On the (high) undecidability of distributed synthesis problems

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00306387

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00306387

Submitted on 25 Jul 2008

HAL

is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire

HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

On the (high) undecidability of distributed synthesis problems

David Janin

To cite this version:

David Janin. On the (high) undecidability of distributed synthesis problems. SOFSEM, Jan 2007,

Czech Republic. pp.320–329. �hal-00306387�

(2)

!"#$%&'()%*+,' -(,'./ !"

0

12"3-.(),'4 4%5+(*%-$"

6700891":4'$3' 3','/"6 ($3'

;<=>=?@<AB>CDB

EFGHIJKHL

:M' ,%)*(%5.*', )N$*M')%)O(-54'P Q22 R%)S$-T$ *- 5'.$,'7

3%,54'UV.(O.(O-)' M'(' %)*- )*.,N W.(*M'(*M%).$,'3%,5%4%*NU

6-(*M%)"T'3-$)%,'(,%)*(%5.*',XP')Q YR"$ %$Z$%*'&(%$*-W['*'()-$

$, '%WP.4*%O4N'(XP')T%*MO(*%4%$W-(P*%-$ Q29R"%$TM%3M [$.'4%

$, -)$'(\) ,%)*(%5.*', )N$*M')%) O(-54'P 3$ 5' '$3-,', $,"TM'$

,'3%,54' Q22"]"^R".$%W-(P4N )-4&', QYRU

_' Z()* O(-&' *M* '&'$ *M' )%PO4' O(-54'P -W )-4&%$X `7O(-3')) ,%)7

*(%5.*',XP'T%*M('3M5%4%*N3-$,%*%-$)%).$,'3%,54'a

Σ₁⁰^73-PO^4'*'^bU

:M%) ,'3%)%-$ O(-54'P"'c.%&4'$* *- *T- O(-3')) ,%)*(%5.*', )N$*M')%)

T%*M W%(4N (')*(%3*', 6V7)O'3%Z3*%-$ T) 4'W* -O'$ QYRU_' O(-&' *M'$

*M**M' )W'*N 3)' %)

Π₁⁰^73-P^O4'*'^U^d-(' ^X'$^'(44N"^T^' ^')*54%)M ^3-(7

(')O-$,'$3' 5'*T''$ `7O(-3')),%)*(%5.*',XP'T%*M d-)*-T)S%\)T'S

O(%*N3-$,%*%-$) QeR$, 4'&'4)-W *M' (%*MP'*%34M%'((3MNUZ$44N",%)7

*(%5.*',XP')T%*M X'$'(4

ω^7('X.⁴⁽^%$^Z^$%*(N^3-$^,%*%-$⁾^('^)M^-T^$^*-

5' M%XM4N .$,'3%,54' a

Σ¹₁

73-PO4'*'bU

f ghijklmniokh

p qrs ttuvwxu sqyz qru yu{|}qz ~qru sqv|yqu szqruss tv~|}u

s qv~y{u |zyu} ~suv rs tv~|}u {|u sqqu s~}}~xs

u

qu}zzsqusquv{~u{quqrv~yr

u uqx~v xqr s~u stu{u }~|} tyq {ru}s }~|}

~yqtyq {ru}s

~u tu{qu {~vvu{q v{rqu{¡

qyvu¢s }~|}|ur~vsu suq~ttsqrqt}~|}tyq

su£yu{us q~ }~|} ~yqtyq su£yu{us sz ¤vsq ¥vuv ¤¥ ~v uu

¦~{ §u{~ ~vuv ¦§¥ ¨~{w s qruvu

©

suq ~ ttsw ~u tuv squw qrq ts su£yu{us ~ }~{} tyqs q~

su£yu{us ~ }~{} ~yqtyqs xr{r ª

«

¬qr stu{{q~ }yus st}u¤¥w~ qru v{rqu{qyvu uu |z qx~

utuuq squs xqr utuuq }~|} tyq {ru}s }~|}~yqtyq

{ru}s suu ¤yvu wqrs tv~|}u s ~x q~ |uyu{|}u

(3)

qz {~q~s ¤¥ }~|} stu{{q~s ussuq}}z sqq qrq s~u tv~tuvqus

uuqy}}z~{{yvqrusqv|yqu szqrusstv~|}u s

Σ₁⁰^¡{~^t^}uqu^qru ^vqr¡

uq{} ruvv{rzwu quv¡vuy{|}u q~ qru r}q tv~|}u ~ yv ¦{ru

¦

LL$ .$,'3%,54'(3M%*'3*.('

