HAL Id: tel-00011713
https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00011713
Submitted on 2 Mar 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Etude en laboratoire d’un courant de gravité turbulent sur un talus continental
Sabine Décamp
To cite this version:
Sabine Décamp. Etude en laboratoire d’un courant de gravité turbulent sur un talus continental.
Océan, Atmosphère. Université Joseph-Fourier - Grenoble I, 2005. Français. �tel-00011713�
.0/ 13241
5+687:9;68<:=?>A@CB9;DE>$F89?GIHC>HC>
JLK(MONQPORQSUT$PWV+XZYL[]\_^(P`Sba\cNQdfeKagP`h`ikj$K(R]Sb\lP`S
mnporqtsvuw_sZxyoz|{}q~ouOx "ynr+ "wZ "sZ
norr"xyotnu
0¡ £¢¥¤ ¦
§ uCxyLLwvu¨ "©xyruq~zpª&oq~r«¬®®"¯
1°]±³²µ´ ´·¶ ¸r¹º¡»L¼¹½°b»-¾8¼Q´ ²À¿A±³¶ Á)»¨±µ¼$¹¶&° ²Â´
Ã
¼¹ÄžưbÇ °$±È¼]ºÉ±µ¸~´¶° Ê˱ȼ ±³¶ °]¹¸r±³Ê Á)»¨¶°Q¾r¶µ´¶°]¹¸
ÌÎÍÐÏ:ÑÒÓÑÔbÏÖÕQѳÓ×QØÙrÑ
Ú +ysZr© Û Ürwbm{ ÚÉÚÉÝ(Þ ß
à-á|âäãá
ÙrÍÐÓÍ áå
ÕQÔkæOÔbÏçéè
Ú +ysZr© ê)© Öë Ý(Þ·Þ {ì ÝËí uîs_uCxyr©
Ú +ysZr© ï(ð+r Ú { Þ·Ýñ Þ unnp +Axyr©
Ú +ysZr© Ú "uîrÎìòó Ú ÝËí uîs_uCxyr©
Ú
+ysZr©
§
urðs_µ-ô|m
ÚÉÝݧ Þ
unnp +Axyr©
Ú
+ysZr©
Ý
î4u©rw|õ
ßöñ÷ñËÝÞÚ
øù ú]oryscr"x
û ×QØÙrÑ ã Ï:ü ã]ý ÏCüÑ ý ÔkÙrÑÍ å ÕQÔ
þ ýÿ(á Ï ý Ó á ÍlÏ:ÑÉÕbÑÙÒ á ÔlÑ â Ñ å ÓÙÈü ápã ×Oç;ÙrÍÔQÑÙ4Ñ"Ó å ÕQÔbÙtÓrÏCÍlÑlÙ
ÔQÍ ã Ñ à þ
"!$#%&(')*+!,.-/
>·= B>@9 > >A9AB>9(=?687:=)5gGÆ9 = BA7CDB9 > >A@~= ò68@&HCBE9 >A=?>A7C9)HC>= >
6D6 >A9 BG
5687C9 G Æ68B9÷G!"6 5gGIF8@#]=?6Æ7:=ËGÆ7D68@:FòH:>$A>$=?9?G%IGÆBED'&
>DE7CB( 7CB÷5gGÆ9 =?B7CDEB9 >" ò>@~=9 >"A68@*)
@CGÆB+?GÆ@~=?>÷H(G%868BE9=?687-, 687C9. 7/ 0#"6Æ7:=?>A9pD689+1t7C>2,G IGÆBpHC>"HC6Æ7:=?>`GI7 Bg<CB>A@+BE>@~=?B4351t7C>"
1t7C>5+>A9 6Æ@C@C>D"+HC> G%Æ68B9Ë>@A687C9 GÆF#)HgGI@]D>6 ò6 ò>@~=ËHCB7ABD>b> =8 7C9 = 687:=$HC>9 :G%868BE9
;
GIBE=A68@3GÆ@>5+>A@CHgGÆ@~=<>Ë= 9 68B;GÆ@C@#A>"&
5=#"ABGÆDE>bH#HCBGA>8(= 687:=?>ËD'0#"1t7CBE5+>8>O689 BE68DB.?GÆ@?1t7CB"DE>"|>A@5=#9 BE>@A>";@(GÆ7C9 GÆB>A@~=B, G GÆB
5:7G%86ÆB9÷DBE>7(5C?G%Æ68B9<Db>A@C9 BFEQBEHC>DED>!G:G )7:>D(H]BE<+6Æ7CH>A=6r=#A5gGÆ@:>I½>A9BE>9&=:GÆ@Ë687C<CDEB>A9
J
GÆ7:=CB>A9$EQ>DE>9A>B@:HCB 5+>A@?GÆ<:D>5+6Æ7C9(9 >" 687CHC9 >DE>"5C9 68<:D>" ò>"BE@
;
689 GI= B1t7C>"$> =H:>ò= 9?GÆBK)
= >" ò>@~=L>?MNH&(OË@F89?GI@CHP ò>9ABQSRT GÆ@t7C>DED>LUCBÆ68DDE>A)V>GWGI=<1t7CBGS 7 ;
GIB9 >DG=?9 GÆ@ B=?BE68@
>A@~=?9 > @:6]= >> =G·F89?GI@CHC>" ò>@~=
;
GABDEBE=#L ò68@LB@~=#F89 GI=?BE68@(&YX>A7C98 B ò5CDBBE=#D>A7C98 G Æ68B9V)
;
GIB9 > > =DE>7C9HCB 568@CBE<CBDEBE=#$ 68@~=
;
GÆB=H#"A687r9 BE9(DE> 5CD GÆB BE9]HC7¨= 9?G%IGÆBD>@Z#1t7CB5>HCGÆ@7C@C>
G! )<CBGI@>]= 9"[A68@\B4rB GÆDE>&
I½>A9AB]$>A= =?>bF89?GÆ@:HC>b5:BAB@C>;= 687C9 @CGÆ@~=?>QHCGÆ@|DG1t7C>ADD>Q,GÆBg>7 DG^_gGÆ@A>]HC>Ë@C>Q5CG|= 6 )
<>9÷> =[1r7:BF G)5+>A9 òBHC>9 >A@68@~= 9 >9ËHC>@C6 <C9 >A7*@HC>^rB BE=?>A7C9÷BE@t= >9 @gGI=?BE68@C@gGI7*@Y&
>` 687CGÆBE= >9?GIB~9 >@:HC9 >`7C@C6 / GÆF8>5gGÆ9 =?B7CDEB>9B
J
7aIGÆ9 >5gGÆ9 =?B~=?9 6859rB=?>- GÆBb GÆ@
1t7CB], >@C> >A9?GÆB$A>9 = GÆBE@C>" ò>@~=(5gGGÆDD#GÆ7-<+687=(H:>/A>A= = >ò=" >&268@c 687=?B>A@~=(5>9+ GI@C>@~=
5>@:HgGÆ@~=$HC>A7*@LGI@6 7C9Q=?6Æ7QDE>"Q5:DGÆ@bHC>d GrB>9 :68@~=e#A=#H(7:@LB >A@ >$ >687C9+"&(I½>9+B
5687C9Ë=?687=8>1r7:>)=?7P G!]GÆ5C5689 =#> =$5687C96 G Æ68B9b687Æ>9 =Q= GÆ@~=]H:>)5+6Æ9 =?>81t7(BDF >(9 >" =?>
>A@6Æ9 >9>f@5CD689 >9&=I½>9+BGÆ7+ B5+6Æ7C9÷D>]=?> 5Ë5CG+#G 9##HC71r7:>9Q7:@½F8>A@C687}H#
;
GIBDDGÆ@~=%&*U7
DGÆB+ >$7C@}F89 GÆ@CHrBHC>!5 GÆBO=?7g G!÷GÆ7 BHC68@C@#DE>"[ 6 aÆ>@÷5687C9;D>^A6 )<CDE>9&
h
Æ>"CI½6Æ9 >D> =dE]G%rBHi* ò>>H¨68@~=<:B>@j8687:D7Zk =?9 >DE>"9?GÆ5C5689 =?>7:9HC>/ ò68@=?9 G IGÆBEDpHC>
=" >+>A=., >D>A7C9÷>@P 7CBË=?9+"Q9 >"A68@C@gGÆB?GÆ@~= >&]I½>"e B@"9 >"b9 >" ò>9+BE>" ò>@~=<868@~=8#AF~GÆDE>" ò>@~=
mlO9 7C@C6ong>9 9 68@(I½6gG ò>HqpQGÆGÆB >A=R. GÆ@t7C>AD6H]BEDDE>9 GÆ7*@r1t7CB$68@~=½G>5=#"}H(0kA= 9 >
ò>" <C9 >ËH:7, 7C9sa&
Rp@3g@]!, >$ 7CB= 9<:>7C9 >7 >(H(G%868BE9;BAB"D'6"G! B6Æ@HC>$9 > >A9BE>9= 687:=?>^ G
;
G òBDED>~= 687
ò>"66 ò5gGÆF8@:68@]HC> F8GÆDA9 >D>8 ò>" )<C9 >"$HC>D'0t8EQ6\uF"> =$=?6876 >G BbH:>
J 9 >@C68<:D>+HC>
ng9 GÆ@>> =÷H(GIBDDE>7C9+":G Æ>"$1t7CB*,GIB5C7½5CGÆ9 =?GÆF8>9 ò>"2, 6ÆB>" ò>"÷5+>AB@C>÷>A=< >;5gG+ B6Æ@"&
! #"$%&' (
) &)
>O687:9?GÆ@~=÷HC>F89 G%B=#P&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9& *
) &) &)
RQ@:> 5:D>"÷F#A685\a B1r7:>" &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9& *
) &)
&,+ >O68@~=?>f@= >(6"#GÆ@CB1r7:>H:>"÷>A@5=#9 BE>@A>" &$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9& -
)
&,+ .]<, >A=?B
;
;HC>D'0#A= 7CHC> &$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)/
)
&,+*&
) 0
7C>" =?B6Æ@[BE>@~=?B4351t7C>" &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)/
)
&,+*&,+ upDGÆ@ &9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) +
1 23465747 98:4;<=>%@?A 9>B DC
+*&
)
R=?7:HC>"Ë>A@5=#9 B >A@~= GÆDE>";HC><A687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=# &9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)E
+*&
) &)
:GÆ@÷9 6Æ= GI= B68@ &$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)GF
+*&
)
&,+ tFÆ>"9 6Æ=?GI=?BE68@ &$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)H
+*&,+ B )7CDGI=?BE68@|HC>"<687:9?GÆ@~=÷HC>F89 G%B=# &L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&I+
F
+*&,+*&
)
I½6rHDE>"÷GÆ@gGIDat=?B1r7:>" &$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&I+
F
+*&,+*&,+ I½6rHDE>";@t7 #9 B1t7C>"Ë6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>" &$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&I+J*
+*&
E
tb5+>A9LK7}HC>DG)H*a@CG B1t7C>6*#GÆ@CB1t7C>F#@#A9?GÆDE> &$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
EJ/
C MN #9?O?DQPR%&ST%@?D :U9'PVXWXYA9? CXC
E &)
uGÆ9?G A= 9 >ËH:>$ B òBDEBE=?7:HC>b> =ËD68BH(0#"_C>ADD> &9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
EJE
E &) &)
B òBDEBE= 7CHC>>A@t= 9 >]DE>" #"_C>ADDE>"HC7 D GÆ<689?G =?68BE9 >;>A=OD>`#_C>DED>"`6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>"
E$F
E &)
&,+ X68BH]#_C>DED>HC>D'0#"A687CD> >A@~= &9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
E -
E
&,+ up9 6"#AHC7C9 >9RQ@5=#9 B >A@~= GÆDE>/&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F6/
E
&,+*&
)
EQB 5+6 BE= B;
&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F6/
E
&,+*&,+ >?C68BK@HC>b5gGI9?G A= 9 >";>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆ7*@ &$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
FJF
E
&,+*&
E
H]B 7gGÆDEB GI=?BE68@ 5gGI9<A68D6Æ9?GÆ@~= &$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F *
E
&,+*&
F
I½>" 7C9 >HC>^rBE= >" >(5CGÆ9<>?MNH &$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F -
G*&5uGÆ9 G A=?9 >"÷H(G"1t7CB B=?B6Æ@HC>"ËB GÆF8>i&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F6Z
<]&GEQB77:DE=#;HC>LGÆD7CDm&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
F6H
up9#A)v=?9 GÆBE= >" ò>@~=;HC>bB GÆFÆ>" &$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&I*
