HAL Id: hal-00685092
https://hal-upec-upem.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00685092
Submitted on 4 Apr 2012
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Probabilistic uncertainty modeling for thermomechanical analysis of plasterboard submitted to fire load
S. Sakji, Christian Soize, J.-V. Heck
To cite this version:
S. Sakji, Christian Soize, J.-V. Heck. Probabilistic uncertainty modeling for thermomechanical analysis of plasterboard submitted to fire load. Journal of Structural Engineering-ASCE, 2008, 134 (10), pp.1611-1618. �10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2008)134:10(1611)�. �hal-00685092�
!"#$#%&%'(%) *+),!($%+(- ."/,&%+0 1"! (2,!."3.,)2$+%)$&
$+$&-'%' "1 4&$'(,!#"$!/ '*#.%((,/ (" 5!, &"$/
!""#$ %$' ()*#+,#%- .#/!2∗ 0 1!%-23#4#!- 5!6$3 7%*6) 89' :99;
!"#$%&# !"# $%$#& '#%() *+," % $&-.%.+(+),+/ 0-'#(+12 -3 ,"# ,"#&0-40#/"%1+/%( .#"%5+-&
-3 /%&'.-%&'4$(%),#&4/%&'.-%&' 67879 0:(,+(%;#& $(%,#) ):.0+,,#' ,- <&# (-%'= !"# $&-$-)#' 0-'#( ,%>#) +1,- %//-:1, '%,% %1' 0-'#( :1/#&,%+1,+#)= !"+) *-&> +) ?:),+<#' .; ,"# 3%/, ,"%,
<&# &#)+),%1/# ,#),) -3 $(%),#&.-%&'4(+1#' $%&,+,+-1) %&# 0%'# +0$-))+.(# *"#1 ,"#+& '+0#1)+-1)
#@/##' ,"-)# -3 3:&1%/#)= A 3:1'%0#1,%( >#; ,- )-(5# ):/" % $&-.(#0 +) ,"# '#5#(-$0#1, %1' ,"# #@$#&+0#1,%( 5%(+'%,+-1 -3 % '#,#&0+1+),+/ %1' $&-.%.+(+),+/ 0-'#( -3 787 0:(,+(%;#& ):.4 0+,,#' ,- <&# (-%'= !"# <&), ),#$ -3 ,"+) *-&> /-1/#&1) ,"# /-1),+,:,+-1 -3 %1 #@$#&+0#1,%(
,"#&0-40#/"%1+/%( '%,% .%)# 3-& % 787 0:(,+(%;#& %1' 3-& +,) /-0$-1#1,)= !"#)# #@$#&+0#1,%(
,#),) %&# /%&&+#' -:, .; ,"# :)# -3 % .#1/" ,#), )$#/+%((; '#)+21#' 3-& ,"+) *-&>= !"# )#/-1' ),#$
+) ,"# '#5#(-$0#1, -3 %1 "-0-2#1+B%,+-1 ,"#&0-40#/"%1+/%( 0#%1 0-'#( 3-& ,"# 787 0:(,+4 (%;#&= !"# ,"+&' ),#$ +) ,"# '#5#(-$0#1, -3 % $&-.%.+(+),+/ 0-'#( -3 :1/#&,%+1,+#) .%)#' -1 ,"#
!!"!#$%# &'()*!!('+ ,%"-*'!"#. &$'"!/0!#+ 1$2('$#("'* 3(4.5"!$#"(% *# 6"785$#"(% 385#" 09:*55*+ 3630
;<0=>?@ AB<6+ C 24 D*!9$'#*!+ EEFCF 3$'%*/5$/G$55**+ ;'$%9*H
!&'()*!!('+ ,%"-*'!"#. &$'"!/0!#+ 1$2('$#("'* 3(4.5"!$#"(% *# 6"785$#"(% 385#" 09:*55*+ 3630 ;<0=>?@
AB<6+ C 24 D*!9$'#*!+ EEFCF 3$'%*/5$/G$55**+ ;'$%9*H 0/7$"5I 9:'"!#"$%H!("J*K8%"-/L$'"!/*!#H)'
"<*!*$'9: 0%M"%**'+ A*%#'* !9"*%#"NO8* *# #*9:%"O8* 48 2$#"7*%#+ PF+ -*%8* Q*$%/Q$8'*!+ EEFFE A:$7L!/
!8'/3$'%*+ ;'$%9*H
C
! "#$#%&'$() "$!*#*(+(,'() #""$!#)-. /0%&$()#+ $&,0+', #$& )!%"#$&1 '! '-& &2"&$(%& '#+ ! &,.
! "#$#%#&' &(%)'*$ +'#,-./&3 4$& $&,(,'# )&5 )#$1*!#$16"+#,'&$6)#$1*!#$1 %0+'(+#7&$5 0 6 )&$'#( '(&,5 "$!*#*(+(,'() %!1&+5 &2"&$(%& ',5 '-&$%#+ +!#1 *& )-.
!"#$%&'"($!
8#$9& +(9-' "#$'('(! , :;< %&'&$, # 1 %!$&= #$& ! 6+!#1 *&#$( 9 &+&%& ',. >-&7 #$& %#1&
!? "+#,'&$*!#$1, ,)$&@&1 ! *!'- ,(1&, !? # %&'#+ ?$#%& !? A#$(!0, )! ,'$0)'(A& )! 490$#'(! ,.
B&,(1&, ,'$0)'0$#+ $&C0($&%& ', ,0)- #, '-& $&,(,'# )& '! (%"#)' +!#1( 9 # 1 )!++(,(! +!#1, :,&&
D0$!"&# E!%%('&& ?!$ F'# 1#$1(G#'(! ;HHI=5 # +(9-' "#$'('(! %0,' A&$(?7 A#$(!0, 4$& $&,(,6 '# )& )$('&$(# ,0)- #, '-& )#$$7( 9 !0' !? ?0++ ,)#+& '&,', 0 1&$ '-& JFK LMI '-&$%#+ +!#1( 9 )0$A&
:,&& J '&$ #'(! #+ F'# 1#$1, K$9# (G#'(! ;HNO=. >-(, +#,' $&C0($&%& ' )# !' *& %&' @-& '-&
,'$0)'0$& 1(%& ,(! , &2)&&1 '-!,& !? '-& '&,'( 9 ?0$ #)&, :0" '! M%=. K & @#7 '! )($)0%A& ' '-& 1(%& ,(! #+ 1(P)0+'7 )! ,(,', ( &A#+0#'( 9 "#$'('(! *&-#A(!$ *7 %&# , !? &2"&$(%& '#+
# 1 0%&$()#+ )!%*( &1 #""$!#)-&,. >-& ?0 1#%& '#+ Q&7 '! ,!+A& '-& #*!A& "$!*+&% (, '!
1&A&+!" # 1 A#+(1#'& @('- &2"&$(%& ', # 1&'&$%( (,'() # 1 # "$!*#*(+(,'() '-&$%!6%&)-# ()#+
%!1&+ !? '-& "+#,'&$*!#$1 ,0*%(''&1 '! 4$& +!#1,. >-(, "#"&$ (, ! +7 1&A!'&1 '! '-(, #,"&)' # 1 '-& 0,& !? '-& $&,0+', "$&,& '&1 *&+!@ ( !$1&$ '! # #+7G& +#$9& +(9-' "#$'('(! , (, ( '$!10)&1 ( '-& 1(,)0,,(! "$&,& '&1 ( '-& +#,' ,&)'(! . R "+#,'&$*!#$1 :)#$1*!#$16"+#,'&$6)#$1*!#$1 :ESE= %0+'("+#7&$= 9(A&, # "#$'('(! -(9-&$ $&,(,'# )& '-# Q, '! '-& (%"!$'# ' C0# '('7 !? )#"6 (++#$7 # 1 )-&%()#++7 *!0 1 @#'&$ )! '#( &1 ( '-& "+#,'&$ :T;U !? (', @&(9-'5 ,&& R2& & Q!5 K. # 1 >-$!"&5 V. ;HHW=. >-& 4$,' ,'&" ( '-(, "#"&$ 1&#+, @('- '-& (1& '(4)#'(! !? '-& ESE
%&)-# ()#+ )-#$#)'&$(,'(), 0 1&$ 4$& # 1 %&)-# ()#+ +!#1,. X!$ '-#'5 ! & #1!"', # '-&$%!6
%&)-# ()#+ &2"&$(%& '#+ #""$!#)- '#Q( 9 (%"+()('+7 ( '! #))!0 ' '-& -71$!0, "-#,&. J 1&&15
T
!" #"$!%&'$%( $!%)%$ ")'* '$* +, !" -.- #/( '(%0") %)" 1" ")#'&"1 /&1") !" *%#" !")#%(
(+%1'&2 !% % 3%) ' '+& 4+/(1 )"$"'5" 1/)'&2 $+&5"& '+&%( )"*'* %&$" "* *6 7+) !'* #% ")8 %
&"4 !")#%( (+%1'&2 9"&$! :;<=> '* 1"*'2&"1 %((+4'&2 % '#" "5+(/ '+& !")#%( (+%1 "?/'5%("&
+ !" @ABCDE ,/&$ '+& + 9" )"3)+1/$"1 +& -.- *3"$'#"&* %&1 !"& +&" 3"),+)#*8 F?/'$G(0F8
#"$!%&'$%( "* *6 !'* #"%&* !% !" "* '* $%))'"1 +/ '& 4+ * "3*6 ;!" H)* * "3 $+&*'* * '&
%33(0'&2 % !")#%( (+%1 + % -.- *3"$'#"&6 ;!" 1/)% '+& ,+) * "3 +&" '* 9" 4""& !)"" %&1 "& #'&/ "* 1"3"&1'&2 +& !" !" $!+*"& @AB H)" (+%16 ;!" *"$+&1 * "3 $+&*'* * '& 3"),+)#'&2 !" #"$!%&'$%( "* +, !" *3"$'#"& +, * "3 +&" ,+) % *"("$ "1 5%(/" +, !" "#3")% /)"6 ;!"
1/)% '+& 9" 4""& !" '#" ,+) 4!'$! !" *3"$'#"& '* "I )%$ "1 ,)+# !" =A; :* "3 J> %&1 !"
