• Aucun résultat trouvé

Incomplete Sensitivities and BFGS Methods for 3D Aerodynamic Shape Design

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Incomplete Sensitivities and BFGS Methods for 3D Aerodynamic Shape Design"

Copied!
25
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)Incomplete Sensitivities and BFGS Methods for 3D Aerodynamic Shape Design Andrea Dadone, Bijan Mohammadi, Nicola Petruzzelli. To cite this version: Andrea Dadone, Bijan Mohammadi, Nicola Petruzzelli. Incomplete Sensitivities and BFGS Methods for 3D Aerodynamic Shape Design. [Research Report] RR-3633, INRIA. 1999. �inria-00073041�. HAL Id: inria-00073041 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073041 Submitted on 24 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) >. =.

(3) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Incomplete Sensitivities and BFGS Methods for 3D Aerodynamic Shape Design Andrea Dadone, Bijan Mohammadi and Nicola Petruzzelli. N ˚ 3633 March 1999 ` THEME 4. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.

(4)

(5) .

(6) 

(7) .0/. 

(8)  

(9)  !#"  $

(10) %&'(*)+-, 1

(11) 2,3('4' 56&'7 8

(12) /

(13)  9. :';3<=?>A@8B@C<3DE;>EFGIHKJML @C;ONPDCQ3@CRSRT@E<JUI@C;3<OV'JXWADCYX@[Z\>^]_=?`3abaA>AYXYXJdc e.*g f  2h7i . j + .

(14)   ++1    f   1

(15)  lk, .   8. m 0+?n  q wyx{z}|?~?€p|+‚„ƒ * (!.08

(16) , bˆ # j

(17) < 

(18)

(19) 0+5,k . '. -r2_s122(i. 

(20) 10+. , :0+  *

(21) 0  *

(22) 6. po 2. '. lt_tpti. 0  *. =. u_v. <1 . ? -  1

(23) + ‡†+1  <10*

(24)  1  1    * 0‰ˆ+% 1 - 0I Aˆ* 

(25) 

(26) ‹ Š !$# %:Œ. *

(27) , -/1024 *    <1

(28) 0+p

(29)        +,+  -;p A n  -Žj 1‘$*

(30) 0 +*

(31) +0’ j

(32) 1 -;+*

(33) 09  0 7- *

(34) “ 5   y$  * 0   +)* +0 .0+ 5    

(35) <  +  > e.*

(36) 0+ -/10+ +( 7.0+*b$*

(37)    , < + * 5  

(38)  ’† 1  *

(39) ,8   1 +*

(40) ”7 + 9y  *  +*

(41)   1, k  >    C+*

(42) \7 ” + 9 *

(43) p

(44) j 9y - 0 -/0   0+  1 ’

(45) j 3 * $<10   

(46) 0?k +  d$  0

(47) < > . e *

(48) 1

(49) + ‡† +1 *

(50) , <18 9  *0 1+ 0‡† 2 8 •j

(51) 0–jIj 0  — 5 4‘ˆ -/0+  :-/0  l 10–˜ -/0  *  )  *  -/0 }  5j 1 9 š™ 0 ,91;-

(52) 0<10   -/10*  

(53) j  +1(- *

(54) <10 1 , - +*

(55)   -Ž

(56) j +d,  •

(57) j 0–j Ij 0 (“?    0 > . e *

(58) ;0   <1 -.+0  

(59)  ( ‰j 0  

(60)  7$  

(61) < *    9 0  +*

(62)  0 -/0  - +*

(63) !$# %; +*

(64) , *›  " 8A †   1 0+   $+*      $,   +*

(65) , > e ?˜ 

(66) < + _

(67) j  * : 

(68) 3 0  * 9 +; lk      00+  p

(69) j ; œj  *

(70) 0+p

(71)        ’†

(72) 0 10+ $+ *

(73) <0  ,  ,bj

(74) ’j  *    8  -/0(j 

(75) < *

(76) 1,0+1 0 ?

(77)   > o

(78) j  09 0 œ

(79) j   *

(80) ? *  * )!$# %  * , ,   1 ‰jb™ 0;-/0 *

(81) "

(82)

(83) 0?, k  1[j   *

(84)  ‡j +   ,+ ,    1

(85) .+() ™  $

(86) 0+   - +*

(87)  }ž   8 - +*

(88) 1

(89) + ‡† +1  +*

(90) , 1<8 e *

(91)  0 ‰

(92) j   # *

(93)  1  0   Ÿ¡¢5£¤œ¥¦§¨¢+¦}§dnIj š© + -/10 . >  1  +. ), < +. +*

(94) .

