Large-scale networked systems: from anarchy to geometric self-structuring

HAL Id: inria-00196714

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00196714v2

Submitted on 13 Dec 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Large-scale networked systems: from anarchy to geometric self-structuring

Anne-Marie Kermarrec, Achour Mostefaoui, Michel Raynal, Gilles Trédan, Aline Viana

To cite this version:

Anne-Marie Kermarrec, Achour Mostefaoui, Michel Raynal, Gilles Trédan, Aline Viana. Large-scale

networked systems: from anarchy to geometric self-structuring. [Research Report] PI 1876, 2007,

pp.21. �inria-00196714v2�

I ^R

I ^S

A

I ^N S T IT ^U

T ^D E R

E ^C H E R C ^H

E E N I N ^F O R ^M

A T ^IQ U E E ^T

S Y ^ST ÈM E ^S

AL É A ^T O ^IR ES

P U B L I C A T I O N I N T E R N E

N ^o

I R I S A

CAMPUS UNIVERSITAIRE DE BEAULIEU - 35042 RENNES CEDEX - FRANCE

ISSN 1166-8687

1876

! #"

$%&! '() * +&!, -. /$0 1 324526'-78

ANNE-MARIE KERMARREC ACHOUR MOSTEFAOUI

MICHEL RAYNAL GILLES TREDAN ALINE VIANA

I NSTITUT DE R ECHERCHE EN I NFORMATIQUE ET S YSTÈMES A LÉATOIRES

Campus de Beaulieu – 35042 Rennes Cedex – France Tél. : (33) 02 99 84 71 00 – Fax : (33) 02 99 84 71 71 http://www.irisa.fr

! " "

#

$ %&'()* "+,-

#

./010+%

2%33465798:<;=4?>@4A:<BC8:D:<4AE.F 2EHGIKJ:%7LIKM,NO46PQ8IKJ;RFKF

7L;=EHG4AS!TU8WV38S FKFF X ;=SYS=4AM'Z[:<4]\^83 FFKFKF 2%S=;Y34%_%;`838 FKFKFKFF

acbWdQegfDhjiDd!k,l6hjh$m.n opkDqrnAesd

tvu l6wRie!xya.x t

t m.z.{po|k,qHeso}l]n~o}nAegi u n in€DA‚rƒ„†…[‡<ki,h*z u iˆ6‰6‰W‚„Š€<‹*ŒqrŽ6i<d

‘’D“,”H•.–r“]— aWi,{}˜š™›dRe um kegm u opn.Žo}n{|q u Ž6i,™`dsk,q6{}in.i,eRœl ugž iDŸdQbcdQegi,hd u i˜ i u degles¡.i1qrz o}{po¢eRbylr˜Weg¡ ivŒ q u ego|kopŒ qregopn.Ži,nAego}egopiDd

egl%kl]{}{|qrzl u qHeso}£]i,{pbUoph'Œl]dgijq‘Ž6iDl6hjie uo|kdQe u m k¤esm u ieglUeg¡.i'n.i,eRœl ugžK¥y¦ ¡ opddRe u mk¤egm ui*h'opŽ6¡Ae{}i<q6Ÿ~eslq‘Ž]i,l]Ž u qrŒ.¡.o|k

l u Ž]q6n.op§DqHeso}l]njlr˜n.lcŸciDdl u q¨˜ m.n kegopl6n q6{dQe u m kegm u o}n Ž$œ¡.i ui!Œq u ego|kopŒ qHeso}n.Ž$i,nAego}egopiDdŽ6i,eq6dsdQopŽ6n iDŸq$dgŒiDko}©k!˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n

opnªeg¡.i%n.i,eRœl ugžK¥@« i,eD¬1dgi,{}˜š™`dQeu m kegm u o}n Ž?opd'i,­Ae u iDhji,{pb®¡ q u Ÿªegl®q]k¯¡.opi,£6iUœ¡.i,n°n l±Ž6{pl6zqr{1opnc˜ l uhqHeso}l]n²qrzl6m.e$eg¡ i

n.i,eRœl ugž o|d!qO£Hqrop{pq6z.{pi ¥

³nªes¡.opd*Œ q6Œi u ¬œi‘Œ u iDdgi,nAe$es¡.iŸci<dQopŽ6n°q6n Ÿes¡.iUiD£Oq6{}mqHegopl6nªl6˜[q~˜ m.{p{}b°Ÿ.iDkiDnAe u qr{po}§DiDŸqrn Ÿ u l]z.m dQe$Ž6iDl6hjie u o|k

dgi,{}˜š™`dQe u m k¤esm u o}n.ŽjqrŒ Œ u lAq6k¯¡ u i,{pbWo}n Žjdgl6{pi,{pbl6n%{plWkDqr{Kl6zdQi u £HqHeso}l]nUl6˜n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl u opn.Ž'k,l6n.n iDk¤eso}l]n d˜ l u dgi,n dgl u n.i,eRœl ugž d ¥

¦ ¡.o|d´qrŒ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡j¡.iDqO£Wop{}b u i,{po}i<d1l]n‘eg¡ iq6z.o}{po}eRb'l6˜iDq]k¯¡‘n.lcŸciyegl*iDdQegophjqregio¢e¯dŒlAdQo}egopl6n‘opn‘es¡.in.ieRœl usž ¬]œo}eg¡ u i<dQŒiDke

egll6eg¡.i

u

n.lcŸci<d

¥´¦

¡.o|d

u

i˜ i

u

deglq6dsdQopŽ6n.opn.Žj£Wo

u

egmqr{k,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregi<deglŒ q

u

esopk,o}Œ qregopn.Žn.lcŸci<d

¥´¦

¡.ikl]nAe

u

o}z.m.egopl6n~lr˜eg¡ i

Œ q6Œi

u

o|dyeRœl6˜ l6{|ŸµU¶`·¸‘q%dQophjŒ.{}ij{po}Ž]¡AeRœiDo}Ž]¡]e¨qrn Ÿ?˜ m.{p{}b±Ÿ.iDkiDnAe

u

qr{po}§DiDŸ?£Wo

u

esm qr{klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregiDŸ®dQbcdQegiDhº¹ »

³R¼¨½¾ a.¿yopd

Πu

l6Œl]dgiDŸ¬

u

iD{}bWopn.Žl6n {}b*l6n{plWkDqr{ k,l6n.n iDk¤eso}£Wo}eRb*opnc˜ l

u

hqHeso}l]nqrn ŸjŒi

u

™Yn i,opŽ6¡Wzl

u

kl]h'h*m.n.o|k,qregopl6n

¥¦

¡.o|dvo|d^egl$l6Œ.Œl]dgi

eglhjlAdRei­co|dReso}n Žjq6Œ.Œ

u

l]q]k¯¡.iDd

u

i,{pbAopn.Žji,o}eg¡ i

u

l6n~Œ

u

i™›Ÿci,© n.iDŸŒl]dgo¢eso}l]n.o}n Ž

u

i˜ i

u

iDnAego|qr{l

u

dgo}Ž]n qr{hji<q6dgm

u

iDhji,nAeDÀ^¶`·š·¸

eg¡ i?ŸciDdgo}Ž]nÁq6n ŸÁi,£Hqr{pm qregopl6n²l6˜¨qÂn.i,eRœl

ugž

Ž]i,l]h'i,e

u

opk~dgi,{}˜š™`dQe

u

m kegm

u

o}n ŽÂq6Œ.Œ

u

l]q6k¯¡9¹

¼

ie¯ÃiDlAa.¿'o|dŒ

u

iDdgi,nAesiDŸ²eg¡ qre

i,nqrz.{piDd%q²{|q u Ž6iÂdQi,e%l6˜$n.lcŸci<d‘eslÁk,l6nc© Ž]m u i?eg¡ i,hdQiD{}£]iDdo}nÄq u z.o}e u q u bCŽ]i,l]h'i,eu opk±dRe u m kegm u iDd ¥Å¦ ¡.iÂi,£Hqr{pm qregopl6n

ŸciDh'l]n dQe u qHegi<deg¡ qreeg¡.iq6Œ.Œ u l]q6k¯¡opd´zlres¡~iƑkopi,nAe[qrnŸq]k,km u qregiœ¡.o}{piq6k¯¡ o}iD£Aopn.Ž*eg¡.iŽ]i,l]h'i,eu opk¨dQe u m k¤esm u o}n.Ž ¥

Ç@ÈAÉKÊgË$Ì ”H͒]— x!mcesl6n.l]hjl6m dydQbcdQegi,h~¬Ãi,l]h'i,e u opk$dRe u m kegm u opn.Ž ¬Î/lck,q6{}o}eRb6¬KaWi,{}˜š™Yl u ŽAqrn.op§,opn.Žjn.i,eRœl ugž ¬aci,n dgl u n ieQ™

œl

usž

¬W»yo

u

egm q6{klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregi¨dQbcdQegi,h

¥

Ï|ÐÑgÒ`ÓDÔ´ÑÕÖ|ÒY×YØÙ

ÚÛ ÜÝ/ۚÞÂÝ/ßRàOàOßRá=â ãKäåߛæ`ç¯è¤à<ߝÞæ=éêç¯à,æ=ëíìDî<ßRâ|Û ÝÛåïDÞ1ðrñHäYç¯à<òQß

ڛÚó àOëôßRäåáYëæ=õ^öOß1ÝßRàOàOßRáv÷›âšÛ Ý/ÛåïDޝðHñHä=ç¯àOòRß

Ú›Ú›Ú ó àOëôßRäåáYëæ=õ^öOß1ÝßRàOàOßRáv÷›âšÛ Ý/ÛåïDޝðHñHä=ç¯àOòRß

Ú›Ú›Ú›Ú ó àOëôßRäåáYëæ=õ^öOß1ÝßRàOàOßRáv÷›âšÛ Ý/ÛåïDޝðHñHä=ç¯àOòRß

Ú›Ú›Ú›Ú›Ú Û ÜÝ/ۚÞï<ç¯òRéêçRø[âÛšéíß^öOß^ñHä=ç¯àOòRߝá=îOöAð<ñHäYç¯àOòRß

Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique Institut National de Recherche en Informatique

( UMR 6074) Université de Rennes 1 – Insa de Rennes et en Automatique – unité de recherche de Rennes

’

— ½ i u

qrŒ.Œl

u

e^Œ

u

‡Ddgi,nAegi´m.ndgbWdQegfDhji!Ÿci!klWl

u

Ÿcl]n.n.‡,i<d£Ao

u

egm.iD{}{piDd^q]Ÿ.qrŒces‡{pqdQe

u

m k¤esm

u

qHegopl6n*Ž6‡Dl6hj‡e

u

oAm.i

Ÿci<ddQbcdQegf,hji<d*Ž u q6n Ÿci¨‡Dk¯¡ i,{p{}i ¥

Ì “D’– ’—

aWbcdQegfDh'iqrmcesl6n.l]hji6¬OdRe

u

m kegm

u

qHeso}l]nŽ6‡Dl6hj‡e

u

oAm.i6¬O{plWkDqr{po¢es‡6¬Hqrm.eglr™`l

u

Ž]q6n.o|dgqregopl6n/¬

u

‡DdgiDq6mŸcikDqrŒcesi,m

u

dD¬

dgbWdQegfDhji¨Ÿ.iklWl

u

Ÿcl6n n.‡,i<d£Wo

u

esm.i,{p{piDd

¥

-K*0%v+

Ì “ È “ x[ndgbWdQegiDhLo|dk¯¡ q u q6kegi u op§,i<ŸyzWbyeg¡.i´qrz o}{po¢eRbeslyqrm.egl6hqrego|k,qr{p{pbq]Ÿ.qrŒceo¢e¯dzi,¡qO£Aopl u q6kDkl u Ÿcopn.Ž

eglUh'lcŸco}©kDqHegopl6ndlr˜^o}esdyi,nW£Wou l6n.hjiDn]e!œo}eg¡ l6mce u i Am.ou o}n.Ž‘q6n~i­Wegi u n q6{opnAegi u £6iDnAegopl6n ¥´¦ ¡.o|deRbWŒ.o|k,qr{p{pb‘˜åqr{p{|d!opn]esleg¡ i

œi,{p{¢™ ž n.lHœn "!$#%'&(Œ u l6Œi u egopiDd!¹=dQm k¯¡q6d1dgi,{}˜š™`¡.iDq6{}opn.Žl u dQiD{¢˜š™›dQesqrz o}{po}§<qHeso}l]n/¬6œ¡.o|k¯¡‘¡ qO£]iŒ u lH£6i,n'esl$zi[¡.opŽ6¡.{pb'ziDn.i©.™

ko|qr{K˜ l u qrm.egl6n l6hjl6m d´dgbcdResi,hds¿*)+ ¬Q‚,¥^t i,i u ™Yegl6™YŒi,i u dQbcdQegi,hd!q6n Ÿœou i,{piDdsddQiDn dgl u n.ieRœl usž dq u i[eRbWŒ.o|k,q6{/i­.q6h'Œ {}i<d

lr˜´qrmcesl6n.l]hjl6m ddQbcdQegiDhjd ¥$³ n®œou i,{piDdsd¨dQiDn dgl u n.ieRœl usž d,¬eg¡ i'Œq u ego|kopŒ qHeso}n.Ž%i,nAeso¢eso}i<d¹ådgi,n dgl u ds¿yq u i*Ÿ.i,Œ.{plHb6i<Ÿ?lH£6i u

qŽ]i,l6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k,q6{Kq u i<q.¬ q6n Ÿ@klWl]Œi u qregiopn?l u Ÿci u eslUkl]{}{piDkegop£6iD{}b~q6kDkl6hjŒ.{po|dQ¡@dgl6hjiŽ6op£6iDn~˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n°¹-! .0/1.p¬/k,l6n dgo|dResi,nAe

Ž]qreg¡.i u opn.Ž*lr˜k u o}ego|k,q6{opnc˜ l u hqHeso}l]n¿ ¥32 l uiŽ6iDn.i u qr{p{}b]¬Adgi,ndQl u™`z q6dgiDŸjq6mcegl]n.l6hjl6mddgbcdResi,hdŒ.{pqObq6nUoph'Œl uesq6nAe u l6{pi

opn~dgm

u

£6iDo}{p{pq6n ki]¬cŸ.qHe¯qH™`Ž]qHes¡.i

u

opn.Ž ¬Al

u

hjl6n o¢esl

u

o}n.ŽjqrŒ Œ.{}o|k,qregopl6n d

¥

4!$#%'&56876:9"87¤·;/

u

i,Œ

u

iDdgi,nAe¯des¡.i[q6z.o}{po}eRblr˜qdQbcdQegiDh egl{pieviDhji

u

Ž6iqdQŒiDk,o¢©kdRe

u

m kegm

u

i6¬r˜

u

l]h dsk

u

qHesk¯¡¬rœo¢es¡.l6m.e

u i Am.o

u

opn.Ži­Wesi

u

n qr{o}nc˜ l

u

hqregopl6n

¥

aWi,{}˜š™›dRe

u

m kegm

u

opn.Žo|dq6no}hjŒl

u

esqrnAeŸ.o}hji,ndQopl6n‘l6˜/q$dgbWdQegiDh q6mcegl]n.l6h*b¹åiDdgŒi<ko|qr{p{}b

opnesi

u

hdlr˜^dgkDqr{|qrz.op{po¢eRb‘o|dsdQm.i<d<)}€<‹, ¿

¥v³ n@dgi,n dgl

u

n ieRœl

usž

d˜ l

u

i­.qrhjŒ.{pi6¬.dgi,{}˜š™›dRe

u

m kegm

u

opn.Ž

u

iDŒ

u

i<dQiDnAesdqrn%oph'Œl

u

esq6nAe

u i Am.o

u

iDh'iDnAe1˜ l

u

k,l6hjhjl6nUl]Œi

u

qregopl6n ddgm k¯¡q]d1˜ l

u

ϫq

u

Ÿcopn.Ž ¬A{pl]q6Ÿ‘z qr{|qrn k,o}n Ž ¬W{}i<q6Ÿci

u

iD{}i<k¤eso}l]n/¬cl

u

i,n.i

u

Ž]b‘kl]n dQm h'Œ.™

egopl6nhqrn q6Ž6i,hjiDn]e ¥>= ­cq6hjŒ.{}i<d1opn k,{}m Ÿ.iyes¡.iŒ q u ego}egopl6n.opn.Ž*lr˜qrn%q u iDqopndgi,£]i u qr{§,l6n iDdlr˜/i Am q6{dQop§,i[˜ l u h'l]n.o}egl u opn.Ž

