HAL Id: inria-00069860
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00069860
Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
A computational grid devoted to fluid mechanics
Patrick Nivet
To cite this version:
Patrick Nivet. A computational grid devoted to fluid mechanics. [Research Report] RT-0318, INRIA.
2006, pp.28. �inria-00069860�
a p p o r t
t e c h n i q u e
Thème NUM
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
A computational grid devoted to fluid mechanics
Patrick Nivet
N° 0318
February 2006
)+*-,/.10325476098;:<,
=>@?ACBDFEHGJILKNMPORQS?ACBTO UNV@ACWTXZY\[]V@BTO
^_XZ`<aRB$QSOHKNAcb<OZ>
deb<f@fg`<XZQhQSBTij>@U-Yk[]V@BUglmon@p1qrIts@Bu-XZV-b<XZM vwm<moxIyvwqzf-b<{<B1O
|}~T5@<< =>@YkOHP`Pi$V@ACBTUoQ+PBTOSi$XSY ugBTO QZ>@BB1ORQjbwu@kY\O>@ACBTUoQe`<bci$`<ACf@V@QSb5QSY `oU-bw{<XSYkPBT<`wQSBTQZ`
V@YkACBTij>-b<U@Y\iOTwV-OZY U@{HQZ>-XZBTBi VORQSBXjO`<^hk`NiTbwkY TBTXZB1OfgBTi$QZYk<BkMb5QRDHd RKN`<f->@YkbwFU]QZYkf`o Y\O
G_sKN`of@>@Y\b5eU]QZYkfg`<kYkO+bwU-REHKP=HGbwXjOBTY kkB< rBC¡ Yk 'B¢Nfg`oOZBQS>@BCBU-i`<V@U]QSBXSBTf@XS`<u- BTACO
b<U-rQZ>@B ij>@`<Y\i$B1OXZBQSb<Y U@B1£b<ii`<XjPYkU@{ QZ`QS>@Bi$`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<XSBTOSO`oV@XSiBTOT¤Ub¥-XjOQf-bwXZQvP¡B
u-XZYkB M PBTOSi$XSYkuB+QZ>-BGhhe¦d R§¨f@XS`waRB1i©QQZ>-bwQHbwYkAcOhQZ`OZB$QZªV-fbci`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU-bw«{oXZY\PBo`wQZB1
QS`Acb<OSOYk<BT kMf-b<XSb< kBi$`<ACf@V@QSb5QSY `oU-OYkU V@Y\PMNU-b<AzY\iOT=>@BOQSb<XQSY U@{fg`<YkU]QSO`<QZ>@Bf@XZ`<aRBTi$Q
b<XZBcOZBoBXjbwi$kV-OQZBTXSOk`Pib< YkB1rYkU¬QZ>@B^;FhbwXSBTbbwkXSBTb<@MV-OB1£uNMrOZB<BTXSb<'QZB1bwAcO¡h`<XS®]YkU@{YkU
hs'§¯HU@BC`wQZ>@BCAcbwYkUrXSBT[]V@YkXSBACBU]QSO+`<_QZ>-YkOf@XS`waRB1i©Q>-b<OugBBTUQS`uBcbwu- BzQZ` \bwV@U-ij>¬`<UrQZ>-YkO
{oXZY\°OZBoBXjbwi$`PPB1OVOYkU@{£G^z¡ Y±QS>²U@`¬AC`PPY±¥gib5QSY `oU²`<eQZ>-BTOZBi`PPBTOT²=>@BTU³_¡hB f@XZB1OBTU]QCb<U
b<U-bwkMPOY\Oh`wf`]OZOZY u- BOZ`<kVPQZYk`<UO_´`oX BTOQSb<u@ Y\OZ>@Y U-{QS>@Y\O {<XSYkYkUij>bwfPQSBX ncbwU- bCPBTOSi$XSYkfPQZYk`<U `wQZ>@B
OZBkBTi$QZB1zOZMPORQSBA'=>@B BU-i`<V@U]QSBXSBTf@XZ`ou@kBAcObwXSB PB$QjbwYk B1QS>@XS`<V@{o>@`<VPQ'QS>@YkO_ij>-bwfPQSBX1 ¬B¥-U-b< kM
OZ>@`5¡°OZ`<ACBhf@XSBkY ACYkU-bwXSMXZB1OV-±QjO'Y UCij>-bwf@QZBX'µbwUOZ`<ACBhB$¢@bwACf@kBTO`w;i$`oAzf-VPQSbwQZYk`<U-O'YkUzij>bwfPQSBX¶P
·¸]¹;ºS»¼ 5½~< i$`oAzf-VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<{<XSYk³'¦¾'¯+¿hE+K;i VORQSBX1G^_©'hs'§f-b<XSb< kB_i`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU-O
ACB1OZOSbw{oBHf-boOZOZYkU@{-Ps V-Yk§HMNU-bwACY\iO
C ( "$ (
~ BP`Pi$V@ACBTUoQ+PWTiXZY QekbCACY\OBBTUf@\b<i$BV@U@B{<XSY k BPBibw\i$V-³XZWT{<Yk`<U-b< BPW1PY WTBCkb
ACW1ibwU-Yk[]V@BPBTO V-YkPB1OPi`<ACf@XSBU-b<UoQh Bi V-OQZBTXh@B+RDFd R KN`of@>@Y\b@PPVG_sBQ@BHRE+KP=©
DF`<V-O_MoBXSXZ`oU-O[]V@BTkO_`<U]Q_W$QSWFkBTO_f@XZ`ou@k?ACBTO_XZBTU-i$`oUoQSXZW1ObwYkU-OZY[]V@BFkBTOij>@`<Y ¢CXZBQZBUNV-OBUc´`oU-i©QSY `oU
@BTOAC`5M<BTU-OPBibw\i$V-_P`<U]QU-`<V-O@YkOZf`]O`oU-OT=`<VPQb<u`oXS¬U@`oV-Obwkk`<U-Ou-XZYk?oBACBU]QPW1i$XSY XSBc B
f-XZ`<aRB$Q+Ghhe¦d R§ P`oUoQ+ Bzu@VPQBTOQ+@BACB$QZQZXSBBTUf@\b<iBV@U-B{oXZYk kBPBCib<kiV@'PWTPYkWCbwViTbw\i$V@
fbwXjbwk ?T BcBTUACWTib<U@Y\[oV-BPB V@Yk@BTO-bwU-O B ij>-bwf@Y QZXSBvNr `oXZYk{<YkU@BPBi$Bf-XZ`<aRB$QTYkMbf@kVP
OZYkBV@XjOh{<Xjbwf@fgBTOhPBib<kiV@«OY QZV@WTBTOBTUXSW{<Yk`<U^«Fh BQePWRabzVPQSY kYkOZWB1Ohf-bwX PB1OWT[]V@YkfB1O_QSXSb/5b<Y kkb<U]Q
BTU°ACWTiTbwU@Y\[]V@B@BTO V@Y\PBTOT°¾V@U PBTOzf@XSYkU-i$Ykf-bwV@¢£u-VPQSOcPBi$B f@XS`waRBQW$QjbwY QC@Bfg`<V@o`<YkX\bwUi$BX
f- V-OZYkBV@XjOi$`PPB1OPBcibw\i$V-VPQZYk Y\OSbwU]QG^OZb<U-O+AC`N@Y±¥iTb5QSY `oU¬PB¤iBTOi`N@BTOTz^b<X+\bOZV@Y±QSB<³U-`<V-O
f-XZW1OBTUoQS`<U-OV@U@BbwU-b< MPOZBPB1OOZ`<kVPQSY `oU-Ofg`oOSOZY u@kBTOfg`<V@X'W$Qjbwu@kYkXiB$QQSB{oXZYkk Bh@bwU-OkBhij>-b<f@Y QZXSBnFb<Y UOY
[]VV@U@BzPBTOSi$XSYkfPQZYk`<UPVrOMPOQZ?ACBXSB$QSBUNV³F¾BTOHf@XS`<u@k?ACBTOFXZBTU-i$`oU]QZXSWTOeOZ`<U]QHPWQSb<Y k W1O¤QZXjb/<BXjO i$B
ij>bwf@Y QZXSB<'sY U-b< BTACBU]QTPU@`oV-Of@XZW1OBTU]QZ`<UO[]V@BTk[]V@B1O_XSWTOZV@ QSb5QjO_f-XZWT YkACY U-b<Y XSBTOh@b<U-O_kBij>-bwf@Y QZXSBFµzB$Q
@BTOB$¢PBTAzf- B1O PBib<kiV@kO -bwU-OkBij>-bwf-Y±QSXZB¶P
¼
1~
º
~
{<XSY kkB+PBiTbw\i$V@ª-¦¾¯+¿EHK«P{<Xjbwf@fgB<@G^_©@WkWACBU]QjOh¥-U@Y\OPf-b<XSb< kWkY\OACB<Nf-boOZOSbw{oB
@B+ACB1OZOSbw{oB<PACWTiTbwU@Y\[]V@BPBTO
V-YkPB1O
( )
'c _$
DFB$QR¡h`<XS®u-b<OZBT²i$`oAzf-VPQZYkU@{£>-b<OCXSBTiBU]QZkMbwf-fB1bwXSBT°boOCbrU-B¡ ¡b/M£QZ`£`*gBTXzBTU-NV-OZBXjOzb£PXjb5
AcbwQZY\icY Ui$XSBTb<OZBCY Ub/5b<Y \bwu@kBcf@XS`Pi$BTOSOZY U@{fg`5¡BTXT ¿hBTOZYkPBPBTiBfPQSY oBkMf-b<XSb< kB_b<f@f@kYkiTb5QSY `oU-O Yk®<B
KP_=,+H>@`<ACBQS>-b5QH>-b/<BAcboPBfg`<f@V@\bwXeQZ>@Bzi$`<Ui$Bf@QF`w{<XSY\i$`<ACf@V@QZYkU@{--QZ>@BXSb<f@Ykfb<i$B`<QZ>@B
YkACf@XS`5]ACBTUoQ`w-U-B$QR¡h`<XS®+i`<U@U@B1i©QSY NY QRMb<U-OZfgBBTAcbw®<B1OY Q'f`]OZOZY u- BQZ`+i$`<UOY\PBX'i$`oACAV@U@Y\ibwQZYk`<UP
YkU]QZBTU-OYk<BHf-bwXjbwkkBwaR`ou-O.-´U@`5¡iV@XSXZBTUoQS MCXSV@U`oUPB1PYkiTb5QSBTOZV@fgBXji$`oAzf-VPQZBTXSO!/boOOZV@Y QSbwu- BF´`<XB$¢PB$
