Coopération et concurrence: le cas des consortia de R&D
Texte intégral
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5) . 12 C o o p é r a t i o n e t c o n c u r r e n c e : l e c a s d e s c o n s o r tia d e R e c h e r c h e & D é v e lo p p e m e n t "!$#&%('*) +-,, ./'.10. C. 2+%'. 35476. .98:% 6. '..9';0. -<>=?'+@.A<>%(B. D EGFHJIKMLONFQPRISE. TVU WXZY\[XZ]^WS_`XRacbd]\[Xe_[gfSU` ah[*ah[ ifWkjY\j l]\[mnY\[oXZpq]^bQr2[oXe[s tSubQ]vrw[W ah[ W ax_ [oXZpQjbdry[oX Wkj`z[(YcY\[X{_|cjbQlUW5]}X~U a\]\jW`]X~jWa$pQjWk_u [X"Xq` b"_[X{ijr:tSjbRah[r2[ W aRX{i jjtkubU a\]cpXG UbRr-] [YcY\[oX~mY\[oX{i joWX~jobqa\]\U&_[[ i fk[bifS[&[a$Tuz[(Y\jttk[rw[W a:Tp~joW a$YQ|cj[a_|` WS[&uac`k_[ Utt bjpQjWk_]\[tkjo` b` Wi[bRahU]^W1Wkjr{ b[&_ [bU]}XjWAX `1W]cz[U`1t bUa\]\`S[ m_|` Wk[tSUbRahm_ [X tkjYc]^a\]\o`k[Xah[ ifWkjY\j l]\o`k[XX~jWar"]}X~[oX[W&t5Y\U i ["_ UWXk[ U `ki jo` t_ [tkUXU(pR]^W_|cU i i bj acb[ YQ|cU i a\]^z ]^ahu>_ [ b~[oi fk[bi fk[]^WS_`XRacbd]\[(YcY\[tSUb{Y\[X"i jWXjbRa\]\U m[aY\[oX"U` ahjbQ]^ahuoX-ijWki ` bRb~[ W a\]\[YcY\[oX U ii [ t ah[W aX~U WX"_]cpRpq]\i `kY^ahu?i[XVt bUa\]h`k[oX-ij jtku bU a\]^z[oX | ]\_u [t bu_ jr-]^WkU W ah[¡[oXqao`k[YhU i jjtkubU a\]\jWZ_[¢{T [oXqaWku i[XX~U(]^b[n£¡YQ|^]^W Wkjz5Ua\]\jWxah[ i f WkjY\j l ]\o`k[1[a{£¡Y\U1ibj]}XXUWki[ u ijWkjr"]h`k[9`&W]cz[U`>acfku jobd]\o`k[ mG_A|vU ` acb[:tkUbQahm¤r2¥rw[ Xd]¦Y\U-ij jtAubU a\]\jW&fkjbQ]c§ojW ahU(Y\[-U Y\jWloah[r-tX"u ahu?UoXXQ]vr"]cY\u [£` WS[?ijYcY^`XQ]\jWSm¨_ [ Wkj`z[(YcY\[X-U WkUY© X~[oX-joW auahu>_ uz[(Y\jt tku[X bu i[r-rw[W a2tkj` b>b[ ijWWkUacb[ªXjWgi U bUiah«b[¬tAU bdpQj]}X]^Wk_]}XRtk[WAX~U Y\[Z_ UWX>` Wgi joWSah[ s ah[ ]^W WkjozU ah[` bm[atSj` b{X~jo`Yc]loWk[ bVU `XXd]$XU _]crw[WX~]\joW¡t bj i joWki` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[ £-ah[bQr2[mMt `]}X`A[ Y\[X{Wkj` z5[ YcY\[Xwjt tkjobqac`W]^ahuX-t bj _o`kia\]cz[oX-pQjW aurw[bl [ b2_ [>pq` ac` bX-rwUbifSuX|vU b~lo`r2[ WSa i joWXd]}XRah[ m]\i]MU`XXd]\m £t bQ]^z ]cY\u lJ]\[bY\[bY\[{_ [VY\U:iojjtkubU a\]\jW>_ U WXYQ|^]^W WkjzU a\]\jW 5]^WXQ]\m9` Wk[ i jjtkubU a\]\jW1X~[~`Xqa\]cpR]\[-_«X$Y\jobX®`k[-i[YcY\[¯qi(]UX XR` b[:Y\[X®i jr{tYhur2[ W ahUbQ]^ahuoX¨ah[ i f W]\`S[X[a ah[r{tkjb[(YY\[oXYc]\u [oX£` Wk[:XQ]^ac`AUa\]\jW_|^]^W Wkjz5Ua\]\jW °i[acah[Vij jtku b~U a\]\jW_ j]^a ahj` ah[ pQj]}Xtb~[ Wk_b[ pR]^W>Y\jbX~o`k[-i [Vb~JY\[-[XRa¦b~[ r:t5Yc][ a@`k[:YQ|^]^W WkjozU a\]}jW[oXqa¦bu U(Yc]}X~u[9M[-i jWAX~jbRa\]^` r±_ [:${T X| ]^WAX~i bd]^aetkUbQpQU]^ah[rw[Wa;_ UWX²i[acah[7Y\j l]\o`[³´]cYªtk[ bRry[aµY\U ij jb_]^WkU a\]}joW _¶ Uia\]cz ]^ahuoX t bu ijr{tu a\]^a\]vz5[X>Yc]hu [oX¡U `g_ uz5[Y\jt tS[r2[W a_S¶ `Wk[¬]^WWkjzU a\]\jWkm{[ay]cY2[XRay_ upR]^W]&XR` b>` Wk[ tku bd]\j_ [´_[ah[ r:tX>Yc]cr-]^ahu[´o`]2i jobqb[oXqtkjoWk_·£´Y\Ux_` bu[Wkui [oXXU]^b[¸tkj` b&bu U(Yc]}X~[ bi [ acah[ ]^W WkjozU a\]}jW¤ ¹¨]\[ Wº`k[2Y\Uwt bU a\]\`k[&i joWX~jobqa\]\U(Y\[XjJ]^ab~[(Y\Ua\]cz[rw[Wabu i[W ah[m»]cY$X[r:5Y\[ _ jWAiy`k[ YQ|cjW¼_]}XRtkjSX[½_ u£½_|` WS[·Yc]^acahubUac` b[½ui jWkjr"]}o`k[ª]\[W¼_ ji` rw[Wahu [½[ a1U kjb_ U W a¡Y\[oX _]cpRpQub[Wah[X pQU i [ acah[X _` t fkuWSjr«Wk[J¿¾Wk[ _J]cpqpR]\i `Y^ahu _[r2[ ` b[ ahj`ah[pQj]}X À[X bU]}XjW Wk[rw[WaRXÁWO|^]^W ah« lob~[WaÂtkUoX~m½[ W [pRpQ[ahm·` Wk[ i U bU iahu bQ]}Xqa\]\`S[ pdjoWk_ Ury[ W ahUY\[ _ [oX i joWX~jobqa\]\U³_ UWXY\U:t bUa\]\`k[m]cY}X¨b[ lobj`tk[W a@_ [oXpR]^bqr[Xo`]X~jW a@i jJYcY\UkjbU acbd]\i[X_ U WX¨`W .
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9) . _ jrwU]^WS[7_|cU i a\]vz]^aRum¬rwU]}X o`] b~[oXqah[ W aµi jWSi` bRb[W ah[oX _ U WX _A|vU ` acb[X _ jrwU]^Wk[oX GW YQ|cj i i ` bRb[Wki[ mtkj` b®Y\[Xi joWX~jobqa\]\U2_ [-${TVmGY\[oXpq]^bRrw[X$tkU bRah[WkU]^b[Xij jtk« b[W a£"`W¸XRahU _[ t bu ijr{tu a\]^a\]cp»ahj`a[W>X[:_]}XRt ` ahU W a_]cpRpQub[ W aRX$X[ lr2[ W aRX_ [r2U b~ifSuXS¦UVijr:]^WAU(]}X~jW_[ i [oX_[` syu(Y\ur2[ WaRX[oXqa ` W2pQU i ah[` b[s t5Yc]\i Ua\]cp@_ [YQ|c[WlU l[ry[W aOijWki b~[ a¦_[Xpq]^bQry[X@_ U WXY\U pQjbRr2[_S[i j jtSubUa\]\jWZXRtAu i(]cpq]\o`k[¡`O|c[oXqaYh[¡i jWXjbRa\]^`r2m$o`]Ut tkU bUa_ uXjbQr2U ]}XwU`XXd] i jor-r2[`Wk[®Wkj`z5[YcY\[pQjbQr2[V_[i joWki` bRb[Wki[T{U WX@i [acah[$tk[bXRtk[ ia\]cz5[ m9joW-Wk[tk[ ` atY^`X$X[ i joW ah[W ah[ bmi jr-rw[Vi [(Y\UV[XRaGpQU(]^a¦_ U WXY\UYc]^acahu b~U ac`b~[m_ [Vi joWXd]\_ub[b@Y\[Vi jWXjbRa\]^` r²_[$-T i jor-r2[/` W*XQ]vr{tY\[ [ sk[r{tY\[´_[b[oifS[bifk[xi jjtSubUa\]^z5[ [a_|c[W½rw[Xq` b[ b_ [¬rwUW]h«b[ XRahUa\]\`k[{Y\[X$]cr{tYc]}iUa\]\jWAX¨WkjbQryUa\]cz5[X$z]}X~¯R£ ¯}z]}X_ [:Y\U"i jWki ` bRb[Wki[ }Y_[z ]\[ W a¦tkUbijW acb[ Wkui [XXU]^b[_|c[Wz ]}XU l[bY\[i jWXjbRa\]^`r _[®:Tµi jr-rw[®`W2j[a _ |cuac`S_ [£tSUbRaO[W a\]\« b[[a _ U WX?` WS[¬tk[bXRtk[ i a\]vz5[ ]^W acbQ]^WX« `k[r[W a_ SWSUr-]\`S[ m-_ U WX1Y\U´r2[oXq`b~[Zj gi[acah[´pQjbQry[ _|cjbQlUW]RX~U a\]\jWy[ s t bQ]vr[Y\UzkjY\joW ahu_ [oXpR]^bdrw[X_[$b~[ Wk_b[ijr:tkU a}]^5Y\[X@U`i j`bX@_`2ah[r{tX YQ|cU i a\]\jW XR` beYQ|c[Wz]^b~joW Wk[rw[W a WkjahUr"r2[ WSaºtAUbZY\¶ ]^WSWSjz5Ua\]\joWZ[a/YQ|cU_ Ut ahU a\]}joW £²i [a [Wz ]^bjWWk[rw[W a»q[ W tkU bRa\]\i`Yc]\[ btkUbY\U{i U tkU i(]^ahu-_ [-X~U(]}Xd]^bbUt5]\_ [rw[W a_ [oXjt tkjbRac` W5]^ahuX_ [ rwUbifku( GWyi [:X[WAX~mY\[i joWX~jobqa\]^`r [Xqa`Wk[r2UW5]cpd[oXqahU a\]\jW-acb«X@i joWkib«ah[V_[X]^W ah[bU i a\]\jW X i jor:tY\[ sA[X2[ W acb[¡i jjtkubU a\]\jW [ai joWki` bRb[WSi [¡`5]X[r{Y\[ W aWku i[XX~U(]vb[Xw_ UWAX-Y\[¡iU _b[ _|` Wk[¨b[ i fk[bi fk[_ [¨z ]\U ]cYc]^ahu ¶ j [ia\]cp_ [&i [tkU t]\[b[XRa_[t bjtkjSX[b` Wk[&UWSUY©X[&_ [&i [oXV]^W ah[ b~Uia\]\jWAX "jacb[ _ u r2U b~i fk[nX[ bU¡_ [¡ijr{t b[WS_b[¡i jr-rw[W apQjWkia\]\jW WS[¡[auz5j Y^`k[?Y\[¡ijWXjbRa\]^`r2m$i[¡`] Wkui [XXQ]^ah[bU$YQ|vU_ jt a\]\joWy_¶ ` Wwi U_b[_ ¶ UWkUY©X[¨t bjifk[_ [oX¦pdU(]^aRX "j`XrwjW acb[bjWAX`S[_UW X Y\Ut bUa\]\o`k[ Y\[X"i joWX~jobqa\]\U¡XjW aYQ|v[ s t b[XXd]\jW£ YhU pQj]}X{_¶ [ W9lU l[r2[ W aRX"i j jtSubUa\]cp~X{Yc]\uX"£ Y\¶ ]^WWkjzU a\]\jWkmrwU]}X"U`AXXQ]_ [>ifkjJ]^sxi joWki` bRb[Wa\]}[(Y}X-dX[ i a\]\j
(10) W -j`AXtb~jotkjSX[bjWX"UY\jobX ` Wk[$]^W ah[ bRt buahUa\]\joW2U WkUY©Sa\]\o`k[_ [i [XjoX~[ bRzU a\]\jWAXX[ i a\]\j W NJISE(IAH . &»HP1-32/+. dF P&K!OK"$#P}EONoP}F%F~PRISE&GL(' "P*)GL,+ P}EGEMI.- H/+0"$#P}EONoP}F%F~PRI9E NJI9I4&2 H5 H. ¦[ t fkuWkjrw«Wk[e_ [·ijWAX~jbRa\]\UeUt tkU bUa¢_ UWXY\[XUW Wku[X768*U(Y\jbXx`O|` Wk[ªz5U lo`k[½_ [ i jjtkubU a\]\jWy_ u(pd[ bQY\[:Xq` b@_ ]cpRpQub[W ah[oX]cWk_`AXqacbQ]\[X@[atY^`X¦tkU bqa\]\i`5Yc]\«b[r2[ W aXq` bY\[oX]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[X _ [¸fkU`ah[ah[if WkjJY\jl]\[J: 9]\m:£/YQ|cjbQ]cl]cWk[m:i|v[oXqa{` Wk[¸z5jY\jW ahu¸tkjYc]^a\]\`S[´`5]2U XRa\]^r-`Y\u/Y\[ _ u z[(Y\jttk[r2[ W aO_ [i [acah[$t bUa\]\`S[i jjtkubU a\]vz5[®tAUbRa\]\i `Yc]\«b[ mkjWyijWXRahUah[o`k[Y\[oXpR]^bRr2[oX¨X[ XjW < a ;~U t t bjt bQ]\u[X ;¨b~U t]\_ [rw[W a»io[r2j_ [:_A|jblUW]}XUa\]\joW>_ [VY\[` bX®U ia\]cz]^ahuX_ [:${TVm `] _ [ z ]\[ W ai jr-t5Y\ur2[ W ahU]^b[{_ [Y\[ ` b$:T½bu U(Yc]}X~u[-[W]^W ah[bRWk[{[aXR` bY\U`k[YcY\[{[XRaGkUoX~u[Y\[`b XRacb~U ahulJ]\[i jWki ` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[J =?>A@CBD>>EGFAHI$BJEK>0EKL MKH4>BONPHI$BDEQ>>R@GSOSO@CH4TNU@5LUFABOVW@CXR@CSZYJBD>>EGFAHI$BJEK>,I[@WV5\>EKSJEMKBJ]TR@. ¦[oXi joWX~jobqah]\U-_ [{$:Tg]cYcY^`Xqacb[ W a¦tkUbQpQU]^ah[rw[WaYQ|^]^r: bQ]\iUa\]\jWibj]}XX~U W ah[-`5][oXqa@U t tkUbR`A[ _ U WXY\[XU W Wku [o? X 68>[W acb[:tkjYc]^a\]\`S["ah[if WSjY\jlJ]}`S[[ atkjJYc]^a\]\`k[2i jWSi` bRb[W a\]\[(YcY\[2_ UWXY\[oX tkUX_ [¬Y\7 U ^bQ]\U _ [JÀ[acah[/pQjbRr2[xi j jotkubUa\]^z5[ mVb~[i jWW `k[x[s tYc]\i(]^ah[rw[W a"tkUb_]cpRpQub[ W aRX ah[sah[X1_[¬tkjYc]^a\]\`S[ªX~i(]\[W a\]cpR]\`S[ [a2ah[ i f WkjY\jJl ]\`k[ [ a_ [¬tkjYc]^a\]\o`k[ i joWki` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[ m"U ku WkupR]\i]\u"_ [X®_ ukU aRX¨b[YhUa\]cp~X®U`&bY\[:tkjSXQ]^a\]cp$_[wY\U"i j jtSubUa\]\jW>]^Wah[b[Wacb[t bQ]}X[X®_ UWXY\[oX t bj i[XXq`X_|^]^W WkjzU a\]\jW ` rw¥ry[a\]^acb[V`k[Y\[Xj]^Wah¯hzS[W ac` b[oXj`yY\[XUi iojb_SX@]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[ ¯ ` W]^z5[bXQ]vahumY\[oX/ijWXjbRa\]\U·_ [Z¨{T jWa&kuWku(pd]\i(]\u·_ [ ahj` ah[ªYQ|cU acah[W a\]\jW _ [XU` ahjobd]^ahuoX ifSUbQl u[X_ [¨t bjrwj`zj]^bMY\Uijr:tku a\]^a\]vz]^ahu¨ah[ i f WAjY\jlJ]\`A[_[XGWkU a\]\jWX .
