Analytical results on Connected dominating sets in mobile ad hoc networks

HAL Id: inria-00071415

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071415

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Analytical results on Connected dominating sets in mobile ad hoc networks

Philippe Jacquet

To cite this version:

Philippe Jacquet. Analytical results on Connected dominating sets in mobile ad hoc networks. [Re- search Report] RR-5173, INRIA. 2004. �inria-00071415�

ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--5173--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Analytical results on Connected dominating sets in mobile ad hoc networks

Philippe Jacquet

N° 5173

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt

Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30

"+*#,-./( 10+2.

3+46587958:6:;=<?>A@CBED6;CF

∗

GIHKJLNM.OQPSRUTWVXMWY[ZK\]M#^_VX`aVb^cJLNMWV

dfecg[hbM^_iUjlk1MWecmgnL

RUY[kKkAgneX^UoaM+ecMWmpHKMWecmpHKMqAr6saOutuvwP PyxNkzYn{nM|V

}]~W€u‚Kƒn€n„ …

M†kKecgu‡ˆjloaM†YnqzY[‰l`Š^Xj‹mY[‰IecMWVXZK‰Œ^cV.Y[AgnZK^.^XHKM†kAMeXŽgnecL.Y[qzmMgnŽ‡uYneXjlgnZzV’‘gCqKqKMWm#^XM|o

“”gnLNjlqzYu^cjŒqz{N•ˆM^!–8‘(“$•K—IY[‰l{ngCeXjŒ^XHzLNVW˜6™†ZK‰Œ^XjldgCjŒqŠ^URMW‰lYš`ˆjlqK{–9™†dR_—(›1gŠgaoajlqK{1œˆ™=dRIž‘(“•?œAŸMqa

MWecYn‰Œjl M|o … Z¡EjE‘(“•¢–9Ÿ … ¡£ž‘(“$•K—¤ˆ¥¦q’kzYnež^cjlmZK‰‹Y[ef§(MUŽgam#Z1VžM”gnqN^XHzM¨O|“©ZKqzjª^IoajlVX«N{nepY[kKH.LNgaoaMW‰9¤

¬†­Š®?¯c°!± u²n„ ™†gnKjl‰lMfYno$HKgam[œšm#gCqKqKM|m^XM|o$oagnLNjlqzYu^cjŒqK{”VžM^Wœ|ZKqKjŒ^oaj‹Vž«LNgˆoKM‰8œ|YCVž`ˆLNka^Xgn^Xj‹m6eXM|VžZz‰ª^pV¤

∗ ³µ´¶u·X¸W·¦´´¹aº¼»½¾X¿pÀ¹pÁ#Â|·¦Ã#Ě·ž½zº‹ÅĚÆ

!f )) "+* ## -.

 „ gnZ1VkKecTWVXMqŠ^cgnqzVoaMWVeXT|VžZz‰ª^pYu^cVY[qzYn‰Œ`Š^cjŠZKM|VVXZKe‰lMWVkAMeXŽgnecLNYnqzm#M|VfoaM$oajATWeXMWqC^pVYn‰ª

{Cgnecjª^cHKLNMWVfVXZKef‰lMWVMqzVXML¨K‰lM_oagnLNjlqzY[qŠ^pVfm#gCqKqKMWm#^XT|V_–8‘(“$•K—#˜CjlqKqKgCqzoKYu^cjŒgCq.kzY[eRM‰‹Y[j‹V™†Zz‰ª^cjŒd6gnjlqŠ^cV

–9™†dR_—#œa™†dRIž‘(“•£œˆYn‰Œ{Cgnecjª^cHKLNMWV … Z]M^(¡'j1{CTqKTWecYn‰Œj‹VžT–8Ÿ … ¡£ž‘(“•z—¤fq]k1Y[eX^Xj‹m#ZK‰ljŒMWeqKgCZzVfqzgnZzV

jlqŠ^XTWeXM|VXVXgnqzVIYnZLNgaoaJ‰lMoaZ{nepY[kKHzM$Yš‡CMWmoaj‹VŠZKM$ZKqKjŒ^XT+MWq†oajŒLNMWqzVžjlgnq On¤

±

€|

¯

ƒ

©„

™=gnKjl‰ŒM Yno HzgˆmnœUMq1VžMWL!K‰lM¢oagCLjlqzYnqC^pVmgnqKqzMWm^cTWVWœLNgˆoKJ‰lMwoaZ oajlVŠZKM=ZKqzjª^cTnœ