iVPQZYk`<U`oU10i`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU-bw³{oXZY\@O32i`<U-OZY\ORQSY U@{`w{<BT`<{<Xjbwf->@YkiTbwk MPYkOQZXSYku@VPQZB1i$`oAzf-VPQZBb<U-N@b5Qjb
OQZ`oXSb<{<BXSBTOSO`oV@XSiBTOi`<U@U@B1i©QSBTCuNM5b<XZYk`<V-Oi$`oAzAV@U@Y\ibwQZYk`<UC YkU@®POT'=>-BFOVii$B1OZO_`w;QZ>-BTOZBFO`<iTbwk B1
i`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU-bw{<XSYk@OXZBT YkBTO_`<UOZBoBXjbwP9boi©QZ`oXSO4QS>@BFXjbwf-YkCYkU-i$XSBTboOBF`w;QZ>@B^_E f`5¡hBX_b<U-cU@BQ
¡h`<XS®i`<U@U@B1i©QSY NY QRMYkACf@XZ`5NACBU]Q1wQZ>-Be{<XS`5¡ Y U-{b/5b<Y \bwu@YkkY±QRM`w«ACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZBePB1PY\ib5QSBTcbwQ_u@V@Ykk@Y U@{
{oXZY\@O+`wf@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<XjOHb<U-rOQZ`oXSb<{<BzXZB1OZOZ`<V-XSiBTOTQS>@B¤PB1OYk{<U¬`<XXSB$PBTOZYk{<U`<{oXZY\BTU-bwu- B1f-b<XSb< kB
b< {o`<XSY±QS>@AcObwU-rkboORQ1u@V@QU@`wQkBTboORQ1«QZ>@BcfbwXZQZY\i$Ykf-b5QSY `oU¬b<U-YkUN<`o NACBU]Q`whQZ>@BcBTU-NV-OBTXi$`oA
AV@U@Y QZYkBTOT
=`P@b/M<@bCk`wQe`<ACYk-P BT¡hb<XZB1O PBT@YkiTb5QZB1QZ`C{<XSYki`<ACf@VPQSY U@{cb<XZBb/5bwYkkb<u@kB+u-VPQ QZ>@BOZB$QZªV-f `<
bi$`<ACf@V@QSb5QSY `oU-bw-{<XSYkzXSBT[]V@YkXZB1Obib<XZB´V@-B¢@bwACY Ub5QZYk`<UC`<gQS>@BH@Y5*;BXSBU]Q_fg`oOSOYku@Yk Y QZYkBTObwU-C`<;QZ>@BTY X
kYkAzY QSbwQZYk`<U-Oboii$`oXS@Y U@{QZ`zQZ>-B+U-BBT-O`w³QS>@BBU-NV-OZBXjO ACYk-P BT¡hb<XZB+Y\Ohbz{oBU@BTXSb<-QSBXSA ´`<X bwUNM
OZ`wQR¡bwXSB QS>-b5Q OBTXZoBTO_QZ`76©{o V@BFQZ`o{<B$QS>@BX6QR¡h`OZBfbwXjb5QZB+bwU-V-OZV-bwk Mcb< XSBTboPMCB$¢PYkOQZYkU@{f@XZ`o{<XjbwAcOT
ACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZB¤PB1PY\ib5QSBT£QS`{<XSY\i$`<ACf@V@QZYkU@{Y\OQS>@B{o V@BV-OB1¬QZ`rACb<®<Bcf-b<XSb< kBkY\OA `<UbOZB$Q
`<Hi$kV-OQZBTXSO`<XcOZ>-bwXSBTACBTAz`oXZM£AV@±QSY f-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XAcb<ij>@YkU@BTOT=>@B AC`oOQz¡ Y\PBkM®NU@`5¡ U°ACY\@PkB$
¡bwXSBeY\Oi$BXZQSb<Y U- MzQZ>-B¦+k`<u@VOh=`N`<k®NY±QPBoBk`<f@fgBT¤bwQFXZ{o`<U@U-BHDFbwQZYk`<U-b<g¾bwug`<Xjb5QS`<XSMu@VPQ AcbwUNM
`<QZ>@BTXSOB¢PYkOQHb<O ¾B{oY `oU³-EeU-Yki`<XSB`<XH¯+de¿Y ACf@kBACBU]Qjb5QZYk`<UOh=>@YkOFXZBTf`oXQei`<U]QSb<Y U-OFbci$`<kkBTi©QSY `oU
`<i`<{oY±Qjb5QZYk`<UOHY\OSOV@B1r´XZ`oA QZ>@BY U-OQSb< \b5QSY `oUrf->-b<OZBcbwU-£bPB1OZiXZYkfPQZYk`<U¬`whQZ>-BcY U-OQSb< kBT£OZMPORQSBA
@BTPY\ibwQZBT¬QS`QZ>-B¤B$¢PBTiVPQZYk`<U`<H`<ACf@VPQjb5QZYk`<Ubw_skV@Yk°PMNU-bwACY\iO1-hs'§8/f-bwXjbwk BT_bwf-f@ Y\ibwQZYk`<U-O
VOYkU@{zQZ>@BG^ACB1OZOSbw{oBHf-boOZOZYkU@{C Yku@XjbwXSM<
=>@Y\Of-bwfgBX'Y\O'i$`<ACfg`oOZBT`<@QZ>-XZBTB_f-b<XQjOsYkXjORQ1w¡Bu@XSY B MPBTOSi$XSYkuB_QZ>@B Ghhe¦deR§ f@XZ`<aRBTi$Q
YkUij>-bwf@QZBXvP¤=>@BU³¡hBCOZfgBTbw®rbwug`<VPQY QSO`ouPaRBTi$QZYk<BTO"-´QZ>@B¤OZB$QSV@f£`w bi$`<ACf@V@QSb5QSY `oU-bw{oXZY\¬PB$
o`wQSBTQZ`chs§./b<U-C¡ >-bwQ_¡BHORQjbwXZQ´XZ`oA9-3OBT<BTXSb<@i$kV-ORQSBXjOYkU¤^«Fhb<XZB1bbwkXZB1b<PMVOB1cuNMk`Pibw
OSi$YkBU]QSYkOQSOHbwU-OZBoBXjbwi`N@BTOeVOYkU@{G^_ AV-OQFugB\bwV@U-ij>-BT`<UQS>@Y\OF{oXZY\&/©e=>-BU³gY Urij>-bwfPQSBXFn
QS>@Y\OXSBfg`<XZQf@XZB1OBTU]QSOhbwUb<U-bwkMPOY\O`wfg`oOSOYku@kBHOZ`<kVPQZYk`<UO_´`oXu@V@YkkPYkU@{QZ>@Y\Oh{<XSYkbwU-b@BTOSi$XSY fPQSY `oU
`<;QZ>@BOBT B1i©QSBTcOZMNOQZBTA'=>-BFBUi$`<V-UoQSBXSBTzf@XS`<u@kBAcObwXSBFPB$QjbwYk B1CQZ>-XZ`oV@{<>@`oVPQQS>@YkOhij>-b<fPQZBTXT rB
¥U-bwk MO>@`5¡ O`oACBf@XZBT YkACY UbwXSMcXZB1OV@ QSOeY Uij>-b<fPQZBTX µCb<U- B$¢@bwACf@kBTO`<'i`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU YkUij>-bwf@QZBX
¶¡ Y QZ>ed ¯+no§ bwU KP=F¯8:hK;
& h'$'³ _
GBTib<{<XSYkY\O+bf@XS`waRB1i©QF`<QZ>-B´XSBU-ij>AzYkU@Y\ORQSXZM`<XZB1OB1bwXjij> QZ>@XS`<V@{o>]QFQZ>-BzFR¦d R§ f@XS`<{oXSb<A
QY\ObaR`oY U]Qf@XS`waRB1i©QugB$QR¡hBBU£RDHd R RKN`<f->@Ykb-G_s `wQZ>@BcDHKPG^ -´_i`<kBPBTOGY U-BTOPB
^b<XZY\O/ `Pib< YkB1£Y U KN`<f@>-YkbwFUoQSY fg`<kY\ObwUREHKP=`< QZ>@B EeU@Yk<BTXSOZY QRM`we^_XZ`5oBU-iB¤ `PiTbwkY TBT£YkU
GbwXjOBTY k Bo£ rB f@XSBTOZBU]Qzu-XZYkB M¬QS>@B`<uPaRB1i©QZYk<B1O`<eQZ>-Bf@XS`waRB1i©Q1'QZ>@BXSBT[]V@YkXZBTAzBTU]QSO`weQS>@BBTU-N
VOBTXSOT@QS>@BB$¢PY\ORQSY U-{i$`oAzf-VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<XSBTOSO`oV@XSiBTO b<U-¡BXZBT]YkB¡ QS>@BQZB1ij>@U@Y\ib<f@XS`<u@kBAcOeQZ>-bwQF¡B
>b/<B+QZ`OZ`<k<Bo=>@Y\O XSB B¢PY `oU Y\O V-OZB$´V-ugBTib<V-OZBY±Q+O>@`5¡eOVO QZ>-B{ob<f ugB$QR¡hBBTU QZ>@BYkU@Y QZY\bwORQjb5QZB
`<QS>@Bi$kV-OQZBXjO bwU OZ`wQR¡bwXSBTOTNbwU-¡ >-b5Qe¡hB>-b/<B+QS`z`ouPQSb<Y UPXZBT<BTb< YkU@{QZB1ij>@U@Y\ibw«f-XZ`ou@ BTAcO
=>-Bzb<Y A `<QZ>-Bzf-XZ`<aRBTi©QY\O+QZ` u@V@Ykk¬bi`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU-bw'{<XSY\PBT<`wQSBTQZ` V@Y\rACB1ij>-bwU@Y\iOT;V-OZY U@{
bcOZB$QH`w'QZ>@XSBBi VORQSBXjO Y U]QSBXji$`<U-U@BTi$QZBT uNMbC¡ YkPBbwXSBTbzU@B$QR¡h`<XS® -9Y U]QZBTXZU-B$Q!/$ =>@BQZ`<QSb<³UNV@AugBX
`<Ff@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<XjOYkO p1x<x¡ >-Ykij>²ACb<®<B1Ofg`oOSOYku@kB¤QS>@Bi$`<ACf@V@QSb5QSY `oU`wHkb<XZ{oBXf-XZ`ou@ BTAcOQS>-bwU²`<U°b
OZYkU@{<kBei$kV-OQZBX1'G`<XSB`5oBX1TQS>@BFb/5bwYk\bwu@Yk Y QRM`<gQS>@Y\OUNV@AugBX_`w;f@XZ`PiBTOSO`oXSO'ib<Ucbwk `5¡ bV-OZBXQS`V-OB
@YkOQSb<UoQU@`PPB1O'Y UzQS>@B BoBU]Q'QZ>-bwQQS>@B UNV@AugBX`<gf-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjOU@BB1PBTQZ`fgBXZ´`<XSA QZ>-Bi`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU
Y\OU@`<QFb//b<Y \bwugB;k`PibwkkM<
=`XZB1b<ij>QS>@B`<uPaRB1i©QZYk<B1O`w@QS>@B GBTiTbw{<XSY\f@XS`waRB1i©QT/QR¡h`PY5*;BXSBU]Qbwf@f-XZ`]b<ij>@B1OiTbwUugB ij>@`N`oOZBU 4
= deFD+KN^«Fd DF= K-¯+¾EH=Z¯+D 4N¿hV@Y \bzi$`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<{oXZY\CQS>-b5QeOZY AV@kbwQZB1O_`oU@BHNYkXQSV-bw
f-bwXjbwkkBi`<ACf@VPQSBXb<O+b¤OZY U@{o Bzi$kV-OQZBXD4 >@`5¡hBoBX1@´`<XFQZ>@Y\OT«¡B>b/<BQS`ugBziTbwXSB$´V@`wU@BQ
¡`oXZ®¤b<U- U@`PPB>@B$QSBXS`<{oBU@BTY±QRMo
¯+G^h¯+DF_DF= ¯+d DF=_§ FdeFR=hh= EFd 4'=bw®oBb<@/b<U]QSbw{oBc`wQZ>-BOZfB1i$Y ¥i$Y QZYkBTO
`wQZ>@B{oXZY\¤uNM¤V-OZYkU@{c¯Hu@aRBTi©Qed B1[]V@BTOQe¿XS`<®oBXQZB1ij>@U@`<k`<{oY B1OU `wQZ>-BX¡`oXS-ONXSB$¡ XZY QZBHQZ>@B
O`<QR¡hb<XZB+YkUb<U¯+dF¿7¡hb/Mo
!#"%$&(')*+),-.0/132546"7
hQHQZ>@BuBT{<YkU@U@YkU@{`<QZ>@Y\OHf@XZ`<aRBTi$QT;OBT<BXjbwbwf@f@kY\ib5QSY `oUi$`PPB1OF¡hBXSBB$¢PY\ORQSY U-{b<OHe_de¯+n<§ ´XS`<A
RDHd R `<XKP=F¯8:hK´XS`<A G_sh=>@B1OBci`N@BTOT³¡ XZY QQSBU¬Y Us'¯+d= dFFD bwU-898«>-b/oBzb
i`<ACAC`<UCij>-bwXjb<i$QZBTXZY\ORQSYki4;QZ>@BTMV-OZBeG^Z;:¦¾<ox&=-kY u@XjbwXSMbwUf@XS`<ubwu@kMY±Q¡ Ykk@uBQS>@Bei$`oACAz`oU
fg`<YkU]Q`<@Az`]ORQbwf@f@kY\ib5QSY `oUi$`PPB1O«QS>]VOY QY\Ob<UYkAzfg`<XZQSb<U]QY U@´`<XSACbwQZYk`<U³eU@`<QZ>@BTXi`PPB<5e§F^
Y\OugBYkU@{¡ XZY QQSBU¬´`<XQR¡`<ªf@>b<OZB `5¡eO+f@XS`<u- BTACOTcU@Y QZY\bwk Mo³QS>@BTOZB¤i$`PPB1O¡BTXZBcPB1OYk{<U@B1QS`XZV-U
`oU£>@`<AC`<{oBU@BT`<V-Oi VORQSBXjOO`YkUb{<XSY\¬@Bf@k`5M<BTAzBTU]QfgBXjOZfB1i©QZYk<BoY QY\Of@\bwU-U@BT¬QS`Y U]QZBT{<Xjb5QSB
k`oboNu-bw\bwU-iY U-{ib<f-bwu-Y kY±QSY B1O
HO+bOYk{<U-Y±¥iTbwU]Q+ij>bwXjb<i©QSBXSYkOQZY\i`<QZ>@BCbwf@f- Y\ibwQZYk`<Ui`N@BTOHQZ>-bwQHQS>-b5Q>-b/oBQZ` uBzXSV@U`<UQZ>@B
{oXZY\«@G^_>: §><ox?=OQSb<U-@bwXj bwU- G^Z YkACf@kBACBU]QSbwQZYk`<U `wG^h¡ Y k³ugBPB$QjbwYk B1 4
G^ : § <<x?=³YkO b Yku@XjbwXSMcOfgBTiY±¥iTb5QSY `oU¤´`<XACBTOSOSbw{<Bªfb<OSOYkU@{-of@XS`<fg`oOZBTboObCOQSb<U-@bwXjcuNM
b u@XZ`]b<PkMu-b<OZBT¬i$`oACAzY QQSBBC`wh<BTU-P`<XjOTgYkACf@kBACBU]QZ`oXSOT³bwUV-OZBXjO+¡ >@Y\ij>¬OZfB1i$Y ¥ibwQZYk`<U-O
bwXSBzb/5b<Y \bwu@kBCb<Ob"0G^_HOQSbwU@bwXj 2©G^+¡b<OPBTOZYk{<U@B1´`oX+>-Y {o>rfgBXZ´`<XSAcbwU-iB`oUrug`wQS>
Acb<OSOYk<BT M¬f-bwXjbwkkBAcb<ij>-Y U@B1Ob<U-£`<U°¡`oXZ®POQSb5QSY `oUi$kV-ORQSBXjOQY\Ou-boOB1£`<U°@YkOQZXSY u-VPQZB1
ACBAC`<XSM¤AC`PPBb<U-B$¢Pf@kYkiY±QFi`<U]QZXS`<;`wQZ>-Bf-bwXjbwk BT Y\OZA
=>@Bb<@/b<U]QSbw{oBTOh`w'G^bwXSB4
U-`C-b5QSbzf@\b<iBACBU]Qef@XS`<u- BTACO
YkACf@kYkiY±QFOZMNU-ij>@XS`<U@Y\OZbwQZYk`<U¡ Y±QS>OZV@u@XS`<V@QZYkU@Bibwk\O
fg`<XZQSb<u@Yk Y QRMcQZ`cPY\OQZXSY u@V@QZBTb<U-O>-b<XZB1¤ACBAC`oXZM¤Acboij>@Y U-BTO
>@`5¡hB<BTXT]QS>@YkOFbwf@f@XS`oboij>¤>-boO bw\O`cOZ`<ACBPXSb/¡ ub<ij®PO 4
U-`COZ`CBTboOM@B<BT `of@ACBU]QebwU- PBTu@V@{<{oY U-{
>-Y {o>kBoB³i$`oACAV@U@Y\ibwQZYk`<U-O -9fBTX´`oXZAcb<U-i$B /
\bwXS{<Bi$`PPB{oXSb<U]V-kb<XZY QRMC`wQZBTUXZB1[oV-Y XSBTQZ`CACY U-Y ACY\OB\b5QSBU-iM
{o `ou-bw;`ofBTXSbwQZYk`<U-O iTbwU uBB¢NfgBUOYk<B
G^Z :¦¾7<<x&=PY\Obef`oXQjbwu@kB_YkACf@ BTACBU]QSbwQZYk`<U`<-G^©1QZ>@BK]QSb<U-@b<XS+´`oXACBTOSOSbw{<Bªfb<OSOYkU@{
Yku@XjbwXSY B1O
=>@BeOZ`wQR¡bwXSBbwXjij>@Y QZB1i©QZV-XZBh`w;G^Z f@V@XjOZV@BTOQR¡h`HAcb<Y Uz{<`]bw\O5fg`<XZQSb<u@Y kY QRMbwU->@Yk{<>zfBTX
´`<XSAcbwU-iB<'s@`<Xf`oXQjbwu@YkkY±QRMo<QS>@BHPB1OYk{<U-BXjO`w³G^_Z¡ Y\O>-BTCQS`Acb5¢PY ACYkBFQZ>@B+bwAC`<V@U]Q_`<
i$`PPBHQZ>-bwQhiTbwU¤ugB+OZ>-b<XZB1«UQZ>@Y\O¡hb/MooAcbwUNMC`w«QS>@Bi$`<ACf@kB$¢¤i`<ACAV@U-YkiTb5QZYk`<Uc`ofBTXSbwQZYk`<U-O
ib<UugB¡ XZY QQSBU Y UQZBTXZAcOh`w `5¡hBXZªkBoB`<U@B1Os@`oXfBTX´`oXZAcbwUi$BTOToQZ>@BTM¤¡ YkOZ>@B1¤QS`f@XS`5NYk@B
bOQZXSV-i©QSV@XZBc¡ >-BXSBuNMrG^_Z i$`oV@\rugBfg`<XZQZB1rQZ`bU@BT¡ f@kbwQ´`oXZA []V@Ykij®NkM<'bwU-rQSV@U@BT
BTboOYk Mo
=`¤boij>@YkB<B+QS>@BTOZB{<`]bw\ONQS>@BM PBTOZY {oU@BTG^_Z bwXS`<V@U-bCi$BTU]QZXjbw«ACBTij>-b<U@Y\OA ibwkkBTQZ>@B
eu-OQZXjb<i$QH§HBNYkiBU]QZBTX9boi$B -3F§HF/©«ekG^_´V@U-i©QSY `oU-O+bwXSBY ACf@kBACBU]QSBTYkUQZBTXZAcOe`<QZ>@B
Acb<i$XS`oOb<U-´V@U-i©QSY `oU-OQS>-b5Qei$`oU-OQZY QZVPQSBQZ>@BH§F©
=>NV-OP`oU`oU@BOY\PB+`wH§F©P¡hB+>-b/<BHQZ>@Bfg`<XZQSb<u@ B+f-b<XQ`wQZ>@BkY u@XjbwXSM<]`<f@QZYkAzYkB1¤´`oXfBTX
´`<XSAcbwU-iB<-b<U- `<U QZ>@B`wQZ>-BXFOZYk@B<@¡hB>-b/<B>-b<XS@¡hb<XZBPBTfBTU-@b<UoQYkAzf- BTAzBTU]QSb5QSY `oU`w'QZ>@B
PBNY\i$Bo'G^Zi$`oU]QSbwYkU-OAcb<U]MY ACf@kBACBTUoQjb5QSY `oU-O`<gQS>@BFH§F©o¡ >@Ykij>cf-XZ`5NY\PB f`oXQjbwu@YkkY±QRM
bwU- >-b<XS@¡hb<XZBH`<fPQSY ACYkTb5QSY `oU-OT
5. 4 .+4 4 + +(32 .0" " . )" %7
`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<«U@`PPBTO b/5b<Y \bwu@kBH´`<X QS>@YkOef@XZ`<aRBTi$Q b<XZBPYkNYkPB1 Y U]QZ`¤nCOZB$QjO@nci V-OQZBTXSOk`PibwQZBT b5Q
RDHd R RKN`of@>@Y\b@_G_s bwUrRE+KP=©b<ij>OY QZBYkOi$`<U-U@BTi$QZBTrQS`QZ>@B`wQZ>-BXjO+QR¡`uNMrikboOZOZY\ibw
U]QSBXSU@B$QU@BQR¡`oXZ®;hbwXjb<i$QZBXSY\ORQSYkiTOF`<i V-OQZBTXSOb<XZBCPBQSbwYkkBT¬Y U¬Qjbwu@kBp<¤=>@B¤i V-OQZBTX`whRDFd R
>b<Op <u@Y f-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjOe^_+b5Q9<<nonG>@7-9fPU@`PPB1O/HbwUpTxu@Ykf@XZ`PiBTOSO`oXSOFh¯+D b5Qv<¦+>-<=>@B
i VORQSBX`wF_Gs>-boOnovu@Ykf@XZ`PiBTOSO`oXSO+^Zb5Q¤p1¦+>-<¤=>@Bci$kV-OQZBTX`whREHKP=+>-b<On]vAz`oU@`w
