HAL Id: hal-00452224
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00452224
Submitted on 1 Feb 2010
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Statistical analysis of extreme events in a nonstationary context via a Bayesian framework. Case study with
peak-over-threshold data
Benjamin Renard, M. Lang, P. Bois
To cite this version:
Benjamin Renard, M. Lang, P. Bois. Statistical analysis of extreme events in a nonstationary context via a Bayesian framework. Case study with peak-over-threshold data. Stochastic Environmental Re- search and Risk Assessment, Springer Verlag (Germany), 2006, 21 (2), p. 97 - p. 112. �10.1007/s00477- 006-0047-4�. �hal-00452224�
Author-produced version of the article published in Stochastic environmental research and risk assessment, 2006, 21 (2), 97-112.
The original publication is available at http://www.springerlink.com/
doi : 10.1007/s00477-006-0047-4
Statistical analysis of extreme events in a non- stationary context via a Bayesian framework. Case study with peak-over-threshold data.
! "# " $ %!# & $
!"!#$%&!' ( )*
+,-' ( *( * .
! /,0"'1!&,123 "4%&5!/,61!++1
' ( )* ' ( + ,
-!./0 $ %!# & $
Abstract
, 07 05,",&,"4707%+!- 1!/!75811!& "4,778/!7 $, 2, ,,107! +1%/ ,7 , 0%&,14#1%5!77 ,"$%86$785$,&
$4#% $!70707&% !,70"4,77!77,9"! ,&27$%8"2 $!1!+%1! 9! 5%&702!1!2,7,&8&5!1 ,0& 4 $! ,0/ %+ $07#,#!107
%2!75109! , ,4!70,& +1,/!:%1;+%1 $07#81#%7! 5%&702!10&67!<!1,"#1%9,90"07 05/%2!"7 7 , 0%&,14 7 !#
5$,&6! ,&2"0&!,1 1!&2/%2!"7 ,&2+%81!- 1!/! <,"8!7207 1098 0%&7 !-#%&!& 0,"6!&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 8/9!"
,&2 > 10%1 207 1098 0%&7 ,1! 7#!50+0!2 94 870&6 1!60%&,"#10%1;&%:"!26! ,9%8 ?8,& 0"!7 %7 !10%1 207 1098 0%&7,1! 87!2 %!7 0/, ! #,1,/! !17 ?8,& 0+4 $! #1%9,90"04%+/%2!"7,&22!10<! ,1!,"07 05+1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 :$05$ ,;!70& %,55%8& !7 0/, 0%& 207 1098 0%&,&27 , 0%&,1048&5!1 ,0& 0!7 /! $%27,1!
&!!2!2+%1 $07#81#%7! ,&2,1! 2!75109!20& $! ,1 05"! @0&,""4 ,& ,##"05, 0%& %, 2075$,16! 7!10!707
#1!7!& !2 :0$,&,&,"4707%+9% $%55811!&5! #1%5!77,&2#!,;207 1098 0%&
Keywords
,4!70,&,&,"4707A!- 1!/! !<!& 7A7 , 0%&,104A8&5!1 ,0& 0!7A5"0/, ! 5$,&6!A+1!?8!&54,&,"4707
1. Introduction
0&5! 8/9!"C7#1!5817%14:%1; 8/9!" D.* ,61!, &8/9!1%+/! $%27$,<! 9!!&
2!<!"%#!2 0& $! 7 , 07 057%+!- 1!/! !<!& 77 820!7 7!! E, = ! ," )) +%1, 1!5!&
1!<0!: /%&6 $!/ ,4!70,& ,&,"47071!5!& "4 1!5!0<!2 , !& 0%& $,&;7 % ,2<,&5!70&
5%/#8 , 0%&,",&2 &8/!105," %%"7 %"!7,&2 %:!"" DDFA %"!7,&2 ,:& DDFA %"!7 ,&2 !1055$0 )) A %"!7! ," )) A 0!9%" ! ," )) A ,1!& ,&2 !1&0!1 ))
& /%7 5,7!7 $!7! /! $%27 ,778/! $, 2, , ,1! 0&2!#!&2!& ,&2 7 , 0%&,14 :$05$
/!,&7 $, $! 7 , 07 05,"#1%#!1 0!7%+ $! 7 820!2#1%5!77,1! 0&<,10,& :0$1!7#!5 % 0/!
!<!1 $!"!77 $07,778/# 0%&7%/! 0/!7,##!,17<!142%89 +8"@%1!-,/#"! :0$2075$,16!7 7!10!7 5$,&6!70&",&287! 5,&/%20+4 $! +"%%27,&221%86$ 71!60/!7 %1! 6!&!1,""4 0&, 6"%9,"5"0/, ! 5$,&6! 5%& !- $421%/! !%1%"%605,"2, , 5%8"2 !-$090 1!&27 %1 7 !#
5$,&6!7 ,7 $,7 9!!& 2!/%&7 1, !2 +%16"%9," !/#!1, 81! ,7 ,& !-,/#"! )) 18#5=!:7;0! ," )) $!1!+%1! 2!10<!2 ,"0;!"0$%%29,7!2 ,##1%,5$ % /%2!" 1!&270&
$! 207 1098 0%&#,1,/! !17 0&5"820&6,510!10%&+%1 $! G9!7 H/%2!"5$%05! 8&2!1"05;,&2 81& )) 87!2 $! 7,/! ;0&2%+/! $%20&%12!1 %0&5"82! 2, ,+1%/ 7!<!1,"70!7,&2 %
!7 0/, ! ?8,& 0"!7+1%/ #%%"!2+1!?8!&54,&,"4707 &,"!1&, 0<! %+0& !1!7 :,7#1%#%7!294
!11!,8" ! ," ))),A )))9 94 ?8,& 0+40&6 $! #1%9,90"04 %+!,5$ /%2!"0& , ,4!70,&
+1,/!:%1; ,&2 5%/90&0&6 $!011!78"7:0$ ,##1%#10, ! :!06$ 0&67 & $07/,&&!1 /%2!"
5$%05! 8&5!1 ,0& 45,&9! ,;!&0& %,55%8& :$05$7!!/7 %9! ,<!14#1,6/, 05,##1%,5$,7 0 070/#%7709"! %<!10+4:$, $! G 18!H/%2!"07B ,&2!<!&0+785$,/%2!"!-07 7 %:!<!1
!11!,8" ! ," /,2! ,& ,778/# 0%& %+&%1/,"04 :$05$ #1!<!& 7 $07/! $%2%"%64 +1%/
9!0&6,##"0!2 %!- 1!/! !<!& 72, ,
$! ,0/ %+ $07,1 05"! 07 % 2!10<! , ,4!70,& +1,/!:%1; +%1!- 1!/! !<!& 7,&,"4707 9,7!2 %& , 5%/#,107%& %+/%2!"7 & 7!5 0%& :! 2!75109! $! 7855!770<! 7 !#7%+ $!
,4!70,& ,##1%,5$ $! #1%9,90"07 05 /%2!"7,&2 #10%1207 1098 0%&787!2 0& $07#,#!1,1!
2!75109!2 0& 7!5 0%&7 ,&2 ( ,1 058",1 , !& 0%& :0""9! #,02 % #,1,/! !1!7 0/, 0%&
2! !5 0%&%+5$,&6!7,&2+1!?8!&54,&,"4707 7!5 0%&. $! #,1 058",15,7! %+ $! !-#%&!& 0,"
207 1098 0%&+%1#!,;%<!1 $1!7$%"2 %10& !1,110<," 0/! 2, ,072075877!20&7!5 0%&F
@0&,""4 :! #1!7!& ,& ,##"05, 0%& % $421%"%605,"2, , :0$ !-#%&!& 0,",&2 6!&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 207 1098 0%&7 7!5 0%& 9!+%1! 21,:0&6 7%/! 5%&5"870%&7,&2 20758770&6 #% !& 0,"
0/#1%<!/!& 7 7!5 0%&*
2. An overview of the Bayesian approach
5%/#"! ! ,&2 2! ,0"!2 #1!7!& , 0%& %+ ,4!70,& ,&,"4707 ,&2 07 ,##"05, 0%&7 5,& 9!
+%8&20& !16!1 D*. %10& !"/,&! ," DD. @0681! I87 7$%:7 $! 6!&!1,"#10&50#"! %+
$! /! $%2 7,+017 7 !# #1%9,90"07 05/%2!"7+%1 $! 2, ,/87 9! 5$%7!& & $! 5%& !- %+
$! #% !& 0,"5$,&6!72!75109!2$!1! $!7! /%2!"75%&707 %+0&5"820&6 1!&27%17 !#5$,&6!7 0& $! 207 1098 0%&#,1,/! !17 0<!&,&0&2!#!&2!& %97!1<, 0%&7<!5 %1 0 07 $!&#%7709"!
