Stabilized Finite Element Formulations for Shells in a Bending Dominated State
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Stabilized finite element formulations for shells in a bending dominated state Dominique Chapelle and Rolf Stenberg. N ˚ 2941 Juillet 1996 ` THEME 4. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4) .
(5) !
(6) "
(7) #$%&$(') * $ *)+ ) # ) $,(( -.0/2143514687"9;:<"=0>?9A@B@B9#CD=03"EGFH.0@JIKMLN9A3MO?9QP R;S T U,WV XWZY[ \]^X_a`cb*de]gfNhWd?fNijde]^Xk]mleb de]gfNh n Wolqpjlqd W
(8) V XW l rsfNXia`gWtAW l u(v fxweWdzy;fl{d v b | b iai}f v d n W v W r U W v r U W~hN Ya[ N_a]^`g`^Wdz
(9) NN[ Yi}b* W l. M aN WrfNh}l{] n W v d U W n Wxlq]^ hf*"}ha]gdeWoW`^WXkWhQd"XW
(10) d U f n l?Jf v d U WZb U n ](l U W`^` Xf n W`]gh;d U WrblqW U W
(11) hd U W n WJf v XHb*d]^fh]cl}Wh n ]gha n fX]^hb*deW n0 T f#Jf v X_a`mb de]^fh}l }bNl{W n fNhHl{db*j]^`^]g]^hj ZdeW r U ha]c_jW l(b v W]ghQd v f n _rW n b*h n ]gd(]ml(i v f W n d U b*d"d U Wpb v WZl{db a`^W U Wh}rsW; v WW; v fNX `^fAr A]^ha T U Wd U Wf v Wde]crb*`¡W lqd]^XHb deW lb v WrfhQ v XW n Ap2hA_aXW v ]mrb ` }Wh}r U XHb v lqd_ n ]^Wxl ¢;£¤¥e¦o§} ¨8N }ha]^dWZW`gWXWhAd(XWd U f n ls}lqdb a]^`g]^W n XWd U f n ljl U W
(12) `^`mlsaZb U n ]8Xf n W` © y\}ª4y«\j¬"lq_jAweW rdzr`cbNlel{]®r
(13) b*de]gfNh}lZªQ v WQ]clq]gfNh0¬ ¯"N°Z±N²A´³x±Nµ°A´³x±*¶²°. ·g¸#ºq¹ »{¼½ º?¹ 8¾ ¿À»{ÁÃÂsÄ ÅÆ ÇÉÈzÊ0ËsÌÎÍÊÏÈzÈÎÐ Ñ ÑNËsÌÎÒJÓ{Ô;ÇÉÕkÑNÏÌJÒÖ×kÒÎÆ ÓØ8Ð Ù¡ÏÚÕÜÛÏÚÑ ÇÉÒ4ÏÚÝMÏÕ Ô)ÞßËsÖ ÇÉÝÉÇÉÒm×àaÌJËásÌ4ÏÚÙãâBäÆ Ó{ÝÉÝÉÈå ÞÏÚÒJÆ ÓqÙ¡ÏÒÎÇÉæÏÝÞßË
(14) Ô*Ó{ÝÉÇçÕ*áDÏÚÕ Ôzè8ÕÏÝÉ×ÈJÇÉÈé äxæ{ÇÉÓ{ÕÒJÇëêæ"Û0ËsÙÑ Ð ÒJÇÉÕ áì(ËíjÒÎÆ Ó"Û0ËsÙÙzÇîÈÎÈJÇÉËsÕ ËíaÒJÆ Ó"ïaÐ*ÌJËsÑNÓÏÚÕ Û0ËÙzÙ Ð Õ ÇÉÒJÇÉÓ{ÈðgÛ0ËÕÒJÌ4ÏÚæ{Òñòï}óôÛ0Øó´õMÛ0ÅMö÷
(15) øùsúûsü{ý þÿ ÏÖNËsÌBÏÒÎËsÇÉÌJÓzÛ0Ó{ÕÒÎÌ4ÏÝ0Ô Ó{È?àQËsÕÒJÈ5Ó{Ò Û0ÆÏÚÐ ÈJÈ Ó{ Ó{È (Þ ó ú ÿ Ûà}Û s Û (óMä
(16) éaÏÝÉÝ Ó{ Ó (Ó{Ñ ÝÉÓ{Ì ÷ , ø"ÿ Û0ÆÏÚÙzÑ È cÈÎÐ Ì JÞÏÌÎÕ Ó Ó cÙZÏÇÉÝmå !#"%$&'#()* &+) ÏÚÖËÌ4ÏÚÒJËsÌÎ×"í^ËsÌäÒJÌÎÓ{Õ ásÒÎÆzËÚíjÞÏÒÎÓ{ÌJÇÀÏÝÉÈ Ïæ{Ð ÝÉÒm× ËíjÞZÓqæ4ÆNÏÕ ÇÉæÏÚÝ ïaÕ*ásÇÉÕ Ó{Ó{ÌÎÇÉÕ á ØMÓ{ÝÉÈJÇÉÕ Í#Ç MÕ 0Ç /Ó{Ì ÈÎÇçÒm×?ËÚí}ÅjÓqæ4Æ*Õ ËsÝÉËsá× ø eùsø ïaÈJÖNËé - ÇÉÕ ÝÀÏÚÕ Ô . -1Ó mÙ¡ÏÇÉÝmå ('$ 2&3!4' )*5"6).
(17) 5')H) $ 5$ã $$. *$ Z $#!)&
(18) $ H!) $
(19)
(20) # )# ) (. £A £ «h lî]^hAdW v W lel{Wb*_jt;XW d U f n W l n W `W XkWhQd l }hj]mlZb iaia`^]c_W W lzb*_Xf n W
(21) V `^W n W rfA_aW n W¡b* U n ] n b h}l`^W rbNlZf _ V `mb n Ws Jf v XÜb*de]gfNhHW l{d! b#V "}WtA]^fh n fX]^hb*hAdeW%$A n b h}l`gW a_ad n W `g]^X]ghaW v `gWZW vev fN_a]g`^`cb* NW?hA_aXW v ]m_aW «hHi v fNi}fl{W n W_atJf v X#_a`cb*d]^fNhlN'b & de]gW l l{_ v `^Wzi v ]gh}r]gi W n W l XW d U f n W l(X]^tAdeW llqdb a]^`g]ml(W W l n fhQd?fh n W XfhQd v Wz_)ëW`g`^W llqfNhAdzlqd b*a`gW l rW_a]}Wtjr`^_ad W®* W rd]^WXWhAd8`gWZW vev fN_a]g`^`cb* NW ,+ Wxl v W l{_a`^d b*dl d U W f v ]m_aW l lqfhQdDrf vv fN}f v W l i}b v n W l-W
(22) de_ n Wxl hQ_aXW v ]c_aWxl8W®* W rd_.W W l?l{_ v n W lzrbNl0/BdW lqd l .
