Contrôle de Routes par des Appareils de Surveillance (CRAS) - II

Texte intégral

(1)Contrôle de Routes par des Appareils de Surveillance (CRAS) - II Olivier Cogis, Benoit Darties, Sylvain Durand, Jean-Claude König, Jérôme Palaysi. To cite this version: Olivier Cogis, Benoit Darties, Sylvain Durand, Jean-Claude König, Jérôme Palaysi. Contrôle de Routes par des Appareils de Surveillance (CRAS) - II. [Rapport de recherche] 05052, LIRMM. 2005. �lirmm-00106694�. HAL Id: lirmm-00106694 https://hal-lirmm.ccsd.cnrs.fr/lirmm-00106694 Submitted on 16 Oct 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3)

(4) !"# $%#

(5) &# '

(6) (*),+-.(

(7) /0# '1" 233++4

(8) 3. LIRMM. 5687:9<;*=7?>@9<ABCDEGF356H7?IJALKNMO7?9<;*=QPJ6R9OSTAVUWUW7:ALKXNX YJY[Z[\. ]. ^. _ d. _. `. ] a. f1gihjklnm ^. b opm. v{vxw|jQmz}~l~t d. n. £¤4. p ¥H¦ §,«nH¬.® -¤¢ ¯N° 7:UWUWA±9"² Z[ZRY. c. ] ]. ]. opm ^. c. d. e. fqrhsmut. c ] vxwyj. d. e. c. opmzt. qpj%imz}~l~l~w1g{m { . . ~ N ¡¢¢ ~ §,~¨R .¥¦©uª D´³µD´³µ¶~X D=·= ZRY[ZRY ². ¸ \¢¸J¹ D ° A´º»½¼/F3¾[¿R¾JÀR²=QP[6Á9OSTAVUWU:7WALKB,AL»HAÂ> Y F3Ã½KO¼[6HÄLA Å;VUÇÆÉÈ#¾J¾Ê ZJË ¿ \RÌ ¿ ¸*ÍRYÎÍRY F3ÃÉ¼Ï>TÆÐÈ´¾[¾QÊ ZRË ¿ \JÌ ¿ ¸/ÍRYÎZJZ.

(9)

(10) !" $#%

(11) & '(!*) $#% % +!,- ./01'!2436575 89;:=<>:@?BADCEGFG:@H IJ?BKLE/MONQPQRSATN+:@?BH UWV>9=<SRX:;KYP[ZA\RXK] ^ ?_RXK7àCb9;RSZL]L?dcDeGK:fF ^Sg AahGij?"k$RX9ORBV>H\: l/mQn ZL:;9@9@?oN l/pGp*q r sutTv*ws xzya{}|~yao %_{} %}|} %{}|o{[y%|~o %o$o|o+ya{}~ oy

(12) B~Q}ya{}| o{¡|yajo[~ %¢o{o~ya %{¤£ %|¥u}f¦§{}|$oo| ~ %{o{}©¨ª %{}|*|S~ %{o{«XToy%~* o}|GS{} %o/¦¬yaoBya|*oL|o+ya{}~ |o>|L{}|J|ya¨®o| %¥u}~¯By%¥«}~ %{o{}©¨ª %{b| %|o+\°«± %}| yao %{}|³²´¶µz·[~o %o\°G± %}| %{u %{}|³¥«}~¢o %o|¢ya{} o|$o %o|¢~ %{o{u}|³|³}|b¹º~ %o+o /¦§{}|o\*ya{}|+¼» |¸ yaf°°°¾½©°«²ya{Bya %¿\{} %}|7L/¦§{Joo¶o|7|oya|Lo~ %¢o©¨ %oz³o %o²´¶µz·¹º±ÀW»@~ %¢o}o\*yaoo ¨®yaoT½©°G± %}|-o|{» %{}|o{}¯}o|¥u}¿\ %o %{o{}$oz~¯}~¯}³oo %¢{Bya{«}ya{}|¶o{oByaf° Á7¦¬ya{ByaÂ|³o|Ãy®~ %¢o©¨¢zoy¥«Byao³||-| %o %{}|¹º{[|zo ¿uyaya{uo¼Äº %®ya{}~T½ {} %}|>Looo¶o|L|oya|L{u||ya{«| o|-{}|ya{}~|zBya~o|$o®²´¶µz·¹Å|ya¨[o¢~ %¢$o{o~ya %{{(yao %Æ{Æ¿\z{} %ya¢{«Ã½©° Ç ÈGÉ Ê ËLÌDÍÎÏÊ7ÐTÌÉ ÁSy[|o+ya{}~ !y

(13) B~b}ya{}|³||yaö¢|J y%~+ %!By%|¼» |+Ñ§±ÒÓaÔBW²ÕGÖ-ÁSÓ\×aØ@°*ÁX®o %ooJ|o+ya{}~By%||+®o|{ub}ya{}| Ñ¾²ÕGÖ-ÁSÓ\×\Ø>~ %{}|| ¸ oy%~$o|yaoBya|o|o+ya{}~J|o¢o}| {} %oÙ \||oo{}|7/¦ o{¢|ya¢ %o7~ %{«Ú%7o{}o % % %{o¨Ù y

(14) B~\°_Û{Æ|ya[|o|{u$Bya¶o{¿\yao¯}aÜTB~¯By%¥«}$~ %¢$o{o~ya %{ Byao{} ~¯By

(15) Ý{} %{}o"¿\yao¯}\7~Æ¥«o~ %{}o %o %oya %{o{} ¸ o©}{o¶-o %oÞÙß%àáºâ=ß%ãÞÙßaäÃäÃâÅåaæzçè%é}âºáfè%à©âêé«ë~ %¢|o£ r ∈]0, 1] öù\î*uï@ìî©õí}ÿþïBî î©ï;ïS÷+öTð

(16) ý-ø+ñOòTý-òTñ ó+îü;ô+üOîWîÃï ïSý \õuø öTÿ¾÷«üOøþï@ó+øúù\ÿ î ûñOûÃLïS÷ï@ö

(17) ÷u÷

(18) ööTü*ü;÷ÙîÃù\ñO÷uîÃò ïSöü;ðTî ñ¼òó+ô+ÿ î©îïX÷uï;ï;øþîý-ö ý Ùó+ÿ ó+îÃÿ îWïÿ «ù+ï_õ îÃï;î©ï/øþïfý-òü ñ ó+ÿ üOîîÃù+ý-ï/øþñOîù î7÷a-ù\ü ð

