A locally nameless solution to the POPLmark challenge

HAL Id: inria-00123945

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00123945v2

Submitted on 11 Jan 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

A locally nameless solution to the POPLmark challenge

Xavier Leroy

To cite this version:

Xavier Leroy. A locally nameless solution to the POPLmark challenge. [Research Report] RR-6098,

INRIA. 2007, pp.54. �inria-00123945v2�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

ISRN INRIA/RR--6098--FR+ENG

Thème SYM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A locally nameless solution to the POPLmark challenge

Xavier Leroy

N° 6098

Janvier 2007

!#"$&%(')*+

,.-0/13254627498;:

<>=@?ACBD7EGFIH)D0J;KMLN?OAPB9KQKNJ7ASRUT5VXWZY7[\BOK

]_^`TbacBLedgfbVhVXWh[\A

iQfbj\jkTl^NLQm;Bg^NB9no=\B^ono=\Bqpsr(tlulv5wxHzy5flp0{7WhB^Q|lulu7}gH~€Pj@fb5BOK

‚„ƒ(…O†‡€ˆ\‰l†lŠ <>=\B‹]Œ]ŽAfb^`‘’no=@fbVhVhBp\5B„WZKPf“nTlVhVXB9n”LNWh{lB•B–;jkB^`WXACBp7LCWXp7L`Bp@m;B9m’L`T$flK`KMB9KNKLN=\B

[UKNflR\WXVhWXLcJTb—L`=\BT5^NBOA!j\^`T€{lBO^`Kfbp@m•j\^`T0Tb—f5KNKNWhKML`flp7L`KWXp•LN=@BgnTlp7LNB–0L>Tl——˜[\pUm\fbACBp7LofbV™^`BOKNBOfb^ono=T5p

j@^NT5l^ofbACACWXp\•Vhflp\l[UfblB9Kš›œpxL`=\WZKg^NBOjUT5^ML9žBCj\^`BOKNBp7L&f‹KMT5VX[;L`WXT5pŸL`TLN=\Bno=@flVXVhBp\5Blm;BO{lBOVXT5jUB9m

žWXLN= L`=\B•¡T;Y.j\^`T7Tl—f5KNKNWhKML`flp7LOfbpUmx[UKMWhp\LN=\B¢MVhT0nOfbVhVXJ.pUfbACBVhBOK`Kœ£Pj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5pxTl—¤L`B^`ACKgžWXLN=

R@WXp@m\B^oK>WXp7LN^`T;m;[@nBOm•R7J•F¥n¦gWhp\p@f@\]*TlVhVhf5no‘k\dGT5^`m;T5p\fbpUm•F¥nO§^NWZm;Blš

¨.©7ªs«`¬­ ‡€®(…lŠ ]Œ]¤ŽAfl^N‘sU¡T;Yk;VXT;nflVXVhJp@flACBVhBOK`K\flVXj\=Uf€¯œnTlp0{5B^oKMWhTlp5R\Whp@m;B^oKO;LcJ0jUB&KNJ0KMLNBOAK

ACBL`f€L`=\BT5^NJ5\KMJ;KMLNBOA±°¯²KN[\R

… Š ŽB–;jO^NWhBp@nBnT5VXVhBOnLNWh{lBg]Œ]¤ŽACfl^N‘•{0WhKNB{€fbVh[\B^eV[;LNWhVhWhK`fbR\WhVhWLm;BOKQmACTlp@KMLN^of€¯

L`B[\^oKfl[;LNT5Af€LNWZY7[\BOKBL(m\BOKf5KNKNWZKcLofbp7L`Km\B¤j\^`B[\{5BOKm@fbp@KVXBnTlp7L`B–0LNB_m;BVhfQ^NB9no=\B^ono=\B*—˜TlpUm\fbACBp7LofbVhB

KN[\^VXB9KQVZfbp\7fblB9Km;Bj@^NT5l^ofbACAf€LNWhTlpšGfbp@KnBS^`flj\jUT5^ML9@p\T5[@KQj@^9KMBOp5L`Tlp@KQ[\p\BSKNTlVh[;L`WXT5pnBLMLNB

B–;jO^NWhBp@nBlm{lBOVXT5j\j B•V!fbWZm;Bm;BVflK`KNWhKML`flp5L&m;BCj\^`B[\{5BOK¡T;YkBL^`BjkT5K`fbp7L&KM[\^&VZf•j\^9KMBOp7L`f€¯

L`WXT5pS¢NKNflp@K_p\T5AK¤VhT;nfb[\–5£em;B9KLNB^`ACBOKf {lBOnQVXWhB[\^oKWXp7LN^`T;m;[\WXLNBGj@fb^F¥n¦gWhp\p@f@5]*T5VXVZflno‘s;dGTl^om;Tlp7BL

FŸn§^NWZm;B5š

" ­ †9… « ‰# …$Š ]Œ]ŽAfb^`‘s_¡T;Yk*KNflp@Kp\T5AKVhT0nOfb[;–™*fbVhj\=@fb¯²nTlp0{lBO^`KNWXT5pVhWXBO[\^oK*KMJ;KMLN?OAPB9Km;B

LcJ0jkBOKO;AL`fbLN=OTl^`WXB5\KMJ;KMLN?OAPB&°¯œKM[\R

2 3547698;:=< >

?A@CBEDEFHGJIJKLBNMOFP@

QSRTQ U

!#"“%')(•+

<>=@B]Œ]¤ŽACfl^N‘ no=@fbVhVhBp\5BWVX§°

+

u7~ZYWZKf.nTlVhVXB9n”L`WX{5BB–;jUBO^NWhACBp7LWhp7LNBpUm;BOm“L`T¥flK`KMB9KNK&LN=\B[UKc¯

flR\WhVXWXLcJŸTl—L`=\BT5^NBOA j\^`T€{lB^oKgfbp@m j\^`T0Tb—flK`KMWZKML`fbp7LoKWhp“LN=@BnTlp7L`B–0LTb——˜[\p@m\flACBp7L`flV_^NB9KMB9fb^ono=ŸT5p

j@^NT5l^ofbACACWXp\•Vhflp\l[UfblB9KšP<>=\Bp\BOBOmŸ—˜Tl^nT5ACj\[;LNBO^flK`KMWZKML`fbpUnBPž=\Bpx—˜Tl^`AfbVhW[OWXp\‹fbpUmxj@^NT€{0Whp\

j@^NT5jUBO^ML`WXB9K_Tb—j\^NT5l^ofbACACWXp@&Vhflp\l[@fllB9K]\—˜T5^NAfbVsKNBAfbp7LNWZnKfbpUmCLcJ0jUBgKMJ;KMLNBOACK^ WZKžBOVXVkB–;j\^`BOK`KMB9m

WhpLN=\BKML`fbLNBOAPBOp7L>Tl—L`=\Bno=@flVXVhBp\5B`_

F¥fbp0J“j\^`T0Tb—KflRUT5[;LCj\^NT5l^ofbACACWXp@.Vhflp\l[@fllB9Kfb^`BVhTlp\U_KcL`^`flWX5=5LN—˜Tl^`žfl^`mfbpUm“LNB¯

m;WhTl[@KOUžWXLN=„ac[@KMLGfC—˜BOž#WXp7LNBO^NB9KcL`WXp@„nf5KMB9Kše<>=@BWh^nT5ACj\VXB–;WLcJ‹fb^`WhKNBOK—˜^NT5A L`=\BAflp;¯

fb5BACBp7LTl—Afbp0Jm;BL`fbWhVZK¤^of€L`=\B^LN=@flp—˜^`TlA!m;BOBjnTlpUnBj\LN[@flVkm;Wan[\VXLNWhBOKb;JlBL>KNAfbVhV

ACWhKML`fl‘lBOK¤Tl^T€{lB^`VhT7T5‘lB9mSnOflKNBOK_nOfbpWhp0{ flVXWZm\fbLNBQVZfb^`lBeflACTl[\p7L`K¤Tb—™žTl^`‘kš*<>=\B9KMBQBTckB9n”LoK

fb^`B&fbACj\VhWed@B9m•f5K>Vhflp\l[UfblB9K>KNnOfbVhB`_*WLQRkBOnTlACBOK>=Ufb^omL`TP‘5BBOjm;BTd@p\WXLNWhTlp@Kefbp@m•j\^`T7Tl—K

nT5p@KMWZKMLNBp7L9@L`T^NBO[@KNB&žT5^N‘sUflp@mLNT„Bp@KN[\^`B&LNWhl=7Le^`BVZf€L`WXT5p@KM=@WXj@KQRUBLcžBOBp‹LN=@BTl^`J‹fbp@m

WXACj\VhBACBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p@KšfXe[;LNT5ACfbLNB9mj\^`T0Tb—flK`KNWhKML`flp5LoK_T`ckBO^¤L`=\B=@TljkBeTb—(KMWhlp\WdUnOfbp7LNVhJCBOflKM¯

WXp@LN=@BOKNBej\^`TlR\VhBAKOšfgQT€žB{lBO^O5m;BOKNj\WXLNBGA[@no=BOp@nT5[\^ofblWhp\gj\^`Tl5^NB9KNK Whp„^`BOnBp7L¤J5BOfb^oK

fbp@m•L`=\Bf {€fbWhVhflR\WXVhWXLcJTb—(KNB{5B^ofbVsAf€L`[\^NBGL`T7T5VhKO0LN=@BWh^Q[@KNBGWZKQKMLNWhVXVp\TbLQnT5ACAPT5p\j\VZflnBlš

<>=\Bno=@flVXVhBp@lB¤WXL`KNBVX—knTlp@KNWZKcLoKTl—\—˜Tl^`AfbVhW[OWXp@eL`=\B>TljkB^of€LNWhTlpUfbV0KMBOACflp7LNWZnK(fbp@mLN=\BLcJ0jkBKNJ;KcL`BA

Tl—

F <:

7fGLcJ7jkBOmP—˜[@p@n”L`WXT5p@fbVUVhflp\l[@fllB—˜BOfbLN[\^`Whp\&jUT5VXJ0ACTl^`j\=\WZKNA fbpUmPKN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\U5fbpUmCj\^NT€{0Whp\GLN=\B

KNTl[@p@m;p\B9KNK(Tb—@LN=\BLcJ0jUBKNJ;KcL`BAqžWXLN=P^NB9KMjkBOnLL`TGLN=\WZK KMBOAfbp7LNWZnKOšhXK fe5[\Whm@fbp@nBl LN=@B>KML`fbLNBOAPBOp7L*Tl—

L`=\B>no=@fbVhVXBOp\lB¤j\^NT€{0WZm;BOKfem;BL`flWXVhBOmTlp;¯²j@fbjkB^—˜Tl^`AfbVhW[9f€LNWhTlpTb—

F <:

fbp@mfej\^`T0Tb—;Tb—@LcJ7jkB>KMT5[\p@m;p\B9KNK

ž^`WXLMLNBOp‹WXp.T5^`m;Whp@fl^NJAf€L`=\BAfbLNWZnKOš¤<>=\Bno=@flVXVhBp\5BgWLoKMBOV— WZK>LNTB–0j@^NB9KNKL`=\BOKNBg—˜Tl^`AfbVhW[9f€LNWhTlp‹fbpUm

j@^NT0Tb—KWhp.fL`=\BT5^NBOA!j\^`T€{lBO^Whp.KM[Uno=fPž>f JCLN=@fbLLN=\B&j\^`T0Tb—KnOfbpRUB&ACBOno=Ufbp\WZnflVXVhJno=\BOno‘5BOm™š

X m\T`[BOpnT5APj@VXBLNBQT5^_j@fb^NLNWZfbVUKMT5VX[;L`WXT5p@K*L`TgLN=\BQ]>Œ]¤ŽAfb^`‘Cno=@fbVhVXBOp\lB>žB^`BQm;B{5BVhTljkBOm™5[@KNWXp\

fŸžWhm\B„{€fb^`WXBLcJ“Tb—Qj\^`T0Tb—eflK`KNWhKML`flp5LoK\²¡T0Yk ›cK`fbRkBVhVXBiggŒGŽ_<žBVX—cQššOšj^qflp@m$Tl—e^NBOj\^`BOKNBp7L`fbLNWhTlp

