• Aucun résultat trouvé

The relationship between the newcomers in the Cévennes and schooling

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "The relationship between the newcomers in the Cévennes and schooling"

Copied!
14
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: halshs-00325676

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00325676

Submitted on 30 Sep 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

The relationship between the newcomers in the Cévennes and schooling

Nathalie Bonini

To cite this version:

Nathalie Bonini. The relationship between the newcomers in the Cévennes and schooling. Oxford

ethnography conference, Sep 2008, Oxford, United Kingdom. �halshs-00325676�

(2)

354 6874 9;:<>=?@:;@A:

BC< D 6FEHG'<GI:;@J4@K687LG?MH?N9;?OPQRS@:UT.<GV:W6YX>Z\[ ]^4/_N< 94 :FVQH`\?aEaGV\bcZG'4@D <d%eKRgfh]jilkmnJoqp'`sr\]rt

tH??N@j4u6Y<Gv687<w<-TH< @K6V#?uxkyiAzLQ^687a<|{J:;OG4 @K65Ma?NM$E}9;4-6~:;?@:;@HDG< 4KV'< €:;@‚687<wƒg4G€?H:V<w4 @€„687H<

BC?…$<G~:4 @woXT.< @@<KV4†@a€„:;@‡?a687a<GˆGEHG'49< @D 94T.<KV‰~[\`Š7a4 6gMH?MEH9;4 6Y:;?N@x‹J4VJ{54 :;@A9;P‡D ?A{SMH?ŒV'< €w?Nu

u8?G{<GJD :W68Pw€K‹< 99<GVŽ[I`7a</P7H4TH<‘V'< 6F689;< €h:;@w7H4 {v9<6VS€<KV<G86Y< €’_Px687< :;GS?a‹S@H<GV‹J7a?hMG< u8<G~G< €

{J?G<J€aPa@H4 {“:DJG<OH:;?N@}V”Ž[A•g9W687?EHO7v687<+‹4/TN<V)?Nu%{5:OG4-68:;?N@v‹4–H< €#?Gq‹4@a< €€<MH<†@a€N:;@O—?N@v687a<

68:;{5<MH<G:;?H€Q>:W6S74VJ@<TN<GV6Y?MMH< €A[I•ˆVJG<OH4G€AVJ€< {J?OG4MH7:DKVQ:W66FEHG~@</€w?aE66c?_N<˜4MH?}V:W6~:™T.<

< TN?A9WE6Y:;?N@š4 u6Y<Gx€< D 4/€<KVx?Au#u89:;OA7$6˜uFG'?N{›687a<‚4G</4†œŽ[•ˆV—G<OH4G'€ŒVžV?HD†:U?A9;?ONPaQ“:Ÿ6#G<KVE.9W6Y< € :;@ 4 @

<@a<G~OH:¡…†4 6~:U?N@x?Huq687a?ŒV'<vGEHG4 9C4G< 4KVŽ[t68:™OH{54 6Y:™…$< €ž4†@H€x€<KV'<G6Y< €xu8?NGg49;?@O˜6Y:¡{5< QIGEHG4 9\4G'< 4V+@a?a‹

4 668G4 D6lMH<?M9;<9U?A?¢A:;@LOvu8?G\4>_H< 6F6Y<Gl‹4 P?Nu£9:u~<<TH< @ˆ687?EHO7K6.687<¤_N< 6F6Y<Gl‹4 PJ?ul9:uY<¥g{v4P574TN<+4

TH<G'P’€:¡uYu~<G'<†@$6{J<$4 @:;@Ox€<MH< @a€N:;@Ox?@MH</?NMH9;<¦cV)MG?u:;9<Vˆ[Ÿ`I7<JG<KVE.9W6V^?Nuq?aEHGgVEHGTN</PH§gV~7a?a‹¨6874-6

687<©KE.<$V68:;?@J?Au£< €KE.D 4-6~:;?@+‹4KV\4{54'ª'?NG\u84 D 6Y?GI:;@“{?a68:™TH4-6~:;@OJMH< ?MH9;<>‹J:W687JD 7:9€G'<†@g6Y?«V'< 6689U<:;@+687H<

oXTH< @@<KVŽ[

¬$­®L¯I°L±¡²³²™´µL¯-¶l· ¸a¹º®L¯\´»8¯´· ¸¯¼L½¾L±™»¿^´»8¯\À-²™´ ¶¶~±™¸F±;¯-Á±™¼¹®L¯%Â-±;¶~·$²™´1¹c¯-Á)»c¾L»F´²ÃÀ-´1¹F¯µL· »c¿)Ä$¿¹®L¯ÅH»¯¼†À ®

Æ

´¹F±™· ¼$´²Ç¼K¶c¹8±È¹¾/¹c¯C· ¸}ÉÀ· ¼L· Êg±™À%´-¼LÁ+Ë/¹c´1¹F±;¶F¹F±™À-´²LǼ$¸8· »Ê´1¹F±;·†¼ÌÇ

Æ

ËÉÉÍÎÀ-¸¹®L¯»F¾L»F´²/¹¿ ÏL·K²;· µ ¿g· ¸a¹º®L¯\Ç

Æ

ËÉÉ

±™¼HÐ Ñl®$´Ê)Ïa¶'´-¾L»ÒÎÈÌÁ ±™»1ÎÍÓ£ÔÕIÖ×LØ.Ù× ÚÛLÔÕ\ÔÜKÝ;Ô-Þ$ß~ÕIàá™Ý;Ý;ÔÕ-â}ãä$äå/âKÇ

Æ

ËLÉÉ£æÇ

ƝçIè

Î

é ÅA· »¯ê´-ÊÏL²;¯-â$´ ¶lÒÎ

ç

¯°·$²$¾K¼LÁ$¯»8²;±™¼¯Ž¶l´ ÄL·¾/¹¹®L¯ÅH»8¯¼LÀ ®)ë$ì´²;²;¯¿.Ð í-îïLÔlðIßÔÛLÖïñK×LÝ;Ý;ÔFòˆÝ;ó Õ-ÜÜÈïßÔ-Ô%ô$Þ ×Lß1ÜUÔ-ß~Õ

óõáÜöÕaÙló~ÙlÞ Ý™×aܙá;óÛg÷$ÔܳøsÔ-ÔÛSù úKûü%×$Û$ýSù úNüŽþAÎí%Ìÿ ÿ$âÏ#ã$Í

ъ¸£Î IßÔ-Ø>á;Ô-ßÔ↼/Ćÿ$â8¾²Ÿ¿ÿC´ ¿L¶~¯1»\â³Ìãä$ä Í}á;ݙÕIó ÛaÜKÖïLó$áUÕ1á™ÕIݙ×^Ö×Ø.Ù×/ÚÛÔâ´\­l·¾L»

Á™´±™µ ¾¯Ž¶â

è

¾$įŽ¶lÉlÁ ±È¹8±;·†¼K¶ ÎÎ )¯»F°L±¡¯¾´-¼$Á"!Îì)±™´»Á¼$·-¹8¯-Á¹º®†´¹}·¼L¯£¹®±³»Á)· ¸¹c®L¯\À·¾K¼ ¹c»8±;¯-¶l¼L·-¹}· ¼$²™¿g¶¾L¸F¸¯1»~¶

´%ÏL·Ï$¾²³´¹F±™· ¼Á$¯-À-»8¯´/¶¯IÄ$¾ ¹AÊ^´±™¼L²™¿´-¼´-µ$±™¼$µÏL·Ï$¾²™´1¹F±™· ¼$#®¯¼^´ ¼L·-¹F®L¯»H¹®$±™»8Á· ¸¹®L¯»F¾L»F´²LÀ-´ ¼¹F· ¼L¶®$´/¶ÄL¯-¯¼

»8¯À· »Á$±™¼$µ¹®L¯Š®L±™µ$®L¯-¶F¹}±™¼$À-»~¯´/¶~¯»8´1¹c¯Ž¶l±W¼Ïa·Ï$¾L²™´¹F±;· ¼¸8· »H¹%#¯¼¹c¿)¿L¯´»~¶IÌÿ}ãÐ}ãÍ

&('&¿^¯~¹c®/¼·$²;· µL±™À-´²¯¼L½¾L±™»8¿LâK±W¼^À·$²™²³´ ÄL· »8´¹F±™· ¼$#)±È¹®Å#ÎÈÑI²™´-°$´±™»·/²¡²;¯\±;¶ÄL´ ¶~¯-Á)·†¼¶¯°L¯»8´²¶F¹F´ ¿L¶l±Ÿ¼¹®L¯´»¯1´

¶~±W¼LÀ¯\ÿ†ÿLâ Ï$´»;¹F²W¿^´Ê· ¼$µ¹®L¯\¸F´Êg±;²¡±;¯Ž¶I¶c¹¾LÁ ±;¯-ÁÎ*)„¯\·Äa¶¯»c°L¯Á)´ ¼LÁ)À· ²;²;¯-À¹¯-ÁÊg·/»~¯l¹®$´-¼g¯±™µ$®¹F¿½¾L´²¡±¹c´1¹F±W°L¯

±™¼¹¯1»c°L±;¯+#)¶l¸F»8· ÊÁ$±™¸F¸¯1»~¯¼¹}²;· À-´²¶F¹F´-,L¯®L· ²;Á$¯»Y¶I̸·/»cÊg¯1»´-¼LÁ>¼L¯+#‡±™¼$®$´ ÄL±È¹F´-¼¹8¶â†¼$´1¹F±W°L¯-¶l·$¸¹®L¯%ÑI¯°L¯¼K¼L¯¶â

²;¯´Á$¯»Y¶l· ¸¹®L¯%À· ÊʾL¼$±È¹c¿^²;±™¸¯Žâ¹8¯´À®¯1»~¶â ÏK¾$ÏL±™²;¶.#ÍÎ

(3)

D7:9€G'<†@—:¡@—4 @˜< @TH:;G?@{5<†@$6%‹S7:;D 7˜:FVˆV< < @—4KV^<†@aD ?EHG4OH:¡@LO687< :™G_H9U?ŒV1V?A{J:;@Ox4 @€QI?@&687a<v?K687a<G

74 @a€QŒV'<†@a€+687< { 6Y?vV~{54 9¡9<G%V'D 7?H?N9FV-[

`I7:cV\MH4MH<G%€< 4 9FV‹:W6~7ˆ687a<+4 @4 9;P}V1:cVC?Au687<G< 94 6~:U?N@HV7:¡Mv_N< 6F‹< < @687a<+uY4†{J:9:<V%4 @a€VD 7?H?N9;:;@O4 @a€Q

?@w4&‹J:U€<GvVD/4†9< Q%_H< 6F‹< <@x687<˜uY4†{5:9;:<VJ4 @€‘687a<˜4 G< 4 Q%:;@hG< 94 6Y:;?@AV7:;Mh6Y?jV'D7??9;:;@O[`I7<˜u8:™T<

MG:;{v4G'PVD 7?H?N9V“V86FE.€:< €x4G<?G~OH4@:™…L< €x< :W6Y7<Gg4G'?aEa@€x4€< D$< @K68G49;:;…L< €‘:;@$6Y<GTH:994OH<< €KE.D$4 68:;?@H4K9

OG?EHM:;@O5b !" #$&%†]'£p~d(£?NGI:;@J4?@<).D†9U4aV1V%V1D 7?H?N9H?G£?N@a<

‹J:W687wV1<TH<G4 9D 94$V-V<KVŽ[I`Š7H<MEHMH:9FVSD ?A{J<u8G?A{ V<TN<†G'4†9\TH:9;94†OH<$VvV:W6FE.4 6Y</€h:¡@˜687LG< <&TN4†99</P.VJ?u>687H<

o<TH< @@<KV%687<=^?G~O@<+TN4†99</PNQA687<+ZG< @D 7vT.4 9;9<†P#4 @a€“687<vtH4 9<†@H€G:;©KE.<5[W`I7H<G<S4G<+_H< 6F‹< < @+* ,#-

4@a€.*Hi -vD 7:9€G'<@5€<M}< @a€N:;@O«?N@ˆ687a<PH< 4G-[`I7<g€N:FV~MH4 G:W6FP5:;@“687a<+@KE.{ˆ_.<G%?ulMEHMH:;9FV%:FV%@a?a6s?@9UP«€KE.<

68?687<€< {J?OG4M7:DV_E6^4 9V?˜68?&687a<vMH< ?M9;<¦cVguFG< ©E.<@$6{J?TH:;@OhuFG'?A{ G<KV:€< @D <“6Y?˜G<$V:;€< @D <0/

_H</DK4-EV<?uŒ687a<€N:;u~uY:D-E}9W68P?Aulu8:;@H€N:;@Ov9U?A€OH:;@O1/I4KVl‹< 99.4KVl68?+687a<MH?NMEH9;4G:Ÿ6P?Nu£4MH4G868:D-E}94G%V'D†7a?A?9F[

•JV%:;@<TH<G'P—V{54†99:cV'?A9;4 6Y</€“GEHG4 9lV'D 7?H?N9;Q6874 6Š€N:VYM}4G~:W68P74VCD ?@}V< ©KE.< @aD <V%?@ˆ687H<+{54 :¡@$6Y4 :¡@H:;@O?G

687<D 9;?}V:;@O5?Au£D†94VV1<$VQH</TN< @v?u687a<V'D 7?H?N9H:W6V< 9u[`Š7H<uE6FEHG<?u}687<ˆVD 7?H?N9FV\:FVC?Nu£OG< 4 6s:¡@$6Y<G<KV86}68?