(95) 0 1+ 

(96)  8.    . ª«+¬d­I®0¯°~?±z_‚. 57 0+,8  9:* (4. }³²7 +0Ij I j

(97) 0+ . 

(98)   3 +, . d ?.  <1 # . C %j

(99)  + 47M™ ´ˆ/-/0  #

(100) 0  l 10I˜ >. !$# %  *

(101) , 5. l°—.  1  0. 5. d. 0+ , 1. 4. µ·¶X¸º¹2»½¼¿¾¨À5Á5Â}Ã?Ä}Å?Æ ÇpȉÉ_Æ}ÃÊÂ}Ã?ÄÌ˨ÍÊÄlÎpȜÏ?ÂÌËœÈœÐ Ñ ¶X¸º¹2»½¼¿¾¨ÀpҳȽÓlÂ}ÅC˺Ô?Ä}Õ?ÂÖÉ É_Â}Ã+ȽÇ_ÈIÅl×_ȽÂÌ˨Ø× Ù ¶X¸º¹2»½¼¿¾¨À5Ú^È}ÛÄlÎl°˨Ü?Æ}Ðl× ÝlÞlÞ?ÆlÎ ÎpȽÇ?ÈIÅl×+ȖÂÌ˨Øl×. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : (33 1) 39 63 55 11 – T´el´ecopie : (33 1) 39 63 53 30.

(102) >. >. >. u.   . 

(103)   .

(104) . " 3 , 

(105)   ?‘. œ- 3? ?{3 . . . l

(106) %

(107)  '

(108) 

(109) 3&'( !  #"   ', '

(110) )+-,

(111)  

(112) 2,3('4'  '

(113)  0 . /.   . «A

(114) z ‰j «'

(115) ‚       +j  bˆ ‰ˆ I bˆ Š Œ ² }j   j  j }j  pj j !^ j 5jk " — ?k ˆ + j 2#¡^ ¢5j £¤œ¥¦§¨¢+” ¦}§ pj  ?$k % j  % k —  ‘j 5ˆ ‡  &+j pj j (' ?j +j )   œj ›j lj Ij Ij +  š™* pj j   f # M— ´ˆ +Af  bj ‰j ,^ j   { j   + j œj ,^j -' j ›j  .  bj ˆ / ) j 5j bj  ‰j Aj  +j (^j   0 '   bj ?k ( j ?  Aj j   }j bj — ?k +j %j 1 ¯|?z}­½€+2"«

(116) ‚3 „ 4 ,^j ³ 5 ° M™* j ,^ j ³  lj Ij Ij + m   ‰j 7.  . 

(117) 0  .

(118) 0  + 7

(119) 0+.

(120) ;  . 1

(121) + 9 ,. -/0   0,,8 .

(122)  214. *

(123) , (!.0+8

(124)   #    *

(125) 0 +%7. - 0 +*

(126) 

(127)  !$#&% 7

(128) ;   0+  0+ (  >

(129) ( 

(130) 

(131) 0, * $ 

(132) 0   <10 1 ,   $ 9 -/1   1

(133) 

(134)    

(135) .  0 

(136) 

(137)   ++1  .  <10*

(138) . 1,0 , 7 030  0. . " ,  (+0  .  + (

(139)

(140) 0 , 1) >

(141) 

(142) $  7  (

(143)

(144) 0+, *

(145) + 9

(146) .!$# %  ,0  0+ $

(147)

(148)   

(149)  1

(150)  >     1  0. 

(151) 0  +;   

(152)   

(153) 

(154)  

(155) + 9  : +*

(156) ,  > <1 1     1;     

(157) 0

(158)     0  1 0 

(159) 0   0 ,91(

(160)  +

(161) 1 

(162) 0  . 

(163)

(164) ,  <10 1 ,  90+   

(165) 

(166) 0 . .   <1 3

(167) 0- 1. ;0 <1 0  

(168)  0 ; 3   .

(169) . 

(170) 0  ,.

(171) . > 

(172)  0 1

(173)  .

(174) " <10+*

(175)  ,. 

(176)  1. +09+; .-/0. . 9:. +*

(177) ,. 534. #

(178) 0+ . 7 0+0.  1

(179) + 9+(.

(180) :  0-/10+  $ $ 97 +*

(181) , $!$# %   1 > <10 1 ,$ 

(182)   +,

(183) " 1$

(184) 0+1 10+ & ) ,

(185) . <0  ,.  0 

(186)    

(187)  0+

(188)   1,0+ , 9: +*

(189) , 3!$#&% 1, 0+<1 7 > 

(190) 0    +     

(191)   ; 

(192)  <0 1, ,  + 

(193)

(194) 0+  +1"  > 0 +1"

(195)

(196) 0  

(197)   

(198) 3  1

(199) + 9+ >

(200)   ++1. 5.

