HAL Id: hal-00001852
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00001852
Preprint submitted on 26 Oct 2004
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Statistical analysis of correlations and intermittency of a turbulent rotating column in a magnetoplasma device
Simone Magni, H. E. Roman, C. Riccardi, Th. Pierre, D. Guyomarc’H, P.
Devynck
To cite this version:
Simone Magni, H. E. Roman, C. Riccardi, Th. Pierre, D. Guyomarc’H, et al.. Statistical analysis of correlations and intermittency of a turbulent rotating column in a magnetoplasma device. 2004.
�hal-00001852�
brought to you by CORE View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
provided by Archive Ouverte en Sciences de l'Information et de la Communication
021 +3
1
!"(54#67(
1
*,89&;: <6(!-(=> <*?A@!BC !
DFEHGJILKNMOQPSRTUE+VEHWXNY2ILM-PZR[CEFW\O^]_]`ILa9bOcPZRde-Ef<O^g_aha9gLPjiklEHm>noNXNY2ILa9]Lpje-PqiCILMbJfrEHkg_s'oM]ut'v
wyx{z}|~LQz Lz<z^zch~J" zLyzH~Lzz~L czcuuh~
z~u~~-zc ~ ¡£¢¤L¥L¢¦§¨z~L ª©c~LZ«
¬u-~¯®9~L zy
©9©u°{±r²³5´) zLuz´
uL uu¥N ¯ 'µ¶·¸~Lyz^u(h~L u
¹yºCuz~Lzc »¼½9~L·±r»¾ºxC³¿±r´±r»²&À±~¯¯~L9~uÁu
¥N '¥¤¡Â5+
~L¼½C)h§x{¼9~L uu9~L u
ÃÅÄ¿Æ`ÇÈÉʾ˿ÌyÇÍÎÈuÏ¿ÐÒѯӽÐ`ÔÔ`Ñ¡Õ
ÖJ×Ø`ÙÚ¡ÛܯÙ
Ý É¯ÈuÇ ÆÞSßZÈÉàÇ Æ`Ç ÞSà Ç ÞSÌuÆ߯Æá'ÆßZâNà ÞSàFÍãÉ'Èá'à ÞZÇQâ\äå'ÌyÇ å'Æ`Ç ÞSÍæá'à-ÞSáCÇ ç¯È<ÌyâLßSÞá'ɯÏÞSÌuÆß¡á¯ÍæáNèéãÅå'à ÞZÍæáCɯÈuêNÞSÌyÈ(ëqì£ÞàÇÏÆßí
ÞSàîÈuÏ ã^ÍÏï>ÈÉð¸ñç'ȪÈyòNîÈuÏÞSï>Èá¡Ç Æß<àÈuÇóèå¯îÞSà>ÞSï>î½ßZÈï>Èá¡ÇÈɨÞáÍÏɯÈuÏ{ÇÍ/ÏÈÆÌç§Ç å'Ï Îå'ßZÈá¡ÇCÎÈçÆêNÞZÍÏôÞSá
Ç ç¯È>Ï ÍÇ Æ`Ç Þá¯õ·îßSÆà ïôƪÌyÍæßå'ï{áðñ<öÍ´É'Þø÷ÈuÏ ÈáÇ¿Ç å¯ÏÎå'ßZÈá¡ÇÏÈuõæÞSï>Èà\Æ`Ï È>ÍÎÇ ÆÞSá¯ÈÉùÌyÍÏ Ï Èà îÍæáÉ'ÞSá¯õªÇÍ·ÇöÍ
àÈßZÈÌyÇÈÉàÈuÇ àÍãúêÒÆßSå'Èàã^ÍÏÇ ç¯ÈªÆá'ÍLɯȪîÍÇÈáÇ ÞÆßrÆá'É¨Ç ç¯ÈªÎÞSÆàÞSá¯õ´ÍãÇ ç'ÈlÌyÍæßßZÈÌyÇ ÞSá¯õ2îßSÆ`ÇÈðùñç¯ÈUû'ÏàÇ
Ï ÈuõæÞSï{È¿ÉÞSàîßSÆâLàÆ>à ßZÍ_öúßZâ¡èéÏ ÍÇ Æ`Ç ÞSá¯õÌyÍæßSå'ïôáªÌ9ç'Æ`ÏÆÌyÇÈuÏÞSüuÈÉ´ÎLâôÇ ç¯È¿î'Ï Èà Èá'ÌyÈ¿ÍãFÆ>à ç¯ÈÆ`ÏßÆâÈuÏúàÈuî½Æ`ÏÆ`Ç ÞSá¯õ
Ç ç¯È<îßÆà ï{Æ¿Îå'ßSý\ãþÏÍæï#Ç ç¯Èúà ÌyÏ9Æ`îÈyèéÍ`÷·ßSÆâÈuÏ(Ãéÿ'Ë-Õ9ÓÇ ç¯ÈúßSÆ`ÇÇÈuÏrà ç¯ÍöÞSá¯õ\ÆàÇÏ Íæá'õÞSá¡ÇÈuÏï{ÞZÇÇÈá¡ÇÎÈç'ÆêNÞZÍÏð
ñç¯ÈràÈÌyÍæá'ÉÏ ÈuõæÞSï>ÈÌyÍÏ Ï ÈàîÍæá'É'àHÇÍÆörÈÆ`ýNßZâ¡èéÏ ÍÇ Æ`Ç ÞSá¯õ¿ÌyÍæßSå'ïôá\ÞSá\öç'ÞSÌçÌyÍæç¯ÈuÏ Èá'ÌyȾÞSàFßZÍæàÇHÞSáÇ ç¯È"î½ßSÆà ï{Æ
Îå'ßSý{Æá'É·ÆàÇ Æá'É'Æ`ÏÉ·ÉÞø÷åà ÞZêÈúîÏ ÍLÌyÈàà¾Ç Æ`ýÈà<îßSÆÌyÈÞSáªÇ ç¯Èÿ'Ë"ð¯ñç¯ÈàÈ¿ûá'ÉÞSá¯õæà"Æ`ÏÈ\à å¯î'îÍÏ ÇÈÉUΡâUÇ ç¯È
ÌuÆßSÌuå'ßÆ`Ç ÞZÍæá·ÍãÇ ç¯È(å¯ÏàÇ<ÈyòNîÍæá¯ÈáÇ<ÍãÇ ç¯È\Ç å'Ï Îå'ßZÈá¡Ç<à ÞZõæá'Æßà<å'à ÞSá¯õ/ÆêÈßZÈuÇóèÆá'ÆßZâNà ÞSàúÇÈÌç'á'Þ¡å¯Èàð
"!# %$&('")"!*) +-,
