Stability of slopes and subdifferentials with respect to Wijsman convergence

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00699033

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00699033v2

Submitted on 16 Jun 2019

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Stability of slopes and subdifferentials with respect to Wijsman convergence

Marc Lassonde

To cite this version:

Marc Lassonde. Stability of slopes and subdifferentials with respect to Wijsman convergence. 43st Conference on Decision and Control, Dec 2002, Las Vegas, United States. pp.3133-3134. �hal- 00699033v2�

(2)

&

')( ")**+, - /.0%1 234*")5*+6

798;:=<?>08A@B@BC;DFEFGIH

JKBL;MONBP;QRKBLSQRTUFPVNXWZY[P;\^]_P`TIaTbNXNBPIc'MOTIaZTedfVMgcihkjIQlf9mMn\oQnfpL_P;q

r6spt=uwvXxzy'u

{}|!~^zXOIX^I|~/';|^ObbIe|B|B'O'

e¢|wO'|=Ie|¥O^bbIw|=?{$¦/~^§¨'ª©*«¬zI¤wo^'I~%O

^z|~lozl¥oV~^z;z¯®|wO|w^¤o¤~£o°eO^¤woIAO~°oI¥O

~/I;b®|wO|w^¤oª~^z§±Oz|=~¡'^|)b|=^¢'|B_©

²Z³e´

u=v¶µV·k¸pyouB¹ºµ

´

z|»Io^'}o£~^A|¼o°6~O)½IIRO}^OzIe|B*¿¾À¶Á

I'~zOX¢'|B*OÂ;|,e|=OO'F¢XoOI~Io^O~oÃz'Iz|='

oI'b~^~=©kÄOIb%oOz|°~/O'zl'Oz|°~^';| ¡¯O#O|=~^A|BR

^*¢XoO¤X^'AoÅ;|w^^zOIXOI~)'°Oz|,½zIe^'Æ'~%z^

XO|=ÇÂ'zÃ^|Be|=Ã'OÈ¾ÉXÁÊ© z¤~°Io^|%¤~#½z^^I|w¡eb

ÔIb^'¥^#^z¤~ÅO'z¤o©pËni¾ÉoÁgÌ°|¬~^zXÃ|=»Îo Î|0~/';|

opÍoÎIÏ%ÐÒÑÓÎÔOÍoÕkÖzÔwÕR×ÙØbÕwÚÍo×ÙÑºÛoÎ¥'A'¢'|w#½zIRO¥Ü¨¤~F~loz|

zIb|=%Io¯nXÝ,z|¼A|=/OzOIXOI~oÃÜpÌ¡z|=^|¼^z|¨z'^'