* +

¨ '6. #

¥¦q-,.ˆœˆvKœAO/?§MoaMWVcm#ecjl1MUL.YnqŠ`Nm#gCqKqKM|m^XM|o’oagCLjlqzY[^XjlqK{!VXM#^zZKjŒ‰Œ^(ŽeXgCL ™†Zz‰ª^cjŒkAgnjlqŠ^IRMW‰lYš`¨LNM#^XHzgˆo

–9™†dR_—#¤K¥¦q,0/£^cHKMecM$jlVIYNoaM|VXmeXjlka^Xjlgnqg[ŽŸMWqzY[epY[‰ljl MWo … Z Y[q1o¡'jEY[‰l{ngnecjŒ^XHKL ŽgneIgCeXjlMqŠ^XM|o’{CecYnkKH

^cHzYu^§(M+VžjlLNkK‰Œj21zM|o]jlq3,s4/£ŽgCeI^XHKM+mgnqŠ^XM\Š^gnŽqKgCqgCeXjlMqŠ^XM|o’{CecYnkKHzVW¤¥¦q^XHzjlVIqKgn^XM$§(M$YnqzY[‰l`ˆ M”^XHKM

kAMeXŽgnecL.Y[qzmMNg[ŽI^XHKM|VžMY[‰l{ngnecjŒ^XHKL ‡Šj‹Y†Y[q1Y[‰l`C^cjlmWY[‰fLNgaoaMW‰lVW¤ … M]jlqˆ‡nM|Vb^cjŒ{ŠYu^XM^cHKM]mYCVžM.§HzMecM.^XHKM

qzM#^b§(gnec«]j‹V_Y’ZzqKjª^$oaj‹Vž«{nepY[kKH†gnŽfoajŒLNMWqzVžjlgnqOn¤ … M¨YnVcVXZKLNM+^XHzY[^_^cHKM!qKgaoaM|V_YneXMepY[q1oagnLN‰l`Y[q1o

ZzqKjªŽgCeXLN‰l`]oaj‹Vžk1Yu^cmpHzMWognq Y[qjŒq11qKjª^cMVžMW{nLNMqŠ^|¤fGIHKM$ecYCoajŒgepY[qK{CM”j‹V+O+Y[qzo]^XHzMoaMqzVXjŒ^b`’g[ŽqKgaoaMWV

j‹V ν/2¤fGIHKj‹VIjŒLNkK‰ljŒM|VI^XH1Yu^^XHzMYš‡nMepY[{CMUqKgaoaMoaMW{necMMjlV

ν^¤

¥¦qwkzY[eX^Xj‹m#ZK‰‹Y[e”§M¨§jŒ‰l‰6kKecgu‡nM+^cHzYu^^XHKMNoaMWqzVžjŒ^XjlMWV”g[Ž(™†dRmgnqKqzMWm^cjŒqz{VXM#^cV_^XMWqzo†^cgmgnqzVž^cYnqŠ^

oKMqzVXjª^cjŒM|V6§HKMq

ν→ ∞¤GIHzMUoaMqzVXjŒ^b`g[Ž'‘(“•¨qKgaoaM|V g[ŽA{nMWqKMepY[‰ljŒ WMWo … Z.¡'jzY[‰l{ngCeXjŒ^XHKL Yn‰lVXg^XMWqzoKV

^cg!YmgnqzVž^cYnqC^f§HzMq’VXM‰lMWm^cjŒgCq’m#ecjª^cMecjŒZzL j‹VfzYCVžM|ognq.¥b“¨œCKZK^^XMWqzoKVf^XgAM_gnŽ?gCecoKMe √

ν §HKMWq.^XHKM meXjŒ^XMWeXjlZKL j‹V^XHKMqKgaoaMNoaM{CeXMWMn¤GIHKMWeXMŽgnecM^XHzjlV$m#gCq1zecL.VU^cHKMNk1gˆgnekAMeXŽgnecLNYnqzm#M¨g[Ž{CMqKMWecYn‰Œjl M|o

