L'impact de la réglementation sur la qualité et le coût de l'audit en Europe

(1)

HAL Id: tel-01517268

https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-01517268

Submitted on 3 May 2017

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

L’impact de la réglementation sur la qualité et le coût de l’audit en Europe

Imen Ben Slimene

To cite this version:

Imen Ben Slimene. L’impact de la réglementation sur la qualité et le coût de l’audit en Europe. Gestion

et management. Université Grenoble Alpes, 2016. Français. �NNT : 2016GREAG006�. �tel-01517268�

(2)

THÈSE

Pour obtenir le grade de

DOCTEUR DE LA COMMUNAUTÉ UNIVERSITÉ GRENOBLE ALPES

Spécialité : Sciences de Gestion

Arrêté ministériel : 7 août 2006

Présentée par

Imen BEN SLIMENE

Thèse dirigée par Pascal DUMONTIER

préparée au sein du Centre d’Études et de Recherches Appliquées à la Gestion

dans l'École Doctorale en Sciences de Gestion Grenoble

L’impact de la réglementation sur la qualité et le coût de l’audit en Europe

Thèse soutenue publiquement le 10 juin 2016, devant le jury composé de :

Jean François CASTA

Professeur à l'université Paris Dauphine, (Rapporteur)

Pascal DUMONTIER

Professeur à l’Université Grenoble-Alpes, (Directeur de thèse)

Cédric LESAGE

Professeur à HEC Paris, (Rapporteur)

François AUBERT

Professeur à l’Université d’Orléans, (Président du jury)

Franck MISSONIER-PIERA

Professeur à l’Université de Fribourg, (Suffragant)

(3)

ii

(4)

À mes parents

(5)

iv

! " ! # $ %

& ' (

) * +, -

&

$ ,

, ./ 0 1 # &

2340 5 23467! & " 2340 5 23467 .+&&

5 2340 +&-8+5 2346 9+ " 23467 !

: ! 1 ! ; < ! 8 < 9 =

: >

+-&< +

- : !

: ! : ! $ ?

$ & ' !

, @ A 5 ,

+-&<! * ! $ ! ) ! 1 ! B ! & !

;' C! ! 8 ! * ! $ ! !D $

) &

&

&( E &

(6)

"

;)5+ +) ;<F-+)

"

;)5+ +)

5

&:"+&FG

4 " 2

4 4 " H

DDDDDDDDD 2

4 2 " ? , /

2 " 0

/ " 6

0 " I

; 44

4 " H 42

4 4 " 42

4 2 " 40

4 / " H @ A 4I

2 " ( F+ 22

2 4 " 22

2 2 " 2J

2 / " % /4

2 0 " ' //

2 6 " , /6

03 &

88+G+) F 9& ;5-+ ";$;8&;-+

(7)

vi

; 6I

; H

K4

; K4

4 " K/

4 4 " K/

4 2 " , K0

2 " I3

2 4 " ( I4

2 2 " I2

/ 5 ! I/

/ 4 $ , I0

/ 2 "

IL

;; "

L/

; L/

4 " L0

4 4 " L0

4 2 " LL

2 " LJ

2 4 " % LJ

2 2 " ! J6

2 / " ' 43/

2 0 " 430

;;; "

H 43K

; 43K

4 " ( 43L

4 4 " 43L

4 2 " 43J

2 " 442

(8)

2 4 " 442

2 2 " 44L

2 / " 44J

2 0 " M 424

/ $

420 / 4 $

420 / 2 $ , 426

/ / $

42L

0 N ( 42J

0 4 " 42J

0 2 " ( 4/3

6 " , H

9 # 4//

K "

4/0 I "

4/I

L & ( 403

L 4 & 403

L 2 & 402

L / & ( 40/

40K 40L

&

88+G+) + "& &-5;+

;

!

; 4L4

; (

4L/

; 4L/

4 " 4L/

4 4 " 4L0

(9)

viii

4 2 " 4LI

4 / " ' 4J4

4 0 " % 4J/

2 " 4J0

2 4 " 4J6

2 2 " 4JK

4JI

;; " H

4JL

; 4JL

4 " 4JJ

4 4 " 4JJ

4 2 " 233

4 / " , 232

4 0 " M 23/

2 " 23K

/ " ( 23I

/ 4 N 23I

/ 2 " 23L

0 " ( 23J

0 4 " @ A + 243

0 2 " 244

0 / "

24/

6 & ( 240

6 4 $ 240

6 2 & 24I

6 / & 24I

6 0 " 24J

6 6 " FO 24J

, 223

&

88+G+) + "& &-5;+

;; ""

"

" #

(10)

$%&'( ) * '+,*'-$-$./ 0(1 $% 1 ./2 $% (/ **&'.,( ,.&' 3* ,+'$.0( " #2**

"

# $%&'( " ) **(1 ,'$/4$,3(1 '+%3(5(/--$./1 0( 36*&0$- (/ &'.,(** "

$%&'( ) * 7&3$-+ 0( 3 &0$- (- 3* 7&3$-+ 0(1 48$99'(1 4.5,-:3(1 ; $%&'( " ) * '(3-$./ (/-'( 3(1 1('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- (- 3* %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3--1 ; $%&'( # ) '+,'-$-$./ 0(1 44'&*31 **0$14'+-$.//$'(1 =3 5.>(//( (- 3* 5+0$*/(?**

**,' 0+4$3(1 0( 3 0$1-'$:&-$./ (- ,.&' 487&( ,>1**

$%&'( ) * '+,'-$-$./ 0(1 5/$,&3-$./1 '+(33( =3 5.>(//( (- 3* 5+0$/(? ,' **0+4$3(1 0( 3* 0$1-'$:&-$./ (- ,.&' 487&( ,>1**