Œ.m u Œl]dgiDd´l u es¡.idQiD{}i<k¤eso}l]nl6˜dgi,n dgl u deglji,ndQm u idQŒiDk,o¢©k˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n d´˜ l u i,n.i u Ž]b‘dgqO£Wopn.Ž ¥

Ì “?@.•c“?Ì ¾ zW£Aopl6mdQ{pb6¬es¡.i%k,l6hjŒ.{pi­co}eRbÂl6˜yqÂdQiD{¢˜š™›dReu mk¤egm u opn.Ž?hjiDk¯¡qrn.o|dQhºdQe u l6n Ž6{pbŸciDŒiDn Ÿ.djl]nªeg¡.i@q6h'l]m.nAe

lr˜

ž

n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]ijo}n.o}ego|qr{p{pb®Œ

u

lH£WopŸ.iDŸ®egl?n lWŸ.iDdopneg¡ i‘n.ieRœl

usžK¥

xe*l6n.i‘iDn Ÿlr˜´es¡.iUdgŒi<k¤e

u

m.h~¬o¢˜!q6nAbÂn.lcŸci‘opneg¡ i

dgbWdQegiDh ¡ q]d[qk,l6hjŒ.{piegi

ž

n.lHœ{piDŸ.Ž6ilr˜eg¡ i$dQbcdQegiDh%¬dRe

u

mk¤egm

u

opn.Žjeg¡ in.ieRœl

usž

o|de

u

op£Wopq6{

¥

xe!eg¡.i$lreg¡ i

u

iDn Ÿ~lr˜eg¡ i

dgŒi<k¤e

u

m.h~¬.o}˜n lWŸ.iDdq

u

i¨l6n.{pbUqOœ´q

u

iyl6˜es¡.i,o

u

lHœn%n.i,opŽ6¡Wzl

u

¡.lWlWŸ/¬AiDn dgm

u

opn.Ž'eg¡qHe[q'Ž6op£6iDn%dQe

u

m k¤esm

u

iiDhji

u

Ž6iDd˜

u

l6h

opn Ÿcop£Ao|Ÿcm q6{/ŸciDk,opdgopl6n do|dk¯¡ qr{p{}iDn.Ž6opn.Ž

¥

Îie´eg¡ i!BA15!$76CD#EFG#H!'I$/!$zieg¡ io}nc˜ l

u

hqregopl6nUŒ

u

lH£Wo|ŸciDŸ‘eglq'n.lcŸci¨zAb‘q6n

i­Wesi

u

n qr{i,nAego}eRbjl

u

Ÿci,£Wo|ki

¥^¦

¡.o|dopd1egl*l6Œ.Œl]dgi!eslU·;J7¤·;:¯·9*EFG#H!'I$/!es¡ qHekl]n dQo|dQesdvl6˜/eg¡ iyopnc˜ l

u

hqHeso}l]njeg¡ qrei<q6k¯¡

i,nAeso¢eRb%Ž]qreg¡.i

u

do}esdgi,{}˜^˜

u

l6h o¢e¯d!l6zdQi

u

£HqHeso}l]n~lr˜eg¡.i*n.ieRœl

usžK¥¦

¡ ihjl

u

ii­Wegi

u

nqr{

ž

n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]iopd

u

iAm.o

u

iDŸ/¬.eg¡ i${piDdsd

u l6z.m dQe$q?dgbcdResi,h-o|dU¹åiDdgŒi<ko|qr{p{}bœ¡.iDn°Ÿci,Œ.{plHb6i<Ÿ±opn°iDnA£Wou l]n.hji,nAesd¨œ¡ i u i¡Am hjq6nªo}nAesi u £6i,nAeso}l]nÂo|d$Ÿ.o¢Æ‘km {¢e¤¿ ¥±¾ n

eg¡ il6eg¡.i u ¡ qrn Ÿ/¬.qrŒ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡.iDd u i,{pbAopn.Ž'hjl]dQeg{pbl6nUopnAe u o}ndQo|k ž n lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6iŸci© n o¢eso}£]i,{pb‘o}nk u iDq6dgiDddgbWdQegiDh qrm.egl6n l6h$bqre

eg¡ iŒ u o|ki¨lr˜q'¡.o}Ž]¡.i u k,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6nlH£6i u ¡.i<q6Ÿ ¥¦ ¡.o|d´hqOb‘kl6ndQi]m i,nAeg{pb ui<Ÿcm k,iyes¡.idQbcdQegiDhÅ{}o}˜ ieso}hji ¥v³ n%dg¡.l ue<¬

eg¡ iqrmcesl6n.l]h$bUŸciDŽ u i,i¨lr˜^qjn.i,eRœl ugž iDŸUdgbcdResi,h opdopnW£6i u dgi,{pbŒ u l6Œl u egopl6n q6{esljeg¡.ii,­Wegi u n q6{ ž n.lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6i u i Am.ou i<Ÿ‘esl

dQe u m k¤esm u i¨es¡.in.i,eRœl ugžK¥³e[opd!¡.lHœiD£6i u k u m ko|qr{KeslUkl]h'im Œ@œo¢es¡?q u i<q6dgl6n q6z.{}ie u q]Ÿci™`lDK?zieRœi,iDn?qrmcesl6n.l]h$bUq6n Ÿ

lH£6i u ¡ iDq6Ÿ ¥

¦ ¡.o|d¨Œ qrŒi u Œ u i<dQiDn]e¯d¨q u l6z m dRedQe u m k¤esm u o}n.Ž~hjiDk¯¡qrn.o|dQh~¬/{piDq]Ÿcopn.ŽUesl@Ž6iDl6hjie uo|k*q6n Ÿ±˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n qr{^l u ŽAqrn.op§Dqregopl6n

eg¡qHekDqrnziŸ.i,Œ.{plHb6i<Ÿ$˜u l6h dsk u qHe¯k¯¡'opnUq$n.ieRœl usž i<Ÿ'dgbcdResi,h œ¡.i u i!es¡.i[opn.o}ego|qr{ ž n.lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6il6˜/iDq]k¯¡n.lcŸci[o|dv{po}hjo}egi<Ÿ

egl±o¢e¯dlHœnªo|Ÿci,nAego}eRbqrn Ÿªk,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6n u qrn.Ž]i ¥%« ie<¬eg¡.i%q6dsdQlcko|qHesiDŸ®lH£6i u ¡.i<q6Ÿ®opd ž iDŒce$hjo}n o}h*m.h~¬^Œ u i<dQi u £Wopn.Ž

eg¡ i‘{}o}˜ ieso}hjilr˜´eg¡.idQbcdQegi,h ¥%³ neg¡.ikl6nAesi­We$lr˜eg¡ opd$œl ugž ¬œi˜ lckmdl6nªdgi,n dgl u n ieRœl usž d ¥¦ l@es¡.i‘ziDdQe$lr˜l6m u

ž n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]i6¬Aeg¡.o|do|deg¡.i¨© u dQeL/1!'DM!$J7¤·9N6J76:9$87¤·;/OD5DC<6P65!$ ŸciDŒ.{}lHb]iDŸm.Œl6n%eg¡.lAdQik,l6n Ÿco}egopl6nd´o}n%eg¡ i

{po¢esi

u

qHegm

ui ¥

aWiD{¢˜š™›dRe

u

mk¤egm

u

opn.Ž±o|dq®ŒlHœi

u

˜ m.{eglWl6{˜ l

u

œo

u

iD{}i<dgd'n.i,eRœl

ugž

d*qrn ŸÁq±mdQi,˜ m.{´l6Œi

u

qHegopl6n²˜ l

u

Ž6i,eQegopn.Ž¡.opŽ6¡.{pb°qrm.™

egl]n.l6hjl]m d[dgbcdResi,hd

¥!¦

¡ opdyopdŸcm.ieg¡.i$˜åq6k¤eyeg¡ qreyo}eŸco|k¤e¯qHesiDdyl

u

Ž]qrn o}§<qHegopl6n%{|qOœ!d˜ l

u

n.lcŸciDd[o}n?eg¡.i*n.ieRœl

usžK¥!¼ lcŸciDd

k,q6neg¡.iDn°ziUq6dsdQopŽ6n iDŸŸcoHKi

u

iDn]e'q6Ÿ.q6Œcegop£6i‘zi,¡qO£Aopl

u

d¨z q]dQi<Ÿl6neg¡ i‘iDdQesq6z.{}o|dg¡.iDŸl

u

ŽAqrn.op§Dqregopl6n

¥%³ nªŒ q

u

ego|km {pq

u

¬q

n.i,eRœl

ugž

l u

Ž]q6n.op§DqHeso}l]njhjqObj˜ l]{}{plHœQ/!BB/R7-BS:TW·9l

u

%'9"Y·#AŒ

u

o}n k,o}Π{}i<d

¥1½

{|q6dsdQo|k,q6{ i­.q6h'Œ {}i<dl6˜qŽ]i,l]Ž

u

qrŒ.¡.o|k!q6n Ÿ

˜ m.n kegopl6n q6{dgi,{}˜š™`dQe u m k¤esm u o}n.Žjq u i6¬ u iDdgŒi<k¤eso}£]i,{pbµ^qjdgiDk¤esl u ™`dg¡ q6Œi<Ÿ‘§,l]n.ik{pm dQegi u opn.Ž'˜ l u {piDq6Ÿ.i u i,{piDkegopl6n/¬.l u qrn~qOœq ž i

qrnŸdg{}iDi,Œ~n.lcŸci<d$U.k,{}m dQegi u™`z q]dQi<ŸUŸco|dRe u opz.mceso}l]n%˜ l u i,n i u Ž6b‘kl]n dgm.hjŒcegopl6n~hqrn q6Ž6iDh'iDnAe¨¹=dQiDiaciDk¤eso}l]n ¥ ¿ ¥

¦ ¡.o|d!ziDk,l6hjiDd!q‘£6i u bk¯¡qr{p{}iDn.Ž6opn.ŽjŽ6lAqr{Y¬q6d[dQlWl6n@q]d!n.iDo¢es¡.i u ŒlAdQo}egopl6n.opn.Ž u i˜ i u iDn]esopq6{=¬zl]m.n Ÿ.q u b%Ÿci,{poph'o}esqregopl6n/¬

n.l u ŸciDn dgo¢eRb?Ÿco|dQe u o}z.m.egopl6n±o|dŒ u lH£Ao|Ÿci<Ÿ ¥« ieD¬o¢eo|dyk u m k,opq6{o}nÂdQm k¯¡Âkl]n]esi­WesdD¬eg¡ qrei<q6k¯¡®n.lcŸci*zijqrz.{pi$eslopnc˜ i u o}esd

Œl]dgo¢eso}l]n@œo¢es¡ u i<dQŒiDkeegles¡.i$l6eg¡.i u n.lcŸci<d ¥y¾ n.i*dQl]{}mceso}l]n%˜ l u es¡.o|d!o|deglqr{p{}lHœLeg¡.i*n.lcŸciDd!eglUq]k,k,iDdsd!qklWl u Ÿcopn qHesi

dgbWdQegiDh ˜u l6h œ¡.o|k¯¡Ues¡.i,bk,qrnl6zce¯qropn%q'klWl u Ÿcopn qregiyq]dgdgopŽ6n.hji,nAe ¥ acm k¯¡%q'klWl u Ÿcopn qregi¨dQbcdQegi,h u i,Œ u i<dQiDn]e¯deg¡.i¨z q]dQo|k

{|qOb6i u l6negl]Œl6˜œ¡.o|k¯¡~q6Ÿ.q6Œcegop£6iziD¡ qO£Wo}l u d´kDqrnUziŸci<dQopŽ6n.i<Ÿ ¥^¦ ¡.i,bkl6ndQi]m i,nAeg{pb{}opiqHe´eg¡ i¨k,l u iyl6˜q6mcegl]n.l6hjl6md

dgbWdQegiDhdŸciDdgo}Ž]n ¥^¦ ¡.o|d!kl]n dReso¢esmcegi<deg¡.idgiDk,l6n Ÿ%kl]nAe u o}z.m.egopl6n%Œ u i<dQiDnAegiDŸopnes¡.iŒ q6Œi uD¥

¦

¡.i

u

i!o|d1q£Oq]dRe{}o}egi

u

qregm

u

i!opneg¡ i[œo

u

iD{}i<dgd^n ieRœl

usž

d u i<dQi<q

u

k¯¡jk,l6hjh$m n.o¢eRbjkl]nAesqropn.opn.ŽnWm.hji

u

l6mdvqrn Ÿ‘£Oq6{}mqrz.{pi

Πu

l6Œl]dsqr{|d^˜ l

u

l]zcesq6o}n o}n.Ž'Œl]dgo¢eso}l]n.o}n Ž*opnc˜ l

u

hqHeso}l]n)}€"V

¬Wc¬`ƒ.¬`.¬s€D‰VW€<.¬›ˆr‰D,

¥«

ieD¬chjlAdRe´lr˜/es¡.iDdgiqrŒ.Œ

u

lAq6k¯¡.i<d

u

i,{pb'l]n

dgl6hjidQŒiDk,o¢©kq6dsdQm h'Œ.egopl6n dq6n Ÿ%eg¡.o|d[dg¡.lHœ!ddQe

u ož

opn.Ži,£Wo|Ÿci,nki¨eg¡qHe[iD£6i,n~hjl

u

iqrm.egl6n l6h$bopd

u

i]m o

u

iDŸ

¥¦

¡.o|d!¡ q]d

zi,i,nÂkl]Œi<Ÿ@zWb~dgl6{pmceso}l]n des¡ qHe¨m dgiXCNS:¤·;Y·:&YDFZ7-!O7-!J%"!"7-!$:Y·#CS:H·;!q6n Ÿ~eg¡qHe

u

i<dQm.{}eyopn\[<·;76J:D#]9B 7BIH·;CD5!"

