HAL Id: hal-01764416
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01764416
Submitted on 11 Apr 2018
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
Les ”cultures” de mutualisation du PSL le positionnent-elles comme un acteur central de la
logistique urbaine ?
Odile Chanut, Paché Gilles
To cite this version:
Odile Chanut, Paché Gilles. Les ”cultures” de mutualisation du PSL le positionnent-elles comme un
acteur central de la logistique urbaine ?. Rencontres Internationales de la Recherche en Logistique et
Supply Chain Management , 2012, Montréal, Canada. �hal-01764416�
! " # $ # $ %& ! '( )%$ $ %&&&*
%"" & # & # ! # %+$ $ , -#$ & .
/!$ 01#&
24345 678 9 :5 ;921 1 <5 =192 8 >8 ?9561
@AB C DE FGHIJK LJIB MN HOJE P Q
R$ '#1S
24345 678 9 :5 ;921 1 <5 =192 8 >8 ?9561 TB C C DUE VHFGDLJIB MN HOJE P Q
4>2W>
12 128 752 91 8 =12 X 7 28 1 9Y 51 766Z158 >279W 2 51 Z 61 WZ798 58 1 52 8 8 >98 91 6>W 18 W 2 22 52 1 W51W158 12 795 28 752 ZY 12 18 Z9 =>12[
9122798 6 91W158 128 9=:1916196111268 7526756198 >128 272 912Z752Y 8 >
\] ^_`a Z 78 1 bc `\de fg_h `ih jg`e _e h e kgl`md^j`kfe h gj`n o`mjdmopoh e d_`\] gq q gh l`g_h jdme r^gl`
s 1567WY91W158 12 5t 928 968 9128 W 8 Z 68 75125 256128 18 6[ u [ 1ZZ 19Y791 n dpe lh e r^g`^jvoe _g`g_`ojp^wg_h o_h `l^j`n ] e wmdjh o_xg`r^g`md^jjoe g_h `mjg_\jg`n gl`yz{`g_`n o`
woh e |jgc ` g_` l] omm^}o_h ` md^j` xgn o` l^j` n g^jl` a 6 8 912 ~8 8 78 W 19 Z79 91 1=19 12 >t 2 1
= 1 9Y 1 ~ 1 1W 5[
@K U FC U Q HIFD @TB UK B JD JQ HB ID JK JHC B UHK B @I B C C D AJQ HC DE
!"# $%&'"()*" + ,-,)%"!.(%/,0 12 ,3 4 "5 6 ()"*,%"75 (%"/0 .)*%"8 .90+ &.)2 %"*6 :5 ,&2 0 $-:)./,0 ".("
;<=>?@ >A BC DA EFG=C ?= HD G=I? J ?B ;GD KF?B L<BIM ?C NA ?;?=B =<C G;;?=C @ O GA BGA C PGD GQ C D ? ?= RSR 5 6 .))$)&," %(+ T.)2 , U V W76 1X 12 57Y1X 15Z 1X 15Y 97551[158 X\ 572 9]^ ]6 22752 _ 5 91`798 [7 a ^ Y b `79 28 9 c19 572 `97 8 2 29d9 2 58 9e [972f g52 61 691\ 572 91619675212`98 15 912`7Y58 `97`7219517^ ^ 91^ Y 12261`8 c 119]`7591X hijkl mjn oin pin qrks it n pu ijt e _e ol rin v wn xkoyv l jwt l kmz n v u l mt y{rwt l kmn it n v wn xl jin imn |}~rin oijn ol yrimt ijn 6758 9 58 128 165 1291 8 Y129]21^ Y 18 679912`7558 X5 Y1X1219Y 612
^ Y X 5]6122 912 _ 51 28 9 c8 75 9] 91 18 2]69 2]1f W Y72 8 12 58 ]9122]2 `9 [ 21 15` 61127 8 75269]8 Y12`79 28 9 c19572`97 8 2525`98 159 8 ^ 75]29 9]1\ 572Y7291[196 7521`915916758 68 Y16572 ? BJ ?C C ?D >?W8 98 ] 12 7 28 1@ S;GD BRSR ?C C ?G==<=I?B<FJ A =?J ?B<FIA >B<D;GA BI<=BC G=C >?B?=C D ?PD A B?B@