Z†Y[qzo¡EjY[‰l{ngnecjŒ^XHKL)§jŒ^XH†oaMW{necMM+m#ecjª^cMecjŒZzL¤

5 687

( ! "#$ #%&'(

GIHzMecM_Y[ecM^b§(g!«ˆjŒq1oKVfgnŽ'™†dR©mgnqKqzMWm^cMWo’oKgnLNjŒq1Yu^XjlqK{VžM^W˜^XHKM$VžM^gCa^cYnjŒqKM|oNˆ`¨^cHKM”^XepY[qzVXLNjª^X^XMe

jlqwYnq¢™†dR ›zgˆgaoajŒqz{Y[q1o†^XHzM¨VXM#^$gna^pY[jlqKMWo†ˆ`^XHzMVXk1M|m#j211mY[‰l{ngnecjŒ^XHKL oaMWVcm#ecjl1M|o=jlq9,v$/8œ£mWY[‰l‰ŒM|o

™=dRIž‘(“•?¤šGIHKMŽgnecLMWeEHzYCV£^XHzMYnoK‡šYnqŠ^cY[{CM^Xg_MWqzY[z‰ŒMf‰lMWVcV£^cecYnqzVXLjŒ^ž^cMepV?^XH1Y[q+^cHKMf‰‹Yu^ž^cMeKZa^§jŒ^XH

^cHKM]oaepYš§zYCmp«†^XHzY[^^XHzMm#gCqKqKM|m^XM|o oagnLNjlqzYu^cjŒqK{wVžM^!jlV¨VžgCZKepm#M.oaMkAMq1oaMqŠ^– :;: ^XHzM]m#gCqKqKMWm#^XM|o

oKgnLNjŒq1Yu^XjlqK{¢VXM#^‡uY[ecjŒM|o §HKMq ^XHKM VžgCZKepm#M.g[Ž^cHKMjŒqKjŒ^Xj‹Y[‰(KecgCYCoKmYCVb^!‡uYneXjlMWVp—¤=¥¦qŽµYnm#^!^XHzM™†dR

›1gŠgaoajlqK{Nj‹VI‰lYCVb^UHKgCkoKMkAMqzoaMWqŠ^W¤

<=

­ˆ±  ­ ?>A@B DC"E"E) ! B FG; H%E)2I& G B KJ(LNMPOQ44 '&()) R S T!EUVW4X

$2)Y Z T

2 ν

:

GIHzMkzeXgˆg[ŽjlVUjŒq3,[.ˆœEO/ ¤

<= ­ˆ±  ­ ]\^@B ZCHE_HE` a B R%; HbE_)2$'&$ K B JcLdMAegfbhi) j Sk aEb_V)W2)Y

3 ν ^l

B )

ν→ ∞^:

¥ ^HzYCV$1MWMq kKecgu‡nMqwjŒqm,[.S/ ^XH1Yu^!YqKgaoaM.HzYnVb.™†dR §HKj‹mpH Y[ecM¨^cHKMNM#\ˆ^XecML.Yn‰ k1gCjŒqŠ^cV$gnŽjŒ^cV

mgu‡nMWecYn{nMfjlqŠ^XMec‡uY[‰8¤ ‘gCqˆ‡nMepVXM‰l`”^cHKMqˆZKL!AMeg[ŽA™=dR VžMW‰ŒM|m^cgne6qKMjl{nHˆAgnepVjlVR.K¤on qzgˆoKM(AM‰lgnqz{CV^Xg

^cHKM™†dR ‘(“•–µj‹—jŒŽ1jŒ^fHzYnV^XHzMIVXHKgCež^cMWVž^¥b“ jlq¨jŒ^cV6qzMjl{nHˆ1gCeXHzgŠgao£œš§HKj‹mpHgˆmWm#ZKepV§jª^cH¨kzeXgCzY[Kjl‰ljª^b`

1 ν

œzgCe!–jlj‹—UjªŽ gCqKM+g[Ž jŒ^cV_™=dR VXM‰lMWm^cgneHzYCV^cHKM!VXHKgneX^XM|Vb^U¥b“jŒq ^cHKMqKMWjŒ{CHŠAgnecHKgˆgao£œK§HKj‹mpH†gammZKecV