@ $%&'( ) * '+,'-$-$./ 0(1 44'&*31 **0$14'+-$.//$'(1 =3 5.>(//( (- 3* 5+0$*/(?**

**,' ,>1 (- ,' //+(**

# $%&'( ) *** '+,*'-$-$./ 0( 3*** /$,&3-$./ **+(33( =3* 5.>(//( (- 3* 5+0$/(? ,'**

**,>1 (- ,' *//+(**

#

$%&'( ) **( 5/0- 0( 3 &0$- (- 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-** ;

$%&'( " ) **(1 1('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- (- 3(1 8./.'$'(1 06*&0$-** ;#

(11)

x

:3(& ) **(1 ,'$/4$,3(1 +<.3&-$./1 0( 3 '+%3(5(/-*-$./ (&'.,+(//(**

**'(3-$<( A 3 '(1,./1:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0(1 &0$-(&'1**

"

:3(& ) **$99+'(/4(1 (/-'( %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3--1 (- 9'&0( 4.5,-*:3(** #

:3(& " ) (1 5.0B3(1 0(1 44'&31 **3(1 ,3&1 &-$3$1+1 0/1 3 3$--+'*-&'(** ;

:3(& # ) **(1 ,'$/4$,3(1 +-&0(1 (5,$'$7&(1 1&' 3 '(3-$./ (/-'( 1('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- (- 7&3$-+ 0( 3 &0$-**

;#

:3(& ) **(1 ,'$/4$,3(1 +-&0(1 (5,$'$7&(1 0( 3 '(3-$./ (/-'( 3 '.-*-$./**

**0& 3 &0$-(&' (- 3 7&3$-+ 0(1 48$99'(1 4.5,-:3(1**

:3(& ) **>/-8B1( 0(1 ,'$/4$,*3(1 8>,.-8B1(1 0( 3 +-&0(**

:3(& ) **>/-8B1( 0( 36(/<$'.//(5(/- '+%3(5(/-$'( '(3-$9 A 36&0$- 1--&-$'( (- A 3 ,'.-(4-$./ 0(1 $/<(1-$11(&'1**

@

:3(& @ ) **-,(1 0( 3 4./1-$-&-$./ 0( /.-'( +48*/-$33./** !

:3(& ! ) **+,'-$-$./ 0(1 (/-'(,'$1(1 0( 3 +48/-$33./ ,' ,>1 (- ,*' 1(4-(&'1**

;

:3(& ; ) **--$1-$7&(1 0(14'$,-$<(1 0(1 <'$*:3(1 0(1 '+%'(11$./1**

:3(& ) --$1-$7&(1 &/$ <'$+(1 0( 3* %(1-$./ %'(11$<( 0(1 '+1&3--1 A 3*

**8&11( (- 3 %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3-*-1 ,.&' +<$-(' &/( ,('-(**

:3(& ) -'$4( 0( 4.''+3-$./ 0( ,('5/ (/-'( 3(1 <'$:3(1 "

:3(& " ) **+,'-$-$./ 0(1 &0$-(&'1 (/-'( $% (- 1,+4$*3$1-( 0( 1(4-(&'** #

:3(& # ) **+-('5$//-1 0& 48.$C 0( 3 &0$-(&' ) -*,( 0& 5.0B3(**

0 **(4D5*/**

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 7&3$-+ 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/-*-$./ 0(**

**3 &0$- 1&' 3 5,3(&' 0( 3* %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3-*-1**

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 7&3$-+ 0( 36&0$-(&' (- 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3* ,'.::$3$-+ 0( 3 %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3-*-1**

@

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 7&3$-+ 0( 36&0$-(&' (- 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$-** 1&' 365,3(&' 0( 3 %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3--1 ) &-'(1 5(1&'(1 0( 3

**%(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3-*-1**

;

:3(& @ ) 5,4- 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3*

**%(1-$./ %'(11$<( 0(1 '+1&3--1**

@

:3(& ! ) 5,4- 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3*

**%(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3--1 ) &-'(1 5(1&'(1 0( 3 1,+4$3$1-$./**

1(4-.'$(33(

@"

(12)

:3(& ; ) --$1-$7&(1 &/$2<'$+(1 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- (- 0( 3*

**%(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3--1 (/ 9./4-$./ 0( 3 7&3$-+ 0( 3 &0$-(&'**

@

:3(& " ) 5,4- 0( 36$/-('4-$./ (/-'( 3* 7&3$-+ 0( 36&0$-(&' (- 3*

**'+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 365,3(&' 0( 3 %(1-$./ 0(1 '+1&3-*-1**

@

:3(& " ) **5,4- 0( 487&( --'$:&- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 1&' 3 %(1-$./**

**4.5,-*:3( (- '+(33(**

@@

:3(& "" ) **+4,$-&3-$9 0(1 ,'$/4$,&C '+1&3--1 0( 3 +-&0(** @;

:3(& ) **>/-8B1( 0(1 ,'$/4$,*3(1 8>,.-8B1(1 0( 3 +-&0(** ;!

:3(& " ) **>/-8B1( 0( 36(/<$'.//(5(/- '+%3(5(/-$'( '(3-$9 A 36&0$- 1--&-*$'(**

""

:3(& # ) **-,(1 0( 3 4./1-$-&-$./ 0( /.-'( +48*/-$33./ ""@**

:3(& ) '4-+'$1-$7&(1 0( 3 +48/-$33./ 1&' 3 ,+'$.0( " #2" ""!