(201) +1. '.   9<1.  >.

(202) %. 0 1, ,. . 1.   . #

(203) 10+ 5. 0+,8  .

(204)    

(205) 0 

(206) 1.

(207) '. +0  

(208) 0 . *

(209) ,. 0 . !$#&%. 47. 0+ +1. .  <10 .

(210) .

(211) 

(212) . 0+ + . 1 . 

(213) 0$ .

(214) >. >. >. ! 

(215)  3 . & ~5¯°x2 «. E|?b|?«. .  . |?~?¯d± {€p|Ž¯. . . . [« | 1„«^| {¯d±{¯ Ž2 ¯ °¬ d~?/[«^®0¯°~ 5 (^ j .

(216) 2. >. u. —. 4. 2. 

(217)   %70 1 ,& . >. . 1. ´ˆ #

(218) 0  ;%. 5. ’†.

(219)  . m. Aj. 0, 

(220) 0 >. 2 & [«b~ Ž€+/2 y«Az2 |?z. " # = >. # >. u. $0¯  . '), . >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. . >>>. >>>. . w C¯°~¨| [z. t l= v !. . .   0.  0+ . 1. |  +b|Ž¯    . . ’j. . h. 2. . . > 2. . # . =. >. 2. . e. # . 

(221)  0  

(222)  . #. ? ?. 0   1  . +j. +2 . € ±%  . 2 ). wy€  +¯ ® Ž«b±&.  >>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. >:>. >>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >:>. >>. >>>. >>. >>. >>. >:>. >>:>. >. =2. >:>. « [~ dz . =. «  |.  . h. !'. #.

(223) .. ,3(    '. ,8. $*

(224) 9. lk. ,  +

(225) <( +*

(226) ,

(227) .-/101 

(228) <. ’†  ;$+* 0 .  *  ( <.  

(229) (. *

(230) . . _ An + $-Žj

(231) +1. _ .

(232) 0

(233)  . -  ). 0. . . . . ,. . #.  . *   . 7j.  <10+* . . . šˆ 8  0 $(*

(234)   <)0 +0 0  + 0  ² ‰j   8++*

(235)  :

(236) šˆ >  ‡†+1  +*

(237) ,1 1<  1   - 3 +j

(238)  .- <1 p   0 +1 }1  *;- +*

(239) 60 +

(240) j 0 < ) 1 j  + - +*

(241) _ An + -Žj

(242)  d "1 j

(243)  1 - *

(244)    +,8 , 01 }   

(245)

(246) 0+1

(247) 0+  ( *

(248) < ;- * (  <1 0+ ?

(249)   110 

(250) < " <1 )<0  ,‰ˆ    1  ’†  <10+*

(251)  .*

(252) 0, Aj

(253) 0 

(254) ‘$*

(255)  *  

(256) -j

(257)  e -* :_ A n + 7-Ž

(258) j  ֈ > 1 9.0  *  e.*  <1

(259) 0+, +. 8;0 +j

(260) 0+ ;œj  ,9  p

(261) j ,-&1 

(262) j  1 > 0  pj 0   e.*

(263) )* <1*  j

(264)  +1    ( :  8)-/0 *

(265) 0    

(266) j  > - +*

(267) (p An + -Žj

(268) +1g 1 *  ’j 0 ^j

(269) 0

(270) < * 1 ’j  - *

(271) - “ ? <1 0+

(272)  < +j+ 57 

(273) + <1 M© (  ;9;bj

(274)  *  9}

(275) j 91 -3* <0  ,;> * _ An  :-Žj

(276)  1 7   + +*

(277) (   1

(278)  $-$ }ž   1  ’ ” †   <10*

(279)   9 > 

(280)   C, 0  0$+;0 Aj +*

(281) b

(282) j   0- <10 1   -Ž

(283) j +  ’j 1$

(284)  +08 (0 1 * *

(285)  

(286) -j  > e * 0 ;9  0< A

(287) j  0$-$ 0 +  +*

(288) ,

(289)    : 

(290)  ‡† 

(291) <( -Ž

(292) j   <1  .  7<10 1 , =pduA 2bC h  >  

(293) 0   *

(294) 

(295)  ^

(296) j } œj  *   ( 0  *  * ,

(297) } ,  0+  +   *  0 +1g   0  * 0    *  ©  *

(298) ( 

(299) -

(300) j  - *

(301) ;-Ž

(302) j  j  

(303) < ; 

(304)  7

(305) }ˆ   1 1  ’ †   *

(306) , > . e *

(307)  