degynb½oXhnan^gÒM]ÒglOþMMXNMénhO^XLM! "ÅI#hY2I2bgs½Oþ]Òg$O%CILM¸O^Y& FXLa'uI¡M()yIht*yXùI#hg$yeg
nMbgÒauILMbO^MKX#+hayILM HXNa'ùOþMY£XNahgJ]ÒXNY& "^g-,FP^ILahKLg/.09]`Iþg1 "^IhY2I]_XNM2KLnayI#hO^XNMÒE drX3heO%
gÒMb-PI>bg/uILO4^g_b2I¡MIþo59O%XFg^g_]$hahXNMOþ]bgÒMhO4o6n]$hnI#yOþXNM"O^Mheg]o5^O^MbahOþ]`I½MXNM7.8én"hOþXNM2bg_sO^]_g
GJO4'yahIO49 HgÒa'éXLahY£gÒb-Erdegg/,7 HgÒahOþY2g_M:uI7hg$.n" ´O4O^Y& "þgÒY£gÒM:yg_blO^M·XNa9bgÒa;yX>X<yILO^MlI=yna'n"^g_M:
ahg_KNO^Y£gOþMJI·a9XuI#hO^MK ÅI9YIl]_X<^nY£M-E
> M*yeO4)?XNa9t@?(gô]ÒXNMhO^bgÒa)0?(X2bO%yO^M]$)hg/AX¾bO4h]ueI¡ahKNg ILahILY£g$yg_a_PH]_XNaha9g' FXNMbO^MKByXByeg
ILMXbg HXyg_M:yOÅI#<ILMbCyeg&OÅI9O^MKùXDyeg£]_X<%þgÒ]/yO^MK@ "ÅIEygLEªdeg^I#hgÒa9g$ôoO^g$^b!0?XJbO4FFgÒahg_M:
ynan"þgÒM:ahgÒKLO^Y£gÒPXLMgU]_XNaha9g' FXNMbO^MKByX2IB^XG?)o(.óahXyI#yOþMK·]ÒX^nY£M3Héahg_KNO^Y£gIJILMb¨I&9gÒ]_XNMb
XNMgùOþMK?\eOþ]ueLhegù]ÒX^nY£M O%ªXNM"þoM?g`ILt(þoahXyI#yOþMKLHéahgÒKLO^Y£g@NOJE > M ahg_KNO^Y£gIUP;yegÒahg/g-,O4'´I
sNg$^X]ÒOPo!heg`ILaÅI`oLgÒaheILa "o!9g ILahI#yOþMK@yeg&n"^tQ "ÅI9YI&éahXNYRyeg£D"STahgÒKLO^XNM-EUdegéXNahY£gÒa
ahX#uI#hg>MgÒILao¸IôIùahOþKNO^b!HXboNPU?\eO4^g·OþM!yeg2D"ST IVyahXLMK/O^M:yg_ahY£O4hgÒM]oX]Ò]_na_E > Ma9gÒKNOþY2g
NCP5yeg "^IhY2IWn"^t&^X<9g\IþY2X'(I%HX"O4(]ÒXLegÒa9gÒM]_gUI¡MbùbO%' "ÅI`o5O^M:hgÒahY£O4'yg_M]_oLP5?\eO4^gOþMyeg
D"STbg_M"hOPo@6n]/ynIEyO^XLM")heXG?XuILMbILahb°bOPFn"9OþsLg+HgÒeIsOþXNaÒE
deg& I HgÒaôO%ôXNahKNILMO%Y_gÒbIéX<%þXZ?)_E > MDgÒ]$hO^XNM >> yeg2g/,7 Fg_ahOþY2g_M(yI[hg/ªn" O%ahOþg$6o§bO%.
]Ònhg_b-ED½gÒ]/`E
>>>
O%úbg_sLXyg_b@yXlIUbg9]ÒahO4 yOþXNMX#Uyeg'yI#yO4'yOþ]`I"hX½X%gÒY& "^XoLgÒbùILMb/D½gÒ]/`E
>]\
hX
yegUbO4h]_n"9O^XNM°X^heg{ahg$hn"PAÒEdeg9gªOþM]þnbgyeg{Y£XNY£gÒM:A\X;yeg6n]/ynIEyO^MK9O^KNMI#%ÒP_9n]ueI#
Y£g`ILM°sLI#^ng¡P`uILMbILahbbg_sOÅI#hO^XNMPa9tLg/?\Mg'UI¡Mb16+I#hMg'ÒPIIBénM]$hO^XNMJXyegªayI¡bOÅIbO%'yILM]_g
b
éahXLYcyeg/]_gÒM:yg_aXyeg°]_o5þO^Mba9O^]ÒI¿bgs½Oþ]Òg¡E deg°]`Iþ]Òn"^I#yOþXNM XTna''2g/,7 HXNMgÒM: ILMbLyeg
]ueILahIL]$hgÒa9O%Y`IEyO^XLM°X#^yegôOþM:ygÒa9Y2OPhgÒM]oùX^heg{]ÒXNa9ahg$ HXNMbOþMK&hO^Y£g/.]hgÒa9O^g$O%) ahg$hg_M(hgÒb-EedO^MI#%þoLP
D½g_]$`E
\
]_XNM:uILOþM"Oyeg{]ÒXLM]þnbO^MK·ahgÒY2ILa9t5_E
fegh)feW-ijfe9klnm_fOOoh
>
MGJO%yahIcP)yegC ÅI9YI O4V ahXbn]_gÒbp'o#IL^ILahKLgYln"PyO% HX<^ILaBhXNna9]Òg¡PX< HgÒayIEyO^MK I#°Iq^XG?
a9g9nahgH
.artseu .v5w(x
YILaJ^IahKNXLM·bO%9]ueILahKLgOþMyeg\Y2ILO^Mª]ueILYHgÒa[hn'uI¡O^Mg_b&¯o·eX2_ÅI¡Y2g_M(
gÒY£O%'hOþXNMMHy9gÒgôgLEjKE{z
.$|
éXNaY£XNahg>bg/uILO4%AJE
I eO^KNeQyayI¡M" I¡ahgÒM]_ot6X¯I#hO^MK2KNahOþbJO4CO^MhgÒayg_b!Fg/0?(g_gÒMCyeghXNnah]Ògª]ueILYHgÒaCILMb1hegªY2ILK#.