/
!&Gu9 >" òB>A9;9# 7CD= GI=q&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&I*J*
E
&,+*&,* I½>" 7C9 >HC>HC>@ BE=#D6GÆDE> &$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&I*J*
E
&,+*& I½>" 7C9 >HC7 /#ADGÆ@CFÆ>]F8D6Æ<gGÆD &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&I*J-
E &E
H8#A9 B435GI= B68@>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD>$HC>÷D68BH(0#"_C>ADD> &9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&I*
H
E &F
r= 9 7 =?7C9 >= 7C9 <:7CD>A@t= >HC>D'0#"6Æ7CD> >A@t= &$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
Z
E &F &)
MÐ@t= >@ BE=#H:>"g7A= 7gGI= B68@;H:>LrB=?>"+ >6C689 BWA68@~= GÆDE>" &L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
Z
E &F
&,+ U>A@ >A7C9bH:>÷>ar@C6ÆDH &$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
H
E &F &E
tQ@CF8DE>$H(0#A= GID>" ò>@~=;= 7C9 <C7:D>@~= &9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&I-J+
E
&,* tQ@CGÆDa >HC>;=?687C9 <CBDED68@aDE68@CB1r7:>" &9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
ZJ/
E
&,**&
)
n9+#"1t7C>A@>HC>"÷=?6Æ7C9 <CBEDDE68@?&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
ZJ/
E
&,**&,+ U9 G-, >" =?68BE9 >$HC>Ë= 687C9 <:BDDE68@ &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
ZJE
E
&,**&
E
>GÆ9?G =#A9 B =?B1r7:>"÷HC>";= 687C9 <:BDDE68@ &L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
Z
E
&,**&
F
H]BE= >"+ >HC>5C9 6Æ5gGÆF~GI= B68@ &9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
H )
E
&,**&,* >O68@DE7 BE68@ 7C9bD #A868DE7:=?BE68@·> =bDG
;
689 GI= B68@·H:>"÷=?687C9 <CBDED68@ &$&9&$&
HJE
E
& >O68@AD7 B68@ &9&$&9&$&$&$&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
HJZ
E
&,- >O6 ò5gGÆ9 GÆB 68@G%8>"D'0#"A687CDE>" ò>@~=÷HC7}H#A= 9 68B=;HC7:E]GÆ@C> GÆ9 &L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
HJH
E
&,-*&
)
X>LA687C9?GI@t=Ë5C9 B@AB5gGID &$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/ )
E
&,-*&,+ X>;=?687C9 <CBDED68@?aAD68@CB1t7C>"g&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/
+
MN !!? ?DPR%&ST%@?D :BG>4A%#< (
F &)
uGI9?G A= 9 >"÷HC>L B òBDB=?7CH:>"O> =÷D68BH(0#"_C>ADDE>^&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/
*
F
&,+ up9 6"#AHC7C9 >>f@:5=#9 B ò>@~= GID> &$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/JZ
F
&,+*&
)
EQB 5+6 BE= B;
&$&$&$&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/JZ
F
&,+*&,+ U>_C@CB1t7C>QHC>L ò>" 7C9 > &9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)G/JH
F &E
.]< >A9+IGI= B68@1t7gGIDBE=?GI=?B48>S&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)$)E
F &F
[#" 7:DE= G =;>A@5=#9 B ò>@~= GÆ7@ &$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)$)
*
F &F &)
X6ÆB;H(0#"_C>ADDE>5>O6 5CGÆ9?GÆB 68@H:>"Ë9#" 7CDE=?GI=÷>A@: òBDEB>7/ = 9?GI= B35#G%8>
D>^G!<:6 6ÆF@C>&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)$)
*
F &F
&,+ nD7 =?7gG =?B6Æ@HC>^rBE= >" > &9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
) + /
F &F &E
tQ@gGÆD4a >HC>";= 687C9 <:BDDE68@AaD6Æ@CB1t7C> &$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
) + /
F &F &F
tQ@gGÆD4a >HC>D'>A@5=#9 BE>@A>L6 )7C@C>$H:>9XbMVn>A=eu.MNH &$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)
+J*
F &F
&,* >O68@DE7 BE68@ &$&$&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
) + H
( G !"$ 9?5'?=%T"J47S&? 9# !S&?D??6 ?A'4 9?DPV?D DC9
**&
)
>O68@3CF87C9?G =?B6Æ@:RQ@5=#9 B >A@~= GÆDE>]>A=Ë5C9 6*#HC7C9 > &$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)GE
+
**&
) &)
EQB 5+6 BE= B;
&$&$&$&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)GE
+
**&
)
&,+ >?C68B4@·HC>"Ë5gGÆ9 G A=?9 >";>f@:5=#9 B ò>@~= GI7*@ &9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&
)GE$F
**&,+ >GÆ9 GA=#9 B = B1t7C>ËF#@#A9?GÆDE>";HC>D'0#"A687CDE>" ò>@~= &$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9& *
**&,+*&
)
R.687CDE>" ò>@~=[ ò6-aÆ>@ &9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)E
*
**&,+*&,+ R.687CDE>" ò>@~=;=?7:9 <C7CDE>@~= &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)E
-
**&
E
I½> 7C9 >(H:>D >A@~=?9?G@C> >A@t=$&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)EJH
**&
E &)
U#6Æ9 B>$H]GÆ7=?6!)N B òBDGÆ9 B=#r&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)EJH
**&
E
&,+ E6#A= >9+ BE@gGI=?BE68@>A@5=#9 B ò>@~= GÆDE>]HC76r>7BE>@~=ËH(>@~=?9 G @C> >A@~= &$&$&9&
)GF
+
**&
F
>O68@D7 B6Æ@ &9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)GF
*
'#"6S& !BG%&'!B W'<D9<=>47S&?DB ?6 ?=>B ?D"$%5'?AB
&
)
[#" 7CDE=?GI=;>f@:5=#9 B ò>@~= GI7*@ &$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)GF
-
&,+ u>9 5+>A= B8> &9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) * /
%#ST%@XW'4#U!%&? D(XC
!9?=8?AB
23?D">U#!% !?DB ?6 PV'?D#B 9? PV?DBG 9?AB %TS&%&B ?DB
t )
H6#D6B /# =?9 B>Ë5gGÆ9[689 9#ADGI= B68@H(B GÆF8>m&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6+
t ) &)
up9 B@B5>
J
#@#A9?GÆD &$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6+
t )
&,+ t"1t7CB BE= B68@H:>"ËB GÆF8>" &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6+
r687C9A>D7 òB@C>A7 > &$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6+
>G! /#A9?G >A=Ë68<, >A= B; &9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6*
uGÆ9 = BA7CD>Z&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
t1t7CB BE=?BE68@ &9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6-
>O6Æ@DE7 BE68@&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6-
t ) &E
U9 GÆBE= >" ò>@~=÷HC>ËH:68@C@#A>"Ë5gGÆ9<>?MNH &$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6-
Ee#A=?>A9 òB@gG =?B6Æ@HC>"÷H#A5CDGA>" ò>@~= &$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
)
6-
H>A= >7C9+bBE@689 9 >A=÷> =QGIDF8689 BE= ><CB#9?GI9_CB1r7:>o&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) - /
t+ I½> 7C9 >"ËHC>L 68@:HC>" &$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) - E
t +*&
)
68@CH:>"÷HC>L68@:HC7A= BrBE=# &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) - F
t +*&,+ 68@CH:>"÷HC>$=?> 5=#9 GI=?7C9 > &$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) -
t +*&
E
68@CH:>"<ò7:DE=?9 G 6Æ@ &9&$&$&9&$&L&9&$&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&L&9&$&$&9&$&9&$&$&9&
) -
"J4;S&%T9W# ?=%&?DB X ! # #S@?D WX4659%@"6 !?DB 9?659%@4 ?D '>%@'ST%&B
? ?D"$ '4 !#% X>P BGS& ?
'
| -' )*% ! ) ) - ' ) -- ! ! /- ) '
! , ) ! -! #" ! $&%(' )"",* -!,+ !- #-/. 0.2143 )
576989: %
;=<>;
@?BADCFEHGJILKMC9NEPO
Q/R&Q/RSQ
DT÷Ñ âäã lÑÙVUü ápã ×Oç;ÙrÍÔQÑÙ
OË@P687:9?GÆ@~=bHC>F89 G%B=#>" =]7C@P#687:D>" ò>@~=bF#@#9#(5gGÆ9Ë7C@C>(HCBXWY#9 >@A>HC>(HC>@ BE=#(>A@t= 9 >
H:>7*@ g7:BHC>"& >O>= a5>H(0#"6Æ7CD> >A@t=>" ==?9
;
9#"1t7C>A@~=·>@4F#A685\a B1t7C>ZY'rB ò5 68@]
)HJZ
+
) &
,?"!
