HAL Id: hal-01022243
https://hal-enac.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01022243
Submitted on 17 Jul 2014
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Air and rail : cooperating and competing ?
Nicolas Gruyer, Nathalie Lenoir
To cite this version:
Nicolas Gruyer, Nathalie Lenoir. Air and rail : cooperating and competing ?. ATRS 2004, Air Trans-
port Research Society World Conference, Jul 2004, Istanbul, Turkey. pp xxxx. �hal-01022243�
∗
!
" # $ %& ' (!# $ %& ' '
) # ++""(, ++" "(
!
" #
"
" $
%
& '(() *'℄ ,
&- -
- -
.//0120 3
4
.
∗
- " -
&
&
&
6
7
!
" . 3
6
5
½
&
5 !
! -
-
!
,
$ #
!
$
4
"
¾
"
".3 &
" "
½
!"
# $%&' (
& )
¾
! *
6 8
9 .
3
!
: ; . !
: 3
<
#
.
< =
: ; < 5
"
<
6) <
: .
&&& 4 3
6
&
. 93
6
: < 4
? . 3 <
" 9
<
.
9 3
? "
&
&
& "
:
& =
&
"
:
:
; =
#
;
Q = α − βp
&
α
2β
@ ;&
.
; "3
α
3β
2α 3β
#
" - -.
-- 3
4
#
4 : ;A
= @
;
Q = α − βp
@ ;A
Q ′ = α ′ − β ′ p ′
& "
α
2β
@ ;
α ′
2β ′
@ ;A
&
p 2 = 3(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
p 1 = 2β α − 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
;: @p ′ 1 = 2β α ′ ′ − 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
;A : @
?
.
p 1 + p 2 = 2β α + 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
p ′ 1 + p 2 = 2β α ′ ′ + 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ ) )
" - -
+ (*
# * ) , -*
. #
/ 0 1
23 # # 4
5 65 (
# # # * #
#
* ) #
# # *
,7 *
C
" -
-
& 9 ;
: <
? 4 < ; --
; :
< : ;
"
: < 8
< ; :
#
= "$
6 "
! :
,
! A
&
A!
A !
: "
) # # 8, 6
# * , 7*
*
) #
1
# $ ,
* ,
$ ,# #
9 *
;
;
4
9
& C E *))℄ 4
!
& $
# F4
"
< : 4
"
& 4 4
4
4
& 4
G4
<
-) -
-' -
"
9
!$
# $ *
#
#$/ # :0
# *#
3 #
6$*
&
- -
: &
:
<
. ! 3
" H
9
: < . "
< :
3
& -9-
4
6
9
.
3 ,
"
."
8>3
!" #
"
$
6 "
< -
½¾
-
? $
<
½¾
) # + # *
( ##
,#*
9
- -
&
5 .
3
$
&
"
? --
&
&
"
!
%
&
:
?
"
&
8## * )
$ #
### #
# / 0*
,# & 6 #$ ;#
,# #'*
&
: & "
6 :
& F
<
<
8 : 4
!
#
: <
&
.3
<
&
& 4
& !
) # #
8 *
&
#
!
H !
!
"
A &
H ! C *)'℄
!
H !
4
&
#
=
v
.v > 0
34= #
<
T 1
T 2
. 3<
p 1
<
p 2
c 1
c 2
m 1
## ;<< /=70
&$& /=70* $##
;<< # ##, .
(# # #$* &$&
( #6( #
# 6(
# 1 122**222
+ #
# # ,
#6 * # # ##
# #>>#
8 # $
m 2
" .m 1 = p 1 − c 1
m 2 = p 2 − c 2
36
#
. 3
p 1 + vT 1 ≤ p 2 + vT 2
m 1 ≤ m 2 + (− (c 1 − c 2 ) + v (T 2 − T 1 ))
4
m 2 ≤ m 1 + (c 1 − c 2 )
"
m i
6(− (c 1 − c 2 ) + v (T 2 − T 1 ))
(c 1 − c 2 )
!
µ 1
µ 2
µ 1 = (− (c 1 − c 2 ) + v (T 2 − T 1 )) µ 2 = (c 1 − c 2 )
. 3 . 3
! J
µ 1
!
# " =
: 4 .