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14) ¦[UtSjW¼U t buzJ` _«X
(15) m _UWX XjW
(16) ^^
(17) S^
(18) c
(19) m5Y\U¨t bjrwja\]\jWy_ [oXi jW XjbRa\]\U_ [®b[ i fk[bifk[`5]Sb[j]vz5[WaOUY\jbXG` W&XRahUac`aY\u lU(Y£ tkU bqa@[ W a\]\«b[ ³9Y\[o X k " !\ $#&%¨
(20) ( $ '®
(21)
(22) () *c,
(23) +-%.0/ 2
(24) 1 `5]joWSa@u ahu"r"]}X[ 4 W 3$`zb[ Xj`X¦Y\U$pQjbRr2[_ [i joWXjbRa\]\U$]vr{tYc]\`SUW a¤_ [X¦pR]^bdr[Xi joWki` bRb[Wah[X¦Y\[ U_ [bX_ U WX¦Y\[XX[ i ah[` bX _ [ tSj]^W ah[*dX[r"]\¯qijWk_`Sia[` bXm¡jt a\]\`S[ mr"]\ib j ¯}]^WpQjbdrwUa\]\`S[QmrwU]}XZU `XXd]º_ [oX·Xj`X¯ acbU]^ahU W aRX~mV_[X>u`]^tk[ r2[ W a\]\[bXmV_ [X&Y\U kjbUahjJ]^b~[oX t ` 5Yc]\iX>_ [nb[ifk[ b~i fk[ mVjo`e[Wkijb[/_ [X ` W]^z5[bXQ]vahuoX 5\7 6lU _]^bQ][ a U(Yc]c]R (m ""8J G W M`b~jotk[ m Y\[X@U ii jb_SX@_ [i jjtkubUa\]\jWSmS[ a9WkjahUr-rw[Wa Y\[X@i jWXjbRa\]\U_[®:Tm9`] [Wacb~[ W a_ U WXY\[yi U_b[ _ [2YQ|vU t tYc]\iUa\]\jW_ [2YQ|vU bRa}]\i(Y\[ 69¡_o` ^b~U(]^ahu _ [2$jrw[ m¦pdjoW aYQ|cj [a _|` Wk[Z[ sk[r{t a\]hjW _[ 5Y\j iZ£ tSUbRa\]^bº_ [ 6:99 }Y}X¡ku WkupR]\i(]\[W a£ªi[´a\]^acb~[Z_ ¶ ` Wk[ Y\Ubl[ ]\[ W z[(]cYY\U Wki [_ [$Y\U¨tkU bqa¤_ [XU ` ahjbQ]^ahuXijWki` bRb[Wa\]\[(YcY\[XM[XX[ iah[ ` bX_ [$YQ|cU ub jWkU ` a\]\`k[[a _ [YQ|c[XRtkUi [:X[:X~jWaahj`atkU bRa\]\i`Yc]\« b~[rw[Wa¦_]}XRa\]cW9lo`kuoXtkUb_ [Xt bj i [XXq`AX_ [t bj _`Sia\]\jW[a _ [-pQU bQ]\iUa\]\jW>b[tkjSXUW aXq` b` WS[XRacbR`Aiac` b[2i jWAXjbRa\]\UY\[2bQ]\UWS[ mM]^bR `Xm¦[ahiJ ^»jo` ah[pQj]RX i [?t b[ r2]\[b-a tk[1_ [1iojWXjbRa\]^`Sr [ ` bjtku [ Wkm¨acb~«oX-` a\]cYc]}Xun[ W´tb~U a\]\`k[m®z]}X~[/X~[ `Y\[r2[ W a"£ i jjb_ jW Wk[ b²_]cpRpQub[WaRX*t fSUX[X¼_` t bj i[XXq`X¼_ [ t bj _`Sia\]\jW _A| `W ]\[W j` _A| `W u o`]^tk[r[W a[s5]l[ U W a_ [Xwi jr:tSuah[WSi [X-r{`Y^a\]^tkY\[7X ;»¾W _[` s]\« r2[&a Stk[¡_ [i jWXjbRa\]^`r [`b~jotku [ Wx[XRa$` a\]cYc]}Xu¡ijr"r2[¡Xq`t tSjbRa_ [&Y\Utkj Yc]^a\]\`k[¡X~i(]\[W a\]cpR]\`S[¡[a$ah[if WSjY\j l]\`k[>_ [ YQ|¾W]\joW G` bjtSu [WWk[2À[YcY\[¯qi(]¡U½[ W¼[pRpQ[a>tjo` bxj[ ia\]cp_|cUXXq`b~[ b XU½i jr{tkua\]^a\]cz]^ahu ah[ i f WkjY\j lJ]\`k[ pdUi [ U ` s GahUaRX~¯¾W]}X [ a U ` U tkjW [ W rwj]cYc]}XUW agY\[X b[XXj` bi [oX Xi]\[Wa\]cpq]\o`k[X_]}XRtk[bXu [oX1[Wacb~[/Y\[X&tkU X¡[ ` bjtAu [ WX[ay[ W;ibuUW ay_[XnXhSWk[ b~lJ]\[X[W acb[ b[ i fk[bifS[t bQ]^zku[?[ a$b[ i fk[bifS[t `Yc]\`k[JM¾W¸tbjlbUr-r[ah[(Y`k= [ <?>"@A%B xU>_ urwjW acbu YQ|c[pRpR]\i Ui]^ahu _A| `Wk[ jbQlUW]}XUa\]\jW _[ Y\U¿b[ifk[ b~i fk[ _[¿a Stk[ i jWAX~jbRa\]\U(Y;£ YQ|cu i fk[YcY\[ [`b~jotku [ W Wk[2RÀY\Uz5[bQ]\[ C m Y^`X$bu i [ r-rw[W amGY\[C X @?!DE F
(25) J H GI
(26) o
(27) c$ !D!\
(28) "UXXq` b[ WSa ulUY\[rw[WaOY\Ur-]}X[V[Wijr"r:` W_|` WS[b~[ifk[ bifA[V£` W>XqahU_ [t bu ijr{tkua\]^a\]cp Ub[sk[ r:t5Y\[ m _ U WXY\[:_ jor2U(]^Wk[:_[Y\U]\jah[if WkjJY\j5lJ]\[ mY\[-X~u`k[JW Ul[{_ [:luWkjrw[XX(|cU t t `]\[-Xq`bi [a Stk[ _|cjbQlUW]RX~U a\]\jW tSj` bpdU(]^b[@j`S[bY\U:ijr{tY\urw[W aUbQ]^ahu:_[Xah[ i f W]\`k[oX[ ai jr{tkuah[Wki[X`] ]^W ahu b~[oXX[Way£¬Y\U/pQj]}X¡Y\[oX>]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[Y}X1[ a2Y\[ X~[oi ah[` b&t `Yc]\iTV[¬rwUW5]\«b[´luWAubUY\[mY\[oX i joWX~jobqa\]\U{[`b~jotku [ WX¯£YQ|^]^rwU l [{_ [XijWXjbRa\]\UUtkjoWkU]}X¯¨XjW aU(]\_ uXpR]^WkUWSi]\«b[ r2[ W aGtkU b Y\[XGtSj` z5j]^bXGt ` Yc]\ioX GahU ahm¾W]\j W G` bjtku [ W Wk[( ¦U{_ ur2U bifk[VU{uahuV`S[Y\`A[tk[ `&_J]pRpQub[Wah[VU` s MahU aRX~¯¾W]}X~mSt`]}X~o`k[Y\[oXi joWX~jbRa\]\U UrwubQ]\iU]^W XWk[:XjW a tkUXWkuX$Xj`XY\Ut b[oXXQ]\jW_¶ ` Wk[V`k[(Y\i jWS`k[tkjYc]^a\]\o`k[ah[ if WSjY\j l]\`S[ GW2pQU]^ahmki [XjW a Y\[XU` ahjbQ]^ahuoXi jWSi` bRb[W a\]\[(YcY\[XlU b~U W ah[X@_ [Y\UY\u l]}XQY\Ua\]\jWyU W a\]^acbR`XqaM`]OjW a _ jWWku` W iU _b[bulJY\[rw[WahU]^b[¡£`W/t fkuWSjrw«Wk[¡o`][s]}XRahU]^a_ u}£ GWxY\UrwUa\]\« b~[m¨Y\[X GahUaRX¯¾W]}XpQjW aO_|cU]cYcY\[ ` bX»tb~[ `z[_ [®b[ahU b_Xq`bY\I [ U tkjWy[ a¦Xq`bYQ| G` bjtk[$t `]}X`k[i [®WS¶ [XRa `O|c[ W K 6Le`A¶ ]cY}X&t bjtkjX~[ W ay_|cjpRp}bQ]^b ` W i U _b[~` bQ]\_]\`S[/£¬Y\U/ij jtku b~U a\]}joW½[ W½${T r{`Y^a\]^tkUbQah[WkU bQ]\UY\[?tkUbwY\N [ MOE *c " "!QP¨d R E *(SJT %
(29) $ $ U: Q+VMQPW%.X1¨M[Xyi joWX~jobqa\]hU XjW ayU ` ahjbQ]}X~uoX&` W]\`k[rw[Way_ UWAX?Y\[oXi UXj ½Y\[ ` bXU ia\]^z]^auXi jWSi [bRWk[ W a2Y\U¸b[ ifS[bifA[ Y$Z[]\^`_aOb cdD[7e7fRgih [kjlm[]\:nDfRjKm\:op`qrsgst]\ rsfRdu\DvHpxwygzr{\"\7wyg|j \}t~dDgih[7jHlmkj\ rs[]\:oKdDfRRdDkWW[]\"\Dfpl{[7jp\:oK7d rs[x 7^7R)g|j \}gz t7[m[7d(jgs[~dE[7jt7fpdD7[l n*t7gsrzgyl{rsEt7ffo7dD7l{gsfjA[kjlsdD[t7fRjt-pd*d([7jl*\mkj\:m[]\xoKdDfRd*W[]\l{[7r{\:vRpK[Jrz[R"~kc~R~k -{R7W\(pd?rz[\t7gydDt-pKgyl*\?g|jl{7RdD]\ Er2ws ys7" ]Hc~RukXk A ¡£¢"H y~¤u¥$c~y7 ~{7A[lArs[C¦" §]y,¨E Kk~ysR ¢"H y7ª© -{R7(«)wy[]\2lrs[t7fRj \DfRd(l{gip¬Rx]XvHpgm7fRjlsd{jfRj®\D[pKrs[7W[-jlrDw|[-n¯n*gst7]tkg|l{m[rsnDfRdDW[t7fRj \DfRd(l{g|rs[ mkj\?rs[Imuh[7r{fooK[7[7jlAmw°pj[±l{[7t-²jfRrsfRgs[Ijfp`h[krzrs[I7g{\?7p \u\DgmR7j \?rsImg|n¯n{p\}gzfRj³m[]\?dD]\(prylzkl¯\?kp'jgih[7kp£m[ rDw|[kj\}[7Xqrs[Em[]\ g|jmRp \(lzd(gs[7r{\ mRpB\}[7t-l{[-pdm[]\"\D[kWg{´{t7fRjmHpKt-l{[-pdu\ µ¤¶I·7W[®\kw|gsr{\t7fRjt7[7d(jK[-jl)rz[¸oKryp\?\DfpRh[7jlXm[]\?\D[kt-l{[-pKdu\m[²7plV[¸l{[7t7²jfRrsfRgs[r2wyf7q-¹u[t-l{gynAdD[7tk²K[kdDt~²[]\(l)or|p \¤pj[ dD77rsg{\DlVgsfRjgyjmRp \(lsd*gs[7rsrs[m[X²7pl{[)l{[7t7²jgst7gyl{AºrDwy7t-²K[krzrs[m[\j-l{gzfRj \E[-l\}fp\ErDwyg|oprV\}gsfRjm[]\J» lzkl¯\JvRpwipj[)h7d(gylz-qrz[ mkW7dDt-²[ªm[ªt7fRfo 7dDlVgsfRj[-l mwyg|jjf7h7l{gsf]j[~jlsdD[n*gyd*[]\ t7fRjt-pKd(dD[-jl{[]\. .