f-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjO^ b5QFvC¦+>@<=`COZV@ACAcbwXSY TB<@b< «U@`PPB1O bwXSBHU]QSB³f@XS`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjO_V-U-PBXe¾Y UNVP¢¯K;Pu@VPQ
®oBXSU@B-<BXjOZY `oU-Oou-b5Qjij>¤OZij>-BTPV@kBXjOT<f@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<XOZfBTBT@OhbwU-CU-B$QR¡h`<XS®ij>-b<XSboi©QZBTXZY\OQZY\iObwXSBFPY*;BXSBU]QT
G_s°bwQHKN`<f->@YkbwFU]QZYkf`o Y\O
DF`PPBTO 4novu@Ykf@XS`z^'BTUoQSY V-A Z8-p1¦ FD/h¡ Y QZ>f@XSY 5b5QSB^
¯K 4-¾³YkUNVP¢d B1 Hb5QP p
DFB$QR¡h`<XS® 4_vU@B$QR¡h`<XS®PO 4GM]XSYkU@B$QFvc¦+uwO8 s-boORQ QS>@BXSU@BQpTmomGu5Oh´V@k±PV@f- B¢
^b<XSb< kB;kY u@XjbwXSYkBTO84G^Z pov@qCeXS{<`oU@U@BGMNXZYkU@BQFbwU- G^Z pov@¶9b<OQ B$QS>@BXSU@B$Q
¿bwQSij>OZij>@B1PV@kBX 4¯H^_D ^_¿ K
`oACf@Y kBXjO 4^'`<XZQZ\bwU-«N<om PPHg898 bwU¦DHE PHg898
RDHd R b5QFKN`of@>@Y\b5eU]QZYkfg`<kYkO
DF`PPBTOD-´fP!/ 4 p <zu@Ykf@XS`z^'BTUoQSY V-A Z8- <<nonG>-D/¡ Y QZ>f@V@u- Y\i^
DF`PPBTOD-´U@YkU-b / 4 pTxzu@Ykf@XS` HB`oU -ªvc¦+>@D/h¡ Y QZ>f@V@u- Y\i^
¯K 4-¾³YkUNVP¢d B1 Hb5QHv@v
DFB$QR¡h`<XS® -´fP/ 4s-boORQZªQS>@BXSU@BQFDeB$QR¡h`<XS®pTmomGu5Oh´V@k PV-f@ B¢
DFB$QR¡h`<XS® -´U@YkU-b/ 4_¦+Y {]bwu@Y QQS>@BXSU@B$QFDFB$QR¡h`<XS®p¦+u@f-O´V@k PV-f@ B¢
^b<XSb< kB;kY u@XjbwXSYkBTO84^ HG n-µv@PG^Z p<vP¶zbwU- ¾HG5G^hx-¶@µ
¿bwQSij>OZij>@B1PV@kBX 4¾KPs
`oACf@Y kBXjO 4^'`<XZQZ\bwU-«N<om@NNHg898 bwU-¦DFE NHg898
RE+KP=b5QeGbwXjOZBYk kB
DF`PPBTO 4nov^'BU]QZYkV@A Az`oU@`<f-XZ` -3vC¦ e /¡ Y QZ>f@XSY 5b5QSB^
¯K 4-¾³YkUNVP¢d B1 Hb5QPv®<BTXZU-B³vPµ-kp
DFB$QR¡h`<XS® 4s-boORQZªQS>@BXSU@BQFDeB$QR¡h`<XS®pTmomGu5Oh´V@k PV-f@ B¢«
^b<XSb< kB;kY u@XjbwXSYkBTO84G^Z pov@¶
¿bwQSij>OZij>@B1PV@kBX 4¯HfBTU@^_¿ K
`oACf@Y kBXjO 4RDF=_¾¬NN<om@Hg898 bwU-¦DFE NH898
=bwu@kBcp4=bwu@kB`wij>-bwXjb<i$QZBXSY\ORQSYkiTO´`oX BTb<ij>i$kV-OQZBTX
§HV@BeQS`QZ>-YkOhf-b<XQSYkiV@kb<Xb<XSij>@Y QZB1i©QSV@XZBooOZ`<ACBFfg`<YkU]QSOU@BB1¤bfbwXZQZY\i$V@\bwX_iTbwXSB<'=>@BMcb<XZB+OV@ACAcb5
XSYkBTugBk`5¡ 4
EFOZY U-{ri$\b<OSOZYkiTbwU]QZBTXZU-B$QU@BQR¡`oXZ® -´YªBoU@`<QOfgBTiYkb< YkB1£`<XzOB1i$V@XSBc YkU@B /QZ`rY U]QSBXji$`<U-U@BTi$Q
i$kV-OQZBXjOY\OebCOB1i$V@XSY±QRMc>-`<kB<
@V@XZYkU@{ bwVPQS>@BU]QZY ¥iTb5QZYk`<UgY QY ACf@kY B1OHQZ>@BV-OBz`w_iXZMNfPQSBTri$BXZQZY ¥iTb5QZB1Oe`oX+OQZXS`<U@{f-b<OSOR
¡h`<Xj@OT
@V@XZYkU@{i$`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-O'ugBTiTbwV-OZBf-b<ij®oB$QjO¡ Ykk-i$YkXSiV@\b5QZBhQS>@XZ`oV@{<>zAcb<ij>@YkU@B1ObwU-XZ`oVPQZBTXSO
¡ >-`oOZBOZBTiV@XSY±QRMcYkU]QZB{oXZY QRM¤Y\OV@U@®NU@`5¡ U¡hB+>b/<BHQZ`cV-OZBi$XSM]f@QZ`<{oXSb<f@>@Y\ief@XS`wQSBTi$QZYk`<U-OT
=¡h`e`<]QS>@BQS>@XZBTB_i$kV-OQZBTXSO -ª_GsbwU-RE+KP=F/«bwXSBu@V@Yk Q`<U¾FD -9¾³`PiTbwoFXZB1b DeBQR¡`oXZ®=/©
QYkACf@ YkBTO³QZ>-bwQU@`PPB1Ob<XZBY\PBU]QSY±¥-B1uNM+bef@XZYk5b5QSB^b<@@XZB1OZOTTu-VPQi`<ACAV@U-YkiTb5QZYk`<UugB$QR¡hBBTU
QR¡`rU@`PPBTO´XS`<A PY*gBTXZBTU]QCOZY±QSBTOT_b<OXSBT[]V@YkXZB1uNMG^©'uB1i$`oAzB1OzY ACfg`oOSOYku@kB<£U-PBTBT«_b
i$`oAzf-VPQZBTX Y UbC¾HD YkOU-`wQe®NU@`5¡ Ub<U- U@`wQ XS`<VPQjbwu@kB+QZ>@XS`<V-{<>QZ>@BU]QZBTXZU-B$QT
=>@Y\OFOZB$QH`<i$kV-ORQSBXjO Y\OFbcACBXS{<B`<n¤PY\ORQSY U-i$Q+b<VPQZ>@`oXZY QZYkBTOTbwU-QZ>NV-OFBTboij>V-OBTXe`w'QS>@B{oXZY\
¡ Y ke>-b/oB OZBoBXjbwY\PBU]QZY QZYkBTOT U `<V@XCB$¢@b<Azf- Bohn£i$kV-OQZBTXSOzYkAzf- YkBTO¤n£b<VPQZ>@`oXZY QZYkBTOCb<U-²n
Yk@BU]QZY QZYkBTOHfBTXHVOBTXTF§HV@XSY U-{OZV@u@ACYkOSOZY `oUbwU-i`<ACf@VPQjb5QSY `oU³-QS>@BOZMPORQSBA AV-OQHugBCbwu@kBQZ`
b<OSO`PiYkbwQZBQZ>-BXSY {o>oQH `Pib<V-OZBXHYkQZ`bXZB1[oV-BTOQ ´XZ`oA b<U@`wQS>@BXHOY QZB?-9OSbwACBf@>NMPOY\ib<fgBXjO`oU
u@VPQ@Y5*;BXSBU]Q¤k`<{<Y\ib< Yk /©=>@BVOB`< ¶<m < :=Fhqoq&=HiBXZQZY ¥ibwQZBTOcOZBBTAcOCQZ`ugBb£{<`N`P
O`o V@QZYk`<U³
=>@Bc\b<OQQZ>@YkU@{QZ`U@`<QZBcY\OQZ>b5Q¡hBz>b/<BcPY*gBTXZBTUoQu-bwQSij>OSij>@BTPV- BTXSO -ª¯HfgBU-^_¿ K :`ofB1m<n&=
´`<XeRE+KP= bwU-G_shg¾KPs :\OR9m-p =k´`<XeRDHd R /$=>@B1OBu-bwQSij>OSij>@BT@V@ BTXSO b<XZBV-U-bwu@kBQZ`
i$`N`<fgBXjb5QSB<_=¡h`c¡`oXZ®5bwXS`<V-U-@ObwXSBf`]OZOZY u- B4_`<U`oU@B>-bwU«-b<Oe¡ Y kugBPBTOSi$XSYkuB1Y Un@kp<kpw
¡BHibwUCAcbw®oBebOfgBTiY±¥gi XZB1[]V@BTOQ`<UcB1b<ij>cOY QZBHbwU-«o`<UCQS>@Be`wQS>@BX_>-bwU-³<¡hBFib<UzVOBFb+QS`N`< -
O`oXQ `<f-b<XSOZBX/bwu@kB+QZ`cPY\OZiV-OZOe¡ Y±QS> B1b<ij>u-b5Qjij>OSij>@B1PV@kBX1'=>-B+VOBb<U-YkU]QZBTXZB1ORQ `wQZ>-YkO
QRMNfB`< 0ACB$QSbwOSij>@B1PV@kBXF2F¡ Y k³ugBPYkOSi$VOZOZBTY UOZBTi$QZYk`<Un@kp<µP
(« $(&# °& '$
! . *. .+
DF`5¡ QZ>-bwQ¡hBPBTOSi$XSYkuB1¬QZ>@Bf@XZ`ou@kBA>-`<\PY U-{oOb<U-`oVPQSi`<ACBTOTOZ`<ACB¤fg`oOSOZY u@kBOZ`<kVPQZYk`<UO¡ Yk
ugBPY\OZiV-OSOB1ugBk`5¡=>@B¥-XjORQQSXZM i$`<UOY\ORQjOhY Ub 0>-bwU-PªAcb<@B2+OZ`<kVPQZYk`<U V-OZY U-{cK-K ´`<XeOZBTiV@XSY±QRM
f-V@XZfg`oOZB<r=>@BU`oV@XzY U]QZBTXZB1ORQ¡ Y kugB´`NiV-OZBT`oU/b<XZYk`<VOG^Z`5<BTXZ\b/M<BTXSOb<u@ BQZ`rAz`PPY ´M
i`<ACAV-U@YkiTb5QSY `oUrugB>-b/NYk`<V@X`< f@XZ`PiBTOSOB1O+QZ`PB1bw¡ Y QZ>£QS>@BOZfB1i$Y ¥i$Y QZYkBTO`< `<V@X{oXZY\«=>-BU£¡B
¡ YkkOfgBTb<®bwug`<V@QF¯+dF¿ QZB1ij>@U@`<k`<{oM¤bwU- ¡ Yk ;¥U@YkOZ>¡ Y±QS>AzY\@PkB¡bwXSBO`o V@QZYk`<U-OT
½ º @½ ¸ ~ ¼ ¼ » 9
=>-BC¥-XSOQQZXSM¡b<O+QS`OBTBcY± b<BTXZMrOYkACf@ B¤OZ`<kVPQSY `oU¬VOYkU@{`<U- M¬G^Z b<U-K@K :Hk`*<<x?=´`<X
OZBTiV@XSY±QRMcY\O fg`oOSOYku@kB<