oªI'nXÝ,z|w'¢'|=^|wIw|¬'~ ^ObbIe|BÇ}¾Þ¶Áª'~Ã»¢

oz|%o^|wOIo^¢'|¬O,~/w|w'¢'|=^|wIw|¡½'¤~^'Ìbz'ßz|=w|=~/

~^'^%w'¢'|wà_Ì¶½zIROI~=©pá0|wO|°Ã|Ã~^zXI~/^|B')OIXFOz|

~/';|oFÜi~~/O'z|%zAb|w¡{$¦/~/§,'ß;|w^^zOIo^'I~ÃoÅÜpÌ

,Ã|=oÈ|w¬'I*¢'|=^Âe¤'~O~/¤w'ªz'^'*o w'¢'|=^|wIw|¨âÙ~/|=|

¾¯ã'ÌäXÁÓåe©°æz£zO|=w|=bz¼^|B~/zÃ=oÇ;|0O|=wX¢'|=^|B»½O'§Oz|

½'X¡zº'e=ç èéwÔêwØIÔeÎëOÔ0ìXÜXíAî¨ÚÍXÐÓÐÒï/Í/ðÎÔ#ëÛXÎAñ¶ÔwÕÙòÔRé¬×nÛ

ÜÑóÍoÎ;ô¨ÛXÎAÐÒÏ¥Ñó¡ì¶Üoí°õö_÷¶îøßÑùéRú,ÍXÎiëÛXÎAñ¶ÔwÕÙòÔRé0×nÛÜõö_÷

óeÛXÕ)ÔeñXÔwÕRÏö ÷ûü÷ ©¡âÙV¼'zÃÈzX¡|Bb'|ÌoOz~°ºR°¤~°z|w

|w¢|w)½Fw'¢'|wà½IIROI~Výþ¡I|w»Ao¯nXÝ,z|°^|BbIe|B~ªO

~/¤e|'©ÿå«0zz=XOI~^Â^I|¨~/O'zlio~/I;b®|wO|w^¤o¤~

zIb|=°{$¦/~^§¨'6e¢'|wO'|=Ie|¡'^|0zoz^|=,½^§ ¾ÉXÁÊ©Åz|

~lI'/~/zX¡z»^z|%zÈ,;|elÃ|w|=ÇOz|)~lozl,O|=~^z¯~

oI6^I|#~/zb®;|=^|=^¤oV~^z§±Oz|=~¤~z|w)©

»Ûo×ÊÍo×ÙÑºÛoÎ àbw|wbÅ¡z|=^|'^z|=^¡¤~/|¡~/Oo^|=ªÌ

ü

~loIz~p½

¬O|='oI#~/A'e|°oI

ü

÷F½kO~V^A'¤wobI'Ù©p«¬

½zIe^'I~%oO|¼~^~^z§¨|=*^ÂA|¥|eà^|=Ib|BgO|='¯Ê¢Xoz|=?oI

XÃ|w¬~^|w§¨¤eOzI~)â½¤~O=å kÄâü å¡z|wz'^|=~¡^z|»~^Ie|

oA'~^I#½zAR^'A~k ü ©zÅÜ¥pÄâü åRÌoÃ|°b|=zoO|

6b'§¿ÜiçìBö ûü ÜFâºö;å$îOz|#b§¨''FÜ}oI

¥|=zwÜ?çì°â½öFå ÜFâºö;å !,î0Oz||wz'oz,'kÜp©Åz|

Ab=XO'¬'#"%$ ü ¤~¡Oz|)½zIe^''&)(ç ü+*-,/. ì0$î

b|21Az|=3&)(Ãâºö;å¥ç54Â½ ö û "#Ì6 oOz|wO¡¤~/|©Çz|

e~^|=87¶gI'ªw|w^|=^|Bßo¡A¬ö*¤~¡^/O|w:9<;â½ö;åe©

=?>@ACBEDGFIHJLKMDONQPIHSRT?UIHJ>VWNQXYYT?ZQ[]\^)_WDGV`TbacV`XdeHJfg[ih2j

Hlk

h

XV2NpTrqD XNpsQT J`f0stDGVvulT w0Tx[zyrDGXY|{I}W~G)I|2~W G22 O 0?WG~Goi

¹Btvx

´

µ

´

v0

´

y

«9~^|=z|wAe|0'V~/|wO~0ìvpí;î6#§¨|w^O~/Ie|¥â]SåÅ¤~°~Oo¤

OøÂÑùéRú¨ÍoÎ?ëOÛoÎIñXÔeÕgòÔO¨ÌÃøßï/ëÛXÎAñ¶ÔwÕÙòÔ^9½Ã~^z/BÌ

I^X¢¤b|=';âiOkíIå * Aâ]O#å¡½|=¢'|=^b û ¾äzÌpãeÁÊ©)«

~^|=z|=Ie|Âo~OÇ½IIROI~Âì¶Ü í î'¿?z^§¨|B~/A'e| ü

¤~6~Oo¤^!øÂï/ëOÛoÎIñXÔeÕgòÔ,^Ü`z^X¢¤b|=^I|i~/|BI|wIw|*o

Oz|wÃ|wz'ozA~¡ì=|=zwÜ í î0{ne¢'|wO'|B~p^¼|wzwÜÂ ü ,

~^zzI|=Â¡^^I|)z'O§+¡oâºöc¢/åW¡ç§,XàìE¡eö¡£ ¢ î©

ËÊ~ÈzX¡ß^Io¬{Êw'¢'|=^|wIw|§,¶ÇIo¬;|)z^|B~/|=^¢|=

IIb|w°|=z¢Xo|w£O|wz^§¨z)o^I|¬zIb|=^I#~/Ie| ü ©

ËnSº'e=Ì¤Ã|=|w¥z^X¢|=OIX,}~^|=z|=Ie|ßow'¢'|wà½zIR

OI~ìXÜXí;îi{Êw'¢'|=^|wIw|=~»^Ü`¡¯O$^|B~/;|=e,^'