Mg/yO%Y_gÒb} "ÅI9YI/]ÒX^nY£M-E f<a9O^Y2ILa9o¸g$^g_]$ya9XNM"@Hy~
v g \ J{XsNg_ah]_XNY2g&yeg&6X¯I#hO^MK* HXyg_M:yOÅI#<Xeyeg
O^MZ9gÒ]$hO^XNMKNahOþb ILMb O^XNMO%YÒgByegK¯IUO^M"9O^bgByeg ]ÒX<þnY£M-EQIAMgÒKNI#yOsNg]ueILahKNghna' "^nlO%U]ÒahgÒI#yg_b
]þX<hg@hXMheg/IE,½O%´Xyegt^I#hgÒa_P[?\eO%^gyeg/O^XLM"´ILahgV HXXNao Y2ILKNMg/yO%Y_gÒb ILMb5]_XNM:yahO4nhg*hXÀI
V^g_]$ya9XNM"{ILMb¸O^XNM"CbahOPO^MQyeghILY2gªbO^a9gÒ]$hO^XNMI#yegyILY£g u sNg$^X]ÒO4oLP-]ÒXLM(hahO4nyOþMKhX
yegôa9XuIEyO^XLMùX;heg{]ÒX<þnY£M-E
>
Mheg9g>g/,7 Fg_ahOþY2g_M(ÒPheg "^IhY2IUeIeHgÒgÒMù]_XNM2MgÒbVyXheg^OþMg`I¡aD ILa'X# yeg]ueILYHgÒaHéX
^g_MKhe
. E
YJ[¯oIU]ÒOþah]_n"ÅILaú]ÒX%^g_]$hXNaÒErdeg "^IhY2IôbOÅILY£g$hgÒaúO%D^O^Y£O4hgÒbyX
.
~l]_Y ¯oIUY£g$yI%þO^]
bO^I eahILKNY Hy^OþY2OPyg_aJP5 "^IL]Òg_bJIEOyeg>g_M(hayILM]ÒgôX;heg^OþMg`I¡ae ILa`E
>
M*yeO4e?¿I`oNPbO4FFn"hOþXNM/]`ILM*Hg
O^M¯sLg'hO^K¯IEygÒb¨O^M*yegWheILbXZ? X^yegW^O^Y£O4hgÒa ?\egÒahgWyegôO^XNMO%Y`IEyO^XLMt ahX]Òg'O%MX^XNMKLgÒa ahg$hgÒM:ÒE
O4he!yeg·KLahO^b¨tLg 7+6X¯I#yOþMKPayeg·]_XNM:yahX^ ILahILY£g$yg_a{ILa9gyeg FXhgÒM:yO^IX#Dheg´ILMXbg I¡Mb
yeg+OÅI9O^MK·X{yegô]_X<%þgÒ]/yO^MK "ÅI#hgE<degô]ÒXNa9ahg$ HXNMbOþMK·sLI#^ng$I¡ahg
W\gÒKLO^Y£gI
\
ILMb
.
\!
W\gÒKNOþY2gN" # \ ILMb $%
.v
\'&
degùg$^gÒ]/ya9XNMO^]yI#hnayIEyO^XLM bgÒMhO4oO%lY£g`I#hna9gÒb3yeahXNnKLe ICT"I¡MKNYlnOþaW ahX<HgLPn"9O^MK¸I!9O^M7.
K<þg@ O^Mq?\OPyeIC FX<^ILahO4Y`I#hO^XNMX . \ E9IM ILn7yXNY2I#yg_b IL]
nO4hOPyO^XLMq9o5'hgÒY O%´I¡bX< hgÒb-P[?\egÒa9g
yegn'yg$ " HgÒa.óY2X#yXNaX*heg#Y2Xs¡I"þg a9X<Fg I¡Mb yeg#X<9]ÒO4%^Xh]ÒX Fg#I¡ahg#Y2ILMILKNg_b ¯o?I T"I#
\ Oþg$?)(* a9XNKNahILYJE
g&ynb½o 'uIEyO^XLMILa9o1yO^Y£gla9gÒ]ÒXLahb"ôXeþgÒMK#ye,+ s@u .v x P)ahg$ ahg$hgÒM:hO^MKJg^g_]$hahXNMÀbgÒMhO4o
6n]/ynIEyO^XLM"I#) FXhO4hO^XNM
b
PyILtLg_MI#\g
nO^bO4'uI¡M()hO^Y£gO^M:yg_a9s¡I4.-/EDN(X#yetI[ILMbJk{[p9O^KNMI%
eI`sNgBHgÒg_MÀ]_XNM"9O^bg_ahgÒbEdXNaa9gÒKNOþY2gWIªP ?g·eI`sNguI¡tLgÒM)-'/
10
{ILMb¸XuILOþMgÒb
#v
hgÒa9O^g$ Fg_a
ayI¡bOÅIa HX<hOPyO^XLMéXNa\k{[ hOþKNMI4ÒPI¡Mb
.Gv<v
hg_ahOþgO HgÒaayI¡bOÅIa HX<hOPyO^XLMéXNaeI[ hO^KLMI%_EdXNa¿a9gÒKNOþY2g
NCP5?(g>eI`sLgyILtLg_M-/2 ~ 0
I¡MbùX<yILO^Mg_b
sv
9gÒahOþgO HgÒa¿ahILbO^I` HX<9O4yOþXNMéXNa FX#ye/k{[#ILMb*I[
hOþKNMI4ÒE
$ m_9kOm_=kl lDm
g&ynb½og$^g_]$ya9XNMÀbgÒM"9O4oC6n]$ynI#yOþXNM"435 Hb ! /'J6879H
b ! /'J:<;=79H
b
J?>_P ?\egÒa9g@;=7AH
b
J>O%yeg
Y£g`ILMôsLI#^ng(I#
b
PNI¡Mbl]`I#^]ÒnÅI#hgDég/? eO^KNegÒaY£XNY£gÒM:A"X35 H b ! /'JPhn]ue´I{yeg 'yILMbILa9blbgs½O^I#yOþXNM-P
BDC
E; 5 i >
R=Fói
P;?\eOþ]ueY£g`I9nahg$Wheg ILY& "þO4ynbg·X 6n]$hnI#yOþXNM"_P;yeg9tLg$?\Mg_PHGIJ; 5 v