% 5%/#8 ! $! "0;!"0$%%212 3 1!", 0&6 % !,5$ /%2!" ,7 07 878,""4 2%&! 0& /%1! 7 ,&2,12 ,##1%,5$!7 $! +8&2,/!& ," 20++!1!&5! %+ ,4!70,& ,&,"4707 5%&5!1&7 $! #,1,/! !17 <!5 %1
0 07 &% <0!:!2 ,7 ,& 8&;&%:& 98 5%&7 ,& ?8,& 0 4 :$05$ $,7 % 9! !7 0/, !2 98 ,7 , 1,&2%/ <!5 %1 :$%7! 207 1098 0%& 5,& 9! 5%/#8 !2 +1%/ %97!1<, 0%&7 @%1 $07 #81#%7! ,
#10%1 207 1098 0%& 07 ,778/!2 +%1 $07 207 1098 0%& 1!+"!5 7 $! #10%1 ;&%:"!26! ,9%8 $! #,1,/! !17 ,&2 /87 9! ,77!77!2 :0 $%8 870&6 $! %97!1<, 0%&7 & 7%/! 5,7!7 $! ",5;
%+0&+%1/, 0%& ,9%8 , #$!&%/!&%& "!,27 % $! 87! %+7% 5,""!2 &%& 0&+%1/, 0<! #10%17 J ! :%&C 5%&702!1 $07 #,1 058",1 5,7! 0& $07 #,#!1 $87 ,778/0&6 $, #10%1 0&+%1/, 0%& 07 ,<,0",9"! $%:!<!1 <,68! 0 /,4 9! $07 07 &% , 21,7 05 1!7 105 0%& ,7 !&<01%&/!& ,"
<,10,9"!7 5,& %+ !& 9! 5%&&!5 !2 :0 $ &% % ,""4 8&;&%:& #$4705," #1%5!77!7
0<!& $! "0;!"0$%%2 ,&2 $! #10%1207 1098 0%& ,4!7 $!%1!/ #1%<02!7 $! #,1,/! !17
#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&'
2 3 12 3
12 3
2 3 12 3 π
= π
$!#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&5,&9!<0!:!2,7,&8#2, 0&6%+ $!#10%10&+%1/, 0%&,9%8
$,&;7 % $!%97!1<, 0%&7 #1%<02!7,/%1!5%/#"! !!7 0/, 0%& $,& $!5",7705,"#%0&
!7 0/, !7 %:!<!1 ,77%%&,7 $!20/!&70%&%+ 9!5%/!7",16! $!87!%+ $07207 1098 0%&
07 &% "%&6!1 7 1,06$ +%1:,12 ,&2 7#!50+05 5%/#8 , 0%&,"/! $%27 ,1! &!!2!2 $! &!- 7!5 0%&72!75109! $!7855!770<!7 !#7 %,5$0!<!,5%/#"! !,&,"4707+1,/!:%1;
3. Models for extreme values analysis
,9"! 78//,10=!7 $!#1%9,90"042!&704+8&5 0%&7 #2+ 5%&702!1!20& $07#,#!1 $!7!
207 1098 0%&7 ,107! +1%/ $!%1! 05,"1!78"7 $87 ,##"40&6 % , :02! 1,&6! %+ 708, 0%&7 0&<%"<0&6 !- 1!/! <,"8!7 :% /,0& 7,/#"0&6 /! $%27 ,1! 5%&5!1&!2 @017 "4 $! 9"%5;
/,-0/8/ 5%&707 7 %+7!"!5 0&6 $! /,-0/8/ <,"8! :0$0& , 9"%5; %1/,""4 , %&! 4!,1 9"%5; 075$%7!& "!,20&6 % $!,&&8,"/,-0/, 7!10!7 !5%&2"4 #!,; %<!1 $1!7$%"2 2, ,5%&707 7%+7!"!5 0&6,"" $!!<!& 7!-5!!20&6,$06$ $1!7$%"2 7!! %79I!16,&2 ,27!& ))( +%1,&8# %2, !1!<0!: %+"0!1, 81! $!!- 1!/!<,"8! $!%1!/ @07$!1,&2 0##! D * 7$%:7 $, :$!& $! 9"%5; 70=! !&27 % 0&+0&04 $!"0/0 207 1098 0%& 0+0
!-07 7 %+ $! 9"%5; /,-0/8/ 7!10!7 5%/#8 !2 +1%/ <,10,9"!7 07 , > 207 1098 0%&
0/0",1"4 :$!& $! $1!7$%"2 <,"8!0&51!,7!7 $!"0/0 207 1098 0%& %+, 7!10!75,& 9!
,##1%-0/, !2 :0$ , !&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 207 1098 0%& 05;,&27 D . & 1!,":%1"2
#1%9"!/7 $!2, ,+1%/ :$05$ $!!- 1!/!<,10,9"!7,1!!- 1,5 !2 /,4 9! %% 5%/#"!- % /!! $!1!?801!/!& 7%+ $!,9%<! $!%1!/7 7,&!-,/#"! 2,0"42075$,16!7%11,0&+,""7,1!
&!0$!10&2!#!&2!& &%102!& 05,""4207 1098 !20&5,7!%+&%&7 , 0%&,104 %1!%<!1 $!9"%5;
70=! 07 878,""4 !?8," % F. 2,47 :$05$ /06$ 9! 0&78++050!& % ,##"4 $! ,74/# % 05 ,168/!& 7%+ $!%1!/7C#1%%+7 %:!<!1 $!7!207 1098 0%&7$,<!9!!&!- !&70<!"4,##"0!20&
7 820!7 0&<%"<0&6 !- 1!/! <,"8!7 !6 +"%%27 $!,<4 1,0&+,""7 :,<! $!06$ 7 ,&2 $,<!
2!/%&7 1, !2 $!0187!+8"&!770&/%7 $421%/! !%1%"%605,",##"05, 0%&7
%1!%<!1 0+, %077%%5!7707,778/!2+%1 $!%55811!&5!%+ 7 0 5,&9!7$%:& $, , %077%& K -#%&!& 0,"/%2!""!,27 % , 8/9!"207 1098 0%& +%1 $! ,&&8,"/,-0/, :$!1!,7 %077%& K !&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 70/0",1"4 "!,27 % $! > 207 1098 0%& ,&6 ! ,"
DDD @0&,""4 $! 0& !1,110<,"7 0/! 9! :!!& :% !<!& 7 5,& 9! /%2!""!2 :0$ , %&!
#,1,/! !1!-#%&!& 0,"207 1098 0%& :$!& , %077%& #1%5!7707,778/!2 +%1 $! %55811!&5!7 ,&6 DDD
J 0$%81&% , 0%&75 07 $! $1!7$%"2<,"8! :$05$0778##%7!2 %9!;&%:& ,&26 7,&28 ,1! $! "%5, 0%& 75,"! ,&2 7$,#! #,1,/! !17 $! :%#,1,/! !1207 1098 0%&7 -#%&!& 0,"
,&2 8/9!" 5,& 9!5%&702!1!2 ,7"0/00&6 5,7!7%+ $!5%11!7#%&20&6 $1!!#,1,/! !1%&!7
!&!1,"0=!2 ,1! %,&2 > :$!&8 )
& %12!1 % ,;!0& % ,55%8& &%&7 , 0%&,142, , ,7 !# 5$,&6!%1,"0&!,1 1!&2 5,&9!
,778/!2 +%1 $!#,1,/! !17 ,7+%1/,"0=!2 0& ,9"! 2!&% !7 0/! 0& ,20751! ! %1 5%& 0&8%87 :,4 % 05! $, $!7$,#!#,1,/! !18 07,":,47,778/!2 % 9!5%&7 ,&
,"$%86$ $!7,/!;0&2%+5$,&6!75%8"2 $!%1! 05,""49!/%2!""!2 9!5,87!%+ $!20++058"4
%+#1!507!"4!7 0/, 0&6 $07#,1,/! !1 %1!%<!1 % $!1;0&27%+5$,&6!75%8"29!/%2!""!2 785$ ,7 , "0&!,1 1!&2 %& $! "%6 1,&7+%1/!2 75,"! #,1,/! !1 E, = ! ," )) &%&
70/8",&!%877 !#5$,&6!70& $!"%5, 0%&,&2 $!75,"!#,1,/! !17 /8"0#"!7 !#5$,&6!7%1
#%"4&%/0," 1!&27 "$%86$ $!/! $%2%"%64#1!7!& !2$!1!5,& ,;!0& %,55%8& 785$;0&2
%+/%2!"7 0 ,":,47$,7 %9!;!# 0&/0&2 $, 5%/#"!-/%2!"75,&0/#1%<! $!2!7510# 0%&
%+,#$!&%/!&%& 98 5,& 21,/, 05,""42!51!,7! $!,5581,54%+ $!!7 0/, 0%&7%10&51!,7!
$!&8/!105,"20++058"0!7
@0&,""4 +%1!,5$%+ $! /%2!"7#1!7!& !20& ,9"! $!"0;!"0$%%2%+,&%97!1<!2<!5 %1 9 2%/: %35,&9!5%/#8 !2,7+%""%:7'
L L
1 1 %
=
=
∏
4. Specifying priors
50!& 07 7 878,""4 $,<! % !7 0/, ! 7%/! !&<01%&/!& ,"5$,1,5 !107 057 , %&! 70! %+
0& !1!7 :0$%8 ,&4 2, , 9!0&6 ,<,0",9"! , $07 #,1 058",1 "%5, 0%& ,&2,12 7 , 07 05,"
,&,"470707 $!& 0/#%7709"! ,&2 ,"!1&, 0<! /! $%27$,<! 9!!& 2!<!"%#!2 +%1 $07#81#%7!
!60%&,"0=, 0%& 5,& $87 9! 87!2 % 1,&7+!1 ;&%:"!26! +1%/ 6,86!2 % 8&6,86!2 70!7 DDFAM,<!""! ! ," )) A ,27!& ! ," )) /%1! #$4705,",##1%,5$
5%&707 7%+2!2850&6 7%/!!7 0/, !7+1%/ 8&2!1"40&6 #$4705,"#1%5!77!7 7,& !-,/#"! 0&
$! $421%"%64 +0!"2 , ",16! &8/9!1%+/! $%27$,<! 9!!& 87!2 % 1!", ! 7 1!,/ +"%: %
!-#",&, %14<,10,9"!7 785$,71,0&+,"" %#%61,#$4%+ $!:, !17$!2 7%0"#1%#!1 0!7 ! 5 7!!
!!2 DDD +%1,&!-,/#"!0& E
J $!&7#!50+40&6#10%17 $!708, 0%&07 $!7,/! ,72, ,/87 &% 9!87!2, $077 !# $!