zi,opn.Žq]dgdgo}Ž]n.iDŸesl‘n.lcŸciDdD¬o}n dQegi<q6Ÿ~l6˜Ž]i,l]Ž

u

qrŒ.¡.o|kklWl

u

Ÿcopn qregiDd<).¬¤€<‰.¬Qˆ6‰,

¥

»yo

u

egmqr{k,lWl

u

Ÿco}nqHegi<dzieQesi

uu

i$^ iDke!eg¡ i

u iDqr{1n.ieRœl usž kl]n.n.i<k¤egop£Wo¢eRb]¬q6n Ÿk,qrnªk,l6n dgi Am.iDn]es{}b®Œ u lH£Ao|Ÿcijhjl u i u l]z.m dQegn.i<dgd¨opneg¡ i‘Œ u iDdgi,n k,i'l6˜l6z dQesq]k{piDd ¥‘³n

ÛàA÷Y`"a'b

q6Ÿ Ÿco¢eso}l]n/¬vdgo}n k,i‘£Wo

u

egmqr{´klWl

u

Ÿcopn qHesiDdq

u i u

i,{|qHeso}£]iegl±n.lcŸciDd?UŒ ¡AbcdgopkDqr{p{}bk{pl]dgi‘n.iDo}Ž]¡Wzl

u

¡.lWlcŸ¬eg¡ i,bªk,q6negl6{pi

u

qHesi

hjl

u

i¨i,nW£Wo

u

l6n.hjiDn]eŸcbWn q6h'o|dghÅeg¡qrn~qrz dgl6{pmcegi¨Ž]i,l6Ž

u

q6Œ.¡.o|k[k,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregi<d

¥

…yiDdgŒ.o¢esi@¡ qO£Wo}n Ž°k{piDq u {pb²Ÿci©n.iDŸ l]mceg{po}n iDd‘q6n ŸÁŒ u i<dQiDnAegopn.ŽªŽ6lWlcŸ qrŒ.Œ u lO­co}hqregopl6nCdgl6{pmceso}l]n d,¬´Œ u i,£Wopl6m djœl usž d

l6n £Aou egm q6{yklWl u Ÿcopn qregiDdUq u i±kl]h'Œ mcesqregopl6n q6{}{pbA™%¹åq6n Ÿ hjiDdsdsqrŽ6iO¿klAdRes{}b]¬l u ¡ q u Ÿc{pbÁŒ u q]k¤ego|k,q6{!opn œou iD{}i<dgddQiDn dQl u

n.i,eRœl ugž dG).¬›€D‰D,¥³n‘q6Ÿ.Ÿ.o¢eso}l]n/¬res¡.i[dgl6{pmcegopl6n dvŒ ui<dQiDnAegiDŸ*opn ) ¬›€<ˆc¬åˆ6‰,`¬6qr{}eg¡ l6m.Ž]¡*n.l6eq6kDkl]m.nAegopn.Ž˜ l u Œl]dgo¢eso}l]nc™›qOœq u i

{|qrn Ÿchq ugž dD¬ u i Am.ou iDd[eg¡.i'n.l6hjopn qHeso}l]n±l6˜1œiD{}{Œ.{|q6k,iDŸ±i,nAego}egopiDd¨opn?es¡.idQbcdQegi,hdyegl%œl usž q]dq6n k¯¡.l u d[l u zlWl6esdQe u qrŒ

ziDq6k,l6n%n.lcŸciDd ¥

³n dQegi<q6Ÿ¬Deg¡.o|dŒ qrŒi u Œ u l]ŒlAdQi<d/q£]i u dgqregop{}i^£Wou esm qr{AklWl u Ÿcopn qHesivdQbcdQegi,hL˜ l u dQiDn dgl u n.i,eRœl ugž d ¥/¦ ¡.i1hq6o}nŸcoHKKi u i,n k,i

œo}eg¡ u i,{|qHegi<Ÿ$œl usž dopd^eg¡ qre^eg¡.i!Œ u l]ŒlAdQi<Ÿ*q6Œ.Œ u l]q6k¯¡'ŸclWiDd^n lre u i,{pbl6nqrnWb'qrn k¯¡.l u dD¬HŒl]dgo¢eso}l]nc™`qOœ´q u i1{|qrnŸchq usž dD¬rl u

dgo}Ž]n qr{/hji<q6dgm u iDhji,nAe ¥« ie<¬n.lcŸci<dŽ6i,eyq6dsdgo}Ž]n.iDŸ%£Wou egmqr{k,lAl u Ÿ.o}n qregi<do}n?q'˜ m {}{pb@ŸciDk,i,nAe u qr{po}§DiDŸ%œ´qOb ¥¼ lcŸciDdyŸci u o}£]i

{plWkDqr{/k,l6n.n.i<k¤eso}£Wo}eRb‘o}n.˜ l u hjqregopl6n/¬.dgl6{pi,{pb‘{pi,£]i u qrŽ6opn.Ž$eg¡.iDou Œi u ™Yn i,opŽ6¡Wzl u kl6hjh*m.n.o|k,qHeso}l]n ¥

Ì “ È “ Ì “ È • 1È ” ³[email protected] u b6¬Weg¡ ikl6nAe u opz.mceso}l]n d´lr˜eg¡.iŒ q6Œi u q u ieg¡.i¨˜ l]{}{plHœo}n Ž*l]n.iDd ¥

•

xdgo}hjŒ.{pi6¬{}opŽ6¡AeRœi,opŽ6¡Ae[qrnŸ~˜ m.{p{}b@Ÿci<ki,nAe u q6{}op§,i<Ÿ¬6768:# !"8FZ7-E1!'I D7-IH·;! 4P6!" ¹ » ³R¼¨½¾ a.¿es¡ qHe q6k¯¡.opi,£]iDdqjŽ6lWlcŸk,lAl u Ÿ.o}n qregi¨q6dsdQopŽ6n h'iDnAe ¥

aWo}nki$œie¯q

u

Ž6i,e!˜ m.{p{}b?q6mcegl]n.l6hjl6md!dQbcdQegiDhjdD¬K»

³R¼¨½¾

a@ŸclWiDdyn.lre

u

iD{}b%l6n®qrnWb~o}nc˜ l

u

hqregopl6n?qrzl6m.eŸciDn dQo}eRb6¬

ŸcopdQe

u

opz.mcegopl6nÁqrn ŸCdQop§,i%lr˜yeg¡.i~n.i,eRœl

ugž

iDٻdgbcdResi,h

¥C¦

¡.i˜ lckm djo|d'l6nCi,nW£Wo

u

l6n.hjiDn]e¯d$œo}eg¡ q®{pq

u

Ž]iUnWm.h$zi

u

lr˜´n.lcŸciDd¨es¡ qHe*¡ qO£6i‘q [!"76P #ê·;*·;!'I 9'D>/R7-D=·D EDCFG#H!'I?/1!¹ n.lcŸci<dl]n.{}b ž n.lHœes¡ qHees¡.i,b¡ qO£]ijŸ.opdQegopn k¤e

opŸciDnAego}© i u d,¬.dgi,iaWi<k¤eso}l]n~ˆ]¿ ¥

•

^x !"8FZ7-E1!'I !'!$J7¤·9N4876:9"87¤·;/q6Œ.Œ u l]q6k¯¡Â¹¼ ie¯ÃiDlAa.¿˜ l u qrmcesl6n.l]hjl6m d´dgbWdQegiDhd ¥

¼ ie¤Ãi,lWa®kDqrnªziUŸciDŒ.{}lHb]iDŸ®m.Œl6n°qrnWb®Œl]{pq u klWl u Ÿcopn qHesidQbcdQegi,h~¬œo¢es¡.l6m.e u i Am.ou opn.Ž@q~n.lcŸciesl@¡ qO£6i‘q6nAb

ž n lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6i*l6n®eg¡.in.i,eRœl ugžK¥ i u i]¬/œidg¡.lHœ ¡.lHœ ¼ i,e¯Ãi,lWa?z m.o}{|Ÿ.dm Œl]n®» ³R¼½¾ a ¥¾ m u q6Œ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡®Ÿci<qr{|d

œo¢es¡Ues¡.opdk¯¡qr{p{}iDn.Ž6izWb‘Œ

u

lH£Ao|Ÿcopn.Ž$iD{}iDŽ]q6n]e´hjiDk¯¡ q6n.o|dQhd˜ l

u

n.i,eRœl

ugž

iDŸŽ]i,l]h'i,e

u

opkyl

u

Ž]q6n.op§DqHeso}l]n d

¥ i¨dg¡.lHœ

¡.lHœCŸcoHKKi

u

i,nAevŽ6iDl6hjie

u

o|k´dRe

u

m kegm

u

opn.Žk,qrnjzi!iDq]dQop{pbl6zce¯qropn.iDŸ*˜

u

l6h es¡.i!£Wo

u

esm qr{.k,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregi<d^q6dsdQlcko|qHesiDŸ*œo¢es¡

n.lcŸciDd´zWb‘»

³R¼½¾ a ¥ 2 l u

iDlH£6i

u

¬Aœidg¡.lHœ es¡ qHe<¬ ŸciDdgŒ.o}egieg¡ iŒ

u

i<dQiDn ki¨l6˜l6zdRe¯q6k{piDdD¬Aeg¡.iŒ

u

l]ŒlAdQi<ŸUqrŒ Œ

u

lAq6k¯¡

qr{p{}lHœ!dq'{pq

u

Ž]iydgie!lr˜n.lcŸciDdesljk,l6{p{pq6zl

u

qregop£6iD{}bj{piei,hji

u

Ž6iŽ6iDl6hjie

u

o|kyl

u

Ž]qrn o}§<qHegopl6nd,¬Ao}n~qjdgkDqr{|qrz.{pi6¬cdgo}hjŒ.{pi6¬

qrn ŸX^ i­copz.{piœqOb

¥

“ JÈ[¦ ¡.i u iDhjq6o}nŸci u l6˜Weg¡.o|dŒqrŒi u o|d/l u ŽAqrn.op§,i<Ÿq]dK˜ l6{p{plHœ!d ¥ x!˜šegi u opnAe u lWŸ.m kopn.Žl6m u dgbWdQegiDhLhjlcŸciD{6opn$aWiDkegopl6n$ˆc¬

œiŒ u i<dQiDnAeeg¡.iUŸ.iDdgo}Ž]n u qHeso}l]n qr{pijlr˜´l6m u qrŒ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡®q6n ŸŽ6op£6iqrnlH£]i u £Aopi,œ lr˜ u iD{pqregi<Ÿ®œl usž d¨o}n°aWi<k¤eso}l]n ¥¦ ¡ i

£Wou egmqr{[k,lAl u Ÿ.o}n qregi@dgbWdQegiDh ¹å» ³R¼½¾ a ¿jopdŸciDdsk u opzi<ŸCopn aWiDkegopl6n + ¥ ³n aWiDkegopl6nQW.¬œi?dg¡.lHœ ¡.lHœ eg¡ opdU£Aou egm q6{

klWl u Ÿcopn qregi$dgbcdResi,h k,q6n?zi*m dgiDŸ@egl%l6zce¯qropn±dQŒiDk,o¢©k$Ž]i,l6hji,e u opkdQe u m kegm u o}n Ž ¥t i u ˜ l u hq6n ki u iDdgm.{}esdq u i$Œ u iDdgi,nAesiDŸ

opn@aciDk¤eso}l]n%ƒ ¥"! o}n q6{}{pb6¬ aciDk¤eso}l]n±‚$k,l6n k,{}mŸciDdes¡.opd!Œ qrŒi u q6n ŸŸ.opdskm dsdgiDd˜ mcesm u iœl usž d ¥

#

j! "%

x[dqr{u iDq6Ÿ.b$opn Ÿco|k,qHesiDŸ¬Aœi!˜ lckm d1o}n‘eg¡.o|d1ŒqrŒi u l]n‘œou iD{}i<dgdvdgi,ndQl u n.ieRœl usž dvqrnŸhjl u i[dQŒiDk,o¢©k,qr{p{pb*l]nh'l]n.o}egl u opn.Ž

dgi,n dgl u ™Yzq6dgiDŸ%qrŒ.Œ.{po|k,qHeso}l]n d ¥$ ie¯q u Ž6i,eyqrŒ.Œ {}o|k,qregopl6n?dski,nq u o}lAd´œ¡.i u ieg¡ i$hjl6n.o}egl u i<Ÿ u iDŽ6opl6n~opdylr˜vŸco}Ƒkm.{}eq]k,k,iDdsd

qrnŸ&%Ol u ¡Wm.hq6nopnAegi u £6iDnAegopl6n%opd´n.l6e˜ iDq]dQopz.{pi ¥^¦ ¡.o|dopdkDqrŒcesm u iDŸzAbUeg¡.i˜ l]{}{plHœo}n Žjq]dgdgm.hjŒceso}l]n d ¥

'@Ì Í È ’ ¦

¡.ijdQbcdQegiDh o|d¨kl]h'Œl]dgiDŸ?lr˜1q¹š© n.o}egiO¿[dgie¨lr˜

N

^{u i<dQl]m u} ki™`{po}hjo}egiDŸ~œo

u

i,{piDdsdyŸciD£Wopk,iDd'¹ådgi,n dgl

u

n.lcŸciDd¯¿!m n.o¢™

˜ l

u

hj{}bÂdgkDqHegegi

u

iDŸ®l6nq~Ž6iDl6Ž

u

q6Œ.¡.o|k,qr{q

u

iDq)(

¥O=

q]k¯¡n.lcŸciŽ6i,esdq]dgdgo}Ž]n.iDŸÂq%m.n.oAm.iopŸ.i,nAego}© i

u

i

^¥¦ ¡.opdopd¨es¡.i‘l]n.{}b

ŸcoHKi

u

iDn kiUo}nes¡.iUopn.o}ego|qr{

ž

n.lHœ{piDŸ.Ž6ilr˜!q6nAb±eRœl@n lWŸ.iDd

¥?¦

¡.i‘n.lcŸci‘o|ŸciDn]eso¢©i

u

d$q

u

in.l6e$n.iDk,iDdsdgq

u

op{pb±kl]n dQi<kmceso}£]i

opn]esi,Ž]i

u d

¥ o}eg¡

u

iDdgŒi<k¤e'eglqrnWbªlres¡.i

u

qHege

u

o}z mcegiª¹R·.;! . kl]hjŒ.mcesqregopl6n q6{=¬1h'iDhjl

u

b6¬viDn.i

u

Ž6b]¬1qrn ŸCkl]h'h*m.n.o|k,qregopl6n

k,q6Œ qrz o}{po¢eso}i<ds¿¬Aeg¡.i¨n.lcŸci<dkDqrn‘zidQiDi,n%q6dk{pl6n.i<dl6˜iDq]k¯¡‘lres¡.i

u

¹ eg¡.iDbUq

u

iyq6{}{+*Qi Am qr{-,Q¿

¥ =

q6k¯¡n.lcŸciq6{pdgl$¡q6d´q${plck,q6{

k{plck žK¥¦ ¡.i1dgielr˜.{plck,qr{Ak{plck ž dopdn.l6edQbWn k¯¡ u l]n.o}§DiDŸ ¥¦ ¡.i u i1o|dq6nm.Œ.Œi u zl]m.n Ÿl]n¨eg¡.i´Ÿ u o¢˜še u qregivl6˜ceg¡.i{}lckDqr{]k,{}lck ž d ¥

Ì =–6•c“ ÌC = q]k¯¡Un.lcŸciopd´q6z.{}iyegljkl]hjh$m.n.o|k,qregij¹šes¡ u l]m.Ž6¡Uz u lAq6Ÿ.kDq6dQegopn.ŽA¿vœo¢es¡.opnq u q]Ÿco}l'kl]h'h*m.n.o|k,qregopl6n

u qrn.Ž]i

R

^¥¦ ¡Wm dD¬cqn.lcŸci

i

o|dq6z.{}i!egl*Ÿ.ou iDkeg{pbjk,l6hjh$m n.opkDqHesi!œou i,{piDdsdg{}b'œo¢es¡Uq$dgm.z dgielr˜/n.lcŸci<dves¡ qHe´q u i u iDq6k¯¡qrz.{pi

.