L`BOno=\p@WhY7[\B9K_—˜T5^¤L`=\BQL`B^`ACKO7LcJ0jUB9Kflp@m^`[\VXB9K¤Tl—™LN=\B

F <:

Vhflp\l[@fllB5š(<>=\B9KMBGKMT5VX[\LNWhTlp@Knfbp„RUB—˜Tl[\pUm



T5pLN=\B]>Œ]¤ŽAfb^`‘ BR¥KNWXLNB€š<>=\WZKQ^`BjkTl^NLQj\^`BOKNBp7L`KL`=\BKNTlVh[;LNWhTlpL`=@f€LežBm;BO{lBVhTljkBOmš¤›²LQ[@KNBOK

L`=\BS¡T;Yj\^`T0Tb—(f5KNKNWZKcLofbp7L%V¡T;Y0u7}7\§Q¡ub Y3@f5K>žBOVXVf5KLN=\BKNTb¯œnflVXVhBOmP¢cVhT;nflVXVhJp@fbACBOVXB9KNKc£G^`Bj\^`BOKNBp\¯

Lof€L`WXT5pWXp7LN^`T;m;[@nBOmPR0JPF¥nO¦gWXp@p@f\5](T5VXVZflno‘s5dGT5^`m\Tlp7fbp@mF¥nO§^NWZm;Bl VF¥]¤vlv@7dGTl^ovb;7F¥F¥ulY3š <>=\B

nTlACj\VhBL`B¡T;Ym\B{lBOVXT5j\ACBp7LWhKef { flWXVZfbR@VXBGTlp\VhWhp\BVŽB^ou7}Y²š

QSR

"“” %* %((g

]*BO^N=@flj@K>KM[@^Nj\^`WZKMWhp\lVhJl5LN=@BGAflWXp‹m;Wan[\VXLcJWXp•LN=@B&]Œ]¤ŽAfl^N‘no=@flVXVhBp@lBGWhKp\TlLL`TPLN^ofbp@KNVhfbLNBLN=\B

=@WX5=;¯3VhB{5BV3T5p;¯3jUfbjkB^&j\^`T0Tb—K&Whp7LNT.BOY7[\Wh{€fbVhBp7LACBOno=Ufbp\W[B9mxj@^NT0Tb—KOš•<>=@BOKNBTlp;¯²j@fbjkB^&j@^NT0Tb—Kfb^`B

ACT7KcL`VXJKNJ7p7Lofln”L`WhnQWXp•p@f€L`[\^NBGfbp@m„m;Tp\TlLWhp0{lT5VX{5B=\WX5=\B^Af€L`=\BAf€L`WhnOKš_D0[Uno=j\^`T7Tl—Kfl^NBe=@fbp@m\VXB9m

žBVhV™R0JAfbp0JB–0WZKMLNWhp\Cj\^NT0Tl—(flK`KNWhKML`flp5LoKš

=@fbL¤Afb‘5BOK ]Œ]ŽAfb^`‘Sm;Wan[\VXL¤WZK L`=\BQp\BOBOmSLNTnTl^`^NB9n”L`VXJ=Ufbp@m;VhB

`T*



*r

flp@m

p " j *r

š.<>=\BCLNBO^NAK&flp@mxLcJ7jkBOKTb—

F <:

nT5p7L`fbWhp { fl^NWZfbR@VXB9K&KM[@no=$f5KG—˜[\p@n”L`WXT5p$j@f€¯

^ofbACBLNB^oK fbpUmLcJ0jkBQ{€fb^`WhflR\VhBOKOlflK žBVhV@f5K_nT5p@KcL`^N[Un”L`K(L`=@f€LR\WXpUmPLN=\B9KMB{€fb^`WZfbR\VhBOKOlKN[@no=flK(—˜[\pUn”LNWhTlp

flR@KMLN^ofln”L`WXT5p@K

λx. x

Whp‹LNBO^NAKfbpUm•[@p\WX{5B^oKNflV™Y5[Ufbp7LNWdUnfbLNWhTlp

∀X. X → X

Whp•LcJ0jkBOKOš¤<TTlR;LofbWhpf KNTl[@p@mL`=\BT5^NJCTb—LN=\BgVZfbp\5[@fb5Bl7WL>WZK>p\BOnBOK`KNfl^NJSLNTPLN^`BOfbLL`B^`AKflp@mLcJ0jkBOK>flKB9Y5[UfbVs[\j•LNTCfbVhj\=@f€¯

nTlp0{lBO^`KNWhTlp5LN=@fbLeWZK\^`BpUfbACWXp@5KTb—*RUT5[\p@m‹{€fb^`WZfbR\VhBOKOš °\Tl^eWXp@KML`flp@nB50LN=\BLcžTPLcJ0jUB9K

∀X. X → X

flp@m

∀Y. Y → Y

AS[@KMLRUBCL`^NB9f€L`BOm“flK&B9Y7[@fbV3š„<>=\WZK&WZKm;Wan[\VXLLNT¥f5no=\WXBO{lBCžWXLN= LNT;m\f J K&j\^`T7Tl—

f5KNKNWZKcLofbp7L`KO_RkBOnfl[@KNB„L`=\BOKNB‹T csB^jkT7T5^KM[\j@jUT5^MLC—˜Tl^Y7[\TlLNWhBp7LKMBL`KOš D0BO{lBO^`flV^`Bj@^NB9KMBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p@KTl—

R@WXp@m\B^oK>=@f {lBGRUBOBp‹Whp7{5BOKMLNWh5fbLNBOm•T€{lBO^¤L`=\B&VZflKMLQ5uSJlBOfl^`KL`TPT€{5B^onT5APBLN=@WhKQm\Wean[@VLcJ5š

.­ ˆ#_‡ © ‡ © … © s†Oˆ;†­ … —˜T5VXVhT€ž!L`=\B.[@KN[@fbVQAfbLN=\BOACfbLNWZnflVj\^`f5n”L`WhnB.Tb—gWhm;BOp7LNWX—˜J7Whp\$RkTl[\pUm

{€fb^`WhflR\VXB9K™R0JpUfbACBOKfbp@m&Y7[\TlLNWhBp7LNWhp\L`B^`ACK[\j&LNTfbVhj\=@f€¯œnT5p0{lB^oKNWXT5peTb—;RkTl[\pUmgp@fbACBOKOš<>=@WhK

nflpRUBWhp5L`B^`p@fbVhW[BOmžWL`=\WXpLN=\BVhTllWZn WXL`KNBVX—c€VXB9flm;Whp\eLNTep@TlACWXpUfbV7VXT5lWZnK(V]_WXL`u

1

Y²š*D0[@j\jUT5^ML—˜Tl^

fp@TlACWXpUfbVkVXT5lWZnQžWXLN=\Whp•fSj\^`T7Tl—flK`KMWZKML`fbp7LWhKKcL`WXVhVsWXp•WLoKWXp;—flp@nJ5;R\[;L>WhKAfb‘0Whp\SKNWhlp\WdUnflp7L

j\^`Tll^`BOK`KOVe<u5~ Y3š BOKNj\WL`BQL`=\BOKNBem;Wan[\VXLNWhBOKOlL`=\WZKflj\j\^`T5flno=PWZK¤f€LNLN^oflnLNWh{lBRkBOnfl[@KNBQWLWhK_LN=\B

nVhT5KNBOKML¤L`T[@KN[@fbVkAf€LN=@BAf€L`WhnOfbV@j@^`f5n”LNWZnB55VhBOf5m;Whp\L`TKcLof€L`BACBp7L`KfbpUmj\^`T7Tl—K L`=@f€L>fb^`BQ{lBO^NJ

nVhT5KNBGLNTž=@fbL>žB&fb^`B&flnn[@KMLNTlACB9mL`TCKNBBgWhpLNB–0L`RUT0Tl‘;Kflp@m^NB9KMB9fb^ono=j@fbjkB^oKOš

®

©

‡ ®‰ © … f {5TlWZmL`=\BWZKNKN[\B&žWXLN=¥fbVhj\=@fb¯²nTlp0{lBO^`KNWhTlpR0J„^`Bj@^NB9KMBOp5L`WXp@P{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBOKQp\TbLQR0J

p@fbACB9KR@[;LR0J¥jUT7KMWXLNWhTlp \˜Whp@m;WZnB9Kj^G^`BVZf€L`WX{5BL`TLN=\BBOp@nVhT5KNWXp@•R\Whp@m;BO^`K_

v 1

WhKGL`=\B{€fb^`WhflR\VhB

RUT5[\p@m R0J“LN=\B-d@^oKcLCBpUnVhT5KNWXp\xR\Whp@m;B^9

v 2

R0J“LN=@B‹KNBOnTlp@m_BLonbš °@Tl^CWXpUKcLofbp@nBl L`=\BLNB^`A

λx. x (λy. x y)

Whp’p\TlACWhp@fbVp\TbLof€L`WXT5p’WhKS^`Bj\^`BOKNBp7LNB9m“flK

λ. v 1 (λ. v 2 v 1 )

^{Whp m;B•§^`[\Wacp}

p\TbLof€L`WXT5pšx<>=\BKcL`^NBOp\bL`=$Tb—L`=\WhKPfbj@j\^NT7flno=“WZKL`=@f€LSLNB^`AK=Uf {lB[\p@WhY7[\B•^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5p@K_

LcžTSLNBO^NAK>fb^`BflVXj@=@f€¯²BOY7[\Wh{€fbVhBp7LWhp„p\T5ACWXp@flVsp\TbLof€LNWhTlp•W—(fbp@m•Tlp\VhJCW—LN=\BOJfb^`BWZm;BOp5L`WhnOfbVsWhp

m;B§^`[\Wacpp\TbLof€LNWhTlpš›²LWhK_LN=\BO^NB—˜Tl^`BBOflKNJL`T^`Bj\^`BOKNBp7L¤fbpUmCžT5^N‘SžWL`=WXp„fj\^NT0Tl—sf5KNKNWhKML`flp7L

Vge[\BOvl Y²š•<>=\Bm\T€žp@KMWZm;BTl—L`=\WhKfbj\j\^`T5f5no=xWZKgL`=@f€L&L`=\BACBOflp\WXp@.Tb—m;B„§^N[@Wacp“Whp@m;WZnBOKWhK

{lBO^NJ m;BjkBp@m\Bp7LTlp“L`=\B„nTlp7LNB–7L9š.F¥fbp0JŸVhWX—LNWhp\ŸfbpUm“^NBOVXT;nfbLNWhTlp TljkB^of€L`WXT5p@K&T€{lBO^&WXpUm;WhnBOK

A[@KMLQRkB&WXp@nVX[Um;BOmWhp•L`=\BKML`f€L`BACBp7LoK>Tb—(LN=\BOTl^`BAK;Afl‘7Whp\PLN=@BA±[@p\p@f€L`[\^ofbVfbpUm„=@fl^`m„LNT

^NB9flm™š

! #"$"&%')($(*,+.-!/#01,+32546$7,4298$%,6/#/2:6&;$8.(#<=%+#>&+8$?.(#>&0-$1$?@-!/.(%.AB%+!C7&D$E.(

~

© ‡ «`­ ‡ ® © ‡ˆ;ƒ*…†O‡ ˆ@‰b†… ª s†Oˆ ‚ [@KNBOK(LN=@B>—˜[\p@n”L`WXT5p@K j\^`T€{0Whm\BOmR0JLN=\B>VhTllWZnLNT&^`Bj;¯

^NB9KMBOp7L>R@WXp@m\B^oKš °\T5^B–\fbACj\VhBl0žBg=@f {lBLN=\Bg—˜T5VXVhT€žWhp\S^`Bj@^NB9KMBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p@K_—˜T5^>LN=\BGL`B^`A

