Dose profile monitoring with carbon ions by means of prompt-gamma measurements

Texte intégral

(1)Dose profile monitoring with carbon ions by means of prompt-gamma measurements Etienne Testa, M. Bajard, M. Chevallier, Denis Dauvergne, Fabrice Le Foulher, Nicolas Freud, Jean Michel Létang, J.-C. Poizat, Cédric Ray, Mauro Testa. To cite this version: Etienne Testa, M. Bajard, M. Chevallier, Denis Dauvergne, Fabrice Le Foulher, et al.. Dose profile monitoring with carbon ions by means of prompt-gamma measurements. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, Elsevier, 2009, 267, pp.993-996. �10.1016/j.nimb.2009.02.031�. �hal-00283936�. HAL Id: hal-00283936 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00283936 Submitted on 1 Jun 2008. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) Dose profile monitoring with carbon ions by means of promptgamma measurements

(3)

(4)

(5) "!$#%'&%

(6) ( (*)+ ,-.-/

(7) 10"&%1234"56759804(+#% :.5;<04>=?1 6@<

(8) 3%2=?1 !ABC8)+D

(9) < %!E F

(10) G H

(11) ,I 3; )J +0> K>B;#G%)+L0%:M0%N(+@

(12) )*>6CG%83;OM3)J&%')* @A76PG%83K"5RQ,S4TU>U4V/6CG%83CWO/3>) &%1')* @6CG%83YXZ

(13) 3% I :\[BRV"]!$:MFM^4O_Fa`>b[[%5RQ+S4TS[>[\cM)d(+(+<0e%

(14) 3>3% 5;

(15) 3%N = I 3; f)g +0 %:\

(16) < )+8 3%

(17) (;> E^N)+<3%N $hAii%( )+L04@ $>6CG%83;6

(18) je%8

(19) k 8)+>/!Z8 3> l(+E:\83;Q+-\ 0%N< )*m9i4

(20) 9F

(21) <G%8343%noj3> I 83%)

(22) 3 prqstu>vPwt xzy{>|~}$;' P{r%*'|%P'j$.f' R{>>}P|'{%%j{r$Pdj<C%P~>,P PZ' R{PZk{P{%+{>{%j' P{}<{%; xrP9' R{}Z +7{_+$%A' R/%% {oAk{%jry7{'% rPP*jP,C¡$}PP_}9M%r%>| Z{%$¢ZKf{%>.'>{K;j'P>{}Z f{_%%PPPj{k¡ }P9P{%£' P{¤%P<{>f<f£{¥r{4{K£' R{¤{Kr$¦}Pk'{¤%P£' P{}P><|¦{;%§kKC{¤%%¨{ {'j {47/©ª|«{%%7 $_*j%{%R {%P{><P|¬%R<{¤_' YP>'PP¡®¥ {%9 {%9{' P{C$d%7}P$'{$' P{}P$_}9/>%'>|7¯{%*j{%_P|a°P± ²¬{%³´µ%>$7 }P}PC¶7 P{Y¸·A²¹²¬xºj><{ P»M P¼j{% PP{YK9¥r{%¼j r$½C{¸' R{a P{%C>%7 P{P'\>Rak%j{>k{%_>rk4|k¡$%P',RrP$_49<{><P_{¥ {%{>' P{}PP_}9>r }PP{r%P' P{rP %9{9»M P}Pk'{¥r;P{%~ª_PjP $A' R{_9{><}Pj,CRM{;*A P+ P{\{>{><{9\%P_{%jP{j{%' {K'<%{K%{k¡R¥ { P9¥r{4Y' R }PP_}9>r%>|r{%9k{K{%/y{¸*'{;+{o;'<P,Y{%%9<{o' P{P9*P,R%7P7{ 9f' R{>>}P|'{%'r{%; ·x¿ÀAÁ;ÂÃ7gÂÄÅ¿ÆCÂ dÇPÄ7 ÈY9ÆCÂÃ7JÂÄ7 ÉY ÈY{>|9¥ k$Á R%9P' P{>}P|7ÆRPZ{'<|7ÆP P*jP97ÆP}PP_}9>r%>|Æ ÊªË Introduction É 49;' P{>k>}|Ì ¤%P<f¦' P{>k>}|ÌrP%*'|«¥r*' ¬}PÌ+$ ;¬{%% ' R r }P{k{>~¥rÍr%,Í4RK;j>{¹9{>Î%9{%jR%k%fR' R{>>}P|ºj{%% PP{Á_Ï_% Ð{j{ }P 9|7;%PZk{%PP'rjP'rPAP*{\%PoÑ{%<+{o©Ò$P4KPÓ'<%{%R4|ÔÑ©oÓ¯ÕA' P %7{j¶P*'|Kf$9' P{%}>®¼' R{µf$µ'k%>y¤Ô<¤ P{%%*j 9|¶j'{>Õ%P¶|C};%,|Î$.' P{ PP{Ò¯Â¤Ò±\' P{_©k>P}{%>y¤%jPÔ' Pª4'{j}R$or}Zj*j,7{ ' R{ rjÕ »M P{k{Ö¥ ×%j>{Ø>y{Ù P49;' P{>k>}|Ú}%'f7>+|Û,P;j{%Ü'PÝ' P{z'{4'r{%Ï %PP{'j>rPÞ ß À9> àKá%%k%>|â%Pà{K'<%{K>|à{%+{ã' {Ü}P{4Kk{ä{><;'PåPæ' R{×PZk{ P'+9PjPÍP{K+{>{4çjº' P{«}'{%; è<RP{%{%P¡49'>'|ºjz}P R'P$¡_' P{ér>¾_7 P7{é P{>}7*j{%r7' R{o©ª>Pr}{%>y %jP' PMP{}{>P7'jC$+|P' P{{%%Í}>%{j{>\%RP' { P{P¼' P{_'{>{4µ<{9»M P{_<'{>|{µ''<P9+|¤ P{j{>P{>P{%9Ò>P¶><|PP¶¥ * '{9Aê' P{'<7d<{j¤9;jK¶' R{µ j> PP{4¥ {%{>~' P{k{%'r{%ª}P%PPP¹%P¶' P{ P7{ P{%f{{%¤>{ $ã' P{ P$ }P{%%${47+k{%P.' P{}'{%ª}RZ*'fPP¹~' P{'{%'r{% %9> r>R_}<f{K;PAP<>YrR{%{% »ë R{{' P$PªPZk{r$P*jP<9Î1P¤ P49;' {>>}P| '{%'r{%ª>k{ {% ' P{ >| {Kr'$9¥rP ' R{Z%{4>M{%%'77RP{><PP{oP| k$r{,%P{%/C»ë R{¸'%<Pr$γ %P{%;.P$\¥r P% >{%;M{%'k{}P}P9~j{99P %ì;í ÄPÄ²¬{>³´>R °PÄ í ~îÄPÄæ²¨{>³¸´ïÞÂ ß »M P{Ì<{>;¤<|7'j{K¤$~%P9'jk{%Ð,Íð{>%9|Í%PÐñ>}%é {¨' P{ j{%> CP{_·/Z*'k_Ór$»\rPP>}P 9|aÔ·Ó®»ëÕA' R\r{%;{9M' P{%PP, jP;'P $.