A =>FBC DA ?J J ?B;GA BGFBBA I<;;?D IA GJ ?B@ >?C D <F?D >?BB<J FC A <=BA ==<G=C ?BP<FD D P<=>D ?GF
=<F?GF >O A B J <A BC A KF?B >?B PD <IMGA =?B G==?B
6 $9 ,&2 + 8 ",%2 4 "7$(0 ",5 5 ,%4 "*,"&$)2 + )(,0 ""2 0 $(T,0 "*,%"%$(0 &,%"*6 :&$)$-+ ,%"*.)%"()"&$)2 ,2 ,"*,"
&0+ %,":&$)$-+ (,",2 "*,"'.(%%,"&$)%2 .)2 ,"*("&$2 "*,"5 6 :),0 /+ ,4 "2 $(2 ",)"0 :7$)*.)2 ""5 6 ,+ /,)&,"
=<F?J J ?@ >??=F? FD ?=C ?@ >F >?J <PP?;?=C >FD GEJ ??C >?J G >I<=?BC A <= >?BA J J ?B ?IA ?BC PGD C A IFJ A D ?;?=C D GA ?= FD <P? < J G ;C D <P<J A BGC A <= PD <D ?BB? D GPA >?;?=C J GGJ @ RR @ ?C <
5 6 $)" $9%,0T," ()," 70+ %," *," &$)%&+ ,)&," .+ /(" *,%" &$)%:(,)&,%" *," 5 ." %$&+ :2 :" *," &$)%$--.2 + $)" %(0"
5 6 ,=A D <==?;?=C ?C J G KFGJ A C >? J G A ? >G=B J ?B GJ <;D GC A <=B G J <A BC A KF? FDEGA =? ?BC >??=F?
()," 70 :$&&(7.2 + $)" *,%" 7.0 2 + ,%" 70 ,).)2 ,%" *," 5 ." T+ 5 5 ,4 " &$--," 5 6 .2 2 ,%2 ," 5 ." -(5 2 + 75 + &.2 + $)" *,%" 2 0 .T.("
BFD J ?BF ?C @ C G=C J ?BO J F>?;GD IMG=>A B?BB?B<=C ;FJ C A PJ A %"#T$+ 0 "7.0 ",,-75 ,"5 6 $(T0 ./,"
&$$0 *$)):"7.0 ".&'.0+ %",2 ",5 $" 3 ¡ "¢$0 &,",%2 "*,"&$)%2 .2 ,0 "(6 (),"0 :7$)%,"7$%%+ 95 ,""&,"
*$(95 ," $9 ,&2 + 8 " *6 :&$)$-+ ,%" *," &$2 %" ,2 " *," *:T,5 $77,-,)2 " *(0 .95 ," 0 ,7$%," %(0 " *,(" :5 :-,)2 % U
£ ¤ ¥6 (),"7.0 2 4 "5 ."-(2 (.5 + %.2 + $)"*,%"0 ,%%$(0 &,BJ <A BC A KF?BP<FD A C ?D J ?BGBPA J J G?B>FBGF D ?;PJ A BBG? A =I<;PJ ?C >?B IG;A <=B PGD ??;PJ ?@ I? KFA BFPP<B? >? O GA D? C D GGA J J ?D ?=B?;EJ ?
>?B ?=C D ?PDA B?B ?=C F?J J ?;?=C I<=IFD D ?=C ?B ¦
£ ¤ ¥6 .(2 0 ,"7.0 2 4 "5 6 + ))$T.2 + $)"$0 /.)+ %.2 + $)),5 5 ,"7$(0 "+ )T,)2 ,0 "*,%"%&':-.%J <A BC A KF?BA =C D G=C
=<C G;;?=C >?BB<J FC A <=B>?C D G=BP<D C ;FJ C A ;<>GJ ?B@ ;<A =B=FA BA EJ ?B?=C ?D ;?B>?§ @
=FA BG=I?B B<=<D ?B <F I<=?BC A <= >?B I?=C D ?B A J J ?B
! "#$ % & % % ! ' ( )( ! ( ( ' ' *%+' ! !,- .- /0, 1 -20,3 01 4 .- 5 6278- .8, 9- 0:-; .-4 0;1 -8, 4 08< , -4468, ;-4 -1 ;6=/91 -2;-4 ;6=/5 9=-21 03 , -4>
? ' ! ' ) %@ ' ) ' ! A%@ A ' B ( @C ! )% % @ &'
! C ! ( & ' ( C % ' ! ' ' %' ! CD' EA ! F F ( ( C% ' ! /0, 1 -203 , -45 3 94/0, 82-3 21 -21 3 62.-;66/9, -, -1 .-/0, 1 07-, , 3 4G8-4-1 H929I 3 ;-4J K0;L9-1 M( )( N OPPQR S #% F F ' !%A%@ A ' ! ( ' ( & ! !%' ( %( %( T%( !