>K
B v
C P
?\eOþ]ueùY2gÒIhna9geheg>Io½Y£Y£g$yaoX# yeg9O^KNMIcPILMb@heg=6+IEyMg$ÒPDL<M; 5 x >K
B x
C
P5?\eO^]ueùa9XNnKNeþo
yg$%4<n"(I#FXNn7Dheg ahg$hgÒM]ÒgXg/,5ya9gÒY2Ig_sLgÒM:AHyhXE.]`I#%^g_bI#[uILO4^gÒb ahX<I#O%þO4olbO%'hahO4nyOþXNM"AJE
deg t'nayX<9O%lO4ªa9gÅIEygÒb}yX1heg6+I#hMg'¯oON PLQR#E!dXNaU]ÒXNY& ILa9O%9XNM-P;heg/m{ILn"'hOÅI¡M HXNa
MXNa9YI# JbO4'hahO%nyOþXNM eIGS
v
ILMbTLI#tHOQEqg¡ENE
v
JE
yeahXNnKLeQyegUbg/yg_ahY£O^MI#hO^XNMùX#^yegªTnaBHQT=J¿g/,7 FXLMgÒM:X#^yegU]_XNaha9g HXNMbO^MK&yO^Y£ghg_ahOþgHyhg_g
W\g$ E*z
E|
IôIùKNg_MgÒahI¾ahgsO^g$?JE´Wg_]Òg_M(þoLP I`sNg$^g$ôILMIo79O%hX°]_XNY& nyg´T eIFg_gÒMI " "þO^gÒb
yXt6n]/ynI#hO^MK1hO^KLMI%yILtLg_M3éahXNY IthO^Y& "þg£Y2ILKNMg$yO4YÒg_b}yXLahn"ªILMb a9gÅIEygÒbMyXbO4FFn"hOs½OPo z#
| E
> M*yegéX<%þXG?\O^MKP(?gUbO4h]_n")yeg9X#.]ÒI%þgÒbV?¿I`sLg^g/6n]$hnI#yOþXNM°ILMIo5hO%+z#
|
P+ILMb°bO%9ahg_K¯ILahb*yeg
s¡ILahO^I"þg
b
éXNaO9O^Y& "^Oþ]ÒO4o£XrMXyI#yOþXNM-E
> MyeO4{?(I`sNgþg$¾ILMIo79O%_PXLMga9gÒK¯I¡ahb" yeg[6n]/ynIEyO^MK=hOþKNMI'I#{yg$ "^ HgÒaéXNahY£gÒb+¯oªI\ayI¡MbXNY
?(I^t¡gÒaI^XLMK´I£XLMg>bO^Y£gÒMhO^XLMIU IEye-P?\egÒahgôO4O FXhO4hO^XNM/IE ygÒaH/ yOþY2gyg$ "O4X<yILO^Mg_b°I
H/'J2
.
-/
/ 3
5 H/PJ
& H . J
deg
nILM:yO4o H/'JO "^Io5)yegôahX^gôX^heg a9X2_þgUI#hX]ÒO^I#yg_bQhX I&éahIL]$hO^XNMI N(ahXG?\MO^ILM°Y2XhO^XNM
HyNY@JPa?\eOþ]ueO%CI2KNg_MgÒahIY£Xbg éXNa^XNMKE.ayI¡MKNg{]ÒXNa9ahg$ÅI#hgÒb1?(I^t(z~ |
EdXNaIo5 Oþ]`I"g/,ILY& "^g
XI6n]$hnI#hO^MK& ahX#2_^g9gÒgôWg/ E{z# | E
deg_M-P;?g I`sNg_ayILKLg H /'JXsNg_aªMXNM5.XsNg_aÅI# " O^MKthO^Y£g£OþM:ygÒas¡I%{X ^gÒMKye 1DK -/P{?\egÒa9g
R-'/¿O%ehegyOþY2g-.KNahILO^M@9]`IþgôI#O?\eO^]ue*6n]/ynIEyO^XLM"\ILahgynbOþgÒb-PoOþg^bO^MKP
H J
.
R /
w
R
!
. ! H J
?\O4he
."!$# !
OþM(H=+K% GJPDéa9XNY ?\eO^]ueL?(g°g_s¡IþnI#yg@hegV6n]/ynI#hO^XNM·X=9n]ue ]_X¯ILa'hg/.óKNayI¡O^Mg_b
?(I^t(ÒPbgÒMXhgÒb¨Ie2aCXLahbg_ae?¿I`sNg$^g/AÒPFIL]_]ÒXNa9bO^MKhX
L i
R
H J2M;AH
R H& GJ
' H J'J
i > H=#:J
?\eg_ahg ; &&$&>bgÒMXyg$[heg\I`sNg_ayILKNgOyILtLg_M£XsLgÒaúI%½]ÒXNMhgÒ]_nyOsNg\O^M:hgÒa9s¡I4)H# ! #)( . JEdegg-,7 FXNMgÒM:
* ]`ILMFggyO^Y2I#hgÒbéahXNY hegg/,7 Fg_]$hgÒb@9]`IþO^MK{ahg$ÅI#hO^XNMP L R
H J,+- /.E¾d"XªbO%hg_M:uILMK^g\O^M:ya9O^M"9O^]
6n]/ynIEyO^XLM"éahXLY heg@ a9g9gÒM]_g°X#) FX<'hO4"^g&yahg_Mb"·OþM}yegVhO^KLMIcPrXNMg2]`ILM I4hX!ynb½o eOþKNegÒa
XNa9bgÒaO?(IsLgþg$A_P hn]ue¨I
L i
i
H& GJ ;Az
i
H& GJ
R H& GJ
(
H& J
|i > Hy~(J
L i
v
H& GJ ;Az
v
H& GJ #
i H& GJ
( #
R H J
H& J
|i > H s J
?\eg_ahghegIsLgÒahILKNg ; &$&&>úILa9g HgÒaéXNahY£gÒb£XNM2]ÒXNM"9gÒ]_nyOsNghahO4 "^g/AH # ! #0( . ! #1(C JúILMb
nILbahn5.
