TCP plasma sputtering of nanostructured fuel cell electrodes

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00214152

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00214152

Submitted on 23 Jan 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

TCP plasma sputtering of nanostructured fuel cell electrodes

Hervé Rabat, Caroline Andreazza, Pascal Brault, Anne-Lise Thomann, Marjorie Cavarroc, Y. Tessier, A. Caillard, Ch. Charles, R. Boswell

To cite this version:

Hervé Rabat, Caroline Andreazza, Pascal Brault, Anne-Lise Thomann, Marjorie Cavarroc, et al..

TCP plasma sputtering of nanostructured fuel cell electrodes. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, 2008, 36, pp.872. �hal-00214152�

(2)

!"#$&%' ()*+,-./01& 2&3,45/6 71&-8'85:9;'.)<$,="?>@A'B;C4%'BDEGFH3"IJLKM &3;(;6NN;O9;'.)3",?P

3"IJLKQF1@A'&DR5B:S'C;T%B"&:(3U%'%5 63;3,.D% 1D#$/49AD%%D$9;'T.HK6!WV;FXAK6!.&YK=Z(;45T%'IXD5'/&&%@1&R4'Y

[\/&]J9A&U6&/6T1Y13WIJLK^<$P:*'>W_`!W%'&01a <:Wb/0c3"(;6P2F1?>P2P;6dE 6$e&/X3$65T& =fK6g*=8@H g8T6 .;$&T .;h&54iY

Df ¢¡?£W¤O£¥¦$§£8¨©ª«U¬h«,"&£8®M®£"¦O¯1£G°6±£8©O²?£8³f©´¥¦$¬«"«U8µ¶ZªT°·)¸U¨L¹2£«O«f¦Oº»£MT¼¨$ªTh§£MU£¨±¦L½f°·ZM°°&ªT¾m¦

¬¹2£8¿W©,§£WªT©T©'£8$¦$§¸,ªT°D¥ª«U§¸"£8©T°¦O¡h¨ÁÀÃÂO²h¨$°&Ä2M©5©

ÅÁÆ8ÇÈ4ÉÊ8ËÈfÌÁÍ»ÎUÏ&ÐÑMÒÔÓiÕÏDÖZ×ÏHØLÕ&ÙÚÛ×ÜÞÝ"Û5ÐmÒÖwÐ)ßÎfØ:Ý8à$ÒÚÙáTá×ÏDâÑã

Ï×Ð&äáTÕ&ÏÞâÒÙÒ×DÜÓTÕÏÞÜ×ÚÕ&ÒRâáâ'ÑWã¢ÚÕ&ÏÕ&ÙÒ)ä&ÐÏåÕ&Ñ\ÚÛ5Ð6áTâÑÙ¾ÖæÚÏÕáÕÑ

×ç&äèÐ6Ñã&×)ÖZ×DÖZåÏ&ÐÑM×ZÓTÙ×ÛUä×ÛÛU×Û'×äáTÏÕÜM×ÒéUØ:Ð&ÏDåÕÑ\ÑÐÑÕäÕÛÙ¾ÖZÑÒ

ÜM×äÕÏ&Ðá×ÜåêHÚÛ5ÐmáâÑÙÖëÑ8ÐÑÕäÛ'ÙÒáT×ÏÒÐÏ×:áèÙÒ$ÕåáÐ&âÑ×Üé

ì

j8kípWk&ko8îïsRð&lòñóTkôDpkDpGkDlõö÷lðoøñmq5rTð&pùjGômúEk

îÔqTlÔðp"õóö¢lkôñqTrú¾ômqko¢q5j8krpWqTklkî4q$sðlAs4øk&óUñ6kóTóTîûüJî4÷8kñ6r5ô6ó5óöWý¾qTjWk