(308)     0  *  +*

(309) ,  .+*

(310)  +     + ,‘Š ,4\Œ  +*

(311) ,C1-$  *

(312)   *;*

(313)  0  *(,0 1(9 d$  +*;*

(314) 0   - +*

(315) <0 1, , ')0 }ž    * ,

(316) .  © 

(317) *

(318)  0  * 0+ 1  8  j 

(319) <( 

(320) 0?k šˆ >   ;+*

(321) \7 ”  9  0+’; k - +*

(322) p An + .-Ž

(323) j  1"1 

(324) j   ,8j   <;*

(325) <10 1 , 0+ +  ‡ j +  Aj

(326) 0

(327) < +*

(328) )

(329)  ’† 1 0, + > +j  *  +*

(330) ,

(331) ;0    1  +j 10 +  

(332)

(333) 0?,k  1;- +*

(334) _ An  -Ž

(335) j  1d,  10+ $ }™  $* : 

(336) 0 

(337) 0?k šˆ  TŠŽ j   +*

(338) ),4  * ,̌ 

(339) 0+ 9

(340) < *

(341) ,0 1 1

(342) <$  *   * œj   ,9

(343) 0+1<10+ (  " 1 >  *  7.  0I˜8 ,  +< +*

(344)

(345) 0 95  8 -31

(346) - *

(347)   +*

(348) ,

(349) 1  *

(350) !.0+8

(351)  bˆ #    *

(352) 0‰+ˆ %7 - 0I b+ˆ *

(353) 

(354)  Š !$# %Œ  *

(355) , = 1 -/10 

(356)    *   <

(357) 0+p

(358)   pj  

(359) < 

(360) 0?k  + $p An   -Ž

(361) j +     > . e *

(362) 3

(363) 0?,k    9  $ )

(364)    ’j 1 - *   }+  <;*

(365)  09  0  * “ 5    0$  *"0   $(*  1,0 095

(366)  $

(367) <1  +  > +j  *" 

(368)

(369) 0+ *   -/0 +*

(370) 7_  0+1(* l+$  *

(371) ;*

(372) 3 -Ž

(373) j   - 7 k

(374) 0+   * 0pj <1*(-/0   0.+*

(375)  *  Š -/10$   +*

(376) 0_

(377) j <1*' _

(378) j 

(379) 08 , <10  ½Œ½ +*

(380) <10 1   $    8 *   $  * 0+    (*

(381)  *  # °s  >  - l

(382)  +*

(383)  .9.-/+  *

(384) 1  bjXˆ 0+  

(385)

(386) 9+}°$  *

(387) 0+ ; 8,

(388)   1

(389) + ‡† + 0p    $* (0 < 0 Aj1"

(390) 0_

(391)   10 *  0,,8    1  0+ bj 

(392) 0_

(393)   > e *  ,  

(394) <10+   &- _

(395) j 0$

(396)

(397) 0+1 * -/0.

(398)    *     <1"0+ 

(399) j   0–j –jbˆ . 0 ‹“?  1  0l  ?

(400) j  + ;š™ 0 ,91  +*

(401) ,1 1<8 -/10 *

(402) ( 1 j  + -  bˆ   }   <1 1 +09  ,,  ›   1  — 5 4‘ˆ -/0+  -/0  l.  0I ˜     3tb$  = v  > . e *

(403)  +*

(404) , 1<8 *7 0 18y  ) 

(405)   -/10$0_j  10   

(406)  ’† 1

(407) 0+p

(408)    -/10 

(409) 0  ‡

(410)   

(411) 0+ ’

(412)  “ ? b© <pj 0 + >     ›tA$  =lv =1=_7  = u  >    * +*

(413) .   <; <10 1 $0$  . .

(414) > * . A†  10–˜.  8  . e.*

(415) 9 " }ž.  ;. 0 

(416) 0+   :. Žj. 1. -

(417) 0+*

(418) 0.  <110++*

(419) . ,   

(420)  ,$-.  . 1. . > ,4.  +*

(421) ,. *

(422) ( +*

(423) , 1<8. . 7 . * . . [j .  . ; ,  

(424) <. O“°j

(425)  8,   *  1

(426) + ‡†+1(

(427) 0+p

(428)    > 53:*   10–˜  ’j    0  +1  

(429) 8 )*

(430) 10+( +0

(431) 1 -3 1 * - +*

(432)  9:<1šˆ     1 uy. -$  -/10+j + +*

(433) ;1

(434) + ‡†+)

(435) 0+p

(436)   $*  , }©

(437)  -$+*

(438)  > p An  7-Žj

(439) +  1 2;        *

(440) 0 0+

(441) +1 -.+*

(442) :-/0  .  10–. ˜ - +*

(443) >  +*

(444) , 1<8(;- *

(445) 1  ’ † ;0  <8 +j  +

(446) j , 8+1   1 h\.  0 , l +*

(447)  91   <10*

(448)  $  *

(449)   * 0 -j  ) +*

(450) ;A

(451) j > 0+    ’

(452) j + -

(453) j  +0 

(454)  1  Mˆ †

(455) 0_

(456)    > #    8+     #   

(457)  ’† 1  <10+*     1 *

(458) (!$# %  +*

(459) ,$  C    ,8  - ‰ -$  

(460) <  < 0p      .  0 -/0  3$     1 0 +;*

(461) 

(462) $-&  <10*

(463)   1  )*  4  *

(464) , >  , . }™. ’†. 