(23) }>'%{Y{K*j{%P|' P{ %PP%P{9Y%jfj{%¹<9¦+<k%jP¬Þ± ß »/¥Y£r{' P$_{. β }7+{PÁZRj{%%Ù·Ó®» ' R,fR¥

(24) µ' R{>>}P|%P'jÔ¥rd' {%%ã%Rµ}j{%¯}7<*jPP,P. {''<jP$jÕPP''k{ ·Ó®»Ù¥r*' Ð4$r{%%_9æjPrPP>}P 9|Ér9¥ {{>k¡¸' P{"<%'+*j| %{%¶P|¤ %9k <%P<fª{%<+{K|¤9¥r¡E¥ P% r}${;o' \' P{_·Ó»é%%*j$9' $ ;<+|~$C{>¼' RK' R{_,j%PjÞî ß »M Pª>|~j> ' P{Y%7''>¯P¯ {%P%%M%{%;j{> >R>y{{%%<{¸ P*jP9r}7+{o¥r*j Z> rP{>%{9. ©Ò{P{R.·Ó®»¼¡7}PjY}9j k%f'P~P{j{%'P~>|~{_{>>P{4¶ª_}PPr,P j{%> PP{ γ <4'P'{%'{K;è<PP{4{%P¡/¥ *< P¹{;' P%¹µR%P7{%%PP '¹>P'jPA' P{ P7{ P£$¤ '$¥ ,C_' P{$_{%% r}%j¡ >R R{P'P$\{{%dj{%P|{>¾%*j{%r%{K{%;% '{¸;K{;> >{%j'P$4M¥r*' P, rγ}P9*'|R²¨k{>{>¡' R{P9*%'+9PjPÔ<%C' { {4KàP+ {%jP9ÕrP' P{¶}PjP_}9%9<P¦{%f¦' $ ;<+|¬4<k{>j{%Î' R{¶}P,><|¹{%; >C{%¡E%{ >{%j'P$4¯%,ZKf$9r' P{P}' 7P»M k¡¥r{%>P{%Z%{r}PK}{Ò' { P7{9''<+9PjP$Í}PP_}9Mk%f'P{%9{%a{>"P»¼{4> PP%%,|R¡' P\{%+ {MjP{;+$% >P P{>%{¥r*' ¸} 9|7%%P¯{>{%'kP%$j_' RM¯>{Òj9>j{%PjP$ %Pr,P¬P+{;'+|¬Ü' P{P'4>y¦$Ü' RZk{4j{>k{%£' P{¤<9PP9¬rj{>k¡¼P%r{%| {%9j%%|RMKR{%j%%|1k;j{>k{%_P{P'j\>R¿Y}9jR1%j{>{4%%'>|7%ÑÒ{%%{>;<+|¡ ²¬ ª P>{£'{4 ' R{P9*P,%Ò'jfCP'$¦}PP'{¤}PP_}9_%r{¶j' P{ j><{r;Kf{K'>{%j'P«%{%ÝP|¬}P9'P«r}%P¦' 9>yÝj>j{"k¡o<9é¹%$j{% 4KPR{>YP{j{%'P¦ {}M»M P{>|¹'RP' Pª' P{¶P'Prj¹P' P{¶kKC{¶y{>}9{>{%¹' }Pr{P{><{9A}ÂÄPÄ¸²¨{>³ Þ ìCß è<¶' R{}P{{|~¥r{}Pk}RZk{ '¹{¾9j{Pµ' P¥ jyµ£%>'PPÎ{%% ¡¼'P¥_ Pf P9 P+|¬j><{r%{%${%j'fR¡o9P%kÏ}Pk {4<{£>{%j'P¦j>y{}$%%{4¡KR¨j