EHOYkU@{K@K ¡ Y QZ>CG^Z YkO'OZ`<ACB$QS>@YkU@{HoBXSMV-OZV-bwPbwUOZY ACf@kB< rBaRV-OQ>-b/<B_QZ`+uB b/¡bwXSB`wQZ>@B
®oBMPO+{<BTU@BXjb5QSY `oUf@XS`wQS`Ni`< -´¡hBCAV-OQ{<BTU@BXjb5QSBzi`<V@f@kBTO`<f@XSYk/bwQZB /f@V@u- Y\i®oBMPObwUf@V@Qf@V@u@kYki
®oBMPOY UXZYk{<>]Qf@kboi$B1O/_bwU-bw{<BTU]QACBTij>-b<U@Y\OA -9Y±Qebwkk`5¡eO_bwU bwVPQS>@BU]QSY±¥iTb5QSY `oUf@XS`/¢PMQS`b<U-O¡hBXQZ`
AV@ QZYkf@ Bb<U]QZ>@BTUoQSY±¥gib5QSY `oU ij>bwk BTU@{<B1Ohb<VPQZ`oAcb5QZY\ib< kM=/©
¿hVPQY QhugBTi`<ACBTOAC`<XSBHi$`oACf@ Y\ibwQZB1¤PV@XSY U-{OZV@u@ACYkOSOZY `oU³¯HUBTboij>¤OY QZBo]¡hB+>-b/<BFb<UbwV@QZ`<U-`<AC`<V-O
b<U-PY*gBTXZBTU]Qu-bwQSij>OSij>@BTPV- BTXSO -3¾KPsh¯HfBTU@^_¿ K;k k/ O`¡Bb<XZBV@U-bwu- BcQS`Acbw®oBCQZ>@BTA ¡`oXZ®
QS`<{oB$QZ>-BX1¿hB$´`oXZBhb+OZV@u@ACY\OZOZYk`<U³5¡hBAV-OQ'ugB i$`oU@U@BTi$QZB1QS`HB1b<ij>´XS`<U]QSBU-«oOV@u-AzY QbwUY U]QZBTXSboi©QSY oB
XSBT[]V@B1ORQH´`<X+U@`PPBTOT«{<BQHu-boij®s+§+D¨UbwACB`<´V@XSU@YkOZ>@B1U@`PPB1O+b<U-¡ XSY±QSBzbf@XS`Ni{<XS`<V@f¥ B´`<X
G^Z-eQZBTX QZ>-bwQT@¡hBbwXSBbwu@kB+QZ`c\bwV@U-ij>bwk³G^hf@XS`Pi$BTOSOZBTOh`<Ui$kV-OQZBXjOT
FU@`wQS>@BXf-XZ`ou@ BTA Y\OQZ>-bwQY±Q_P`NB1O'U@`wQXSBTOZ`<k<B_QZ>@B9boi©QQZ>b5QG^Z@BNYkiBTO'U@BTBTQZ``ofBTUzPYkXSBTi©Q
i`<U@U-B$¢PY `oU-O´XZ`oA U@`PPBQS`zU-`N@Bu]MV-OYkU@{zQSifi$`<U-U@B$¢PYk`<U uBQR¡BTBU QR¡`zf@V@u- Y\i^7b<PXSBTOSOB1O
=>@Bb5QQSBACfPQHQZ`cB\bwug`<Xjb5QSBbwU10>-bwUNªAcboPB2OMPOQZBA OZ>@`5¡eOV-OFb¤ `<Qe`wf@XS`<u@kBAcOeb<U-¡ >-b5Q
OZ>@`oV@kugBij>-bwXjb<i$QZBXSY\ORQSYkiTO_`<`oV@XeO`o V@QZYk`<U³
5 ¸ 5~c@~"!|$#&% º !')( |+*-,/.0,/'213,4'5'5'
¬Xjbwf@fgBXjOO`o oBHf@XS`<u- BTACOb<u`oVPQ AV@ QZYkf@kBU@B$QR¡h`<XS®cPBNY\i$BTO`oUbz{<XSY\bwU`ofPQZYkACY TBHQS>@Bij>@`oYkiB
b<U-+V-OZB`wPb i$`<kkBTi©QSY `oU`wPPBNY\i$BTOT=¡h`hB¢@bwACf@kBTO«`<]¡ Xjbwf@fgBXjO«bwXSB^«F eG^«bwU+GF§H_¾³RDF
^«F FG^_):fb<imon&=;YkOhbwUG^i`<ACf@kYkb<U]QkY u@XjbwXSMzV-OB1C´`<X>@B$QSBXS`<{oBU@BT`<V-O_{<XSYkCBTU]NYkXZ`oU@U@BTAzBTU]Q
b<U-YkOPBT<BT `of@fB1YkUQZ>@B)FY {o>^'BXZ´`<XSAcbwU-iB `oACf@VPQZYkU@{BU]QSBX`w«K]QZV@QQZ{]bwXZQT'=>@Y\O Yku@XjbwXSM>-b<O
b<UYkU]QZBXSBTOQZYkU@{H´BTbwQZV@XSB4@bwBTAz`oU-OT5XZV@U-U@Y U-{+`oUB1b<ij>´XS`<U]QSBU-«obwXSBV-OZBTQZ`+ACBXS{<Bbwk@i$`oU@U@BTi$QZYk`<U-O
ugB$QR¡hBBTUQR¡h`i$kV-OQZBXjOeYkU`oU@Bi`<U@U@B1i©QSY `oU³F=>@B¥-XSOQFAC`wQSY 5bwQZYk`<U¡b<OeQZ`XSBT@V-i$BQS>@BUNV@AuBTXH`<
i`<U@U-BTi©QSY `oU-OHuBQR¡BTBUKPG^ u@VPQQZ>@Y\O+´BTbwQZV@XSBzACb<®<B1OHfg`oOSOZY u@kBCG^Ff-XZ`o{<XjbwAcO QS`i`<ACAV-U@YkiTb5QSB
´XS`<A `<XeQZ`5¡bwXj@OU@`PPBTOF¡ Y±QS>f@XSY 5b5QSB^¡ >@Y\ij>Y\Oe<BTXZMY U]QSBXSBTOQZYkU@{C´`<XH`<V@XFi`<UP¥{<V@Xjb5QSY `oU³h¿hVPQ
QS>@Y\OhOZ`<kVPQSY `oU¤YkOb<kOZ`bPYkOSb<@/b<U]QSbw{oBFugBTiTbwV-OZBFY QhXSBT[]V@YkXSBTO_QZ`zkb<V@U-ij>v@bwBTAC`<U-OfBTXhOZV@u@ACY\OZOZYk`<U³
boOhV-OBTXTN`oUBTboij>¤´XS`<U]QZBTU-¡ >@Ykij> P`NBTOU@`<Qi`<U-OQZY QZV@QZBbXSB{oV@\bwXhV-OB`<³QZ>@B+´XS`<U]QZBTU- bwU-u-b5Qjij>
OSij>@B1PV@kBX1
GF§H_¾³RDF Z :FG = YkOV-OZBT QZ``ofPQZYkACYkOZBi`<ACAV@U-YkiTb5QZYk`<UOcuBQR¡BTBUOZBoBXjbwei$kV-OQZBTXSOc`<
¡h`<XS®PORQjb5QSY `oU-OU OZf@Y QZB`<V-OZY U-{zOQSb<U-@bwXj¤f-XZ`<QZ`Pi$`o;OQSboij® -´`oX B$¢@bwACf@kB=F^²¡ Y QZ>G^Ze¦v
::bwX =-`<X'^«F eG^F/$<GF§H_¾RDeY\OPB1OYk{<U@B1QS`B$¢Pf@k`<Y QT5QS`+Y QSO'Acbw¢NYkAV-A wQZ>@Beij>-b<XSboi©QSBXSYkO
QSYkiTO`wgOZfgBTi$Y\bwkYkBTU@B$QR¡h`<XS®POugB$QR¡hBBTUi V-OQZBTXSO'boOkYk®<Bb<O'GMNXZYkU@BQ'`oXK-©5=`P@b/Mo5U@`b<OSOV@ACfPQSY `oU
Y\Of`]OZOZYku@ Bh`<UQZ>@BU-bwQZV@XSB_`<YkU]QZBXZi$kV-ORQSBX YkU@®POT/QZ>NV-O'¡hBhb<XZBV@U-bwu- BQZ`+V-OZBhGH§F¾³RDFOfgBTiY±
¥gi$Y QRM<
=>@B1OB¡ XSb<f@fBTXSOT-OZ`<k<BQS>@Bf@XS`<u@kBA `wf@XSYk/bwQZB^boPXSBTOSOB1OuB1ibwVOBY Q+b< k`5¡ VO QZ`Az`PPY ´M
QS>@B YkUoQSBXZi VORQSBX_i`<U@U@B¢PY `oU-O=>@B AcbwYkUcPXSb/¡ ub<ij®`<;b< PQS>@BTOZB ¡ Xjbwf@fgBXjO'YkOQZ>@BeOSbwACBeboO 0R>bwU-N
AcboPB2OZ`<kVPQZYk`<U 4F¡hB>-b/oBQS` PB1bw'¡ Y QZ>`oU@BCPY5*;BXSBU]QbwVPQS>@`<XSY QRMbwU-u-b5Qjij>rOSij>@BTPV- BTXH`oUBTboij>
OZY QZB<QeYkACf@kY B1O bCACb<UNV-bw;\bwV@U-ij>bwU i`N`<XjPY Ub5QZYk`<U`wf@XZ`PiBTOSOB1O
~
FU`<u@aRBTi©QHXZB1[oV-BTOQeu@XZ`o®<BTX -ª¯+de¿ /Y\OFb¤AzY\@PkB¡bwXSBQSBTij>@U@`o `o{<McQS>-b5Q+AcbwU-b<{<BTOFi$`<ACAV@U@Y\ib5QSY `oU
b<U-@b5QjbzB$¢@ij>-bwU-{<B+uBQR¡BTBU`<uPaRB1i©QjOUQS>@YkOFbwf@f@XS`oboij>³PPY\ORQSY U-i$Q ´BTbwQZV@XSBTOeb<XZB+BUibwfOV@\b5QSBT YkU
`ouPaRBTi$QSO+k`NiTbwkY TBTrO`oAzBT¡ >@BXSB`oUQS>@BC{<XSYk³=>@Bzu@XS`<®<BTXH>b<O+Y U£ij>-b<XZ{oBQZ`i`<U@U@B1i©QXZB1[]V@BTOQSOHQZ`
OZBXSNYkiBTOT=>@Y\OOZ`<kVPQZYk`<UY\OoBXSMU-bwQZV@Xjbw_´`<Xzi$`PPBi`<V@f- YkU@{u@V@QY QY\OU@`<QQS`wQSb< kM£OV@Y QSb<u@kBc´`<X
AcboOZOZY oBkMrfbwXSXSb< BT bwf@f- Y\ibwQZYk`<U-OTG`<XSB`5oBX1YkUQS>@BGBTiTbw{<XSY\£f@XZ`<aRBTi$QTQS>@YkOCOZ`<kVPQZYk`<U²O>@`oV@\
>b/<BeXSBT[]V@YkXZB1cbwU¤YkACf`oXQjbwU]Q_XSB$BU@{oY U-BBXSYkU@{`w³B1b<ij>OZ`wQR¡bwXSBebwU-¤¡hboOU@`<Q_´`<V-U-¤f@Xjb<i$QZY\ib<PV@B
QS`zQZ>@B\bwXS{<B+UNV@AugBXe`<i`N@BTOhQZ>b5Q QZ>-BBU-NV-OZBXjOh¡hb<UoQQS`cXZV@U `<UQZ>-B{<XSYk«
~ 9½½
¸o»
P
¸
`oU-i$BTXZU-Y U@{CACY\@PkB¡bwXSBTOT@bC `<Qe`wO`o VPQSY `oU-O bwXSBf`]OZOZYku@ Bo FBXSB+¡hB¡ Yk @YkOSi$V-OSOeb<u`oVPQH¦+ `ou@V-O
¡ >-Ykij> YkO QZ>@BAC`oOQ f`of@V@\bwX1@EeU@Y\i$`oXZBo@¾³BT{<Yk`<U³-KNV-U¦+XSY\U-{<YkU@BbwU-`<UP`<X1
-.