(23) . "! "
(24) #. _ v ]^ha Zd U W?`mblqd n W rb n W v W b*d"i v fN v W ll U bNl8}WWhfadb ]^haW n ]^hd U W?_ah n W v lqd b*h n ]gha f*®d U W `^fAr Q]gha zf*}}ha]gdeW W
(25) `^WXW
(26) hQd}XWd U f n l´Jf v b v ]^fN_led U ]^hl{d v _rde_ v W l $ f v fNhaW/ n ]gXWh}l{]^fNhb*` i v fa`^W
(27) XHl] W Wxb*XHlb*h n b v r U W ls(]^d]mlhaf rfXia`gWdeW`gpH Qhaf ?h U f* e`gfArÚ A]^hj /J v WW%$ }ha]gdeWW
(28) `^WXW
(29) hQd XWd U f n lZl U fN_a` n }Wrfh}lqd v _}rdW n r W N0Y f v ia`cb*deWxl}bNl{W n fNh d U W | W]mllqhaW v /{y;]gh n `g]^hd U Wf v prfNh}l{] n W v b*j`^W¡b n b*hrW l U bxW¡b*`clqfo W
(30) Whbr U ]^WW n b*h n Qp haf d U WZi v fNa`gWX?]gd U d U Wol U W b v `^fAr Q]gha r
(31) b*h)lebJW`^p}Wrs`mb*]gXW n def}Wolqf`^W n0 hd U ]ml v W l{i}W rd W v WJW v dfd U W i}b i}W v l ±Q
(32) QA²A* Y
(33) Q]gh U ]mr U d U W fNijde]^XÜb*`Nf v n W v f*®rsfNhAW v Wh}rW ]ml v ]^ Nf v f_}lq`gpW lqd b*a`g]ml U W n Jf v lqWW v b*`®XWd U f n l b h n 4b X]^`g]^W l(f "XWd U f n l ]^d Uov W b v n dfl U W
(34) `^`mld U W?i v W l{WhAd(l{]^de_b*de]gfNh]cl8_ahQJf v de_jh}b*dW`^p4b v v fNX lb*d]ml 4brdef v p Wh]d U W`^]gdeW v b*d_ v WZfh;d U WZ}W` n ]cl fN`^_jX]^haf_}l]gd?]mlzrfNXXkfNha`gpb n X]^ddeW n d U b*dzd U W W`^W
(35) XWhAdli v W l{WhAde`^po]^h_lqWb v WZhafd?rfXia`gWdeW`gp v W`g]mb*j`^WArÚ W d U Wlq_ v Wp v fNX d U W Q]gW?i}fN]ghQdMf*}hA_aXW v ]mr
(36) b*`b h}b*`gpal{]mlsN]^dM]mlhafNd lq_ v i v ]clq]^hj ZdefzWh}rf_ahAdeW v n ] Ür_a`gde]gW l0?]^d U l U W
(37) `^`ml h4bNrsdd U Wz NW
(38) haW v b `®rfNh}rsWiad(f . l U W`g` $rf W v lM U fN`gW 4b X]^`g]^W lf*,i v fa`^WXÜl8?]^d U W v pHXHb v W nHn ] *®W v WhrW l]gh;}W U bA]^fN_ v n Wi}Wh n ]gha fNh W d U W WfNXW
(39) d v pkf*?d U WX] n / Wh}rW ´d U W fb*` f* n WW`gfNia]gha lq_ v 4bNrW 8d U W}fN_ah n b v p rfNh n ]^de]gfNh}lob*h n d U W`^f b n ]gha ed U Wol U W`g`0W`gWXWhAd $ZXHbp}Wdffb X#j]^de]gfN_}lsab d?`^W blqd¡b*d?i v W lqWhAd T U W v Wßb v Wd{ foXHb*]ghrs`mbNllqW l f "l U W`g` }W U bxA]^f_ v d U b*dzrb h}Wrs`^W b v `^p n ]mlqd]^ha _a]ml U W n ¯ d U WXW
(40) X# v b*haW¡b*h n W
(41) h n ]^hj n fX]^hb*deW n r
(42) bNlqWxl yb*d U WXHb de]mr
(43) b*`^`gpd U WoXWX v b*haWßrbNl{W ]ml?bl{]^ha _a`mb v `^pki W v de_ v }b deW n lqWxrfNh n f v n W v W`g`^]^ijde]mr?i v fNa`gWX U WhHd U Wd U ]mr QhaWxlel5f "d U W l U W
(44) `^`}]ml lqXHb `^` f v d U ]cl rblqWZd U Wl{db*h n b v n ha]^dWW`gWXWhAdMXWd U f n _}lq_b*`^`gp f v jl _a]^dW W`g` ] Ür_a`gde]^Wxl#b v ]ml{W]^h d U WfNd U W v rblqWz] W U Wh d U W n WJf v XHb de]^fh2]cl#}Wh n ]gha n fNXk]^h}b deW n0 T U Whad U WZ`g]^X]gd5i v fNj`^WX `^W b n l?defrfh}lqd v b*]ghQd l U ]mr U N]gW v ]clqWdef`gfArÚ A]^ha ]Md U WpHb v WWtjbNrd`^p]^Xi}fl{W n ]^hHd U Wßha]^dWZW`^W
(45) XWhAd(Xf n W` T U WhQ_jXW v ]crb*`Mb h}b*`gpal{]mlf ?d U W`^fAr Q]gha i v fa`^WXÜlDJf v l U W`g`ml?]mllqd]^`^`M]^h]gdl]ghQ4b*hrp T U W;ib*i}W v lkb v W)]^h 4bNrdklqfJW
(46) d U b dd U Wp rb*h W v p W`^`?}W v ]^W "p v WA]^W
(47) W n U W v W u ]^de b v b*hAdbDbNl#d U W; v lqddf b nan v W ll#d U ]cl_aW lqd]^fh ]^h Y² B? U W v W U W rfh}lq] n W v l W }ha]gdeWHW`^W
(48) XWhAdZXWd U f n lJf v b rpQ`g]^h n v ]mr
(49) b*` l U W
(50) `^`?]^h b}Wh n ]gha n fNX]gh}b*dW n lqd b*dW l U f zld U b*d;d U W lqdb h n b v n /4W v l{]^fh `^fAr al#Jf v `gf*ãf v n W v XWd U f n lzf v ]od U W ha]^dW W`^W
(51) XWhAd?XW l U ]clhafdb*`g]^ haW n ?]^d U d U Wb tQ]clßf ?d U WrspQ`g]^h n W v h d U Wi}b*i}W v ]gd]clb*`ml{f l U f ?hd U b*d d U W /BW v lq]gfNh?]^d U bß}tAW n XW l U ]cl v WW v fNX `^fAr Q]gha ]^hb*`^`gpborb v WJ_a`^`gp n W l{]^ NhjW n /4XWd U f n ]cll U f ?h2def}W)bNl{pQXkiadefde]mr
(52) b*`^`gp rfNhAW v NWhAd fd U ?]^d U v W lqi}W rd def b h n }"a_ad_ahQJf v d_ah}b*dW`^p fNha`gpfNh b*h b `^]g NhaW n v W rdb ha N_j`mb v XW l U u ]gde b v b hQd b b*h}b `^pjlqW lzd U WoXWd U f n;n ] v W rd`^p# v fNXãd U WkªÎXf n ]À}W n ¬ WhaW v NpHWtAi v W lel{]^fNh T U W i}b v de]mb ` lqW`gW rd]^W v W n _}rW n ]^hAdeW
(53) v b de]gfNh $]^hAd v f n _}rW n ]^hd U WXf v W v WxrWhAd?i}b*i}W v Ap © v haf` n b h n ! v W
(54) ] " ]cl5}blqW n fNh)d U Wor`cbNlel{]mrb `b iai v f bNr U f ( v ]^de]gha d U Wi v fNj`^WX ]^hHX]gtQW n Jf v X T U Wp v lqd"_}l{WZbolqia`g]^ded]^ha f d U WWhjW v pHªBb*` v W b n p_}l{W n Ap u ]^d# b v b*hAdb]^h Y² άMdf v ]^dW d U WoX]^tAW n lqpjlqdWX%]^h l{_}r U b Jf v X d U b*dZd U W $/4W`g`^]^ijde]mrs]^d{p $orfNh n ]^d]^fNhf d U W r`mblelq]crb*` . ±.
(55) leb nan `^W)i}fN]^hAdd U Wf v p ]mlbfN] n W n " T U Wh d U Wp i v f W;d U W ]^hQ / lq_ji $ rfNh n ]^de]gfNh Qp rfNhlqd v _}rd]^ha b f v d]^h fNi}W v b def v f v d U ]ml"d U WdW r U ha]m_aWf -ej_aaa`gWJ_ah}rsde]^fh}l $]ml _}lqW n0 hHd U W rfNh}l{d v _}rde]gfNh)f*"d U W f v de]ghfi}W v b def v 0d U Wb*_jd U f v lhaW
(56) W n d U W bNlel{_aXiad]^fh d U b dd U Wk NWfXWd v ]mrb `"i}b v b*XWdW v lªÎ] W d U W#J_ah n b XWhAdb `5Jf v XHlb*h n d U W + Uav ]clqdef%*®W` lqpAX#}f`mlÚ¬ b v Wia]gW rW?]clqWrfh}lqd b*hAdls U ]cr U lqWW v W`^p v Wxlqd v ]mrd l d U Wob iaia`^]crb*j]^`^]gd{pf*"d U W] v d lqWW
