, V), φ2:=f(P, V)≤x

çFA;=<>;

x CV15D=8ÅҝDGQSÒ+Ü

C^ߦ57MH? f(P, V)CV15º8VCVMA;k5+<;WÓA<>;k1>1LCVÒ+MÒ7Ü

P ^57M[? VÚHRAÒ@<¥K2ç$Ò 1L;=K>1

L1

5+MH?

L2

ß L1\L2

çCÅ8V8œ?;kMAÒ7K>;K4FA;.14;K

L1\L2={a|a∈L1∧a6∈L2}^Ú

5 768 -/0&. 9;:=<?>[email protected]#NYXZW#NYV.W#N8[W#N\ZRT[N\ZH^]_A`.abGdc

QfeA[hgjilk\NW*V2mnJ

M = (S, L, C, P, V, V0, P red, Ass, s0,→) ^{o-p JrqsJut}

v S Qfew[yxHzQSN\Je1JrN+Z={e|N\[N\J|e1}

v s0

Qfe~N

p

JAQSHQSNQ[lm(e|N\[N\J0}

v L Qfew[xHzQSN\Jw[lmV p

[j€UJrNyZ{w[j‚1NQZlHeUƒ

L=Li∪Lo∪I^}

v C Qfew[yx„HQSNOJAe1JrN+Z={w‚1mnZ*‚M…e1}

v P Qfew[yx„HQSNOJ~e1JrN†Z={‡Vz[qs[lRuJ1N\JrqUe1}

v V Qfew[yxHzQSN\Je1J1N+Z{ˆ‰[lq|Q[j€1mnJ|e1}

v V0

Qfew[yxHzQSN\Je1JrN+Z={~N

p

JwQSHzQSNŠQ[m-ˆ‰[lm‹WzJre{rZlqAˆ[q|Q[j€1mnJreDZ={

V^}

v P red=Φ(C, P, V)∪ ˜P[P, V]^{ƒ o-p J1qsJ} ˜P[P, V] Qfe[De1JrNZ{mYQSH.JU[q?QSH.JUŒ1Wz[m‹QSNŠQJ|eAZH

V ^[lH.P P^}

v Ass={x:= 0|x∈C} ∪ {v:=f(P, V)|v∈V} QfeA[e1JrNdZ={W*VzPj[N\Jre~ZlH‚rmŽZ0‚U…‰e [H2PTˆ[q|Q[j€1mnJre1}

v →⊆S×L×P red×Ass×S Qfew[ue1JrN+Z={~NŠqs[lHe|QSNQZlHe1}

Û¥FA;$5+8ÅÓAF[57å¦;K

LCV1œÓH57<4K4CÅK4CVÒ+MA;]?.CVM@K>ÒK4FH<4;k;`1L;=K>1

Li

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

Lo

ÞCE1K4FH;$CVMAÓA՝K¥Ý°<>;k14Ó Ú=Ò@՝KLô

ÓA՝KGÞ 578VÓAFH57å¦;K]ßk5+MH?

I CV1K4FA;`5+8ÅÓHFH57å¦;KœÒ+ÜoCVMoK4;k<4MH5+875+DK4CVÒ+MH1kÚ

t= (s, a, pred, ass, s⁰)∈→

<4;kÓA<4;]1L;kMoK>1¥57M;k?à@;¢Ü°<>Ò+3 12KG5PK4;

sK>ÒS12KG5PK>;

s⁰ Ò@M14áŽ3å¦Ò+8

a^Ú pred⊆P red CV15º14;KÒ7Ü DÒ+M[12K><>5+CÅMoK>1kߝ57MH?

ass⊆Ass CV15º14;K!Ò7ÜUÕAӄ?A5PK>;k1kÚ

_L[RV.mnJugj}

RUCÅà[Ú CÅ8V8VÕH12K><>57K4;]157M;WA573ºÓA8V;Ò7ÜO57Mí`Û¥04ï!ðÚ

v S={s0, s1, s2, s3}^5+MH? s0

K>FA;.CVMACXK>CV5+8œ1LK>5PK>;+Ú

v L={!a,?b,!c,?d}^ß C={x, y}^ß P ={β, λ}^ß V ={v1}^5+MH? V0={β}^Ú

v

Û¥FA;.ØP57<>CV5+åA8V;

v1

FH5@1K4FA;.CVMACÅK4CE578 ØP5+8ÅÕA;

β^Ú

v P red={y ≥λ, x≤1, v1≤4}^ß Ass={x:= 0, y:= 0, v1 :=v1 + 1}^Ú

v

Û¥FA;K4<G57M[1LCÅK4CVÒ+M

tÜ°<>Ò+3

s2

K>Ò

s3

CE1

t= (s2,!c,{x≤1},{v1 :=v1 + 1}, s3)^Ú

J1Ru[lqs…Kg3}

RAÒ@<!57Mí`Û¥04ï¢ð

M= (S, L, C, P, V, V0, P red, Ass, s0,→)

v

ÖFA;=M

P =∅ ^57M[? V =∅ßK>FA;=Mç;ºÔHMH?óK4FH;SÕH14ÕH578Ÿ?;=ÔHMACÅK4CVÒ+MÄÒ+Ü¥5K>CÅ3º;k?C°äsÒ 57՝K>Ò+35PK>Ò+Mݾۥ04ï¢ð§Þڝ0vMK>FACE1!D=5@1L;@ß

M çCV8Å8 å¦;-14CÅ3ºÓA8VáSMAÒ+K4;k?

(S, L, C, s0,→)^Ú

v

ÖFA;=M

C =∅^ß P =∅^5+MH? V =∅ßHK4FA;kMJç$;-ÔHMH?K4FH;-ÕH14ÕH578U?;ÔHMHCXK>CÅÒ@MJÒ7ܟ57MJC°äsÒ 57՝K>Ò+35PK>Ò+MÝ°04ï¢ð§ÞÚA0vM€K>FACE1!D=5@1L;@ß

M çCV8Å8 å¦;-14CÅ3ºÓA8Vá€MAÒ+K4;]?

M= (S, L, s0,→)^Ú

s0

†

s3

Š

s1 s2

Z

y≥λ

v1≤4 x≤1

x:= 0

{

y:= 0

v1 :=v1 + 1

™ o™

Ãc_‹ú

¿ 

S >d&&.&.$D&†'j&. - "'3!#/0& ! ",

%

& " -'j!#/* ($1/*7$

ð K4Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@áìÒ7Ü.DÒ@3º3ÕAMACED=57K4CVÒ+M

Top

Ò7Ü.51L;=KSÒ7ÜÓA<>ҎD=;k1>1L;]1CV1S514áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+M

3ҝ?;k8Ò7Ü K>FA;.?CÅé¦;k<4;kM@KÓA<>ҝD;]1414;k1kÚ@0‹K!?;]14D=<4CVå¦;k1$K4FA;.?áŽMH5+3ºCVD«DÒ@MÔHà+ÕH<>57K4CVÒ+MH1$Ò7ܜÓH<4Ò+ô

D;k1>14;k1kß757MH?öK4FH;!Ó[Òo1414CVåA8Å;!14áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+MH1UCVM5à+CVØ+;=MD=Ò+MÔHà@ÕA<G5PK4CVÒ+MœÚsÛ¥FH;¢?;Ô[MACXK>CÅÒ@M

Ò7Ü

Top

CE1«CÅMH14ÓACV<4;]?JåŽá Aß ‹Ú¦0‹K?;=ÔHMA;]1«514;KÒ7Ü`à@8ÅÒ@åH578c5+DK4CVÒ+MH1kߦ514;KÒ7Ü$14;KG1§Ò+Ü

5+D|K>CÅÒ@MH1kßH57MH?J5Û<G57MH1>?ÕHD=;=<-ݑK>FACE1K4;k<43ºCVMAÒ+8VÒ+à@á€CE1å¦Ò+<><4ÒPç;k?€Ü°<4Ò@3 ‘Þ3ºÒ?;=8V;k?%åŽá