4@KE.{_.<G%?ul¢H<P5MA94PH<G V'QVE.D 754KVI687<g< 9<KD-6Y< €“G<MG<†V'< @K6Y4 68:WT.<$VQN687a<+{54/Pa?GQN687a<+< 9;< D-6Y< €“MH4G'<@K6VC:@

VD 7a?A?9MH4G< @K6V5?G~OH4@:;…$4 6Y:;?@Q%687<6Y< 4 D 7<GV4 @a€687H<x:¡@7H4_H:W6Y4 @$6V54KV4‹J7a?A9< Qq6Y4¢A:;@O 4 D 6Y:;?@‚4 9F9

68?OH<687<G‹S7< @J687< :;GqTH:;994O}<ˆ:FV687LG< 4 6Y<@a< €}[$3v<TN<G687< 9;<V1VQ€<KV~MH:W6Y<687:FV)D ?@AV'< @}VEV6Y?MGY?K6Y< DŽ6£687< :™G

VD 7a?A?9;QA6Y<@AV:U?A@AV)4 @€#€:cV'4OG< < {5< @K6V)< –H:FV86_N< 6F‹J</<†@v687a<ˆMH4G<@$6V)4@€v687<J< 9;< D 6Y</€&G<MG<KV<@K6Y4 68:™TH<V'Q

_H<-6F‹J< < @687a<“6Y< 4 D7H<GVg4 @€687<MH4G< @$6Vg4@€‘_N< 6F‹< <@687a<vM}4G'<@K6V687a< {&V1< 9™T.<KVŽ[Z}EHG687a<G{J?NG'< Q687<

D ?@AV'<†@HVE£V\€?H<KV~@¦™6£{J< 4 @+6874-6}687<uY4 {“:9:<VlEH@G'<aV'<GT.< €9™PVEHMMH?G6H687< :™G%V'D†7a?A?9VŽ[

=^< u8?NG<V6FE.€KPa:¡@O#687<“MH4G<@K6VŽ¦\</–aMH< D 6Y4 68:U?N@HV>6Y?‹J4G€AVVD7a?A?9FV4@€&687a<†@687<5< €KE.D 4 68:U?N@H4 9I{5< 687?H€AV

687< {vV1< 9™T.<KV'Q9< 61¦FV9;?A?¢#4 6I687a<ˆ€N:;u~uY<G< @$6I‹J4 T.<$V?AuV<6689U<GV:;@v6~7a<ˆoXTN<†@@a<KV%6Y?˜V~7?‹ 687<ˆ€:;u~u~<G< @K6

MG?u:;9<V?AuIMH</?NMH9;<ˆ:;@TH?A9™T.< €:;@v687:FVV6FE.€P.[A•g9W687?EHO7“687a<J€N:;u~uY<G< @K6\MH<G:U?A€AVq?NuV< 6F689U<†{5< @K6C4G<+@?6

D ?{ˆMH9<-6Y<†9™Pž€:FV1DG< 6Y</Qs687a</P—G<MG'<KV< @K6^€:;u~u~<G< @K6gV< 6F689;:;@O4GD7H<-6FPM.<KVJel687a<&{5:¡OG'4 6Y?GPxMG?HD <KV1VQl687<

{J?6~:™TN4 6~:U?N@HV 4 @€ 687< u8?G{5V ?Au :;@K6Y<OG4 68:;?@ :@$6Y? 687< ‹J< 9;D/?A{J:¡@O V?HD†:U< 6P G'</TN< 4 9 687<

V?HD :;?H< D ?@?{“:D 4 9.4 @€“:U€< ?A9;?OA:UD 4 9}D ?@K6Y<-–6£:;@+‹J7:D 7+687<G</4KV?@AV\u8?GI9;< 4TH:;@Ov4MMH< 4G< €}[

5`I7<G<+4G<>6F‹J?Ju8?NGY{&VŠ?Aup@$6Y<GTH:9¡94 OH<>rq€KE.D 4 6Y:;?N@a4 9ƒG'?aEHM:;@O2% 687<gD < @K68G49;:;…L< €ˆprqƒOH4 687a<G:¡@Oˆ687H<

D7:9€G'<†@#?Hu%{54†@P#T.:¡994†OH<$V:;@˜?@<VD 7?H?N9s4 @€v687<J€A</D < @K68G49;:;…$< €#prƒ _N4KV< €—?N@v687a<“OG?EHM:;@Ox?Au

687<€:;u~uY<G< @$6lMGY:¡{54G~P5V1D 7?H?N9H9;<TH< 9FV\:¡@V'</TN<G4 9H9;?}D 4 9VD 7?H?N9V-[

(4)

ZG~?{ kyiAz68?+687<vkym % ¤ 687a<>E68?M:;4 @J:¡{5{v:;OHG4@K6VY¥

ZG?{ 687<ˆ< @a€?Aul687a<˜kyi -AV6Y?v687<ˆ{J:€€9<J?NuI687<k/ym -AVQA687a<+MH< ?MA9;<vV'< 6F689;:¡@O#:;@GEHG4 9I4G< 4KV%‹<G<

{54 :¡@H9¡P’MH< ?NMH9;<[<GTH:< E|4†@a€=ˆ[BC<OH<GˆD 4 9;9<$€‘¤-E6Y?NM:;4 @x:{5{v:;OG4 @K6V^¤ bkymAz$dJ[Ÿ`I7<P˜‹54 @$6Y< €68?

MG?K6Y<KVF6s4OH4:;@HV6\V?HD:;< 68P4†@a€+68?v4-TH?:;€+687<4 _LElV'<KV\?uŒ687a<+V?#/~D 4 9;9< €JD ?N@HVE.{5<G%V?HD :;< 68P}[

]^<~ª</D 6~:U?N@ˆ_.< :;@O{J?NG'<+:;{“MH?GF6Y4@K66874@“MH94 @@:¡@OHQ687<P7a4 €6Y?ˆ6FGPˆ‹4P}Vq?NuI9:uY<+?MMH?ŒVY:;@O0/\:¡@ˆ687a<†:;G

€< u:;@H:W6Y:;?N@ /q687a<“‹J4P’?Au9;:uY<v?Au8u~<G< €_P687a<“MG<TN4†:9:;@OhV'?AD :< 68P—4†@a€˜4 :{5:¡@O’4 6MG?{J?68:™@Ož4“G'< 4K9

D ?EH@K6Y<G /VY?AD:U< 6P.[J< @aD < QŠ687a<9;:uY<:;@wD ?A{J{ˆE.@:W6PD$?EH@K6Y<G</€—687a<&@a?NGY{v4 9DP?Nu687<#D ?N@-ª~EHOH4 99:u~<

‹J:W687#D 7:9€G'<†@aQŒ687a<«V868G<@LO687#?NuI687<V?HD†:U4†9I9:;@¢&‹J:Ÿ6~7:@v687<“@a< 6F‹?NG~¢#?uI687<JD ?A{J{ˆE}@:Ÿ6P—D ?EH@K6Y<G< €

687<V< 9;u~:FV7@H<KV-V^?AuV?HD :4†9IG'<†94 6Y:;?@AV7:;M}Vg:;@EHG_.4 @˜4G</4KVQI4 @€687<“G'4G:W6P’?u>OH?H?H€AV:;{JMH?ŒV'< €˜:;@687<

¤-‹J:9€<G@<V1V~¥D/?aEH@$6Y<G< €&687a<“G4{ˆM}4 @$6)D ?@AVE.{J<G:FV{QI4@€‘V'?‘?@}[SG~:WT.< @_Px4 @—4 @K6Y:/~:¡@}V86~:Ÿ6FE68:;?N@a4K9

:€< ?A9;?OP—4†@a€˜?Au6Y<@#_H< D 4-ElV'<687<Px7a4 €_H< < @—€N:FV14MM.?:¡@$6Y< €˜:;@&687a<†:³Gu8?NG{5<G{J:9:W6Y4 @K6)< –aMH<G:<†@aD <VQ

687<xu:³G V86J€K‹< 9;9<GV5€N:€@}¦™6ˆOH<-6ˆ:;@TH?H9UTN< €„:;@w687<‘9U?AD 4 99:¡uY<[If 4†@P|?Au687< { @< :W6Y7<G54 6F6Y<{ˆM6Y< €h68?

_H</D ?A{J<h:;@K6Y<OG4 6Y< €‚:;@K6Y?|687a<’TH:;994O.<KV@a?NGˆ6c?|6Y4¢H<687<xMH?N9;:W6Y:D 4 9MH?a‹<G5?aTN<GQ>_N< D 4 E£V<˜687<P‚@a?

9;?A@LOH<Gw_H< 9:<TH< €¨:;@ 687a4 6x‹J4P ?uwD 7a4†@LOA:;@O 687< ‹?NG~9U€}[“puh@a?a6‡V8P}V6Y< {J4-68:D/4†99¡P¨G'<'ª1< D-6Y< €Q“687<

D7:9€G'<†@.¦VC< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@v:;@ˆ687<TH:994OH<ˆVD 7?H?9N‹4V@a?a6s4MG~:;?G:W6P5u8?Gl687?}V<u:;GV86I@a< ‹5D ?{5<GVI‹J7?HQA:;@

4@P5<TN<†@$6YQ?N@9™PJ7a4 €J4uY< ‹ D7:9€G< @}[

`I7<4GYG:™TN4†9H?HuŒ687a?ŒV'<>‹ˆ7a?“7a4 €ˆM94 @HVu8?G687a<uE6FEHG'<

ZG?{ 687a<+{v:€€9<g?Au687<ˆV1</TN< @K6Y:;<KVI6Y?687a<+< @€5?Au687a<ˆ< :™OH7K6Y:;<VQN687a<+D 74 @LOH<_H?687v:;@“687a<MG'?Nu8:9<ˆ4 @€

:;@ 687<‹4P¨?Huh9;:uY< ?Nu˜687a< o>XTN<†@@a<Vw{v:;OG4 @K6Vž‹J4KVžTH<G~P D 9< 4G-[J•g9W687?EHO7 687< :€<$4 9#?Aux4

D ?{J{E.@:W68PJ9:u~<>‹4V%V68:;99AMG<$V< @K6YQ7?EV:;@O“_N< D 4 {5<{?NG<:;@€:™T}:€KE.4 9QAu8?AD-EV< €J?@+687<u84 {v:9;PJ?@HD <