(57) XHlZdef}WHhafNh /4d v ]^A]mb ` defW
(58) tQdWh n d U W] v v W l{_a`^d l#ªJh}b*XW
(59) `^pdef rs] v rs_a`mb v rpA`^]gh n W v lÚ¬ b*h}b `^pjlq]cl5defod U W¡ NWhaW v b*`,rbNl{W h Y 8\_ v ]l{de_ n ]gW l(d U Wßb*iai v fbr U f* © v haf` n b h n ! v W
(60) ] bNlb*h /4XWd U f n Jf vv W rsdb*hj N_a`cb v W`^W
(61) XWhAdl T U Wb h}b*`gpal{]mlf Z\_ v ]"]ml]ghd U Wlqia] v ]gdZf* u ]^de b v b*hAdbAQb h n d U WzXf n ]À}W n W
(62) haW v pWtAi v W llq]gfNh]ml"b h}b*`gpal{W n#n ] v Wxrde`gp?]gd U f_ad"d U Wz_}l{W f*Dd U WWx_a]gb*`^W
(63) hQdZXk]^tAW n XW
(64) d U f n0k© `ml{f U W v Wd U Wblelq_jXiade]gfNh f*zia]gW rW?]clqWrfh}lqd b*hAd rfW Ür]^W
(65) hQd l]ml_}lqW n® Wd_l v W
(66) XHb v ;d U b*d(]ghQd_a]^d]^W`gp}d U ]clbNllq_aXkiade]gfNh l{WWXHldf;}W WWhoXf v W v W l{d v ]crde]gW(Jf v !b / n fNX]gh}b*dW n WtAdeWhlq]^fh $Zi v fArsW n _ v WZbl d U WzW`^WXkWhQd l0d U W
(67) h rb*h}WZ_a]gdeWz`mb v NW¡b*h n d U W?b v ]mb de]^fh]^hd U W WfNXW
(68) d v pa]g Wd"_}l(}h}b `^`^pXkWhQd]^fhd U W i}b*i}W v Qp µß] v XHl{W
(69) 8]gh U ]mr U bklqi U W v ]mr
(70) b*`lq_ v 4bNrW]clZrfNhlq] n W v W n b*h n b#`gfArÚ A]^ha v W
(71) W XWd U f n ]ml n W lq]g NhaW n® T U Wia_ v i f lqWf ?d U Wi v WxlqWhAdZi}b i W v ]cldefHWtAia`gf v Wd U Wb*ijia`^]crb*d]^fNhf zl{db*j]^`^]g b*d]^fh deW r U ha]c_jW l dfZl U W`^`i v fNj`^WXHl T U W l{W?l{db*j]^`^]g b*d]^fhdW r U ha]m_aW l U bW"W b v `^]^W v }WWh l U f ?h def) N]^WXWd U f n lZ v WW v fX&`gfArÚ A]^ha Jf v lqW
(72) W v b ` v W`mb deW n i v fa`^WXÜl]^h rsfNhAde]^hA_a_aX XkW / r U b*ha]crllq_}r U bNl]gh}rfXi v Wxlelq]ga`^WW
(73) `mbNl{de]cr]^d{p NaNQQ 48}W b*XÜl ±A 4"b v r U W l ±"² ?b h n | W
(74) ]mlel{haW v /{y;]gh n `^]ghia`cb*dW l ±NAA³ANYA³AQ±"± T U Wl{db a]^`g]^ b de]^fhdeW r U ha]c_jW ]ml"_a]^dWzlq]gXia`^W T U WW _}b*d]^fNhl?b v WZ v lqd? v ]^dedWh]gh;bb v ]mb de]gfNh}b `8X]gtQW n Jf v X T U Wh,ai v fi W v `^pk W]g U / deW n `^WxbNlqd /{l_b v Wxl /4dqpAi}WW
(75) tQi v W lel{]^fh}l5f d U WW _a]g`^]^ v ]^_jX b h n rfh}lqd]^d_ade]gW?W _b*de]gfNh}l"b v W b nan W n defd U Wj]^`^]ghaW b v Jf v X T U ]ml ]mlsa]^h n WW n U f G W U W v Wd v W b d?d U W¡W _b*de]gfNh}l f "d U W Zb* U n ]l U W
(76) `^`Xf n W
(77) ` ±N°A0° f v d U W v W l{_a`^d]^ha }ha]gdeWoW`^WXkWhQd"XW
(78) d U f n W b v Wb*j`^Wdf i v f Wzd U Wßlqdb a]^`g]^d{p U WhrWd U WZXW
(79) d U f n ]ml( v WW v fNX `^fAr Q]gha f v f_ v?v Wxlq_a`gd W n fhafd haWW n b hQp v W l{d v ]mrd]^WobNllq_aXijde]^fh}lfhd U W NWfXWd v p W
(80) ]^d U W v n f WhaWW n b hQp lqd b*a] / `^]g]^ha Ha_jaa`^W n W v WW lf ? v WW n fNXb*h n WÜb v W)b a`^Wdf_}lqW)l{db*h n b v n }ha]gdeWW
(81) `^WXW
(82) hQd lqi}brW l WHl U f_a` n b `mlqfW
(83) Xi U blq]^
(84) W#d U b*dd U WHd U WHb _atA]^`^]cb v pb v ]mb a`^W l]ghQd v f n _rW n ]gh d U WX]gtQW n l{db*j]^`^]gW n j]^`^]ghaW b v Jf v X%b v Wrfh n WhlqW n ]^h)b h;]^Xkia`^WXWhd b*de]gfNh U ]mr U d U W
(85) h db W l d U Wol{db*h n b v nn ]ml{ia`mbrWXWhAd(Jf v X «z_ v XWd U f n ]ml5Jf v X#_j`mb*dW n ]ghd U W /BW v lq]gfNh . hi v ]gh}r]^ij`^Wad U WXWd U f n rb*h}WJf v X_a`mb deW n ]^h b NWhjW v b ` )lqWdde]^hj a0a_jdbNlZ WW
(86) t / deWhlq]^W
(87) `^p_lqW]^hAW v l{WWxlqde]gXHb*dW l8d U W v W l{_a`^d]^ha oXWd U f n f_a` n hjfNd?}W_aha]Jf v X`gplqd b*a`gW ?]^d U;v Wxlqi}W rd?dfd U Woi}fN`^pAhafX]mb ` n W v WW T U ]ml?`mbrÚ f Dlqdb a]^`g]^d{pX]g U d U f WW v Q}W rfNXki W
(88) h}leb deW n Jf v Apd U W W
(89) dedeW v b iai v f*tA]^XÜb*a]g`^]^d{pi v fNi}W v de]gW lZf*zb h /4XWd U f n 0W l{i W / r]mb `^`gp] b#i v fNi}W v `gp v W}haW n XW l U ]cl _lqW n0¡© WhaW v b*`b*h}b `^pjlq]mlz fN_j` n v W _a] v Wd U b*dßb*`^` deW r U ha]crb*` v W l{_a`^d l b v WZW v ]}W n b*`clqf?]gd Uv W lqi}W rd"df "© l5d U WZi v W lqWhAd"i}b*i}W v ]cl b ` v Wxb n p v b d U W v dW r U ha]mr
(90) b*`B W U bxW¡hafNdzd v ]^W n defi}W v Jf v Xd U ]cl . Y. .
(91) Nf d U W vv W lqi}W rd lf_ v b h}b*`gpal{]mllq_(*0W v lß v fNX d U WÜleb*XkWl U f v drfX]^ha lbld U Wi v W/ Q]gfN_}lZi}b i}W v lfhd U Wklq_jAweW rd hf v n W v def rfNh}rsWhQd v b deWfNhd U W#`gfArÚ A]^hj a W ]^Wf_ v W lqd]^XHb deW lzbNllq_aXk]^ha Hd U b*dd U WWtjbNrdßlqfN`g_ade]gfNh ]mllq_ Hr]gWhAde`^p)l{XffNd U © lZ]^d]ml Ahaf ?h d U b d#d U W)l U W
(92) `^` i v fNj`^WXHl U bWH f_ah n b v p `mbpW v lf* n ] *®W v W
(93) hQdo`^Wha d U ler
(94) b*`^Wxl Ya45d U ]ml bNllq_aXijde]^fh]ml hjfNd?W v p v W b*`g]mlqd]mr ! _ad?bl W U bWbl{db*j`^WXWd U f n Qd U WZd v W b deXWhAd"f* d U W¡ f_ah n b v p`cbpW v l l U f_a` n }W n fhaWZApbi v fNi}W v XWxl Uv W}hjWXWhAd"b*h n d U ]ml"]ml bi v %f / a`^W
(95) X f b*iai v f tQ]gXHb*d]^fhd U Wf v p T U Wza]g N NWxlqd l U f v d rfNX]gha ZJf v d U W?XWd U f n Wzi v W l{WhAd b*h n b `mlqfJf v d U WZXWd U f n l"d U b d U bW}WWhHXHb d U W
(96) XHb*d]mrb `^`Àpolqde_ n ]^W n ]^hi v WA]^fN_l5 f v jl A*Y a
(97) BN]cl8d U b d"d U Wp n fhafd"i W v Jf v X i v fNi}W v `^p U Whd U W
(98) pb v W¡b*iaij`^]^W n defXW