"þg$AWH
# !
#2( . !
#3(j
!
#2(
#:JPa9g' Fg_]$yOsNg$þoNE
deg¸Tna g-, HXNMg_M:/]`ILa9ahO^g$OþY HXNa'yILM:£O^MéXNa9YIEyO^XLM5I#FXNn7yegILnhX#.]_XNaha9g^I#yOþXNM"´Xyeg
hOþKNMI 53 H/'J_E > * 4 v &s
yeg&hOþKNMI9eXG?) HgÒa'hO%yg_M]Òg¡P¾OcEjgLE FX<9O4hOþsNg´]_XNaha9gÅIEyO^XLM"ÒE \ I^ngôX
* v &s * v &s
hOþKNMIO%MX\]_XNaha9g^I#yg_b¨I_P"éXNag/,ILY& "þgLPéXNa\I?\eOPyg{MXNO4hg9O^KNMI#cE
S=yeg_a)Y2g/yeXb")eI`sNg Fg_gÒMª]_XNM"9O^bg_ahgÒbUO^Myeg "^IhY2IO^OPygÒahI#ynahg9yX]`I#^]ÒnÅI#hgTUP?\O4heUbO4FFgÒahg_M:
bg_KNahg_gúX#I¡]Ò]ÒnayIL]o{ILMbhn]Ò]Òg$eHyhg_ggLEjKEez
E|
JE"deg?¿I`sLg^g/rILMIo79O%-eI Fg_gÒM{bg9O^KNMgÒbyXbg/ygÒ]/
yahnþoHp"^XLMK#.]hO^Y£gC]_XNaha9gÅIEyO^XLM"O^MVyeg+9O^KNMIU¯oùgþO^Y£O^MIEyO^MKWyegôg/Fg_]$X; HX<9O%"þgyahg_Mb"_PFI¡Mb
heXNn"^bFgyeg_ahg$éXLahgY£XNahgIL]_]ÒnahI#yg=heILM X#yeg_a(Y£g$yeX½b"_E
>
MùILbbO4yOþXNMhX
*
P(yegO^M:yg_ahY£O4'ygÒM]_o
O^MyeghILY£g=yOþY2g-.0hg_ahOþgú]`ILMVHgO^M¯sLg'hO^K¯IEygÒbV¯oY2gÒILM"¿X)a9gÒ]_gÒM:'.óahg_sOþg$?gÒbt'uIEyO%yOþ]`I yXX<%=zsE| E
@ fm"l_m
W\gÒKNOþY2g$OI ILMb!N 9gÒg_Y hX2bO% ÅI`o@0?X bO4FFgÒa9gÒM: egÒMXNY2g_MX<þXNKNO^g$ÒEdeg9gª]`I¡M1HgW9gÒgÒY OþM
dOþKE
.
O^M1?\eOþ]ue!yegªY2gÒILM¨s¡I^ngXbgÒM"9O4oNPa9g^I#yOsNgW6n]$hnI#yOþXNM"_P ht¡g$?\Mg$UILMb!6+IEyMg${ILa9g
heXZ?\M§I#CIénM]$hO^XNM°X<ahILbOÅI#{ HX<9O4yOþXNM
b E > M1hegW2KNnahg$ÒPFI%9Xheg HX<hOPyOþXNM/X9yegªbO^I eahILKNY
HyþO^Y£O4hgÒaJ<O%OþMbOþ]`I#hgÒb-E
degHgÒeI`sO^XNa\X{yeg+ ÅI9YIlOþM°a9gÒKNOþY2gI H hgÒg+dOþKE
.
J(a9g9gÒY"þg)yeg{XNMgôbgh]_ahO4Fg_bJOþMJW\g$ E
z
.|
EúD]uegÒY2I#yOþ]`I4þoLP7?gU]ÒILMJbO%'hO^MKLnO%9e@éXNnabOPFg_ahgÒM:YÒXLMg
XNMg
. H v ! b
!
]_Y@J <degW ÅI9YIl]_XNahg¡P+I´]_XNeg_ahgÒM:^XG?p6n]$hnI#hO^XNM")uI#hgLE
XNMg H ! b
! ]_Y@J <degUa9gÒKNOþXNM sNg_a9o/]$^X<9ghXyeg{]ÒX^nY£M}H Mg`ILa_pHD"ST{JE
XNMg #tH ! b ! .. ]_Y@J I eO^KNeùOþM:ygÒa9Y2OPhgÒM:`PsLgÒao/MILaha9XG? ahg_KNO^XLMMH?\O4heO^MVhegUD"ST;JE
XNMg+~QH
b 4 . .