(30)
(31)
(32)
(33) t bu ijr{tu a\]^a\]vz5[oY^`X2t bu i(]}X~urw[Wahm]cYRX&jWa:tkj` bj[ ia\]cp_ [¸ijr:Yh[byY\[¸z ]\_[¸[sk]}XRahUW a [Wacb~[Y\U®b[ i fk[bi fk[U t tYc]\`ku[[ a Y\[X¦t b[r-]\«b[X@uahUtS[X@_`-t bj i[XXq`X@_|^]^W Wkjz5Ua\]\jWkmki ¶ [oXqah¯R£¯ _]^b[¡_ ¶ uahUYc]^b{` Wk[UbRa}]\i `Y\Ua\]\joW [W acb[¡Y\[Xwuac`k_ [Xw_ [?pQU]}XU5]cYc]^ahun[ aY\U¡i jr-ry[ bi]\UYc]}XUa\]\jW Y\_bQ]\if[a 95UXU ]\m "9À¨[WO|c[oXqaM`O|`Y^ahu bd]\[ ` b[rw[W ahmXUWAX_ j` ah[:Xj`X@YQ| ]cr{t `Y}XQ]}jW_ [oX UWSUY©X[Xu ijWkjr-]\o`k[X_ [ Y\Uwb[(Y\Ua\]\jWºij jtAubU a}]\jWS¯]^WWkjzU a\]\jWkmo`k[Y\[o X GahUaRX¾VW]}Xz5jW a [Wz ]}XU l [bY\[½i jWAX~jbRa\]^`r ijr"r2[ª` W¼j`a\]cY¡_[ªtkjYc]^a\]\o`k[ÂX~i(]\[W a\]cpR]\`S[½[a]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[YcY\[ tk[ bqrw[acahUWa½_[±buahU5Yc]^b*Y\U XR` t bu r2U a\]\[±ah[ i f WAjY\jlJ]\`A[7[aµi jor-r2[ bi]\UY\[ _ [Xgpq]^bQr2[oX UrwubQ]\iU]^WA[XXR` b¦Y\[¨b[XRah[_`:rwjWk_[ 9]Y\[X$ah[ s ah[XUrwubQ]\iU]^WXmUtkjWSU]}X[a[` bjtSu [WAX$b~[i j`zb[Wa_ [oX$b~uUYc]^ahuoX_]vz5[bX[X. i jobqb[oXqtkjoWk_ UWaº£Â_[X·XhXRah«r2[oX´WkU a\]\jWkU ` s _|c]^W Wkjz5Ua\]hjW Xqtkui]cpR]\`k[Xm>`k[Y\o`k[XxpQU]^aQX XRa 9Yc]}X~uoX ijWki [ bRWkUW aeY\[oXÂtkU bqah[ WkU]^b[oX*]cr:tYc]\`AuXm´Y\U XRacbR`kiac`b~[ [aeY\[X;r2j _UYc]^ahuX _ [ pQjWki a\]\jW Wk[rw[W aM[aM_ [pR]^WkU Wki [rw[W a tk[ bdrw[acah[Wa_ [r"]\[` si [ bRWk[b@Y\Updjobdrw[V_|cjb~lUW]}XUah]\jW tkU bqa\]\i `Yc]\«b[`k[ijWXRa\]^ac`k[$Y\[ijWXjbRa\]^` r TV[oX` W]cz5[bX~]^ahuX[a®_ [XVY\U AjbU ahj]^b[Xt `Yc]\iX{_[b~[ifk[bi fk[tk[`z5[W a
(34)
(35) •¥acb [-r2[r{ b[X_`ºijWXjbRa\]^`rGÀ[acah[wtSUbRa\]\i]^tkU a}]\joWºU iU _ u r-]\`k[y[XRajYc]\l U ahj]^b[ _ U WXY\[oX t bj [ aRXV[ ` bjtku [ WX ¦YcY\[ [oXqaacb«Xi j` bU W ah[&U` s GahUaRX¯¾W]}Xj ¡b[ifk[ b~ifS[X]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[YcY\[&[a U iU _ u r-]\`k[ X~jWanacb«oX ]cr: bQ]\`Su [X0 ¦YcY\[ b[XRa[ ahj` ah[(pdjJ]}X´rwUb~l]^WkUY\[*U ` U tkjW yY^`X pQjWk_ U r2[WahUY\[rw[W ahmn` W iojWAX~jbRa\]^`r ]cr-tYc]\`S[ U ` X[]^W _|^` Wk[Ár2¥rw[ ]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[ _ [oX i joWki` bRb[WaRX_]^b[ iaRXo`]S` W5]}XX[W aAY\[` bXGb[XX~j`b~i[XGtkj` bOb~uUYc]}X[b_[XGb[ i fk[bifS[X_ [¨kUoX~[[a UttYc]\`ku[X@_ UWXY\[iU _b[_ [®t bj [ aRX_[Y\jWlVah[bQr2[J ¦[X@U i a\]vz]^ahuX@_`yijWXjbRa\]^`rÂtk[ `z[ WSa _ jWSi-_ utSUXX~[ b$Y\[XRacbQ]\iah[-i U_b[-_ [:Y\U:b[ i fk[bi fk[2_ [kUoX~[-[ a@i jWki[bRWk[ bYQ|cUt tYc]\iU]cYc]^ahu2_ [oX buXR`Y^ahUaRXGtSj` b¦Y\[_ u z[(Y\jt tk[rw[W a¤_ [$p}` ac` bXGt bj _`]^aRXG b[z5[ahU Y\[X[ a ijr"r2[ b~i(]\UYc]}XUY\[X ¦[oX{i joWX~jobqa\]\U?X jW a®_]cpRpdu b[W aRX{_[oX J"^E {F7So(E
(36) yo`]$ijWXd]}XRah[Wa[ W¸YhU •ibuUa\
(37) ]\jW¬ _|` Wk[ Wkj` zk[(YcY\[?[ W acb[t bQ]}X[( }Y}X"_]cpRpQ«b[W a_ [oI X
(38) 2 # F! (So
(39) # P¨ Q R E *(SJ %
(40) $ $ £PE `] i joWki [ bqWS[W ak` WA[b[ifk[ b~i fk[®t5Y^`X¦pQjWk_ Urw[W ahU(Y\[ m[a¤_ [AX % "$# (G @? ©
(41) »
(42) y`]XjW a®_ [Xtb~j~[aRX{_ [&ij` bRaah[bRr2[acb«oX{i]^Y\uoX-XR` bVYQ|cUz5UY_ [Xtb~ji [XXR`X _|^]^W WkjozkUa\]\jW}Y\_obd]\i f[? a 95UXU ]\? m ""9J¦ÀjWki b«ah[rw[Wahm»` Wi jWXjbQa\]^`Sr tk[` ab[ ij`zbQ]cb ` Wk[2XqacbR`ki ac` b[acb«X_]cpRpQub[Wah[X~[ Y\joW>YQ| ]^WS_`XRacb~]\[2[aY\[XhXRah«r2[WAU a\]\jWkUY_|^]^W WAjz5Ua\]\jW ¦[oX i joWX~jobqa\]\U¨ah[(Y}X`k [ <?>@%yX~jWa9kUoX~uoXXq` bO` Wk[XqacbR`ki ac` b[_ u i[W acbUYc]}Xu [U ` X[]^Ww_ [$Y\U `S[YcY\[ _]cpRpQub[Wah[Xu o`]^tk[X@_ [¨acbj]}Xpq]^bQr2[oX[W2rwj [WWk[®rw«Wk[Wa _ [oX»t bj [ aRX& %®bQ]^WA_Y\[m 'º)j ([bhm [(a 9]cYvz5[bQr2U Wkm K" L RY [ Wy[XRaO_ [®rw¥rw[®tkj`bY\[X@i joWX~jobqa\]\UGUtkjoWkU]}XT[®ah[YcY\[oX¨XRacbR`kiac`b~[oX XjW a²l u bu [X¿U _r"]^W]}XqacbU a\]vz5[r2[Wa*tkUb ` W X[ i b~u ahUbQ]\Ua i jr-r{` W % ;~ 7 E
(43) ª *c ?R ~? !\ c ;d GW¡b[ zU Wkifk[m»Y\[oXVijWXjbRa\]\U UrwubQ]hi U(]^WXVjoW a` Wk[&XqacbR`ki ac` b[ i [ W acbUYc]}Xu [yUz5[ i luWku b~U(Y\[ry[Wa$` Wk[ ` W]^ahu>_ [ b~[ifk[ bifk[>i jr"r:`Wk[>U` s¬_]cpRpQub[W aRXVrw[r:b~[oX ¦¦[ a Stk[>_ [ XRacbq`Siac` b[2ifkjJ]}Xd]]^WpRY^`k[ Xq` b®Y\U_J]cpqp}`XQ]\jW¢_ [-YQ|^]^Wp~jbRrwUa\]\jW¢[W acb[-Y\[Xr2[r{ b[XrwU]}XU`AXX~] XR` b¦Y\[_ [lobu_ [i jWpR]\U Wki [U ii jb_ u¨tkU b¦Y\[XGrw[r" b[XU`wi joWX~jobqa\]^`r& MUVi jW acbQ]^ `a\]\jW_ [oXr2[r{ b[X •U`ij + *-,.
(44) 0/12.34,,*-55.34
(45) 67*-8 WXjbRa\]^`Sr¼X(|cjtk« b[:l u WkubU(Y\[r2[ W atAU bY\[z[ b X[rw[W a_[pdjoWk_SX_ [oXda\]^WkuoX£Y\Ub[ ifS[b~i fk[ i jor-r:`Wk[1[ a{£¡YQ|cU _r-]^W5]}XqacbUa\]hjWkm¨rwU]}XyU`XXQ]tAUb2Y\U?r"]}X~[1£º_]}XqtSjSXd]^a\]\joWZ_ [?tk[ b XjW Wk[(Y}X 9 Z[t7`\Jm[ :R» ¶I;» «0<,[\(l \2pKdtk[)o fRgsjllzd=\gsjRl{7dD[\u\Dkjl(« [XtfRj\}fRd(l{gipK -l{Xt7fRje-p[7j?>&@BA mwipj[)o7d¯l¯oKfpd t7fRjl{dD[7t77d(dD[-d)rs mg|WgyjRplsgsfRj®m[]\.oK7d¯l*\¤7W-dDgst7]gyj[]\\(pd)rs[W7d(t7² Wfjmgy]r"m[\A\}[7Wg{´¯t7fRjmRpKtlV[pdu\X[lV m w|kpRlzdD[oKkd{l{ oKfpdX[-jdDDC[7dXrDwi-h]jt7[l{[7t7²jKfRrsfRgzvHpK[E¹ukoKfj7g{\D[?m7j \.pj±mfRW7gyj[W²7pRl{[7W[-jl \¯lsdD-l{7gsvRp[ [-j±W-l{gE=-dD[ m[ \}7t-pdDgil{ jklzgsfRj7rs[GFHJdDg|jmrs[CK ¶IfJIX[7dC[-lK:gsrih[7dD7j >&@B@ KL :Ro[7jt7[-dA[l6HdDgyjKmRrs[C5>&@@BMJN t7[lsg|lsdD[]"gsrEC-l{n(gzj7jt7Cº ²kpl{[-pdm[ JO o7drs[Em-o7d¯lV[kW[-jl 7~dDgst7g|jm[rsªm-n*[7j \D[H. . . .