'#" $+))"*3+&1'&2 + !" "&1 +, !" #"$!%&'$%( "* '* !') 0 *"$+&1* %* % #%I'#/#6 ;%G'&2 '& + %$$+/& !" 9)'", 1"(%0 + )"%('K" !" #"$!%&'$%( "* 8 !" "5+(/ '+& +, !" "#3")% /)" '*
&"2('2'9(" %&1 $+&*"?/"& (0 !" "#3")% /)" '* &+ #"%*/)"16 L !")#+M#"$!%&'$%( #"%& #+1"(
'* 1"5"(+3"1 /*'&2 % !+#+2"&'K% '+& 4' ! )"*3"$ + !" !'$G&"** +, !" -.-6 @& !'* #+1"(8 N%O%)P* 9)' (" 1%#%2" #+1"( :*"" N%O%) JQCR> '* '& )+1/$"1 ,+) !" 3(%* ")6 L 1"5+ "1 H&' "
"("#"& $+1" !%* 9""& 1"5"(+3"1 %&1 %G"* '& + %$$+/& !" "5+(/ '+& +, 1%#%2" 4' !'& !" (%0M
")*6 ;!'* #"%& #+1"( '* 5%('1% "1 4' ! "I3")'#"& * %&1 $+&* ' / "* % 9%*'$ #+1"( + '#3("#"&
!" &+&3%)%#" )'$ 3)+9%9'('* '$ %33)+%$! :A+'K" STTU> %((+4'&2 #+1"( %&1 1% % /&$") %'& '"* + 9" %G"& '& + %$$+/& 6 7'&%((08 !" &/#")'$%( )"*/( * %)" $+#3%)"1 + !" "I3")'#"& *6
;!" +/ ('&" +, !" 3%3") '* %* ,+((+4*6 @& !" *"$+&1 A"$ '+&8 !" 3)+$"1/)" +, $+&$"3 '+& '* 9)'"V0 1"*$)'9"18 !" /*" +, !" ;<= '* 3)"*"& "1 %&1 H&%((08 !" !")#+M#"$!%&'$%( "* * 3"),+)#"1 +& 3(%* ")9+%)1 %&1 ' * $+#3+&"& * %)" 2'5"&6 ;!" !')1 A"$ '+& */##%)'K"* !" -.- !")#+M
#"$!%&'$%( #"%& #+1"( +, !+#+2"&'K% '+& %&1 !" #+1"( 3)"1'$ '+& 4!'$! %)" $+#3%)"1 + !" )",")"&$" "I3")'#"& %( )"*/( * 3)"*"& "1 '& !" *"$+&1 A"$ '+&6 ;!" !+#+2"&'K"1 !")#+M
#"$!%&'$%( 3)+9%9'('* '$ #+1"( %&1 ' * &/#")'$%( )"*/( * %)" 3)"*"& "1 '& !" (%* A"$ '+&6
D
!"#$%&#'()* %+#'(%,-)(%.' ./ (0# (0#$&.1&#-0)'%-)* "$."#$(%#2 ./ (0# 343
! "#$%&"'( &)$ &)$*+!,+$-).%"-./ 0*!0$*&"$1 !' &)$ 2324 . &)$*+!,+$-).%"-./ .00*!.-)4 &.5"%6
"+0/"-"&/( "%&! .--!7%& &)$ )(#*!71 0).1$4 "1 .#!0&$#8 97*"%6 :;< =>? $@7"A./$%& &)$*+./
/!.#"%64 $.-) 232 10$-"+$% "1 &.5$% 0.*.//$/ &! &)$ )$.& 1!7*-$ .%# !%$ 1"#$ !' &)$ 10$-"+$% "1
$B0!1$# &! &)$ '!*+$*8 2!%1$@7$%&/(4 &)$ #"*$-&"!% !' &)$ )$.& C7B .%# &)$ )(#*!71 &*.%10!*&
.*$ +."%/( &*.%1A$*1./ &! &)$ 10$-"+$%8 )$ $B0$*"+$%&./ .00*!.-) "1 #$A$/!0$# "% &D! 1&$01E
• )$*+./ /!.#"%6 F( +$.%1 !' . &)$*+./ /!.# F$%-) G HIJ #$1"6%$# .%# *$./"K$# '!* &)"1 D!*58
• )$*+!,+$-).%"-./ "#$%&"L-.&"!% F( +$.%1 !' . '!7*,0!"%& F$%#"%6 &$1&8
!"#$%& &'%( )"*+! , -./
)$ HI G1$$ M"68 NJ *$0*!#7-$1 .% "%-"#$%&./ )$.& C7B $@7"A./$%& &! &)$ !%$ &).& . 0.*&"&"!%
D!7/# *$-$"A$ #7*"%6 . +.%#.&!*( &$1& 71"%6 . 6.1 '7*%.-$8 :& "1 -!+0!1$# !' . *.#".%& 0.%$/
G&)$ )$.& 1!7*-$J .%# . +!F"/$ -.*& 0*!A"#$# D"&) . 10$-"+$% )!/#$*8 )$ )$.& C7B *$-$"A$#
F( &)$ 10$-"+$%4 ).%6 !% &)$ 10$-"+$% )!/#$*4 "1 +!#"L$# F( +!A"%6 &)$ -.*& D"&) *$10$-& &!
&)$ *.#".%& 0.%$/8 O$%-$4 !%$ -.% *$0*!#7-$ &)$ :;<,&)$*+./,/!.#,$@7"A./$%& )$.& C7B4 %!& F(
+!#"'("%6 &)$ C!D !' -!+F71&"F/$ 6.1 G.1 #7*"%6 &$1&1 !% -!%A$%&"!%./ '7*%.-$1J4 F7& F( +!#", '("%6 &)$ #"1&.%-$ F$&D$$% &)$ 10$-"+$% .%# &)$ *.#".%& 0.%$/8 )$ 10$-"+$% &)$*+./ /!.#"%6
&.5$1 0/.-$ !%/( D)$% &)$ *.#".%& 0.%$/ *$.-)$1 "&1 1&$.#( 1&.&$8 )$*$'!*$ &)$ "//7+"%.&"!%
-.% F$ -!%1"#$*$# .1 -!%1&.%& &)*!76)!7& &)$ &$1& #7*.&"!%8 )$ -!+F"%.&"!% !' . )$.& 1!7*-$
71$# "% "&1 1&$.#( 1&.&$ .%# . 10$-"+$% +!A$+$%& -!%&*!//$# D"&) +"//"+$&$* 0*$-"1"!% "%17*$1 .% $B-$//$%& *$0*!#7-"F"/"&( !' &)$ &)$*+./ /!.#8 M7*&)$*+!*$4 &)$ P2OQM< 1!'&D.*$ G !"! 1$$
?
!"#$ %&' ()!*%* +,,,- './.0"1.' 2& "!'.! *" #"'.0 *3.!#%0 .453%&6.7 2& 8!. !.727*%&5. 9)!:
&%5.7; %00"<7 )7 *" 1.!9"!# *3. 5%05)0%*2"& "9 *3. *"*%0 3.%* =)4 !.5.2/.' >$ *3. 71.52#.& 7)!9%5.
%* '2?.!.&* *2#. 7*.17 "9 5"&/.&*2"&%0 8!. !.727*%&5. *.7*@ 2!7*; "&. 53%!%5*.!2A.7 *3. 2&52'.&*%0 3.%* =)4 !.5.2/.' >$ % =)4#.*.! %* '2?.!.&* '27*%&5.7 9!"# *3. !%'2%&* 1%&.0 %&' *3.&; *3. 5%!*
'2710%5.#.&* 1!"6!%# 27 9")&' ")* 2& "!'.! *" !.1!"')5. >$ #.%&7 "9 *3. BCD *3. 2&52'.&*%0 3.%* =)4 5%05)0%*.' >$ E(FG H@ 26)!. I 5"#1%!.7 *3. 1!"1"7.' BCD '.&72*$ 3.%* =)4 <2*3
*3. 5%05)0%*.' 2&52'.&*%0 '.&72*$ 3.%* =)4 "& *3. 7)!9%5. "9 % 10%7*.!>"%!' 71.52#.& 7)>#2**.'
*" *3. JKH *3.!#%0 0"%' 2& % 5"&/.&*2"&%0 9)!&%5.@ B327 86)!. 73"<7 *3. 6""' !. 1!"')52>20:
2*$ "9 *3. BCD *3.!#%0 0"%'2&6 %&' /%02'%*. *3.& 2*7 )7. 2& *3. .41.!2#.&*%0 2'.&*285%*2"& "9
*3.!#":#.53%&25%0 53%!%5*.!27*257 "9 (L( 10%*.7@
!"#$%&"$' '($) *!%"#
B3. 7.5"&' 7*.1 "9 *3. .41.!2#.&*%0 1!"*"5"0 5"&5.!&7 *3. *3.!#":#.53%&25%0 2'.&*285%*2"&
*.7*7 "9 *3. (L( #)0*20%$.! %&' 2*7 5"#1"&.&*7@ B3. /%0).7 "9 *3. M")&6 #"')0)7 "9 *3. (L(
#)0*20%$.! %* '2?.!.&* *2#. 7*.17 "9 *3. JKH *3.!#%0 0"%' 3%/. >..& 2'.&*28.'@ B3.!.9"!.; %9*.!
3%/2&6 .41"7.' %0.4×0.4#2 71.52#.& *" % *2#. ./"0)*2"& "9 % 3.%* =)4 5"!!.71"&'2&6 *" *3.
JKH *3.!#%0 0"%' )72&6 *3. BCD; %0.08×0.4#2 &.< 71.52#.& 27 5)* 2& *3. 71.52#.& 5.&*!%0 1%!*@ G 9")!:1"2&* >.&'2&6 *.7* 27 *3.& NO)25P0$N 1.!9"!#.' Q7.. *3. 8!7* K.5*2"&-@ B3. 53"25.
"9 *3. 71.52#.& '2#.&72"&7 Q5)**2&6 ")* % 0.08×0.4#2 &.< 71.52#.& 2& *3. *3.!#%0 0"%'.' 71.52#.&- 27 #"*2/%*.' >$ % 5"&5.!& *" 1!.7.!/. 3$'!")7 >")&'%!$ 5"&'2*2"&7 >$ %/"2'2&6 *3.
