Enforcing trace properties by program transformation

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00000937

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00000937

Submitted on 15 Dec 2005

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Enforcing trace properties by program transformation

Thomas Colcombet, Pascal Fradet

To cite this version:

Thomas Colcombet, Pascal Fradet. Enforcing trace properties by program transformation. Principles

of Programming Languages, Jan 2000, Boston. �inria-00000937�

(2)

+,-/.1032546-/798:-/.<;=?> @A0328?037BDCE03FD=?>

G&HIKJML -/N O HMPRQTS

O

PRQUIVS

WXEY&Z\[^]M_\`*a`bXE[\cedf`g[ih3jlkEmEn:o6p `rq^q^`r]W'`g_\`rs/h\t\uvXEq\wg`

xlylzl{?ylzg|}?~U:V?~lV:E:

Dgg^l

`Z\uEZ3l]`&XqX[\lYXdfwY&`r^V_5`gq\Euwg`uvXwg`Z\uEZ3`ru

df`g]6lq1Z\uEEuvXEY&]g ¢¡^`$Z\uEEuvXY&Y&`ru6]Z3`rwgd¤£¥`g]6\`Z\ulZ3`¦uU§

]`rZ¥XuvX`gc¤§¨ulY©^`ªZ\uluvXEY«X5ZulEuvXY©uvXq^]¬uY&`ru®vXE¯l`g]

\`6ZulEuvXY"XEq^_¨\`6Z\uEZ3`ruU§Xq¥_XE[lYXdfwbXcfcf§ZuV_\[^wr`g]

Xq^^`ru$°U`g±V[\df²lXce`rqV³6Z\uluvXEY´]Xde]¬µ§deq\^`®ZulZ3`ru§? ¡^df]

]`rZ¥XuvXdflqwgEq^wg`ruq\]RYXE¯:`r]'^` Z\uluvXEY´`bX]df`ruR_`g²:`gcflZ

Xq¥_YXEdfq?vXEdfq¶ ·[uRXZ^Z\ulXEwv5df]R¸35]¬vXdewAXEq¥_$_§q^XEY&dfwl ¹T

dfq?`guvX`g]]¬vXdfwªXEq^XEc¤§]`g]dfquv_\`ruMXb²:lde_º[\]`gcf`g]]MuvXEq^]¬Eu

YXdflq^]g ·q\`ª^`ru¥Xq¥_ih¥df q^`r²:`ruu`U»¬`gw¦]AZ\uEEuvXEY&] ¸^[

XE_^_]6_V§\q^XEY&dfwwv^`gwv¯V]®¼M^`gq½q\`gwg`g]]Xu§? K¾ q¢deY&Z3uvXEq?ªw¦^XEc¤

cf`gq\l`5de]ª¨YXE¯:`\de]6_§q¥XY&dfw&`gq\Euwg`gY&`rqV6XE]¿dfq^`rsZ3`gq\]de²l`

X]5Z3E]]df¸^cf`l À¡^`KY&l]¬$E¸²Vdfl[\]$XEZ^Z\cfdewgXdflqÁ_lYXdeqÂde]&\`

`rq\uwg`gY&`gq?ªEM]`rwg[\ud¤U§<Z3lcfdfwgdf`g]g K¹qZ¥Xudfwg[^ceXubhX5Z3E`gq?deXEc

[\]`&E\`Y&`r\V_df]®^`]`rwg[\udfÃbXdeEq½ERY&E¸^dfcf`wgV_`&[^Z3lq

u`rwg`gdfZ\b

Ä ÅÀÆ

bÇµÈ\\bÇ

Æ3É

ÉÊ

^ËË

Æ

¥Ì

Í uluvXEY&Y&dfq^½wgXEqÁ¸3`K]`g`gqÎX]5\`vXE]¯Â*dfY&Z^cf`gY&`gq?dfq^¢X

wrlcfcf`gwrdflq'ZulZ3`rudf`g]6Ï^`ª]Z3`gwgd¤£¥wbXdflq3Ð¦ ªÑi`r®[\] ?wr[^]®lq

¼Zul¸\ce`rY&]M\`AZ\uEEuvXY&Y&`ruMYXg§&ÒXEwr`ªdfq$^df]RvXE]¯3

ÓÕÔ¶Ö^×6×Ø¦Ù¥Ú×¦ÛÛÜÝbÜÞÒßªÙ¥Úàlágâe×¦ãä

¾ ²EXEdfceXE¸\ce`®ZuluvXEY&Y&dfq^ceXq\

E[¥XEE`g]$YXE¯:`]EY&`KZ\uEZ3`rudf`g]²:`ru§å_\d¤æ&wg[\c¤$¢deY&Z\cf`r

Y&`gq?b *¡\`ru`Xu`6q\5][\dfvX¸^cf`X¸^]¬uvXwrdflq^]Au`gZu`g]`gq?

\`gYçXq¥_½^`gd¤udfY&Z^cf`gY&`gq?vXdeEq1de]&]wgX`ru`b_1\uE[^l

E[\\` ZulEuvXY è`gwr[\ud¤U§6EuuE¸^[^]¬q\`g]]ZulZ3`rudf`g]RXu`

¼]¬udf¯dfq\$`¦s^XY&Z^cf`g]g équwgdfq^][^wv¨Z\ulZ3`¦ude`r]YXg§

dfqV²:lcf²:`®dfq\]`rudfq^wv^`gwv¯V]MXEcfc²:`¦uR^`AZulEuvXY

ÓÕÔ¶Ö^×RêàEÚvÚ×êrÞÒë/×¦ÛÛÙ^Úà:ágâe×¦ã&ä

¡'¼' ¯Vdfq¥_]¶\XEZ^Zu:Xw¦\`g]^X²l`

¸3`g`rqwglq\]de_\`ru`b_$&Z\u²:`ì`gq^][u`¥XX¿Z\uluvXEYí]Xdf]¬

£^`g]®XZ\ulZ3`¦uU§? *è?vXdfwXZ^Zu:XEwv^`r]A][^wv¢X]uYXEcDZuE

uvXEY"_\`¦ude²EXdfEq¶hD_df]wgdfZ^cfdfq^`g]*EZ\uluvXEY&Y&dfq^<ÏÒ`l \ &`rq\

Euwg`b_¿¸V§ªXU§Z3`']¬§]¬`gYuXA_\EYXEdfq\T]Z3`gwgd¤£^w'ceXEq\l[¥Xl`Ð¦h

Xq¥_A]¬vXdfwZ\uluvXEYîXEq^XEc¤§]`g]wbXq*`gq^][u`ZulZ3`rudf`g]i¼Md¤\

E[\XEq?§*u[^q?dfY&`Z3`gq^XEc¤U§? ïb¼`g²l`rubhl\`r§ªXu`M`gd¤^`¦u²l`ru§

wgE]¬c¤§?h_\`b_dewgX`b_¢¨X]Z3`gwrdf£^wZ\ulZ3`¦uU§?hDu¿u`U»U`gwr¿Z3`ru

`gwrc¤§ÂwrEuu`gwr5Z\uEEuvXY&]¼Md¤\l[\u`r[uq^dfq^¢XEq?§[^]`r[^c

`g`b_\¸^XEwv¯3 ð§q¥XY&dew¢ÏÒEu5]¬§\]¬`rY$ÐXZ^Zu:XEwv^`r]gh ][\w¦ñXE]

Y&Eq^d¤Eu]u]`gwr[\ud¤U§*¯:`¦uq^`gcf]gh`gq\Euwg`^`Z\uEZ3`ruU§®¸^XE]`b_

òó9ôeõ¶ö÷÷µöøUù¶úeøõiûUüUóýöþ¬öúûÿøUôvûôµýøvöó9÷VøûUôfú\øUôûÿÿgø lúö÷:øUôµü

ø¬ôó9ôµ÷eø¬ùûUÿ?ø¬ôÒÿûU÷µ÷ôfø¬ø¬õv÷eóö÷¥þ¬ôeûUù¬úeó9ýVöúøúóÒóvôfø öýó9ý'úûú

øöó9÷3ûôeóùøú3õiûUýó/ø¬ô¥ýö÷µúµôµöúeó9ýø¬ôôfø¤öú3ø¬ôø¬õiõió9ôÒöûÿEûýUûù

úµûþó'ûùýMúûúøöó9÷vó9ûô¶úvö÷ùøúöóûUùýRúóÿÿÒöúûTúöø¬ùMø¬ùRúó

öôe÷µú ûþó!#"bøø$øUúó9ôVö÷µó%vúeøiôeó&ÿö÷'%vúµø(ø¬÷eúøUù÷µó9ô)¬ó9ôe÷ %øUôVúeø

ôfó9ýö÷eúôeö*úeó¶úeøÿö÷µúµ÷ %vôfó&+vöôfó9÷ôµöø¬ô\÷ó&Òööó9ôeõ¶ö÷÷µöøUùDûUùý*,Tø¬ôû(óÒó!