:3(& ) **--$1-$7&(1 0(14'$,-$<(1 0(1 <'$:3(1 (C,3$4-$<(1 ,' ,>1**

**=&-'(1 7&( 3(1 --'$:&-1 0( 3* '+%3(5(/-*-$./?**

"";

:3(& ) -'$4( 0( 4.''+3-$./ 0( ('1./ (/-'( 3(1 <'$*:3(1 "#

:3(& @ ) **5,4- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$-** "#

:3(& ! ) **5,4- E.$/- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$-**

"##

:3(& ; ) **/-('4-$./ (/-'( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- (- 3( ->,( 0(**

**3 &0$-(&' 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-**

"#

:3(& ) **/0$4( 0( 3* '(1,./1:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0( 3 &0$-(&'** "#

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 '(1,./1:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0( 3 &0$-(&' 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$- ) &-'(1 5(1&'(1 0( 3* '(1,./1*:$3$-+**

"#

:3(& " ) **5,4- 0( 3 $/0$4( 0( F$/%-( 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$- "#@**

:3(& # ) **5,4- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$-**

**=3 .:3$%-$./ 0( ,&:3$(' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-?**

"#!

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0 &0$- 1&' 3(1 8./.'*$'(1 ) "B5(**

**+-,( 0( (4D5/**

"

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$- ) +-8.0( 0( 5* (-** *4 (-8 = ;@#?

" "

:3(& ) **5,4- 0( 3 -$33( 0( 3 (/-'(,'$1( &0$-+( 1&' 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$-**

" #

:3(& @ ) **+4,$-&3-$9 0(1 ,'$/4$,&C '+1&3--1 0( 3 +-&0(** "

(13)

1

(14)

! "# $ %

! & ! ' ( !! !

# ) % # # * ) &

) +

5 &

& .& &7! $ 2344

"

% , '

M P .& & 23447 "

.9

B 23427

+ ! ! (

Q , !

* 5.-$<*-$./ 0( '(48('48(

* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 3+%3 ) &/ +3+5(/- 43+ 0( 3 7&*3$-+ 0(1 **5$11$./1 0 *&0$-**

+ ! & .4JL47

& .4JL47 H @ , ' ! !

-) ) # # ! ! # .

/ * -0. * # -1. )

*

⁰

A . & 4JL4! 4467

) ! !

.

H 7 .

H 7 " ?

4

@ " ,% P .

! ! P ! 7

H .47 ( ! .27

A

(15)

3 ! , ! ?

?

8 ?

! , !

!

$ ! '

' M '

8 M

8 + N

P !

' M

! ( , ! R , ?

! ? ?

+

+ , ! R

,

!

. 7

8 R ( M

Q +

! !

!

! % Q

" $/-+'G- 0& 4./-(C-( (&'.,+(/

: , N %F +

% , !

8 H 7 "

+ , N %F , N S

(16)

F ( + -

? + 7 "

E F + .F+7

' 7 "

, (

R (

! ( 8

46 ( F + .F+7 , 2330

"

, ! %

' ( F+ +

" %

( !

"

; (

( F + ; (

"

M

( F + +

" P ' T ' !

( ' ! , (

? ( ! (

! (

" * 7&(1-$./ 0( '(48('48(

M

N PF+!

(17)

5 8 Q

R Q

! ,% !

? !

H

&(3 (1- 3 $5,4- 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 3+%3 1&' 3

**7&3$-+ (- 3( 4.H- 0( 3 &0$- (/ &'.,( I**

& , ! , "

"

Q

• '(5$B'( 7&(1-$./ 0( '(48('48(

**&(3 (1- 3 $5,4- 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3* 7&3$-+ 0(1 48$99'(1 4.5,-:3(1 ,&:3$+1 ,*' 3(1 9$'5(1 (&'.,+(//(1 I**

8 , M ' M

P ! M ' P

• (&C$B5( 7&(1-$./ 0( '(48('48(

**&(3 (1- 3 $5,4- 0( 3 &0$-(&' (- 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 1&' 3( /$<(& 0(1 8./.'$'(1 0 &0$- ,>+1 ,*' 3(1 9$'5(1 (&'.,+(//(1 I**

8 , P

,

# * 1-'&4-&'( 0( 3* -8B1(

,

( F+!

(

. +7 "

(18)

"

*'-$( ) **(1 4'4-+'$1-$7&(1 0( 3 &0$-(&' 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- (- 3* 7&3$-+ 0(1 48$99'(1 4.5,-:3(1**

P ! .233L7 B .23427!

! (

P P

. 7

F

F ,

, (

! !

"

(

( !

! ;

" $

+ P

;

M

! ?

, ,

; ,

! ;

'

(19)

7 *'-$( **(1 4'4-+'$1-$7&(1 0( 3 &0$-(&' 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- (- 3(1 8./.'$'(1 0( 3 &0$-**

, . $ 7! , Q

.+ ) > C 23407

" U .$

7 ! !

;

. ! !

' 7

" ,

! ( !

! ,

, " ,

8 , !

@ A C

" (

"

, ( " ,

( , "

* 4./-'$:&-$./ 0( 3* '(48('48(

8 ,

! "

S @ ) %, ( & A .)G7 2332 ,

N F ! .") 7 233/ ! +

(20)

2343 @ H

A ( 2340 S M '

8 ,

7 + ( M ,%

!

7 +

! , !

7 + , ,

% " !

H " !

! ; ?

.$ 7

! ? !

8 % F , , H 8 (

Q !

8 ! ,

R

% " , H "

"

En ce !

, " ,

. 2334 V B 23427 ;

(21)

9 , ( ,

(

, +

!

)*G (

5 ' ! !

, )*G . #

1 233KV < " 233IV < > > C 233J7 + + ! &

.23467

5 ! ( . ! ; - ( %

F 7 ( !

(

8 +

" , " '

" Q

(22)

2 2

(23)

2 2

11 /-'.0&4-$./

" !

! +

,!

,

. % 7! ." =

$ 23447 ? ,

! +

!

+ ;

( F+ ,

" !

