Data reconciliation: a robust approach using contaminated distribution

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00151299

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00151299

Submitted on 26 Mar 2014

HAL

is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire

HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Data reconciliation: a robust approach using contaminated distribution

José Ragot, Mohammed Chadli, Didier Maquin

To cite this version:

José Ragot, Mohammed Chadli, Didier Maquin. Data reconciliation: a robust approach using con- taminated distribution. American Control Conference, ACC’2004, Jun 2004, Boston, United States.

pp.CDROM. �hal-00151299�

(2)

**!"#"$%&'()'+"#()$,$"$%(-./#$"00%("'1$./)2$'()#"3)"#&4$4/#%-.#()**

!"#$%&'()*+%,"-.//01%23'456+%471708%,'9:6;

<=/.7>?%@A8.B"C+%/D-.1>7+%1/.EF7GHI0G#0/J7GK>=G.GDLJM8 20GC80%10%&0D-08D-0%0G%'FC"/.C7EF0%10%;.GDLJ%2;&N%:,&%OPQR

6G#C7CFC%;.C7"G.>%S">LC0D-G7EF0%10%5"88.7G0J%T+%'U0GF0%10%>.%M"8VC%10%3.L0J%W%=%XY%XZ[%\.G1"0FU80%>0#%;.GDL 5-/#%"'#$ 6$ )G=>7G0% "KC7/7#.C7"G% K8"U710#% .% /0.G#% M"8

/.7GC.7G7GB%.% K8"D0##% .8"FG1% 7C#% "KC7/F/% "K08.C7GB% K>.GCJ% 'G 7/K"8C.GC% D"/K"G0GC% "M% "KC7/7#.C7"G% 80>70#% 7G% 1.C.

80D"GD7>7.C7"G%]-7D-%7#%F#01%M"8%"^C.7G7GB%D"G#7#C0GC%1.C.J%)G%.

/.C-0/.C7D.>%K"7GC%"M%U70]+%C-0%M"8/F>.C7"G%7#%B0G08.>>L%^.#01

"G% C-0% .##F/KC7"G% C-.C% C-0% /0.#F80/0GC% 088"8#% -.U0% G"8/.>>L K1M% ]7C-% _08"% /0.GJ% :GM"8CFG.C0>L+% 7G% C-0% K80#0GD0% "M% B8"##

088"8#+%.>>%"M%C-0%.1AF#C/0GC#%.80%B80.C>L%.MM0DC01%^L%#FD-%^7.#0#

.G1%]"F>1%G"C%^0%D"G#710801%.#%80>7.^>0%7G17D.C"8#%"M%C-0%#C.C0

"M% C-0% K8"D0##J% *-7#% K.K08% K8"K"#0#% .% 1.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G

#C8.C0BL%C-.C%10.>#%]7C-%C-0%K80#0GD0%"M%#FD-%B8"##%088"8#J 78$9)#%(4.'#*()

*-0% K8"^>0/% "M% "^C.7G7GB% 80>7.^>0% 0#C7/.C0#% "M% C-0% #C.C0% "M% . K8"D0##%7#%.%MFG1./0GC.>%"^A0DC7U0+%C-0#0%0#C7/.C0#%^07GB%F#01 C"% FG108#C.G1% C-0% K8"D0##% ^0-.U7"F8J% W"8% C-.C% KF8K"#0+% .% ]710 U.870CL% "M% C0D-G7EF0#% -.#% ^00G% 10U0>"K01% C"% K08M"8/% ]-.C% 7#

DF880GC>L% `G"]G% .#% 1.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"GJ% :GM"8CFG.C0>L+% C-0 /0.#F80/0GC% /.L% ^0% FG`G"]7GB>L% D"88FKC01% ^L% B8"##% 088"8#J '#% .% 80#F>C+% C-0% 1.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G% K8"D01F80% D.G% B7U0% 87#0% C"

.^#F81%80#F>C#%.G1%C-0%0#C7/.C01%U.87.^>0#%.80%D"88FKC01%^L%C-7#

^7.#J% N0U08.>% #D-0/0#% -.U0% ^00G% #FBB0#C01% C"% D"K0% ]7C-% C-0 D"88FKC7"G% "M% G"8/.>% .##F/KC7"G% "M% C-0% 088"8#% a;.8.#7/-.G+