·Y\O bAzY\@PkB¡bwXSBe´`oX{<XSYki$`<ACf@V@QZYkU@{z@BTOZY {oU@BT`<U¤QS>@XSBB+BkBACBU]QSOU-BTi$B1OR
OSbwXSM+´`<Xi$`oACf@VPQZYkU@{YkUzb¦+XZY\BUNNY XS`<U@ACBTUoQ1=>@Bh¥-XjORQY\O'd BTOZ`<V@Xji$BGb<U-bw{oBACBU]Qb<U-Y±QYkU]o`<k<B1O
b< k`PibwQZYkU@{XSBTOZ`<V@Xji$B1Of@XS`5NYkPB1cuNMcb¦+XSYk«=>-BHOZBTi$`oU-cY\OhUP´`<XSAcb5QZYk`<U KNBXSNYkiBTOhbwU-cY Qf@XZ`5NY\PBTO
YkUP´`oXZAcb5QSY `oUb<u`oVPQ ¦+XSY\XSBTOZ`<V@Xji$B1O'=>@BHQZ>@YkXjY\O §HbwQSbzGbwUbw{<BTACBU]Qb<U-¤Y QeYkU]o`<k<B1Oboii$B1OZOZYkU@{
b<U-ACb<U-bw{oY U-{z@bwQSbzYkUbc¦+XSYk BTU]NYkXZ`oU@ACBU]QT
d B1O`oV@Xji$B_Gb<U-bw{oBACBU]Q³YkUN<`<k<B1O;QZ>-Bbwkk`NiTb5QSY `oUbwU-AcbwUbw{<BTACBU]Q`w¦+XSY\XZB1O`oV@XSiBTOT³s@`oXB$¢N
b<ACf@ Bo/Y±Qi`<U]QSb<Y UO«9b<iY kY QZYkBTO«QS`eAcbw®oBPY5*;BXSBU]Qu-b5Qjij>OZij>@B1PV@kBXjO³i$`N`ofBTXSbwQZBb<O¾KPs`<X'¯HfBTU@^_¿ K;
U@´`<XSACbwQZYk`<UCKNBXSNYkiBTOf@XZ`5NY\PBTOYkUP´`<XSAcb5QSY `oUbwug`<V@Q¦+XSYkXSBTOZ`<V@Xji$B1O§+b5QjbHGbwU-b<{<BACBTUoQ'YkU]o`<k<B1O
QS>@BHb<u@Yk Y QRMQS`boii$B1OZO_bwU-cAcb<U-bw{oBF@b5QjbYkUb¦+XSYkcBTUN]YkXS`<U@ACBU]Q1s-`<X_B¢@bwACf@kB<]Y±QhY U-i VPBTOhi$`oA
fg`<U-BU]QSO'OZV-ij>zboO¦+XZY\@s'=^'w¡ >@Y\ij>Y\O'V-OB1QS`HAC`5oB_¥-kBTO'ugB$QR¡hBBTUC¦+XSY\NªBTU-bwu- B1OQZ`<Xjbw{oB_OZMNOQZBTAcO
¦+k`<u@VOei$`oUoQjbwYkU-O bCk`wQe`w'QS`]`okOVOB´V@³´`oXe{<XSYk i$`oACf@VPQZYkU@{G`oXZBT`5<BX1NbcOfgBTiY±¥iPBNY\i$B+´`<X
G^Z ¡b<O YkACf@kBACBU]QZB1bwUi$`<V-kB¢Nf-kb<Y UY QOFfg`<f@V-kb<XZY QRM< ¬B aRV-OQH>-b/oBQZ`¤U@`<QZY\i$BQS>-b5Q+Y±Q
@`]B1OU@`wQFOZ`<k<B+`<V-X f@XZ`ou@kBA `<i$`oACAV@U@Y\ibwQZYk`<U uBQR¡BTBU U@`PPBTOeV-OYkU@{Cf@XSY 5bwQZB^7b<PXSBTOSOB1O
9 ¼ ¸ , #¡b<OPBT<BT `of@fB1£b5Qz¯ *;BUNu-b<ij>¬YkU°¦+BXSACb<UNMuNMrEFDFZ ¯+d s@`oXZV-Ayb<OSOZ`NiY±
bwQZYk`<U³=>@YkOf-XZ`<aRBTi©QbwYkAcOHQZ>@Bz´`<kk`5¡ Y U@{AcbwYkUr{o`obw 4H@B<BT `of@YkU@{bACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZB´`<Xb OB1bwAC B1OZO
OZBTiV@XSB<PbwU-Y U]QSV@Y±QSY oBb<iiBTOSOQS`cPYkOQZXSYku@VPQZB1¤XSBTOZ`<V@Xji$B1O´`oX{<BXSAcbwU¤V-U@Y oBXjOY QRM¤bwU¤XSBTOZBTbwXjij>¤\bwuP
`oXSbwQZ`oXZMo=>@BOBQh`<«QZ`N`<\Ohf@XS`5]Y\PB1cuNMCEFU@Y\i$`<XSBFY\OQZ>@B+AC`oOQi`<ACf@kB$QSB+boO_Y Qh{o`NBTO_´XZ`oA `5¡ BT<BT
XS`<V@QZYkU@BTOzQS`BU-NV-OZBX¤b<f@f@kYkiTb5QZYk`<UO¤OVij> boO¦Ee©f@ V-{wY U-Oz´`oXOSi$YkBU]QZY ¥ii$`PPB1O ¿V@Q¤U@`wQb<
k`5¡ BT<B'QS`N`<\OU@BB1PBT£uNM¬{<XSYk£i`<ACf@VPQSY U@{rbwXSBcY ACf@kBACBU]QSBT«QzOZBBTAcOQZ`ugBb<UY U]QZBTXZB1ORQSY U-{
b<±QSBXSU-b5QSY oBFQS`¤¦+ `ou@V-Oeb<U-OZ>@`oV@kugBORQSV-PYkBT AC`<XSB+f-XZB1i$Y\OBT Mo
. ¸ ¼ # ·· 9bwk\OY U]QZ`zQS>@BOZb<AzBibwQZBT{<`<XSMcb<O ¦+k`<u@V-OT=>@BAcbwYkU{o`obw;`<¾³BT{<Yk`<UY\OhQZ`
{oBU@BTXSbwQZBQZ>@BcYkk V-OZYk`<U¬`whbOZY U-{<kB<@YkOQZXSY u-VPQZB1ri`<ACf@VPQSBX1C=>-B¤¾³{oY `oUr^XS`waRB1i©Q¡b<OT³Y U-Y±QSYkb< kM<
bf-XZ`<aRBTi©Q`wQZ>@BEeU@Yk<BTXSOZY±QRMr`w HY XS{<YkU@Y\b@EeUP´`oXQSV@U-b5QSBkM<QZ>-YkOf@XZ`<aRBTi$QuB1ib<AzBbi$`<ACACBXji$Y\bw
f-XZ`PPV-i$Q U-bwACBT :´XS`<A ' :e`<XSf`oXSbwQZYk`<U³] `PiTb5QZB1 Y UGboOZOSb<ij>NV-OZB$QZQSOT
9½ , ¸
5
(# ¼ ½ ¼
.
bwXSBcU@`wQ1b<i$QZV-b< kM<'{<XSY\£AzY\@PkB¡bwXSB<=>-BM
iTbwUugB OZBBTU°b<OACB$QSboOZij>-BTPV@kBXjOb<U-iTbwU°P`QZ>@B OZb<ACBaR`<u²b<O¾KPs `<X^_¿ K£YkU²b@YkOQZXSY u-VPQZB1
BTUN]YkXS`<U@U@BTACBU]QT
%" .+ ./ . " . .+
¬B PBTiYk@BTQZ`u@V@YkkCbi$`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-b<N{<XSYkQZ>-bwQ_OYkAV@\b5QSBTO`<U-BhNYkXQSV-bwNf-b<XSb< kBPi`<ACf@VPQSBX1wAC`<XSB
f-XZB1i$Y\OBT MC`<U-BHNYkXQSV-bw«i$kV-OQZBTXT=>@Bu@Yk{<{oBTOQhb<@/b<U]QSbw{oBFY\O¡BaRV-OQ >-b/<BFQZ`zf@VPQebwk«`<V@XhB*;`<XZQSOh`oU
`oU@BQZ>-Y U@{ 4_QS>@BBTkb<u`oXSbwQZYk`<U `wbCNY XZQZV-b<i V-OQZBTX QZ`AzYkU@YkACY TBO`<QR¡hb<XZBbo@bwfPQjb5QSY `oU³UOZf@Y QZB`<
OZfgBU-PYkU@{Cbk`wQ`w«QSY ACB+`<UAC`PPY ¥ibwQZYk`<U-OT]XZBªBTU@{<YkU@BBTXZYkU@{w´`<X !!% OZ`wQR¡bwXSBe¡BH¡hb<U]Q_QZ`zV-OZBF`oU
QS>@Y\O_{oXZY\«N¡B+OfgBUb¥U@Y±QSB+b<AC`<V@U]Q_`<³QZYkACBH`oU-i$BF´`<X G^_Zu-boOB1¤OZ`wQR¡bwXSB<^'`<QZBU]QSYkb< kM<
b< «s'¯+d= dFFD-H-898 i`N@BTOu-b<OZBT`<UG^Z Yku@XjbwXSMzb<XZBHB$¢PBTiVPQSb<u@ B+`<UQZ>@B+{<XSY\ -´®oBBTfYkU
ACYkU-QS>@Bz>@B$QSBXS`<{<BTU@BY QRM `wQS>@YkOH{<XSY\&/©=>@Y\OF>b<OHuBTBU´`oV@U-QZ` uBCbPB1i$Y\OYk<Bzb<P5b<UoQjbw{oB`5<BTX
¯+dF¿²=BTij>@U-`<k`<{<Mo=>@B+ij>@`oOZBU¤OZ`<kVPQSY `oUcYkOhi$`oU-ORQSY±QSVPQZB1cuNMcbACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZB -ª¦+ `ou@V-O!/`5oBX_b F^_D
:`<U =
!1 =`O`o oBhQZ>@B f@XS`<u- BTA `wgQZ>@Bei VORQSBXjOY UCf@XSYk/bwQZB i$\b<OSOZBTO'`wg^'wQZ>-Bei$`<ACAV@U@Y\ib5QSY `oU-O'¡ Yk
ugBXS`<VPQSBTQZ>@XS`<V@{o> bzNYkXQSV-bw«U@BQR¡`oXZ® -F^_D8/YkU-ORQjbwk B1 uBQR¡BTBUbwk;´XZ`oUoQSBU--O
KP`<ACB`w³QS>@Bi$kV-OQZBXjOi$`oU-ORQSY±QSVPQZYkU@{zQZ>-YkO{oXZY\b<XZB+u@V@Yk±Qe`oU ¾FD@=>]VO i$`<ACAV@U@Y\ib5QSY `oUugB$QR¡hBBTU
QR¡h`cbwXSu@Y QZXjbwXSMcU@`PPBTO´XS`<A PY*gBTXZBTUoQFOZY QZBTOT-boO XZB1[]V@Y XSBTuNMG^_ugBTi`<ACBTOebCf-XZ`ou@ BTAU-PBTBT«-b