ò.-ò0/21333(4:ø¬÷eúµøUù65798:7

; ø$ôµöþ¬ú7 ; 5<1333=&)>?==&@=&1>)A,33,=!!!B>*!33

lq5]lY&`¯Vdfq¥_E]¬vX`AYXw¦\dfq^` ^XR`r²:lcf²:`g]MXq¥_w¦\`gwv¯]

^`¿Z\ulZ3`¦uU§KdfqZ¥XuvXcfce`rc¼Md¤Z\uEEuvXEY `rs`gwg[\dfEq¶ ª¡^`

YXEdfq_VuvXg¼M¸¥XEwv¯$E\de]XZ^Z\ulXEwvdf]Mdf]Ru[\qVdfY&` wgl]¬b

¹Uq¿^df]Z^XEZ3`rubhl¼`Xl_²:?wbX` XEq\E\`ruXEZ^Zu:Xw¦ih?u`gY&dfq^df]wg`gq?E

XE]Z3`rwrTEudf`gq?`b_åZuluvXEY&Y&dfq^DCE.E'F9h¥X²l`ruwglY&`r]6^`5`rsV

Z\u`r]]de²Vd¤U§5Xq¥_5wrEuu`gwrq\`g]]Z\ul¸\cf`gY&]uX¿Z¥Xudfwg[\ceXuwgceXE]]E

Z\uEZ3`rudf`g]g

¡^`ZulZ3`ru§Kdf]®`rsZ\u`g]]`b_¨]`gZ^XuvX`rcf§uEY ^`¿Z\uEEuvXEY

X&X]Z3`gwrdf£^wbXdfEqÂcf`g²:`gcÒ ¾´Z\uEEuvXY uvXEq\]¬EuY&`¦uvXE¯:`r]6^`

Z\uEEuvXY Xq¥_º^`*ZulZ3`ru§?h3XEq^_KXE[lYXdfwbXcfcf§Z\uV_\[\wg`g] XEq

E\`ru1°U`g±V[\df²lXce`rqV³<Z\uEEuvXEYçu`r]Z3`gwrdfq^¢\`Z\uEZ3`ruU§? Â¡^`

uvXEq\]¬uY&`b_<ZulEuvXY df]®`b±?[^df²EXEcf`gq?A5\`6udeEdfq¥XEcZ\uEEuvXEY

`rswg`gZRudfq^Z\[\]EuM¼M^dfwvº^`A]E[\uwg`*ZulEuvXY´²VdeEceX`g]M^`

Z\uEZ3`ruU§? ¶¹Uq*^df]wgXE]`lh^`uvXEq^]¬EuY&`b_*Z\uEEuvXY Z\uV_[^wg`g]XEq

`rswg`gZdflq&Xq¥_¿]¬EZ^]g ¾q6dfY&Z3EuvXq?w¦^XEcfcf`gq^E`Rde]DAYX¯:`\df]

_§q^XEY&dfw®`gq\Euwg`rY&`gq?AX]dfq^`rsZ3`gq\]df²:`ªXE]Z3E]]df¸^cf`l A¹qKZ¥Xudew¦

[^ceXubh3d¤¼'`ªXu`ªXE¸\ce`*_\`¦`gwr]¬vXdfwbXcec¤§^X^`®]E[\uwg`ªZ\u

EuvXY ]Xdf]¬£¥`r]A^`ZulZ3`ru§?hi\`gqq^uvXEq^]¬EuYXdeEq]^E[^ce_

¸3`*_\Eq^`l

¾Z¥Xudfwg[\ceXud¤U§®^E[\u¶Z\uEZ3l]XEc?df]^X¶d¤wgEY6¸^dfq\`g]XR]¬vXdew

XEq^_Xª_V§q¥XEY&dfwXEZ\Z\ulXEwv¶ ¹dfq?`gEuvX`g]R]¬vXdfw XEq¥Xc¤§\]`r]Rdequ

_\`¦u Xb²:Edµ_[\q^q\`gwg`g]]Xu§5u[\qVdfY&`®wgE]¬b ·q^`®^`ru ¥Xq¥_/h

d¤®_?`g] q\E u`U»¬`gw¦AZ\uEEuvXY&] ¸\[\Xl_^_]_V§q¥XEY&dfw®wv^`gwv¯V]¼M\`gq

q^`rwg`g]]Xu§? ¾q^^`ru]dflq\df£^wbXEq? `bX[\u`ªde] d¤]HG^`rsde¸\dfced¤§(I'Z\u

EuvXY&Y&`ru]wgXEq¨]Z3`gwgd¤§K\`gd¤uAb¼MqZ\ulZ3`¦ude`r]Adfq<X$_\`rwgceXuvXdf²:`

¼RXg§?

`ªwglq\]dµ_`ruA\`ru`ª]X`¦U§KZulZ3`rudf`g] `rsZ\u`g]]`b_KEq¨\`*`rsV

`gwg[dflquvXEwr`g]¿MZ\uEEuvXEY&]g ¡^`&Y&E]¬¿E¸V²dfE[^]ªXEZ\Z^cfdfwbXdflq

_\EYXEdfqKdf]^`*`gquwg`gY&`gq? E]`gwg[\ud¤§KZ3lcfdfwgdf`g]g KJXq?§K]`gwg[

ud¤U§$Z3lcfdfwgdf`g]wbXEq5¸3`A]Z3`gwgd¤£^`b_ºX]ZulZ3`rudf`g]MEq5uvXEwr`g]g Ñi`rM[^]

wgd¤`lhEu`¦s^XY&Z^cf`lh'XEwgwr`g]]¬Twglq?ulcY&V_\`rce]6][^wvåX]^`5^dfl

¼RX`ruTYXu¯KY&V_`gcÒhu®^`&W'\dfq^`g]`¼XEcfcZ3Ecfdew¦§LCE'F9 W'cf`bXuc¤§?h

E\`ruM¯Vdfq¥_\]'EDZulZ3`rudf`g]gh\][^wvºX]M]lY&`A]X`r§5uRul¸\[^]¬q^`r]]

Z\uEZ3`rudf`g]gh¥wgXEq¸3`A`¦s\Zu`g]]`b_X]RuvXEwg`®ZulZ3`rudf`g]g

¾îZ3E`rqVdeXci[\]ÀE^ÀY&`r\V_&de]R\À]`gwg[udeÃgXdflqDY&E

¸^dfcf`wgV_\`M[^Z3Equ`gwg`gdfZb èVvXq¥_^Xuv_¸?§`RwrV_\`Mwglq?vXdeq\]'`gq\l[\l

]¬u[^w¦[\u`KXq¥_ådfqEuYXdflqå¢YXE¯:`$^`XZ^Z\cedfwbXdflqÁEAl[\u

Y&`r\V_¨u`bXcfde]¬dfwl º¡^`6¸3`gq^`r£\*ER][\w¦¢X¿»¬[\]¬Tdeq9deY&`ªuvXEq\]¬

uYXdflq¨df] ^X d¤AwgE[^ce_¸3`6_lq\`¿Xwgwguv_\dfq^&wg[^]¬EY&dfÃg`b_

]`gwg[ud¤U§åZ\ulZ3`¦ude`r]g ¡^df]$wgl[\cµ_ñ¸3`K]`r`gqÎXE]5XMG¥`rsdf¸^cf`¨Xq¥_

]dfY&Z^cf`XEc¤`ruq^Xdf²:`&KZ\u?TwbXuu§\dfq\wrV_\`NCEPOFEuª^`&wrcµX]]

EZulZ3`rudf`g]MwgEq^]de_\`¦u`b_º^`¦u`l

Q R ÈSVÈÇS T

pl[^E^c¤§]Z3`gXE¯Vdfq^\h3¼'`¿]¬vXu ¼Md¤X&Z\uEEuvXEYVU6h/Xq¥_KXuvXEwg`

Z\uEZ3`ruU§XWÁXq¥_6ZuV_\[\wg`XuvXEq^]¬EuY&`b_ZuluvXEY

Ô^ÚYEë\Û CUZW2F

(3)

U

:::å?ylylz???