57M%57՝K>Ò+35PK>Ò+M Ú

5

768 -/0&. :=>d&&.&-E‰ ` p

JNOZUVZlmnZ Z{ ‚MZlRDRW#HzQ‚U[lNQZlH

T op ^{Z={ [ e1J1NFZ{}

n V2qsZ*‚MJreUe1J|e Qfe^[lk\NŠW*V.mŽJ

(G, I, T r)^{ƒ o QSNp} G [Tx„HQSNOJ e1JrNuZ={jmnZj€U[m[j‚1NQZlHeUƒ

I = {Ii}1≤i≤n

[Ix„HQSNOJAe1JrNyZ{e1JrNeUƒd[H2P

T r= (Str, Ltr, s0tr,→tr) ^[lH [lW#NOZlRu[lNOZlH e|Wz‚

p

Np [NyN

p

JTJ1ˆ‰J1HzNeZ{

Ltr

[qsJuˆJU‚rN\ZqUe −→v ^Z={ n+ 1 JrmnJ1RTJrHNeUƒ+[lH.P

∀−→v ∈Ltr

ƒ −→v =<

ag, a1, ..., an> ^{o QSNp} ag ∈G ^[lH.P ∀i∈[1, n]^ƒ ai∈Ii∪ {idle}^}

ð Ø@;kDK4Ò+< −→v =< ag, a1, ..., an > ^Ò+Ü Ltr

?;]14D=<4CVå[;]1«K4FA;5@D|K4CVÒ+M

ai

K>FH5PKK>FA;ºÓA<4ҝD=;k1>1

i^ß i∈[1, n]ߦFH5+1!K4ÒSÓ¦;=<4Ü°Ò+<>3%Ú¦Û¥FH;ö14áoM[DGFA<4Ò@MACk5PK>CÅÒ@MÒ+ÜOK4FA;5+DK4CVÒ+MH1

(ai)i∈[1,n]

à+CVØ+;]1

ÓA8V5@D;K4ÒK>FA;Jà+8VÒ+å[5785+DK4CVÒ+M

ag

Ú ÖFH;=MÖ5óØ+;kDK4Ò@< −→v =< ag, idle, ..., ai, ..., idle >

?;ÔHMH;k1§Ò+MA8Vá%Ò+MA;5+D|K>CÅÒ@M ß[K4FA;ÓA<>ҎD=;k1>1

i ;W;]D՝K>;k1§8ÅÒ@MA;=8Vá

ai

߄57MH?ñDGFH57MAà@;k1¢CXKG1§1LK>57K4;+Ú

RAÒ+<§5K4Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@á

T op= (G, I, T r)ßHçFA;kMK>FA;-MŽÕA3öå[;k<!Ò7ÜO12KG5PK>;k1Ò+Ü

T r CV1;]æoÕH578K>Ò

1

K4FA;kM

T opCE1D=5+8Å8V;k?5 e|NO[lNQ‚

K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+á@Ú

ðK>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@áÒ+é¦;k<>1§K>FA;ºÓ[Òo1414CÅåHCÅ8VCXK2áJÒ+Ü$3ºÒ?;=8VCVMAàD=Ò+3º3ÕHMACVDk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1«å[;=K2ç$;k;=MãÒ@MA;+ß

K2ç$Ò§Ò+<c1L;kØ+;=<G578@ÓA<>ҎD=;k1>1L;]1 kÕAMACED=5@12K]ß]3öÕA8ÅK4CED=5+1LKkßP5+MH?.åA<>Ò@5@?AD=5@12K]Ú=0‹KOD=57Möå[;ÕH14;k?ßsCVMöD=;=<4ô

K>57CVM€Dk5+14;k1kß+5+1$5.QŽCÅMH?SÒ7Ü DÒ@M@K><4Ò@8Å8V;=<`Ò+MS5+DK4CVÒ+MH1$578V8ÅÒPç;k?åŽáÓA<4ҝD=;k1>1L;]1OCÅM5.à+CVØ+;kMSDÒ+MAô

ÔHà+ÕA<G5PK>CÅÒ@M€Ò+Ü K4FA;à@8ÅÒ@åH57814áŽ1LK4;k3%Ú¢Ò7K>;§K>FH5PK]ߝCÅMÒ+<G?;k<`K>Òº?A;k1>D<>CÅå¦;§CVMoK4;k<LôvDÒ@3Ó¦Ò+MH;=MoK

DÒ+3º3öÕAMACED=5PK>CÅÒ@MH1kߜ5JÓA<>ҝD;k1>15+8Åà@;=åA<G5%D=5+MÄå[;3Ò@<4;;=WÓA<4;]1414CVØ+;ºK4F[57MK4FH;SK4Ò@Ó[Ò@8ÅÒ@à+á@ß

FAÒPç$;kØ+;k<kßoK4FHCV1¢8V57KLK4;k<!Ò7é„;=<G114ÕACXKG57åA8V;-3ºÒ?;=8VCVMAà3º;kDGFH5+MACV143157MH?J5+8Åà@Ò+<>CXK>FA31¥ÕH1>57åA8V;

CÅM%ÓA<G5+DK4CED=578¦K>ÒoÒ@8V1kÚ

5

768 -/0&. : %

&!" -'j!#/* "($0/0 E‰G ‚UZRRW#HzQ‚U[NŠQSH# e$‰eUN\J1R

CS ^QfeD[

%

k\NŠW*V.mnJ

(SP, SV, SV0,(Mi)1≤i≤n, T op) ^{o-p JrqsJ*t}

v SP Qfew[Te1J1NdZ={~e

p

[qsJUPV[lqs[RTJrN\J1qUer}

v SV QfeD[TerJ1NdZ{e

p

[lqsJUPTˆ[q|Q[j€1mnJre1}

v SV0

Qfew[ue1J1N+Z{N

p

JAQSHQSNQ[lmˆ[m‹WzJre„{rZqAˆ[q|Q[3€rmnJreZ{

SV^}

v T op= (G,{Ii}1≤i≤n, T r) ^{Qfew[ NOZUVZlmnZ j}}

v Mi= (Si, Li, Ci, Pi, Vi, V0i, P redi, Assi, s0i,→i)Qfe†[lHD_A`.abG eUWz‚

p Np

[N Ii⊆ Li

ƒ ∀i∈[1, n]^}

<!a,!a,?a>

!a/v:=2

SV: v SP: p

?a

v>1/!b/v1:=p Shared resources

Entity 1 Topology Entity 2

™ ™

bOeö¡.z7{+rG…‘

RCVàHÚ!CV8V8ÅÕH1LK4<G5PK>;k1U57Mö;WA573ºÓA8V;$Ò+Ü[5.I¥ê„ÚsíŸMoK4CÅK4CV;k1c<>;=ÓA<>;k14;=MoKÓH<4ҝD;]1414;k1kÚsÛ¥FA;=á-5+<4;$3ҝ?Žô

;=8V;k?öåoáí`Û¥04ï!ð§1=Ú@Û¥FA;K4Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@á.Ò7܄DÒ+3º3öÕAMACED=5PK>CÅÒ@M?A;k1>D<>CÅå¦;k1K4FH;!?CXé„;=<>;=MoKOÓ¦Ò@1>1LCVåA8V;

1LáŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MHC]5PK4CVÒ+M[1!å¦;K2ç;=;=MãK4FA;º;kM@K>CXK>CÅ;]1=Ú ó;5+1>1LÕH3;]?JCVMãK>FA;?;ÔHMHCXK>CÅÒ@MñÒ+Ü`;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1