i`<ACf@VPQSBX+Y Urb¾HD Y\OHU@`wQ®NU@`5¡ UbwU-U@`wQ+XZ`oVPQSb<u@kBQZ>@XS`<V-{<>U]QZBTXZU-B$Q³=F^f-b<ij®oB$QSOHib<U@U@`wQ
iY Xji$V-kbwQZB`oUQZ>-B{o `ou-bwU@B$QR¡h`<XS®rY F`oU@B`< QZ>@Bb<-PXZB1OZOZBTO-9OZ`<V@Xji$B`<XzPBTOQZYkU-b5QSY `oU /YkOf@XSY 5b5QSB<
=>NV-OT-¡hB>-b/oBQZ`¥-U-bc¡b/M¤QS`BUbwu@kBQZ>-Bi$`oAzAV@U@Y\ibwQZYk`<UugB$QR¡hBBUU-`N@BTOTe=>@XZBTBOZ`<kVPQZYk`<U-O
b<XZB+fg`oOSOYku@kB4
b<OSOYk{<U-Y U@{zf@V@u- Y\i^7b<@PXSBTOSOZBTO´`<X B1b<ij> U@`PPB
V-OZY U@{¤bzACY\@PkB¡bwXSBF´`oXQZ>@B{oXZY\¡ >-Ykij>YkUoQSB{oXSbwQZBTObzf@XS`/¢PMcXZV@U-U@Y U-{z`oUB1b<ij>´XZ`oU]QZBU«
V-OZY U@{cbz¡h`<XS®/b<XZ`oV@U-¤b<f@f@kY B1¤QS`zQZ>@BU@BQR¡`oXZ®CYkU`<XjPBXQZ`CBUbwu@kB+QZ>@BXS`<VPQSY U-{ugB$QR¡hBBTU b<
U@`PPBTOT
=>-BH¥XSOQe`<U@B>-boOU@`wQ ugBBTU´`oV@U- fg`oOSOYku@kB+uNM OMPOQZBAb<PACYkU@YkOQZXjb5QS`<XjOOYkU-i$BY Qe{<BTU@BXjb5QSBTOhAC`<XSB
fg`wQSBU]QZY\bwOB1i$V@XSY±QRM>@`<kBTOHbwU- XSBT[]V@YkXZB1O AC`<XSBb5QZQZBU]QSY `oU³h=>-BOB1i$`oU- `<U@BXSBTPVi$BTO QZ>@Bfg`oOSOZY u@YkkY±
QSY B1O´`<XQZ>@Bij>@`oYkiBF`wQZ>@BACYk-P BT¡hb<XZBo=>-BFQS>@Y Xj¤`oU@BibwUuB+YkAzf- BTAzBTU]QZBT¡ Y QZ>¤QSBTij>@U-Yk[]V@B1O`<
fg`<XZQ´`<XS¡hb<XS@Y U@{`<X F^D-HY XZQZV-b<«^XSY 5b5QSBDeB$QR¡h`<XS®=/©KN`C¡ >@Y\ij>`oU@BuBQR¡BTBU f`oXQ´`oXZ¡bwXjPYkU@{
`oX H^_D YkOhugB$QQSBX=>@BO`o VPQSY `oUi$`oU-OZYkOQZYkU@{YkUVOYkU@{QS>@B+f`oXQ´`<XS¡hb<XSPYkU@{Y\Oh<BTXZMz>@BTb/NMQZ`zY Az
f- BTAzBTU]Qb<U-¤OZBBAcO_QZ`zuB+YkU-i$`oAzfb5QZYku@kBF¡ Y QZ>QZ>@B+V-OZBH`<³ Yku@XjbwXSY B1O_OZV-ij>boOG^_¡ >@Y\ij>¤AcbwU-b<{<BTO
i`<U@U-BTi©QSY `oU-OugB$QR¡hBBUQS>@BU@`PPB1OeYkUb<UbwVPQS`<U@`oAz`oV-O¡b/M<h¯HUQS>@B`<f@fg`oOZY QZB<-QZ>@BYkU-OQSb< \b5QSY `oU `<
b F^_D YkO´V@ kMi$`oAzfb5QZYku@kB¤¡ Y QZ>QS>@BV-OZB¤`< G^uB1ib<V-OBY±Qzf@XZ`5NY\PBTObQZ`<QSbwkkMQSXSb<U-OfbwXSBU]Q
XS`<V@QZYkU@{C´`<XeACB1OZOSbw{oB$f-b<OSOYkU@{z Yku@XjbwXSY B1OhQF{oY oBTO V-OHbCAcb5¢PY AV@A `wf`]OZOZYku@Y kY QZYkBTO QS`¤ij>-bwU-{<BbwU
B¢PfBTXZYkACBU]Qh`<QZ>@BTXAzY\@PkB¡bwXSBTO`<XF¯+de¿7OZ`<kVPQSY `oU-ONbwUb/o`<Y\@OQS>@BORQjb<ij®NY U-{`w'G^Z \b/M<BXjOT
=>-YkOY\OQZ>NV-OhQS>@Bij>@`]OBTU OZ`<kVPQZYk`<U
=>@BPB¥-U@Y QZYk`<U`<eb F^_D'{<Yk<BU£uNMrQZ>@B FYkXQSV-bw^XZYk5b5QSBDeBQR¡`oXZ®`<U-OZ`<XZQZYkV@A -F^D+ /YkO
sYk{<V@XSBCp4 F^_D i$`<U-U@B$¢PYk`<UugB$QR¡hBBTU QR¡`z´XS`<U]QZBTU-@OT
QS>@B´`o k`5¡ Y U-{-QFY\OFbCf-XZYk5b5QZB-b5QSbCU-B$QR¡h`<XS®cQZ>-bwQFAcbw®oBTOV-OZB`w'QZ>-Bf@V@u@kY\iQZBT B1i$`<ACAV@U@Y\ib5QSY `oU
YkUP´Xjb<OQZXSV-i©QSV@XSB<AcbwYkU]QSb<Y U@YkU@{£f@XSY 5boi$M£QZ>-XZ`oV@{<>²QZ>@BV-OZB`wbQSV@U@U@BT YkU@{f@XS`wQS`Pi$`< b<U-²OZBTiV@XSY±QRM
f-XZ`Pi$B1PV@XSBTOT'KPBBsY {oV@XSBzp<
§HV@XSY U@{ QS>@BCY U-OQSb< \b5QSY `oU`wQZ>@B H^_D«U@`U@BT¡ f@XSY 5bwQZBz^ bo@PXSBTOSOF>b<O+uBTBU¬{<Yk<BTUQZ`BTboij>
`oXS@BXeQS`f@XS`5NYk@Bi$`oU@U@BTi$QZYkNY±QRM uBQR¡BTBUrBTb<ij>i`<V@f- B`wU@`PPB1O=>@Y\OFYkACf@ YkBTOFQZ>b5QbwUNMf-XZYk5b5QZB
^ b<@PXSBTOSO >-boO QS`¤uBV@U@Y\[]V@BbwAC`oU@{oOQeQZ>-B¡ >@`<kBU@`PPB1Oe=>-YkO+ib<UuB{<V-b<XSb<UoQSBB1uNMQZ>@BV-OB
`<@Y5*;BXSBU]QOZV@u@U@BQUNV@AugBXjO`oU¬B1b<ij>OZY±QSB -´>@BTXZBo¡hBcV-OZBCQZ>@Bi$\b<OSO¿ f@XSYk/bwQZB¤OZV@u@U@BQ!/$G`<XSB
INTERNET
INRIA frontend CEMEF frontend
IUSTI frontend
nina
pf
bi−processors nodes mono−processors nodes
IUSTI CEMEF
CIPE tunnels INRIA
sYk{<V@XSBv4U]QSBXji$`<U-U@BTi$QZYk`<U`wQZ>@B´XZ`oUoQSBU--O 4bzQSV@U@U@BT³´`<XFBTb<ij>i`<V@f@kB`w´XS`<U]QZBTU-@O Y\O V-OZBTQZ`
iTbwXSXZM¤=F^ f-boij®<BQSO´XZ`oA `<XQS`Cf@XZYk5b5QSB^ bo@PXSBTOSO
OZfgBTi$Y ¥iTbwk Mo<b<O'¡hB ibwUCOZBBY UcsYk{<V@XSBevPw¡hB >-b/<BQZ>-XZBTB´XS`<U]QSBU-@O'¡ Y QZ>Cf@V-u@ Y\i^b<@@XZB1OZOZBTOT=>@B
RDHd R i$kV-ORQSBXi$`<UOY\ORQjO`<@U@`PPBTO¡ Y QZ>f-V@u@kYki^b<-PXZB1OZOZBTOu@VPQQZ>@B _G_sbwU-RE+KP=i V-OQZBTXSO
b<XZBAcb<PB`wgU@`PPBTO¡ Y QZ>zf@XSY 5b5QSB^¬bo@PXSBTOSOB1O³QACBTb<U-OQZ>-bwQBTb<ij>zi$`oV@f@kBh`<@´XS`<U]QZBTU-@O'U@BTBT@OQZ`
ugBi$`oU@U@B1i©QZB1uNMbQZV@U-U@BªYkU¡ >@Y\ij>iXZMNfPQSBTbwUBU-iTbwf-OZV@\b5QZB1fb<ij®<BQSO b<XZBQSXSb<U-OACY QQSBT«hs@`<X
QS>@Y\Ow¡hBhV-OBe^ :=Y QSmon&=<bFoBXSMOYkACf@ BhQSV@U@U@BT YkU@{O`<QR¡hb<XZB¡ >@BXSB^¬f-boij®<B$QjOb<XZB_QZXjbwU-OZACY±QZQZB1
YkUBTU-i$XSMNfPQZB1EF§H^f-boij®<BQSO³`oUV-OZBXZ@B$¥-U@B1fg`<XZQSOTs@V@XZQZ>-BXSAz`oXZBo5bFi$`oACf@XZB1OZOZYk`<U`<UQS>@Bhf-b/MN `]b<
`<`oV@X f-b<ij®oB$QjOhiTbwUugBbwf@f@kYkBTQZ`CY ACf@XS`5<B+QS>@B `5¡Xjb5QSB+`<QS>@Bi$`oU@U@B1i©QZYk`<U
=>@B F^_D U@BTBT@O_QZ`uB+i$`<ACf@kB$QSBTcuNMQZ>@Bb<-PY±QSY `oUc`w³XS`<VPQSBTOT U@`PPBeAV-OQugB+b<u@ BeQZ`OZBU
bo@PXSBTOSOB1O -´YªB<£U@`wQz`<UQS>@BOSbwACB ¾FD8/©s@`oXYkU-OQSbwUi$B<bf-b<ij®oB$Q´XS`<A b<URDFd RU@`PPBQZ`rb
G_s U@`PPBY\OFOZBU]Q QZ`cQS>@BRDFdeR ´XS`<U]QZBTU-«¯HUQS>@B´XS`<U]QZBTU-«-OZfgBTi$Y\bwXZ`oVPQZB1OebwXSBOBQeV@fQZ`
OZBU¤QS>@Bf-b<ij®oB$QY UQZ>@Bb<f@f@XS`<f@XSYkbwQZBFQZV@U@U-BªU`oV@XB$¢@bwACf@kB<NQS>@Bf-b<ij®oB$QYkO OZBU]QQZ`QZ>@BNYkXQSV-bw
YkU]QZBTX9boi$B`<_QS>@BRDHd Ro_G_sQZV@U-U@Bª=>@BTUQS>@Bfb<ij®<BQ+Y\O+XZB1i$BTY oBTuNMr_Gs ´XZ`oU]QZBU
b<U- PYkOQZXSYku@VPQZB1 `<UQZ>@B¾FD