]ÒYJ <deg ILa_p+D"STahg_KNO^XLM-E
>
MCYÒXLMg
. P
ILMbC~P`6n]$ynI#yOþXNM"CbO% ÅI`oJI Mg`ILa'þo:.m{ILn"'hO^ILM¨]ueI¡ayIL]/ygÒa_P ?\eO4^gªOþM1Y_XNMg#heg_o
heXZ? I
nI#^O4yI#yOsNg$þoùbOPFg_ahg_M(heI HgLE > M!yegWÅI#'yg_aÒP 6n]$hnI#hO^XNM"CILahgUbXNY£O^MIEygÒbQ¯o¨g-,7hahg_YI
g_sLgÒM:AO^MV?\eOþ]ue°IB^ILahKLg=éayIL]/yOþXNMùX{yeg>bg_M"hOPoNP"o5 Oþ]`I4þo£s½O4hnI#^O%Y_gÒb/I\I¡MJI¡ahY X#¾I O^ayI#z
.|
P
]`I¡MhXLY2g/yO^Y£gbg/uIL]uegCKNOs½OþMKôahO%9gOyX^ILahKLgbgÒM"9O4o&"^X"ÒE¾deghg6n]/ynI#hO^XNM 9gÒgÒY yXôY£X½bOPo
yegôbO4FFn"hOþXNMVFg_eI`sO^XNa\O^MVheg{Mg`ILa'¯oVYÒXNMgLE
> M/ahg_KNO^Y£gNCP?gUbO%'hO^MKLnO%9eùg9gÒM:yO^I%o0?Xa9gÒKNOþY2g$
XNMg . H v ! b
! ]_Y@J <degW ÅI9YIl]_XNahg?\eg_ahgôMXG? O^M:hgÒahY£O4'yg_M]_oO%O a9ghg_M:`E
XNMg
H b 4
]_Y@J degW9eILbXG? a9gÒKNOþXNM/O^MV?\eOþ]ueQyeg+ ÅI9YIlbO4 "^I`o7\MXLahY2I-bOPFn"9OþsLg
HgÒeI`sO^XLaÒE
ð`Ê"Ä¿Þø÷ÈuÏ Èá¡Çï>Íæï>Èá¡Ç àÍãɯÈáà ÞZÇâªäå'ÌyÇ åÆ`Ç ÞZÍæá'àÆàÆ>ã^åá'ÌyÇ ÞZÍæá·ÍãÉ'ÞSà Ç Æá'ÌyÈNðì£ÈÆá´ê`ÆßSå¯È ÃÕ
Ã^ÇÍî ßZÈuãþÇ9Õ9Ó¾Ï ÈßÆ`Ç ÞZêÈ£äåÌyÇ å'Æ`Ç ÞZÍæá'à ÃÕ´Ã^ÎÍÇÇÍæï.ßZÈuãþÇ9Õ9Ó<àýÈuöá¯Èà à Ã^ÇÍîÀÏÞZõæç¡Ç9Õ9Ó<äÆ`Ç á¯Èàà2Ã^ÎÍÇÇÍæï
ÏÞZõæç¡Ç9Õ9ðñç¯ÈCîÍæà ÞZÇ ÞZÍæá£Íã)Ç ç¯ÈßSÞSï{ÞZÇÈuÏêÌuïUÕÞSàÞá'É'ÞSÌuÆ`ÇÈÉ2Ρâ£Ç ç¯ÈCàç'ÆɯÍöÈÉ ÎÆ`ÏðÈuõæÞï>È Ý
Ã^ÇÍî£î½Æá¯ÈßþÕ9Ó¯Ï ÈuõæÞSï{È ÃÅßZÍöÈuÏúîÆá'ÈßþÕ9ð
Ý
Ç ç'ÞZÏ9ÉlÍÏɯÈuÏ<ö¾ÆêÈßZÈuÇ¿Æá'ÆßZâNà ÞSàuÓ
v
ÃÕ9Ó½ðHÃæÕ9ð
W\XNnKNe"o@' FgÒILt'O^MKPa9gÒKNOþY2g=I a9g9gÒY"þgI·drXNtILY2ILt ]_XNM2KLnayI#hO^XNMMH ?\egÒa9gUXLM"þo@hegUD"STO%
'hahXNMK<þoVhnan^gÒM:JP_?\eO%þg{ahgÒKLO^Y£gWNphg_gÒY&]$^X<9gÒa)yX I¡M¸DGJd H?\eg_ahglI&'hahXNMK2O^M:yg_ahY£O4'ygÒM]_o
O% ahg9gÒM:UO^MCyeg´OþMMgÒa I¡a'{XDyeg·s¡IL]_nnY8]ueILYFg_aUI¡MbOP>O%ya9O^]$þo¨]ÒXNa9ahg^I#yg_bMhX* "ÅI9YI
a9X½bn]$yOþXNM JE
degôTna'\g-,7 FXNMgÒM:AeI`sNgHgÒgÒM°gyOþYI#hgÒb/n"9O^MK?(I`sNgþg$CILMIo5hO%(n" VyXyeOþahb7.óXNahbgÒaÒEdeg
ahg$hn"PA_P½]_XNaha9g HXNMbO^MK+yXyeOþahb7.óXNahbg_a?¿I`sNg$^g/AÒPV
E H s
JPILahgahg$ FXNayg_bO^MdOþKE
EdXNaahg_KNO^Y£gOIªP
6n]/ynIEyO^XLM"bO%' "ÅI`o * . H I%þO%yO^]bOPFn"9O^XNM_JO^MVY_XNMg . PI·]_XNM"hg
ngÒM]_gªX{yegIL]$OheI#Oyeg
"^IhY2I ahXyI#yg${IôI
nIhO.ahOþKNO^bQFXboLE > M}Y_XNMg
P ?gB2Mb * RH
v &~ s v &
s<s
J]ÒXNa9ahg$ HXNMbOþMK
yXVuILMbILahb§bOPFnhO^XLM-E
> M Y_XNMg#P
* H v &<s
v & #:J HXNOþM(hO^MKyX°I@hn" HgÒa .bOPFnhOþsLghOPynI#hO^XNM
]ÒXLM"hO4'yg_M:9?\O4heWyeg Oþ]$ynahgrXg-, n"%9gÒb"þX<""Xbg_M"hOPoNEdrO^MI4þoLPOþMWY_XNMg ~P * H v &<s v &<s J
]ÒXLahahg$ HXNMbOþMKQhX¨IV?g`ILt¡gÒa9n" Fg_a.óbO4FFn"hOsNg&Fg_eI`sO^XNa_E deO%ô]`I¡MKHg2OþM(hgÒa' ahg/ygÒbIUI°a9ghOþbnI
bOPFn"9OþsLgV ahX]Òg$B?\eO^]uetLg_g "2Y2g_Y2XNaoX#hnan^gÒM:£]ÒXLM'sLgÒ]/yO^XLM éa9XNYcyeg/IFXsLgJY£gÒM:yOþXNMg_b
bg/uIL]ueg_b1yahn]$ynahg_E
dXNa£ahgÒKLO^Y£gQNPD?geI`sNg§IMþO^KNe:AoILM:yO.0 HgÒa9O%ygÒM:hOþKNMI)?\O4he
* H v &# 1 v &~ s
JQH hn"5.
