• Aucun résultat trouvé

Les indicateurs du développement, entre information scientifique et normativité

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Les indicateurs du développement, entre information scientifique et normativité"

Copied!
5
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: halshs-00742686

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00742686

Submitted on 16 Oct 2012

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Les indicateurs du développement, entre information scientifique et normativité

Philippe Bourmaud

To cite this version:

Philippe Bourmaud. Les indicateurs du développement, entre information scientifique et normativité.

A contrario. Revue interdisciplinaire de sciences sociales, BSN Press 2011, pp.5-10. �halshs-00742686�

(2)

123456378912345678794 ABCDECADFF

ABC295D9E86BF7C2DF2DB4BB56

B567B29547869452CE9B5699FB2B6254786996

1234567849A249B45958C4D8459E2FCD45946958CB45 9424D696499B98FE4D5CD929 4B4F4D6 9 46 9 4 9 545 9 6CA2459 9 9 D54 9 D3 9 C4D 9 3C4D6 9 4D 9 C5D 9 32D 9 2C55D69 5846C8C5F49F2624B94598E48E42594D958C4D845958CB4595254864D69B45962459529B494B4F4D69 3649DF6C459469DD9B4C459529846649DF6CC6998499A2C9D9D9D59B49FD4929 4B4F4D69A249B45958C4D845958CB4594 4D69B429!"46942C59B4952BF!932D496293CC49 46 9 A24 9 B42 9 8C6CA24 9 9 B3 9 2 9 4B4F4D6 9 4564 9 4 9 24 9 F6E4 9 #45 9 86425 9 29 4B4F4D69D6926D69429255C9C69B98C6CA249CB CA2494984B2C78C9$%C569&''()9*B945649 A249B495846C8C5F4945958CBC56459294B4F4D695498F4D9+9CB9CF649498F4D49,9 8C5F4D69B9DF6CC69549B 49D59B4296CB9469489A24B5944659-255C9D2595FF457D259 4859D5984955C494984D4929B259.59B4955 4929DF6C9D59B325 49A2C94569C6949 B326CBB 49294B4F4D6

&

/D49459886C56CA245945962459529B494B4F4D694699C49498D5A24D849459 BC6CA245 9 4 9 4B4F4D6 9 5C4 9 D5 9 B4 9 4825 9 CD64D5C 9 9 2D4 9 F2B6CBC8C6 9 3CDC864259 CD64D6CD2 9 !C4D 9 B25 9 DF!42 9 A24 9 842 9 8FCB5 9 625 9 B45 9 D5 9 9 B 9 0DA24 9 1DCB49

$0DA2491DCB4923&&)9/D49C5D9295288.59459CDC8642592.59459864259CD64D6CD29 A2C98D4C4D69B38EC648624934D54F!B49459 FF459494B4F4D694569A249845926CB595D69 9 B9 D6C.49 4D649 B3CDF6C 9 469 B49 DF6C 9 29 54C849 32D49 4D64C549 A2C9 4569 9 CDC6CD9 6BB CA24 9 5 9 B4 9 4B4F4D6 9 456 9 524D6 9 C5 9 8FF4 9 56DD6F4 9 4 9 .59 5 9 46 9 DF6C49

$05649&'729+98)

958349295674334

9F6CC69A2345678499C499952849459DF4595C47674BB49D59B459. B459F4BB459469 82459CD56C626CDD4BB459B459B4259B25929FCD596 459469CD6CC5459B459CD6486CD59 4D64 9 CDCC259 9 :6 9 A23C4D67CB 9 45 9 DF45 9 A2D 9 4BB45 9 5D6 9 F2B45 9 2 9 4D6CD45 9 9 459 CD56D845 9 CD64D6CDB459 8FF4 9B9 0DA2491DCB4 9 B49 ; FF4 945 996CD57/DC45 9 29 B49

#4B4F4D69$;9/#)929B459!CBB425949D59CD64D6CD299 9/D498E54945695<49+9B3869 ECA2494D649B45984D6459498C5CD9A2C92C54D69459DF459CD64D6CDB459469B45964CD59 ,94BB45953BCA24D6984D69459C55DDD8459326D69B259 D459A249B459DF4595D69!56C645959 944FB49A2D6C66C459$=8E4F4CB99469:!4>4CD9233'9+92272?)