K4FH57K

∀i∈[1, n]^ß Ii⊆Li

Ú7Û¥FHCV1c;kMH57åA8V;k1UK>FA;?;Ô[MACXK>CÅÒ@MºÒ7Ü[Ó[57<4K4CE578oK4Ò@Ó[Ò@8ÅÒ@à+CV;k1UCÅMçFACEDGF

Ò+MA8Vá.578V8ÅÒPç;k?.14áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+MH1 5+<4;$<4;kÓ[Ò@<LK>;k?ݾCÅMK4FA;MA;WŽKc1L;]D|K4CVÒ+Mœß]ç;`çCV8V8@à@CÅØ@;$14Ò+3º;

;WA573ºÓA8V;k1Ò+ܟ1LÕHDGFK>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+CV;k1GÞ|Ú[Û¥FA;-DÒ@33ºÒ@MJ<4;]1LÒ@ÕA<>D=;k1<>;=ÓA<>;k14;=MoKK4FH;1LF[57<>;k?%?A5PKG5

Ò7ÜK4FH;JI¥ê„Ú ó;çCV8V8<>;k1LK4<>CED|K-K>FA;14FH5+<4;]?ì?A5PKG5%K4ÒóØP57<>CV5+åA8V;k15+MH?ÄÓH5+<>5+3º;K4;k<>1kÚÛ¥FH;

ÓH57<G573º;K>;=<G1SÝ°<>;k14Ó ÚØs5+<4CE57åH8Å;]1>ÞDk57MÄå¦;€<>;k5+?ùݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú<4;]5+?Ä5+MH?3ºÒŽ?ACXÔH;]?HÞ.åŽáñK4FA;JI¥ê

;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1sÚÛ¥FA;º1L;k3º5+MoK4CED=1«Ò7Ü$5%I¥ê¼CE1?;Ô[MA;k?ãåoá¼5+Mãí`Û¥04ï¢ð-ÚÛÒ14CÅ3ºÓA8VCÅÜ°á+ßç;öçCV8Å8

5+1>1LÕA3º;¢K4FH57KK>FA;«MH573º;k1Ò+ܜÓH57<G573º;=K4;=<G1`5+MH?SØP5+<4CE57åA8V;k1$Ò7Ü;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1¥57<>;§?ACXé„;=<>;=MoKkߝ5+MH?

?CXé„;=<>;=MoKÜ°<>Ò+3 K>FAÒ@14;Ò7ÜUK4FA;öI¥êÚ

5

768 -/0&. : 7! 2/0'j$E‰ ` p J e1JrRT[HNQ‚re Z{^[‚UZRRW#HzQ‚U[NŠQSH# e ‰e|N\JrR

S = (SP, SV, SV0,(Mi)1≤i≤n, T op)^{ƒ o QSNp} Mi= (Si, Li, Ci, Pi, Vi, V0i, P redi, Assi, s0i,

→i) ^[lH.P T op = (G, I,(Str, Ltr, s0tr,→tr))^{ƒwQfe PjJx„H.JUP € Np J _A`.abG} ζ(S) = (S, L, C, P, V, V0, P red, Ass, s0,→) ^{e|Wz‚p Np [N†t}

v S={s= (str, s1, ..., sn)|str∈Str,∀i∈[1, n], si∈Si}

v s0= (s_otr, s₀₁, ..., s0n)^}

v L=G^ƒ C=C1∪...∪Cn

ƒ

P =SP∪P1∪...∪Pn

}

v V =V P∪V1∪...∪Vn

ƒ V0=V P0∪V₀₁∪...∪V0n

}

v P red=P red1∪...∪P redn

ƒ

Ass=Ass1∪...∪Assn

}

e+šoZ=t2r|{S›ŽZtLZk¡.r>w2r>t2u¥ZkmŽ{SpkZ=t2nXZ

Š

…Xr>u¢†GZkmZk›o›rGZ=t!nqm€w2š@r{+r>£Žm@nqw2nqzkmz

Œ

Z-wvtLZ=mouvnxw2nqz]m%z

Œ

Z=m

rGmPw2nxw9¤P

v →= {(str, s1, ..., sn) ^a,pred,ass−−−−−−−→(s⁰_tr, s⁰₁, ..., s⁰_n)| ∃−→v =<a, a1, ..., an>∈Ltr, str

−

→v

−→trs⁰_tr,∀i∈[1, n],(((ai=idle)∧(si=s⁰_i))k((ai6=idle)∧(si

ai,predi,assi

−−−−−−−−→i

s⁰_i))), pred=pred1∧...∧predn, ass=ass1∧...∧assn}^}

Û¥FA;!578VÓAFH5+å[;=K

L^Ò+Ü ζ(S)CE1UK4FA;!14;K

GÒ7܄à+8VÒ+åH5+85+D|K>CÅÒ@MH1cÒ7Ü

T opÚ7ðÖ1LK>57K4;Ò7Ü

ζ(S)^DÒ@Mô

1LCE12KG1Ò7ܝ51LK>5PK>;OÒ7Ü

T op57MH?1LK>57K4;k1 Ò7Ü

(Mi)i∈[1,n]

Ú]ðóK4<G57MH14CXK>CÅÒ@M

(str, s1, ..., sn)−−−−−−−→^a,pred,ass (s⁰tr, s⁰1, ..., s⁰n) ^Ò7Ü ζ(S)CE1D=Ò+MH?ACXK>CÅÒ@MA;k?€åoáºK>FA;«;WCV1LK4;kMHD;«Ò7ÜU5-K><>5+MH1LCÅK4CVÒ+MÒ7Ü

T op^Ü°<4Ò@3 str

K>Ò

s⁰_tr Ò@M%5Ø@;kD|K>Ò+<¥FH5s؎CVMAàK>FA;.à+8VÒ+å[578 5+DK4CVÒ+M

a^Ú

Û¥FoÕ[1=ß]K4FH;¥14;=35+M@K>CVDk1œÒ+ܦ5.I¥ê5+8Å8VÒPç!1œK4FA;¥Ó¦Ò@1>1LCVåACV8ÅCÅK2á.Ò7ÜAK>FA;1LáŽMHDGFH<4Ò@MAC]5PK>CÅÒ@M-çCXK>F

Ò7K4FH;=<§I¥ê1kߝçFACEDGFà@CÅØ@;k1¥5FACV;=<G57<GDGFACVDk578„?;Ô[MACXK>CÅÒ@MÜ°Ò+<§I¥ê1kÚAð Ó[Òo1414CVåA8Å;;=WoK>;=MH14CVÒ+MÒ7Ü

K4FA;I¥êñ3ºÒ?;=8`D=Ò+MH14CE12KG1CÅMóK4FH;S?;ÔHMHCXK>CÅÒ@MóÒ+Ü;=WŽK4;=M[?;k?ñK4Ò@Ó[Ò@8ÅÒ@à+CV;k1¦K4FA;ºK><>5+MH14?AÕHD;k<

3ҝ?;k8Å;]?óåoáñ57Móí`Û¥04ï!ðõÝ DÒ+ÕH8V?ñå[;Õ[1L;=Ü°ÕA8OÜ°Ò+<.3ºÒ?;k8ÅCVMAà%MA;K2çÒ+<>QJ8E5PK4;kMHDCV;k1GÞ|Ú¢Ò7K>;

K4FH57Kkß7K>FA;¢14Ck;-Ý°MŽÕA3öå[;k<ŸÒ7ܦK4<G57MH14CÅK4CVÒ+MH1GÞUÒ7ܦK4FA;§1L;k3º5+MoK4CED=1Ÿ5+՝K4Ò@3º57K4Ò@MöCE1O8VCÅMA;]57<ŸCVMºK4FH;

1LC=;ºÒ7Ü;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1.K4CV3;]1K4FH;º14C=;ºÒ7ÜK4FA;ºK>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@á+ڄ0vMñÓH<>5@D|K4CED;@ßFAÒPç;=Ø+;k<kß[K4FHCV1-14C=;ºCV1

