HAL Id: halshs-00564702
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00564702
Preprint submitted on 9 Feb 2011HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
of industrial emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese
provinces
Jie He
To cite this version:
Jie He. Environmental impacts of international trade: the case of industrial emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese provinces. 2011. �halshs-00564702�
Document de travail de la série
Etudes et Documents
Ec 2005.07
Environmental impacts of international trade:
the case of industrial emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO
2)
in Chinese provinces
Jie HE
CERDI Université d’Auvergne 65 Boulevard de F. Mitterrand 63000 Clermont-Ferrand France Tel: 00.33.4.73.17.74.23 Fax: 00.33.4.73.17.74.28 Email: Jie.HE@u-clermont1.fr (Feb 2005) 34 p.!
"
"
"
"
#
"
"
$ %
"
"
!
$
&
"
' (
&
"
"
)
*
!
+
*
+
*
+
"
,
"
"
-
"
.
.
!
/
-
"
-
-(
"
-0
"
%1
0' 22
-%
/
'
"
-
-%1
3
4
-
%1
" 2 2
4
4!
%1
" 2
4
5
6
5
"
6
! -
1
-!
"
.
-
!
/
"
-
" '
"
"
5
'
6
"
!
"
"
'
"
'
7
! "
#
$%!!&
''%(
#
-
-%1
)
*
+
,
"
,
8
!
%
!
%!-.
"
,
/01
%'2
%!.'
&32
%!!'
4
"
5 # 4
''&
6'2 $ 7 ''8( "
"
9
"
:
"
4
4
%!!'
"
;&
"
"
<
1
4
$<14(
=
,
5
>
"
>
,
/
$%!!3(
)
*
,
9
?
,
"
$ ''&(
7
,
$?
%!.&+
@
A
%!!'
A
%!!-(
4
)
*
:
"
$%!!-(
)
*
?
:
1
$1
B
%!!3+C
D
%!!.(
:
)
*
,
/
"
>:
,
>5
"
>
E
$
(
$
(
$
(
,
,
! "
,
$#
(
%!!&
''%
,
,
,
/@@
7
7
$%!!.(
$%!!6(
?
/
9
@
$/@@(
9
E
"
8 ?
3
"
# $ %
?
%
#
"
''% "
9
&' "
,
5
/01
#
/ 9
$E
?
%
(
$E
?
(
,
'
"
%1
"
"
,
-
"
"
'
%1
3:;
-1"
"
&"
'
$
(
,
E
4
0
$%!!.( E
"
:
)
*
,
?
8
4
4
9
,
,
E
,
"
,
+
4
"
$%!!!(
! " # $ $ " $ $ % & '(' )2 ! " # Ω τ $% & "' % "' ( ( ) * % "+ ( , - % ' ( ./0 ./0 ∆)+ * $% -+ % $% % )+ * $%
-<
$%(
?
/
$%!!3(
#
Ω
τ
#
,
* >2"
Ω
/
2 > Ω/
$%!!3(
4
+
,
/
+
,
2 < τ?
,
4
$ ''%( A
$%!!6(
"
$%!!.(
4
"
$%!!!(
,
7
,
@
A
$ (
,
,
,
,
+ !ϕ
1
,
/01
,
,
E
,
<
4
F
E
9
<
$FE< (
@
A
$%!!'(
# $$
(
,
# $ $$ (
# $ $4
# $ $ψ
1
E
$&( 4
"
$%!!3(
)
*
5
,
,
,
"
$ ''&(
B
4
"
,
9
<@G' 5
5
$%!!6( 5
7
$ '''(
)"
*
,
9
E
H
4
,
9I'
$8(
$
%!!3+B J9 %!!8(
:
$H (
9
,
G' /
,
/"20301
,
,
)
*
"
,
0 "'0
4
:
1
)
$
(
$
(
$
(
$
(*$C
D
%!!!( E
"'01
4
,
,
E
,
4
,
"
+01
,
$%K(
* , , , , ,$L(
$L(
$(
$>(
$>(
-$L(
$L(
$L(
$L(
* * , , , % % % -&$(
$L(
$(
7 '(' * .!/! .!/! .!/! -) .!/! , , .!/! .!/! , ,
$L(
$L(
$>(
$L(
M
5
,
.!/! .!/!#
7
$%K(
$8K(
9
$3(
$6(
,
$"' (
"+
$" (
6
9
8
?