&%&!-$,87 0<!,9%<!"07 %+!-,/#"!77$%:7 $, 1!60%&,";&%:"!26!07%+!&,<,0",9"! 85$
0&+%1/, 0%&I87 $,7 %9! 1,&7+!11!2 % $!#1%9,90"07 05/%2!"#,1,/! !17 &!- 1!/!<,"8!7 ,&,"4707 ,<,10,9"!%+5811!& 5%&5!1&07 $!1 ?8,& 0"! 1 $, 07 $!<,"8!:$05$07!-5!!2!2 :0$ #1%9,90"042/ 13 %"!7,&2 ,:& DDF $87#1%#%7!2 ,/! $%2 +%1#1%2850&6 #10%1 207 1098 0%&7+1%/ $!7!?8,& 0"!7 ! 12%; 3 9!%&!%+ $!7 , 0%&,14#2+ /%2!"7<! :0$ 20/!&70%&= ∈ = ! 1 < < 1= ,&2
1 < < 1=9! $! 5%11!7#%&20&6 ?8,& 0"!7 :$05$ 5,& 9! !-#1!77!2 ,7 ,&21 +8&5 0%&7 7 ,& !-,/#"! :0 $ $! <)!-# /%2!"
"%6
1 = −σ λ −1 7,&, 81,"%12!1!-07 79! :!!&
1 1= $87"!,20&6 %7 1%&6"4
&%&0&2!#!&2!& <,"8!7 #10%1#1%285 0%&072%&! 870&6 $! +%""%:0&6/%20+0!2?8,& 0"!7'
= =
1 1 1 = 1 1 −
= = − = −
! 02 ; 39! $! #2+%+,6,//,207 1098 0%&:0 $#,1,/! !17 ,&2 '
{ })
L
0 = − − >
Γ (
:$!1! N 2!&% !7 $! 6,//,+8&5 0%& ,&2 Ω2 3 07 $! 0&205, %1+8&5 0%& %+ $! Ω 7!
0+ ) % $!1:07!
Ω = ∈Ω $! = = ,1! 78##%7!2 % +%""%: 0&2!#!&2!& 6,//, 207 1098 0%&7'
L L
= 0 0 = = =
π = .
$! 6,//, 207 1098 0%& 07 87!2 9!5,87! %+ 0 7 +"!-090"0 4 98 ," !1&, 0<! 5$%05!7 ,1!
#%7709"! $! $4#% $!707%+0&2!#!&2!&5! 0787!2 $!1! +%15%&<!&0!&5! !<!1 $!"!77 $0707
&% ,21,7 051!7 105 0%& ,7 $! I%0& #10%1207 1098 0%&/87 1!+"!5 20++87! ;&%:"!26! :$05$
:0""9! 8#2, !2 0& $! +%""%:0&6 7 !# %1!%<!1 7 185 81,"2!#!&2!&5! 9! :!!&#,1,/! !17 :0"" 9! #1!7!1<!2 :$!& 1,&7+!110&6 #10%1 ;&%:"!26! +1%/ $! ?8,& 0"!7 7#,5! % $!
#,1,/! !177#,5!
$! #10%1207 1098 0%&07+0&,""45%/#8 !2 941!#",50&6 $! 94 $!01!-#1!770%&0& !1/7
%+ ,&2/8" 0#"40&694 $! M,5%90,&%+ $! 1,&7+%1/, 0%& = ' L = L= = L L
0 0
π = F
:$!1! 07 $! M,5%90,& /, 10- %+ $! ,9%<! 1,&7+%1/, 0%& ,&2 $! 5%8#"!72 3 ,1!
5,""!2 $! $4#!1#,1,/! !17 %+ $! /%2!" :$05$ $,<! % 9! +0-!2 , , #,1 058",1 <,"8!
1!+"!5 0&6 $! #10%1;&%:"!26! ,9%8 $! /%20+0!2?8,& 0"!7 = = ,9"!7 ,,&2 97$%:
$! 12 3 /, $!/, 05,"!-#1!770%&70& !,5$ /%2!"<! </ ,&2< ,&2 $! 5%11!7#%&20&6 M,5%90,&/, 10-!7 $! 2! !1/0&,& 7%+ $!7! /, 10-!75,&9! 5%/#8 !2&8/!105,""4:0 $,&4 /, $!/, 05,"7%+ :,1!
& $! 5,7! %+,7 , 0%&,14/%2!"<! #10%17#!50+05, 0%& 07 $871!", !2 % , /%7 $1!!
/%20+0!2 ?8,& 0"!7 10%17#!50+05, 0%& 5,&9! ,5$0!<!2 0& $! 7,/! /,&&!1:0 $
&%&7 , 0%&,14/%2!"7</ ,&2< 2!7#0 ! ,&0&51!,7! 0& $! 20/!&70%& & $! 7 !#5$,&6!
/%2!"</ ,20751! ! 207 1098 0%&O2τ3 $,7 %9! ,778/!2+%1 $! 5$,&6! #%0& τ 8&0+%1/ %&
/ : / +%10&7 ,&5! ! 9! ,& 0& !6!1785$ ,7 ≤ <= 10%17#!50+05, 0%&7 ,1! $!
+%""%:0&6'
!+%1! 5$,&6! +%""%: 0&2!#!&2!& 6,//,207 1098 0%&7 + !15$,&6! = +%""%: 0&2!#!&2!& 6,//,207 1098 0%&7
=
= −
778/0&60&2!#!&2!&5! 9! :!!& $! 5$,&6! #%0& τ,&2 $! #10%1207 1098 0%&07 $!&'
L L
L = L= = L L
0 0
0 0
π
− − − π τ
=
×
+&%#10%1;&%:"!26! ,9%8 $! !-07 !&5! %+,5$,&6! 07,<,0",9"! $! 7,/! 7#!50+05, 0%&7 +%1?8,& 0"!7:0 $7,/! #1%9,90"0 49!+%1! ,&2,+ !15$,&6! 5,&9! 5$%7!&'
/0& =
= ∀ = − *
+, 1!&2 07,778/!2 0& $! #,1,/! !17 < "! /> 9! :% 0/! #%0& 7 ,&2 ≤ <= 10%17#!50+05, 0%&7,1! $!&'
+%""%: 0&2!#!&2!& 6,//,207 1098 0%&7 +%""%: 0&2!#!&2!& 6,//,207 1098 0%&7
=
=
= −
=
=
$! #10%1207 1098 0%&5,& $879! :10 !&'
L L
L = L= = L L
0 0
0 0
π
− − −
=
×
D 7#1!<0%87"4 !-#",0&!2 0& $! </ 5,7! !?8, 0%& * 5,& 9! 87!2 % 5%/#"! ! $! #10%1 7#!50+05, 0%&7
",7 $! ,##1%,5$ #1%#%7!2 94 %"!7,&2 ,:& DDF :,7!-#%7!2 $!1! 9!5,87!
1!60%&,"%1!/#0105,";&%:"!26! 07%+ !& !-#1!77!2 0& !1/7%+?8,& 0"!7<,"8!7 1, $!1 $,&
#,1,/! !17<,"8!7 %:!<!1 ," !1&, 0<! #10%1207 1098 0%&75,& 9! 87!2 :0 $%8 ,220 0%&,"
20++058" 0!7:0 $0& $! #1!7!& !2+1,/!:%1;
5. Computations on posterior distributions
$! /! $%272!75109!20&7!5 0%&7 ,&2(,""%: ,4!7 $!%1!/ %9! 87!2 %5%/#8 ! $!
#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&12 ; 3 %:!<!1 $! 0& !61,"%+ $! 2!&%/0&, %1%+!?8, 0%& 07 6!&!1,""40& 1,5 ,9"! 12 ; 307 $87%&"4;&%:&8# %,5%&7 ,& %+#1%#%1 0%&,"0 4'
L L
1 ∝ 1 π )
%1!%<!1 $! $06$ 20/!&70%&,"0 4 %+12 ; 3 /,;!7 $07 +8&5 0%& 20++058" % $,&2"! 0&
#1,5 05! !- 7!5 0%&7#1!7!& 7%/! /! $%27 %%<!15%/! $0721,:9,5; !,2!170& !1!7 !2 0&+81 $!1!-#"%1, 0%&%+#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&7 $,& $%7! 2!75109!29!"%: 5,&1!+!1 % ,&&!1
DDF
5.1. Parameters estimation via marginal densities
$!12 ; 3 ? /,160&,"072!+0&!294'
L L
? = ? ? =
1θ = 1θ θ θ θ − θ + θ
&5! ,6,0& $070& !61, 0%& 07%+ !&0& 1,5 ,9"! % ,&,"4 05,"!-#1!770%&%+ $! #%7 !10%1 /,160&,"07 $!& ,<,0",9"! & ," !1&, 0<! 07 % 70/8", ! , 7,/#"! +1%/ $! I%0& #%7 !10%1 207 1098 0%&12 ; 3 :%/,0&/! $%275,&9! 87!2+%1 $07#81#%7!' $! ! 1%#%"07 ,7 0&67 ,"6%10 $/ ! 1%#%"07 ,&2 ",/ D(DA ! 1%#%"07 ! ," D. A ,7 0&67 D ) ,&2 $!
610224 0997 7,/#"0&6 0 !1 ,&2 ,&&!1 DD $! ", !1 07 5%&5!# 8,""4 !,70!1 % 8&2!17 ,&2 ,&2 07 $87#1!7!& !2 0& 2! ,0"0& &&!- ," $%86$ $! +%1/!1/! $%2 /,49!
/%1! !++050!& 0&7%/! 70 8, 0%&7
0<!& , 7,/#"! %+@ <!5 %17 = @ = θ θ= = @ , 7,/#"! +1%/ $! ? /,160&,"07 70/#"4 %9 ,0&!2 94 5%&702!10&6 θ? = @ 7 0/, 0%& 5,& $!& 9! /,2! 94 /!,&7 %+ $07 7,/#"!' $! /!,& %1 $! /!20,& 60<!7 , #%0& !7 0/, ! ,&2 , 5%&+02!&5!