¬qr suqz {~q~s ¤¥ }~|} st u{

{q~ ussuq}}zsqq qrq s~u

| tv~tuvqus uuv ~{{yvw }}~x qrys qvz |ur~vs ~u z {~¡

u{qyvu }qr~yr qru qx~ s ~ tv~|}us vu ~q y} qrq qru sqv|yqu

szqruss tv~|}u s

Π₁⁰^¡{~^t}uqu ^qrû ^vqrûq{} ^rûv^v{rz

¦~vu uuv}}zw ~u z s xrq s qru vu}q~srt |uqxuu qru u tvus¡

suuss~qru}~|} stu{{q~ }yu sz xqr ¤¥ }~{~vuu xqr

¦§¥ }~{ xqr ~vu {uqvz {~q~s qru {~t}u qz ~qru

vusy}qsqv|yqu szqrusstv~|}uspqrsttuvwxuusxuvq~ qrs

£yusq~

¬u vsq tv~uqru ~}}~x vuuuq ~ yu} ~suv¢svusy}q

! " #$

% %

©

Σ₁⁰^$

©

ª & '%

( ª% )

k^$ ^*^+$^,

-u qw xu tv~uqrq

.! " #$

'% %

$

Π₁⁰^$©^,

§{u qru suq ~

qu sqqu ~v uu {~tyq|}u sqv|yqu tv~vs s

Σ₁⁰^¡u^|}u^w^qrs ^vusy}q ^}^s~ ^t^}us^qr^q

/0 ! " 1 '% %

© &

©

,

¬u sqyz qru vu}q~srts |uqxuu ~vu uuv} qvz {~q~s ~v

sqv|yqu szqrusstv~|}us }uu}s~qru vqruq{} ~v qru }zq{}

ruvv{rz¦~vutvu{su}zwxusr~x qrq

2! * ª%

n≥1³^ª ^%^© ^&

& 4 ©

5

&6

% 4' 7&6

89:5

'

[0, n+ 1] ⁴^,[1, n]⁵ Π_n⁰^$© ⁴^,Σ_n⁰^$^©⁵^,

¬qr ~vu {~t}u qvz {~q~s

;! " %

4©

%%

5

% 4

Σ1¹

$©

5

,

(4)