:::?y:yE:{

|^ ?~E

?y:yEz?V?

y:yl:{

|^ ?~E ! "# |

:y:ylz:V?!$"#

y:yE:{ ! "# y

W&% ÏÏ('*)+-, +.)'\ÐrÏ('/,+Ð 021bÐ 0

Ô\ÚYEë\Û CUZWHF3

?E?~54$6

|¥ ?~l7

7?:::VE?~84*9

?y:ylz8?V?7

7?::::?E?~5446;<:}VzE:

ylyl:{

|¥ :~l=

?ylylz???

yV:yll{

tdfl[u` E.I¾î]YXcfc¶`rs\XY&Z^cf`AEZ\ulZ3`¦uU§$`gq\Euwg`rY&`gq?

u`r]Z3`gwrdfq^<W* ¹T^`&`¦s\`rwg[\dflq<uvXEwg`E*Ï&UZ >?gÐ&Ï\`&]l[uwg`

ZuluvXEY)¼Md¤ ]EY&`îdfq\dfdeXc<]¬u`Ðu`g]Z3`gw¦]ñ^` Z\ulZ3`¦uU§

\`gqÎÏ

Ô^ÚYë^Û

CUZW2F&Z> ? Ð*§df`gce_\]¿^`º]XY&`$u`r][^c¤]g Â· ^`ru¼Mdf]`lh

Ï

Ô\ÚYEë\Û

CUZWHF&Z>3?bÐAZ\uV_\[\wg`g]¿XEq`¦s\wr`gZ\dflqXEq¥_]¬lZ\]»U[^]¬ª¸3`r

Eu`ª²VdeEceXdfq^&^`®ZulZ3`ru§? ¹qºÒXwrbh¥¼`ªXce]&vX¯:`*XE] deq\Z^[X

[^q\wrdflq

YXZ^Z\deq\dfq^]¬u[\wrdflq^] E6U&`g²:`gq?]MEdfq?`ru`g]¬b

¡\df][\q^wrdflq*df]¶\`EuYXc:cfdeq\¯A¸3`r¼`g`gqA\`ZuluvXEY Xq¥_\`

ZulZ3`ru§®¥XDdf]`rsZ\u`g]]`g_ªEq¿^`r]`'`g²:`rqV]g tdfl[\u`HEZu`g]`gq?]

X$]dfY&Z^cf`6`rs\XY&Z^cf`¿¼M\`ru`6^`¿`g²:`gq?]Adfq?`ru`g]¬

|'¨y

Xu`

wgXEcfcf]^`Zu?wg`b_\[u`g]

|¥V ?~l

h

?y:ylz8?V?

hXEq¥_

yV:yl:{

¡\`®Z\uEZ3`ruU§ W*h^`¦s\Zu`g]]`b_5XE]X6u`gl[\ceXu`rsZ\u`g]]dfEq¶h^u`g±V[\d¤u`g]

^XD`r²:`gq?]

|

XEq^_

vXE¯:`Z^ceXEwr`'¸3`rEu``bXw¦*`g²l`gq?

y

¡¥Xde]

]Xg§?h¥Xwrud¤dewgXEcDXwrdflq¨wbXEq\q^ vX¯:`®Z^ceXEwr`ª¸3`¦Eu`*^`®wrce`gXuvXEq\wg`

\`*YXEq¥Xl`ruAXEq^_º^`ªXEwgwrl[^q?vXqV6ÏÒ]`gEu`r:XdfEq<_[\df`g]vÐ¦

¡\`M]l[\uwr` ZulEuvXY YXb§ª²VdflceX`M^df]Z\uEZ3`ruU§ª¼M^`gq\`g²:`ru\`

£\u]¬ªwglq^_\d¤dflq¥Xcdf]®ÒXcf]`l ¡\`6uvXEq\]¬uY&`b_¢Z\uEEuvXYh¶¼M\`ru`

¼XE]]dfEq^Y&`gq?]¿XEq¥_¢Xwglq^_\d¤dflq¥Xc¥Xb²:`¸3`g`rqdfq^]`ru`b_/hDu`r

]Z3`rwr]^`$Z\uEZ3`ruU§ÁÏÒdÒ `l åXE¸3u]¼M^`gq\`g²:`ru¿^`5Z\ulZ3`¦uU§½df]

X¸3l[6¸3`A²VdeEceX`b_^Ð¦

·[uXEZ\Z\u:Xw¦ºwglY&Zude]`r]]`r²:`gqºZ\¥X]`g]g

EE A@

Úà¦Ù\×¦ÚvÞÒßº×¦ë3êàCBEÜëED?ä

`wgEq^]de_\`ruMEq^c¤§]X`rU§$ZulZ3`rudf`g]g«

ÏÒdÒ `l AZulZ3`rudf`g]]¬vXdfq^&¥XAq\°¸¥XE_K\dfq^l³^XEZ^Z3`rq^]vÐ¦

Ñide²l`gq^`g]]MZulZ3`rudf`g]ªÏb°UE?V_º^dfq^E]³_\^XEZ^Z3`rq3Ð'wbXq^q^

¸3`K_V§q¥XEY&dfwbXcfcf§1`rq\uwg`b_ ÏC)EGFF9hC)EGH.FÐ¦ ñ¾í]X`rU§îÏÒEu&`rq\

Euwg`bX¸^cf`Ð5ZulZ3`ru§ñwbXqÎ¸3`wv¥XuvXEwr`¦udeÃr`b_ ¸?§ÂX½]`r

_de]Xcfceb¼'`b_å£¥q\d¤`º`rs`gwg[dflq^]g `5u`g]¬udfwrE[\u]`gcf²:`g]

u`gE[^ceXu]X`¦U§Z\uEZ3`rudf`g]AÏÒdÒ `l D^`]`r'E_\df]XEcfcfb¼`b_`rs`r

wg[dflq^]df]u`gE[^ceXu¦Ð¦ ¡\`McµXq^E[¥XEE`®`¦s\Zu`g]]][^wvZ\uEZ\

`rudf`g]wbXq¸3`¸¥X]`b_6Eq6cflEdewªÏÒ`l \ DÑ\¡RÑMCn0F^u èEè C)EgjFÐ

u¿u`gE[^ceXu¿`rsZ\u`r]]deEq^]g º¡^`&dfY&Z3EuvXq?*Z3ldfq?ªEuª[^]*df]

^X^`®Z\uEZ3`ruU§5wbXqK¸3`®`gq^wgV_`b_¸?§X6£^q^d¤`®]¬vX`ªX[\

EYXlqi &¡\`ceXEq^E[¥Xl`&u`gwgElq^dfÃg`g_¢¸?§K^`X[\EYXlq

¼Mdfcfc3¸3`R^`M]`rE¶XEcfc3X[\^udfÃg`b_Z¥XudeXEc^uvXwg`g]'i`g²:`gq?]g

o? A@

Úà DEÚYEã Yë^ë3àÞ YEÞÒÜ9àEë3ä

¡^`£\u]¬¿Z\¥X]`&de]®cf?wbX`$XEq¥_

Xq^q^vX`ª^`*`g²:`gq?]EdfqV`¦u`g]¬AdfqK^`*Z\uEEuvXY A¡\`g]`

`g²l`gq?]'wbXq5¸3` XE]]dflq\Y&`gq?]ª]Z3`gwgd¤£¥w ²lXudeXE¸^cf`g]ghwbXcfce]

]Z3`gwrdf£^wY&`r\V_\]ghlZ3`gq\deq\¢£¥cf`g]gh'`rwl å¾ cfcMd¤uu`gcf`g²EXEq?

dfq^]¬u[\wrdflq\]Xu` XE]]?wrdµX`b_&¼Mdf&\`M_\[^Y&Yª§*`g²:`gq?JI¥ ¾

¯:`¦§Kwglq\]¬uvXEdfq?®df]A¥X®XZ\uluvXEY dfq\]¬u[^wrdflqdf]®XE]]?wrdf

X`b_º¼Md¤lq\cf§ºlq\`®`g²:`gq?b '¡^df] df]`bXE]¬§5&`gq^][u`A¼M^`gq

`g²l`gq?]Xu`R]Z3`gwgd¤£¥`g_¸¥XE]`g_6]lcf`gc¤§Eq6^`RZuluvXEY ]¬§qVvXs

ÏÒ`l '^` [^q\wrdflq dfqKtdfl[u` EbÐ¦ a[\bh\lq^`A¼'l[\cµ_ºXEcf]

cfde¯l` ª`rsZ\u`g]]ZulZ3`rudf`g]REqå°]`gYXEq?dfwg³ª`g²:`gq?]][^wvºX]

°LK

ÜÛHYEÛÛvÜMDEë/×B6ÞÖ^×Ý0YlâN^×PO

³\ ¹Uq&l`rq^`ruvXc9hEq^`wbXEq\q^E'_\`¦

wgde_\`]¬vXdfwbXEcfc¤§ª¼M^`r\`ruDXq6X]]deEq^Y&`gq?QSR4ñ~7 ¼MdfcfcVl`gq

`ruvX`^df]`g²:`rqVEuq\Eb ¹q*Euv_\`¦u vX¯:`']`gYXq?dew`g²:`rqV]

dfqV*XwgwgE[^q?bhl\`RZ\uluvXEY Y6[\]¬¸3`RuvXEq^]¬EuY&`b_¿¸3`ru`r

¥Xq¥_i 5t^u*¥X*`¦s^XY&Z^cf`lh`bXEwv½XE]]dfEq^Y&`gq?TQJR4:~ wrl[^ce_

¸3`uvXq^]¬EuY&`b_dfq? Á~468UV~ QR4:~ñ~?{:E~ QJR 4l~;V ]

¥X dfq\]¬u[^wrdflq\]Xu`*XE]]?wgdeX`b_¼Mdf¨X¿]deq\lcf`*`g²:`gq?b ¹

df]DXEc¤¼RXg§]Z3E]]de¸\cf`Mdfq^]`ruD][\w¦A`r]¬]XE[lYXdewgXEcfc¤§i«E^`

u`bXEcwv¥Xcecf`gq\l`Eu®^df]®Z\¥XE]`¿df]AXb²:lde_¨dfq^]`rudfq^5]Z^[

udfl[^]A`r]¬]g t^uA¥XAu`bX]lq¶h¶][^wvZ\u`r9uvXEq\]¬uYXdflq\]

Y6[\]¬u`gc¤§ºEq]¬vXdfw®ZulEuvXY XEq¥Xc¤§\]`r]g

j P@

Ú¬à DEÚYEã Y:árÛÞÒÚYlêrÞÒÜ9àEë/ä

¡^`&ZulEuvXY df]¿XE¸\]¬uvXEwr`b_dfq?