)H$H
- AI>@5gGÆ9 =?B7CDEB>9D689+1t7C>;HC>p5#A@C6 @C>= >" ò5+6Æ9?GÆBE9 >"F#@A9 >A@t=|HC>F89?GÆH:B>@~=HC>;HC>A@*)
BE=#:689 BW68@~= GI7*@6Æ7P8>9 =?BGÆ7*@Y
;
689+ GI@t=QHC>"5gGI@gG_C>= 7C9 <:7CD>A@t="&bEQGÆ@^>L#"6Æ7CD> >A@t=
A68@\8>" =?B
;
"D G ;
689+>$HC> g6Æ= = GÆ<:BDB=#b>" =ËDGC 687C9+>H(0#@C>A9 F8BE>H:>"< 687*8>" ò>@~="&
E]GÆ@D'GI= 6 5A9 >ò5gGÆ9>A@>" ò5CDE>D>(F89 GÆB@(G! 6B#"(GÆ7*@¨689 GÆF8>"L 68@~=)HC7}D GI9 9 B4#A>
H(7C@iA687C9 GÆ@~=)HC>òF89?G%rBE=#H]GÆBE9
; 9 68BEH¨> =)HC>A@ >!&.>O>"9687:9?GÆ@~=9 68@~=5gGÆ9
;
6ÆB9 >A@CHC7$B BE<CD>
5gGI9DGg 7 5>@ B68@HC>5+6Æ7 B9 >")> =)HC>5gGÆ9 =?BA7CD>(H:7i 68D & >O>)@t7gGÆF8>5>7Æ>@~=òGI= =?>BE@CHC9 >
)/$/J/
HC>LgGÆ7:= >7C9÷5687C9;7C@:>LrB=?>"+ >HC>
HJ/
!gA6 / ò>^ 7:9ËDG3gF87C9 > ) &) &
X>"L687:9?GÆ@~=HC>F89 G rB=# 6Æ@t=(@gGI= 7C9 >ADDE>" ò>@~=$>@~= 9 >A= >@t7(5gGÆ9DG5>@~=?> =?6Æ5+68FÆ9?GÆ5:B1t7C>&
>6>" =bDE>6G"C5CGÆ9;>A@>" ò5CDE>:H:>"÷G%IGÆDGÆ@_C>";HC>$@:>BFÆ>Y DË6853g@CFÆ>9"
)HJZJE
A:H:>";F8DEB >" ò>@~=OHC>
= >9 9 GÆB@]r6Æ7 D6Æ9|HC>bH:BXWY#9 >A@~=`= ar5>"H]#A9 7C5:= B68@`86ÆDGI@CB1t7C>"&X>"`3CF87C9 >
)
&,+L ò68@~=?9 >@~=7:@C>
A687CD#A>b5\ar9 6DG = B1t7C> YcG%IGÆDGI@_C>ËHC>@ >QHC>bF~GW!rH:>eA>@CHC9 >"> =OH:>b<CDE6*`_CGÆ7CH`1r7:B+5>7Æ>@~=
GÆDED>A9F, 71t7( * / ) ) * / ! O>A=Ë7C@C>L6Æ7CD#A>H:>DG%8><gG GÆDE= B1t7C>:5CD7rB1t7C>7 >&
` ! . '2. )* '( /- +) ++
:
/"'1 ! 5
'
, ) / B ! -3 M )' ! - ) ,2. !/(- )
, ' !/ )
◦
5 #-/. ( !2.-.)! : 2. - ! : % )- '2.)*.')!$"!++ #" / ! #-/. ( !2.- )%$ , - - %
Rp@ òBDBE>7 GÆ9 B@(CH:>"bG IGÆDGÆ@_C>e 687V) GÆ9 BE@C>"÷5>7Æ>@~=^ >5C9 6HC7:B9 >!51t7C>(D 6Æ@GÆ5:5+>ADD>
A687C9?GI@t=÷HC>]=?7C9 <CBH:BE=#!&5>O>L 6Æ@t=÷H:>"[#"A687CD> >A@~=;H(>GÆ79 B_C>Ë>A@5gGÆ9 = BA7CD>>@ 7 5+>A@ BE68@
1t7CB|HC>"+>A@CHC>@~= 7C9D>"$ GÆ9 F8>L68@~=?BE@C>@~=?GÆD>"&BMÐDL 6Æ@t=(H#D>A@_#)5gGÆ9HC>(=?9 >" )<:D>" ò>@~=
HC>=?>A9 9 >(687}HC>QF8DEB >" ò>@~=÷HC>=?>A9 9 GÆB@&
0
7gGÆ@CH:>"<6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=eA6 / ò>@>@~=bD>A7C9÷HC>"+>@~= >
BED;G7 7CD>A@t=÷H:>"[#AHCB ò>@~=5>^1t7CBDE>";9 >A@CHHC>5CD7;>@5CD7;HC>@ >"Ë5gGÆ9;9 GÆ5C5689 =[ D >GÆ7
G <CBGÆ@~= >&]MÐD6 > H#5CDG>A@~=GÆD689+QHC>5CD7Q>@5CD76rBE=?>!"5687IGÆ@~=^A9 >7 >9$H:>d#9 BE=?GÆ<CD>8G-)
@\a86Æ@` 687V) GÆ9 BE@"&!X689+1r7:>ËDG]5+>A@~=?>"GÆHC6Æ7B =5+687:9
;
689 ò>9DGQ5CDGÆB@:>;GÆ<\a?GID>;HC>|6"#GÆ@
& &G>O687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=#
D #687:D>" ò>@~=÷5>9 HHC>D'0#@C>A9 F8BE>$>A=ËD>[#H:B ò>@~=< >H#56 >@~=%
;
689 GÆ@~=÷HC>b<gGI@"ËHC>L?GÆ<:D>
> =;HC>8IG >&5OË@}>f@>" ò5CD>8#D<C9 >$HC>86Æ7C9?GÆ@~=÷HC>]= 7C9 <:BHCB=#]G)>A7DBE>7·>A@
)GH
+ H
)DG GI9 F8>bHC>"
J
9?GI@CHClGÆ@" HC>U>9 9 >A) pb>A78>!& t DG 7:BE=?> H(7:@4= 9 >" <CD> >A@t=)HC>·=?>A9 9 >!7C@îF8BEF~GÆ@~=?>1t7C>
FÆDB+ > >A@t=bHC>= >9 9?GÆBE@VY )/$/
3
bGS òBË>@ 7 5>@ B68@LH:>"]=?6Æ@C@C>"QHC>d#AHCB ò>@~=";
689 GÆ@~=
DE>L687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>@ >&=MÐDb">" =6#687CD#L 7C9Ë5CD7ËH:>
ZJ/$/
HC>D #A5CBA>@~=?9 >H:7 #AB+ >!gH#A= 9 7CB?GÆ@~=
H:>"[Æ<:D>"=#D#F89 GÆ5CB1r7:>"1t7CB9 >A5+6?GÆBE>@~=[ 7C9÷DE>
;
68@CH(&XGdrBE= >"+ >HC>5C9 6Æ5gGÆF~GI= B68@ HC7
; 9 68@~=
GGÆBE@ B"5C7:k =?9 >> = B #>G = =?>ABF8@CGÆ@~=;D>
)G/J/
!(&
Q/R&Q/R
à-áå ÓÑ TÓÑ á Ò"ü ýå Í OÔQÑ ÕbÑÙÑ T ã üÏ:ÍlÑ å Ò"ÑÙ
E]GI@D>:68@~=?>f@r=?>6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>`H(GÆ7:=?9 >"·= ar5>"HC>PA687C9 GÆ@~=HC>FÆ9?G%rBE=#>A@B =?>@~="5+6Æ7C9
DE>"+1r7:>DQD>"bHCBXWY#9 >@A>"$HC>HC>@ BE=#@C>d 68@~=$5gG69##>$5gGÆ9]DGò=?7:9 <CBEHCBE=#G GIBË5C9 6 rB>A@C@C>@~=
H]BE@C6 ò68F#A@#B=#"`HC>$DG=?>" ò5=#9?G =?7C9 >]687HC>$DG?GÆDEB@CB=#!&*uGÆ9;>A@> 5CDE>$GÆ7@CB48>GÆ7HC7H#A= 9 68B=
H:>
J
BE<C9?GÆD= GÆ9DG ò>9I:#AHCBE= >9 9 GÆ@#A>}H#8>A9 >: >">GÆ7@m_gGÆ7CH:>" GÆB GÆD#A>"HgGÆ@ D 6"#GÆ@
t= DGÆ@~= B1t7C>BYlGI9 B@:F8>9 up9 B>!
)HJH
- A&\XGHC>@ BE=#Y 7C5=#9 B>7:9 >e )/
+ Z &H
*QF X >A=|DG^ GÆDBE@CBE=#
B 5689 = GÆ@~=?> Y EJZ
&,*ò5 7 ËHgGI@QDG/ ò>96I:#HCB =?>A9 9?GI@#>(5C9 6 rB>A@C@C>@~=$H:>DG=?9+"
;
6Æ9 =?>$#IGÆ5689 G )
= B68@-HgGÆ@> = = > >A9
;
>9 #>>A=_gGÆ7CHC>!21t7CB|>" = 7:5Y#A9 B>A7C9 >S½D GÆ5:5+689 =>@&>GÆ7HC6Æ7>5gGÆ9
DE>"÷5C9+#"BE5CBE=?GI=?BE68@;> =bDE>"Ë9 B4B9 >""&=>O> = = >(>GÆ7 >9 #DGÆ@CF8>$>A@5C9 6 ;
68@CHC>A7C9ËG%8>"(D>Ë>GÆ7*@}5CDE7
;9 68BH:>">A= 68BE@^?GID#>(H:> D'6"#GI@ct= DGÆ@~=?B1t7C>&2>O>"9#"_gGI@CF8>"9 68@~=_# GI= B+#" 7C9DG3)
FÆ7C9 > ) &E
G> =>" =?B /#` 7C9ODGL3gFÆ7C9 > ) &E
< 5gGÆ9`HC>"` > 7C9 >"`B@*)N BE= 7H:>QDGL?GIDB@:BE=#!& X.B 5gG!A=|HC>
A>"<#"_gGI@CF8>"QGÆ7}@CBÆ>GÆ7½HC7: >7CBED>" =÷= 9"ËB ò5689 =?GÆ@~==YlO9sarHC>@
!
)HJH F
lO689 >@!
!