(99) X v b haW n fNXk]^h}b deW n l U W`g`ml Wh}rsWQ Wb v Wolqd]^`g` 4b v v fX U bA]^ha d U Wol U W`^`W`gWXWhAd $ © hfN_ad`^]ghaW?f*,d U Wzi}b*i}W v ]cl(bNl(JfN`^`gf zl hd U WhjWtQd lqW rd]^fh W¡lqi}W r]ÀJpfN_ v hjfNdb de]gfNh v W b v n ]^ha d U W n ] *®W v WhQd]mb ` WfNXW
(100) d v p f* l U W
(101) `^`¡lq_ v 4bNrW l h \W rsde]^fh ± W v W r
(102) b*`^`zd U W Zb* U n ]Ml U W`^`Xkf n W`b h n N]gWZd U WW _}b*d]^fh}l ]^h)d U W}Wh n ]gha n fNX]gh}b*dW n rblqWod U b d W JfAr_}lfNh h d U WHhaW
(103) tQdd{ f lqWxrde]gfNh}l WH]^hAd v f n _}rW b*h n b*h}b `^pjlqW)dq f;}ha]gdeW;W
(104) `^WXW
(105) hQd Jf v X#_a`cb*d]^fNhlArf vv W l{i}fNh n ]gha df n ] *®W v WhAd?r U f]mrW l"f*"d U Wolqd b*a]g`^]^xb*de]gfNhH W
(106) ]^ U dl T U Wh ]^h\W rsde]^fh)Qa W ]^WhQ_jXW v ]crb*` v W lq_a`gdl fadb ]^haW n ?]^d U d U W l{WXkWd U f n l ]^hH}Wh}r U XHb v rfNXkia_adb de]gfNh}l ]^h}b `^`^p * W?r`gflqW d U W?ib*i}W v ?]gd U b hb*iai}Wh n ]^to]^h U ]cr U W i v f W?l{fNXW v W l{_a`^d l f* n ] *®W v WhAde]mb `0 WfNXW
(107) d v pd U b*d? W U bW_}l{W n ]^hHfN_ v b*hb*`^pjlq]cl . h. ;') * + Z# ( )(5
(108) # ?W _lqW?d U Wzr`mblelq]crb*` v Wi v W lqW
(109) hQd b*de]gfNhof*d U Wzl U W`^`A NWfXWd v pbNl n W lr v ]g}W n ]^h *Y T U _}l d U Wkl U W`^` X] n / lq_ v 4bNrsW]mlr U b v bNrsdeW v ]^W n Ap bXHb iH U ]mr U ]clbHfNhaW/4def%/BfhaWHXHb*ijia]^ha v f X Zb*h fNi}Wh n fNXHb ]^hf
(110) (]ghQdf ?]^`g`" WÜbNlel{_aXW n def;}WHbllqXffd U bl v W _a] v W n ªJ]^hi v brde]crW ª ¬e¬ T U Wbrde_}b `®lq_ v 4bNrWz W n WhafdeWzQp¡] W ª ¬ W rfNhlq] n W v bl U W
(111) `^`f*_aha]ÀJf v Xd U ]crÚ AhaW ll | W b v n ]^ha )d U Wkrfh}rWiad lb*h n _}b hQd]^de]gW lZf*Dd U W n ] *®W v W
(112) hQd]mb*` NWfXWd v p;f zlq_ v 4bNrsW l d U b dZ Wo_}lqW]gh;d U ]mlZl{de_ n p0 W b* b*]^h v WsJW v df Y 8Jf v }fNd U n W}ha]gde]gfNh}lZb h n hafdb*d]^fh f WW v (?]^d U bA]^W defXÜb* A]^ha W _}b*d]^fNhl Xf v W)rfXi}bNrsd Wb*`clqfXÜb* WH_}lqW)f* d U Wkb*`gdeW v h}b*dWhafdb*d]^fhòAp U ]cr U l{_ v 4brWdWh}lqf v lob v W v Wi v W lqW
(113) hQdW n Ap`^W
(114) dedeW v lZ?]^d U b hQ_jX#}W v f*_ah n W v b v lW _}b*`?dfd U W] v f v n W v h i}b v de]mrs_a`mb v blerb `mb v ]cl n WhafdeW n Qp b;l{]^Xia`gW`gWdedW v ]gd U d U ]mlZhafdb*d]^fh"bdWh}lqf v ]mlrfh}lq] n W v W n bl]^h n W
(115) i W
(116) h n WhAdf*zd U W d{pQi}WªBrsf*b v ]mb hQd"f v rsfNhAd v bb v ]mb hQds¬f*M]gdl v Wi v WxlqWhAdb de]^fh}l(]^hd U WZrs_ v A]^`g]^haW b v rsff v n ]^h}b deW lqpjlqdWX(b h n d v b h}l Jf v X]gha fNhaW)l{Wdf*orsfNXi}fNhjWhQd l]ghQdf b*hafd U W v ]mll{]^Xij`^p n fhaWHQp _}lq]gha d U Wd v b h}l Jf v XHb de]^fhJf v X_a`mbl T U _}l W?]g`^`® v ]^dW ! " ! ! " ! $ # ! " ! # ! " ! &%. °.
(117) W v W ! G b v W d U WZrsf*b v ]mb hQd lq_ v 4bNrWz}bNl{WZW rdf v l(b*h n ! ~ ]ml"d U WrsfNhAd v bb v ]mb hQd }bNl{W © lq]^hjN `^W n fNd??]g`^` n WhafdeWZd U Wl{]^Xia`gWZrsfNhAd v brde]gfNhfi}W v b def v ¯ .
(118)
(119)
(120)
(121) !
(122) ! % % % ! " ! ! " ! % % %
(123).
(124) . . . . U W v W bNl?brfN`gfNh n WhjfNdeWxlb n f_aa`gWrsfNhAd v brde]gfNh¯ ¯ % T U WXWd v ]mrdeWh}l{f v Jf v d U Wlq_ v 4bNrsW W n WhafNdWQp ! b*h n d U W l{W rfNh n b*h n d U ] v n n ª !¯ ¬ v W l{i}W rde]gW`^p J_ah n b XWhAdb `Jf v XHl?b v W n WhjfNdeW n A p b h f v b#l{W rfh n /4f v n W v dWh}l{f v a W n W}haWd U Wd v b h}lqi}f lq]^d]^fhb*h n lqpAXXW
(125) d v pofNi}W v b*def v l bNl JfN`g`^f zl " $. ! " ! # " ª ¬ ª % ¬ %. WZhjWtQdDrfNhlq] n W v n ] *®W v WhAde]cb*`}fNi}W v b*df v l T U WZ v b n ]gWhQd f* bdeWhlqf v ]ml"fNad b*]^hjW n Qp db Q]gha d U Worf b v ]mb hQd n W v ]^b de]^Wßb*h n b njn ]^ha fNhjW]^h n Wt & '. ')( . &. . ! . ! ( ! " ! '+*. . b*h n d U W n g] W v Wh}rWzApHrfNhAd v bNrd]^ha d U W v b n ]gWhQd?fh;d U W`mbNl{d?d{ f]^h n ]mrWxl n ]^, ( n ]g ( ! % f v bklq_ v 4bNrWo]^hAdeW v b*`Mf W . v - 0bklq_a n fXHb*]gh;f* Z} Wo_}lqWod U WJf`^`^f ?]gha rsfNXi}brd hafNd b*d]^fNh /0 /0 '2143 ' ª 5 ¬ 6 ! 1 5 1 % . Wob `mlqf v ]^dW / 7 / 7 '1!8 ' ª 95 ¬ 1!8 Jf v b*h]ghQdW v b*`}b `^fNhj br_ v )W :?]^d U ª 1!8 ¬ ! 1 1 ]gd U d U ]ml(hafdb de]^fh< ;¡b _}lel / 0 / = 0 d U W
(126) f v W
(127) X v W b n l n ]^. 143 . > 1!8 ª4 ¬. .
(128) U W v W > m] l8d U W?_aha]gd(fN_ad{Db v n haf v XHb `B ]^hd U W?db*hj NWhAde]cb*`aia`cb*haW Ndefd U W? f_ah n b v p ª - ¬ v fNX d U ]cl d U Z W JfN`g`^f ?]^hj ; v WWhJf v X#_j`mbNl b v W n W v ]gW n / 0 /= 0 / 0. & '2143 ª > ¬ ' 1!8 ª n ]g ¬ '143 ª4 ¬ / = 0. /0 ". /90. ¯ & 143 ª > ¬ 1!8 ª n ]^ ¬ 143 % ª4 ±¬ f v fN_ v b*h}b `^pjlq]ml]^d?]^`g`(}WHrfhQWhj]^WhAddf;_}l{WHlqi}W rs]mb*`"haf v XHlJf v \ fN}fN`gWl{i}bNrsW l f*deWhlqf v l Mdq f#
(129) W v %f /Bf v n W v dWh}l{f v .l
(130) kb*h n ' b v W]gh ª - ¬" W n Ws}haWd U W e]^hAd v ]^h}l{]mr$ 0 / 0 ]^hahjW v /4i v f n _}rdzb*h n haf v X .
(131) ' 0
(132) ' 143 0 ' * ' '
(133) % T U ]mlZhaW
(134) jh f v X ]clZW _j]^b*`gWhQdzdefHd U W v W N_j`mb v ª - ¬ /4haf v X rÚ Y ±" kW b*`clqfHWtAdeWh n. d U ]cl n W }hj]^de]gfNhHdef U ]^ U W v f v n W v ed Wh}l{f v 0 l?b*h n v ]^dW . .
(135) . /0. . .