@466495C4949A2456CD594D94BB492D492649A2C9DF4D6B4F4D6945693CB C49A9767CB9 8D54D525 9 FC 9 B45 9 86425 9 2 9 4B4F4D6 9 A2D6 9 2 9 F4 9 54BD 9 B4A24B 9 B4 9 4B4F4D69 4C6 9 64 9 DF6C9 9 #4B4 9 456784 9 F2C 9 6D6 9 64 9 2D49 66C624 9 86C4 9 469 CD456C9D59B9BC56CD9459!"486C59294B4F4D699#49C69B495486429294B4F4D69

!554 9 45 9 5FF45 9 CF455CDDD645 9 D6 9 B3BB86CD 9 456 9 524D6 9 8DC6CDD4 9 2 9 454869 3!"486C5 9 469 49 DF45 9 469 4D 9 6CA24 9 9 45 9 B26CD5 9 C6459 4D 9 D86CD 9 3CDC86425 9 @459 4DC459534D64D69B5992D95656.F49498D6CD645

B264C59846649CDC6CD9549E4264992D492649+984BB49D7BC!B4954BD9BA24BB49B386CD9 2!BCA24 9 4C6 9 54 9 BCFC64 9 9 2DC 9 45 9 845 9 DF6C5 9 45 9 . B45 9 DB45 9 4D 9 BC55D6 9 B459 CDCC259469B459 245958C2953698DF499B9FDC.492984949B92649$C282B6923389+9

&(7)9B264C595C9B9CDC6CD9459DF4594549B94D849529459CDC864259B3B26CD9459

& @4955C499698D56C629D59B49BD 4F4D6932D945945949B4CD929 FF49-9%9D9BDFC949

4B4F4D69!CA24949B386CD92!BCA249D59B49FD49!499E9D69D69C696C49846CD5945926425949849

55C49$16CF9=7=!4CE9;ECBC4902F2)992594F48CD59B459DCF6425949849 FF4949B429

526C4D946949B42594D82 4F4D659D59D649B4CD9529B459CDC864259294B4F4D6

(3)

4FD8459459 FF459494B4F4D69D49C5A247674BB49599D242932C9B9C499 29CD 4D8459D59B459BC6CA2459B8B459469D6CDB4599@49D3456959B49FCD49 C49455929 8D54D5259D7BC!B949F5ECD 6D996C9459DD459&''3

4647836989323746979639292854

45 9 CDC86425 9 D4 9 8D56C624D6 9 5 9 4D 9 427FF45 9 45 9 DF45 9 FC5 9 45 9 F45245 9 @459 4DC.459424D696498D42459469FBC54594D9D86CD949B4259469CD646459D592D954D59 DF6C9+98345694D984954D59A234BB459D86CDD4D698FF4 91231456789A99FC59846649E4FD426CA249549 C56CD 24949B354869648EDCA24949B9F452494694598B6CD59!544594D649B459F452459

3CD6466CD9459CDC8642595469844DD693CD648494D649B3CDF6CD9A2D6C66C49469 B9CDC6CD94956D594693!"486C59A2C962C54D694D9BC6598D8.6459B3C49494B4F4D69 4596C8B459A2C98F54D6984955C49D6929CD5C6CD598FF2D459B49528C949FD6498FF4D69 2D49 F8DCA249 4B4F4D6BC5649534569B!4929 CB929 64F59 2629 459CDC86425 9469459 CDC8459 5