(19) îÃïSñOòTðTó+ñ¼ô+òîó+ôuÿ îÃîÃï/÷uîü ÷+ï;îö

(20) ý ÷zöTÿþñOî*øþîÃù\ÿ ÷aîÃîÃü;ï÷uûÃï@Tï îÃöTý øúïOï;òøþ÷u÷«ÿ îïï ù\ù\î©û u÷ïÙ+ï@ø}ö

(21) ýóuòTý-ñ îüOïÙòóuóuòñ;ü;îÃ÷uò÷aü îü 7÷+îõ¼ôuò ú÷uî-ù ö

(22) ñOù\ñOî î©ïfü +÷bðTñ¼òóuô+îøúï;öTý-öTñOó+ô+î-ò ðTñ¼òó+ôuî. !. . .

(23). . E(G) NG (X) . . . . . . . X ⊆ V (G) N (X) X n X(Pn ) = {1, 2...n} E(Pn ) = {i, i + 1} | 1 ≤ i < n. ¸. G . V (G) . . . . . . Pn.

(24) ªw

(25) P P M ÞÙß%àáºâ=ß%ã_ÞÙßaäÃäÃâÅåaæçè%é}âºáfè%à©âêé«ë Ss Séë%à¼ßræ G é æ©é_áºâ=æ©à èaäÃâºáºâ ! h é æ©é}äæ"$#©ãæ&%uæ&'ªß)(ÅéæÃä R +% ß%éoä æá éæ*! è%é'áºâ=è%é+%«æ,è%â-%aä w %uæ R %uß%éoä Q+∗ /.0 âßaäÃäè1'âfæ é è%â-%aä,G23'ªß . æ 'ªß4(êéæ5%uæ R 6 7 v8u t19;: <= >@%? âêä©á@æDáB@A âÅã é äè äDæ©é}äæ"$#©ãæ F ⊆ E(G) á@æ©ã . æ |F | ≤ h æá P è)C R = {P | P ∈ R æá E(P ) ∩ F 6= ∅}*D w(P ) P ≥r. xzya{}|Ñ¾²ÕGÖ-ÁGÓ\×aØ@oX|Ù %{«¥«}--o %o |±ÀW»@~ %¢o° -x ¶Äfya{} %}|Ù %{« %{}|¶¥«X¦ { \yo-FEo P PPMP M %o %oya %{o{} y+~ o|³ %o|$o{oya|HGQ¹º{!®ya¥«Bya{u¥«}Jy~ %{}|ya{« r {} r ∈]0, 1] Ä=I ya¢By%|ByaÆo|®o %{o{}|Jo %oÆ¥«} {} %}|¢f¦¬y+ %{}|Jo©}{o~ê½©° ~$ J/{} %}|{u ªo| %{}|y {} % %{oF KMLONPQ R:SNLO;9;:-Mt : K<Ss£X~\¦§| o{"¿\yao¯} H {} % H = (V , V , E) ¶¥u} {V , V } | %o{}ÆoBya %{ o E(H) = E /-7¥«}$ %oyaT E³o H ya-o{}¢©¨¢¢}ya{}| ~¯By%V~o(H) {}$o|o¨b~y%||| V V ° U{Æ{} %y¢¥«} (V , V , E) (V , V , E) o|¿\{}{uF E¿\yao¯}-oByaW V\u®ya|By%|F E¶¿\yao¯}-oBya/|¿\{}\° À*yay|o\+|L¿\yao¯}|>oBya|| %{«L %) X %o|L|oo \||L|¿\{}|« V (H) |X° V (H) +o|¿\{}y- %) X %o|7yo¢~y%||\%|X°%yo¨ª~y%||\ oz| %¢|¶o H ° ± %}| o©}{o|| %{}|Æya %| %o %o ya %{o{} r ∈]0, 1] Do %oQo Y4è "âÅé_ß%<é 'æZà A=ÞÙß%àáºâ=æ©ãÅã, æ %uß%éoä \é [àZß /æ ]^â oß%à©áºâo©}{oS~ %¢$|o£ ª

(26) w `_ DP GB Y4è "âÅé_ß%<é 'æZà A=ÞÙß%àáºâ=æ©ãÅã,æ %uß%éoä \é [àZß /æ ]^â oß%à©áºaâ Ss Sé ë%à¼ß æ #©bâ ß%àáºâ H æá éæ©éBáºâfæ©cà è%äÃâºáºâ ! h 6 7 8v u1t 9;: <= >@?%âêä©á@æBá A@âÅã é äè ä A¼æ©éoäæ "$#©ãæ X %uæ V (H) ß%åaTæ ' |X| ≤ h á@æ©ã . æ D ≥r dD %{«-y±ÀW»@~ %¢o}o¢o %o {} %}|¶{oú» |ya{uo{(|oyaof e o|{«ya %h{ gQ©¨DP \|®GB o}| %{X*/¦§{!oo®y ±À »@~ %¢o}oÆo %o P P M y+~z %o|o{oya|° ²{}}ya{«W}ya{}|~yao %X{} %}|${} %}|{«|| %{}|$o{}~Bya{u®ya ~y%|bBya~o) i r = 1 Ù~Q¥«o{} %}|~ %{}o ¸ o©}{o [o %oo j è%éBáºlà k%ã, æ %«næ mÙè á@æÃoä ß%,à %uæ©qä prsß%àæ©âÅã¾tä %uæ u à©åaæ©âÅãÅãúß%<é 'æ~ %¢|o£ ª