7*.%# 0"77 2& *3. 71.52#.& 5.&*!%0 1%!*@ ("&5.!&2&6 5%!'>"%!'; *3. 7%#. 1!"*"5"0 27 %'"1*.';
*3. >.&'2&6 *.7* >.2&6 !.10%5.' >$ % *.&720. *.7*@ B3.7. #.53%&25%0 *.7*7 %!. %532./.' )72&6 %&
JRKBSHR 1!.77 "95.103R 5%1%52*$ %&' %3.10−1#T7 '2710%5.#.&* !%*.@
U
!"#$%&$"'!()*'(+ ",-"#*$").(+ #"/0+./
! "#$ %&'!"$()*'(+ ,! '- *("#*"(*%,. /'"$(,'&0 "#$ )$-+,-1 "$!"! '($ .'((,$+ *2" ,- "#$ &*-1,"2+,3 -'& 45560 "('-!7$(!'& 48860 '-+ +,'1*-'& 4586 +,($.",*-! '" +,9$($-" !"$%! *: "#$ ",/$ $7*&2",*-
;<= "#$(/'& &*'+,-1 4'/),$-" "$/%$('"2($0 >??! ;<=0 @A?! ;<= '-+ B??! ;<=6C D*( $'.# .*-3 E12('",*- 4/$.#'-,.'& &*'+ +,($.",*- F "#$(/'& &*'+ ",/$ !"$%60 !,G !%$.,/$-! '($ "$!"$+C /$'!2($ *: "#$ "$/%$('"2($ 4%$(:*(/$+ 2!,-1 ' "#$(/*.*2%&$ &*.'"$+ ,- "#$ /,++&$ *: %&'!"$(3 )*'(+6 1,7$! ' .*(($!%*-+$-.$ )$"H$$- "#$ ;<= &*'+,-1 ",/$ '-+ "#$ '7$('1$ "$/%$('"2($ ,-
"#$ %&'!"$()*'(+C IG%$(,/$-"'& ($!2&"! !#*H ' -*- &,-$'( )$#'7,*( *: "#$ JKJ /2&",&'L$( $!%$3 .,'&&L '" (**/ "$/%$('"2($C D,12($ > +,!%&'L! "#$ )$#'7,*( *: "#$ JKJ %&'"$ '..*(+,-1 "* "#$
&*-1,"2+,-'& +,($.",*- :*( +,9$($-" 7'&2$! *: "#$ "$/%$('"2($ 4A?MJ0 NA?MJ0 NO?MJ '-+ AP?MJ6C D,12($ @ !#*H! "#$ /$'- 7'&2$ *: "#$ $G%$(,/$-"'& Q*2-1 /*+2&2! *: "#$ JKJ /2&",&'L$( '! ' :2-.",*- *: "$/%$('"2($C J*-.$(-,-1 "#$ "#$(/*3/$.#'-,.'& ,+$-",E.'",*- *: JKJ .*/%*-$-"!0
"#$ !'/$ $G%$(,/$-"'& %(*"*.*& #'7$ )$$- 2!$+C R$-+,-1 "$!"! %$(:*(/$+ *- %&'!"$( !'/%&$! '"
+,9$($-" !"$%! *: "#$(/'& &*'+,-1 !#*H &,-$'(3$&'!",. )$#'7,*( 4D,1C P6 H,"# ' +$.($'!,-1 !",93 -$!! H,"# ($!%$." "* "$/%$('"2($C ! :*( "#$ .'(+)*'(+0 ,"! )$#'7,*( !#*H! ' &,1#" #'(+$-,-1 H#,.# 7'-,!#$! H#$- "$/%$('"2($ ,-.($'!$! 4D,1C B6C D*( "#$ /*+$&,-1 H$ '!!2/$ "#'" "#$ "H*
/'"$(,'&! '($ $&'!",. &,-$'(C
! "#$%&$'()* %+)*",-").+'/&.'$ ")'/ ",0)$
J*-!,+$( ' JKJ /2&",&'L$( .*/%*!$+ *: "#($$ %#L!,.'& &'L$(! 4!2)!.(,%"j6S .'(+)*'(+ N0 %&'!"$(0 .'(+)*'(+ AC I'.# %#L!,.'& &'L$( ,! +,!.($",T$+ ,"!$&: ,- U-2/$(,.'&U &'L$(! 4!2)!.(,%" k6 4!$$
D,1CO6C 8#$ "*"'& -2/)$( *: "#$ -2/$(,.'& &'L$(! :*( "#$ .*/%*!,"$ ,! +$-*"$+ )L -C I'.# %#L!,.'&
.'(+)*'(+ &'L$( ,! '!!2/$+ "* )$ *("#*"(*%,. H#,&$ "#$ %&'!"$( &'L$( ,! '!!2/$+ "* )$ ,!*"(*%,.C
B
!" "#$%&'('&) *$&+', -. &!" (-/%&'&0&'1" "20$&'-/ -. "$(! /0*"+'($# #$)"+ k 3k = 1, . . . , n4 .-+ &!" *"$/ *-5"# '% 5"/-&"5 6) [Ak] $/5 '% $ *$&+', 6"#-/7'/7 &- &!" %"& +5(!) -. $## &!"
8-%'&'1"95":/'&" %)**"&+'( 35×54 +"$# *$&+'("%; !" *0#&'#$)"+ %)%&"* '% 5":/"5 '/ $ ($+&"%'$/
(--+5'/$&" $,'% 3-,)<4 =!"+" - '% #-($&"5 '/ &!" (-*8-%'&" *'58#$/";
! "#$%&$'()* +,",-).&/'%&,. 0&%+ 1'"'-)
!" 0%0$# -/" 5'*"/%'-/$# !-*-7"/'<$&'-/ &!+-07! &!" &!'(>/"%% -. &!" *0#&'#$)"+ (-*8-%'&"
)'"#5% $ *$&+', "20$&'-/ +"#$&'/7? 6) *"$/% -. &!" !-*-7"/'<"5 *"$/ *$&+',[Ag]? &!" *"*6+$/"
.-+("%"i, i={1,2,6}? &!" 6"/5'/7 *-*"/&%#i, i={1,2,6}$/5 &!" %!"$+ .-+("%?"i, i={4,5}?
='&! &!" *"*6+$/" 5".-+*$&'-/% emj , j ={1,2,6}? &!" 6"/5'/7 5".-+*$&'-/% κj, j = {1,2,6}
$/5 &!" %!"$+ 5".-+*$&'-/%ej, j={4,5} $((-+5'/7 &- @2; 3A4;
"1
"2
"6
−
#1
#2
#6
−
"4
"5
=
| | 0 0
[H] | [B] | 0 0
| | 0 0
−− −− −− − −− −− −− − −− −−
| | 0 0
[B] | [C] | 0 0
| | 0 0
−− −− −− − −− −− −− − −− −−
0 0 0 | 0 0 0 | F44 F45
0 0 0 | 0 0 0 | F45 F55
em1 em2 em6
− κ1
κ2 κ6
− e4 e5
, 3A4
B
!"#"
[H]ij = Xn k=1
(zk−zk−1)Aekij(M, θ) i$%&j = 1,2,6 , '($)
[C]ij = 1/3 Xn k=1
(zk3−zk−13 )Aekij(M, θ) i$%& j= 1,2,6 , '(*)
[B]ij = 1/2 Xn k=1
(zk2−zk−12 )Aekij(M, θ) i$%& j= 1,2,6 , '(+)
[F] = Xn k=1
(z3k−zk−13 )
GkT N 0 0 GkN L
. '(&)
,!" -./0 '($)1'(&) +2##"/32%& #"/3"+456"78 42 4!" 9"9*#$%" /45:%"// 9$4#5; "7"9"%4/< 4!" *"%&1 5%= /45:%"// 9$4#5; "7"9"%4/< 4!" 9"9*#$%"1*"%&5%= +2>375%= 9$4#5; "7"9"%4/ $%& 4!" /!"$#
/45:%"// 9$4#5; "7"9"%4/0 ?% 4!"/" ".>$452%/<θ5/ 4!" 4"93"#$4>#" $%&M = (x, y, z)5/ $ 325%4 5%
4!" @A &29$5%0 ,!" 9$4#5+"/[Aek(M, θ)]$#" />+! 4!$4[Aek(M, θ)] = (I−[Dk(M, θ)])[Ak(M, θ)]
5% !5+![Ak(M, θ)]$%&[Dk(M, θ)]+2##"/32%& 42 4!" /45:%"// $%& &$9$=" 9$4#5+"/ 2B 4!" 7$8"#
C< #"/3"+456"780 D5%$778< 2%" !$/ Ak11 = Ex/(1−νxyνyx)< Ak22 = Ey/(1−νxyνyx)< Ak66 = Gxy<
Ak12=νxyEy/(1−νxyνyx) =Ak21<Ak44 =Gyz<Ak55 =Gzx $%& Ak45=Ak54=Ak26=Ak62=Ak16= Ak61= 00
!"# #$"%&'!$ "%"()&*&
,!" 9"$% 4!"#9$7 &5:>/56548 '/"" D5=0 E) 2B 4!" FGF 37$4"/ 5/ 5&"%45H"& *8 $% 5%6"#/" 3#2*1 7"9 3"#B2#9"& 54! $ &"6"723"& H%54" "7"9"%4 +2&" 2B !"$4 4#$%/B"# $%$78/5/ $%& $++2#&5%= 42 4"93"#$4>#"1459" 4"/4/ +$##5"& 2>4 54! 4!" ,IJ0 ,!" FGF 4!"#9$7 +2%&>+456548 5/ $7/2 5&"%1 45H"& *8 4!"#9$7 ";3"#59"%4/ $4 4!" /4"$&8 /4$4" 3"#B2#9"& 54! 4!" ,IJ0 ,!" !"$4 4#$%/B"#
$%$78/5/ 4!#2>=! 4!" 4!5+C%"// 2B 4!" FGF 9>7457$8"# '4$C5%= 5%42 $++2>%4 4!" 5&"%45H"& 3$#$91
"4"#/) $772 / 4!" 4"93"#$4>#" 5% 4!" 95&&7" 2B 4!" &5:"#"%4 %>9"#5+$7 7$8"#/ 2B 4!" FGF 42 *"
+$7+>7$4"& $/ $ B>%+452% 2B 4!" 4!"#9$7 72$&5%= 459" 'D5=0 K)0 ,!" 9"+!$%5+$7 +!$#$+4"#5/45+/ 2B
E
!" #$# %&'"() *+,-./0) 1,2-%-)3 &(" 1,2"%"2 4' &. &5." 6-.7 8,. ,6 !" 1"&. "19"(& -("
T: ;!" 9&(&1" "() & &.2 4 !&<" 4"". 82". 8="2 >8 ! !" !"(1,?1"7!&.87&% (")9,.)" ,6 !"