λx.x

^_

D0LcJ7VhB iBj@^NB9KMBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p•Tl—

λx.x

p@TlACWXpUfbV "!#"$

m\B§^`[\Wacp %"!'&"$

ggŒ]XGD )("*,+-/.1023$

\<>=\B4("*,+¥nT5p@KcL`^N[Un”Lm;Bp@TbLNB9Kgf„—˜[@p@n”L`WXT5pxTl—¤LN=@BVXT5lWZnb™R\Whp@m;Whp\.fVXT5lWZnfbV({€fb^`WhflR\VhB5.L`=@f€L

^`flp\lB9KT€{lBO^„fbVhVQL`B^`AKš^ <>=\BŸRkBOfl[;LcJ Tl—gLN=\WZK•flj\j\^`T5f5no= WZKL`=@f€LfbVhj\=@f€¯œnT5p0{lB^oKNWXT5p fbpUm

KM[@R@KcL`WL`[;LNWhTlpŸTb— RUT5[\p@m‹p@flACBOKQfl^NB&=@flp@m;VhBOm.fl[;LNT5ACfbLNWZnflVXVhJ„R0J•LN=\BVhTl5Whn&flp@m‹p\BOBOm‹p\TlLeRUB

Afbp@fllBOm•B–;j\VhWZnWXLNVhJlš<>=@Bm;T€žp@KNWhm\BGTl—)ggŒ]XGDWhKLN=@fbLQWLeWZKp\TlLenT5APjUf€LNWhR\VhB&žWL`=‹LN=\B^NWZno=

VXT5lWZnK Tl—™lBp@B^ofbVX¯3j\[@^NjkT5KNB>j\^NT0Tl—™f5KNKNWZKcLofbp7L`K KN[@no=flK¡T0YPfbpUmC›cKNflRUBOVXVhB i gGŒGŽ.fbpUmPLN=\BO^NB—˜Tl^`B

nflp&Tlp\VhJRkB¤KN[\j\jkTl^NLNB9mgR7JgKNJ0KMLNBOAKKM[Uno=flK<žBVX— KACBL`fbLN=\BOTl^`Jl9ž=\WZno=fb^`B VXB9KNKB–;j\^`BOK`KMWh{lB5š

XQVZKMTU0WLVXB9flm\K¤LNTPKcLof€LNBOACBp7L`KTb—™L`=\BT5^NBOACK_LN=@fbL>fl^NBY5[@WL`BGm;WcsB^`Bp7L¤—˜^`TlA ž=@fbLžBež^`WL`BeWhp

Tl^om;Whp@fb^`JAf€LN=@BAf€L`WhnOKš

›œp Tl[\^PKMT5VX[;L`WXT5p$LNTŸLN=\B•]Œ]¤ŽACfl^N‘$no=@flVXVhBp@lBl*žB[@KNB•fŸ^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5p —˜Tl^PR\WXpUm;B^oKL`=@f€L

WZKPfŸnT5AR\Whp@fbLNWhTlp$Tb—eLN=\B•p\TlACWhp@fbV>fbj\j@^NT7flno=$žWXLN= m;B‹§^N[@Wacp’Whp@m;WZnB9Kš“<>=\WZKP^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5p“WhK

‘0p\T€žp‹flKLN=\Be¢MVXT;nOfbVhVXJpUfbACBVhBOK`Kœ£&fbj\j@^NT7flno=VF.]¤v5v\UdGT5^`vl;UF¥FŸubY²š_›²Le[@KNBOKem;B§^N[\Wacp‹WXpUm;WhnBOK

L`TCWhm;BOp7LNWX—˜J„RkTl[\p@m{€fb^`WZfbR\VhBOKO;fbp@mp@flAPB9KLNTCWZm;Bp7LNWX—˜J—˜^`BB&{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBOKOš*°\Tl^B–\fbACj\VhBl;žBG=Uf {lBGLN=\B

—˜T5VXVhT€žWhp\S^`Bj@^NB9KMBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p@KT_

D7LcJ0VhB iQBj\^`BOKNBp7L`fbLNWhTlp•Tb—

λx. y x

p\T5APWhp@flV 6,634798,8:)"!'<;"!=1$,$

m;B§^`[\Wacp 6,)798,8:)"!?>@A"!=&"$,$

VhT0nOfbVhVXJ„p@fbACBVhBOK`K 6,)798,8:)B,!C,CED"!F;3GH1*,+9D"!'&"$,$

ŽWX‘5Bm;BP§^`[\Wacp¥Whp@m;WZnBOKOULN=\BSVXT;nflVXVhJp@fbACBVhBOK`KQ^`Bj@^NB9KMBOp5Lof€L`WXT5p=UflKL`=\BP{lB^`J„p@WhnBj\^`TljkB^NLcJ„L`=@f€L

flVXj@=@f€¯²BOY7[\Wh{€fbVhBp7LQLNBO^NAKG=@f {5BSKNJ7p7Lofln”L`WhnOfbVhVXJBOY7[@flV*^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5p@KOšŽWh‘lBPp\T5APWhp@flV(flj\j\^`T5flno=@BOKO

L`=\B>VXT;nOfbVhVXJgp@flAPBOVXB9KNK(^`Bj\^`BOKNBp7Lof€LNWhTlpBp@flR\VXB9K([@KLNTG[@KMB—flAPWhVhWhfl^(pUfbACBOKLNTG^`B—˜B^(L`Te—˜^`BB{€fb^`WhflR\VXB9K

VhBOf5m;Whp\PLNTKcLof€L`BACBp7L`K>Tl—L`=\BT5^NBOAKLN=@fbLfl^NB&nVXT7KMBGLNTCT5^`m;Whp@fl^NJAf€L`=\BAfbLNWZnKOš

X n^`[@nWZfbV7Whp7{€fl^NWZfbp7LWhpL`=\BVXT;nflVXVhJgp@fbACBOVXB9KNK(fbj\j@^NT7flno=&WZKL`=@f€L*^NBOj\^`BOKNBp7L`fbLNWhTlp@KTb—\L`B^`ACKp\BO{lB^

nTlp7L`flWXp¥—˜^NBOBSm;BC§^N[\Wacp¥Whp@m;WZnB9Kš¡TlpUKMB9Y5[@Bp7LNVhJlsž=\BOpŸ^`BOn[@^`KNWXp@T€{lBO^f„m\BS§^N[@Wacp;¯œnVhT5KNBOm.LNB^`A

flp@m’BOp@nT5[\p7LNBO^NWhp\xfxR\Whp@m;BO^KM[@no= flK

Lambda(t)

^WLWZKPWXp@nTl^`^NB9n”LSLNT“^NB9n[\^oKNB„T€{lBO^

t

KMWhp@nBL`=\WhK L`B^`A nOfbp¥nTlp7L`flWXpAGH1*,+9D"!'&f5KefC—˜^`BBm\BS§^N[@Wacp.Whp@m;B–sš<>=\BnT5^N^`BOnLefbj\j@^NT7flno=‹WhKQLNT•WXp0{lBOp7L

f.—˜^NB9KM=’pUfbACBI LNT KcLofbp@m$—˜Tl^SLN=\B„—˜Tl^`ACflV¤j@fl^`flACBLNBO^Tl—LN=\BVhflARsm\f€¯œfbRUKcL`^`f5n”LNWhTlp“fbpUm$^NB9n[\^oKNB

T€{5B^

t[0 ← x]

_L`=@f€LWZKLN=\BL`B^`A TlR;LofbWhp\BOm R0J KM[@R@KcL`WL`[;LNWhp\“L`=\B—˜^NBOB{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBB9!C,C"D1!'

—˜T5^fbVhV_T;nn[\^`^NBOp@nB9KgTb—LN=\BRkTl[@p@m“{€fb^`WhflR\VXBJGH1*,+"D"!'&Whp

t

^š \3D0BB•KMB9n”LNWhTlp’|\š|\š1 —˜Tl^Sm;BLofbWhVXB9m B–;j\Vhflp@f€L`WXT5p@KOš^ <>=\WZKgKcLcJ0VhBSTl—m;BdUp\WL`WXT5pŸWZK&KMVhWhl=7LNVhJ‹[\p\p@fbLN[\^ofbV f€L%d@^oKcL9™R\[;L&WZK^`BOf5KMT5p@fbR@VXJBOf5KMJ

L`T.lBL[@KMB9mxLNT@š•›œp$j@fb^NLNWZn[@Vhfl^O™L`=\WZKKN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`WXT5p$R7J f—˜^NB9KM=“p@flACBACfbLNBO^NWZfbVhW[OBOKGL`=\BKMTl¯²nOfbVhVXB9m

¢N§>fb^`Bp@m\^NBObLnTlp0{lBOp7LNWhTlp0£e—˜T5^p\TlACWhp@fbVsL`B^`AKš

t

QSR

!„

<>=@B^`BAfbWhp@m;BO^*Tb—\L`=\WhK*^`BjkTl^NL*WhK*fGnTlACj\VhBL`BKMLNBOj;¯²R7J7¯œKcL`BjSj\^NB9KMBOp7L`f€L`WXT5pTb—kTl[\^¤¡T;Y&m;BO{lBVhTlj@APBOp7L

WhpVhWL`B^of€LNBj@^NT5l^ofbACACWXp\&KMLcJ0VXB5š XeVXVkm;Bd@p@WL`WXT5p@K5LN=@BTl^`BAK_flp@mCWhp5L`B^`ACBOm;WZf€L`BVXBOAPAf5K¤fb^`BQKN=\T€žp

Whp ¡T;Y“KMJ0p7L`fb–s(Whp5L`B^oKMjkB^oKNBOm žWL`=’B–;j\VZfbpUf€LNWhTlpUKš  B„TlACWXLL`=\B„j\^`T0Tb—KNn^NWhj;LoK&—˜Tl^PfbVhV¤VhBACAflK

R@[;LgKN=\T€ž LN=@BA —˜Tl^LN=@BSAfbWhp¥L`=\BT5^NBOAKsKMT„LN=@fbLL`=\BP^NB9flm;BO^nflp¥lBLGf—˜BBVhWhp\•Tl— LN=\BCKNW[OBSfbpUm

nTlACj\VhB–;WXLcJŸTb—>L`=\B„j\^`T0Tb—KNn^NWhj;LoKš.<>=\B—˜[@VXVQ¡T;Yxm;BO{lBOVXT5j\ACBp7LO(WXpUnVh[@m;Whp\ŸK`n^`WXj;LoK(WZKf {€fbWhVhflR\VhB

T5p\VhWXp\BVŽBO^`u0}TY3š

¡=@fbj\LNB^|•m;BdUp\BOKGL`=\BKMJ0p7L`fb–‹Tl—

F <:

LcJ0jkBSB–0j@^NB9KNKNWXT5p@KGfbp@m¥LN=\BKN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\•^`BVZf€L`WXT5pŸRkB¯

LcžBOBp.LcJ0jkBOKO™fbp@m.j@^NT€{5BOKL`=\^`BB‘5BJj\^`TljkB^NLNWhBOKQTl—_LN=@WhK^NBOVhfbLNWhTlp _>^`B@B–;WX{0WXLcJlkLN^ofbp@KNWXLNWh{7WXLcJl

fbp@mKML`fbR@WXVhWLcJ„R7J•KM[\RUKcL`WL`[;LNWhTlpš ›²LQnTl^`^NB9KMjkTlp@m@K_L`TPjUfb^NLZX fbp@mf—˜^ofb5ACBp7LTb—jUfb^NL|`X Tl—

LN=\B&]>Œ]¤ŽAfb^`‘„no=@flVXVhBp@lBlš

¡=@fbj\LNB^ 1 m\Bd@p\B9K_L`=\BKNJ0p7L`f€–Tl—™LNB^`AK5LN=@BeLcJ0jkBKNJ0KMLNBOA‹7flp@mCLN=@BGm;J0p@flACWhnKMBOACflp7LNWZnK_Tl—