+
/J/
+ f&`X.0#"A687CD> >A@~= H(>GI7 ?GÆD#> 689 = GÆ@~= 5gGÆ9òD>}H#A= 9 68B=H:>
J
B<C9 GÆDE=?GÆ9 6rHCB43g>HC>
; G K68@
@:6Æ= GÆ<:D>·DGHCB =?9 B<C7:= B68@¨HC>?GIDB@:BE=#òHC> G+ >òH]>GÆ7HgGÆ@ D6"#GÆ@ t=?DGÆ@~=?B1r7:>&.>O>B;> =
BEDDE7 = 9#$5gGÆ9÷DG3CF87C9 > ) &F
H:68@C@gGÆ@~=ËDG9#A5gGÆ9 =?BE= B68@H:>(DGC GÆDBE@CBE=#LòH:>"Ë5C9 6 ;
6Æ@CHC>7:9[868B B@:>"
H:>
)/$/J/
W5687C9|D>1t7C>DED>`DGH:>@ BE=#ËHC7A687C9 GÆ@~=`Æ>@gGÆ@~=OHC>bDG$ ò>9`I:#AHCBE= >9 9?GÆ@#A>]GÆ5:5C9 6_C>
A>DED>$HC7 BEDBE>7·G! )<CBGI@t="&
EGÆ7:= 9 > >A@> 5CDE>"HC>687:9?GÆ@~=HC>@ >:#687:DGÆ@~=>@ÖH:B9 >A= B68@îHC>D'6"#GI@rt= DGÆ@~=?B1t7C>
>f@B = >@~=%26 ò> D>>GÆ7*@
;9 68BEHC>"5C9 6 Æ>@gGÆ@~=HC> DG½<CGÆ@1t7CB >·HC>nB_:@C>9(6878>A9 = > 7C9(DG
ò>9HC>¨>HCHC>ADDp> = ;
689+ GI@t=DE>"9RGÆ7*@jtQ@~=?GÆ9 =?B1t7C>(H:>Sng68@CH Y$BEDD`689 =(
)H
-J- f&BIGÆBDG
;
6Æ9 GI=?BE68@LH(>GÆ7¨5C9 6 ;
6Æ@CHC>òDG5CD7BE@t= >@ >/rB>A@~=HC7¨9 > ; 9 68BEHCB+ >" ò>@~=HC>>GI7*@-HC> 7C9
;
G>
HCGÆ@QDE>"< >A9ËHC>dpË689+F8>!+H:7PXGÆ<C9 GÆHC689Ë>A=bHC7
J 9 6@CDGÆ@CHZY$BDED`689 =(;+
/J/ )
f&YX>$687:9?GÆ@~=
H]>GÆ7·HC>A@ >e1r7:B+>A@·H#"A687CDE>r5gG >]GÆ7DGÆ9 F8>÷HC>" DE>"`nQ#9 6*#`> =5gGÆ9|D>÷H# =?9 68BE=`HC7EQGÆ@C>" GÆ9
Y EQB 68@ lO9 6÷@]
)GHJH$F
5CGÆDD up9 B>!
)GHJHJZ
>
! +
/J/JE
f&=>O>(5#@C6 @:>5gGÆ9 =?BK)
"!$#%!'&(*)+,&!"-/.02143.%#5(7689 #/&!"$":;#<1=30> .51?0A@B0C+D07E&F1?(CG%#!"0*07#<HI:;#96&!":;#J1?.<+ ))K:;+&MLN1?02"
6O:;#91?.%6&!$P!$&(Q(C"076O&+!"-/.0Q1?0Q6C0O&R(768%;#/&!"$":;#S1=30> .M10T@B0C+VUXWZY
◦
[0O&VU\])%+0>!$:^#S,&@B:^)8(C+!]-^.%0T#:^+@_ "0;`
E.+6O07$"0143.#0R:;".?&!":;#1?0a68":;+.+01?0b)K: &;E!".@c1 #%];-/.0C""0d"HI+^6&!$:^#e0C#\@_^0b1?0aL
[
^07E&f`f;g/h,i/g^Y j%`
.?kS@Bl7@m06C:;#%1!'&!$:^#%V1?0n&07@B)9(7+ &.+0n0O&)+07E!":;#po/qb$"0e07E&T1?:;#96Q #9R.#!$&(e:;.D#:;&(C0Br)%.?sto
) &
,?"!
a)
Maroc Espagne
b)
`M !%
5
( . ', ! -3 " .)%!+ !- -'X .) ' . !%)* !
) ! !' Z ) '"! - ! ) )'/- ) - ! ! =&% (
: ) 6
) ) !* - , , / !$ ")' -' M ! /- )) ' - -
)! !, ! - '-/)
34.8 34.6 35.2 35.8
35.4 35.6
35
80°W 20°W
0° 40°W 60°W
Longitude
20°N 0°
Latitude 40°N 60°N
` - - - ) !- -'X ) ! /! /-3
6
) , )7 )
AB5>CDG F#A@#9 GI=?BE68@HC>"$RGÆ7*@Pt=?DGI@t= B1t7C>Lu9 6 ;
68@CH:>""&F>O> = ar5>òH:>687C9 GÆ@~=HC> F89?G%rBE=#G
HC6Æ@HC>"Ë> W+>A=<1t7CBB# =?>@:HC>@~=e 7C9÷HC>F89 GÆ@CHC>e#_C>DED>"&
>O>"#"A687CD> >A@~= 68@~=½7C@ #"GÆ@CB+ >LB 5689 = GÆ@~=HgGI@½DE>9 >@:6878>ADDE>" ò>@~=}HC>"½>GÆ7*@
& &G>O687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=#
6"#GÆ@CB1r7:>"5C9 6 ;
68@CHC>1r7:B
;
68@~=5gGÆ9 = B>H:7 AaD>HC> A68@\8>A=?BE68@Â=C>A9 ò6gGÆDEB@C>: 6rHCB3gGÆ@~=
DGHCB =?9 B<C7:= B68@F8D68<CGÆD>HC>=?>" ò5=#9?G =?7C9 >>A=HC>g?GIDB@:BE=#!&QX>=?9 GÆ@ 5+689 =HC>_gGÆDE>7C9C1t7CB;> =
GIB@ B;>@CF8>A@CHC9+#B@ g7C>@>
;
6Æ9 =?> >A@~=DE>gDB G =%&T>O>/A687C9?GI@t= HC>}F89 G rB=#=?9+"·G!A=?B
;
C 68@~=
;
6Æ9 #"|HgGÆ@`HC>"`>@CHC9 68BE=`5CGÆ9 = B7:DB>A9~5C9 6 8>A@gGÆ@~=;HC>e >A9 GI9 F8BE@gGÆD>p687
;
>A9 #>"`6 D>GÆ7
H:>@ >> =;F#@#A9#>*YZD G_CGÆD>A7C9>" =÷5+>A9 HC7:>88>9+;D'GI= ò6 59 >]>A= I687·D>GÆ7>" =÷5CD7??GID#>Q5gGÆ9
#AIGÆ5+6Æ9?GI= B68@ 687
;
689+ GI= B68@HC>÷F8DGA> f&MÐDp5gG! >A@~=>@ 7CB=?>÷5gGÆ9pHC>`H#A=?9 68BE=p687ò5gGÆ9pHC> 7O7C@
>7CBED>A@~=?9 >OHC>"<gG B@6*#GÆ@CB1t7C>"&X>`= 9?GÆ@ 5689 =HC>?_gGID>7:9" DB#`eA>">GÆ7*@91t7CB >H#A8>9+ >A@t=
Æ>9+|DE>"5:9 6 ;
68@:HC>7C9+"~BE@CHC7CB=7C@C>A>DED7CDE>OHC>A68@\8>" =?BE68@FÆD68<gGID>`Q=?9?G%Æ>9DE>"p6"#GI@"&\X> C7*@
H]>GÆ7
;9 68BEHC>|>@ 5C9 6 ;
68@CHC>A7C9> =.#1t7CBDEB<C9+#`5gGI97C@ g7@)HC>`_gGÆDE>7C9>A@d 7:9
;
GA>8H#A5CDG KGÆ@~=D>GÆ7
_CGÆ7CHC>÷HC>;D #1r7CGI=?>A7C9 8>A9|D>"58DE>"p5gGI9D'B@~=?>A9 #HCBGÆB9 >`H:>;F89?GÆ@:H.687:9?GÆ@~=TA6 / ò>DE>
J
7:D
;
t=?9 >G &G>O>A= =?>$B9+7CDGI=?BE68@ =C>9+ 6CGÆDBE@C>Q> =bBDDE7 = 9#A>8 7C9÷DG3gF87C9 > ) &**&
| 5 -! - . , (. !- $! ' ! ' . ! '43 ! P ) )
! . ! !$# & ' - , ! ! , !- !+ )-/ - /- )
. !. !- ! ! )* !+ , )* , , 2/- !
' ) !$#+M ) 9 , ! ! ) -/) !' - ' %
'43 -- ' ! ! ) ! . ! ) , - !'* - !- %
E]GI@ D>A7C9HC>A>@~=?>D>D68@:FHC7&= GID7968@~=?BE@C>@~=?GÆD'F>687C9 GÆ@~=)H]>GÆ7>@CFÆ>@CHC9 >@~=òHC>
;
6Æ9 =QF89?GÆH:B>@~=$HC> HC>@ BE=# >A=^Æ68@~=>@~=?9 G @C>A9$D> C7CBHC>>@\rB9 6Æ@C@gGÆ@~=%"5CD7$D#F8>A9"Y 6rHCB3gGÆ@~=
A68@ BH#A9?GÆ<CDE>" ò>@~=ËD>Ë5:9 685C9 B# =#"÷HC>$>e G+ >"ËH(>GÆ7]&YX.>@~=?9 G@:>" ò>@~=Ë9 >5:9#" >@~=?>7C@ C7*@
H:>< G+ >;HCBGÆ5\a*A@gGÆDE>ËB 5689 = GÆ@~=H:>ËD 6"#GÆ@d8>A9|D>A687C9?GI@t=|F89 G%B= GÆBE9 > Y #DGI@CF8>?Æ>9 = BGÆDgHC>
C7CBHC>$=?9?G%Æ>9bD><A687_C>QHC>(HCBXWY#9 >@~=?>bH:>@ BE=# f&(>O>$ /#ADGÆ@:F8>$B@ C7C>@A>(>A@5gGI9 =?B7CDEB>A9
DG(56 B=?BE68@ HC>e =?GÆ<CBDEB GI=?BE68@HC>8> G! >H(>GÆ7 6*#GÆ@CB1t7C>*1r7:B]6Æ@t= 98DE>Q>A@F89?GÆ@:HC>Q5gGI9 =?BE>
DE>$5C9 6> 7bH:>$A68@\8>A=?BE68@½=C>9+ 6gGÆDBE@C>&
) &
,?"!
