HAL Id: hal-00086454
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00086454
Submitted on 18 Jul 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Contrôle optimal appliqué au problème de rentrée atmosphérique
Emmanuel Trélat
To cite this version:
Emmanuel Trélat. Contrôle optimal appliqué au problème de rentrée atmosphérique. 2004, 6 p.
�hal-00086454�
!"$#&% ' % ()*,+- ./ (-01'2
3 40*5 67"#&%'
8:9;9=<?>$@BADCFEHGJI
KMLNBOFP
PRQ
<?SUTWVX<ZY[TW\]VXA_^7`bac8edgf
h<ZYXi,j]kMl7hmonWpqZnrkBs<tYujwv$qWx"kwyrzuv{Wx}|gV~[<uA rAkUMVX<?>BDA?j
t$wZ"BW?rZw?BZUr¡ "
""¢£$£Z¤$¤$¤¥M?wZU¦¡ $B£B§¦"BW?
¨©
ª«¬®
©
ª°¯²±F³2´cµ·¶¸³º¹»¼X½¼X´¥´¥¼0¾¿=À¦½ÁDÂÃÅļ[Æe¼gÇu¼HÈcÁD³º¹½ÊÉÁDÃ˼gÁÀ ¹¡¶ÌƾÃ
Ç?µ·¿¦³ ¼(³ ¾Íº¼R¹¥¹¼´Àu¾[¹¡¶Ë¾Ã·¼¼X³JÀÎ ¾º´°¼Çu¼b½¼X³º¹½»¼R¼¾[¹¡ÆÁ´ÀÎM»¼½c¶ËÏu¿ ¼ºÐ
ÁWÄ¿3Ã˼;ÈcÁD³º¹½ÊÉÁDÃ˼ѼX´Ò¹HÃÓµ¾³ Ô Ã·¼ÑÇu¼=ÔXÉÕ·¹¼ºÐÖ¼×¹ØÃ˼;ÈcÁÉ¿D¹J¼´°¹HÃ˼ÑÙZ¿ Ú
¹¡Î ¼X½cƶ¸Ïu¿ ¼¹Áʹ¾ÃÛÓÜžºÈ¡¹¼X¿u½gÇ?µ·¿u´¿u½¼ÑÇu¼Ñ÷¾2³ ¾Í¼×¹¥¹¼XÝcÞ,ßµÁ ఼ȡá
¹¡¶ËÜâ¼´Ò¹Çu¼(ÇU»¼×¹¼½cƶ¸³ ¼X½e¿¦³ ¼b¹¡½¾[à°¼XÈ¡¹Á ¶Ë½¼ÁÀ ¹¡¶Ìƾ÷¼Öà¿u´¥Ïu¿ZµÌľg¿¦³ ¼
ÈR¶¸Â÷¼HÇuÁD³¦³U»¼R¼Ð,´¥¾ºÈcÎ ¾³Ê¹(Ïu¿ ¼HÃ˾ѳ ¾Íº¼R¹¥¹¼g¼´Ò¹_Çu¼JÀÃÌ¿u´b´°Á ¿¦Æ¶¸´°¼
ľÇu¼X´ãÈcÁD³º¹½¾¶Ì³Ê¹¼´;´¿u½ÃÓµ¥»¼R¹¾[¹Ð7ľ´°¾XͺÁD¶¸½=´¿u½-Ã˼äÙZ¿ Ú¹¡Î ¼½á
ƶËÏu¿ ¼ºÐuÃŵ¾ºÈ×È?»¼[ỼX½¾[¹c¶·Á ³e³ Á½cƾ÷¼Ðº¼×¹âÃ˾À¦½¼X´¥´¶·ÁD³Çu妳 ¾Æ¶ËÏu¿ ¼ºÞ æ¼
À¦½ÁÂỼXƼw¾(»¼×¹»¼ÈcÁDÆÀÃÅļR¹¼[Æe¼[³Ê¹½»¼´¥ÁDø¿ÖÇu¾³u´"¿¦³ ¼â´u»¼½c¶Ë¼UÇ?µ¾º½¥¹c¶ËÈ÷¼X´
çè[é
Ð
çËê×é
Ð çëXé
Þ
ìeícî
«ïñð¥ò
©
ª¥«ó¯ ¹½¾[à°¼Èc¹ÁD¶¸½¼ôÁÀ ¹c¶¸Æ¾Ã˼ºÐ_À¦½¡¶Ì³uÈR¶¸À¼Ç¿Æ¾ÊÚu¶ÌÆe¿¦Æ(Ð
Æe¹¡Î ÁuÇu¼õÇu¼¹c¶Ë½Þ
ö[÷ø;ùúeû
ütýDþÓÿþ
ù ú ?ù
ýüÖü
ú ü ü
:û
ütü
ù ÿ
û
ü þ
ü
!#"%$&"('*)&!,+.-0/
)21"
354768:9<;=4 >@?BA4 >A46#9DCA4E6?<8GFH4I3JIK5LNM<4 >@4OCP>GQR9&>:SUTVA4E6?&8GFXWSHQ0Y
6Z9<8:>[?&\#] 4E] 8[9<S^C:C[?&\D>:45_45F^?`>:aEA4O9<8[SH4_bR] 9<\D>[8dc9eFH4eMO4>_bR] 9e\D>:8.c9<FU4
9<6>:SUQR?<F(M#_?&\CEFU4OC>[4O]fa\SUgDb4hCi_W?A4O8:9]?<6>:b8:4kj
l
68[9<mF(n4OQR4OC_45o<bS^_?<o<4<M>:8f?&\CPp48:>[C_W9<8[mSq>[4OC?A4O8:9D?<C[CPS^C=>A4OCOM
l
_A4T<4OFH9e66Z4QR4\D>r_4sF^?&\]4b8fCR_4BC:?&>:4OFHFUSq>[4OC
ht-h/
$<uvH
w
F(W4\.;=4Obyx\?<\] SU48E>[8On4hCSHQR6Z9<8:>[?&\D>{z{M
l
68[9<mF(n4OQR4OCi_4k8:4O\D>:8A44|?.>[QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4}jZ]<W4hC=>IF(W9<m;=4>~_b
p*?<Q04Ob68:9<;=4 >}
$
}$.`/ZvHR`"X- !