rusu vusy}qs vu {ruu |z tv~ }~~ys sqquuqs ~v ¡tv~{uss s¡

qv|yqu us rusu us vu vq xqr qu |ur~vs ~ u¡

quvs~ u¢s y}qt}zuv us xqr tvq} ~vq~ q~ xr{r

sqv|yqu szqruss tv~|}us{ |uu{~u w ~sq u{|}u{sus w

wwy~v}z s~}u

¡tv~{uss sqv|yqu u s u£y}uq q~ ¡squ sqv|yqu szqruss

tv~|}u xqr v}zvusqv{qu stu{{q~p {qwqru}~|} stu{{q~

sqv|yquust}{q}zu{~uq~ qruus{vtq~~t}zuvst~ss|}u

~us

qvz {~q~ stu{z qru }}~xu

qu|ur~vs

p }~{} quvsw ~us vu st u{

u |z yuvs}}z £y qu

k^¡}~^{^} ^~v¡

y}s ¬qr vu{r|}qz {~q~w u xru ~

qu |ur~v s }}~xuw

2^¡tv~^{uss ^sqv|^yqu ^u ^s ^qrys ^v}z ^vusqv^{qu 2^¡squ ^sqv|yqu ^szqr^u¡

ss tv~|}u uuv}

2^¡^squ ^sqv|y^qu ^szqruss ^tv~^|}u^s ^x^qr ^v|qvvz ^¨^¨

stu{{q~ vu ~q ~x q~ |u vuy{|}u q~

2^¡tv~^{uss ^sqv|yqu ^us

ru |usq ~x vuy{q~ s q~ qrv tv~{uss qrq t}zs qru v~}u ~

yq~q~ qvs}q~ ~qruu quv} ¨¨ ~vuu ¦§¥ stu{{q~

rs us ~yv yu{|}qz vusy}q qru vu{r|}qz {su sqv~uv qr

yu} ~suv¢s vusy}q

p ¦~r} ¬}yux{¢s x~v w qru u{|}qz ~ ¡tv~{uss s¡

qv|yqu usxs}s~ }uq ~tu¥yvvusy}qssr~x qruzvu~q u{|}uuu

xqr qrust}usq qvz {~q~s

njkmhl

x~v ~ }tr|uq

A ^s ^y^{q^~ w :ω →A ^x^qr ^tvu ¡{}~^su ^~

¬ru

dom(w) ^s ^qu^w ^x^u ^sz w ^s ^qu ^x~^v^w ^~^qr^uvx^su^w w ^s ^qu

x~v ru suq ~ qu x~vs vust qu ~ utqz x~vs ~ }tr|uq

A ^s

xvqqu

A^∗ ^vustA⁺^w ^qru ^suq ^~ ^qu ^x~^vs ^s ^x^vqqu A^ω^w ^qru ^suq ^~ ^qu

~v qu x~vss xvqqu

A^∞^r^u^u^tqz^x^~v ^s^x^vqqu ^ru ^{^qu^q~ ^~

uuvz x~v

u∈A^∗ ^uuvz^x^~v v∈A^∞ ^s^x^vqqu u.v

u qx~ suqs

A B^w^x^u^x^vqu πA

~v π1

vust

πB

~v

π2

qru tv~u{q~

v~

A×B ^~q~ A ^vust ^v~ A×B ^~q~ B ^r^usu ^~q^q^~^s ^vu ^u quu

q~ z sy|suq ~

A×B ^x^~v^s ^~ A×B ^u P ⊆ A×B ^vust w ∈ (A×B)^∞^w^x^u ^}s~ ^x^vquP[1] =πA(P) P[2] =πB(P) ^vustw[1] =πA(w)

w[2] = πB(w) ^u w∈ (A+B)^∞^w ^x^u ^}^s~ ^x^vqu πA(w) ^vust πB(w)

qru x~v ~|qu v~

w^|z ^u}uq ^}} ^}uqquvs ^~q A ^vust^~q B

p qru su£yu}wxux}} ysu}yus~ qu x~vssqvz {{utq{u

{~q~s¬u vsq vuux ruvu qru uq~ xux}} ysu

0 0 !

L ⊆ A^ω

' &,

L ^t^vqz ^{~^q^~ ^&

©

m n∈IN ^&m≤n ^©^% ^©Ω:A→ [m, n] L={w∈A^ω: lim infΩ(w)≡0(2)}³ ^,,L ^'

(5)

ª

) '

,

3

ª

[m, n] ^v^u ^' ^% ^,

suqz{~q~

% 4&6

%5

&

[0] ⁴

&

L=A^ω⁵ ^vu^{r|^}qz^{~^q~ ^% ⁴ ^&⁶^%5

&

[1] ⁴ ^& L=∅⁵^,

sqv|yquus vustu{}~y}qt}zuvusxqrtvq}~v¡

q~ u quu q~

qu t}zs xqr {~~tuvq v~{uss qu t}z

sq y£yu v~uqt}zuv

. ! $ 4 & %

5

© )

G =hP, E, T, ei ^& ^' P³

' ª©

e∈E^,

{rv~~yssqv|yqu uvu

G ^'^© ^© G1³

,,,

3Gn³

©

G =hP, E, T, ei ^& P =Q

iPi³E =Q

iEi³e= (e1,· · ·, en)

' ©ª

T ^'^& ⁽ ^' ^ª^% u∈P v∈E

$©ª (

(u, v)∈T ^' ^% ^' ^' ^ª^% i∈[1, n]³(u[i], v[i])∈Ti³

$©ª ('

(v, u)∈T ^' ^ª^%i∈[1, n]³(u[i], v[i])∈Ti

,

¥|suvu qrq qruvu s y£yu sqv|yqu u vu |y}q v~ qru }~{}

vus

G1

w w

Gn

xqr }suq~v~uq~usrsvuwxvqqu

G1⊗ · · · ⊗ Gn

w s {}}u qru vuu sz{rv~~ys tv~y{q ~ qru us

G1

w w

Gn

¥|suvuqrqz~qruvsqv|yquvu

G ^|y^}q ^v~ ^qrû^sû^}~^{}ûs^{

ysq |u suu s sy|u~ qru vuu tv~y{q ~|qu |z t~ss|}z s}}~x

s~u v~uq~us¬u st}z xvqu

G ⊆ G1⊗ · · · ⊗ Gn

q~ u~quqrq

p w ~vu uuv} ~q~ ~ sqv|yqu xqr % ~us s u¡

uruq~}u tvussuussuxqrsz{rv~s s~qysuqrs

ttuv §{uxuvuussuq}}zusq|}sr }~xuv |~ysvusy}qwqrs {qus

sqquuqs uu sqv~uv

2 0 ! ª &

% ©

G = hP, E, T, ei³ ^sqvquz ^' ^% ⁴^, ^sqvquz ^' ^ª^$

©

%5 ©

"

% %

σ τ³ ^& σ∗τ³

©1© &

w ∈ (P +E)^∞ w(0) = e ³ ^' ^ª% i ∈ dom(w)

&

i >0³(w(i−1), w(i))∈T ³^ªw⁰ =w(0)· · ·w(i−1)³^' w(i−1)∈P

w(i) =σ◦πP(w⁰) ^' w(i−1)∈E w(i) =τ◦πE(w⁰)^,

%

σ ^~^|}^~^{ ^&³^' ^ª% ^%τ³σ∗τ∈ (P+E)^∗.E∪(P+E)^ω^,