>O>" #"A687CDE>" ò>@~=L6"#GÆ@CB1t7C> 68@~=-HC>F89 GÆ@CHC> #_C>DED>> = 68@~=<>GÆ7A687C5¡5CD7D>A@t=
Y
∼ 1
! 1t7C>}D>687C9 GÆ@~=òHC>=?7C9 <CBH:BE=#!& MÐD 6Æ@t=òHC6Æ@HC>"=?> 5CGÆ9?G =#A9 B =?B1r7:>"C1t7CB H#A5gG+ >@~=½DG, 687:9 @#A>&X>">W"> =HC>LDG;
689A>LHC>j>O689 BE68DB DEB#"SD G9 6Æ= GI= B68@ÖHC>D G¨= >9 9 >
HC>ArB>@:@C>@~=ËGÆDE689|B ò5+6Æ9 = GI@t="&\MÐD`=?>A@CHC>A@t=68@~= >@CBE9?>6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=OHgGÆ@7C@C>bHCB9 >"A= B68@5gGÆ9V)
= B7:DBA9 >!CF#@#9?GID>" ò>@~=bD>D6Æ@CFH]7C@:>9 Æ=?>!>A@H#ABGÆ@~=QDE>"÷5gGÆ9 =?B7CDE>" g7CBEHC>"< 7C9bDG HC9 68BE= >
HC>ËD>A7C9pH#A5CDGA>" ò>@~=|HgGÆ@D # B 59 ><pË689 H(& XG$Har@gG òB1t7C>÷HC>[A>" 687C9 GÆ@~=|H(>GÆ7òHC>@ >
>A@ò5:9#" >@A>÷HC>9 6I= GI= B68@(>A=pH(7C@C>;5>@~= >=?68568F89 GÆ5CB1r7:>
;
G Æ689 B >DE>H#A8>DE685C5>" ò>@~=pH(B@ = G-)
<CBEDB=#"|=?7C9 <C7CDE>@~=?>;>A=;DG9+#GI= B68@5=#9 B6rHCB1t7C>bHC>]=?687:9 <CBEDD6Æ@` #" 6!) #_C>DED>"&XG)Har@gG! B1r7:>
HC>D #687CDE>" ò>@~=^ 689 =?GÆ@~=HC7¨H#A=?9 68BE=]HC>
J
BE<C9?GIDE= GI9b5gGI9$>A@>" ò5CD>!>@:F8>@CH:9 >HC> =?>ADD>8 = 9 7f)
= 7C9 >=?687C9 <CBDED68@:@gGÆB9 >"GÆ@~=?BaDE68@CB1t7C>"ÆGÆ5C5>D#A>"
>AHCHCBE>""41t7CB:5+>A9 B = >@~=
F Z
GÆ@9Yu9 BA>
!
)GHJHJE
f& EQ>"=?687:9 <CBEDD6Æ@.aDE68@CB1r7:>" 68@~=`#F~GÆDE>" ò>@~=|68< >9+#"HCGÆ@|D>÷H#A= 9 68B=|HC7E]G-)
@C> GI9 G&(MÐD`, 6Æ7C>@~=7C@9ÆD>)B 5689 =?GÆ@~=]HgGI@D>"b=?9?GI@ 5689 =$HC>C_gGÆDE>7C9$687HC> GÆDBE@CBE=#&]>O>
68@~=[>";5:9 6>"+ 7÷HC>6 /#ADGÆ@CFÆ>Q>A=DGGÆ5gGABE=#QHC>$D'0#"A687CD> >A@~==?9 GÆ@ 5+689 =?>A9HC7 g7CBEHC>8 7C9
HC>QF89?GÆ@:HC>"H:B =?GÆ@A>"1t7CB9 >A@CHC>@~=[A>"A687C9?GI@t=HC>]FÆ9?G%rBE=#Ë>"+ >A@t= B>AD;HgGÆ@OD>O5#@C6 @:>"
>A@ rBE9 68@C@:>" ò>@~= GÆ7@]&
u687:96 ò5C9 >A@CHC9 >DE>"÷5#A@C6 @C>[1r7:BB@~=?>A9+rB>A@C@C>@~=ËHgGÆ@ËDGB9+7CDGI=?BE68@·6"#GÆ@CB1t7C>!CBD
> =Ë@#"A>"+?GÆBE9 >HC>D>";6Æ< >A9+8>A9bH:B9 >A= >" ò>@~=Ë5gGÆ9;HC>e ò>" 7C9 >ËBE@*) BE= 76875gGÆ9?G =?>DEDB=?>&IGÆB
A>"68< >9+IGI= B68@9#A>DDE>"2 68@~=T 6Æ78>A@t=|HCB47BDE>"Q]B@~=?>A9 5C9+#A=?>A9T8GÆ7 >;HC>;DG6 7C5>9 5+6 BE= B68@HC>
)7:DE=?BE5CD>5#A@C6 @C>`1t7CBG 68@~=` GÆDCBEHC>@~= B35#"& X>"|>A@5=#9 BE>@A>"`>@òDGÆ<689?G =?68BE9 >O5>9+ > = = >@~=
H(B 68D>A9>A9 = GIB@;HC>e #"GÆ@CB ò>";HC>DG)H*a@CG B1t7C>^ /# 6!)N#"_C>ADDE>$>A=ËHC>D>68@~=?9 8D>A9"&5X>A7C9
GÆ@CGÆDa > ;
GBEDB=?>p>@ 7CB=?>ODG<A6 ò5C9#C>@ B68@(HC>?A>"5#@C6 /A@C>"5 a B1t7C>">A=5>7=5>9 ò>A= =?9 >
HC>LGÆD>A9>9 = GÆBE@ËG 5>" =ËHC>DG)5gGI9?G #A= 9 B GI=?BE68@·HC>[ 6rHDE>";@t7 #9 B1t7C>"&
;=<
" E $GJI O EHAI
Q/RR&Q
ÔQÑÙ~ÓÍ á|å ÙîÙÒ+Í Ñ å Ó:Í ÔQÑÙ
X>$5C9 BE@BE5gGÆD"6Æ<, >" =?B
;
HC>LA>A= = >$= >>" =bH:>^ BE>7*@6 ò5C9 >A@CHC9 >$DG)Har@gG òB1t7C>$H:>"[687)
9 GÆ@~=HC>`FÆ9?G%rBE=#p= 7C9 <C7:D>@~="HC>"+>A@CHgGÆ@~=7:@C>`5>@~= >O>@(9 6Æ=?GI=?BE68@$HgGÆ@7C@9 BEDBE>7$G <CB GÆ@~=BC6 )
ò68FA@C>Q687S =?9 GI=?B435#Ë>@HC>A@ B=#&>O>"sa = >B ò5CDEB1t7C>@~=|HC>#"_C>ADDE>" 5gGI=?BGÆD>`> =O= >" ò5+6!)
9 >DDE>"|=?9#A= >@CH:7C>"[1t7CB"BE@~=?>9 GÆF8B >A@~=>@~= 9 >$>DED>"&*E]GÆ@D 6"#GÆ@(rD>O5C9 6*A>" 7;HC>8 ò6 a8>A@C@C>
#_C>DED>B, 6Æ7C>@~=p7C@98DE>O5C9 B ò689 HCBGÆD8HgGI@D G<BE97:DGI= B68@$=:>9 ò6gGIDB@:>`F8DE68<gGÆDE>&-XGQHar@gG! B1r7:>
HC>CA>"$5C9 6*A>" 7>" =BE@t= B ò>" ò>@~=]DEB#A>)GÆ7*@5#A@C6 @C>H:>= 7C9 <:7CD>A@>C5>A=?B=?>d#_C>DED>!b
DG9 6Æ=?GI=?BE68@>A=/LD GP =?9?G =?B3GI= B68@&H:7r òBDEB>7G )<CBGÆ@~= >A=/LD'B@ g7C>@>HC>DG= 68568F89?GI5CB>
F#A@#9 GÆ@~=QH:>@:6 )<C9 >7 >"÷B@ = GÆ<:BDB=#"&
XGbHar@gG òB1t7C>|HC>`>"2687:9?GÆ@~=HC>OFÆ9?G%rBE=#=?7:9 <C7CDE>@~=2#A=?GÆ@~=5gGI9 =?B7CDEBA9 >" ò>@~=F6 5CDE>A@>
)
&,+*&X.]<, >A= B ÷HC>D'0#A= 7CHC>
H:>"÷D68BH(0#"_C>ADDE>^ B ò5CDE>" 68@~=b5:9 6856#A>"÷5687C9;H#9 BE9 >$D #A868DE7:=?BE68@>A=÷DE>86 ò5689 = >" ò>@~=÷HC>
A>A=6#"6Æ7CD> >A@t=QHgGÆ@b7C@P òBDEB>77C@:B
;
689+ >!&GRDED>e >)<gG >@~=8 7C9QDG/6Æ@ >A9+IGI=?BE68@H:7 g7*@HC>
C6Æ= =?GÆ<CBDEBE=#·HgGÆ@7C@r687:9?GÆ@~=/ 7C5C56+#½>A@ÈGÆ7:= 6!) B òBDGÆ9 B=#&BMÐDGÆFÆBE=HC68@5gGÆ97C@C>#A= 7CHC>
>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD>!gHC>(H#A=?>A9 òB@C>A9÷D>"÷5C9 B@AB5gGID>"GÆ9?G!A=#A9 B =?B1t7C>"ËHC>$>"e687:9?GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=#
> =ËHC>L68@3C9 ò>9>bDE68BOH(#A868DE7:=?BE68@HC7687C9 GÆ@~=%&
u687C9<>DGgBD">" =bB ò5689 =?GÆ@~=;HC>$ > 7C9 >9÷D>Ë>W"> =bHC7: #DGÆ@CF8>G%Æ>"DE>^ BEDBE>7G <CBGÆ@~="
BE@CHC7CB= 5gGI9 DGLHar@gG òB1t7C>=?7:9 <C7CDE>@~=?>> =BE@ =?GÆ<CDE>HC7rA687C9 GÆ@~=%& >O>g /#ADGÆ@:F8>B@ C7C>@A>DG
56 BE=?BE68@H(0#"1t7CBEDB<:9 >}GI= = >BE@t= >5gGÆ9D>g6Æ7C9?GÆ@~= =?GÆ<CBEDB+#D>D6Æ@CFHC>" Æ= >"ò5gGÆ9D G ;
689+>}HC>
>O6Æ9 B6ÆDB& >O>BE@~=?>9 GA= B68@ >@~=?9 >½DE>687C9 GÆ@~=ò>A=D> òBDEB>A7G )<CBGÆ@~=%DEB# GÆ7*@î5#@C6 /A@C>"
H]>A@t= 9?G@C>" ò>@~=Q>A=]H:>)9 > , >A=Y
H:>A=?9 GÆB@:>" ò>@~=% AG6Æ@t= 98DE>@~=]DGHC>A@ B=#(HC7P6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=Q5C9 BE@BE5gGÆD'