(27) w wv CRAS j è%é_áºxà k%ãræ %u@æ mÙè á@æÃyä oß%rà %uæ©ä pzsß\àæ©âÅãþcä %u{æ u àÃå%æ©âêãÅãß%é '|æ Ss SéQë%à¼ß æ 'è\é}élæ ?uæbé_è%éè%àÃâfæ©éB~á } Gq é æ©éoäæ "$#©ãæ R %uæ 'ª4ß (êéæ©ä %+ß%éoä G æá éæ©éBáºâfæ©cà èaä©âÅáºâ ! h 6 7 8v u1t 9;: <= >@?%âêä©á@æBá A;âêã é[äè ä A¼æ©é}äæ "$#©ãæ %Q ß%Tà á@æÃä F ⊆ E(G) ß%åalæ ' |F | ≤ h æáLá@æã . æäÃâ P æ©ä©á é5æ 'ª4ß (êé5æ %uæ R ß%ãúè\àä E(P ) ∩ F 6= ∅ D Û¶{| %}|¼»@{}|o |yyaooR{ <91S 8 8LGt °*ÀWya yÆ|o\ "³âêé j mqp*uDo|¿\{}Fy¢o %ob/¦§ %o¢|ya %={ Reb{ByaoG{« gby%|| ª~zya o %o CRAS ¹Åf°§\° %o G R o %{o{}|}o¢{}-o}| Ãí}ö

(28) ñOï +î ÿ nò ö

(29) ÷uõüOøþö

(30) ÷³ù+îÙó«ö

(31) ø ù+ïWî©ïfü>ïOò÷«ï*ï;ø ðT÷+ø «õòü;÷ø öTî©÷ïfüLó«ö î+÷ñ ð

(32) ÿ ûîÙ÷+ó+ûÃñ;ñOöòTÿ}ÿ óuòTý-ï î +÷+ø +î ö +ñ>ÿ îÃï í}ö

(33) ñOï u÷¢ðTñ¼òó+ô+îÙî©ïfü øþó«òñ;ü;ø ÿúò ø óuòñ;ü;øþü;ø öT÷ ðTñ¼òóuô+îÃï ø óuòñ;ü;øúï ï;øþð

(34) ÷+ûÃï ÿ òóuòTñ@üOø¾üOøþö

(35) ÷$î©ïfü ÿúnò öTøúï ï@óªûÃõø uûÃîÙîü7ö

(36) ñOù\ö

(37) ÷+÷+ûÃî P ∈RF P ∈R. F. w(P ). 1. r. 1. 1. 2. 1. 2. 2. 1. 2. 2. 1. 1. 2. r. 1. |NH (X)| |V2 (H)|. r. r. . . . r = 1 . . . . . {V1 , V2 }. . ². . . . . . . .

(38) h %o$¥u}®o %o CRAS y%o{}® %{}|® \|+J %o f¦ {}|ya{}~ (G, R, h)½_ %o %o¶o %o\{} %}|o| %{}|o{}{} %ya %{ |¢yaz %o|{o¿\}|Ãy+| %{o~| %{oz|Ãy+| %{ %o¢|ya %{X° {y%|| «~ya{« %o³{}|ya{}~ Qo %o ³¿\yao¯} oBya_¥«X¦§ %{{} %¸ y B(G, R) + %o7(G,¥«R,}h)V = E(G) V =CRAS R 7B¥«X¦ o{} yaT E e ∈ E(G) |by% Xy%~{u[}ya{}| B(G, R) ¸ o{}D~¯By

(39) Ý{} C ∈ R |- |o{u7| |*o{}ÙyaT Eo

(40) %{¢~ %{}|ya¥«} |*o{}{}|ya{}~ \|+L$oe %o CRAS |«CW|o{u | (B(G,(G,R),R, h)h) |Go{}>{}|ya{}~ \|+Qjo %o DP GB o %o¥«}Q{} %}| {} % %{}|o %{By%ya{« ¹ Y$)è "³âêé_ß\é '5æ %+ß%éoä é [àZß o*æ ]bâ ß%àáºâ½©° DGB ª

(41) w DGB Y)è "³âÅé_ß%é 'Ãæ %+ß\éoä é [àZß æ ]^â ß\à©áºaâ Ss Sé ë%à¼ß æ #©bâ ß%àáºâ H æá éæ©éBáºâfæ©cà è%äÃâºáºâ ! h 6 7 8v u1t 9;: <= >@?%âêä©á@æBá A@âÅã é äè ä A¼æ©éoäæ "$#©ãæ X %uæ V (H) ß%åaTæ ' |X| ≤ h á@æ©ã . æ D N (X) = V (H) Uo %o DGB |o{Do %o$|}\_o}|-~ %{o{u[| %}||| {uoya %{}|-{}|$o||£ |/o{{}|o S ¥«}~ %{}¥«}\ ~ %|¢7o{« %o|o 7oq 'è | %å%{«æ©à©á o à|æ ª| %V}|¼(G) »@{}|o|Ùo « | y% Xy%~{« ¸ S ∈VV(G)(G) %|¥u} x ∈ S ya %|zSo{oS %¢{Bxya{u∈Vo (G)V (G) }ya{}| G |o{Æ{}|o X ⊆ V (G) S¥«} ~ %¢o %oo áºàß%éoäÃå%æ©àäß%ã + V (G) |Do{ S{}|=So S ¥«}ú» ~ %{}¥u}\|-{u|o V (G) | %{uzo|z| %}|¼»@{}|$o|zo S _ x ∈ |y% Xy%~{« %|¥u} ya %|-o{[o %¢{Bya{« V (G) o V (G) }ya{}| G |¸ oS{∈{}V|$(G)o X ⊆ S x∈S¥«S}z %o¶~¯By%¥«}Bya yaoBya{Bya{u ¸ V (G) _ %{ya S ∩ X 6= ∅ ° S ∈S U{ |ÃyaJ{ Bya~o ¥«}ÆÆo %o |®±ÀW»@ ®~[ {} %{»@µ À

(42) ¹º~\¦§|¼» ¸ »@¥«X¦ {X¦§©¨ª|By%|Ù/¦¬ya¿+ %minDGB ¯o %Âª{} %¢ya/| %\ya{u o{ Äfy%~o~ %{}|ya{«Æo||yaÄ¢|À ±ÀL½©°·ª \|Qo %{}~y minDGB ¥u}| %{o®¸ |Ãy+ %$|> %{(o+ %$o %o minCRAS ~ %¢®o{~y%| Bya~o o %o minDGB %Æ~ %¢o{ o %oya}||/¿+{}yaf° ·« |/o{¿\yao¯} oBya_¹ºSo %{}~7o{}W{}|ya{}~7o %o minDGB ½© Ù{X¦§©¨ªH|bBy%|¢{}~||ya{«J/¦ {}|ya{}~ (G, R) o %o minCRAS [¥u} H = B(G, R) °¶²{}}ya{uyao %{}|Æ1t w(