X¿uvXEZ^¼M^E]`Aq^V_`g]R_`gq^`Z\uEEuvXY Z3ldfq?]RXEq^_$`g_\l`r]

u`gZ\u`r]`gq?dfq^]¬u[\wrdflq^]g ¡\df]Z^^XE]`$YXE¯:`g]ª^`$wgEu`5E

^`åXEZ\Z\u:Xw¦dfq¥_`gZ3`gq¥_`gq?¢5\`åZuluvXEY&Y&dfq^ÎceXEq

l[^XEl`E 1¹Uq½^df]6Z^XEZ3`rubh¼`5wglq\wg`gq?uvX`5lq1wgEqVuEc¤ G^b¼

EuvXZ^^]$Xq¥_uvXwg`ZulZ3`rudf`g]g î· \`ru$XE¸\]¬uvXEwrdflq\]wbXEq

¸3`MXEwgwrlY&Y&V_^X`b_¿¼Md¤^E[\w¦^XEq\ldfq^A\`RwgEu`ME3\`MXEZ

Z\ulXEwv¶ ¹Uq5Euv_\`¦u6Z\uV_\[\wg`®X6Zu`gwgdf]`*XE¸\]¬uvXEwrdfEq¶h^\df]

Z^^XE]`AYXg§u`gc¤§EqX¿]¬vXdfw®XEq^XEc¤§]de]®ÏÒ`E X¿wgEqVuEc¤ G^b¼

XEq^XEc¤§]de]vÐ¦ ¡\` dfY&Z3uvXEq?Z3ldfq?df]¥X\`]`¦'Xwr[¥Xc

uvXEwg`r]Ïu`r]¬udew¦`b_<`g²:`gq?]vÐ¿df]X<][\¸^]`r\`ºuvXEwg`r]

l`gq\`ruvX`g_1¸?§<^`EuvXZ^ÁÏÒdÒ `l <\`$XE¸^]¬uvXwrdflqdf]6]X`Ð¦

t^Eu ^`*]XE¯l`ªwgceXud¤U§?h¥\`®`gw¦\q^dfwbXcZ¥Xu\`ªZ^XEZ3`ru

df]Zu`g]`gq?`b_¿¼Md¤&]dfY&Z^cf`*ÏÒdfqVuvXZ\u?wg`g_\[\uvXcµÐuvXEZ^\]g ¡^`

`rsV`gq^]dfEqñdfq?`ruZu?wg`b_\[uvXEcÏÒuºwrlq?`rsV9u`g`Ð&EuvXZ^\]

df]5E[\cfdfq^`b_Âdfqñè`gwrdfEqÁn\ `KY&`gq?dflqådfqÁè`rwrdflq kV o

XEq\E^`¦uX¸^]¬uvXEw¦deEq ÏÒwgXEcfcAEuvXZ^\]vÐ&¼M\`ru`<q\`r¼©Z\ulZ3`¦u

df`g] ÏÒ]¬vXw¦¯*ZulZ3`rudf`g]vÐ¦h:¼M\dfw¦6¼'l[\cµ_¿q^E¸3`u`rl[^ceXu'²:`ru

]¬vXEq^_^Xuv_$uvXEwg`g]gh^wbXEq5¸3`®`rsZ\u`g]]`g_i

n\ AW

ÜÚ×êrÞÜë\ÛvÞÒÚNVã×¦ë\Þ YEÞÒÜ9àEë3ä

¡^`'q^`rsVDZ\¥XE]`df]MuvXEq\]¬uY

^`¨EuvXZ^ñdfqÁuv_\`ru$u`gY&²:`uEY d¤]$]`r5EªZ¥XudµXc

uvXEwg`r]^l]`$u¸^de_^_`gqÂ¸?§\`ºX[\lYXlqi Â¾´q^X[\uvXc

de_\`bX®¼E[^ce_$¸3`Mªwglq\]dµ_`ru\` ZulEuvXYÕuvXEZ^5XE]XEq$XE[

lYXlq<XEq¥_¨`rsZ\u`r]]^`ªuvXEq^]¬EuYXdeEqX]*X5Z\uV_[^wr

E/X[\EYXvXRlcfcfb¼`b_¸?§*EZ\dfY&dfÃbXdflq\]g ¡^df]Dde_\`gX df]q^E

]Xdf]¬ÒXwrEu§6Eu¼u`bX]lq\]g tdfu]¬c¤§?hl]deq\wg`^`'l¸V»¬`gwrdf²:`

df] YXZ®^`uvXq^]¬EuY&`b_®EuvXZ^ª¸¥Xw¦¯AX ZuluvXEYh^`

=X7YZ\[AZ\]^Z_Z\] `a_bYCc[ed`ffg[hZ\ij^2kajlmYi\no[cpgGqpajr gaj[sCr [kGZut] ^aj[a

g[=lmY2ij[Z\] [JbYnot `f[iwv[=Z\a7^obL]^2kb[ZxYyZ\ij^2ka(lmY2ijnz`Zg^2bL{oZ\Yu|E}~

(4)

q0

q1

q2

q3

q4 a

m

m c a

c

a

m

c c

a m c

m a

★

v1

v2

v3

v4

v5 v0

v6

★ c 3 a

★

6 m1

4

m5

a 7

c 2

8

{q0, q1, q2, q3, q4}

e T T

T

c a

T

a

T e

Tm T

c m

e Tc Ta Tm

T v3

v2 v1

v4

v5 v0

v6

q3 q4

q3 q4 q2

q0 q2

q3

q1 q1

q0 q4

q2 q4 q3

q1 q0 q2

q4 q3

q3

q4 q4

q2 q0 q1

q4 q4 q4 q0

q3 q4 q2

q3 q0

q1 q1

q1

q3 q2

★6

c8 c 4

★3

7 a 2

m m1

a 5

Ï9X:Ð ÏÒ¸3Ð ÏÒwÐ

tdfl[u`ªoI¾ [lYXEq¢Ï9XlÐ¦h^wgEq?ulc¤&G¥b¼ EuvXEZ\ÏÒ¸3ÐXq¥_5_\d¤u`gwrdfq^]¬u[\Y&`gq?vXdflqÏÒwÐ

u`gZu`g]`gq?vXdfEq<Y¿[^]¬Mu`gYXEdfq¨X]wgcfl]`6XE] Z3l]]df¸^cf`¿&\`

]E[\uwg`EuvXZ^i ¨è`rwglq^_\c¤§?h¼M\decf`dfq?uvXEZ\u?wr`b_\[uvXEc'uvXEZ\^]

Xu`]dfY&deceXu®ºX[\lYXvXhi^df]Adf]®q^A^`¿wbXE]`¿¼M^`gqdfq\

`ruZu?wg`b_[\uvXEc¶wglq?uEcf&G^¼ df]RvXE¯:`rqºdfq?&XEwgwrl[^q?b

`'wv^?l]`u`gZu`g]`gq?\`'dfq?`gEuvXdflq6¥Xq6X[\EYXlq

dfq?$XZuluvXEY EuvXEZ\K¸?§KXEqKdfq\]¬u[^Y&`gq?`b_ºuvXEZ\KEuD

uvXEZ^i ¾TEuvXZ^ df]RX*EuvXZ^`b±?[^dfZ\Z3`b_6¼Md¤ºXE_^_\d¤dflq^XEc

]¬u[\wr[\u`g]¨ÏÒ]¬vX`g]$XEq¥_1uvXEq\]dfdfEqñ[^q\wrdflq\]vÐ¿Y&dfY&dew

\`<X[\EYXlqÁ`¦s\`rwg[\dflqi

`¨¸3`gEdeqÁ¸?§ÂX1_\d¤u`gwr5dfq\

]¬u[\Y&`gq?vXdflq^Xde]'lZ\dfY&dfÃg`b_¸?§¿^`RU¼'ª][\¸^]`b±?[\`gq?