4OH4 :;@}[)ta68:;99+V</<¢A:;@O 4’_aG< 4¢w‹J:W6Y7h687< :™G5u8?NG{J<G59;:u<x4@a€Qu8?NGJ{J?}V6S?u687a< {JQq‹J:Ÿ6~7‡D :W68P‡9:u~<x:@

OH<@a<G4 9Q>687<P‚@a?a‹ 4GYG~:™T.< €|‹J:W687 {E.D 7‚{?NG<˜687?EO7$6 /~?aEL6ˆM9U4†@}VŽ[`Š7a<G<˜‹J4KV«4hD 7a4†@LOH<h:;@„687<

G< 9;4 6Y:;?@AV7:;M˜6Y?687<vG<O:U?N@aQ@?h9;?@OH<GgD ?N@HV:€<G< €˜_P˜687<{54'ª'?NG:W68Px4Vg4 @x< {JM68PhVYMH4 D$<«_LE64$Vg4

GEHG49}4G'< 4>6874 6s@< </€< €“MG?K6Y</DŽ68:;?@54 @€&V8EHMMH?NGF61[$`I7?AV<MH</?NMH9;<‹J:W687vuE6FEHG'<MA94 @AV\u8?Gl687< :;G9:uY<4†@H€

687< :™G%‹?NGY¢˜:;@v687<vD/?aEH@$68GPG</4†99¡P—:;@K6'<†@a€< €v6Y?:;@K6Y<OG4-6Y<:;@$6Y?&687<J9;?AD/4†9\V?HD :;< 68P}[.`Š7H< :™G):;@K6Y<OG4-6~:;?@

68??¢#M9;4 D$<“:;@hV'</TN<G4 9‹4P}V'QŠ@a?a6C{+E6FE.4 9;9¡P—<–HD 9™ElV:™TŒ< QŠV8E.D 7#4aV%6Y4¢A:;@O#MH4G6q:¡@687<JD ?EH@D :9Ql:;@687<

4KV1V?HD†:U4 6~:U?N@}V'QA:;@687a<9U?AD$4 9}</D ?N@a?A{J:D+4 D-6~:™TH:W6Y:<KV\?G%VEŒD754KVI6Y4¢A:;@LOv4/D 6~:U?N@ˆ68?5€< u8<†@a€+687<MH4 68G~:;{J?A@PNQ

687<˜VD 7a?A?9VS?NGg?K687a<GgME_H9:D’V'<G~TH:D <V-[Io?@K68G4G8P˜6Y?687<u8?G~{J<GgMH<G:;?H€’‹J7a< @’687a<D 7:;9€G< @˜‹J<G1<

:€< 4 99;PV?HD :4 9;:;…L< €+687G?EHO7+687<OGY?EHMHQK687<uY4†{J:9¡PˆE.@:W6I@a?a‹šG<MG<$V<@$6Y< €+687<MG~:™TH:9<OH</€&V<-6F68:¡@LOvu8?G

687<D 7:;9€G< @¦cVC< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@.[•ˆVC4MA9™EHG:4 D 6Y:UTN<>‹J?H{J4 @vuY4G{J<Gl‹J7a?“74/€“_H< < @ˆG< @a?aTN4 6~:;@LO47?EV<u8?NG

(5)

" ! ! # #! " # # %$ # # .

&! ' # ( )*! +#' #,.-#0/ ) $ # 02#1 2

3 " ! !! # # 4$ ### "# ¡¥a[

tH:¡@aD <>687<@:;@H< 6Y:;<V %4{gE}9W6Y:;u8?NG{ {v:;OG4 6Y:;?@

`I7?EHO7’687a<‘V<-6F689;<GVS?Au687<#<K4G9;:<GgMH<G:;?H€h@<TH<GSu8?AG{J< €h7?H{J?NOH<@< ?EVgOG?aEHM}V'QŠ687<vTH4G:< 68Pž?Au

687< :™GCMG?Nu8:;9<aV7a4V_.< < @<TN<†@{?NG<S4 D D < @K6FE.4-6Y< €V~:;@HD$<687<g@:¡@H<-6~:;<$V-[H`Š7:FV94V6I‹4 TH<S?Au{J:;OG4 6Y:;?@Q

OH?:¡@LOx?@&6c?A€4PaQl74V_N< < @G< u89<KD-68:¡@LO687<5€<$<MxD 74 @OH<V:;@687<“ZG'<†@aD 7‘V'?AD :< 68P˜u8?G4 _N?aE6Cu8:u6Y< < @

PH</4GVC4 @€QA{J?G<MG</D:FV< 9¡PaQ687<ˆV?HD†:U4†9.4 @€J< D ?@?H{“:D$4 9HDG:FV:cV£6874 6£74VIG'<†:;@u8?GD < €+687a<:;@H< ©KE.4 9:Ÿ6~:<KVŽ[

=^<KV:€<VQ_.< D 4 EV1<>687a<G<4G<T.<G~P5u8<‹ GE.@€?‹ˆ@J7a?aEV'<KVl6Y?_LEAP“4†@a€+6Y?v€?ˆEHMHQa_N< D 4 EV1<>687a< :¡G\:FV@¦U6s4

9;?6s?NuG<@$6Y4 9A7a?aEV:;@O54 @€ˆ_.< D 4 EV1<?u}687<7KEHOH<:;@HDG<$4KV<:;@ˆ687<MG:;D <?Au£94†@a€J4†@a€“7a?aEV:;@OHQOH< 6F68:;@O

7?EV:;@O :FV @?‹ 687< V86FEH{_H9:;@O _H9;?HD¢ ?uV1< 6689;:@LO :;@ 687< o>XTN<†@@a<VQ‘7a< @D < 687< OG?‹J:;@O

M7< @a?A{J< @?@ ?ux¤ 7KE6F68:;@LO¥$b~9¡:™T.:;@O :;@ MG:¡{5:W6Y:UT.<€‹J< 9;9:;@O}VYd-[ˆ`I7H<oXTH< @@<$Vw{v:;OG4@$6Vž?Au687:V

MH<G:;?H€D 4@_N<w€N:™T.:€< € :;@j687LG< <w{54†:;@ D$4 6Y<OH?G~:U<aVŽ[qZ£:;GV86YQ^687a<hMH< ?NM9U<‹J:Ÿ6~79;?‹ :;@HD ?A{J<Vv‹J7a?

V?{5< 68:;{5<aV<†@a€KEHG<vOG< 4-67a4G€AVY7:¡M}V'QŠ_H?687˜{J4-6Y<G:;4 94@€x<TH< @˜M}V~PND 7?A9;?OH:D/4†9º[l`I7H<Px4G'<&@a?A{J4 €AV'Q

4 TN?A:;€:¡@Ov6c?a‹S@AVq?NG\EG_N4@<–HD 9™E£V:;?N@«4 @€“687<P«4G~G:™T.<ˆ:;@“687<So>XTN<†@@a<V{J4 :¡@H9¡P&4KV4gG<KVE.9W6C?ul687< :™G

D7a4†@HD/< {v</< 6~:;@LOV4 @€ 68G4 TN<†9FV65-[tH< D/?N@a€Q“687<_H<-6F6Y< G /8?uužu~4 {v:9;:<V‡u8?G‘‹S7?A{ {J?NTH:;@O 6Y? 687a<

oXTH< @@<KV«4 @€‡D 74 @OH:;@O|687a<†:³Gv9:u~<$V68P9<‘7H4KVJ_H</<†@ 4‘9U?N@LO#/~D ?@AV:€<G< €wMH94 @aQ{v4 :;@H9¡P u:;@H4 @HD :4 9;9P

V~MH</4¢A:;@OHQ}V?+687<P4G<{J?G<9;:;¢H< 9¡Pˆ6Y?VE.D D/< < €}[L`Š7a<>6F7:;G€JD 4 6Y<OH?G8PJD ?H{_H:;@H<V\?@+687<?@<7a4 @€+687<

MH< ?M9;<>‹J7a?“74T.<D 7?}V<@+6Y?“{J?TH<>6Y?+687a<D ?aEH@$6FGPg6Y?ˆu~:;@H€J4^_N< 66Y<G\©KE.49¡:Ÿ6P5?Hul9;:uY<^_LE6‹ˆ7a?“74TN<†@¦™6

D7a4†@LO}</€’687< :;GS4 D 6Y:UTH:Ÿ6P4 @€Q%?@‘687a<?687<G+7a4†@a€QG<68:™G</€‘MH< ?MA9U<&‹J7?wD/4†{5<&_N4 D¢h6Y?h9;:™T.<:;@‘687H<

uY4†{5:9™P57?EV< QH:¡@g‹ˆ7a4 6EV< €+68?+_N<>687< :™G%V</D ?N@a€4G~PJ7H?EV<?G‹S7?ˆ_H?EHO7K6£47a?aEV'<q687a<G<%7-[

`I7<˜@< ‹“D ?N{5<G1V-¦MG?u8:9<x4†9FV'?„D7H4 @LOH<KV54 D D ?G€:;@Ow68?‘687<#MA94 D <Vg‹J7<G'<&687H<P‚V1< 6689;<x4†@a€‘6Y?‘687<

V?HD :;4 9%@<-6F‹J?G~¢}V-[\t?{J<?Au%687<vTH:994OH<V‹J:W6Y7x4˜V68GY?@OžiAz68G4 €:W6~:U?N@aQs687a4 6:V)6Y?|V4P#6874 6^{J?}V6^?Nu

687< :™G:;@7a4/_H:Ÿ6Y4†@$6V4G~G:UTN< €˜:;@&687a<&V<TN<†@$6~:U<aV^4@a€˜4G<v@a?a‹¨‹<†9;9\<KV86Y4 _H9:FV7a< €˜:¡@#687<vD/?aEH@aD†:;9FVg4 @€˜:;@

6 è Æ Î '´1¹®$±;¯¾ ¶F¹F»¯Ž¶¶¯-¶˜ÐÈí-îïLÔÞ ÛLÔ-Ø.ÙlÝ¡óòØ)ÔÛÜÖ-ßáUÕ1á™Õ68)ÜWïLÔ%õ Ô×Lßvóõ’Õ1ó$Ö-á™×LÝ>ýLÔ-Ö-Ý;áUÛLÔ×$ÛKýóõ‘Ô:9 Ö-Ý¡Þ Õ1á;ó Û ÔÛLÖ-ó$ÞKß~×/ÚÔHÙlÔ-óYÙsÝ;Ôܙó£Ùlßԟõ Ô-ß\ܳïLÔ%Ö-ó$Þ ÛaܙߡòS÷KÔ-Ö×LÞ Õ1ÔÜWï$×ÜßÔUÙsßÔÕ1ÔÛaÜWÕ;8aá;Øq×/Úá™Û$×aܙáUàÔ-Ýòˆó$ßIßÔ×LÝ;Ýò(8™×sÙlݙ×LÖ-ԏølïLÔ-ßÔ

ÙlÔ-óYÙsÝ;Ô Ö×$Û Ý;á™àÔ Øó ýLÔÕ-ܙÝò ܳï$×$Û=<-Õ Ü™ó × Ý™ó ø ßÔÛÜ>8x× àÔÚÔÜW×L÷$Ý¡Ô Ú×Lß'ýLÔÛ=8^õ ߍÔ-Ô Û$×aÜUÞ$ßԐÙsß~×LÖܙá;Ö-ÔÕ?8

á™ÛaÜUÔ-ßßÔ-ݙ×aÜUá;ó Û ÕïLáÙ£Õ@8L÷KÞLÜ ×ݙÕ1óܙó×KÛLó Û1òØáÜòHí%Ìã1ä$ä â†Ï^ÿBA†ÍYÎ

7 `Š7a4 6)D 4-6Y<OH?GP’?Nu)@< ‹ D ?aEH@$68GP#G<V:;€H< @K6VQI:;@D 9™E.€N:;@HO687<V< D/?N@a€‘7?H{J<v?‹ˆ@a<G-VQIu8?NG{¨‹J74 6DCv[