(136) 143 0 / 0 " 140 3 . ¯. %. W b*`clqf n W
(137) hafNdWd U W rf vv W l{i fh n ]gha Hhaf v XHl Ap * b*h n d U W lqW rb*h}Wl U f ?hdef}W W _a]^b*`gWhAd0defzd U W v W N_j`mb v ª - ¬ /Bhjf v X f ®b*hApf*}d U W v Wi v W lqW
(138) hQd b*de]gfNh}l0f }d U W lqW5 deWh}l{f v l´]gh rf b v ]cb*hAd8f v rsfNhAd v bb v ]mb hQdrfNXki fhaWhAdl Y ±" ]^hb*`^`gp W ]^hAd v f n _}rW haW ª - ¬ /Bhaf v XHl 0 0 0 d Uav fN_a U ' . 5 * 0 ' 5 * . *0 *. %. %. &. '. &. *0 * %. | xW rb*`g`^]^hj Zd U W v W
(139) `mb*d]^fh}l U ]gi#}Wd{ WWhrf b v ]mb*hAd b*h n v W _a`mb v n W v ]^b*d]^W ls*]gd"]ml"r`^Wxb v d U b d d U ]cl#haWãhaf v X ]clb* b*]^h~W _j]^b*`gWhQddef d U W lqd b*h n b v n 5 ª - ¬ /4haf v X f* d U Wd U WdWh / lqf v l?]^hHb hQp v Wi v W lqWhAdb de]gfNh l{]^ha U ]^ U W v /4f v n W v rf b v ]mb*hAd n ] *0W v WhAde]cb*de]gfNhAd U W v WZ]cl haf n ] Ür_a`gd{p]^h)lq]gX]^`cb v `gp n Ws}ha]^hj #]ghQd v ]^hlq]mr /Bhaf v XHlZª ¬Db*h n W lqd b*a`g]ml U ]^ha d U Worf v / v W l{i}fNh n ]gha ;Wx_a]gb*`^W
(140) h}rWi v fNi}W v d]^W l f v b `^`"haf v X b*h n ]^hahjW v /4i v f n _}rdl{]^ h}l( W#?]g`^` fNX]gd"d U W n fXHb*]gh;l{_a}lr v ]giad? U WhHd U W n fNXHb ]^h)rfNhlq] n W v W n ]cl ]gdlqW
(141) ` . ') oD
(142) 5
(143) #) $(') ) . T U Wzl U W`^`aXkf n W`A Wzrfh}lq] n W v d U Wzlqf%/{rb `^`gW n ¡b* U n ]aXf n W
(144) `BN]cl8f*,d U W | W]mllqhaW v / y;]^h n `g]^h d{pQi}Wa] W ]gd?]^h}rs`^_ n Wxl d U WW*®W rdzf*Dl U Wxb v n WJf v XHb*d]^fh}rÚ ±°Q®°Q®°N²Q®°NaM(b h n d U W v WJW v Wh}rsW l d U W v W]gh T U W_aha Ahaf ?h}lb v W ª ¬0d U W n ]clqia`cbNrWXkWhQdDb*dW br U i f]^hAd f*d U WX] n / lq_ v 4bNrW n W rfXi}fl{W n ]^hAdefdb ha NW
(145) hQd]mb*`,b*h n d v b*h}l{W v l{Wib v d lª v W l{i}W rde]gW`^p b v l{d /4f v n W v b*h n W v %f /Bf v n W v l{_ v 4brW dWh}lqf v ¬ Nb h n bNl8d U W( v l{d /4f v n W v deWh}l{f vMv Wi v W l{WhQd]^ha ³.
(146) d U W v Nf d b*de]gfNhf Mb }}W v haf v XHb `QdfZd U W?X] n / lq_ v 4bNrsW]ghd U W?_ah n WJf v XW n rfhQ} N_ v b*d]^fh Wz`^W
(147) d 5 b*h n Wblelq_jXWd U b*d d U W¡ f_ah n b v pHrsfNh n ]gde]gfNh}l"fNh ª ¬ ª 5 ¬¡b v W N]^W
(148) h lqfHd U b d Q ª ¬?]mlZd U Wi}b v df* d U W}f_ah n b v p b*`^fha H U ]mr U d U Wl U W`g`(]ml J_a`^`gpr`cb*Xi}W n ªÎ] W ²A ² ¬b*h n ª 5 ¬Md U Wzi}b v d U W v Wzb*`g` n ]ml{ia`mbrWXWhAdlb v Wz`^WJd v WW T U Wi v fNa`gWX%]ml i}fl{W n ]^hHd U W n fXHb*]gh Gb*h n W n WhaWd U W n ]ml{ia`mbrWXWhAd lqi}brW Ap }ª
(149)
(150) ¬ 5 ª ¬ 5 ª ¬
(151) ² b h n ² fh % T U Wb v ]cb*d]^fNhb*`0Jf v X#_j`mb*d]^fhd U W
(152) h v W b n l "° B¯8h n ª ¬ lq_}r U . . /. /. ª / ¬}¯ ¯ ª
(153) ¬ 1432% ª 0 ¬}¯/ ¯ ª
(154) Q ¬ 143 % ª ¬ ª
(155) ¬ 143
(156) 143. W v WZd U WXHb deW v ]mb ` i v Nf i}W v de]gW l?b v W N]gWhApd U Wd{ fdeWh}l{f v l !" Aªe % >}$¬ # ! ! ! " % ! " ! ! % > >. . . . . ª
(157) ¬ !!. !%"'&. . ª4± ¬ %. . Qª % > ¬ ! b*h n n W
(158) hafNdWd U W}Wh n ]gha a}XWX v b*haW¡b*h n l U W b v l{d v b ]^h)deWh}l{f v l v Wxlqi}W rd]^W`gp0¯ ª ¬ $ ª & ¬ $ ª & ¬ % ª , ¬ $ ª & ¬ ª ¬ & % % % Wob `mlqf v Wxrb*`g`d U b d) b*h n b v Wd U Wl{pQXkXWd v ]gr dWh}lqf v lzrf vv W l{i}fNh n ]gha df#d U WolqW rfh n b*h n d U ] v n J_jh n b*XkWhQd b*`}Jf v XÜl f*d U Wolq_ v 4bNrsW v W l{i}W rde]gW`^p Wob*`clqf v ]gdeWZW _}b de]^fh ªB± *¬ ]^hHd U Wl U f v deW v Jf v X¯ ª4± ¬ ( ª )
(159) ¬ % *ª )
(160) + ¬ ª
(161) Q ¬ / ?]^d U ( ª )
(162) ¬ ª ¬}¯ ¯ ª
(163) ¬ 143 ª4± ±¬ / / b*h n ) 4 1 2 3 % *ª
(164) + ¬ ª 0 ¬}¯ ¯ ª
(165) Q ¬ ª ¬ ª
(166) ¬ 143 % ª4± YA¬ . Xkia`^]cr]^d ]^hd U W#_}l{Wf* bl U W`g`(Xf n W`]mld U WbNllq_aXijde]^fhd U b*dd U Wl U W
(167) `^`(]cl $*d U ]^h $ Wh}rsW?]^d]clÜWxlelqW
(168) hQd]mb*`¡def l{de_ n p U f d U Wl{fN`^_jde]^fh }W U bxWxlÜ]gh d U W`^]gX]^d U Wh d U W d U ]crÚ AhaW ll -, ² T U ]ml`g]^X]gd? W U bQ]gf v ]mlW v p n ] *®W v WhAd n Wi}Wh n ]^ha HfNh d U W NWfXWd v p.
(169).
(170) f*d U Wol U W`^`,b*h n d U W f_ah n b v p)rfh n ]^d]^fh}l?b*h nHn W
(171) i W
(172) h n l?]^hHbr v _}r]cb*`0DbpªBrÚ YY}QY°a °Aa}±Naj±³J¬"fNh;d U Wolq_alqi}brW ª
(173) ¬ *ª
(174) )
(175) ¬ ² rfNhlq]ml{de]gha f*"d U W n ]ml{ia`mbrWXW
(176) hQd8W` n l ?]gd U b*ha]cl U ]gha kl U W b v b h n XWX v b haW¡lqd v b*]gh}l . hkd U ]cl5i}b i W v WzfNha`gprfh}lq] n W v d U Wr
(177) bNlqW U W
(178) hd U Wßl U W`g`}]ml lb*] n df}W]^hkb
(179)
(180)
(181)
(182) Q T U ]ml ]ml d U WorbNl{W U Whª4rÚ YNY}®a}±³J¬ " !Aª ² ² ¬ # % T U Whd U Wz`^]^Xk]^dMi v fa`^WX ]cl5fadb ]^haW n Qpblelq_jX]^ha od U Wz`^f b n ]gha defo}WZ N]gWh#Ap $ ?]^d U $ ]gh n Wi}Wh n WhQdMf*d U W?d U ]mr QhjW lel hod U WDlqW _aW`A W d U W v WJf v W?l{de_ n pod U W"JfN`g`^f ?]^ha i v fa`^W
(183) X " % ¯ & ª ¬ ()
(184) ' ( ª )
(185) + ¬ % +* *kª )
(186) ¬ ", ª
(187) Q ¬ ª
(188) ¬ % ª4± °¬. W v WZ W]^hAd v f n _}rW n d U WhafNd b*d]^fNh-,ª ¬ % ª $ À¬ v fNX " b*h n
(189) ( W Ahaf d U b*d
(190) ,Jf v b*hAp . ²Q % " U blbÜ_jha]m_aWlqf`^_ad]^fhi v f%/ Q] n W n d U b*dd U W n ]mlqd v ]ga_adeW n Jf v rW}" W
(191) ` n $ ]cl]^h b*h b*iai v fNi v ]mb deW lqi}brW?lbxp ª ¬ _ v d U W v Xkf v W Nbl MdeW
(192) h n l(defW v fa % rb*h}WZl{WWhbl5bolqd b*h n b v n i}Wh}b*`gd{pi v fa`^WX T U W `^]gX]^d(i v fNj`^WX % ]cl n W}haW n bl¯ % ' ¯ & ª ¬ (/)
(193) ( ª )
(194) ¬ 0,ª
(195) ¬ ª
(196) + ¬ % ª4± ¬ T U W;dW v X `^]gX]^doi v fa`^WX $]mlzwe_}l{de]W n l{]^h}rW bl , ²A ]^drb h2}Wl U f ?h d U b d d U Wl{fN`g_ade]gfNh ª ¬Df* % " rfhQW v NWxlZlqd v fNhj N`^p]gh defHd U WlqfN`g_ade]gfNh ª ¬zf* % ªBrÚ
(197) ±QaY² J¬ . h)d U W b*iai v f tQ]gXHb*d]^fh;f* ia`cb*dWi v fNa`gWXHl ]^d U blßf JdeWh)de_ v haW n f_adZdefk W b n b hQd b / NWf_}l?def_}lqWobX]^tAW n Jf v X_a`mb de]^fhArÚ Q
(198) ²a}N² T U ]ml?]ml d U Wob*iai v fbr U d U b d W_}l{W U W v WZbl W`g` Wh}rW W n W}hjWbNl haW
(199) _aha Ahaf ?h}l?lqd v W ll Nb v ]cb*a`gW l n _b*`0dfd U Wßlqd v b*]gh}l ]^hd U W?b v ]cb*d]^fNhb*`QJf v X_a`mb de]^fhª4± °¬ ! p 1 W n W
(200) hafNdW?d U Wzl{pQXXkWd v ]mr8XW
(201) X v b haW(Jf v rsW deWhlqf v W v Wo W n Wi}b v d v fNX%d U W_}lq_}b `8hjfNdb de]gfNhr | WXHb v ± }W`gf T U W l U W b v Jf v rW; W n WhjfNdeW)Q3 p 2 T U W lqW b v W rsfNhahaWxrdeW n dfd U W)XWX v b haWkb*h n l U W b v lqd v b*]gh}l d Uav fN_a U d U WorfNh}l{de]gde_ad]^WZW _}b de]^fh}l ¯ ª 0 ¬ 1 ª4± ³¬ ª ¬ % 2 ª4±
(202) ¬ . . . . .