,
$3(
$6(
$%K(
9
,
,
$8K(
9
$3(
$6(
9
8
M
$E
?
&
(
5
?
&
,
,
$
(
$3( 0 11 , 11 2 3 , 0 11 $ 4 5 # 6 (7 4 ( (8 9* 4 11 4 5: 0 11 $ 4 5 # , , 0 # , , 0 11 ;(8'( ( # 6 (7 4 ( (8 9* 4 11 (8'(: ( 0 11 ;(8'( ( # , , 0 , , $6( 0 11 , 11 2 3 , # 11 $ 4 5 # 6 (7 4 ( (8 9* 4 11 4 5: # 11 $ 4 5 # , , # , , 0 11 ;(8'( ( # 6 (7 4 ( (8 9* 4 11 (8'(: ( 0 11 ;(8'( ( # , , 0 , ,)"
5
/
"
%!!& ''%
?
"
9
,
3
"
%!!
%!!& ''%
"
?
"
"
,
"
$E
%
(
6 %
-#
?
#
"
$ 1(
4
%!!'
"
#
)
*
/
"
#
#
% %: @ N @ $ '''( #"
5
/01
9
< < <#
7%&
M
7#
%&
%!!%
&O
$N;B(
"
$%!!8 %!!3( 4
$ ''%( "
$ ''&(
"
$ ''8(
?
,
O
$N;B(
,
E
0
$ '''(
:
$ ''&(
)
*$0
'''(
%&
?
%&
!.2
/01
%& , $0 " E < H %!.! '' ( &N B $ '' ( , M"
/
$"
%!!8 %!!3+4
''%
"
''8(
,
,
:
,
,
O
, 9
,
,
E
:
"
?
"
?
,
"
<
1
4
$<14(
#
"
)
<
P
"
$ <P"(*
O
(
6
%
E
,
M
$"
%!!!( 5
$ '' (
"
1
,
/
( 6 %
-,
1
/
,
,
$<C (
,
/01
$<@ (
@
A
$%!.!(
%!!
85
7
#
,
#
7
8 %!! " , %!!& %!!& ''% %!.'2
/@@
7
7
$%!!.(
E
4
:
$%!. (
4
7
$%!!%(
4
,
4
7
$%!!%(
= # = > # > * # * ? * # * # # # @ @ # #,
ε
5
,
* # * # # = # = # * # #* # ?* # #* #& >@ # #>@ # = # #= # * # =7
7
$%!!.(
4
:
$%!. (
4
7
$%!!%(
* # * # #7
8 * # * # #4
:
$%!. ( 7
7
,
4
7
$%!!%(
* # * # # & 8Q
%0
4
7
7
7
$%!!.(
)
/@@
4
7
*$7
''&( "
9
* # * # # 8 8
9
% 88
8 88
859
8
/
= = (A < <M
/
9 @
@
$/@@(
,
,
:
,
/@@
7
7
/@@
B
7
F
$%!66(
$%!!6(
,
,
,
/@@
E
$%!!6(
E
,
/@@
,
E
5
"
%
@
,
:
$%!-.(
R
4
/@@
$E
(
#
"
/
#
,
,
5
,
<,
,
<
,
/01
%2
' %%!2 #
%2
%!!
#
' 8&82
,
,
/01
,
,
ϕ
' ' % 5
,
,
ψ
0
' % 3
3"
,
,
,
$
' %(
"/<
4
@
A
$%!!'(
N
A
$%!!6(
E
,
"
,
,
,
/01
,
,
,
@
A
,
,
,
5
%2
,
;/01
' '-&2 5
E
"
H
,
"
"
4
%2
' 62
%2
' 6!2
6,
<N"
"
3 , αψ ψSαψ;αS' '&3;' - S' % 3 6E /01 : /01 /01 $ -32( /017
,
$: ''&(
"
%!!'