µ 1
µ 2
3"
'
6 A
p 1 + vT 1 = a 1 − b 1 q
:
p 2 + vT 2 = a 1 − b 1 q
#
, # $
*
# # *
• m 1 = (a 1 − c 1 − vT 1 ) − b 1 q
• m 2 + µ 2 = (a 1 − c 1 − vT 1 ) − b 1 q
4
p 1 = a 2 − b 2 q
:
p 2 = a 2 − b 2 q
#
• m 1 + µ 1 = (a 2 − c 2 ) − b 2 q
• m 2 = (a 2 − c 2 ) − b 2 q
(
& "
") '.) F' 3
m i
=
µ i
m i = A i − b i q i
A 1 = a 1 − c 1 − vT 1
A 2 = a 2 − c 2
µ 1 = − (c 1 − c 2 ) + v (T 2 − T 1 ) µ 2 = c 1 − c 2
&
q 1 = α 1 − β 1 m 1
q 2 = α 2 − β 2 m 2
β i = 1 b i
α 1 = A 1 b 1
= a 1 − c 1 − vT 1 b i
α 2 = A 2
b 2 = a 2 − c 2
b 2
( (
" "
m 1 + µ 2 < m 2 m 1 (α 1 − β 1 m 1 + α 2 − β 2 (m 1 + µ 2 )) 0
m 1 − µ 1 ≤ m 2 ≤ m 1 + µ 2 m 1 (α 1 − β 1 m 1 ) m 2 (α 2 − β 2 m 2 )
m 2 < m 1 − µ 1 0 m 2 (α 1 − β 1 (m 2 + µ 1 ) + α 2 − β 2 m 2 )
!
m 1 + µ 2 < m 2 m 1 (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 − (β 1 + β 2 )m 1 ) 0
m 1 − µ 1 ≤ m 2 ≤ m 1 + µ 2 m 1 (α 1 − β 1 m 1 ) m 2 (α 2 − β 2 m 2 )
m 2 < m 1 − µ 1 0 m 2 (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 − (β 1 + β 2 )m 2 )
)
(
* +,
& H ! = &&
m i
"" "
= && .((3 H !
"
= &&
·
, "
α 1 2β 1 ; 2β α 2
2
=&& &
H !
α 1 2β 1 ; 2β α 2
2
G
" "
·
, "
α 1 2β 1 ; 2β α 2
2
= && =
& .= ) 3 &
H ! =&& H !
= && = &
m 1 ≥ 2β α 1
1
m 2 ≤ 2β α 2
2
"
"
= &&
H
! " )
. 3 " '
H !
α 1 2β 1 ; 2β α 2
2
= && .
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤ 2β α 2
2 ≤ 2β α 1
1 + µ 2
3 &
% +
(
* +
6
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤ 2β α 2
2 ≤ 2β α 1
1 + µ 2
6 H !
"
& "
"
.
>3 "
i
"
(α i ) 2 4β i
"
α j
2β j − µ j
.j = i
3A
# H !
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤ α 2
2β 2 ≤ α 1
2β 1 + µ 2
.)3(α 1 ) 2 4β 1
≥ − (β 1 + β 2 ) X 2 + (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 ) X
X = α 2
2β 2
− µ 2
.'3(α 2 ) 2
4β 2 ≥ − (β 1 + β 2 ) Y 2 + (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 ) Y
Y = α 1
2β 1 − µ 1
.>3& H !
α 1 2β 1 ; 2β α 2
2
- )
$#.
# !A
T 1
.
a 1, a 2
b 1
b 2
c 1
c 2
T 2
36
" H !
T 1
.! ! ) ' > "3<A "
T 1
α i
β i
µ i
.
a 1, a 2
b 1
b 2
c 1
c 2
T 2
3
T 1
5 A "∂µ 1
∂T 1
= −v
∂µ 2
∂T 1 = 0
∂α 1
∂T 1 = − v
b 1 = −β 1 v
∂α 2
∂T 1 = 0
∂β 1
∂T 1 = 0
∂β 2
∂T 1
= 0
#
T 1
1,
µ 1
v :
:
<
ν
AA 4 !
<
v
.3
α 1
β 1
.3
<
< &
T 1
)v.
!
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤
α 2 2β 2 ≤ 2β α 1
1 + µ 2
α 2 2β 2
− α 1 2β 1
+ µ 1 ≥ 0
α 1
2β 1
+ µ 2 − α 2
2β 2
≥ 0
∂ α
2 2 β 2 − α 1
2 β 1 +µ 1
∂T 1 = v 2 − v = − v 2 < 0
∂
α
1
2 β 1 +µ 2 − α 2
2 β 2
∂T 1 = − v 2 < 0.
! " .
a 1, a 2
b 1
b 2
c 1
c 2
T 1
T 2
3 "T 1
&
! "
4
"
"
#
T 1
) )v 2
v
" !
C 4 :
<
!
+1 # #$#
# # " *
4
A
(α 1 ) 2 4β 1
≥ − (β 1 + β 2 ) X 2 + (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 ) X
X = α 2
2β 2
− µ 2
(α 1 ) 2 4β 1
+ (β 1 + β 2 ) X 2 − (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 ) X ≥ 0.
?
