• Aucun résultat trouvé

Interaction of ascending magma with pre-existing crustal fractures in monogenetic basaltic volcanism: an experimental approach

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Interaction of ascending magma with pre-existing crustal fractures in monogenetic basaltic volcanism: an experimental approach"

Copied!
43
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00855253

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00855253

Submitted on 6 Sep 2013

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Interaction of ascending magma with pre-existing

crustal fractures in monogenetic basaltic volcanism: an

experimental approach

Nicolas Le Corvec, Thierry Menand, Jan Lindsay

To cite this version:

(2)

!"

#$%&'()%*+$" +," (-)&$.*$/" 0(/0(" 1*%2" 3'&4&5*-%*$/" )'6-%(7" ,'()%6'&-" *$"

!"

0+$+/&$&%*)"8(-(7%*)"9+7)($*-0:"($"&53&'*0&$%(7"(33'+()2"

;" " <"

=*)+7(-">&"?+'9&)!@"A2*&''B"C&$($.;@<@D@"E($">*$.-(B!" D"

!

" F)2++7" +," G$9*'+$0&$%@" A2&" H$*9&'-*%B" +," I6)J7($.@" K'*9(%&" L(/" M;N!M@" I6)J7($." !!D;@" =&1" O"

P&(7($.Q"G40(*7:"$Q7&)+'9&)R(6)J7($.Q()Q$S" T"

;"

(3)

;" "#$%&'(%"" !<" C(/0("%'($-3+'%"%2'+6/2".*J&-"*-"("0(\+'")+03+$&$%"+,"%2&".&9&7+30&$%"+,"0+$+/&$&%*)"9+7)($*)" !D" ,*&7.-Q"A2&-&"9+7)($*)",*&7.-"('&")2('()%&'*S&."8B"$60&'+6-"9+7)($*)")&$%&'-@"&()2"%B3*)(77B"'&-67%*$/" !O"

,'+0" (" -*$/7&" &'63%*+$Q" A2&'&,+'&"0(/0(" 06-%" 8&" %'($-3+'%&." ,'+0" -+6')&" %+"-6',()&" (%" .*,,&'&$%" !T"

37()&-@" 12*)2" '(*-&-" %2&" ]6&-%*+$" +," %2&" '&7(%*9&" *03+'%($)&" +," !^" %2&" -&7,43'+3(/(%*+$" +," 0(/0(" !Y" %2'+6/2"3'*-%*$&"'+)J@"($.";^"%2&")+$%'+7"&5&'%&."8B"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&-Q"A+"(..'&--"%2*-"*--6&@"1&" !W" 2(9&")(''*&."+6%"("-&'*&-"+,"($(7+/6&"&53&'*0&$%-"%+")+$-%'(*$"%2&"*$%&'()%*+$"+,"("3'+3(/(%*$/".*J&" !M" 1*%2"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&-Q"A2&"&53&'*0&$%-"*$9+79&."%2&"*$\&)%*+$"+,"(*'"*$%+"($"&7(-%*)"/&7(%*$"-+7*.@" ;N"

12*)2" 1(-" 3'&9*+6-7B" )6%" *$%+" *%-" 633&'" 3('%" %+" -*067(%&" 3'&4&5*-%*$/" ,'()%6'&-Q" A2&" 9+760&" +," %2&" ;!"

.*J&-@" %2&*'" .*-%($)&" ,'+0" %2&" ,'()%6'&-" ($." %2&" (08*&$%" -%'&--" ,*&7." 1&'&" -B-%&0(%*)(77B" 9('*&." %+" ;;"

(--&--" %2&*'" *$,76&$)&" +$" 3+%&$%*(7" .*J&4,'()%6'&" *$%&'()%*+$-Q" A2&" '&-67%-" -2+1" %2(%" .*-%($)&" ($." ;<"

($/7&" 8&%1&&$" .*J&-" ($." ,'()%6'&-" *$,76&$)&" %2&-&-" *$%&'()%*+$-" ($." %2&" .*J&" %'(\&)%+'BQ" [*J&" ;D" /&+0&%'B"($.".B$(0*)-"('&"(7-+"(,,&)%&."8B"8+%2"%2&"3'&-&$)&"+,"%2&",'()%6'&-"($."%2&".*J&"9+760&_" ;O" .*J&-"3'+3(/(%*$/"*$"8&%1&&$",'()%6'&-"%&$."%+".&)&7&'(%&Q"#$"$(%6'&@"*$%&'()%*+$-"('&"&53&)%&.",+'" ;T" .*J&-"($.",'()%6'&-"-&3('(%&."8B"7&--"%2($"(8+6%";NN"0@"($.".*J&-"1*%2"("9+760&"7&--"%2($"(8+6%"!N4;" ;Y"

J0<" 1+67." &53&'*&$)&" (" 9&7+)*%B" .&)'&(-&Q" A2&-&" '&-67%-" 2*/27*/2%" %2&" *$,76&$)&" +," 3'&4&5*-%*$/" ;W"

,'()%6'&-"+$"%2&"0&)2($*)-"($.".B$(0*)-"+,".*J&-Q"A2&-&"2&%&'+/&$&*%*&-"06-%"8&")+$-*.&'&."12&$" ;M"

-%6.B*$/"%2&"%'($-3+'%"+,"0(/0(-"1*%2*$"%2&")'6-%Q" <N"

)*+,-&.$/" [*J&" 3'+3(/(%*+$"に" K'&4&5*-%*$/" )'6-%(7" ,'()%6'&" に" F%'&--" ,*&7." に" C+$+/&$&%*)" 8(-(7%*)" <!" 9+7)($*-0"に"I$(7+/6&"0+.&7*$/" <;" " <<" ! #$%'+.6)%*+$" <D" V+7)($*)"&'63%*+$-"('&"%2&"'&-67%-"+,"%2&"3'+3(/(%*+$"+,"0(/0(",'+0"-+6')&"%+"-6',()&Q"`&+)2&0*)(7" <O"

(4)

<" &9+76%*+$" +," %2&" 0(/0(" .6'*$/" 8+%2" %'($-,&'" %2'+6/2" ($." -%+'(/&" 1*%2*$" %2&" 7*%2+-32&'&" a!"##$"%& <Y"

'()& *(("(@" ;NNWbQ" c+1&9&'@" %2&" 32B-*)(7" ($." 0&)2($*)(7" 6$.&'-%($.*$/" +," %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," ("

<W" 0(/0(4,*77&.")'()J@"+'".*J&@"($."*%-"'&7(%*+$-2*3"1*%2"%2&"7+)(%*+$"($."9+760&"+,"($"&'63%*+$"('&"-%*77" <M" (")2(77&$/*$/"36SS7&"a+',-("&'()&.'/0'%1@";NNM_"+',-("&'()&+',1@";NNM_";N!!bQ"" DN" A2&",+'0(%*+$"($.".&9&7+30&$%"+,"0+$+/&$&%*)"8(-(7%*)"9+7)($*)",*&7.-"('&" 6-&,67"&5(037&-"+,"%2&" D!" )+037&5*%B"+,"0(/0("3'+3(/(%*+$"*$"%2&"7*%2+-32&'&Q"I7%2+6/2"0+$+/&$&%*)"8(-(7%*)"9+7)($*)",*&7.-" D;"

+))6'" 1+'7.1*.&@" %2&B" ('&" 0+-%" )+00+$" 1*%2*$" &5%&$-*+$(7" '&/*0&-" a+'2')'@" !MMDbQ" #$" (..*%*+$@" D<"

&9&'B",*&7.@"*$.&3&$.&$%"+,"*%-"%&)%+$*)"&$9*'+$0&$%@"*-")2('()%&'*S&."8B"$60&'+6-"9+7)($*)")&$%&'-" DD"

-2+1*$/")76-%&'*$/"($."7*$&(0&$%-"a34((4%@"!MMN_"34((4%&"1&'#5@"!MM;_"6'77'%,(,&'()&89:%'7,4@";NN<_" DO"

6'77'%,(,& "1& '#5@" ;N!N_" ;"& 34%<"=& "1& '#5@" F680*%%&.bQ" G()2" 9+7)($*)" )&$%&'" %B3*)(77B" '&-67%-" ,'+0" ("

DT"

-*$/7&" 0(*$" &'63%*+$" 1*%2" 0(/0(" %'($-3+'%&." ,'+0" %2&" 0($%7&@" *%-" 3'*$)*3(7" -+6')&@" %+" .*,,&'&$%" DY"

37()&-"+$"%2&"-6',()&"1*%2"&'63%&."9+760&-"'($/*$/",'+0"!N4O"%+"!"J0<"+,"0(/0("dA(87&"!^Q"" DW"

A'($-3+'%" +," 0(/0(" *$" 0+$+/&$&%*)" 8(-(7%*)" 9+7)($*-0" *-" )+$-*.&'&." %+" +))6'" 9*(" 0(/0(4,*77&." DM"

)'()J-@"+'".*J&-"a>'#"(1,("&'()&?,%'(4@";N!NbQ"[*J&"3'+3(/(%*+$"-%('%-"12&$"%2&"0(/0("3'&--6'&"*$" ON"

%2&"-+6')&"*-"7('/&"&$+6/2"%+",'()%6'&"'+)J-"a>'#"(1,("&'()&?,%'(4@";N!NbQ"A2&$@"(-"(".*J&"/'+1-"($." O!"