r}P9{' R{P{j{%'Pj{%> PP{ P| 9¤4_7{4a'{%<P'<, ®>R{%P{><P|~P >j$ j{%> CP{R"¼·/> P' P~9|« RRr{4{K¬{><|¬{%;{>;<+|Ì}P{k{K;j{%««£{j{>~ÞÇ ß ¯»ë P}>}{% }P{k{>µ%$_}{K{%jk|Ì{'7dk¡«}>j>¡' P{¦P{>}{%PP{%R%{¦$r%£>|çKRæR{P'%{Ej~9Pª{¾P}{1{%k¡Z¥ { P>{ P{{Kf}{% _7jP$¤P ' R{ºðÓ. x »ëîÍ}%%y>{éÔ{>¢Ã7 Õ¬Þ° ß _»M P{é% $ ' P{9 { _7jP7.¼R' _'r}P9{%P%Pj{' P{P}9PëP"j' P{}$ 9|R¯{%r' P{_%P{%¡ >RYjY};',½;{o' P{{¾R}{>{%j%7{} è<¤PP{>'£'j$4{ RR}P 9|79%9{%¡A¥ {}P{{%; A9{ ' R{¶%%j{%¤{>{><| >Rµ<{P'+9PjP$P{P'<P$Ò%P¶%9ª}$k$%{4<9¶' R{<%P'P¤ª_·E²¹²«x Ô< ¿ ! É <ê#"<Õ.j<{.P|°P±µ²Ì{³¸´¹%>$7' Pª<{_' P7{ ¥ { k{%9{¾R}{>{%; 7x¼' P {>R{><P|¡Ã í P_' P{£%P{K;7rPP{><éP{%R''£ZK{% %$f$$ {%'P{¨'j}P}PC»ë { _{>P.%%'>|7%PR{P'<P$Ò{%*j{4¶}{>{%%'>{%Z {_jÂ>R±P¡A{j}{%j+{%,|Z xr P9¥Y¦,$ <%¡ë' R{{>R{><P|«<}{4' %r~>|7_kKC{r$Û½;{>£'£rP{µ' R> ÂÄ²¬{>³7»M P<}{%'ãÒ%Y}Zk{%¶.P>{j{ }{4>y7¡>P~$¯4;<Pï%P<{j}R9 j %r9Y{%*j{4Î{%'P{~{%7++7 _{4%% P{%£¦ P$ P|¬{>¾%*j{4£%{_j{>Þ %C¡.Ã ß M»M P{ P{P'.}P{;{%¯_% ¥ P{{%P{><P|j}{%' 9{¸' P{><|P y${j_{%R{><P|~P¼'>{K; x*< RRP ' P{_{>M+{%r>9{>{kRP R¡' P{>| < RR¥Ø' P' P{}Pk_}949jr*j}$%*j| < RR¶{r P$ ~{%P9P '%9¥ ' P{rPP{rPP*P<9P¼' P{rP7{¥r*j ~%$j{%~P{j{%9 ¦ P9¥ª' P{'{ 'jfCP<f¤P.' P{ {%P{<| P{>}7<d<P¤¤ P{j{%f$%j{%¤"ªÇPÄ¤> ¡ }{><}{PP7>,| j ' P{ {%% P{%jPÔ' R{ '{µ %%{+j{ÒM' P{_'{}4ªP ' P{j<{"'Õ"Ex £ Pj%P4{%¡/' R{¶'$ ;{%99' ¤><{~{%P9P ¶j£,fR¥Û~%{4>k{>}>j|aP{P'P$®Ôk{%P~' & ´'±A' R{<}{4{% $\, 'Õ¼¥ *' '9 %jjPrP{j{% . Â.