#D59B9B CA249294B4F4D69A2C94C4D69DD649D59B4594B6CD59D7529 489B4598BDC56CD59FC59A2C94569"94D982593B!6CD9D59B3:D647427 244592629 49B9=8C6945996CD59B9D6CD93!"486C9456984D6B49:BB49536C82B499626459B4598E4BB45929 4B4F4D6 9 42C5 9 B45 9 FF45 9 FDC2 9 D5 9 B4 9 84 9 45A24B5 9 5D6 9 B!45 9 B459 CC65 9 46 9 B45 9 8D8465 9 562862D65 9 C 9 B45 9 G9H 9 CD64D6CDB45 9 46 9 B45 9 BC6CA245 9 2!BCA2459

"25A2329FC87"4659B829D69B49CDD84F4D6945696C!26C4949B9252C64929FCD59F4BB49 498459FF459!"486C59 D29459!"486C59494B4F4D69C4D69496E.F45949B386CD9 2!BCA249CD64D6CDB49FC59CB594DD4D69 B4F4D692D49F49A2D6C66C49+95C698FF49!"486C59 8EC59CDC5996992D9CDC86429494D8495C698FF49CDBC69 DB4949B9F45249 -CD5C 9 B344FB4 9 4 9 B 9 F4524 9 4 9 B3CC6 9 4D 9 =6C4 9 $% 9 I2!46 9 46 9 1 9 =7=!4CE) 9 FD64 9 B459 45 9 4 9 B 9 8D846CD 9 3CDC86425 9 4D 9 D86CD 9 3!"486C5 9 5 9 C8C 9 B 9 B2664 9 8D64 9 B9 546CC86CD959D69B946CD4D8494D98D6464945692642549945C!CBC69459CDC86425949B9 F4524945945528459984BB4949B9D2C49CBB25649B3869A2C942694C56494D649459CD8C45949 F45249 B!B4F4D69CD8ED 59469459CD6466CD59B2862D645

5A23CB953 C693!"486C598EC59446594698C425964D4D699532649529459542CB59 A2C98D56C624D692D96BD9295288.59459 FF459459542CB59D495D6926D69594D9427FF459 45 9 DF45 9 9 D5 9 2D4 9 45486C4 9 4 9 8B554F4D6 9 45 9 DD45 9 3!546CD 9 CB5 9 4F4664D6 9 49 8BCC49B9C56C!26CD945952B66593!546CD9*B598D6C!24D69844DD6994D 4D4945944659 49BBC49469459D9645992469E94699B99C4D6494696D5F49B386CD92!BCA2499 B4CD9529B4598D5A24D8459459542CB59CD64D6CD29529B494B4F4D698DFCA2494FD649 29FCD59294FC45964F59459 DC56CD59CD64D6CDB459D59B3:D647427 24459+98FF49 D94269B49C9489B459!B.F459A249549B9CDC6CD932D98C6.49CD64D6CDB9298B492D49 CD 9 CFB24 9 D5 9 B45 9 DD45 9 &'23 9 B36CD 9 32D 9 542CB 9 2DC454B 9 C5A24 9 3C 9 459 48255CD5 9 8DFCA245 9 46 9 5DC6C45 9 F"4245 9 6 9 8FC5 9 4D 9 CDC5C!CBC5D6 9 B8B4F4D6 9 B9 54D84929B2C5F494694D94CDD69CD5C9B386CC69$;902F2)