Z\¥XE]`r]g

k?

Üë^Üã¿ÜPYEÞÒÜ9àEë3ä

¡\`6_dfu`rwrdfq\]¬u[^Y&`gq?vXdfEqKde]£^u]¬ ]Z3`r

wgdeXcedfÃg`g_¿\`'ZulEuvXY D¡\de]DZ\¥X]`'dfqV²:lcf²:`g]wglY&Z\[\dfq^

\`']`rD\u`gXEwv¥XE¸\cf`']¬vX`r]Eu`bXEwv¿q\V_\` Ï^df]YXg§*Xb²:Edµ_

dfq^]`¦udeq\[^]`rce`r]]wv^`rw¦¯V]dfq^`AZulEuvXY ceX`ruEq3Ð'Xq¥_$X

uvXq^]¬uYXdflq¿]dfY&deceXuD ^`]¬vXEq^_^Xuv_ªXE[lYXlqªY&deq

dfY&dfÃbXdfEq¶

OV

ÚYEÛÜëED?ä

¡\`6`ruvX]dfq^ºZ\¥X]`ªuvXq^]¬uY&]^`ªY&dfq^dfY&dfÃg`b_

DTEuvXEZ\©dfq$Euv_`ruRª[uq$XE]RYXEq?§uvXq^]d¤dflq\]MXE]RZ3l]]d¤

¸\ce`deq?ª^`de_`gq?df§&[\q^wrdflqi ¡^df]RZ^^XE]`AdfqV²:Ece²l`g]]`g²?

`ruvXc]¬vXdfwXEq^XEc¤§]`g]'IAwv^?E]deq\º^`ªuvXEq\]dfdfEq^]A$`ruvXE]`lh

£^q¥_\dfq\&X6q^`¦¼ÀqV[^Y¿¸3`rudfq^ªE]¬vX`g]gh3Xq¥_ºwgEY&Z^[deq\¿\`

q\`r¼ DTEuvXZ^¶ éDuvXE]dfq\*u`g_\[^wr`g]D^`MqV[^Y6¸3`¦uE/]¬vX`M`g²lE

cf[\dfEq^]$_\[udeq\¢^`º`rs`gwg[\dfEqÀÏÒdÒ `l Î^`KqV[^Y¿¸3`ruªXE]¬

]dflq\Y&`gq?]^X¼E[^ce_¸3`Mdfq^]`ru`b_dfq&Xq&dfY&Z3`ruvXdf²:`RZuE

uvXEY$Ð¦

àEë¥êrÚ×¦ÞÒÜPYEÞÒÜÒàEë/ä

¡\`ÀEZ\dfY&dfÃg`b_TuvXEZ^ Y¿[^]¬å¸3`

[uq^`b_Ádfq?ÂX1Z\uEEuvXEY í¹TKdf]]¬dfcfcª²l`ru§Áwgcfl]`<\`

]E[\uwg`KZulEuvXY<I¨d¤]$q\V_\`g]$Xq¥_å`g_\l`r]u`rZ\u`g]`gq?]&ZuE

uvXEY Z3ldfq?]XEq¥_¿deq\]¬u[^wrdfEq^]g Ñide¯l`^`MXE¸\]¬uvXEwrdfEq¶h:\`

wgEq^wru`¦deÃgXdflqdf]RceXEq\l[^XEl`*_`gZ3`gq^_\`gq?b D¹qºXqV§wgXE]`lh\lq\`

q^`g`g_\]*X5¼Xb§º]¬u`lh`rw¦ihDXq¥_`r]¬ªXº²lXcf[^`Ï\`&XE[

lYXlq]¬vX`Ð®¼Md¤\l[\6X/`rwrdfq^^`&]E[\uwg`ZulEuvXY

·q^`KXcf]½q^`g`b_åX¼Xb§½X¸3Eu&^`ºZ\uluvXEY Î¹qÂceXEq

l[^XEl`r]¼Md¤ª]de_`rT`/`gwr]gh^df]wgXEq*¸3`'_lq\`¸?§ce?wgXEc?uvXEq\]¬

uYXdflq\]ÏÒ`l \ 1dfq^]`¦udeq\¢X]]dflq^Y&`rqV]ghwgEq¥_\d¤dflq^XEcf]vÐ¦

¹Uq&XAZ\[\u`R[\q^wrdfEq¥XEc\ceXEq^E[¥Xl`lhd¤¼'l[\cµ_dfqV²:Ece²l`MXAlcfl¸^XEc

uvXEq\]¬EuYXdflqºdfq5Euv_\`¦uRªu`bXl_^`AX[\EYXlq$]¬vX`

\uE[^l\l[R^`®`rs`gwg[dflq¶

¹Uq½^df]`rsV`gq^_\`b_1X¸^]¬uvXEw¦bh¼'`5?wr[^]&lq1^`$wgu`ºE ^`

Y&`r\V_ih¥Xdf]M]Xg§?h Í ¥XE]`r] nh/kVh¥XEq^_<OÏTè`gw¦deEqKj:Ð¦ Rè`gw¦

dflqn*df]_\`r²:E`b_6®\``¦s`rq^]dflqEi^`X¸^]¬uvXEw¦'uvXY&`r¼u¯

¨^`ºdfq?`ruZu?wg`b_\[uvXEcRwbX]`l ¹Uqåè`rwrdflqÂkVh'¼'`ºZu`g]`gq?bh'dfq

_\`rZ3`gq¥_`gq?cf§EXªZ¥Xudfwg[\ceXuZ\uEEuvXEY&Y&dfq\¿ceXEq\l[^XEl`Eh^^`deY

Z3EuvXq?6ZulZ3`rudf`g]*¥X¿\`5X¸^]¬uvXwrdflqÎÏÍ ^XE]`$j:Ð*XEq^_¢^`

wgEq^wru`rdfÃbXdflqÏÍ ¥X]` Ð'Y¿[^]¬]Xdf]¬§5deq$Euv_`ruR6`rq^][\u`^`

wguu`gwrq^`r]]'E3\`Rlcfl¸^XEc^uvXq^]¬EuYXdfEq¶ Í ¥XE]`r] EXEq^_&oAXu`

q^ _\`g]wrudf¸3`b_5XEq?§$[\u\`rub

JXEq?§ñ¿E[\uº_\`r£^q^d¤dflq\]gh[^q\wrdflq^]ghuºuvXEq\]¬uYXdflq\]

Xu`¿u`gceXdf²:`65]¬u[^wr[u`g]&Ï9XE[lYXEq¶hiEuvXZ^ihDTEuvXEZ\3Ðcf`rµ

dfY&Z^cfdfwgd¤Ddfq6q\EvXdfEq^]g ¡\`uvXEq\]¬uYXdflq\]_`bXEc:¼Md¤6X]dfq^Ecf`

]¬u[^w¦[\u`®Xq¥_ºq\6wgEq\[\]dflqK]^E[^ce_Xude]`E

Dgg^lT ST Æ

¡^`XE¸\]¬uvXEwrµuvXEY&`r¼'Eu¯Xcecfb¼M]M[^]'¿_\`¦£¥q^`l[uMXEZ\Z\ulXEwv5dfq

XE`gq^`rudfwR¼RXg§? `]¬vXu¸?§ªZ\u`g]`gq?dfq^ ^`RX¸^]¬uvXEw¦u`gZu`g]`gq

vXdfEq^]MEZ\uluvXEY&]ghZ\uEZ3`rudf`g]gh^XEq¥_uvXEq\]¬EuY&`g_$ZulEuvXY&]g

`®Zu?wg`g`b_5¸V§\`®_\`g]w¦udeZdflqKE^`A\u`r`A]¬`gZ^]cf`bXl_dfq^6

^`lZ\dfY&dfÃg`b_5deq\]¬u[^Y&`gq?`b_&uvXEZ^i

(5)

ÒÄ É Æ¥É

^.SÀË

Æ

ËSVbÇSå^

Æ

^g `u`gZ\u`g]`rqV5X¢uvXwg`

ZulZ3`ru§¸?§½Xº£^q^d¤`]¬vX`5XE[lYXEq % Ï Z ? ZKZ ZlÐ

¼M\`ru` df]*X$£^q^d¤`6]`¦*E]¬vX`g]gh G?¿^`¿deq\d¤dµXc]¬vX`lh \`

]`¦E£¥q^XEc\Ï9XEwgwg`rZ\dfq^:Ði]¬vX`r]ghK^`XEcfZ^^XE¸3`rYXl_``g²:`gq?]gh

Xq¥_^`uvXEq\]d¤deEqª[^q\wrdflq¶ ¾ q?§ ]¬udeq\¼M\dfw¦ª_\?`r]q^²VdfE

ceX`M\`MZ\ulZ3`¦uU§ªdf]'Xwgwg`gZ`b_¸?§ª\`MXE[lYXEq¶ D¹qZ\uvXwrdfwg`lh

\df]RdeY&Z\cfde`r]¥XRXEcfc¶]¬vX`g]¼Mdfcfc¶¸3`£^q¥Xc3`rswg`gZ\Xª]dfq^lcf`lhuvXEZ

]¬vX`l R¾]M]?lqXE]M^df]RuvXEZ]¬vX`*de]Mu`bXw¦\`b_ih\^`®Z\uEZ3`ruU§$df]