§jŒ^XH kKecgn1Y[Kjl‰ŒjŒ^b`

2 ν

¤fGIHzMWVXM$^b§gM‡CMqŠ^cVIAMjlqK{.M#\Km‰ŒZzVXjl‡nM”^XHKM+kKecgn1Y[Kjl‰ŒjŒ^XjlMWVVXZKL ¤

p q

I6#r(ts vu #%+6p - "

w(`¥b“ meXjŒ^XMWeXjlZKL §M”YnVcVžZKLNMI^cHzYu^IY+qKgaoaMUAM‰lgnqK{ŠV ^cg+^XHKM+‘(“•.§HKMqN^cHKM_qKMWjŒ{CHˆ1gCecV §jŒ^XH]HKjŒ{CHKMe

¥b“oagnqgx^ŽgnecL YNm#gCqKqKM|m^XM|omgnLNkAgnqKMWqC^I^cHzYu^_mgu‡nMepV^XHKM+§Hzgn‰lMqzgˆoKMqzMjl{nHˆ1gCeXHzgŠgao£¤

<= ­ˆ±

 ­

@B QCHE"E) G B $ RU4 "KE)2I& TU B k&H))`; %c jZegfbh

l

B f

) #| T) (EUVY$g T

4 ν ^l

B )

ν → ∞

¥¦qŽµYCm^ eXZz‰ŒM

kjlVfMŠZKjl‡šYn‰ŒMWqŠ^^cg$eXZK‰lMk.”jŒq.oajlLNMqzVXjlgnqOn¤¥ ^fHzYnV6AMMq.VXHKgu§qjŒqi,[.4/K^XH1Yu^ ^XHzMUYš‡nMepY[{CM qˆZKL¨1MWeg[Ž‘(“•LNML¨1MWecVIjlq†YNVžMW{nLNMqŠ^g[Ž‰ŒMWqK{[^cH

x j‹VM\aYCm^c‰Œ`

2x−1^¤

w(`NoaM{CeXMWMImeXjŒ^XMWeXjlZKL §MUYCVXVXZKLNMI^XHzY[^Y$qKgaoaMUAM‰lgnqz{CV6^cg$^XHKM‘(“$•N§HKMWq^XHKMUqzMjl{nHˆ1gCecV6§jŒ^XH

HzjŒ{CHKMeIoaM{CeXMWM_oagCqgx^(ŽgnecLY!mgnqKqzMWm^cMWom#gnLNkAgnqKMWqŠ^^XH1Yu^m#gu‡nMWecVf^XHKM§HKgC‰ŒM”qKgaoaM”qzMjl{nHˆ1gCeXHzgŠgao£¤

<= ­ˆ±  ­ @B UCHE_HE` 3 B ; H E2$'&$c B G&H))`; %m jUe fKh

l B

HT&$U )# S TcE%V)Yg √

8πν

l B

ν→ ∞^:

¡'M#^

N(x)AM^cHKM(qŠZzL!AMeg[ŽKqKMWjŒ{CHŠAgneg[ŽzY_qKgaoaMIYu^‰lgamY[^Xjlgnq

xgnq+^cHKMIVžMW{nLNMqŠ^L.YnkE¤¡'M#^

I([a, b])

AM^XHKMqˆZKL!AMegnŽ'qKgaoaM|V(mgnqŠ^cYnjŒqzMWo’ˆ`.jlqŠ^XMec‡uY[‰

[a, b]^¤ GIHKMWeXMŽgnecM

N(x) =I([x−1, x+ 1])^{¤f¡EM#^}

∆(x) =N(x)−N(0)^¤ M+qKMWMWo]^XHKM$ŽgC‰Œ‰lgu§jŒqz{‰lMLNL.Y

­ ‚3>

$

x∈[−1,0] ^$ y∈[0,1] ∆(x) ^$ ∆(y) HTCY) ")Y ZW"E)2):

dfecgˆg[Žb˜U¥ Ž

x∈[0,1]œA^XHKMWq¢§(M¨HzYš‡CM

∆(x) =I([−1,−1 +x])−I([1,1 +x])^¤+¥Ž x∈[−1,0]

^cHKMq

∆(x) =I([−1 +x,−1])−I([1 +x,1])¤•ˆjlqzmM_^cHKM”jlqŠ^XMWeX‡uY[‰‹V(oagnqgx^gu‡CMec‰lYnkN^XHKMWq