(43) w 9"tT8v GtTv*ws!/¦ o{ ¿\yao¯} %o| %¢/¥«X¦ /©¨ª|o{Æyao-| %¢Ù¿\yao¯}zy% Xy%~{u ¸ %}|W||*+ %|{}| a %o* %o ¿\yao¯}oBya H %yao %{}| V ;t :º

(44) w NB:Ws-o H %o>¿\yao¯}oBya H _¥«X¦ _©¨|o{}|o (H = H, H , ..., H = H ) y+~ p ≥ 0 Q¥u}\ %o %o i ∈ [1, p] H | % %o{u ¸ ByaÆo Bya-y|ooo|| %{Q/¦ o{Qo|z| %¢|z|o}|o|o V (H ) ° U{[©» H ®ya¥u}-¥«}-| H |Lo{ V »@|¢oúB-o H oya %|f¦ {}|ya{}~ H bo %o y%¢~ %¢| %o %{ %o®ya %o|$|³| %o %{}|³ %o®ya| minDGB o[f¦ {}|ya{}~ H °¶²Q¥uo{«« ¸ o©}{o~ %¢ CRAS M N8asu;t <91LO. ÷ò÷uðTÿúòøúï ó+ñOö ÿ ý-îÙù ÷ò÷uðTÿúòøúï ó+ñOö ÿ ý-îÙù Hö +ñ7ù\î©ï ñOûÃï +ÿ¾ü¼òü¼ïWó+ÿ «ï õöTý-ó+ÿ îü¼ï TöTø ñWóuòñ î\îý-ó+ÿ î ù+ò÷uï 1. 2. 1. 1. H. 2. 2. 1. 0. 2. 0. 1. 1. 2. 0. S 0 ∈X. 1. 0. 1 0. 2. 0. 2. 2. 0. 2. 1. 0. 0. 1. p. 0. i. i−1. 0. 1. i−1. 1. 0. . . . . . . SET − COV ER HIT T IN G − SET . ¾. SET − COV ER. +. !#"%$.

(45) y1. y3. y2. x2. x1. y5. y4. x3. Ê¼ Ë. x4. x3. x1 x2 y2 x3 y4. y1. x4. x1. y3. y1. y2. y5. x2. x4. y4. y3. y5. Ê Ë ÊÄ Ë ¸. Ê ¼ Ë 56 87WS½¼[K9<7 H ¹ 7W6HM9 ¼[68ÄLAG»8A minDGB Æ47:U

(46) ¼ ° 9 Ä8PJ7WMN7WK*UWA SHU ° MSTA±9<7?9 6HPHKOA»HA x »HAMOP[KN9<A ° AsÄ½¼ ° A y MOP[7:9 I[PJ7WMN7W6» ¼ ° P[7W6HM ° 6»HALM x Ä8PJ7WMN7WML³ Ê Ë ¶ 7W6R9OALKOS8KO;Vj 9<¼ 9<7:PJ 6 "!$#&%' #(!*),+-!$.0/1!$i 2 3546!»HAÎU7 7W68MN9 ¼ 6HÄLA H »8A minDGBj ÆnU:ALM y MOP[6Á9 UWALM*;LU:5; AL6R9<9 M 8QÄLP ° I@KO7WKS½¼[K ° 6 6HPHKOA* 7:6H76 ° p»HAGMNP ° M FAL68MOA5HUWAVM x ³,Ê Ä Ë i ¶ 7:6R9<ALKNSHKO;±9 ¼ 9O7WPJ* 6 %'#;:".0/$"!$#(/5:"4»HA'U 7:6HMN9<¼[6HÄVA H »8A minDGB Æ[UWAVM x MOPJ6R9¡U:ALM;VUW;5 j AL6R9OM »HPJ6R9Î7: U

(47) ¼ ° 9 Ä 8PJ7WMN7WK ° 6 6HP 98KO< A 7W6867 ° »HA%MOP[KN9<< A ° A%Ä ½"¼ ° Aj MNP ° MF AL6HMN5A 98UWA y i SÐPJMO;M =L»HA¼ ° P[7W6HM ° 6»HAVM;VUW>; AV6Á9OM"Ä HPJ7WMN7WMV³. %ob{}|ya{}~ !o %o minDGB %o¢y%¥«}b©¨ª|o{}b{}|¼» ya{}~ (G, R) jH o %o minCRAS ¥u} H | % | % %o¯} ¸ o{ »@|¢oúB¶o R) °+Û{}Ù{}|ya{}~ (G, R) |yzyaoÙo{} CRAS V M N8asu;t <91L 9;:SB(G, Do H ¹ÅBya>©ö¢o\\f¦ {}|ya{}~¶o minCRAS oy}¿\o | o{} CRAS»fo|{«ya %{Jof¦ {}|ya{}~o minDGB oy}¿\o ¹=y+½½©° @|Dya %|D %{u }ya{}|(Ñ¾²ÕGÖzÁSÓ\×%Ø³¥u}Q %o({}|ya{}~ o %o | CRAS»fo|{«yao \*~¥«o{}Jo %o minCRAS minDGB ya}|| ®~Æ¥«}bbo %o minDGB °*µo{u7| %{"~ %{}|o f¦ {uoya %{/¦ o{}-{}|ya{}~ (G, o %o minCRAS ~ %¢zo{} R) o %{o{} %oy~¯}~¯}z/¦ o{ya{}|+|ya/o~ya{Bya¢{o$o¹º|~ %{» {}Gyaz %{}|Xo{}LyaT E7o G ByaS~¯By

(48) Ý{}>o R½©Wf¦ {Ä= %®ya %{$o~|ya{« ¥u}³|z{}|o|o %{« %{~¯}~¯}o{Qya{}|+|Ãya>| %{u~ %{}|}|/¦¬yaT E| ù\î \ó+ñOøþý-ó+û-ñOöTîóª÷ö

(49) ï;ù ûîò \ù+ü;òTñO÷uîÃïLï üO îñOýî©í ï ! õ $ î©ïfüÙÿ òTñ;ð +ý-î÷aüLî©ï;ï;î÷aü;ø îÿ/ù\îÿúòó+ñOî Tî-ù\î-ÿ ò { õö

(50) ý-ó+ÿþûü uù+î 1. @?. BA. C. $D. E. P P M1. . IH. . . 5J. . . ¿. ! . GF. . .