ñ0/¤äæ21<ߨá`ç43¤ß5/46òRéêç¯ä=ëæšøð87ßç¯áYá=î:9ß[ç$îOà<ë6;/¤ä<9 öOëíá=æ=ä=ë>=<î<æYë>/¤à@?Þéæ21A/¤îOèB1‘ëæëíáæC//EDOäåßQéíë>9ëíàOç¯äåø*æ2/*òQéêç¯ë>9ÄæC1HçsæF/¤îOä´ç¯éíèB/¤ä=ëæC1:9

òG/¤à,ôßRäåè¤ßRá´ä=ßRèç¯äåöOéíßRáYá/46/æC1Oß!öOëíá=æ=äåë>=Oî<æ=ë>/¤àAð+7ßòG/¤àOöOîOò›æ=ßQö‘áC/B9ß´áYë>9îOéêçsæYë>/¤à<á1ëíà*áYîOò21'áYߛæåæYëíà<è¤áH?JI1OßäåßRáYîOéæ=ááC1:/H7ªæC1HçsææC1Oß!á=øDá=æ=ßG9

òG/¤à,ôßRäåè¤ßRáëíà5D<ä=ßRáYßRàOòRßK/46.à:/¤ä<9!ç¯éAöOëíáåæYäåë>=Oî<æ=ë>/¤àL/¤äæ2/BDM/¤é>/¤è¤ëíßRáæC1HçsæN9ëOöOëP6ßRä=ßRàæö<ßQà<áYëæ=ëíßQáRQ01:/¯æá2DM/¯æ=áH?

¹ œi

u

i˜ i

u

esl'eg¡.o|d!dgm.z dgie[q6des¡.iC!,·/T'7'l6˜es¡.in.lcŸci

i

^{¿ ¥v¦ ¡.i u} i¨o|d!qrn%m.Œ.Œi

u

zl]m.n Ÿ

δ

l]nes¡.ihjiDdsdgq6Ž6iye

u

qrn dQ˜ i

u

ŸciD{pqOb‘zieRœi,iDn%q6nWbeRœljn.iDo}Ž]¡Wzl

u

n lWŸ.iDd

¥

i<q6k¯¡ q6z.o}{po}eRbUn.l6eyl6n {}b~Ÿci,Œi,nŸ.d[l]n@Ž6iDl6Ž u qrŒ ¡.opkDqr{/Ÿco|dQesqrnkiDd[z.mce¨qr{|dQl‘l]n@n qHesm u qr{l]z dQesq6k,{}i<d ¥³n@l6eg¡.i u œl u Ÿ.dD¬

iDq]k¯¡~n.lcŸci

i

k,qrn?k,l6hjh$m n.opkDqHesiœo¢es¡±qrn.l6eg¡.i u n.lcŸci

j

^{Œ u} lH£WopŸci<Ÿeg¡ qre

j

o|d!{plck,qHesiDŸ~œo}eg¡.opn?o}esd!e u qrn dghjopdsdQopl6n u qrn.Ž]i

R

qrn Ÿ°n.l?l6zdRe¯q6k{pi‘opnAegi u˜ i u iDd$œo¢es¡°es¡.ik,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6n ¥ i~q6dsdgm.hji·Ir·;7-!'9"Y·#kl6hjh*m.n.o|k,qHeso}l]n°qrn Ÿªeg¡ qre eg¡ i¨Ÿ.i,n dgo¢eRbl6˜n.lcŸci<dopd´dgm k¯¡‘es¡ qHe´eg¡ i u iDdgm.{}egopn.Žjkl6hjh*m.n.o|k,qHeso}l]n‘n.i,eRœl ugž o|dkl6n n.iDkegiDŸ®¹R·.;! .p¬.es¡.i¨n.ieRœl usž opdn.l6e

Œ q u eso¢eso}l]n.iDŸ ¿ ¥

"  “ å• ÌWË È Í> ȳ n.o}ego|qr{p{}bq!n lWŸ.il]n.{}b ž n.lHœ!do¢e¯do|ŸciDn]eso¢eRb]¬Oeg¡.i˜åq6kees¡ qHen.l[eRœlyn.lcŸciDd¡ qO£6iveg¡.i´dgq6hji1o|Ÿci,nAego}eRb6¬

qrnŸ±q%Œ q u qrhji,egi u

d

eg¡qHeœo}{p{vŸci,© n.i'eg¡.idgo}§Di%¹ål u Ÿcophji,n dgo}l]n¿ylr˜ves¡.ij£Wou egm q6{k,lWl u Ÿco}nqHegijdgŒ q6k,i ¥ ¡.op{pijq~dgo}n Ž6{pi klWl u Ÿcopn qregi$dgŒ q6k,i$o|dyk,l6n dgo|Ÿci u iDŸ~opn?es¡.i$˜ l]{}{plHœopn.Ž ¬l6m u Œ u l6Œl]dsqr{kDqrn?zi'iDq6dgop{}b%i­WegiDn Ÿci<Ÿ@eglŒ u lH£Ao|Ÿcin lWŸ.iDdœo¢es¡

dgi,£6i u q6{klWl u Ÿcopn qHesidgŒ q6k,iDdD¬ciDq]k¯¡‘esq u Ž]ieso}n.ŽqjdgŒi<ko}©kqrŒ.Œ {}o|k,qregopl6nq6n Ÿ~k¯¡ q u q6kegi u op§,i<ŸzWbUqdQŒiDk,o¢©kŸ.o}hji,ndQopl6n ¥

! opŽ6m u ij€6µ = ­cq6hjŒ.{}i<d´lr˜Ž6iDl6Ž u qrŒ ¡.opkDqr{q u iDq6d ¥

'@È “ Ë$Ì ” ’?• 1ȼ l‘n lWŸ.iopd[Œ u lH£Wo|ŸciDŸœo}eg¡@Ž6iDl6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k,qr{esl6Œl6{pl6Ž6bUo}nc˜ l u hqregopl6n¹ådgm k¯¡?q6d´Œ.¡WbcdgopkDqr{/l]z dRe¯q6k,{}i<ds¿ ¥

¦

¡.iŒ

u

iDdgi,nAesiDŸ%¡.i

u

iDqr˜šegi

u

qrŒ.Œ

u

l]q]k¯¡.iDd

u

i,{po}i<d!dgl6{pi,{pb‘l6n~n.lcŸci$k,l6n.n iDk¤eso}£Wo}eRb

¥^«

i,eD¬qjŒ.¡WbWdgo|k,qr{l6z dQesq]k{pij¹B!?.0/.p¬Kqj¡.o}Ž]¡

hjl6m.nAe¯qropn‘dQiDŒ q

u

qHeso}n.Ž¨eRœl£Hqr{p{pi,bcd^es¡ qHeh'i

u

Ž]i[qHe´dQl]hji!Œl]o}nAe¤¿vk,q6nŒ

u

i,£6iDnAekl]n.n.iDkegop£Wo¢eRb'zi,eRœiDi,n‘n lWŸ.iDd^es¡ qHe´q

u i

lres¡.i

u

œo|dQijŽ6iDl6Ž

u

q6Œ.¡.o|k,qr{p{pb?k{pl]dgi

¥O=

­.q6h'Œ {}i<dlr˜Ž6iDl6Ž

u

q6Œ.¡.o|k,qr{q

u

iDq]dklH£]i

u

iDŸ?zWb®eg¡.in lWŸ.iDdD¬esl6Ž6i,eg¡.i

u

œo¢es¡eg¡.iDo

u

zl u Ÿci u d,¬q u i$Ÿci<dgk uopzi<Ÿ~o}n ! opŽ6m u i‘€ ¥[¦ ¡.in lWŸ.iDdq u i{}lck,qregi<Ÿ@o}ndQo|Ÿcies¡.i*dQe u o}Œ Œi<Ÿ@§,l]n.iDd ¥!¦ ¡.i©Ž6m u il6n~es¡.i${pi˜še

dgopŸciŸci,Œ.o|k¤e¯d*q6n°q u iDq~œ¡.i u i‘eg¡.in.lcŸciDd*q u i *Rm n.o¢˜ l u hj{pb@,Ÿco|dsdQiDh'opn qregiDŸ/¬œo}eg¡ l6mce'l6z dQesq]k{piDd ¥~¦ ¡ i‘© Ž]m u iUl6neg¡ i

u o}Ž]¡]e´dQo|ŸciŸci,Œ.o|k¤e¯d´qrnUq u i<qœo}eg¡q *Qk,i,nAegi u i<Ÿ ,!l6z dQesq]k{pi*¹åo}nUeg¡ qre´kDq6dgi!eg¡ iyzl u Ÿci u ˜u l]h œ¡.opk¯¡Ueg¡.i¨klWl u Ÿcopn qregiDdq u i

kl]hjŒ.mcegi<Ÿ%opdes¡.il6mcesi u zl u Ÿci u ¿ ¥

-+Š+%

x!{}eg¡ l6m.Ž]¡Czi,opn.Žªz q]dQi<Ÿ²l]nCi,­Ae u iDhji,{pb°dQophjŒ.{}i@Œ u opn kopŒ.{piDdD¬ves¡.i?qrŒ.Œ u lAq6k¯¡.i<d$Œ u iDdgi,nAesiDŸ°opnÁeg¡.i@ŒqrŒi u oph'Œ {}iDh'iDnAe

hjiDk¯¡ q6n.o|dQhdes¡ qHei,hjŒlHœi u n.lcŸci<d[œo}eg¡?mdQi,˜ m.{o}nc˜ l u hqregopl6n?qrzl6m.e[eg¡ i$n.i,eRœl ugž ¬dgm k¯¡±q]d!zl u Ÿci u ŸciesiDkegopl6n±q6n Ÿ

k,q u Ÿ.o}n q6{}o}eRb6¬Ÿci,ndQo}eRb²k,q uesl6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k‘hqrŒ ¹ l u Ÿci,n dgo}eRb]™`z q]dQi<Ÿ²o|dQl]{}opn.i<ds¿¬Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,i~eglªŸciDn dQi u i,Ž]o}l]n d,¬ie¯k ¥ ¦ ¡.o|djopd

q6k¯¡ o}iD£6iDŸm dgopn.Ž!l6n {}byeg¡.in qHesm u qr{]q6n Ÿ¨{plWkDqr{Ak,qrŒqrz.op{}o}egopiDd/lr˜.œou iD{}i<dgd/k,l6hjh$m n.opkDqHeso}l]n‘¹R·.;! .p¬rm.n Ÿci u {pbWo}n Ž!kl6n n.iDkegop£Ao}eRb6¬

hjiDdsdgq6Ž6i<dlH£6i u ¡.i<q u o}n Ž ¬q6n Ÿ n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl u ¡.lWlcŸÁ£Oq u o|qHeso}l]n d¯¿ ¥ ¦ ¡ qHe%o}n.˜ l u hjqregopl6n k,q6n eg¡.iDn zi±m dgiDŸÁesl²oph'Œ {}iDh'iDnAe

£Hq u o}l]m dn.i,eRœl ugž ˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n qr{po}egopiDd ¥´¦ ¡ opd!dgiDkegopl6n?Ÿco|dskm dsdQi<d´eg¡ i˜ m.n Ÿ.q6hji,nAesq6{Œ u o}nkopŒ.{}i<d´eg¡qHe[m.nŸci u {}opii<q6k¯¡~lr˜^l6m u

kl]nAe u o}z.m.egopl6n d ¥

"!$#&%('*)+!$#&%,-".%0/12436557.98:;1<%0)>=?@=%0)+A

t l]dgo¢eso}l]n$qOœ´q u i,n.i<dgdo|dq ž i,b˜ m.n kegopl6n q6{}o}eRb¨eglyz.m.op{pŸ*qrn Ÿ$hjq6o}nAe¯qropn$qrmcesl6n.l]hjl6m dn.ieRœl usž i<ŸdQbcdQegi,hd ¥ xÁklWl u Ÿcopn qHesi

dgbWdQegiDh Œ u lH£Ao|Ÿci<diDq]k¯¡²n.lcŸci%œo}eg¡Cq *QŒlAdQo}egopl6n),‘es¡ qHejo|d*zlres¡Copn Ÿcop£WopŸ.m qr{qrnŸ°Ž6{pl6zqr{p{}bªkl]n dgopdQegiDn]e ¥ x[dqr{u iDq6Ÿ.b

l6zdQi u £]iDŸ¬q®n lWŸ.i%n ieRœl usž qOœq u iDn.iDdsd*hjqObCkl6hji%˜u l6h eRœlªdQl]m u k,iDdDµ%q6nÄ·;:87¤·; ¤·9EDCDF #!BI?/1! ui<dQm {¢eso}n.ŽÂ˜u l6h

eg¡ i'q6{}Ž]l u o¢es¡.h i­ciDk,mcegopl6n²¹B!?.0/.p¬/n.iDo}Ž]¡Wzl u ddQi,eD¬¡.l]Œ±Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,i$eslq%dQŒiDk,o¢©k$n.lcŸci]¬Kiesk ¥¿¬/qrn Ÿ !-A1!"76# EFG#H!'I$/!

dgm.Œ.Œ.{po}i<ŸUzWb‘i,­Wegi u n q6{KŸ.i,£Wopk,iDd¨¹-! .0/.CBdsqHesi,{p{}o}egi¨l uuq6Ÿ.o}ljdQopŽ6nqr{Ÿci,£Wo|kiO¿¤¬cl u Ÿci<dQopŽ6n¡WbAŒlres¡.iDdgo|d¹=dQmk¯¡%q]d"*Qq6{}{dgi,n dgl u d

¡ qO£]iqjm.n oAm.ij·I ,¤¬ *Reg¡ in ieRœl usž opdopn.o}ego|qr{p{}bkl6n n.iDkegiDŸ),¯¬ci,esk ¥¿ ¥

¦ ¡.i®Œ.¡WbWdgo|k,qr{Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,i±zieRœi,i,n n.lcŸciDd%dQ¡q u o}n.Žes¡.idgq6h'i *RŒl]dgo¢eso}l]n),?opd%q u i,{pi,£Hq6n]eh'i,eu opk?eglCiDdQegophjqregiÂq

klWl u Ÿcopn qregidQbcdQegiDh Ud Am q6{}o}eRbX)p€$+¬åˆr‰D,¥ aWl6hjin.i,eRœl ugž ˜ m n k¤eso}l]n qr{po¢eso}i<d u i Am.ou i´i,­Ae u iDhji,{pb*dg¡ q u ŒklWl u Ÿcopn qHesi´dgbcdResi,h

¹-! .0/.p¬Ž u i,iDŸ.b u l6mceso}n ŽA¿¤¬œ¡.op{}i*lres¡.i u d[q6{}{plHœ!d´˜ l u qœiDq ž i u ˜ l u h¹B!?.0/.CBŸ qHesqUqrŽ6Ž u iDŽ]qregopl6n¿ ¥´¦ ¡ i$Œ q6Œi uyu i˜ i u eglq

klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregi¨dQbcdQegi,h Am qr{po¢eRbq6do¢e¯d<-T D78SCC!"'