F <:

še›²Lj@^NT€{5BOKL`=\BSKNTl[@p@m;p\B9KNKeTb— LN=@BLcJ0jkBSKNJ0KMLNBOA žWL`=¥^NB9KMjkBOnLeL`TLN=@BSKNBAfbp7LNWZnKOš<>=@WhK

nT5^N^`BOKNjUT5p@m\KLNTPL`=\B&^NBOAfbWhp@m;B^Tl—j@fl^MLe|`X Tb—L`=\Bno=@flVXVhBp\5Blš

¡=@fbj\LNB^G„KN=\T€žQKQ=@T€ž B–;BOn[\LNWhTlp@KeTb—

F <:

j\^NT5l^ofbAKQnOfbp.RkBSjkB^N—˜Tl^`ACBOmA\—˜T5^eL`BOKMLNWhp\j\[@^M¯

jUT7KMB9Kj^>RUTlLN= žWXLN=\Whp ¡T;Y flp@m LN=\^`Tl[\5=’¢cB–7L`^`f5n”L`WXT5p0£ \fl[;LNT5Af€LNWZn‹lBOp\B^of€L`WXT5p ^PTb—¡fbACV

nT;m;Bg—˜T5^QfS^`B—˜BO^NBOp@nB

F <:

Whp7LNB^`j\^`BL`B^9š*<>=@WhKWZK>j@fl^ML

1

Tb—(LN=\Bno=UfbVhVXBOp\lB5š

¡=@fbj\LNB^(~>nTlpUnVh[@m;BOK™LN=\WZK^`BjkTl^NL™R7JGfbp&Whp;—˜Tl^`AfbVbf5KNKNBOK`KMACBOp5L™Tl—7L`=\B¤Y7[@flVXWXLcJQTb—;T5[\^KMT5VX[\LNWhTlp

fbp@m•ACTl^`B5Bp\BO^`flVXVhJCTb—LN=\Bg[@K`fbR\WhVhWLcJTl—LN=@B¢MVhT0nOfbVhVXJpUfbACBVhBOK`Kœ£gfbj\j\^`T5f5no=„fbpUmTb—LN=\B¡T;Y

j\^`T7Tl—(f5KNKNWhKML`flp7L—˜T5^]Œ]¤ŽACfl^N‘7¯œKcLcJ0VhBj@^NT5R\VXBOAKš

}

2 3547698;:=<

F D M&B M K I B M @

<>=@WhK&no=@flj;LNBO^&nTl^`^`BOKNjUT5p@m\KeLNT.j@fl^ML X Tb—LN=\B]>Œ]¤ŽAfb^`‘Ÿno=@flVXVhBp@lBl™pUfbACBVhJ.LN=@BS—˜T5^NAflV_m;B—¯

Whp\WXLNWhTlp“Tb—f‹KM[@R;LcJ0j\WXp@^`BVZf€L`WXT5pxRkBLcžBBOp LcJ7jkBOKTb—

F <:

fbp@mŸLN=@Bj\^`T7Tl—Tl—R@f5KMWZnPLcJ0jUB¯L`=\BT5^NBLNWZn

j@^NT5jUBO^ML`WXB9KTl—L`=\WZK^NBOVhfbLNWhTlpš

 B&KcLofb^NLR0J¢cWhACjUT5^ML`WXp@€£QLN=@^NBOBeACT;m;[\VhBOK—˜^NT5A LN=\B¡T;YCVXWhR\^ofb^`JSTl—KML`fbpUm\fb^omm;BTd@p\WXLNWhTlp@K>fbpUm

L`=\BT5^NBOAKT_ *r! \fl^NWXLN=@APBLNWZnPT€{lB^p@f€L`[\^ofbV*p0[\ARkB^oKj^ *r! \fb^`WXLN=\ACBL`WhnST€{lBO^Whp7LNBOlB^oK^QfbpUm

'fr \˜TljkB^of€L`WXT5p@K>T€{lBO^Od@p\WXLNBSVXWZKcLoKj^š xBflVhKNTWhAPjkTl^NLefACT;m;[\VhB `*, *j*r L`=@f€LžBm;BO{lBOVXT5jUB9m

KNjkBOnWZfbVhVhJl7ž=\Whno=„j\^NT€{0WZm;BOK¤flm\m;WXLNWhTlpUfbVkVXBOAPAf5K¤fbRkTl[\LVhWhKMLACBOARkB^oKM=\Whjš*<>=\WZK¤ACT;m;[\VhBWZKTlACWLNLNB9m

WhpLN=\WZK>^`BjkTl^NLO;R\[;Lef {€flWXVZfbR\VhB&flK>j@fl^MLTl—LN=@B xBOR{5B^oKMWhTlp•Tb—(LN=\WZKQm;BO{lBOVXT5j\ACBp7L%VŽBO^`u0}Y²š

! #"%$'&() *r! š

! #"%$'&()

*r!

š

! #"%$'&() ')r

š

! #"%$'&()

`*, *j*r

š

RTQ *

,+ .- ±%/ •

 B>[@KNBp@fbACBOK \fbVZKMTgnflVXVhBOmPf€L`TlAK^L`Tg^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7L—˜^`BB>{€fb^`WhflR\VhBOK(WXpPL`B^`ACKOš)XQp0JWhpd@p\WXLNB>LcJ0jkBžWXLN=

m\BOnWZm\flR\VXB&B9Y7[@fbVhWLcJ•žWXVhVm;TUš›œp‹j\^`BjUfb^of€LNWhTlp•—˜Tl^QLN=\BKNBOnTlp@mj@fl^MLQTl—L`=\Bno=@flVXVhBp@lBl;žBfbLML`f5no=f

‘0Whp@mSLNTgB{5B^`Jp@flAPB0_BOWL`=\B^¢cLcJ0jUB£T5^¢œL`B^`A£”lflp@mBOp@KN[\^NB>L`=@f€L L`=\B^`Bfb^`B>WXpdUp\WL`BVhJAfbp0JpUfbACBOK

Tl—B9flno=‘7Whp@m™š¡T5p@n^`BL`BVhJl;žBg^NBOj\^NB9KMBOp7Lp@flACBOK>R0J„j@flWX^oKTb— fP‘7Whp@m‹fbpUm•flp•Whp7LNB5B^ \˜LcJ7jkB10 ^š

#243456)78 +

_9 T

_;:

<>=@? #>A

_ +

<>=

ACBED _ + š

FHGI2')&J2 _9 _K: \ +

×

^{]^ML " š}

FHGI2')&J2 + \ _ ^%_ + _K:ON r% š

w

Y5[UfbVhWLcJRkBLcžBBOp‹p@fbACBOK>WZKm;B9nWZm\fbR\VhBlš

4"%"

_

∀

^\

_

^”

:

6=

^š

F¥Tl^`BT€{lBO^O7žBG=Uf {lBLN=\Bg—˜T5VXVhT€žWXp@PT5R0{7WhTl[UKKNWhAPj@VXWdUnfbLNWhTlp^N[@VXB9K>Tlp•LNBOKML`KQT€{lB^>p@flACBGB9Y7[@fbVhWLcJ5š

4"%"

*rp

_

∀

^{\ _I9}

T

^\

_

^\

_ ^” \ N

A ! "T=TT

Z^ : š

4"%"

N

T

_

∀

^{\ _I9 T^\ A _ ^\ `_ ^}

6=

→

^{\ N p Z^ : š}

<>=@B&—˜TlVhVXT€žWhp\VhBACAfKN=\T€žQK>LN=Uf€LQL`=\B^`BfbVhž>f J0K>B–;WhKML`Kfp@fbACBTl—*LN=\B5WX{5Bp.‘0Whp@mLN=@fbLeWZK—˜^`BOKN=

ž&š^9šL9š*LN=\B&5WX{5Bp„VhWZKcLQTl—(p@flACBOKO0LN=@fbLQWhKO\m;WZKcL`WXp@nL—˜^NT5A±fbVhV™L`=\B&p@fbACB9K>WXpLN=@WhK>VhWhKMLOš

FHGI2')&J2 N *jr, \+ _ + ^\ _ r ^%_ _K:

\+  N *re. / \#N \ _ ^

⇒

^{H \r ^ ^u ^ML š}

4"%" N *jr, N *jr, _

∀

^{+ T _;: N *,r, +}

¬

∧

^{+ : + š}

4"%" N

*,r,

_

∀

^\

+ _ +

^ \ _

r%

^”

∃



¬

∧

+ : + š

XK_fb^`l[@BOmSR7J]_WLNL`Kfbp@mPTbL`=\B^oKOlKMž>fbjUK \˜jkB^`A[;Lof€LNWhTlpUK Tb—ULcžT&p@flACBOK^fl^NBflpPWhp7LNBO^NB9KcL`WXp\&KNjUB9nWZfbV

nOflKNBTb—Q^`Bp@flACWXp\7Kš BžWhVXV[@KNB•KNžflj@K&VZf€L`B^L`T¥j\^`T€{lBCL`=@f€LPTl[\^Pm;Bd@p@WL`WXT5p@KSfl^NBB9Y7[\WX{€fl^NWZfbp7LO

L`=@f€LQWZKO;WXp@KNBpUKMWXLNWh{lBGLNTCL`=\Bno=\T5WhnBOKTb—(—˜^NB9KM=WZm;Bp7LNWd@BO^`KOš

FHGI2')&J2 &&

\ _

^%_

_;:

N

A ! "T N

W! "T AT š

<>=@B*—˜TlVhVXT€žWhp\>VXBOACACf5Kfb^`B_KML`fbpUm\fb^omej@^NT5jUBO^ML`WXB9KsTb—\KMž>fbjUKT_™KNBVX—¯3Whp0{lB^oKNBlWhp€acBOnLNWh{lB59‘0Whp@m0¯²j\^`BOKNB^`{7Whp\Uš

4"%" && N _

∀

^{ & : š}

4"%" && ! "T* _

∀

^

6=

→

6=

→

^{&A : š}

4"%" && _

∀

^{A  &= :} &&= W

→

^{: š}

4"%" && + _

∀

^{ + : +}

→

^{+ \}&&= ^: + š

R U

 ±,+k ‹+ ”%(S

"! #%$&(')'+* &,-'././02143.

<>=@BKNJ0p5Lof€–’Tl—QLcJ0jUB‹B–;j\^`BOK`KNWXT5p@KWZKCKcLofbp@m@fb^om™_B–\nBj;LPLN=@fbLžB=@f {lB„LcžT ^`Bj\^`BOKNBp7L`fbLNWhTlp@K—˜Tl^

{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBOK_

=

" *, ^NBOj\^`BOKNBp7L`K—˜^NBOB¤LcJ0jkB{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBOKO Whm\Bp7LNWd@BOmR0Jfep@flACBl€ž=\WhVXB

= * ^`Bj\^`BOKNBp7L`K

v

RkTl[@p@mCLcJ0jUBG{€fb^`WhflR\VhBOKOlWZm;Bp7LNWd@B9mR0JPLN=\BOWX^>m;Bg§^`[\WacpWhp@m;WZnBOKOš¤Œ[\^>m;B§^`[\Wacp„WXp@m\WhnBOKKcLofb^NLf€L>u\š

›œp.f

*,

LcJ0jUB5;LN=\B&{€fl^NWZfbR\VhB

= *

uPWhK>RkTl[@p@mR7J„LN=\B

*,

WXpLcJ0jUB š

#243456)78 p _9 T _K:

<>=

" *, _

→

^p

<>=

* _

→

^p

<>=

_ p

< *r*, _ p

→

"

→

p

< *,

_ p

→

p

→

"

š

<>=@Be—˜^`BBp@fbACBOKTl—f&LcJ0jkBGfl^NBGm;Bd@p@BOmflK¤—˜TlVhVXT€ž&šQTlLNWZnBLN=\B *, nf5KMB0_ *, m;T0B9Kp@TbLR@WXp@m

flp0Jp@fbACB5š

$'& 2 ) N " \ _ p ^%_ e _K:

j f!