ZRbRcJ% ,0C-"1#% C"% 7GD>F10% ^"FG1#% 7G% K8"D0##% U.87.^>0#% C"% 7/=

K8"U0% B8"##% 088"8#% 10C0DC7"G% -.U0% ^00G% 10U0>"K01J% )G0% /.A"8 17#.1U.GC.B0% "M% C-0#0% /0C-"1#% 7#% C-.C% C-0L% B7U0% 87#0% C"

#7CF.C7"G#% C-.C% 7C% /.L% 7/K"##7^>0% C"% 0#C7/.C0% .>>% C-0% U.87.^>0 F#7GB% "G>L% .% #F^#0C% "M% C-0% 80/.7G7GB% M800% B8"##% 088"8#

/0.#F80/0GC#J

*-080% 7#% .>#"% .G% 7/K"8C.GC% D>.##% "M% 8"^F#C% 0#C7/.C"8#% ]-"#0 7GM>F0GD0% MFGDC7"G% .80% ^"FG101% .G1% M7G7C% .>>"]7GB% C"% 80A0DC

"FC>708#% a3./K0>+% ZRb[cJ% 'G"C-08% .KK8".D-% 7#% C"% C.`0% 7GC"% .D=

D"FGC% C-0% G"G% 710.>7CL% "M% C-0% /0.#F80/0GC% 088"8% 17#C87^FC7"G F#7GB% .G% "^A0DC7U0% MFGDC7"G% D"G#C8FDC01% "G% D"GC./7G.C01% 088"8 17#C87^FC7"GJ

6G% C-0% M">>"]7GB+% ]0% .1"KC% .G1% 10U0>"K% C-7#% 710.% M"8% C-0% 1.C.

80D"GD7>7.C7"G%K8"^>0/J%N0DC7"G%T%]7>>%^0%10U"C01%C"% 80D.>>% C-0

^.D`B8"FG1% "M% 1.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"GJ% 6G% #0DC7"G% Q+% 8"^F#C% 1.C.

80D"GD7>7.C7"G%7#%10U0>"KK01% .G1% ]7>>% ^0% 7>>F#C8.C01% C-8"FB-% .G .D.10/7D%0d./K>0%7G%#0DC7"G%YJ

:8$!"#"$%&'()'*+*"#*()$-"';2%(.)4

*-0%D>.##7D.>%B0G08.>%1.C.%80D"GD7>7.C7"G%K8"^>0/%a,.-+%ZRO[c+

a28"]0+% ZRR[c+% 10.>#% ]7C-% .% ]07B-C01% >0.#C% #EF.80#

/7G7/7#.C7"G% "M% C-0% /0.#F80/0GC% .1AF#C/0GC#% #F^A0DC% C"% C-0 /"10>% D"G#C8.7GC#J% 6G1001% C-0% /"10>% K8"D0##% 0EF.C7"G#% .80 C.`0G%.#%>7G0.8%M"8%#.`0%"M%#7/K>7D7CL%?

!" P+ %!^{# $}^J + %"^$ eZf

]-080%"%7#%C-0%#C.C0%"M%C-0%K8"D0##J%*-0%/0.#F80/0GC%10U7D0#

B7U0%C-0%7GM"8/.C7"G%"%g%^$^?

!!"%g% "H+ %&eHf|"eP +'f eTf

]-080% H ^$% .% U0DC"8% "M% 8.G1"/% 088"8#% D-.8.DC087#01% ^L U.8.7GD0%/.C87d%'%.G1%G"8/.>%K8"^.^7>7CL%17#C87^FC7"G%eK1fJ%6G C-0%>0.#C%#EF.80%#0G#0+%C-0%]0>>=`G"]G%#">FC7"G%"M%C-7#%K8"^>0/

7#% "%h% e('!⁾e!'!⁾f^Z!f*J% a,.EF7G+% ZRRZcJ% 6G% M.DC+% C-0

/0C-"1%1"0#GiC%]"8`%7G%.GL%#7CF.C7"G+%C-0%/.7G%18.]^.D`%^07GB C-0% D"GC./7G.C7"G% "M% .>>% 0#C7/.C01% U.>F0#% ^L% C-0% "FC>708#J% W"8 C-.C% 80.#"G% 8"^F#C% 0#C7/.C"8#% D"F>1% ^0% K80M08801+% 8"^F#CG0##