3'+3(/(%&-@" *%-" 86+B($)B" +9&')+0&-" %2&" -+6')&" 3'&--6'&" (-" %2&" .'*9*$/" 0&)2($*-0" a6"('()& '()& O;"

+',1@";NN;bQ"A2&"3'+3(/(%*+$"*-"%2&$".'*9&$"8B"%2&".*,,&'&$)&"8&%1&&$"0(/0("($."0(%'*5".&$-*%B@"+'"

O<"

86+B($)B@" %2&" &7(-%*)" -%'&--" *$" '&-3+$-&" %+" %2&" .&,+'0(%*+$" +," %2&" 2+-%@" ($." %2&" 0(/0(" OD"

+9&'3'&--6'&" d%2&" 0(/0(" 3'&--6'&" *$" &5)&--" +," %2&" 7*%2+-%(%*)" ($." ($B" 3+%&$%*(7" .&9*(%+'*)" )'6-%(7" OO"

-%'&--"()%*$/"$+'0(77B"+$"%2&".*J&^Q"e$"%2&"+%2&'"2($.@".*J&"3'+3(/(%*+$"*-"'&-%'*)%&."8B"%2&",'()%6'&" OT"

%+6/2$&--"+,"%2&" 2+-%" '+)J-" a@/A,(@"!MM<b@"($."%2&"9*-)+6-"3'&--6'&" .'+3",'+0"%2&" ,7+1"+,"0(/0(" OY"

a@40"%& '()& ;,-1"%@" ;NNYbQ" A2&" -%'&--" ,*&7." )($" &*%2&'" 3'+0+%&" &5%'6-*9&" +'" *$%'6-*9&" /'+1%2" aB)'@" OW"

!MMMbQ" #$.&&.@"HWI; W" ;" SキニW" キ " Iラミ キSW WS" ; " ;" Wミ キノW" I ;Iニ" ふラ Wミキミェ" W WミSキI ノ; " ラ" ゝ<^@" %2&"

OM"

-%'&--" ,*&7." 1*77" *$,76&$)&" %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" .*'&)%*+$" ($." +3&$*$/" +," %2&" .*J&" a*()"%-4(@" !MO!_" TN"

6"('()& "1& '#5@" ;N!Nb" ($." %2&'&,+'&" %2&" 3+--*8*7*%B" +," 2(9*$/" (7*/$0&$%" +," 9+7)($*)" )&$%&'-" (%" %2&"

(5)

D" -6',()&" a@44("C& "1& '#5@" ;N!!bQ" c+1&9&'" .*J&-" ('&" $+%" 3(--*9&" ,&(%6'&-@" 86%" *$-%&(." *$,76&$)&" %2&*'" T;" -6''+6$.*$/"$&('4,*&7."-%'&--")+$.*%*+$-"8B"/&$&'(%*$/"7+)(7")+03'&--*9&"($."&5%&$-*9&"-%'&--"('&(-" T<" a@4$'(@";NNO_"6'=='D"%%,&"1&'#5@";N!Nb"dX*/Q"!)"($.".^Q"I..*%*+$(77B@"%2&'&"&5*-%-")+$.*%*+$-"+,"(''&-%" TD" ,+'"%2&"9&'%*)(7"3'+3(/(%*+$"+,"(".*J&"*$"%2&"633&'")'6-%@"&Q/Q"7&9&7"+,"$&6%'(7"86+B($)B@"3'&-&$)&"+," TO" -%'(%*,*)(%*+$"($."%2&"9+760&"+,"0(/0("1*%2*$"%2&".*J&" a+',-("&"1&'#5@";N!!(b@"12*)2"0(B")2($/&"(" TT" 9&'%*)(7"3'+3(/(%*$/".*J&"*$%+"("2+'*S+$%(7"3'+3(/(%*$/"-*77"aE'<'('FG&"1&'#5@";NNT_"6'=='D"%%,&"1&'#5@" TY" ;N!N_"6"('()&"1&'#5@";N!Nb"($."%26-"3'&9&$%"0(/0("%+"'&()2"%2&"-6',()&Q"" TW"

A2&" 633&'" 3('%" +," %2&" 7*%2+-32&'&" *-" J$+1$" %+" 8&" 8'*%%7&" ($." 2*/27B" ,'()%6'&." a@'('##,@" !MMOb@" 1*%2" TM"

3'&4&5*-%*$/")'6-%(7",'()%6'&".*-%'*86%*+$-"%2(%"('&"-)(7&"*$.&3&$.&$%"($.",+77+1"3+1&'"7(1-"aH4(("1& YN"

"1&'#5@";NN!bQ"[*J&-"($.")'6-%(7",'()%6'&-"('&")+00+$"*$"%2&")'6-%_"2+1&9&'"2+1"%2&B"*$%&'()%"*-"$+%"

Y!"

+89*+6-Q" [&7($&B" &%" (7Q" a!MWTb" -6//&-%&." %2(%" .*J&-" )+67." &*%2&'" ,+77+1" -&7,4/&$&'(%&." ,'()%6'&-" +'" Y;"

6-&" 3'&4&5*-%*$/" \+*$%-" .&3&$.*$/" +$" %2&*'" +'*&$%(%*+$" ($." 0(/0(" +9&'3'&--6'&Q" Z&)&$%" -%6.*&-" Y<"

-2+1" %2(%" 0(/0(%*)" *$%'6-*+$-" *$%&'()%" 1*%2" )'6-%(7" 3'&4&5*-%*$/" ,'()%6'&-" dKX-^" a>'#"(1,("& '()& YD"

E%4FG@";NNT_"I'DD("C&"1&'#5@";NNY_"J"1$4%"&"1&'#5@";NNMb@"/*9&$")&'%(*$")+$.*%*+$-:"*^"KX-"('&"(70+-%"

YO"

W WミSキI ノ; " ラ" エW"ノW; "Iラマ W キ W" W "ゝ<"($."-%&&37B".*33*$/"dfTNg^_"**^"-2&('"-%'&--&-"+$"%2&"

YT"

,'()%6'&"('&"-0(77")+03('&."%+"%2&"&5)&--"0(/0("3'&--6'&_"***^"&,,&)%*9&"(08*&$%".*J&4$+'0(7"-%'&--" YY"

*-"-0(77")+03('&."%+"%2&"'+)J"%&$-*7&"-%'&$/%2"a!,<&"1&'#5@";NNN_">'#"(1,("&'()&E%4FG@";NNT_"I'DD("C&"1& YW"

'#5@" ;NNYbQ" I..*%*+$(77B@" (" '&)&$%" -%6.B" 2(-" -2+1$" %2&" -%'+$/" *$,76&$)&" +," (" KX" +$" %2&" -%'&--" ,*&7."

YM"

(--+)*(%&."1*%2"("3'&--6'*S&."0(/0(")2(08&'@"($."%2(%"%2&"3+-*%*+$"+,",(67%-"/'&(%7B"*$,76&$)&-"%2&" WN"

3'+3(/(%*+$"+,"(".*J&"aK,$'2,(&'()&IG'--"$,@";N!NbQ" W!"

K'&4&5*-%*$/" ,'()%6'&-" *$" %2&" 8'*%%7&" 633&'" )'6-%" %2&'&,+'&" *$,76&$)&" %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," 0(/0(-" (-" W;"

1&77" (-" %2&" .&9&7+30&$%"+," 0+$+/&$&%*)" 8(-(7%*)" ,*&7.-Q" A2*-" *-" *776-%'(%&." *$" X*/Q" !@" 12*)2" -2+1-" (" W<"

.*J&" %2(%" )'+--4)6%" -&.*0&$%('B" 7(B&'-" ($." 3'+3(/(%&." 3('(77&7" %+" %2&" .*3" +," %2&" -6''+6$.*$/" 3'&4 WD"

&5*-%*$/" ,'()%6'&-Q" c+1&9&'@" 12(%" )+$%'+7-" 12&%2&'" (" .*J&" *$%&'()%-" 1*%2" +'" *-" *$,76&$)&." 8B" (" KX" WO"

(6)

O" .(%(" 3'+9*.&" 7*0*%&." *$,+'0(%*+$" +$" %2&" .B$(0*)-" +," .*J&" 3'+3(/(%*+$@" 1&" -%6.*&." %2&" *$%&'()%*+$" WY"

8&%1&&$" .*J&-" ($." KX-" %2'+6/2" ($(7+/6&" 0+.&7*$/Q" h&" 7*0*%&." +6'" ($(7B-*-" %+" %2&" ,+77+1*$/" WW"

3('(0&%&'-@" )+$-*.&'&." %+" *$,76&$)&" %2&" *$%&'()%*+$" 8&%1&&$" (" .*J&" ($." (" KX:" !^" %2&" 9+760&" +," WM"

*$\&)%&."0(/0(@";^"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"(".*J&"($."("KX@"($."<^"%2&"*03()%"+,"(".&9*(%+'*)"-%'&--Q"" MN"

c&'&"1&"-2+1"%2&"+8-&'9(%*+$-"($."'&-67%-"+,"-)(7&."($(7+/6&"&53&'*0&$%-@"12*)2"(*0"%+")+$-%'(*$" M!"