E-</4†@D 4 9¡9FVGF# !/&3 * # !# HJI)b *#- -mQMxk z$d1[

(6)

< D ?9;?OA:FV86VQ6FG'4 €</cEH@:;?@:FV6V'Q68G4 TH< 9<GVwd_H< D$4 EV'<“6F7a</P’?Au8u~<G4 @x< @TH:™G?@{5<†@$6VEHMMH?G68:™TH<5?Au687H<

< –aMG<KV-V:;?A@#?HuŠ687a<S‹4P—?Au%9:uY<“?G)?NuI687<ˆTH4 9™E.<V%687<PEHMA7a?A9;€}[.`Š7a<&V:W6FE.4 6Y:;?@:FV^€N:;u~uY<G< @$6:;@#?a687a<G

TH4 99<P.Vv‹J7<G<hMH< ?MA9;<„V'< 6F689;<h:;@ 4h{J?G<h:;@H€N:™T.:€KE.4 9‹54PaQ‹J7:D†7 €?H<KV@}¦™6JMG<TH< @$6v9U?AD 4 9ˆV'?AD :4K9

@<-6F‹J?G~¢}V68?J€< TH< 9;?M54@€vVYMG< 4 €QA{4†:;@H9¡P54G?aEH@a€vVD7a?A?9V-[

?a‹< TH<GQ+:;@ V~MH:W6Y<„?u“687a<|7a< 6Y<G?OH<@a< ?aEVY@<VV—bV'?AD :;4 9Qˆ< D/?N@a?N{J:D$4†9UQ+OH< ?OG4M7:D 4 9ˆ?G:™OH:¡@aQˆ4OH<

4 TN<G4OH<d—?u“687<wMH< ?MA9U<‹J7a? 74TH<w_H< < @ V1< 6689;:;@O :;@687a<„oXTH< @@<V—u8?NG#u8?NG86FPPN< 4GV'Q687<P 4 9F9

D ?GG'<KV~MH?@€ˆ68?4_H:¡@a4G~P«€N:4OG4 { G<~ª1< D 6Y:¡@LO“EHG~_H4 @59:;u<g4@€54†99:W6V%@$E}:FV14 @D <V'QN‹ˆ7a< 687<G%<–MH<G:< @D/<K€

?Gˆu8< 4G</€wb~4 :™GJ4 @€w@?:FV<MH?A9;9™E6Y:;?N@aQ>:;@AV'<$D EHG:W6PaQ_.4$€‘‹J?G~¢:™@LO‡?NGJ9;:™T}:;@O‡D ?@€:W6Y:;?@}VQ€N:;9™E6Y:;?N@?Nu

V?HD :;4 9h9:¡@¢}V'Qx< 6YDwd„6Y? 687a< D ?EH@K68GPaQ|V'< < @ 4KV‚687<¨4 @K6Y:W687a<KV:FV ?Auh687<¨D :W68P b~©KE.4 9:Ÿ6P ?Auh687<

<@TH:;G?@{5<†@$6YQ}O??H€v9¡:™T.:;@O#D ?N@a€N:Ÿ6~:;?@}VQlV868G~?@O˜V'?N9;:€4 G:Ÿ6FP<-6YD[ÈdI3v<-TH<G687a< 9<$V-VQ}7?‹ MH</?NM9;<S</–aMA94 :@

?GAªEV86~:;uPJ687a<†:;GC€<MH4G6FEHG'<^6c?a‹4G€AV\:FV?A9U4 6Y< €v4G< 4KVC4 @H€687a<†:³G%@< ‹ D 7?A:UD <+?HuI9:uY<+:FV687a4 6YQA{J?G<6874 @

687<vG'<†9U4 6Y< €x©KE.4 9:W68Pž?Au)9:;u~</Qs687a<†:;Gg€<V:™G1<“‹4aV)6Y?‘9;<$4$€x4&9:¡uY<#D ?NGYG<KV~MH?@€:;@O˜6Y?687< :™Gg@<‹ TH4 9™E.<VQ

687G'?aEHO7x4v@a< ‹ G'<†9U4 6~:U?N@HV7:¡M˜‹J:Ÿ6~7687a<<@TH:;G?@{v< @$6YQ‹J:W687x?K687a<GMH< ?M9;< Ql‹J:W687xD ?@AV8E}{5<G:FV{ 4†@H€

‹J:W687g687< :™G\D 7:;9€G'<†@¦FV\< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@.[

p~p / tH< 6689;< €ˆMH4G<@$6VIG< ©KE.<$V6s< €KE.D 4 68:U?N@

tHD 7?H?9I:cV^@?6)4@—</–ND <M6Y:;?@&6Y?&687L:FVGEHG'4†9E.G_H4 @—€N:D 7?68?{ˆP}[`\7<G< u8?G< Q687a<v4@a4†9;P}V:FVg?Au

687<gMG4 D 68:;D/<aV9;:;@¢.< €“68?˜VD7a?A?9;:;@OG< T.< 4 9FV687a<‹J< :;OH7K6C?ul687<ˆ:;{v4OA:;@H4G~P#:€< 4V?uIGEHG4 9£4 @€“EHG_N4K@

9:™T.:;@OHQ«687a< :;{54OH< ?Au˜687< V1D7?H?N9v‹J7:D 7¨:FV‚:W6V'<†9uhTH<G~P 6~:U< € 6Y? 687a< :;{54OH< ?Auž:W6VwMH7P}V:D$4K9

<@TH:;G?@{5<†@$61[`I7<g< €KE.D 4 68:;?@5?Au687a<ˆD 7:;9€G'<†@57<G'<+:FVV< < @54V%?MMH?}V< €+68?ˆ687<g€?N{J:;@H4 @K6ITN4†9™E.<KVC?Au

D ?{ˆMH< 6Y:W6Y:;?N@aQ?u6Y<@ 4KV-V?HD :;4 6Y< €h‹J:W687hEHG~_H4 @‡9:u~< QV~PH{ˆ_H?A9:¡…$:;@O‚:;@H€:UT.:€KE.4 9:;…$4 6Y:;?@„u8?Gˆ687?}V<‹ˆ7a?

u~9< €v:W6YQ.4@€JMH<GD < :™T.< €6Y?“_N<+9<KVVC:;@vGEHG4 94G< 4KVŽ[`Š7H<gMH?ŒVY:W6~:™TN<+:{54OH<VC?AulG8EHG4 9}9:;uY<^687H4 6s74TH<_H< < @

MH4G689™PG<KV~MH?@}V:™_H9<‘u8?GJ< @D ?EHG4OH:;@O‚V<-6F689;< {v< @$6ˆ:;@w687:V54G< 4—4†9FV'?„:;@HD†9™E.€<hVD 7a?A?9Vˆ‹J7:D 7‘‹<G<

V?{5< 68:;{5<aV^:€</4†9:;…$< €_H< u8?G<“MH< ?M9<v9;< u61[`Š7a<Px4G'<€<KVDG:™_.< €˜4$V_H< :;@Ox?u>¤/7KE.{v4 @hV:;…$<¥$Ql7H< @D <

uY4/TN?NGY:¡@LO„687<x7KE.{54†@ :¡@$6Y<G4 D-6~:;?@QG??K6Y< €„:;@h687a<h4G1< 4xb~:;@„MH< ?MH9;<¦cV{5:;@H€dv4 @a€„?MH< @‡?N@w68?|687a<

TH:994OH<J4†@a€«687a<vVEHG~G?EH@€:;@O@H4-6FEHG<[Nf?G<?aTN<GQl€<$V~MH:W6Y<+687<+TH4G:< 68P#?uŠ687a<“@a< ‹JD/?A{5<GV-¦£MG?Nu8:9<V

4@a€?Aul687<ˆD/?N@a€N:W6Y:;?A@HV?Aul687a< :™G{J?NTH:;@O:;@aQ.687a<P#4 99s< –MH<$D 6CD ?{J{J?@“687:;@O}VuG'?A{¨< €KE.D 4-6~:;?@ %687<

D7:9€G'<†@.¦V _H9;?VV?H{“:;@OHQh687< :™G uFG< < €?H{ 4†@a€ 687< :;G V< 9;u /ŽV8E}u8u~:D :<†@aDPHQhTH<G~P ?u6Y<@ D ?@}V:;€H<G< €

<KV1V< @K6Y:;4 9OH?A4 9V?Aug< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@}[35</TN<G687a<†9<KV-V'Q687<˜:;€H< 4 9¡:;…L4 68:;?@w?HuGEHG4 9VD 7a?A?9FVJ4 @€‘687a<MG< D :FV<

€:™G< D 6Y:;?@¨?u’687a< MH4G<@$6V-¦#G< ©KE.:™G1<†{5< @K6V|D ?N@aD <G~@:@O < €KE.D 4-6~:;?@ V'?A{J< 6Y:;{v<$VwMG?TH?¢H< 4 €< <M

€:V:99UEV:U?A@J4 @€J<TH< @JD ?@u89:D 6Vl‹J:Ÿ687+687<>6Y< 4/D7<G1Vl687<{V1< 9™T <KV-[

(7)

687<—< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@w<–.4 {“MH9<˜u8?AD EV'< €‡?N@x687<‘@$E.D 9</4GJu~4 {v:9¡P|4†@a€687a<hVD 7?H?N9V~P.V6Y< { MG<MH4G:;@Oh687H<

Pa?aE.@Ov6c?&:;@$6Y<OG4 6Y<:;@K6Y?“687<SD ?N@HVE.{J<GV'?AD :;<-6P«4KV\‹5< 9¡9£4KV\687<+MH4-E.D†:Ÿ6P«?Au\< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@a4†9Œ?NM68:;?@AV9< €

68?w{J?G<˜uFG< ©KE.< @K6S¤/4†9Ÿ6Y<G@4 6Y:™TH<¥žD ?A9;9< D 6Y:™TH<x< €KE.D 4-6~:?@4 9)</–aMH<G:<†@aD <Vˆ6874@h6Y?H€4 P.[l35< TN<G687< 9<VV'Q

©KE.<KV868:;?N@:;@O 687a< V~P.V6Y< { ‹?aE.9;€ @?6x@a< D <KV1V4G:9;P 9º< 4 € 6c?¨4 6c?K68495G<~ª1< D 6Y:;?N@ ?uhV1D 7?H?N9:;u687H<

€:¡u8uY<G< @D$<KVv_N< 6F‹< <@w687<|V1D 7a?A?9F¦V5M7:9;?V?M7P4 @€„687a<‘MH4G<@K6V-¦g€< {54 @€AVJ‹J4V5@?6+6c??jOLG< 4 6'[

•g9cV'?AQ6874 6£7?}V68:;9;:W68PJ6Y?a‹4G€AVVD7?H?N9V68:;99Œ</–H:FV86V%:;@54+9:{v:W6Y< €ˆ‹J4P.[}tH?A{J<MH4G< @$6VQN‹S:W687ˆ687<7H< 9¡M«?Nu

?K687<GIMH4G<@$6Vl‹J7?J74T.<>687<ˆV4 {5<MH?A:;@K6s?ulTH:< ‹JQH?GOH4@:;…$<6Y?v</€KE.D 4Ž6Y<@$EHGV<G'P“?NGIMG:;{54G~PV1D 7?H?N9

4OH< €JD7:9€G< @QH4 67?{J<[ =E6£7<G<4OH4†:;@aQa687a<KV<< €KE.D$4 68:U?N@a4†9HMG4 D-68:D/<KV\D 4 @ˆ_H<G<-TH<G-V</€«V:;@HD <+V'?A{J<

uY4†{5:9;:<V%¢H< <M#D 7:9€G'<†@«?aEL6\?u%VD 7?H?9u8?G?@9™P#4ˆu8<‹ Pa< 4GVq4†@a€V?A{< 6~:;{5<Vu84 {v:9:<aV{4/P#uY:¡@H4 99P

u~:;@H€ 4V'D†7a?A?9JD ?G~G<$V~MH?@€:¡@LO 6Y?š‹S74-6v687<Pš4G<‚9º??N¢:;@O u8?GQvVE.D7š4aV’o[¡¦8VhV6Y?G8P 4_H?E6#7a<G

€4 EHO7$6Y<G%4-66Y<@a€N:;@OJ687<TH:994OH<“VD 7?H?9 %F # +## 1 /& #' # ' #

#2 3 " H ! F # H " # ! #! !