^07GB%C-0%.^7>7CL%C"%7BG"80%C-0%D"GC87^FC7"G%"M%0dC80/0%1.C.%7J0J

#FD-%.#%B8"##%088"8#J

<8$=(-./#$4"#"$>"+*4"#*()

6M% C-0% /0.#F80/0GC#% D"GC.7G% 8.G1"/% "FC>708#+% C-0G% .% #7GB>0% K1 10#D87^01%.#%7G%eTf%D.GG"C%.DD"FGC%M"8%C-0%-7B-%U.87.GD0%"M%C-0

"FC>708#J%*"%"U08D"/0%C-7#%K8"^>0/%>0C%F#%.##F/0%C-.C%/0.#F80 G"7#0% 7#% #./K>01% M8"/% C]"% K1+% "G0% -.U7GB% .% #/.>>% U.87.GD0 80K80#0GC7GB%80BF>.8%G"7#0%.G1%C-0%"C-08%-.U7GB%.%>.8B0%U.87.GD0 80K80#0GC7GB%"FC>708#J%*-F#+%M"8%0.D-%"^#08U.C7"G+%]0%10M7G0?

& " "

+ , $

+ ,

+

, ,

+

+ 0dK

j

+ % +T+ +JJ+

!

"# $

%&

!

"

## $

% &&

Z T

Z

T Z Z

T

SV V

& "

_, *_,+T

^P^&^Z+^,^eZ^P^f&^T+^,

.>>"]7GB%C"%10M7G0%C-0%>7`0>7-""1%MFGDC7"G%?

)

& " "_, _,

,

$

'

j +T

(

Z

eQf ,7G7/7#7GB%eQf%7G%80#K0DC%C"%"%B7U0#%?

"

!

( - !_" ⁾ !- !_" ⁾ ! "

" $

%

) *

^Z ^j ^eY.f

-_"^Z .,/0 P

VZT &_Z+,Z P

VTT &_{T +,} P&_Z+_,eZPf&_T+,

§

©

¨¨

·

¹

¸¸

¸¸ ^{eY^f}

*-F#% #L#C0/% eYf% 7#% D>0.8>L% G"G% >7G0.8% .G1% ]0% #FBB0#C% C-0 M">>"]7GB%7C08.C7U0%#D-0/0%?

"^{e f}P "j eX.f

& " "

+1 +

+

1 +

e f e f

0dK

j

+ % +T

!

"# $

%&

!

"

## $

% &&

Z T

Z

T Z

T

SV V ^{eX^f}

"^e¹^f ( -_"^{e f}¹ !⁾ !-_"^{e f}¹ !⁾ ! "j

!

" $

%

Z Z

) *

^eXDf

?8$@A"30+&$")4$4*/'.//*()

*-0% /0C-"1% 10#D87^01% 7G% #0DC7"G% Q% 7#% .KK>701% C"% #L#C0/% e[fJ

&.G1"/% 088"8#% ]080% .1101% C"% C-0% Z[% U.87.^>0#% ^FC% C-0% B8"##

088"8#%]080%.1101%"G>L%"G%#"/0%"M%C-0/J

(3)

"_Z "_T "_Y P %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%"_T "_Q"_ZZ P

"_Q"_Y"_X P %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%"_X"_["_ZP P

"_[ "_O"_b P %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%"_O"_R"_ZP P

"_ZT"_ZQ"_ZY P %%%%%%%%%%%%"_ZY"_ZX"_Z[ P

"_ZZ"_ZT"_ZQ"_Z[ P

e[f

*-0% K08M"8/.GD0% 80#F>C#% .80% B7U0G% ]-0G% C-800% B8"##% 088"8#

e]7C-% .% D"//"G% /.BG7CF10% "M% bf% .MM0DC% C-0% /0.#F80/0GC% Q+% O .G1% Z[J% 2"/K.87#"G% "M% C-0% K8"K"#01% 8"^F#C% >0.#C% #EF.80 .>B"87C-/%e&5Nf%]7C-%C-0%D>.##7D.>%>0.#C%#EF.80#%e5Nf%.>B"87C-/