_A4T<4OFH9e66EA406?<8|FH4
3JIK5LNM gDbS] 9<\#CPS^C=>[40n?|4O\ T<9.<4O8@b\4~\?dTe4 >P>[4`C:6?.>[SU?<FH4Ia?.Y
mSH>A44`Te48fC@F^?6F^?&\n4 >[4`B?&8fCOMe_?<\CVFU4`mb>E_4I8f?&QR4\485C:b8
48[8:4|_4hCA4O]fa#?&\D>:SUFHFU9<\#C5Q}?<8P>[SH4O\C
K@\o<8[9eCOMFH48.c9<FU4_4~FXW?&8f]~?&>:QR9eC:6aEA48[SUgDb4~4OCP>|j
l
_478A4h_bSU8:47C:brC:?<Q0QR4O\e>@FXW=A4\4O8:oeSH4E] SU\EA4>:S^gDb4<M.6?<8Gp8[9&>P>[4 Y
QR4\D>`_?<\CEFXW?&>:QR9eC:6an4O8:4eM
l
_W?&QR4O\48F(W4\o<SU\CP6#?.>:S^?&FN_Wb\4~6#9DCPSH>:SU9<\SH\SH>:S^?&FU4~68A4O] S^C:4
n
?0b\4]SHmFH4_9e\\EA4O4<M
l
_476FHbCVSHFp*?&b>@68[4\#_8:474O\}] 9<QR6>[4i] 4O8P>f?&SU\4OCG]9<\D>:8f?&SU\D>:4OC
C:b8iFXW=A4 >[?&>|j] 9e\e>[8[?<SH\D>[4C:b8iFU4b>:a4O8:QRS^gDb4 w]O?&87SUF?
_4hCGo<4O\C`n?FXWSU\D>A4O8:SU4b8@_47FU?\#?dT<4 >:>:4Gz{MDCPb8VF(W?<]O]NA4OF A4O8[?&>:SU9<\
\9e8:Q}?<FH4
w
] 9<\p9<8:>V_4iT<9eF^z M&4 >CPb8VFU?68[4OC[C:SH9e\0_ \?<QRSUgDb4
w
] 9<\D>[8[?<SH\D>:4~>[4O]fa\S^gDb4|_4CP>:8[b]{>[b8:4dz{M
l
4O\x\M#9<\s]fa48f]fa4_4|6FHbC0n?RQRSH\SUQRSUC:48`b\B] 8[Sq>On48[4|_W9<6Y
>[SHQRS^C:?&>:SU9<\jFH4#b>[a48[QRSUgDb4~>:9<>[?<F_4FU?R\#?dT<4 >:>:4e
4I]9<\D>:8.c9<FU474OCP>VF^?] 9e\xoeb8[?&>:SU9<\}?A48[9 _D\#?&QRSUgDb47_4IFU?\?.Y
T<4>P>[4< ?,68[4QRS(n48[4gDb4hC=>[SH9e\gDbSiC:4y6#9DCP4y4hC=>}F^?,C:bSUT.?&\D>:4j
FU4OC|p9e8[]4OC?A48[9_ \?&QRS^gDb4OC6Z4bTe4\D>PY%4FUFU4OC]9<\D>:8[SHmb48n?sp8:4OSqY
\4O8F^?B\?dTe4 >P>[4_4rQ}?<\S(n48[4r?<_A4hgDb?.>[4KV\p*?&SH>0C:S5FXW?<Fq>[Sq>[b_4
4OCP>>:8[9<6A4FU4TVA44
w
C:b6EA4O8:SU4b8:4n?,d&r Qrz{M?<FH9e8[CIF^?_4O\C:Sq>A40?&>PY
QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4~4OCP>7>:8[9<6p*?&SUmFU4<M4>iSHF4OCP>`6a CPS^gDb4QR4\D>7SUQ06Z9eCPY
C:SHmFU4s_4soGA4\EA4O8:4O8k_4hC0p9<8f] 4hC}?A4O8:9_ \?<Q0S^gDb4OCkCPb}C[?&QRQR4\D>
SU\e>[4\C:4OCOib]9<\D>:8f?&SU8:4eMC:S5FXW?<Fq>[Sq>[b_44OCP>>[8:9e6m?<C[CP4 wQR9<SU\C
_4< Qrz{MVFU?_4O\CPSH>A4y?&>:QR9eC:6aEA48[SUgDb44OCP>}>:8[9<6o<8f?&\_4eMG4 >
FU4rCP4ObF@4QR6FU9<S5_4OCp9e8[]4OC|?A48[9_ \?&QRS^geb4OC] 9e\_bSU8[?<Sq>n?yb\
_A4O6?<C[C:4QR4\D>0_bC:4bSHFi?<b>:9e8:S^CA46Z9<b8}FU4b>[a48[QRSUgDb4y9<b
F^?y68:4hC:C:SU9<\_ \?&QRS^geb4<KV\4 N4 >F^?y8:4O\D>:8A44R?.>[Q09DCP6aA48[S^geb4
COW4 Z4h]{>:b4sn?_4hCIT SH>:4hC:C:4OCI>:8hn4hCyA4OFH4OTVA44OCO#KV\8[4T.?<\]fa4kC:SF(W?&FH>:SHY
>:b#_44hC=>] 9<QR68[S^CP44O\D>:8[4k&}4>kd&R QyM#9e\B6#4Ob>~>:8[9<bTe48ib\
] 9eQR68:9eQRSUCO 3IW4OCP>5] 4~gDbW9e\r?&66Z4FUFU4`F^?