# " %#+ 0# & # $ 0 0# ' "# !

/ / #', ) "!#& %# G "# +# "

!# 2:( %# ' / #' ! && 2:( !/ %# 3 #

! # H# (H# '! /

•6F6Y<@a€N:;@Ov687H<+TH:994OH<ˆMEA_H9;:DvV1D 7?H?N9}G'<†{54 :;@}V%687<ˆ@H?G~{¨u8?NG687a<ˆ{v4~ª?G:W68P#?Aul687a<«V1<-6689;< €#u~4 {v:;9:<VŽ[

`I7<+MEHMH:9FV¦MH4G< @K6Vq4G~OE.<687a4 6V< @€:;@Ov687< :;GD 7:9€G1<@“6Y?˜VD7?H?N9£4 9;9;?N‹< €&:Ÿ6I6Y?«_N<{54 :;@K6Y4 :;@H< €:¡@

687<“TH:994OH<4Vg:W6:FVJV</<†@’4aV4vMG:{5<vMA94 D <u8?G687<#D7:9€G< @}¦8VˆV?HD :4 9;:;…L4 6~:U?N@x4 @a€‘u8?G687<vMH4G<@K6V

{5< < 6Y:;@OHQH4KVl‹<†99;Q}4KVŠ4>‹J4P5?Au£:;@K6Y<OG4-68:;?N@4†@a€J?Au£4 D 68:;?A@gEHMH?N@+687a<9U?AD 4 9.< @TH:™G?@{v< @$6-[†f|?K687<G\?u

6F‹S?D7:;9€G< @Qlt[AVYMH< 4¢}VC4_H?E6687<+:;{JMH?NGF6Y4@aD <+?u687H<ˆVD 7a?A?9}4$V%uY4G%4$VM.< ?MA9U<¦V\G< 94 6~:U?N@HV7:¡M}VC4G1<

D ?@D <G~@< €%¤ & / #! #* %# #2 1 # ## + #""

#"!$#$ #1 %# !"@ !! # ) % # "1 2H -#1 %#

# ! %B/ + #/ $ , # #*/

# !1## !'& # !(#$( %# & 2! 3 ! I

8r\TH<@J:;uI:W6sD ?@D <G~@}V\?@9UP“4u8< ‹šMH< ?MA9;</QŒV'?N{J<>6Y</4 D7H<GVCV~MH< 4¢54 _N?aE6‹S74 6H687<PD 4 99.4D7H4 ?68:;D VD 7a?A?9;:¡@LO5?AuIV?{v<D7:9€G< @+‹S7?}V<MH4G< @$6V\4G<:;@J<–68G'<†{<MG< D 4G:;?EV%V:W6FE.4-68:;?N@}V'QA:V'?A9;4 6Y< €J?G

‹J:W687SMH<GV?@4 9H€:u8u~:D E.9W6~:<V\b~€G8EHOv4/€€:;D 6Y:;?N@aQA4 9;D/?N7a?A9;:V{ˆd-[

9•6}687a<<@€J?u}687<+V<TN<†@$6~:U<KVQ [ <GTH:;< E«4 @€+=S[ BCX†OH<GI@?K6Y< €ˆ¤ 0# %# # #

)+ %# ) #B ! ! :# # / +)& #B . =!2+! # #

# /' # # ! /0# !H # ) 3 # ! "B #

! "!#/0# #& !1#/I)bkymy0%k -Az/d

(8)

4 9W6Y<G~@a4 6Y:UTN<v< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@a4†9V68G8E.DŽ6FEHG<$VQŒ687a<“MH4G'<@K6V)74T.<v:;@TH<V6Y</€’:;@687<JME_H9:DVD 7?H?9687G'?aEHO7687<

VD 7a?A?9 MH4G< @$6V-¦ 4aV1V?HD :;4 6Y:;?N@}V :;@ ‹J7:D 7 {J?ŒV86 ?Nu 687a< { D 9;?}V< 9¡P D ?9;94/_N?NG'4 6Y< ‹J:W687 687<

VD 7a?A?9W6Y< 4 D7<GVŽ[ < @HD <‘687<P‹?NG~¢‚6c?NOH<687<Gv6c?{5?H€<9+:Ÿ6#?@„687< :;G#<–M.< D 6Y4 68:;?@AVŽ[>p@„687a<‘687G<$<

TH4 99<P.VQ>687<hu8<V86~:™TH<ž4 D 6Y:™TH:W6~:<KV'Q>687<wVD 7?H?N9^?aEL68:;@OV#4@€w68G~:™MVQb{J?G<ž< –MH< @}V:™T.< Q4KVu84G4KVJ687<

68G4@HV~MH?Gc68:U?N@J:FV\D ?@D <G@a< €QA:;@+687a?ŒV'<{J?E.@K6Y4 :;@J4G< 4$V~d%:;@:W6Y:4 6Y< €+_Pˆ687<>6Y</4 D7<GV\4 @€5D 4G~G:;< €J?E6_P

687<‡MH4G<@$6VQJ4G<‚94G~OH< 9¡P uY:¡@H4 @aD < € _P uFE}@a€G4 :FV:¡@O 4 D 6Y:™TH:W6Y:;<Vxb~9;?6F68?Q6c?N{ˆ_H?H9;4 QTH:994OH<{v</4†9FV'Q

G<uFG'<aV7{5< @K6žV6Y49¡9FV'QV7?‹vVwdh?G~OH4@:³…$< € _P 687a< tAD7?H?N9"'s4G< @K6VŽ¦•ˆV-V?HD†:U4 6~:U?N@.[ ?a‹< TH<GQv:W6

:;@TH?A9™T.<KV\{54 @PJ?687<GIMH< ?NM9U<uFG?H{ 687<>TH:;994 OH<[

`I7<G< u8?G< I # 3 H/ !/ %# I:FV4MMG</D†:4 6Y</€“_P“687a<+MH4G< @$6V‹S7?˜V< 6689;<ˆ:@

687<—D ?aEH@$68GP}V:U€A<[lr\–MH<G:< @D :;@Oh687<hV</4aV'?N@HVQ%¢H@?‹ˆ:;@Oh687<x@4 {5<KV5?u68G</<KVQ_H< :;@O‡D 9;?V'<&6Y?‘687<

4@:{v4 9FVQG<KVYMH< D 6Y:¡@LO˜4 @a€9;:UT.:;@O˜:;@v687<J{v:€€N9<J?ul34-6FEHG<J4 G<J€<KV'DG:™_H< €#4KV):¡{JMH?G6Y4@$6%MH4-G4 {J< 6Y<G1V

?u>uY4 {v:9¡P’4†@a€hVD 7?H?N9\</€KE.D 4 6Y:;?N@.[`7<5?NMH<@:¡@O˜EHMž?u687<V'D†7a?A?9\?@K6Y?&687a<v@4 6FEHG49\<†@TH:;G?@{5< @K6

4@a€?N@$6Y?“687<TH:994OH<ˆbc687a<ˆ<–MH9;?G4 68:;?@?Au\€:;u~uY<G< @K6.ª1?a_.VQD 4G~@:™T.4 9FV< 6YDL[ödC:cVq4MMG< D :4 6Y< €“_P&4 99}687<

VD 7a?A?9AMH4G< @K6VI‹J7< @ˆ687<PJ6Y7:¡@L¢:Ÿ6\:cVCG< 4 9F[p86l687KEVCD$?GG<$V~MH?@€AVI6Y?49U?a6Š?Nu£MH4G< @K6VŽ¦€<aV:³G<6Y?vGY??K6

687< :™G^D7:9€G< @¦FV</€KE.D 4 6Y:;?N@—:¡@687<v9U4†@a€&687<Px7a4TH<vD 7a?ŒV'<†@—4KV‹J< 9;9\4V:;@&687a<“MG4/D 68:;D <[E6q?Nu687a<

VD 7a?A?9%:W6V'<†9;uYQŠ687<v6Y< 4 D7:¡@O‚V86Y4u8ug4†@a€h:W6VgG< 94 6~:U?N@HV7:¡Mx‹J:W6Y7˜687<#D†7:9€G<@QI687G?EHO7˜687<MG?NMa?ŒV'< €

< €KE.D 4-68:;?N@H4 94/D 6~:™TH:W6Y:<KVQ4G'<’:;{JMH?Gc6Y4@$6gu84 D 6Y?GVˆ:;@x687<‘V'D7?H?N98¦FVˆG<ME6Y4 68:;?@‰-[I•+9Ÿ687?EHO7w:W6g:FVJ9;<VV

MH?}VV:™_H9<:;@v687a?ŒV'<:FV'?A9;4 6Y< €4G< 4KV\687H4†@:;@#?687<Gq4G< 4KV'QA687<+MH4G'<@K6V{54P#€< D :€<6Y?#D74 @LOH<«V'D 7?H?N9FV

4@a€„<TH< @h6Y?h‹ˆ:Ÿ687€G4 ‹ 687< :™G5D 7:9€G< @„uFG'?A{ VD 7?H?N9‹ˆ7a< @h687<hVD 7?H?9€?H<KVY@¦U6S9;:UT.<EHMw68?h687< :™G

< –aMH<KD-6Y4 68:;?@AV-[)`I7:cV—@<OH4-6~:™TH<hG'<†94 6Y:;?@AV7:;M :FV#{J?NG'<„uFG< ©KE.< @K6«:;@ V'< D ?@€4G~P VD 7a?A?9Vv‹J7H<G<‘687<

< €KE.D 4-68:;?N@H4 9){v<-687?H€AVJ4G<—D ?N@}V:€<G'< €|{?NG<68G4 €:W6~:?@4 9)4 @€‘687<˜G< 94 68:;?@}V7:;M|_N< 6F‹< < @‘6Y< 4 D 7a<GV

4@a€MEHMH:;9FV9<VVsOH?A?H€A[

p~p~p / Z£?GI4+V'D7?H?N9H?MH<@J?@687<?E6V~:U€<

R@€?E_6Y< €9™PHQl687<@< ‹D ?A{5<GVg7a4/TN<D/?N@$68G~:™_E6Y< €68?687a<&:;@HDG</4KV<:;@’687H<@KE.{ˆ_.<Gg?u>MEHMH:9FVS:@

VD 7a?A?9V«4†@a€|6Y?< TH?9™TH<˜687<h€< {54 @€‚u8?G< €KE.D 4-6~:;?@[ ?a‹< TH<GQq687a<|VD 7a?A?9>6Y< 4/D7<G1V74T.<h4 9FV?