7#%G"]%K8"U7101J

\.8J C8F0%1.C. /0.#J %&5N%0#CJ 5N%0#CJ

Z ZZXJPP ZZYJXP ZZYJT[ ZZYJRZ

T ZQTJPP ZTRJbP ZQPJXX ZQTJPX

Q ZP[JYP ZZYJXQ ZPXJT[ ZPbJTb

Y ZOJPP ZOJPY Z[JTb ZOJZY

X bRJYP bbJQO bbJRO RZJZY

[ ZPRJ[P ZZPJRP ZZPJPX ZZZJb[

O [ZJPP [RJOT %[ZJOY [QJX[

b YbJ[P YbJXb YbJQP YbJTR

R YPJbP %YPJRQ YPJ[[ YTJbX

ZP TPJTP TPJTQ TZJPb TPJOT

ZZ TXJ[P TXJXX TXJTR TQJOO

ZT QQJZP QQJQY QQJXY Q[JRO

ZQ XJZP XJPO XJTO %XJZX

ZY %QbJTP QRJPQ QbJbT YTJZQ

ZX TXJ[P TXJX[ TXJTR TQJOO

Z[ ZTJ[P TPJ[Z ZQJXQ ZbJQ[

*.^>0%ZJ%,0.#F80/0GC#%.G1%80D"GD7>01%1.C.

! " #! #"

!

"

#!

! " #! #"

!

"

#!

W7BF80%ZJ%2"880DC7U0%C08/#%M"8%&5N%.G1%5N

6G%C.^>0%Z+%D">F/G#%Y%.G1%X%#-"]%C-0%0#C7/.C7"G#%"^C.7G01%]7C-

&5N% .G1% 5N% k% .G.>L#7GB% C-0% 0#C7/.C7"G% 088"8#+% M"8% &5N 0#C7/.C"8% D>0.8>L% .>>"]#% C"% #F#K0DC% U.87.^>0#% Q+% O% .G1% Z[% M"8

^07GB% D"GC./7G.C01% ^L% .% B8"##% 088"8J% NFD-% D"GD>F#7"G% 7#% /"80 17MM7DF>C%C"%0dK80##%]7C-%5N%0#C7/.C"8J%W7BF80%Z%U7#F.>7_0#%/"80 D>0.8>L% C-0% 0#C7/.C7"G% 088"8#% ^"C-% M"8% 5N% .G1% &5N% e"G% 0.D- B8.K-+%-"87_"GC8.>%.G1%U08C7D.>%.d7#%.80%#D.>01%]7C-%C-0%GF/^08

"M%C-0%1.C.%.G1%C-0%/.BG7CF10%"M%C-0%.^#">FC0%0#C7/.C7"G%088"8fJ

*-0%K8"K"#01%/0C-"1%-.#%^00G%0dC0G101%C"%G"G%>7G0.8%#L#C0/J l0% 80>.C0% "G>L% C-0% ^7>7G0.8% D.#0+% 7G% ]-7D-% C-0% /"10>% 7#

10#D87^01% ^L% ?%!" P+%!e"*f P% ]7C-%"^$^+%*^$⁺

!^#J^$J%%%%%*-0%D87C087"G%C"%^0%/.d7/7#01%7#%C-0G%10M7G01%^L ) & "

_, "%g%_,+T

, Z

2 ^{& *}

^, ^g%^*%^,⁺^T

^eOf

;F/087D.>% 1.C.% .80% G"C% B7U0G% .G1% "G>L% B8.K-7D.>% 80#F>C#% .80

#-"]G% ]7C-% M7BF80% T% ?% C-0% FKK08% K.8C% 7#% D"GD08G01% ]7C- 0#C7/.C7"G% 088"8#% "^C.7G01% ]7C-% &5N% ]-7>0% >"]08% K.8C% 7#

10U"C01% C"% 5NJ% W"8% C-.C% #7/F>.C7"G% C-0% "% .G1%*% 1.C.% ]080 80#K0DC7U0>L%D"88FKC01%]7C-%B8"##%088"8#%"G%D"/K"G0GC%Q+%O+%Z[

"G%"%.G1%Z+%R+%ZT%"G%*J%l7C-"FC%./^7BF7CL+%.>>%C-0%B8"##%088"8#

-.U0% ^00G% 10C0DC01% .G1% 7#">.C01% ]7C-% &5N% C-.C% 7#% G"C% C-0% D.#0 ]7C-%5NJ

! " #! #"

!

$

%

&

' ()*+,

! " #! #"

!

#

$

()*+-

! " #! #"

!