/¡$d$&"(})dX/¡
'*¢-
£
b8f?&\D>]4 >P>[4s6a?eCP4s?.>[QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4<MF^?\#?dT<4 >:>:4sC:4B] 9<Q0Y
6Z9<8:>:4] 9eQRQ04b\
/NvH$.!N -
MZ]&W4OCP>PY n?.Y2_SH8[4geb4|FH4hCEQ09<>:4Ob8[C`CP9e\e>
] 9eb6EA4hCj|SHF}\W¤?¥6?eC_4p9<8f] 4_46#9ebC[CA4O4< W4\o<SU\¤4hC=>
_9e\]¦C:9<bQ0S^C§b\S^geb4QR4\D>¨n?©F^?©p9e8[]4¥_4¦oe8[?dT SH>A4ª4>ª?<b
p9<8f] 4hC?A4O8:9_ \?<Q0S^gDb4OCO 4}] 9<\D>[8dc9eFH4k4OCP>FXW?&\oeFH4R_4Rodc«H>:4RgDbS
8[468A4OC:4\D>[4FXW?<\o<FU4y4\D>:8[4sFH4hC}?&SUFH4hCR4 >rb\6F^?&\ª]9<\D>:4O\?&\D>RFU?
\?dTe4 >P>[4<K@\x\MN9<\,]fa9<S^CPSH>|] 9<QRQR4R] 8[Sq>On48[4_W9<6>[SHQRS^C:?&>:SU9<\FH4
b>:a4O8:QRS^gDb4~>:9&>f?&F_4~F^?R\?dTe4 >P>[4<
¬
)h+
v'^$."X'*).!+.-0/
)<uv ®R
?~QR9 _A4FUSUC[?.>[SH9e\68A4h] S^CP4E_bR68[9<mF(n4QR4E?BA4 >A454 Z4h]{>[bA447_?<\C
¯°.±M ¯²d±³I\ªb>:SUFUSUC:4BFU4OCrFU9<S^C_4BFU?Q§A4h]?<\SUgDb4B]FU?eC:C:S^geb4<M@b\
QR9_Nn4FU4B_4_4\C:Sq>A4B?.>[QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4y4 >b\´Q09_n4FU4s6#9eb8rFU4OC
p9<8f] 4hCCOW448eµ]?&\D>C:b8FU?\?dT<4>P>:4eM5F^?p9e8[]4Bo<8f?dT Sq>f?.>[SH9e\\4FUFU4
4 >F^?p9<8f] 4}?A48[9 _D\#?&QRSUgDb40gDbSVC:4R_A4O]9<QR6#9DCP404\b\4r] 9<Q0Y
6Z9eC[?&\D>:4_SH>:4_4
"
$¶·¸!
h
4 >sb\4,]9<QR6#9DC:?<\D>:4_Sq>[4_4
/) {¹
"2$.!Ztf
4~C:C=>On4QR4`4hC=>EQR9<\9<YX4O\D>:8A44i4>7FH4] 9e\e>[8dc9eFH4I4OCP>7FU?Rº
¶·¸"2
t'¸!
R$&"('*¢-
wFXW?&\oeFH4_W?.>:>[?egeb4~4hC=>7x5A4hz{
³I\_9<\\4kb\QR9_Nn4FU4oGA4\EA48f?&FN>[4\?<\e>|] 9eQR6>:40_4kF^?r8[9&>f?.Y
>:SU9<\ wb\SHp9<8[Q04dz0_4sFU?
48[8:4y?&b>:9<b8r_4sF(W?.4y»½¼¿¾ÀEM`n?
T Sq>[4OC[CP4s?<\o<bF^?&SU8[4y_4sQ09_bFH4Á~³I\\9<>:4BÂü w(Ä&ÅdÆ:ÄdÇ<Æ:ÄdÈ z
b\}8[46n48[4oD?&FUSHFA4O4\R_9<\D>VFXW9e8:SUo<SU\4E4OCP>VFU4`] 4O\D>:8[4`É_4iF^? 4O8:8[4<M
Ê Å ¼ w(ËÆÌÆ
»zb\8[46n48[4V_W9<8[SHoeSH\4É4O\8[9&>[?&>:SU9<\n?`FU?IT Sq>[4OC[CP4
Á?&b>:9<b85_4IF(W?.4`»Me4> Ë F(WSH\D>[48fCP4h]{>:SU9<\r?dTe4O]EFU4`Q§A4O8:S^_SU4\r_4
Í~8[44\ Î7S^]fa
L 9<SH> Ê FU4}8[?de9<\,_4}FU? 48[8[404>ÏÐFU4r] 4O\D>:8[4r_4}Q}?<C[CP4}_4
F^?r\?dTe4 >P>[4<³I\B\9<>:4
Ê~ÑÅ
¼ w*ÄdÒ&Æ[ÄOÓ2Æ[ÄdÔ z`FU4k8[46n48[4?<C[CP9] SA4?<b
] 9 9e8[_9e\\EA4O4OC0CP6aA48[S^geb4OC0_4BÏÕ¼ wÖ.Æ:×PÆ:Ø z{M ÖÙ
Ê A4 >f?&\D>RFU?
_S^C=>f?&\]4ÉÏRM × FU?0FU9<\oeSq>[b_4|4> Ø F^?0FU?&>:SH>:b_4<
4C: CP>On4QR4|_4] 9 9<8f_9e\\EA4O4OCECP6aA48[S^geb4OC68A4OC:4\D>:4b\4CPSU\Y
QRSUgDb4~CP9ebCGp9e8:QR4i6FHbCC:SHQR6FU4`9e\rSH\D>[8:9_bSH>5FU4`8[46n48[4EQ09emSUFH4
Ê Ç ¼ wfÆeÆ
z_9<\D>|FXW9e8:SUo<SU\4R4OCP>Ï _4}FU?Q}?&\SXn4O8:4RCPbSHT.?&\D>[4<
L 9eSq> j wwPz ÆNwPz Æ#wPzPz|F^?>:8f?.;=4h]{>:9eSH8[4R_4rÏÐQR4hCPb8A4O4
_?<\C@FU4`8[46n48[4
Ê Å 4>
FU?|T SH>:4hC:C:4i8[4F^?.>:SUT<4
¼ZË ZÌ »
9<b8~_A4 x\SU8
9<\B6Z9eC:4j
¼
40T<4h]{>:4Ob8
4OCP>~b\T<4h]{Y
>:4Ob8|b\SH>[?<SH8[4R_b6FU?<\
wfÆ[ÄhÒ
z`6Z48[6Z4\_S^] bFU?<SH8[4yn?