%2&" &,,&)%" +," %2&" .*'&)%*+$" +," 3'+3(/(%*+$@" -2(3&" ($." 9&7+)*%B" +," (" .*J&" +$" (" 3+%&$%*(7" *$%&'()%*+$" M;"

1*%2"KX-Q"A2&-&"'&-67%-"('&"%2&$".*-)6--&."($."'&7(%&."%+"$(%6'(7")(-&-Q" M<"

; I$(7+/6&"0+.&77*$/" MD"

A2&" 8&2(9*+'" +," (" 86+B($%" .*J&" ($." *%-" *$%&'()%*+$" 1*%2" KX-" *$" 2B.'+-%(%*)" ($." &5%&$-*+$(7" -%'&--" MO"

,*&7.-" 1&'&" 8+%2" -%6.*&." 8B" *$\&)%*$/" (*'" *$" (" 2+0+/&$&+6-" /&7(%*$" 3'&4)6%" 8B" +$&" +'" -&9&'(7" MT"

,'()%6'&-Q"`&7(%*$"*-"("/++."($(7+/6&"0(%&'*(7"2(9*$/"&7(-%*)"($."8'*%%7&"8&2(9*+'"*,"3'&3('&."3'+3&'7B" MY"

a6"7F"%@" ;NN;_" 8,& I,/-"00"& "1& '#5@" ;NNM_" E'<'('FG& "1& '#5@" ;N!;bQ" #$.&&.@" /&7(%*$" -2+1-" (" /'(.6(7" MW"

)2($/&"*$"8&2(9*+'",'+0"("36'&7B"&7(-%*)"%+"9*-)+4&7(-%*)"'2&+7+/B"*$"%2&"-+7*.4-%(%&"%+"36'&7B"9*-)+6-" MM"

'2&+7+/B" *$" %2&" $+$4-+7*.4-%(%&@" .&3&$.*$/" +$" *%-" )+03+-*%*+$@" )+$)&$%'(%*+$@"%&03&'(%6'&@"(/&*$/" !NN"

($." %2&" (337*&." -%'(*$" -%(%&" a8,& I,/-"00"& "1& '#5@" ;NNMbQ" X+77+1*$/" (" 3'&3('(%*+$" (-" -3&)*,*&." 8B" !N!" i(9($(/2"&%"(7Q"a;N!;b@"%2&"/&7(%*$"*$"+6'"-&%63"1(-")+$-*.&'&."%+"8&"($"*.&(74&7(-%*)"0&.*60"*$"*%-" !N;" -+7*.*,*&."-%(%&@"-6)2"%2(%:"" !N<" " !ND" 購 噺 継" 綱" d!^" !NO" " !NT"

12&'&" " *-" -%'&--@" !"キ " エW" ラノキS" ラ ミェげ "cラS ノ " ;ミS" " *-" -%'(*$" dKララニWげ " ノ; ぶQ" A2&-&" '2&+7+/*)(7" !NY"

(7)

T" 12+7&@"*$"($"&7(-%*)"1(B",+'"*$-%($%($&+6-"(337*&."-%'&--"a@'('##,@"!MMObQ"h&"6-&."(*'"(-"($"($(7+/6&" !NM" ,76*.",+'"("86+B($%7B"'*-*$/"8(-(7%*)"0(/0(Q"" !!N" ;Q! C&%2+.+7+/B" !!!" G9&'B"&53&'*0&$%"1(-")(''*&."+6%"6-*$/"%2&"-(0&"-&%463Q"I"-]6('&48(-&"%($J"d8(-&:"DN")0"5"DN")0@" !!;" 2&*/2%:"<N")0^"1(-"6-&."%+")'&(%&"%2&"/&7(%*$"87+)JQ"A2&"%($J"1(-"0(.&"+,"K&'-3&5@"($."*%-"8(-&"2(." !!<" ("-&'*&-"+,"*$\&)%*+$"3+*$%-"+,"O00".*(0&%&'"&9&'B")&$%*0&%&'",'+0"%2&"0*..7&"+,"%2&"%($J"+6%1('.Q" !!D" A2&"/&7(%*$"d("2*/24)7('*%B@";TN"87++0@"()*.@"3*/-J*$4.&'*9&."/&7(%*$^"1(-"3'&3('&."8B"0*5*$/"/&7(%*$" !!O" 3+1.&'"1*%2"2+%"1(%&'"*$"%2&"%($JQ"C&%(7"37(%&-"1&'&"*$%'+.6)&."+$"%1+"3('(77&7"-*.&-"+,"%2&"%($J" !!T"

dX*/Q" ;(^Q" A2&" /&7(%*$" 1(-" )+9&'&." 8B" (" %2*$" 7(B&'" +," +*7" %+" (9+*." &9(3+'(%*+$" .6'*$/" )++7*$/" ($." !!Y"

37()&."*$"(",'*./&"(%"!Ng?",+'";D"2+6'-"%+"(77+1"*%-"-+7*.*,*)(%*+$Q"" !!W"

e$)&" -&%@" %2&" 3'+3&'%*&-" +," %2&" /&7(%*$" 1&'&" 0&(-6'&." (-" ,+77+1-く" エW" ラ ミェげ " マラS ノ " ふ!^" 1(-" !!M"

(8)

Y" #$"-+0&"&53&'*0&$%-@"KX-"1&'&")'&(%&.@";a W " エW" ラ ミェげ "マラS ノ "エ;S"HWWミ"マW; WSが"8B")6%%*$/" !<!"

%2&" 633&'" 3('%" +," %2&" /&7(%*$" 6-*$/" (" '(*74/6*.&." J$*,&" dM" )0" .&&3^Q" A2&$@" 8&,+'&" -%('%*$/" ($" !<;"

&53&'*0&$%@" 8+%2" 0&%(7" 37(%&-" d!;"00"%2*)J^" 1&'&" '&0+9&." ($." '&37()&." 8B" )+7." 1(%&'" %+" )'&(%&" !<<"

,'&&"-6',()&")+$.*%*+$-"+$"&()2"-*.&"+,"%2&"/&7(%*$"dX*/Q";8"($.")^Q"A+")'&(%&"($"&5%&$-*+$(7"'&/*0&@" !<D"

%2&"/&7(%*$"1(-",*'-%"6$-%6)J",'+0"%2&"%2'&&"+%2&'"-*.&-"d,'+$%@"8()J"($."8+%%+0"-*.&^"+,"%2&"%($J"%+" !<O"

&$-6'&" %2&" &5%&$-*+$" %+" 8&" 2+0+/&$&+6-" %2'+6/2+6%" %2&" /&7(%*$" -+7*." dX*/-Q" ;" ($." <^Q" A2&$" (" !<T"

2+'*S+$%(7" %&$-*7&" .&9*(%+'*)" -%'&--" 1(-" )'&(%&." 8B" *03+-*$/" (" 2+0+/&$&+6-@" 9&'%*)(7" )+03'&--*9&" !<Y"

7+(." +$" *%-" &$%*'&" 633&'" -6',()&" dX*/Q" ;)^@" (-" .&%(*7&." *$" -&)%*+$" ;Q<Q" X*$(77B@" (" 3'&4)6%" +," (" ,&1" !<W"

0*77*0&%&'-" 1(-" 0(.&" (%" %2&" 8(-&" +," %2&" /&7(%*$" -+7*." 8&,+'&" *$\&)%*$/" (*'" *$" +'.&'" %+" ,+')&" %2&" !<M" &53&'*0&$%(7".*J&"d'&,&''&."*$"%2&",+77+1*$/"(-".*J&^"%+"3'+3(/(%&"3&'3&$.*)67('7B"%+"%2&",'+$%"-*.&" !DN" +,"%2&"%($J"+'@",+'"-+0&"&53&'*0&$%-@"3('(77&7"%+"%2&"37($&"+,"%2&"KXd-^Q"I"3'&.&%&'0*$&."9+760&"+," !D!" (*'"1(-"*$\&)%&."*$-*.&"%2&"/&7(%*$"%2'+6/2"%2&"*$\&)%*+$"3+*$%-"6-*$/"("-B'*$/&@"12*)2"(77+1&."6-"%+" !D;" )+$%'+7"($."9('B"%2&"9+760&"+,"*$\&)%&."(*'",'+0"+$&"&53&'*0&$%"%+"($+%2&'Q"G()2"&53&'*0&$%"1(-" !D<"

'&)+'.&." 6-*$/" (" .*/*%(7" 9*.&+" )(0&'(Q" A2&" 0+9*&-" 1&'&" -68-&]6&$%7B" ($(7BS&." 6-*$/" (" CIA>IL" !DD"

-)'*3%" %+"0&(-6'&" %2&" &9+76%*+$" +," %2&" -2(3&@" %2&" .*'&)%*+$" +," 3'+3(/(%*+$" ($." %2&" 9&7+)*%B" +," %2&" !DO"

.*J&"*$-*.&"%2&"/&7(%*$"dF&&"I33&$.*5"!^Q"A2&"3*)%6'&-"1&'&"($(7BS&.",'+0"%2&"0+0&$%"%2&".*J&"1(-" !DT"

-&3('(%&." ,'+0" %2&" -B'*$/&" 6$%*7" *%" '&()2&." %2&" -6',()&Q" A2*-" ($(7B-*-" (77+1&."6-" %+" .&%&'0*$&" ($B" !DY" 3+%&$%*(7"*03()%"+,"KX"+$"%2&".*J&"3'+3(/(%*+$Q" !DW" ;Q; F)(7*$/" !DM" I$(7+/6&"0+.&7-"('&"6-&."%+"*.&$%*,B"($."($(7BS&"%2&"0(*$"3'+)&--&-"+3&'(%*$/"*$"$(%6'(7"-B-%&0-" !ON" (%"%2&"7(8+'(%+'B"-)(7&"a@'$A"%F@"!MW!bQ"A2&"($(7+/6&"0+.&7"+,"%2&"G('%2"-2+67."8&"/&+0&%'*)(77B@" !O!"