0& !1<,"5,&9! 5,"58", !2945%/#8 0&6"%:!1,&28##!1!/#0105,"?8,& 0"!7 % 05! $, $!
<,"8!7 θ? = @ ,1! &% 0&2!#!&2!& ,",16! 7,/#"! 70=! 07 $871!?801!2 %,<%02,&490,7 28! %,8 %5%11!", 0%& 7!&70 0<0 4,&,"47075%8"29! &!5!77,14 %2! !1/0&! ,510 05,"7,/#"! 70=! ,9%<! :$05$!7 0/, !77 ,47 ,9"!
5.2. Detection of changes
J ! ,##"0!2 $! /! $%2%"%642!75109!294 !11!,8" , ," )))9 9,7!2%& ,4!7+,5 %17 E,77 ,&2 ,+ !14 DD. % 2! !5 5$,&6!7 0& !&<01%&/!& ,"7!10!7 ! 87 2!+0&! $!
/,160&,"207 1098 0%&%+ ,7+%""%:'
L L
1 < = 1 <
70/#"! 5,"58", 0%&7$%:7 $, 12 ;<3 07 $! 2!&%/0&, %1%+ $! ,4!7 $!%1!/ ,##"0!2 %,#,1 058",1/%2!"<'
L L L
1 < = 1 < π <
77 , !2 #1!<0%87"4 $07?8,& 0 45,& 6!&!1,""4&% 9! !-#"050 "45%/#8 !2 $09 DD.
#1%#%7!2 , 70/#"! /! $%2 +%1 !7 0/, 0&6 $! /,160&,"207 1098 0%& %+ 9,7!2 %& 610224 0997 7,/#"0&6 2! ,0"!2 2!7510# 0%& %+ $07 ,##1%,5$ 07 /,2! 0& &&!- !
{
< <}
$Ω = = Ω ∪ Ω :$!1! $! !-#%&!& $ 2!&% !7 $! 5%/#"!/!& %+,7! 9! ,
#,1 0 0%& %+ $! 5%""!5 0%& %+ /%2!"7 5%&702!1!2 7 ,& !-,/#"!
{
<)!-# <!-# <!-#<)1 < 1 < 1} {
<)!-# <)1} {
<!-#< 1 <!-# < 1}
Ω = = ∪ 5%8"2 9!
,#,1 0 0%& +%1 2, ,/%2!"7 %1! 6!&!1,""4 $! #,1 0 0%&Ω ∪ Ω$ 5,& ,;! $! +%1/
G7 , 0%&,14 <7 &%& 7 , 0%&,14 /%2!"7H %1 G #,1,/! !17 <7 #,1,/! !17 /%2!"7H 778/! $, O 07 , #10%1 #1%9,90"0 4 207 1098 0%& %&Ω $! #%7 !10%1 #1%9,90"0 4 %+, /%2!"<?5,& $!& 9!
5%/#8 !2 :0 $ $! ,4!7 $!%1!/'
L L
L
? ?
?
1 < <
1 <
1 < <
π π
=
= (
$! ,4!7 +,5 %1 9! :!!& /%2!"7< ,&2<?07 $!& 2!+0&!2 94' L
L
L L
?
? ? ?
1 <
1 < <
+ 1 < < 1 <
π
= π = .
5%/#%70 ! ,4!7 +,5 %1 9! :!!& Ω ! Ω$ 5,& ,"7% 9! 5%/#8 !2' L
$ L
$ $
< <
< <
1 < <
+ 1 < <
π π
∈Ω ∈Ω
Ω Ω
∈Ω ∈Ω
= F
$! ,4!7 +,5 %1 #1%<02!7 , /!,781!/!& %+ $! #!1 0&!&5! %+, $4#% $!707 5%/#,1!2 % ,&% $!1 5,& $87 9! 5%/#,1!2 % 5",7705," "0;!"0$%%2 1, 0%7 %:!<!1 /%2!" "0;!"0$%%2 07
&% 5%/#8 !2 94 1!#",50&6 $! #,1,/! !17 94 $!01 !7 0/, !7 98 94 0& !61, 0&6 %& $!
#10%1 207 1098 0%& %1! 6!&!1,""4 $07 ,##1%,5$ 07 &% , 5",7705," !7 #1%5!281! $! ,4!7 +,5 %1 <,"8! 2!#!&27 %& #10%1 7#!50+05, 0%&7 0& ,220 0%& % 7,/#"0&6<,10,&5! $87 0 5,&&%
9! 0& !1#1! !2 ,7 , 107; 0& !1/7 %+"0/0 !11%1 #!15!& ,6! :$!& 1!7,/#"0&6 70=! !&27 % 0&+0&0 4 98 1, $!1 0& !1/7 %+ , +,"7! 2!5070%& 5%7 7!! !11!,8" ))) +%1 +81 $!1
!-#",&, 0%&7 ",7705,""4 $! :% !11%1 4#!7 ,1! ,778/!2 % $,<! $! 7,/! 5%7 $! ,4!7 +,5 %1 07 $!& 5%/#,1!2 % :0 $ 61!, !1 5!1 ,0& 4 +%1 $06$ %1 &!,1 =!1% <,"8!7 E,77 ,&2
,+ !14 DD.
5.3. Frequency analysis.
!5 0%& . #1%<02!7 , :,4 %+70/8", 0&6, 7,/#"! +%1 $!12; 3 207 1098 0%& :$05$ 1!", !7 % !7 0/, 0%& 8&5!1 ,0& 4 !5 0%& . 2!75109!7 $! 5%/#8 0&6%+#%7 !10%1 #1%9,90"0 0!7 %+ $!
/%2!"7',7 , 5%""!5 0%& %+/%2!"7 5,&&% 9! 5%&702!1!2 % ,""4 !-$,87 0<! , #,1 %+ $!
/%2!""0&6 8&5!1 ,0& 4 07 $87 5%& 1%""!2 $!7! :% ;0&27 %+8&5!1 ,0& 4 5,& 9! ,;!& 0& % ,55%8& 0& +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 94 $! +%""%:0&6#1%5!281!'
!#!, @ 0/!7'
,&2%/ 5$%05! %+ , /%2!"<A :0 $ #1%9,90"0 0!712</; 3: 12<=; 3 ,&2%/ 5$%05! %+ , #,1,/! !1<!5 %1 +1%/ $! 7,/#"! %+12 <A3
%/#8 , 0%& %+ 123 $!1 ?8,& 0"! 0& /%2!"<A:0 $ #,1,/! !1 , 0/!
$! ?8,& 0"!75%""!5 0%& %9 ,0&!2 5,& 9! 5%&702!1!2 ,7, 7,/#"! %+ $! ?8,& 0"! 207 1098 0%&
, 0/! 0&5"820&6 !7 0/, 0%& ,&2 /%2!""0&6 8&5!1 ,0& 0!7 5,& $879! 87!2 % #1%<02! ,
#%0& !7 0/, ! , 5%&+02!&5! 0& !1<," %1 !<!& , 207 1098 0%& !7 0/, ! +%1 123 + 2, ,
7 , 0%&,104 07 ?8!7 0%&,9"! $! +8&5 0%& 1 #1%<02!7 , 2!7510# 0%& %+ $! #%7709"! 5$,&6!0& !1/7%+?8,& 0"!210+ :0$ 0/!
6. A particular case: the exponential distribution
# % $07 #%0& $! /! $%27 87!2 0& $07 #,#!1$,<! 9!!& 2!75109!2 ,7 6!&!1,""4 ,7
#%7709"! $!+1,/!:%1;07 $877 0"",##"05,9"!:0$% $!1/%2!"7 !<!1 $!"!77 207 1098 0%&7 9!"%&60&6 % $!!-#%&!& 0,"+,/0"4 5,& 9! 1!, !2 0& ,70/#"!1:,4 :0$ ,&,"4 05,"1!78"7 9!0&6 ,<,0",9"! :0$%8 870&6 /! $%27 & $! &!- 7!5 0%&7 #%7 !10%1 /,160&,"
207 1098 0%&7 ,&2 $! /,160&,"207 1098 0%& %+%97!1<, 0%&7 ,1! 5%/#8 !2 +%1 !-#%&!& 0,"
/%2!"7 "!,20&6 % 7897 ,& 0,"70/#"0+05, 0%&7 % 05! $, ,1!& ,&2 !1&0!1 )) ,"7%
7855!!2!2 0& 2!10<0&6 , +1!!/! $%2 0& $!5,7!%+,7 , 0%&,14 6!&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 207 1098 0%&
6.1. Stationary model
$!"0;!"0$%%2+%1<)!-#/%2!"07'
L L !-#
1 1 % σ
λ λ
=
=
∏
= − −>0!:!2 ,7 , +8&5 0%& %+λ $07 "0;!"0$%%2 07 #1%#%1 0%&," % ,& 0&<!17! 6,//, #2+
B02 ; 3'
{ })
L !-#
B0 = + − >
Γ *
$07#,1 058",10407;&%:&,7 $!5%&I86,54#1%#!1 4 $87 0+O2λ3 0778##%7!2 %+%""%:
,&0&<!17!6,//,207 1098 0%&:0$#,1,/! !17 ,&2 $!#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&%+λ07'
L L
!-#
1 λ π λ 1 λ
σ λ λ
λ
+ +
∝
+ −
= −
Γ
=
D
# % #1%#%1 0%&,"04 λ #%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&077 0"",&0&<!17!6,//,207 1098 0%& :0$ 8#2, !2#,1,/! !17'
σ
′ = +
′ = + − )
$!/,160&,"207 1098 0%&%+%97!1<, 0%&707+0&,""470/#"4%9 ,0&!2940& !61, 0&62λ3'
!-#
L )
!-#
1 < λ λ
λ λ λ ′+
′
=
= − ′
Γ Γ ′
= Γ ′
6.2. Step change model
@%""%:0&6 $! ,9"! &% , 0%&7 $!<!-# "0;!"0$%%207'
L !-# % !-# %
1
τ τ τ
τ
σ σ
λ λ λ λ
−
= = +
− −
= − −
@%1 +0-!2 τ $! "0;!"0$%%2 07 #1%#%1 0%&," % $! #1%285 %+ :% 0&<!17! 6,//, 207 1098 0%&7 778/0&6 0&2!#!&2!&5! 9! :!!& $! 5$,&6! #%0& ,&2λ <,"8!7 $! #10%1 207 1098 0%&07'
L L
B0 B0
π = λ λ π τ
:$!1!O2τ3 07,&420751! !207 1098 0%&%& &5!,6,0& ,70/#"!5,"58", 0%&7$%:7
$, +%1,+0-!2τ $!#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&077 0""#1%#%1 0%&," %,#1%285 %+0&<!17!6,//, 2!&700!7'
L L L L
L L
1 B0 B0 1
B0 B0
λ λ π τ
λ λ π τ
λ λ τ
∝
′ ′ ′ ′
=Γ Γ
=
(
:0$'
%
%
τ
τ
τ τ
σ σ
=
= +
′ = +
′ = + −
′ = + −
′ = + −
.