¥

³n »

³R¼½¾

aK¬iDq]k¯¡ n.lcŸci±o|d‘opn.o}ego|qr{p{}b kl]nc© Ž]m

u

i<Ÿ œo¢es¡ eg¡ i®Œ q

u

q6hjiegi

u

d

opn Ÿco|k,qregopn.Ž°es¡.i®Ÿ.o}hji,ndQopl6n l6˜eg¡.i klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregidQbcdQegiDh ¹ nWm.h*zi

u

lr˜klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregiDd¯¿

¥¦

¡.i£Wo

u

egm q6{1klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregiDdl6˜´q~n.lcŸci

i

^{q u} i‘kl]n dQiAm.i,nAeg{pb±q%esm.Œ.{pi

(x 1 , . . . , x d )

^{¬.œ¡.i u i}

x j

o|deg¡.iŒ

u

lrwRi<k¤eso}l]nUlr˜

i

^l]nes¡.i

j

eg¡@qH­co|dlr˜eg¡.i

d

™`Ÿcophji,n dgopl6n q6{£Ao

u

egm q6{/dQΠq]ki

¥

ÛàA÷Y`"a'b

(2, 4, 2) (1, 1, 5)

(5, 0, 4) Segment for

coordinate 1 Segment for

coordinate 2

Segment for coordinate 3

ç

(4)

(3) (1) (2)

Ideal case

VINCOS Low level of sharpness external knowledge

High level of

High Cost (1) Satellite−based methods (3) Rao et al. method, in [10]

(2) Measurement−based methods (4) Benbadis et al. method, in [20]

=

! o}Ž]m u iˆ.µ¹=q]¿x!nji,­cq6hjŒ.{}i´l6˜£Wou egmqr{.klWl u Ÿcopn qregiDd ¥ ¹åz¿» ³R¼¨½¾ a*œ ¥u<¥e ¥ k,l]dQeD¬ri,Ƒkopi,n k,b6¬6q6n Ÿ'i­Wegi u n q6{ ž n lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6i ¥

¦

¡.ij£Wo

u

egmqr{

d

™`Ÿ.o}hji,ndQopl6n q6{vdQŒq6kijo|dŸci,© n.iDŸq]d˜ l6{p{}lHœ!d

¥‘¦

¡.izl

u

Ÿ.i

u

lr˜eg¡ iŽ6i,l]Ž

u

qrŒ.¡ opkDqr{q

u

iDq%klH£6i

u

i<Ÿ?zWb

eg¡ in.lcŸciDd!opd[Œ q

u

ego}egopl6n.i<Ÿ%o}nAegl

d

*Qdgi,Ž]hji,nAesdG,

¥¦

¡.opd!zl

u

Ÿci

u

dgi,Ž6hji,nAe¯d!k,q6n%¡qO£6ieg¡.i*dgq6h'idgop§,il

u

ŸcoKKi

u

i,nAe[dgo}§DiDd

¥

Î/i,em d´kl6ndQo|Ÿci

u

q6nAb‘qr­copd

j

^¬

1 ≤ j ≤ d

¬.l6˜/eg¡ i¨k,lWl

u

Ÿco}nqHegi¨dgbWdQegiDh

¥¦

¡ i¨k,lWl

u

Ÿco}nqHegi

x j

o|deg¡.i¨{pi,n.Ž6eg¡/¬copn¡ l6Œ dD¬Wlr˜

qdg¡.l u egi<dReŒ qreg¡~˜u l6h es¡.in.lcŸci

i

egljeg¡ izl u Ÿ.i u dgi,Ž6hjiDn]e

j

¹R·.;! .p¬ esljeg¡.i*k{pl]dgiDdQe´n lWŸ.il6n%eg¡qHe!zl u Ÿci u dgi,Ž]h'iDnAe¯¿ ¥

¦ ¡.o|d^o|do}{p{}mdRe u qregiDŸ'l]n ! opŽ6m u i[ˆ.¹=q]¿eg¡ u l6m Ž6¡jqdgoph'Œ {}ii,­cq6hjŒ.{}i ¥¦ ¡ i!klWl u Ÿcopn qHesidgbcdResi,ho|d

3

™`Ÿcophji,n dgopl6n qr{¹

d = 3

^{¿ ¥}

¦ ¡.iy£Aouegm q6{klWl u Ÿcopn qregiDdvlr˜eg¡ u iDi[n.lcŸci<d1q u i!opn Ÿco|k,qregiDŸ ¥¦ ¡ iyklWl u Ÿcopn qregiDd

(2, 4, 2)

hjiDqrnd^eg¡qHe1es¡.iyk,l usu i<dQŒl6nŸco}n Ž n.lcŸcio|d[qreyŸco|dRe¯qrn k,i

2

l6˜zlres¡~eg¡.i*zl u Ÿ.i u d

1

^{qrn Ÿ}

3

¬qrnŸ@qHeyŸco|dQesqrnki

4

^{l6˜es¡.izl u Ÿci u}

2

^¥ x[d[h'iDnAegopl6n.i<Ÿ~zi,˜ l u i6¬

dgm k¯¡°q?klWl u Ÿcopn qregiUdgbcdResi,hopd*n.lre u iD{pqregiDŸÂesl®q6nAbqrnk¯¡.l u d¨l u ŒlAdQo}egopl6nc™›qOœ´q u i'{|qrnŸchq usž d ¥@³n dQegi<q6Ÿo}e'k,q6Œcegm u i<d

opnA£Hq u o|qrn k,iyŒ u l]Œi u eso}i<dq6dsdQlcko|qHesiDŸUœo¢es¡~k,l6n.n iDk¤eso}£Wo}eRb‘l6n {}b ¥

¦ ¡.iUdg¡ q u Œ.n iDdsdlr˜» ³R¼¨½¾ a®eg¡Wm dD¬^Ÿci,Œi,n Ÿ d$l]n°qrn°q6kDkm u qHesi‘Ÿci©n.o¢eso}l]n°lr˜´es¡.i'7-I1!"7X$!8/R!"¤¬·.;!?.p¬^es¡.i

d

*gdQiDŽ6hji,nAesdG,´Ÿ.o}£Wo|Ÿco}n Ž¨eg¡.i!zl u Ÿci u lr˜eg¡.iykl6ndQo|Ÿci u iDŸ*Ž6iDl6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k,qr{cq u i<q ¥¦ lŸci,© n.ies¡.i!zl u Ÿci u dgi,Ž]h'iDnAesdD¬6» ³R¼¨½¾ a

u i,{po}i<dl6n q'!$#yk,l6n dQe u m k¤eso}l]n h'i<k¯¡ qrn opdgh ¥9¦ ¡.i u i<dQm.{}egopn.Žªzi,{}eD¬!Ÿci,© n.i<Ÿ q6d‘qªdgielr˜ '7-I1!"76&'!$# ?I1!6]¬opdUq

l6n i™›Ÿco}hjiDn dQopl6n n.n qr{/k,l6n.n iDk¤esiDŸ%dRe u mk¤egm u i¨es¡ qHe$¹Q·¢¿´i,n q6z.{piDdkl]hjh$m.n.o|k,qregopl6n~qrhjl6n Ž*zl u Ÿci u ™`ziD{¢e!n.lcŸci<dqr{pl6n.Ž'eRœl

ŸcoHKi u iDnAeŒqHeg¡d,À ¹Q·š·¢¿qr{p{}lHœ!dq6n$l u Ÿci u q]dgdgo}Ž]n.hji,nAeeglyeg¡.i<dQi´n.lcŸci<d,À ¹Q·š·š·¢¿o|dl]n.i™`¡.l]Œ$œo|Ÿci6ÀAqrn Ÿ¹R·;[¤¿¡ q6dŒ u l6Œl u egopl6n q6{

dgo}§Di@œ

u

ees¡.i?n.i,eRœl

ugž

dgop§,i

¥L¦

¡.o|diDn dQm

u

i<djeg¡ qreD¬´Ž6op£6iDnÁeg¡.i@z

u

l]q]Ÿ.k,q]dRe‘k,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6n Œ qreQesi

u

n/¬q6{}{yhjiDdsdgq6Ž6i

˜ l

u

ϫq

u

ŸciDŸqr{pl6n.Ž*eg¡.izi,{}e$¹åk,l6hjŒ.{piesi

u

l]m.n Ÿ ¿

u

iDq6k¯¡ iDdi,£]i

u

b‘zl

u

Ÿ.i

u

™Yzi,{}en lWŸ.i

¥

¼ iD£6i u es¡.i,{piDdsd,¬HŸco|dsklH£6i uopn.Ž[qkl]n.n.i<k¤egi<Ÿ$zl u Ÿci u qre^qy{plHœ²klAdRe^qrn Ÿ$o}njqrn'q6kDkm u qHesi1œ´qObopdŸco}Ƒkm.{}e ¥ iŸci<dgk u opzi

qHe´es¡.i$aWiDkegopl6n + ¥ ¬c¡ lHœ » ³R¼¨½¾ aUk,l6hjŒ.mcesiDd!dgm k¯¡~q'ziD{¢e<¬ u i,˜ i usu i<ŸU¡ i u iDqH˜šesi u q6d 'D7-IR!$76&'!"#¥

5$= %"5&;1;1! =?-= %0)+A = .)+ % )<8 '*57.

¦ ¡.i´oph'Œl u esq6n ki´l6˜qklWl u Ÿcopn qHesidgbcdResi,h ˜ l u qrmcesl6n.l]h'l]m ddQbcdQegi,hdo|d^Ÿci,hjl]n dRe u qregi<ŸzWbeg¡ i£Oq]dRe^{po¢esi u qHesm u il6n*eg¡ i

egl]Œ.o|k)}€"V

¬›ƒ ¬`V€D ¬Rˆr‰,

¥$

iDŽ]q

u

Ÿcopn.ŽqrzdQl]{}mcesiŒlAdQo}egopl6n o}n.Ž‘dgbcdResi,hdD¬.eg¡ i{}o}egi

u

qregm

u

i¨opdyŸcl6hjopn qHesiDŸ%zWbUes¡.i$dsqHesi,{p{}o}egi,™

z q]dQi<Ÿh'i,eg¡.lcŸ.dD¬^{po

ž

i%Ã

t a )ƒ,`¬1Ã{pl6n q]dgdX)}€$,Y¬^qrnŸ²Ã¨qr{po}{pi,l )ˆ,

¥=

]m o}Œ.Œ o}n.Žqr{p{1iDnAego}egopiDd*œo¢es¡Cq?dsqHesi,{p{}o}egi

u

i<ki,op£6i

u

kl]n dQego}egmcesiDdyeg¡.ijziDdQeœ´qOb%egl%Œ

u

lH£Ao|Ÿci$eg¡.iDh œo¢es¡®q£6i

u

b~¡.opŽ6¡®{}iD£6i,{l6˜1i­Wegi

u

nqr{

ž

n lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6i]¬

u

iDdgm.{}egopn.ŽUopnq‘£6i

u b

iƑk,o}iDn]evk,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregidgbWdQegiDh ¹ådgi,i

!

opŽ6m

u

i!ˆ.¹ z¿Q¿

¥ n.˜ l

u

egm.n qregiD{}b]¬reg¡ opd^q6Œ.Œ

u

l]q6k¯¡'dQm Ki

u

d˜

u

l6h ophjŒl

u

e¯qrnAe^Ÿ

u

qOœzq6k

ž d

œ¡.iDn±qrŒ.Œ {}opiDŸ~esldgi,n dgl

u

n.ieRœl

usž

d,µo}eo|d[i,­cŒiDn dQop£6i]¬iDn.i

u

Ž6bA™`o}n iƑkopi,nAeD¬KqrnŸ?k,q6n.n.lreyœl

ugž

œ¡.i,n?eg¡.ijdQiDn dgl

u

d!q

u i

ŸciDŒ.{}lHb]iDŸ~opn±q§Dl6n.ies¡ qHeopdyl6m.eylr˜1dsqHesi,{p{}o}egi<d u iDk,i,op£6i u dgk,l6ŒiDd$¹=q6d[o¢e¨opd!eg¡.i'k,q]dQiopn±dgl6hji$opn ŸclWl u l u m.n Ÿci u Ž u l]m.n Ÿ

dgi,n dgl u ŸciDŒ.{}lHbWhji,nAe¤¿ ¥

ß´ç¯áYáYîA9ßëíàæ21<ßDHç4DrßRäQð 7"?é?/:?è:?íðræ21Oçsæ1æC1Oߛø 1HçRôß!ç4D:DOä</HODë>9!çsæYßRéøæC1Oßá`ç49ß1áYëRßB?I1Oëíá^öOßGDrßRàOöOá"/¤àOéø /¤àæ21<ßç¯éíèB/¤ä=ëæC1:9Lç¯àOö

9!çQø!ßQç¯á=ëíéøF=6ß^ò21Hç¯àOè¤ßRö ?

ÜN/,öOßRáæC1Hçsæç¯ä=ß^é>/,òQçsæYßRöçsææ21<ß D6ßRäåë>9ߛæYßRä/46cæ21Oßvè¤ßG/¤è¤ä=ç4D:1OëíòQç¯é.ç¯ä=ßQçA?

Þ%æ2/ /1á29!ç¯éíé0=rßRéæòG/¤îOéíöè¤ßRàOßRäYçsæ=ß^ëíàHç¯òRòRîOäYç¯òRëíßRáëíà´æ21OßòG//¤äåöOëíàHçsæ=ß^á=øDá=æ=ßG9ªä=ßRáYî<éæYëíàOèëíà9!ç¯à,øà:/¤à<â|àOßRëíèB1=M/¤ä/à:/,öOßRá8=6ßRëíàOè1ç¯á=áYëíè¤àOßRö

æC/æ21<ß1áYç49ßòG//¤äåöOëíàHçsæ=ßRáH?