! +

"

( 8

, '

+

(24)

2 2

* '+%3(5(/--$./ (&'.,+(//( 0( 3 &0$- ) &/( -(/-*-$<(

**0 8'5./$1-$./**

M ! +

" ' +

!

, 8

+

**(1 4'4-+'$1-$7&(1 1,+4$9$7&(1 0& 5'48+ (&'.,+(/ 0( 3 &0$-**

* P ! ,

.1 # 2334! 233L7

, ?

P !

,! $ 3 . W 5 ! + W X !

> O $<7 4 5$ !

P ,! , .

234/V ) ## 234/7 < , M

, !

;

$ ( 4 '$

+ ( ! $

+F J3Y " = $ .23447

' ! Z (

' H P P $

2

? (

^/

2

, ! O .23437 P

P T ! .234/7

( R

( ! : .23427

P

(25)

2 2

13 "

' . 233LV : 233LV

O .23437V : .23427V 234/V 7 , + !

: .233L7 (

46 ( PF+ 4JJL 2330 "

! & &

" ( !

! .3 47 233/ 2344!

( ? ( H (

$ ! + V ( $ !

< ! & V ( - ( %F

: .233/7

!

! ) .23437

? !

.& ) 7 "

Q ,

/

" P P

$

. " 23437

$%&'( **) * '+,'-$-$./ 0(1 $% 1 ./ $% (/ &'.,( ,.&' 3 ,+'$.0( " #2"**

(26)

2 2

;

Q " ?

.& % 233L7 " $

, , ' !

.& % 233L7 ,

F

. ) 23437

" * '+%&3-$./ 0( 3 ,'.9(11$./ 0( 3 *&0$-

8 !

, M

& , + ! '

, ' !

P ? !

,

" **(1 '%&5(/-1 (/ 9<(&' 0 &/( '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$-**

0 1 0 0 /

.9 ( $ C 233L7 + !

, + +

!

. )*G , N %F ! 7

, .9 ( $ C

233L7

" ?

" " Q

%

(27)

2 2

15 0 1 0 1 (

" ) .4JI47 .4JI07

) ! H 7

V 7 P ?

P

? V 7 .

! ! ! P ? ! 7

,

" , , P ? ,

? " [ [ P ?

! ) .4JI47

H ! !

! ! , , .)

4JI47

( ? !

.< # 23367 " , (

,

. P ! \

P ? 7 P

5 ! , !

, + !

? !

! .9 C 234/7

" " * 5$1( (/ ,34( 0 &/( /.&<(33( %.&<('//4( 5./0$*3(

+ !

.- 233L7

(28)

2 2

, ( ( (

. 7 , . 7

6 7 $

. ;*:7 ? 8 ! .; & 7!

.

% $ S ;&&):7 . 2 % $ ! S ;+):&7

.- # #

23427 " ;&&): !

.;)&7!

" ;+):&

! ,

"

, M

T /K ! +

M

, , !

+, + . ++7

, +

5 ' !

, N

F+! 2336 , H -

& .& - 7 < + * ) & 92 : !

7 $ .+<&*:7 " ! !

( ( , M "

, (

M , F+ .$ C 233J7

(29)

2 2

17 # * '+9.'5( (&'.,+(//( 0( 3 &0$- ) <('1 &/ J 5'48+ &/$7&( 0( 3 *&0$- K

" M +

" M ,

!

M ( + P

! PF+ P

.; -)7 2336 "P P .;)&7

P PF+

# 0.,-$./ 0( 3 8&$-$B5( 0$'(4-$<( =! L" #L ?

"

⁰

! !

! ,

+ M ! M

N & ! ' !

C P F+

.) 233I7

! 4JJK @ ; #

; 2 A . * /24! 2L 4JJK7!

,

(

M ,

N ,

? " ,

P P M

PF+ ; P PF+

0

" ] L0\26/\ ++ 43 4JL0 . * " 42K 42 36 4JL0! 237

M

(30)

2 2

"

+ 4JJL! @ ; / A "

P

N "

(

P , , PF+

# " **.0('/$1-$./ 0( 3 8&$-$B5( 0$'(4-$<(**

" , N %F F+ 2333

+

! )*G , N %F

, P

^K

+ 233/! + , ,

P M @

M F + A

'

M , F+

" + ! ? 2333

F+ M "

+ ! ( ?

F+

!

6

" 233K\0/\ + 4I 233K M

! F+ J ' 233K

233L\/3\ + 44 233L

, ! ' ] "L4 23

233L

K

+ , N %F

" ) %*, ( .23327! @

< ! ; / =

. *$.233/72LK 24 233/7 43

( " ! , 233/%2330

V P P V

M PN PF+ P E ;)&

M , PF+ 2336 " ( ! ,

2330%233K! ! ! P ( V

, P , V P

M ! P

(31)

2 2

19 P . > - 23307 " M ,

, ,

M , P

,

" P

M , + P

, P + P

M PF+

) ,

N !

" , N %

! !

+

# # **.&<(33( ,'.,.1$-$./ 0( 3* '+9.'5(**

^@

**0(1-$/+( A J'+-:3$' 3 4./9$*/4(K**

+ 2343! + P ( [6 (

> [ " '

!

) ! F+ 2344!

M P ! P !

! P ! ,

( . $+7 , ( . $ 7!

, P ,

+ 2340! !

P

^L

2340\6K\F+! ! .F+ ] 6/I\23407

^J

+

I

" 233K\0/\ +

M ,

L

" 2340\6K\F+ 4K 2340! ! 4K ' 2340 "

N ' P 4I ' 234K " .F+7 ]

6/I\2340 4K 2340 4K ' 2340 ; 4I ' 234K

+ ! P , P 4K! ^ K! 4I ' 234I

J

" , M P ? .+; 7

.F+ ] 6/I\23407 % 2336\J3J\ +

+

(32)

2 2

, M P ?