J*$&0(%*)(77B" ($." .B$(0*)(77B" -*0*7('"%+" *%-" $(%6'(7" 3'+%+%B3&" a?/AA"%1@"!M<YbQ"c&'&" 1&" ,+77+1" %2&" !O;"

(9)

W" e6'" &53&'*0&$%-" )+$-*.&'" %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," (" 86+B($%" 0(/0(4,*77&." )'()J" %2'+6/2" ($" &7(-%*)" !OD"

0&.*60@" %26-" +6'" -&%%*$/" 06-%" )'&(%&" (" .&$-*%B" )+$%'(-%" d*Q&Q@" 86+B($)B^" ($." (" '&-*-%($)&" %+" %2&" !OO"

a ;I キミェ"ラa" エW"マWSキ マ"ふキくWくが"a ;I W" ラ ェエミW ぶ" キマキノ; " ラ" エラ W"W キ キミェ"キミ" エW";; エげ "I く"" !OT"

e6'" &53&'*0&$%-" )+$-*.&'" %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," (" 86+B($%" 0(/0(4,*77&." )'()J" %2'+6/2" ($" &7(-%*)" !OY" 0&.*60"'&-*-%&."8B"%2&",'()%6'&"'&-*-%($)&"+,"%2&"0&.*60Q"A2&"8(7($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&-&"%1+",+')&-" !OW" %(J&-"37()&"$&('"%2&"%*3"+,"%2&".*J&"+9&'"%2&"86+B($)B"7&$/%2"-)(7&"()@"12&'&:" !OM" " !TN" 詣決 噺 岾懲迩 ッ諦直峇 態 " dD^" !T!" " !T;" ($."Ft"*-"%2&".*,,&'&$)&"8&%1&&$"%2&".&$-*%B"+,"%2&"-+7*."($."%2(%"+,"%2&",76*.@"%"*-"%2&"/'(9*%(%*+$(7" !T<"

())&7&'(%*+$@" ($." &'" *-" %2&" ,'()%6'&" %+6/2$&--" +," %2&" -+7*." a+',-("& '()& +',1@" ;NNMbQ" A2*-" 86+B($)B" !TD"

7&$/%2@" ()@" )+''&-3+$.-" %+" %2&" 0*$*060" .*J&" 7&$/%2" $&&.&." ,+'" ,'()%6'*$/" %2&" -6''+6$.*$/" '+)J-@" !TO" ($."*%"+))6'-"12&$"%2&"-%'&--"*$%&$-*%B",()%+'"(%"%2&".*J&"%*3"&*"&]6(7-"%2&"'+)J",'()%6'&"%+6/2$&--"&'+ !TT" a6"('()&'()&+',1@";NN;bQ" !TY" A+"-)(7&"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-"/&+0&%'*)(77B@"1&")(7)67(%&."%2&"'(%*+"d(),^"8&%1&&$"%2&"86+B($)B"7&$/%2" !TW" +,"%2&"*$%'6-*+$"*$"+6'"0+.&7"d()-^"($."%2(%"*$"$(%6'&"d().^:"" !TM" " !YN" 詣決茅噺"挑長尿 挑長韮 噺" 岾 懲頂尿"ッ蹄尿 懲頂韮"ッ蹄韮峇 態 " dO^" !Y!" " !Y;"

#$"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-@"Ft"j"t%/0$12."j"!NNN"J/k0<"($."%2&"/&7(%*$"0&($",'()%6'&"%+6/2$&--"&'"l"YN"4"WN" !Y<"

(10)

M" ,'()%6'&"%+6/2$&--"&'"j"!NY"K(Q0!k;"(-"'&3'&-&$%(%*9&"9(76&-",+'"("8(-(7%*)"9+7)($*)",*&7.@"1&",*$."%2(%@" !YO"

,+'"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-@"%2&"'(%*+"(),+l"!N4DQ"e6'"0+.&7"*-"%2&$"l!ND"-0(77&'"%2($"%2&"$(%6'(7"-B-%&0"($." !YT"

%26-" '&3'&-&$%-" (" -2(77+1" 3+'%*+$" +," )'6-%@" $(0&7B" %2&" 633&'" ;4<" J0Q" A2&" $(%6'(7" .*0&$-*+$-" !YY" '&3'&-&$%&."8B"+6'"0+.&7"('&"7*-%&."*$"A(87&";Q"A2&"-)(7&."9+760&"*$\&)%&."*$"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-"7*&-"*$" !YW" %2&"'($/&"+,"9+760&"&'63%&."*$"0+$+/&$&%*)"9+7)($*)",*&7.-"dA(87&"!^Q"" !YM" >*J&1*-&@"%2&"%*0&"-)(7&"*$"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-".*,,&'-",'+0"%2(%"*$"$(%6'&@"($."+6'"&53&'*0&$%-"06-%"8&" !WN"

-)(7&." J*$&0(%*)(77BQ" h&" -)(7&." +6'" &53&'*0&$%(7" 9&7+)*%*&-" 6-*$/" %2&" '&.6)&." /'(9*%B"̌ " aKG'(2'%& !W!"

K/A%'$'(,'(@" !MM;b@" 12*)2" *-" %2&" &,,&)%*9&" /'(9*%(%*+$(7" ())&7&'(%*+$" *$" %2&" 2+-%" -+7*." .6&" %+"

(11)

!N" 12*)2"(77+1-"6-"%+")(7)67(%&"%2&"9&7+)*%B"-)(7&" !MO" " !MT" 戟 噺 " 詣決 劇斑 " dM^" !MY" " !MW" 戟 噺 岫ッ貢訣岻迭展"計潔迭典"貢鎚墜鎮沈鳥貸迭鉄"" d!N^" !MM" " ;NN" +'" ;N!" " ;N;" 戟 噺 岾懲頂 濡任如日匂峇 迭 典"訣" d!!^" ;N<" " ;ND" I"J*$&0(%*)"-)(7*$/"'(%*+"3,")($"%2&'&,+'&"8&")(7)67(%&.:" ;NO" " ;NT" 戟茅噺"腸尿任匂賑如 腸韮尼禰祢認賑" d!;^" ;NY" " ;NW" H-*$/"%2&"-(0&"'&3'&-&$%(%*9&"$(%6'(7"9(76&-"+,".&$-*%B".*,,&'&$)&"($.",'()%6'&"%+6/2$&--"(-"8&,+'&@" ;NM"

($." %(J*$/" (" '+)J" .&$-*%B" +," ;ONN" J/k0<@" &]6(%*+$" d!;^" /*9&-" (" J*$&0(%*)" -)(7*$/" '(%*+" 3," j" NQNDTQ" ;!N"

K'+3(/(%*+$" 9&7+)*%*&-" *$" +6'" 0+.&7" d0&($" 9(76&j" l!<Q!N4<" 0k-^" ('&" %2&'&,+'&" *$" ())+'.($)&" 1*%2" ;!!"

8(-(7%*)".*J&"9&7+)*%*&-"*$"$(%6'&"dNQ!4!"0k-^"a+',-("&"1&'#5@";N!!8bQ" ;!;"

(12)

!!" h&"*$9&-%*/(%&."%1+".*,,&'&$%"-%'&--"'&/*0&-"1*%2"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-Q"" ;!D" ;Q<Q! cB.'+-%(%*)"'&/*0&" ;!O" #$"%2*-"-&%"+,"&53&'*0&$%-@"$+".&9*(%+'*)"-%'&--&-"1&'&"(337*&."%+"%2&"/&7(%*$"dX*/Q";8^Q"L&)(6-&"%2&" ;!T"

ェWノ; キミ"キ "Iラミ キSW WS"; ";" W"Wノ; キI"マWSキ マ" キ エ";"vラキ ラミげ " ; キラ"p"j"NQO@"%2&"-%(%&"+,"-%'&--"*$"%2&" ;!Y" /&7(%*$"(%"%2&"-%('%"+,"($"&53&'*0&$%"*-"2B.'+-%(%*)"a+'2')'@"!MMNb"($."'&,&'&$)&-"%2&'&*$^:" ;!W" " ;!M" 購掴 噺 購槻噺 購佃" d!<^" ;;N" " ;;!" ;Q<Q; G5%&$-*+$(7"'&/*0&" ;;;"