(25) Ê7ÊªË Experimental set-up »ë R{_{¾R}7{>{%j¡7}{><'P<r{% A' P{Yð¸x è '%%*'|~Ô<¿%{P¡ %P4{>Õ¡${% }97 {4{; P\°P±Y²¨{>³´ ¿ P7Ô{4Kï}97k{R®$ & 7{>{%<" | %CÄ<Õ»M P{k>${%j'~Z {%<P7 >Rç' R{Ý%é{Kr$Ð|P{;$Î$ ¿ %P ¿ ~¹>{¨' R{º%{¨¥r*j P Ä í »ë { %PP*jR%o{P'<P¹. k ¿ P7_{%%7jÝ, j+|¬><{>_R{P'j¹{%P£|{K$"M»¼ P{¶{% j{%$d| $' P{ j><{¥ r {¦99 CxÜ¬PP{¸£P}'½;{µ' R{¶4R;<9¹j{~' { P{j{%'P" 9{Â P9¥\}k{7' P{P{j{%"'f {j}7C»ë R{o{%%r¡{>¾9'4j{%_r%+¼k$º' P{ 4P7å{%%{%¡¸r}$9{%«Pé·E²¦²¬x $« P>}{4Ìj<{"a{PÌÎj{¦%R¥ ,PØ* '>jP«%$C«' P{{4KâP{%jPÝP|é{;%$~Prk{K Rj{¹%;'<P_<|7'j{%

(26) Ï{Î{4¨¥r j><{¥Y*' éP<<{{%~P{¦{%C9' 7¡ ì P %ì K~Æo' R{£{'7*µ%j{<}PPÝær{%;{%{% }{><'Pr{%¥r*j ' R{¸j{>j><{ »M P{_%,P{j{%'P<¡_>|P91%% >è®P{j{% ì %ï,~P%{j{>>R¶{KC9' P¡$¥ R¯}$%;{% ¯_P'j>P%{r$z' R{¸j><{M><|PP~$ î ì % j¶Ã ì > ¡EP{}{KRP~P' R{_%$<fk{j }»ë R{«%$jPÐ%PP<9jP$~Ak{%Ð>{æ'7>,½K{%Ð9¤'$R¥aÁ¬ÂÄ% ' P>yÍ{4 %Pj9k¡¸¥_d' Ð%Ø% <j{æ* ¥ ' ØÔ<$ 'ºîrr_Õ¶¥ 9¤ {~µÝP{j{%"'fØ%9{ ÂÄ Ô%>y9¥> P+{;'P9Õk¡ ÃPÄ «%R ÇPÄ ÌÔk'P¥ > P+{4<fCÕ¥r*j {;<}{%j ' P{æ{% θP +{%jP7;x %Pd<PP%}>%'<4<f<|j{%¢%Rf {4PP{%7 »M P{PZk{Ò¥ ¯rPdj{4 P|{%%$¯$M_{4%R %è.P{j{%9¼}P4%{%\><{>¯P'j>P;{ ~kP{>ëµ{¯_R;'9 j{}P<P}P9'PP%7j' P{¸{%%ãj{%$d|¡EP{4>f|~P{>}{%PP{%j+|a$A' P{ j><{Y}P7<*jP¬KRÝ4$jP7¯»ë Pr$P*jP_¥r%%%+Pkj{%£¥r*' ¬ E>%P>|Ì}é_ P+ P{% j{%$d<{9 »ë R{åP{j{%9 {%%CRCïÔ',{å%P {>{<| P''<+PP<f<Õã¥ }{>'P1 {% ¥r*' %P{K;<fRKM;%{;>ª{%{%'jPfRk¡ERK{%,| rè<² >},C%r}'{>ª%P¶Pr%P~_³²£ÓæPj %%*jEx¢y{4|Î}o9{¾P}{>{%¯¥r' P{ >jP¶{¥r{%{%P{j{%j{4¶% >|¦%RÖ{P'<P$£P|Í' P{«'{4<$'<$ ;j{%> CP9{ºÔj»¼ê ÕÁ' P{Ø'<{>k{KR% { {¥r{%{%Ð' P{ P{j{%'Pj{P|' P{r%jj®>P P+{K}$ R {_PA' P{¸ Ñ ,P%'Í' P{_%4%{%{jPë¥ '{%j{%P|a_»Mx¿éÔ<»¼{¸' xP%P$%%¿9{>j{>jÕ P%|¡$' P{_Pj{%kP{% ¥ {>{' P{_{P{><| P{>}7*j{% Ú>R ' R{Î'{£» k$%j{% «{%% «P{j{4"'PÌ{4{%j¡%P9¦¥r*j £' P{¤_{>Z %9 çP{j{%"j{4YP|' P{P7{ P*jP\<+C »ë R{K¤}>%{j{> P9{>¾P}{>{%j%. {j} ¥r{{ ' R{'$9¥r9ÁA+Õ' R{ j>j{j P %,P{j{%'P9j%R%{rKRa' R{rP{j{%'~%C${ ,Õ.' P{r%Pj9¸j*¼¥ ' ~+Õ.' R{ }Pk{{%P;{ PMPPK %Pd<P%$}%< P{%PP>7%7θ{P'jP$\>RP¡$+PÕ¯''<{%¡9' P{_{%{%jPr$7' P{ P{j{%j{% %9<P$ª9ªr7R<f~Pë' R{r{KR{><P|~P{%}7<*j{%~,' R{rP{j{%9P~M' P{%+.'{%<$' <$ ; \¿oPP4{><PP£' P{{%$ {'<;%}>%{j{>k¡¯' R{µj><{j'Pr%¬{j{%9r9j>R%{¤KR' P{ %Pj9 *¥r{{£{'«ÇPÄ¬>à%P¦Â«r¡o{9<}{4<+{K|R¡®' P{¤%PP*j$RK P{KPP«>%7 P{P'APjP{%r99' {o{%{' P%9y7A' P{»\ ê j{%> PPZ{9 Ê7Ê7ÊªË Results ,9k{_±¶< RR¥¸¥Y<9{%$$R%ëj}{%' PA' P{ <{%+K{%¯{P{><P|aP{>}7*j{%Ø ' P{Y%j{%¶kK;<jP®PjP $A' R{¸' {_P¼' γ«¥_ {%' R{_P{j{%'P> ¯ %jPÐ' P{ÝrP{«P' P{¬$º}' ºÔ¥r*j ºéP{j{4"'PÐ%C${ ÃPÄ Õ»M P{¬K;<d| {%+%{K;/{>P{>j| P{>}7*j{% {%'{>j¸' P{'%7' R7' R{P{j{%'PM%>+θ jP_ M{4{KY}{>'<{%γ ¥r*' Kr%P%j+{9%{4¡yPRR¥Y9_' P' P{*r{Rk%{%P;{|P{%rPAR{P'P$\\P<<{{% $º' R{%PP{9 x¯{>¾P}{4j{%P¡7r7/' P{Â <}{%'¢®P$rj{% P|aP{P'kë¥ *' ¸P%_',{%j' <$ ;r<}{%'7 j{%+%{K;Y{%P{><P! | 9¥r{' P% ²¬{³\x }PY}9 k|¹}7{%y¬>}P}{%> γ. ±. γ.