Ò+<G?;=<G1!Ò+ܟ3º5+à+MACÅK4Õ[?;8V;k1>1=ڄRAÒ@<¢;=W5+3ºÓA8Å;@ßHK>FA;ö14C=;Ò+Ü`5I¥ê„ß14ÕHDGFJK>FH5PK«CXKG1!K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+á

CV1!5öK><4;k;+ߝCE1¥8ÅCVMA;k5+<CÅMK>FA;-1LC=;Ò+ÜUCÅK>1¥K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@á+Ú

;7/"&(,"&& &F -7'F -7!#/*&. Ch.&z/" $j

Û¥FA;!35P÷2Ò@<4CÅK2á-Ò7܄K>;k1LK`à+;kMA;=<G5PK>CÅÒ@M5+8Åà@Ò+<>CXK>FA31O57<>;åH5+14;k?Ò+MS5.?A;=ӝK>Fô Ô[<>1LK$14;k57<GDGFÒ7Ü5

K>57<>à+;=K!12KG5PK4;.Ò@<K4<G57M[1LCÅK4CVÒ+MCÅM%K>FA;5@D=D;]1414CVåACÅ8VCÅK2áSà+<G57ÓAFœÚ0‹K¢CV1K4FA;kMJÓ[Òo1414CÅåH8Å;K>ÒS?;ÔHMH;

à+;=MH;=<>CVD.à@;=MA;k<>57K4CVÒ+MJ578Và+Ò@<4CÅK4FH3º1Ü°Ò+<¢ØP5+<4CVÒ+ÕH1!K4;]12K§K2áoÓ¦;k1kÚH0vM¼K4FACE1¢Ó[57<4Kkߦç$;14FAÒPç FAÒPç

K4Ò?;Ô[MA;-1LÕ[DGF5+8Åà@Ò+<>CXK>FA31=Ú

5 768 -/0&. AG ‚UZRRW#HzQ‚U[NŠQSH#Ae$‰eUN\J1R W#H2PjJ1q†NOJre|N] †`c~Qfe[D‚UZlRDRW#HzQ‚U[NŠQSH#

e ‰e|N\JrR

S= (SP, SV, SV0,(Mi)1≤i≤n, T op)ƒ"e|Wz‚

p Np [N‡N

p

JrqsJ~Qfe~[lNmnJU[‰e|N‡ZlH.JDJrHNQSN

Mi

ƒ i∈[1, n]ƒ‡PjJx„HQSH#FZH2JDZlqerJ1ˆJrqs[lm(e|N\[N\J|emn[j€UJ1mnJUPh€

ACCEP T^}

êoK>57K4;k18E57å¦;=8V;k?€åoá

ACCEP T ?;Ô[MA;¢K>FA;«å[;kFH5s؎CÅÒ@<>1ŸK4Òå[;§K4;]12K>;k?ÚHï§ÕA<¥?;Ô[MACXK>CÅÒ@M€Ò+Ü I¥êò¢Û DÒ@MH14CV?;k<>1Ò@MA8Váó1LK>57K4;k1-8V5+å[;k8Å;]?åoá

ACCEP TßåA՝KCÅKCE1-Ó¦Ò@1>1LCVåA8V;ºK4Òã?;=ÔHMA;

K4<G57MH14CXK>CÅÒ@MH1O8E57å¦;=8V;k?åŽá

ACCEP TÚoÛ¥FACV1`8V5@12KD=5+14;!CE1ŸMAÒ+KŸK4<>;k57K4;]?ºCÅMK>FACE1`ÓH5+Ó[;k<kß+åA՝K K4FA;-5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5+DGF<4;k357CVMH1$K4FA;-1>573º;+ÚAîœ;K!ÕH1¥MHÒ7K4;.åŽá

CSUTߎK4FA;-14;K!Ò+Üc5+8Å8I¥êò§Û1kÚ

5

768 -/0&. (-Zqh[

S ∈ CSUT^{ƒ?[ e|NO[lNOJ} s = (str, s1, ..., sn) ^Z={ ζ(S) ^[H2P ρ = t0...tn

[ue1JUŒrWzJ1H.‚UJZ={NŠqs[Hze|QSNQZlHe~QSH

ζ(S)^{{UqMZR Np} JAQSHQSNQ[lm(e|NO[lNOJ*t v s ^QfeA[H [3‚U‚MJ\V.NŠQSH# e|NO[lNOJwZ={

ζ(S) ^Q{?Np JrqMJwJMLjQfe|Ne

i∈[1, n] ^{eUWz‚p Np [lN} si

QfeA[e|NO[lNOJ

mn[j€UJ1mnJUPh€

ACCEP T^}

v ρ ^Qfew[lH [j‚U‚UJ\V.NŠQSH#~V[lN

p

Z={ ζ(S)^ƒ‡Q{

g3} ρ ^QfeA[lH JMLJM‚1W#N\[j€1mnJdVz[N p }

}h`

p

JDN\[q7JrNe|NO[lNOJZ={N

p

Jwmn[‰e|NdNqM[He|QSNŠQZH

tn

QfeA[lH[j‚U‚UJ\V.NŠQSH#Ke|NO[lNOJDZ={

ζ(S)^}

ð 12KG5PK4;

sÒ7ÜUK4FA;.í`Û¥04ï¢ð

ζ(S)ßAK>FA;-14;=357MoK4CED=1Ò+Ü

SߝCE1!5+M5@D=D;kӝK4CVMAà1LK>5PK>;.Ò7Ü

ζ(S)^ß

CXÜ¢Ò@MA;€Ò+ÜK4FA;12KG5PK>;k1K4FH57KDÒ@3ºÓ[Òo1L;CXK]ßCE1ö5ñ12KG5PK>;€8E57å¦;=8V;k?ÄåŽá

ACCEP T^{Úcð Ó[5PK4F} ρ= t0...tn

Ò7Ü

ζ(S)^Ü°<4Ò@3 K4FA;CVMACÅK4CE578Ÿ1LK>57K4;ºCV1.5+Mó5@D=D=;=ӝK>CÅMAàÓH57K4FóÒ7Ü

ζ(S) ^{CÅÜ sÞ¢K4FA;}

12KG5PK4;

sn

Ò7ܟK>FA;8V5@12K«K4<G57MH14CÅK4CVÒ+M

tn = (sn−1, a, pred, ass, sn) CE157Mã5@D=D=;=ӝK>CÅMAà12KG5PK>;

Ò7Ü ζ(S)^{5+MH? @Þ} ρCV157M€;W;kD=՝K>5+åA8Å;öݑܰ;k5@1LCVåA8V;]Þ`ÓH5PK>F ßoC Ú;+ßoK4FH;§?CÅé¦;k<4;kMoK¥D=Ò+MH1LK4<G57CVMoK>1OÒ@M K4FA;§K4<G57MH14CÅK4CVÒ+MH157<>;¢578V8„1457K4CE12ÔH;]?ڎۥFA;§;=W;kDÕAK>57åHCÅ8VCXK2áºÒ+Ü5-ÓH57K4FSCE1$K4<>;k57K4;k?SCÅM +ß ‹Ú

5

768 -/0&. AG 3J1H.J1q|Q‚7JrH2Jrqs[lNQZlH [m7Zq|QSN

p R ]Gdc-{rZlq

CSUT ^{Qfed[H [lm3Zlq|QSNp R}

Np

[N†‚MZlRyV2W#NOJreUƒz{rZqw[lmSm

S ∈ CSUTƒ‡[mSm"[3‚U‚MJ\V.NŠQSH#~Vz[N

p

eDZ={

ζ(S)^}

ð!Mù578Và+Ò+<>CÅK4FA3

gga CE15 ð-ßOCÅÜ

gga 57ÓHÓA8ÅCV;k?ÇK4Ò

ζ(S) <4;=K4ÕA<>MH1º51L;=K

P AT H(S)