(465)  . >. +.  * ,. -/0. 214. . ,

(466) .  —1. ?. y\

(467) \.

(468)  . \“°j

(469) 9“?. 1

(470) +  +1.   , 0$*

(471) -/1   $

(472) <. . _ . 3Š

(473)  bŠ CŒ 0Š^Œ–Œ. ‡†. š†. .     .

(474) 0

(475)  . KŠ  bŠ

(476) CŒ 0Š+ŒIŒ v Š+=5Œ Š CŒ  v "l! Š#0 Š+ ŒIŒ$ v $*

(477) 0+   

(478)   *

(479) (p An   -Žj

(480)  1d &%('*) , 0+’  7+*

(481) ( < 0   0 }+bŠ

(482) CŒ * < 1 09 + 7Š/

(483) 10+  9} œj

(484) 0 -  }  ’j

(485)  ֌½ +*

(486) “ 5\    1  +*

(487)    +j+ ,#- !0  7Š  <1 1 +09 1.C Œ  0+  10  'Š  *8  9 

(488) 1/7Š

(489) ^Œ–Œ .  +0  . . ‰j An . $. >. %j ‰j   8   *

(490) 1,0+1   #

(491) 0 24  *   

(492) 2 ,8; }© 

(493) 

(494) < œ.  +

(495) <3‰j

(496) 0- 1>   œ.  -$*

(497)   *  *   0+ 102 0+ ;  ?.  *

(498) (, 8   

(499) < +*3 4 Š CŒ 502 6 4 !lŠ CŒ 7 Š u^Œ *

(500) 0 < 1 0+   +0 ,  , 0 +*

(501)

(502) 0_

(503)  

(504) j  0) 1  0 +1 >  *

(505) 9y.10–˜ * 0+  <1 -  07$

(506) <  1  0  e . *

(507) d *

(508)  1 10 ,0 +j

(509) 0  *  > * ;10<1 $

(510) <

(511) -/10+  *

(512) _

(513) j )0+  j  * 

(514) <  > . e *

(515) (   < 1 0+  10 ,  9 0 9:* ;*  ’

(516) j  98 - +*

(517) y$  

(518) <)* ' 1 0 0;0+ 1  bj

(519) 0

(520) < * 7

(521)  ’†1;

(522) 0+,  e . *

(523) ‘ © 0 $   1(1  0  .  5˜ (, 1p

(524) j ,3 8 > j

(525) < (

(526) 0?n 1)  0 10 C$  *

(527) 9 *© + 0 $*

(528) 09+1 7- * ; <) 0   0  > . e *

(529)    +0 ,  +0,bj   *

(530)   $-Ž

(531) j +)7    8 + 0 > #   8³1 

(532) *,8

(533)    10 , $ 0+ +*

(534)  0,8,    }ž      *0 1+ 09 +  - *

(535) 7“ 5 # 0   +   8 (0 ^

(536) j 0   0 bj ;+*

(537) (0 <  0,

(538) < 00+ ʈ >  

(539) <(*

(540)  -/$07+  

(541)  š † $*

(542)  0+,8, 9  1   }ž  -/10 <1   -/ ),0 <  }ž    m *,8     10 ,  0+ :+0,bj    *        8 + 0  > & > 1 . 

(543) . ’†. - * . <1 1 +09 10 , . _ . +*

(544)  .  ;

(545) 0

(546)  . . . . . s. >.

(547)  !.8. bj. +0,  

(548) <(   8) 0. }.  +0  . j

(549) . +*

(550) . 1  0 

(551) . š†. ’†. _ . + j -> j

(552) .   +. $ ..  *. . ©. 

(553)

(554) 0+1 *. 0  0   $.  

(555)  1 .

(556) 3&'(' -9-4. e.*

(557) 97 1

(558) 0+ }“8 p j

(559) +   *1  . .    . ‡j. . (. "10  0.  1

(560) 1. pj. ,. 1

(561) ,. 1 . *

(562) ,,1 <18. +*

(563) . >.

(564)  -,. ,3. _j. ’†. 7  +*

(565) ; 1

(566)  .-

(567) 07

(568)  . 0+   . ?˜. +   .