#$" %2*-" -&%" +," &53&'*0&$%-@" (" 2+'*S+$%(7" %&$-*7&" .&9*(%+'*)" -%'&--" 1(-" (337*&.Q" L&)(6-&" +," %2&" 1&(J" ;;<" %&$-*7&"-%'&$/%2"+,"%2&"/&7(%*$@"%2*-"1(-".+$&"8B"*03+-*$/"("7+(."+$"%2&"633&'"-6',()&"+,"%2&"/&7(%*$Q" ;;D" F*$)&"%2&"/&7(%*$"1(-")+$-%'(*$&."8B"%1+"+33+-*%&"%($J"1(77-@"*$"%2&"m4.*'&)%*+$@"(-"1&77"(-"%2&"'*/*." ;;O" 8(-&"+,"%2&"%($J@"%2&"/&7(%*$"1(-"+$7B",'&&"%+"0+9&"*$"%2&"+%2&'"n4.*'&)%*+$"dX*/Q";)^Q"A2*-"2+'*S+$%(7" ;;T"

.&,+'0(%*+$" +," %2&" /&7(%*$" -+7*." +8%(*$&." 8B" *03+-*$/" (" 9&'%*)(7" 3+-*%*9&" )+03'&--*9&" .&9*(%+'*)" ;;Y"

(13)

!;" ;QD >*0*%(%*+$-"

;<O"

L&)(6-&" $(%6'(7" -B-%&0-" ('&" )+037&5" -B-%&0-@"%2&*'" 0+.&7*$/" '&]6*'&-" -*037*,*)(%*+$-Q"h&" (--60&" ;<T"

+6'"2+0+/&$&+6-"-+7*."1*%2"8'*%%7&"に"&7(-%*)"8&2(9*+'"%+"'&3'&-&$%"%2&"633&'")+637&"+,"J*7+0&%&'-"+," ;<Y"

%2&" )'6-%Q" c+1&9&'@" %2&" )'6-%" *-" $+%" 2+0+/&$&+6-@" ($." 7(B&'*$/" 0(B" *$,76&$)&" .*J&" .*'&)%*+$" ;<W"

aI/)$/()--4(@" ;NNO_" +',-("& '()& .'/0'%1@" ;NNM_" 6'=='D"%%,& "1& '#5@" ;N!Nb@" 12*)2" )+67." 2(9&" ($" ;<M"

*03+'%($%"*03()%"+$"%2&"*$%&'()%*+$"+,"(".*J&"1*%2"KX-Q"h&"$&/7&)%&."7(B&'*$/"($."2&%&'+/&$&*%*&-"%+" ;DN"

,+)6-"+$7B"+$"%2&"KX-"($."%2&*'"3+%&$%*(7"&,,&)%"+$".*J&"3'+3(/(%*+$Q" ;D!"

#$" +6'" &53&'*0&$%-@" 1&" $&/7&)%" 9*-)+6-" ,+')&-@" 12*)2" 0(B" 37(B" ($" *03+'%($%" '+7&" *$" %2&" .*J&" ;D;"

.B$(0*)-" a;,-1"%& '()& E"%%@"!MM!b@" ($." (--60&" *$-%&(." %2(%" ,'()%6'*$/"+," %2&" 2+-%" -+7*." )+$%'+7-" %2&" ;D<"

.B$(0*)-" +," %2&" .*J&-Q" LB" *$\&)%*$/" )+$-%($%" 9+760&-" +," (*'" (-" ($" ($(7+/6&" ,+'" 0(/0(@" 1&" )'&(%&" ;DD"

86+B($)B4.'*9&$".*J&-"1*%2")+$-%($%"9+760&@"12&'&(-"*$"$(%6'&"%2&"9*-)+-*%B"+,"0(/0("3'&9&$%-"%2&" ;DO"

)+037&%&" &5%'()%*+$" +," %2&" 7*]6*." ,'+0" %2&" .*J&" %(*7" aK1"<"(-4(@" !MW;_" +',-("& '()& +',1@" ;NNMbQ" ;DT"

c+1&9&'@" %2&" 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," 86+B($%" .*J&-" *-" )+$%'+77&." 8B" %2&" 7+)(7" 86+B($)B" 8(7($)&" %2(%" %(J&-" ;DY"

37()&" (%" %2&" .*J&" $+-&" '&/*+$" a;,-1"%& '()& E"%%@" !MM!bQ" X*$(77B@" 1&" (--60&" %2(%" 0(/0(" 2&(%" 7+--" *-" ;DW" $&/7*/*87&".6'*$/"%2&"3'+3(/(%*+$"+,"0(,*)".*J&-".6&"%+"%2&*'"2*/2"9&7+)*%B"d63"%+"0&%&'-"3&'"-&)+$.:" ;DM" a8"$4/=GC&"1&'#5@";NNTb^@"12*)2"*-"("'&(-+$(87&"(--603%*+$",+'"8(-(7%*)".*J&-"/'&(%&'"%2($"("0&%&'"*$" ;ON" %2*)J$&--"aH%/="&'()&?/00"%1@"!MWMbQ" ;O!" < e8-&'9(%*+$-"($."'&-67%-" ;O;"

#$" &9&'B" &53&'*0&$%@" (" 3'&4.&,*$&." 9+760&" +," (*'" *-" *$\&)%&." (%" %2&" 8+%%+0" +," %2&" %($J" 6-*$/" (" ;O<"

-B'*$/&Q" A2&" &53&'*0&$%(7" .*J&" /'+1-" *$*%*(77B" (-" (" 3&$$B4-2(3&." )'()J" 6$%*7" %2&" .*J&" '&()2&-" (" ;OD"

)&'%(*$"2&*/2%@"*Q&Q"*%-"86+B($)B"7&$/%2"d()^Q"X'+0"%2(%"3+*$%@"%2&"%*3"+,"%2&".*J&"*-"(87&"%+",'()%6'&"%2&" ;OO"

/&7(%*$" 7&(.*$/" %+" *%-" 631('." 3'+3(/(%*+$Q" e$)&" (77" %2&" 9+760&" +," (*'" *-" *$\&)%&.@" %2&" .*J&" 8'&(J-" ;OT"

7++-&" ,'+0"%2&"-B'*$/&"($."3'+3(/(%&-"9&'%*)(77B@"J&&3*$/"*%-"9+760&")+$-%($%"8B"+3&$*$/"(%" *%-"%*3" ;OY"

(14)

!<" (" 37($&" 3('(77&7" %+" %2&" )(0&'(" (5*-Q" c+1&9&'@" %2&*'" +'*&$%(%*+$" )+67." 8&" &*%2&'" 3('(77&7" +'" ;OM" 3&'3&$.*)67('"%+"%2&"KX-Q" ;TN" <Q! e8-&'9(%*+$-" ;T!" <Q!Q! =+"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&" ;T;"

#$" %2&" &53&'*0&$%-" 1*%2" $+" KX-@" 1&" +8-&'9&." 9&'%*)(7" %+" -6849&'%*)(7" .*'&)%*+$-" +," 3'+3(/(%*+$" ;T<"

1*%2+6%"($B"$+%*)&(87&")2($/&-"*$"%2&"-2(3&"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&"12*7&"3'+3(/(%*$/"1*%2*$"%2&" ;TD"

/&7(%*$Q"h&".*."+8-&'9&."($"*$)'&(-&"*$"7&$/%2"($."($"*$)'&(-&"*$"9&7+)*%B"(-"%2&"%*3"+,"%2&".*J&"1(-" ;TO"

'&()2*$/" %2&" -6',()&" +," %2&" /&7(%*$Q" A2&-&" +8-&'9(%*+$-" ,*%" 1&77" 1*%2" -*0*7('" &53&'*0&$%-" .+$&" *$" ;TT"

3'&9*+6-"-%6.*&-"d&Q/Q@"@,<'#1'&'()&8'G$@";NNT_"6"('()&"1&'#5@";N!N^Q" ;TY"

<Q!Q; e$&"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&" ;TW"

#$" %2&" &53&'*0&$%-" 1*%2" +$&" KX@" 1&" +8-&'9&.@" (-" *$" %2&" &53&'*0&$%-" 1*%2+6%" KX-@" %2(%" %2&" ;TM"

&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&-" 3'+3(/(%&."9&'%*)(77B"+'"-6849&'%*)(77B"1*%2*$"%2&"/&7(%*$Q"h&" +8-&'9&."*$"-+0&" ;YN"

&53&'*0&$%-"%2(%"%2&".*J&"*$%&'()%&."1*%2"%2&"KXQ"h2&%2&'"(".*J&"*$%&'()%&."1*%2"("KX".&3&$.&."+$" ;Y!"