4 >|9e8:SU4\D>A4
6?<8 ! Ä Ò#" ³I\s6#9DCP4 ¼ %$
?r_SU8[4O]{>[SH9e\s_4F^?}T Sq>[4OC[CP4
4OCP>6?&8f?&Q§A4>:8[SUCA44_?&\CIFH4R8[46n48[4
ÊÑÅ
¼ w(Ä Ò Æ:Ä ÓÆ:Ä Ô zI6?&8_4Ob
?&\o<FU4OCj
l
F^?6#4O\e>[4'& M?<bC[CPSG?&66#4OF A4O4
$.!
º
vH+<)(d)&v
MgDbS@8[468A4hCP4O\e>[4
FXW?<\o<FU44O\D>:8[4b\6FU?<\Ba9e8:S+*9e\e>f?&F4 >b\6F^?&\] 9<\D>[4\?<\e>
F^?0\?dT<4>P>:4eM
l
FXW?,*SUQb>.-5M<gDbS4OCP>GF(W?&\oeFH44\D>[8:4EF^?I68:9<;=4O]{>[SH9e\k_4'
_?&\C
b\y6F^?&\ya9e8:S+*9e\D>[?&FN4>EFU4|T<4h]{>[4b8 Ä Ô
WPA4hgeb#?.>:SU9<\ p9e\_?&QR4O\e>f?&FU4´_4¦FU? Q§A4h]?<\SUgDb4eMgDbS4hC=>b\4
A
4hgeb#?.>:SU9<\_SH `A48[4\D>:SU4FUFH4}_bC:4O]9<\_,9e8[_8[4}CPb8/0 È
MC:4R>:8f?<_bSq>
6?<87b\sCPCP>On4OQ04_?<\CEFH4hCi] 9 9e8[_9e\\EA4O4OC
wÖ.Æ[×=Æ:Ø`Æ
Æ& Æ -z{
G?&8V?<SHFUFH4Ob8fCMe9<\rC:b66Z9eC:4`_Wb\4`6#?&8:>5gDb4iF^?\?dTe4 >P>[474OCP>5b\
6F^?&\4Ob8hM]&W4OCP>PY n?.Y2_SH8[4geb4
vU$~/).- f
O0+<vH$}!N$1(. "X"2 f"5!-v¸vH
M
4 >_W?&b>:8[4k6?<8P>|9e\C:b66Z9eC:40gDb4RF^?T SH>:4OC[C:40_4RFXW?&>:QR9eC:6an48[4
4OCP>|FU?T Sq>[4OC[CP4R_4RF^? 48[8:4.2NF^?TDSH>:4hC:C:408:4OFU?&>:SUT<4k_40F^?\?dT<4>P>:4
6?<878[?<66#9e8P>n?0F^? 48[8[4~4hC=>i_9e\]~FU?RT SH>:4hC:C:48:4OFU?&>:SUT<43
4OCp9<8f] 4hCk?<o<S^C:C[?&\D>kC:b80FU?\?dTe4 >P>[4C:9<\D>kF^?sp9e8[]4_4o<8f?.Y
T Sq>A4r4>FU?sp9<8f] 4?A48[9_ \?&QRS^geb4<MgDbSECP4_A4O]9<QR6#9DCP4R4O\b\4
] 9eQR6#9DC:?<\e>[4r_SH>:4_4
"
$¶·¸!
h
w9e66Z9eCA44Bn?yF^?sT Sq>[4OC[CP4dz{M4>b\4
p9<8f] 4B_Sq>[4_4
/)
"2$.!Ntf
w6Z48[6Z4\_S^] bFU?<SH8[4§n?F^?T Sq>[4OC[CP4dz{³I\
\9<>:454}4OCP> FXW?<\o<FU4V_4o.c«q>[4<M76 wÖ
zF^?`_4O\CPSH>A45_45F(W?.>[Q09DCP6an48[4<MO4 >
859 Æ 8 Ô
FU4OCG]9 4 r] SU4\D>[C_45>:8f?dc«H\EA44@4>G_46Z9<8:>[?<\] 4e.354hCG] 9 4 RY
] SU4\D>fC_A4O6#4O\_4O\e>_4@FXW?<\o<FU4V_W?.>:>[?egeb4<MSX4<hF(W?&\oeFH4V4\D>:8[4@FXW?& 4
_bB6FU?<\4b8I4 >~FH4kT<4O] >:4Ob8`T SH>:4OC[C:4.2Z]<W4hC=>?}68[SH9e8:Sb\] 9e\D>:8.c9<FU4
Q}?&S^C@9e\rCPb66#9DCP4~geb4`_b8f?&\D>VFXW?<8[]`?.>:QR9DCP6aEA48[SUgDb4ESUF#4hC=>Vx5A4<
Ji9<>:8[4C:4bF] 9<\D>[8dc9eFH4R4OCP>k_9e\]}FXW?<\o<FU4r_4odc«H>:44ª_9e\e>kF(W4 N4 >
4OCP>I_9ebmFU4}jQR9_SHx48IF(W?&FH>:SH>:b_4Q}?&S^Ci?&bC[C:S>:9eb8:\48kn?}_8[9<SH>:4
9<bn?RoD?&b]fa4<Z³I\B]fa9eSUC:SH>`6#9eb8iF^?r_4O\CPSH>A4?.>:QR9DCP6aEA48[SUgDb4b\
QR9_Nn4FU404 6#9e\4\D>[SH4OF:6 wÖ z¼;6!<h4>=?,@fM4 >|6?&8|?<SHFUFH4Ob8fC`9e\C:b6Y
6Z9eC:4gDb4BA w*Ö
zV¼DCE
ÒF