¦

¡.o|djŒ

u

l6z.{pi,h k,qrnÁzi±dQl]{}£]iDŸCzWb°i Am.opŒ.Œ.opn.Žªl6n {}bÁq±˜ iDœ i,nAego}egopiDd?¹=k,q6{}{piDŸÁŒl]dgo¢eso}l]nc™`qOœ´q

u

iU{|qrnŸchq

usž

d¯¿*œo¢es¡

q?dsqHesi,{p{}o}egi

u

i<ki,op£6i

u

¬qrnŸ{}i,e$eg¡ iUlres¡.i

u

i,nAego}egopiDd*opnc˜ i

u

eg¡.iDo

u

ŒlAdQo}egopl6n°˜

u

l]hk,l6n.n.i<k¤eso}£Wo}eRb®opnc˜ l

u

hqHeso}l]n/¬l

u

dgopŽ6n q6{

dQe u i,n.Ž6eg¡'h'i<q6dgm u i,hji,nAesd ) ¬š.¬`€]€6¬`€ Vc€<, ¥ ¡.op{pi!qr{p{}lHœopn.ŽydgbcdResi,hdegl¨zi!ŸciDdgopŽ6n.i<Ÿ$œo}eg¡*˜ i,œi u i,­Aesi u n qr{ ž n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]i

¹R·.;! .p¬/l]n.{}b%˜ iDœ i,nAego}egopiDd ž n.lHœÄeg¡ i,ou Œl]dgo¢eso}l]n¿¤¬dgm k¯¡?¡WbWz u opŸ?q6Œ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡.iDd!q u i*kl]dQeg{pb@qrn Ÿ±q u i$n.l6eyiƑk,o}iDn]ey˜u l]h q

klWl u Ÿcopn qregiyq]dgk,i u esq6o}n.hjiDn]eŒl]o}nAe´lr˜£Wopi,œ ¥ …yoKKi u i,nAes{}b]¬.dQl]{}mceso}l]n d1eg¡ qre´q u i!zq6dgiDŸ‘l]n.{pb'l]nk,l6n.n.i<k¤eso}£Wo}eRb ) ¬g€ ¬Q€$+R,

q u i?qr{pŽ6l u o}eg¡ h'o|k,q6{}{pb°dgo}hjŒ.{pi u<¥9¼ i,£]i u eg¡.iD{}i<dgdD¬1es¡.i,bÁ¡ qO£]i~q¡ o}Ž]¡ kl6hjh*m.n.o|k,qHeso}l]nÁk,l]dQeD¬´zi,opn.Žªeg¡ i,ou klWl u Ÿcopn qHesi

dgbWdQegiDh Ud´i,Æk,o}iDn kbdRe u l]n.Ž6{pbUŸciDŒiDn Ÿci,nAe!l6˜eg¡ i{pq6n Ÿchq usž dŸ.i,n dgo¢eRb%qrn ŸŒl]dgo¢eso}l]n.o}n Ž )p€<ˆ.¬Rˆr‰, ¥

x°hjl ui1qreQe u q]k¤egop£6iqrŒ.Œ u l]q]k¯¡˜ l u q6mcegl]n.l6hjl]m ddgbcdResi,hd/o|dœ¡ i,nn.lyŒlAdQo}egopl6n.™`qOœ´q u i u i,˜ i u i,nAego|qr{]opdm dgiDŸ ¥^½ {}i<q u {}b]¬

opn~eg¡.i'qrz dgi,n k,ilr˜vi,­Aesi u n qr{ ž n lHœ{}i<ŸcŽ6i]¬ dQiD{¢˜š™›dQe u m k¤esm u opn.ŽziDk,l6hjiDd[h'l u ik,l6hjŒ.{pi­¬ u i]m ou o}n Ž‘dQbcdQegi,hd´esl‘ziDkl]hji

dQegop{}{^hjl u ijqrmcesl6n.l]h'l]m d ¥³n®l u Ÿci u esl%k,l6Œijœo¢es¡±es¡.opd¨o|dsdQm.i]¬ u i<kiDn]e u iDdgiDq u k¯¡.i<d!Œ u l6Œl]dgi*dgl6{pmcegopl6nd[es¡ qHe u iDdgm.{}eopn

[<·;76J:D#>9'?D7-IH·;!6´ziDo}n Žjq]dgdgopŽ6n.i<Ÿ‘esl'n lWŸ.iDdD¬co}n dQegi<q6Ÿ%lr˜Ž6iDl6Ž u qrŒ ¡.opkklWl u Ÿcopn qregiDd*).¬¯€D‰ ¬Rˆr‰,¥

ç

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

y

x Parti ti ons

parti tion 1 parti tion 2 parti tion 3 i ni ti ators

=

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

y

x Network partitioning

Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Group 4

ò

! opŽ6m u i µ¹åqA¿`™¤¹ z¿ = ­.q6h'Œ {}il6˜Ž]i,l6hji,e u opkdRe u mk¤egm u opn.Ž ¥ ¹=kD¿ = ­.qrhjŒ.{pilr˜˜ m.n kegopl6n q6{dRe u mk¤egm u opn.Ž ¥

!

o}Ž]m

u

i%ˆ.¹åz¿$£Ao|dgm qr{po}§DiDd*eg¡ i%k¯¡ q

u

q]k¤esi

u

opdQego|k,d$lr˜

u

i,{|qHesiDŸ°œl

usž

dopn°es¡.i~{}o}egi

u

qregm

u

ik,l6hjΠq

u

iDŸªegl®eg¡.i~»

³R¼¨½¾

a

qrŒ Œ

u

lAq6k¯¡

¥³

edQ¡.lHœ!d!eg¡.iDo

u

ŸcoHKKi

u

i,n k,iDdyœo¢es¡

u

iDdgŒi<k¤eyegl~kl]dQeD¬k,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregi'dQbcdQegi,h i,Æk,o}iDn kb°¹Q·.;!?.p¬o¢e¯ddg¡ q

u

Œ.n iDdsds¿¬

qrnŸUopn.o}ego|qr{ ž n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]i ¥^¦ ¡.ik{pl]dgiDdQe´egl'eg¡ il u o}Ž]o}n/¬Wes¡.izieQesi u o|deg¡ ikl6hjŒ u l6hjo|dQizieRœi,i,n%es¡.iDdgieg¡ u i,ik u o}egi u o|q ¥

) %) 5@ !7) 5$A ) %0.9 3 =% . /13 %/-.9 ;-!

³

nªes¡.iU{po¢esi

u

qHesm

u

i]¬n ieRœl

usž

klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregiDd*q

u

ihqropn.{}bm dgiDŸÂ˜ l

u$u l6mceso}n Ž

¥ iq

u

Ž6m ijeg¡ qre$eg¡ i,o

u

opnAegi

u

iDdQe$Ž]lAi<d˜åq

u

zi,b6l]n Ÿ

¥

¡.i,n‘q6Œ.Œ

u

l6Œ

u

o|qHegiD{}bhq6n.o}Œ m.{pqregi<Ÿ¬6n.i,eRœl

ugž

klWl

u

Ÿcopn qHesiDd

u

iDŒ

u

iDdgi,nAesd^q¨ŒlHœi

u

˜ m {WeglWl6{c˜ l

u

ŸcoHKi

u

iDnAe

ž

opn Ÿ.d

lr˜/n ieRœl

usž

hqrnqrŽ6iDhji,nAe

¥ x hq6o}n%kl6nAe

u

opz.mceso}l]n‘lr˜es¡.opdŒ q6Œi

u

{popiDdo}n%dQ¡.lHœopn.Ž¡ lHœ egl

u

i,{pbjl6nUdgm k¯¡Uq*klWl

u

Ÿcopn qHesi

dgbWdQegiDh ˜ l u q6n~l u o}Ž]o}n q6{KŒ.m u ŒlAdQi ¥

ñ0/¤ä ßO<ç49DOéíߤðsæC1OßáYëíè¤àOç¯é9ßQç¯áYî<ä=ßG9ßRà,æåâ=Hç¯á=ßRöáC/¤éíî<æYë>/¤à<áí÷Yb<ðp÷-aHç¯äåßéíßQá=ácßòRëíßQàæ ëíàëíà<ö://¤ä+/¤äcîOà<öOßRä=è¤ä</¤îOàOößRàô<ëíä</¤à:9ßRà,æ=á =6ßRá=ëíöOßRá

=rßRëíàOèç¯éíèB/¤äåëæ21:9ëíòQç¯éíéø!òG/¤á=æ=éíßRáYáR?

ÛàA÷Y`"a'b

x dQŒiDk,o¢©k*n.i,eRœl

ugž

dRe

u

mk¤egm

u

ijdQ¡ l6m.{|Ÿ@i,nqrz.{pi*n lWŸ.iDd[egl%Ž6ieq6dsdgo}Ž]n.iDŸ?Ÿ.oKKi

u

i,nAe¨ziD¡ qO£Wo}l

u

dB%<˜ m.nk¤egopl6nqr{po¢eso}i<d!Ÿci™

Œi,n Ÿcopn.Žl]nes¡.i,o

u

Œl]dgo¢eso}l]n%opn%eg¡.in ieRœl

usž¥

x[{¢es¡.l6m Ž6¡%eg¡.o|d!kDqrn%zii<q6dgo}{pbUŸcl]n.im.Œl6n@qrnWb‘Œl6{|q

u

k,lAl

u

Ÿ.o}n qregi<d,¬Wœi

dg¡.lHœ ¡.i u i¨¡.lHœ ¼ i,e¯Ãi,lWa‘o|d!ŸciDŒ.{plHb6iDŸUm.Œl6n~» ³R¼¨½¾ a ¥

¼ i,e¯ÃiDlAa%Ÿci©n.iDdyq‘dQŒiDk,o¢©k¨˜ l u h$m.{|q*eg¡ qreD¬l6n k,iqrŒ.Œ {}opiDŸ%esleg¡.i$£Aou egm q6{klWl u Ÿcopn qHesiDd´l6˜i<q6k¯¡~n.lcŸci]¬ Ž6op£6i<d u opdgi

egl*qdQŒiDk,o¢©k!Ž6i,l]hjie u o|kdReu m kegm u opn.Ž‘¹šes¡ qHekDqrnjes¡.i,n‘Ÿco|k¤e¯qHesi!l u Ž]q6n.o}§<qHeso}l]n*{|qOœ!d˜ l u eg¡.i!n lWŸ.iDdvopnjeg¡ i!n.ieRœl usž ¬r{pož i

eg¡ iyl]n.i u i Am.ou i<Ÿ'˜ l u µk,{}mdResi u o}n.Ž¬AŸ qHesq*qrŽ]Ž u i,Ž]qregopl6n/¬6l u iDn.i u Ž6bk,l6n dgm.hjŒcegopl6nUhjq6n qrŽ]i,hji,nAe¤¿ ¥ x[dqrn‘i,­cq6hjŒ.{}i]¬W{}i,e

m dkl]n dQo|Ÿci u dgi,n dgl u dvŸco|dsdQiDh'opn qregiDŸ‘o}n%q{|q u Ž6i!Ž]i,l6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k,q6{.q u iDq ¥¦ ¡.i<dQidQiDn dQl u dq u i!Œ q u eso¢eso}l]n.iDŸopnes¡ u iDi[Ž u l]m.Œ dD¬

eg¡ i 76T%Ž u l]m.Œ/¬es¡.i 4D;TŽ u l]m.Œ/¬q6n Ÿ®eg¡.i$:7¨Ž u l]m.Œ ¥¦ ¡.i = Am qregl u Ž u l6m.Œ®opdq@dgoph'Œ {}iE*gdRe u q6o}Ž]¡Ae{po}n iB,

lr˜n.lcŸci<d¨eg¡qHe*dgi,Œ q u qregopn.Ž%eg¡.iUn.l u eg¡ªqrnŸÂdgl6m.eg¡ªŽ u l6m Œ d ¥ Î/ie*m dkl]n dgopŸci u eg¡ iUqrŒ.Œ {}o|k,qregopl6nªdgk,i,n q u opl~œ¡.i u ijeg¡ i

n.lcŸci<d¨o}n®eg¡.i ¼ l ueg¡®q6n ŸaWl6mces¡®Ž u l]m.Œ dq u i*opnk¯¡ q u Ž6i*lr˜k,l6{p{}i<k¤eso}n.Ž~dgl6hji*opnc˜ l u hqHeso}l]n/¬/dgm.z dgi Am.i,nAes{}b±dgi,nAe¹ £Wo|q

q u l6m.egopn.Ž‘Œ u lreslWk,l6{š¿´esl‘eg¡ i = Am qregl u Ž u l6m Œ ¥[t i u oplWŸ.opkDqr{p{}b]¬qUŒ.{pq6n.iN^o}i<dylH£]i u es¡.i = Am qHesl u {popn.i'q6n Ÿ?k,l6{p{}i<k¤esd[eg¡ i

u i,{pi,£HqrnAevŸ.qHe¯q¨dResl u iDŸ*o}n'eg¡ i = Am qHesl u dgi,n dgl u d ¥¦ lophjŒ.{pi,hji,nAe1dgm k¯¡qrnjqrŒ.Œ.{po|k,qHeso}l]n/¬Hes¡.i!dQiDn dgl u n.i,eRœl ugž dg¡.l6m {pŸ'zi

Œ q u eso¢eso}l]n.iDŸ%opn?dQm k¯¡~es¡ u i,iŽ u l6m Œ d ¥³ e!egm u n d[l6mce[eg¡ qre!eg¡.o|d[kDqrn~ziiDq]dQop{}b%q6k¯¡.opi,£]iDŸ%œo}eg¡?q

2

™›Ÿcophji,n dgo}l]n qr{/£Wou esm qr{

klWl

u

Ÿcopn qregidgbcdResi,h

¥

Î/i,e

(x 1 , x 2 )

^{zi%es¡.i» ³R¼½¾ a²klWl u} Ÿcopn qHesiDd*lr˜[n.lcŸci

i

^¥

i

ziD{}l]n.Ž]d$egl®eg¡.i

¼ l u eg¡²Ž

u

l]m.Œ°o}˜

x 1 < x 2

¬.es¡.i*aWl]mceg¡@Ž

u

l]m.Œ~o¢˜

x 1 > x 2

qrnŸ%egles¡.i

=

Am qregl

u Ž u l6m.Œ~o}˜

x 1 = x 2

¥!

opŽ6m

u i

¹=q]¿Ž6op£6i<d!qrn@i,­.qrhjŒ.{pilr˜

dgm k¯¡%q'Ž]i,l6hji,e u opk¨dQe u m k¤esm u opn.Ž'o}n@q‘ˆ6‰6‰6‰r™Yn lWŸ.i[n.i,eRœl ugžK¥

aWophjo}{|q u {}b]¬Ho}njq

d

™›Ÿcoph'iDn dgo}l]n qr{WdQbcdQegiDh%¬reg¡.i´n.lcŸci<dkDqrn*zi´iDq]dQop{}bq]dgdglcko|qHegi<Ÿœo}eg¡'ŸcopdQegopn kevŒ q uego}egopl6n dq6d˜ l]{}{plHœ!d,µ eg¡ i‘n.lcŸci

i

zi,{pl6n Ž]degl?eg¡.iŒ q u eso¢eso}l]n

x

¬dQm k¯¡Âes¡ qHe

x = min(x 1 , . . . , x d )

^¥%¦ ¡.inWm.h$zi u l6˜Œq u ego}egopl6n dŸ.i,Œi,n Ÿ.d l6n {}b®l6nÂeg¡.iUn.ieRœl usž kl]n.n.iDkegop£Wo¢eRb ¥ x[d$dQ¡.lHœnopn ! opŽ6m u i ¹ z¿¬˜ l u q?ˆr‰]‰6‰H™`n.lcŸci'n.ieRœl usž ¬eg¡ iUdQophjŒ.{pij˜ l u h$m.{|q

x = min(x 1 , x 2 , x 2 )

Ÿci,© n.iDdi Am.op£Oq6{}iDnAeŒ q u ego}egopl6n dD¬œ¡ i u i'n lWŸ.iDdl6˜i<q6k¯¡ÂŒ q u ego}egopl6nªq u ik,q6Œcegm u iDŸÂzWb@es¡.iUdsqrhji