1-% 8%&'"( 7,19,)8 ": *;!8) 82". 8=7& 8,. '8"%2) a=−3.71 &.2 b = 2.453: @ )!,-%2 4" ., "2 !& ., 9(,4&48%8) 87 1,2"% ,6 -.7"( &8. 8") 6,( !" !"& (&.)6"( &.&%')8) 8) 819%"1". "2 8. !"
1,2"%:
!"!#$ "%&$'
A) & =() &99(,&7!B & 7- ?,C 1,2"% >&) &2,9 "2 6,( !" 9%&) "( %&'"(): D,( "&7! 9,8. ,6 !"
1,2"%"2 2,1&8.B !" 2&1&/" 8) "E-&% , F"(, 86 !" ) (")) 8) %")) !&. !" %818 ) (")) &.2 "E-&%
, G , !"(>8)": ;!8) =() .,.%8."&( &99(,&7! -)"2 6,( 1,2"%8./ !" /%,4&% 4"!&<8,( ,6 !" #$#
)!,>) & /,,2 E-&%8 & 8<" &/(""1". >8 ! "H9"(81". &% (")-% ) & 120I# &.2 ),1" 28C"(".7")
& (,,1 "19"(& -(" *J&KL8 " &%: MNNO3: @. ,(2"( , 819(,<" !" 1,2"% 9("287 8,.B & 4(8 %"
2&1&/" 1,2"% *)"" P&L&( GQRS3 !&) 4"". 819%"1". "2 6,( !" 9%&) "(: A77,(28./ , !8) 1,2"%B
>!87! 8) 4&)"2 ,. ) (&8. "."(/' 6,(1-%& 8,.B !" 2&1&/" "<,%- 8,. %&> ,6 "&7! .-1"(87&% %&'"(
,6 !" 9%&) "( 7&. 4" >(8 ". &)
βk=
β0k "H9(ωk) 86α= 0 , β0k(1 +αωk)1/α 86α6= 0 .
*T3
@. UE: *T3 !" 9&(&1" "() β0kB α &.2 ωk 2"9".2 ,. "19"(& -(" θB ,. !" 9,8. V &.2 ,.
ωk = Wperfk /Wk∗: ;!" E-&. 8 ' Wperfk 8) !" ) (&8. "."(/' ,6 !" -.2&1&/"2 1& "(8&% 6,( !"
%&'"(k: ;!" .,18.&% 2&1&/" "."(/' 6,( !" %&'"(kB 2"., "2 4' Wk∗B 8) 2"=."2 &) !" .,18.&%
7&9&78 ' ,6 !" 1& "(8&% , ) ,(" "."(/' 8. !" 6,(1 ,6 8. "(.&% ) (-7 -(&% 2&1&/": D8.&%%'B β0k 8) !" 8.8 8&% 2&1&/" 6,( !" %&'"( k &.2 α 8) & 1,2"% 9&(&1" "(: A) & =() &))-19 8,.B >"
7,.)82"( !" 9%&) "( 2&1&/" &) 8), (,987 &.2 6,%%,>) !" 2&1&/" "<,%- 8,. %&> ,6 UE: *T3 8. "&7!
9(8.789&% 28("7 8,.: ;!" 2&1&/" 1& (8H [Dk] ("%& "2 , !" .-1"(87&% %&'"( k ,6 !" 9%&) "( 8)
Q
!"# $%& "# '(
[Dk] =βk[I], (k= 2, . . . , n−1) . )*+
,&#'--./ !" 01 234 536"- &( 1("6 73% !" 0'%683'%6 $!&-" ' 8%& -" 6'5'9" 536"- &( 1("6 73% !"
:-'( "%83'%6;
!"#$"%&' ()%'*!+*%,)&"$,&# &"&#-.$. !/ ()% 010 *%&" *!2%#
< 51- &-'."% !&# :-' " !"3%. &( 1("6 $& ! !" 03#( & 1 &=" ">1' &3# ?>; )@+; < A#& " "-"5"#
036" &( 6"="-3:"6 73% !" #3#-&#"'% !"%532"-'( &0 536"-; B!" 5"0!'#&0'- %"(:3#(" 37 !" CDC
&( 0'-01-' "6 '( ' 71#0 &3# 37 !" "E "%#'- 5"0!'#&0'- -3'6 03%%"(:3#6	 3 ' 731%2:3&# 8"#6	 "( ; B!" 6'5'9" :'%'5" "%( '%" (10! !' α20FC = 0.1/β20FC = 0.005/(Wk∗)20FC = 3.2KJ/m3 73% !" "5:"%' 1%" θ= 20FC '#6 α120FC = 0.8/ β120FC = 0.005/(Wk∗)120FC = 2KJ/m3 73% !"
"5:"%' 1%" θ = 120FC; ,&91%"( @G '#6 @@ (!3$ !" 035:'%&(3#( 37 !" "E:"%&5"# '- %"(1- (
$& ! !" #15"%&0'- (&51-' &3#( 73% !" '::-&"6 5"0!'#&0'- -3'6 '( ' 71#0 &3# 37 !" %'#(="%('- 6&(:-'0"5"# ' 20FC '#6120FC %"(:"0 &="-.;
! "#$%&$'()* +*,-'-&$&.%&/ ",0)$ ,1 #2/)*%'&2%&).
H" #3$ 03#(&6"% 6' ' '#6 536"- 1#0"% '&# &"( &# !" :!.(&0'- -'."%( )(18(0%&: I+; H" !'=" 1("6 !" #3#:'%'5" %&0 :%38'8&-&( &0 '::%3'0! )("" J3&K" LGGM+ &# 3%6"% 3 'N" &# 3 '0031# !"("
1#0"% '&# &"(; <003%6	 3 !&( '::%3'0!/ ' 9-38'- %'#635 536"- &( 03#( %10 "6 1(	 %'#635 5' %&E !"3%. %' !"% !'# 1(	 ' :%38'8&-&( &0 536"- 37 "'0! 1#0"% '&# :'%'5" "% ):'%'5" %&0 :%38'8&-&( &0 '::%3'0! ) !"! ("" O!'#"5 '#6 J:'#3( @PP@++;
@G
! "#$%&' ()*+$,(( '#)"*-
!"# $!%&'( )*+,%-)) (!*$+. [Aj] +) /+*# 0!12- +% +5(!) 341!*- ('&-156 7#- 4$'8!8+1+*9
&-%)+*9 :2%"*+'% ': *#+) (!*$+. +) "'%)*$2"*-& :'11'/+%; *#- 4$'"-&2$- ;+0-% +% *#- %-.* )-"*+'%6
<% #'(';-%+=!*+'% *#$'2;#'2* *#- *#+">%-)) ': *#- ?@? 3!) :'$ *#- (-!% ('&-15 +) !441+-& *'
*#- $!%&'( (21*+1!9-$ "'(4')+*- !%& 9+-1&) *#- $!%&'( (!*$+.[Ag]': *#- $!%&'( #'(';-%+=-&
"'%)*+*2*+0- -A2!*+'%
[Ag] =hom{[Ae1], . . . ,[Aej]} . 3B5
!"&.#.*/*)0 %,$(*)0 12$3)*&$ &1 )4, "#$%&' ()*+$,(( '#)"*- &1 )4, /#0," 5
7#- 4$'8!8+1+*9 &-%)+*9 :2%"*+'% ': *#- (!*$+.[Aj]+) "'%)*$2"*-& 2)+%; *#- (!.+(2( -%*$'49 4$+%"+41- 3)-- C'+=- DEEB56 7#- (!.+(2( -%*$'49 4$+%"+41- !11'/) *#- 4$'8!8+1+*9 &-%)+*9 :2%"F
*+'% ': ! $!%&'( 0!$+!81- *' 8- "'%)*$2"*-& 89 (!.+(+=+%; *#- -%*$'49 :2%"*+'% 2%&-$ "'%)*$!+%*)
&-G%-& 89 *#- !0!+1!81- +%:'$(!*+'%6 7#- !0!+1!81- +%:'$(!*+'% $-1!*-& *' $!%&'( (!*$+.[Aj] +) &-G%-& !) :'11'/)H
I6 7#- $!%&'( (!*$+. +) /+*# 0!12-) +% +5(!)6
D6 7#- (-!% 0!12- +) )2"# *#!* E{[Aj]} = [Aj] +% /#+"# E{·} &-%'*-) *#- (!*#-(!*+"!1 -.4-"*!*+'%6
J6 E{k[Aj]−1k2F}<+∞/#-$-k[A]kF = (*${[A][A]T})1/2 +) *#- K$'8-%+2) %'$(6
7#- 1!)* "'%)*$!+%* +%)2$-) *#- -.+)*-%"- ': ! )-"'%&F'$&-$ )'12*+'% ': *#- )*'"#!)*+" 4$'81-(
!%& *#-% *' 8- "'%)+)*!%* /+*# (-"#!%+"L) "'%)+&-$!*+'%)6 7#- $!%&'( (!*$+.[Aj]': *#- jth 1!9-$ +) /$+**-% !)