=91 3 -, U .-4 0;1 -8, 4 268:-08< 621 9=-, 79 ! CD' EA ! F F ( N ' )( ' ' ( ! ( @ & ' *% V M#?R N !' ) ! ! CA C ! ( W ' ( N ' ' % @ % ! :65 8=-41 , 03 1 94G8-.-41 X;L-40448=9-4JY85 ;623 418 Z U [\]]^ > _-4K`_4621 .-:-284.-4 /0, 1 -203 ( Aa %( ! !%' ( ' ! ! ' ( B%' %( N *% ' )( ' ' ( % *% ! % % ! %( ! ( !( N b ' ( ! ?c # ( @ N M#?d ' ( *% ' e % F ! f ! g( N % *% @ ! ' %( )( ' ' & ' *% b ) % %( d(7-8, 4U 468:-21 ;62;8, , -21 4U -2 79, 021 /0, -<-=/5 - .-4 -21 , -/h1 4 =85 1 3 i;5 3 -21 4>
j( CF C( %!C@ )) A ' ( ) ! ! !%' ( ! )( ' ' & ' *% % ! /5 8/0, 1 .-4/0k46;;3 .-21 08<U 5 0G8-41 3 620H6, .9-.0245 -/0/3 -, -41 ;-5 5 -.8, h5 -/6443 H5 -G8- /68, , 03 -21 1 -23 , 5 -4K`_.0245 0, -;62I 3 78, 01 3 62-2;68, 4.-44;L9=045 673 41 3 G8-4U 261 0==-21
%( B N *% %)) ! F ( ' ( @ ( AB ! %( ( ' ' ! +' ( N )%( N /0, 1 3 ;85 3 l, -=-21 3 226:021 -2 =01 3 l, - .- /3 5 61 07- .-4 I 5 8<> m2 eA ' %( ! @' &
%( ( ' !C) DC )( M#? ! )% %( CA ( & a %*% b %( e) N ' ) B
! ! ' F ( ) % %( C CA ' & F ' F *% A ' ' )%( % ) ' C( %@ C b+' ( % 0;1 -8, =0n -8, .-5 0=81 805 3 401 3 62-2;621 -<1 -8, H03 2-1 o/0, 1 3 ;3 /-, .-=023 l, --I I 3 ;0;-o82
%& !%( B ! ( %( & ' *% S ? )' )( ' ! !C( ( *% M#?
! ) ' ! % % ' %( p L3 41 6, 3 G8- q.-5 0=81 805 3 401 3 62G83 /68, , 03 1 5 -8, /-,=-1 1 , -.- ( ( N % ! C! ' MdC V OPPrR N ! & ' ! % & ' *% %( B !%( B S K68, ;-5 0U 2684 2684 0//83 -, 624 48, 82- .9=0, ;L- .- 201 8, - 0H.8;1 3 :-U s t976u91 t19v18 wxyz {|}x|ywx~y{ x |x~yy | |yw w x~yx ywxy |x~ qJ 2789U [\\^ U .9H68;L021 48, 82 /0/3 -, 41 , 8;1 8, 9-21 , 63 4/0, 1 3 -4> 684, -:3 -2., 624U .02482-/, -=3 l, -/0, 1 3 -U 48, 5 -
!C@ )) A ' ! !%' ( ! M#?N A) e F ' ! %( ( ' %( A T%@( !