(51) y1 y2 y3 y4 y5 x1 x2 x3 x4. Ð². . 568A[KO7WU:UWA. M[6×7]. AV9 \ Ä½¼ 68ALM»HPJ6R9 Y MNPJ6R9»HALM"Ä½¼W6HALMUW7J6HAÂFÄLP[UWPJ6H68A[³. o¶~¯By

(52) Ý{}|Ù/¦ o{JFE¿\yao¯}¶{}¶ «úBBy%|Ly{Byao®o %o-¥«o_| /¦ E±ÀW»@ ®~Ù{} %{»@µÀ

(53) ³° ÒS %o©Ä= %|+ ) i| |yaö~ %¢o{o~ya %{b| %{u~ %{}~{}|uo|> % a» %¿\|SBya~o¸ |Wo ¿\yao¯}|*Go|*~y%|||XBya~o|*oL~¯By

(54) Ý{}|*o+{u E7{}{u|°\²¦§|XL~y%|So|*yao|GWya}||+L~y%|So|X¿\| £o{}z K):SBS |o{¿\yao¯}-o %{«Ù|| %¢| | %{uÙo©}{o|ByaLo{b{«o ¢o M ¿\{} i 1 ≤ i ≤ n Ùo{ {«o ®oz~ % %(i,{o{}j) j 1 ≤ j ≤ m o) iÆo¨ | %³» || %{uy% Xy%~{u|Ù|fªÙ|o{u|f«|{} J/{u¥«}|oLo{}-|o-o o| ~ %¢ \|Ãya{u|77ya %| /¦ o{}\yaoWo \°%xzya{}|Wo{}¿\\ao{}Ù~¯By

(55) Ý{}Ù| o{} P8L~Q 8 9 N{ B:SK8 SQ Æ %|¥uX¦§³ \||oo{Q| %¢ (i, j) G¥«} %}|||yao|-| %¢|-yaoBya{o{}{u ¸ y¿\{} i % ¸ y®~ % %{o{} ¹Å+ %>}¿\o +½©°ª·«~¶| %¢|Lo{o¥u}\ª %{®f¦¬yao¶* s<:S[o¶y~¯By

(56) Ý{}\ j |{} %{Æ %{¶¥«}-y³~¯By

(57) Ý{}$|o/ 9

(58) N{ `B:SK8 ® %Æo/ 9

(59) N{ wSQ _° µ}{/¦¬ya¿+o{|z ª~o %{}|S| |zo{}®~y%||³Bya~oo ¿\yao¯}|Ù| T |Lo{b@ÂªBya~oo-F~¯By

(60) Ý{}| %{by¥«X¦ o{}{}|ya{}~ o minDGB | F M N8asu;t <91LO 3N8LO 8 «/t P8L~Q «t 8 F9 N{ T |o| »fo|{uyaoJByao{}¢{}|ya{}~ (G, R) o minCRAS ) i G |o{ CRAS ¿\yao¯}o¶y~y%|| F %o|>|~¯By

(61) Ý{}|o R | %{«Lo@Âª T uyz{u %{ @Âª T %o%ya{«q Ez %¢|z %|¥«}z~z;Â«z|Ù{} J/{u° µ¶{}|f{} %}|G %{u %{}|W¥u}7 %oS¿\yao¯}LoBya«|G¿\©»fo|{uyaoBya o|S~¯By

(62) Ý{}|*o>@Âª7o}|G~ %o|*~¯By

(63) Ý{}|

(64) 7~ya~o/¦ o{}7o|{«ya %{¢ya{u %Âª{} %¢yaf°*²J¥uoL{} %}|$oJ~ %{}~oJ¥«}¢o %o minCRAS |±À »@ ®~Ù*{} %{»@µÀ

(65) F E|{uLya¨$¿\|77yaö}| ~ %o| ~¯By

(66) Ý{}|z/¦§{[o a}- %o}{ozo %{«¥u}$o %o P P M | ±À »@~ %¢o¶ %oÙ %o r ∈]0, 1] ° ÁSyJ|o$o~y%yaW %|oy¢o|{uya %{/¦ o{}$¯}o|¥u}$¿\ %» %{o{}z %oÙzo %o minDGB ©ö| %}|Ùy$Ä= %z/¦ o{Dya¿+ %¯o H/òñBî \îý-ó+ÿ î îÃ÷¶õ8î uøaõöT÷uõîñO÷+î/ÿþî©ï}ñOûÃï;îÃò >üOö \ü ö

(67) ó\ü;ø +î TöTø ñ *îÃò ! ! Gôuø

(68) ! "%$ n×m. A. . r. . . Y. . . . . . . . . .