(203) T U W?l{pQXXkWd v ]mr0}Wh n ]^ha zXfXWhAd dWh}l{f v ]mlhafNdMdb WhobNl(b h]^h n Wi}Wh n W
(204) hQd_ahj Qhaf ?h a_ad? W_lqWd U WZJf`^`^f ?]gha b*a v WA]mb de]^fhH}bNl{W n fh;d U W}Wh n ]^ha rsfNh}l{de]^d_ade]gWZW _}b*d]^fh¯ ª ¬
(205) ¯ ª ¬ % ª4± ¬ ! p#]ghQd v f n _r]^ha " ª 1 2 ¬ ! ª ¬ # ª ¬ bNlhaW
(206) _aha Ahaf ?h}lb*h n Ap v ]gde]^hj d U W)rfh}lqd]^de_jde]^WW _}b*d]^fh}lª4±
(207) ¬ob*h n ªB± ¬]^h b W b #Jf v X WfNjdb*]ghb h;W _a]^b `^WhAd eX]gtQW n $ßJf v X#_j`mb*d]^fhf*d U Wi v fNa`gWX¯ " ¯ & ª 1 2 ¬ (/)
(208) ª 1 2 )
(209) ¬ ,ª
(210) Q ¬ ª
(211) ¬ ªB± ²¬ ?]^d U d U WhaW a]^`g]^haWxb v Jf v XHl n W}haW n d Uav f_a U ª 1 2 )
(212) ¬ ( ª )
(213) ¬ % ª
(214) .
(215) ª 1 2 ) ¬ b*h n . ª
(216) ) ¬. ) 1 2 ¬ % ª ) ¬. /. ª ª
(217) Q ¬}¯ % ª
(218) ¬ ¬ 143 / ) ª1 2 ¬ ª1 ¯ ¯ % 2 ¬ 143 . W v WZ W_}l{Wd U WhafNd b*d]^fNh. %. !" % > # ! ! ! " % ! " ! ! % > > ! ! !" & Qª % > ¬ ! % T U WolqW rsfNh n f v n W v dWh}l{f v ]ml?d U W]^hAW v lqWZf ªÎ] W . . !. ¬ U W v W bl . ]ml?l{_}r U d U *b d
(219) QJf v b*hApHd{ flqpAXXW
(220) d v ]gr dWh}lqf v l b*h n ¯ ¯ ¯ % ªB± N ¬ ]^h}b `^`gp5 W v W r
(221) b*`^`?d U b*dH_}l{]^ha d U W lqpAXXWd v p f*od U W lqW rsfNh n f v n W v deWh}l{f v lZb h n d U W ; v W
(222) Wh#Jf v X#_j`mbNlzªB ¬Db*h n ªB ±¬ad U WJfN`g`^f ?]^ha ]ghQdW v b*d]^fNhHApi}b v dl Jf v X#_j`mbNl"b v W fNad b*]ghaW n /0 /0 /0 n n ]g ª ¬
(223) 143 4 1 3 4 1 3 % ¯ / 0 ª
(224) ¬ ]^ / = 0 ªB± ¬ / = 0 % ª ¯ª ¬e¬
(225) 143% ª > ¬ 1!8 ªeª ¬ > ¬
(226) 1!8 ².
(227) / 0. ¯ ª
(228) Q ¬. b*h n. 1. / 0. 143. / 0. / 0. n ]g. 1
(229) 143. / 0. . / 0. ª ¯1 ¬ / 0.
(230). . 143 %. ª1. > / = 0. ¬.
(231) 1!8. ªB± ±¬. ¯ ª
(232) ¬ 2 ª2 > ¬
(233) 1!8 % ªB± YA¬ ª 2 ¬ 2
(234) + fN`g`^W rd]^ha od U WxlqWZJf v X#_a`cbNl" N]^Wxl /0 /0 /0 ¯ / 0 ª
(235) + ¬ 1432% 1 ¯ ª
(236) Q ¬ / 140 3 % 2 ¯ ª
(237) ¬ 143 /0 ª n ]g 2 ¬ 143 ª n ]^ ª1 / = 0 ¬ 2 ¬
(238) 143 ª > ¬ 1!8 ªB± °¬ / = 0 ª n ]g 2 % ¯
(239) ª 1 ¬e¬
(240) / 14= 320 % % ªeª 1 ¬ > ¬
(241) 1!8 % ª2 > ¬
(242) 1!8 % Wh}rW v W r
(243) b*`^`g]^ha d U Wrfh}lqd]^d_ade]gWWx_}b de]gfNh}lªB± ³¬ }ª4± ¬Zi v fNj`^WX % " N]gW l#d U W JfN`g`^f ?]^ha Wx_}b de]gfNh}l f "W _a]^`g]^ v ]^_aX n ]g 2 ² ªB± ¬ n ]^ ª 1 ¬ 2 % $ ² ªB± *³¬ n ]^ 2 % ¯ª 1 ¬ % $ ² ªB±
(244) ¬ ]^hHd U W n fNXHb ]^h Z}b h n d U Wh}b*d_ v b `8}fN_jh n b v p)rfNh n ]^de]gfNh}l > ² ªB± ¬ ª 1 ¬ > ² ªB± N²¬ 2 > ² ªB± Q ¬ fNhHd U Wß v WW}fN_ah n b v p 5 . hd U Wob*}f WW _b*de]gfNh}l?d U W_}b hQd]^d{p (£ òj ªB± N¬ 1 1 ]ml(d U WZdeWhlqf v fNad b*]ghaW n Qp]ghQdW v b*d]^ha od U WZd Uav W
(245) W / n ]^XWhlq]^fh}b*`AXWX v b*haWDlqd v W lel{W l5f W v d U W l U W`g`d U ]crÚ AhaW ll
(246) rÚ W Na
(247) *Y} ±N°A °N lq_}b `^`^pzd U ]ml0]mlr
(248) b*`^`gW n d U W(XWX v b*haW0Jf v rW f v n W l{]^ ha]^ha kblqdb a`^WXW
(249) d U f n ]^dzl{WWXHl"Xf v WZi v bNrd]mrb `def]^hAd v f n _}rWd U Wb v ]mb a`^ W 1 n v v v U v b*h hafd 1 Abl b*hkhaW2_jha Qhjf*?h f lq]^Xkia`^]cr]^d{pZ W WJW df 1 bNl(d WXW
(250) X# b*haW(Jf v rW 143. 2. 143 %.
(251) 143. n ]^. / = 0. 143 %. . . N.