X
)
∂X
∂T 1 = 0,
∂
(α 1 ) 2
4β 1 + (β 1 + β 2 ) X 2 − (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 ) X
∂T 1
= 2α 1
4β 1
∂α 1
∂T 1
− ∂α 1
∂T 1
X
= ∂α 1
∂T 1 ( α 1
2β 1
− X)
= −vβ 1
α 1
2β 1
+ µ 2 − α 2
2β 2
≤ 0
!)! ) ' .
a 1, a 2
b 1
b 2
c 1
c 2
T 1
T 2
3T 1
&
! '
1
4
A &
T 1
α 1
!!
α 1
" )A4A
<A )A "
•
& Am
"
m (α 1 − β 1 m) m = 2β α 1
1
" 6
"A
α 1
!m = 2β α 1
1 .
•
& Am
"
m (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 − (β 1 + β 2 )m) m = 2β α 2
2 − µ 2 .
? :α 1
"
"A
α 1
!m = 2β α 2
2 − µ 2 .
&
∂α 1
α 1
A "
m∂α 1 .
)A
"
T 1
)A
A
(α 2 ) 2 4β 2
≥ − (β 1 + β 2 ) Y 2 + (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 ) Y
Y = α 1
2β 1
− µ 1
(α 2 ) 2 4β 2
+ (β 1 + β 2 ) Y 2 − (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 ) Y ≥ 0.
?
Y
'
1
∂Y
∂T 1 = − β 2β 1 v
1 + v = v 2 ,
∂
(α 2 ) 2
4β 2 + (β 1 + β 2 ) Y 2 − (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 ) Y
∂T 1
= (2 (β 1 + β 2 ) Y − (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 )) ∂Y
∂T 1 − ∂α 1
∂T 1 − β 1
∂µ 1
∂T 1
Y
=
2 (β 1 + β 2 ) α 1
2β 1 − µ 1
− (α 1 + α 2 − β 1 µ 1 ) v
2 − 0
=
β 2 α 1
β 1 − 2 (β 1 + β 2 ) µ 1 − α 2 + β 1 µ 1
v 2
= v 2 2β 2
α 1
2β 1
− α 2
2β 2
− 2β 2 + β 1
2β 2
µ 1
= −vβ 2
α 2
2β 2 − α 1
2β 1 + µ 1 + β 1
2β 2 µ 1
≤ 0
!)! ) > .
a 1, a 2
b 1
b 2
c 1
c 2
T 1
T 2
3T 1
& ! > K'
4
&
T 1
"
G
.
T 1
3T 1
A
/
#
¾½
H !
C
<
!
¾½
) # $# * ! ,
# # *
--
¾¾
&
:
4 &
"
! !
4
" !
A . 3
"4 G
.
3
4 : <
H
. 3
¾¿
, # *'℄ "
E
" "
)22)
.,L2)F//(F, '2 M
)22) ,A G9 M < '>1
'/F(IF)22) 8 (('B (('I3
-
-
.3
. 3
4
4
¾¾
$
¾¿
8
!&
9
0
"
? % *B℄ ?
% , < % N >( /B
'> &
. 3
G
O@8, O
*1℄ 8
./B B( 3
& . 3
.'( 3
"
&
"
4 4
4 < 4
. 3
G . 3
4 #
& "
: " "
8
" G
'('B
=
8
C
9
6
"
" " 9
.
3 "
"
--
4
"
#
9
# "
&
& '((>*>℄&
F &
'?8 ? 6
.
3 6
. 6 8
3
A
.
> '((/3
'()(N
& .3
"
.
3
&
!
=
& 4 "
"
"
"
#
' #$ # ##6
$
# *
; # #
* # ***
"
. 3
!
,
9
8
"
/(.'(/(
3
&
8
4 & "
.
3
8
, *)℄
. 3
"
.
3 5
" .3
9 &
&
&
" =
=
A 6
1(A "
E
8
A
4
"
&
6"
. 3
,
, "
" '(0 & '(() #
*'℄
! 9
.3 "
&
"
:
5 *1℄
/ DD0 ? % *B℄ 3
" --
& F
& "
,
?
"
&
!
,
H
!
" 4 &
" ! A
&
) ' "
8
&
4
-- #
!
<
p 1
p 2
A A& "A "
p 1 (α − β (p 1 + p 2 )) + p 2 (α − β (p 1 + p 2 )),
(p 1 + p 2 ) (α − β (p 1 + p 2 )).
(p 1 + p 2 ) = 2β α
.
X(α − βX)
3HA "
& " H ! " "
"A A
p 2 ,
A "p 1 (α − β (p 1 + p 2 ))
p 1 = α−βp 2β 2 .
&
p 1 ,
A "p 2 (α − β (p 1 + p 2 ))
p 2 = α−βp 2β 1 .