(69) ¥uoL~ya~o®o{}| %o %{ y+~J¿uyaya{uo¼Ä= %®ya{}~®}ya{}|o{yao % ρ ¥uoX|Ùo{{u¶~ya~oByaÙf¦§©¨~o %{ozf¦¬ya¿+ %¯o\° @{|o¥«}b %|¥«X¦§ %{ |ya®yMX % ρ y[o %¶Byao{}Æ~ %{}|ya{« { |¿\{Bya{uÆ| o %{o{}|y%~~o|Byabf¦¬ya¿+ %¯o\¶ %{ {j~ %{}~o k ¥u}¶o %o minDGB |{u{J~ %{}|¥«}{}~| »@µÀ

(70) ³«~\¦§|¼» ¸ »@ ¥uX¦ ©¨ª|Æo{ ya¿+ %¯o %Â«{} %¢ya k»;yaoo «~¯}| %%ya{«Jo %o\° ²¦§|>{} %ya¢{«¶~y%|L %o7¶o %o minDGB |{«ya¨{}|ya{}~| yao©»fo|{uyao|Ù %oÙ-o %o minDGB |{uya¨{}|ya{}~| ¿\©»fo|{uyao|7y+~>o|G~¯By

(71) Ý{}|*o @Âª7¿\{}©»@~ % %{o{}Lo>F E>~y%|| % ¥uX¦§ %{³ %{«Ù %}| o5¨ E

(72) »@µÀ

(73) ³°aÁS|oya yaúÄya¨³{}|ya{}~|7yao©» o|{uyao|®|o X ¸ ~ %{o{u Ü G®ya|³Äfya³¥uX¦ ©¨ª|Jo|{}|ya{}~|¢o ¥uo/| %{«¶yao©»fo|{uyao|®ya|By%|¿\©»fo|{uyao|-y+~ minDGB o| ~¯By

(74) Ý{}|7o;Â«¿\{}©»@~ % %{o{}\«ya}||ªo{¥«}o|W{}|ya{}~| o minDGB ¥uoL| %{u$¿\©»fo|{uyao|®y+~Jo|$~¯By

(75) Ý{}|³o¢;Â«¿\{}©»@~ % %{o{}®ya| By%| yao©»fo|{uyao|¶{Äº %~f¦ {«T EÆoDyo®ya~¯}o|{u[~f° ÁX %|¥«} ρ = 1 /f¦¬ya¿+ %¯o AminDGB |ªo¢{u³©öy%~°G²¦§|{} a» ya¢{uLÙ~y%|7 %o o %o minDGB |{«Lya¨¢{}|ya{}~|7¥«o}| %{u ~¯By

(76) Ý{}©»fo|{«yao|«o %oo %{u> %{¢ %o+ya{}|oy %Âª{} %¢ya\\y

(77) » ¥u}\ ¸ | %{( %oS{«y

(78) Ý{}b~Jo %oJ|{u¢ya¨({}|ya{}~|¥uo | %{uya{o{}ya»fo|{uyao| ÜÜ ° {}{XÙ{} %}| + ª¥u} %{}|bo+{«Æy o|{«yao+ e %{u g o %o °>ÁX %|¥«X¦ ¶Â y ¹Å+ %ByaJ©ö¢oÑ Ö ØÅ½¢o o|{u¢minDGB ||ya¨!ob~ %¢o{o~ya %{"Bya¢o|³¿\yao¯}|¢ %{u | ~Ü G * oj %o CRAS |¦§{} e({Byao{uf g | %}|Äº %[¡o %oQo è%éBáºlà k%ã,æ %«næ mÙè á@æÃ ä

(79) à©âfæ©éB~á }æÃcä oß%,à %uæÃ*ä prsß%àæ©âÅã¾,ä %«/æ u à©åaæ©âÅãêãß%é 'Ãæ£ ª

(80) w CROAS j è\éBáºxà k\ã*æ %uæ mÙè á@æÃä

(81) à©âfæ©éB~á }æÃ{ä ß%*à %«æÃrä pzsoß%àæâêãþä %uæ u àÃåaæâêãÅãúß\é '|æ æ 'æ "âÅéoä %+ß%é}ä Ss Séë\à¼Zß æ³è%à©â=æ©é_~á } 'è\é}élæ ?uæ G { éæ©éoäæ "F#ãæ R %u, æá éQæ©é_áºâ=æ©à èaäÃâºáºâ ! h 6 G 7 8v u1t 9;: <= >@?%âêä©á@æBá A@âÅã é äè ä A¼æ©é}äæ "$#©ã5 æ %Q ß\xà '©ä ß%åalæ ' |F | ≤ h æá á@æ©ã . æäÃâ P æÃä©á é 'æ "âÅ

(82) é %uæ R ß%ãè%àÃä E(PF) ∩⊆FE(G) D 6= ∅ ÿï;îÃöTïý-õ¼ý->ôuò î5îüS÷+ù\òîîWù+öTó+î÷Dÿ uü øþ%ï/s÷ ó«óªöTîîñOüOýÿ ø¾øþüSð

(83) îÃ÷+ø ÿþ÷uÿ î î ù\õøúõö

(84) ï;î7ÿþøWö

(85) ù+öT÷+î ÷÷+ÿþî¶øû©ðTõï;÷+öTòTîW÷añ@üOüLîî$üSñOûÿù\îÃó«î ï-òó+ñ;õ¼ÿü;ôuuø òîÃï/ï ú÷+óªîÃî©î3÷ nïü;øþüS u+ø ÷uòø7ù\üOï;ñ;øúöTõîî ÷aõüzù\ÿúòTî7ù\ïOî$õï@öTî©ü ÿï>aöTóªï÷++î³÷+ø î ÿþòTø ðTñ;÷a÷uî©rü ï@î$óª îÃö+õDî¶ü;ø ÿ ù\Tî î$îÃuýñü %îÃõ÷aó«öTü/øî¢÷ù+õîîÃö

(86) ï@ÿþ>üLö

(87) ÷+óuÿ î ÷+ÿ +uî ñï óªø ÷uîù\ü;øúøþüõîó+ù\ÿ î¶uïÙõöTðTÿ ñ¼öTò÷+÷«÷uù î + íBò-ñOó+ûó«ÿ uòïÙñ;ü;ð

(88) øþü;ñOø òTöT÷u÷³ù ù\îÃó+ï7ÿ uõ¼ïÙô«ò óªî÷+üOîÃø¾ï ü ù\®îîü ü aóªîÙó+ÿ ÿøþuð

(89) ÷+ïÙîÙðTñ¼ö ò¢÷«ù\ù îó+ü %ÿ uóªïÙî¶ðTõñ¼ö

(90) òÿþö

(91) ÷«÷+ù ÷+Jîó«ø ÷uî ù\\øú{ü õîò

(92) ù\õøîzÿþîÃÿ ýøþð

(93) îÃ÷+÷aî ü ï;îz%ì $'òT& øþñOîÃîï@ü;îñO÷uîï ø +÷aøþü*ü;îò - ù òTòñ ø ÿ ÿþñ;î î©+ï ñOï ÿ î>ù+óuîñ;ù\ö ø aÿ ûÃñOý-î÷aî üOîÃïò!öT÷uï#" îÃï@üGî +òTõüOîý-î÷aüSÿ î>óuñ;ö aÿ Ãý-î óªñ¼òö ÿ +îñ*öÿþ,$î ÿ +îÃï îÿòTø ñ ÿ«î ü;%î©ï øúï@ü;ï@îö