(569) 0+p

(570)    > Š+=5Œ    0 -/10  ,   +* 0     *

(571)  *  < 1 08")*

(572) 7“ 5 $ l -Žj

(573)  1 X *

(574) (   8)-Žj

(575) +d ‰j * +*  .  

(576) ( +. 10 

(577) ) 

(578)   +

(579) 0

(580)  .  

(581) . Žj. .)* ;  7-

(582)  1. + 24. 

(583)

(584) 9+. +$*. >.

(585)  

(586) !"

(587) # %$'&)(. e.*

(588) 9.  1. 9.   . )+*

(589) . .  0+

(590) +1. -. * .   . ‡ +j“ ?. $*

(591) 9 *0 

(592) 0  ,  +*

(593) $ 8 j

(594)  0 +j+1  

(595)  +  +0 “°j

(596) 9 > . e *

(597) Aj

(598)  0+  + *  %j  -/07 $  ’j

(599) +($  E . . -Š

(600)  bŠ

(601) gŒ 0Š+ŒIŒ . . . ’ .  -  1

(602) 0+ 

(603)  , +. pj.  9 (

(604) +  . e * +*

(605) 0  ˆ   .  j

(606)  0 +j7-/100j

(607)  + 1,8“?  \$0+ ". :. >.  0+. 0 0+*-,/.10 Š 2-Š Œ–Œ  v .   Š43 5378 6 53 0Œ%9. vb. -/10+. . Š 2^Œ.  *

(608)  +10-  1 0 ;0+ 5   :2 0  0    *

(609)  ֈ .*

(610) 978

(611)   e  $  yj 

(612) < +*

(613)  +j+1 -    ;<;EŠ43 >=2Œ > > e  90+ ‡† +*

(614) ^j 1;-  1 ‹© 

(615) + }ˆ ’j

(616)  }ˆ%3  0–˜ 

(617)

(618) 0 1 * *1-    

(619)   5 1 8<1 ° _

(620) j  ;1  - 1 j

(621)  1*1     }©  ;, , :+ >  0 *

(622) 0+     9 e . *

(623) + j :*        j

(624) < +*

(625) “°jk+ˆ M™ 0+  

(626) + < >  +*

(627) ,:-{$ q   =2  5 ': ² — ˆ 8  $ l,k 0  1 91d+$  *( -/0 

(628)  1 ^ˆ0  0.}j

(629) 0 18    +  *1%   > 

(630)

(631)   + l,k 0  1 9 *

(632)

(633) *,8

(634)   1095

(635)  71,(*  -/ )0<1*,  9  -  *     <1 e *

(636) #? (57 ’ 

(637) $   0 *  7j   +  

(638) j + .   1b/ˆ -/0  . >   ’

(639) j + > . e *

(640)  + 18+ˆ      ’

(641) j +)-  > Š 2^ Œ *´   _

(642)  

(643) $*"" l,k

(644) 9 +. , <10 1• j  

(645) <  -/p

(646) j 0œˆ  < 'q´

(647) j  <1 }Aˆ @2

(648) j  ) *

(649)  > e  1   0  (*  0<1  ;*  *

(650)  +   ,

(651)   + 

(652)

(653) 

(654) <  *

(655) 

(656)  ^

(657) j *1  (  8  . e *

(658) 

(659)  

(660) 1 ‡

(661) j 1  p

(662) j 

(663) 0+8(1,1 0  1+ 9 > ; 0+ }

(664) j 90  b“ ? ;p

(665) j œ“ > ?[ _

(666) j 

(667) 08( * %   0 +0‡ 10  <:+ +*

(668) 7+*

(669) 08(-  *0 1  0+  +    1  -$    *

(670) 

(671) 8 > +0’ 

(672) j 1 +*

(673) 1, + d“°j,k    *

(674) 

(675) 0+ œ

(676) j 0 > 5

(677) 1 ,   9 -/0 ©   ˆ  ’

(678) j  ˆ %3  0I, ˜  +  * 

(679)  +

(680) j ; -/0 _

(681) j 

(682) 08 1,1 +0  ,38 ;-/p

(683) j   0+ -/ 0    =2b =h° = #  = s =   >. $*

(684) 0+ . 1  0 +10. . . . '. ( ,. . . .