=42CB59469!"486C59C4D6949F452459A2C94DC4D6992D9F.B49CD6466C9+9D98BB48649

45 9 F45245 9 2 9 B24 9 2D 9 EDF.D4 9 5C6 9 4D 9 B42 9 !5B24 9 5C6 9 9 8B6CD 9 48 9 2D9

CDC8642 9 454D66C 9 9 44FB4 9 B4 9 DF!4 9 4 9 645 9 B2FCD42545 9 8FF4 9 56F6JF4 9 29

B2C5F4949!B.F49A2C953456959D59B3EC56C49294B4F4D694569A23CB99BB2964D49

F55C4F4D6984598BB48645949F452459.59&'8K9294D B!49B49FD498BDCB92C59B459659

CD4DD659D59B459BC6CA2459494B4F4D699469A23CB9D369C69 DB4F4D695949DD459

4 9 !54 9 2 9 B45 9 8BDC45 9 4 9 8C6 9 4 9 B 9 8D56286CD 9 45 9 CDC86425 9 4 9 246 9 4D 9-CA249

G88C4D6B4 9 CD4C54 9 CBB2564 9 B45 9 8D5A24D845 9 4 9 84664 9 5C626CD 9 A2C 9 9 8D2C6 9 B45 9 4465 9 9

FDC2B4 9 B45 9 DD45 9 A23CB5 9 8B6C4D6 9 2 9 B45 9 4D4 9 B25C!B4 9 :2 9 9 9 B 9 6DFCA24 9 49

286CD9459CDC864259294B4F4D694693862BC56CD949B429F49498B82B9D94269549

4FD495C98496649496CA249D34D6F49592!B4F4D69B9C!CBC69459CDC864259492469

A2C 9 2 9 4564 9 5D6 9 DB4F4D6 9 8D6462BC55 9 $L 9 0DD4854) 9 45 9 CDC86425 9 FDA2D6 9 49

(4)

C!CBC694C4DD4D69459CD562F4D659494B6CD592!BCA24592954C849495C6CD59BC6CA245929 54CD9459CD56D8459CD64D6CDB459B26J69A24945926CB59A2D6C66C59456CD599F649B386CD9 2!BCA24

459CDC864259294B4F4D695D69524D698B55D6599B3CD569459542CB59A259B259 E26599469CB59B495D69326D69B259A249B459 DC56CD59CD64D6CDB45926CBC54D69459CDC8459D59 529B3 6CD949B25C4259CDC864259459CDC845964B59A249B49;2C69*D6C4290269$;*0)929 B3*DC84 9 4 9 #4B4F4D6 9 M2FCD 9 $*#M) 9 2C54D6 9 45 9 8B554F4D65 9 CD64D6CD2 9 846459 C4D659D59B429CDBC69$19233N9+92K&72K7)9:698495D6984598B554F4D659A2C99B49559D69 4D6OD94596CDFC4594D649D96594B59E9D96594D9C49494B4F4D69E9469D9659B459 FCD59D859E9CDC55D6984594DC4598FF49CC6C459D59B386CD929B494B4F4D69 FC594D96CA249B4598DCDD69D59B956686CC698DFCA249469B92BD!CBC6998D56286CD9 495257CDC84598FF49B459CDC8459 CD299B3CD6C42945965945694BB49255C98D42498FF492D9 F64D9298C!B49B386CD92!BCA2492954C84949PD459CC6C459@44DD69CD5C9A249B49FD49 B3DB6549296949233K9529B494B4F4D694D9IDC4946949B98D56286CD9459C45949 8B82B59459*#M9 CD29D59849849B4592C592!BC85964DD69953C49B98D56286CD9 459F45245929 FF49846CD459C5C6594F!55D64594698D649B4259459!"486C59 494B4F4D69$C94904B7-C)9-984664964DD849CB9269"2649A232D9CDC849 98FF49B3*#M9 54 9 9 B 9 C5 9 B 9 A2456CD 9 2 9 8EC 9 45 9 CDC86425 9 A24 9 B3D 9 . 4 9 46 9 4 9 B 9 D6CD 9 459 C4D645 9 8F5D645 9- 4 9 D5 9 B3*#M 9 2D4 9 F4524 9 4 9 B 9 C8E4554 9 8DFCA24 9 2D49 2649 4B6C4929DC4293286CD94692D496C5C.F4962C5D69B49DC4295DC6C49 DB983456945A249 C864929:66592929 CD59B49F64D93FBC49B4294FD849A2C66499D BC 49326459