(94) ÷

(95) +ü ÷ý ò+ÿ ðT÷+ö

(96) ø îÃñ;øþï ü;ôuù ý+î ÷³( ó«ö

(97) òøó+ùuóuï ñ;ö\ó«õ¼öaô+ï@ûøþü;øa ö *) ÷ !u+ ÿ $ zõöTý-ó+ñOøúïGù+òT÷uï +÷+î

(98) îñ¼ï@ø öT÷zóuÿ uï*ð

(99) û÷+û ì;ì ò +³ðTý-î÷uî÷aõüOöTûñOîÙîù\-õ \îÙõÿ ÿ î òTñ ñ;îÃü;ó+î ñ;û©ï@îÃ÷aüOò ÿþî >÷³-õ \õÿ îÙîÃï@ü +÷³ðTñ¼òó+ô+î ò TîÃõ øúï@ö

(100) ý-öTñOó+ô+î ÿ òzõ¼ôuò ú÷uî õóuö òT+ì ñ ó+%ÿ îÃø ï*ù\îLîÃï@ï;ü öTý-+÷bý-ðTîü¼ñ¼ïòóu7ô+î÷$îüö

(101) õ¼ô+ñ;ø îîý-÷aüOø û÷ù ÿ îÃöT÷uñ¼ù\ï@îÃñ;ý î ÿ î îÃï@ü +÷ðTñ¼ù+òûÃó+ï;øþô+ð

(102) î>÷+öTî-ñOÿøþîÃî÷

(103) ÷uüOï;û7îýøúï@ö

(104) ýÿ î-ö

(105) ù+ñ;óuîô+ï@î>î©ïò òñ¼ðTõñ¼ï òó+ ô+uî øSï@ö

(106) ÷aù+üÙû u÷ù+îÃ+ï ø C. +. . . . . . . . .

(107) Pn G . . . . . . . . . . . . ! . X(Pn ) = {1, 2...n}. . . . . {1, n} E(Pn ) =. . . . . E(G) . . . . . . . . . ! . !. . . n (i, i + 1) | 1 ≤ i < n. \. . . minCRAS. . . . . . . . M U LT I− CU T . . . . n ≥ 3. . . . . . Pn.

(108) ± %}|- %{« %{}|ya %|{Qo©}{o||ya{«zByazya{Bya %¿\³|{} % %{}|z %{«| ¥u}L %o{}|ya{}~o |W¿uya{u »fo|{«yao\%®ya| {} %}|- %{u %{}|¥«}minDGB By%||ya¿+³Q~y%|-{} %{[ %CROAS {«yaQ~y%|z %{u¢{}ya{}|¼» %¶By%|Ùyao %®ya¥u}{«Ù|>|oya|T° {b J/+o{}ss 91:BS ¢/¦§ % n | o{®¿\yao¯} G = (X, E) %oL¥«}B|| %¢|o X o+{uc E{uo a» |7oÓ ¸ n − 1 oÙ| %Ù¥u} E = {{0, i}|i ∈ [1..n − 1]} +Ù| %¢LÓ-ya{u> s <91 ¢of¦§ %\° U{b|yaL¥«}|{uÙya¨J %|«o %oaÜ V oo ±À »@ ®~

(109) »@µÀ

(110) Ñ¾Ö ØS¹=ya|{}| ¥«X¦§ %{¢{}|ya By%|W %o yaoya{«Lya©» %¶Ä=y%~o ¢\yayao % o ¶|-yao|{D¿+{}yaê½©B®ya|{} %}|¶ %{« %{}| ¥u}\B}ya{}|~$~y%|Bya~o_f¦§ %{uya %{Q¿\yao¯}{}Æo %o$o}| Ä=y%~®£}{o©}{o||ya{«¶o{}$ss 91:BS &): <9s b~ %¢o{} %}ya{}|y%¥«} ~¯By%¥«}$yaT E |Ù¢oy%~$Byao{Dya~ a %Æo{Dya~ B{} %}| %{u %{}|z¥«}{i,j}o %o minCROAS |(i,{uj)ya¨ %|- %(j,{ui)|z| ofo %Â«{} %¢yaf° ÁSy¢|o yao %¶| %¿uya{o|~ %¢|o£ |~ %{ d %{«!y"¿\©»fo|{«yao Bya[o|[o}|[~ %o| ~yd ¯By

(111) Ý{}|Wo %o *{$ooG¥«}7>o %o minCras |¶±ÀW»@ ®~{} %minDGB {»@µÀ

(112) oy®|o~ %~{ yaoo %-oy®± ÀW»@~ %¢o}o¢o %o DP GB /¦§) i %{ PPM S|y\yaya{u AminDGB ¥uyÙo|* ~J %{{«¶ÔÙoo{} %¿u \ya|Wyaf{«¦¬ya$¿+ %o¯o¼ Ä= %AminDGB ®ya{}~\B\ya}$y \| %G}ya{}|¶ ~y%|¿+{}yafS®ya|$y o %L %o$~ya{}|$~y%||||~úB¥u}|$oo %{» {}| {$Bya~o AminDGB *o>~ %{}~o ¸ yÙ{ByaoLµ À

(113) o¶y|~ %{ Jo %o minDGB ya~y%|o|{}|ya{}~|¥uo| %{u yao©»fo|{uyao| %®¿\©»fo|{«yao|y+~o|~¯By

(114) Ý{}|o@Âª ¿\{}©»@~ % %{o{}\ªya{}|_¥uX¦ ¸ y- %Âª{} %¢yao %o¶}ya{}|7~y%|7o| {}|ya{}~|¶¥«oX| %{u~¯By