4V8[46n4O8:4V\W=A4 >[?<\D> 6?eC?<mC:9<FUbMOF^?I\?dT<4>P>:4
4OCP>A4Ooe?<FH4OQ04O\D>CP9ebQRSUC:4n?sF^?yp9<8f] 4r_4y359<8[SU9<FUSUC4>yn?sF^?yp9<8f] 4
_W4\D>:8f?dc«H\4OQR4\D>O
G SU\?<FH4OQ04O\D>OMhF(W?&8f]@?.>[QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4G4OCP> _A4O] 8[SH>6?&8FH4CPCP>On4OQR4
C:bSHT.?<\e>j
H Ò
HI
¼
CPSU\&
HJ
HI
¼ KACPSU\&)K
ÅÇ
6.LNMO
P Ç
Á Ç Ö
]9eC ØIw
C:SH\5&~]9eC
Ø
K] 9DCQ&IC:SH\
Ø
] 9eCQ-z
HR
HI
¼ ]9eCQ&
w
KC
J JÒ z Å
Ç
6.L!M%S
P
]9eCT4
eÁ] 9eC
Ø
CPSU\-
Á Ç ÒJ
]9eC ØIw
] 9DCQ&I]9eC ØU
CPSU\&~C:SU\
Ø
] 9eCV- z
H Ô
HI
¼ JÒ
]9eCQ&] 9eCV-
H Ó
HI
¼ K J
ÒXWZY[
R
[]\^%_
WZY[
Ô
H _
HI
¼ ÅÇ
6.L!M%S
P J
WZY[
R
C:SH\`4 JÒ
]9eCQ&I>[?<\
Ø
CPSU\-
eÁ
w
C:SH\
Ø
K>[?<\&~] 9DC
Ø
]9eCQ- z Á Ç Ò
J
[\^ Ô WZY[
Ô
[\^%_
WZY[
R whz
9<b8|FU4OC_9<\\EA44OC~\ bQ§A4O8:S^gDb4OCb>[SHFUS^CA4O4OCOM9<\C:408A4p2n48[40?<b
?&8:>:S^] FU4OCE68A4h] SH>A4hC
a cb
7/
)eu v ®}0+eRt[)&!"
¶).vH0)[/N"('¸}$.v
468:9emF(n4QR44hC=>}_W?&QR4\48RF(W4\o<SU\§C:6?.>[SU?<F_Wb\4yT.?&8[S A4 >A4
SU\Sq>[SU?<FH4)de<n?b\4}T.?&8[S A4>A4kx\?<FH4fd
Å
M9nb,FU4R>:4QR6C>:4O8:QRSU\?&F
hg4OCP>VFHSUm8[4<MD4 >FH4hCV] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\C5?&bRFUSHQRSH>:4OCC:9<\D>_9e\\EA4O4OC@_?&\C
?&FH>:SH>:b#_4 wji
z <lkmD| Q ²
Q
T Sq>[4OC[CP4 w z npoe,ok ² Qfq&C o!o ² Qfq&C
?&\o<FU4_4~Te9<F
w
&z Y[em,o0_4Oo FUSHm8:4
F^?.>:SH>:b#_4 w*Ø z hk,k_4o
FU9<\oeSq>[b_4 w*×z FHSUm8[4~9ebx5A44rn?<lr² k_4Oo sr,ro!mk_4o
?>*OSHQkb>
w
-z FHSUm8[4 FUSHm8:4
tTuwv%xQy)z
{}|>~>>p|,~, 11%pl
?\?dTe4 >P>[44OCP>OM?<b ]9<b8fC_4ªF^?6a?eCP4ª_4 8[4\D>[8A4O4?&>PY
QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4<MC:9<bQRS^CP4rn?k>:8[9<S^C7] 9e\D>:8f?&SU\e>[4OC~j
l
359e\e>[8[?<SH\D>[4~C:b87FU4
-,"¡
k'*¢-
j
¼8l 6
È
P` Æ w
<z
l
359e\e>[8[?<SH\D>[4~C:b8
vh$et[t
v
$."X'*).!!Z)
R$&vH
j
&TR¼&Q><
w]
zZ6
Ç
& P`
Æ w(°
z
l
359e\e>[8[?<SH\D>[4~C:b87F^?
/
ff'*)&!,+>.!Z$.0'*¢-
j
6 Ç
P`
w
oDz
K@FUFH4hC|CP9e\e>|8[468A4hCP4O\e>A44hC`C:b8|F^?xoGr_?<\CFU4r_9<Q}?&SU\4}_4
T<9eF(M4O\p9<\] >:SU9<\y_4|F(W?<]O]NA4OF A48f?.>:SU9<\f0¼
Å
Ç
LNMO
P 6 Ç
4 >`_4
normal acceleration dynamic
pressure
thermal flux
J
H
¡ ¢p£
P
£¤%¥¦¨§©ª ¦7§j«¬:¬j®p©}¯±°²«§ª§h³1«Z§X¬]§©ª§l²«¢ «´p«µXª©¶>¥¯´>·¸:©¹ªº¨«¬
4`68:9emF(n4QR4i_4I]9<\D>:8.c9<FU479<6>:SUQR?<F#4hC=>E_4iQRSU\SHQRS^CP4O85FU4i#b
>:a48[Q0S^gDb4>:9<>[?<FGj
8 w 4zV¼¼»
Ij½
< 8 6 È
!