|Bz¢X'|=¨z^§ o

ü

¯®`Ü í ~/w|ßw'¢'|=^|=~%OÜâÙ~/|=|

¾ãeÁ½åR©Äb§¨'^'Ì {ne¢'|wO'|=Ie|,§,¶z'¥;|z^|B~/|=^¢|=

IIb|w0z|='¡A|=/OzOIXOI~ok^z|%½zAR^'A~w©ÅËnÂº'e=ç

¥

vXµ¦£µ;t=¹ºu=¹ºµ

´9²¨§ ÎÍiÎ;ÛoÕRú¨ÔôégÖIÍ'ëÔ ü/© ÍÂéwÔêeØIÔwÎ;ëÔ6Û/ó

ÐÒéeë°óØbÎ;ëw×gÑºÛXÎzéì¶ÜXí;îßÚÍoÐÓÐÒï/ÍlðSÎ;Ô¥ëÛXÎIñXÔwÕÙòÔeé%×ÊÛ#ÜÑª ÍXÎAÏ¥éeÔwï

êwØIÔwÎ;ëÔì¶ÜXí¡õiö ÷ î «ÅÑÓ×i¬¼ö ÷)ûßü÷ øÂï/ëÛXÎAñ¶ÔwÕÙòÔRé0×nÛ%Üõiö ÷

'ÊoÝ,z|w'¢'|=^|wIw|¡Ã~ O^bbAe|=Ç¾ÞoÁg©FËÊ¡o'O|w|B~

¡^¨~^¤e|Ãe'¢|wO'|wAe|Å'#^z|~/A'e|°oAw'¢'|wà½IIROI~w©

I|?½X¡I§¨'O|iOORO'z|?Io'e^|=^®=o^'o»{

w'¢'|=^|wIw|o;½zIROI~°¨O|wO§¨~ o^z|e'¢|wO'|wAe|Ão

Oz|w¬bwo_g1I§,¨¤~¡o*'IobX^'ßoF^|B~/I¯~Æ¾ÞbÌzÉoÁÊç

¯° µAv

±§

ÎÍßÎ;ÛoÕRú¨ÔôßégÖzÍëÔ

ü/©

ÍßéwÔêwØIÔeÎëOÔ,Û/ó»ÐÒéeë

óØbÎëe×gÑºÛXÎIé,ì¶Ü í îøßï/ëÛoÎIñXÔeÕÙòÔeé¨×nÛÂÜ9Ñª`óeÛXÕÔeñXÔwÕRÏÇö

û$ü

ÍoÎ;ô³²´µ4$×i¬zÔwÕ^Ô?Ñ¤é}ÍéwÔêeØIÔwÎ;ëÔìBö í î!$ ü éRØIëG¬×i¬zÍX×

ö í * ö © Ü í â½ö í å * ÜFâ½öå»ÍXÎô

~/z

¶2·¸

b

¹»º ¼I½ ¾®¿)À

ÜÁ±~/I

¶ ·¸

§Sb

í

b

¹»º ¼I½G¾®¿)À

ÜXíÂ âQÃwå

I|w'O|w§ ÀÆ~^z'|=~/O~ÇA~^~^I|}bw'®=o^'$'Oz|e'z

w|wb,'¬{Êw'¢'|=^|wIw|:Äo¨?'¢'|=A¨öcÅ©I~=Ì

~^|=z|=Ie|,'Ã¤~O»½IIROI~¨ì¶Üoí;î¨¡ A|ßb|=w'^|BiO9øÂï

ëÛoÎIñXÔeÕÙòÔ?×ÊÛ}ÜÍo×0öI^X¢¤b|=^z|=^|*¤~ìBöAí;î?~^I¿^Io

ö í * öVÌ¬Ü í â½ö í å * ÜFâ½öå,oI9âQÃ=å¨zz~,o,ö$½'Ç'