G]DGÆ9 F8>7:9687?G6rBE= >" >&U687Q>"5gGÆ9?G! / =?9 > 6Æ@t= #IGÆD7#"5gGI9D>Q ò>" 7C9 >p>A@5Y#A9 B >A@t=?GÆD>
HCGÆ@÷D>^A687C9?GI@t=Ë>A@:#1r7:BDBE<C9 >QF#6 =?9 685CB1r7:>DE>$D68@:F HC7½5:DGÆ@B@DBE@#&
X>"e > 7C9 >"]H:>9rBE= >" >HgGI@QD #687CDE>" ò>@~=b5C9 BE@BE5gGÆD5>9 ò>A= =?>A@t=QHC>A6 ò5CD# =?>9ËDGHC>s)
A9 BE5:=?BE68@HC7A687C9 GÆ@~=p5gGÆ9H:>"BE@
;
689 GI= B68@B 7C9D'B@~= >@ BE=#`HC>" g7A= 7gGI= B68@=?7C9 <C7CD>A@~=?>"pHCGÆ@
7:@ 5CD GÆ@ 5CGÆ9?GÆDEDAD> ]DGQ5>@~= >& IGIBDE> #DGI@CF8>|5C9 6 rB>A@t=> >@~=?BE>DDE>" ò>@~=pHC> g7 =?7gGI= B68@HC>
rB=?>"+ >$8>9 =?BGÆDE>91t7CBH#A= >9+ BE@C>@~=bD'>@~=?9 G@C> >A@~=bH:7 g7CBEHC>9 ò68BE@÷HC>@ >)HgGÆ@bDE>9A687C9?GI@t="&
>O>ADDE>"s)NB 68@~=L#F~GID>" ò>@~=^# =?7CH:B#>5gGÆ9$7C@C>GI7:=?9 > >A@5Y#A9 BE>@A>òH:>ò5:D7$5>A= BE=?>(= GÆBEDD>!&=R@*3g@(
DE>"BE@ =?GÆ<CBEDBE=#"|HC>$5CDE7F89 GÆ@CHC>^#_C>DED>8 68@~=÷68< >A9+#>"GGÆ9 GA=#9 B#A>"÷5gGÆ9DGF#A@#9 GI=?BE68@5Y#f)
9 B6rHCB1t7C>bHC>]=?6Æ7C9 <CBEDDE68@ aDE68@CB1t7C>"&GOË@C>
;
68B
;
689 #"?>"Æ689 = >A@68@~=;7:@C>L =?9 7A= 7C9 >$5:D7:=Æ=
<CGÆ9 6Æ= 9 685>$>A=ËBED >5:9 685gGIF8>@~=Ë5gGÆ9 GÆDDD> >A@~=;GÆ7= GÆDE76Æ@t= B@C>A@~= GÆD &5X.GÆ@CGÆDa >$H:>DE>7C9+÷689 BK)
FÆB@C>Q>A=QHC>)DE>7C9+6GI9?G =#9 B =?B1t7C>]>" =$B ò5689 =?GÆ@~=?>5+6Æ7C96 ò>A= =?9 >(>@P#ArBHC>A@> DE>7C9eGÆ5gG!BE=#
)= 9?GÆ@ 5+6Æ9 =?>A9÷HC7 C7CBHC>^ 7C9÷HC>F89?GI@CHC>"÷HCB =?GÆ@>"&
XGHar@gG òB1t7C> HC>(6"#GÆ@>" =<CBE>@9 >A5C9 6rHC7CB=?>5gGÆ9$DG7Æ>ò= 687C9 @CGÆ@~=?>/>O689 BE68DB"Y 689 =?>
H:>b<gGI@÷H(> GÆB+5687C9D 6"#GÆ@C68F89 GÆ5CBE>685=#9 GI=?BE68@C@C>ADD>!&\>`FÆ9?GÆ@CH:>"|HCB ò>@ B68@p5+>A9 ò>A= = >@~=
H]GÆ5:5C9 6_C>9 DE>" 9+#F8B >B@:>9 = B>AD1t7CB?GÆ9 GA=#9 B >A@t=D6"#GÆ@(&QR@
;
GÆB=%H(7C@î5+68BE@~=)HC>r7C>
>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD'% >7CDE>DG;F89?GI@CHC>T7Æ>`H:>>O689 B68DEB+5+>A9 ò>A=H(68<:=?>A@CB97C@$6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=HC>F89 G rB=# ;DG
;
6ÆBp=?7C9 <C7CDE>@~=> = ;
689 =?> >A@t=`B@ g7C>@"#Q5CGÆ9`DG9 6Æ= G =?B6Æ@(& IGÆB`DG$ B òBDEBE=?7:HC>>@~= 9 >QDE>" #"_C>ADDE>"
H:7µDGÆ<689?G =?68BE9 >>A=DE>"#_C>DED>6*#GÆ@CB1t7C>"·@]> =5gG=?687 , 6Æ7C9·B / #H:BGI= >}> =D'>A@r= >@ B68@
H:>"]9+#" 7:DE= G =]GI7 G!Q9#A>D@(> =$5CG6#ABEHC>@~="&]u687C9QDE>"e687C9 GÆ@~=]H:>F89 G rB=#7C@:>d B BEDBE= 7CHC>
>A@~=?9 >>"^#_C>DED>]>" =$5C9 6Æ5+6+#>!]6 5CD#A=#>5CGÆ9]7C@C>6 ò5gGÆ9 GÆB 68@>A@t= 9 >)DE>"]DE68BËH(0#"_C>ADDE>"
>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD>Q>A=QD>e ò>" 7C9 >]B@*)N B=?7}HgGÆ@]DE>9GQH:>)D'0#"A687CD> >A@~=6 689 =?GÆ@~=]HC7H#A=?9 68BE=bHC7
EQGÆ@C>" GÆ9=&
u687C9^ > 9 GÆ5C5C9 6*_:>9]HC>^68@:HCBE= B68@b6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>"$9+#>ADD>"+HC>"$>f@:5=#9 B>A@>$ 68@~=$9#GÆDB#A>"
>A@P òBDBE>77C@CB
;
689 #" ò>@~=< = 9?GI= B35#(>@H:>@ BE=#!&YMÐDF"GÆF8B=QH:>H# =?>9+ BE@C>9<1t7C>DED>6 6Æ@t=QD>QHCB
;)
;
#A9 >A@>(G%Æ>" D>G]H]7C@ òBDEB>7C6 ò68FA@C>)> =$H(>@H#H:7CB9 >)H(GÆ7:=?9 >"$DE68Bb>A@5Y#A9 B >A@t=?GÆD>
1t7CB5>9+ > = = >@~=ËHC>D>"÷>f@:5:DBABE= >9"&
) &
,?"!
Q/RR
ý|å
tQ5C9+"A>A= = >B@~=?9 6HC7A=?BE68@·F#A@#9 GÆD>!1t7C>AD1t7C>";= 9?G%IGÆ7*@H#V, 9#GÆDB#"? 7C9;DE>"6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=;HC>
F89 G%B=#!= 68@~=Q<:9 BA8> >A@t=b5C9+#" >A@~=#"]GÆ7 _gGI5CBE= 9 > +*&GEQ>@:6 )<C9 >7 >"Q>f@5Y#A9 B>A@>"+GÆB@ BB1t7C>
5CDE7 BE>7C9+8 ò6HAD>]GÆ@gGIDat=?B1r7:>"Q> =$@t7 #9 B1t7C>"$5>9+ > = =?>A@~=$HC>)H#9 B9 >>9 = GÆBE@$G 5+>A=$HC>
DE>7C9;Har@gG! B1r7:> GÆB`5+>A7:A68@A>9 @:>@~=Ë7C@:A687C9 GÆ@~=÷HC>$F89?G%rBE=#]=?7C9 <C7CDE>@~=[ 7C9÷7C@:>$5+>A@t= >>@
9 6Æ= GI= B68@]&
X.# =?7CHC> HC>> =#"A687CDE>" ò>@~= HgGÆ@)D>/G)H]7C@ òBDEB>A7¨G! )<CB GI@t=C6 ò68FA@C> > = >f@:56+#>
GÆ7S_gGÆ5CB=?9 > E
&*MÐD=6Æ@t= B>A@t=D G(H:>"A9 BE5:=?BE68@·HC7·H:B 56 BE=?B
;
>f@:5=#9 B ò>@~= GID' 6 ò5CD#A=#A>QHgGI@D'GÆ@*)
@C>f@>6tÎ5gGÆ9|D>ËH#A=?GÆBDgHC>`= >"_C@CB1t7C>"`HC>6 ò>" 7C9 >O>" ò5CDE6-a#>`5687C9 68@>Æ68B9|>A=GÆ@gGÆD4a >9TA>"
>f@:5=#9 B>A@>QHC>DGI<+689 GI=?6ÆB9 >!&X>b5C9 B@AB5gGID>"GÆ9?G!A=#A9 B =?B1t7C>"÷HC7687:9?GÆ@~=< 6Æ@t=< ò>" 7C9#A>"
DG9rBE=?> >]B@ = GÆ@~=?GÆ@#>$> =GÆDA7CD#A>Q5gGI9O7C@C>^ #A=C6rHC>QHC>6689 9#DGI=?BE68@ H]B GÆFÆ>bHC>Q5gGÆ9 = BA7CD>
> =]D>eIGÆ9 BGI= B68@÷HC>(HC>@ BE=#HC7:>"$GÆ7 /#ADGÆ@CFÆ>$ 68@~=]>A@C9 >AF8B =?9#A>"]5CGÆ9QHC>]5C9 63gDËHC>9 68@CH:>"
HC>6Æ@CHC7 =?BrB=#g687:5CD#A>"/-HC>/GÆ5:= >7C9+HC>=?> 5=#9 GI=?7:9 >& >O>9+#" 7CDE=?GI=ò68<:= >@t7ò>A@5Y#f)
9 B ò>@~= GÆDE>" ò>@~=9 >9s8>A@t=/:#9 B3g>A9)D>D6ÆBHC>6 5689 = >" ò>@~=d 7C9)D #687CDE>" ò>@~=)FÆD68<gGID'&BXG
;
689+ )7CDGI=?BE68@ HC>6A>"`D68BpH(#_C>DED>O>" =>f@:5:DBABE=#>÷HgGÆ@ >e /k >[_gGI5CBE= 9 >&XG9 =?9 7A= 7C9 >Ë=?7C9V)
<C7:D>@~= > HC> D'0#"A687CD> >A@~=$>" =L#F~GÆDE>" ò>@~=$68<=?>@t7C> 7C9$7C@5CDGÆ@L5gGÆ9 GÆDDD>9·DG5+>A@t= >&BRp@3g@]