H ! &
p 1 = α−βp 2β 2 p 2 = α−βp 2β 1
p 1 = p 2 = 3β α ,
(p 1 + p 2 ) = 2 3 α β
<
p 1
p ′ 1
A ; ;A@
<
p 2
A @# "
&" H !" " "A
A
&
p 2 ,
A"p 1 (α−β (p 1 + p 2 ))+
p ′ 1 (α ′ − β ′ (p ′ 1 + p 2 )),
p 1 = α−βp 2β 2
p ′ 1 = α ′ −β 2β ′ ′ p 2 .
&
p 1
p ′ 1
A"p 2 (α − β (p 1 + p 2 ) + α ′ − β ′ (p ′ 1 + p 2 )),
p 2 = α+α 2(β+β ′ −βp 1 −β ′ ) ′ p ′ 1
⎧
⎪ ⎨
⎪ ⎩
p 1 = α−βp 2β 2 p ′ 1 = α ′ −β 2β ′ ′ p 2
p 2 = α+α 2(β+β ′ −βp 1 −β ′ ) ′ p ′ 1
⎧
⎪ ⎨
⎪ ⎩
p 1 = 2β α − 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ ) p ′ 1 = 2β α ′ ′ − 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
p 2 = 3(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
H !
@ ;
p 1 + p 2 = 2β α + 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ )
@ ;A
p ′ 1 + p 2 = 2β α ′ ′ + 6(β+β α+α ′ ′ ) .
"
"
α
2β
@;α ′
2β ′
@ ;A # " A
"
C "A"
; ;A . "
α
3β
;α ′
3β ′
;A3 &=
:
&
2
!
m 2 = 2β α 2
2 .
& A
m 1 m 1 < 2β α 2
2 − µ 2 ,
"
m 1 (α 1 − β 1 m 1 + α 2 − β 2 (m 1 + µ 2 )) = m 1 (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 − (β 1 + β 2 )m 1 ) .
m 1 (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 − (β 1 + β 2 )m 1 )
m 1 =
α 1 +α 2 −β 2 µ 2
2(β 1 +β 2 )
m 1 = α 1 2(β +α 2 −β 2 µ 2
1 +β 2 ) ,
m 1 = α 1 2(β +α 2 −β 2 µ 2
1 +β 2 )
.
m 1 ,
!0
α 1 +α (β 2 −β 2 µ 2
1 +β 2 )
3"
m 1
A "
α 1 +α 2 −β 2 µ 2
2(β 1 +β 2 )
α 2
2β 2 − µ 2
α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 2(β 1 + β 2 ) ≥ α 2
2β 2
− µ 2
⇐⇒ 2β 2 (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 ) ≥ 2(β 1 + β 2 )α 2 − 4(β 1 + β 2 )β 2 µ 2
⇐⇒ β 2 (α 1 − β 2 µ 2 ) ≥ β 1 α 2 − 2(β 1 + β 2 )β 2 µ 2
⇐⇒ β 2 α 1 + β 2 µ 2 (2β 1 + β 2 ) ≥ β 1 α 2
⇐⇒ α 1
2β 1 + µ 2 + β 2
2β 1 µ 2 ≥ α 2
2β 2
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤ 2β α 2
2 ≤ 2β α 1
1 + µ 2 ,
!
m 1 (α 1 + α 2 − β 2 µ 2 − (β 1 + β 2 )m 1 )
m 1
α 1 +α 2 −β 2 µ 2
2(β 1 +β 2 ) ,
"m 1 m 1 ≤ 2β α 2
2 − µ 2
m 1 = 2β α 2
2 − µ 2
.
A 3
1
!
α 1
2β 1 − µ 1 ≤ 2β α 2
2 ≤ 2β α 1
1 + µ 2
m 2
A
m 2 = 2β α 1
1 − µ 1
.A3
*)℄ , M .'(('3 - "
-
*'℄ ,.'(()3 -# 8
'()( -
*>℄O== M M M6 .)2I'3 -8 L4
& L & C-
!"
*/℄ & '((> F E &
#$# # $ % &' ()
*B℄ % O .'((/3 - - ) $
() *
*D℄< .'((/3 -'> ?%A- )
$ () *
*1℄ < .'((/3 - - ) $
() *
*I℄<C.'(()3 - APEQ,
LO <AR S E- +
*2℄< & .'((/3 - - )$ ()
*
*)(℄ C M E.)2I/3 -C & &-
#, ! , & "* -".
$+%/ # 0-
*)'℄C 8 G .'(((3 -5 !- 120
*)>℄ .)2123 -C , G O- 3
*)/℄ M .)2I'3 UE 8 ,
8 L4V '1 & "
*)B℄ M .)2B(3 -@ -
% ! 4*-!
*)D℄ M .)22>3 - & G=- 5$
)05 "