<>= " *,

⇒

__

<>= *;

⇒

p

<>=

⇒

< *r*,

⇒

^{N " ( N "}

< *,

⇒

^{N p ( N p}

T

š

<>=@B^`Bfl^NB„LcžT“KM[@R@KcL`WL`[;LNWhTlp TljkB^of€L`WXT5p@KPT€{lBO^LcJ0jUB9Kž^NWXLML`Bp

Tr r

fbpUm

r r

Whp ]*TlVhVZflno‘ K

LofbVh‘sš

Tr

KN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`BOKefSLcJ0jkBg—˜Tl^QfCRkTl[\p@m{€fb^`WZfbR\VhB\fCm;B§^N[@Wacp‹Whp@m;B–p^š

r

KN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`BOK

fSLcJ0jkBg—˜Tl^QfS—˜^NBOBg{ fl^NWZfbR@VXB\fPp@flACBZ^”š

<>=\Bgn^`[@nWhflV@TlRUKMBO^N{€f€L`WXT5pWhKL`=@f€L{ fl^NWZfbR@VXBGnfbj\LN[\^`BnOfbp\p\TlL¤T;nn[\^m\[\^NWhp\SBWXLN=\BO^KN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`WXT5p _

<¤J0jkBOKGp\BO{lB^GnT5p5LofbWhp.—˜^`BBCm;BS§^`[\WacpxWXpUm;WhnBOKO™KMWhp@nBSLN=@BOKNBWhp@m;WZnBOKgfl^NBS[@KMB9m.Tlp@VXJ‹—˜T5^^`Bj;¯

^NB9KMBOp7LNWhp\¥RkTl[\p@m’{ fl^NWZfbR@VXB9Kš.<>=\BO^NB—˜Tl^`Bl

Tr

m\T7B9Kp\TlLp\BOBOm“L`T¥jUBO^M—˜T5^NA VhW—L`WXp\xTb—em;B

§^N[\Wacp‹WXpUm;WhnBOK>WhpLN=\BKN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`BOmLcJ0jkBlš

<¤J0jkBOKPp\BO{lB^CR\Whp@m p@fbACB9K_T5p\VhJ m;B‹§^`[\Wacp Whp@m;WZnB9Kš <>=\B^`B—˜T5^NB5

r

p\B{5B^Cp\BOBOm\KSLNT

jUBO^M—˜T5^NA±^NBOp@fbACWhp\CTb—pUfbACBOK>WhpLN=\BKN[\R@KMLNWXLN[;L`BOmL`B^`A!ž=\Bp.m;B9KNnBp@m\WXp\CRkBVhT€ž fPR\Whp@m;BO^Oš

$'& 2 ) Tr r p \ _ p ^\ _ ^\B `_ p ^ r*rp _ " _K:

j A f

<>=

" *,

⇒

=

p*,

<>=

*;

⇒

j j p*j f

<

⇒

= *

< Tp

⇒

< .`*,*

⇒

= *

\ *,& ^

T

<>=

⇒

⁼

< *r*, =

⇒

^{*r*, \ r "; ^\ Tr p Z^}

9u

<

*,

⇒

^{*, \ Tr p Z^ \r r p \9 ^ ^}

T

š

$'& 2 ) r p

\ _ p

^ \ _

^ \B `_

"

^

*rpT%-

_ p _K:

j A f

<>= " *,

⇒

N

p = " *,

<>= *;

⇒

= *-

<>=

⇒

⁼

< *r*, =

⇒

^{*r*, \ r r p Z^\ r r "- Z^}

< *,

⇒

^{*, \ r r p Z^\ r "; ^}

T š

›œp¥LN=\BP^NBOAfbWhp@m;B^Tb— L`=\BSm;BO{lBOVXT5j\ACBp7LO r WhKTlp@VXJ‹[@KNBOm‹L`T„^`Bj\VZflnBRkTl[\p@mŸ{€fb^`WhflR\VXBSuR0J‹f

—˜^`BOKN=U—˜^NBOB{€fb^`WhflR\VhB\f„p@fbACBZ^ž=\Bp.Lofb‘0Whp\„fbjUfb^NLf *, LcJ0jUB5še<>=\WZKeT5jUBO^`fbLNWhTlp.WZKeKNWXACWhVhfl^QLNT

L`=\B¢œ—˜^`BOKN=\BOp\WXp@€£ST5jUBO^`fbLNWhTlpŸ[UKMB9mxWhp“°\^`BOKN= F¥Ž flp@m ^NBOVhfbLNBOmxKMJ;KMLNBOACKOš xBnOfbVhV WL@N *,, "T "

—˜T5^QnVZfb^`WLcJ5š

FHGI2')&J2 N *,r, p p \ _ " ^\ _ ^%_ p _K: r r "; u \ =

p*, ^š

°@^NBOBg{ fl^NWZfbR@VXB9Kflp@m•—˜^NB9KM=@Bp\Whp\Cj\VZf JžBOVXV™L`Tl5BLN=@B^9š

4"%" N " r r p

_

∀

^{ \N p ^}

→

^{\N p \ r "; Z^ ^”š}

4"%" N "

N

*jr, "T "

_

∀

^{ \#N "; ^}

→

^{\#N " \N *,, "T ";W ^,^”š}

 Bep@T€ž m;BTd@p\BGKMž>fbj@K \˜jkB^`A[;Lof€LNWhTlp„Tb—™p@fbACB9Kj^*T€{5B^ LcJ0jkBOKfbp@mKN=\T€ž R@flKNWZnj\^`TljkB^NLNWhBOK_Tl—KMž>fbj@K

L`=@f€LQžWhVhV™RUB&[@KNB—˜[@VVhfbLNBO^Oš

$'& 2 ) & " \ _ ^ \ _ " ^ r*rpT _ " _;:

j f!

<>=

" *,

⇒

=

p*, \ &= ^

<>=

*;

⇒

=

*-

<>=

⇒

=

<

*r*,

⇒

^{*r*, \& p W ^\&& " W ^}

<

*,

⇒

^{*, \ & " W ^\& p W ^}

T

š

D;žflj@Kfb^`BWhp0{lT5VX[;L`WXT5p@K\KNBVX—¯3Whp0{lBO^`KNBZ^š

4"%"

&& "

_

∀

^{W && " \&& " W^: š}

D;žflj@K>Tb—({ fl^NWZfbR@VXB9K¤L`=@f€Lem\TPp@TbLQT;nn[\^>—˜^NBOBgWXp.fSLcJ0jUB&VhBOf {5BeL`=\BgLcJ0jUB&[\pUno=@fbp\5BOm™š

4"%" && " N *, _

∀

^W

¬

^{\#N " ^}

→ ¬

^{\#N " ^}

→

^{& p W : š}

D;žflj@KnT5APAS[;LNBgžWXLN= r KN[\R@KMLNWXLN[\LNWhTlp.fbp@m„—˜^`BOKN=\Bp\Whp\Uš

4"%" Tr p & _

∀

W



& p \

Tr r p-

^:

r p

\

&& " W

^ \

&& "

Z^”š

4"%" N

*,r, p p &

_

∀



& p

\N

*,, "T "; ^ :ON

*,, "T p

\

& "

^ \

&=

^”š

D;žflj@KnT5APAS[;LNBgžWXLN=LN=@BnTlACj\[\L`f€L`WXT5p•Tl——˜^`BBg{€fb^`WZfbR\VhBOKOš

4"%" N " && _

∀

^{A  \N p ^}

↔

^\ &&= ^ \#N " \&& p W^,^”š

#%$&0"3 '3 0",-143 '3-.

<J0j\Whp\„BOp7{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7L`Kfb^`BSKML`flp@m\fb^om _VhWhKML`KGTl— \˜p@flAPB5sLcJ0jUB ^Qj@flWX^oKOšG§Whp@m;Whp\5Kgfb^`Bf5m\m;BOm¥LNT•LN=\B

VhB—LQTl—L`=\B&Bp0{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7L[UKMWhp\PLN=\B " VXWZKML>T5jUBO^`fbLNWhTlpš <>=0[@KO;VhfbLNBO^R\WXpUm;WXp@5KQnTlACB%d@^`KMLOš

FHGI2')&J2 p _;: r \

×

^{" ^š}

FHGI2')&J2 ` \ _ "T ^%_;: & \ N r% p ^ š

4"%" ` "T _

∀

^{ ` \ ( ^@: 0 ( ` š}

<>=@B Z+ —˜[@p@n”L`WXT5p^`BL`[\^`p@KLN=\BgLcJ0jkBflK`KMT;nWhfbLNBOm„žWL`=.fSpUfbACB&WXp‹fPLcJ0j\Whp\CBp0{0WX^`Tlp\ACBOp5L9š

$'& 2 ) Z+ \ _ ^\ _ p ^ *rpT% _ =p _K:

j A f

< p

⇒

< \  ^ __

⇒

^{N ! "T 9 T Z+}

T

š

4"%" Z+ _

∀

^{ Z+ : 9}

→

^{\ ` ^”š}

4"%" Z+ M0r _

∀

^{=  \ 0 ^}

→ ∃

^{ Z+= : 9 š}

 B&B–0L`Bp@mKMž>fbjUKLNTPLcJ0j\WXp@Bp0{0WX^`Tlp\ACBOp5LoK0jkTlWhp7LcžWhKNBlš

$'& 2 ) & T \ _ ^\ _ p ^ r*rp _ p _;:

j A f

<

p

⇒

< \  ^ __

⇒

^{\&=  & p W ^%__ &&}

T š

¤p7{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7LVXT0T5‘7[@jnTlACA[;L`BOK>žWXLN=.KNžflj@Kš

4"%" Z+ &&

_

∀

^{ Z+ : 9}

→

Z+

\

&&=

^\

&& TW

^ : 9 \

& p W

^š

|

<>=@B 0 TljkB^of€L`WXT5pnTlACA[;L`BOK>žWXLN=.KNžflj@Kš

4"%"

` &

_

∀

^{ \ ` ^}

↔

^{\ &= ^\0 \& TW ^ ^š}

' 14, '3'./. 1 $&('. 3 '3 02,-1 3 '3-.

X LcJ0jkBgWhKžBVhVX¯—˜T5^NACBOm„WXp.fSLcJ0j\Whp\Bp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7LWX—_

fbVhVp@flAPB9K—˜^NBOBgWXpLN=@BgLcJ7jkBfb^`BGTb—*‘7Whp@m

=@?

#>A b

fbVhVp@flAPB9K—˜^NBOBgWXpLN=@BgLcJ7jkBfb^`BGRUT5[\p@mWXpL`=\B&Bp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7Lb

WLem\T7B9Kp\TlLnTlp7L`flWXp•—˜^`BB&m;B§^N[@Wacp‹{€fb^`WhflR\VhBOKOš

 Bnflj;LN[\^`BGLN=\B9KMBnTlp@m\WL`WXT5p@K>R0JLN=\Bg—˜T5VXVhT€žWhp\SWhp;—˜BO^NBOp@nB&^`[\VhBOKOš

#243456)78 N

p

_

p

→

p

→

#O*,

_K:

< N p p*j

_

∀



+ : = ? #>A

→

\

0 ^

→

N

";

\ = p*, ^

< N p

_

∀

^

N "; =

< N p *r*, _

∀

^

N ";

→

^{N p;}

→

^{N "; \ *r*, L ^}

< N p N *,_

∀

^{A }

N ";

→

\

∀

^

+ : = ?