$!/,160&,"#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&5,&201!5 "49!5%/#8 !2940& !61, 0%&+1%/ $!I%0&
#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&'
L
L
!-#
L 1
1
1
τ
τ
τ λ λ τ λ λ
π τ
λ λ λ τ λ τ
π τ λ λ
λ λ λ τ λ τ
π τ λ
′ ′
− ′ +
= ′
− ′ +
= ′
∝
′ ′
Γ Γ
∝ ′ ′
∝
′ ′
∝ Γ −
′
∝ Γ ′
∝ ′ !-#
λ
− ′
F
@0&,""4 $!/,160&,"207 1098 0%&%+%97!1<, 0%&707' L !-#
1 <
τ
λ λ τ λ λ τ
− π τ
′ ′
=
=
′ ′
Γ Γ
= Γ Γ ′ ′
6.3. Trend model
$!"0;!"0$%%25,&9!:10!&,7'
) )
L !-# %
1 σ
λ = λ λ = λ
= − −
+ +
∏
*@%1+0-!2λ/ $07"0;!"0$%%2 <0!:!2 ,7,λ! +8&5 0%&07#1%#%1 0%&," % ,&0&<!17!6,//,
#2+ &+%1 8&, !"4 &%5%&I86,54#1%#!1 4,##!,17+%1 $!λ/#,1,/! !1 &4#10%1207 1098 0%&
5,& $879!5$%7!& +%1λ/ +%10&7 ,&5!,&%1/,"207 1098 0%& :0$#,1,/! !17 ,&2 $!
I%0& #10%1207 1098 0%&07 $!&'
) L L
B0 @
π = λ λ D
"!,20&6 % $!+%""%:0&6#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&'
) )
)
L
!-#
1 1
% π
σ λ
λ π λ λ λ
λ λ
+ +
=
=
∝
− −
= − + −
Γ + +
=
∏
)$! +8&5 0%& 5,& 9! !-#"050"4 0& !61, !2 :0$ 1!7#!5 %λ! $8760<0&6 $! /,160&,"
#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&%+λ/'
) )
L
!-#
1
%
λ λ λ λ
λ λ
σ π λ λ
+ =
=
∝
Γ + −
= −
Γ + − +
+
=
∏
$!/,160&,"#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&%+λ! ,&2 $!/,160&,"207 1098 0%&%+%97!1<, 0%&75,&
9!5%/#8 !294 &8/!105,"0& !61, 0%&'
) )
!-#
) )
L L 1 1 <
λ λ λ λ
λ λ λ λ λ λ
∝
=
=
7. Application
$! ,4!70,&/! $%2:,7,##"0!2 %,7 1!,/ +"%: 7!10!7+1%/ $! 1P/!10<!1, 85!&
0%07 D(;/ %8 $ ,7 %+@1,&5! ,0"47 1!,/ +"%:7:!1!,<,0",9"!9! :!!& $!4!,17 D) ,&2 )) J ! !- 1,5 !2 , 7!10!7%+0&2!#!&2!& #!,;7,9%<! , / 7 $1!7$%"2
"!,20&6 %,7,/#"!%+D <,"8!7 <!1 $1!7$%"2<,"8!7,&20& !1,110<,"77!10!7:!1!7 820!2 +0681! $!+%1/!1:,77 820!2:0$ $!70-/%2!"7<)!-# <!-# <!-#<)1 < 1 ,&2< 1
$!", !1:0$<)!-# <!-#,&2<!-#
7.1. Prior specification
$!+017 7 !#5%&707 !2%+7#!50+40&6,20751! !#10%1207 1098 0%&%& $!/%2!"75%""!5 0%&
:!5%&702!1!2 &%12!1 %,<%02,&490,70& $!$4#% $!707:!:07$!2 %!<,"8, ! 7 , 0%&,14
&%&7 , 0%&,14 ,&2 -#%&!& 0," !&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % $!+%""%:0&6 #1%9,90"00!7:!1!
5$%7!&'
!-#
) )
!-# !-#
) .
) .
1
1 1
< <
< < < <
π π
π π π π
= =
= = = =
+%1 $!%<!1 $1!7$%"27!10!7 ,&2
!-#
)
!-# !-#
) .
) .
<
< <
π
π π
=
= =
+%1 $!0& !1,110<,"77!10!7 & $07/,&&!1!,5$$4#% $!707$,2,&!?8,"#10%1#1%9,90"04
$!7!5%&27 !#5%&707 !2%+!<,"8, 0&6%81#10%1;&%:"!26!%&?8,& 0"!7 ,7!-#",0&!20&
7!5 0%& ( J ! ,##"0!2 $! /! $%2%"%64 #1%#%7!2 94 ,"Q, ,&2 182$%//! DD ,&2 M,<!""!! ," DDD ;&%:&,7 $! 2@ +"%: 281, 0%&+1!?8!&54 /%2!"7 7,+017 7 !# :!
!7 0/, !2 $! 0&7 ,& ,&!%87 2075$,16! ?8,& 0"! :0$ #1%9,90"04 ) D 94 870&6 $! 18#!20- +%1/8", @! ," D*) D* '
) * ) D ) D=C *)
:$!1!C 07 $!:, !17$!2,1!, ! #07 $!2,0"41,0&+,""?8,& 0"!:0$#1%9,90"04) D ,&2 07,1!60%&,"0&2!- $! %5%7!281, 0%&D @! ," D*) D* :$05$5$,1,5 !10=!7
$!+"%%2281, 0%& :,7 $!&5%/#8 !2'
R
) D
"%6D = −) FD )+ "%6C + (
:$!1! 07 $!/!,&,&&8,"1,0&+,"",&2 $!/!,&,&&8," !/#!1, 81! "" $!#,1,/! !17
&!!2!2 +%1 $!5,"58", 0%& %+ !#,&2D ,1!,<,0",9"!%& /,#7 $! 2@ /! $%2%"%645,&
$!& 9!87!2 % 2!285!+"%%2 ?8,& 0"!7:0$ % $!1281, 0%&7%1+1!?8!&50!7 945%/#,107%&
:0$ $1!!1!+!1!&5!2, ,7! 7 1!#1!7!& , 0<!%+ $! $1!!/,0&61%8#7%+$421%"%605,"+"%%2 1!60/!7 0& @1,&5! $! 1!+!1!&5! 2, , 7! 780,9"! +%1 $! 1P/! 10<!1$,2 ,"1!,24 9!!&
5$%7!&94 182$%//! DD.
J ! $87%9 ,0&!2 ) D ,&2 ) DD?8,& 0"!7%+2,0"4 7 1!,/ +"%:7 "!,20&6 % S ,&2 S
<,"8!7,72!+0&!2 0& 7!5 0%& ( & %12!1 % +0 , :%#,1,/! !17#10%1207 1098 0%& % !,5$
/%20+0!2 ?8,& 0"! ,& 0&205, 0%& ,9%8 $!01<,10,90"04 :,7 ,"7% &!!2!2 & $! 18#!20- /! $%2 ,D)T 5%&+02!&5!0& !1<,"07URA V !5,87!%+ $!",5;%+0&+%1/, 0%&,9%8 $!
+0&,"8&5!1 ,0& 4 0& %81#10%17#!50+05, 0%& #1%5!77 :! 2!502!2 % 87! $! 7,/! 7$,#! %+
5%&+02!&5!0& !1<,"7+%1 $!/%20+0!2?8,& 0"!7 J ! $87!<,"8, !2 $!$4#!1#,1,/! !17 ,&2
%+ $! ,//,207 1098 0%& 7% $, $!/!,
%1<,"8!%+ :,7!?8," % S ,&2 $!) D.
?8,& 0"!%+ $!6,//,207 1098 0%&:,7!?8," % ×S & $!!-#%&!& 0,"5,7! $!70/#"0+0!2
#1%5!281! 2!75109!2 0& 7!5 0%& F :,7 ,##"0!2 $! !7 0/, !7 S S
"%6 1 λ= σ −
− ,&2 S S
"%6 1 λ′ = σ − ×
− :!1! 5%/#8 !2 ,&2 $! $4#!1#,1,/! !17 ,&2 %+ $! &<!17! ,//, 207 1098 0%&:!1!!<,"8, !27% $, $!/!,&:,7!?8," %λS ,&2 $!) D.?8,& 0"!:,7!?8,"
%λSW @0&,""4 $!7,/!<,"8!%+ $! $4#!1#,1,/! !1:,75$%7!&+%1 $!#10%1207 1098 0%&
1!", 0<! % 0& !1,110<,"7 "!,20&6 % $! 7,/! 5%!++050!& %+ <,10, 0%& ,&2 $!