²VdflceX`b_KXEq^_$^`AXE[\EYXEq5¼Mdfcfcu`gYXEdfq5deq$^df]M]¬vX`l

¡^`]`rRE`g²:`gq?']¬udeq\l]R²:`¦udfµ§deq\ª\`ZulZ3`ru§&df]M_\`r£^q^`b_

¸?§

Ï¿Ð % x

0

,\Ï ? Z Ð

¼M\`ru`lhXE]Ad¤®df]®wgEY&Y&lqih¥^`ªuvXEq^]d¤dflq¨[\q^wrdfEq¥X]A¸3`g`gq

`¦s`rq¥_\`g_$uEY´cf`r`ru]M6]¬udfq^E]g

tdfl[u`®oEX®Zu`g]`gq?]\` X[\EYXlq_`rudf²:`b_6µulYZ\ulZ3`¦uU§

WMtdfl[\u`<EE $¾uvXq^]d¤dflq¢¼Md¤¢\`&_\[\Y&Y¿§`r²:`gq?eI ^XE]

¸3`r`gq1Xl_\_\`b_<Eu¿`bXEwv½]¬vX`E ^`gq\`g²:`ru®\`Z\ulZ3`¦uU§<de]ª²VdfE

ceX`b_ih^`X[\EYXlql?`r]5Xq¥_½u`gYXEdfq\]gh'dfq1^`5uvXZå]¬vX`

l

Æ!

¢A¥ ^ËDÌ `'u`rZ\u`g]`gq?XZulEuvXYXE]X u?E`g_

uvXEZ\" % Ï$#6Z&%8?.Z Ð¦ ¹Uq?[^d¤df²:`gc¤§?hE²:`rudfwg`g]MÏ$#ªÐ¶u`gZ\u`g]`rqVZuE

uvXEY Z3ldfq?]gh\`$u?Ï% ?

#ªÐ¿_`gq^`g]¿\`£\u]¬ZulEuvXY

Z3EdfqVbhD¼M\`ru`bX]6`b_l`g]5Ï(' #*)+)-,.)+#ªÐAu`rZ\u`g]`gq?¿dfq\

]¬u[\wrdflq\]l`rq^`ruvXdeq\`g²:`gq?]MEdfq?`ru`g]¬¿Ï

RÐ¦ `*]Xg§º¥X

Xq*`b_\E`Ï%Z'Z/Z%0ÐiEu%2143

5!6

%0VE`gq^`ruvX`g]\`'Xq^q^vX`b_®`g²l`gq?

'87?«^`¿dfqV`rl`ru9/¨]`ru²:`g]A$de_\`gq?d¤§¨\`6dfq^]¬u[\wrdflq¢ZuV_\[\wr

dfq\º^``r²:`gq?b ``rsV`gq¥_K^`6q^EvXdflq¢5Z¥X\]*XEq^_¼Rud¤`

%;:

5!6

%0/EuXªZ¥X$µulY<%9%0¶E`gq^`ruvXdfq^6\`]¬udfq^DXq\

q\EvX`b_$`r²:`gq?] Ï Ï$=)>,$Ð

0

Ð¦ ¡^`A]`rEDXcfciZ^XudeXEc3uvXwg`g]

E`gq^`¦uvX`b_º¸?§5X6uvXEZ^?"de] _\`¦£¥q^`g_5X]

@&Ï"Ð % x Ï$A)B,$Ð 0 ,8CD% #ZE%

? :

5!6

%

`®¼Rudf`

Eu\`*]¬udeq\&E`g²:`rqV]l¸vXEdfq^`g_¸V§5l`¦deq\&udµ_

D^`Adfq?`gE`ru]Mdeq

tdfl[u`¢o¸ÁZ\u`g]`rqV]&\`u?E`b_ñuvXEZ^ñ_\`rudf²:`b_ulY \`

ZuluvXEY UÎitdfl[\u` EE W'lq?ulc¤&G¥b¼å`b_\E`g]wrEuu`g]Z3Eq¥_\dfq\*

d¤uu`gcf`g²EXEq?dfq^]¬u[\wrdflq^]M¸3`bXuM^`®_[^Y&Y¿§`g²:`gq? I^

É Æ S Ê Ë

Æ!

¢º¥ GF ^ËDÌ

IH

de²l`gq¢XEuvXZ^"

ÏÒdÒ `l ÕXEq XE¸\]¬uvXEwrºZ\uEEuvXEY$ÐXEq^_ÎXEqÎXE[lYXlqJ ÏÒdÒ `l ÕX

uvXwg`ZulZ3`ru§¥Ðª]¥Xudfq\<^`º]XEY&`º`r²:`gq?&]`rK h'¼`]`g`r¯1

_`rudf²:`ªX&q^`r¼îEuvXZ^¼M^dfwv¨l`gq\`ruvX`g]^`*]XEY&`®]`¦AEZ^XudeXEc

uvXwg`g]RX]L"`rswg`gZ\^E]`dfqV²lXcfdµ_\X`b_¸?§¿^`XE[lYXEq¶ ¡\`

dfq?`guvXdflq$EXEq5XE[lYXEq&dfq5X*EuvXZ^df]'u`gZu`g]`gq?`b_&¸?§&XEq

Üë^ÛÞÒÚNVã&×¦ë^Þ×B DEÚYvÙ\Ö ÏÒEu NM

DEÚYvÙ\Ö Ð¦

¾ DuvXEZ\ % Ï" ZO ZP ? Z&Q ZRÐ®de]ªYXl_`&EXuvXEZ^S"'hDX

]`¦®E]¬vX`g]TO¿hiXEq¨dfq^d¤deXEcD]¬vX`>P?

O¿h/Xwglcfcf`gwrdflq<E£¥q^XEc

]¬vX`g]R]`r]NR % x

VU ' O ,W%

#

h\XEq^_5X*uvXEq^]d¤dflq$[\q^wrdflq

Q I1Ï$J)?,$Ð

6 O 6

O¿ `®¼Rud¤`XQDY&ÏÒdfq^]¬`bXE_KEZQDÏ[ÐÐREu

\`uvXEq\]d¤deEqº[\q^wrdfEqXE]]?wrdµX`b_º¼Md¤º^`AXEq^q\EvX`b_5`g²l`gq?

[:

¡^`6deq\]¬u[^Y&`gq?vXdeEq¨`gq^wgV_`g]A^`¿]¬vX`g]ªXq¥_K^`¿uvXq^]d¤

dfEq^]^`ªXE[lYXEq¶ éXEwvKEuvXZ^Kq^V_`¿df]`b±?[^dfZ^Z3`g_º¼Mdf

X]`¦6R£¥q¥Xc']¬vX`g]5Ï9Xwgwg`gZdfq^¨]¬vX`g]vÐ*XEq^_¢`bXw¦1Xq^q^vX`b_

`r²:`gq?MwglY&`r]M¼Md¤KXªuvXEq^]d¤dflq[^q\wrdflq5¼M\dfw¦º¼MdfcfcYX¯:`\`

X[\EYXlqº]¬vX`®`g²:Ecf²:`®XEwrwgEuv_deq\6^``g²:`gq?b

¡^`®]`¦ Z¥XudµXciuvXwg`g]E\` TuvXEZ^ ådf]_\`r£^q^`b_5XE]

@ÏÐ %

x

Ï$+)9,$Ð

0

,\CD%

#6ZZ% ? :

5!6

%^]_Q

:

ÏP?bÐ

U

¼M\`ru`R^`'uvXq^]d¤dflq6[^q\wrdflq>Q^XE]¸3`g`gq¿`rsV`gq¥_`b_ªA]¬udfq\l]

Ï`Q

:

Uh%AQDULabQ

:

Ð¦

Äon

ë$Üë^ÛÞÒÚNã&×¦ë^Þ×BADEÚYvÙ\Ö ÜÛ

Û YEÜjB&ÞTàº×¦ëpgàEÚ¬ê¦×*ÞÖ^× Y NVÞTàEã YEÞTàEë Üq

@&Ï'ÐJ%

xW_

@&Ï"Ð , r

Ï¿Ð

mQ Ì S Ê Ç SlÇÉ ggW S É g\bÇÆ3É

¡^`A_\d¤u`gwrMdfq^]¬u[\Y&`gq?vXdflq$EX¿uvXEZ^B"½XEq^_5XqXE[lYXlq

vXE¯:`g]R\`A]`rED]¬vX`g]Es XE]Md¤]M]`rED]¬vX`g]gh^\`Adfq^d¤deXEc

]¬vX`ºE XE]&d¤]&dfq^d¤deXEc]¬vX`Eh^`5]`rEA£^q¥XcR]¬vX`g]EV

XE] ^`*]`r®Xwgwg`gZdeq\]¬vX`g]Eu®`gXEwvq\V_\`lhiXq¥_¨XE]]?wrdµX`g]