!45CD5958C29DD9FCD594B59#CDC945984C8C4D659298B82B492D9CDC849834569255C9CDC9 459CC659B259E26459A24932645

@345692A2C9529B4964CD9B459CDCC259549624D69C59D59459CC6595245459 C494D8EQ55459+9D59B459PD45954FC7C45949B9=6C49B3E5CD9B25929FCD594D6E25C564929 CF4994598C6.459CD64D6CD2949B266498D649B9546CC86CD954962C6992D4988C69 C!B499D 8C49B326CBC56CD945942929B3CC 6CD946998D5A24D69B9C!CBC698DFCA249 498459 CD59:D9B38824D849B45965D5956C4D59D495D69595CFB4F4D69D592D98477849 48 9 B4 9 24D4F4D6 9 56C4D 9 262 9 32D 9 CDC8642 9 + 9 846 9 4D"42 9 C6 9 B4F4D6 9 CD644DC 9 G9H9 CD64D6CDB459469!CBB425949D59$%9I2!46946919=7=!4CE)

@45 9 C4D65 9 6C8B45 9 4D6 9 2649 2D9 DF9 459 25 45 9 459 CDC8459 D5 9 C4D659 5486425 9 2 9 4B4F4D6 9 $5D6 9 9 B2664 9 8D64 9 B 9 246 9 9 C82B624 9 46 9 B2664 9 8D64 9 B9 546CC86CD) 945 9BF4D65 934BC86CD 9529 849A2C9 549 "249D5 9B45 9CDC864259 +9459 DF459 CD64D6CDB459A2C9D495D69598D54D524BB459C5 9D7BC!B459469C59B259C486C459469 D59B9CDC6CD945A24BB459B49!694F4D6958C4D6CCA24953CDC649255C9B264C59CB9O69 A24 9 B4 9 8C6.4 9 4 9 58C4D6CC8C6 9 4564 9 8DCD 9 9 2D4 9 8FF2D26 9 34465 9 CD64D6CD2 9 46 9 A249 B325 4 9 45 9 CDC86425 9 D5 9 B45 9 2F5 9 CD64D6CD2 9 C54 9 52626 9 9 4 9 B 9 6286CD 9 32D9 8D54D52599FCDCF9529B459B425949B386CD929B494B4F4D6

%4D8459+

0-91/:91G9#*-:9$23&&)9BC9D3EF77DC726E231456C9AE9F5ECD 6D90*%#9R90DA249 1DCB4

0-=B:%99D869$&'72)9D9#44BF4D69CDC8659+9D9CD6286CD9E9CD90-=B:%99D869$)9 75A8912EF77DC726EE67E9CD7E523E537854ECE377DC726E1231456C9A9D459CDS9@559 9&723

CG/@-/B 9 1C8E4B 9 $2338) 951AA5247 E 37 E D5 E 1CCD16187 E !C89A E 58 E !CDD"7 E 37 E #95247$ E

%&'(%&%98BB9D9M26459:62459E9;C59HBBCF7=42CB

1:#-9#FCDCA249$233N)9)8(F7D*E38E+ E+C89E827E58697E7A897E37ED5E9147AA798BB9D9@EF59 8624B9E9;C59CBFFCD

%*=B9HCB!469$&''() 9,7EF-7DC7726 E.1A6C197E3/827E49C5247EC44137265D79;C59;45545949

=8C4D8459;

(5)

=@M:1:* 9 A45 9 46 9 :0:%F:*9 9 FB7#C464 9 $233') 9 D9*D6286CD 9 4 9 F656.4 9 49

B3DD8C6CD 9 + 9 DF45 9 46 9 DFBC6 9 4D 9 4B6CD5 9 CD64D6CDB459E 9 CD 9 =@M:1:* 9 A45 9 469

:0:%F:*99FB7#C4649$C)9C979ED7EC2379;C593MF66D9977(2

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to