(46)
(47)
(48)
(49) `kU(Yc]cpR]\uX[W b[ i fk[bi fk[TV[Xi joW acbUaRX_ [nYc]\i[WAi [ºj`e_ [oX&Ui i job~_Xah[if W]\o`k[X2tk[`z5[W a ]^W ah[ bqz5[W5]vbY\jbX~o`O|^]cYX|cU l ]^a@_ [:r2[ acacb[-_UWXY\[tkUW]\[ bijr"r:` W_[XijWWkU]}XXUWki[Xjo`1_ [oX XUz5j]^bX~¯RpdU(]^b[tb~jot b[X£¨` Wk[$pR]^bRr2[J ¦UtkU bRa\]}i(]^tkUa\]\jW_ [oXU`aRjbQ]^ahuoXt ` Yc]\o`k[XU`>X[]cW_`i jWXjbRa\]^`r*WO|c[XRaGtkUoX` Wk[VijWk_]ca\]\jW Wkui [XXU]^b[wrw¥r2[ XQ]\mWkj`XYQ|cUzjWAXz`SmMYQ|^]^Wki(]^ahUah]\jW>t ` Yc]\`S[U$j`ku:` W1lJb~U Wk_ b~JY\[ _ U WX YQ|curw[bl [Wki[ _[X ijWXjbRa\]\U·MU tkUbRa\]\i(]^tkUa\]hjW t` Yc]\`k[ X(|cjtk« b[ z ]\U YQ|vjiacbj]²_ [ pR]^WkUWSi [r[W aRX}pQjWk_Xtkj` bY\Ub[ifk[ b~i fk[ mU acacbQ]^ `a\]\jW_|cUYcY\j iUa\]\jWX[aM_ [Sj` bX~[oX~m[ ahi j` _ [ r-]}X[¡£>_]}XRtkjSXQ]^a\]\jW _|^]^Wp}bUXRacbq`Siac` b[X|cU ` aRjobd]^ahu t ` 5Yc]\`k[>[sk[ b~i[?U(Y\jb XV` W¬_bj]^a_[ i joW acbY\[·Xq` b¢YQ|vUia\]cz ]^ahuZ_` i jWXjbRa\]^`r&{À[tk[WS_ UW ahm XQ] Y\U´t bUa\]\o`k[Zi jWXjbRa\]\UY\[ZUeuahu XRa\]^r:`Y\u[ tkU be_ [oXªrw[XR`b~[oXe_ [ÂtkjYc]^a\]\`A[oXe£ Y\U*pQj]}X ah[ i f WkjY\j lJ]\`k[ m¡]^Wk_o`XdacbQ]\[YcY\[ [a i joWki` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[ mVY\[X>pR]^bRr2[oX1X~[ X~joW a-bUt]\_[r2[W aX~U(]}Xd]\[oX¡_[´i[rwj _ [xi j jotkubUa\]cp tSj`b jbQlUW]}X[bY\[ ` bb[oifS[bifk[J4 ^b~jJ]}XuY\ury[ W aRXz ]\[ WW[ W a ahur2j]\loWk[b_S[Vi[acah[VjbQ]\[W ahU a\]\jW 4 ^¦j` a _|cUSjb_ m]cY®Ut tkU bUa`S[Y\U t bUa\]\`S[¢X¶ [oXqau ah[Wk_o`k[?£>_|cU`acb~[oX{]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[X"`k[&Y\[X2X[r"]\¯ i joWk_`ki ah[` bXm-[W½tkU bRa\]\i`Yc]\[ bº_ UWAX¡Y\[X]^Wk_`XRacbd]h[X¢j ;YQ|^]^W ah[bQz[ W a\]\jW;t ` Yc]\o`k[ [XQat5Y^`X rwUb~lJ]^WkU(Y}[JR GWXq`5]^ah[ mGi[X~joW aY\[XpR]^bdrw[X®`]¨XjWa@_ uXjbQr2U(]}X£:YQ|^]cW]^a\]\Ua\]cz["_ [2i [Xt bj [aRX GWpR]^WkmG[(YcY\[X[ W>pR]^WkUWki[W aY\UtSUbRaY\UtY^`X]^r:tkjobdahUWah[-[al«b[W a@[(YcY\[X¯rw¥ry[XY\[X¨buoXq`Y^ahU aRX _ [$Y\Ui j jotkubUa\]\joW . . . BDL0@GN. H ASOHKVG@ XR@GN VWEK>N EKL I$BOH,XAH >AN SO@GN N%I%L HI GMQBO@GN XR@?L @WVG\R@5L V5\@CXR@WN. j` b®i jor:t b[ Wk_b[:Y\[t fSuWkjrw«Wk[-_[XijWXjbRa\]\U m]cY[oXqa¦Wkui [XXU]^b[-_ [r2[ acacb[-[Wu z ]\_ [ Wkio[ ` Wi [bRahU(]^W WAjr: b[{_ [-iUbU i ahubQ]}Xqa\]\`k[oX_ [XjW[s tSubQ]^r2[WahUa\]\jWi jWkib« ah[ m9ah[YcY\[X®`k[-X~jW Ur{tY\[ ` bm9Y\[:_ [ lobuV_¶ ]cr:tY\]\i U a\]\jW_ [XpR]^bdrw[X@Y}jbX_ [:XUr"]RX~[V[ T W 3`zJb[ m[aX[Xt bQ]^Wki]^tSU` s j [ia\]cp~X 6$W¸Wk[ tk[`aVo`k[?ijWXdahU ah[bVahj`aV_¶ Ukjb_1Y}¶ ]vr{tkjbRahUWki[?i b~jJ]}XXUW ah[_ [?i[acah[?pQjbQry[ _ ¶ jb~lUW]}XUa\]\jW _ [>Y\Ub[ ifS[bifk[³Y\[X-pR]^bQr2[oX2jWa_ [tY^`AX2[W/t5Y^`X:b[ ij` bX2£>Y\Ut bUa\]\`S[ i joWX~jobqa\]\U(Y\[S]^WXQ]\m 9Q '1 ^ À gU-u ahu:`AU(Yc]cpq]\uVtkUbYQ|cU _r"]vW5]}XqacbUa\]\joWÀYc]^W ahjoW>_ |c[sk[r{tY\[ £:XR`]^zb[{[Wyr2U a\]\«b[V_ [Vioj jtSubUa\]\jW_ [oXqa\]cWku[V£:Ui ibj acb[Y\UVijr{tku a\]^a\]vz]^ahuah[if WSjY\j l]\`S[ Ga[pRpQ[ i a\]vz5[rw[W ahmU`s GahU aRX~¯¾VW]}XmY\[oX"i jWXjbRa}]\U¡X~[¡XjW ar{`Y^a\]^tYc]\uXVWkjoWZX~[ `Y\[r2[ W aU` X[]^Wy_ [YQ|^]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[_ [oX¨X[r"]\¯Ri jWk_o`kiah[ ` bX~mSrwU]}X@U`XXQ] _ UWX@_|cU`acb~[oX]^WS_`XRacbd]\[oX~m ah[YcY\[oX`S[ Y\[-X~[iah[`b_ [X®U` ahjrwj]cY\[X®uY\[iacbQ]\`k[oX~m j`[WSiojb[:_ [VYQ|cU u b~joWkU` a\]h`k[JSY\_bQ]\if[a 95UXU ] ""9J¦UzU Wki [ W atkj`?. b K"{Y\[if5]cpqp}b[_ [ K9{iojWXjbRa\]\UoT[t5Y^`X~mkjWwi jWXRahUah[`k[Y\UtSUbda _`pq]^WSUWki[rw[W a$t ` 5Yc]\i?_ U WX{Y\[X"i joWX~jobqa\]\U>U`s MahU aRXV¾W]}X"[aU ` UtSjW X¶ Urw[W `5]}X~[>_ [ rwUW]\« b~[-XQ]loW]cpR]\i U a\]vzk[V% 9U 5U ]ckU b~Um ""8JdmU(Y\jb X`k[YQ|c[WklU l[r2[ W a_ [oXpR]^bdrw[Xr2[r{ b[X b[t buoX~[ W ah[Y\UV`kUoXd]ahjahUYc]^ahuV_o``k_l[aQ ¦[oXi jW XjbRa\]\U:X~joW a¦_[tY^`X[ Wt5Y^`Xr"]}X[N W 3®`zb[ £ YQ|^]^W]^a\]\Ua\]^z5[&_ [oXVpR]^bdrw[X{[(YcY\[X¯rw¥r2[oX G¦[&iUX"_ [ Y\U]\j¯]^WS_`XRacbd]\[&[oXqaXR` b{i[tkj]^W aacb«X tkU bdY\U W aQTV[ t `]}X2Y\[XyU W Wku[X K8 m_ [XyijWXjbRa\]\Unu r2[ b~l[W a"X~jo`X2YQ|^]vr{t `Y}XQ]\jW _ [nlobUWk_ [oX pR]^bRr2[oX*t fkUbQryU i[` a\]\o`k[X²U(Y\jbX rw¥ry[ `k[mª_[t `]}X Y\[ _ u ` a _ [X²U W Wku [oX 8K8 m Y\[ _ u z[(Y\jttk[r2[ W aµ_ [7YQ|^]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[ 5]\jah[ i f Wkj Y\j l]h`k[7u ahU]^aZkUoXu XR` b*tY^`XQ]\[`bX z5U l`k[oX _|cU ii jb_SX¡t5Y^`X¡acbU _]^ah]\jW Wk[(Y}X~m2_ [´a StS[ k]^tkU bRaR[ WkUbQ]\UYD '¸U ` tk[ bqac`5]}X~ m "*UZ[a 5{¦[ t b[r"]\[bijWXjbRa\]^`Sr _[w]\jah[if WSjY\j l]\[m #£(So
(50) #
(51) CcJ !\ #P
(52) *(5m»U2u ahui bu u U`7 s MahU aRX~¯¾W]}X2[ W L 9jW/` at bQ]^Wi(]^tkUYuahU(]^aV_ [ ;qbUXX~[r{Y\[ b2Y\[X{b~[oXXj` bi[X-tkj`b [stY\jb[bY\U_J]vz5[bXQ]^ahuryjY\u i `Y\U]^b[[aOY\[X@_ u ij`zk[bRah[X@_ U WXY\Urwu _J]\i Uah]\jWyijr:]^WSUahj]cb[ ÀjWk_`]^atkUU b x P mY\[oX/r2[r{ b[X _ [ #
(53) CP ;~u i fkUW5l [ b~joWSa¢Y\[` bX/t bj _`]^aRXm. . . . . |R- J||7 s 7¥7hfRrypK[ > m[7t7[7¤q[7d > @@. . A.
(54)
(55)
(56)
(57) WkjbRrwUYc]RX~[ bjW a"Y\[` bX ah[oXqaRX[a{tkU bqahU l[bjWa-Y\[Xi j aRX>_ [¸Y\[ ` bX acbUzU ` sµi jr-r-` WAX $M[ i joWX~jobqa\]^`r Y\[?tY^` Xyi joW W ` [XdaY\[&%J @ !h5 &% =@? ©
(58) $ }Yb[ lbj` tS[ 9 pR]^bRr2[oX»t fAU bdrwU i [ ` a\]\`k[oXo`]GXjW aOijWki ` bRb~[ W ah[X_ UWXY\[_jrwU]^WS[_ [oX»acfku bUt]\[oXl uW5]\`k[X ¦[oXtSUbRah[WkU(]^b[XjW a_u i]\_u:_ [j]^Wk_ob~[VY\[`bX[(pqpQjbRaRX_ U WXY\Ub[ i fk[bi fk[wXR` bY\, [ 9K}Tg[ 6848 ifS[bifk[ ` bX[W z]^bjWX~joW ai joWki [ bqWSuXQUpR]^W>_|cUi i u(Y\ub[bY\[oX_ u ij` z5[bRah[X_ U WXY\[XacfkubU t]\[X i jor:]^WSUahj]^b[X }YªX[r{Y\[ uz ]\_[W a `k[ÁYQ|cj([ i a\]cpªt bQ]^Wki(]^tkUY _` i joWX~jobqa\]^`r [oXqa Y\U i jor:]^WSU ]}X~jW¢_ [oX_]cpRpdu b[W aRX$buXR`Y^ahUaRX_[-${T- GW ""9.m @
(59) " VU2uY\U kjbu-Y}' [ @
(60) 7 P
(61) *c G¿tSj` b2Y\[?acbU]^ah[ry[ W a{_[Xy_ jWWku [oX?XR` b2Y\[¡luWAjr2[J hY:X[r-Y\[¡]vr{tkjbRahU W a{_[ t bu i(]}X~[ b`k[mi jr-rw[_ UWAX¦Y\[X_ [ ` s2iUXGt bui u _[W aRXmi [i jWAX~jbRa\]^` rg_[5]\jah[ i f WkjY\j lJ]\[[oXqa ]^W]^a\]\u$tkUb@_ [lbUWS_ [XpR]^bqrw[X¦t fkUbRrwU io[ ` a\]\`k[oX»AuWSupR]\i]\U W aO_ [®b[(Y\Ua\]\jWX¦t bQ]^z]cY\u l]\u[X@[W acb[ [YcY\[oX_`&pQU]^a»_ [:ij jtku bUa\]\jWX]cY\Uahu bUY\[X®UW ahu bQ]}[ ` b[X9À[acah[{i U b~Uiahu bd]}XRa\]\`k[-X[r:Yh[{U`XXd] t buX[Wah[V_ UWX@Y\[Vi jWXjbRa\]^` r²[ Wkl U lutkUb >G { I!u^
(62) $ ""G;£tSUbRa\]^b_ [:XjWU ii jb_2_ [ i jjtkubU a\]\jW U z[o i 2 GO.