$4#!1#,1,/! !1:,75%/#8 !2 %%9 ,0&,/!,&<,"8!%+ +%1 $!λ#,1,/! !1 "!,20&6 %%&!
!<!& #!14!,1%&,<!1,6! ?8, 0%& * :,787!2 0&/%2!"7</ ,&2< ,9"!(60<!7 $!
1!78"7%+ $!#10%17#!50+05, 0%%5!77 7.2. Results
,9"! . 78//,10=!7 $! /%2!"7W #%7 !10%1 #1%9,90"00!7 ,&2 ,77%50, !2 ,4!7 +,5 %17 55%120&6 % $!75,"!#1%#%7!294E,77,&2 ,+!14 DD. !<02!&5!+%1&%&7 , 0%&,104%+
$!0& !1,110<,"77!10!7,##!,17 % 9!#%700<! ,"0&!,1 1!&2 %& $!!-#%&!& 0,"207 1098 0%&
9!0&6 $! /%7 #1%9,9"! /%2!" @0681! 7$%:7 $! #1%5!77 /!,& +%1!,5$ %+ $! $1!!
/%2!"7 @%1 $07 #81#%7! #,1,/! !1 !7 0/, !7 ,1! $! /!,&7 %+ /,160&," #%7 !10%1 207 1098 0%&7 +0681!( !-5!# +%1 $!5$,&6!#%0& 0&/%2!"<!-# :$05$07 $!/%2!%+ $!
20751! !#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&
% 5"!,1!<02!&5!,##!,175%&5!1&0&6 $!7 , 0%&,104%+ $!%<!1 $1!7$%"27!10!7 :0$, ,4!7+,5 %1&!,1 % %&<!17!"4 $! 6!&!1,"0=!2 ,1! % 207 1098 0%& 7!!/7 % 9! /%7
!++050!& ,77$%:& 94 +0681! . +%1/%2!"7<)!-# ,&2 <)1 81#1070&6"4 $! /%2!"< 1 ,##!,17 % 9! $!/%1!#1%9,9"! 98 2%!7&% #1%<02!,& ,5581, !!7 0/, !%+ $!5$,&6!
#%0& @0681!F &!#%7709"!!-#",&, 0%& 5%8"2 9! $!7!&700<04%+ $09 ,##1%,5$ % $!
7 ,1 0&6#%0& ' $!,5581,54%+ $!/! $%2/,49!"%:!1:$!&&%5"!,107%", !2/%2!,##!,17 0& $!#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&%+τ !<!1 $!"!77 $!#%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&%+ $!75,"!#,1,/! !1 ,+!1 5$,&6! 07 <!14 5"%7! % $, %+ $! 75,"! #,1,/! !1 0& /%2!"<)1 @0681!
%&7!?8!& "4 1!78"7 %+ $! +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 7$%8"2 ,"7% 9! <!14 5"%7! +%1 $!7! :%
/%2!"7
@0681!*7$%:7 $!1!78" %+785$,&,&,"4707 &%12!1 % ,;!0& %,55%8& 5$,&6!70& $!
0& !1,110<,"7#1%5!77 :$05$0778##%7!2 %9!0&2!#!&2!& +1%/ $!%<!1 $1!7$%"27 $!
#1%5!281!#1!7!& !20&7!5 0%&. :,7/%20+0!2,7+%""%:7'
!#!, @ 0/!7'
,&2%/ 5$%05!%+, /%2!"<A+%1 $!%<!1 $1!7$%"27 :0$#1%9,90"00!712</; 3: 12<=; 3 ,&2%/ 5$%05!%+, #,1,/! !1<!5 %1 +1%/ $!7,/#"!%+12 <A3
,&2%/ 5$%05!%+, /%2!"<E+%1 $!0& !1,110<,"7 :0$#1%9,90"00!712</; 3: 12<=); 3 ,&2%/ 5$%05!%+, #,1,/! !1<!5 %1 +1%/ $!7,/#"!%+12 <E3
%/#8 , 0%& %+µ2329/Fλ233 $!/!,& &8/9!1%+!<!& 7#!14!,10& /%2!"<E , 0/! :0$
#,1,/! !1
%/#8 , 0%& %+ $! #1%9,90"0 4 1!", 0<! % , 1! 81& #!10%2', 0/! '1= − R'µ
%/#8 , 0%& %+ 123 $!1 ?8,& 0"! 0& /%2!"<A:0 $ #,1,/! !1
, 0/!
@"%%2 ?8,& 0"!7$,<! 2!51!,7!2 94 ,9%8 DT 9! :!!& 4!,17 D) ,&2 )) @0681! D +%587!7%& $! 1,I!5 %14 %+ $! )4!,1 1! 81& +"%%2 $! 581<! 7$,#! 0& $! !,1"4 4!,170728!
% $! 7 !# 5$,&6! /%2!"'%&5! $! #%7 !10%1 #1%9,90"0 4 %+ , 7 !# 5$,&6! $,79!5%/! %%
:!,; $07/%2!" ,778/!7 $, $! #1%5!77:0"" 7 ,4 0& $! 7!5%&2 7 , ! $879!$,<0&6"0;! , 7 , 0%&,14 /%2!" $! 581<! 07 $87 7/%% $!2 ,+ !1 785$ , 2, ! 1!205 0%& %+ ?8,& 0"! +8 81!
<,"8!7 /87 9! 1!6,12!2 :0 $ 5,8 0%& 9!5,87! :! &!6"!5 $! 8&5!1 ,0& 4 28! % 5$,&6!
#!1707 !&54 0& $! +8 81! !<!1 $!"!77 785$ , +0681! !/#$,70=!7 $! ,/90680 4 1!", 0<! % $!
87! %+ G1! 81& #!10%27H +%1 5$,1,5 !10=0&6 +1!?8!&54 0& , &%& 7 , 0%&,14 5%& !- & 785$ , 5,7! 0 :%8"2 9! 9! !1 % 87! $! )D?8,& 0"! :$05$ $,7 , ) #1%9,90"0 4 %+ 9!0&6!-5!!2!2 0& $! &!- 4!,1 $07 <,"8! 9!0&620++!1!& !,5$ 4!,1
8. Conclusion and discussion
$! ,0/ %+ $07 ,1 05"! :,7 % 2!10<! , ,4!70,& +1,/!:%1; % 2!," :0 $ 2, , +%1 :$05$
7 , 0%&,10 4 07 ?8!7 0%&,9"! $! /! $%2 #1!7!& !2 $!1! 5,& ,;! 0& % ,55%8& /%2!""0&6 8&5!1 ,0& 0!7 0& %12!1 % %9 ,0& , /%1! 1!,"07 05 ?8,& 0+05, 0%& %+ $! 1!78" 7 ,5581,54 $07 7$%8"2 1!78" 0& :02!1 5%&+02!&5! 0& !1<,"7 5%/#,1!2 % /! $%27 06&%10&6 $! /%2!""0&6 8&5!1 ,0& 0!7 %&<!17!"4 #10%1 7#!50+05, 0%&7 5,& 9! 87!2 % 0&I!5 #$4705," %1 1!60%&,"
;&%:"!26! ,9%8 , #$!&%/!&%& :$05$ /,4 0&51!,7! $! ,5581,54 %+ !7 0/, !7 %"!7 ,&2
%:!"" DDF $87 &% !2 $, #10%1 7#, 0," 0&+%1/, 0%& 5,& 9! <!14 87!+8" +%1 !7 0/, 0&675,"!
,&2 7$,#! #,1,/! !17 %+ , > 207 1098 0%& !<!& :0 $ +!: 2, , :$!1!,7 $! "%5, 0%&
#,1,/! !1 07 /%7 "4 70 ! 7#!50+05 ,&2 2, , 2!#!&2!& %1! 0&+%1/, 0%& ,9%8 $! ,2<,& ,6!7 ,&2 21,:9,5;7 %+ ,4!70,& /! $%27 5%/#,1!2 % "0;!"0$%%2 9,7!2 %&!7 0& !- 1!/! <,"8!7 ,&,"4707 ,1! &!!2!2 %1! #1!507!"4 +8 81! 7 820!7 5%8"2 5%/#,1! $! ,5581,54 %+ !7 0/, !7 $! 1%987 &!77 % %8 "0!17 ,&2 0&<!7 06, ! $! 0&+"8!&5! %+ #10%1 7#!50+05, 0%&7 %1 /077#!50+05, 0%&7
" $%86$ :! +%587!2 %& #,1 058",1 /%2!"7 0&5"820&6 :% 7,/#"0&6/! $%27 :% ;0&27
%+ 207 1098 0%&7 ,&2 $1!! 5$,&6! #%77090"0 0!7 $! +1,/!:%1; 5,& !,70"4 9! 87!2 0& % $!1 5%& !- 7 "0;! #%"4&%/0," 5$,&6!7 /8" 0#"! 7 !# 5$,&6!7 7!,7%&," 207 1098 0%&7 /0- 81! 87!
%+ 5%<,10, !7 ! 5 %/! $4#% $!7!7 :! /,2! 5%8"2 ,"7% 9! 1!",-!2 94 /!,&7 %+ ,##1%#10, ! /%2!"7 @017 "4 :! ,778/!2 $, 2, , ,107! +1%/ ,& 0&2!#!&2!& 7,/#"! :$05$ 5,&
7%/! 0/!7 9! <!14 2%89 +8" /%2!"7 ,1! $!& 6%%2 5,&202, !7 % %<!15%/! $07 20++058" 4 7!! ,4 ,&2 7,4 )) +%1 0&7 ,&5! !5%&2"4 :! ,778/!2 ,&4 5$,&6! % 9!
+0&," $87 :$!& +%1!5,7 0&6 , +8 81! ?8,& 0"! <,"8! $! 8&5!1 ,0& 4 28! % 5$,&6!