[Aj] = [LAj]T[GAj][LAj] . 3M5
II
!"#"[LAj] $% &(5×5) #"&' ())"# *#$&+,('&# -&*#$. %(/! *!&*[Aj] = [LAj]T[LAj]0 1!" )#234
&3$'$*5 6$%*#$3(*$2+ 7(+/*$2+ 27 *!" #&+62- -&*#$. [GAj] $*! 8&'("% $+ +5(!) $% 6"9+"6 35
*!" )#23&3$'$*5 6"+%$*5 7(+/*$2+ [GAj]7→ p[G
Aj]([GAj]) 7#2- +5(!) $+ !+ $*! #"%)"/* *2 *!"
-"&%(#"dGe Aj %(/! *!&*dGe Aj = 2n(n−1)/4Q
1≤i≤k≤nd[GAj]ik &+6 %(/! *!&*
p[G
Aj]([GAj]) =" +5(!)([GAj])×cGAj ×(det[GAj])
31−δ
2 j δ2
j ×exp(−3
δj2tr[GAj]) , :;<
$+ !$/! *!" +2#-&'$=&*$2+ )2%$*$8" /2+%*&+*cG
Aj $% #$**"+ &%
cG
Aj = (2π)−5(3
δj2)15δj−2/{ Yn l=1
Γ(3
δ2j +1−l
2 )} . :><
?+ @A0 :><B 72# z > 0B Γ(z) $% *!" ,&--& 7(+/*$2+ 6"9+"6 35 Γ(z) = R+∞
0 tz−1e−tdt0 1!"
)&#&-"*"#δj &''2 % *!" )#23&3$'$*5 -26"' 6$%)"#%$2+ 27 *!" #&+62- -&*#$.[GAj]*2 3" /2+*#2''"6 :&+6 *!"+ *!" 6$%)"#%$2+ 27 *!" #&+62- -&*#$. [Aj]*2 3" /2+*#2''"6<0 C" !&8"
δj ={E{k[GAj]−[GAj]k2F}/k[GAj]k2F}1/2 . :D<
1!" )&#&-"*"#δj $% $+6")"+6"+* 27 *!" #&+62- -&*#$. 6$-"+%$2+ &+6 -(%* 3" %(/! *!&*
0< δj <√
0.6 . :EF<
G2# *!" H2+*"4I&#'2 %$-('&*$2+ -"*!26B *!" #"&'$=&*$2+% 27 *!" #&+62- -&*#$/"% [A]j &#" /2+4
%*#(/*"6 (%$+, *!" 72''2 $+, &',"3#&$/ #")#"%"+*&*$2+J
[GAj] = [Lj]T[Lj] , :EE<
!"#"[Lj]$% &+ ())"# #&+62- *#$&+,('&# -&*#$. %(/! *!&*J
• K&+62- 8&#$&3'"% {[Lj]kk′, k≤k′} &#" $+6")"+6"+*B
• G2#k≤k′B *!" #&+62- 8&#$&3'"[Lj]kk′B $% %(/![Lj]kk′ =σjYkk′B $+ !$/!σj =δj/√ 6&+6 Ykk′ $% & +2#-&'$="6 L&(%%$&+ #&+62- 8&#$&3'"B
EM
• !" k= k′# [Lj]kk = σjp
2Vkjσj =δj/√
6 $%&"& Vkj '( ) *)++) "),-!+ .)"')/0& $%'1%
2"!/)/'0'34 -&,('34 56,13'!, *'.&, /4
pVj(ν) = !+(ν)Γ(3/δj2+ (11 −k)/2)ν
3 δ2 j
+1−k2
e−ν . 789:
!"!#$ $%$&$"# '!()*$#!+,#!-" -. #/$ (#-)/,(#!) 0-1"',*2 3,%1$ 4*-0%$&
;%& ,!,0',&)" (3!1%)(3'1 /!6,-)"4 .)06& 2"!/0&+ '( )22"!<'+)3&- /4 3%& 6(6)0 =,'3& &0&>
+&,3 +&3%!- 7)0(! 1)00&- (3!1%)(3'1 =,'3& &0&+&,3 +&3%!-:? ;%& +&), *0!/)0 (3'@,&(( +)3"'<
7[K(q,T)]: !5 3%& 10)(('1 +&), =,'3& &0&+&,3 +!-&0',* 7 !"! [K(q,T)]q=f: '( 3%&, "&20)1&- /4 ) "),-!+ +)3"'< [K(q,T)]? ;%& (!063'!, q '( ,! 0!,*&" -&3&"+','(3'1 ),- 3%&, /&1!+&( ) (3!1%)(3'1 2"!1&(( -&,!3&- /4Q? ;%& +&), &A6)3'!, '( 3%&, "&20)1&- /4 3%& (3!1%)(3'1 &A6)3'!, 1!""&(2!,-',* 3! 3%& 2"!/)/'0'(3'1 +!-&0 !5 6,1&"3)',3'&( $%'1% '( $"'33&, )(
[K(Q,T)]Q=f , 78B:
$%&"&[K(Q,T)] 1!""&(2!,-( 3! 3%& *0!/)0 (3'@,&(( +)3"'< 1!,(3"613&- /4 3%& )((&+/04 !5 3%&
"),-!+ &0&+&,3)"4 +)3"'1&([Ke(Q,T)](61% 3%)3
[Ke(Q,T)] = Z
De[B
e(x1, x2,0)]T [Ag(x1, x2,Q,T)] [Be(x1, x2,0)]dx1dx2 . 78C:
D, EA? 78C:#[Ag(x1, x2,Q,T)]-&,!3&( 3%& %!+!*&,'F&- +)3"'< 1!,(3"613&- )11!"-',* 3! EA? 7G:
$%&"& 3%& 62-)3&- -)+)*&# )11!"-',* 3! EA? 7B: ),- EA? 7C:# '( 3)H&, ',3! )11!6,3 6(',* ',3&",)0 '3&")3'!,(? I)3"'< [Be(x1, x2,0)] 1!""&(2!,-( 3! 3%& (3")', ',3&"2!0)3'!, +)3"'< !5 &)1% =,'3&
&0&+&,3 -&=,&- ', 3%& &0&+&,3)"4 -!+)',De?
5#-)/,(#!) (-%3$* ,"' )-"3$*6$")$
;%& I!,3&>J)"0! ('+60)3'!, +&3%!- '( 6(&- )( 3%& (3!1%)(3'1 (!0.&" 5!" 3%& "),-!+ ,!,0',&)"
&A6)3'!, 7 !"! EA? 78B::? !" j = 1,2,3# 0&3 [Aj(r1)], . . . , [Aj(rns)] /& ns ',-&2&,-&,3 "&)0>
'F)3'!,( !5 "),-!+ +)3"'< [Aj]? E)1% "&)0'F)3'!, {[Aj(rℓ)], j = 1,2,3} !5 3%& 2%4('1)0 0)4&"(
8B
!"#$%&"#$ '( )*"+,-# ".$ !"#$%&"#$ /0 1+ !&.+,#2!,-$ 2+1.3 ,4- +!4-5- $-+!#1%-$ 1. ,4- 6&2#,4 7-!,1&. ".$ "!!&#$1.3 ,& 89: ''0( 89: ;0 ".$ 89: <0: =4- 4&5&3-.1>",1&. )#&!-++ 31?-. %@
89: A0 ".$ "))*1-$ ,& ,4- #".$&5 5",#1!-+ &6 -"!4 .25-#1!"* *"@-#k( k= 1, . . . , n0 ,4#&234&2, ,4- ,41!B.-++ &6 ,4- CDC( @1-*$+ ,4- #-"*1>",1&. &6 ,4- #".$&5 5",#1E[Ag(x1, x2,Q(rℓ,T), rℓ)]
&6 ,4- 4&5&3-.1>-$ 52*,1*"@-#: =4- !&##-+)&.$1.3 #-"*1>",1&. &6 89: 'F0 1+ ,4-. G#1,,-. "+
[K(Q(rℓ),T)]Q(rℓ) =f . 'A0
892",1&. 'F0 1+ +&*?-$ %@ )-#63.3 1.!#-5-.,+ &. *&"$ G1,4 " *&"$ +,-) +5"** -.&234 ,& ,"B- 1.,& "!!&2., $"5"3- G41!4 1+ 2)$",-$ "!!&#$1.3 ,& 89: F0 &6 ,4- $"5"3- -?&*2,1&. *"G: =4- 2)$",-$ $"5"3- 1+ ,"B-. 1.,& "!!&2., 2+1.3 1.,-#."* 1,-#",1&.+:
=4- !&.?-#3-.!- G1,4 " #-+)-!, ,& ,4- .25%-# ns &6 #-"*1>",1&.+ r1, . . . , rns 2+-$ 1. ,4- H&.,- C"#*& +152*",1&. 1+ +,2$1-$ %@ "."*@>1.3 ,4- 62.!,1&.
ns7→conv(ns) = ( 1
ns
ns
X
ℓ=1
kQ(rℓ)k2 )1/2
. '<0
I-,Qj %- ,4- #".$&5 ,#".+?-#+"* $1+)*"!-5-., &6 ,4- CDC )*",- ", " 31?-. .&$- &6 ,4- 5-+4:
=4- !&.J$-.!- #-31&. G1,4 #-+)-!, ,& " 31?-. )#&%"%1*1,@ *-?-* Pc 1+ $-J.-$ %@ ,4- 2))-# ".$
,4- *&G-# -.?-*&)-+ q+ ".$ q− #-+)-!,1?-*@0 +2!4 "+
P rob(q−<Qj ≤q+) =Pc . ';0
=4- -+,15",1&. &6q−".$q+1+ )-#6-$ 2+1.3 ,4- +"5)*- 92".,1*-+: I-,Q1 =Qj(r1), . . . , Qns = Qj(rns)(ns %- 1.$-)-.$-., #-"*1>",1&.+ &6 ,4- #".$&5 ?"#1"%*-Qj: I-, Qb1 < . . . <Qbns %- ,4-
&#$-# +,",1+,1!+ &6 ,4- 1.$-)-.$-., ?"#1"%*-+ Q1, . . . , Qns: =4-#-6&#-( " )&++1%*- -+,15",1&. &6 ,4- *&G-# ".$ ,4- 2))-# -.?-*&)-+ &6 q− ".$q+ 1+
q−≃Qbj− G1,4 j−=f ix(ns(1−Pc)/2) , 'K"0 q+≃Qbj+ G1,4 j+=f ix(ns(1 +Pc)/2) , 'K%0
'L
!"#"f ix(x) $% &!" $'&"("# )*#& +, &!" #"*- './0"# x1
!"#$%&$'( ') &*" +!',-,$.$/&$% 0'#". -(# "1+"!$0"(&-. %'0+-!$/'(/
2" 3+'%$4"# &!" 0+.'4*#5 6*-." )#+0-"/ 3+##"%)+'4$'( &+ * ,+.#7)+$'& 0"'4$'( &"%& *'4 4$%7 3#"&$8"4 05 &!" %&+3!*%&$3 9'$&" "-"/"'& /"&!+41 2" *#" $'&"#"%&"4 $' &!" #*'4+/ #"%)+'%"Q*%
* ,.'3&$+' +, &!" *))-$"4 /"3!*'$3*- -+*41 : + 3*%"% *#" 3+'%$4"#"4; &!" 9#%& +'" 3+##"%)+'4%
&+ * &"/)"#*&.#" +, <=>? @#++/ &"/)"#*&.#"A *'4 &!" %"3+'4 +'" 3+##"%)+'4% &+ B<=>?1 :!"