(63) GV >k c(
(64) o2 j` bxpQjbRrw[bxY\[;i jWXjbRa\]^`r YQ|vUi ijb_ ]cY\U ahubUYG]^W5]^a\]\UY¦U{uahu{j` z5[bRa£{_|cU` acb[oXtSUbRah[WkU(]vb[oX$WkjoahUr-rw[W a x
(65) I¤>k ^ @?!\ E>K#E { ! ³o @ "R G oJ *c$ "!c
(66) dm$r2U(]}X Y\[oXWSj`z5[ U ` se[Wacb~U W aRX>_ jJ]vz5[W a tkU[b_[X_bj]^aRXGtkjo` bU ii u_ [b£$Y\USUX[_[_jW W5u [X_ [
(67) > À[X¢`k[Y\o`k[X¢i UXm-_ [´rw¥r2[Z`S¶ ` Wk[´]cr:tSjbRahUW ah[´Yc]^acahubU ac` b[ [r:t5]^bd]\o`k[·Xq` b¢io[ acfk« r2[m¤t bu i(]}X~[ W aY\[Xjo [ i a\]cp X®_`i joWX~jobqa\]^`r9¦jbX`k[-_[X¨tb~j~[aRX$]^WWkjzU ah[` bX_[:Y\jWkl ah[bRrw[:X~joW a¦[ W[`km9]cY¦X~¶ U l ]^aM_ [tk[bQr2[ acacb[` Wk[bUah]\jWkU(Yc]}X~U a\]\jW_ [Y\Ub[ ifS[bifk[V[ W2b~uUYc]}XUW a Y\[X¢i jr{]^WkU ]}XjWX>Wku i[XX~U(]^b[X1_[X¡rwj [W Xm-_ [oX1i joW WkU]}XXUWki[X1[ a_ [X¢i jr:tSuah[WSi [Xm rw¥r2[ Xd] i [oX i jr-5]^WkU]}XjWX b[`5]\«b[W a `Wk[ i jjtkubU a\]\jW uacbj]^a[ [W acb[ pR]^bdrw[X i joWki` bRb[Wah[X ^¦j` ah[pQj]}Xm XQ] jW X[ tY\U i[ _ UWX ` Wk[ tS[bXdtk[ia\]cz[ f5]}XqajbQ]\`k[ _` _ u z[(Y\jttk[r2[ W a¿_ [ WSj`z[(YcY\[X ]^Wk_`XRacbQ]\[X AUXu [oX Xq`b _ [ Wkj`z5[ U`s tkU b~U_]\lr2[oX ah[ i f WkjY\j lJ]\`k[oX ]cY¦UttkUbUa@U `XXQ]¦`S[:Y\[:ijWXjbda\]^`rÁWO|c[XRaGtkUoX$Y\UVpQjbdrw[:ijjtkubU a\]vz5[:o`9] U ii jr{tkU lWS[ Y\[X²t b[r-]\« b~[oX _u ioj`z5[bRah[X ah[oif WSjY\jl ]\`S[X¼[agY\[X t bur-]}X X[X¼_|` WA[ jbQlUW]}XUa\]\jW ]^WS_`XRacbd]\[(YcY\[0 6®bmxi |c[XRae_ U WXgi [acah[Át fkUoX~[ `k[ Y\[X½b[lobj` tk[r[W aRXg[a UXXj i]\U a\]\jWX_[b[XX~j`b~i[X®hf`SrwU]^WS[XmpR]^WkUWki(]\«b[X[ a¦r2U ahubQ]\[YcY\[oXdX~joW a@Ut bQ]\jbQ]¦Y\[X¨t5Y^`X ]^r{tkjbRahUW aRXG¦[X{ijWXjbRa\]\U&Ut tSUbU]}X X[Wa¨tY^`aha_UWX{_[Xt fSUX[X{_ [b[ r-]}X[&[W`k[oXqa\]\jW _ [oXacbU[ i ahj]^b[Xah[if WSjY\j l]\`S[X`5]»X[r-Y\U(]\[W au ahUYc]\[oX£tkU bqa\]^b_`2Wkj`z5[ U`2tkU bU _]\lrw[ ]^WXQ]\mtkj` b Y\[XeX~[r"]\¯Ri jWA_`Siah[`bXm?Y\[oXZi joWXjbRa\]\U WO|cjWantSUX·X[bQz ]º_ [ Xq` ttkjbRaU` s ]^W WkjozU a\]}jWAXrwU[ ` b[X¡XR` bY\[X>i(]^b~i `]^aQX&]^W ahu lob~uXyr2U(]}X¡X~joW a-]^Wah[ bdz5[W `Xy]\[WZtY^`XyahUb_ m Y\jbX`k[Y\Ut b[XXQ]\jWiojWki`bqb[ W a\]\[YcY\[»U tjoWkU]}X[:X|c[XRa¦U zubu[acb~jot pQjbRah[-Xq`bY\[XrwUbifSuX_ [ t bj _`5]^aRXGkUXuXXR` b¦Y\[oXi]^bi`]^aRX¦]^Wahulob~uoXRjb_]^WkUa[`bXmtkUb»[sk[ r:tY\[( T¶ j 2Yh¶ ]^Wah[bRbj5lUa\]\joW&Xq`5]vz5UW ah[³ `O|c[XQah¯qi[`5]pdU(]^aO`O|c£®`W-r2jrw[W aO_jW Wku_ UWX¦` WA[ ]^Wk_`AXqacbQ]\[:f]\lf>ah[oif¢`]@U Uacah[(]^W a`Wk[:b[Y\U a\]vz5[t fkUoX~[2_ [-r2U ac` bQ]^ahu mGY\[XpR]^bdrw[XRU ]\_ u[Xj` WkjW>tkU bY\[X$tkjo` zkj]^bX$t ` 5Yc]\iXQjW ab~[i j`bXU ` sºijWXjbRa\]\U mUY\jbX$rw¥r2[2`S[wY\[oXrwUbi fkuX _ [?t bj _`5]^aRXy[s]}XRah[W a[a`k[1io[X2pR]^bdrw[X&XjW a"ijWki ` bRb~[ W ah[X ?` zJ` _ [¡Y\Utb~Ua\]\o`k[ m$Y\[ i joWX~jobqa\]^`r X[r{Y\[&UzjJ]^b` Wk[t5Y\U i [&[ a¨`WnbY\[5]\[W1t bu i(]}X{£j`k[ b{_ U WXVY\[X"XqacbUahu(l]\[oX i joWki` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[X¬_ [X/pR]^bQr2[oXx[a¢U·pQjbRa\]\jbQ]¡_ U WX/Y\¶ uzjY^`a\]\jW¼_ [X/]^WS_`XRacbd]\[oXx_ [ªfkU ` ah[ ah[ i f WkjY\j lJ]\[9T[X®uY\urw[W aRX_ [Vb~u tkjWX [-£Wkjacb[-]^W ah[ bqbj lUa\]\jW&tk[ `zk[W a@¥ acb~[Vacbj`z5uX_UW X ` Wk[[Wko`k¥ah[$b~ui [ W ah[r2[WSu [U ` t b«X@_ [ 8-i jWAXjbRa\]\UMU tkjWkU(]}X% 9U 5U ]ckUbUm "8 À[acah[ [WS`k¥ah[ rwjW acb[ [pRpQ[ i a\]vz5[r2[Wa;`k[7Y\[oX pq]^bRrw[X²ijªW jJ]vz5[W aµY\[` bgtkUbRa\]\i]^tSUa\]\jW U` R ¡R` >"-hdDg|r0>D@B@M. @.
(68)
(69)
(70)
(71) i joWX~jobqa\]^`r Uz5UW a-ahjo` ayi jr-r[` W½rwj [ Wg_|Ui i«X£´_o`*XUzj]^bijr:tY\ur[W ahU(]^b~[C}Y UttkUbUa@`S[:Y\U:${T*r2[ Wku [-[ Wiojr-r:`W&WO|c[XRatkUoXXR` XRa\]^ac`kUY\["£:Y\U:${T*]cW ah[bRWk[JS` i joW acbU]^b[ m$YQ|c[WlU l[ry[W a_|` Wk[¡pR]^bdrw[¢rw[r- b[¬X|cU ii jr-tSU lWk[1_|` W ]^Wz[oXqa\]}XX~[rw[W a[W :T ]^W ah[ bqWS[ t5Y^`X1u Y\[z5uu i(]^t bj `k[r[W ahm:` Wk[ uzU(Y^`kUa\]\jW _`½t b j [a 9K 'n ^À }G]^W 4m ^¦[ [i [[a ]^WkUWSm K""GrwjWacb~[`S[®Y\[oXGkuWku(pq]\i[XGa\]^buX_[®Y\U¨b[ i fk[bi fk[i j jtSubUah]vz5[ U`xX[]^W_`¬i jWXjbRa\]^`r _ utk[ Wk_ [ W aU`AXXQ]$_[Y\U WkUac`b~[&[ a_`ºzjY^`rw[?_A| ]^Wz5[XRa\]}XX [r2[ W aRX UYcY\jo`kuX£VY\U${T½t bjt b[:£VY\UVpq]^bQr2[JR }YGpQU ` a_ jWki{`k[VY\UpR]^bQr2[{Uacah[(]loWk[` W>i[bRahU]^WX~[ `]Y _ [V${T tkjo` b¨tSj`zj]^ba\]^b[ b¨tkU bRa\]¦_ [VYQ|vUoi a\]vz]^ahu-_`i jWAX~jbRa\]^`r9À[XbuXd`5Y^ahUaRX[r:t5]^bd]\`k[oX ]cYcY^`XRacb[W aY\Uyi jr:t5Y\ury[W ahU bQ]^ahu [Wacb~[ :T²]^W ah[bQWk[ [ a$:T¼[s ah[ bRWk[ ¯[ W¡tkU bqa\]\i `Yc]h[b[W ah[bRrw[X_¶ ]^Wz5[XRa}]}XX[r2[ W aRX[a¤_ [i jW WSU]}XX~UWki[X¯¦[aAY\U¨Wku i[XXd]^ahu_ [$Y\[Xij jb_ jWWk[bGtSUb_ [oX pQjbRr2[oX>_¶ jbl U W]}XUa\]\jW;XRtku i(]cpq]\o`k[X }Y}X Wk[1pQj`bqW5]}XX[W ahmi [ tk[Wk_UW ahm`A¶ ` Wk[º[s t5Yc]\i Uah]\jW tkU bqa\]\[(YcY\[¡_ [?Y\¶ [WklU l[r2[ W a_ [X"pR]^bdrw[X2_U WX-Y\U?t bUa\]\o`k[¡i joWX~jobqa\]\U(Y\[T[tY^`Xmahj`j` bX _ ¶ Ut b«X 9U kU ]^kUbU K""8QmS]cY¦X[r:Y\[ bU]^aO`k[Y\UtSUbRa\]\i]^tkU a\]\jWyU `yi jWXjbRa\]^`rÁXj]^aMi jªW `k[ i jor-r2[¨` WS[®z5ubQ]^ahUY\[XRacbUahu lJ]\[o`]Stk[ bdrw[a¤_|c[W a\b[t b[WS_b[_[WSj` z5[YcY\[XUia\]cz ]^ahuoX[a¤i [[W bu _`5]}X~U W aGY\[oXioj aRX_ [b[ifk[ b~i fk[X¦U:_J]vz5[bXQ]cpq]hi U a\]\jW_ [X@Yc]lWS[X_ [t bj _`5]^aRX$_[Y\Upq]cbdrw[ tk[ ` aX|cUt t`J[bXq`bY\Ub[ i fk[bifS[Vi jW jJ]vW ah[rw[WAu [VU `?X[]^W_`ijWXjbRa\]^`Srwm`]ah[WS_U(Y\jbX £ X(|cu(Y\j]clWS[b_ [-Y\U:b[ i fk[bifS[_["SUX[[ a£X[:bQUtt bj ifk[ b_ [oXUt tYc]\iUa\]\jWAX[W>ah[bRr2[oX_ [ t bj _`5]^aRX-pR]^WkUY}X ¦[X"pq]^bRrw[X-z ]}X[bU(]\[W aU]^WAXd]$`W U ii «X{tY^`Xw_]^b[ iaU ` s/buXR`Y^ahUaRXw_ [?Y\U b[ i fk[bifS[[atS[bi [zJbU ]\[W atY^`AXiY\U(]^b~[rw[Wa Y\[X»AuWSupR]\i [oX_ [Y\[` bb[ ifS[bifk[i jW(j]^Wah[ À[ a Stk[²_|cuzjJY^` a\]\jW X|cU i ijr-tkU loWk[Á_|cU(]cYcY\[` bX;_|` WS[ acbUWXQpQjbdrwUa\]\joW _ [Xeb~[(Y\Ua\]\jWAX½_[ i jjtkubU a\]\jWXfkjbQ]c§ojWahUY\[X[W1b[Y\U a\]\jWX_ [ ij jtkubU a\]\jWXz5[bRa\]\i U(Y\[XGÀ[X[ ijWk_¡u(Y\ur2[ WSa rw[aº[ W uz]\_S[ Wki [½Y\¶ U`acb~[;i U bU iahu bQ]}Xqa\]\`S[Â_ [X i jWAX~jbRa\]\U³ i [(YcY\[Â_ ¶ ¥ acb[µ` WS[ pQjbQr2[;_ [ i jjtkubU a\]\jWxYc]\u [¡U ` s/t bj i[XXq`Xw_ [?r2U bifkuJU¡_uah[bRr"]^WkUa\]hjW _ [i [Xwi U b~Uiahu bd]}XRa\]\`k[oX i joWkib«ah[oX:Wkjo`X-]^Wki(]^ah[¡£¡`S[XRa\]\jW Wk[ b-Y\[oX2UWSUY MX[Xw[s]}XRahUWah[X2U(pR]^W _ [?zj]^bw_ U WX2`S[YcY\[ rw[XR` b[Á[YcYh[XepQj` bRW]}XX~[ W a/` Wk[²[stYc]\iUa\]\jW _[ YQ|vu r2[ b~l[Wki [m¸_ [ Y\U t bU a\]\`k[Á[ a _ [ YQ|cuz5jY^` a\]hjWw_ [XijWXjbRa\]\U #\P}EF 5H 9NJFdPRIE. . NIEGNJLHH E F~PZ5". EGFH5. ". &»H SF~P)GL. N I9IA&25H S FQP1-3. oF. ". &¦HJIN L. ¦[oX buXR`Y^ahUaQX>_ [oX acbUzU ` sµ[r:t]^bQ]\`S[X&Y\[oX tYc`Xyb~ui [ W aRX Wkj`AX ryjW acb[ W a2_jWki/`k[¸Y\[oX pR]^bRr2[oX¦pdjobdrw[Wa _ [oXi jWAX~jbRa\]\U_ U WXG` Wwi jW ah[ s ah[_[rwUac`bd]^ahu¨ah[if WkjJY}j lJ]\`k[_ [X¦]^WS_`XRacbd]\[oX [a¤`k[$Y\[XGtb~j~[aRX¦r2[ WkuX_ U WX¦Y\[i U_b[_ [i [ acah[XRacbR`kiac` b[i jjtkubU a\]vz5[¨tk[`z5[W a¤u lUY\[rw[W a Uz5j]^b` Wk[y_]cr2[ WX~]\jWºijWki ` bRb~[ W a\]\[YcY\[-tY^`X]vr"r2u_]\Uah[JGÀ[X_ [` snuY\urw[W aRX{X~[r{Y\[W aX[ _ u(l U l[b®_ [rwUW]\« b[tY^`XWk[ acah[-_ [t`]}X`A[Y\[oX$pR]^bRr2[oXX¶ [Wkl U l[Wa_¶ [YcY\[oX~¯}r2¥r[X_ UWAX¨YhU t bUa\]\o`k[?ijWXjbRa\]\UY\[m]R [X~U WX"¥acb[?jobd]\[ W ahu [oXVtkUb"_ [oXVr2[oXq` b[oX:]^WSi]^ahUa\]cz[oX-_[tkjJYc]^a\]\`k[ u ijWkjr"]h`k[JÀjr-rw[W aA]^W ah[bRt bu ah[bU WkUY©Sa\]\`k[rw[Wa i [ acah[Xd]^ac`kU a\]\jW . . 7d