" H

• @ P M P "

P P ? , 43 !

? 23 . 7 20 .

' 7V

• P , M H @ A %

V

• H ! P

P V

• P H '

P ? !

! P , +; V

• P _ .;)& ;)` 47

" ? N

A . + 23407

" .3 27 P

+ %

(33)

2 2

21

$%&'( " ) (1 ,'$/4$,*3(1 '+%3(5(/-*-$./1 0( 36*&0$- (/ &'.,(

(34)

2 2

" * '+%3(5(/--$./ 0( 3 &0$- 0/1 3(1 ,>1 5(5:'(1 0( 3

+ + !

, .3 47 8

" = $ .23447! ` # .233L7! - C %) # .23427! 9

.23407! P

P ; &

8 '

, (

" +

( ! + 8

! +

M P , F+ "

M ! !

! ,

! ' 8 (

" * '(1,./1:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0( 3 &0$-(&'

"

+ !

! \ 8

? , . ) 23437

?

! ? !

(35)

2 2

23 "

! ' '

"

` % (

a ` a T

a "

P

, ' ." 4JJJV 9 ( ) 23407

⁴³

"

,

' ;

! ! (

' ( R ' + !

' F+

T !

N

% % , .) 23437 " !

! P

' .<> 2330V ) 9 (

23407

⁴⁴

" . +,

+ % ++7! !

. ! 7

'

!

8 ( F+

43

__ @ A @ A , ?

, ." 4JJJ /4%/27

44

' M ' !

P , < + .+ <7!

! 4JJ/ : , ! P+ <

.O ( 4JJK7

(36)

2 2

" **$1-.'$7&( 0( 3* '+%3(5(/--$./ '(3-$<( A 3* '(1,./1:$3$-+ 0( 3 &0$-(&'**

" + 4JJK @ M ! M

PF A

⁴²

+ ' 2334! +

^4/

C N

P "P

P P (

,

' , @ A P

. + 233/! / 437

T 233/ @< ! ;

/ A! , M

,

!

P " ! P+ !

"P P& &

, , !

' , ?

P

+ " + ' 233I

⁴⁰

M F+

. 7

42

! +

+ M ! M !

?

.$&- 7! P

N " P [,

#

* ! * ) 2

[ : ' ! 1 ! $ ' ! ) ! $ > !

- = 1 ' ! 4JJK

4/

N M , ! @

* * ! * !

* ! % ? & ! 2

A V 5 (

44 2334

40

" /4 .233K\0/\ +7 , + @

E M

, M ,

! ( ( ' A T

! , N

(37)

2 2

25 E

⁴⁶

F+ , ,

N " L6

" ' ! ( !

,

( (

"

.233L\0I/\ +7 ' 233L "

! + , N

M ! (

' " N

P

, P & ! N

! P

( %

" .3 47

M , %

46

"P P ( !

P % ( "

2336 !

P

(38)

2 2

:3(& ) (1 ,'$/4$,3(1 +<.3&-$./1 0( 3 '+%3(5(/--$./ (&'.,+(//( '(3-$<( A 3*

**'(1,./1:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0(1 &0$-(&'1**

//+( **.$1 L '(4.55/0-$./1 L -&0(1**

4JJK " @ -M ! M PF

[! ! 4JJK

4JJL

[" M PF H [

4JJL . * 40/! L 4JJL7 P

PF+

^4K

! 2334

- P [ & ) ( )( " ( ) ( &

, ) $ # & ) + F [ 5 (

.23347 ' 2334

2336

! +!

" , . !

! ! ! 7

233K

.233K\0/\ +7 M

, "P /4 ,

+ , N

, + ! + ! 2 !

233I - L6

M PF+ .; \3I\K37

233L

- + K 233L , M

, M ?

.233L\/K2\ +7

" " **(1 0$<('%(/4(1 (/ 5-$B'( 0( '(1,./1:$3$-+ 0( 3 *&0$-(&'**

) " + +> 233K! +

F ,

! '

PF+ 8

(

^4I

F (

N PF+ , .3 27 !

4K

F 4JJL P P ; &

- ( %F ." + ! 4JJL7

) ! '

"

P; & @ ?

! , P P A

4I

, ! 46 ( F+

2330

(39)

2 2

27 +

" 5 ( 2334 " , ! "

+ +> 233K!

M

N + (

, !

233L 8 ,

" ( , .3 27 , "

" ,

! % ?

1 0 1 0

" ( PF+ +

!

5 !

" ,

, +

' ! . 7 .

% 7 " , (

!

' !

( . ! 7 +

! ! ?

? .& ) , 23437

N !

' N ! P

F

? P "

' N !

, P

(40)

2 2

! . 7!

( ! <

P ! %

?

! +

^4L

5 ! !

(

' (

1 0 1 1

& P P !

M ,

P P !

. + 233L7

^4J

+ ! ( !

N

! !

" P

+ ' ,!

,% ( 5 ! '

M

+ 233I! , (

!

, !

.$ ! 5 ! K 233L7

4L

" @ M ,

, A 233I (

, N %F

4J

M ,

P ! + .233L7

! P

." + +> 233K! J47 5 ! P P

." + +> 233K! 0K7 + !

, P P P

+ !

, P (

,

(41)

2 2

29 " " * 0&'+( 0& 5/0- (- 3* '.--$./ 0(1 &0$-(&'1

" " * '+%3(5(/-*-$./ (/ <$%&(&'

& ( !

N ,

, . , 7 : . 7 !

! +! 4K 2332!

? " ?

I M ?

6 . 03 .233K\0/\ +7 7

" , .3 47 N PF+ E !

!