5
5
$%!!6(
5
7
$ '''(
"
,
' '8
1
)
*
5
"
4
$E
?
8
(
E ?
8
#
"
,
,
,
,
,
5
%2
,
;/01
#
9
6
' '-%2
#
%2
' 2
,
?
8
,
8
?
*"
A
9
#
0
$%!!.(
5
,
6
9
"
!
#
,
4
$ ''%(
"
#
5
,
#
5
%2
,
/01
#
%
' '-%2
%2
#
' 2
#
,
,
"
5
)
*
"
"
1
"
9
9
"
"
)
*
E
,
1
"
9
+
4 R 0 " $%!!!( T4 < N 9 " < < .$ ( 6- --4 " : $%!. ( T? R < %. 6-. 4 5 7 A " @ $ ''%( TE ? / < > 4 < A !%$8( .--!'. 4 @ # 7 $%!!3( T4 B E U < < " @ R < 6. ! 3% 4 @ A 7 $%!!%( T 0 @ " < 4 < < A < 3. -- !-7 1 @ F $%!66( T1 " 0 < 0 @ 0 F / < &8 3.3 6% 7 7: $%!!3( < 4 1 0 5 B 5 , < &'8 7 4 $ ''&( T4 " 0 1 0 < @ " < 4 E ? 0 '3;'& < A " 0 7 7 A A 7 $%!!.( TE " @ A 0 1 0 @ R < .- %%3 %8& " 0 R H " / $%!!!( T# " , 1 " <, A #<"0 < , A 0 " #<"0 " #<"0 1 && 3-" @ 4 $ ''8( T N 9 , < < 8.$%( -% .% " @ 4 A RA < $ ''&( T0 VR < < @ 86$&( &6& &.&
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
N 5 4 B $%!!!( T1 4 " ? 0 E E O F7<A 5 1 -&6! " @4 N 5 4 B $ ''%( T1 4 " ? 0 E E O A < BCCCEU $8( 6!% -'& B 9 A $%!!8( T < ? < < / B R < < @ - %6& %.8 B A < 70 5 : : $%!! ( T< 0 < A E @ , E %!6' %!.. 1 B E < 0 F %3! 5 7 5 0" @ @ 0 5 $%!!-( TE 1 : >0 E 5 < %!63 %!!3 E 1 #<"0 " ? E < $%!!!( F @ B 1 $%!! ( < 1 0 : 4 N 4 1 33 @ ? < A $%!.8 ''%( 4 " ? < A 7 M " 1 @ < " B $%!!3( T 4 F " < " A R < 1 ! !-%%. A 9 AB $%!! ( TA E " A )A 7 * F H O B A 6- % %' % 38 A / " < $%!!-( T / 4 A / < 4 E 5 0 3$%'( %6'! %6 3 @ 0 $%!!8( T< P 0 E N 9 " 4 1 < > R < < @ - %8-%6 @ 0 $%!!3( TF / R" 4 E O 1 R < < @ ! %6 %6. <14$ < 1 4 1A"( $%!.6 %!!- " < H 7 M " 1 : <14$ < 1 4 1A"( $%!!. '' " < H 7 M 1 4 $%!!6( T0 B @ B @ 1 < 1 0 " - N 4 1 7$ 7 1A"( $%!.8 ''8( " H 7 M " 1 : 7$ 7 1A"( $%!.6 %!!- " E < H 7 M " 1 : U 0 " $%!!.( T< N 9 < < 3$ ( %!3 '. 5 : $ '''( T1 " " 1 4 " E 1 " 1 A 5 1 F &&- 5 7 5 0" 5 : 0 5 $%!!6( T1 E 1 " 4 < 4 B 1 A 5 1 F %688 5 7 5 0" 5 R $ '' ( T< # " ? < " & 1 < % " O O F R 5 R@ $ '' ( < 4 " 1 0 " @E 1 -8' 5 7 $ '''( / E F #, O 1 %3' 5 H %!!! T1 < " A < E ? $< ( < < 1 / 4 1 A < < 1 &3% C 4 4 D $%!!!( T< 1 " 1 : " " R < < @ &- %63 %. D B $%!!-( T @ > F / 9 < #<"0 / 9 < #<"0 < 0 1 #<"0
,"
- # " " " " . " . " # -" 4 # %''' 6% 8!8 8! &6& '% %6 6. %-6' '6 # A /01 %'!H %!!' 6% -' %' 63 !' - &3& '' Ω 6% 8 - 3 3& %& ' 88 3 τ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