#>A

→ ¬

^{\N p ^}

→ ¬

^{\ ` ^}

→

N p \,\  ^%__ ^ \N *jr, "T " ^,^

→

N

";

\

*j

^”š

<>=@BS^`[\VhBOKgfb^`BSKMLN^ofbWhl=7LM—˜T5^Nž>fb^om™UB–\nBOj;LGjkB^`=@flj@KLN=\B

N p

N

*,

^N[\VhBlš›²L—˜T5VXVhT€žQKgflBOp\B^ofbV

jUf€LML`B^`p—˜Tl^QT5jUBO^`fbLNWhp\CT€{lB^KN[\R;¯3LNBO^NAKTl—*fCR\Whp@m;BO^OUKM[@no=.f5K

WXp

*, O

š<>=\Bm;B§^`[\Wacp

{€fl^NWZfbR\VhB

= *

u¥WZKSjUTlLNBp7L`WhflVXVhJ —˜^NBOB„Whp

š“<T¥^`BOnT€{lBO^f¥žBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm L`B^`A žWXLN=@Tl[;LP—˜^NBOB•m;B

§^`[\WacpŸ{€fb^`WhflR\VhBOKOkžBCKM[\RUKcL`WL`[;LNB

= * u•žWL`= f„—˜^NB9KM=xp@fbACB š<>=\B^`B—˜T5^NB5kLN=\BPj\^`BACWhKNBS—˜Tl^

flj\j\VhWXB9KLNT N *,, "T p š

geT€ž“KN=\T5[\Vhm RUBno=\T5KNBpXeK™WhpgLN=@B¤p@flAPB¯3RUflKNBOmGKMjkBOnWedUnOf€L`WXT5p A[UKcLp\TlLRkB_WXpgL`=\B¤m;T5AfbWhp

Tl— kTbL`=\B^`žWhKNBgLN=@BB–0L`Bp@m;B9m‹Bp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7LS\  ^__ žT5[\VZm‹RUBSWXVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm™š>›œp¥f5m\m;WXLNWhTlpULN=\B

pUfbACB A[UKcL>p\TbLRUB—˜^`BBeWhp 0TlLN=\BO^NžWZKMBeLN=\B—˜^`BOKN=\Bp\Whp\@N *jr, "T " žT5[\VhmWXp@nTl^`^NB9n”L`VXJ

WZm;BOp5L`W—˜J„LN=\BgRkTl[\pUm™\[\p\Wh{lBO^`K`fbVhVhJ5¯œY7[@fbp7L`Wed@B9m{€fb^`WhflR\VhBTl—L`=\B *,

LcJ0jUB9K>žWL`=‹flp•B–;WhKMLNWhp\@0—˜^`BB

LcJ0jkB&{€fb^`WhflR\VXB5š

geT€žqKM=\T5[\VZm

RUBCY7[@fbp7L`Wed@B9m <>=@fbLWZK™KN=\Tl[\VZm.L`=\BCKMB9nTlpUm‹j\^NBOACWhKNB N

"

\,\



^S__

^

\#N

*, p p ^^ =@TlVZmC—˜Tl^Tlp\BQjUfb^NLNWZn[\VZfb^p@fbACB

p\TlL¤WXp

`

\

^\Tl^¤—˜Tl^fbVhV@p@flAPB9K

p\TlLWhp

0 \ ^ <>=\BG¢c—˜Tl^GfbVhV£SflVL`B^`p@f€L`WX{5B&TlR0{0WXT5[@KNVXJVXB9flm\KQLNTf„KMLN^`Tlp\5B^QWhp@m;[@nLNWhTlpxj\^NWhp@nWXj\VhB`_j@^NT0Tb—K

L`=@f€Lj\^`T0nBB9mR0JPWhp0{lBO^`KNWXT5pTl^WXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5p„T€{lBO^flp=0J7jkTbL`=\BOKNWZK

N p

\

*j&

^¤nOfbpL`=\Bp

no=@T7T7KMBfbp0JnT5p0{lBp@WXBOp5L

—˜^`BOKN=—˜T5^

LNTGB–;j\VhTlWXL*LN=\BKNBOnT5p@mSj\^NBOACWhKNBl€^of€L`=\B^(LN=UfbpP=@f {0WXp\eLNT&nT5jUB

žWXLN=‹f d\–;BOm™;B9fb^`VXWhB^no=\T5WhnBTl—

š_D0J0ACAPBLN^`WhnOfbVhVXJ50LN=\BQ¢c—˜Tl^>Tlp@B”£GflVL`B^`p@f€L`WX{5BWZK>ACTl^`BGnTlp0{lBOp\WXBOp7L

—˜T5^&j\^`T7Tl—KgLN=Uf€LA[UKcLnTlp@nVX[@m\B N

p \

*, %

^r_WXLKN[anBOK&LNT.B–;=\WhR\WXLTlp\BKN[\WXL`flR\VXB

—˜^NB9KM=$Whp

LN=@fbLSK`f€LNWZK d@BOKLN=\B„KNBOnTlp@m j\^`BACWZKMB5*^`fbLN=\BO^&LN=@flp$=@f {0WXp@‹LNT¥B9KcLofbR\VhWhKN= LN=\BKMB9nT5p@m

j@^NBOAPWZKNB—˜T5^QfbVhVKM[Uno=

š

<>=\Bgn^`[@nWhflVUT5R@KMBO^N{€fbLNWhTlpWZK¤L`=@f€LLN=@T5KNBQLcžTSfbVXLNBO^NpUf€LNWh{lBGfb^`BQBOY7[\Wh{€fbVhBp7L_(L`=\BGK`fbACBGKM[\R\LcJ7j@WXp\

ac[Um;lBOAPBOp7L`Knflp•RkBm;BO^NWh{lB9m„žWXLN=LN=@Be¢œ—˜T5^QfbVhV£g^N[\VhB&fbp@m„LN=@Be¢œ—˜T5^Tlp\B£G^`[\VXB5š \D0BOB&](T5VXVZflno‘ KL`fbVh‘

—˜T5^ ACTl^`BB–;j\Vhflp@f€L`WXT5p@KOš^<>=\B^`B—˜T5^NB5bWXpPL`=\BQm;BdUp\WL`WXT5pTb—kLN=\B N " j\^`BOm;WZnfbLNBQfbRkT€{lB5€žBQno=@T5KNB

L`=\B&¢œ—˜T5^gflVXV£^`[\VXB5KMT‹flKeLNTlBLL`=\BKcL`^NT5p\lB9KcLWXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5pxj\^`Whp@nWhj\VhBlšSXep@m¥žBSžWhVhV_KM=\T€žqKN=\T5^ML`VXJ

L`=@f€L(LN=@B ¢c—˜Tl^(Tlp@B”£¤^`[\VXBWZK(f5m;ACWhK`KNWXR\VhB>fbp@mSnfbpSRUB[@KNBOmWXpPj\^`T7Tl—KL`=@f€L nT5p@nVh[@m;B N p \ *,

^š

Xep’Bp0{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7LWZKžBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm“WX—QB{5B^`JŸLcJ0jkB„WXLCnTlp7L`flWXp@KWhKSžBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm“Whp$LN=\B•j@fb^NLSTl—LN=\B

BOp0{7Wh^`Tlp\ACBp7LQL`=@f€LGT;nn[@^`KeLNT•WLoKe^`WX5=7LOsWšBlšLN=@BBp0{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7Lf€LLN=\BSLNWhACBL`=\WZKQLcJ0jkBSž>flKeWXp7LN^`Tb¯

m\[@nB9m™š<>=\WZKBOp@KN[\^NB9KeWhp j@fb^NLNWZn[\VZfb^eLN=@fbLfbVhVL`=\BC{ fl^NWZfbR@VXB9KeWhp¥L`=\WhKLcJ0jkBCfl^NBSRUT5[\p@mŸBOfb^`VhWXBO^ \WšBlš

L`TLN=@B^`WX5=5Lr^>Whp.LN=\BSBp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7LOšQF.T5^NBOT€{lB^9;žBWXACjkT5KNB&LN=Uf€Lp@Tp@fbACBSWhKeRUT5[\p@m‹LcžWZnBWhpŸflp

BOp0{7Wh^`Tlp\ACBp7L9š

#243456)78 N T _ pT

→

^{# *,& _K:}

< N _

N T p

< N

p

_

∀



N

T

→ ¬

\

0 ^

→

N p

→

N T

\ \  ^ __

^”š

4"%" N p * _

∀

^{ N p}

→ ∀

^{ T \ ` ^\` ^}

→

^{N p š}

X LcJ0jkBgžBOVXV™—˜T5^NACB9m„Whp =@f5KfbVhV™WLoK>—˜^NBOBgp@fbACBOK>WhpLN=\Bm\TlAfbWhp•Tl— š

4"%" N N p

_

∀

^{ N p;}

→

^{\#N " ^}

→

^{\ ` ^š}

ŽT0Tl‘0WXp@S[\jL`=\BgLcJ0jUB&Tl—(fPp@fbACB&Whp.fSžBVhVX¯—˜T5^NACBOm„Bp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7L>^`BL`[\^`p@KfPžBOVXVX¯—˜T5^NACB9mLcJ0jUB5š

4"%" N p Z+ _

∀

^{ N}

→ ∀

^{A  Z+ : 9}

→

^{N "; š}

<J0jUBgžBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm;p@BOK`KWZKQKML`flR\VXBgR0J„KNžflj\j\Whp\@š

4"%" N p & _

∀

^

+ : +

→

^{N p}

→

^{N " \ & TW ^ \ && p W ^š}

¤p7{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7LžBOVXVX¯3—˜Tl^`APB9m;p\B9KNKWZKKcLofbR\VhB&R0J„KMž>fbj@j\WXp@@š

4"%" N

T &&

_

∀

^{ + : +}

→

^N

→

^{N \ & W ^”š}

O

<>=@Bgm\TlAfbWhp‹Tb—(flp•BOp0{7Wh^`Tlp\ACBp7LWZK>WXp0{€fb^`Whflp7L>R0J„KNž>fbj@KTb—*p@flAPB9KLN=@fbLefb^`Bp@TbLQWhp•L`=\WZKQm;TlAflWXpš

4"%"

&& T 0

_

∀



¬

\

` ^

→ ¬

\

` ^

→

0

\

&

^ :

` š

X žBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm.BOp0{7Wh^`Tlp\ACBp7LGWhKgWhp0{ fl^NWZfbp7LGR7J¥KNž>fbj@KTb—¤pUfbACBOKLN=Uf€Lfb^`Bp\TlL&WXpxLN=\BCm;T5ACflWXpUKTl—

L`=\WZKBp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7LOš

4"%" && T

N

*,

_

∀

^{ N T}

→ ¬

^{\ ` ^}

→ ¬

^{\ 0 ^}

→

^{&& TW : š}

 Bp\T€ž KM=\T€ž LN=@fbL&LN=\BflVL`B^`p@f€L`BP—˜Tl^`A[\VZf€L`WXT5pxTl—^`[\VXB N " N *, \˜LN=\B„Tlp\BCžWXLN=¥¢œ—˜T5^&Tlp\B

—˜^`BOKN=p@fbACB £GWhp@KcL`BOf5m„Tl—™¢c—˜Tl^QflVXVs—˜^`BOKN=•pUfbACBOK £GWhpLN=\BKNBOnTlp@m•j\^`BACWZKMB ^¤WZKQf5m;ACWhK`KMWhR\VhBlš

4"%" N p N *, _

∀

^{% }

N p

→

^{+ , :}

=@?