7C@:>½GI@gGÆDa >}H:>" =?687:9 <CBEDD6Æ@Aa*AD68@:B1t7C>"F#A@#9+#"ò5gGÆ9 DE>687C9 GÆ@~=5+>A9 ò>A=HC>g 7CF8F#A9 >9DE>
#"GÆ@CB+ >HC>(D>7:9QF#A@#9 GI=?BE68@> =]HC>(D>7:9Q5C9 685gGÆF~G =?B6Æ@(&5U6Æ7QDE>"Q9+#" 7CDE=?GI=e 68@~=^A6 5CGÆ9#
GÆ7@G6"#GI@CB1t7C>`9+#>D>@ò5C9 6856 GÆ@~=O7C@:>< B òBDEBE=?7:HC>O>A@t= 9 ><>`#687CDE>" ò>@~=|>A=|DE>687C9 GÆ@~=
D'0#"_C>ADDE>$HC7DGÆ<+6Æ9?GI= 68B9 >&*XGC6Æ@3gF87C9 GI=?BE68@g#A= 7CHCB#A>>" =b5gGÆ9 =?B7CDEB9 >" ò>@~=;5C9 6*_:>(HC>D >GÆ7
HC>A@ >[#687CDGÆ@~=pHC7 H# =?9 68BE=HC7E]GÆ@C> GÆ9G&Ob@:>6 ò5gGÆ9 GÆB 68@)H# = GÆBEDD#>|>@~=?9 >;D>"5C9 6Æ5C9 B#A=#
HC>/> =#687CDE>" ò>@~=)> =H:>"GÆ9?G!A=#A9 B =?B1t7C>"HC7iA687C9?GI@t=(F#A@#9+# >@¨DGÆ<689 GI=?68BE9 > > =(H#"A9 BE= >
HgGI@[>$ /k >8_CGÆ5CBE= 9 >!&
u687:9)7C@C> B òBDB=?7CH:>ò5:D7dA6 ò5CD =?>·G%Æ>"D>d68@:HCBE= B68@(6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>"HC> >A@5Y#A9 BE>@A>"
68@~=9#GIDB+#>$HgGÆ@$7C@ òBDEB>7G )<CBGÆ@~=]7C@:B
;
689+ /# >A@t=6 = 9?GI= B35#)>A@HC>@ BE=#&bX>_gGÆ5:BE=?9 > F
687CDBEF8@C>D>e B òBDB=?7CH:>";HC>9>A=6#"A687CD> >A@~=$G%8>)D>$GeC6 ò68FA@C>> =QDE>"QH:B8>A9 F8>A@>]DB#>
GÆ7@> W+>A=bHC>DGd =?9 GI=?B435G =?B6Æ@ 7C9÷D>;5C9 6Æ5C9 B#A=#÷F#@#A9?GÆDE>"÷HC7687:9?GÆ@~=%&
Rp@3g@5687C96Æ<:=?>A@CB97C@C>·H:>"A9 BE5:=?BE68@&5CDE7H# = GÆBEDD#>HC7 #DGI@CF8>ò>A=)H:>")BE@t= >@ BE=#")HC>
g7A=?7CGI=?BE68@pHC>rBE= >"+ >8>A9 = BGID>I7C@C># =?7CHC><]5CDE75>A= BE=?>?#"_C>ADD>OH(7:@A687C9 GÆ@~=H(>GÆ7HC>@ >
HgGI@÷7C@:GÆ@gGÆD> =ËH#9 B=?>HgGÆ@ËDE>$HC>9 @CB>A9_gGÆ5CB=?9 >&
)
'
Ob@C>÷HC>9 B5:= B68@9 GÆ5CBH:>;HC>"T#A= 7CHC>|>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD>p>A=|@t7 /#A9 B1r7:>"p9#GÆDB#A>"
GÆ7C5gGÆ9 G%ÆGI@t=]>A=8rB GÆ@~=L·9 >A5C9 6rHC7CBE9 >9>"^A687C9 GÆ@~=$HC>)FÆ9?G%rBE=#!+5>9+ > =$H(>A@ )
5+6 >98A>9 = GÆBE@$G 5+>A=$H:>)DG H*a@CG B1t7C>HC>>"^#687:D>" ò>@~=""@:6Æ= G ò>@~=
>@ZA>/1t7CBTA68@>A9 @C>D>C #DGI@CF8> >@~= 9 >òD>"HCBW]#A9 >A@t= >"$ G! >HC> g7:BHC>1t7CB
>@~=?9 >@~= >A@ , >A7(&TX>"#"1t7gGI= B68@ F#@#A9?GÆDE>"HC7o 6Æ78> >A@t= 68@~=/#AF~GÆDE>" ò>@~=
5C9# >@~=#>"QHgGÆ@÷D>^GÆHC9 >H:>DG)Har@gG òB1t7C>6"#GI@CB1t7C>!&
<>;
EHAI G O C ÷FE A G I G ? ADC(FEHGJI K=C9NEPO
X.B ò5+689 = GÆ@> HC>>6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=(HC>òF89 G rB=#= 9
;
9+#"1t7C>@~=)>@¨F#685 a B1t7C> > =5gGÆ9 = BA7*)
DEBA9 >" ò>@~=Q>@6*#GÆ@:68F89?GI5CB>!GA68@CHC7CB=LHC> @C6 <C9 >A7 >^#A=?7:HC>"$=#689 B1t7C>"@t7 /#A9 B1r7:>"
> =Q>f@5Y#A9 B ò>@~=?GÆD>"&GX.6Æ<, >" =?B
;
#A=?GÆBE=ËHC>H#9 BE9 >D'G 5>" =ËHC>9A>"e687C9 GÆ@~=Ë>A=bHC>$ BE>7*@6 )
5:9 >@:HC9 >·D BE@ g7C>A@>HC>·D >A@t= 9?G@C>" ò>@~=(=?7C9 <C7CD>A@~=d 7:9)D>A7C9(5:9 685gGIF~GI=?BE68@(F#A@#9 GÆD> >A@t=>@
òBDEB>A7@C68@= 687C9 @CGÆ@~=%& IGÆB 7C9 DE>" 5#@C6 @:>"òD>@~= >A=HC>F89 GÆ@CHC>#_C>DED>pDG
;
689A>HC>
>O6Æ9 B6ÆDB`DB#>L DG)9 6Æ= GI= B68@H:>DG)=?>9 9 >G 7C@}> W+>A=ËB ò5+6Æ9 = GI@t=? 7C9ËDG)H*a@CG B1t7C>$HC>D'0#"6Æ7CD>f)
ò>@~="&u>A7H(# =?7CH:>">A@5=#9 B >A@~= GÆDE>"BE@DE7C>@~=p7C@:>O=?68568F89 GÆ5CBE>OHC>
;
68@CH >@C òBDEB>7=?6Æ7C9 @gGI@t="
= 687:=>A@A68@ >9+IGÆ@~=|D>?GÆ9 GA=9 >;= 7C9 <C7:D>@~=HC7 g7:BHC>;HC>A@ >!&B ò5 68@ Y )H$Z
+ 5gG! >÷>A@ò9 >r7C>
DE>"[6Æ7C9?GÆ@~=QHC>F89?G%rBE=#>A=
J 9 B7=BY
)HJZ
?A6 ò5CD =?>L> = =?>(GÆ@gGIDa >(GÆ7GËHC>"e BEDBE>7*@ >@
9 6Æ= G =?B6Æ@(&
X>"ò9 >_C>9+_C>"/ 7C9òD>687:9?GÆ@~=HC>}F89 G rB=#5>7Æ>@~=S >½H:BrB >9 >@4HC>A7*@oGI=#F86Æ9 B>
>O>ADDE>"Q6 LDG/ 687C9+>)> =$HC>9868DE7 >$3@>(A6 >HgGÆ@QD>"b>A@5=#9 BE>@A>"$HC>
X6 \) >A@*_gGÆ@:F8>
> =?A>DED>"|6òDGL 687:9>b>" =?A68@~=?B@t7C>!&EQGÆ@ODE>">A@5=#9 B>@>"OHC>
X6* ) >A@*_gGÆ@CFÆ>4:HC>A7*@g7CBH:>"
H:> HC>@ BE=#"$HCBW]#A9 >@~= >"^ 6Æ@t=BE@CBE= BGÆDE>" ò>@~=[#A5gGÆ9+#"5gGÆ9]7:@C>
5689 =?>Y1t7CB>" =>@ 7CBE= >)9 > =?BE9#>!
B )7:D GÆ@~=5gGÆ9ò>A@> 5CDE>DG5C9 685CGÆF~GI= B68@îH(>GÆ7ÅHC687A>GI7ÖHC> 7·H(>GÆ7r?GÆD#>}D689+òH:>½D 687)
Æ>9 =?7C9 >H]7C@:>^#"DE7 >$)D > )<+6Æ7_t7C9 >$H(7C@C>$9 BrBA9 >!&E]GÆ@ËDG B=?7gG =?B6Æ@·6*#GÆ@:B1t7C>:68@5+>A7:=
+*&
~r 4!
HCB = B@CF87:>97C@:>;9#FÆB68@ H(B@:BE=?BGI=?BE68@$6 ò5gGÆ9 GÆ<CD>GÆ7 5C9 6> 7`H:>
X6 \) >A@*_gGÆ@:F8>~> =7C@C>÷9#f)
F8BE68@òHC>Q5C9 685gGÆF8GI=?BE68@D>÷D68@:F(HC7= GÆDE7T68@~=?BE@C>@~=?GÆDG B 7CD#A>b5gGI9|DG$ 687C9+>6A68@~=?BE@r7:>QHC> g7CBH:>
HC>A@ >!&]X>H#A<CBE=Ë>" =6A68@~=?9 8D#5gGÆ9÷DE>$5C9 6> 7QH(B@CB=?BGI=?BE68@·>A=ËDGH*a@CG B1t7C>HC7 A687C9?GI@t=ËDE>
DE68@CFHC7L= GID7]@]G5gG$H]BE@ g7C>A@>C 7:9^> H#A<CBE=>A@-9 GÆB 68@LHC> DGSB=?> > 7C9 5>9+9 BE=?B1t7C> HC7
A687C9?GI@t=(HgGÆ@9 G½5gG! >òHC>H:>"A>@~=?>B@CB=?BGÆD>DY 7:5Y#A9 B>A7C9 >/D GB=?> >òHC>ò5C9 6Æ5gGÆF~GI= B68@HC>
68@:HC>" HC>FÆ9?G%rBE=# A& >6> =C>1t7(68@4GÆ5C5>DED>òD>·9+#F8B >HC>A68@~=?9ÆD>\arHC9?GI7CDB1r7:>·HC7îH#<:BE=%
<CBE>@68@:@r7}HgGÆ@ËDE>"÷5C9 68<CD >;HC>9 B4B9 >""&
R&Q R&Q
ýå ÙÏ á Ó ý ÓÍ á|å
MN8 <D>%@?D#"J?O# " ?689">U!47!WX?