‹?NG~¢H</€68?{J4¢H<JVD 7?H?N9FVq4 668G4/DŽ68:™TH<J4 @€“687$EV74TH<JD ?@K68GY:U_LE6Y< €6c?&{4†:;@$6Y4†:;@H:;@O#?NG%:;@HDG'< 4KV:;@Ov687<

@KE.{ˆ_.<G\?uMEHMH:9FVŽ[Kp€</4aVŠ4/_N?aE6£¤/4 9W6Y<G~@a4 6~:™TN<¥g< €KE.D 4 6Y:?N@a4 9A{5< 687a?A€AVl‹7:D 7vV86Y4G6Y< €ˆ9;?@OJ_H< u8?G<>687<

10`I7<MH< ?M9;<:;@K6Y<GTH:< ‹< €J€:€@¦™6V'4PJ49;?K6s4 _H?E6.687< :™G\< –aMH< D 6Y4 68:;?@J?u}687< :™G\D 7:9€G<@¦8V%VD 7?H?9F¦V V6Y4@€4G€AVŽ[j7< @+687<P€N:€QA:Ÿ6ID/?N@aD <G~@a< €QA{J?}V6£?u}687<>68:;{5< Q}V< D ?@€4G'P5VD 7a?A?9FV-[

(9)

V<TN<†@$6~:U<KV-[

`I7<˜€<V:™G1<˜?Au687a<‘@a< ‹JD/?A{J<GV5?u687<hV<TH< @$6~:;<$Vˆ6Y?‘_G< 4¢|‹J:Ÿ6~7x687<hVD 7?H?9/~D < @K6Y<G< €w< €KE.D 4-6~:;?@

V?{5< 68:;{5<aVSD ?H:¡@aD :€</€’‹J:W6Y7˜687<v6Y< 4 D 7<GV¦QC4KVS4«6Y< 4$D7a<Gˆ:;@w4xtH4 9< @a€G:;@H©KE.<&TH:994OH<#4 6F6Y<KV86V0%l¤

2# "!+ )+/ 2)2#" 2 3 . 2 &# %# + #

'J1 ! / ) # )2 0 # # ! " #!@)3/

1! # ## /G 13 # % 1 %#+ + . ! # )

# # & !( %# )@ # ! F ) .I # J !#

%# -# " # ' %1##)+ ! ' %# G! & %#+ #

### ( %# ! # ! . # -#, #+ # 3 # 2H

# . ! 1!# -#0/G %#+ ./ H & #/+ " !# #! 0! /¥[

•g9W6~7a?aEHO7˜687a<< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@a4†9C{v<-687?H€AVˆ4 @a€’687<OH??H€’G'<†9U4 6~:U?N@HV7:¡M}V‹J:Ÿ6~7˜687<v6Y< 4 D7<GVSu~4TN?NG</€—687a<

V<-668:;@O˜:;@—?N@a<ˆMA94 D <ˆG4-687<G%6874 @#:;@#4†@a?a687a<GQ£4«V'D7?H?9¦FVG<ME6Y4-68:;?N@#:FV@?˜9;?@OH<G)< @?EHO7v6Y?¢H< <M

D 9;4VV'<aV^:¡@’4G< 4KV‹J7a<G<687a<v7?EV:;@O˜MH?}VV:™_.:9:Ÿ6~:<KV^4G1< QI4KVgV< < @_N< u8?NG</QŠ9;:{J:W6Y</€}[`Š7H<5D ?aEH@aD :9\D 4 @

<@aD ?aEHG'4OH<MH< ?M9;<‚6Y? V'<Ž6689;<_P¨:;@HDG</4KV:;@O 687< @E.{ˆ_H<G?Nu˜G'<†@$6Y4 94 D D/?A{J{J?A€4-6~:;?@AV4 @€ _HP

€< TN<†9U?NMH:;@OHQA{J?}V6s?Nu6Y<@6Y?OH<687<Gl‹J:Ÿ687+687H<MH4G< @K6V'QŒV1?{J<+u84$D :;9:W6Y:<V\4G?EH@€VD 7?H?N9HbV1D†7a?A?9H{v</4†9FV'Q

4 u6Y<G /V'D7?H?9HD†9ŸEA_VŽ[öd

p@g687<>6F‹S?“pFrqƒV%V86FE.€:;< €Q687<%6Y< 4 D7a<GV\:;@}V:V6?N@687<@a<KD/<KV-V:W68Pˆ_E6s4 9V?ˆ687<€< TN< 9;?NMH{5< @K6

?u6Y< 4 { ‹?NGY¢˜:;@&687a<aV'<v{ˆE}9W6Y:/V<-668:;@OwVD 7a?A?9V‹J7H<G<5€< D ?{ˆM}4G68{J< @K6Y4 9;:;…$4 6Y:;?N@—:cV4†9FV'?’MG'4 D 68:;D </€}[

p~@ž?@<#?Au>687a<†{QŠ687<MG:;{54G~P4†@a€’687a<:;@K6Y<G{5< €:4-6Y<D 9;4VV'<Vˆ4G<«687$ElVgME6)68?OH<Ž687a<Gˆ4@€’6F‹:;D <˜4

‹< <¢HQŠV'<TH<G4 9£OG?aEHM}V)4G<“u8?G{J< €v6Y?˜4Ž66Y<@€#D 94KV-V<KV^:¡@v687a<vu:;@H<54G6VQIV~MH?Gc6VYQl{+EV:D QIVD :< @HD <J4†@H€

687< gD D :W6Y4 @v94 @OE.4OH<[•gD D/?NG€:;@OJ68?687a<^6Y</4 D7<GVQN687a4 6\uEV:;?A@5?AuI9<TH< 9FVCbMH<G{54 @< @K6\:;@5?N@a</~D 94VV

VD 7a?A?9Vg4 @€x9:{“:Ÿ6< €x:;@˜prqƒV'QUd7a< 9¡M}V)687<D 7:9€G< @6Y?˜_H< D ?{J<:;@H€<MH< @€H<†@$6YQs_N?K687x:¡@’4†@a€x?aEL6)?Nu

VD 7a?A?9F[xƒg<@H<G4 9;9¡P VYMH< 4¢H:;@OHQhMH4G< @K6V 9;:;¢H< 687:FV :;@H€<MH< @a€<†@HD/<[ Cˆ<-6YQh:W6 V</<†{V6Y? _H< 9<KV-V

4MMG</D†:U4 6Y< €:¡@xV</D ?N@a€4G~PxVD 7?H?9V%‹J7<G<JD†7:;9€G< @#4 G<ˆ4KVY¢H< €v6Y?€L?“687<vV4 {5<687:;@O}V)4 6I687<vV'4†{5<

68:;{5<[\`?‡<@9:;OH7K6Y<@x687<xu~4 D-66874 6)687<˜D 7:9€¦cV5:;@H€< MH<@€< @HD <&‹4VJ@?6TH4 9™E.< €w:¡@h6Y7<hV'< D ?@€4GP

VD 7a?A?9}?ul687<g4G</4ˆ4KV%:Ÿ6\:cV%_P«7<G1V1<†9;u\4 @€7<G%D ?H9¡9< 4 OE.<KV'Q}?@<g?Nul687a<prqƒ VD 7a?A?9;{v:FV68G<$VVC©KE.?a6Y<$V

‹S74 6)V~7H<J€<KV'DG:U_.<$V)4aV_H< :;@O F & # ##*H#B # !G! # +/

#( ! 3/ %# 2 %# & # 3 %I,I ! !# 3 0# # %#H#&. / +

2#" # & ! ! ! ! %# J # 2) 0 #B ' ! #

!! 2-# %#+ # #2)G #B !# # %# # %#

/# ) ! #!! # ## # / $+#B "#"# ! ## .#0/

(10)

!! 1 '/& # H " " I

tHD7?H?9VJ7H4TH<˜4 9FV?wOH?N@a<˜:¡@$6Y?|MH4Gc68@a<GV7:;M}VQ{J?NG'<˜?NGS9;<KV-VˆG'<OE}94G9™P 4KVg687<˜D$4KV'<’{54Pw_.< Q‹J:W6Y7

V?{5<˜4KV-V'?AD :;4 6Y:;?@AV5bG8EHG4 9D ?A{J{ˆE}@:Ÿ6P‡7a?A{J<VQo>:;@.< D ?}‰~‰ºQC687a<&68G4 TN< 9¡:;@OwMH94†PLG?H?N{JQ{ˆEV:D/4†9^4 @€

V~MH?GF6)4KVV'?AD:;4 6Y:;?N@HV~d-[•¨9;?6?uVD 7a?A?9;{v4V86Y<GV^4G<“¢H</<@˜?@6Y4¢A:;@LO687< :™G)MEHMA:9cV^?E6?uVD 7a?A?9I4 @€

?MH<@:;@O‚687< :;G{5:;@H€ 6Y?„687a<w?aEL6V~:;€<h‹J?G~9;€‚_H<$D 4 EV1<‘687a<P„687:;@¢‚6874 6«:W6:FV#@?65?@9™P 4‘‹J4P‚6Y?

D ?{ˆMH< @}V4 6Y<hu8?G“687a<w<@HD 9;?}V:¡@O ?uˆ687<w4G</4 Q^_LE6J{54 :¡@H9¡P _.< D 4 EV1<w:W6:VQg4 D D ?G€:;@O‚6Y?|687a<†{Q+4

@</DK<$VV:W68P#4Vu84G4Vq< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@:cVqD ?@D$<G~@a< €}[p~@€H< < €Q4 9W687?EHO7vMH4G< @K6V4@€“6Y< 4 D7H<GV{5< @K68:;?@“687H<

:FV?A9U4 6~:U?N@J?HuŒ687a< :™GŠTH:994OH< QH:W6s€?A<KVY@}¦™6s4MMH< 4Gl6c?_H<>687a<{4†:;@JG< 4$V?@“u8?G\{J4¢H:¡@Oˆ687a<V'D†7a?A?9H?MH<@< €

?@687a<+?E6VY:;€<[p86I:FV%{J?G<g4+©KE.<$V6Y:;?N@5?Aus< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@4 94 €TH4 @$6Y4OH< Q}?uI4ˆV?EHGD <g?Nus€<TH< 9;?MA{5< @K6\u8?G

687<JD7:9€G< @QŒ‹74 6Y< TN<G%687<5D ?N@$6Y< –6q{J4P_N< Ql:FV?A9;4-6Y< €?G@?K6'[ @v687:cV)4$D D/?aEH@$6YQ.687a<ˆMH4G68:;D :;M}4-68:;?A@

?u687a<’MEHMH:;9FVv:;@w687<’TH:994OH<x4 D 6Y:™TH:W6Y:<$Vv:FV«4KVv{ˆE.D 7 4MMG< D :;4 6Y</€_P ?@<x4 @€‡4 994$Vˆ687<|V'D 7?H?N9

?E68:;@O}V'QA?G}687<+VD 7a?A?9_H:94 6Y<G'4†9H<-–.D†7a4 @OH<KV'QA?uuY<G:;@Oˆ687<D7:9€G< @J4D7a4†@LO}<L[

`I7?}V<<–68G4 /~D EHG~G~:UD E}94Gg4/D 6~:™TH:W6Y:<KVS4G<#4 9cV'?h?MM?Gc6FEa@:W6Y:<$Vˆu8?GˆV?HD†:U4†9:;@K6Y<G4 D 68:;?@}[£`7a4 6‹J4KVSD 9< 4G

<@a?aEHO7ˆ‹J7a<†@aQA?@J4ˆV1D 7?H?N9;{J:FV68G<KV1V¦cVC:;@A:W6Y:4 68:™T.<4 @€“‹J:W687g687<+7a<†9;M5?Aus4D ?A9;9< 4OEŒ<uFG?H{ B\Pa?A@Q687<

prqƒ ?uI687<+ZG< @D 7S4 9¡9< P#4 @€#4vVD 7?H?N9£:;@v687H<SBC?@Oˆ4 9;9</P—bFBC?N…G<dV< 6IEHM—4@#< –ND 74 @OH<+‹J:W6Y7

687<BC4 €4¢H74@a€“f‡?@OH?A9;:40%A`I7<ˆ:;@7H4_H:W6Y4@$6V?ul687<ZG'<†@aD 7“TH:994OH<VbMEHMH:;9cV¦MH4G<@K6V?G%@a?K6Fd%MEL6

EHM< :™OH7K68P54 €KE.9W6VC4 @€ c?NGCD7:;9€G< @vuFG?A{ 687?}V<gu8?NG< :™OH@5D ?EH@K68G~:<KVŽ[`Š7a<+@<–L6IP</4GQ}:W6l‹4KVI687<P?EH@O

o<TH< @@<KV\:;@7H4_H:W6Y4 @K6VŽ¦N6FEHG~@68?JO?687a<G<[

p/ `I7<+V'?AD :;4 9H:¡@$6Y<G4 D-6~:;?@J4G'?aEH@a€«V'D 7?H?N9F[

p~@x687<˜4G'< 4&‹S7<G<687<G<‹J<G'<˜4@€‘687a<G<‘V86~:;9;9)4G<˜{54 @P‡@< ‹ :;@7H4_H:W6Y4 @K6V'QŠ687<—D ?N{J{ˆE.@:W6P9:u~<

V~7a?a‹5V54˜OG< 4 6gTH:W6Y4 9;:W68P}[ 'C[Š]^<TH?A9)b *#- -!*d54 _N?aEL6687<ZG< @D 7S4 99<P 4†@a€|•J[I]:™T.:G</?N@@a<OH<G

bkyyAz$dž4 _N?aEL6687<„BC4KV4 9;9<€N:FV68G:;D-6x€< {J?@AV868G4 6Y<h6F74-6687a<jMGY?M?Gc68:;?@ ?u˜{J< {ˆ_.<GV7:;M 4 @a€ ?Au