óTðþqkÿÞ÷kl`ômqTølk1sTø8kóOñk6óóîîÔøWñDjhôîWü 8lð&qð6pwüñjGôpOõk

kÿl`ômpWk8øWkó:kóTó?ôDlkÁ÷lð&ÿr5îr´pUõ÷ðþHkDl2îðølñkî?oø8k\qTð

qTj8k&rlòj"r5õEj kpWkml`õ6öñ&ð6p8úEkml`î`rðp kssrTñr5kmpWñö sRð6lò÷ðlq4ôó5k&ý

qTlôDpUî4÷8ð&lqôDp"oæîqRôDqrðpGômliöæôm÷÷WórTñmômqrðp"îDû

ì

j"këñ&ð6lk ð&sô

Oü ñðp"îrTîqRî ðs ôkmÿlôDp"k üAók&ñDqTlðoMk^îDîkDÿóö

ûü1ûÞûsðlRÿhkomö qTþHðk&ók6ñqTlðok&î2î`kD÷GôDlôDqkoö ô÷lð&qð6p

ñ6ð&p"oøWñDqrpGõ ÷Wðóö¾ÿ?kDlð6sqkp ñ&ô6óóTko qTjWkíÿ?kDÿl`ômpWk¾û

ì

jWk

k6ó5kñqlðoMk&îcôlkðpWkðs\qj"kñlr´qr5ñ&ô6óhñðÿÞ÷ðpWkmpqRîrp qTjWkñ&kóTó

k6ó5kñqlðñmjWkÿ?rTñ&ô&ó:÷lðñ&k&îîû

ì

j"kÔöõkDp"kDlôóTó'ö2ñðpGî`r5îÔqJðsô?ñ&ômlð6p

ñ6ó5ð6qTjGýGþ1jWrTñDj kjUôDúk&îXór"!kwô^ors5s4øGîrTð&p\óôöMkl;sðlqTj8kQõMô&îk&îý8ômpWo

ðs2ôDp»ô6ñqrúkcóôökDl2ðsôskþ q5kp"î\ðs?ÿ?rTñDlð&ÿ?kqkDlîÿhôoMkcð&s

ñôDlEðp÷ðþHokDlî;îø÷÷8ð&lqr'pUõÞô)ñôDqRôó'öîÔqT÷óômq5rpøMÿ»ð&lOqivô&óó5ðö8î#Ôý

qTj8kërTðpWrTññ&ð6p"oøWñDqð&lýôp8o ô îðó´úkp8q$&%8ý(')Dû*"ðlîrõ6p"r'sRrTñ&ôpMq

kmssr5ñrTkp8ñöýqTjWkqTjMlkkvTsðóo ñ&ð6p8qiô6ñDq+kDq5þ)k&kDp»ñôDlðpGýñôDqRôó'ö8î4q

ômpWo qTjWkcrTð6pGrññ&ð&p"oø8ñqð6lhÿøWîq*kk,qkDpGok6or'p8q5ð qTjWkcô&ñDqrúEk

óôDöklû

ì

jWk\ô6ñqrúk?óôökDl?î4jGð6øóTo-kÞ÷ðlðøWî)sð&lÿô6îî)qTlôp"î÷ðlq

kmssr5ñrTkp8ñö8û.1ôDlðpñóTð&qTjGýJñmôml#ð&p÷Gô÷klZðlZñ&ôl#ð&ppUôDp"ð6q5ø/k&î

ômlkñøMlRlkDp8qóöø"îk&o?ôî:ô1orlkñq8÷jöîrTñ&ô&ó"îÔø÷÷ðlqWsðl$q5j8k1ñôDqRôó'ö8î4q

óôDökl$&08v21/`û43 5,687&9 :<;,=/>?5A@CBEDF:?:F=G;HIB BEJF=/DK"@L:F;=G><7M@N5OQP

7"P?R);5AO/B,5Q@-RSOQHIOTKUBEHVO/RQH7"><7"H(UXW=G;YO;5A@TDRA5)@ RSOSHZOTKUBEHVK"=[O)@?7\P[]?^

OSP<@OX@?5_R);5/O/B,57\P`5)K(5)R_HZ;=N@G5 H2J<7MR)aGP<5/BBb6cJ<7MK(5 9O)7"PNHIO)7"P?7(P?]

]?=G=<@b5_WW7MR/7"5_P?R_U-W=G;dOe;5_@GDFR)5A@:?;,=N@GDFR)H7M=TPfR)=<BgHghij?kgh

l

JF5mK"=?RSOSH7M=TPn=?WoHMJ[5RNOQHO)KUBEH7"P[B,7"@?5HMJF5mO)R)H27"><5

K2O6ökl)jGôîô?õ6lk&ôq;rpMsRóøkpWñ6kwð6p2qTj8kZs4øk&óñ&kóTókms5sr5ñrTkp8ñÔöOû?Uð6lQô