(685)  >. . *  ; -/0. 1. e.*

(686)  .9› 1 . >. >. "( & & &

(687)

(688) &) (  

(689)  &. .  . >.  . j. —. <0 < 

(690) 0 1"0+  0 -/10+ . ?. *

(691) . . -/1   $ <; , .   < . ‘ˆ -/0+  <1  0+ $ 5ˆ 5. 4. \ ,8"0+  1,0 1,  > u > 5 <10+   ( ,   *

(692) 

(693)  ^j  ›j  (<1  0   

(694) l   * > e.*

(695) œj

(696) 

(697) +1  1 =   5 " 5˜  * " -/10 1$*

(698) _j

(699)  + 0 - 

(700) < +*

(701)  <

(702) 0, 7+ *

(703) — 5 4´ˆ  8  +   1 7

(704) 0_

(705)   .0  9+  + *

(706)

(707) 0 < +1 :+01 1$0+ 7+ +*

(708) *

(709) 0‘ ,8  +0 ’† 1 1  > e 

(710) 0+  0+ *  9 , 0 <_j

(711) 0 8 - *

(712) 3 *  bj

(713) 0+

(714) <*   < 0, +. +;19 +  +}, ,   1* 

(715) <; 0 +10$* +*

(716) y    }©    0 +*

(717) *  +$  *

(718) 9 * 1  . 0 -/10+  <  -/ l  p   0 +.    +*

(719) -/1  ?$  

(720) <(8

(721)    =. ,. 57  +*

(722) 

(723) , $1"*

(724) . >.  .  . $*

(725) 0+ 60     <1 • 8 *

(726) . +*

(727) .  1+*

(728) . ‡†. 1

(729) +  +1. . ,   *

(730) 

(731) <. *

(732) .  0++  - * .  -/10. ŠyŒ 0  6502  0   50   v 1'. ,<1   * .  . . 0 1. +1 . -/10;+*

(733) .  ) . ,,8. ŠŽhbŒ . 1, . 0  + 0. . 0 . 9. 0  0. *

(734) . 1091  0-/10. . ’j

(735) 0 10+ )> +*

(736) (

(737) 10+ - *

(738)   1 0 † 0 Š/*

(739) 9&9.

(740) bj 0 <:+*

(741) p

(742)  1 ½Œ -. 0  + 0 * 1;  1. (  . 0! Š

(743) 02  Œ Š

(744) 02 dŒ 9. ". lv. = $#$%. $*

(745) 0+ 0&lŠ

(746) 02  $ Œ  $* (M™ 0+  \  œ.  )* ;1091 - *

(747) ;œ  

(748) ,,  - 1 *)-$+*

(749)  <1 , -& œ

(750) j 0 -  0+  <1   Š

(751) 02  Π9 *

(752)   0+ ))*  .0+ 

(753) <1  > e * <0 )   ,.+  *

(754) 

(755)  +j

(756)  ,

(757)   10u  9    0 

(758) <  

(759) l6<10+ . ,8 0Ij 0I

(760) 

(761) < *

(762) 10    -$+*

(763) (10<1 <10+ ,   (  8$*   * 9: 1  + , $+* *

(764)  0–

(765) j 0I 1 - *

(766) 0 ,8 1,  > . e *

(767)     1

(768) -, 8"  ,

(769) < (1 ’j   7  198  8  + ,     90  > ŠŽhbŒ  Š (*)+yŒ 0 ,  0 ,* ' Š# Œ. . (. j

(770) , 0$*

(771) . .  . . - . >. Š # Œ½.  02 ,  v -/.10/2  v - ) 02 ,  0 3,. . 0 ,. lk.  .+*

(772)  + 1. b“ ?    pj. $  6 . ‘.  -.   02 ,  0 02 ,  v . _j ‰“ 5„ pj 

(773) 0+  .    , . 

(774) . Š s^Œ. >. 0 3" 0.+*

(775)   *.  

(776) . -/10$  * 

(777) ,, . )+*

(778) . }©.  ,8. \$  X. }. -/10$+ 0 

(779) ,, . . . 

(780) 0+ . Š Œ.

(781)  ). ). 9$. +  0   0 >. e.  19   *. ‡†. 97

(782) 0+1 10+ + *

(783) ; 0  . l. 

(784) . <10+. e * . p ' . - * ; ,    ,$   >    <1   8  , +  (*

(785)  9 1

(786) . ;0 . * .

(787) 0+

(788)  . -u4.   

(789) . . lk.  0-/10.  

(790) . %. *

(791) ;. (214.  *.  -/10. b© pj.  <. "0  ,0   8. 1 :    +.

(792) . d +j. & &. l “ 5 . -/. ‡j.  <1 

(793) 0 1

(794) +*

(795)  *. 

(796) - *

(797) . 0   0. . -/10  7+*

(798) . >. 0    0+ 18'j  1

(799) + ‡†+1 ‡ “ ?     > e.*

(800) 8 * ›   ;

(801) 0+  ) 1 j  +    ^j

(802)    +)+*

(803) . 1"1 9:*. 0 +&-/01. ©

(804) . %$*.  *

(805) .  0 +. .