#!1707 !&54 07 &% ,;!& 0& % ,55%8& & $! 7 !#5$,&6! 5,7! 022!& ,1;%< $,0&7 5,& 9!
87!2 +%1 $07 #81#%7! %9!1 ! ," )))A !11!,8" ,&2 @%1 0& )) !<!1 $!"!77 /%7 %+
$! #89"07$!2 ,##1%,5$!7 ,778/!2 2, , &%1/,"0 4 %/! 0/#1%<!/!& 7 ,1! $87 7 0""
+%1!7!!,9"! 0& $!7! %#057
@0&,""4 %&! %+ $! /%1! #1%/070&6 ,7;7 :%8"2 9! % 2!10<! , ,4!70,& /8" 0<,10, ! /! $%2 +%1 !- 1!/! <,"8!7 ,&,"4707 %1! #1!507!"4 0& , 6"%9," 5"0/, ! 5$,&6! 5%& !- , 70 ! ,&,"4707 07 &% 7, 07+,5 %14 &+%1 8&, !"4 6!&!1,"0=, 0%& %+ !-07 0&6/! $%27 !11!,8" ! ," )))5 07 &% 7 1,06$ +%1:,12 +%1 !- 1!/! <,"8!7 207 1098 0%&7 $! 87! %+ 5%#8",7 @,<1!
! ," ))( /06$ 9! 5%&702!1!2 +%1 , 1!7 105 !2 &8/9!1 %+ "%5, 0%&7 2,# , 0%& %+ $! +"%%2 281, 0%& +1!?8!&54 ,##1%,5$ M,<!""! ! ," )) 0& , &%& 7 , 0%&,14 5%& !- 07 ,"7% %&! %+
$! #%77090"0 0!7 ",7 $0!1,15$05," ,4!70,& /%2!"7 0&5"820&6 1!&27 %1 7 !#5$,&6!7
#,1,/! !17 /,4 9! 87!+8" +%1 1!60%&," ,&,"4707 %+ !- 1!/!7 %%"!4 )).A %%"!4 ! ,"
)). ,7 :!"" ,7 +%1 /!,781!/!& 8&5!1 ,0& 0!7 $,&2"0&6 !07 ,&2 !20&6!1 )).
Acknowledgements
$07 :%1;:,7 5%&285 !2 ,7 #,1 %+ , &, 0%&," #1%61,/ %+ $421%"%605," 1!7!,15$
:$05$ ,77%50, !7 !/,61!+ 4%& 1!&%9"! 421%750!&5!7 %& #!""0!1 ! !%
@1,&5! %8"%87! ,&2 "!5 1050 Q2! @1,&5! @ $, %8 ,&2 1!&%9"! $! ,8 $%17 :%8"2
"0;! % $,&; ,"" /!/9!17 %+ $07 #1%I!5 $! +0&,&50," 78##%1 #1%<02!2 94 !/,61!+ ,&2
@ +%1 $! $ 1!7!,15$ %+ !&,12 07 61, !+8""4 ,5;&%:"!26!2 J ! ,"7% $,&; :%
,&%&4/%87 1!<0!:!17 +%1 $!01 $!"#+8" 5%//!& 7
Bibliography
!16!1 M D*. , 07 05," 2!5070%& $!%14 ,&2 9,4!70,& ,&,"4707 #10&6!1 >!1",6 F #
!: %1;
$09 DD. ,160&," 0;!"0$%%2 @1%/ $! 0997 8 #8 M%81&," %+ /!105,& , 07 05,"
77%50, 0%& '
%"!7 ,&2 !1055$0 )) & 050#, 0&65, ,7 1%#$!7 $1%86$ !- 1!/! <,"8! /%2!""0&6 M%81&," %+ $! %4," , 07 05," %50! 4 !10!7 ##"0!2 , 07 057 '().( F
%"!7 !1055$0 ,&2 077%& )) +8""4 #1%9,90"07 05 ,##1%,5$ % !- 1!/!
1,0&+,"" /%2!""0&6 M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 '..)
%"!7 ,&2 %:!"" DDF ,4!70,& /! $%27 0& !- 1!/! <,"8! /%2!""0&6' 1!<0!: ,&2 &!: 2!<!"%#/!& 7 & !1&, 0%&," , 07 05," !<0!: ' D F
%"!7 ,&2 M ,:& DDF ,4!70,& ,&,"4707 %+ !- 1!/! 1,0&+,"" 2, , ##"0!2 , 07 057 M%81&," %+ $! %4," , 07 05," %50! 4 !10!7 '(F ( *
%%"!4 )). , 07 05," &,"4707 %+ - 1!/!7 % 0<, !2 94 J !, $!1 ,&2 "0/, ! 820!7'
##"0!2 ,&2 $!%1! 05," 2<,&5!7 &0<!170 4 %+ %"%1,2% #
%%"!4 45$;, ,&2 ,<!,8 )). #, 0," ,4!70,& 0!1,15$05," %2!" +%1 , 1!50#0 , 0%& ! 81& !<!"7 ,# - 1!/! >,"8! &,"4707 % $!&9816 :!2!&
*
@ 1,! ,&2 0,/! D*) D* 4& $X7! &, 0%&,"! 781 "!7 518!7 2!7 #! 0 7 9,770&7 <!17,& 7 @,75058"! '", /Q $%2! %5%7! A &+%1/, 0%& !5$&0?8! &Y *
M80& D*) A@,75058"! '", /Q $%2! 18#!20-
8&2!1"0; M ,&2 81& )) %& 7 , 0%&,14 #%%"!2 +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 M%81&," %+
421%"%64 ' )
0!9%" M " 1%80 ,1102% ,&2 01,12 )) 8,70 5%&I86, ! ,4!7
!7 0/, !7 +%1 #,1,/! !17 ,&2 ,##"05, 0%& % $!,<4 ,0"7 /%2!""0&6 ,##%1 2!
1!5$!15$! D#
@,<1! " 2"%8&0 !11!,8" $0!/%&6! ,&2 %9!! ))( 8" 0<,10, !
$421%"%605," +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 870&65%#8",7 J , !1 !7%815!7 !7!,15$
@07$!1 ,&2 0##! D * 0/0 0&6 +%1/7 %+ $! +1!?8!&54 207 1098 0%& %+ $!
",16!7 %1 7/,""!7 /!/9!1 %+ , 7,/#"! ,/91026! $0" %5
,"Q, ,&2 182$%//! DD % 0%&7 2! 9,7! ! 5%&5!# 7 8 0"!7 #%81 ", 5%/#1Q$!&70%& 2! ", /%2Q"07, 0%& 74& $Q 0?8! 2!7 1Q60/!7 2! 518! 2!7 9,770&7
<!17,& 7 ,8 7!&7 2!7 /%2X"!7 2@ !<8! 2!7 50!&5!7 2! "W,8 '* )
!"/,& M ,1"0& !1& ,&2 890& DD. ,4!70,& 2, , ,&,"4707 ,""
. F# $,#/,& ,""
DDF 1!7!& , 0%& ,&2 1!<0!: %+ 7%/! /! $%27 +%1 1!60%&," +"%%2 +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 'F *(
8/9!" M D.* , 07 057 %+ !- 1!/!7 .# %"8/90, &0<!170 4 1!77 !: %1;
,7 0&67 J E D ) %& ! ,1"% 7,/#"0&6 /! $%27 870&6 ,1;%< 5$,0&7 ,&2 $!01 ,##"05, 0%&7 0%/! 10;, 'D )D
)) "0/, ! 5$,&6! )) '74& $!707 1!#%1 ,/91026! &0<!170 4 1!77 ()* # ,/91026!
M,<!""! M 1Q70""%& ,&2 ,"Q, DDD 075$,16! 281, 0%& @1!?8!&54 581<!7 /%2!"0&6 +%1 +"%%27 ,&2 75,"! 0&<,10,&5! %/# !7 !&287 2! "W5,2Q/0! 2!7
50!&5!7 50!&5!7 2! ", !11! ! 2!7 #",&X !7 'D((
M,<!""! 8,12, ,&6 %9!! ,"Q, ,&2 M 1Q70""%& )) !<!"%#/!&
%+ 1!60%&," +"%%2 281, 0%& +1!?8!&54 581<!7 9,7!2 %& $! 0&2!-+"%%2 /! $%2 M%81&,"
%+ 421%"%64 '(D .D
E,77 ,&2 ,+ !14 DD. ,4!7 @,5 %17 M%81&," %+ $! /!105,& , 07 05,"
77%50, 0%& ' D.
E, = J ,1",&6! ,&2 ,<!,8 )) , 07 057 %+ !- 1!/!7 0& $421%"%64 2<,&5!7 0& J , !1 !7%815!7 ' * )(
,&6 DDD $!%1! 05," 20758770%& ,&2 %& ! ,1"% 70/8", 0%&7 +%1 , !6, 0<! 0&%/0,"
#1%5!77 #,1,2%- %5$,7 05 &<01%&/!& ," !7!,15$ ,&2 07; 77!77/!& '*
))
,&6 M 8,12, ,&2 %9Q! DDD %:,127 %#!1, 0%&," 6802!"0&!7 +%1 %<!1 $1!7$%"2 /%2!"0&6 M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 ')
,27!& 0;;!"7!& %79I!16 ,&2 )) !60%&," !7 0/, 0%& %+ 1,0&+,""
0& !&70 4 281, 0%& +1!?8!&54 581<!7 870&6 6!&!1,"0=!2 "!,7 7?8,1!7 1!61!770%& %+
#,1 0," 281, 0%& 7!10!7 7 , 07 057 J , !1 !7%815!7 !7!,15$ ' D
! 1%#%"07 J %7!&9"8 $ %7!&9"8 $ !""!1 ,&2 !""!1 D.