÷8ð&lð6øGî;îÔø÷÷ð6lq4ýEqTjWkHõElÔkôqikî4qp6øGôDpMqrq'öÞð&s$ñ&ôqô&óöWî4qOÿwøWîÔq?k1ñ&óðîk

qð^q5j8k)ÿ?kÿlôp8k1þr'qTjô)oMkñlÔkô&îrpGõñ&ð6p"ñkpqTlôqrðp\õ6lôorkpqUr´p

qTj8kQôñmq5rúk1ó5ôDökldEqN`û

ômpEö ÿ?kqj"ðoWîôDlkëñðÿÞÿ?ð&p"ó'ö kmÿw÷óTð&ök6oëqð sRð6lÿ

ô6ñDqrúk ñôq4ômóöMîqcóôökDlî krqTjWkml$ö ñDjGkDÿ?rTñ&ô&ólð6øqikîëî4øWñDj ô&î

ñ6ðóTóTðArToô6óý?ñ&ômlð6pöóý?ð6lñj8kÿ?rñôó\r´ÿÞ÷lkõ6pUôDqr5ð6p slÔðÿîômóqRîDû

p8ð&qTj"kDlhþôörî¢÷jEö8îrñôóokD÷8ðEî`r'qrTð&pëóTr"!k\÷8ó5ôî4ÿôîÔ÷øqTq5klrpGõ

E/mvs')Dûüúkp\r'sAókîî:ð6sqkDp?øGîk&oýW÷óiô6îÿhôî÷øMqqkDlJokm÷ðîrqTrTðphð&s

Oq2ð&l OqivôóTó5ðö8îcñ&ômqiô6óöMîq2ð6pWqTð ÷Wð6lð6øWîsRrTó´ÿîðs2ñôDlðp jUô&î

îÔjWðþ1p÷lðÿ?r5î`rp"õÁlkmîÔøóqiî-#Gv,'TtLqj"r5î^qk&ñDj8pWr2p6øWk\ôóTóðþQî^qTjWk

ñ&ð6pWqlðóðs qj"k okD÷8ðEî`rqTk&oupEøWôpMqirqTr5kîýñ&ð6pWñ&kDp8qTl`ômq5rTð6p oMk÷Mqj