Œ u l6Œi u eRb?¹ n q6hji,{pb6¬.n.lcŸci<dqHe[Ÿco|dQesqrnki

x

^{˜u l]h} eg¡ ik{pl]dgiDdQe´zl u Ÿci u ¿ ¥

¾ eg¡ i u Ž6i,l]hjieu o|k,qr{Œ q u eso¢eso}l]n.o}n Ž%kDqrn±zi'l6zce¯qropn.iDŸ±zAb®Ÿci© n o}n.Ž~qrŒ Œ u l]Œ u opqregi$Œ u i<ŸcopkDqHesiDdyl6n?es¡.ij£Wou egm q6{^klWl u ™

Ÿcopn qHesiDd¨l6˜1eg¡ in.lcŸciDd ¥'¦ ¡ iDdgi'Œ u i<ŸcopkDqHesiDdhqOb@˜ l6{p{}lHœ /1!'B/D7-'S Tc·9l u %'9"Y·#Œ u o}n k,o}Œ {}i<d ¥¦ ¡.i'˜ l u hji u Ÿci,© n.iDd

Ž6iDl6hjie u o|k!dQe u m k¤esm u o}n.Ž*z q6dgiDŸ‘l6nes¡.iyŽ]i,l]Ž u qrŒ.¡.o|k´{plWkDqHeso}l]n‘lr˜es¡.iyn lWŸ.iDd¨¹åq]ddg¡.lHœnopn ! o}Ž]m u iDd ¹åqA¿vq6n Ÿ ¹åz¿Q¿ ¥^³n

eg¡ i${|qHegi u ¬eg¡ i$Ž6iDl6hjie u o|kdQeu m k¤esm u o}n.ŽUopdŸci©n.iDŸ@zq6dgiDŸ~l6n?˜ m.n k¤eso}l]n qr{zi,¡ qO£Wopl u l6˜vn.lcŸciDd[o}n±eg¡.i*n.ieRœl usžK¥ 2 l u i

dgŒi<ko}©k,q6{}{pb6¬o¢ee¯q ž i<d'o}nAeglªq]k,kl]m.nAe'n lWŸ.i%{pl6Ž]opkDqr{˜ iDqregm u iDdjzi,b]l6n ŸCn.lcŸci<d*Œl]dgo}egopl6n.opn.Ž ¥ ! l u i­.qrhjŒ.{pi6¬kl]n dQo|Ÿci u

dgi,n dgl u d^Ÿco|dgdgi,hjopn qHesiDŸ'o}n‘q¨{|q u Ž6i´Ž]i,l6Ž u q6Œ.¡.o|k,q6{Wq u i<q.¬6q˜ m n k¤eso}l]n qr{.Œ u i<ŸcopkDqHesi!k,qrnq6{}{plHœ²es¡.i[Ÿco|dQe u o}z.m.egopl6njlr˜/dgi,n dgl u d

opnes¡.in.i,eRœl ugž opn~h'o}­ciDŸŽ u l6m.Œd´lr˜Ÿ.oKKi u i,nAe[dQesqHesiDd´l6˜i,n i u Ž6bUk,l6n dgm.hjŒcegopl6n¬.q6ddg¡.lHœnopn ! o}Ž]m u i ¹=kD¿ ¥

x!n lreg¡ i u i,­cq6hjŒ.{}i[lr˜qrŒ.Œ.{po|k,qHeso}l]nlr˜qŽ6iDl6hjieu o|kdQe u m k¤esm u opn.Žo|degl*Ÿci© n i[q¡.opi u q u k¯¡.o|k,qr{.dQeu m kegm u i´eglophjŒ u lH£6i

Πu

lreslWk,l6{|d/œ¡.o|k¯¡$k,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6nk,l]dQeo|d

O(N ² )

^¥v½ l6ndQo|Ÿci

u

¬D˜ l

u

i­.qrhjŒ.{pi6¬Hq!n ieRœl

usž

œ¡.i

u

in.lcŸciDdk,q6nzi´Ÿcop£WopŸci<Ÿ

opn]esl

p

^{Œ q u} eso¢eso}l]n d¹

!

o}Ž]m

u i ¹ z¿ŸciDŒ.opkesd^dgm k¯¡*qyŒ q

u

eso¢eso}l]n.o}n Žyœo}eg¡

p = 3

^{¿ ¥} x[n*opn dQesqrnkilr˜ es¡.iz q6dgiŒ

u

l6eglckl]{WkDqrn*zi

i­ci<kmcesiDŸ%o}n~i<q6k¯¡%Œ q u ego}egopl6nª¹-! .0/.p¬.˜ l u q*{piDq]Ÿci u iD{}i<k¤eso}l]n¿œo¢es¡?klAdRe

O (N/p) ²

^{¥ xČ u}l6eglckl]{œ¡.opk¯¡@k,l]dQe´o|d

O(p ² )

k,q6n±es¡.i,nªzim dgiDŸ±egl@Œ.opiDk,ijeg¡.i u iDdgm.{}esd¨l6˜i<q6k¯¡ÂŒ q u ego}egopl6n ¹-! .0/1.CBo}nl u Ÿci u esl?Ÿciesi u hjo}n.i‘q%Ž]{}l]z qr{{piDq6Ÿ.i u qrhjl]n.Ž

eg¡ i{}i<q6Ÿci u d!lr˜^iDq]k¯¡@Œ q uego}egopl6n

p

^{¿ ¥!¦ ¡.o|d u} iDdgm.{¢e¯dopn±qŽ6{pl6zqr{/kl]hjh$m.n.o|k,qregopl6n?k,l]dQe!lr˜

O (N/p) ² + p ²

¬ opn dResiDq]Ÿ~lr˜

O(N ² )

lr˜^es¡.i$z q]dQi*Œ u lreglck,l6{ ¥[³n@˜åq]k¤eD¬Ko}e¡q6dyziDi,n±q6{u iDq]Ÿcb%dg¡.lHœn@opn?es¡.i*{po}egi u qHesm u ieg¡ qre¨k,{}mdResi u iDŸ@qrŒ Œ u lAq6k¯¡.i<d i­c¡.opz.o}e!zi,eQesi u dsk,q6{pq6z.o}{po}eRbŒ u l]Œi ueso}i<deg¡ q6n~m.n k{pm dQegi u i<ŸUl]n.iDd<)p€D‹D,¥

-7 #" # $ $&'†j+0%C%+

¦ l‘z.m.op{pŸ±qhjiDqrn o}n.Ž6˜ m.{klWl u Ÿcopn qHesidQbcdQegi,h~¬eg¡.i*n.lcŸciDd[n.i,i<Ÿ~eglq6k Am.ou i$dQl]hjiŽ6{pl6z q6{qrnŸ?kl]n dQo|dQegi,nAe ž n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]i

l6n'es¡.in.ieRœl usžK¥¦ ¡.iŒ u l]ŒlAdQi<Ÿ*q6Œ.Œ u l]q6k¯¡*Œ u lH£Ao|Ÿci<dn lWŸ.iDd^œo}eg¡q¨n.lH£]i,{.qrnŸ˜ m.{p{pb'Ÿci<kiDn]e u q6{}op§,i<Ÿ$œ´qObl6˜q6k Am.ou opn.Ž

eg¡qHe ž n.lHœ{piDŸcŽ]i ¥~¦ ¡.i‘Œ u lreslckl6{^o|d$k,l6hjŒl]dgiDŸÂlr˜´˜ l6m u kl]n dgiDkm.egop£6iŒ.¡ q]dQi<d¨eg¡qHe*q u i‘Ÿci<dgk u opziDŸopneg¡.i˜ l]{}{plHœopn.Ž

dgm.z dgiDk¤eso}l]n d ¥9³n l u Ÿ.i u egl²Œ u lH£Wo|Ÿci~eg¡ i u i<q6Ÿci u œo}eg¡ qŽ]{}l]z qr{!opnAegm.o}egopl6n¬´eg¡.i®m.n Ÿci u {pbWo}n.ŽªŽ]i,n.i u q6{!o|ŸciDqo|d© u dQe

Ÿci<dgk u opzi<Ÿ ¥

¦ ¡.i© u dQe$Œ.¡ q]dQiU{}iD£6i u qrŽ]iDdq?Ÿ.i,n dgo¢eRb¡WbWŒl6eg¡.i<dQo|desl?opŸ.i,nAego}˜ bªq?dQhq6{}{dQi,e$lr˜·; ·;Y·7'¤¬^œ¡.o|k¯¡°œop{}{¡ qO£6i‘q6n

oph'Œl u esq6nAe u l]{}i$lH£6i u eg¡.i*n.i­WeyŒ ¡ q6dgiDd!q6n Ÿ@i<dQŒiDk,opq6{}{pbopn@es¡.i$zl u Ÿci u ŸciesiDkegopl6n ¥ …ym u o}n Žeg¡.i'dQi<kl]n Ÿ~Œ.¡ q]dQi]¬i<q6k¯¡

n.lcŸcij{piDq u n d¨o}esdŸco|dQesqrnki'egl~iDq]k¯¡®opn.o}ego|qHesl u H¥ q]dQi<Ÿ±l]n±es¡.iDdgiŸco|dRe¯qrn k,iDdD¬q%ziD{¢el6˜zl u Ÿci u n.lcŸci<dopddgi,{piDkegi<Ÿ±opn

t ¡ q]dQi qrn ŸÂes¡.i‘zi,{}e*Ž6i,esd¨es¡.i,nCŸco}£Wo|ŸciDŸopnAegl

d

dQiDŽ6hji,nAesdU¹

d

zi,opn.Ž@es¡.iUŸcophji,n dgopl6nªlr˜´es¡.iUklWl u Ÿcopn qregi‘dgŒ q6k,i<¿ ¥

! o}nqr{p{}b]¬ opn t ¡ q]dQi +¬ iDq]k¯¡@Œ u lWk,iDdsd´{}i<q u n do}esdŸco|dRe¯qrn k,iœo¢es¡ u i<dQŒiDkeegl‘i<q6k¯¡~zl u Ÿci u dQiDŽ6hji,nAeD¬qrn Ÿ@k,l6hjŒ.mcesiDd!o}esd

d

™`Ÿcophji,n dgopl6n q6{/klWl u Ÿcopn qHesiDdz q6dgiDŸl6neg¡ iDdgio}nc˜ l u hqregopl6n ¥ x dgm.hjhjq u bl6˜es¡.iDdgiŒ.¡ q]dQi<do|d!Ÿci<dgk u opziDŸo}n ¦ qrz.{pij€ ¥ ãKßQëíà<è

N

æ21Oßvà,î:9$=rßRä/46.à:/,öOßRáëíà[æ21Oß^áåø<áåæYßG9L?

ۚàyæC1Oß 6;/¤éíé>/R7ëíà<èOðOçö<ëíá=æYç¯àOòRߝç¯é7çQøDáäåß6pßRäåáæC/æC1Oß"9ëíàOë>9!ç¯éHöOëíá=æYç¯àOòRß"=rßRæ7KßQßRàæ7/à:/Dö<ßQáëíà!æYßRä<9áN/46.à,î:9$=rßRä/46+1:/BDOáR?

i@i,£Hqr{pm qHesiDŸ²eg¡.o|d‘Œ

u

l6eglckl]{es¡

u

l6m.Ž]¡Ádgo}h*m.{|qHegopl6ndjo}n q{|q

u

Ž6i%nAm h$zi

u

l6˜n.i,eRœl

ugž

d ¥

i@m dgiDŸCes¡.opdUdQi,e‘lr˜

dgo}h*m.{pqregopl6n d[egl@dgiesm.Œ®dgl6hjijdQŒiDk,o¢©k*Œ q

u

q6h'i,egi

u

d'¹ hjl

u

ijŸcie¯qrop{pd¨q

u

i$Œ

u

lH£Wo|ŸciDŸ@opn®eg¡.ijŒ.¡ q]dQi<d$UKŸci<dgk

u

opŒcegopl6nds¿

¥E!

l u

iDq]k¯¡²Œ.¡q6dgi6¬1œi~qr{|dQlŒ u lH£Ao|Ÿci%qÂk,l6hjŒ.{pi­co}eRb°qrn q6{}bcdgopd ¥ i%hji<q6dgm u ieg¡ i~k,l6nW£6i u Ž]i,n k,iegophji@q6d*eg¡[email protected]*zi u lr˜

opn]esi u q6kegopl6n d¹=qrn@opnAegi u q6kegopl6n@o|d[Ÿci,© n.i<Ÿ@q6des¡.ieso}hji u i Am.ou iDŸ%˜ l u z u l]q6Ÿ k,q6dQegopn.Žq

1

™Y¡.l]Œ~h'i<dgdsqrŽ]i<¿ ¥³n?q]Ÿ.Ÿco}egopl6n/¬

˜ l u eg¡.iydgq ž ilr˜dgoph'Œ {}o|ko}eRb'q6n Ÿjœ ¥{¥l ¥Ž ¥¬6œi[q6dsdgm.hji!o}n‘eg¡.i[q6n qr{pbcdQo|dvq6nm.n.o}˜ l u h Ÿco|dQe u o}z.m.egopl6n‘l6˜Kn lWŸ.iDdvopnUqd Am q u i

Ž u o|Ÿ¬cl u qdgŒ q6k,iŸco}£Wo|ŸciDŸ~q]k,kl u Ÿ.o}n.Ž*egl‘qj{|qHegego|ki ¥v³n%eg¡.o|d!kl]nAegi­We<¬.kl6ndQo|Ÿci u opn.Ž

N

n lWŸ.iDdD¬ciDq6k¯¡ u lHœ l u k,l6{pm.hjn~lr˜

eg¡ i{pqreQego|ki,™`Ÿ.o}£Wo|ŸciDŸ%dQŒq6kik,l6nAesq6o}n d

√

N

^{n.lcŸciDd ¥}

- #12=) 2;1"%" %057. 8-) % )<3 %05$;

ç

20 25 30 35 40 45 50

0 50 100

150 200

250 300

350 400

450 500 x position

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 y position

20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55

score

=

! o}Ž]m u i + µ¹=q]¿ ¼ lcŸciDdyœo}eg¡±¡ o}Ž]¡.i u dgk,l u iDdyq u i{}lckDqHegi<Ÿ@l6n?eg¡.i'zl u Ÿ.i u<¥ ¹ z¿ ¦ ¡.i'Œi u o}hjiesi u zlWl6esdQe u qrŒ@n.lcŸci<dyq6n Ÿ

opn.o¢esopqregl

u

dŸci,© n.o}egopl6n%˜ l

u q

2000

™`n.lcŸciyn.ieRœl usžK¥

å’<–

Ì @ È

”

È JK

Ì

”

Ì/Ì Í ³

n%l

u

Ÿ.i

u

eglŸco|dgk,lH£6i

u

o}esd´lHœn%n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl

u

¡.lWlcŸ¬ciDq]k¯¡Un.lcŸci

i

^{z u} lAq6Ÿ.kDq6dQesdqjhjiDdsdgq6Ž6i k,q ugubWo}n ŽUo}esd¨o|Ÿci,nAego}eRb ¥'³ e¨eg¡.iDn®œ´qro}esdy˜ l u qdgo}hjop{pq u h'i<dgdsqrŽ]i˜ l u q‘©.­ci<Ÿ±Œi u o}lcŸ®lr˜veso}hji?¹ eg¡.iŸcm u qHeso}l]n±l6˜œ¡.o|k¯¡

o|dŸci,egi u hjopn.iDŸ ˜u l6h"dgo}h*m.{pqregopl6n u iDdgm.{}esd¯¿ ¥¦ ¡qHeœ´qOb6¬i<q6k¯¡ n.lcŸci

i

^{{}i<q u} n dUq6zl]mceo}esdn.i,opŽ6¡Wzl u d,¬!q6n Ÿ k u iDqregi<d kl]n dgi Am.i,nAes{}b?q{}lckDqr{^dQi,e

neighbors i

¥*¼ lcŸci

i

^{eg¡.iDn®z u} l]q]Ÿ.k,q]dRe¯d!es¡.ik,q u Ÿcopn q6{}o}eRb@lr˜ves¡.o|ddQi,e

| neighbors i |

^{dgleg¡ qre}

iDq]k¯¡n lWŸ.i{piDq u ndeg¡.inWm.h*zi u lr˜n.i,opŽ6¡Wzl u do}esd´n i,opŽ6¡Wzl u d´¡qO£6i ¥

%È “ È ” å“?å•.“ Ì ”O’ xees¡.iji,n ŸÂlr˜eg¡.lAdQi'eRœl%k,l6hjh$m n.opkDqHeso}l]nÂdQegiDŒ d,¬iDq6k¯¡Ân.lcŸci

i

o|dqrz.{pi'egl@Ÿci,egi u hjo}n i o}˜´o}e$o|dqrnopn.o}ego|qHegl uD¥ x!nªopn.o}ego|qHegl u o|d$q~{plWkDqr{*QhqH­co}hq6{,n.lcŸcij˜u l6h q@Ÿ.i,n dgo¢eRb®Œl]o}nAe$l6˜£Aopi,œ ¥³ nAegm.o}egop£6iD{}b]¬es¡.opd

o|d u i$^ iDkegi<Ÿ®zWbq~n.lcŸci¡ qO£Wopn.Ž@hjl u i'n i,opŽ6¡Wzl u des¡ qrnªo}esdn.i,opŽ6¡Wzl u d ¥ x n.lcŸci

i

o|dq6nªo}n.o}ego|qHesl u o}˜´eg¡.i˜ l]{}{plHœopn.Ž

Œ u iDŸco|k,qregi¨o|ddgqrego|dR© i<Ÿµ

∀ j ∈ neighbors i : | neighbors i | > | neighbors j | .