(72) XR skX- KsH|¥ Ks]¡ rs[]\En*gsdDW[\)[7jHlV[kjm[kjRl"pj[WtfRjj7g{\ \D7jt7[WvHpKg{tkfRXqgsjKk[Wº ry rs[-pdDo[-dDW[-lm[ kjKkdD[~dm[W[7gsrsrs[-pdu\dD]\2pKryl{-l*\m[W ¶Ig{\D[E[~juhgsm[7jt7[JoK7d« f]²[7j[-l Z[ hgzjHlz²7r F >&@AB@JND. ±)g|j \Dg HJd(g|jmrs[C¶If IX[7d CT[-l$:gsrih[7dD7jFD>&@B@ NCd(kooK[krzrs[-jRlCtkfRWW[7jHlCrz[ t7fRj \DfRd(lsg|p |k~*7s7y~H zkcOH K¡ ¢"H y7ª^kR Ks 7¥C¢"R R~s|R ¢J¢N´$n*g|j7jt7)\(pdn*fRjmK\:oKd(gih]\"´)dD7fRdDgs[-jl{EmR7j \ rz[Jl{[7o \\}ªdD[kt~²[7dDt-²[)\(pKd m[\odDfD¹u[-l*\ ( oKryp\xod=]\ mRpAkdDt7²u oryp\ t7giqrs]\ [-l ºª²fdDg!fRj¤lV[koKfRdD[7ror|p \t7fpd(l#". . >.
(73)
(74)
(75)
(76) ¦ U¸t bUa\]\o`k[´ijWX~jobqa\]\U(Y\[b[`]\[bRay_[´ijr{tYhua[bj` _ [¸b~u z ]}X[b>YQ|cU WkU Y©X[´_ [/Y\U b[Y\U a\]\jW1ij jtku bUa\]\jWk¯RijWki`bqb [Wki[2`][oXqa[pRpQ[ iac`ku[2_ UWXY\U-Yc]^acahu b~U ac` b[ ¦U2i jWXRacbR`kia\]\jW _ ¶ ` Wk[Wkjo`Sz5[YcY\[-lobQ]cYcY\[-_ [:Y\[iac` b[-U t tkUbUaU(Y\jbX$Wku i[XX~U(]^b[À[YcY\[¯qi(]¦]^r:tYc]\o`k[-_ [-_u ibQ]^b[ i [ acah[®b[Y\U a\]\jWy_|` W"tkj]^W aO_ [$z`S[®tY^`X@_ SWSUr-]\`A[UpR]^Wy_ [i jr{t b[Wk_ob~[Y\Uijr{]^WkU(]}X~joWy_ [ Y\UV_ urwUbifS[V_S¶ ]^W Wkjz5Ua\]hjW[aM_ [Y\Ub[ifk[ b~i fk[{X]^r:`Y^ahU WAu [@_|cU _ U t ahUa\]\jW`]O_ u ah[bdr"]^Wk[W a Y\[$pQjWkia\]\joW Wk[rw[Wa¤[aYQ|cu zjY^`a\]\jW2_[®Y\U¨t bU a\]\`k[i jWAX~jbRa\]\U(Y\[ EQE. 5LWHI$BDEK>@ I(VGEK>AV5T3LWL @5>VG@CXAH. . >N SZYJHK>HQSANU@ WVGEK>E. . BD]T@. ¦U;i j jotkubUa\]\joW U½pdU(]^a1Yh¶ j [ aº_ ¶ ` WA[ Yc]^acahu b~U ac`b~[·z5jY^`r-]^Wk[ `X[;i [oX _[bRW]\«b[oX U W Wku[X ^¦j` ah[(pdjJ]}X~m Y\[i jWAX~jbRa\]^` rg_[®-T b[XRah[¨` W2jo [a¤_ ¶ u ac`k_ [_]cpRpR]\i]cY\[£Ut t bu fk[Wk_[b_ U WX¦Y\[X i U_b[Xg_ ¶ UWkU(Y©X~[oXg[s]}XRahUW aRXm¸t `]}X`k¶ ]\Y pQU]^aªi j [ s]}Xqah[ bg_ [X;Y\jlJ]\`k[oXgi j jtSubUa\]cz[ [a i joWki` bRb[Wa\]\[YcY\[À¨[(Y\U]cr:t5Yc]\`k[_[_ uz5[Y\jt tk[ b` W_]}X~ij` bX@UWkU(Y©Sa\]\`k[i jfku b[W a¦Xq`b_[` s tkj]^WaRX pdjoWk_ Urw[W ahU ` sO³ _¶ ` Wk[ tkUbRahm7Y\U Wkuoi [oXXQ]^ahu _ [ i j job~_jW Wk[ b _]cz[ bX a 9tk[oX _ ¶ ]^WSz5[XRa\]}XX~[ry[ W aRX2[ a_ [¡i joW WkU]}XXUWki[X2¯b[XRtk[ i a\]^z[rw[Wa[W5l U luX2[ aV_uah[W`k[X{tkUbw_ [X pR]^bRr2[oX>_]cpRpQub[W ah[oX>¯ U(pR]^W½_[/_ uz5[Yhjt tk[ b>_ [nWSj` z5[YcY\[Xyb~[oXXj` b i [oX>[ahmV_ ¶ U` acb[ntkU bRahmY\U i U tkU i(]^ahu1_S¶ ` a\]cYc]}X[byU `ei j`bXy_o` ah[r:tAX2Y}[oX-b~uoXd`Y^ahU aRXy_ [1i [X2b[ i fk[bifS[Xy[WZrw[acahU W a"[W 3®`zb[&_ [oX:XRacbUahu lJ]\[XV_]cz5[bX~[oX{[at5Y^`XtS[bdpQjbQryUWah[X`k[Y\[oXVijWki` bRb[WaRX A 6®bm»Yh¶ U WkUY©X[ u ijWkjr"]h`k[X~[$pj i U(Yc]}X~[X[`Y\[ry[ W aGXR` b¦Yh¶ `Wyj`"Y}¶ U ` acb[_[i[XGtAj]^W aRXMUbU(]}X~jW[Ww[XRaO`k[ Y\UªpR]^bRrw[ Wk¶ [Xqa&tkUoX/ijWXQ]\_ ubu[·i jor-ry[ `Wk[·[ W a\]^ahu·`5] r2[ a[W 3$`SzJb[·_ [oX/Uia\]^z]^aRuoX t bj _`Sia\]cz[oX_]vz5[bX[XR_ [t `5]}X¦Y\U®:T¡`X~o`¶ £$Y\Ui jor-r2[bi(]\UYc]}XUa\]\jWw[aAY\U_]}XRacbQ]^ ` a\]\jWQm[a `]U-tkj` bj [ia\]cpV_[t buX[bdz5[b{XUz]\U5]cYc]^ahu&[W¡bu UYc]}XUWa_ [oXVi fkj]^sº]^W Wkjz5Uah[` bX[a®[W b[tku bUW aXd]cr:`5Y^ahUWkury[ W a_[Xjt tkjbRac` W5]vahuoX_ [r2U bifku-tY^`X]vr-rwu _J]\Uah[X À¨[ aah[-pR]^bdrw[ [oXqa tY^` ahoa"UXXd]cr-]cY\u[¸U¡` WµU l [ W aVbUa\]\jW WS[ Y{`]{_ ua\]\[ W aV` W tkjobqah[(pQ[`]cYcY\[º_S[/XqacbU ahu l]\[oX&_ jW a ifSU i`Wk[_ j]^aGX[¨acbU _`]^b[m5]}XjY\u r2[ W ahmtkUbG`Wk[¨tkj5XQ]^a\]\jWw_ ¶ u`]cYc]^ b[JÀ[acah[¨tk[ bXqtk[ia\]cz[¨Wkjo`X i joWk_`]^aO£$` Wk[z]}Xd]\jWyp}bU lrw[W ahu[_ [oXt bjY\«rw[Xijr-ry[[W-ahurwj]\lWS[` W-bUt]\_[[sSUry[W _ [´Y\UxYc]^acahubUac` b[ ijWXU i b~u[ £´Y\U¬b[ifk[ b~i fk[ i(j jtSubUa\]cz[J¦U ijWki(Y^`Xd]\joW½t bQ]^Wki]^tkU(Y\[ £ Y\U o`k[YcY\[/U kj` a\]}XX~[ W a2Y\UntY^`tkUbRa2_ [oX acbUz5U`s;[XRaw`k[¸Y\U/ioj jtSubUa\]\jWµ_ [/${TVmV[ a2[W tkU bqa\]\i `Yc]\[bºY\[oX/ijWXjbRa}]\UmpQUzkjobd]}X[Wa>Y\U·i jjb _]^WkU a\]\jW²_ [oX/ijW WkU(]}X X~U Wki [oXnah[if W5]\`S[X ^¦j` ah[(pdjJ]}X~m·r2¥rw[ Xd] i[acah[ i jWSiY^`XQ]\jW pQU(]^a²i jWAX~[ WXq`AX~m½Y\[X UbQlo` rw[W ahU a}]\jWAX XjW a _]cpRpQub[Wah[X ¾ W t b[r"]\[b lob~jo` tk[ _|cUWkU(Y©X~[oX rw[a U ` i3$` b _ [ X~[oX _uz5[Y\jt tS[rw[W aRX YQ|^]^W ah[Wa\]\jW WkU(Yc]^ahu?XqacbUau lJ]\`k[&*^¦[ [ i[ m? 46"k° Ua\§om? 6:9° 'ºj)([bhx[ajSX[W S[b~lm? R69° ¹U` rwjY\m K" ]^WXQ]\mSY\UijYcY\USjbUa\]\jWy[ W2$-Tµ[W-ahU W aO`k[VXqacbU ahulJ]\[®tk[ bdrw[aO_ [$b~u_`]^b[ Y\[X@i j aRX_[®b[ i fk[bifS[ m9_[®butkU bRa}]^bY\[X¦bQ]}X~o`k[Xm_ [®bu_`]^b[Y\U_` tYc]\iUa\]\jWy_ [oX»buXR`Y^ahU aRX_ [ b[ i fk[bifS[ m[aM_|c[stY\j]^ah[b@Y\[Xui jWkjr"]\[X_|cuifk[ YcY\[V`5]¤WkU(]}XX[Wa¦_ [Y\UV${T;[Wi jr-r"` W TVU WXi [ acah[¬tk[bXRtk[ i a\]vz5[ m{_ [¬WSjr{ b[`s½acb~Uz5U`s jW ayu ahu _ u _J]\uX1£/Yh¶ ]\_ [ W a\]cpd]\iUa\]\jW _ [X pQU i ah[` bX@`]pQjW aM`k[_ [X¦tAUbRah[WkU(]^b[X@_]cpRpdu b[ W aRXUbRbQ]^zk[ W aO£®` WUi i job~_m9£Y\U_ uah[ bdr2]^WSUa\]\jW _ [oXÁt fku Wkjr2« Wk[X _ ¶ ]^Wi(]^ahUa\]\jW £ acbQ]\ifk[ b `k]½tk[`z5[W a Ut tSUbU}acb[ U` X~[(]vW _ [ YhU i jJYcY\UkjbU a\]\jWkm [ a£ªY\¶ uY\USjbUa\]\jW²_ [ªrwj [ WXx_ [e_ uah[ia\]\jW²[ a_ [·ijbRb[ ia\]\joW²_ [·i[X t bUa\]\o`k[XGÀ[acah[2Yc]^acahubUa\` b[ mX~j`z5[W aryj _uYc]}Xu [?Xj`Xpdjobdrw[&_ [®[ ` skmX ¶ ]^WXib]^a_ UWX` Wk[ z5jY\jW ahu-_¶ UWkU(Y©X~[ bY\[Xt fku WAjrw«WS[X_ [{i j jtAu b~Ua\]\joW>[Wyah[bQr2[oX$_[:ijr"tkjbRah[r2[ W aRXm[ a_ [ _ u ah[bRr-]^WA[ b_UWX@`k[(YcY\[®rw[XR` b[Y\UXRacbUahu lJ]\[_ [$tkUbRa\]\i(]^tkUa\]\jWU`yijWXjbRa\]^`Sr i jobqb[oXqtkjoWk_-£ ` W¢u `5]cYc]^ b[wrwUs]cr-]}XUah[ ` b_ [2l U(]^W X$tkj` b$`Wk[pR]^bRr2[m¦i jr:tah["ah[ W `¢_`1i fkj ]^s1_[XU`acb~[oX pR]^bRr2[oX U 6®W rwjWacb~[ U(Y\jbXe`k[*Y\[XeUi i job~_Xe_ [ i j jtSubUa\]\jW tk[ ` z[ W a XR` t t5Y\u [bªU` s . . >>.