"
$/@@ ?, ! ! '& ( ( - + + + + B + $' '''(' 8&6KKK B + ' -'.KKK$' '''( B + $' '''(' 83KKK B + ' 8.&KKK$' '''( + '%KKK$' ''3( $' '%!(' -!KK ' 6''KKK$' '''( + %-&KKK$' '''( + $' '%8(% %-% KK + ' -&KKK$' '''( + ' '&'$' %%( + ' %%!KKK$' ''-( ' ' %KKK$' '''( $' '' (' '-&KKK ' '8 KKK$' ''8(+ $' ''-(' 8&8KKK ' '&3KK$' '&%( ' ! KKK$' '''( ' ''!$' 3! (
'(' + '(' ' 6!KKK$' '''( %-!! 3 -% %& . 8 !8 : $ ( $' ''6( $' '''( $' ''.( $' 8& ( ! 86 6 .8 % 8- ' &% : $ ( $' %8!( $' &&( $' .& ( $' !!-( 4 $?B ' 38'KKK $' '''( ' 33-KKK $' '''( ' 8%3KKK $' '''( ' %--KK $' '%&( R $ ( ' 6 A -6< %. / % KKK !!2 KK !32 K !'2 4 , /@@ 5 , & : 8 4 5 $ '' ( 1 . .& E , # ( B ? B C S& 8 Q +S% Q F 5 ?B V' 3 , 3 R /@@ @ R % 6 -S' 6 × '& , " / &6 $ ( " %.& -! % '''
0
0 #
,"1
#
# $ %
22,
$0 " H '' ( 22' 0 222 0 222' 7 222 7 222' 8 222 8 222' 9 222 * 2 +'
' 2 2 ' 8 8 ' 02 4' 74 74' 94 94' 84 84' 74 4 ' 74 74 ' 4 4 ' 24 24'9840 GDPPC-(X+M)/GDPxmgdp .05019 1.39815 1709.91 16291.2 HENANHUNAN GUIZHOU JIANGXI QINGHAI GANSU Sichuan+ HUBEI GUANGXIYUNNAN HEBEI ANHUI HEILONGJ INNER MO SHAANXI XINJIANG JILIN SHANXI NINGXIA hainan SHANDONGLIAONING ZHEJIANG JIANGSU FUJIAN BEIJING TIANJIN SHANGAI GUANGDON SO2PC-GDPPCgdppc 1709.91 16291.2 2.42249 29.9789 GUIZHOU GANSU YUNNAN Sichuan+ SHAANXI NINGXIA GUANGXI HENAN QINGHAI HUNAN JIANGXI SHANXI ANHUI INNER MO XINJIANG HEBEI hainan HEILONGJ HUBEI JILIN SHANDONG LIAONING FUJIAN JIANGSU GUANGDONZHEJIANG TIANJIN BEIJING SHANGAI SO2PC-X/GDPxtgdp .026977 .744294 2.42249 29.9789
HENANHUBEIHUNAN GANSU XINJIANG Sichuan+ GUIZHOU JIANGXIYUNNAN QINGHAI INNER MO GUANGXI HEILONGJ HEBEI ANHUI JILIN SHAANXI hainan NINGXIA SHANXI SHANDONG LIAONING BEIJING JIANGSU FUJIAN ZHEJIANG TIANJIN SHANGAI GUANGDON SO2PC-M/GDPmgdp .023213 .653855 2.42249 29.9789 HENAN QINGHAI HUNAN GUIZHOU JIANGXI GUANGXI SHANXI GANSU HEBEI Sichuan+ ANHUI YUNNAN HUBEI HEILONGJ SHAANXI NINGXIA INNER MO JILIN XINJIANG SHANDONG hainan ZHEJIANG LIAONING FUJIAN JIANGSU TIANJIN SHANGAI BEIJING GUANGDON 3:;; = 2 0 >*?@A +B3:;@ 9 8 DE&F --- GEH ---I J EK .J H %1 ; =2 222 ×3:;; @ 2 EG )EGG ---I J# E .J H %1 ; = 08>?B3:;@ 0 *2 + *9 +>>> C =2 22 D= %1 ; =0 >?B3:;@ *2 88+ * 8 +>>> C ='2 2 D=
!