(27) P%{%,|¹RRµ' P{j+$¤¼' P{'{¶%%{ {>{% ' RP ' P{_',{{;$*PjPP9ªªP {¾R}{j{%z{%;k{zP¦{%{%'PPæPP }P9{%~¬Ô<%Pz' ¦' R{ 9{>{4<%P >}{Ð {%%PP${9jÕd»ë P}P$_}9Ò}{%>y %Y}${j{%+| }$}{%¥r P{%' P{~P{j{%Y> Y¶f$%'$ {>|R$R' R{ ©ª>P¤}{%yk{>$f»¼ P{j%.' R}P RRP{j{%'f ¥r*j ²¬{>³ %_}${j{%| 9{>¥Y P{%{4 P|_' R{P{P'jP%>yPP9Pr}7{;¼'r}{><'P<ÍPRP{{%{;'P{%P{><P|%P '{PM< '$j{¸}PP_}9 >|P»M P{{%j9{P +9{±µ RR¥M' P{_{%{%j_¥ { P>{ > RZk{KZÁ ²¨{>³Ð>Rr<±_$ »\ê γ ±r$ {A¯%P$P{>¯rP{%7$P%7}P'a' P{_}P{fR\P{%7$R%A<}{;'Ðj 99j>' P{<{~' _j}{%' ¥r*j ¹Î {%{%jP ²¨{>³M»ë Pj,{~$'$ ;_j}{%' Ô<r{%'{%_¥r*' P{j{%'f%9{ ÃPÄ 1Õ\\}P{;{%j{%r! 9{îaKf$9_¥r*j ¥ ' R{>.<}{%' θ ÂÄ KR {%9{4¦ ÇPjÄ }>{ '