÷lðsr5óTk&îcômpWo ÿ?ðlR÷MjWðóTðõr5k&îðsqj"kcqj"rp sRrTó´ÿîv#0ýIw/û

ì

j8k

okD÷Wðîr´qwrîsRð6lÿ?k&oðsÿ?kqiô6ó)pUôDpWðñóøGî4qkDlîÞþ)rqTjëôokñlk&ôîrp"õ

okDpUîrq´özslð6ÿ qTjWk îølsÔômñ&k k,÷8ðEî`ko qð qj"k ÷Wóô&îÔÿhô qTð q5j8k

îø/Wî4qTlôDqk#NDûnp qTjWrîôlqrTñóTk&ý^þQk ÷lk&îkDp8qô pWkmþ þQôDösRð6l

ørTóorp"õqTjWk)þ)jWðó5kZô6ñDqrúkóôö¾kl1orlkñqTó'ööÞ÷óô&îÔÿhôî÷øqqklrp"õ

ðs1ñmômlð&pôDp8o?÷8óiôqir´p8øÿû

ì

j"kok÷ðîrq5rTðpGî)ôlk÷8kDlsRð&lÿ?korpô

óTð&þ ÷lkîîÔølk qTl`ômpGîÔsðlRÿhko ñ6ð&ø÷8ó5ko ÷8ó5ôî4ÿhô okDúrTñk

M)÷lrÿyx1rTok/zj8k&rõ6j8q{|%/}/qÞÿÞÿýMoMr5ômÿ¢kDqkl{%|,qÿwÿ+ûTHphôml`õ¾ð&p

÷WóTôî4ÿôrîñmlÔkôqiko rp qj"kñDjUôDÿkloö ô~JôoMrð"lÔk)p6øWkDp"ñÔö

k,qkDlpGô6óAômpqkDpWp"ô+s'8ûw/} ohv')q/q ;þHrqjô^÷8óiôpGômlQî÷rlô&ó

îj"ô÷k'^lð6qRôDqr5ð6pUî#$ñ&ððó5kocö?ôXþQômq5kl:sRóTð&þû

ì

jWk¾ôîk;÷MlÔkîîÔølk

rîwôsð&øMqYw8ûM,q/Uô2ôpWo\qTj"kÞþHð6l!rpGõ÷lkîî4øMlÔk?rîYkqTþHk6kp q8û&w

ôp8owffôû

ì

þHð÷óôDpUôDlZqôlõkDqRî*#w)q/<wTqÿÞÿ)ôlkøGîk&oFtOðpWkÞðs

õlô÷j"r´qikÞñôlEðp 2NMû&/N/ QôDp8oqTjGkÞð6qTjWklð&p"kÞð6s1÷óôDqrpMøÿ

/GûN/-ýM÷óôñ&ko?ôq"qTj8k1ÿhrooóTkXjWk&rõ6jq$rp?qj"k)ñDjOôÿkDl&û

ì

j8k

q4ômlõkDq?riô6î,úðóqRô&õ¾k&îômlk;sr(8koqðZv')qGqxû

ì

j"kHîôÿÞ÷8ókî:ôDlk

îkDq?ðp»ôlðqiômqr'pUõëõ6lð6øp8ok&oëî4øNîqTlôqTk2j"ðóToklû

ì

jWkorTîqRôDp"ñk

kDq5þ)k&kDp?qTjWkZî4øNîqlôDqkQômpWoqTjWkXqiômlõkDqUr5î1)q^ÿwÿ sRð&l1ôDphôp"õók1ðs

0<w/ þHrq5j qTjWk îø/Wî4qTlôDqkj8ðóokDl ôsrîDû

ì

jWk ñôDlðpNT÷óôDqrpMøÿ

óôökDlîôlkcokD÷ðî`r'qkoërpëqTþHðî4qk÷"îDû"rl`îÔqRýôñ&ôl#ð&p óôökDl\rî

õlðþ1pæôDqhlððÿqikmÿw÷kml`ômqøMlÔkðpæô trþQôskl gq)q ÿwÿ+2

oølr´pOõ}/qÿ?rpþHrqj%XfôôDlõðp÷lkmîDî4ølkû

ì

jWk2îkñ&ð6pWoîqkD÷

ñ&ð6pOîrî4qRîÞrpok÷ðîrqr'pUõÁqj"k÷óôqTrpMøÿ ðpMqð\qTjWk÷Wð6lð&ø"îñmôml#ð&p

óôökDlho¾ølrpGõhÿ?rp ôDq-+fôôDlõðp÷lkmîDî4ølkû

ì

j"ktñôDp8pWrp"õ

üAók&ñDq5lð6prñlðîñð÷ötüXÿ?r5ñDlðõlô÷j rp|qTjWk rp"îkqðs

Ur5õEølk+HîÔjWðþQî;ôXqö÷Wrñôó,ñDlðEîDîvî`kñmqirðphð6s$qj"k1÷óôDqrpøMÿ ñ&ðEômqko

ñôDlðpcó5ôDökl&û$tðÿ?kwñðóøÿÞpUîôDlkÞð_Wî`klúk&oþHrqjq/q8vgsw)qpMÿ

j"krõ6j8q ôDp8ou%Gqw)q|p8ÿ þHrToq5j,û

ì

lômpGîÿ?rTîîrðp üAók&ñDqTlð&p

rTñDlðEî`ñ&ð6÷ö

ì

üÿ?rñlðõ6lôD÷MjGî ñ&ð&p8srlÿ?ko qTjGômq\÷óôDqrpMøÿ

or´ssøWîkoæôóTðp"õ ôóTó\qTjWk ñmômlð&pæñ&ðóøÿÞpæokD÷qjÃôp8o sðlÿ?ko

pUôDp"ðñ&ó´øGî4qkDlî þHrqjô orôDÿ?kqkDl ú¾ômlRörpGõ sTlðÿ% qTðuw6p8ÿ\û

HðþHkúklý;qTj"kpGôpGðñ&óøWîqTklîÞokDpUîrq´öôDp"oîr"k4ð)¾î`klúk&oX&öô

oWôDl! ñðpMqTl`ôî4qrp sRr5õ\úWôDlRö þHr'qTj qTjWkok÷qTjUûóðîkqð q5j8k

îølsRô6ñkýôX%NqpMÿóôöMklñ&ð&ÿÞ÷8ðEî`koðsZp"ôp8ðñóøWîÔqklîrpqTj"k0v

wpMÿÃorôDÿhkDqkDl1lôp"õkþHrqjô^j"r5õj2okmpGîrq'öhrî;ð)îkDlúk&o?óTk&ô&orp"õ

qð¢ôcpøWôîrvTñ&ð6pWqTrpWøð6øGîJóiô`ökDl&û/sTqkDl1qj"r5î%/qp8ÿæok÷qTjóôö¾klý¾q5j8k

pUôDp"ðñ&ó´øGî4qkDlîokDpUîrqö ok&ñlkô&î`k&îþHrqj ô jWðÿ?ðõkDp"kðøWî

orTîqTlÔr"øqTr5ðp ô&óTð6pGõ ô6óóqj"kñðó´øÿÞpGîmû

ì

jGk pGôpGðñ&óøWîqTklîî`r"k

okñlkô&î`kmîLqTð*%v#'6pÿ2û

(3)