/, 01 3 G8-4 .- =81 805 3 401 3 62> 684 ;-21 , -, 624 5 0 .-8<3 l=- /0, 1 3 - 48, 5 -4 ;621 , 03 21 -4 268:-5 5 -4 .- 5 0
5 673 41 3 G8-8,H03 2--1 5 -49:65 81 3 62401 1 -2.8-4-2=01 3 l, -.-=81 805 3 401 3 62> 684-</64-, 624
! "# $ % & & & ' & ( '& ) # & ! *+,
& $ - $! . / ' #0 & & !% 1 2 3
45 6 789:;<==:>:?@6 7:A6 =A;6 B 6 CD:;CD:A6 E<?7F>:?@FDG6
HI JKKLM NOJKNPQHR NOJSTU KNV JKNWXXYJKNZ[\]R NJK^ NV WM _J`JX^ NV U YNWTaNK^ M W^ Y_U JKNOJNM JbJX^ M W_JNOJKN & 2 & '!#$- ' !# & c & '!'$ ! !de
$ ! d ' & '!## ' ! $2& ' ! $ # 1 ! % &
-d& !$$# 'f 1d ! % & '3 g & $ 'f %$ & *+, OI LSYM W^ U LXKNhWKU iTJKNV U YJ #$& $fj 1$ ! '! $!!f V JTM KN bV U JX^ KN OJN KJN OYKJX_W_JM N OI WhLM ON OJN iTJV iTJKN Wb^ U kU ^ YKN V L_U K^ U iTJKN SYMU SlYMU iTJKN m ^ M WXKSLM ^ R N JX^ M JSLKW_Jn R N STU KN OJN V I JXKJ`hV JN OJKN LSYM W^ U LXKN bL`SV JaJKN V U YJKN oN V WN `Wp ^ MU KJN OJN bLXbJS^ U ! j "#' '& !q r e 18 s R NZ[[tn u Nv V NKJM WU ^ Nw WK^ U OU JTaNOI YXT`YM JM NV I JXKJ`hV JNOJKN
`WXxTkM JKNK^ M W^ Y_U iTJKNWyWX^ NbLXOTU ^ NoNTXJNJa^ JM XWV U KW^ U LXNOJNV WNV L_U K^ U iTJNOJNV WNSWM ^ NOJN
#& $& 'f % 3 g & & - z{{| #2& -# 1 -d!& ! '! d
& 2 } ~'! & !% 1$ # . ' ! & '!#$% - + %$!
g & '! $! $ & % ! $ "' - 'f- . + ! '! } ~ d .
-! & & & !2& ,!% ' blJw N OI LM blJK^ M JN OJN V WN 2 6 5 #! & % !$ d' . V WN bV YN V WN KU _XW^ TM JN OI TXN bLX^ M W^ N V LX_N ^ JM `JN SLTM N SU V L^ JM N V WN V L_U K^ U iTJN OTN bLXK^ M Tb^ JTM N U Xw LM`W^ U iTJu HI U X^ JV V U _JXbJN K^ M W^ Y_U iTJN OJN bJM ^ WU XKN PQHN w T^ N OI WX^ U bU SJM N STU KN OJN KW^ U Kw WU MJN V JKN W^ ^ JX^ JKN2'!$
SV TKN KLSlU K^ U iTYJKN iTU N KJN KLX^ N `WXU w JK^ YJKN OJSTU KN V LM KR N OWXKN V I U XOTK^ M U JN `WXTw Wb^ TM U M JN J^ N OWXKN V WN 2 ! $! d ' . f d& 0 ! - q & '! *'f- z{{ 3 , *+, !
$ !% d# ! -'!#$- '!d& & !X^ NbJM ^ WU XJKNXI LX^ NiTI TXJNV LU X^ WU XJNM JV W^ U LXN WkJbN V JN `Y^ U JM N OI LM U _U XJu N HJKN LhKJMkW^ JTM KN OU K^ U X_TJX^ N OYKLM `WU KN ^ M LU KN bL`SLKWX^ JKN SMU XbU SWV JKN OTN
#- *+,q !1 'f j z{{ 1& r2& j f- c $ # "
'!#$! ( 8 19 )q $!% $! e "#'!#$!
( 19 612 8 7551 26 158 )q % !$ !#! ! ' +g
! "# '!#$! ( 71 8 192 R N bL``JN V WN _JK^ U LXN OJN bJX^ M JKN OI WSSJV N LTN V JN 67
5 68 9 5
1 -#! % & d!& ! -'! ' *+,# . $! ! OI JX^ M JSM U KJKR NSWMw LU KNJXNbLXbTM M JXbJNw M LX^ WV JR NOJKNM JKKLTM bJKNbL``TXJKNJXN`W^ U M JNOJN6