(28) é{¤Ü%¶¦' R}${µ9j{%{49Î'' P{%{~£<K}r{%'% k4Ô '|¨ R{%$_%}yPPPP{%R;YRRCj>P{%{%¦%kj{{> θ a%>yPP9Pθ£ PC'%'f¤Pª {>|R$Ra' R{P }' ~®99 Â ì r_Õ$xrª{>¾P}{%>j{%P¡P' P{_P{P'jP~%Y}R{K;P{4>{%k{.¥r*j ' P{Y>9{ P\P{j{%'PÁ$'P ÇPÄ ªÔ'P¥r >9{%Õ¡7*\>RP¥Y;{¸' P{k"j{ {%9{% ¯ÃPÄ >Rµ' 9{4{ θj,{9' P{kj{r{%9θ k{% ÂÄ 7è<PP{;{;P¡M' P{R{P'<Prr{% %,|Î%${ $ ' R{r${%ï$M' P{%P{%¯}P< {;'{%¡AP{>P'jª>{r{%dj{%µ}Pk{><{{>j%|'P¥ > >C${9$²¨{9{>¡7' P{r>¾ ÚP¼' P{R{P'P',{'+9P'f>k{%9{¥r*j µ' R{%9{$ P{j{%'PÁ' P{Í><{>¦' P{ÐP{P'ï{%r$ï%9{%¡µ' R{z9¥r{>£' R{%+«{%% y$P{<Í{%P{>j|Z ÂÄ ª>P ÇPÄ %%{%7P{>k{%9¯{%%7¥r*' P ¿R%{><PP } P¡' R{¸j{.{%'{% ' P{¬{>¾P}{>{%j%P%{>'jK;<{;»¼ R{¨kj{Ý9θ9 j,{;Ø~ÃPÄ ¤¹ jf|¢K{>¡_%*' RRP é¥r{ %>PRR/%PP%*P{ P<%%/>PkR'j}9|' Pj>{Ô}/PZ' P\{%<j{%/%%_{'<+9Pj{%' >¤>{%9k{ $.' P{ <{K¤${¥ã¥r R{K' R{ P{j{%9rP{%¹¥r>|¹$ã' { P{j{%'P¤%9{ ÃPÄ Õ»ë R{>{%'P{%¡$' P{%j%yPPRR' jf| {j{>M4>y9¥r %9{9\¥r P θ%9 Ï{j>y{>é4RK;j>{¦P'P' P{¦P{;,éP £}P|C}{'ær}P9{' R{¦k>,RjR{P'<P$k¡_}<f7>A¥ *' r P+$ {KR{><P|_{%% γ P®' R{}P{;{%.¥ P<yP¡E¥ { k{%P{j{%'P%C${ ÃPÄ jÎ {;{_' P{P{j{%'P¶kj{ }PP{¬RÝPjPºP' R{Ý$C$d%_}7*<f 9 θ9 { ì P9¥¶%r«%PºR{P'<{/>j{>M+j%P'9»M P%CyEAj' P{ P$ PZk{P{K+{>{%j¸' R{oj><{M Ô Ä ð¸|CÕ¡' P{P%>{% ½;PP{ ¥ 9éP>jy{KR{%P¡¤%9¥rP×Í}P{%% { P{j{><<f $£' P{ $ãkKC{PÁ îÛ »ë { %P_}>PØr' P{ >|«}Pk${£¥r*j Ý' P{¦><y{>{4æ{%¦{>¾9j{>7f$é%{%>,|Í P9¥' Pr' P }PP{_'jP9f|Î%Pγ <{>fj{%µµ' P{P~}' µ' {_j><{êµ' R{%P >|R¡E' R{P{P'~|P{% 9¥r+|¤>{%; {;'P¼' P{r}Zj*<f. {4%{R{P'P$Ò>{rP'*j{>{%¶P| ' R{{4 %Pj9\P' P{>| >{rZ''+|{%dj{%'9¥r>k'¥ >r>9{ ê¸R{Ý>|º{«<}P{%æP|é' {¬{%P P%P%{%{%µr' P{ k4|é|{%ÐR{><{4Ï¥r R{Ké' P{ P {j{%'P\> \7' R{o©ª>Pr}{%>y$4'P7C»ë P\%%_{}'+|'γ<+9Pj{4¸'}P7+{¸P{%9{$ >{%j'P>7{4<fë¥ P{%_' P{P{%P{><P|aP{%>{4{ªÞ Ä ß ÉYR¥ {{>¡' R{¸R><9¥_R{¯$ ' PY{%P P%P;{%{%4>{¶rP{µ}Pj9>+|¦{>¾R}$%{9ÎP|' P{~{Kj<{%P{%j+{%,|¹9£k%j+{ P{%%>|_j{¯$M{¾%*j{%>{%

(29) é*j k%f<+{{%%>|_j{;.E' P{9P{>\PE' R{¸}' k"'P P®' R{µf¤' P{j><{ÒÔ .'{¥ãj{>$}$f%Zk{%;R$<Õ¡. ¤a|{%¤{KP R%P%{%{%Ò%9Î{ {>}Pj%{%P|_}Pk{K><| _<f Ê

(30) Ë Discussion »ë R{z%%j{%k{Ì¤' P{ k| }PP{zÔ%{%+|Ù' R{Öj}j%{k$*Pjï%P ' P{ P{j{%'Pj{;<Õr{%{.' P{r{%+ {K{%γÒP%¤R<,P{ rPP*j'PPµ' R{>>}P|7èRP{%{%P¡E¥r*j ¤ +%j%yPPRRº'ÍP~4RP±Ð' R{¨©ª>PÐ}{%yz%jPP¡' P{«º%9{Ì%º{ P{j{>j{% ¥r*j %¤%4%>|Î$>9P r Exµ¥ {P¤97{{ >99 Ä }PP_}9%r î.

(31) }{>%${%;.P¥r*j ~P${ ì %ãP%{j{>¡ ì %Ö' P>y >èÔ<»M+ÕªP{j{%¯$4j{%~¯ÇPÄ¶% >R' C9P ¤Â£¥rP{ %$<P7»M P|P{¹%%Î{µ>k{%9{%P||C}%%,|±PP{> >P*P{P|¤r}P99¬Á,Õ' P{r{%$r{'j;K\{%'<%{%R4|P|¤rP{ ' RK~Â¤PP{>ÒPo >$Pd${ ' P9y¸Î' R{¶»\ê ¬j{%> CP{a' Rr>y{9_d}7+{aj¤{%%{' R{µ4<P¦ P{KPPjÎ' R{ _âKR¨j«P>{4 {Î' R{£ { PP{j{%'Pk¡, Õ' P{£;'17¦{%j%{%P>|¡o¥ *< Ì{%*j P{> ><{> >èkÔ<»ë Õ %,;<j¯9.' R{>P{j{4"ª> a¼©Ò "