4$%)"#%$+' )*#*/"&"#% +, &!" )!5%$3*- -*5"#% !*6" 0""' $4"'&$9"4 $&! &!" "C)"#$/"'&*- 4*&*
.%$'( &!" #*'4+/ #"%)+'%"Q*'4 5$"-4%
• (δplaster)20>C = 0.15 *'4(δcardboard)20>C = 0.08*& <=>? ;
• (δplaster)120>C = 0.18 *'4 (δcardboard)120>C = 0.09 *& B<=>? 1
D+# "*3! &"/)"#*&.#" 3*%"; &!" E+'&" ?*#-+ %$/.-*&$+' /"&!+4 $% 3*##$"4 +.& ,+#ns %$/.-*&$+'%
$&! (ns)20>C = 350 *'4 (ns)120>C = 7001 D$(.#"% B< *'4 BF *#" #"-*&"4 &+ &!" 3+'6"#("'3"
,.'3&$+' @GH1 @BIAA *& <=>? *'4 *& B<=>? #"%)"3&$6"-51 D$(.#"% BJ *'4 BK 4$%)-*5 &!" 3+/)*#$%+' +, &!" "C)"#$/"'&% $&! &!" 3+'94"'3" #"($+'% 3*-3.-*&"4 ,+# Pc = 0.98 *& 20>C *'4 120>C
#"%)"3&$6"-51
!"#$""!%& '& #%&#($"!%&
L 4"&"#/$'$%&$3 '+'-$'"*# &!"#/+7/"3!*'$3*- /+4"- !*% 0""' )#"%"'&"4 ,+# %&.45$'( * 3*#40+*#47 )-*%&"#73*#40+*#4 /.-&$-*5"# )-*&"1 L '" &"%& 0"'3! ,+# &!"#/+7/"3!*'$3*- 3!*#*3&"#$8*&$+'
!*% 0""' %)"3$*--5 4"6"-+)"4 $' +#4"# &+ $4"'&$,5 &!" )*#*/"&"#% +, &!" &!"#/+7/"3!*'$3*- /+4"-
*'4 &+ )"#,+#/ $&% "C)"#$/"'&*- 6*-$4*&$+'1 M." &+ &!" !$(! 3+/)-"C$&5 +, &!" &!"#/+7/"3!*'$3*-
%5%&"/ $'4.3"4 05 &!" '*&.#" +, &!" /*&"#$*-% .%"4 $' &!" ?N? )-*&"% @)-*%&"# *'4 3*#40+*#4A;
BK
!"#" $% & %$'($)*&( +&#$&,$-$ . $( !" #"&- /0/ 1-& "% $(23*"2 ,. !" 1#4*"%% 45 5&,#$*& $4(
&(2 !"#" &#" ,4 ! 642"- 3(*"# &$( $"% &(2 2& & 3(*"# &$( $"% $( !" !"#6476"*!&($*&- 642"- 1#414%"28 /4(%"93"( -.: & 1#4,&,$-$% $* 642"- 45 3(*"# &$( $"% !&% ,""( $( #423*"2 $( 4#2"#
4 $(*#"&%" !" #4,3% ("%% 45 !" 1#"2$* $4(%8 ;!" 2$%1"#%$4( 1&#&6" "#% 45 !" 1#4,&,$-$% $*
642"- 45 !" 6"*!&($*&- 1#41"# $"% 54# !" *,4 &(2 54# !" 1-&% "# !&+" "<1"#$6"( &--.
,""( $2"( $)"2 54# =4 "61"#& 3#" % "1% &**4#2$(' 4 !" >?@ABC !"#6&- -4&2 *3#+"8 ;!"
*4()2"(*" #"'$4( !&% ,""( *4(% #3* "2 4 1#"2$* !" '-4,&- !"#6476"*!&($*&- ,"!&+$4# 45 !"
/0/ 63- $-&."# 1-& " %3,6$ "2 4 & >?@ABC !"#6&- -4&2$('8 ;!" 1#414%"2 642"- =$ ! 3(7
*"# &$( $"% *&( ," *4(%$2"#"2 &% +&-$2& "2 ,. "<1"#$6"( % &D$(' $( 4 &**43( !" *461-"<$ . 45 !" !"#6476"*!&($*&- %.% "68
>( !$% 1&1"#: !" !"& #&(%5"# &(&-.%$% !&% ,""( 1"#54#6"2 =$ ! 2" "#6$($% $* !"#6&- 1#41"# $"%: =!$*! 6"&(% !& (4 3(*"# &$( $"% 642"-$(' !&+" ,""( &D"( $( 4 &**43( 54# !"
!"#6&- 1#41"# $"%8 > %!43-2 ," (4 "2 !& &(4 !"# $(+"% $'& $4( !&% ,""( 2"+"-41"2 4 &(&-.E"
!" !"& #&(%5"# =$ ! 3(*"# &$( !"#6&- 1#41"# $"% $( !" *4( "< 45 !" 1#4,&,$-$ . !"4#. F%""
?&DG$ HIIJK8 > !&% ,""( 1#4+"( !& !" "61"#& 3#" )"-2 $( !" /0/ 1-& " $% %"(%$ $+" 4 !"
3(*"# &$( $"% $( !" !"#6&- 1#41"# $"% ,3 $( 4114%$ " $ !&% ,""( 1#4+"( !& !" % & $% $*&- L3* 3& $4(% 45 !" "61"#& 3#" )"-2 &#" (4 %3M*$"( -. -&#'" 4 %$'($)*&( -. 642$5. !" (4(-$(7
"&# !"#6476"*!&($*&- ,"!&+$4# 45 !" /0/ 1-& " %3,6$ "2 4 )#" -4&2 &(2 6"*!&($*&- -4&2%8
;!$% $% !" #"&%4( =!. =" !&+" 1#"%"( "2 & %$61-$)"2 +"#%$4( 45 !$% =4#D $( 4#2"# 4 $(*#"&%"
$ % #"&2&,$-$ .8 N$(&--.: $ %!43-2 ," (4 "2 !& !" 3(*"# &$( $"% $(23*"2 ,. )#" %*"(&#$4 $% (4
*4(%$2"#"2 $( !" *4( "< 45 !$% 1&1"# ,"*&3%" !" !"#6&- -4&2$(' $% )<"2 ,. !" >?@ ABC !"#6&- -4&2$(' *3#+"8
;!" -$6$ & $4( 45 !" 642"- 2"+"-41"2 $% 23" 4 !" 3%" 45 & (4(-$("&# !"#6476"*!&($*&- 642"- $(% "&2 45 & (4(-$("&# !"#647!.2#47*!"6$*476"*!&($*&- 642"-8 O4="+"#: $ %!43-2 ,"
PJ
!"#$ "%&" "%# %'$(!)*%#+,*&- .%# !+# & &(# ,+.-,*,"-' "&/# , "! &**!0 " 1' "%# .(!.!2#$
#3.#(,+# "&- .(!"!*!- 4%,*% (#.(!$0*#2 "%# 567 89: "%#(+&- -!&$ *0(;# & $ ,2 &-2! "&/# , "!
&**!0 " 1' "%# 02# !< "%# .(!1&1,-,2",* +!$#- !< 0 *#("&, ",#2=
>! *#( , ? "%# 2"(0*"0(&- # ?, ##(, ? &..-,*&",! 2@ "%# +&, *! *-02,! 2 !< "%,2 .&.#( *& 1#
20++&(,A#$ &2 <!--!42B CDE $#;#-!.+# " !< & #4 #3.#(,+# "&- .(!"!*!- <!( "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&-
*%&(&*"#(,A&",! !< "%# >F> .-&"#G CHE $#;#-!.+# " !< & ! -, #&( "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&- +!$#- , *-0$, ? 0 *#("&, ",#2 & $ #3.#(,+# "&--' ;&-,$&"#$ <!( >F> .-&"#2 , 2.,"# !< "%# <&*" "%&" ! +!$#- #3,2"#$ <!( 20*% >F> , "%# -,"#(&"0(#G C9E "%# #3.#(,+# "&- "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&- +#&20(#) +# "2 ! 2#;#(&- 2.#*,+# 2 2%!4 2+&-- ;&(,&1,-,"' !< "%# ! -, #&( 1#%&;,!( 10" 2%!4 & -&(?#
;&(,&1,-,"' <!( "%# 0-",+&"# -!&$G "%,2 "4! "'.#2 !< ;&(,&1,-,"' &(# ;#(' 4#-- .(#$,*"#$ 1' "%#
! -, #&( "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&- +!$#- , *-0$, ? 0 *#("&, ",#2 C2## I?=CD:E & $ CDJEE=
K%# !1L#*",;# !< "%,2 .&.#( ,2 ! -' <!*02#$ ! "%# $#;#-!.+# " !< #3.#(,+# "&- & $ +!$#-, ?
"!!-2 "! & &-'A# "%# ! -, #&( "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&- (#2.! 2# !< >F> .-&"#2 201+,""#$ "! I(#
-!&$ & $ +#*%& ,*&- -!&$2= M!4#;#(@ "%#2# $#;#-!.+# "2 *! 2","0"# & #*#22&(' I(2" 2"&?# "!