%2&" +'*&$%(%*+$" +," %2&" .*J&" d3('(77&7" +'" 3&'3&$.*)67('" %+" %2&" KX^" ($." +," %2&" KX" .*3" d9&'%*)(7" +'" $+%^" ;Y;"

dX*/Q" D(" ($." 8^@" (-" 1&77" (-"%2&" .*'&)%*+$" +," 3'+3(/(%*+$" +," %2&" .*J&" d9&'%*)(7" +'"-6849&'%*)(7^" ($." *%-" ;Y<" .*-%($)&",'+0"%2&"KXQ"I-"-++$"(-"%2&".*J&"%+6)2&."("KX@"*%-"(-)&$%"-%+33&."($."(77"%2&")+$%(*$&."(*'" ;YD" 1(-"*00&.*(%&7B".'(*$&."*$"%2&"KXQ"" ;YO" <Q!Q< A1+"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&-" ;YT" #$"%2&"&53&'*0&$%-"1*%2";"KX-@"1&"+8-&'9&.@"(-"*$"%2&"3'&9*+6-"&53&'*0&$%-@"9&'%*)(7"%+"-6849&'%*)(7" ;YY" .*'&)%*+$-"+,"3'+3(/(%*+$"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&" *$"8&%1&&$"%2&"KX-Q"h&"(7-+"+8-&'9&."%2(%"%2&" ;YW" .*J&-"1&'&")2($$&7&."*$"8&%1&&$"%2&"KX-@"12*)2"(,,&)%&."%2&*'".*'&)%*+$"+,"3'+3(/(%*+$"dX*/Q"O@"&53" ;YM" ;ONN^Q"c+1&9&'"*,"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&"KX-"1(-"%++"-0(77"%2&".*J&"*$%&'()%&."1*%2"+$&"+,"%2&" ;WN" KX-"dX*/Q"O@"&53"<NNN^Q"I7-+"%2&")2($/&-"*$"%2&".*'&)%*+$"+,"3'+3(/(%*+$"1&'&"0+'&"*03+'%($%"12&$" ;W!"

(15)

!D" *$,76&$)&" +," %2&" ($/7&" 8&%1&&$" %2&" .*J&" ($." %2&" KX" -&&0&." %+" 37(B" ($" *03+'%($%" '+7&" *$" %2&" ;W<" *$%&'()%*+$"d&53";WND>^Q"h&"+8-&'9&."%2(%"("2*/2"($/7&"8&%1&&$"%2&".*J&"($."%2&"KX"&$2($)&."%2&" ;WD" 3+%&$%*(7*%B"+,"*$%&'()%*+$"8&%1&&$"%2&"%1+Q" ;WO" <Q; Z&-67%-" ;WT"

#$" +'.&'" %+" ]6($%*,B" %2&" 0&)2($*)(7" 3('(0&%&'-" 3+%&$%*(77B" )+$%'+77*$/" %2&" *$%&'()%*+$" 8&%1&&$" (" ;WY" .*J&"($."("KX"dA(87&"D^@"1&".&,*$&."%2'&&".*0&$-*+$7&--"9(76&-:"6,!"7,"($."890,Q"" ;WW" 6,+*-"%2&".*0&$-*+$7&--".*-%($)&"+,"%2&".*J&",'+0"%2&"KX:" ;WM" " ;MN" 穴茅噺"鳥 挑長" d!T^" ;M!" " ;M;" 1*%2")".&,*$&."(-"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&"%*3"+,"%2&".*J&"($."%2&")7+-&-%"KX@"+'"*$"%2&")(-&"12&'&" ;M<"

%2&".*J&" *$%&'()%&."1*%2"("KX"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&" %*3"+,"%2&".*J&" ($."%2&"*$%&'()%*$/"KXQ"A2*-" ;MD" .*-%($)&"."1(-"0&(-6'&."12&$"%2&"%*3"+,"%2&".*J&"'&()2&."%2&"7&9&7"+,"%2&"KX"dX*/Q"D(^Q"" ;MO" 7,"*-"%2&".*0&$-*+$7&--".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$";"KX-:" ;MT" " ;MY" 経茅 帖 挑長" d!Y^" ;MW" " ;MM" 1*%2"7".&,*$&."(-"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&"%1+"KX-"%2(%")2($$&7"(".*J&"dX*/Q"O^Q" <NN"

890," $%" (" .*0&$-*+$7&--" .*J&" 9+760&" .&,*$&." (-" %2&" '(%*+" +," %2&" 9+760&" +," (*'" *$\&)%&." ,+'" &()2"

<N!"

&53&'*0&$%@"890"dA(87&"<^"($."%2&"86+B($)B"9+760&@"890):"" <N;"

(16)

!O" 撃剣健決 噺 ""に岫な 伐 荒態岻 貢訣詣決継" d!W^" <ND" " <NO" 8(-&."+$"%2&".*J&"86+B($)B"7&$/%2"():" <NT" " <NY" 撃剣健茅噺 " 蝶墜鎮"帳" 態岫怠貸程鉄岻綻諦直挑長填" d!M^" <NW" " <NM" #$"%2&",+77+1*$/@"1&",+)6-",*'-%"+$"%2&"0&)2($*)(7"3('(0&%&'-")+$%'+77*$/"(".*J&4KX"*$%&'()%*+$@"%2&$" <!N" +$"%2&"*$,76&$)&"+,"%2&"KX-"+$"%2&"-2(3&"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&@"($.",*$(77B"+$"%2&*'"&,,&)%"+$"%2&" <!!" .B$(0*)-"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&Q" <!;" <Q;Q! C&)2($*)(7"3('(0&%&'-")+$%'+77*$/"(".*J&4KX"*$%&'()%*+$" <!<"

A2&".*0&$-*+$7&--"9+760&"+,"(*'" 890,"*$\&)%&."($."%2&"($/7&"c"8&%1&&$"%2&".*J&"($."%2&"KX"12&$" <!D"

%2&" %*3" +,"%2&" .*J&" '&()2&." %2&" KX" 7&9&7" dX*/Q" D8^" 1&'&" 37+%%&." (/(*$-%" )L" ($." 7," dX*/Q" T^Q" X*'-%@" 1&" <!O"

+8-&'9&" %2(%" %2&" .*-%($)&" 8&%1&&$" (" .*J&" ($." (" KX" d6,^@" ($." %2&" .*-%($)&" 8&%1&&$" ;" KX-" d7,^" <!T"

*$,76&$)&-"%2&"3+%&$%*(7"*$%&'()%*+$"8&%1&&$".*J&-"($."$&('8B"KX-Q"I))+'.*$/"%+"X*/Q"T@".*J&-"*$%&'()%" <!Y"

1*%2" KX-" 12&$" )Lo" lNQD" ($." 12&$" 7," o" lNQW" d&53" <NNN" *$" X*/Q" O^_" +%2&'1*-&" .*J&-" ('&" $&*%2&'" <!W"

*$,76&$)&." dX*/Q" D(^" $+'" )2($$&7*S&." 8B" %2&" KX-" d&53" ;ONN" *$" X*/Q" O^Q" X*/Q" T" -2+1-" (7-+" %2(%" .*J&-" <!M"

3'+3(/(%*$/" (%" (" 2*/2" ($/7&"c" '&7(%*9&" %+" %2&" KX-" ,(9+'" *$%&'()%*+$" +9&'" 7('/&'" .*0&$-*+$7&--" <;N"

.*-%($)&-"6,"($."7,"dX*/Q"D8"($."&53";WND>"*$"X*/Q"O^"c+1&9&'@"1&"$+%&"%1+"&5)&3%*+$-:"!4".*J&-"%2(%" <;!"

)2($/&"%2&*'".*'&)%*+$"+,"3'+3(/(%*+$"d.+%%&."&77*3-&"*$"X*/Q"T"($."Y"($."&53";WNMZ"($.";W!!Z"*$"X*/Q" <;;"

(17)

!T" <Q;Q; #$,76&$)&"+,"%2&"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&"+$"%2&"-2(3&"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&" <;Y"

A2&"7&$/%2"($."%2&"%2*)J$&--"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&"1&'&"&5%'()%&."6-*$/"%2&".*/*%(7"9*.&+"'&)+'.-Q" <;W"

h&"&5%'()%&."%2&"(9&'(/&"7&$/%2"d()^" ($."%2&"%2*)J$&--" d1)^" +,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%(7".*J&"+$)&"*%"8'+J&" <;M" 7++-&",'+0"%2&"-B'*$/&"6$%*7"*%"'&()2&."%2&"7&9&7"+,"%2&"KX@"($."%2&"(9&'(/&"7&$/%2"d($^"($."%2*)J$&--" <<N" d1$^"(,%&'"%2(%"7&9&7"86%"8&,+'&"%2&"7(-%",*$(7"())&7&'(%*+$".6&"%+"%2&",'&&"-6',()&"dA(87&"D^Q"h&"%2&$" <<!" )(7)67(%&."%2&".*,,&'&$)&"*$"7&$/%2@"デ(@"($."%2*)J$&--@"デ1@"8&,+'&"($."(,%&'"%2&"KX"7&9&7:" <<;" " <<<" ッ詣 噺" 詣伐"詣" d;N^" <<D" " <<O" I$." <<T" " <<Y" ッ建 噺 " 建伐"建" d;!^" <<W" " <<M"

K+-*%*9&" 9(76&-" *$"デ(" ($." デ1" *037B" ($" *$)'&(-&" *$" 7&$/%2" ($." %2*)J$&--" +," %2&" 3'+3(/(%*$/" .*J&-@" <DN" '&-3&)%*9&7B@"(-"%2&B")'+--&."%2&"7&9&7"+,"%2&"KXQ"" <D!" デ("($."デ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

(18)

!Y" 7&$/%2"+,"%2&".*J&-@"2+1&9&'@"-&&0-"%+"8&"(,,&)%&.".*,,&'&$%7B".&3&$.*$/"+$"%2&"$608&'"+,"KX-Q"#$" <DM"

&53&'*0&$%-" 1*%2" (" -*$/7&" KX@" (" -*0*7('" $608&'" +," .*J&-" /+%" 7+$/&'" +'" -2+'%&'Q" A2*-" )+$%'(-%-" 1*%2" <ON"

&53&'*0&$%-"*$9+79*$/"%1+"KX-@",+'"12*)2@"*$"(70+-%"(77")(-&-@"%2&"3'+3(/(%*$/".*J&-"-2+'%&$&."dデ("o" <O!"