éRú,ÍXÐÓÐL²Æ´Ç4I©È°|='^'Ì âº''I'¤å0{Êw'¢'|=^|wIw|»§¨z|=~

{ne¢'|wO'|=Ie|*oÇ|=';'=Ì¡zb6^z|?w'¢'|=O~^|z|w|B

Io¬;|%^Oz|'©

(3)

z|¬éRÐÛÖzÔÃ'IÜiç üÎ*, . ì£î%XVö û b§¿ÜpÌ¶O^bbIw|=

Æ¾ÀBÁÊÌz~0b|21II|=ß

~/';|ªÜFâ½öåç$§~/z

ÏÐ¤Ñ

ÏWÒÓ Ñ

âgÜFâ½öåÔÆÜFâizå/ålÕ

¡RöÖÔ³»¡

¡z|wO|8Õ §,Xà_â]4Få)½ û×,. ì0$î©?« ;'¥ö

¡¯O*~/';|ªÜFâ½ö;åS4¨¤~¡wo|=ÂëwÕRÑÓ×gÑºëOÍoÐbÖIÛXÑÓÎA×Ã'ÅÜp©

¯Ø° µAv ÉÚÙóÜ í øÂï/ëÛXÎIñXÔwÕÙòÔeé?×nÛÆÜÍX×»ö û z'§SÜ ©

×z¬IÔeÎ×i¬zÔwÕ^Ô¥Ñ¤é¨Í6éwÔêeØIÔwÎ;ëÔ¼ìBö í îÖ$ ü éRØIëO¬?×i¬zÍX×£ö í * ö ©

Ü í â½ö í å * ÜFâºö;å © ÍXÎ;ô

§~/I

í

~^A|VÜoí_â½öAíAå S~^A|VÜFâºö;å Â

µIvXµË]ËºxzvvÌ É»ÛÙ²Ü Ôw×_öÆÚÔ)Í,ëwÕRÑÓ×ÙÑºëÍoÐ'ÖIÛXÑÓÎA×£ÛlóÜ ÙóÃÜ í øßï

ëÛXÎIñXÔwÕÙòÔeé0×nÛ%ÜÍX×ö © ×i¬zÔwÎÂ×i¬zÔwÕ^ÔÑ¤éÍ»éwÔêeØIÔwÎ;ëÔ0ì=ö í î¼éRØIëG¬

×z¬IÍX×pö í * ö © Ü í â½ö í å * ÜFâ½öå»ÍoÎ;ô¼~/';|ªÜ í â½ö í å * 4

µIvXµË]ËºxzvvÌ É»Ûz è%ééØbú,Ô»×z¬IÍX× ÜÑ¤é¼ÚÛXØbÎô'Ôô0óÕOÛXúÚÔeÐÛ0«¤

ÙóÜ í øÂï/ëOÛoÎIñXÔeÕgòÔeé#×ÊÛ¨Ü © ×i¬zÔwÎ×z¬IÔeÕOÔ»Ñ¤é¨ÍÇéwÔêwØIÔeÎëOÔ»ìBö í î

éRØIëO¬*×z¬IÍX×pÜ í â½ö í å * bAÜFâü å¼ÍXÎô#~^A|ªÜ í âºö í å * 4

ÝÞÊ

u=xbsF¹]ËÙ¹½uGÌSµÍ

Ê

¸Vs°·k¹]ß

v

´

uB¹ºxoËÙt

ª|wà*;|%o,';|wXO'Ã¡zÂ'~O~/bwo^|=~Ã¥~/zA~/|wà_ÜFâ½öå

o ü÷ ^i'ÁoI~^I'w| ü Ìk'Ü û pÄâü å%oI

oÇö ûü ~/A¥¶¨^Io=ç

âº«á4å,ËÊ¨ÜX/oI~Â/1Iz^|}b=o§¥z§»z§ oßökÌ¬^I|w

4 û à_ÜFâºö;å

âº«»ãBå£ËÊFÜÂ¤~Ãw'¢'|wà¥I|=oÃöVÌOz|wâà_ÜFâ½öå ¤~°^z|%~/I;b®|w^

|w^¤o_'Fw'¢'|wà6oI'b~^~)