# A

→ ¬

^{\#N " ^}

→ ¬

^{\0 ^}

→

N p \,\  ^ __ ^\N *,, "T p ^

→

N p \ *, ^š

R

+%(o( •U ‹•+

 Bgp\T€ž m\Bd@p\BGL`=\BKM[@R;LcJ0j\WXp@ac[Um;lBOAPBOp7Lf5Kfbp•WXp@m\[@n”L`WX{5B&j\^NB9m;WZnf€L`Blš ¤f5no=nTlp@KMLN^`[@n”L`Tl^Tb—(LN=\B

j@^NB9m;WhnOf€L`BgnTl^`^NB9KMjkTlpUm\K_L`TfbpWXp\—˜B^`Bp@nBG^`[\VhB&WXp•LN=@B&Tl^`WX5WXp@flV™m;Bd@p@WL`WXT5pTl—*KN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\Uš

#243456)78

r p

_ p

→

p

→

p

→

# *j

_K:

< T

_

∀



N

T

→

N

";

→

"; = &

< T *, *

_

∀

^{1 }

N

T

→

^{+ : =@? #>A}

→

^{Z+ : 9}

→

";

\ = p*,

^%\

= p*j ^

< T *,p * _

∀

^{1 }

+ : = ? #>A

→

^{Z+ : 9}

→

^{r p}

→

"; \ =

p*, ^

<

T *r*j _

∀

^

";

→

^";

→

"; \ *r*j ^ \ *r*j ^

<

T _

∀

^{A }

";

→

\

∀



+ : = ? #>A

→ ¬

\

` ^

→

"

\ \ 

^%__

^\N

*jr, "T "

^%\N

*,, "T p ^ ^

→

";

\

*j

^ \

*,

^”š

~

<>=@B T ^`[\VhB¥—˜Tl^ *, LcJ0jkBOK„—˜TlVhVXT€žQKLN=\Bxj@f€LNLNB^`p L`=@f€LžBŸflVX^`BOf5m;J Whp7LN^`T;m;[@nB9m —˜Tl^•LN=\B

N

"

j@^NB9m;WhnOf€L`BlsWXpx^N[@VXB N

p

N

*j

š›œpŸLN=\BPTl^`WhlWhp@fbV3UpUfbACB¯²R@flKNBOmŸKMjkBOnWedUnOf€L`WXT5psžBPKNf J

L`=@f€L

E ` (∀x <: σ 1 . σ 2 ) <: (∀x <: τ 1 . τ 2 )

^WX—

E ` τ 1 <: σ 1

fbpUm

E, x : τ 1 ` σ 2 <: τ 2

š <>=\BLcJ0jUB

{€fl^NWZfbR\VhB

x

^\RkBWhp\

α

¯²nTlp0{lBO^ML`WXR@VXBgWhp•L`=\BnTlp@nVX[@KNWhTlp;WZK \˜WhACj\VhWhnWL`VXJTl^B–0j@VXWZnWXLNVhJ"^>no=\T5KNBp‹KMTCL`=@f€L

E, x : τ 1

WZKžBOVXVX¯3—˜Tl^`APB9mWhpLN=\BKNBOnTlp@m•j\^`BACWhKNBl0L`=@f€LQWZKO

x

WhKQno=@T5KNBpp\TbL>—˜^`BBgWXp

E

^š

›œp$T5[\^&VXT;nOfbVhVXJ¥pUfbACBVhBOK`Kg^NBOj\^`BOKNBp7L`fbLNWhTlp™L`=\BCLcJ0jUB{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBOKgRkTl[@p@m R7J *,

Whp LN=\B„nTlp;¯

nVX[UKMWhTlp m;T„p\TlL&=@f {lBSp@fbACBOKOš  BPAS[@KMLL`=\B^`B—˜T5^NBSWXp0{lBOp7LgfKM[@WLofbR\VhBSpUfbACB

flp@mŸKN[\R@KMLNWXLN[\LNBCWL

—˜T5^QL`=\BRkTl[\p@m¥{ fl^NWZfbR@VXB

= *

uWXp.L`=\BLcJ0jkBOK

fbpUm

še<>=\B^`B—˜T5^NB5;LN=@BSKNBOnT5p@m‹j\^`BACWZKMBj@[;L`K

N *jr, "T " fbpUm N *jr, "T " WXp.KN[\R;LcJ0jkBG^`BVZf€L`WXT5pš

XKSACBOp5L`WXT5p\BOm fbVh^NB9flm;J5 KM=\T5[\VZm’RkBno=\T7KMBOp’p\TlLPWhp’L`=\Bm\TlAfbWhp Tl— \˜TlLN=\BO^NžWZKMB„LN=\BB–0¯

L`Bp@m\BOmPBp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7L \  ^O__ žTl[\VZmSRUBQWhVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOmp^*flp@mPp\TbL —˜^`BBWhp fbp@m 5TbLN=@B^`žWhKNB>LN=\B

—˜^`BOKN=\BOp\WXp@5K N *jr, "T "; fbpUm N *, p p- žTl[\VZm.Whp@nT5^N^`BOnLNVhJWZm;BOp5L`W—˜J‹L`=\BPRUT5[\p@m™

[@p\WX{5B^oKNflVXVhJ7¯²Y7[@flp7LNWd@BOmP{€fb^`WhflR\VhBQTb—™L`=\B *j LcJ0jkBOKžWL`=„fbpB–;WhKMLNWhp\@7—˜^`BBLcJ0jkB{€fl^NWZfbR\VhBlš)gQT€ž>¯

BO{lBO^O\f5KžBgžWhVXVj\^`T€{lBGRUBOVXT€ž&;L`=\B^`[\VhBOK>—˜T5^ r p K`f€L`WhKM—˜J•fCžBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm;p@BOK`KnTlpUm;WL`WXT5p _ WX—

r " A @L`=\Bp fbp@m fb^`B&žBOVXVX¯3—˜Tl^`APB9mWXp UWhACj\VhJ7Whp\L`=@f€LGfp@fbACB&p\TlLeWhp.LN=\B

m\TlAfbWhpTb— nOfbp\p\TlLRkBe—˜^`BBeWXp T5^ š*<>=@B^`B—˜Tl^`BllLN=\BgnT5p@m;WXLNWhTlpS¢ p\TlLWhpLN=\Bgm;T5ACflWXp„Tb— £

KN[anB9KLNTPBp@KN[\^`BeL`=@f€L

WZK>p\TbL—˜^NBOBWhp

flp@m

\fbp@mLN=@fbLL`=\BG—˜^NB9KM=@Bp\Whp\5K N

*,, "T p

flp@m N

*,r, p p

Afb‘5BgKNBpUKMB5š

XKACBOp5L`WXT5p\BOmŸfbVh^NB9flm;J‹flKžBOVXV3sžBS=@f {lBSf„no=\T5WhnBRkBLcžBBpxY5[Ufbp7LNWX—˜J0WXp\•T€{lBO^fbVhV*KM[\WXL`flR\VhB

T5^QT€{lBO^Tlp\BKN[\WXL`flR\VXB

Whp‹LN=\BSKMB9nTlpUm•j@^NBOAPWZKNBlš XQ7fbWhp@žB&lTžWXLN=.L`=\B¢c—˜Tl^eflVXV£fbVXLNB^`p@fbLNWh{lB&Whp

T5^`m\B^>LNT„TlR;LofbWhp‹LN=\BKMLN^`Tlp@lBOKMLQWhp@m;[@nLNWhTlp.j\^`WXpUnWhj\VXB5Uflp@m‹žBžWXVhVKN=\T€ž VhfbLNB^QLN=@fbLQLN=\Bg¢œ—˜T5^QTlp@B”£

flVL`B^`p@f€L`WX{5BWZKm;BO^NWh{€fbR\VhBlš

°@Tl^SLN=\BLNWhACB•RkBWhp\U_žBKcLofb^NLSžWXLN= KMWhACj\VhB•žBVhV¯3—˜Tl^`ACBOm;p@BOK`Kj\^`TljkB^NLNWhBOKSTb—L`=\B„LcJ0jkBOKCfbpUm

BOp0{7Wh^`Tlp\ACBp7LoKWhp0{lT5VX{5BOmWhp.f r p ^`BVZf€L`WXT5pš

4"%" r p N _

∀

^{ r p}

→

^{N š}

4"%" r p N p _

∀

^{ r ";}

→

^{N p;}

∧

^{N pš}

4"%" r p N p _

∀

^{ r p}

→

^{N p š}

4"%" r p N p * _

∀

^{ r p}

→

^{N p; š}

 Bp\T€ž KN=\T€ž L`=@f€LeLN=\B

r p

j\^`BOm\WhnOf€LNB&WZKeKML`flR\VhB&R7J‹KNžflj\j\Whp\@š<>=\WhKej\^`TljkB^NLcJWhKn^`[@nWZfbV

L`TKM=\T€ž LN=\B&B9Y7[\WX{€flVXBOp@nBgTb—LN=\Be¢c—˜Tl^QflVXV£gflp@mC¢œ—˜T5^Tlp\B£GWhp5L`B^`j\^`BL`fbLNWhTlp@KTl—(^`[\VhB T

š

4"%"

r p &

_

∀

^{ + : +}

→

∀

^{ r p}

→

r p \& T ^\& p ^\&& " W ^”š

<žTCKNWhVXVhJVhBACAflKfbRkTl[\L—˜^NB9KM=\p@BOK`KTl—(pUfbACBOK>WhpLcJ7jkBOKOš

4"%" N *,r, N " _

∀

^{ N ";}

→ ¬

^{\ ` ^}

→ ¬

^{\#N " ^”š}

9t

4"%" N *,r, N *jr, "T " _

∀

%



N p

\ \  ^ __ ^ \#N

*, p p ^

→ ¬

A

\

0 ^

→

6=

→ ¬

\N

"

^š

 Bgp\T€ž KN=\T€ž LN=Uf€L>LN=\B&flVL`B^`p@f€L`Bj\^`BOKNBp7Lof€LNWhTlp„Tb—^`[\VhB T

\˜LN=\BgTlp@BGžWXLN=¢c—˜Tl^>Tlp\BGp@flAPB£Whp

L`=\BKNBOnT5p@m•j\^NBOACWhKNBgWXp@KMLNB9flm•Tb—¢œ—˜T5^fbVhVp@fbACB9Kœ£^WhKf5m;ACWhK`KMWhR\VhBlš

4"%"

_

∀

^

r p

→

+ : =@? #>A

→ ¬

^{\ ` ^}

→ ¬

^{\#N " ^}

→ ¬

^{\N p ^}

→

r p \,\  ^%__ ^ \N *jr, "T " ^\N *,, "T p ^

→

r p \ *, ^ \ *, A ^”š

R

ok ,+ %*o C”U %/ •U •+

 Bp\T€ž LN[\^`p \fbLeVZflKML^PLNTj\^`T€{0WXp@SL`=\B&LcžTCLN=\BOTl^`BAK>Tb— j@fl^ML &Tl—L`=\B]Œ]ŽAfb^`‘•no=@flVXVhBp@lB`_

^`BUB–;WX{0WXLcJfbp@m•L`^`flp@KMWXLNWh{0WLcJ„Tb—(KN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\Uš

iQB@B–0Wh{0WLcJ“Tl—KM[@R;LcJ0j\WXp@ŸWZKPKN=\T€žp’R0J$KMLN^ofbWhl=7LM—˜T5^Nž>fb^om WXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5p Tlp LN=\B‹m;BO^NWh{€f€LNWhTlp Tb—ežBVhV¯

—˜T5^NACB9m;p\BOK`KgTb—LN=@BLcJ0jUB5š;XeKp\TbL`BOm R0JxF¥nO¦gWXp\pUf.fbp@m ]*TlVhVhf5no‘sKM[Uno= Whp@m;[Un”LNWhTlpUKnT5p7{5Bp\WhBp7L`VXJ

^`Bj@Vhf5nBGWXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5p@KTlp•LN=@BKcL`^N[@nLN[\^`BgTb—(LcJ0jUB9Kš

&("

r *,

_

∀

 N

p

→

N

T

→

r ";%

š

& &š

p

`b p*,

š

¡f5KMB

: = p*,

`r*rpT

\

Z+ `r

^ VLeŽ Y²š

T *, *f A

b

š

¡f5KMB

: =

T &

š š

"r*rpT*

š

¡f5KMB : *r*,

T *r*, š š š

¡f5KMB : *,

`r *rpT \N *,, = ?