wX²
z
359<\]48[\?&\D>]4¦]8:SH>On4O8:4¦_W9e6>:SUQRSUC[?.>[SH9e\MR6FUbCPSU4b8[C]fa9<SH
C:9<\D>4\p*?&SH>06Z9eC[CPSUmFU4OC4 >kFU4OC0] 8[SH>On4O8:4hCrn?B68[4\_8:4r4O\] 9eQR6>:4
C:9<\D>@FH4ip*?<]{>[4b8_WbCPb8:4iFUS A4n?|FXWSU\D>A4Oo<8f?&FU4_brb0>:a4O8:QRS^geb4i4 >
FU4] 9<\p9<8:>7_4T<9eFFHS A4rn?RF(WSU\e>A4oe8[?<FH4_4|FXW?e]]NA4F A48f?.>[SH9e\}\9<8[Q}?&FU4<
³I\y]fa9<S^CPSH>7FH4|68:4OQ0SU48i]8:SH>On48[4<M FH4~>[4QR6CEx\#?&F}hgA4>[?<\e>7FUSHm8:4e
¾
Z"
$&"
º '*+}¿k$
/).vH+y"ÁÀ
$>(d
L S<9e\p*?&SH>F(W?&668:9dSUQ}?.>:SU9<\Â
'Ã
KMOFH45] 9cb>6#4Ob>Vc4>:8[4kA4O]8:SH>@j
8 w
4z5¼ »;»
J½
J E Ç
Æ » " Æ
4 > FU? C=>[8[?&>A4Oo<SU4 9<6>[SHQ}?&FU4Õ]9<\C:SUCP>:4 ?&FU9<8fCÕn? Q}?.SUQRSUC:48
FXW?e]]NA4F A48f?.>[SH9e\Ä06Z4\_?<\D>5>[9<b>[4IF^?k_b8A44`_bT<9eF(3IW4hC=>EF^?6Z9&Y
8[SUCA4OCOM_?&\#CF(W9<8f_8[4RC:bSUT.?&\D>}jb>:a4O8:QRS^geb4}QR?&SHQ}?&FXM6bS^C
?<]O]NA4OF A48f?.>:SU9<\\9e8:Q}?<FH4Q}?.SHQ}?<FH4eMG6bS^CR68:4hC:C:SU9<\_ \?<QRSUgDb4
Q}?.SUQR?<FH4eMT<9eSH8xo#<
W?dTd?<\D>[?&oe4B_4]4 >P>[4Q§A4>:a9_4B4hC=>geb4FU4BFH9e\o_Wb\´?<8[]
p8[9<\D>:S(n48[4FH4`]9<\D>:8.c9<FU47CW4 68[SUQ047C:9<bCGp9<8[Q04i_4
u[)&-t vU
O
M
]&W4OCP>PY n?.Y2_SU8:44O\¤p9e\]{>[SH9e\ _4 FXW=A4>[?&>Ok354 >:>:4ªp9e8:QR4ª4hC=>mSU4\
?<_?&6>A44?&b68:9emF(n4QR4OC4O\>[4QR6C78A44OF(M 4>`CP468Oc4 >[4ImSH4O\y?<b
68[9<mFXn4OQ04hCE_4C=>f?&mSUFUSUC[?.>[SH9e\
3546Z4\_?<\D>I] 4>P>:4kQA4 >[a9_4
! {{"/$.k)[/N"('¸}$.vH
6Z9<b8I\9&>[8:4
] 8[SH>On4O8:4eM4 >0\9&>[8:4mb>k4hC=>R_4]fa48f]fa48b\4r>[8[?&;=4O]{>[9<SU8:4}9e6>:SHY
Q}?&FU4<
öRöX÷Ñû
ütÿ
ý D$ÿü ÿþ¸
ý<þ ù
ÿ
û
ü þ
üZÿ
#"
$&"
º
'*0¢-$d{'
¹
)[/N"('¸}$.vH
³I\B8[?<66Z4FUFH4FU48A4hCPbFH>[?&>IC:bSHT.?<\e>hM#QR9e\e>[8A4_?&\C
¯ ±
oe8dc?e] 4n?
b\4?&\?<FHC:4}oGA4O9<Q§A4>:8[SUgDb4kx\4_4OC4 >:8A4Q}?&FU4OC|_9<\\EA44OC6?&8
FU4|68:SU\]SH6Z4_byQ}?.SHQkbQÐ?dTe4O]~] 9<\D>[8[?<SH\D>:4hCECPb87FXW=A4 >f?.>O
)[/)d{'¸"X'*).!
L 4FU9<\ FU4OC©_4Ob¿68:9emF(n4QR4OC¥4\ T S^C:?<oGA4hC
w
Te9<SU8E>[?<mFH4/Pz M9<\s?j
<iL S~F^?FH9e\o<SH>:b_4BSH\Sq>[SU?<FH4B4hC=>FHSUm8[4<MVF^?CP>:8f?.>A4oeSH4y9<6>:SUQR?<FH4
4OCP>OMD?dT<4h]5b\47m#9e\\4`?<668[9dSHQ}?.>[SH9e\M
=
g
Ó
EM<9nb
w
8[4OC:6
=
zI4hC=>b\?&8f]] 9e8:8[4OC:6Z9<\_?<\D>I?&b,] 9<\D>[8dc9eFH4 4§¼¨
w8[4OC:64 ¼z{ME4>sg Ó
w8:4hCP6
z4OCP>yb\¦?<8[]Bp8:9e\e>[S(n48[4
] 9e8:8[4OC:6Z9<\_?<\D>0n?F^?] 9<\D>[8[?<SH\D>:40CPb8~FU40bs>[a48[QRSUgDb4 w8[4OC:6
C:b87F(W?<]O]NA4OF A48f?.>:SU9<\}\9<8[QR?<FH4dz{
iL S F^?iFU9<\oeSq>[b_4SH\Sq>[SU?<FH454OCP>xA4O4<MOFU?~C=>[8[?&>A4Oo<SU4G9<6>[SHQ}?<FH454OCP>OM
?dT<4h]`b\4|m#9e\\4?<668[9d SUQ}?.>[SH9e\M
= lg
Ó
=
4OC~] 9e\D>:8.c9<FU4OC`]9<8[8:4hCP6Z9<\#_?&\D>0n?b\?<8[]p8[9<\D>[S(n4O8:4kCP9e\e>]?<FqY
] bF A4hCp9<8[QR4FUFH4OQ04O\D>E6#?&8i_A4O8:SUT.?.>[SH9e\
354}8A4hCPbFq>f?.>|_W?<668[9dSHQ}?.>[SH9e\\W4OCP>6?eC~p*?<] SUFU4sn?QR9<\D>[8:4O8O
9<b84\_9<\\4O8b\4SU_A44eM8[4Q}?&8fgDb9<\C|gDb4FH4CPCP>On4OQ04 whz
_A4h] 8[SHT.?<\e>EFXW?<8[]?.>[QR9eC:6aEA4O8:S^gDb4`4hC=>`_4|F^?kp9<8[QR4
¼
w
&z
Å Å&w
&z
NÇZÇ<w
&z
Æ
?dT<4h]
Å
¼¤] 9DCT4GM Ç
¼¤CPSU\`44>!¼ w*Ö.Æ
Æ &
Æ:Ø`Æ:×=Æ
- z ZKV\6Z9&Y
C[?&\D>"
Å ¼ wÖ.Æ
Æ
&z`4 >#
Ç ¼ w(ØiÆ[×=Æ
-z{M#9<\B6Z4b>|_A4h] 9eQ06Z9eC:48`FH4
C: CP>On4QR4~_4|FU?0Q}?&\SXn4O8:4CPbSHT.?&\D>[4}j
Å
¼%$
Å&w
ÅdÆÅ
z É w
Á7z Æ Ç
¼&$
Çew
ÆNÇ
z
4068[4QRSU48CP9ebC=Y2C: CP>On4QR4|8:4O68A4OC:4\D>:4|F^?