∆(x)^Y[qzo

∆(y)YneXMjŒq1oaMkAMqzoKMqŠ^_§HKMWq

x ^Ynqzo y HzYš‡nM+oaj?MecMqŠ^UVžjl{nqzVW¤

¡'M#^

Rr

1M”^XHzM$YnzVXgn‰lZa^XM”‡šYn‰ŒZzM”gnŽ£^XHKM 1zepVb^

x∈[0,1]VžZ1mpH’^XH1Yu^

∆(x)>0^–∀t∈[0, x]∆(x)≤ 0^{—¤ ¡EM#^} Rl

AMw^XHKM Y[zVXgn‰lZa^XM¢‡šYn‰ŒZzM¢kAgCVXjª^cjŒgCq g[Ž+^cHKM 1zepVž^

y ∈ [−1,0] ^{VXZzmpH ^XH1Yu^} ∆(x) > 0

–

∀t ∈ [y,0]∆(x) ≤ 0^{—¤ … M]«ˆqKgu§ ^XH1Yu^} Rr

Y[qzo

Rl

YneXM’jlqzoaMWk1MWqzoaMWqC^|¤ n qKgaoaM]Yu^k1gŠVžjŒ^Xjlgnq

AM‰lgnqz{CV(^Xg^cHKM¨‘(“•j

Rr+Rl>1

­ ‚-\

)

x∈[0,1] ^B FCHE"E)

P(x) ^{YB B} Rr=x ^{B Sz_C"% $ #}

Z ^∞

0

P(x)e^−ωxdx= 2 +^2ω_ν +q

(2 +^2ω_ν )²−4 2

i”Yš‡ˆjŒqK{

∆(t)≤0ŽgCeIYn‰Œ‰

t∈[0, x] j‹VIMŠZKjl‡uY[‰lMqŠ^^cHzYu^UYnq™[™ˆOVž`aVž^XMWL§jª^cHVXMec‡ˆjlmM”epYu^cMYnqzo YneXecjl‡šYn‰KepYu^XMM ŠZzY[‰z^Xg

ν 2

Vb^pY[eX^cV §jŒ^XH’gCqKM_mZzVb^cgnLNMeY[qzo.oagˆM|VfqKgn^MLNka^b`jŒ^cV CZzMZKM_oKZKeXjlqK{!Y^cjŒLNM

jlqŠ^XMWeX‡uY[‰ gnŽ‰lMqK{n^XH

x^{¤’¡'M#^} f(ω) AMN^XHKM’¡Y[kK‰‹YnmM!^cecYnqzVbŽgCeXL gnŽ^cHKM.oaj‹Vb^ceXjlKZa^cjŒgCq gnŽ^cHKMN^XjlLNM’G qzMMWoKMWo†^cgMWLNka^b` ^XHKM ŠZKMZzM

f(ω) =E[e^−ωT]^{¤¡'M#^} θ AM!^cHKM^XjlLNM¨qKMWMWoaM|o=ŽgCe_^cHKMM#\ajª^+gnŽf^XHKM 11ecVž^Um#ZzVž^XgCLMWeWœa§(M$HzYš‡nM”ŽecgnL m‰lYCVXVXj‹m ŠZKMWZKMjlqK{^XHKMWgnec`?˜

T =θ+Nθ×T ^–žO|—

§HzMecM

Nθ

j‹V.Y d6gnj‹VXVXgnq epY[q1oagnL ‡uY[ecj‹Y[K‰lMgnŽ”LNMWYnq

θ ^Y[q1o N ×T LNMWYnqzV¨^XHKM=YCoKoajŒ^Xjlgnq g[Ž

N

jlqzoaMWk1MWqzoaMWqC^_mgnkKjlMWVIgnŽ

T ^–N ^j8¤j8¤oE¤ ‡šYneXj‹Y[z‰ŒM|V(oKjlVž^XecjŒzZa^XM|oYCV

T—¤fGIHzMecM#ŽgnecM

f(ω) = Z ^∞

0

P(θ=x)e^−xωe^{xν2(f(ω)−1)}dx ^–.n—

= ν/2

ν/2(1−f(ω) +ω

–µvC—

‘gCqzVžM ŠZKMqŠ^X‰l`^XHKM¡'YnkK‰lYCm#M+^cecYnqzVžŽgnecL gnŽ ^XHKMNoaj‹Vb^ceXjlKZa^cjŒgCq=g[Ž

Rr+Rl

j‹V f(ω)²¤$GIHKMWeXMŽgnecM

^cHKM kKecgnzYnKjŒ‰ljŒ^b`

P(ν) ^XH1Yu^’qKgaoaM†Yu^.kAgCVXjª^cjŒgCq wAM‰lgnqK{ŠV^Xg ^XHKM¢‘(“$•?œ ^cHzYu^.j‹V