*! 2"(0*" & *!+.0"&",! &- +!$#- "! & &-'A# "%# ! -, #&( "%#(+!)+#*%& ,*&- 1#%&;,!( !< &
*!+.-#"# -&(?# -,?%" .&(",",! = K%,2 &2.#*" (#N0,(#2 &$$,",! &- 4!(/2 <!( 4%,*% !"%#( "'.#2 !<
$#;#-!.+# "2 +02" 1# .#(<!(+#$ & $ &(# !" (#-#;& " !< "%,2 .&.#(= O#;#("%#-#22@ 4# ?,;# 1#-!4 2!+# , $,*&",! 2 &1!0" "%# +#"%!$!-!?' 4%,*% *!0-$ 1# 02#$ & $ 4%,*% ,2 , .(!?(#22= K%#
I(2" $#;#-!.+# " ,2 (#-&"#$ "! "%# *! #*",! !< "%# >F> .-&"#2 "! 2"##- <(&+# 4,"% 2"0$2= P 4&' "! 2!-;# "%,2 .(!1-#+ ,2 "! $#;#-!. & -!&$)$,2.-&*#+# " *! 2","0",;# #N0&",! <!( "%# 2"0$2
*! #*"#$ "! "%# >F> .-&"# 02, ? & -!*&- "%(##)$,+# 2,! &- I ,"# #-#+# " ! -, #&( "%#(+!) +#*%& ,*&- +!$#-= K%# 2#*! $ $#;#-!.+# " *! 2,2"2 , &22#+1-, ? &-- "%# >F> .-&"#2 ! "%#
2"##- <(&+# 4,"% 2"0$2 & $ , *-0$, ? , "#( &- , 20-&",! = 5 & I(2" 2"#.@ "%# %#&" "(& 2<#( & &-'2,2 4!0-$ 1# $! # ! "%,2 .&(",",! & $ "%# 2#*! $ 2"#. 4!0-$ 1# $#;!"#$ "! "%# ! -, #&( "%#(+!)
DQ
!"#$%&"$' $%$'()&) *+ ,#! -$.,&,&*% /)&%0 '*$121&)-'$"! !%, "*%),&,/,&3! !4/$,&*% +*. ,#! ),/1)
$%1 /)&%0 +*. !$"# 565 -'$,! ,#! %*%'&%!$. ,#!. *2 !"#$%&"$' *1!' &%"'/1&%0 /%"!.,$&%,&!)
$%1 -.!)!%,!1 &% ,#&) -$-!.7
!"#$%&'()'*'#+
8#&) 9*.: 9$) )/--*.,!1 ;( ,#! 5<8= $%1 ,#! <>?67 8#! ,#!. $' '*$1 ;!%"# 9*/'1 %*, ;!
$"#!&3!1 9&,#*/, ,#! #!'- $%1 ,#! !@*., *+ 67 A.* (B C7 5!) $,B D7 6$.1*%B 57 E! !.'!B 67 F&3&''&*%B 67 6& &!%,$ $%1 57 =$'*"#!7 8#&) #!'- $%1 )/--*., $.! 0.$,!+/''( $":%*9'!10!17
,$+-+.$#
8#! +*''*9&%0 )( ;*') $.! /)!1 &% ,#&) -$-!.G
HI
[Ak] !"# $%&'#!$$ "%(&) *+ %,! -".!(k/
[Aek] !"# 0" "1!0 $%&'#!$$ "%(&) *+ %,! -".!(k/ [Ag] ,* *1!#&2!0 $%&'#!$$ "%(&) *+ %,! 3-%&-".!(/
[B] ! 4("#!54!#0 6*37- $%&'#!$$ "%(&)/
[C] 4!#0 $%&'#!$$ "%(&)/
[F] $,!"( $%&'#!$$ "%(&)/
[GAj] ("#0* "%(&) 1!( (!-"%!0 %* %,! ("#0* "%(&)[Aj]/ [H] ! 4("#! $%&'#!$$ "%(&)/
[I] &0!#%&%. "%(&)/
J #3 4!( *+ 7,.$&6"- -".!($/
[LAj] (!"- 377!( %(&"#13-"( "%(&) *+ 6,*-!$8. 0!6* 7*$!0 "%(&)[Aj]/
+(!) $!% *+ 7*$&%&9!50!:#&%! $. !%(&6 (!"- "%(&6!$/
n #3 4!( *+ #3 !(&6"- -".!($/
ns #3 4!( *+ $& 3-"%&*#$/
;<
q−, q+ !"#$ %&' ())#$ #&*# !)#+ !, -.# /!&0'#&/# $#12!&3
rℓ !"ℓth #"$%&'$ &() *"%()+&)+ ( !" ," (- $%% !" #"$%&'$ &(),.
[S]T #$),/(," (- 0$ #&1 [S]. #([S]) #$2" (- 0$ #&1[S]. [S] 0"$) 0(3"% 0$ #&1.
[S] #$)3(0 0$ #&1.
T 4"2 (# (- !" 0"$) "0/"#$ 5#" &) )50"#&2$% %$6"#,.
βk 3$0$+" /$#$0" "# (- !" %$6"# k.
δj 3&,/"#,&() /$#$0" "# (- !" #$)3(0 0$ #&1 [Aj].
θ 3")( ", !" "0/"#$ 5#" .
7#(*(X > x) /#(*$*&%& 6 !$ X *" +#"$ "# !$)x8 !+(x) "95$% ( 1 &- x∈!+ $)30 "%,":!"#".
!"!#!$%!&
;1")")<(= >8 $)3 ?!#(/"= @8ABCCDE8 F?!" 0(3"%%&)+ (- 3"!63#$ &() $)3 , #",, $)$%6,&, (- +6/,50 /%$, "#*($#3, "1/(,"3 ( G#"8F !"#$%&%'!(&) *&%+,'&)- ./'+(/+= DHIJBKICL8
M5#(/"$) N(00& "" -(# O $)3$#3&'$ &() ANMPE ABCCLE8 FM5#(2(3"BH $2 &(), ,5# %", , #52 5#", K 7$# &" IKI H $2 &(), +Q)Q#$%", K ;2 &(), ,5# %", , #52 5#", "1/(,Q", $5 -"58F 0$,!#+&( !""'%++
1!, .%&(2&,2'3&%'!(= MPR BCCBKIKIABCCLE8
S#(06= 78 $)3 N5# $ = T8ABCCCE8 FU"$ #$),-"# &) G#" #",&, $)2" -5#)$2", /&%( "3 :& ! !"#0(K 2(5/%", (# /%$ " !"#0(0" "#,8F 4,!/5 6th7(%8 .9"# !( :',+ .&1+%9 ./'+(/+= V;SOO= T8N5# $ =
"38= WXBKWLI8
@!$)"0= @8 Y8 $)3 O/$)(,= 78 Z8ABCCBE8 .%!/;&-%'/ :'('%+ 0)+"+(%-< = .#+/%,&) =##,!&/;8
I[
!"#$%&"'(&")*%+ ,&- ./"01
2$3&"$*3#/$*) 3*$4*"45 6"%*$#7*3#/$ 82 69 8:;<=91 !"#$ %$&"&'()*$ +$&'&, -.$/$)'& 01 23".4,
")5 60)&'#3*'"0)7 8)'$#)('"0)(. 9'()4(#4 89: ;<=1
,*>*"1 ?1 8:;@<91 60)'")33/ 4(/(5$ /$*>()"*&? +>$0#@ ()4 (AA."*('"0)&7 60)'")303& B(/, (5$ 01 2#"''.$ 90."4&+ A1 B"*>C#$/D#C *$4 ?1 E&F*#3"&+ &451 !"#$%&"'(&")*%+ G#&$',&- ./"0+
HHI'H;J1
*0>#+ 1 8HKKL91 C#0D(D"."&'"* /04$.")5 ()4 $EA$#"/$)'(. F(."4('"0) 01 >$(' '>$ '#()&1$# ()(.@&"&
()4 '>$ '>$#/0/$*()"*(. G"'> 4(/(5$ D$>(F"0# 01 ( *(#4D0(#4,A.(&'$#,*(#4D0(#4 /3.'".(@$#
&3D/"''$4 '0 H#$ .0(4&7 #$ M"&$CN+ O$#D&"5#3P 4& Q*"$&')*'(*))&&+ R"*$C&1
*0>#+ 1+ /#7&+ S1 *$4 T&C0+ ?1'(1 8HKK=91 UVN&"F/'F&CN*$#C*) F/4&) /M * C*"4W/*"4'!)*53&"' C*"4W/*"4 C/F!/5#3& !)*3& 5XWF#33&4 3/ Y"& )/*4 *$4 &Z!&"#F&$351U60/A3'('"0)(. I$'>04&
()4 -EA$#"/$)'& ") I('$#"(. 6>(#(*'$#"&('"0) 88 S1[1 \]^\\2[+ G&55&Z 2$53#3X3& /M V&CN'
$/)/%_ OB *$4 [1[1 Q[QQ6E2+ O$#D&"5#3_ /M ,&- Q&Z#C/+ &451+ G2V V"*$5*C3#/$5 /$
^$%#$&&"#$% C#&$C&5+ (/) =:+ IL=!1
/#7&+ S18HKK=91 U]*$4/F F*3"#Z 3N&/"_ M/" F/4&)#$% X$C&"3*#$3#&5 #$ C/F!X3*3#/$*) F&CN*$'
#C51U 60/A3'$# I$'>04& ") JAA."$4 I$*>()"*& () -)5")$$#")5+ :;J8:H':L9+:III':ILL1
H:
!"#$%&' %( )*+,-' .