MH4G68:UD†:;MH4 6Y:;?@ uFG?{ 687< @a< ‹ :;@7H4_H:W6Y4 @K6V :;@ 687a< 4$VV?HD :;4 6Y:;?@}V‚:FVwTH<G~P 7:;OH7Q˜{J4 :;@A9;P :¡@¨687<

4KV1V?HD†:U4 6~:U?N@}V9;:;@¢H< €&6Y?xVD7a?A?9V ‰” [`I7<54KVV'?AD :;4-6~:™TH<JMH4 G68:;D :;MH4 68:;?@G<TN< 4 9cV687<JMH?NME.9;4 6Y:;?@¦cV^€<KV:;G<

11`IG4 TN<†9;9:¡@OJMG?-ª< D-6~:;?@AVŠ?Aulu8:;9{V\:¡@ˆ687a<ƒ+4G'€“4@€+BC?N…G< S4†9;9<P}V\:;@+687<oXT.< @@<KVŽ[

12

-#)+) .#( : ) ( ) /& ! ! ! 1!# # +

#* ! % !# 4! ! !#! 2) H !JI 2)

(11)

4@a€ V~MH?G6V~dYQJ4„M?9;:W6~:UDK4 9J?@< b@H4 68:;?@H4 9J4VV?HD :;4 6Y:™TH<‚{J?T.<†{5< @K6VYdx4@a€ ?N@š4@ < D/?N@a?A{J:D/4†9?N@H<

bOGY?aEHM:;@LO‡?AuMG?H€KE.D <GV'Q%?Nug?G~OH4@:UD’u8?H?H€Q%D ?9¡9< D-6~:™TH<TN<OH< 6Y4 _H9<OH4G'€<†@}V wd-[\`Š7:VJ:¡@T.<$V6Y{J< @K6

€?H<KV~@.¦U6s4MMH< 4Gl6Y?_H<4>‹:W6~7a€G4 ‹4 9;QA?@+687H<D ?@K68G'4GPaQ}:W6I:FV\?u6Y<@ˆ687?EHO7K6s?ul4$VŠ_.< :;@O9;:;@¢.< €+6Y?S687a<

¤OA9;?_H4 9;¥ˆ{5<†@$6Y4 9¡:Ÿ6PaQ687KE£Vu8:W6F6Y:;@Oˆ687<+{?a668?¥687:;@¢5OA9º?a_N4†9;9;PQ.4 D 6I9U?AD 4 9;9¡Pa¥$QH4+{J?668?ˆ‹J:;€< 9¡P“D†94 :{5< €

_P 687a< @< ‹5D/?A{J<GVŽ[v`I74-6w4-_EH@€4 @HD < ?už4KV-V?HD :;4 68:;?H@AV‡@?6x?@9™P 7< 9;M}V„:;@$6Y<OG4 68:;?@ _E649FV?

< –aMG<KV-V<VI687<g€:¡uYu~<G'<†@$6IMa?N:;@K6VC?ulTH:< ‹ 4 @€687a<ˆD ?@u9:D 6VI_H< 6F‹< < @ˆ687<+:;@7H4_H:W6Y4 @K6VC4 6Š< TH<G~P59<TH< 98[

@“687<S?K687<G%7a4 @€QA687<ˆD/?N@HV<@}V8EV?Au6Y<@«D ?@D <G@HVV1D7a?A?9}_H< D 4-ElV'< Q4 6\9;< 4KV86%:;@J687<+MH?9;9</€4G< 4 Q:W6

G<MG'<KV<@$6V>_N?a687#4ˆMH94 D <+6Y?‘V?HD:;4 9:¡…†<v4 @€#4ˆMA94 D$<J?AuD ?9;94/_N?NG'4 68:;?@v‹J7H<G<ˆMH< ?MA9U<“D/4†@—{v</< 6‹S7?

@?G{J4 9;9¡Pˆ‹?aE.9;€ˆ@?6£:;@K6Y<G4/D 6}‹S:W687J?@<4@a?a687a<G ‰œ

•JVI=ˆ[S4P}V<G%@?K68:D <KVC¤# !/ # :# #H1" %1"! ! " &

3 " # +) ##/ #1# 3 ! !# ! ! #

3 !+/ &+ + ! @ ¥[abS4P}V<GQ~kyynQAMIk z$d-[• VD7a?A?9;{54KV6Y<G\‹J?G~¢:™@LO:;@?@H<ˆ?ul687<

VD 7a?A?9VTH:cV1:W6Y< €#{v< @$6~:;?@AV6874-6%uY< €<G4-68:UT.<ˆG?H9;<J?Au>V1D 7a?A?9V %F2-#. ! ,! .3 #

!J !! #' !# #0/ #! $ &# % ##:-# ! #0/ # # ##

!"'J! G &#/ %# + ! 2#0/1$#B # 0##

#/ & # 3 / ) -# #* # ) & ' &

!% / #! # !% # 3 !4 ! # %#+ I+p~u

€:UTH:FV:;?H@}V%< {5<G~OH<g4 {J?A@LO“687<g€:¡uYu~<G'<†@$6IOGY?aEHM}VŠ?NuI:;@H74_H:W6Y4 @K6VCuFG?A{ 68:¡{5<6Y?68:;{5< QAMH< ?M9<V'< < { 6Y?

_H<G'< D ?@D :9< €J4 6}687a<+VD7a?A?9OH4 6Y<¥a[

35< TH<G8687< 9<aV1VQVD 7?H?N9)D 4 @ 4 9cV'?|_H<x4wV?EHGD <˜?u6Y<@}V:;?N@}VŽ[%`I74 6g‹4KVˆ687<xD 4KV'<‘:;@ kyy -‹J7a< @‚4

VD 7a?A?9IuFG?A{ 4†@a?a687a<GD/?N{J{ˆE}@:Ÿ6P‹54 @$6Y< €&68?_N< D ?{5<“MH4G86)?Nuq4†@—< €KE.D 4-6~:;?@4 9IOG?EHMH:¡@LO6874-674 €

_H</<†@ž:;@‡</–H:FV86Y<@D <#u8?NG6Y<@‘PN< 4GVŽ[I`7a<< €KE.D/4 6~:U?N@ž4E687?G~:W6FP˜687LG< 4 6Y<@H< €’6Y?wD9U?ŒV'<«687a<’V'D†7a?A?9C4†@H€

MG?M?}V< €EH@:W6Y:;@Ož:W6‹J:W6Y7687<<–H:FV6Y:;@Oxprqƒ“[£`Š7a<&:;@H74_H:W6Y4 @K6V)‹J<G'<€N:™T.:€</€}[tH?h4$V68?˜G<ª1< D-6>687a<

MG?M?}V49V'?A{J<‚:;@7H4/_H:Ÿ6Y4†@$6Vx4GYOE.< €6874 65687<‚€:FV6Y4@aD <|6Y? VD7a?A?9+‹?aE.9;€ _H<‚:;@HDG< 4V'< €}[ ^687a<G

MH4G<@K6V\4OG'< < €+‹J:W687+687H<4-E687?G~:W68PJ< :W6Y7<GI_H</D 4 E£V<>687H<PJD/?N@}V:€<G</€S687a4 6sD 9;?ŒV:;@LOv4ˆVD 7a?A?9‹J:W6Y7J@?6

p~@g687<>BC4KV'4†9;9<€:cV868G:;D 6YQ ?Au}687<@a< ‹ €K‹< 99< GVl_N<†9U?A@Oˆ68?J?@<)?NG\V< TN<G4 9}4$V-V?HD†:U4 6~:U?N@HV\Q

EVE.4 9;9¡P“DG< 4 6Y</€S_Pg687<< 9€<KV86 ) +! # % =

13 Z?NG^< –H4 {ˆMH9< QI4 9¡9l687a<“MH< ?M9;<ˆ‹J<¦¡TN<v{v<-6YQ‹ˆ:W687—?G‹J:W687a?aE6qD7:;9€G< @MG?TH:;€< €‹J:W6Y7‘V'D†7a?A?9;:;@OHQ 74TN<+{5<†@$6~:U?N@a< €687a<MG<MH4G4 68:;?@5?Nu687<_H:94 6Y<G'4†9.<–.D74 @LO}<g4@€ˆ687<‹J< 9D ?A{<+?uIu8?NG'<†:³OA@5D 7:9€G< @

4@a€“4/€KE}9W6VŠ4KV\:¡@$6Y< @AV<{J?A{5< @K6VŠ?NuIV?HD:;4_H:9:W68P54 @€JD ?9;94_N?NG4-68:;?N@.[

(12)

‹<G<„V<TN<G4 9687:;@O}V—4 6#V6Y4¢H<w4@€„687<w:;@K6Y<G'<aV86Vv‹<G<w€:¡u8uY<G< @K6«4 D D/?NG€:;@O‚6Y?MH<?M9;<¦cVxV6Y4-6FEV

bcrC9;< D 6Y</€vMH< ?NMH9;< Q}MH4G'<†@$6VQ4@a€“6Y< 4 D 7<G1VQ™d‹S7H<G<687a</P#9:™T.< €QA687<+_H?@€}V%_H< 6F‹< <@v687a<+TH:9;94†OH<$VQA687<

4 668:W6FE.€<&68?‹4G€AV+687a<˜MH4G6S?u687a<—TH:;994O}<˜MH?MEH9;4 6Y:;?N@h6Y?h_H<x:;@K6Y<OG4-6Y< €Q7?‹ {+E.D 7h687<˜MH4G<@K6V

4MMG</D†:U4 6Y<687<6Y< 4 D7a<GVˆ‹?NGY¢‚<6YDK[\p~@wMH<G~:U?A€AV5?uˆD G:V:FVQ%687<hVD 7a?A?9)D 4 @‡4†9FV'?‚DG< 4-6Y<˜?GJG< TH:™TH<

6Y<@HV:;?N@}VŠ4†{?N@LO687a<:;@7H4_H:W6Y4 @K6VŠ4KVI{+EŒD 7J4KV\:W6sD 4@+EH@:Ÿ6Y<>687< { 4OH4 :;@}V6s4D ?{“{?A@J4 €KT.<G1V4G~P.[

o?N@aD 9WEV:;?A@

`7<Ju~4 {J:9:<V)€:;€@¦U6qD7?H?}V<6c?&{J?TH<+6Y?#4@#:V?A9U4 6Y< €GEHG49IV<-6F68:¡@LO‘V'?A9;< 9¡P—u8?G>G'< 4KV?@AV7a4TH:¡@O68?

€?“‹S:W687VD 7?H?N9;:;@O[ J?‹J<-TH<GQH:W6l‹4KVC?N@a<+?u687a<V868G~?@LOH<V6\4G~OEH{J< @K6VŽ[Kf‡4@PM}4G'<@K6VI‹S7?v74TN<+4

@<OH4 6~:™TN<vMA:D 6FEHG<5?Nu%EHG_N4 @hVD 7?H?9cV'QŠu8?G?@<vG'< 4KV?@ž?Gg4@?K687a<GQ687L:¡@L¢˜687<P˜‹J:;99Cu:;@H€x?NGg49™G< 4 €P

74TN<’u8?E.@€w4 @‡< €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@4 9)< @TH:™G?@{v< @$6ˆ{J?G<˜9;:;@A¢H< €‘6c?‘687< :™GJ<–aMH< D 6Y4 68:;?@}VJ:;@‚V{54†99)D ?aEH@$68G~P

VD 7a?A?9V-[.`Š7a<&V'< 6F68:;@O—?AuMG:;{54G~PhV'D 7?H?N9V'QŒ687a<†:;GV{54K99V:;…L<“4 @a€«687a<E.@:;?N@—?u687<J€:¡uYu~<G'<†@$6%OG'4 €<

9<TH< 9FV%4MMH< 4Gl68?ˆ_H<MH?}V:W68:™T.<D ?@€:W6~:U?N@}V'Qa_LE6I4 9;?@<4 G<@a?a6<@?EHO7+68?5<@AV8EHG<4OH?H?A€“V'D7?H?9¡:;@Oˆ6Y?