XG÷= >"_C@CB1t7C>OHC7
DE6* )Ð>f@*_gGÆ@CF8>!ÆG[#A=#ODGÆ9 F8> >A@~=>" ò5CD6 a#A>O5687C9D'0#A= 7CHC>|>A@5=#9 B >A@~= GÆDE>
HC>`687:9?GÆ@~=H:>OF89 G rB=#`bHC>A7*@)H:B ò>@ B68@y>"+ >@~= B>DED> >A@t=HgGÆ@HC>"2GÆ@CGÆ7*@(@C68@= 687C9 @gGÆ@~=&
X.B@~=#A9kA=5C9 BE@BE5gGÆDtHC>?A>O= ar5+>;H]# =?7CHC>O>" =HC>F#A@#9 >9 B ò5CD> >A@t=7C@
;9 68@~=DE689+1r7:>D> g7CBH:>
> =$DEB<=#9#HgGI@QDE>9 òBDEB>7H:>HC>A@ B=#H:BXWY#9 >A@~=?>&]XG
;
689+ >>A=QDGCB=?> >(HC>5:9 685gGIF~GI=?BE68@}HC>
A>
;9 68@~=< 68@~=bGÆD6Æ9;H# = GÆBEDD#A>"&
X>"A687C9?GI@t=HC>]FÆ9?G%rBE=#e 68@~=A68@ =?BE= 7#"OH(7:@
;9 68@~="
;
689+ /#ËH(7C@C>Q=kA=?>Q5CD7?#5gGÆB >81t7C>
DE>g7CBEHC>1t7CBQ 7CB=%&Yu687C9QHC>
;
GÆBE<CD>b@C6 )<C9 >QHC> Ë>Aa@:68DH"DE>"
;
6Æ9>6rB+1r7:>7 >"HC6 òB@C>A@~=
DE>"
;
689A>"OH:> g6Æ= = GÆ<:BDB=#;> =OBEDa G5+>A7·HC>e /#ADGÆ@CFÆ>\6 / ò>÷HgGÆ@`D>[G`HC>"`687:D#>OHC>bD G%8>
BEDD7 =?9+#> 7C9DG63gF87C9 > ) &+*&\IGÆBD689+1t7C>÷D>@:6 )<C9 >;HC> Ë>Aa@:68DH|GÆ7:F >A@~=?>ÆD>"pBE@ =?GÆ<CBEDBE=#"
GÆ5:5gGÆ9?GIB >@~=%&2E]GÆ@)DG9#AF8B68@c B=?7#A> HC>A9 9 B9 > DG=k =?>!BEDTa¨G7:@i BEDDGIF8>)=?7C9 <C7CDE>@~= G+ 6B#
HC>"BE@ =?GÆ<CBDEBE=#"]HC>$>D4rB@*) Db>D /:68DE=W5rB BE<CD>^ 7C9DG3CF87C9 > +*&
)
G"687ZHC>(BE@ =?GÆ<CBEDBE=#"
HC>DË68D )<6r>&Q>O>"òB@ = GÆ<CBEDB=#"5C9 6-rBE>@C@C>A@~= HC7mAB?GIBDDE>" ò>@~=D BE@~=?>9
;
G> >@~=?9 >}H:>7*@o òB4)
DEB>7@HC>HC>@ BE=#"HCBXWY#9 >@~=?>"&FX689+1t7C> DE>"> W+>A=(H# =?GÆ<CBDEB GÆ@~=$HC7cB GÆBDED> >A@t=6 68@~=(5CD7
G <
`
-/. / -3 +) ! ( )* ! ) !$ - ' '! ! )- '
, / ! !% "- ! - -' ). - ", . D
: -, '
S% &% ! , !/-+)
$ # #++ " !- !%
+& &GR= 7CHC>"Ë>A@5=#9 B ò>@~= GÆDE>";HC>[687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=#
B 5689 = GÆ@~=F1t7C>DE>"
;
6Æ9>HC>OF89?G%rBE=# D'B@~=?>A9
;
GA>`HC>ArB>@~=pBE@ =?GÆ<CDE>`> =HC68@:@C>DBE>7QHC>"H#
;
689V)
GI= B68@ = GI= B68@:@gGÆB9 >"÷HCB=?>"ËHC>A$>DrBE@*)VDË>D C68D=W!&X689+1t7C>DE>5:9 63gDHC>$rBE=?> >>" =QH#"GID#
5CGÆ99 GÆ5C5689 =GÆ7 5C9 6!3gD:HC>OHC>@ BE=#ÆD BE@ =?GÆ<CBEDBE=#.9 68B+?GÆ@~=?>OF#@A9 >;HC>A7*@(=?9?GIB@HC>=?687:9 <CBEDD6Æ@"
B 7QHC>(HC>7@68@:HC>"]H:>dDb6ÆD )<6>L1t7CBF >(5C9 685CGÆF8>@~=QHgGÆ@]H:>"QH:B9 >A= B68@<6Æ@t= 9?GÆBE9 >Q>A=61t7CB
5:9 6 rB>@:@C>@~=)H:>"$687_:>")DEB òBE=?>QHC>òHCBW"7 B68@-HC>ò5gGÆ9 =(> =H]GÆ7=?9 >òHC>òD'B@~=?>A9
;
GA> Y Db6ÆF8F5
MNÆ>a= + /J/JE
f&G>O>"ËHC>A7*@= ar5+>bH(68@CH:>"ËH#Æ>D6Æ5C5+>A@~=QHC>DG= 7C9 <:7CD>A@>$1t7CB>" =eD'689 BEF8B@:>QHC7
#DGÆ@CF8>QB ò5+689 = GÆ@~=÷GI7}@:B8>GÆ7}HC7
; 9 68@~=÷HC7687C9 GÆ@~=ËHC>F89?G%rBE=#&
EGÆ7:= 9 >` 689 = >"H(B@ = GÆ<CBEDB=#">A@B =?>A@t="~D6GÆDEB+#>"Q 7C9pDE>
;9 68@~=HC7687:9?GÆ@~=%ÆD>;H#
;
689 GÆ@~=
>A@g68@ =?B=?7gGÆ@~=÷HC>÷D68<>"> =<9 >AIG >" Y_68@CH:7CDGI= B68@OHC7
; 9 6Æ@t=[ 7C9;DG3CF87C9 > +&
)
< A&5X>7:9;689 BK)
FÆB@C>$@(>" =Ë5gG÷>@A689 >$6Æ@C@t7C>G%Æ>"5C9#B B68@)YI:%RpD GÆBE@C>
!
f&
XGdrBE=?> >H:>$5C9 685CGÆF~GI= B68@HC>^A>
;9 68@~=÷>" =÷H#"A9 B=?>$5gGÆ9[l`>@ , G òB@)Y
)H Z
A:5CGÆ97C@C>GÆ@CG )
D4a >·=#689 B1t7C>HC> g7:BHC> @C68@ rB1t7C>A7*@4>A=@:68@=?7C9 <C7CD>A@~=%HgGI@ D>G H(7C@o687C9 GÆ@~=HC>
FÆ9?G%rBE=#HgGÆ@7C@iGI@gGÆDO9 >" = GÆ@CFÆ7CDGÆBE9 >CC689 BWA68@~= GÆD Y nBEF&#+*&,+ A&2Rp@&D'GÆ< >@A>·HC>·9 6Æ= GI= B68@]DE>
A687C9 GÆ@~=`# =?>A@CHS 7C9p=?687:= >÷D G$DGÆ9 F8>7:9HC7GÆ@gGIDg>A=`G$7C@C>< =?9 7A= 7C9 >< ò6-aÆ>@C@:>Ë> >@~=?BE>DDE>" ò>@~=
<:BHCB >A@ BE68@C@C>ADD>!G%8>" 7:@ 68@~=?9 >A)N687C9 GÆ@~=$HgGÆ@$D> òBDEB>A7½G! )<CBGI@t="&]l`>@ , G òB@ Y )H Z
bGI5*)
5:DB1t7C>D>#"1t7gG =?B6Æ@HC>S68@~=?BE@t7CBE=#> = HC>l`>9 @:687CDDEBD> DE68@CF½HC>·D'B@~= >9
;
G!>ò>@~=?9 >·D>HC>A7*@
A687_C>H:> C7CBHC>"&.MÐD ò68@~=?9 >>@45gGÆ9 = BA7CDBE>91t7C>DE> >7:D#"6Æ7CD> >A@t= = GÆ<CDE> A68@ >9+IGÆ@~=
D #A@C>9 F8B>Q>" =[A>DE7CB(1t7CBb >$H#5CDG>G%8>7C@C>L#5gGIB >7C9
h = 1 2 H
C6H
> =ËDG9gGÆ7:= >7C9;=?6I= GÆDE>H:7 GÆ@gGID'&]:G/rBE= >" > >" =GÆD6Æ9
U = 2
√
g 0 h
6g 0 = g∆ρ/ρ
> =$DGF89 G%B=#(9#H:7CBE= >Y∆ρ
# = GÆ@~=÷DGHCBXWY#9 >@A>$HC>]HC>A@ B=#$>A@t= 9 >$DE>8687:9?GÆ@~=÷>A=D> g7:BHC>$G! )<CB GI@t="
g
DG!""#AD#A9?GI= B68@·H:>]DG 5>" GÆ@~=?>A7C9 ;>A=h
> =ËD'0#5CGÆB+ >7:9ËH:7:A689 5÷HC76Æ7C9?GÆ@~="&h
H ρ+∆ρ
ρ U
V
| : . ', ! ) ', )# )-, - ) ! ! ! . - !
IGIBHgGI@pD> #"A687CD> >A@~="IBD a G]F#A@#9 GÆD> >A@~=pHC>DGQHCB+ BE5gGI=?BE68@H]#A@C>9 F8B>!1t7C>[lO>@-, G )
òB@B@AD7:=OHgGÆ@OD'0#"1t7gGI= B68@·H:>^lO>9 @C687CDEDB>@ 7C5C56?GI@t=[1t7C>^A>A= =?>]HCB B5gGI= B68@>" =÷7C@CB
;
6Æ9 ò>
HCGÆ@÷D>^ òBDEB>7·G )<CBGÆ@~=%&MÐD= 9 687*8>GÆB@ B(1t7C>DGrBE= >"+ >HC7
; 9 68@~=÷>" =