(77)
(78)
(79)
(80) _ u(pdU(]cYcY\UWki[X®_`&r2U bifku-o`]ur2[ b~l[W aY\jbX`k[:Yh[Xpq]^bRrw[Xt bj _`]}X[W a@[ auifkU Wkl [ W a@_ [:Y\U i joW WkU]}XXUWki[ }bqb)j (m " 7 }Y}X XjW a u l U Y\[ r2[ W a XR`X~i[t a\]^5Y\[X¼_|^]^W ah[bRWkU(Yc]}X~[ b Y\[X XRt]cYcY\jz5[bX®_ [-${TÁ}Tw| {Xqtb~[rwjW a[a Ui `k[rw]^Wkm 6Q6° VUa\§y[ a 6$b_Sjz5[bm K8QmG[a_ [ bulJY\[btkUbY\£r2¥rw[Y\[V_]cY\[r"r2[V[ W acb[_]cpRp}`XQ]}jW>Xj i]\U(Y\[_ [Y\UVi jWWkU]}XX~U Wki [V[ a ]^Wki]^ahU a\]}joWX t bQ]^z5u [X£ ]vW WSjz5[bRÀ@butSjWkmT`klo`k[ahm GWkiU j`SU?[ a 'ºjf WS[Wk? m GW/i[?X~[ WXmifkU`k[ pR]^bRr2[[XRaOi UtSUY\[_S¶ uzU(Y^`k[bXjW2]^W ahu b¥ahm¤Xj]^aO_ [¨tkU bRa\]\i]^tk[ bU `yi joWX~jobqa\]^`rwm¤Xj]^aO_ [$b~[oXqah[ b@£ Y\¶ [ s ahubQ]\[ ` b_ [ i[acah[XRacbR`kiac`b~[J ^¦j` ah[(pQj]}X~m_ UWAXifkUi` Wk[y_ [ i[X{Xd]^ac`SUa\]\jWXm»Y\[oXV_u i]}XQ]\jWX tkjSXXQ]^Y\[X ;~[W acb[ b ;[a ;qWS["tSUX[ W acb[b ;VX~jWaU WkUY Xu [oXXutkU b~urw[Wa_ [oXifSj]^s1U ` sk`S[Y}X$YhU pR]^bRr2[1[XRai jW5pbjWahu [?tkUbwU]cYcY\[ ` bX(³`k[(Yo`k[¸Xj]^aY\[¡ifSj]^sxpR]^WkUY[pRpQ[ ia\]cz5[r2[ W aVr-]}Xw[W UttYc]\i U a\]\jWkm9i[Y^`]\¯Ri(]9Wk[®b[rw[atkUoX[ Wyi U `X[Y\[oXU`acb~[oX¨XRacbUahu lJ]\[X@_ [Y\UpR]^bdrw[`]GXjW atkU b fJStSjacfk«X[V£Y\¶ uoo`]cYc]^ b[ TUWXi[acah[Vjta\]\`k[ m9Yh¶ UWSUY©X[V_ [Y\Ub[Y\U a\]\jW[W acb[Vi joWXjbRa\]^`r²[a i joWki` bRb[WSi [X~[¨buXR`r2[£$` Wk[UWkU(Y©X[WSjbdryU a\]vzS[5 }YX ¶ U lJ]^a U]^WAXd]A_ [_ u ah[bQr-]^Wk[ bXQ]9Yh[i fkj]^s _ ¶ u `]cYc]^b~[º_ [nY\U1pR]^bdrw[¸[XRa"[pRpR]\i]\[ W a"U` W]vz5[ U`ª_ [nY\U/X~j i(]\uahuJ¨TVU WXi [¸ijW ah[ s ah[ mY\[X UWWku [oX K8:joW a9zJ` X[®r{`Y^a\]ctYc]\[bMY\[XUbRa\]\i(Y\[XXR` b¦YhUb[(Y\Ua\]\jWw[W acb[i joWki` bRb[WSi [[a¤[pRpR]\i]\[WSi [ u ijWkjr"]h`k[1 ]\i 5[bX~ m "9k ° U i o`k[r-]cWk m ""L°¹$U `r2jY\ m $ ° %[ bjSX ]\m K" À¨[oX UbRa\]\i(Y\[XjW ab[Wkj`z[(Y\uwY\[oX_]}Xi j` bX$acbU _J]^a\]\jW Wk[ YRXVXq`bY\U2i jWki ` bRb[Wki[[ a$X[ X~jWajbQ]\[WahuX z5[bX ` Wk[ºUWkU(Y©X[ntY^`X_ SWkUr2]\o`k[ m[W ah[ bdrw[X>_ [¡t bj i [oXXR`X GWe[ pRpQ[ahmi [acah[¡b[Y\Ua\]\jW i joWki` bRb[WSi [ ¯R[(pqpR]\i(]\[Wki[ WA¶ [XRa¸tSUX·XQ]cr:tY\[mt `k]}X`k[ÂY\¶ ]^W aR[ bU ia\]\joW _ [ÂpR]vbQr2[oXZ_ U WX´`W i joW ah[s ah[ _ ¶ ]^Wki[bRah]^ac`k_ [ U _[X1[(pRpd[ aRX1_]}XRa\]^Wki aRX/Xq` bY\¶ [(pRpq]\i(]\[Wki[ UYcY\jiUa\]cz[ dXR` bRtY^`X¢_ [X i joWX~jor-ryUah[ ` bXdQm:Y\¶ [pRpR]\i]\[Wki[¬t bj _`Sia\]cz[ Rui jWkjr"]\[X¢_S¶ u i fk[YcY\[mbUa\]\jWkU(Yc]}X~U a}]\joWg_ [´Y\U t bj _`Sia\]\jW[aY\¶ [(pqpQ]\i]\[ Wki [ _SWkUr2]\`S[ }]^W WAjz5Ua\]\joW¾VWk[ ijWkiY^`AXd]hjW;]cr:tkjobqahUWah[ [W rwUa\]\«b[y_ [wtkjJYc]^a\]}`S[ _ [2Y\U i joWki` bRb[WSi [X[ _u lUl[ _ [yi [ acah[Yc]^acahubU ac` b[ ³Gi [-WA¶ [XRatY^`XY\U XRacbq`Siac` b[:]^Wk_o`XqacbQ]\[(YcY\[-`]X[bRa@_S¶ uY\urw[W a@_ [Vb~u(p~u b~[ Wki [Vtkj` bY\[X®i jWki(Y^`XQ]\jWX¨WSjbdrwUah]vz5[Xm i [/X~joW a"_ uXjbQr2U(]}X&Y\[Xi jr{tkjbRaR[rw[WaRX&_ [oX&pR]vbRrw[X>o`]-X~joW a"ua\`k_]\uoX ¨]^WXQ]\mi[bRahU]^Wk[oX t bUa\]\o`k[XGah[(YcY\[X@`k[Y\[oXi jWAX~jbRa\]\U`]GXjW a r-]}X[X[W{tY\U i[®tkU b¦` W:tS[a\]^aWkjr{ b[_ [$pd]^bQr2[oX Wk¶ [Wkl [ Wk_b[WatAUXpQjbi urw[Wa_¶ [(pqpQ[ aWku lUa\]cpVXR` bY\¶ [pRpR]\i]\[ Wki [2ui jWAjr-]\o`k[ m¦[aWk[:tk[`z5[W a ¥acb[VijWXQ]\_ ubu [oXi jr-r[VUW a\]\ijWki`bqb[ WSa\]\[(YcY\[XUt bQ]\jbQ]RÀ[Xt bU a\]\`k[XXjW aMU ii [tahu [X_ «oX Y\jbX`k¶ [YcY\[Xtk[ bdrw[acah[ W aG` Wk[bUa\]\jWSUYc]}XUa\]\jW_ [Y\Ut bj _`Sia\]\jWq[(pRpq]\i(]\[Wki[tb~j_`kia\]^z5[ j` ` Wk[:XRa\]^r{`Y\Ua\]\jW_ [Y\¶ ]^WWjz5Ua\]\jWR[pRpR]\i]\[ Wki [V_SWAUr"]\`k[@`]¦X~[acbU_`]cb~joW a¦£ah[ bdrw[V[W2` W W]^z5[ U ` _[´]\[WS¯q¥ acb[µXR` tku bQ]\[` bºR[pRpR]\i]\[ Wki [ZUYcYhj iUa\]^z5[{À¨[´t b[r2]\[ b¡a Stk[Z_|cUtt bj ifA[ UWSUY©X[_ jWki_ [rwUW]\« b[XutSUbu[$Y\[XGbY\[Xj`kuXGtSUbi[X¦pQjbdrw[X_ [i jjtkub Ua\]\jWw_ U WXY\[oX XRacb~U ahulJ]\[X_|^]^W Wkjz5Ua\]\jWw[a¤_ UWX¦Y\[oXXqacbU ahulJ]\[X1ijWki ` bRb~[ W a\]\[YcY\[oX . ¾W _ [`s]\«rw[nlobj` tA[1_ ¶ U WkUY©X[Xmrwj]^WX-fSjrjl « Wk[ mjpRp}b[?` Wk[1[s t5Yc]\i Ua\]\joWZ_ [oX i joWX~jobqa\]\U pQjWS_ u [?XR` bVY\U&ijr:tkY\urw[W ahU bd]^ahu&_[X"U i a\]^z ]^ahuoX~m_ [oX{i jr-tSuah[WSi [X[a®_`xX~Uz5j]cb r"]}Xy[W 3`zb[tSUb2Y\[oX-tkUbRah[WSU]^b[XyR¦j UXRJm $ °¨MUWklY\jJ]}Xy[aVjk[ bRaRX~jWSm, ""9J[ tkj]^Wa_ [2_ u tkUbRa_ [2i [2ij`b~U W a[oXqa_[XR` t tSjSX~[ bmrwU]}XU` XXd]@_ [wz5ub]cpR]\[b[r{t]^bQ]\`A[r2[ W ahm `k[-Y\[oXpq]^bRrw[XVXjW a_ jahu [oX_¶ ` Wk[:bUa\]\joWkUYc]^ahu-pQU ]^Y\[2[aWkjW>r2U s]vr"]}XUacbQ]\i [JÀ[Y\U XQ]loW]cpR]\[ `k[2Y\[XpR]^bqrw[XWk[XjW atkUoXV[ W1r2[oXq` b[y_ [ i fkj]RXd]^bY\[Xrw[]cYcY\[` b[XU i a\]\jWXtkUbi[ `k[2Y\[X i joW WkU]}XXUWki[X Wku i[XX~U(]^b[X U` _ uzk[Y\jot tk[ry[ W a _ [ Wkj`z5[YcY\[X ijr{tku ah[Wki[X XjW a _]}XRtk[bXu [oX$[ W acb[tY^`XQ]\[`bXpR]^bdrw[Xm¤r2U(]qXU `XXQ]GtAUbi [{`k[{i [oXi joW WkU]}XXU Wki [oXXjWa¦Y\[t5Y^`X Xj` z5[W aahUi]^ah[X]^WXQ]\m Y\¶ [ WX[r{Y\[_ [X¦r2[(]cYcY}[ ` b Xi fkj]^s{tkjSXXd]^5Y\[XGWA¶ [oXqaktkUX_ jW WSu m5rwU]}X¦]cY uz5jY^`k[>[WpQjWkia\]\joWx_ [oX-jot a\]\jWX"`]X~jWai jWSib«ah[ r2[ W a[stkubQ]cr2[W ahu[XVtkU b{Y\[X{pR]^bqrw[X ¶ [ W [`_ [Vi [ acah[VUWAUY©X[V[XRa_ [Vijr:t b[ W_ob~[V_UWX`k[(YcY\[XijWk_]ca\]\jWX@Y\[XpR]^bdrw[Xtk[ `zk[W a [Wacb~[ b_ UWX_ [¡Wkj`zk[YcY\[oX&Uia\]cz ]^ahuoX~muah[ Wk_b[¸Y}[oX&Uia\]cz ]^ahuoX&o`¶ [YcY\[oX r2UacbQ]}X[W a"_u£ m[W >.