(32) Ï{_%%' R{>{%'P{_{>¾P}{%¯Y|R{K $ Ä }P_}9 '|rja{_ *j}${;aP|' P{ Ä Ä {%+{%~'¼' R{¸'{%'r{%¯P\ K. rP¨¥Y*' P γ PP{ {9ÜÞ Pß »M ÌP{z;P'j ¥r*' }P$Y}9¦%P'fïÌ{%%'<C ²¬P{R{>¡P}'r½9'Ì$' R{¨P%j$%>yPPkPÝ<é%Ý{¹RCjKR{%«R{%%{9k><|«| r}P99_' P{o'{{k$*PjPr7' R{KrP{j{%'P r{{%P}${%>k{£,¬}PPP{ _jÝ}PkR{9PZk{rPP*jP<9Ýj{4> PP{9À$r{¤$ ' P{% ¥rA{R{%%{9k><| '~RCj>~P{>%{' P.r{;{\' P{_{% {%{%;ª. R%9P' R{>>}P|~P7{ r$Pdj<C¶¥r*j µ' R{y$RP$¶{4K Ak{%'Ò;>P<%PjPP¡MP%{K|¤ P$ {%{><P|R¡ PPP'}97{4µ{4K ®${%+{>{%P|<|RK C9jPè<PP{4{%P¡\ P+ {>R{><{9k¡¥ {_{¾R}{%¯f><{> P{P'£%>yPP9P¬%PÝRR}9k{%Ý¨{% r}$|¦' P' P{¶'{{%<{>k{>%{'P_' P{¤»\ê j{%> CP{¶ P9'{µ}PjRfP{%P| ¶'¸P{j{%'Pj{>4{>}9'9' R{a{;KaM»ë R{9{~P{4{%}{% ¥r R}{%,|¹{>K4{¶'PYRP{>¾9ª{%%Üj,{ðrÀè'%,Pj{~9_P7{ rPP*j9 j{%> CP{o¥r*j ro|C}$%% %9P' P{>}P|_{%% .

(33) é*j P' P{%{P' P{. Z{%P% · P{ <fRK®${µÑÒ{%% R{>% P{{%É%9k;' P{>}${4¡ë' P{ ÑÒ{{4>% rPR}P {K;/ð Ñ«²¦èjÂ9©¡7}P}Pj{%P|_' R{ {%P% ¿ ÑYÀ¡KR ' R{oÓ»\ê¸è Ó¬%{%j{M' . É %9P' P{>}P|P¡A'}P}j{%P|' R{Ñ PP{_x}{R\ÑÒ{KPP¡' P{>ªP{9>{_RR¥ÍPP{>'j>y{>j r}P9{o' P\PZk{¸ P*jP<9_j{% PP{C . ì.

(34) >Õ. PÕ.

(35) !"#$%&%'

(36) ()*,+ -.*,) $+- /+10

(37) 23 /45"64*%7 89/:3*&"#;<>=? @BA3 *$ 0*C3*D*EGF=?=DHI.$* KJLM /-:NO9P%723*- 0-KQ8P%72 *+R63%7 S+-T. P08(*U"VW X * +- $Y /+13&

(38) +4 6$Z$9Y63* *+&/\[4]^%_"6 *%_6W Z.** `a^YW&B*232P3%'$B2Yb"c

(39) %&%. Beam. 'c$ dFb : '"B6W & e* *3%7 -.2f9 :ghia^YWjk.$ gh6*gT%l3j+- $'+-T.*- VT BV[4]^%m*+D +- 6 `3*l*2Y ]*pfJqarYW& /9 BW B0- /%E+-P 63*- θn,o. Ç.

(40) ><4 #a^*g6+-3%7 ,3$2 9 % "W g: 4(*23 - **'+- $Y6 *+' 3'W

(41) *23233%l/6 *+V93-:3232P/6$ $ZM": 63* ")6W ^3%&

(42) ")"2PW-M a^W 'γ W( +- : $

(43) *3%'f/5M2P**3* /#W

(44) %7q++-23 ^")6W >3* W Jqa^bWi'+- 6 TP*i*23 ]$p : W 2b "Tr .*23 $` /T*+5.1W & 23 P* "B $%7- g(5a^ W, $ θn,6

(45) γ o B -9 *' 2P 3* W$

(46) -*+MW( B qW-* Z. θ. θ . θ!". CN$ )3%& gT"6gh"6233*W-S9 6U%& *$6 *+ /?6W E+- `3* *23 *GJ c$]$p ]$p_*+ [$]4p?"$C 23**YT+-3*2,$9Y63* %7% +'7 2P :3*V*7W ^ *&+- $Y /+7d B= θ n @^

(47) )W ^o 3T #$ /9*+#.

(48) n W 63%7 gT"6gh"2P3*W-&9 6 % "

(49) 6W W.*7*0-.*3 *+X"T: * T0-.3*X"&i0,*$ +MO 9 % JT $+- /+7 c!%&%1 n. °.