/$
"('*rt'¸!
}$."X'*¢ -
M
SX4eFU4
R)&-T(dR!"vH)&!
º
'¸"(-+&'¸!Z$.v
_4FU?R\?dTe4 >:>:4<M>[?&\#_SUC`geb4|FH4
C:4O] 9e\_CP9ebC=Y2C: CP>On4QR4i8[468A4OC:4\D>[4`F^?
/$
"X'*0+1.!Z$&k'*¢- MSX4eFH4
}).-T(. } !#"`vH$&"
$&v
}/2F@COW?dTNn4O8:4gDb4RFU4R68:4OQRSH4O8CP9ebC=Y2C: CP>On4QR4
] 9e\CP>:SH>:b4Eb\47mZ9<\\47?&668[9dSHQ}?&>:SU9<\_b}C:C=>On4QR4E] 9<QR6FU4 >hM.4 >
4\68[4QRS(n48[4?&\?<FHC:4SUF p*?&b>|CP40] 9e\] 4O\e>[8:4O8~C:b8~FHbS(3IW4OCP>~b\
C: CP>On4QR4~?&}\4|QR9<\9<YX4O\e>[8A44I_4c/0 È
M_4|F^?p9e8:QR4Rj
¼&
w
z
'w]
z Æ
³I8hM_?&\C_4hC|] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\CoGA4\EA48[SUgDb4hCM#FH4RmZ9<8f__4RFXW4O\C:4QmFH4
?<]O] 4hC:C:SHmFH4E4\R>[4QR6CV6#4>:SH>V4OCP>V] 9e\C=>[Sq>[bEA4i_4hC@C:b8Pp*?e] 4hC p9<8[QA44OC
6?<8FU4OC?<8[]OC
=
4 >
=
7MR4>ª_4¥6FHbC>[9<b>ª6Z9<SU\D>©n?
FXWSU\D>A4O8:SU4b8 _4F(W4\C:4QkmFU45?<]O] 4hC:C:SHmFH4@6Z4b>c4>:8[45?&>P>:4OSH\D> 6?&8 b\4
>:8f?.;=4h]{>[9<SU8:4_4kF^?}p9e8:QR4 = =
9eb = w] p ¯k ±z{'(5SU4\
C&cb8]4V8A4OC:bFH>[?.>\4@>:SU4\D>6?<C] 9eQ06>:45_W=A4OT<4O\e>[b4FUFU4OC]9<\D>:8f?&SU\D>:4OC
C:b87F(WPA4>[?.>h
/2Fp*?<b>_9e\]74O\CPbSq>[4A4 >f?&mFUSU85] 4`o<4\8:4`_4i8A4OC:bFq>f?.>fCGFH9e8[C[gDbWSHF
4 S^C=>[4B_4OC] 9<\D>[8[?<SH\D>:4hCRCPb8}FXW=A4 >f?.>O ?&\#C ¯ ±MVSHF`?¨A4>A4´A4>[?&mFHS
6Z9<b80FH4CPCP>On4OQR4}68A4O]NA4O_4O\e>4hC=>R_4F^?yp9e8:QR4 =
*)
*+,)
= M
9nb ,)
4hC=>7b\s?&8f]I>[?<\o<4O\e>n?0FXW?<8[]Ip8[9<\D>:S(n48[4 '+
G
SU\?<FH4OQ04O\D>OM_?<\C ¯ ± SHF4hC=>74 6FHS^gDbA4] 9<QRQR4\D>i] 48A4OC:bFH>[?&>
6Z48[Q04>R_W=A4>[?<mFHSU8F^?68:9e6#9DCPSH>:SU9<\]SqY2_4hC:C:bCk6#9eb8RFH4CPCP>On4OQ04
] 9eQR6FH4>O
¬
~
vº )
'¸"¡ }R+<"('
0-v"X'/ZvH
354 >?&FUo<9e8:SH>:aQ04R4hC=>kCP>[?<\_?<8[_M4>b\4r8A4phA48[4\]4k]FU?eC:C:SUgDb4
4OCP>
¯
<
±
J`9<bCª8f?&66#4OFH9e\Cm8[S(n4OT<4OQ04O\D>FU4 68[SH\#] SU6#4¨_4 FU?