,

²³

+ 2343! +

% "

2340

.F+7 ]6/I\2340 ) ! M P

43 , 8 ! ?

43 , ! 40

P '

²⁴

. // .F+7 ]6/I\23407 ! +

, , N !

,% ,

; ,

" " " **( 0+:- 1&' 3 '.--$./ 0( 3 &0$-(&'**

" ! . 7 '

. 7 E

23

= +> %O .23427

(

24

" 4I ' 2340 4I ' 234K

(42)

2 2

. 23407 ! ,

22

1 1 1 0 !

"

"P @ P A

"

' ! , ,

( ' ! !

! F

; F

, P !

Z

, - .233K7

M "

, , ;

" ,

@ P P A!

. 23367 ? ! '

Q P

F ,

!

1 1 1 1

"

Z P !

,

! ?

P .O

22

F , , , ,

;

(43)

2 2

31 4JJ47 " Z Q

! Q . 2336V O>

23407 " R

. ,

@ A , 7 !

Q P

" # **(1 1('<$4(1 0( /./2*&0$-**

` @4 ' % A !

@ % A " ,

! ,!

M

@ , ! !

A . $ # 4JJJ7 " ! $ !

. % 7

M %

'

, " N

F +

% !

P . % 7 " , .3 07

%

, ( F+

" % '

, ?

? . & 4JL4 V

) 4JL0 V : # 4JLL V : 2330 V : ( 23327 ;

% Z .: ( 23327

(44)

2 2

2332 N %F ,

M .)*G! 2347 " F+ ! !

( ! (

" + ,

? , . 22

233K\0/\ +7 ! M

! ! ! (

.

22 233K\0/\ +7 " , ,

M , % ! ?

+ ! +

P %

( 7 , ! 7 ,

! 7 !

( F+!

! + 2343

@ A "PF+ M ,

P

' !

+ ! . +!

' F+7

'

%

" 2340\6K\F+ .F+7 ]6/I\2340

@ A % . , 3 07 "

+ , N %

. ,7! ,

233K\0/\ + " 22

PF+ ,

! N

(45)

2 2

33 " **.:3$%-$./ 0 &/ &0$- 4./E.$/-**

" % , A ' ! P '

^2/

, M

' " % ,

' , 4JKK

, $ .9 23447! +

, 2343 " %

, (

M Q

' P

P P .- C %) # 23427 )

! .23447

' ; @ @ A = 8 # B &

( ( # ( C # ( !!

# # # (

B & # ! # 1DDEA

& ! ' '

2342 P +

' .- C %) # 23427 " ' 2344

P ' ! P ' ?

; " ( %

, 4JKK ( ! P& ! )

- ( %F ! ' + 2336! #

' 4J/3

²⁰

" ! ?

' & (

.$ . +

! " .23427 , " $

' ! Q

! P ' !

2/

& ! ! @ ' A

20

- C %) # .23427 - C %) # .234/7

'

(46)

2 2

!

? ." 23427

P P '

! ,

P P ' !

P Q !

Q ! P

. + 23447

, ? % , P a " P

P ' " ,

M ! , P

P

P ! ,

, !

P ?

, '

+ ' ! %

, ,%

.$ C 2343V B 23437

,% ? ' "

, ' . ;

7 ' (

" +

P M ' P ,

! P 8 %$ $ " (

' ,

P ! R .

233L7 + ! , P P

!

, ! P P

(47)

2 2

35 (

! , .$ 7 F ,

( @ ( ,A .

% , 7 ;

P

F P M '

.: 2330V " $ , 2330V 5 O C 233L7 + !

, ,

. 7 "P& $

.&$ 7 P

2343! &$

! ,

$ 233J . J4 Y > J Y 7

" * '+%3(5(/--$./ '(3-$<( &C 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-

" % '

.& % 233L7 L // .233K\0/\ +7 ,

%

2344! + P . 2K 2I7

+

. 4/7! / & 2340 .

23407 " , .3 47 , ' (

F+

" **( ,39.//(5(/- 0(1 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-**

+ 2344! + P P

R P ? !

P

% ,

46 Y . 0

23407 ' N "P

P ! , ,

(48)

2 2

" 0 2340

! M

, % !

, I3 Y (

, M M

" " * ,'.:3+5-$7&( 0( 3 0+-('5$/-$./ 0(1 8./.'$'(1 0 *&0$-

"

5 !

,

! !

!

"

M "

, ( ,

26

T

! ; &

203 % @

, P '

" P ,

, P P 8 !

,

" 26 M

@ N

,

M H 7

P M V 7 ? ; ?

M A & (

26

" , %

) .4JLJ7 ) @ !

M D ! M

! !

, A

(49)

2 2

37 ! ( ! , !

, "

. , 7

^2K

$ ,

.9 ( 233K V 9 ( 234/7!

) .4JL3! 4K47

@ ! = @ P , P bDc

P A ; P .

Q 7 Q P

" '

! .

, 7 M "

(

. 4JLK V ) 4JLI V ) ) 4JJK V = # 233L V

233J7 " - ( > ( .233L7

! ! .:

& " 234/7

2334! , N %F !

, )+ . # 2332 V ;( 233/7

! @ ! A!

, , ! @ ' ! A

2I

! @ ! A

) , @ ! =#

! ' !

P P ,% @ ! =

' F

^2L

!

, # .23327 ,

2K

! , H ,

. 424 J6J 24/!IJ 7

2I

" .)+ 2333! ) ;; 67! P

% ! P , P 43%

O 43%`

2L

+, , @ % A @

A H ) 4JL0 @

*

A! > 2332! @

'

A @ % A ? 4JJI! , !

@

* !

A @

'

A , 2332

(50)

2 2

)+ @ 8 A! , ,

! , ,

( @ 8 ! %* 8 A

@ 7 8 A

^2J

, !