âº«À'åËÊ ç üãiüä*å,æ. ì0$î¥¤~%'¢'|=?',â½ölzåç

ÜFâ½öåVõéè_âizåeÌ^z|='à,âºöcbå $êà_ÜFâ½ö;å àè_âizåR©

{}|¨¡O¯O|ÖàÜ$ç±ìâ½öc^ö ÷ å ûüãiü÷8 ö ÷ßû àÜFâºö;åRî¥½

^z|)O'z6'#à_Üp©

Äb¶,OIX ü ~ràpï/ÍÖ'Ö;ÕOÛOÖ;ÕRÑºÍo×ÊÔ¼zOX¢z|=

ë

ìíêî èÇ¤~^£

îï

w'¢'|wà6eOzI~2^¯Fö*¤~¡b=o_§¨I§¼z§

oè%õ

ï

Oz|wÂOz|wO|)oO|¨â]'íl ÷

í

å $êàèªâ]ð¶íð ÷

í

å $!à

ï

~^Iß^Io=ç'íOð¶í * ögè_âi'ízå * è_â½öå ÷

í

õæð ÷

í * 4oÂ

ñòÍXú0Ö;ÐÔeéWã'© ü ¤~)ßá0;|w^)~^Ie|'Ì»à~Oz|¨z^¶àb§,o

~/I;b®|wO|w^¤op

Àb© ü ~)'«~/IzA~^Ie|'ÌàÆ~Oz|Çw'z'I=o6zó|Bz|e

~/I;b®|wO|w^¤op

¯Ø° µAv

Ý

èééRØbú¨Ô×i¬zÍo× ü Ñ¤é#àpï/ÍOÖÖ;Õ^ÛÖ;ÕRÑºÍo×ÊÔv

Ü

Ôw×zö?ÚÔ

Üoí_â½öAíAå * ÜFâ½öå»ÍoÎ;ô)ö ÷í * 4

ö5Ê

¸Vs£·p¹iß

v

´

u=¹ÙxoË

Ê

¸ø÷6¸Ë

t

Äz¶,^Io)ìWèIùv)ÂWÂ)Â2?èúî)¤~#ô'ÔëÛXØBÖÐÍ'ÚwÐÔ¼X¡ö ûÂü zOX¢z|=

½0oÇ~^§,o²â´!4zÌ

~^z

¶ ·¸

z

¹»º ¼I½G¾û¿vÀeü èeý#

~/I

¶ ·¸

b þ

ü è ýâºö ýå ö ý û 9 ÿ;â½ö;å2v¡eö ý Ôö

¡çê&ØÂ âwå

XÃ|w|=¢'|=V~/|wO~z|Bo¡ö

V|eÖ ç¬âºöù£WÂWÂ)ÂW^öúoå û`ü ú

* èeýOâ½öýgå¼oI|wÈ ;|

Oz|)b¤o'Io;o ü ú

O|=zIe|B~Ã^iâ=å

¯° µAv

ö ¾¶ÁVèééRØbú,Ô¬×i¬zÍo× ü ú

Ñ¤é¤àpï/ÍOÖ'ÖÕ^ÛOÖÕRÑºÍX×nÔ)

Ü

Ôe×

ö9ÚOÔßÍiëwÕRÑÓ×ÙÑºëÍXÐ;ÖIÛXÑÓÎA×Û/ó èeý

Ù

ó»ì)èIùvWÂ)ÂWÂ)?èúîiÑ¤éÇô'ÔëÛXØbï

ýí

åîM$!àèeý

ýí * 4ÆÍXÎ;ô

z'§[â½öõùí WÂWÂ)Â2/öúí å»¡eö ÷

ýí ¡ * 4

÷ Í v ´ y t

|w§¨Fbp|w¢'w'z|%?~/A£wk§¨|e^O¤eV|¼ezO¢'|#bp§,'~O~/§,

;|wAb|woBzÌ_è×Ù×gÑVè0ëëÍ'ô»»Ío×t

Ü

|wIw|)o#ªXÃ|w¬Ä|w§¨¤eOzI~LzIIROI~rªzÈ|=ß¡¯O

Oz|»oz:°'¢'|=^|wIw|0ok^z|=0Äbz;z¯®|wO|w^¤o¤~=Ì/ ÛoÎIï

ÞÀ¶ÊÉz©