^¹R€O¿

aWoph$m.{|qHeso}l]n dl6nÂqU£]i

u

b@{pq

u

Ž]i$nWm.h$zi

u

l6˜dski,nq

u

o}lAd[¡ qO£]i*dg¡.lHœn?es¡ qHe<¬˜ l

u

nWm.hji

u

l]m d[n ieRœl

usž

dyœ¡.i

u

i'n.lcŸciDd

q u i'm.n.o}˜ l

u

h'{pb±Ÿco|dQe

u

o}z.m.egiDŸ/¬/eg¡ inAm h$zi

u

lr˜o}n o¢esopqregl

u d u

i,hqropn d{}lHœ ¹ m dgm q6{}{pb ¬ +%l

u

W6¿

¥

x[{¢es¡.l6m.Ž]¡®n lreegl~ziq

u i Am.o

u

iDh'iDnAe˜ l

u

es¡.iŒ

u

lreslWk,l6{8Udkl

ugu

iDkegn.i<dgdD¬cq*dghqr{p{nWm.h$zi

u

lr˜o}n o¢esopqregl

u

d´{piDq6Ÿ d1eslj{}i<dgdhjiDdsdgq6Ž6i<dq6n Ÿ‘iDn dgm

u

i<d´q

˜åq6dQegi u kl]nA£]i u Ž6iDn ki ¥N! o}Ž]m u i*+¹åqA¿dg¡.lHœ!dq6ni,­cq6hjŒ.{}i¨l6˜opn.o}ego|qHegl u d´dgi,{piDkegopl6n ¥

1È @ È ”H• C ÄÍ È ’?å“ É aWopn kiœi%q6dsdQm.hji%q?m.n.o}˜ l u h n.lcŸci%Ÿci,n dgo}eRb6¬vn.lcŸci<d*q uiUi­cŒi<k¤esiDŸªesl®¡qO£6iUq±nAm h$zi u lr˜

n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl u djŒ u l6Œl uegopl6n q6{egleg¡ i?q u iDqÂlr˜eg¡.i?dgbcdResi,h klH£6i ui<Ÿ°zWb°es¡.i,ou‘u q6Ÿcopl u q6n.Ž6i ¥ ¦ ¡.i u i˜ l u i~n.lcŸci<dl6nÁeg¡ i

zl u Ÿci u q u ii,­cŒi<k¤egi<Ÿ%egl‘¡qO£6iq u l6m n Ÿ%¡ qr{}˜^lr˜eg¡.i u q]Ÿcopl u q6n.Ž6iq u iDqD¤·I1!es¡.i$dgbcdResi,h qrn Ÿ%es¡.i u i˜ l u i]¬.¡ qr{}˜v{piDdsd

ÝßG9!ç¯ä<3!æC1Hçsæ/¤àOéø!æC1OßvàDî:9 =rßQä/46.àOßRëíèB1 =M/¤ä=áç¯àOöà:/¯æ/æC1Oßvéíëíá=æ/46.àOßRëíèB1 =M/¤ä=áQðrëíá=<äC/ç¯öOòQç¯áåæYßRö ?

ÛàA÷Y`"a'b

n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl

u d

¥¦

¡Wm dD¬]Œ

u

i<ŸcopkDqHesi€[iDn qrz.{piDdvegl'dQiD{}i<k¤e1opn.o}ego|qHegl

u

d1eg¡qHeq

u

i[n.lrel6njeg¡ iyzl

u

Ÿci

u

¹šeg¡ opdo|d1ophjŒl

u

e¯qrnAev˜ l

u

eg¡ i

n.i,­Ae!Œ ¡ q6dgiDdD¬.q6di­cŒ.{|qropn.i<Ÿ{|qHesi

u ¿ ¥

Ì È1 å“ É • • É ’ å’ ½ {piDq u {pb6¬<eg¡ ik,l6hjh$m.n opkDqHegopl6n*kl]dQelr˜ceg¡ opdŒ.¡q6dgi1o|d

2N

hjiDdsdgq6Ž6i<d,¬OdQopn kin.lcŸci<d© u dQeopnc˜ l u h eg¡ i,ou €™`¡.l]Œªn.i,opŽ6¡Wzl u dqrzl6mce$eg¡.iDou

id

d$q6n ŸÂeg¡ i,n/¬^l]n ki‘n i,opŽ6¡Wzl u d$q u iUŸco|dgk,lH£6i u iDŸ/¬/eg¡ i,bªdQiDn Ÿªq?dgiDk,l6n Ÿ €,™Y¡.l]Œ

hjiDdsdgq6Ž6i¨kl]n]e¯qropn.opn.Ž'eg¡.iDou nWm.h*zi u lr˜n.i,opŽ6¡Wzl u d ¥¦ ¡.i¨egophjilr˜^kl]nA£]i u Ž6iDn kiyopd

2

^{opn]esi u} q6kegopl6n d ¥

- #12=) 57.98-)+.= 3657.9) 81);: %"5$;

¦ ¡.i‘q6o}h lr˜eg¡.o|dŒ.¡ q]dQio|d¨esl@Œ u lH£Wo|ŸcijiDq]k¯¡®n.lcŸciœo}eg¡ªo}esd BD7-IR!$7M$9'7-!,¬Ÿ.i© n.i<Ÿ¡.i u iDqr˜šegi uD¥‘¦ l~eg¡ qrei,n Ÿ/¬i<q6k¯¡

n.lcŸciŸci,egi

u

hjopn.iDd´o}esd!Ÿ.opdQesq6n kieglji<q6k¯¡%o}n.o}ego|qHesl

u<¥

Ì “? CÍ>=’,“<• – È ’“ Ì  “?=•c“ Ì ”H’ =

q6k¯¡±opn.o}ego|qHesl

u

i

^{z u} l]q6Ÿ k,q6dQesdqh'i<dgdsqrŽ]i*k,l6nAesq6o}n.opn.Žo¢e¯d¨opŸciDnAego}eRb?qrn Ÿ®q

¡.l]ŒCkl]m.nAegi

u

¹åo}n o¢esopq6{}op§,i<Ÿ°esl

0

^{¿ ¥ x!˜šegi uu} i<ki,op£Wo}n Ž®q®h'i<dgdsqrŽ]i

m

^{qrnŸ°o}˜}

m

^{oph'Œ u} lH£]iDd*o¢e¯d'Ÿ.opdQesq6n ki%egl

i

^¬1n.lcŸci

j

opn k u iDq]dQi<dves¡.i¡.l6Œ~kl]m.nAegi u q6n Ÿz u lAq6Ÿ.kDq6dQesdo¢e´esl'o}esd´lHœn%n.iDo}Ž]¡Azl u dDÀ]l6eg¡.i u œo|dQi]¬

j

^{Ÿco|dgkDq u} Ÿ.d1eg¡.ihjiDdsdsqrŽ6i

m

^{¥v¦ ¡ i}

Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,i¨lr˜^q*n lWŸ.i

j

^{œ u} e[q6nopn.o}ego|qHesl u

i

^¹

dist(i, j)

¿o|d!Ÿci,© n.iDŸ%q6d˜ l]{}{plHœ!dDµ

dist(i, j) = min { dist(i, `) | ` ∈ neighbors j } + 1.

^¹=ˆ6¿

È  Ì ”HÍ È ”U’<– Ì ” ȑ¦

¡.i£Hqr{pm.iŸci,n lregi<Ÿ

score j

Ÿci©n.iDdes¡.i '7-I1!"7 $9'7B!´lr˜q*n lWŸ.i

j

¬q6d˜ l6{p{plHœ!d,µ

score j = X

i∈initiators

dist(i, j).

^{¹ ¿}

¦

¡.o|ddgk,l

u

i'Ÿ.i© n.o}egopl6nk,q6n®zi‘dgi,i,nq6d¨hji<q6dgm

u

opn.Ž~qrn*QqO£]i

u

qrŽ]i$Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,iB,$esl~q6nWb?o}n o¢esopqregl

u<¥

Î/ie

dist(i, `)

^zi

eg¡ i$Ÿco|dRe¯qrn k,ilr˜n.lcŸci

`

^{œo¢es¡ u} iDdgŒiDk¤e[egljeg¡ io}n o¢esopqregl

u

i

^¥ Î/ieym dl6zdQi

u

£]iyes¡ qHe[q6nWbUn.lcŸci

j

iDq6dgop{}b‘{piDq

u

nd

dist(i, `)

˜ l

u

iDq6k¯¡%n.lcŸci

` ∈ neighbors j

¥1¦

¡Wm dD¬.iDq]k¯¡n.lcŸcik,l6hjŒ.mcesiDdo}esdydgk,l

u

iq6n Ÿeg¡.i*dgk,l

u

iyl6˜o}esd[n.i,opŽ6¡Wzl

u d ¥ xk,k,l

u

Ÿcopn.Ž

egl

t

¡ q]dQi

1

¬Aeg¡.i¨qO£6i

u

q6Ž6i´Œl]dgo¢eso}l]n.o}n Ž$lr˜/opn.o}ego|qHesl

u

dvo|dqre1es¡.ik,i,nAegi

u

l6˜/eg¡.idQbcdQegiDh%¬Aes¡.i

u

i˜ l

u

i!n lWŸ.iDd1l]neg¡ iyzl

u

Ÿci

u

Ž6i,e[q'¡.o}Ž]¡.i

u

dgk,l

u

i[es¡ qrn~n.l]nc™Yzl

u

Ÿci

u

n.lcŸciDd

¥K!

o}Ž]m

u

i*+¹ z¿´dg¡.lHœ!d´opn@qjŽ

u

qOb‘dgkDqr{piyes¡.i$Ÿco|dQesqrnki¨lr˜n.lcŸciDd˜

u

l]hÅeg¡ i

opn.o¢esopqregl

u

dD¬cœ¡.i

u

ieg¡.iqO£]i

u

qrŽ]i!ŒlAdQo}egopl6n o}n.Žjo|d!qHe´es¡.ikiDn]esi

u<¥

Border width <=1 hop i

j h

ç

Stamp = g1, g2, g3, h1, h2, i a

b c d

e1 e2

f

m n

i

l h1

h2 g1 g2 g3

j1 j2 Stamp = c, b, d

hc = 7 hc = 6

=

!

o}Ž]m

u

iXWcµ¹=q]¿

¼

i,opŽ6¡Wzl

u

¡.lWlcŸ.dqHees¡.ieRœl@¡.l6Œd

i

^{qrn Ÿ}

j

^{o}nAegi u} dgiDkeD¬œ¡.o|k¯¡°qr{p{}lHœ!dn lWŸ.i

h

n.lre$egl@es¡.o}n

ž

¡ i‘¡ q6d

u iDkiDo}£]iDŸjŒ u l6ziDdv˜u l]h Ÿ.oKKi u i,nAedgo|ŸciDd ¥ ¹ z¿ tvu l6zi!hjiDdsdgq6Ž6iDdk,q ugu bWo}n.Žes¡.iyn i,opŽ6¡Wzl u dv{}o|dRelr˜es¡.i

2nd

^u i,{|qObAopn.Žn.lcŸci

%È °“? È 1È ” È “ È ” ¦

¡.i'dQi<kl]n Ÿ@qroph l6˜

t

¡ q]dQijˆjopd!egl%ŸcopdsklH£]i

u

dgl6hjin lWŸ.iDdes¡ qHej¹%"D7 67-!O¿!q

u

il]n@eg¡ i

zl

u

Ÿci

u

¬kDqr{p{}i<Ÿ@lr˜ S:!$7¤·;M!$5!$7 B J6J7BBS C IR!"

¥¦

¡.l]dgin.lcŸci<dyq

u

i$eg¡.i'l6n.i*o}n o¢esopqregopn.ŽUzl

u

Ÿci

u

™`ziD{¢e¨kl6ndRe

u

m kegopl6n?qre

t

¡ q]dQi

3

^{¥ x n.lcŸci}

j

^{{}i<q u} n dyo¢˜1o}eopd¨qUŒi

u

ophjiegi

u

zlWlre¯dRe

u

q6Œ±n.lcŸci'œo}eg¡

u

iDdgŒiDk¤eegl~qrn®o}n o¢esopqregl

u

i

o}˜1eg¡ i$˜ l]{}{plHœo}n Ž

Πu

iDŸco|k,qregi¨o|ddgqrego|dR© i<Ÿµ

∀ ` ∈ neighbors j : dist(i, j) ≥ dist(i, `).

^¹+W¿

Î/i,e

x

^{zi$qŒi u} ki,nAe¯qrŽ6i¨l6˜es¡.inWm.h$zi u lr˜o}n o¢esopqregl u d ¥¦ ¡.iŒ u l6eglckl]{/kl6ndQo|Ÿci u d´es¡.i,n/¬ eg¡ qreyqjn.lcŸcizi,{pl6n Ž]d´˜ l u dgm uiyegl*eg¡ iyzl u Ÿci u q6n ŸUk,l6n dgi Am.iDn]es{}bjo|d´q$Œi u o}hji,egi u zlWlresdQe u qrŒUn.lcŸci6¬co}˜es¡.iyŒ ui<ŸcopkDqHesiL+'opd´dsqHesopdQ© iDŸ˜ l u qHe´hjl]dQe