!

& ! & % .233L7 @

, M

A + @ %

, ,

, H

! A : ( .233J7

@& A ;

, ! ! ,

! ,

, @ & A . ' ! 7

, ! @ % A .4JJI7 [

[ ( , P

! ( P !

! ! !

/3

8 !

P , (

& - ( %F ! : ( .23327! %

?

! %

2J

# .23327! .)+ 23337

H

@

8

A! ,

V

@

8 ! %* 8

A 4]7

! ! ( P P 2]7

P V

" @

7 8

A

/3

.4JJI7 8 !

P , P P R P( [ [

(51)

2 2

39 . 7

P . P 7 "

, & ! @ P @ A

% A .: ( 23327

" %

( R !

P

;;

. % 7 ,

,

(52)

2 2

./43&1$./

" ' +

( F+ 8

+ !

, , $

+!

( !

P

F ( ( F+

, +

! 2340

M !

!

! ,

! ' , !

(

(53)

2 2

41

(54)

2 2

42

//(C( ) *'*4-+'$1-$7&(1 '+%3(5(/-*$'(1 0( 3 *&0$- ,*' -*- 5(5:'( 0( 3 /$./ &'.,+(//(

,*>1 */0*- '(1-*-$./1 0( 1('<$4(1

0( /./2*&0$- = ?

*1(

E&'$0$7&( 0(

3*

'(1,./1*:$3$-+

:3$%*-$./ 0 &/

*&0$- 4./E.$/-

:3$%*-$./ 0(

,&:3$4*-$./ 0(1 8./.'*$'(1

0 *&0$-

(1-'$4-$./ ,.&' 3(1 8./.'*$'(1

0 *&0$-

0.,-$./ 0(

3* 0$'(4-$<(

="

L #L ?

* *

&-'$48( 4 2336

.6 7

8&)

2

8 . 7 233L 233J

(3%$7&( / 233L

.K 7

;

8&)^/

\ 8 . 7 233I 233L 233J

*/(5*'D 4 233/

.I 7 , 8&)⁰

4J/3 2330 H

T 2330 H

2332 233J 233L

$/3*/0( 4

.I 7 , 8&)⁶

8 . 7 233/ 233L

'*/4( K 2330

.K 7

;

8&)^K

* 233/ 233L

33(5*%/( 4 * .I 7 2336 H

8&) ^I

\ 8 . 7 2336 233J

'B4( 4 233J

.I 7 , 8&)^L

8 . 7 233J 233J

'3*/0( 4 2336

.I 7

2336 H

8&) ^J

\ 8 . 7 2336 2343

-*3$( / 4JI0 233I 233KH '

8&) ⁴³

8 . 7 233K 233J

&C(5:&'% 4 2343

, 8&)

\ 8 . 7 2343 233J

*>1 *1 4 233I

.I 7 , 8&)⁴⁴

8 . 7 233L 233L

.'-&%*3 0 233J

.I 7

233J H

8&) ⁴²

\ 8 . 7 233J 233J 233L

1,*%/( J 233/

.I 7 , 8&)^4/

8 . 7 233/ 2343

&B0( 0 233J

.I 7 , 8&)⁴⁰

8 . 7 233J

.>*&5(

/$

4 233L

.6 7

2336 H

8&) ⁴⁶

\ 8 . 7 2336 233L

(55)

2 2

43

) H ! " = $ .23447 ! 9

) . 234/7 ! ` # .233L7 P P ; &

8 ' (

2" % 2I4! 2I4 2I4 F<: .F C 7

J3 2 423 ] 43 15:< H @ ; , %

; , C ? A $ ^^2I3

.F<:7! ^LL 1 C .15:<7H " 15: ^^24%2/ 1 d %& e

.15%&-"7 %" .^^2I4! 2I4 F<:7 ; ? A .<

, % H , ! ) * +, S + > S 43\233I S /63 7

/" , P , P ? ( 43 4JJ0! 4// 4/0 ! , 4L/ 4LK P ? ( /3 2334

? ( 0 233/ , ! . $

+1*" ! 23307 ' 22 ' 4J6/ . ; -

P+ .;-+7 .233I77

0" ' % ] KK/ 2K 233L

6" ' % @8 A .06J\233I7! 20 26 . 4 233I7 + !

, ; -) " .= ) > C! 23437

K % 4J/6! , ,

! ( ! @ A 5 ! % ,

,

T ! " C .4JJ/! 4JJI7 , ! ? K

+ ! -

" ") . L22%447 @ ,

! , M M % bDc

, ! , A "

, . ! // , 7

I" % ^ /4J! & /! ] / .9<:7! [: C C .: - <7[ 2330

2336 & ' ? ! ' 2330H

f P ,

f - P , .

/4J! / 9<:7 + ! P P H f ' P , P %

! ! P ! P ,

Vf P , ! E ( P !

. /4J ! 4 9<:7

L" ' P % /KJ/\233L! ;=! 23 .27 2/ .