(806) 0 + 

(807)  . >. (   &  $7 5

(808) . C. . ›“ ?. 57  

(809) <0  , 

(810) 0  ,   +*

(811)     0    +*

(812) $*  3  > >  $, 0 + + 7:0  0 31

(813)  +

(814) * <10 1  -* . ‘ M™ l k 1+ 8+ $ .<1  8+ * . pj. 

(815)

(816) 0+ *. j.  *.  -/0.           7   ,   ,    g^ ‘j 5j. }. 1. _ An + Ž- j

(817) +1. >. +1 9. ')10+. Š Œ.  *  3 <1  3 

(818) +1   M™ 0+ , 1Š534Œ  }ˆ = tupvAu,=  

(819) 0,Aj *

(820) 3  ,8  0  - *

(821) 390+  p An   -Žj

(822)   ²3‰j  8³ 5 4  - 1  0 + ‘$*(œ.2 1 9.

(823) 0, bj

(824) 0+ $*

(825) 9 *(0 $0 -/ 00+  >  1$-/10I 0 )0+  0   ,  ƒ \j  +*

(826) 0+  0   , 

(827) 0, bj

(828) 0+ +Ì$*   *)     8 > 0  + ;;ln1  +*

(829) ,

(830)   2bAupuA u 2 X,  +*

(831)  œ

(832) j  5

(833)  7+; 

(834) j + 7<0 1, , 3$*

(835)  +*

(836) Aj

(837)   0-*

(838)   < 1095

(839)  . $ 08( 0< > e * .    ,Mž }

(840) j  0 +*

(841) 1 

(842) j  -+*

(843) <10   -+*

(844) p An   -Ž

(845) j +1 Š  Œ .   +*

(846) M™ 0+ , 1 -*

(847)  “ ?   *0      8$  *

(848)  * .1 ‡

(849) j 1-+*

(850) o  0‰+ˆ +p˜  + j +$ I

(851) j 0– 

(852) j    ,  .0 ,1   >   C

(853) *

(854) 

(855) *,8    1  0. 0  .-/  

(856) M™ 0+ , ?

(857)   1,    0  

(858)  +  1 yŠ -/10   + *

(859) ( ;, <0    1 : 0 

(860) ,      ,    © 

(861) + ;    ,  1  0}Π = v  > . e *

(862)   9  0  šž }j 8)-/10;+*

(863) 0  0   , -5347      8)-/10;     

(864) 0_

(865)   }  

(866)   10+   .+*

(867) , 0+ + (     *

(868) 1l   * 17    * 5$   *

(869) ? ' j  > 5j 1 9;M™ 0+ , 1) 0  0   , ;+  0-/10+ *    ‰˜  2b =. v  > ')10+

(870) 0+ 9  8+   

(871) j +  +*

(872) -/1  ?$ .  

(873) <(    0  02 , 02 0  0 3Š  0  \Œ e *

(874) 0+p

(875) j <* š™ 0 , A

(876) j  0+  l,k  0  }

(877)  •$ . q -/ 0+    # E s   *12    19  *l  *

(878) "*

(879)   $-Ž

(880) j +) › 1 )1) , ,-/10 1 0_

(881) j )* ; *   y/Š *

(882) 0+p

(883) j <* _

(884) j bˆ $

(885) 08)+ <10  9 -/10    pŒ  +*

Références

Documents relatifs

Dans chaque ville et pour toutes les lignes de tramway considérées, il faudrait disposer des trafics avant et après ouverture d’une ligne et de plusieurs projections d’évolution

Le fait d’écrire à partir d’une oeuvre d’art visuelle ressemble à une forme de contrainte; nous croyons par ailleurs que cette pratique a eu un effet durable sur l’écriture

variables d'ordre psychologique: soit f.amiliale ou personnelle, soit so- ciale, soit professionnelle, soit une combinaison de ces facteurs. Ce patient a récupéré

For the two coolest objects in Figure 3.6, HD 4539 and PG 1716+426, both at Ta &lt; 27, 000 K, there is a good match between the predicted synthetic spectra and the FUSE data: the

lui inculquer le registre li'lquistioue, les l1abitudes alimen- taires et vestimentaires ainsi que le comportement des bour- geois de Québec. Pierrette Paul doit

La conciliation emploi-famille : des mesures à développer dans les milieux de travail Tableau 4 : Les dispositions favorisant la conciliation travailfamille dans les

Figure 2.4 Predicted (continuous lines) and observed values (filled circles: stands aged from trees with root collar; open circles: stands aged from trees without root collar)

Cette posture permet de dégager deux idées centrales : le poids des milieux professionnels locaux dans l’intermédiation et le transit des idées, modèles et pratiques