N^"(-"%2&B"&$%&'&."%2&"'&/*+$",7($J&."8B"%2&"%1+"KX-Q"A2&"0(5*060")2($/&-"*$"7&$/%2"'&()2"l<NpQ" <O;"

e9&'(77@" *%" -&&0-" %2&" )2($/&-" *$" 7&$/%2" ($." %2*)J$&--" 1&'&" -%'+$/&'" *$" &53&'*0&$%-" *$9+79*$/" +$&" <O<"

-*$/7&"KXQ"" <OD"

c+1&9&'@" %2&" '&(-+$" ,+'" %2&-&" )2($/&-" *$" 7&$/%2" ($." %2*)J$&--" '&0(*$-" 6$)7&('" (-" $+" $+%*)&(87&" <OO"

&,,&)%" +," &*%2&'" %2&" .*-%($)&" 6," 8&%1&&$" .*J&" ($."KX" dX*/Q" Y(@8^@" %2&" .*-%($)&"7," 8&%1&&$" %1+" KX-" <OT"

dX*/Q" Y)@.^@" +'" %2&" 9+760&" 890," +," (*'" *$\&)%&." dX*/Q" Y&@,^" *-" +8-&'9&.Q" A2&" 7('/&-%" .&)'&(-&" *$" .*J&" <OY" 7&$/%2"2(-"8&&$"+8-&'9&.",+'"6,"l"NQO"($."7,"l"!@"86%"%2&-&"+$7B")+$)&'$"(")+637&"+,"+8-&'9(%*+$-" <OW" ,+'"12*)2"1&")($$+%".&%&)%"($B"(--+)*(%&."&,,&)%"+$"%2&".*J&"%2*)J$&--Q"" <OM" <Q;Q< "[B$(0*)"(-3&)%-" <TN" <Q;Q<Q! =+"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&" <T!" A2&"-&]6&$%*(7"($(7B-*-"+,"%2&"&53&'*0&$%-"-2+1-"%2(%".*J&-"3'+3(/(%&"(%"(")+$-%($%"9&7+)*%B"1*%2*$" <T;"

%2&" /&7(%*$&Q" I-" %2&" .*J&-" '&()2" %2&" -6',()&@" 1&" +8-&'9&" ($" ())&7&'(%*+$" .6&" %+" %2&" 3'&-&$)&" +," (" <T<"

,'&&"-6',()&"(-".&0+$-%'(%&."8B"Z*9(7%("&%"(7Q"d;NNT^Q" <TD"

<Q;Q<Q; h*%2"3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&-" <TO"

h&" +8-&'9&." %2(%" %2&" 3'&-&$)&" +," KX-" )+67." )2($$&7" 3'+3(/(%*$/" .*J&-" dX*/Q" O^" ($." %2(%" %2&B" <TT"

)2($/&."%2&".*J&-"-2(3&Q"h&"$+1"&5(0*$&"12&%2&'"KX-")+67."(7-+"(,,&)%"%2&*'"3'+3(/(%*+$"9&7+)*%BQ" <TY"

A+" .+" %2*-@" 1&" &5%'()%&." ,'+0" %2&" .*/*%(7" 9*.&+" '&)+'.-" %2&" (9&'(/&" 9&7+)*%B" :)"+," %2&" .*J&-" 8&,+'&" <TW"

(19)

!W"

"ッ撃 噺" 懸伐"懸" d;;^"

<Y<"

" <YD"

I/(*$@"$&/(%*9&" 9(76&-" ,+'"デ8"0&($-"%2(%".*J&-"&53&'*&$)&"(".&)&7&'(%*+$"(-"%2&B"3(--"%2&"7&9&7"+," <YO"

KX-Q"#$"+'.&'"%+"($(7B-&"%2&-&"3+%&$%*(7"9&7+)*%B")2($/&-@"デ8"*-"37+%%&."(/(*$-%"6,@"7,+($."8,;" <YT"

A2&" '&-67%-" -2+1" %2(%" (70+-%" (77" &53&'*0&$%(7" .*J&-" &53&'*&$)&." (" )2($/&" *$" %2&*'" 3'+3(/(%*+$" <YY"

9&7+)*%B@" (7%2+6/2" %2*-" )2($/&" 1(-" +," -0(77" 0(/$*%6.&" dX*/Q" M^Q" C+-%" .*J&-" -2+1" (" .&)'&(-&" *$" <YW"

9&7+)*%B".6&"%+"%2&"3'&-&$)&"+,"KX-:"($"*$)'&(-&"*$"9&7+)*%B"dデ8"f"N^"*-"+$7B"+8-&'9&.",+'"&53&'*0&$%-" <YM"

1*%2" +$&" -*$/7&" KX" d63" %+" <p" *$)'&(-&@" X*/Q" M^@" 12&'&(-" &53&'*0&$%-" *$9+79*$/" ;" KX-" (77" '&-67%&." *$" <WN"

&*%2&'"$+"9&7+)*%B")2($/&"+'"("9&7+)*%B".&)'&(-&"d63"%+"Tp".&)'&(-&@"X*/Q"M^Q"" <W!"

A2&".*-%($)&"-&3('(%*$/"(".*J&",'+0"("KX"-&&0-"%+"2(9&"-+0&"*$,76&$)&"+$"%2&"9&7+)*%B"(-".*J&-"%2(%" <W;"

3'+3(/(%&" )7+-&-%" %+" KX-" %&$." %+" &53&'*&$)&" (" 9&7+)*%B" *$)'&(-&" 12&'&(-" .*J&-" ,6'%2&-%" (1(B" <W<"

&53&'*&$)&" %2&" 7('/&-%" 9&7+)*%B" .&)'&(-&" dX*/Q" M(^Q" [&-3*%&" -+0&" -)(%%&'" *$" %2&" '&-67%-@" 1&" (7-+" <WD" +8-&'9&"%2(%"12&$"(".*J&"3'+3(/(%&."8&%1&&$"%1+"KX-"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"%2&-&"KX-"*$,76&$)&." <WO" %2&".*J&".B$(0*)-Q"K7+%%*$/"%2&".*,,&'&$)&"*$"9&7+)*%B"+,"%2&".*J&@"デ8@"(/(*$-%"%2&".*0&$-*+$7&--"7," <WT" 9(76&@"'&9&(7-"%2(%"%2&")2($/&"*$"9&7+)*%B"*$.6)&."8B"%2&"3'&-&$)&"+,"%2&"%1+"KX-"*-"7('/&-%"12&$"%2&" <WY" KX-"('&"-&3('(%&."8B"(".*0&$-*+$7&--".*-%($)&"7,&l!"dX*/Q"M8^Q"e6'"'&-67%-"-6//&-%"%2(%"KX-"%2(%"('&" <WW" %++",('"(1(B",'+0"&()2"+%2&'")($$+%"*$,76&$)&"%2&"9&7+)*%B"+,"3'+3(/(%*$/".*J&-Q">*J&1*-&@"($."0+'&" <WM"

*$%&'&-%*$/7B@" KX-" %2(%" ('&" )7+-&" %+" &()2" +%2&'" d7," o" !^" .+" $+%" -&&0" %+" *$,76&$)&" %2&" .*J&" 9&7+)*%B" <MN"

&*%2&'Q"" <M!"

A2&"*$\&)%&."9+760&"*$,76&$)&-"(7-+"%2&"9('*(%*+$"+,".*J&"9&7+)*%B"dX*/Q"M)^Q"X+'"%2&"&53&'*0&$%-"1*%2" <M;"

(" -*$/7&" KX@" $+" (33('&$%" )+''&7(%*+$" *-" +8-&'9&.Q" e$" %2&" +%2&'" 2($.@" 12&$" ;" KX-" ('&" 3'&-&$%" 1&" <M<"

+8-&'9&" (" 3+-*%*9&" )+''&7(%*+$" 1*%2"デ8@"1*%2"デ8"8&)+0*$/"&9&$"0+'&"$&/(%*9&"(-"890,".*0*$*-2&-Q" <MD"

I..*%*+$(77B@"1&"+8-&'9&"%2(%"デ8"%&$.-"%+"S&'+"12&$"890,"l"!NNN@"12*)2"1+67."-6//&-%"%2(%"8&B+$." <MO"

(20)

!M" &537($(%*+$"0*/2%"8&"%2(%"%2&"86+B($)B"+,"-6)2".*J&-"*-"7('/&"&$+6/2"%+")+6$%&'"%2&"3+%&$%*(7"&,,&)%" <MY" +,"$&('8B"KX-"+$"%2&*'".B$(0*)-Q" <MW" A2&")2($/&"*$"%2&".B$(0*)-"+,"%2&".*J&"*$.6)&."8B"%2&"3'&-&$)&"+,"KX-"-&&0-"%+"8&"'&7(%&."%+"%2&" <MM"

)2($/&" *$" %2&" -2(3&" +," %2&" .*J&Q" #$.&&." X*/6'&" !N(" -2+1-" (" 3+-*%*9&" )+''&7(%*+$@" (78&*%" 1&(J@" DNN"

8&%1&&$"デ8"($."デ(:"($B"*$)'&(-&"d.&)'&(-&^"*$".*J&"7&$/%2"*-"(--+)*(%&."1*%2"($"*$)'&(-&"d.&)'&(-&^" DN!"