=>@B H^_D f@XS`5NYk@BTObCOBQ`<hp1x<xU@`PPBTOk`Pib< kMi$`oU@U@B1i©QZB1YkUbz]YkXZQZV-b<«¡hb/M¤u-VPQeY±QF@`]B1OU@`wQ
XSBTOZ`<k<B`wQZ>-BXf@XS`<u@kBAcOOVij>rb<O+OSij>@BTPV- YkU@{-³b<VPQZ>-BU]QZY ¥ibwQZYk`<U³«V-U@YkiY±QRM`wOQZ`oXSb<{<BOZf-b<iB<=>-YkO
OZBTi`<U-f-b<XQ Y\OhQSbw®oBUib<XZBuNMcQZ>-B¦+ `ou@V-OACYk-P BT¡hb<XZBb<U-Y\OePB1OZiXZYkugBTY UOZBTi©QSY `oU n- poµP
& ¸ ¼ }~ 9½½ ¸o» P ¸ ¯H<BXHQZ>-YkO H^_D¦+ `ou@V-O+ACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZB -9OZBBcn@kp<µ/H¡b<O+Y UORQjbwk B1
b<U-¡h`<XS®POboOY±;bwkPU@`PPBTO¡hBXSB`oU HD5 ¬Beij>@`oOZBQS`+VOB ¦+ `ou@V-OT=>-YkOACYk-P BT¡hb<XZBhBUbwu@kBTOV-O
QS`CACb<®<BOZ`<ACBf@XZBT YkACY UbwXSMcQZB1ORQjO¡ Y±QS>bci VORQSBX k`NiTb5QSBT b5Q QZ>-BRDHKP ¾M<`<UbwUb< XSBTboPMcV-OZY U@{
¦+k`<u-V-O=>@B+YkU-ORQjbwkkbwQZYk`<U¤`<¦+k`<u@V-OhXSBoBTbwV-OO`oACBHf@XS`<u- BTACO_QZ>b5Q¡BTXZBF¥@¢PBT@V@XZYkU@{QZ>@BH¥-XjORQ
QSBTOQSOTUr9b<i©Q1³bu-Y {f-b<XQ+`w`oV@XOfgBTiY±¥izf@XS`<u- BTACO+>-b/oBugBBTU¬OZ`<k<B1PV@XSY U-{QS>@BCY U-OQSb< \b5QSY `oU
`<QS>@B F^_D OfgBTiY±¥gi$Y QRM¤`w'`<V@XYkU-OQSbwk\b5QZYk`<U Y\OhQZ>@BAcbwU-b<{<YkU@{z`wfb<ij®<BQSOhXS`<VPQSY U@{FO¡hBOSb/¡
¡ Y QZ>¬G^Z;i`<U@U-B$¢PY `oU-OeugB$QR¡hBBTUU@`PPB1O -9f@XZYk5b5QSB^ b<PXSBTOSOB1O/ AV-OQHV-OZBC^_QSV@U@U@BTkOHu@VPQ
b< i$`<U-U@B$¢PYk`<U-OugB$QR¡hBBTU£´XZ`oU]QZBU@ObwXSBcfgBXZ´`<XSAzB1¬`<VPQjOY\PBcQS>@YkOQZV@U-U@BbwU-¬XSBT[]V@YkXZBCQS`b<5aRV-ORQ
¥±QSBXSY U@{CXSV@kBTOT
=>@BYkU-OQSb< \b5QSY `oU`wQZ>-B F^D¨b<U-¦+ `ou@V-OHACYk@@ BT¡hb<XZBOQSb<XQSBTYkU<V-U@Bzv<m<m<n--b5QSBX
bQZB1ORQeb<U-i`<{<Y QSbwQZYk`<Uf@>-b<OZBH´XZ`oA s@Bu-XZV-b<XZMzQS`CGb/Mvwm<mon@=>@B+¥-XSOQXZV@U `<UQZ>@Bi`<ACf@kB$QZB{oXZY\
>b<OuBTBU°fgBXZ´`<XSACBTYkUQS>@B AzY\@PkB `w]bwUNV-bwXSMvwm<m<µ-£KNY Ui$B¤QS>@Y\Oz-b5QZB ¡hB¡h`<XS®QS`YkAzf-XZ`5oB
fgBXZ´`<XSAcbwU-iBTOTNXZ`ou@V-OQZBTOSObwU- V-OSbw{oBH`<`oV@X{<XSYk³
('y ¬5# ( &°& '$'& j _'
Uc`oXS@BXQS`B5b< V-bwQZBQS>@BFfgBXZ´`<XSAcbwU-iB `w«QZ>-Be{<XSYk³]bACB1b<OZV@XZBQS`N`<-¡b<O_Y ACf@kBACBTUoQSBTcboOf-b<XQ_`<
QS>@BC§F_ `<_d `PP`<kf@>@BC¾b<U@XZYk5bwYkU :¾bwU-mon&=¿hBT `5¡g¡BzXSBfg`<XZQH`<UQZ>@BzXZB1OV-±QjOF`ouPQSb<Y U@B1uNMQZ>@B
VOB`wQS>@YkOHQS`]`o@V@XZYkU@{fBTX´`oXZAcbwUi$B`<hv5µ¤>-`<V@XjOF¡ >-BXSBQZ>-BfgBXSY `PPY\i$Y QRM`wQS>@BzAzB1b<OZV@XSBTOe¡b<O
`<n<mCACY UNVPQSBTOT =>@BTOZBQZB1ORQjOFOZ>@`5¡ V-O QS>@BkBoB³`<'>-B$QZBTXZ`o{<BTU@BY QRMb<U-f`]OZOZYku@ B/b<XZY\b5QSY `oU-O bwk`<U-{
QSY ACB´`oX U@B$QR¡h`<XS®¤bwU-f@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<X OfgBB1@OT
|C ¼N» ¸ ½ ¸ ¸ ;T~ =>@Y\OXZB1OV-±QjO¡BTXZBf@XS`5NYkPB1¤uNM¯HkYk]YkBX ¿b<OSOZB$QT
!#".% .0" 9"/ .0" -4 +%
GBTb<OZV@XSBT+f@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<X³OZfBTBT@OY UQjbwu@kBhvhAcb5Qjij>¡ Y±QS>f@XS`Pi$BTOSOZ`<X³ij>-b<XSboi©QZBTXZY\OQZY\iO;u@VPQ'sY {oV@XZBnFO>@`5¡eO
VOeOYk{<U-Y±¥iTbwU]Q 5bwXSYkbwQZYk`<U-Oh´`oXeRDFd ReªU-Y U-bCU-`N@BTOT ACBTb<UOQSb<U-@b<XS PBNY\b5QSY `oU `<'n ´`oX QZ>@B1OB
f-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjO¡b<Oh`ou-OBTXZoBT¡ >@Y kBY±QeY\O`<U- Mc`<m@v ´`<XhQZ>@B`<QZ>@BTXU@`PPBTOT=>@YkOfbwXZQZY\i$V@\bwXSY±QRMc¡b<O
U-`wQ`ou-OZBXS<BTc@V@XZYkU@{`wQZ>-BXQZBTOQSOT'Qhf-XZ`ou-bwu@kMz>-b<OuBTBU{<BU-BXjb5QZB1CuNMCbf@XS`<u@kBA `wOZij>@B1PV@kY U-{
-9¡BU@`<QZY\i$B1 OZ`<ACBQZYkAzB1Of@XS`NiBTOSOB1Oi`<U]QZYkUNV@YkU@{zQZ`CXZV-U BT<BTUY QS>@Bi$`oXZXSBTOZf`oU-PYkU@{HaR`<u YkO¥U@YkOZ>@B1
´`oXQZ>@Bu-bwQSij>OSij>@B1PV@kBX1=>@Y\Ou@Ykb<YkOZBTOACBTboOV-XZB1O/$ ¬Bij>-`oOZBQZ`®oBBfQZ>@Y\O 0u-b< 2QSBTOQ'QZ`+>@Y {o>@kY {o>oQ
QS>@BYkUoQSBXSBTOQ `wb<Ub<@b<fPQSbwQZYk<B+ `]b<Nu-bw\bwUi$YkU@{b< `oU@{zQZYkAzBYkUXZB1bw«i$`oACf@VPQSbwQZYk`<U-OT
sYk{<V-XZBn=4^_XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XOZfBTBT@Oeb< `oU@{QZYkAzBo
^_XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XjO RDHd R U@YkU-b RDHd R fP _G_s RE+KP=
oBXjbw{oBHf@XS`Pi$B1OZOZ`<XOfgBB1@O -3G `<fO/ p/v<¶Pm-p µ<µoµ-¶Pp µ w¶@<]¶ p1v w¶Pv5µ
^_E ´XSBT[]V@BTU-i$YkBTO vC¦+>@ < <onG>- p¦+>@ vC¦+>@
=bwu@kBv4GB1b<OZV@XSBT¤f-XZ`Pi$B1OZOZ`<X OZfBTBT@O -3b/<BTXSb<{<BD/_bwU-^_E ´XSBT[]V@BTU-i$YkBTO
(32 .0" 9"/ .0" -4 +%
,« ¸ ¸ »¼ ¸ ¼ ¸ ~ bwXSYkbwQZYk`<U-O`<OZfBTBT£`oU¬B¢NQZBXSU-b< YkU@®PObwXSBCY ACfg`<XZQSb<UoQ
b< `oU@{QSY ACBHb<U-c¡hBFib<UOZBBF`oU¤sY {oV@XZBHµ@]QZ>-bwQ_QS>@BFACBTb<UOQSbwU@bwXjcPBNY\b5QSY `oUcXZB1b<ij>@B1Oep1¶ =>@B
9boi©Q QS>-b5Q QS>@BTOZB YkU@®POeb<XZBU@`<QFPBTPY\ibwQZB1¤QS`CQZ>@B{oXZY\ -´`wQS>@BX VOBTXSO b<XZBf@XSBTOZBU]Q `<UBTboij> OZY QZBbwU
VOBcOZ`<ACBubwU-P¡ Y\NQS> /+B$¢Pf@\bwYkU-O+QZ>-BTOZBz5b<XZY\b5QSY `oU-Oze{]bwYkU³³Y QOZ>@`5¡eO+V-O+QS>@BcU@BTiBTOSOY QRMQZ`bo@bwfPQ
k`oboNu-bw\bwU-iY U-{PV@XSYkU@{zQZ>@BaR`ou³
sYk{<V@XSBµ&4'¢NQZBTXZUbw«U@BQR¡`oXZ®OZfgBBT-O bwk`<U@{QZYkACB<
¢]QSBXSU-bw«kYkU@®PO RDFd R <_G_s RDFd R /RE+KP= _G_s 5REHKP=
oBXjbw{oBFU@BQR¡`oXZ®OZfgBBT-O -9G` 5O!/ m@q<x m@x m-µoµ
=b<u@kBn=4'¢NQZBTXZU-b<«U@B$QR¡h`<XS®¤OZfBTBT@O -3b/<BTXSb<{<BD/