Rl+Rr > 1^œ

VcYu^cjlV 1zM|V

P(ν) = 1 2iπ

Z i∞

−i∞

1−(ω+ 1 +p

(ω+ 1)²−1)²

w e^νωdω

”VžjlqK{¨^XHKMŽµYCm^I^XHzY[^

1−(ω+ 1 +p

(ω+ 1)²−1)²∼2√

ω+O(ω)^§HKMq ω→0§(M”H1Yš‡nMUŽecgnL

‰‹YuhbgC‰ŒM^Ynqzooa‰Œ`ˆ W«ng¨^XHKMWgnecML ˜

1 2iπ

Z i∞

−i∞

1−(ω+ 1 +p

(ω+ 1)²−1)²

w e^νωdω∼ 2Γ(1/2)

π ν^1/2.

… M_oaj‹Vžkz‰lYš`jlqa1z{CZKeXM$OI^cHKMU‡uY[ecjŒgCZzV6qKgaoaMUoaMWqzVXjª^cjŒM|Vfg[ŽA^XHzMUm#gnqzqKMWm#^XMWoNoagCLNjŒqzY[^XjlqK{VXM#^Vž^XZzoKjŒM|o

jlq^XHKj‹VIqKgn^XMn¤

uI6(

,ŒO)/$d6¤CYCmŠZKM#^|œ n¤¡'Y[gCZKjŒ^Xj8œ'd6¤'™†jlqKM#^|œ¡¤ _jlMqzqKg[^|œd6MWežŽgCeXL.Y[q1m#Mg[ŽL¨ZK‰Œ^Xjlk1gCjŒqŠ^!ecM‰‹Yš`ˆjŒqK{jlq

LNgCKjŒ‰lMYnoHKgam$qKM^b§gCeX«aVWœ M#^b§(gnec«ˆjŒqz{a. H.KœˆdfjlVcYKœY. '.a¤

,./$d6¤ŠYnmŠZKM^Wœdn¤6¡'YngnZKjŒ^Xj8œ d6¤™=jŒqKM^Wœ¡¤ ”jŒMWqKqKgn^WœNd6MeXŽgnecL.Y[qzmM]Y[q1Y[‰l`ˆVXj‹Vg[Ž¡•aR)L!Zz‰ª

^cjŒkAgnjlqŠ^’eXMW‰lYš`ˆjlqK{¢jlq ^b§g Yno HKgam]§jleXMW‰ŒM|VXVqKM^b§gCeX« LNgaoaM‰‹VWœ¥

R¥n RM|VžM|Y[epmpHRMWkKk1gCež^

R_RI0I.[x Kœ . KOn¤

,v$/!‘”¤nošhbjŒH'œzd6¤ŠYnmŠZKM^Wœz¡¤ _jlMqKqzg[^Wœ+‘gnLNkKZa^cjŒqK{’oKgnLNjŒq1Yu^XjlqK{.VXM#^U§jŒ^XH L!ZK‰Œ^XjlkAgnjlqC^”eXMW‰lYš`aVWœ

¥ R¥n RUR0ˆsŠtaœI. '.a¤

,0"/1¤ … ZEœYnqzo(¤f“Y[j8œn {CMqKMWeXj‹moKjlVž^XecjŒzZa^XM|o KecgCYCoKmYCVb^NVXmpHKMWL jŒq YnoHKgam]qzM#^b§(gnec«ˆVWœjlq

egf!eoh œ. Cv

,s/$d6¤CYCmŠZKM^Wœžd6MeXŽgnecL.Y[qzmMgnŽfm#gnqzqKMWm#^XMWo†oKgnLNjŒq1Yu^XjlqK{]VXM#^”jŒq¡•aRQkKecg[^Xgamgn‰8œ+¥ R¥nRM#

VXMWYnecmpHRMkzk1gCež^_RUR¦s zœI. "0z¤

0 5 10 15 20 25

50 100 150 200 250

nu

"!$#&%"('*),+-%./012!31546157879:<;>=@?BAC

;>=@?ED7'*)F+GCIHFJLKMD7'*)F+ONP70(Q)RCGHFJLKMD7'*)F+ONP70S T U

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt

Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique 615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis : 2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Éditeur

INRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399