DÒ+MoKG57CVMACÅMHà578V8O5+DkD;=ÓAK4CVMAà€ÓH57K4FH1«Ò+Ü

ζ(S)ÚíOWA573ºÓA8V;k1«Ò7Ü ð Dk57M¼å¦;öÜ°Ò+ÕAMH?ñCVM +ß

!Aß 9Ú ¢Ò7K4;`K4FH57K K4FH;!CÅKLô‹Ò+<4ô+ÕA3ºÓ.578Và+Ò@<4CÅK4FH3 ! Ž?ÒŽ;k1œMAÒ7K?A;k578@çCXK>F.K4FH;ŸK4;k3ºÓ[Ò@<>5+8

5+14Ó[;]D|KÒ7ÜO1Lá1LK4;k3º15+MH?DÒ+M[1LCE?;=<G1

ACCEP T K4<G57MH14CÅK4CVÒ+MH1kÚ RCVMH5+8Å8Vá+ßc57MÇ5+8Åà@Ò+<>CXK>FA3

gga ?ÒŽ;k1öMAÒ7Kº?;=Ó¦;=MH?×Ò+M×5óI¥êò§ÛÚU0‹KD=5+Mìå¦;5+ÓAÓA8VCÅ;]?

K4ÒÄ57MŽáÄí`Û¥04ï¢ð 57MH?×CÅKºCE1º;WFH5+ÕH1LK4CVØ+;%CÅM×K4FH;¼1L;kMH1L;K4F[5PK€578V8!5+DkD;kӝK4CVMAàóÓH5PK>FH157<>;

<4;=K4ÕA<>MA;k?ãåŽá

ggaÚ[0‹KG1.DÒ+3ºÓA8V;WCÅK2á¼?;=Ó¦;=M[?A1Ò+MñK4FA;14Ck;öÒ+Ü`;=MoK>CXK>CÅ;]1.57MH?ãK4FA;14Ck;öÒ+Ü K4FA;K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+á€ÕH1L;]?Ú ó;.FH5sØ+;.DGFAÒo1L;kM€K>FA;-12KG5PK>;-DÒPØ+;k<>5+à+;¢D=<4CÅK4;k<4CVÒ+MÜ°Ò+<!?A;ÔHMACVMAà

gga

åA՝KK4FH;K4<G57MH14CXK>CÅÒ@MóݾÒ+<Ò+K4FA;k<GÞDÒPØ@;=<G57à@;§D<>CÅK4;=<>CVÒ+MDk57M%578E1LÒºå¦;-DGFAÒ@14;=M ‹Ú

œÊ ÌHÑLÐ ÍÎyG͟Ì@˝Ñ4Êy

0vMÖK4FACE1%1L;]D|K>CÅÒ@MÖç$;ñÓA<4;]1L;kMoK€K4FH;ã;WÓA<>;k1>14CÅ؎CÅK2ái5+MH?ùK4FH;ãà+;kMA;=<>CED¼DGFH57<G5+DK4;k<SÒ7ÜI¥ê1

Ü°Ò+<!?;]14D=<4CVåACVMAà5+MH?€K4;k1LK4CVMAàºÓA<>Ò7K>ҎD=Ò+8E1=ڝëJҝ?;k8ÅCVMAàº1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ¦D=5PK>CÅÒ@MH1¥CE1¥ÓA<4;]1L;kMoK4;k?€CÅM'!HÚ@Ú

ۜ;]12K>CÅMAàºçCÅK4FJ?CÅé¦;k<4;kMoKK2áoÓ¦;k15+MH?%57ÓAÓH<4Òo5+DGFA;]1`CE1ÓA<>;k14;=MoK4;]?SCVM'!AڝÚ

0vMJK4FA;ö<4;k357CVMH?;=<§Ò7ÜOK>FACV114;kDK4CVÒ+M ß[ç$;öçCÅ8V8UD=Ò+MH14CE?;=<¢K2ç$Ò1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1

SA

5+MH?

SB

ߜ14FH5+<4CVMAàK4FA;1L;=K-Ò7Ü¥ÓH57<G573º;K>;=<G1

SPߜ57M[?ãK>FA;€14;K-Ò+ÜØP57<>CE57åA8V;k1

SVߜ1LÕ[DGFñK>FH5PK

SV0

CV1§5ºÔHMACÅK4;1L;=K¢Ò7ÜOK>FA;CVMACÅK4CE578Øs5+8ÅÕH;k1Ü°Ò@<¢ØP57<>CE57åA8V;k1Ò+Ü

SV^{Ú ñ;3ҝ?;k8} SA

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

SB

Þ«åŽáJK>FA;í`Û¥04ï¢ð

A = (SA, LA, CA, PA, VA, V0, P redA, AssA, s0,→A) Ý°<>;k14Ó Ú

B = (SB, LB, CB, PB, VB, V0⁰, P redB, AssB, s⁰0,→B)^ÞÚ LAB

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

LBA

Þ-çCV8Å8¥?;kMAÒ7K>;SK4FH;

1L;=KSÒ7Ü;=Ø+;kMoK>1ºÒ7Ü

LA

Ý°<>;k14Ó

LB

ÞçFACEDGFÖ1LáŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MHCk;çCÅK4FÖ57Mù;kØ+;=MoKÒ7Ü

LB

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

LA

Þ|Ú¦RAÒ+<§;WA573ºÓA8V;+ßHCXÜ

LA={?a1,?a2,!a3}^57MH? LB ={!a2,?a3,!a4}^K>FA;=M LAB = {?a2,!a3}^ß LBA = {!a2,?a3}^ßO57MH? ?a2

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

!a3

Þ1LáŽMHDGFH<4Ò@MACk;k1çCXK>F

!a2

ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

?a3

Þ|ڎۜÒ-14CÅ3ºÓA8VCÅÜ°á+ßoç$;çCV8Å8¦5+1>1LÕH3;¥K>FH5PK

∀a∈LAB

ß7K>FA;=<>;CV1$5.ÕAMACEæoÕA;

b∈LBA

14ÕHDGF

K4FH57K

a1LáŽMHDGFH<4Ò@MACk;k1çCXK>F

b^Ú

(

% !$T! '368'j!#/*&. ;&(,"7

(a) Topology TopS

LAB

LBA

GA

LA\LAB

! "

G^{B! "#}L^B\L^BA

(b) Topology TopS’

τLAB

LBA

GA

LA\LAB

$ "

GB

! "#

LB\LBA

™$%H™'& n)(Ar>t2rGmPwOw2z]›zk…qz]»]nqrGu

B+*8$07-,!.*8K/,.7 2/*$j

êŽÕAÓAÓ¦Ò@14;§K4FH57K

S CE1$K4FA;«1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@MS35+?;§ÕAӀÒ+ܜ1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔAô D=5PK>CÅÒ@MH1

SA

5+MH?