(50) $ B : TP*C: * $ D"T3*O"'W ?23*bT+-3*21$YP* X*0-.*3 *+ "$ 6W Ta^S+-Y"T": / - 23 63*

(51) *DW k63%7 V"^"T2PW-

(52) *,+ 6W- ' * +4 $9Y6 *+DC3D6W- +8 `6 $'3+-Y//: *+DP?/ '< W.*' 23 :3*'J: 4$ ^$%70*2T#+1 -.*' 23 63*'J3`2b ^9$%70*2T. %.

(53) u w s. Þ ß ;x KP7%Rðr%È%j¡RÑÒ{>}>·jK· 9|CÇ %YÔÂÄPÄ ì Õ %CÇ ÞÂ ß èPÀP P%¡a$À> R>j¡Éa;ð{%k{Kf¡RÉaèj<P% P¡9Ó%ÈY>Cy7{%{%*j¡ð%È%j¡PxrK²¨>{%¡R²Ï \K²¨ R>¡ ðP ² 9½C{%9{<¡ \ >y{%¡M¿AÀ> {%{%9{><{¡A>

(54) çAÀ% ¥ 4¡ _%è<7'"$xP ²¬{' ©¡ P °_Ô ÃPÃPÇ9ÕMÂPÂ Þ± ß ·.ª¿.{j}$¡ê¸};'½;jPºPèjP©¸{%% ·/7*'PÝÓ.$é»\ P}P 9|º'P ²¬PP*jj,P Ér{%P|rèPr»/rPM»M P{>k>}|R¡ rk{>j'PÁd» r1 'j%Kj¡ 4K 9{>{%% · 9|7y¡ÂÄPÄ ì Þî ß ñ%¼·/¥ {K y{%¡»o¼©ÒP''{%P ¡ \ {4{>¡»¼ÈY*7{4¡ ¼ ²

(55) $>y{¡ÒÈ¼·/>k$9¡ \¼ ·

(56) PPk% P¡ðr À R>y,P¡%P

(57) çKÓ¯9 P>kj¡9è©ªè©ªx² }P%{%{%P97\ÔÂÄPÄP°9Õ\ÃP° Þ ìCß ¿¸dÉa%²¦P¡¿KÉa>È_¡9²éd 9P¡>P_ñ4*

(58) Ð%È_r¡x}P}$%·M 9| {d¡ %CÃ_Ô'ÂÄPÄPÇ9Õ %C± ì ° ÞÇ ß Ó»\{j%¡¸²Ïo©Ò >P¡¸²Ï¿o R{>%{¡ a rP{><PP{4¡ ë { 97 R{>¡ ~ {P¡ñ%d²Ï j>9¡Pñ%d<¿%·P+½;j¡¿>Ñ>|R¡>P²éC»\{j¡x}P}%· 9|7 {k9ÃP±_Ô'ÂÄPÄ %;ÕMÄPÃP± ì ÄPÇ Þ° ß ÀEMx7',R{% ªÔ<ðoÓ¯ x »Mî¬¿>P'P9Õ¡ %Jè<7'' A²¬{' R$$Yx¡ ì ÄPÇ¦ÔÂÄPÄP±9Õ Â ì ÄP<±PÄP± Þ% ß ðA²¬ P{>½;¡ \ ²éA²¬ ¡ À> ;P'½;¡ð¸|

(59) Ï'¡oñ% >½K¡¯²Ï kKCy{%¡À/É > %¡¼ÑY ÉrP+½;KPR¡ë·¯ P'<fPR¡ ë {% 4R{%¡ëÉa

(60) P 9{>k¡¼xrE²¬ R¡.»o²¬{¥r>½K¡

(61) çE²¬*' ¡ Ñ_

(62) çê_j{PPP<'¡¸ñ4 É dðr®K¬·M¡¸ñ4 {>j¡·\¼ÑÒR {%<¿ P$r½;¡xrÀ$ {>j¡ÑY É À${% {%P¡PÑ_À7ÀPr$R!¡ ª7À9 jyR¥<y¡$³

(63) é>P{¡>P_É

(64) Ð

(65) é % Pj¡· 9|7" {k©Ø±9îÃ Ô ÃPÃ ì ÕMÂ± ÞÃ ß É '{%{%>y{>\P_ñxÏ·/7'PP¡PxP%ÑÒ{> %%·/>À>d¡PîÄ_Ô ÃPÃPÄ9Õ P ±P îPî Þ Ä ß

(66) é ×À P{%P¡¼©

(67) ÏKC¡.ñ {%9¡

(68) Ï ¯ P%P" ¡ Y<# » ¯ Ì%PÓ · {%9¡ _%'E·M 9|Mx îÃ Ô Ã %CÃ9Õ ±PÄ Þ Pß À> P>k>P' R{oÉr{%P|èPr»M P{>k>}| ¿$4k'R¡ _>%· 9|7Cxr9° %C°P¡PÔÂÄPÄP°9Õ/ÇP±P±P. Ã.

(69)