"
#
$ %
% &'
#
(
(
)**+,
00 ↓↓↓↓ , , ↓↓↓↓ , , ∆∆∆∆ , ∆∆∆∆ , ! -".##! / & (// & # / ( 0 ##! -/ 1#2 # ( & # (1#2 # ( & # + & # 3 ↑↑↑↑ +4 3 ↑↑↑↑ +4 (! # # (( #5 ↑↑↑↑ ϕ *E- - + ↑↑↑↑ αψ *& - + / ∆∆∆∆ , ↑↑↑↑ , 6 1 ##! # // ↑↑↑↑ , ↑↑↑↑, ↑↑↑↑ , ↑↑↑↑ , ↓↓↓↓ , , ↓↓↓↓ , , ! ∆∆∆∆, F, ↑↑↑↑, , ! " # ∆∆∆∆ , F, ↓↓↓↓ , , $ =, , @, F, @, F, , F, F @, , *E- + =, , @, , @, , , F, F @, , *& + ↓↓↓↓ , ↓↓↓↓ ,
07 ↑↑↑↑ *"++74 )38 , ↓↓↓↓ *"9-94 ). , ! 9" // & # / & / ( ##! -/ 1#2 # ( & # (1#2 # ( & # + & # 3 ↑↑↑↑ +4 3 ↑↑↑↑ +4 (! # # (( #5 ↑↑↑↑ 2 2 4 *E- - + ↑↑↑↑ 2 2084 *& - + / ↓↓↓↓ 2 2 04 ↑↑↑↑ 2 4 6 1 ##! # // & ↑↑↑↑ 2 27 4 ↑↑↑↑ 2 22 4 6 1 ##! # // ↑↑↑↑ 2 9×2 2 4=2 2 04 *E- + ↑↑↑↑ 2 9×2 2084=2 2 4 *& + ↑↑↑↑ "*+××××*"* +4 *"*9:4 )38 , ↑↑↑↑ "*+××××*"*-;4 *"*<<4 ). , ↓↓↓↓ +"+<+××××*"*+-4 *"*+;4 )38 , ↓↓↓↓ +"+<+××××*"* +4 *"* ;4 ). , ! ↓↓↓↓ "+<-××××*"*<-4 *"+;74 )38 , ↑↑↑↑ "+<-××××*"7 4 *":-;4 ). , ! " # ↓↓↓↓ +"+<+××××*"*9 4 *"*974 )38 , ↓↓↓↓ +"+<+××××*"**74 *"*++4 ). , $ = ( 3 4 (8' 4 (8' 2 3 # E K L E FL # E &L # E )HL # E FHL # L )G E L H E *E- + = ( 3 4 (8' 4 (8' 3 L E E FL # E L # E L # L G&F E L KK E L )&) E # *& + ↓↓↓↓ 2 ×2 2 4=2 2294 *E- + ↓↓↓↓ 2 ×2 2084=2 2 24 *& + ↓↓↓↓ "+<-××××*"**:4 *"*+-4 )38 , ↓↓↓↓ "+<+××××*"*+*4 *"* 4 ). ,