(115) Ý{}©»fo|{«yao|z %Dya{o{}ya»fo|{uyao| { %{uoLy CRAS»fo|{uyao y¶ |o~ % %o{³×o |{uL7o{}®>+ %{«| % ¥«} Æo %o | | %{D %oz±ÀW»@DGB ®~¢{} %{»@µÀ

(116) ³ya{}|z¥u}$$ominCROAS %o minDGB¸ |{u-ya¨{}|ya{}~|¥uoX| %{u¶ %©»@ %{«©»fo|{uyao||Ù a» Â«{} %¢ya y¢|~ %{ ~ %{}~oyao %°

(117) Ë QË É Ê Ð

(118) Ð!Ê " Í DGB ·ª % Æ¿\yao¯}oByao|{uya{uby[ya %{¡/¦¬yaoBya{Bya{}~[o| {u|H/¦ o{({}|$o®o~ya{Bya× ¸ ||| %}|»@{}|o|$o~ya{Bya ôuò ì \$ü;#=î ÿo+îÃñ*ï@ü )ÙZû ù+ ò+÷uø ï òTÿþ îÃ ÷a*üW)ò + ó+ñOö ÿ ý-îù &%'# !#(% % & /öTø ñWóuòñ* î \îý-ó+ÿ îÿþî©ïWòñ ñ;î©ïGù+î ?. r. r. k. k. ?. . . . $. . . F. . Ì. . .

(119). .

(120) ~\¦§|¼» ¸ »@o©}{o Ü Bya V1 (H) = {1, 2, 3, 4, 5} {1, 2, 3, 4, 5} V2 (H) = 3. ·«oo \| %{}|G¥«X¦ u©¨| o{} {}|ya{}~ o %o %o y%¥u} %{ya B(G, R) ≈ H °Gµ %|(G,|¢yaR)TE|³o G | %{«$minCRAS |³{«|¢o ¸yaT ×JE-|{X/¦¦ o¢{}¢ %o|³~¥«¯B}y

(121) Ý*{}~¯}| %oú¨ o$° U %{|-{o~ %~{}|~{}o %$¥uo} |zo©|}{o~ %{of¦§{}{}©¨|\/¥«o}¢¢o||| | %¢|Ù| %{«o-o¿\-®y

(122) ¨Ro ªoo|¥«}-|{} %{bG %|yaT E|{}~o{u| ¸ o{DF E¢| %¢{}$ %oya{uzBy%|yaoBya{o ¸ o{}$F E³~¯By

(123) Ý{}¢o R ¥u}-o %{}~ G |o{}-~¯By

(124) Ý{} %bo{ ~Âª~-o %{o¿\}o¶×°xzya{}||Ùo¨~y%|ª |¢ \||o¥«} %o~¯By%¥u}-~¯} %úö %|yaT E|©¨ª|¶o{}~¯By

(125) Ý{}zo ¥uoS|~ %{u{o{}®ya|{}z~ %{u{o{}By%||o¨Æyao|° G ²{}}ya{« H |o{ CRAS»fo|{«yao\Q° U{DoByaz©ö¢o³o©» }{oo{ ¿\yao¯} G Bya$£ E(H) =. . {i, C} | i ∈ V1 (H), C ∈ V2 (H), i ∈ C. *A. . xi | 1 ≤ i ≤ 5 ∪ yi | 1 ≤ i ≤ 5 1 2. ∪ zi,j,k | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5 ∪ zi,j,k |1≤i<j<k≤5 . E(G) = {xi , yi } | 1 ≤ i ≤ 5 1 1. ∪ {zi,j,k , yi } | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5 ∪ {zi,j,k , xj } | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5 2 2. ∪ {zi,j,k , yj } | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5 ∪ {zi,j,k , xk } | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5 V (G) =. . {Æ \|ya{u. . 1 2 (xi , yi , zi,j,k , xj , yj , zi,j,k , xk , yk ) | 1 ≤ i < j < k ≤ 5. %{[o-+úBz¥u} |-o{ »@|¢oúB¢o R) ~³¥uo*{~ %¼» o %o minDGB y+~ | %{}}ya{}~|| %oH %{}|Ù %o®Vya|Ùo H %oLB(G, o{}ÙByao|L| %o %{}|> %o®ya|Lo (G, R) °²Ù¢|{~ %| %{}}ya{}~ |¦§©ö¶o}|¿+{}ya{uoy-Äfy %{b|o%ya{«\ )iJ %{ y%o %oy{} %ya %{ %oo|¿\{}y¢\yao/¦ o{}$| %o %{ %o®yaof¦ {}|ya{}~ OP T (I) %oo{ o %o/¦§ %o¢|ya %{ minP £ I { ªw(

(126) w uBâ æÃäá é ë%àZß &æ #©bâ ß%àáºâ A;à|æ _là }©äæ©éBáfß #©ãæ æá-ä©â æÃä©á éæ CRASHA;à|æ _là }©ä æ©éBáfß+áºâºè%é %«æ H ß%ãCRAS è%àÃäáfè á@æÆäè%ã áºâ=è%éjZè áºSâ "¢ß\ã&æ (G,%uæ R)H è àzãræ _àè #©ã "®æ minDGB æ©ä©á 2 éæ #â læ 'áºâ=è%é à Ãä @ éæ-äè%ã áºâºè%é[Zè áºSâ "ß%ãæ %uæ (G, R) è àzãcæ _àè #©ã "®æ minCRAS 6 >é ß\à©áº-â ' ãþâfæ©à OP T (H) = OP T (G, R) 6 ù\î ì íBò>ù\îÙ÷+öõü¼òTòñOü;ù\ø öTø ÷u÷ òTÿ 7ö ö , «ï ÿ îÃò ï@Tü ö

(127) +÷u÷ïGîî÷«ý-ï@îÃó+ý ñ +÷aÿ îSü;ûîî ü + % ÷î÷a ü;ø îñ ù\ûÃï;øþð

(128) ÷+îSÿ î÷uï;îý ÿþî*ù\îÃïï;ö uï îÃ÷uï;îý ÿþî©ï R=. 1. . minP. . . . . . minDGB. minCRAS. X. X k F. . k. X . . . . . . k. Í. F. . $. . . . . . .