bOPFn"9O^XNM_Je?\OPyeOþMthegôeX<^g{X^yeg+^OþY2OPygÒaH
b ]ÒYJ\ILMb * v &s H'yILMbILa9b¨bOPFnhO^XLM J¿O^M°O4A
heILbXG? Hb 4
]ÒYJH dOþKE
JE
>
2O%£O^M:yg_ahgyOþMKMhXKynbo yegQ a9X<IO%^OPo bO4'hahO%nyOþXNM énM]$hO^XNM HQfkdJéXNaByegt FXhO4hO^XNM
b .Gv &s ]ÒY O^M yegJ]`I9g¨X>a9gÒKNOþY2gtIªP[?\eOþ]uebO%' "ÅI`o52I}I#'.8uILO4 éXNa& FXhO4hOþsLgt6n]$ynI#yOþXNM"ÒE
> Mjheg1éX<4^XG?\O^MKP ?g]ÒXNM]ÒgÒM:hayI#hgn" XNM yegQ FX<9O4hOþsNgQhOþbg¨Xhegfkd(P[?\eOþ]ueO%2bO%' "ÅI`oNg_b
10 0 10 1
g
10 −7 10 −6 10 −5 10 −4 10 −3 10 −2 10 −1 10 0
PDF(g)
g −3.5
y=0.3e −(ln(g/0.5)) 2
(Tsallis: q=0.81) (green line)
y=0.5(1−0.248(1−q)ln 2 (g/0.118)) 1/(1−q) (blue line)
ðLÊ)ñç¯Èúî'Ï ÍÎÆ`ÎÞßSÞZÇâCÉ'ÞSàÇÏ9ÞZÎå¯Ç ÞZÍæáãÅå'á'ÌyÇ ÞSÍæá£Ã"Ä Õã^ÍϾɯÈá'à ÞZÇQâäå'ÌyÇ å'Æ`Ç ÞZÍæáà)êÈuÏà åà"à ÌuÆßZÈÉUê`Æ`ÏÞSÆ`ÎßZÈ
ÔNÓ¯ãþÍÏ<Ï ÈuõæÞï>È Ý Æ`ÇúÆ>ÉÞSàÇ Æá'ÌyÈ
uÔ{Ìuï?Ã^ÍîÈá·à Lå'Æ`Ï Èà9Õ9ðrñç¯ÈßSÞSá¯ÈàÆ`ÇúÉ'ÞZ÷ÈuÏ Èá¡Ç¾û'Ç à
ÇÍlÇ ç¯ÈÉ'Æ`Ç ÆNÊúîÍöÈuÏèßSÆö Ã^Ï ÈÉ ßSÞSá¯È_Õ9ÓßZÍõ`èá¯ÍÏïôÆß¾Ã^νßSå¯ÈßÞSá¯È_Õ9ÓÆá'É2Ælï>ÍNÉ'ÞZûÈÉ£ßZÍõ`èá¯ÍÏ9ï{Æß<Ã^õÏ ÈuÈá ßSÞSá¯È_Õ9ð
ñç¯ÈÈyòNî'Ï Èàà ÞZÍæá'à<å'à ÈÉ·Æ`Ï È\Ï ÈuîÍÏ ÇÈÉ´ÞálÇ ç¯Èû'õæå¯Ï Èð
O^M3dO^KE #E§deO4 ILa'hO^]_n"ÅILa+heI FgùX#heg/fkd eIHgÒg_Mq2"hgÒb-PéXNalO4%þn"'hayI#hO^XNM-P"n"9O^MK!heahg_g
bOPFg_ahgÒM:énM]$hO^XNMI#{éXNa9Y I@ FXG?gÒa.]ÅI?{PIuILMbILahbCþXNK#.óMXNahY2I)ILMb§I Y2XbO42gÒb1þXNK#.óMXNahY2IQE
degtÅI#'yg_a£O4£I9nY2g_b hX}Hg/X=hegtéXLahY XIÀdOhI%þO%·bO4'hahO%nyOþXNMpHy9gÒg¨g¡EqKEW\g$ E%z
E|
JE
>
2O%
I " ILahg_M(éahXLY dO^KE#BheI#IB FXG?gÒa.]ÅI? O4MX]ÒXNM"9O%ygÒM:?\O4hethegW ÅI9YI·bI#yIPg/,½]_g éXNaI
sNg_a9o¸MILaha9XZ? ahg_KNO^XLM¸X[yeg9]`IþgÒb¸s¡ILahO^I"^gHEWI þXNK#.óMXNahY2I heI Fg£I ahX,½O^Y2I#yg$=yeg "ÅI9YI
fkd Hg$'ygÒanILO%4\I#yegUg/,5ya9gÒY2I; ILa'X^hegWyILO%QE¿degUY2X<=hI#yO4'IL]/yXNaoV2"O%X<uI¡O^Mg_b
n"9O^MK£I´Y2XbO42gÒbV^XLK#.MXLahY2IcE"deO%OHgÒeIsOþXNa\ahgÒY2ILOþM" yXBHg{nMbg_a'hX½Xb-E
geI`sNg\]ÒXNMhO^bgÒahg_b&heg
ngyOþXNM´XHO^bg_M(hO4oO^MKyegO9eI HgX naAO^MhegOhOþKNMI4)H]/éaÒENW\g$ E
zsE|JE(d"XbXByeO%ÒP+I&na''O%\bg$2MgÒb¸I#I6n]/ynIEyO^XLMQ?\eOþ]ue¨XsNg_ah]ÒXLY2g$heg+heahg$heX^b@#
B
_P+I¡Mb
HgÒa'éXLahYAILMùI`sNg_ayILKNg>XsLgÒaI4`9n]ue/g_sLgÒM:AO?\O4heO^M&yeghO^Y£g9gÒa9O^g(]ÒXNa9ahg' FXLMbO^MKyX·I ILa'hO^]ÒnÅILa
HX<hOPyO^XLM
b
E¨W\g9n"4WéXNayeg@na''9eI HglXuILOþMgÒb}éXNaW HX<9O4yOþXNM
b .Gv &s