$

%

&

' )*+,

! " #! #"

!

#

$

)*+-

W7BF80%TJ%2"880DC7U0%C08/#%M"8%&5N%.G1%5N B8$C()'+./*()

*"% 10.>% ]7C-% C-0% 7##F0#% "M% B8"##% 088"8#% 7GM>F0GD0% "G% 1.C.

0#C7/.C7"G+%C-0%K.K08%-.#%K80#0GC01%.%8"^F#C%.KK8".D-J%W"8%C-.C KF8K"#0+% ]0% F#0% .% D"#C% MFGDC7"G% ]-7D-% 7#% >0##% #0G#7C7U0% C"% C-0

"FC>L7GB% "^#08U.C7"G#% C-.G% C-.C% "M% >0.#C% #EF.80#J% '#% . K08#K0DC7U0% "M% 10U0>"K/0GC% "M% 8"^F#C% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G% #C8.C0B70#+

C-080% 7#% .% G001% M"8% C.`7GB% .DD"FGC% "M% /"10>% FGD08C.7GC70#% .G1

"KC7/7#0%C-0%^.>.GD7GB%K.8./0C08%P^J

=&D&%&)'&/

aZc ;J% '8"8.J% &010#D0G17GB% 0#C7/.C"8% M"8% 1.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G .G1% K.8./0C08% 0#C7/.C7"GJ% 34#&56789% /$.% 3:7#,;/<

=$0,$778,$0+%TX+%KJ%ZXbX+%TPPZJ

aTc 2J,J% 28"]0J% 4.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G% =% K8"B80##% .G1% D-.>=

>0GB0#J%>458$/<%?84;799%34$684<+%[%eT+Qf+%KJ%bR=Rb+%ZRR[J aQc WJ&J% 3./K0>+% <J,J% &"GD-0CC7+% SJ!J% &"F##00F]+% lJ'J

NC"-0>J% &"^F#C% #C.C7#C7D% ?% C-0% .KK8".D-% "G% 7GM>F0GD0 MFGDC7"G#J%l7>0L+%;0]=m"8`+%ZRb[J

aYc &JNJ3J% ,.-+% (J,J% NC.G>0L% .G1% 4J% 4"]G7GBJ

&0D"GD7>7.C7"G% .G1% 80DC7M7D.C7"G% "M% K8"D0##% M>"]% .G1 7GU0GC"8L% 1.C.+%($.@% =$0@% 3:7#J+% S8"D0##% 40#J% 40UJ+% ZX eZf+%ZRO[J

aXc 4J% ,.EF7G+% (J% n>"D-+% !J% &.B"CJ% 4.C.% 80D"GD7>7.C7"G% M"8 /0.#F80/0GC#J%=584&77$% +458$/<% 4A% .,/0$49,9% /$.% 9/A76*

,$%/564#/6,4$+%Z%eTf+%KJ%ZYX=ZbZ+%ZRRZJ

a[c NJ% ;.8.#7/-.G+% &JNJ3J% ,.-J% *80.C/0GC% "M% B0G08.>% #C0.1L

#C.C0% K8"D0##% /"10>#% 7G% B8"##% 088"8% 710GC7M7D.C7"GJ 34#&56789% /$.% 3:7#,;/<% =$0,$778,$0+% % ZQ% eOf+% KJ% bXZ=

bXQ+%ZRbRJ

Data reconciliation: a robust approach using contaminated distribution

HAL Id: hal-00151299

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00151299

Submitted on 26 Mar 2014

is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Data reconciliation: a robust approach using contaminated distribution

José Ragot, Mohammed Chadli, Didier Maquin

To cite this version:

José Ragot, Mohammed Chadli, Didier Maquin. Data reconciliation: a robust approach using con- taminated distribution. American Control Conference, ACC’2004, Jun 2004, Boston, United States.

pp.CDROM. �hal-00151299�

!"#"$%&'()'*+*"#*()$,$"$%(-./#$"00%("'1$./*)2$'()#"3*)"#&4$4*/#%*-.#*()

!

"# $

%&

!

"

## $

% &&



'

(

!

" $

%

) *

!

"# $

%&

!

"

## $

% &&

!

" $

%

) *



**!"#"$%&'()'+"#()$,$"$%(-./#$"00%("'1$./)2$'()#"3)"#&4$4/#%-.#()**