SB

ڎð I¥ê3ºÒ?;k8ÅCVMAà-Ò+Ü

S ^CV1 CS1= (SP, SV, SV0,(A, B), T opS)^ß

çCXK>F

T opS K4FA;ã5+՝K4Ò@35PK4Ò@M×Ò+ÜRUCVàHÚ !Öݾ5@ÞÚ

T opS CE1S5Ä12KG5PK>CVDK>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+á@Ú10O;kDK4Ò@<

<

G, LAB, LBA > ?;kMAÒ7K>;k1-K4FA;SØ@;kDK4Ò+<G1

< gab, a, b > 14ÕHDGFóK4FH57K

a ∈ LAB

14áoM[DGFA<4Ò+ô

MACk;k1çCXK>F

b ∈ LBA

ߥ57MH?ÙK4FA;kCÅ<%14áoM[DGFA<4Ò@MACk5PK>CÅÒ@MÖà+CVØ+;]1SÓA8E5+D=;ãK>Ò×57M Ò+åH14;=<>ØP57åA8V;

gab gab a b a b

1LCVÒ+MÙÝ°K4FA;S؎CE1LCVåA8V;€5+DK4CVÒ+MÄÒ+Ü5+MÄ;=3ºCE1414CÅÒ@MÄ57MH?Ä5%<>;kD=;=ӝK>CÅÒ@MÄCV1ö57MÄ;=3ºCE1414CVÒ+M[ÞÚ 0vMÄK4FH;

145+3;öç5sá@ß

< GA, LA\LAB, idle > ?;=MHÒ7K4;]1!K>FA;Ø@;kDK4Ò+<G1

< ga, a, idle > 14ÕHDGFJK>FH5PK

a ∈ LA\LAB

ÚO0vM

< ga, a, idle >ßUK>FA;%í`Û¥04ï!ð

A Ó[;k<LÜ°Ò@<431K4FA;J5@D|K4CVÒ+M

a à+CVØoCVMAà ÓA8V5@D;K>ÒºK4FA;-Ò@åH14;=<>Øs5+åA8V;5@D|K>CÅÒ@M

ga

ߦ57MH?K4FH;-í`Û¥04ï¢ð

B <4;k357CVMH1¥CÅM%K>FA;-1>573º;-12KG5PK>;

Ý

idleÞÚ Û¥FA;S14;K

GA

DÒ+<><>;k14Ó[Ò@MH?A1kߦCVMóà+;=MH;=<G5789߄K4ÒK4FA;S14;K

LA\LAB

ڜRUCÅMH5+8Å8Vá+ß

T opS

578V8ÅÒPç!1$K4FH;-57ÓAÓA8VCED=5PK>CÅÒ@MÒ+ÜU;]5+DGFØ+;kDK4Ò@<-Ý°CÅÜUCÅK!CV1¥Ó¦Ò@1>14CÅåA8V;]ÞCVMJ5à+8VÒ+åH5+8„1LK>57K4;.Ò+Ü

S^Ú

& M& *"$*7-,!.*" ,. 2/0$3

¢ÒPç.ß 1LÕAÓHÓ[Òo1L;öK4FH57KK4FA;14áoM[DGFA<4Ò@MACk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1§Ò7Ü

LAB

;=Ø+;kMoK>1cçCÅK4F

LBA

;=Ø@;=MoK>1c5+<4;MAÒ+MAô9Ò@åH1L;k<4ØP5+åA8Å;ݾ5@1cCXKŸCE1UK4FH;!D=5+14;Ò7ÜHK>FA;åA8E5+DGQoô‹å[ÒsW.K>;k1LK

57<GDGFACXK>;kDK4ÕA<>;]ÞߜK>FA;=Mi3ºÒŽ?A;=8VCÅMAà

S CVMÖI¥êìCV1

CS2 = (SP, SV, SV0,(A, B), T opS⁰)^ß

çCXK>F

T opS⁰ K>FA;J57՝K>Ò+35PK>Ò+MiÒ7Ü«RUCVàHÚ !iݾå[Þ|Ú`0vM

< τ, a, b > ^Ò7Ü < τ, LAB, LBA >^ß

K4FA;€14áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+MñÒ7Ü

a ^çCÅK4F b à+CVØ+;]1ÓA8V5@D;ºK>Ò¼57MCÅMoK>;=<>MH578`5@D|K>CÅÒ@M

τ^Ú «;=MA;k<>5+8Å8Vá+ß ç$;SDk57MÄ?;k1>D<>CVå[;ºK>FA;€14áoM[DGFA<4Ò@MACk5PK>CÅÒ@MãÒ@MóCVMoK4;k<4MH5+8`5+DK4CVÒ+MH1-Ò+MA8Vá¼Ü°Ò@<-5%ÓH57<4K-Ò7Ü¥K4FH;

1LáŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MHC]5PK4CVÒ+M;=Ø@;=MoK>1¥5+1¥CÅK!CE1¥K4FA;-Dk5+14;§Ò+Üc5öK>;k1LK¢57<GDGFACXK>;kDK4ÕA<>;+Ú

Û¥FoÕ[1=߄ܰ<>Ò+3 5K>;k1LK4CVMAàJ12KG57MH?Ó¦Ò+CVMoKk߄K>FA;I¥ê¼3ºÒ?;k8ŸCV1MHÒ7K.Ò+MA8Váã5Ü°Ò+<>3578O3ºÒ?;=8

578V8ÅÒPçCVMAàSK>FA;º?;k1>D<>CÅÓAK4CVÒ+MãÒ+Ü`CVM@K>;=<4ô‹D=Ò+3ºÓ¦Ò+MA;kM@KDÒ@33öÕAMACED=57K4CVÒ+MH1kß[åH՝K-578E1LÒ5€3ºÒ?;=8

K4FH57K!CV15+åA8Å;K>ÒºCÅMHD=Ò+<>Ó[Ò@<>57K4;§K4FA;K>;k1LK¢57<GDGFACÅK4;kDK4ÕA<>;k1kÚ

(S

% !$T! >‡$0/ F "7‰!/0&. ;&(,"

ۜçÒ¢35P÷2Ò@<U5+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5@DGFA;k1œç$;k<4;$ÕH1L;]?.Ü°Ò@<ÓA<>Ò7K>ҝDÒ+8@K4;]12K>CÅMHà G‚1NŠQSˆ‰J`zJre|NQSH 5+MH? [‰eUe|QSˆ‰J

`zJre|NQSH Ú70vM5@D|K4CVØ+;K>;k1LK4CVMAàHßPK>FA;¢?;k<4CVØP5PK>CÅÒ@MöCE1O35+?;Ü°<>Ò+3 1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1=Ú7Û¥FH;!?;=<>CÅØP57ô

K4CVÒ+MÄD=5+MD=Ò+MH14CE?;=<-Ò@MA8Váñ5%ÓH5+<LK-Ò+Ü$K>FA;€14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+MçCXK>FK4FA;S5+CÅ3 Ò7Ü¥8VCÅ3ºCÅK4CVMAàJK4FH;

12KG5PK4;14ÓH5+D=;¢;WÓA8VÒ@14CVÒ+MSçFACEDGFҎDkDÕA<G1?ÕA<>CÅMAàK4FA;.14á12K>;=3 DÒ@3ºÓ[Òo1LCÅK4CVÒ+M€5+MH?€5+MH578Vá1LCE1kÚ

Û¥FACV15+ÓAÓA<>Ò@5+DGFJCE1«QŽMAÒPçMñ5@1!K>FA;K4;k1LKÓAÕA<>Ó[Òo1L;öK4;]DGFAMACEæ@ÕH;+ÚðD|K>CÅØ@;K>;k1LK4CVMAàDk57Mã?A;k578

çCXK>FóÒ@MA;ºÒ+<.14;=Ø+;k<>5+8ODÒ+3º3öÕAMACED=5PK>CÅMHà;kM@K>CXK>CÅ;]1 ‹Úï§MóK>FA;ºÒ7K4FH;=<.FH5+MH?ßÓH5@1414CÅØ@;

K4;k1LK4CVMAàSD=Ò+MH14CV?A;=<G1$;=W;kDÕAK4CVÒ+MK4<G5+D=;k1Ò7ÜO57M%CV3ÓH8Å;k3;kMoK>5PK>CÅÒ@M ߝçFACEDGFJD=57M%DÒ@MoK>57CVM%ØP578Åô

ÕA;k1¢Ò7ÜOØP57<>CV5+åA8Å;]1!57M[?JD8VҎDGQ1kßH57M[?JDGFA;kDGQ1¥K>FA;ØP578VCE?CXK2áÒ7ÜcK>FA;k14;.K4<G5+D=;k1¢çCXK>FJ<4;]1LÓ¦;kDK

K4ÒñK4FA;J14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+M ÚU0vMÇK>FA;ç$Ò@<4Q1-<>;=8E5PK>CÅMHàãK>ÒñÓH5@1414CVØ+;K>;k1LK4CVMAà 9ßUK>FA;5+՝K4FHÒ+<G1