233L7

(56)

2 2

44

J" ' % 2330 + ) 6 233L 2343 . &

.234477

43" ' % " . 20 4JJL7! 6L! 4K3 . 2/ 23367 ) ; .23427! (

P , .& 234/7

44" ' % @ & ) & A 4J 233K! 2/ . 7

! ' P M

! 40 2342

42" , % B ' F 113G1DDH.* 7 23 233L! 2! 6! KL .I%427

4/ % " ! ( 4\2344 4 2344! & 4/

40" % " %) .2334HLL/ 7! ) 24 . 4 23327

46" ' % 2330 + ) 6 233L 2343 . &

.234477

(57)

2 2

45

//(C( " ) (14'$,-$./ 0& 1>1-B5( E&'$0$7&( 0( 3* '(1,./1*:$3$-+ 4$<$3( 0(1 4./-'M3(&'1 3+%*&C 0(1 4.5,-(1 0*/1 36 /$./ (&'.,+(//(

*-&'( 0( 3* '(1,./1*:$3$-+ 0(

3 *&0$-(&' 3+%*3^"

$5$-*-$./ 0( 3* '(1,./1*:$3$-+

*>1 *:$/(- 0 *&0$- $('1 3*9./0 ./-*/- 0& ,3*9./0 ./0$-$./1

&-'$48( ^/

\ ⁰⁶ . 23367

2 gH M P ( .^

224.27 9<:7

0 gH M P .^ 224./7 9<:7

L gH M P V P

, P

42 g H M P ! , P

, P

, P , , P

N P V

, ,

(3%$7&( \ ^K

. 23367

% / g

V

%42 g ,

&

*/(5*'D ^I

$/3*/0(

'*/4(

33(5*%/( \ \

L

J 4 g . 7

0 g . 7

&

'B4( 6 ?

P ,

% P

&

V R

V

" P

'(3*/0 \

-*3$(

&C(5:.&'% ⁴³

*>1 *1 ⁴⁴

.'-&%*3 ^\ ^\

h

1,*%/( ⁴² ^4/ ' 2344

&B0(

.>*&5(2 /$

\ h ⁴⁰ ⁴⁶

(58)

2 2

46

4) H + ! P [ % * %* !

I * ! % * I ! % ? & ! % 2 [ 5 ( ' 2334! @% *

! * = + " + 233I +

, V ( 6 ' 233L

2+ : ! ! & ! , ( %: - ( %F !

) P P

/+ ! M P . ,

7

0+ ! M P

. , ! 7

6 !

K K2 2/ 2336 4I 22 ' 4J6/ /3 233I

IF

L !

J ; 2/0 4 20 ' 4JKK! , & 4J/4

& < CC O 5 CF .O 5 <7! 4JJL & !

0 g .^ /2/.27 .9<:9 C 77

43F

44F

42F

4/ %" 8 0LI\JJ . 4K 4JJJ7! 5 ;;! ;! ;;! 60

40; . & 233K! K7

(59)

2 2

47 //(C( **# ) .1$-$./1 0& -'$/%3( $/1-$-&-$.//(3 0( 3 (1&'(1 .1$-$./ 0( 3 .55$11$./**

(&'.,+(//(

**.1$-$./ 0( 3* .55$11$./**

**0(1 99$'(1 E&'$0$7&(1 0& *'3(5(/- (&'.,+(/**

.1$-$./ 0& ./1($3 0(

36 /$./ (&'.,+(//(

) P

.

43 6 '

7

/-('0$4-$./

P

P P

P +;

4!6 P

*1 0( 1+,*'*-$./

P

/-('0$4-$./

P P

P

P +;

4!6

P .47

-

P

. //

' 7

&'+( 5*C$5*3( 0( */1

. , J

% 7

&'+( 5*C$5*3( 0( */1

' P 26

P H

P !

% ,

! P

P

&'+( 5*C$5*3( 0(

*/1

. , 42

% 7 .27

"

%

. J

43 '

7 P

M

$5$-( 7&*/-$-*-$<(

H

P ,

43Y

P M

P

$5$-( 7&*3$-*-$<(

H

P ,

. ,

7 " %

.

!

P 7 .

7 . P

P 7

*1 0( 3$5$-( 7&*/-$-*-$<(

P ,

$5$-( 7&*3$-*-$<(

H

% ?

P

P H

. 7!

,

!

% H

!

M !

$5$-( 7&*/-$-*-$<(

H

%

26 Y

P M

P

$5$-( 7&*3$-*-$<(

H

% H

!

P ! "

%

? .27

"

P

. J

' 7

" P ?

P+;

23Y

P 46Y

,

" P ?

P+;

23Y

P 46Y

,

" P ?

P+;

23Y

P 46Y

.47

% B G 2 ' ' 1 1D0J

(60)

2 2

//(C( ) **C(5,3(1 0( 0+9$/$-$./1 0(1 1('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- 1(3./ 3 '+%3(5(/-*-$./**

**(/ <$%&(&' 0/1 3(1 --1 5(5:'(1 0( 3**

" , % %

P %

(1 **('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- $/-('0$-1 ,' 3( 'B%3(5(/- (&'.,+(/ =*'-$43(** 0&

'B%3(5(/- = . #@L" **? 0& ,*'3(5(/- (&'.,+(/ (- 0& 4./1($3 0&** *<'$3 "

**'(3-$9 &C (C$%(/4(1 1,+4$9$7&(1 ,,3$4:3(1 & 4./-'M3( 3+%3 0(1 4.5,-(1 0(1 (/-$-+1 06$/-+'G- ,&:3$4 (- :'.%(/- 3* 0+4$1$./ " L; ;L 0( 3* .55$11$./?**

" @ A H

@ 7 , H

7 V

7 M V

7 V

7 !

M

V

7 M , !

M

M V

7 M M V

7 , V

7 ?

M V

7 V

7 E M

\ M

E ( V

7 !

V 7 ' ( H

(61)

2 2

49 7 , V

7 M V

7 , M V

7 M V

7 ! ! ,

M !

!

M V

'7 ! M V

#7 ( H

7 , ,

' M

! H

% V

7 V

7 M Q A

**(1 1('<$4(1 0( /./2&0$- $/-('0$-1 (/ (3%$7&( ='-$43( !# -(' 0( 3 ''G-+ '.>3 0&**

**# E/<$(' " ,.'-/- 1&' 3 (C+4&-$./ 0& .0( 0(1 1.4$+-+1?**

4 M V

2 &

M V

/ N ! ! E (

M V

0 -

M ! %

V

6 V

K - M ! , V