(252) $% " 5
(253) # $ ') W¡_}lqWobßha]^dWZW`^W
(254) XWhAd(i}b v de]gde]^fha]^hj f* ]^hAdef lqd v b*]g U d / lq] n W n d v ]mb*hj N`^Wxl f v _}b n v ] / `mb deW v b*`ml Zb de_ v b*`g`^p}d U Woi}b v de]gde]^fha]^hj ]mlZblel{_aXW n defHlb*de]cl Jp)d U Wo_}lq_}b ` v W
(255) N_a`cb v ]gd{p;b h n rfNXki}b*d]^a]g`^]^d{pHrsfNh n ]gde]gfNh}ls(rÚ Ya(³AY T U W n ]mb XWdeW v f*¡b hW`^W
(256) XWhAd W n WhafdeWzQp ¡Qb h n W`gW d XÜb* t
(257) ! p W n WhafdeWzd U W¡rf`^`^Wxrde]gfNhf*,W n W l ]^h d U WkXW l U (b*h n Q p d U Wk`^Wha d U f*ßb*hW n NW T U Wk`^WddeW v l : b*h n b v W U Wh}rsWJf v d U _lqW n def n WhafNdW NWhjW v ]crlqd v ]crde`gpi}f lq]^d]^W rfNh}l{db hQd l]^h n Wi}Wh n WhAdzf*?}fd U zb*h n U ]mr U b v Wb*`g`^f W n defd b* W n ] *0W v WhAdb `^_aW l¡b*d n ] *®W v WhAdfArrs_ vev Wh}rW lzWtarsWiad U Wh)b*iji Wxb v ]gha ?]^d U ]gh n ]mrsW l Wd b*h n }W}ha]gdeWoW`^WXkWhQd l{_a}lqibNrW lZf b h n v Wxlqi}W rd]^W`gp ?© Xk]^tAW n }ha]gdeWW`gWXWhAd?X" Wd U f n f*Dd U W r`cbNllq]mr
(258) b*` $Hlb nan `gW#i}f]^hAdd{pAi}W# fN_a` n }W}bNl{W n fhd U W Jf v X#_a`cb*d]^fNh aA]^ " ¯ & ª 1 2 ¬ ()
(259) ª 1 2 )
(260) ¬ 0, ª
(261) ¬ ª
(262) ¬ % ªJY ¬. dMb iai}W b v l n ] Hr_j`^ddef n W l{]^ hb¡lqdb a`^W(}hj]^deW"W`gWXWhAd}XWd U f nn ] v W rde`gpbNlqW n fNhd U ]ml Jf v X#_a`cb*d]^fNh # Wh}rsW* W JfN`g`^f b*hkb*iai v fbr U d U b*d U bl d_ v hjW n fN_addef}W v _a]gdqJ_a`Jf v d U W v W`cb*dW n }W b XAb v r U b h n ia`mb deWZi v fNj`^WXHlsArÚ NaaANAYQ³ T U Wob*iai v f tQ]gXHb*d]^fhlr U W
(263) XW Wi v fNi}f lqW]ml n W v ]gW n v fNX ªJY *¬oQp b nan ]^ha W]g U deW n `^W blqd / le_}b v W 0l /Bd{pAi W)deW v XHlZf* d U WW _a]^`g]^ v ]^_aX%W _}b de]^fh}l#ª4± ¬ }ª4±
(264) ¬ b*h n d U WkrfNhlqde]gde_ad]^W v W`cb*d]^fNhl ª4± ³N¬ ªB±
(265) ¬ . h2f v n W v def lq]gXia`^]ÀJpd U W;i v W l{WhQd b*d]^fNh f*f_ v XW
(266) d U f n " W)]^hAd v f n _}rW)d U W) W]g U deW n ]^hahjW v /4i v f n _}rd
(267) '
(268) ' ªJY ¬
(269) ?]^d U b h}b*`gfN fN_}l n W}ha]gde]^fh}lJf vU ]^ U W v f v n W v deW
(270) h}lqf v l _ v d U W v 5]gh bNrrsf v n b*h}rW)?]^d U ªB± ¬ b h n ª4± N¬ W]ghQd v f n _}rsWd U WhafNd b*d]^fNh 1 ª
(271) ¬ ª
(272) ¬ % ªJY ±¬ «_ v v l{dZl{db*j]^`^]gW n XkWd U f n ?]^`^`®haf G}W n W}haW n blDJf`^`gf*zls¯ " ¯ & ª 1 2 ¬ (/)
(273) ª 1 2 )
(274) ¬ , ª
(275) + ¬ ª
(276) ¬ ªJY YA¬ U WvW ª ' 8 )
(277) ¬ ª ' 8 )
(278) ¬ % 3 ª ' 8 )
(279) ¬ % 3 ª ' 8 )
(280) ¬ ªJY °¬ . . . .
(281) ?]^d U bl{db a]^`g]^]gha deW v X f v ]g N]^hb*de]gha v fNX d U WW _a]^`g]^ v ]^_aX Wx_}b de]gfNh}l 3 ª ' 8 )
(282) ¬ ª' ¬ 8 n ]^ ª
(283) ¬ 5 n ]g n ]g 1 ª ' ¬ 8 n ]^ 1 ª
(284) ¬ n ]g 8 % ¯ 1 ª' ¬ n ]^ % ¯ 1 ª
(285) ¬ b*h n fNhaWZ v fNXd U WorfNh}l{de]gde_ad]^WZW _}b de]^fh}l 3 ª ' 8 )
(286) / ¬ / # ª ' ¬ ¯ & ¯ ¯ # ª
(287) Q ¬ ¯ & 143 % ª ' ¬ 8 ª
(288) ¬ 143 % T U W v ]g U d U b*h n lq] n W]ml n WhaW n bNl , Nª
(289) ¬ ,ª
(290) Q ¬ % $ n ]^ 1 ª
(291) ¬ $ n ]^ % ¯ 1 ª
(292) ¬ % % 5 T U Whaf v X _}l{W n Jf v d U W n ]ml{ia`mbrWXW
(293) hQd ]mld U WXf n ]À}W n ª ¬ /Bhaf v X d U b*d Q]gfN_}l{`^p n W}hjW n a] W . ªJY ¬. ªJY ³¬. ªJY
(294) ¬.
(295) + 5
(296) 5.
(297) 5 . %. 5. 5 % %. f v d U W l{d v W lel{W la W_lqWob n ]mler v WdWZhaf v X n WhaW n Qp . " * . ?]^d U ]^hAdeW v ]^f v $deW v XHl.
(298). . .
(299) . . * . b*h n mwe_aXki $dW v XHl. . . %. .
(300) . .
(301) .
(302) . . . . %. n ]^ * /. . %. >.
(303) . %. %. . >. 5. ªJY ¬ ªÎY ²¬. . n ]g. % . . . 1!8. Wi v W/. 5. ¯ * . 5. . ªÎY N ¬ ªÎY ¬. U W v W ,lqd b*h n l?Jf v d U W we_aXiHf "d U W _b*hAde]^d{p]À(d U WW n NW]ml?]^h)d U W]ghQdW v ]gf v }b h n J f v d U Wo_}b*hAde]gd{p#]gdlqW
(304) `M]]^d ]ml fh 5 ]^h}b `^`gp W`^Wd 5.
(305) " *
(306) 5 % " * % ªÎY ±¬ WZ}W ]^hf_ v b*hb*`^pjlq]cl Qphj" fNde]gha d U WrfNhlq]ml{deWhrp#f Jf v X#_a`cb*d]^fNh " ?]gd Uv W lqi}W rd defd U WorfNhAde]ghQ_af_}l i v fNa`gWX ±.
(307) £(" (
(308) $ ª ¬
(309)
(310) Nª 1 2 )
(311) ¬ , Nª
(312) ¬ . . +. ª . ª
(313) ¬. . . . ( . 1 2. ¬. . . ªÎY YA¬. %. ] v lqd W)hafNdWd U b d n _aW)defd U Wblelq_jXiade]gfNh $ ª ¬ d U W _}b hQd]^d{p ª 1 2 )
(314) ¬ ]ml W`^` n Ws"}haW n Jf v b*`g`"ª
(315) ¬ T U W v WsJf v W a_}lq]gha d U W)rfhQd]^hA_afN_l Jf v X_a`mb de]^fh "d U W)W _j]^`^]g v ]g_aX W _}b*d]^fh}lª4± ¬ }ª4±
(316) ¬b h n d U W rfNhlqde]gde_ad]^WZWx_}b de]gfNh}lZª4± ³¬ ªB±
(317) ¬ W n ] v W rd`^pfNad b*]^h Nª 1 2 )
(318) + ¬ ª 1 2 )
(319) + ¬ 5 n ]^ ª ¬ 2 n ]g ª
(320) ¬ n ]^ 1 ª 1 ¬ 2 n ]^ 1 ª
(321) ¬ / n ]^ 2 % ¯ 1 ª 1 ¬ n ]g % ¯ 1 ª
(322) + ¬ % ª ¬ ¯ 1 & ¯ ¯ ª
(323) a ¬ ¯ & 143 # / # % 143 ª ¬ 2 ª
(324) + ¬ ,ª
(325) Q ¬ % $ n ]^ 1 ª
(326) ¬ $ n ]^ % ¯ 1 ª
(327) ¬ % % , Nª
(328) + ¬. . ¯. . . v n W v d ffNad b*]^h)bolqdb a`^WXW
(329) d U f n W U bxWzdefl{i}W r]Jpd U W}ha]gdeWzW`^WXkWhQd ql i}brW l T f d U ]ml?Wh n W`gWdJf v ²A ª ¬ ]À ã]ml?bd v ]mb ha N`gW. ê ¬ ªÎY °¬ ª ¬ ]À ã]ml?b_}b n v ]^`cb*deW v b*`4 b*h n Jf v G Whaf n WhaW !Aª
(330)
(331) ¬
(332) 5 ª ¬ ± ªÎY ¬ b*h n ª ¬
(333) # . hkf. . . Aª ¬ !. b h n. . . £(òj . *. ª ¬ . * 5 ª ¬ . . 5 . . . . # %. ªÎY *³¬. ]^d U d U Wor U fN]mrsWf (}ha]gdeWZW`gWXWhAdllqi}brW l d U b*dz WZXHb n WAd U Wl{d v W lel{W l b v W]^hAdeW v i f`mb deW n)n ]mlrfNhAde]ghQ_af_}lq`gp;}Wd{ W
(334) Wh;W`gWXWhAdl T U ]ml]gXia`g]^W l d U b*dZd U Wp rb*h}W . . Y.