DÒ+M[1LCE?;=<Ò@MA8VáSÒ+MA;ÕAMoK>CÅ3º;k?%14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+M Ú

ۜÒó1LCV3ºÓA8ÅCÅÜ°á+ßO8V;KÕH1ºDk578V8

ZlH.J1k‚MZlRyVzZH2JrHNAN\J|e|NŠQSH#

K4FA;K4;]12KÒ+Ü¢Ò+MA;1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ¦D=5PK>CÅÒ@M

ݾDÒ@MÜ°Ò+<>357MHD=;K4;k1LK4CVMAàŽÞ57MH?

e1J1ˆ‰J1qs[mYk‚MZlRyVzZH2JrHNDN\JreUNŠQSH#

K4FA;%K>;k1LK€Ò7Ü.1L;kØ+;k<>5+8¥14Ó¦;kD|ô

CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@MH1JÝ°CVMoK4;=<>Ò+Ó¦;=<G57åHCÅ8VCXK2á@ßO;=3öå[;]?A?;k? ß`DÒ@3Ó¦Ò+MH;=MoKK4;]12K>CÅMAàŽÞ|ڟ0vMiK>FA;J<4;]12KÒ+ܧK>FACV1

1L;]D|K4CVÒ+Mœßoç;DÒ+M[1LCE?;=<K>FH5PK

ggaCV15ð-ÚAÛ¥FHCV114;kDK4CVÒ+M14FAÒPç!1`K4FH57K¥K4FA;«K4;]12K!5@D|K4CV؎CXô K4CV;k1573ºÒ+ÕAMoK$K4Òö5I¥êº3ºÒŽ?A;=8VCÅMAà[ß@åŽá?;=Ü°;=<><4CVMAà.K>FA;§?CÅé„;=<>;=MoKDGFH5+<>5@D|K>;=<>CV1LK4CED=1OÒ+ܜ5.K>;k1LK

K4ÒK>FA;-K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à+áÒ7ܟDÒ@3º3ÕAMACED=57K4CVÒ+M ß[57MH?%K>FA;5+ÓAÓA8VCVDk5PK4CVÒ+MJÒ+ÜcK4FA;578Và+Ò+<>CÅK4FA3

gga ^K4Ò

Øs5+8ÅCE?A57K4;.5öK4<G5+D;ݾÓH5+1>1LCVØ+;«K>;k1LK4CVMAàoÞ$Ò+<¥K>Òà+;kMA;=<G5PK>;¢K><>5@D;k1Ý 5+D|K>CÅØ@;«K4;k1LK4CVMAàŽÞ|Ú

!$*$0, /0$1/*

êŽÕAÓHÓ[Òo1L;K>FH5PK

I CE1!5+MCV3ºÓA8V;=3º;=MoK>57K4CVÒ+M%Ò7ÜUK4FH;-1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@M

SA

ß

57MH?óK>FA;SK><>5@D;S3ºÒ?;=8V;k?ìåoáñK4FH;€í`Û¥04ï¢ð Ò+ÜRUCVàHÚ#Çݾ5oÞ.CE15%K><>5@D;SÒ+Ü

IÚUÛ¥FACV1K4<G5+D=;

<4;kÓ[Ò@<LKG1K>FH5PK

I F[5+1º;W;]D՝K>;k?

a ∈ LA

Ý°ç;J<4;]D=5+8Å8K4F[5PK

A CV1K>FA;Jí`Û¥04ï¢ð Ò7Ü

SA

Þ

5PK3ºÒ+3º;kM@K !Aß Ü°Ò@8Å8VÒPç;k?óåŽá

b ∈ LA

5PKö3Ò@3º;=MoK $J14ÕHDGFK4F[5PK-K>FA;14FH57<>;k?óØP57<>CE57åA8V;

v ∈SV CV1¢;kæoÕH578œK4Ò #[Ú¦I$FA;]DGQoCVMAàºK>FA;ØP578VCE?CXK2áÒ7ÜcK>FACV1!K4<G5+D=;-DÒ+M[1LCE12KG1CVM¼3ºÒŽ?A;=8VCÅMAàS5 I¥ê

CS3= (SP, SV, SV0,(A, P T race), P T op)^ßPçCÅK4F P T raceK>FA;!í`Û¥04ï¢ðÖÒ+ÜRUCVàHÚ # ݾ5@Þ¥5+MH?

P T op K>FA;-57ÕAK4Ò+357K4Ò+MÒ7ÜORUCÅà[Ú#JÝ°å[ÞÚ Û¥FA;K4Ò@Ó[Ò@8ÅÒ@à+á

P topCE1OÓH5+<LK>CV5+8 ß7C9Ú;+ß7CÅK$?;=ÔHMA;k1`Ò+MA8Vá-K>FA;¢14áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+MH1UÒ+M

P T race

h=3/a/− h=5,v=4/b/−

ACCEPT

"

<a,a,a> <b,b,b>

™¦™

Zkuvuvnqpsr¥w2r>u‹w2nXm@»@

;=Ø+;kMoK>1kÚ

< a, a, a > ݾ<4;]1LÓ Ú

< b, b, b >Þ!D=Ò+MH14CE?;=<G1¥K4F[5PK

A ^57MH? P T race 1LáŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MHCk;

Ò+M

aÝ°<>;k14Ó Ú

bÞ|ß75+MH?K4FA;؎CE1LCVåA8V;5@D|K4CVÒ+MçCV8Å8å¦;

a Ý°<>;k14Ó Ú

b^ÞÚ ñ;FH5sØ@;$8E57å¦;=8V;k?K4FH;¥1LK>57K4;

<4;]5+DGFA;]?ºåoáK>FA;§5@D|K4CVÒ+M

b^CÅM P T race^åŽá ACCEP T CVMSÒ+<G?;=<`K4Òö3º5+Q+;

CS3

5I¥êAò¢Û

57MH?K>ÒSå[;ö57åA8V;K4Ҁ5+ÓAÓA8Vá

ggaÚ¦I$Ò@MH14;kæoÕA;=MoK>8Åá@ß

gga 578V8VÒPç!1K4Ҁ?;]DCE?;-CÅÜ

P T race^CE1!5

Øs5+8ÅCE?JK><>5@D;öÒ7Ü

A^¦CÅÜ gga <4;=K4ÕA<>MH157Mã;=3ºÓK2á¼14;KÝ

P AT H(CS3) =∅^ÞK4FA;kM P T race

CV1MAÒ+K¥5öØP578VCV?€K4<G5+D=;¢Ò7Ü

A ݾç$;«<>;kD=5+8Å8[K4F[5PK

ggaCE1¥57ÓAÓH8ÅCV;k?€K4ÒöK4FA;14;=357MoK4CED=1Ò+Ü

CS3

Þ|Ú

J1Ru[lqs… } ô «;=MA;k<>5+8Å8Vá+ߦK4FH;ºD=Ò+MH1LK4<>ÕHDK4CVÒ+MãÒ+Ü

P T op ?;=Ó¦;=MH?H1.12K><4Ò@MAà+8Vá%Ò+M

P T race^Ú

0‹K¥14FAÒ+ÕH8V??;ÔHMH;§Ò@MA8Åá14áŽMHDGFA<>Ò+MACk57K4CVÒ+MH1`Ò+M

P T race;=Ø+;kMoK>157MH?€CÅM€K4FA;145+3º;¢Ò+<G?;k<kÚ ô‹Û¥FA;€K4<G5+D=;

P T race CE1DÒ+M[1LCE?;=<>;k?Ç5+157Mì;kM@K>CXK2áÒ+Ü

CS3

çCÅK4FAÒ@՝Kº5+MŽá?ACV1LK4CVMHD|K>CÅÒ@M

DÒ+3ºÓH5+<4;]?öK4ÒK4FH;!Ò7K>FA;=<$;=MoK4CÅK4CV;k1kÚ@Û¥FACE1Ÿ5+8Å8VÒPç!1cK4Ò.;kMA8E57<>à+;¥K4FH;Ü°Ò+<>3Ò+ܦK>FA;¢D=Ò+MH14CV?A;=<>;k?