QA4 >[a9_4<|359<\C:S^_5A48[9<\#Cyb\ 68[9<mF(n4QR4_4§] 9<\D>[8dc9eFH49e6>:SUQ}?&F
oGA4\EA4O8[?<F(M<9nbFXW=A4 >f?.>E6#4Ob>c4 >[8:4~CP9ebQRSUC|n?0_4OC7]9<\D>:8f?&SU\D>:4OCO
W?&6Y
6FUSU]O?.>[SH9e\r_br68[SH\#] SU6#4`_brQ}?.SHQkbQ 8A4h_bSH>@FH4`68:9emF(n4QR4n?|b\
/
)<uv{® }R$.-,)(d$&vH-
v'¸0'¸"%
_b>=D6Z4Rj
#wPzV¼%- w]ZwPz ÆPz@¼
.///
0///1 - < w ÆZwPzPz¦C:S <
32 Å
- Å w ÆZwPzPz¦C:S Å
32 Ç
-54 w
Æ#w
PzPz´CPS 4
g wrez
9nbe
Å Æ Ç Æ7 7 l Æ
476
¯< Æ
hg
±
6Z4bTe4\D>c4>:8[4r_4OC>:4OQ06#C_4] 9<Q0Y
Qb>[?.>[SH9e\M#_47;=9<\] >:SU9<\s9ebB_4] 9e\D>[?<] >I?dT<4h]~b\?&8f]~p8[9<\D>:S(n48[4<
³I\r?_4`6FHb#CV_4hCV] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\C w_4I] 9<\D>[SH\ bSH>A4eM<_4`C[?&b>OM<4>[]hzG4\
] 4hCi>[4QR6COMZ_4OC~] 9<\#_Sq>[SH9e\C~?&byFHSUQRSq>[4OC~4 >_4OC~] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\C~_4
>:8f?&\#CPTe48fC:?<FHSH>A4e
©68[SH9e8:SFH4>:4OQ06#Cix\#?&F:hgr4hC=>~SH\]9<\\ bG?&8~?&SUFHFU4b8fCi_?<\C
F^?sQA4 >[a9_4r_4}>[SH8kQbFH>:SU6FU4FU4r\9<Qkm8[498_4] 9<QRQkb>[?&>:SU9<\C
_9eSq>sc4>:8[4xA4.2V9<\FH4s_A4>:4O8:QRSU\4FU9<8fC[geb4y]<W4hC=>}6Z9eC[CPSUmFU4y6?&8
b\4?<\?&FUCP4~oGA49<Q§A4>:8[SUgDb4~_b68:9emF(n4QR4<
?RQA4 >[a9_4|_4>:SU8iQkbFq>[SH6FH4]9<\C:S^C=>[4}n?}C:bmN_SUTDS^C:48iFXWSU\D>:4O8PY
T.?&FUFH4 ¯Z< Æ g ± 4O\¾ C:9<bCPY%SH\D>:4O8:T.?<FHFU4OCOM{FU?`T.?&FU4b8 _4 ZwPz?&b_A4Omb>
_4E]fa?<gDb4EC:9<bCPYXSU\D>:4O8:T.?&FUFU40A4 >f?&\D>SH\]9<\\ b4e1@FUbC 68A4O] S^CA4QR4\D>hM
C:9<SH> < 2;:
Å
2=<<<*2;:,>?2 hg}b\40CPbmZ_SUT SUC:SU9<\A@
h
_4FXWSU\Y
>:4O8:T.?<FHFU4
¯< Æ
hg
±
DKV\R>:9<b>V6#9eSH\D>:CB`F^?p9<\] >:SU9<\
4OCP>
tf).!"X'¸!-
³I\6#4Ob>r] 9<\#CPS^_A4O8:4O8D: B ] 9eQRQ04b\6Z9<SU\e>r_4s]9<QRQb>f?.>[SH9e\
x4<M4\FH4hgeb4F9e\?j
E
#w:
B
z@¼ #w: =
B z Æ
:CB~¼%:GF
B
x5A4
³I\y_5A4 x#\Sq>iQ}?<SH\D>:4O\?&\D>7FU4OC
!Z)h-+d
j
HsNÅ.Æ7 7 l Æh
PI
¼ H
Z<
Æ g
IKJ H :
ÅdÆl 7 7 OÆ
: >
I5J H
ÅdÆl 7 7 Æ
4
I
w
n&z
G
SH\#?&FU4QR4\D>9e\4OCP> ]9<\_bSq>?&b
/
)<uv ®RI$.-,(.$.vU -
v'¸k'¸"2
j
L
w
PzV¼- w
ÆZw
PzPz@¼
.///
0///1 - Å w ÆZw
PzPz C:S
Å
32 Ç
- Ç w ÆZw
PzPz C:S
Ç
32 È
- P =
Å&w ÆZwPz:z C:S P = Å P
L!M
6 H Æ7 l 7 ÆON K§
I Ö B w] B ÆZw
=
B z Æ#w]
B
z:z@¼
L Ö P w
P
Æ#w]NÅ
z
ÆZw
P
z:zV¼´
w
mez
9nb Å
¼Z<B4OCP>}xA4eM P
¼g MV4>FU4OC
Ö B 8:4O68A4OC:4\D>:4O\e>RFU4OC
] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\CESU\D>A4O8:SU4b8:4hC59ebFUSUQ0SH>:4hC768A4O]NA4O_4\D>:4hC
³I\§?&Q§A4OFHSU9<8[4}F^?CP>[?<mSHFUSH>A4_4F^?QA4 >:a9 _44\?&boeQR4\D>[?<\e>
FU4\9eQm8[4_4B\9D4Ob_CO73IW4OCP>F2n?4O\ 4 N4 >FH468:SU\]SH6Z4_4FU?
QA4 >[a9_4_4>:SU8kQkbFH>:SU6FH4eM6#?&89e66Z9eC:Sq>[SH9e\´n?sFU?QA4 >[a9_4_4
>:SU8`C:SHQR6FU49nbyFU4OCE48[8[4b8fC6?&878f?&66Z9<8:>n?kF^?}] 9e\_SH>:SU9<\SH\Sq>[SU?<FH4
A
4OT<9<FUb4O\e>E4 6Z9<\4O\D>:SU4FUFH4OQ04O\D>E4O\p9<\] >:SU9<\s_4hg.Y¹ MT<9<SU8 ¯e ±