4e/ME-G.&1%b´U4/95$/T&e)/&O.;!M" /&4/6 4&/& /&%&01 9A.'%J5.1/D5.&,45/m9J$X&/&'65'eH/&mWT.J!G66 %4,%/6&e

T.:%DeD5.X/&bT.& DT/H /&%'01-8.&:D%'DY&,AK6="» 4/m*T `5'/&&%&9d.''e:5.6/m´1 D&/&1 D/%&0)D

ì

jWk ñ&ômlEð6puï÷óiôqirpMøÿ~ñ&ðóøÿÞpUî ôDlk qTjøGî ñmôm÷÷Wko|þ)rqj

÷8óôDqr'p8øÿ ômq$qTjWkwîÔølsRô&ñkwômpWookñ&ð6lôDqk&obmöpUôDp"ðñ&ó'ø"î4qikml`î)ô&óTð6pGõ

qTj8kZñðó'øMÿwp"îû8tøñjñmôml#ð&p?÷8ó5ômqr'p8øÿ óôöMkDlJômlk1p8ðþ î4øWr´q4ôó5kô&î

s4øk&ó8ñ&kó5óîLk&ók&ñDqTlðok&îû

,="g=8$=¾IX3,=UK

<HXA/&/e&DR g%Þ3$D%%?-M .&/&%/eYcAD6//&]3O$3 !&

+G/&/&

K8K.&&& Q6+" ¾H&7X&A KM()1/e& 6)EKM3,.&

>RHC;. D!/9ADUK/&& D E *

'V +"/T/ ¾2/Te6/m +8&T& HWK D/i !/9AK/&6

! " #*$ %

!U#T&%' (&3,%'%TE ()*+,E-M./01& hD5.6 3;3$.&T%

1[#$/&49A%% "KM¾=O 4'D/ DPAT&E 8-,K&&e& 6!.&Y&D

PV! V$*TVV&'"

( 3;HM[DE W2G-O+" *))H+".66e 83:)+"' 8K&b3,/&

-8 D.&/%4,D -*./

. K\=f4 T/& *¾g"#%' D.&/5 *D=85.0& (h/&T ;h/&&%

.! K8D+"i4 <1h +"D !/9;GK¾/T -V 2D*(!&3

(# gU7 mQD,Ym DI1&/T .6/%/eY6 $6*4 %'"

.$ +;;;>i01De&%'/6m Q2()AN.6mi ;I&5)HK.']6m :()1K8

+"'54YE E+f6#1C:].&%/]&/6& ¾3;I#$5]/ 6K]6m.6'5 -O

>5601& "m-M&/&]&/6/& 3UD%T-M/&&DY/*7&VE #*3%

C1(X5/&& ,7H8#$%5% O!""C$N%5 GA8P;T& 8="% T/ .&0(; 5

2& $&V*8 "&'

(3U%'%TE E!"#$D%´5 2DhT.'& M33,.&%'& ;&[#/m49;%%5

-,&KDem K6b&3,/&m-G .6/% XV$2*V$"/"

(3$D%%' 3 3U.% ;#f/T91%%5 !U#f4%i 3U.M

3$/&& D (;&%D!W.mY6`+WD$E "V, $&' !

V (&3,%'%T 33U/65& D 6!"#$%i \T.&& &*´2+"Be&DR

D!W/D91"K/ &9 *3!&V&3

(*+UA-M.&/601&E *!"$f/mN6D0H L!,U#$D%´5 ;38(1&TNN*

5e&&/&%'%& !,Ô(;&NDN& (X&%TKTbK T2#& *! *#6V&3

!U8#$&%´5 "()*'+$"-8.&/&0X ,3(16TNDN*35:e/%% $KTbGK¾

E m+:$!&*+,%$$#