(81)
(82)
(83)
(84) USUWk_ joW Wk[bi [ bqahU(]^Wk[X[ a[WypQU]^b[b~uUYc]}X[b_ ¶ U`acb[oXz ]\U` WS[b[Y\U a\]\jW>ijW acbU i ac`k[YcY\[JÀ¨[{`] i jor:t ah[mio¶ [XRaYh¶ u ac`k_ [_ [$Y\U®z]\Uk]cYc]^ahu_ [i [XpR]^bdry[oX~mi¶ [XRa £_]^b[Y\[` buz5jY^` ah]\jWwU`wi j`b X_` ah[r{tX [a Y\[` b r2U W]\«b[ _ [ X~¶ U _ U t ah[b t bj lb[XXQ]^z[ry[ W a²U ` s i fkUWl[ry[ W aRX eÀ[acah[ tk[ bXRtk[ia\]cz[$W¶ [ski(Y^` a ]\[Wyuz]h_ [r-rw[W atAUX¦` W_[lobuV_ ¶ ]^W ah[Wa\]\jW WkU(Yc]^ahuV_ [XpR]^bdry[oX '¸¥rw[ X| ]cY [XRa½Xq`t tkjSXu7`k[ Y\[X;pR]^bdr[XgjW a WSuoi [XX~U(]^b~[ r2[Wae_ [Xgijr"tkuah[ Wki [oXÂYc]cr"]^ahuo[Xm Y\jbX`O|` Wk[U ia\]cz]^ahu®Wkj`z5[YcY\[_ j]^aO¥acb[_ uzk[Y\jot tAu [[ aO`O|^]cY [XRaWkui [XXU]^b[_|cUz5j]^b@U ii «X@£ ` Wk[½ijW WkU(]}XXUWSi [½j` ` Wk[½ijr:tku ah[Wki[½_¶ ` WA[½U`acb~[·pR]^bRrw[ m` Wk[½ij jtku bUa\]\jW¼uacbj]cah[ X¶ ]cr:tkjX~[mi [V`] ]^r{tYc]\`k[` Wijr{tkjbRah[rw[W a Wkuoi[XX~U(]^b~[rw[Wa¦Uia\]cp_[Y\UtkUbRaM_ [XpR]^bRrw[X TVU WX@i [iU _b[mSY\[ijWXjbRa\]\UX[r:5Y\[¥acb[$tkUbRa\]\i`kYc]\«b[rw[Wa¦U_ Ut ahu£Y\U$b~uoX~jJY^` a\]\jWy_ [_[` s t bjY\« ry[X¢i jWSib[aRX³t b[r-]\« b~[rw[Wahm:Y\U l [oXqa\]\jWg_ [´Y\U _]^z[ bXd]^ahu _[X1ijr:tku ah[Wki[X¢[ahm _ [ ` s]\«r[r2[ W ahm-Y\U WSu i [oXXQ]^ahuZ_ [·ij jb_ jWWk[bU`;t bu U(Y\UY\[Zi[Xºi jr{tkuah[WSi [XºU(pR]^W _[ tk[ bqrw[acacb[2Y\U"buUYc]}XU a\]\jW1_[Y\¶ ]^WWjz5Ua\]\jW¢[aXU _J]cpqp}`XQ]\jWºXq`bY\[r2U bifkuJ ^¦j`ah[pQj]RX~m¦_ U WX Y\[X>acbUzU ` sg[s]}XRahUWadXm-i [ _ [ lbu _¶ ]^W ah[W a\]\jW WSU Yc]^ahu¬Wk[´zU/tkUX-~`X`A¶ £/Wkj`X¡tk[ bdrw[acacb[ _ ¶ ]^W ah[bRt buah[ b>Y\[/i jWAX~jbRa\]^`r i jr-rw[n` W·rj [Wµ_ [/_ uz5[Y\jttk[bmV£/i oahu/_ [X1XRacb~U ahu l]\[oX _ ¶ ]^W WkjzU a\]\jWkmy_ [XxXdacbUahu lJ]\[X_ [ªrwUbifku{¦Uªt bQ]}X[·[W i jr:tah[·_ [ei [X¬uY\urw[W aRX[Xda ahj` ah[(pQj]}X[Wz]}X~U l[ U Y\[V_ U WX` WA[VUWSUY©X[V`]OU ioijb_ [` Wk[tY\Ui [Vi[W acbUY\[VU ` s2t bjY\«ry[oX _|^]^WpQjbQr2U a\]\jW:b[ Wki jWacb~uoXGtkUbMY\[X¦pR]^bRr2[oX¦]^W WkjzUacbQ]\i[X. . . >>E F HI$BJEK> @ I H4XAH 4I$HI$BDEK> SO@GN V5EK>AN E.L I$BOH XA@ X YJBJ> $E.L 0HI$BJEK>RN I$@WV5\>RBJ]TR@GN @ I X YJBD> $EKL 0HI$BJEK>RN<XR@ H LWV5\. . . . . V5E. 0@. F GSOHI$@5T L. L. ¾WgijWXjbRa\]^`r _ [ ${T [XRa `Wk[ i jjtkubUa\]\jWg_ [¬b[ifk[ b~i fk[¬b[ lbj` tSUW a_ [oX1pq]^bQr2[oX ]^W WkjozU acb~]\i [oX2[ aVijWki ` bRb~[ W ah[X }Yi jr{]^Wk[¡_ joWi_ [` s jo [ i a\]cp XTw| `Wk[tkU bqahmi |c[XRa` Wk[ pQjbRr2[1_|cjbl U W]}XUa\]\jWxt bQ]vz]cY\u lJ]\u [?tkj` bw_ uzk[(Y\jt tk[bw_ [oX2U i a\]vz]^ahuX-]^WWkjzU acbd]\i[X~m_ jW aY\U t bQ]^Wki(]^tkUY\[ iUbU i ahubQ]}XRa}]\`S[ [XRa>_ [ i jWXRa\]^ac`k[b¡`Wk[¬bR` t ac` b[ZUz5[ i´Yh¶ [ s]}XqahU W a>o`]&U¬tSj`b i joWX~u`k[ Wki [V_¶ [ Wkl [ Wk_b[b` WS[Vi [bRahU]^Wk[]^WAXqahU]cYc]cahuK GW[pRpQ[ahm9Y\[oX]^Wzk[XRa\]}XX~[rw[W aRXbu U(Yc]}X~uoX tkU bY\[XpR]^bqrw[XX~joW aXR`X~i[t a\]^5Y\[X_|cUkj` a\]^b£{_ [XifSj]^s>[ bqbjWSuX`]\m _`&pQU(]^a_`>iUbU i ah«b[ ]^bRbuz5[bXd]cY\[º_ [X>_utk[ WX~[oX~m$tk[`z[ W a"i U `X[ b&_[X&_ uoX~u`]cYc]^ b[oX>i`r{`Y\Ua\]cp~X>[ a2_`b~U Y\[X T2|cU ` acb[ntkUbRahmY\[xi jWXjbRa\]^`r tk[bQr2[ a2Y\[/_ uz5[Yhjt tk[ r2[W aw_ [/pQ[Wk¥ acb~[oXj`z[ bqah[oX1Xq` bY\[X jt tSjbRac` W]^ahuX&ah[if W]\`k[oX[ay_ [´rwUbifSu´_[X&tAUbRah[ WkU]^b[Xm{_ jW a2YQ|cj[ ia\]cp[XRay_ [ ibu [ b i [ bRahU]^WXu(Y\ur2[ W aRX_A|vU_ UtahUa\]\jWy[ a _ [VXqahU ]cYc]^ahuU(pd]^Ww_ [®rwU]^Wah[W]^b¦Y\Uz]\U]cYc]^ahul Y\jkU(Y\[_[Y\U pR]^bRr2[J "j`XVt bjtkjSXjWX"_ joWki`Wk[lobQ]cYcY\[?_[Y\[iac` b[¡Xq`Xi [ t a\]^Y\[>_ [ t b[Wk_b[>[W¬i jr{t ah[ i [ acah[Á_`SUYc]^ahuÀ¨[ acah[ lobQ]cYY\[mn]^WXRt]^bu [²_ [ ]\ifkUb_SXjW K8Qm¬X[bU pQjWS_ u [ Xq` bµ_ [oX t bjY\« ry[Xw_ [¡ioj job~_J]^WkUa\]\jW _ ¶ ]^WSzS[XRa\]}XX[r2[ W aRX`]$b[ `]\« b[W a`Wk[b[ i fk[bi fk[?t bu UY\U Y\[ _ ¶ ]^WpQjbdrwUa\]\jWX "jacb[?U t tkjbRaVX[bU>_ ¶ U bRa\]\i`Y\[ b2i[XVt bjY\« r2[X"_ [>i j job~_J]^WkUa\]\jW¬Uz[iY\[oX i U bU iahu bQ]}Xqa\]\`S[Xi jWki b«ah[X_ [oX&iojWAX~jbRa\]\U³¨Y\[X&pR]^bRr2[oX?X jW aVtkU bqah[ WkU]^b[oX&£1Y}¶ ]^W ahubQ]\[`b&_` i joWX~jobqa\]^`rwmr2U(]}XX~[$pQjW a¤i jWki ` bRb[Wki[£$Y\¶ [s ahu bd]h[`b_ [i [ acah[XRacbR`kiac`b~[m ]} [JXR` b¦Y\[¨r2U bifkuJ ¦U tSUbRa\]\i]^tkU a\]\jW U` ijWXjbRa\]^`r b[Y\«z5[Á_¶ ` W t bjY\«rw[Á_[Ái jjb_]^WkUa\]\jW _[ _ ]cpRpQub[WaRXa tk[X_¶ ]^Wz5[XRa\]}XX[ry[WaRX¡o`k[´_j]^a-buoX~jo`k_b[¬Y\U/pR]^bdrw[´U(pR]^W;_ [¬rU]^W ah[ W]^b1XU z]\U]cYc]^ahuJ$¦UnpR]^bdrw[n]^WWkjzU acbd]\i[¢bu U(Yc]}X~[º_ [Xy]^Wz[oXqa\]}XX[ry[W aRX_ [¡b~[ifk[ bifk[m®tkU bWSUac` b[ ]^bRbuz5[bXd]cY\[oX ( GWx[pRpQ[ahmY\[X"ij aRX"[WlU luX"_ «X"Y\[?_u ` a_`¸t bj [ a$Wk[¡X~[ bjW aU `¸r"]\[` s bu i ` tkubuoXZ`k[;Y\jbX`k[ÂYh¶ ]^WWkjzU a\]\jW X[bU*ijr-r2[ bi]\UY\]}Xu [yTVUWAX Y\[Xe_J]cpqpQu b~[ W aRXZiUX i joWkib[aRX®`k[:Wkj`AXUzkjWAX[sSUr-]cWkuXmY\[oX_ utk[ W X~[oX_ [b[ifk[bifS[X~joW aacb«Xu(Y\[zu[X®[aY\[oX pR]^bRr2[oXWk¶ jW atkUoXY\U:tkj9XXQ]^]cYc]^ahu2£-Y}¶ jbQ]lJ]vWS[_[iojoW WkUacb[2Uz5[ i:t bu i(]}Xd]\jW¢Y\U"b[ W ahU]cYc]^ahuy_ [ i [oX[W5l U l[r2[ WaRX ¦[:X[`5YGijr{tkjbRah[rw[Wa tkjSXXd]cY\[V[XRaM_ [r2[ acacb[V[W2tY\U i[Y\[XijWk_]^a\]\joWX . >&M.
(85)
(86)
(87)
Documents relatifs
To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed
Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à
Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine
En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages
Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur
A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated
The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide
Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to