K4<G5+D;]1K4Ò57MŽáK><>5@D;]1$3ºÒ?;k8Å;]?åŽá€5+Mí$Û¥04ï!ð ?;=ÔHMACVMAàS14Ò+3º;.5+D=D=;=ӝK>CÅMHà1LK>57K4;k1kÚ

ô‹Û¥FA;;WA5+3ÓH8Å;Ò7Ü!K>FA;Ó[5+1>1LCVØ+;K>;k1LK4CVMAàóÒ7Ü!K>FA;14Ó¦;kDCÅÔ[Dk5PK4CVÒ+M

SA

CV1Ò@MA;ôvDÒ@3Ó¦Ò+MH;=MoK

K4;k1LK4CVMAà[ßUåH՝KºK4FA;%57ÓAÓH<4Òo5+DGFÄ<>;=357CVMH1öK4FA;%1>573º;CVMìK>FA;%D=5+14;Ò7ܧ14;=Ø@;=<G578Åô‹D=Ò+3ºÓ[Ò@MA;=MoK

K4;k1LK4CVMAà[Úk0vM.K>FACE114;K4K4CVMAàHßkK4FA;¥?CSDÕA8ÅK2áCV1œK4Ò§<4;kÒ+<G?;=< ØP5+<4CVÒ+ÕH1K4<G5+D;]1Ü°<>Ò+3 K4FH;$?CÅé¦;k<4;kMoK

DÒ+3ºÓ¦Ò+MA;kMoK>1K4ÒSD=Ò+MH1LK4<>ÕHDK!Ò+MA8VáSÒ+MH;K4<G5+D;@Ú ñ;K>FACVMAQSK>FH5PK!K>FA;-1LK>573ºÓ%3º;kDGFH5+MACE1L31kß

57MH?%;]1LÓ¦;kD=CV5+8Å8Vá€K>FA;1LK>5+3ÓJÓH<4ҝD;]141!ÓA<4;]1L;kMoK4;k?CVM # ‹ßHD=Ò+ÕA8E?%å[;öÕH14;k?Ú¦Û¥FACV1§1LÕHå÷2;kDK

à+Ҏ;k1¥å¦;=á@Ò+MH?€K4FA;Ü°<G573º;kç$Ò@<4QºÒ7ÜUK4FHCV1Ó[57Ó¦;=<!57M[?€MA;k;k?A1!3Ò@<4;«CVMoØ@;k1LK4CVà@57K4CVÒ+M Ú

C'j/0,^/*$1/*

RAÒ@<!5SI¥êò¢Û

SߝK>FA;.ÓH5PK>FH1

P AT H(ζ(S))à@;=MA;k<>57K4;]?€åŽá

gga ^Dk57M

å[;-Õ[1L;]?K4ÒS?;k<4CVØ+;K>;k1LK§D=5@1L;]1¥K4FH57K§DÒPØ@;=<]ߎܰÒ+<!;=WA573ºÓA8V;+ßH5+8Å8

S 1LK>57K4;]1=ÚHÛ¥FHCV1§573ºÒ+ÕAMoKG1 K4Ò%?;ÔHMH;5+8Å8

S 1LK>57K4;]1«5@1¢å¦;=CVMAàJ5+DkD;kӝK4CVMAà1LK>57K4;]1Ý

gga DÒ+ÕH8V?ãå[;57Mó5+?A5+ӝK>57K4CVÒ+M¼Ò+Ü K4FA;€ÛÛ¢ä7ò!04ï.ä ñÓ3º;K>FAҝ?A1-Ü°Ò@<-ÕAMoK4CV3º;k?Ä14á12K>;=31>ÞÚÛ¥FŽÕH1kߜç;SDÒ@MH1LCE?;k<-FA;=<>;Ò+MH8Åá

K4FA;K>;k1LK!ÓAÕA<>Ó[Òo1L;«K4;]DGFAMACEæoÕA;+Ú

5

768 -/0&. (AG N\JreUN3V2W#qŠVZerJ?]1`

cQfe‡[lH~_w`alb8G

(S, L, C, P, V, V0, P red, Ass, s0,

→)^{p [ˆ*QSH#No} Ze1J1NeyZ={+e|N\[N\J|e

ACCEP T ^[H2P REJ ECT ^{‚ p} [qs[3‚rN\Jrq|Q1QSHN

p

JI€UJ

p

[ˆ*k

QZqUeAN\Z €UJAN\J|e|N\JUPj}

ð Û¥N CE1.5ÓA<>Ò+Ó¦;=<4K2á%K4FH57K-Ò+MA;ºçÒ+ÕA8E?¼8VCÅQ@;K4Ò¼DGFA;]DGQJÒ+MóCÅ3ºÓA8V;=3º;=MoKG5PK4CVÒ+Móå¦;=FH5s؎CVÒ+<]Ú

T P1Ò7Ü`RUCVàHÚ $¼Ý¾5@Þ¢CV8Å8VÕH1LK4<G5PK4;]1¢5+M¼;WA573ºÓA8V;Ò+Ü`5€Û¥N Ü°Ò+<§K4FA;1LÓ¦;kD=CXÔ[Dk5PK>CÅÒ@M

SA

Ú

T P1

K4;k1LK>1!K4FH57K¢57M%CV3ÓH8Å;k3;kMoK>5PK>CÅÒ@M

I ^Ò7Ü SA

D=5+M;=W;kDÕAK4;

aÜ°Ò+8V8ÅÒPç;k?åoá

b 5PK¢5+MCVMH1LK>5+M@K å[;=K2ç$;k;=M

[2, Sig]5@D=D=Ò+<G?CÅMHà¥K4Ò!K>FA;$D=8ÅҝDGQ

h^ÝSig∈SP CE1œ5§1LF[57<>;k?ÓH5+<>5+3;=K4;k<œÒ7Ü

SA

Þ|Ú

Û¥FA;.8V5+å[;k8H?;kMAÒ7K>;k1K4FH;-578VÓAFH57å¦;K

LA

Ò7Ü

AÚó;-5+1>14ÕA3º;«FH;=<>;§K>FH5PK

a, b, c∈LA

Ú

bdH2Jrk‚UZlRyVzZH2JrHN„NOJre|NQSH3}

êŽÕAÓAÓ¦Ò@14;!K>FH5PK

T P1CV15-Û¥NÄÜ°Ò@<14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+M

SA

ڎðÙ3ºÒ?;k8ÅCVMAà-Ò+ÜK4FACE1ŸK>;k1LK$CVMI¥êºCE1

CS4= (SP, SV, SV0,(A, T P1), T P op1)^ßoçCÅK4F T P op1K4FA;.K>Ò+Ó¦Ò+8VÒ+à@áSÒ7ܟRUCÅà[Ú $%ݾå[Þ|Ú Û¥FA;$Ø@;kDK4Ò+<G1

< LA\{a, b}, LA\{a, b}, idle >?;=MAÒ+K4;$Ü°<4;k;$;kØ+Ò@8Å՝K>CÅÒ@MH1Ò7ÜH14Ó[;]DCÅÔ[D=57K4CVÒ+M

AÒ+M;=Ø+;kMoK>1cÒ7K>FA;=<cK>FH57M

a^5+MH? b^Ú CS4

CE1Ÿ5-I¥êò§Û×5+MH?-K>FŽÕH1

ggaçCV8Å8Hà+;=MH;=<G5PK4;ÓH57K4FH1 DGFA;kDGQŽCVMAà

T P1^Ú