]_Y éXNaªa9gÒKNOþY2gBIªP
ILMb@éXLa
b
I# &s ]_Y éXLa(ahg_KNO^Y£gNPILa9gheXZ?\M/OþMVdO^KE5~EXhg=yegCbO4FFgÒa9gÒM:e?\O^b7ye"X yegna
heI Fg$ÒE
îÍæà ÞZÇ ÞZÍæá
uÔ>Ìuï ãþÍÏ<ÏÈuõæÞSï>È
Ý
ÃÅßZÈuã^Çrî½Æá¯ÈßþÕ9Ó¯Æá'ɪîÍæà ÞZÇ ÞZÍæá
Ìuï ãþÍÏ¾Ï ÈuõæÞSï{È Ã^ÏÞZõæç¡Ç¾îÆá¯ÈßþÕ9ð
Ý Îå¯Ï9àÇÞSàÌyÍæá'à ÞSɯÈuÏÈÉ/Æàà å'Ìç°öúç¯Èá°Ç ç¯ÈôäåÌyÇ å'Æ`Ç ÞZÍæá/Í_êÈuÏÌyÍæï>Èà ÓÞðÈð
LÓÆá'É°Ç ç'ÈUà ÞZõæáÆß)ÞSà
ÆêÈuÏ9Æ`õÈÉ2Í_êÈuÏÆßSßÈuêÈá¡Ç àî'Ï ÈàÈá¡ÇúÞSálÇ ç¯ÈÇ Þï>È\àÈuÏÞZÈàð
ð Lʾñç¯È\î'ÏÍÎÆ`ÎÞSßSÞSÇâUÉÞSàÇÏÞZνå¯Ç ÞZÍæáªã^åá'ÌyÇ ÞZÍæá·Íãö¾ÆÞZÇ ÞSá¯õ>Ç Þï>ÈàÎÈuÇöÈuÈá à å'ÌuÌyÈà àÞZêÈ\Îå¯Ï9àÇ à<êÈuÏà åà
+àéÓ¯Æ`ǾîÍæà ÞZÇ ÞZÍæá
uÔÌuï ãþÍÏ¾Ï ÈuõæÞSï{È Ý ÃÅßZÈuãþÇîÆá¯Èß^Õ9ÓLÆá'ɪîÍæà ÞZÇ ÞSÍæá
Ìuï ãþÍÏ<ÏÈuõæÞSï>È5Ã^ÏÞZõæç¡Ç
îÆá¯Èß^Õ9ð
deg?(ILO4hO^MK@hO^Y£g §g^I "hg_b}Hg$0?gÒg_MK0?XQ9n]Ò]_g9OþsLgna''ôeIFg_gÒMÀbg$hgÒahY£O^MgÒbCéXNayeg
yI¡Y2g& FXhO4hO^XNMô]_XNM"9O^bg_ahgÒbO^M}dO^KE ~Eùdeg]_XNaha9g' FXNMbO^MK¨fkdILa9g ^X'ygÒbO^M}dO^KE
s
EVN(Xhe
bO4'ya9O%n7yO^XLM"9heXZ?I>bO% ´ILa9XNnMb .Gv<v 0 _P:éX<%þXZ?gÒb¯o´Ia9X¯ILbBnY& £I#<eOþKNeg_a9yO^Y£ge9]`IþgÒE
d"X1HgMXhgÒb O4+heI#+yeg ÅI#hg`ILn-p)X<hgÒasNg_bO^M}heg fkd I#^ILahKLgÒayOþY2gBh]ÒI^g$ÒP 4
.Gv<v0 ÒP
]ÒXLahahg$ HXNMb*yXByeghO^Y£gO^M:yg_a9s¡I4e?\egÒa9ghegôTna''g/,7 HXNMgÒM:eI`sLgWHgÒg_MJbg/yg_ahY£O^Mg_b-E
deg·a9XuI#hO^XNMJX[yeg ÅI9YI£]ÒX<þnY2M1hgÒg_YhXùO^Mbn]Òg´I@9n" Fg_a.óbO4FFn"hOsNg ahX]Òg'{XbgÒMhO4o
6n]/ynIEyO^XLM"ªOþMKyegùD"STED7þXZ?\OþMK#.óbXG?\MKyegahXyI#yOþXNM-PbO4FFn"hOþXNMKHgÒ]_XNY2g$l]þX<hg_aWhX!'yILMbILa9b
HgÒeI`sO^XNa_EI Y£X½bO42g_b@^XNKE.MXNa9YI#bO%yahO4nhO^XNM&hg_gÒY&eyX2"I " a9X< ahO^I#yg$þoByeg=I#'.8uILO4^g_bfkd(E
deg/I`sNg_ayILKLg@heI# Fg X#naAÒPOQEqg¡Eg_sLgÒM:ABÅI¡ahKNg_a+heILM # B
PbO%' "ÅI`o5·IQ?\OþbyeXI#FXNn7~
v 0
éXNaOyegô]ÒIhgôX^'ya9XNMK£O^M:yg_ahY£O4'ygÒM]_o Héahg_KNO^Y£gIJPFI¡MbJX#¾IHXNn . # v0 éXNaehegô]`I9gUX{?g`ILt¡gÒa
ynan"þgÒM]_gHahg_KNO^Y£gNOJE
Uñç+ðrÞZÈuÏ Ï ÈÓ Ý ð rà ÌuÆ`Ï õæå¯ÈßÓ'ÄCð
å¯âLïôÆ`ÏÌ`íçÓ ð Æ`Ï9á'ÞÓ
ð ÞSÌuÌuÆ`ÏÉ'ÞÓ
rçâNàuð Èuêð HÈuÇÇuðÐLÓ½Ô `ÔÔ`ÑùÃÐ`ÔÔ`Ñ¡Õ
Ð (ð
Ý ð
Æ`Ï Ï ÈuÏ9ÆàuÓ'ÈuÇúÆßðZÓ rçâNàuð rßSÆà ï{Æà+Ó £Ã æÕ9ð
lÿðì2Æ`õæá'ÞÓ ð úÞSÌuÌuÆ`Ï9É'ÞÓðð ÍæïôÆáÓ "ç¡âNàuð "ßSÆàï{Æà LÓ 2ÃÐ`ÔÔ`Ñ¡Õ
Ñ 'ð ÈɯÈuÏÓÃ"ßZÈáLå'ï·ÓÈuö)ÍÏ ýÓ æÕ
ðCð
Ý
áÇ Æ`ÏÓÈuÇúÆßðZÓ rçâNàuð rßSÆà ï{ÆàuÔNÓ½Ñ ´ÃÐ`ÔÔ æÕ
Uñð
Ý
ÏÞSïôÞZÇ à åÓð
Ý
ÏÞï{ÞZÇ à åÓ"ç¡âNà ÞSÌuÆ
Ý
`Ô LÓÐ 2ÃÐ`ÔÔæÐæÕ