!"# $# %&'()*+ +,*- .'/0& 0,)1,2'- ,34 $°4 51'0!)'/ &,+-'(6 7°4 ),.!+' 0*(8 */- 9°4 (*-!*/8 1*/'+#
!"# 7# :/0!-'/8 -'/2!8; &'*8 <=> ?@'(8!0*+ *>!2 !/ AB/)2C *2 * 3=/08!,/ ,3 8!)' ?&,(!D,/8*+
*>!2 !/ 2'0,/-C4 0*+0=+*8'- &'*8 <=> ?8&!0E 2,+!- +!/'C6 %FG )'*2=('- &'*8 <=> ?-*2&'- */- )*(E'- +!/'2C6 =11'( */- +,H'( :5I J9K 'L=!@*+'/8 -'/2!8; <=> .,=/-2 ?-,8M-*2&'- */- -*2&'- +!/'2 ('21'08!@'+;C#
!"# 9# G'/-!/" 8'28 '>1'(!)'/82 3,( -!N'('/8 @*+='2 ,3 8')1'(*8=(' ,/ OPO 21'0!)'/2 0*((!'- ,=8 *00,(-!/" 8, 8&' +,/"!8=-!/*+ -!('08!,/4 "(*1& ,3 8&' )'0&*/!0*+ +,*- ?@'(8!0*+ *>!2
!/ QC *2 * 3=/08!,/ ,3 8&' 8(*/2@'(2*+ -!21+*0')'/8 ?&,(!D,/8*+ *>!2 !/ ))C4 8&!0E 2,+!- +!/'2
?7RSTOC6 8&!/ 2,+!- +!/'2 ?$USTOC6 -,8M-*2&'- +!/'2 ?$7STOC6 8&!/ -*2&'- +!/'2?7STOC#
!"# K# %&'(),)'0&*/!0*+ '>1'(!)'/82 3,( 8&' OPO4 "(*1& ,3 8&' )'*/ V,=/" ),-=+=2
?@'(8!0*+ *>!2 !/ WP*C *2 * 3=/08!,/ ,3 8&' *@'(*"' 8')1'(*8=(' !/ 8&' OPO ?&,(!D,/8*+ *>!2 !/
TOC4 2,+!- +!/' )*(E'- ”∗”?XLLC6 2,+!- +!/' )*(E'-”+”?XT TC6 2,+!- +!/' )*(E'-”T” -*2&'- +!/'
?XLTC#
!"# R# G'/-!/" 8'282 3,( -!N'('/8 @*+='2 ,3 8')1'(*8=(' 0*((!'- ,=8 ,/ 1+*28'( 21'0!)'/24
"(*1& ,3 8&' )'0&*/!0*+ +,*- ?@'(8!0*+ *>!2 !/ QC *2 * 3=/08!,/ ,3 8&' 8(*/2@'(2*+ -!21+*0')'/8
?&,(!D,/8*+ *>!2 !/ ))C4 8&!/ 2,+!- +!/'2 ?(,,) 8')1'(*8=('C6 8&!/ -*2&'- +!/' ?$7STOC6 8&!0E +!/'2?$USTOC6 8&!0E -*2&'- +!/'2?7RSTOC #
!"# Y# %'/2!+' 8'282 ,/ 0*(-.,*(- 3,( 8H, -!N'('/8 @*+='2 ,3 8')1'(*8=('4 "(*1& ,3 *>!*+
28('22 ?!/ WP*C *2 * 3=/08!,/ ,3 28(*!/# 5,+!- +!/'2 ?8'282 *8 (,,) 8')1'(*8=('C6 -*2&'- +!/'2
?8'282 *38'( R)!/ :5I 8&'()*+ +,*-C#
!"# U# 50&')*8!0 ('1('2'/8*8!,/ ,3 0*(-.,*(-M1+*28'(M0*(-.,*(- 1+*8'2#
77
!"# $# %&'()*+ ,!-./!0!12 34 1&' 565 70'(1!8*+ *9!/ !: 7)2//;; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1&'()*+
+3*,!:" 1!)' 7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/ !: 7/;;#
!"# =# %')>'(*1.(' >(3?+'/ !: 1&' 83(' 34 565 >+*1'/# %')>'(*1.(' !: 1&' )!,,+' 34 :.)'(!8*+ +*2'(/ 7@'(1!8*+ *9!/ !:AB; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1&'()*+ +3*,!:" 1!)'7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/
!: /;#
!"# CD# E'8&*:!8*+ *>>+!', +3*, 70'(1!8*+ *9!/ !: F; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1(*:/0'(/*+ ,!/>+*8'G )':1 7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/ !: ));H '9>'(!)':1/ 7,*/&', +!:'/;I :.)'(!8*+ /!).+*1!3: 34 1&' )'*:
)3,'+ *1 (33) 1')>'(*1.(' 71&!8J /3+!, +!:';#
!"# CC# E'8&*:!8*+ *>>+!', +3*, 70'(1!8*+ *9!/ !: F; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1(*:/0'(/*+ ,!/>+*8'G )':1 7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/ !: ));H '9>'(!)':1/ 7,*/&', +!:'/;I :.)'(!8*+ /!).+*1!3: 34 1&' )'*:
)3,'+ *1 CKDA5 71&!8J /3+!, +!:';#
!"# CK# 53:0'("':8' L!1& ('/>'81 13 1&' :.)M'( ns 34 ('*+!<*1!3:/H "(*>& 34 1&' 4.:81!3:
ns 7→conv(ns) 43( :.)'(!8*+ /!).+*1!3: *1 (33) 1')>'(*1.('#
!"# CN# 53:0'("':8' L!1& ('/>'81 13 1&' :.)M'( ns 34 ('*+!<*1!3:/H "(*>& 34 1&' 4.:81!3:
ns 7→conv(ns) 43( :.)'(!8*+ /!).+*1!3: *1 CKDA5#
!"# CO# P'/.+1/ 43( KDA5H )'8&*:!8*+ *>>+!', +3*, 7@'(1!8*+ *9!/ !: F; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1(*:/0'(/*+ ,!/>+*8')':1 7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/ !: ));H '9>'(!)':1/ 7,*/&', 1&!: +!:'/;I :.)'(!8*+
/!).+*1!3:/ L!1& 1&' )'*: )3,'+ 71&!8J /3+!, +!:';I 83:?,':8' ('"!3: L!1& 1&' /138&*/1!8 )3,'+
7"('2 ('"!3:;#
!"# CQ# P'/.+1/ 43( CKDA5H )'8&*:!8*+ *>>+!', +3*, 7@'(1!8*+ *9!/ !: F; */ * 4.:81!3: 34 1&' 1(*:/0'(/*+ ,!/>+*8')':1 7&3(!<3:1*+ *9!/ !: ));H '9>'(!)':1/ 7,*/&', 1&!: +!:'/;I :.)'(!8*+
/!).+*1!3:/ L!1& 1&' )'*: )3,'+ 71&!8J /3+!, +!:';I 83:?,':8' ('"!3: L!1& 1&' /138&*/1!8 )3,'+
7"('2 ('"!3:;#
KN
!"#$% &' ()%$*+, ,-+. /%01) 1-*2-3%. -4' &°' 52%1!*%0 )-,.%$6 7°' *-/!,% 1+$8 +0. 9°'
$+.!+08 2+0%,:
7;
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 0
20 40 60 80
Time (s)
Incident flux density (KW/m²)
!"#$% &' ()*!+%), +%)-!,. /%0, 1#2 34%$,!*05 02!- !) 67/829 0- 0 :#)*,!;) ;: ,!8% 3/;$!<;),05 02!- !) -%*;)+9' *05*#50,%+ /%0, 1#2 3,/!*= -;5!+ 5!)%9> ?@A 8%0-#$%+ /%0, 1#2 3+0-/%+ 0)+
80$=%+ 5!)%-9> #BB%$ 0)+ 5;C%$ (DE FGH %I#!405%), +%)-!,. 1#2 J;#)+- 3+;,K+0-/%+ 0)+ +0-/%+
5!)%- $%-B%*,!4%5.9L
&M
0 5 10 15 20 0
50 100 150 200 250 300
Transversal displacement (mm)
Load (N)
20°C 120°C
170°C
250°C
!"#$% &' (%)*!)" +%,+ %-.%$!/%)+, 01$ *!2%$%)+ 345#%, 10 +%/.%$4+#$% 1) 676 ,.%8!/%), 84$$!%*
1#+ 4881$*!)" +1 +9% 51)"!+#*!)45 *!$%8+!1)' "$4.9 10 +9% /%894)!845 514* :3%$+!845 4-!, !) ;<
4, 4 0#)8+!1) 10 +9% +$4),3%$,45 *!,.548%/%)+ :91$!=1)+45 4-!, !) //<' +9!8> ,15!* 5!)%, :?@AB6<C +9!) ,15!* 5!)%, :DEAB6<C *1+F*4,9%* 5!)%, :D?AB6<C +9!) *4,9%* 5!)%,:?AB6<G
?H
0 50 100 150 200 250 0
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000
Temperature (°C)
Mean Young modulus (MPa)
ELL ETT ELT
!"#$% &' ()%$*+*%,)-.!,-/ %01%$!*%.23 4+$ 2)% 565' "$-1) +4 2)% *%-. 7+#." *+8#/#3 9:%$2!,-/ -0!3 !. ;6-< -3 - 4#.,2!+. +4 2)% -:%$-"% 2%*1%$-2#$% !. 2)% 565 9)+$!=+.2-/ -0!3 !.
>5<' 3+/!8 /!.% *-$?%8 ”∗”9@LL<A 3+/!8 /!.% *-$?%8”+”9@T T<A 3+/!8 /!.% *-$?%8”>” 8-3)%8 /!.%
9@LT<B
CD
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 0
10 20 30 40 50 60
Transversal displacement ( 10−3 m)
Load (N)
!"#$% &' (%)*!)" +%,+, -.$ *!/%$%)+ 012#%, .- +%34%$1+#$% 51$$!%* .#+ .) 421,+%$ ,4%5!3%),'
"$146 .- +6% 3%561)!512 2.1* 70%$+!512 18!, !) 9: 1, 1 -#)5+!.) .- +6% +$1),0%$,12 *!,4215%3%)+
76.$!;.)+12 18!, !) 33:' +6!) ,.2!* 2!)%, 7$..3 +%34%$1+#$%:< +6!) *1,6%* 2!)% 7=>?@A:< +6!5B 2!)%,7=C?@A:< +6!5B *1,6%* 2!)%,7>&?@A: D
>E