687< :™GqD7:9€G< @e687a<†:;G€< {J4 @a€ŒVqD ?N@aD <G@:;@O#¤ ?MH<@¥J</€KE.D 4 68:;?@H4 9{5< 687a?A€AVq4@€vOH?H?H€“G<9U4 6~:U?N@HV7:¡MV

_H<-6F‹J< < @ˆ687<gD7:9€G'<†@54 @€ˆ687< :™GI6Y< 4 D7a<GVC4 9FV?vOE.:;€<687< :™G\G< 9;4 6Y:;?@AV7:;M“‹:W6~7V'D†7a?A?9FV-[`I7<MH4G<@K6V

4@a€ 687< :;GwD 7:;9€G< @¦cVžG< 94 6~:U?N@HV7:¡M ‹J:W6Y7 V1D 7?H?9< TN?A9™TH< 4 9;?H@O ‹J:Ÿ6~7 687<PN< 4GV?NuwV'D†7a?A?9;:;@OHQ

:;@K68G?H€KE.D:;@Ow@H<-‹ < €KE.D 4 6Y:;?@4 9:cV-V8E.<Vˆ:;@„V'< D ?@€4G~P‚V'D 7?H?N9VŽ[%tH?N{<&M.< ?M9<v687:;@¢x6874 6)687<˜V{v4 9F9

V:;…$<?uq687a<vMG:¡{54G~Pž4 @a€V'<$D ?N@a€4G~PwVD 7a?A?9Vg:FVg4 @h4/€KTH4 @K6Y4OH</Qs‹S7:9<?687<GMH<?NM9<“687:;@¢˜687a4 6:;@

V</D ?N@a€4G~PxVD 7?H?9:Ÿ6%:FV)4J€N:FV'4 €aT.4 @$6Y4OH<‹J7a<†@aQuY4GuFG1?N{ < @74 @D :;@Ov687<J?MH<@:;@O&‹:W687v687<ˆ?E6V:;€<

4@a€«687a<“:;@K6Y:;{v4$DP‹J:W687v687a<+6Y< 4 D7H<G1VQl:W6)V< < {V%68?—D?@u~:;@H<+687<JD7:9€G< @:;@—4@H4G~G?‹ <@KTH:;G?@{5< @K6

4@a€:;@x€N:FV86Y4@K6CG< 9;4 6Y:;?@AV7:;MV%‹:W6~7v687a< :¡G%6Y< 4/D7H<GVŽ[}•+9™687?EHO7v687<J9;?@Ox€4 :9;P—D ?A{J{ˆE6Y<KV_P_LEV?G

9:™T.:;@Oh4-6>_N?A4G€:;@OwVD 7?H?9Vg4G<?u6Y<@_N?NGY@<4KVg7</4/TP‘D ?N@HV68G4 :;@K6V^u8?NGˆV'< D ?@€4G~PžVD 7?H?N9IMEHMH:;9FV1Q

687<$V<ˆD ?@AV:€<G'4 6~:U?N@HV4_H?E6IG<9;4 6Y:;?N@HV7:;MVq?NGC< €KE.D 4 68:?@b6Y<@AV:U?A@AV%_N< 6F‹J</<@“687a<ˆD7:9€G< @«4†@a€“687< :™G

6Y< 4 D7<GV'Qa_.4/€G'<†94 68:U?N@}V7:;M}VI_.< 6F‹< <@+687a<+D 7:;9€G< @QH€A<MG'< D :;4 6Y:;?N@?Au}687<< €KEŒD 4 6Y:;?@4 9}{5< 687?H€AV\< 6YDL[öd

‹?aEH9;€ V?H{J< ‹J7H4 6j< –aMA94 :;@ 687<¨D 7?A:;D$<¨?u‚7?A{< VD7?H?N9;:;@O u8?G V'?N{5<¨D 7:;9€G'<†@.[˜ƒg< @<G4 99P

V~MH</4¢A:;@OHQŠ687a<&OH4M‘_H<-6F‹J< <@’687a<</€KE.D 4 68:;?@4 9<–MH</D 6Y4 68:;?@AVS?Au687<@< ‹D ?A{J<GV6Y?hoX TH< @@a<aVS4@H€

687<JVD 7?H?N9IV:W6FE.4-6~:;?@“6Y<@€}V6Y?v_H< D ?{5<ˆ€< <M.<G:;@˜V1< D$?N@a€4G~P˜V'D†7a?A?9V'Q7< @aDK<SD ?N@$68G4KV868:¡@LO&‹:W687v687<

VE_ª1<$D 68:™T.<›V14 68:FVuY4 D 6Y:;?N@ ?Au 687< M.4G< @K6V D/?N@aD <G~@:;@O 687< TH:;994 OH< MG:;{54G~P V'D 7?H?N9F[ `7a<†:;G

:;@TH?A9™T.< {5< @K6£:;@+687<+V'D†7a?A?9H:cVs@?6I4$V%VF68G~?@OHQ@< :W687a<G:FVl687a<>_H?@€+_H<-6F‹J< < @+687a<+VD7a?A?9H4 @€+687<4G< 4[

(13)

/ •+9;MH<Cv[ŸQIo%74 {JMH?A9;9:;?H@ 'C[ŸQZGY?N{J4~ª?EH–]S[/~o[ŸQ '£?N:³G<P E /cB)[ŸQIb~D ??G€}[ÈdYQ *#- -lk-Q #"

# ! "! - ! ! # %&!#$ #$Q

=^<KV4 @/?N@&%'lG'<KVV'<KVlRJ@:™T.<GV:Ÿ6Y4†:;G<$VŠZŒG4@HD/~D/?N{+6Y?:FV<KV[

/ •+9;MH<*C5[WQ*#- -nQ+B)¦_V<G'TN4 6Y?:™G<ˆ€<ˆ98¦Ur>D ?N9<]EHG4 9º< QAEH@<ˆ@?ET.< 9¡9<J4MMG?HD7a<ˆ€A<$VVD ?A9U4G:W6YXKV

<@J{J:9:< E5GEHG'4†9Q + ! ! ! $ @ gkn!,HQ 's4G~:VQHoŠ3 '%[

/ •+9;MH<v[C¨<-6 E/cB)[Z£4 EHOE.<-6YQ *#- -iQ+fžE6Y4Ž68:U?N@}Vq€<KVuY?G~{J<KVV'D ?A9;4 :;G<KV)< 6\G'4MMH?Gc6Vq4 E6Y<G8G~:W6Y?:™G<

€<KVJX 9TH<VˆG8EHG4 E–wD ?H9¡9U?A©KE.<+BC<KVJ{J?A@a€A<$VˆGEHG4E–‘98¦XMG< EHTH<x€<KVVD :< @D$<KVV'?AD :;4 9<VQ

J:ª?A@˜km /ky{54 : *#- -i}[

/ =^?N@:;@:}3#[}<-6o%9;4T.4 :™G?A9;9<ZŠ[WQ*#- -LQJo%7a4†@LOH<G)€}¦<VMH4 D/<MH?EHG%TH:™TG<J{“:< EH– %}< 687L@?A9U?NOH:;<J€<V

ˆ@?ET.< 4 EH–w7a4/_H:Ÿ6Y4†@$6VJ€<KVoX/T.< @@a<KVQ>:;@&%lZ£9<-E}G<-6Jt[Ib~€:™GYd(!! # % ! #)

$Q!'G<$VV<$V\€<98¦™E}@:™T.<G1V:W6YX€}¦•g@OH<G-VQMM *Hny!/ * ,Hi}[

/ =^?aEªE/Yƒ+?E ª'?N@w•J[ŸQ *#- -nQJo7?:™– €<’98¦FX/D ?A9;<x€4 @AV59;<V5<KV~MH4/DK<$VˆGEHG4-EA–Œ[sBq<KV5< @-ª1< EH–‡€<‘94

D ?@AV68G8E.DŽ68:;?@h9U?AD 4 9<€KEwG'4MMH?NGF6&98¦X D ?A9U< + ! ! ! ! $ %@ ˜kn!,HQ 's4G:FVQ

oI3 'C[

/ o%7H4†{SMV'4 EHG 'C[b~D??G€dQlkyyAzLQ % # :)+% Q 's4GY:cV'QNpº3])• Fpº3tr\r[

/ Z\[Ho>9;4T.4 :™G?H9¡9< *#- -AzLQ <ˆ94ˆD ?@K6Y<KV86Y4Ž68:;?@ˆ94+MH4G868:D :™MH4-6~:;?@&%A9;<VC@HX ? /8GEHG4 E–&< 6I9;4gMH?A9;:W6~:©KE.<

b~oX TH< @@H<KVYdQJ:¡@ %=<G687< 9< E «[ˆ< 6=^?EHG€4G~:;4$V˜Z%[gb~€:³G~d 2 # % !# 2 #

†Q`I?aEHGV'Q 'R+Z}]S[

/ +B^¦X D/?A9;<GEHG4 9;</QaEH@a<X D ?A9;<€}¦º4/TN< @:™GaQ #H %@ %niLQ-ªE.:¡@xkyyAzH[

/ J<@G:;?6 / ˆ4@ C4@$6Y<@v•J[ŸQkyAz LQB"!X/D ?A9;<g< @v{J:9:<-E#GEHG49 %GX 4 9;:W6YXV%<-6IG<MG'XKV<@$6Y4 68:;?@AV'Q )

## # †QN@ 1mn}[

/ J<GTH:< EJ=ˆ[ŸQ +:4G'€4E/[ŸQ *#- -lk/[$ %#2 /' ABC4)`?EG\€}¦;•+:³OE.<aV'Qarq€:W6Y:;?@}V\€<9º¦•EA_.<L[

/ J<GTH:< EJ=ˆ[ŸQBCXOH<G «[ŸQlkymyA[% !'&G ! 2%(' ! "#(' !)! ;Q 's4-G~:FVQtH< E}:;9F[

/ J<GTH:< EJ=ˆ[ŸQBCXOH<G «[ŸQlkymAz[$¤>BC<KV\:;{v{5:¡OG'XKV\€<9¦™E6Y?M:;<¥$Q*( #Q@ $k, % ,}z /~iy}[

/ + ! ! $Q@ %m!*HiQ-ªE}:99< 62*#- - -}[

/ E-< 4 @C5[WQ#*#- -nQ,+rqD?N9;<V\GEHG4 9;<$V-[ J:™T.<G1V:W6YXV'?AD :;4 9<ˆ€<KVV868GE.DŽ6FEHG'<KVVD ?9;4 :™G1<KVC< 6\€<$VMa?N9;:W6Y:©KE.<V

{ˆE}@:D :;MH4†9<VaQ- + ! ! ! $ .@ $k n!,HQ!'s4G~:V'QAoI3 'C[

/ E-< 4 @GCv[Hb~€:™G~dQ # # #* !2.( H % #!$ - Q 'I4G~:FVQAr€:W68:;?@}V

M7LG~P}VQ *#- -m}[

/ S4P}V1<Gl=S[ŸQŠkyy -H[/ " #: # ! $Q 's4G:V'QA•G~{54 @€Jo?A9;:;@}[

/ ! # #+) H¤0EH:W6F6Y<GI9;4>TH:99<¥$Q@ *Ik$[

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to