`bXw¦1`b_l`¼Mdf\`&uvXEq^]d¤dflq1[\q^wrdfEq½EN ]Z3`gwgdeXcedfÃg`g_1

^``b_\E`®`g²:`gq?b t^uYXEcfc¤§?h ute% Ï" Z Z C?ZQ ZRÐ¼Md¤(I

Ó R % x U %v ,X% #

Ó

Q/%Jw![xwzy{x\Ï$y.Z [Ð

¹df]`gXE]¬§½¨w¦\`gwv¯¢¥X6^`5_\d¤u`gw¦&dfq^]¬u[^Y&`rqVvXdflq½`gq

uwg`g]N©ÏÒð`r£¥q\dfdfEq EÐ¦

tdeE[\u`AowZ\u`g]`gq?]^` _\d¤u`gwr'deq\]¬u[^Y&`gq?vXdeEq&Ei^`MZ\u`¦

²Vdfl[^]EuvXZ^Xq¥_&XE[lYXlq¶ Dé_l`g]'Xu`_\`gwrEuvX`g_¸?§6XuvXEq

]d¤dflqÂvX¸^cf`KXEq^_q\V_\`g]&¸?§X]`rE®]¬vX`g]&¼M^`ru`XEwgwg`rZ\dfq^

Ï£¥q^XEcµÐ']¬vX`r]Xu`®[^q¥_`rucfdfq^`b_/

¡^df]M]lcf[\dflqºwbXEq5¸3`A]`g`gqKX]XªuvXEq\]¬uYXdflq¸^XE]`b_5deY

Z^cf`gY&`rqVvXdflq®E]¬§]¬`gYÎ¯:`ruq\`gc:XZ^Zu:XEwv¶ éXEwvª`r²:`gq?iEdfqV`¦u

`g]¬MdfqV²:lcf²:`r]MX6]¬vX`AuvXq^]d¤dflqº^`[^q¥_`ruc¤§deq\X[\lYXlqi

t^uMXEqdfY&Z3`ruvXdf²:`Z\uEEuvXYh?^df]¼'l[^ce_Y&`bXEqXqºX]]dflq^Y&`rqV

XEq^_ÂX¨`g]¬¸3`ru``bXw¦åZ\uluvXEY dfq^]¬u[\wrdflqål`gq\`ruvXdfq^XEq

`g²:`rqVb ¹Mdf]Rl¸V²Vdfl[^]c¤§$Y6[\w¦Y&u`wgE]¬cf§^XEqºq\`gwg`g]]Xu§? `

?wr[^]q^b¼ lqºEZ\dfY&dfÃbXdfEq^]E\`®_\d¤u`gwrdfq^]¬u[\Y&`gq?vXdflqi

m Å ÇÉ Ç¢Çi|:\bÇ Æ3É

¡^`$X[\lYXlq]Z3`rwgd¤£¥`g]¿Xl`gq\`ruvXEcZ\uEZ3`ruU§<dfq¥_\`rZ3`gq¥_`gq?cf§

E*ZuluvXEY&]g ¾ ZuluvXEY YXg§ÂE¸3`r§å\`KZ\uEZ3`ruU§ÂXEq^_ñq^

uvXEq\]¬uYXdflq$df]q^`g`g_\`b_&dfq&^df]wbX]`l 'è\h?\`£\u]¬]¬`gZdf]'

]Z3`gwgdeXcedfÃg`*^`*X[\EYXlq56^`®ZulEuvXY `®wglY&Z\[\`lh[\]¬

dfq^*XA]¬vXq¥_^Xuv_6£^sVTZ3ldfq?d¤`ruvXdflqih?^`M]`rE3u`bXw¦^XE¸\ce`]¬vX`r]

X`bXw¦ºZ\uluvXEY´Z3Edeq?PI

} % #

Ú×Y:êvÖ

Ï%Ð % x Q :

ÏP?bÐh,D% ? :

5!6

%

ðA`r`rwrdfq^¥X*^`&uvXEZ]¬vX`wbXEq\q^E¿¸3`u`bXw¦\`b_½X6XZ\u

EuvXYíZ3ldfq?MZ3`ruY&d¤]]Xb²:`*X¿`g]¬b

`wbXq<q\b¼ Y&deq\dfY&deÃr`¿^`¿[^q^_\`ruc¤§dfq^X[\EYXlqi ¡\df]

de_\`bXdf]A]dfY&dfcµXu®&^`ª]¬vXEq¥_\Xuv_XE[lYXEq¨Y&deq\dfY&deÃgXdflq(I d¤

^`RceXq^l[^XEE`Mu`rwglEq^dfÃg`b_]¬vXudeq\uEYU¼]¬vX`g]df]\`R]XEY&`

^`rq\`M]¬vX`g]wgXEq¸3`Y&`ruE`b_i ¹Uq&l[uwbX]`lh][^wv$X*ceXq^l[^XEE`

df]A^`ª]`r*E'XE[^udeÃr`b_<Z^XudeXEcDuvXEwr`g]®]¬vXudfq^uEY X5q\V_\`

%ºdfqX]¬vX`9P A¡^df]ceXEq\l[^XEl`6de] ¼Rudf`rq@&Ï2C%ZP~

6 % ? Z&P

?

FÐ

¼M^`¦u` HC%ZPT~

6

% ?.ZP? Fde]\`'dfq^]¬u[\Y&`gq?`b_®EuvXZ^ K¼M^`¦u`'^`

u?EA¥XE] ¸3`g`gqKwv¥Xq^l`g_KI%5XEq^_K\`*deq\d¤dµXcD]¬vX`*IP ¡'¼

]¬vX`r]u`bXEwv¥X¸^cf`KXq^V_\`%½Xu`5wglq\]de_\`ru`b_`b±?[^df²EXEcf`gq?Ï9Xq¥_

wbXqº¸3`AY&`ruE`b_¥Ðd¤^` cµXq^E[¥XEE`®l`gq\`ruvX`g_5]¬vXudfq\6uEY%&df]

^`]XEY&`Au¸3E]¬vX`g]g t^EuYXcec¤§?h

P

V9

U PWv@ÏHC%ZP

V ~6

% ?.ZP? FÐ %v@Ï2C%ZPWu~

6

% ?.ZP? FÐ

¡^`*u`gceXdflq

TU6df]AXqK`b±?[^df²EXEcf`gq^wr`*u`rcµXdflqXEq^_º¼`*¼Rudf`

êgâ)YEÛÛ

U

ÏPlÐ½Eu^`Á`b±?[^df²EXEcf`gq\wg`ÎwgceXE]]Â-P

H

de²l`gq´XEq´dfq

]¬u[^Y&`rqV`g_uvXEZ^ Mhdf]Y&dfq^dfY&dfÃbXdeEqÂdf]&¼Rud¤`gq Õ¼Md¤

% Ï" ZOe ZP\? Z&Q ZRZRÐXEq¥_I

Ó

Oez%_

UW\

x

êgâ)YÛvÛ

U

ÏPlÐh,DP

Ú×Y:êvÖ Ï%Ð

(6)

Ó P ? % êgâ)YEÛÛ

3

ÏP ? Ð

Ó

R % x

U , % #

ÜÞÖ

TU % x

êgâ)YÛvÛ

U

ÏPlÐP,P

U

Ú×Y:êvÖ Ï%Ð

Ó } % Y

5z6

%0 Z } P

Ú×Y:êvÖ Ï%ÐZ

Q

Y Ï

êgâ)YEÛÛ

U

ÏP:ÐÐJ%

êgâ)YEÛÛ U

Ï`QDYÏP:ÐÐ

¡\`Â]¬vX`g]1Xu`åq^b¼ç^``b±?[^df²EXEcf`gq\wg`ÂwgceX]]`g]1E$u`bXEwv¥X¸^cf`

]¬vX`g]gh^`&q\`r¼Õdfq\dfdeXc]¬vX`$df]ª\`$`g±V[\df²lXce`rq^wg`&wgceX]]ER\`

dfq\dfdeXc]¬vXÈh\\Àq^`r¼Î£^q¥XEc/]¬vX`g]XuÀ^``b±?[^df²lXcf`gq^wg`wgceXE]]`g]