#>A \N p ( 0 ^ ^ V V°*iDgq¦g› ]YY²š

T f! b š

b š

p*rpT * b š

3 š

 Bp\T€ž m;T&KMT5ACBQKNnOfcsTlVZm;WXp@GžTl^`‘g—˜Tl^_LN=\Bj\^`T0Tb—sTb—kLN^ofbp@KNWXLNWh{7WXLcJlš*°(WX^oKMLObžBžWXVhV\p\BOBOmPL`T&jUBO^M—˜T5^NA

Whp@m;[Un”LNWhTlpUK>T€{lB^L`=\BKMW[BgTl—LcJ0jkBOKOš Bnflp\p\TlL(ac[UKcLem;TCWhp@m;[@nLNWhTlp@KQT€{lB^L`=\BKcL`^N[Un”LN[@^NBgTb—LcJ0jUB9K

f5K>LN=@BTl^`WX5WXpUfbVj@fljUBO^Qj\^`T0Tb— m;WhmURkBOnOfb[@KNB&WXp¥LN=\BnOflKNB&Tb—

*,

@žB&žWXVhVp@BBOmL`T^NB9n[\^oKNB

€}

p@TbLTlp R@[;LTlp!N *,r, p p —˜Tl^KNTlACBG–s;ž=@Whno=WhKp\TlLQfPKN[\R;¯3LNBO^NA±Tb— šfgeT€žBO{lB^97LN=\B

KNW[BgTb— N

*, p p

WZKLN=\BK`fbACB&flKL`=\BKNW[OBGTl—

\KNTCWXpUm;[@n”L`WXT5p‹T€{lB^KNW[OBOK>žWhVXVžT5^N‘sš

$'& 2 )

r p

\ _

"

^r_

_K:

j f!

<>= " *,

⇒

^u

<>= *

⇒

^u

<>=

⇒

^u

< *r*,

⇒

^{rZ " r p}

<

*,

⇒

^{rZ p rZ "}

T š

4"%"

Tr p rZ

_

∀



rZ "

\

r r p \ = " *, ^ ^ :

rZ p

š

4"%" N

*,r, p p r

_

∀

^{ rZ " \N *,, "T p ^: rZ p- š}

 Bp\T€ž±m;BTd@p\B.fŸp@TbLNWhTlp Tb—eWhp@nVX[@KNWhTlp RkBLcžBBOp BOp7{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7L`KLN=Uf€LžB‹nflVXV_¢MžB9fb‘5Bp\Whp\€£”š

žBOfl‘lBOp@K WX—sflVXV0L`=\B>R\Whp@m;Whp\5K*Whp fl^NBj\^`BOKNB^`{lBOmWXp b7=\T€žB{lBO^O Af JnT5p5LofbWhpPf5m\m;WXLNWhTlp@flV

p@Tlp;¯²WXp7L`B^N—˜B^`WXp\PR\Whp@m;Whp\5KOš

FHGI2')&J2 &+0 \ _ "T ^%_ # *,& _;:

∀



Z+ : 9

→

Z+

: 9

š

4"%"

&+0 0

_

∀

^{ T &Z+`T=}

→

^{T \ ` ^ \0 ^”š}

<>=@BgKN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\^`BVZf€L`WXT5p„WZKQKcLofbR\VhBgR0JžB9fb‘5Bp\Whp\PTb—(LN=\BGLcJ0j\Whp\Bp0{0WX^`Tlp@APBOp7LOš

4"%"

&jZ+`T

_

∀

 r p

→ ∀

^

N

T

→

T &jZ+`T ;

→

r ";

š

X KNjUB9nWZfbV*nflKNBTl—_žB9fb‘5Bp\Whp\WZKLN=\BPflm\m;WXLNWhTlpxTb—_R\Whp@m;Whp\7KeL`T•flpŸB–;WZKcL`WXp@LcJ0j\Whp\„BOp7{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7LO

j@^NT€{0WZm;BOmLN=\B&^`BOKN[\VXLNWhp\CBp0{0WX^`Tlp\ACBOp5LWZK>žBOVXVX¯3—˜Tl^`APB9m™š

4"%" &+0 _

∀

^{`T .0 }

N \ `T( .0 ^

→

^{&+0 .0 \ `T( . ^š}

<>=@B—˜TlVhVhT€žWXp\•VXBOACACf5Kej@^NT€{5B&[@KMB—˜[\V*j\^`TljkB^NLNWhBOKTb—_Bp0{0Wh^NT5p\ACBp7L`KeTb— LN=@B—˜T5^NA

(

\  ^ __

0L`=@f€L>WZK;fbVhVsR\Whp@m;Whp\5KTb—

0—˜TlVhVXT€žBOmR0JfSR\WXpUm;WXp@STl—

L`T

7—˜TlVhVhT€žB9mR0JfbVhVUR\Whp@m;Whp\7KTl—

š

4"%" ` T 0T _

∀

^{W  0 \ ( \  ^ __ ^ : ` \ ( \  ^}

__ ^š

4"%" N T M0 _

∀

^{ N T \ ( \  ^ __ ^}

→

^{N p}

→

^{N \ ( \  ^ __}

^”š

4"%" Z+ `T _

∀

^

N

\ (

\ 

^__

^

→

9w

Z+ \ ( \  ^S__ ^ : N ;, ! "T 9 T;Z+ \ ( \ 

^%__

^š

eT€ž nTlACBOKLN=\BAfbacTl^Q^`BOKN[\VXL__L`^`flp@KNWL`WX{0WXLcJ•fbpUm„L`=\Bp@fl^N^`T€žWhp\Cj\^NT5jUBO^MLcJ„Tb—_KM[@R;LcJ0j\WXp@@@j@^NT€{5BOm

KNWhA[\VXL`flp\BT5[@KMVhJlš <>=\B¥j\^`T0Tb—g—˜TlVhVhT€žQKPLN=\B KcL`^N[@nLN[\^`B.Tb—gL`=\B¥j@fljUBO^j\^`T7Tl—c>žWL`= LN=\BxKcL`^N[@nLN[\^ofbV

Whp@m;[Un”LNWhTlp‹T5p RUBOWXp@^NBOj\Vhf5nB9mR0J•fP]*BOflp\TCWXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5pT5p„L`=\BKNW[OBGTl— š

4"%"

*, " *r*j _

∀

\

∀

^

rZ p

≤

→

r p

→

^{r p}

→

r p ^

∧

^\

∀

^{;* }

rZ p

≤

→

r p \ ( \  ^%__ ^ *

→

^";

→

r p \ ( \  ^%__ ^ * ^”š

& &š

p*,- š pT*rA š #]j pT š

p*, rZ B%r š

] fl^ML `_(L`^`flp@KMWXLNWh{0WLcJ

TT*r \

∀

^{ r p}

→

∀



r p

≤

rZ

→

r p

→

r p

^”š

D;[\R;¯²WXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5pT5p„L`=\Bm;BO^NWh{€f€LNWhTlpTb—

r p

p

`b p*,

š

¡f5KMB

T

T* š

T &

š š

j š

¡f5KMB

T *, *

š

¡f5KMB T *,p *

T *, " *f b š

¡f5KMB T *r*j

T* š

T š š T* š pr*rpT * b š

r% b r r b r š r š

T*r \ 9 " _ *,&WrZ r ^š .0 š

\ B%rZ \*,& Z ^ 9J " ^rb *j @B B š

T *r*, š

Xej\j\VhWhnOf€L`WXT5p•Tl—L`=\B&Tl[;L`B^Whp@m;[@nLNWhTlp‹=0J0jUTlLN=\B9KMWZKLNT

B f! b š

.0

š

Xej\j\VhWhnOf€L`WXT5p•Tl—L`=\B&Tl[;L`B^Whp@m;[@nLNWhTlp‹=0J0jUTlLN=\B9KMWZKLNT

B f! b š

.0

š

¡f5KMB T

N

*j

T*

š

9v

T š š

r " N

p 4f!

\

*,

^”š

j "r*rp*

b r

š

r% b

r r b

r

š

r (

š

T*r

\ 9

"

_

*,&WrZ r

^š

.0

š

\ B%rZ

\

*,& Z

^ 9J

"

^rb

*j @B B š

¡=@TlWZnBgTb—*fbp.fbj\j@^NT5j\^NWZf€L`BVhJP—˜^NB9KM=‹p@flAPBG–

\N

*jr, =@? #>A

\

` (

N " (

N p

^,^”š

p*, %

V°(i Dgq¦g› ]Y²š

T f b

j š

Xej\j\VhWhnOf€L`WXT5p•Tl—L`=\B&Tl[;L`B^Whp@m;[@nLNWhTlp‹=0J0jUTlLN=\B9KMWZKLNT

B f! b š .0 š

Xej\j\VhWhnOf€L`WXT5p•Tl—L`=\B&Tl[;L`B^Whp@m;[@nLNWhTlp‹=0J0jUTlLN=\B9KMWZKLNT N *,, "T

B f! \N *jr, "T " ^š

*, f*r N *jr, "T " Z š .0 š

j p . \\  ^%__ ^ f! \ ( \  ^%__ ^”š

Xej\j\VhWhnOf€L`WXT5p•Tl—L`=\B&p@fb^`^`T€žWXp\Sj@fb^NLTb—(LN=\BgT5[;LNBO^WXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5p=0J0jkTbLN=@BOKNWhKOš

B f! š .0 š

š

b

š

š

& e b

š

] fl^MLe|_*p@fl^N^`T€žWhp\

TT*r

\

∀

*



r p*

→

∀

^{- }

: (

\ 

^%__

→

^{r p}

≤

^rZ

→

^{r p}

→

r p

\ (

\  ^ __

^

*

^”š

D;[\R;¯²WXp@m\[@n”L`WXT5pT5p„L`=\Bm;BO^NWh{€f€LNWhTlpTb—

r p *

p `b p*, b r r š

¡f5KMB T

T & š & e N `T f b š

N p T *f \ ( \  ^%__ ^b š

*,f*r \ 0 T M0 ^”š & *, š

¡f5KMB T *, *

T *, *f \N 1 A p TT ^”š

N T M0 f b š š

*,f*r \

Z+ T M0 !

^š

T

\

1

^b

š

T *j" *

T *, " *f

\ N

! "T TT

^š

š

*j f*r

\

Z+ `T !

^”š

T \ 1 ^b š š

T \ 1 ^b p*, š

KN[\R;¯œnf5KMB :

. *, Z š *,f*r \ Z+ M0 ! ^b š

|lu

*,f*r; b *,f*r ; *rp b p*, A b TT A b p*, b r r š

f! š

r &+0 f!

b

š

N

T M0 f b

š

"/.0

\ (

\ 

^__ ^ f!

\ (

\ \\ 

^__

^

(

^,^”š

*,f*r

←

š

&+0T

š

*,f*r;

š

r

š

& e N

`T f! b

š

š

r p f! b š

KN[\R;¯œnf5KMB

6=

r p f! b š

¡f5KMB T *r*j

T *r*, š

r p f! b š

r p f! b š

¡f5KMB T N *j

T š

r p f! b š

p*,

š

"/.0

\\ 

^%__ (

\ 

^__ ^

f

\,\ \ 

^%__ ^ (

\  ^ __

^š

( f! š

š

*,f*r \

0 T M0

^”š

š

*, M0:Z š š

š

¡T5AR\Whp\Whp\PLN=\BgLcžTPj@fb^NL`KL`TllBLN=\BO^

š p*, b f! b š

p*, b f! \ ( \  ^%__ ^ b š

3 š

XKfnT5^NT5VXVZfb^`Jl7žBgT5R;L`flWXp•LN^ofbp@KNWXLNWh{7WXLcJTl—*KN[\R;LcJ0j\Whp\@š

&(" r *,p _

∀

^{ ";}

→

^{r p}

→

^{r p š}

XK>žBOVXVflK>p@fl^N^`T€žWXp@@š

&("

r *r*, _

∀

*



r p

\ (

\  ^ __

^

*

→

^{r p}

→

r p

\ (

\ 

^__ ^

*

š