*$"3'+3(/(%*+$"9&7+)*%BQ"A2*-")+''&7(%*+$"*-")+$-*-%&$%"1*%2"%2(%"*.&$%*,*&."8&%1&&$"デ8"($."890,@"-*$)&" DN;"

7('/&'" 9+760&-" *037B" 7('/&'" .*J&" 7&$/%2-Q" I" -*0*7('" )+''&7(%*+$" *-" +8-&'9&." 8&%1&&$" .*J&" %2*)J$&--" DN<"

($." 9&7+)*%B" 1*%2" %2&" 7('/&'" 3+-*%*9&" d$&/(%*9&^" 9&7+)*%B" )2($/&-" (--+)*(%&." 1*%2" %2*)J&'" d%2*$$&'^" DND"

.*J&-"dX*/Q"!N8^Q"e6'"*$%&'3'&%(%*+$"*-"%2(%"%2&"3'&-&$)&"+,"KX-"(,,&)%-"%2&"-2(3&"+,".*J&-"3'+3(/(%*$/" DNO"

$&('8B@" 12*)2" *$" %6'$" (,,&)%-" %2&*'" .B$(0*)-Q" A2*-" &,,&)%" (33&('-" 0+'&" *03+'%($%" 12&$" .*J&-" DNT" 3'+3(/(%&"*$"8&%1&&$"KX-"-&3('(%&."8B"(".*0&$-*+$7&--".*-%($)&"7,"l"!Q"" DNY" X*$(77B@"1&"$+%&"%2(%"+6'"&53&'*0&$%-".+"$+%"'&9&(7"($B"3+%&$%*(7"&,,&)%"+,"%2&"-%'&--"'&/*0&"+$"%2&" DNW" .B$(0*)-"+,"%2&"KX-Q" DNM" D #037*)(%*+$-",+'"%2&"*$%&'()%*+$"+,"3'+3(/(%*$/".*J&-"($."3'&4&5*-%*$/",'()%6'&-" D!N" A2&"&53&'*0&$%-"-2+1"%2(%"KX-")($"*$,76&$)&".*J&-"*$"-&9&'(7"1(B-Q" D!!" DQ! C&)2($*)(7"(-3&)%-:"*037*)(%*+$-"+$",'()%6'&".&$-*%B"($.".*J&"9+760&" D!;" X*'-%@"*,"(".*J&"3'+3(/(%&-"'&7(%*9&7B")7+-&"%+"("KX@"%2&B")($"*$%&'()%"(-"-2+1$"8B"?+$1(B"&%"(7Q"a!MMYb" D!<" ($."+6'"&53&'*0&$%-"dX*/Q"D8^Q"#,"%2&".*J&"+9&'3'&--6'&"*-"2*/2&'"%2($"%2&"$+'0(7"-%'&--"()%*$/"+$"%2&" D!D" KX"aE,C4-/F,&"1&'#5@";N!Nb@"%2&$"%2&".*J&"1*77"8&"(87&"%+"&537+*%"($."%26-"3+%&$%*(77B"'&()2"%2&"-6',()&Q" D!O"

c+1&9&'@" +6'" &53&'*0&$%-" .+" $+%" .*-%*$/6*-2" ,+'" 12*)2" )+$.*%*+$-" %2&" *$%&'()%*+$-" .*J&4KX" ('&" D!T"

3(--*9&@" *Q&Q" (" .*J&" *$%&'()%-" 1*%2" (" KX" -*037B" 8&)(6-&" *%" *-" +$" %2&" .*J&" 3(%2@" +'" ()%*9&@" *Q&Q" %2&" KX" D!Y"

*$,76&$)&-" %2&" %'(\&)%+'B" +," %2&" 3'+3(/(%*$/" .*J&" 3'+8(87B" 8B" 0+.*,B*$/" %2&" 7+)(7" -%'&--" ,*&7." ($." D!W"

(21)

;N" .*0&$-*+$7&--".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"(".*J&"($."("KX"*-"7+1&'"%2($"l"NQD@"%2(%"*-"12&$"%2&".*-%($)&"%2(%" D;N" -&3('(%&-"(".*J&",'+0"$&*/28+'*$/"KX-"*-"7&--"%2($"(8+6%"NQD"*%-"86+B($)B"7&$/%2"():" D;!" " D;;" 穴 隼 ど ね詣決 噺 ど ね 岾懲迩 ッ諦直峇 態 戴エ " d;<^" D;<" " D;D" A26-@"%2&"3+%&$%*(7",+'".*J&4KX"*$%&'()%*+$".&3&$.-"$+%"+$7B"+$"%2&".&$-*%B"+,"KX-"*$"("/*9&$"'&/*+$"+," D;O"

%2&" -63&',*)*(7" )'6-%" 86%" (7-+" +$" %2&" )2('()%&'*-%*)" 7&$/%2" d()^" +," %2&" .*J&-" *$%'6.*$/" %2*-" )'6-%(7" D;T"

'&/*+$Q" D;Y"

A2&")+$%*$&$%(7")'6-%"2(-"($"(9&'(/&"]6('%S".*+'*%&4%B3&")+03+-*%*+$@"1*%2"(".&$-*%B"+,";WNN"J/k0<Q" D;W"

A2&" 9(76&-" ,+'" %2&" &7(-%*)" 0+.67*" !" j" WN" `K(" ($." " j" NQ;O" a+/%=411"& '()& K=G/A"%1@" !MW;bQ" A2&" D;M"

.*,,&'&$)&"*$".&$-*%B"8&%1&&$"("0(,*)".*J&"($."%2&")'6-%"*-"/&$&'(77B"%(J&$"(-"デ "j"!NN"J/k0<"a@/A,(@" D<N"

!MMObQ"I7%2+6/2"%(J*$/"("-*$/7&",'()%6'&4%+6/2$&--"9(76&",+'")'6-%(7"'+)J-")($"8&".&8(%(87&"aZ68*$@" D<!"

!MM<b@" !N" CK(Q0!k;" -&&0-" (" '&(-+$(87&" '&3'&-&$%(%*9&" 9(76&" ,+'" %2&" )+$%*$&$%(7" )'6-%Q" A2&" D<;"

/'(9*%(%*+$(7" ())&7&'(%*+$" %" *-" %(J&$" (-" MQW!" 0k-;Q" h*%2" %2&-&" 9(76&-@" +6'" '&-67%-" -6//&-%" .*J&4KX" D<<" *$%&'()%*+$"1*77"+))6'"*,"%2&".*-%($)&"8&%1&&$"(".*J&"($."("KX"*-"7+1&'"%2($"l";NN"0"d&]Q";<^Q" D<D" X6'%2&'0+'&@".*J&4KX"*$%&'()%*+$-"('&"0+'&"7*J&7B"*,"%2&"-%'*J&"+,"%2&"KX".*,,&'-",'+0"%2(%"+,"%2&".*J&-@" D<O" ($."*,"%2&"($/7&"8&%1&&$"%2&".*J&"($."%2&"KX-"*-"2*/2Q"#$%&'3'&%(%*+$-"+,"9+7)($*)"9&$%-"(7*/$0&$%-"*$" D<T" $(%6'&"2(9&"'(*-&."]6&-%*+$-"+$"%2&*'"3+%&$%*(7")+$%'+7-:"!4"%2&"-%'&--",*&7."aM'2'$/%'@"!MYYb_"($.";4" D<Y" %2&"3'&4&5*-%*$/")'6-%(7",'()%6'&-"a>'#"(1,("&'()&E%4FG@";NNTbQ"e6'"'&-67%-"-6//&-%"%2(%".*J&-"2(9&"(" D<W"

/'&(%&'" )2($)&" +," *$%&'()%*+$" 1*%2" )'6-%(7" KX-" ,+'0&." .6'*$/" (" 3'&9*+6-@" .*,,&'&$%" -%'&--" '&/*0&" D<M"

8&)(6-&".*J&-"1*77"%2&$"%&$."%+"3'+3(/(%&"(%"2*/2"($/7&-"%+"%2&"KX-Q"#,"%2&"-%'&--"'&/*0&"2(-")2($/&." DDN"

-*$)&" %2&" KX" ,+'0(%*+$@" %2&" (7*/$0&$%-" .+" $+%" '&3'&-&$%" %2&" -%'&--" '&/*0&" .6'*$/" *$%'6-*+$Q" [*J&-" DD!"

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to