?8, 0%& %+ 7 , ! 5,"58", 0%&7 94 +,7 5%/#8 0&6 /,5$0&!7 M%81&," %+ 5$!/05,"
#$47057 ')* )D
! 1%#%"07 ,&2 ",/ D(D $! %& ! ,1"% /! $%2 M%81&," %+ $! /!105,&
, 07 05," 77%50, 0%& ' . (
,1!& ,&2 M !1&0!1 )) &5%20&6#10%1 !-#!1 7 I826/!& 7 % 0/#1%<! 107;,&,"4707 %+
!- 1!/! $421%"%605," !<!& 7 <0, /%2!"0&6 M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 ' *
!11!,8" ))) &,"47! 9,4Q70!&&! 1Q 1%7#!5 0<! 2W8&! 18# 81! 2,&7 "!7 7Q?8!&5!7 2!
<,10,9"!7 ,"Q, %01!7 $421%"%60?8!7 @ ,8 ))#
!11!,8" M !1&0!1 %9!! ,&2 ,1!& ))), ,4!70,& 5$,&6! #%0& ,&,"4707 0&
$421%/! !%1%"%605," 0/! 7!10!7 ,1 $! &%1/," /%2!" 1!<070 !2 M%81&," %+
421%"%64 ' (
!11!,8" M !1&0!1 %9!! ,&2 ,1!& )))9 ,4!70,& 5$,&6! #%0& ,&,"4707 0&
$421%/! !%1%"%605," 0/! 7!10!7 ,1 %/#,107%& %+ 5$,&6! #%0& /%2!"7 ,&2 +%1!5,7 0&6 M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 '( F
!11!,8" ,&2 > @%1 0& )) 0- 81! ,&2 022!& ,1;%< /%2!"7 +%1 #!,; +"%:
,&,"4707 !0=0X/!7 !& 1! 0!&7 28 5!& 1! M,5?8!7 ,1 0!1 4%& @1,&5!
!11!,8" ,1!& M !1&0!1 %9!! ,&2 "0<0 =;4 )))5 ! 1%7#!5 0<!
/8" 0<,10, ! ,4!70,& 5$,&6! #%0& ,&,"4707' 70/8" ,&!%87 70&6"! 5$,&6! 0& $!
/!,& %+ 7!<!1," $421%"%605," 7!?8!&5!7 %5$,7 05 &<01%&/!& ," !7!,15$ ,&2 07;
77!77/!& '( F
05;,&27 M D . , 07 05," 0&+!1!&5! 870&6 !- 1!/! %12!1 7 , 07 057 &&,"7 %+ , 07 057 ' D
182$%//! DD. %2X"!7 74& $Q 0?8!7 2!7 5%&&,077,&5!7 !& $421%"%60! &0<!170 Q
%& #!""0!1 @ 4%& ())# %& #!""0!1
,4 E ,&2 7,4 )) ,4!70,& /! $%27 +%1 5$,&6! #%0& 2! !5 0%& 0& "%&61,&6!
2!#!&2!& #1%5!77!7 M%81&," %+ 0/! !10!7 &,"4707 'F* ).
!!2 J DDD @"%%2 7 0/, 0%& ,&29%%; >%"8/! ' <!1<0!: % 421%"%64 )*#
J ,""0&6+%12
!07 ,&2 M !20&6!1 )). ,4!70,& +"%%2 +1!?8!&54 ,&,"4707 :0 $
$07 %105," 0&+%1/, 0%& M%81&," %+ 421%"%64 'D F
0 !1 ,&2 ,&&!1 DD @,50"0 , 0&6 $! 0997 ,/#"!1 $! 0997 %##!1 ,&2 $! 10224 0997 ,/#"!1 M%81&," %+ $! /!105,& , 07 05," 77%50, 0%& '*F
*F*
%9!1 42!& ,&2 0 !10&6 %& ))) ,4!70,& 0&+!1!&5! 0& $022!& ,1;%<
/%2!"7 $1%86$ $! 1!<!1709"! I8/# ,1;%< 5$,0& %& ! ,1"% /! $%2 M%81&," %+ $!
%4," , 07 05," %50! 4 !10!7 , 07 05," ! $%2%"%64 '. .
%79I!16 ,&2 ,27!& ))( 2<,&5!2 ,##1%,5$!7 0& R /%2!""0&6%+ !- 1!/!
$421%"%605," !<!& 7 421%"%64 ' 50!&5! 1,5 05! +%1 $! 7 !& 814 %&2%&
%50! 4
18#5=!:7;0 J ,&2 Z E,5=/,1!; )) %& 7 , 0%&,14 ,##1%,5$ % , 70 ! +"%%2 +1!?8!&54 /%2!""0&6 J !06$ !2 "!,7 7?8,1!7 !7 0/, 0%& M%81&," %+ 421%"%64
'( .
18#5=!:7;0 J > 0&6$ ,&2 J @!"85$ )) %& 7 , 0%&,14 ,##1%,5$ % , 70 ! +"%%2 +1!?8!&54 /%2!""0&6 ,-0/8/ "0;!"0$%%2 !7 0/, 0%& M%81&," %+ 421%"%64
' (
,&&!1 DDF %%"7 +%1 , 07 05," &+!1!&5! #10&6!1 >!1",6 )*# !: %1;
Annex 1. Griddy Gibbs sampling
$! ,0/ %+ $07 /! $%2 07 % 70/8", ! , 7,/#"! +1%/ $! #%7 !10%1 207 1098 0%&12; 3 $!
09977,/#"0&6,"6%10$/ 5,&9! :10!&,7+%""%:'
• $%%7! ,7 ,1 0&6<,"8! ) =
(
θ ) θ=))
,&27! ?[)• !#!, @ 0/!7' o ?[?K A
o ,/#"!θ ? \1
(
θ θL ?− θ=?−)
o ,/#"!θ ? \1
(
θ θL ? θ ?− θ=?−)
o ]
o ,/#"!θ ? \1
(
θ θL ? θ −? θ +?− θ=?−)
o ]]
o ,/#"!θ=? \1
(
θ θ= L ? θ=−?)
• !&2
$! <!5 %177!10!7
3 5%&<!16!7 % $! ,16! #%7 !10%1207 1098 0%&,7? !&27 %0&+0&04
& %12!1 % 2!51!,7! $! 0&+"8!&5! %+ $! 7 ,1 0&6 #%0& $! +017 0!1, 0%&7,1! 878,""4 2!"! !2 ,&2 0&+!1!&5! 07 /,2! :0$ $! ",7 @ 0!1, 0%&7 !&700<04 ,&,"4707 /,4 9!
&!5!77,14 % 2! !1/0&! ,55!# ,9"! <,"8!7+%1 ,&2@ 878,""4 , "!,7 ,+!: $%87,&27%+
0!1, 0%&7,1! 87!2+%1 ,&2@ %1! 6!&!1,""4 $07/! $%2#1!7!& 7 $! 7,/! 21,:9,5;7,7
% $!10!1, 0<! 70/8", 0%& !5$&0?8!7 %&<!16!&5! $87$,7 % 9! /%&0%1!2 94 5$%%70&6 7!<!1,"7 ,1 0&6 #%0& 7%15%/#8 0&6 5%&<!16!&5! 0&205!7 !"/,& ! ," DD. %1 ,&&!1
DDF #1%<02! 7%/! 6802!"0&!7+%10/#1%<0&6 $! &8/!105,"70/8", 0%&7!++050!&54
&+%1 8&, !"4 $! 09977,/#"0&6 ,"6%10$/ 5,& 878,""4&% 9! 87!2 0& $071,: <!170%&
9!5,87! 0 0&<%"<!7 9!0&6 ,9"! % 7,/#"! +1%/ $! +8"" 5%&200%&," 2!&700!7
(
L ? ? ? =?)
1 θ θ θ − θ +− θ − 0!1 ,&2 ,&&!1 DD #1%#%7!2 $! 87! %+ , 20751! ! ,##1%-0/, 0%&%+ $! 58/8", 0<! 2!&704+8&5 0%&7 52+ %+ $!7! 207 1098 0%&7'
• $%%7! ,6102%+#%0& 7 /: 1
• <,"8, !12G ; G/ : G / GE/ : G 3%& $076102 %%9 ,0&H/: H1
• %/#8 ! $! 58/8", 0<! 78/7%+H/: H1 %%9 ,0&,&,##1%-0/, 0%&%+ $! @
• ,/#"! +1%/ ,8&0+%1/ 207 1098 0%&%&U) V
• 1,&7+%1/ 94 $! 0&<!17! %+ $! ,##1%-0/, ! @
$07,"6%10$/ /87 9! ,22!2, !,5$ 7 !#%+ $! 09970!1, 0%& + $! +8""5%&200%&,"
2!&700!7,1! ;&%:&%&"48# % #1%#%1 0%&,"04 1
(
θ θL ? θ −? θ +?− θ=?−)
5,&9! 1!#",5!294
(
θ ? θ −? θ +?− θ=?−)
$! #1%285 %+#10%1,&2"0;!"0$%%2 ,&2$! 58/8", 0<! 78/7%+H/: H1/87 $!&9! 20<02!294 $! % ,"78/ %#1%<02! $! @ ,##1%-0/, 0%& &<!170%&%+ $! @ 5,&9! /,2! :0$ ,"0&!,10& !1#%", 0%&9! :!!& :%
6102#%0& 7 $! 61025$%05! 07 $! /%7 0/#%1 ,& 0778! %+ $07 !5$&0?8!' 0 $,7 %9! 91%,2
!&%86$ % 5%<!1 $! 1,&6! %+ $! 207 1098 0%&7 ,&2 +0&! !&%86$ % !&781! , 78++050!&
,5581,54 ;!!#0&60&/0&2 $, $0778##"!/!& ,147 !#075%/#8 0&6 0/! !-#!&70<! %/!
0/#1%<!/!& 7%+ $! /! $%2,1! 2!75109!20& 0!1,&2 ,&&!1 DD