/^`Ru`bXEwv¥X¸^cf`R£¥q^XEc^]¬vX`g]ghXEq^_ih:Eu`bXEwv&`b_l`N%

Y

5!6

%09h:\`

uvXq^]d¤dflq[^q^w¦deEqYXEZ\]^`A`g±V[\df²lXce`rqVMwrcµX]] D`bXw¦ºu`gXEwv\

X¸^cf`®]¬vX`ePªdfq?%6^``b±?[^df²lXcf`gq?MwgceXE]]EsQDYEÏPlÐ'dfq?%09

v5

v6 v4 {q2} v3

{q3}

{q2, q3}

v2 v1 {q2}

{q0}

v0

{q2, q3}

{{q0}, {q4}}

{q4}

{q2}

{q3}

{q4}

{q2}

{q0}

{q4}

{q2, q3}

{q4}

{q3}

{q0}

{q2}

{q3}

{q4}

{q0}

{q4}

{{q0}, {q4}}

{{q3}, {q4}}

{{q2}, {q3}}

{{q2, q3}, {q4}}

★3 a 2

m5

a

c 8 m

7 1

★6

c4

tdfl[\u`*jI Jºdeq\dfY&deÃgXdflq

¡^`ºY&deq\dfY&deÃgXdflq1E ^` TEuvXZ^EAtdeE[\u`ow df]Zu`r

]`rqV`g_deqtdeE[\u`ªj R¡^`*]¬vX`g] XEq^_B *¥Xb²:`®¸3`g`gqºY&`rul`b_

XAq\V_\`e% Ï9XEcfcuvXwg`g]]¬vXudfq^ulY % dfqK^`*]¬vX`9 4®EuV

Xu`X[\^udfÃg`b_¥Ð¦ ¡^`r§½Xu`u`gZ\u`g]`rqV`g_1¸?§<^`$]deq\lcf`º]¬vX`

¼Rud¤`gq

x

4.Z

¡^`MY&dfq^dfY&dfÃbXdeEqZ\u?wr`g]]_?`g]q\Ewv¥XEq\l`R^`R]`rYXEq?dfwg]

X DuvXEZ\¶

8lDd\j Q

àEÚ YlââVÜë^ÛÞÒÚNã&×¦ë^Þ×BPDEÚY¦Ù\Ö

@&Ï'ÐJ%v@$Ï

Ð

¾ ]*u&X[\lYXvXºY&dfq^dfY&dfÃbXdfEq¶h\`$Y&dfq\deYXc TEuvXZ^½df]

[\q^de±?[^`¿[^Z¨ºdf]lY&uZ^^df]Y ¾`¦u*Y&deq\dfY&deÃgXdflqih`bXw¦<q^V_`

^` dfq^]¬u[^Y&`rqVvXdflq$EDXªEuvXZ^$l¸3`r§dfq^ª^`AZulZ3`ru§¼Mdfcec

^Xb²:`AXª]deq\lcf`u`bXw¦^XE¸\ce`]¬vX`l a'[^` YXEdfq¸3`gq^`r£\REY&dfq^d¤

Y&dfÃbXdflq¨df] &YXE¯l`A^`*q^`rsVuvXEq\]¬EuYXdflq¨Y&Eu`*`/`gw¦de²l`

Xq¥_56ce`gXl_5EZ\dfYXEc/dfq^]¬u[\Y&`gq?vXdflq\]®ÏÒ]`g` Í ulZ3`ru§KkEÐ¦

m

É

bÇgÇ

Æ3É SV¥bÇ

É

¡¶uvXq^]d¤dflq^]MX]]?wgdeX`b_$¼Mdf5`b_\E`g]'u`gZu`g]`gq?\``g²:Ecf[\dflq$E

]¬vX`r] Xq¥_&¼Mdfcec¶`gq?vXEdfc/q^`r¼ wgV_`6¸3`deq?uV_[^wg`b_dfq5\`AZ\u

]¬udf²:`A&X]]?wgdeX`¿XE]MYXEq?§`b_l`g] XE]MZ3l]]df¸\ce`®¼Md¤º\`Ade_\`gq

d¤U§®[^q^w¦deEq¶ `'wbXcfc\de]uvXq^]¬EuYXdfEq

ÞÒÚYEë\ÛÜÞÒÜ9àEëº×¦ÚYÛvÜë!D

Ñ¶`¦&[^]ªvXE¯:`ºX¨`r¼í¸¥X]dew5`rs\XEY&Z\ce`r]¿decfcf[^]¬uvX`º^`5de_\`bX¨E

`ruvX]deq\\

{1, 2}

{0, 1}

{1}

0 1

v1

2 v3

1 1

0 0 1 1

1 1 0

v4 v0

6

{0, 1}

v1

v3 v4

v0

¾ cfc^`*uvXEq\]d¤deEq^]AEqK^`*Eudfldfq^XEcMÏÒcf`r¦Ð DTEuvXZ^¨wbXEq¨¸3`

u`gZ\cµXwg`b_K¸?§de_\`rqVd¤§ºuvXEq\]d¤deEq^]g ¹UqKEuv_`ru¯:`r`gZ^`ª]XEY&`

ceXEq\l[¥Xl`E'uvXEwg`g]ghDXEwgwg`rZ\dfq^]¬vX`g]ªY6[^]¬A¸3`w¦^XEq\l`b_ÂÏÒ]`r`lh

uª`rs\XEY&Z^cf`lh¶^`q\V_\`% Ð¦ $¾ cf]hD]lY&`]¬vX`g]*YXg§¨¥Xb²:`6

¸3`ªXl_\_\`b_X®Xq\V_\`ÏÒ`l \ M¸3K]¬vX`g] mXEq¥_ E6Xq\V_\`e% dfq

^`udfl? TuvXEZ^$u`gZ\u`r]`gq?]9EAdfq$\`cf`rµ Eq^`Ð¦ ¡\df]R`ruvXE]dfq^

EDuvXq^]d¤dflq\]wgXEq¸3`*_lq^` EuXEq?§u`g`A]^XEZ3`b_5EuvXEZ\¶

¡^`]XY&`de_\`bXwbXEqÀXEcf]ñ¸3`XZ^Z\cedf`b_ÎÂ^`ruK§\Z3`r]E

EuvXZ^\]gh¥X]\`Ececfb¼Mdfq^`rs\XEY&Z\cf`A]^b¼M]g

{0, 1}

v0

v1 0 0

0 1 1

0 1

1

6

{0, 1}

v0

v1

¡^`*U¼&uvXq^]d¤dflq^]Xu`ª`b±?[¥XcXEq^_Kdf df]q\E q^`gwg`r]]Xu§

_\df]¬dfq^E[^df]^`¼¨Z¥X^]g a'EuvXq^]d¤dflq^]¿wbXEq¢¸3`$`¦uvXE]`b_

]dfY6[\cfvXq^`gE[^]c¤§?

· Dwgl[u]`lh¥q\EM`g²l`ru§uvXEq^]d¤dflqºwbXEq¸3`®`¦uvXE]`b_/

{0, 1}

v0

v1 1 0

0 1 1

0 1

1

6

{0, 1}

v0

v1 0 0 1

0

^Eu

{0, 1, 2}

{0, 1}

v1 v0

0 1

0 2

¹Uq½\de]6wbXE]`lh¼`YXg§¢w¦\?l]`º`ruvXE]`5^`$ce`¦Eu6^`udeE?

uvXEq\]d¤deEq¶h^¸^[\Mq\EM¸3¶

¹Uql`gq\`ruvXEcÒh¼'`6wbXq^q\E*`ruvX]`6uvXEq\]dfdfEq^]®¼M^`gq¨U¼'ºZ^X^]

uEY \`&]XEY&`q^V_`%\`&]XEY&`q^V_`I% 0 YXEZ^`]XEY&`

]¬vX`XP&U¼5_\d/`ru`rqV ]¬vX`r]TP

V

Xq¥_?P

¹lq^`¿XE]]?wrdµX`g]

`g²:`¦u§`b_\E`E¶^`g]` Z¥X^]'¼Md¤5\`de_\`rqVd¤§uvXEq\]dfdfEq¶h^`ru`

df]q^¨¼RXg§1½_\d/`ru`gq?deX`BP

V

XEq^_ P XI%0AXqV§Y&u`l ñ¡\df]

¼E[^ce_º¸3`®dfq^wrEuu`gwr]dfq^wr`*\`AceXEq\l[¥Xl`g]V@&ÏHC%0Z&P

V ~6 % ? Z&P ? FÐ

XEq^_?@&ÏHC% 0ZPW ~6

%8?.ZP?*FÐRY&dfl?M¸3`*_\d/`ru`rqVb '¾ w¦[¥XEcfc¤§?h^X`¦u

Y&dfq^dfY&dfÃbXdfEq¶hM^`g]`ceXEq\l[¥Xl`g]

ã NVÛÞ

¸3`_\d/`ru`gq?b ¡\de]5df]

13qt`b^2ffqGZ\]`a3b^a\[wYCbbri\a lmY2i*Z\][bY2kGZ\ijY2f8Y dpYlEbY2kc `Zx`Y2k^2fa ^2kc

fYCYt aL