(335) W`^]gX]^hb*deW n b*dd U WHW`gWXWhAdZ`^W
(336) W`"deffNjdb*]gh bia_ v W`^p n ]ml{ia`mbrWXW
(337) hQd /B}blqW n hA_aXW v ]mrb ` ler U WXW rÚ W _}b*d]^fhª4 ±¬ W
(338) `^f . £(òj «z_ v r U fN]crWf*Drf b v ]cb*hAdZrsfNXi}fNhjWhQd lDJf v d U W n ]clqia`cbNrWXkWhQd b v ]cb*a`gW l . . b*h n *f rfhQd v bb v ]cb*hAd"fNhaW l(Jf v d U W¡lqd v W llqW lsQWh}b a`^Wxl _l5defoW lqd b*a`g]ml U WXXHb?Y YªJ_}lq]gha WXXHb © ¬ Q U ]cr U W¡haWW n Jf v i v f*A]^hj d U Wolqd b*a]g`^]gdqpf*d U WXkWd U f n® Wb v Whaf v W b n pdefHl{db*dW#f_ v XHb*]ghl{db*j]^`^]gd{p v W lq_j`^d W?]g`^`bNlel{_aXWd U b*dd U W l U W
(339) `^`0d U ]mr AhaW lel"]ml ]ghd U W v b ha NW ² a?]gd U }tAW n0 (£ (
(340) ªq\} ¬H² :
(341)
(342) + ) :
(343) + ( ªq\A¬ . ² ªq\A±¬H² * 2Y ° ªq\YA¬ ( ) (
(344) " ) (/)
(345) ª ' 8 ¬ + ª ! ¬
(346) Nª ' 8 ) ! ¬ : ' 8 " * ªÎY
(347) ¬ . . . . ! . . " *. ~ %. ªÎY ¬. ¯ Wdª' 8 ¬ }Wb v a]gd v b v p T U Wi v ff* W?]^`g`haf n ]gQ] n WZ]^hAdef d Uav WWl{deWi}l #" ] v lqd
(348) ab n ] v W rd?r
(349) b*`mrs_a`mb de]^fh N]gW l ª ' 8 ) ' / 8 ¬ / ( ª ' ) ' ¬ % ª' ¬}¯ ¯ ª' ¬ 1432% ª' ¬ ª' ¬ 143 / / % ªe 1432% ª 8 8 143 ¬ ¯ ¯ ¬ % 5 8 * n ]^ ª ' ¬ * ªÎY N²¬
(350) % n ]^ 8 * n ]^ ª' ¬ *
(351) % n ]^ 8 % ¯ * ¯ ª' ¬ * % . . .
(352) . °.
(353) W?]g`^`0_lqWd U WZJf`^`^f ?]gha ]^hAW v l{WZW l{de]^XÜb*deWxl n ]^ ª ' ¬ * : 5 ª ( ª ' ) ' ¬ % ' * ¬
(354) n ]^ ª ª ' ¬e¬ * : ª ( ª' ) ' ¬ % ' ¬ %. ªÎY Q ¬ Ϊ Y N ¬.
(355) . f v r`mb v ]gdqp ´ W#?]g`^`(Wxlqdb a`^]cl U ªJY Q *¬ßb*h n ªÎY N ¬bNlb)lqWib v b deW v W l{_a`^do]^h WXXHbY ± }W`^f Wb `ml{f U bW ¯ ª' ¬ * : ª' ¬ ªÎY N±¬ . . b*h n v fX.
(356) . WXXHb © N ¯ ( ª' ) ' ¬ lqfd U b d? W NW
(357) d . /.
(358) . ª ' ¬}¯ ¯ ª ' ¬ 143 : ª' ¬ ¯ ª' ¬ * : ( ª' ) ' ¬ %. ªÎY *YA¬ ªÎY N°¬. + fNXa]^hj]^ha oW _b*de]gfNh}lZªJY Q*¬ ªÎY N¬?b h n ªJY N °¬ ?]^d U ªÎY N ²¬} WZfadb ]^h ª' 8 ) ' 8 ¬ ªe . . % %. . %. /. . : ª' ¬}¯ ¯ ª' . 5 : 5. . . ª . . 5 . . . . ¬. . /.
(359) %
(360) . n ]^. 8 %. ) ' ¬ : ' ' ' 143 ªÎY N¬ ª ¬ ª ¬ / % ª 8 8 143 ¬ n . ¬ ( ª' /. 1432%. ¯ ¯ . 8 * . . ¬. : . %. . . 143.
(361) ¯ * %. ]g . 8. \]^hrW . Q² Y °Q}d U WW`g`^]giade]cr]^dBp v W l{_a`^d?i v f W n ]^h A0
(362) N]^Wxl ª 5 : / 5 : : ¬ ( ª' ) ' / ¬ % ª ' ¬}¯ ¯ ª' ¬ 143 % ª' ¬ ª' ¬ 143 U Wh)r U ffl{]^ha 5
(363) ªB!: ¬ * ~ : % b*h n Jf v )lqXHb `^`0W
(364) hafN_a U WtAd W
(365) XXHb © Z]gXia`g]^W l / ¯ ¯ 143 : % _ v d U W v A]^d U f` n l / % >}¬ 8 % 8 8 143 Qªe. * . :. '. . 5 . ªÎY ³¬ ªÎY
(366) ¬. . . . . ªÎY N¬ ªÎY ±N²¬.
(367) \]^hrW. brfNXa]gh}b*d]^fNhkf*"d U Wob*}f W v W`m b de]gfNh}l ]^W l Nª ' 8 ) ' 8 ¬ . ' 5 . : %. . 5 . 8 * .
(368) %
(369) . %. n ]g. . 8. . %.
(370) ¯ * . . 8 %. ² Y ° .. . ªÎY ±Q ¬ . n ]^ . 8. * . b* b*]^h U Wh 2]cl#l{XHb*`g`?WhafN_j U ?def db Wrb v W)f*d U W;dW v X : ' ]^hb*`^`gp_}lq]gha d U Wb v ]^d U XWde]cr /4 NWfXWd v ]cr5XW b h]^hjW _b*`^]gd{pb*h n d U W}fN_ah WZ WdQJf v ² N n ]^ 8 * ªe ¬ n ]g * : ª ¬
(371) . .
(372) . ªÎY ±N¬. ]^hGªJY N¬ . n W n ah W ll f* .
(373) . . 8 * %. Wh}rsWQpHl{Wded]^ha r`^f lqWWhaf_a U deffNhaWa WZfNjdb*]gh ª ' 8 ) ' 8 ¬ : ' 5 % 8 % 8
(374) "WtAd W_}l{Wd U W v Wxlq_a`gd?d U b dd U W v W¡WtQ]clqd lZª
(375) ² ¬ lq_}r U d U b d / ª >
(376) % 8 >
(377) 1!8 : 8 . ªÎY ±N±¬. b*h n. ªÎY ±*YA¬ ªÎY ±N°¬.
(378) .
(379) 5 . %. Ϊ Y ±N¬ T U Wzi v ff (f Md U ]cl v Wxlq_a`gd5]cl v *b d U W v deW r U ha]crb*`}b h n U W
(380) h}rWz WZ?]g`^`ai}fl{dei}fNhjW]gd d f WXXÜb Y Y W
(381) `^f ]^d U d U ]ml
(382) # W v lqdz v ]^dW Nª ' 8 )
(383) ² ² ² ¬ % & ªÎY ±³¬ ?]^d U / ( ª' )
(384) ² ¬ % ª' ¬¯ ¯ ª
(385) Q ¬ 143 ªÎY ±
(386) ¬ / % ª ' ¬ ª
(387) ² ¬ 143 5 n ]g ª ' ¬ 8 n ]^ ª
(388) ² ¬ n ]^ 1 ª ' ¬ 8 n ]g 1 ª
Documents relatifs
Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution
Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture
variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré
For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta < 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the
lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit
La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les
Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)
Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques