Better understanding EMI generation of power converters

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00021518

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00021518

Submitted on 22 Mar 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Better understanding EMI generation of power converters

Piotr Musznicki, Jean-Luc Schanen, Pierre Granjon, Piotr Chrzan

To cite this version:

Piotr Musznicki, Jean-Luc Schanen, Pierre Granjon, Piotr Chrzan. Better understanding EMI gener-

ation of power converters. 36th IEEE International Power Electronics Specialists Conference (PESC

2005)., 2005, Recife, Brazil. �hal-00021518�

(2)

!"#$%'&'"() *+,!(%-

./ 012"3,!/.'41%+"3 /*0*&+/5 //.6%798):

. /+ %!"/;"(< =>#!41"3?"#@&+0BAC9:"D35E /

F5&+BDG 0/9>AG%4H#/? E&+"3@5->& /I"&2JK /2

%+L 3%&2 0M798:N./ 0CM"L5/>(A=%1>AG> 4PO9%RQS/

(%!0%/+.QT4P >"3UV +0!5CXWY"%UZ3+,!41/ 0$ /2

4P&0 %!"/@#I ,D3(%"34NY4N ,A1[&5C2-\41%+"3P-9!00!& %

/]%+^4P0!_Z5 4P0!_"(` X+""3`>#!/+.a00!C

0!- %"/=>"N4P"3N"4P0 %R+"#,b0"/ [&%&

#%@D3 0>#!-9 0-"+"3+0C

cd c>e1f9ghKiEjbklfmchKe

c%n=o%pqErss?t2uvqEuwnyx2zn{p|q<o!n%}x2ou2~2x2ru2v5?ru2z*ouHvqEr

rsr}n%v5u2o}3p}v5uG2rnyrJpzr znn%x2r v5o~ou vYc

ysr}n%v5?z~u2rn%o}Ecu+n%rrru2}rm~+ru2rznyov5udfYxrEr5},nyov5uRv

n%x2oypUr?o%pJpov5u nyv ?rr,nnyx2ro-u+n%ru2znyov5u2zspn%z3u2+z32p

u2r}r3ppo!n%zn%r3pu2rJp|n%z3u2ou2~Pmc9~rurzn%ov5u?zuP2vz~znyov5u

v5}r3pJp,d*rJ2rzs*z+n%xv5Jpwx2z 2rn%o-rXn%vXou52r3pn%o~zn%rn%x2o%p

z5pr}nKpou~2zovpRrro?runpRzu25%v5po@sznyov5up;

!? 5dIfmx2r¡ur,q^qEz ¢+£'v?z5pn1Yc@r+o}n%o-u2~*?r,nyx2v52

qExo}xHzss-vq1p=z6z5pn?zu¤?v5r;z3}}zn%r¥rpn%o?zn%ov5uv@n%x2r

mc>mkVr,%r}np¤v*z¦vqErrsr},nyv5u2o}§z2s-o}zn%ov5u{o%p

rpru+n%rdKfmx2r?r,nyx2v5¨r3pru+nyrx2rrpn%zn>p©v5ª+o~o!n%z3s

po~+uzs«2v5}r3pJpou~¬2z5po%pJzu2n%or3p®n%v+rn%r?ou2rVn%x2r

}v5u+n%oB¬+n%ov5u*n%v2rn%¬2zn%o-v5upRsrJ2rs%Krn%v¯p|q<o!n%}x'nu*v5u

zu°n-2u?v%Jd5fYxo%p\i?5±=?rn%x2v5@oyp¬2z5pr@v5u@2vq<r%s²'oru2r

os!n%rou~³z2v5z3}x ´+|®qExo}x s-ou+tpµn%xrUpv}rTv

o%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rpmzu2@uv5o%prI?rzGp|r@v5u@¶mc5e?d

fmx2r?YcKvz~zn%ov5up<zn%x¥o%pbo!%rrunMv5Erz3}xp|nyzn%r

v@±·vqEr@sr},nyv5u2o}¥p>¢p|n%r=dMfmx2o%p??r,nyx2v5'o%p?oss!pn%zn%rou

n%x2oyp<zrEv5u{n%xr?po-°sr@rz@sr@vz1¬2v5vpnM}v5u52rn%rEo~¸d

+qEx2rrKnq<v@?zou?2vz~znyov5u@2zn%xpY}zu1¬2rI+rou2r@52rn%v

pr?o}v5u25},nyv5JpRpn%zn%r3p¹\n%xrRo-Jp|nIqEx2ru6hKYºfwoyp°v5uzu2

ov5+r)o%p?v>|Mn%x2r¥pr}v5u26»rJ2rJpr5dmcuv5+rPnyv;r}v5up|n%}n

o%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rp;qEz 2r,v5L©²oru2r;o-s!n%rJp;zr*}zs}sznyrHv5

rz}xLp|nyzn%r5d

cu6n%xo%p@©rn%xv52\mc¬2rx2z 2ov5Pvl¬2v5vp|nIo%p1r,r3pru+nyr

¬5¢¤n%x2r¯p>¢p|nyrVqEx2o-}x¼}v5un%zoupn%z3uprR%u2}n%ov5up?¬2rnqErru

pr?o}v5u25},nyv5PrJ2o}rp1zu2rn%¬2zn%ov5up,d·c>nz3ssvqbp<ou2ou2~

n%x2rNv5sr@vMn%xr@+oyp|n%¬2zu}rNpv2}rNyh@5ºMf¸ov5rMv5uRn%x2r

~sv¬2zs2mc9~+ru2rzn%ov5u?zu212vz~zn%o-v5ud

º·oJpn\n%xr©n%x2rv5rn%o}z3s[rJ2rsv2?ru+nIvKnyx2r?©rn%xv5{q<oss9¬2r

¬2orsB¢½rn%zo-sr]pr}n%ov5u]ccJdfYx2ru6nyx2r2zs-o+zn%ov5u¾zu2

}v5@2z3o%pv5u)qEo!n%x¥vn%x2rE?r,nyx2v52pEvYcKsrJ2rsYro}n%ov5u¥ou

r¿ru2}or3pP+v5?z3ou;qEossm¬2r@rpru+n%r¥pr}n%o-v5u;cccdmr},nyov5u

cÀÁ}v5un%zoupÂr}v5upn%},nyov5upHv*2rn%¬2znyov5up¨q<z2rv5Rp

v¬+n%z3ou2rÃq<o!n%x$?rz5p2r?ru+npHzu2«n%r@v5zs*po@szn%o-v5up,d

i1o%p}pJpo-v5u=zu2?2vvpon%ov5upMvmzso}zn%o-v5upM}z3u@¬2rKvu2?ou

pr}n%o-v5u©À@d

ccd ²'ÄÅÆ9Å5ÇKº·c>¶mf9Yg)c%eYcÈÇÅ5ÉÄÊ2Ë+ÄBÆ9Ì°Í+Ë+Î·Å5ÏÇ2Ð

fmx2rK?z3ou?z5pJp|@+n%o-v5upYvnyx2o%pY?rn%x2v5@z3rKzGp\v5ssvq1p¹

• n%xrp>¢p|nyrªr,r3pru+nyr¬5¢*v5u2r)²'o-rur@os!nyr?o%p so-u2rzmzu2Pnyo?rÍ%ou52z3ozu+n>

• u2v5oyprRv5$vn%x2r?pv}r3p@o%p@u2vn<}v5rszn%rqEon%x n%xrK?zouLpo~u2zs%pd

cu6v5rbnyv{ou2)n%zuprb%u2}n%ov5uvKn%xr=p%¢2pn%rRmznIsrz5pn

nq<vÑpo~u2z3s%pÃz3r$u2rrr]»Òo-u++nÓpo~u2zsÔpv2}r$v

o%pn2%¬2z3u2}r3p9z3u2@vn+nÕpo-~+u2z3s·>o%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rpm©rzGp|r+Jd

±o-vn%\¥pÖu2o-},to× Ørz3uÍy¶9}P}x2zuru Ù ±·orr<ÚKzuÛJv5u Ü ±o-vn%MkMx2Ö3zu ×

ÝÞß2àá5âMã1Þã1ä+Þâå|æYæmæ

d ±·v5son%r}xu2o!tz1ÚK+z3up|tz5

²;¢+Ö3ozçsr}n%vn%r}x2u2o!too¸èKn%v5?zné¢toê1ro!¥s9v¬2or3p|tor~+v1ë2ìíÍ>Õî?ÚK+z3upt@2@pÖGï6rsB¢d~¸d~+zds

d ¶mz ¬2v5zn%v5o-rKðsr}n%vn%r}x2u2o¿5rKrEÚKru2v¬2sr3

jK¥g*ññ52òPc%eE±ÕÚ[jEØºR»LkYeEgEme?c>lÚ¤Í¸ó±=´î?Í9 +ì5´í+Rz3ou+nÍzn%o-uÍ>ðôEõr3pMkMrrMÛJrz3uÍ>s2}5dp}x2z3u2ruï6sr~drupor~dou2~d

2d ¶mz ¬2v5zn%v5o-rKrpmc?z~r3pYrnr3p[o~u2z?y¶mcJ

c>eE±ÕÚEó±´î2 +ì5´í+R5nz3n%ou?2ðô<õr3pJº·zu2}r2orr5d~+z3uÛv5uï6so%pdou+~¸d

Ë! "#$ &%(')"+*-,.%0/1'32547608ÕÉÊ9BÉ·Ê

:&;

9

:<&;>=

%(%'32?#%@*A"+/2B"$/

CED@F@GIHJD@K?LMC5NF@G.OP)Q&HRJ@C

S

LMC5NF@G.OP)Q&HRJ@C

G)JRH@DQC5NGBF(H$N3J@L T L(MCINF@GBO7PEQ(H@JUC

VWJ@PCBF@GIJL T

Q(DMC)JK3G.D0V

D@NXJ+GICYCED@F@GIHJ@C T

Z[Z(\^]`_

a

D b

"$*&"$/`, 2B"$/25 "%@/.8

(3)

∗=

= ∗

105 106 107

-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10

WIENER vs Saber transfer function

frequency[Hz]

dB(V)

Wiener close Wiener open Saber open Saber close

! #"!$&%('*)+-,/.0%#,1)324/5!)+&67.0)!4/,8:94<;:)71=>.0%2*'!?+(=1@?'04-5!)3+&'*)6

?rz5p2r y½z3r}v5rs-zn%rED«?v5rv2r¾n%x2rro%p]u2v

}v5rszn%o-v5uP¬2rnq<rruLpo~u2zs2v5pv2}rIzu2@vnyx2rJpYu2v5o%pr3p,d5cu

n%x2r?r¿5ru}¢;v5?zou\n%x2rL²'oru2rEo-s!n%rPvn+nGFNEoypbn%x2r

v5}n?v?n%x2rou++n©po~u2z3sBHNyRz3u2*n%x2r;os!n%rRr¿ru2}J¢

r3p|v5uprK²¯y¹

c%n)}z3u§¬2r¨v2rHn%x2znLn%zup|r%2u},nyov5u¦v=n%xrp>¢p|n%r

}v2s-$¬2rXv¬+n%zour$pou~®n%xr vqErÓp2r}n% vwJI,

>r¿52zn%ov5uHz|bz3u2*n%x2r}vppJÍyvqEr)p2r}n% v?JILzu2

JI1r3p|r},nyoB2rsB¢'%r¿zn%o-v5u'3¬2?ò5d9fmx2rRs-rzGp|nI?rzup¿zr

rv5Y²oru2r\osn%rYou@n%xr[r¿ru2}J¢@+v5?zo-u©oypY~+o2ru?zGp¹

q<x2rr+¹

¶mou+t°¬2rnqErru=ou++nmz3u2Rvn+npo~u2zsyp[}zu?¬2r1zs%pvPvu2?ou

n%o?r@v5?zouL¬5¢=+rou2o-u2~=o@+s%pr@r3p|v5upr@vMn%xr?p>¢p|nyrÓô

zu@}v5u52v5s!n%ov5u?vn%9zu21n%d

ór}zpr@x2ru2v5?ru2zR52o-u2~;pqEon%}x2ou2~)zu2Rmc~rurzn%ou2~

ou±·vq<rKsr}n%v5u2o}?z+so}znyov5upEzr?u2v=sourz3JÕq<r?+r}or

n%v?}v5@2vprbnyx2r@p%¢2pn%rqEo!n%xRn-qEv?sou2rz3Yos!n%rJpYv5YnqEv°p|n%zn%r3p,d

c>npx2vs@¬2r1u2vn%o-}r?n%x2zn9nyx2o%pln-qEvLpo-u2~+s-r1p|n%zn%r3pMou2}s!+r3pMzs%pv

n%x2rn%zuporu+nÕpn%znyrKvnyx2rEpqEo!ny}x·d

fmx2r}v5@srn%r;Yc©~ru2rzn%o-v5u¤x2zGp@¬2rruoru+n%o!or¬5¢'n%x2r

z5pJpr1¬2sB¢;v<+o>rru+nos!n%rJpd9fYxrRo%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}r=pv2}rRoypbn%x2r

h@5ºMf2v5s!n%z3~+r?ÀLKNM\z3u2{nyx2r?~+zn%rLpo~u2z3sYÀPO0MqEos-s¬2rPpr

n%v1~+o2r[n%x2r<p|nyzn%rIvn%x2r<p>¢p|nyrÔyo~d 5d

fmx2r1u2rq§z2v5z3}x=o%pY¬2zGprRv5u) Lp|nyr,L}zs-},szn%ov5uRz3u2?x2z5p

¬2rru©o-°sr?ru+n%r@ou@zn%sz¬EQ§pv%nqEz3r+¹

• ou?n%x2rKoJpnmpn%rRz3ss9po~u2zsyplz3r1przzn%r©o-u+n%vPnq<v@~v+p

v5u2rRv5@v5u¯p|n%zn%r=zu6v5urRv51v%1pn%znyrdÕfYx2rL+rn%r}n%ov5uv

n%x2rSR|},nn%o-u2~@n%o?r3pTRmpr3plÀPOJM2v5Mo!npMroB2zn%o2rdGè¨n%xrpx2v5s

o%pE+rou2rÕq<x2o}x;@p|nz3ssvq`z?}v5r}nlprzzn%ov5u)vMn%x2r

o!%rru+nÕpn%zn%r3pJ

• nq<vou2r,ru2runsou2rz3*p%¢2pn%rRp'z3rHoru+n%o!oroun%x2r pr}v5u2Lpn%rÍÕn%xrKo-Jp|nÕv5u2rKv5Yn%x2rEv5up|n%zn%rKz3u2Pn%xrEpr}v5u2

v5u2r=v5Pn%x2r=v%Npn%zn%r=vNpqEon%}xdmcu6nyx2o%pP2v5}r52r=zGp°z3u

ou+n§rrru2}r3ppo~u2zs¼À K*M }z3u ¬2r«z+sB¢;¬++nÂyv5

x5¢2po}zsz5pr}n%9onoyp¬2rnn%r\nyvbprI+À KNM%5n

• rn-2%¬2zn%ov5up;~rurzn%r§zr*r}v5up|ny2}n%r§ouwnyx2r'n%x2o

pn%rd$f9qEv p%¢2pn%rRpzrpr nyvr}v5upn%}n]n%x2r

rsr}n%v5?z~u2rn%o}Rrn-2%¬2zn%ov5upP~ru2rzn%r=¬5¢nyx2r@¬2v5vpnIou

¬2vn%x_p|nyzn%r3p'v;n%xrHpqEo!ny}x·dPe1rn>©v¬+n%z3ou2rpo~u2zs%pzr

p2??rPn%vEo-u2@zs-srn%¬2zn%ov5upYou@n%o?rKv5?zou·d

rJ2rzs^po-~+u2z3s%p½x2z 2r]¬2rruTou52r3p|nyo~+zn%r¹§n%x2r]¶mc5e

2v5s!n%z3~+r3pPz3r©n%xrR~sv¬2zs}v5upr¿5ru}rLvKn%xr©}v5u52rn%rKmcd

fmx2rKo!%rru+n·v5o~ou??z¢E¬2r¹

Í¸h@5ºf;~+zn%rEpo~u2zs

Í¸h@5ºf;}2ru+n

Íov5rM2v5s!n%z3~+r

Íov5rK}2ru+n|d

c%nMo%pKo-°v5n%z3u+n9n%v@prNp|%o-}o-runmu+21¬2rv9¬2v5vpn9qEv5tou2~

ro-v52p¤qEon%x zÓp+%o}oru+n¯pz@2s-r¦u+1¬2rJ)z}}v5+ou~n%v

eI¢+¿5o%p|nLsrH-ò|Pou§v5rRnyv'o-u2Hpo~u2zsyp{z 2rz3~+r;vqEr

p2r}n%z)zu2;n%v;r}v5upn%},nIn%x2r$oun%x2rRr¿ru2}J¢;zu2~rRv

n%x2rI}v5u2}n%r@r?o%ppov5uLpn%zu2z°ítôEÖ1Í9 5íx2Ö

cccd èLU@UV&W/XZY

$

W-[E\]W<\

^`_&acb:_

\XZd1ie[fPYEW\

cuwv5rz3u2zs¢2pr6n%x2r¥¬2v5vp|nN¬2rx2z 2ov2=o-u¤n%x2r;r¿ru2}J¢

zu~+r?vn%x2r?}v5u252}n%r=Yc|Õnyzupr%2u2}n%o-v5uR¬2rnq<rru=n%x2r

pv2}rvL+o%pn%¬2zu2}r3p)>À K*MLzu2*o%pn%¬2zu2}r3p=>ÀPgihjk+?x2z5p

¬2rru o-+ru+n%oo-r pou2~nyx2rrUo!%rru+nÑzv5z}x2r3pµ»

u+?ro-}z3s)po-°szn%ov5upJRpo@2s¢¦zu2z3sB¢nyo}zs=}zs}sznyov5uzu2

po~+uzs@2v5}r3pJpou~¸dEèE}}zn%rz}'z3u2zs¢2po%p;po@2szn%ov5up)x2z2r

¬2rru½v5u2rq<o!n%xV+z ¬2rJ6qEx2rr«z2z3n*v5 zs-s'2o?z3%¢

}v5@2v5u2ru+n>pKz3ssbzzGpon%o};rsr?ru+npRx2z 2r=¬2rru*n%zt2ruou'n%v

}v5upo+rzn%ov5u -ñJdf9qEv n%zupr %2u2}n%o-v5upx2z2rT¬2rru

}v5@+n%r¹@fmx2rv5u2r*}v5r3p|v5u2ou2~Hn%v¤h@5ºfÃv5uÔp|nyzn%r

r2s-z}r3pnyx2rE+o-v5+rKq<o!n%xRonpp|n%z ¢©}z2z3}on%v5Yz3u2Pn%xr[h@5ºMf

qEon%x$o!npHg K*Ml0m d)fYxrv5u2r¦v5¤n%x2rv%¼pn%zn%rrsz}r3p¤n%x2r

h@5ºMfqEon%xHo!npRzz5po!n%o-}6}z2z3}on%v5)k l*MMEzu2'n%xr;+o-v5+r

qEon%xHz's-vq$v5u¼p|n%zn%r;r3po%p|nyv5dhEu¨o~52r¥´2K}v5@2z3o%pv5u¤v no/pp/qrCst

u!vwJx<yNz

v{n0z |}!}!n~

v}*u!s

/ /

70E*

*JN#*

7!!0/

¡#¢i*!

£

N¢!¤*!

!

@3¦¥#"E$&9:56i,,/.0%.0)!4#+/8+4/.=>+#,/5!%&.N'!2;+4-'04-.`5¦,34<;3.

f§[¨

@_&$Z

,

©

ª

©

ª

©

ª «¬««

®Z¯ =

°

± °±

°

± ²

³ ²

³

²

´ µ

µ¶

= ^>

>z

>3¬2

(4)

6.4 6.42 6.44 6.46 6.48 6.5 x 10⁴ -3

-2 -1 0 1 2 3

samples Ulisn

[V]

real reconstructed

"Zb=>.N'!+-1%(.*6'*)36c%(.*2N5¦)3+4%-1@2(4-.N6 i8Ae.)3.%C,/?4-.%

5!).3.%(5i6]

Cp

Cpm L

Ce Vex 2.LN

CN

CN ZN

ZN

@3@"

¨ =3?,/.*6:'*)'!?8!4/2*'!?i=>576i.*?

105 106 107

-60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10

W IENER vs. analytical transfer function

frequency[Hz]

dB(V)

W iener close W iener open analytical

@3C" $ %('*)3+-,/.%C,1)2(4-5¦)3+#,%5!= '*)'!?8!4/2N'!?7=>576i.*?'*)36Ae.0).0%#,/?4-.0%+

zu'²'o-rur@os!nyr?z3r{r3pru+n%rdMc%n1}z3u¬2ruvn%o}rnyx2zn<ou

zu~+r)ñ5ítôEÖ=»Â,í5;ô<Ö5Yn%x2r=srJ2rs%p@zu;ru52rsv2r3pbv51rz}x

pn%zn%r¾zrªpo?oszJHn%x2r¾+o>rru2}r3p¬2r~+o-uouÒn%x2r¾x2o~x

r¿ru2}or3p°z3u2~rM52rRnyvz}nKn%xzn@z ¬2r°po@sznyov5u+v5uBn

n%zt2rou¤n%v*z3}}vu+n@n%z3uporu+n@x2ru2v5?ruz51pv'n%xr'pn%zn%r3p{v

pr?o}v5u25},nyv5Jp¨z3rwuvnr+z3},nysB¢¦n%x2r§pz?r¤v56nyx2r3pr¤n-qEv

zv5z}x2r3p,dv5rv2rJn%z3up|rM%2u2}n%o-v5u=vm²'oru2rYos!nyrJpMo%p

prupo!nyoB2r@n%vRn%x2r@oB2oou2~=?v5?ru+nlyn%x2r3px2v5s=srJ2rsJdcu¥p|o!n%r

v¥o!n©on)o%p6oun%rrpn%ou~wn%v`prr*n%x2zn=n%x2rro%p;zs?vpní+5ó

o!%rru+n ¬2r,n-qErru vru zu2 }svpr p|nyzn%r5d$fmx2r n-qEv

v2z3~+zn%ov5up\znyx°v59Yc9zr[nyx+pm+o!%rru+ndd

cuRzuzsB¢5n%o}zsqEz¢?Í¸nyx2r[h@5ºf;zu21n%x2rKov5rKx2z 2rM¬2rru

r2s-z}r¤qEo!nyxwzpo@sr;2v5s!nyz~r*pv2}r3Pzu¤u2v*o-u2}n%oB2r

zz?rn%rJpPx2z 2r@¬2rru;n%ztru6o-u+n%v)z}}v2u+nv5Eou+nyr}v5u2ur}np

yo~dÕñJdèE+on%ov5u2z3ssB¢2z3ssm}z2z3}o!n%oB2r@zGp|r}npKx2z2r<¬2rru=t2rn

ou;n%x2rL?v5+rsso-u2~¸dÕf\q<v?zo-uzzGpon%o}R}z2z3}on%zu2}r3pJYr@n%v

n%x2r=s-z¢+vnEz3r=zs%pvn%zt2ruou+nyvz3}}vu+nN!ëd9fmx2o%p1srzpbn%v)z

2r%¢so~x+n;s-ou2rz©v5rs%Rzu¦n%x2rrv5r*n%vHz5pn)zu2`rz5p%¢

}zs}sznyov5upd

hEu?o-~rEî22²oru2rYos!n%rpYn%z3uprY%u2}n%ov5u?o%p\r3pru+nyr

ou`}v5@zo%pv5uwq<o!n%x`v5u2r*v¬+n%zo-u2rÂq<o!n%x§zuzsB¢5n%o}zs??v5+rsd

fmx2o%pRn%zuprR>u2}n%ov5u¼o%p{s-v5}zn%r'¬2rnq<rruvruzu*}s-vpr

z}}vu+np\v5·¬2vn%xLp|n%zn%r3p,d

fmx2o%ppr}n%o-v5u©xz5pMpx2vqEu@n%xznpou2~NzKo-s!n%rou2~@?rn%x2v5+o!n·o%p

vppoB¬2sr;n%v*oru+n%o!-¢*n%zuprR>u2}n%ov5upRsou+tou2~'n%xr=2v5s!n%z3~+r

z}vpJp¨n%x2r§h@5ºMf½nyvn%xrH2v5s!n%z3~+r`z}vpJp¯¶mcJe?dLf9qEv

o!%rru+n·n%zuprY%2u2}n%o-v5upMx2z2r¬2rruRoru+n%o!or2v5u2rKv5Yn%x2r

v5u§pn%znyrEv5u2r;v5Rn%x2rv%p|n%zn%r5dKfmx2r~rzn?ou+nyrr3pn?v?n%x2o%p

?rn%x2v5=o%p[n%xzno!nMv5r3pKu2vnmu2r}r3ppo!n%zn%rPz3u5¢©tu2vqEs-r~rPvmn%x2r

}v5u52rn%r)p|ny2}nr5dKc%n?o%p=zuHoru+n%o!o}zn%ov5u¤v5}rpJpJ<q<x2o}x

}v5upo+rJpKn%x2r?}v5u52rn%rEz5pKnqEv Ry¬2sz}t¬2v5+r3pRdfmx2o%pK?rn%x2v5

x2zGp[¬2rru;}v5@2z3r¥p2}}r3pp%2ss¢{qEon%x'èKóMmgHè1k¤z3u2zs¢2po%p

pou~=2r%¢{r}o%pr??v5+rsMvn%x2r?}v5u52rn%rKv5Erz}xpn%zn%r?v

n%x2r'h@ºf[d1èVpo@sr;zu2z3sB¢nyo}zsR?v5rs%bprHouHz5pn

qEv5tpKx2zGpKzs%pv@¬2rru}v5@zrRn%v@n%x2o%p?r,nyx2v5¸dh¬52ovpsB¢Lo!n

o%pYs-rpJp\r}oypr3¬+nn%x2rKv5rYvÕ?z~u2o!n+rIo%pYr3p2r}n%r¸d

cÀ@d g _

XZ[E\>¨

$ ^ b X $ W/[c\ [

W(¨

$&b:^

YZ\X

_ ¨ $ _ fPU@[

^

YcV

A

Y

_&

[ ^ f ¨

èK%n%rMn%x2r1o+ru+nyo!o}zn%ov5u=vmn%x2rEnq<v?p>¢p|nyrLpM}v5r3p|v5u2ou2~@n%v

n%x2r¬2v5vpn$o!nVo%p vppoB¬2srn%vUr}v5upn%2}n¾n%x2r mk

o%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rpdhEu=ºo-~¸dë=zrPr3pru+nyrN2v5s!n%z3~+r3p[r~o%pn%rrLv5u

¶mc5eÔv¬+n%zourRq<o!n%xz¬2r[n%o-©r°po@sznyov5up¤ou=}v5@zo%pv5u

qEon%x;r}v5up|ny2}n%r¥po~u2z3s%Õpou2~=n%x2r@nqEvL²'oru2ro-s!n%rJp,dè1p

6.11 6.12 6.13 6.14 6.15 6.16 6.17 6.18

x 10⁴ -6

-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4

samples Ulisn

[V]

real reconstructed

@3C"Zb +=1@?'04-.N6c9:4/2;

¨

'!3.% "]'*)6E%.N2*5!)+4%-1T24-.N6 i8Ae.0).0%#,/?4-.0%0

(5)

5.74 5.76 5.78 5.8 5.82 5.84 5.86 5.88 5.9 x 10⁴ -3

-2 -1 0 1 2

openpert

5.74 5.76 5.78 5.8 5.82 5.84 5.86 5.88 5.9

x 10⁴ -2

-1 0 1 2 3 4

samples Ulisn

[V]

closepert Ulisn

[V]

hKn%x2rLpr?o}v5u25},nyv5Jp°qEz 2rv5Lp@?z¢x2z2r?¬2rru6pr;v5

oru+n%o!o}znyov5uRz3u2?r}v5upn%}n%ov5ud5ôEvq<rJ2rJ©rzGp|r©ru+n·v

n%x2rÑ2v5s!n%z3~+rz}vpJp h@5ºf qEzGp½n%x2r?vp|n®po-°sr

>}v5@zrPn%v1}2ru+n·?r3p|r©ru+nv5moupn%zu2}rd

o~u2zs%p?ou'n%x2r=n%o?r=v5?zouprnyv;v¬+n%zo-u'²'o-rur1o-s!n%rJp

x2z 2r¬2rru v¬+n%z3ou2rUqEo!nyxro!n%xrVz3}}zn%ru+?ro-}z3s

po@2szn%ov5upMv5M?rz5pr?ru+npMv5u?n%x2rKrz3s¸v¬ÛJr}nd5fmx2r[r}oypr

èKóMmg`po-°szn%ov5upJÕnyztou2~=ou+nyvRz}}vu+nMz3ssp|n%z ¢=rs-r?ru+np

x2zGpR¬2rru¼}z3or¤vnEouHv5rRn%v'n%r3p|nNn%x2r)2zso-+o!né¢¤v?n%x2r

?rn%x2v5¦qEon%x«po@szn%rÓpo~u2zs%pd=o@2s-zn%ov5uoyp6r3p|r}ozss¢

ou+nyrr3pn%ou2~¥pou2}r?zsspo~u2zsypbz3r©z 2zos-z¬2sr5d·fYx2rN+zq¬2z}t)o%p

n%x2rÂpr?o}v5u252}n%v5©v5rsz3}},z}J¢zu¦n%x2rHo!%o}2s!né¢wn%v

rz}x6nyx2r=pn%rz3¢pzn%r3\qEon%x;n%x2rRs-z~r©n%o?rL}v5up|n%z3u+npPvIn%x2r

¶mc5e !Hñ5d;º·v5`©rzGp|r©ru+n>p'v5u2s¢Ã2v5sn%z~r3pÂqErr

z2z3osz ¬2srÓ>u2v_},ru+nprupv5Hou«n%x2r`}v5uG2rnyrJd=èv

}x2zuu2rs'vp}o-ssvp}vr¦qEzGp¤pr¸d)fmx2rÓpo-~+u2z3s%p¤x2z 2rH¬2rru

~zn%r3Ípv}r2v5s!n%z~r5dc>nNo%p°vpJpoB¬2s-r{n%v}x2v5vprz¥©v5?ru+n1v

po~+uzs+o2o+o-u2~E¬5¢?pr,n-n%ou2~PLp2on%z¬2srn%x2r3px2v5sd

º·o~52r3pXëÒzuìVpxvq³x2vq n%x2r ¶mcJ5e 2v5s!n%z3~+r$o%p

r}v5up|ny2}n%r$qEo!n%x pzn%o%p¢ou2~¾z}}2z3}J¢¸dèEss§po~+uzs%pv5u

o~52r3pPz3rRu2v5?zs-oÖr%©rz3u=2zs!r?o%pEÖrv5Kz3u2{r3pru+nyr

z5p@z=%2u2}n%o-v5u'vNpz@2s-rRu+1¬2rd·ôEvqErJ2rJYx2z 2ou2~;z=?v5r

r}o%prRs-v5vtv5u;n%x2o%p@po~u2zsIpx2vq1p1zRso!n-n%sr?+o>rru2}r3\znMn%x2r

¬2r~+o-u2u2ou2~=vn%x2r?pqEo!ny}xou2~Rv5}r3pJp,dfYxo%p[o!%rru2}r1?z¢@¬2r

zn-n%oB¬+n%r¨n%v'nyx2r;oB2rR}v5?°n%zn%ov5u[q<x2o}xHpqEo-u2~2p©v5

íÀ n%v ñ5À]qEo!n%xouz2v5o?znyrs¢wn%x2r¼pz3?r¨n%o-©rz5p;n%x2r

vqEr?po~+uzsE%í;n%v´ÀEd9cuz3},n>Yo!nIo%pPz3u2vn%x2r1+o%pn%¬2zu2}r

pv2}rKo-u°nyx2rK}v5u52rn%rd

cu¦v5r)n%vHr}v5up|ny2}n=?rz5pr2rn%¬2zn%o-v5uPÀ %5n

po~+uzs9x2z 2rK¬2rruRprRzGp[rrru2}r1ou++npo~u2zsdglrps!npMzr

rpru+n%rRv5uRo~ìdc>nm}zu?¬2r1u2vn%o-}r?n%x2znmuv5o%pr3pYn%x2zn9z+rz

ou;5ou2~)©rzGp|r©ru+nlzr?u2vnr}v5upn%2}n%r¥yº·o~d9ò=z5¬2

pou2}r©n%xr¢;z3rRu2vnI}v5rsznyr)qEo!n%xpv2}rLvEo%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rpNÍ

À dfYxzu+tpln%v@n%xr ! ¸onmo%pY2vpJpo¬2srKn%v

pr,zzn%r©nyx2rR}v5u+n%o¬++n%o-v5u6vIn%x2rL+oB2rKv5«n%x2r?v5u2r?vn%x2r

vqEr¨zn¥¬5¢«}x2v5vpou2~Ó+o>rru+n;n%xrpx2v5sÓou«oB2oou2~

v5}r3pJpEpv'oB2rR}v5u+nyoB¬++nyov5u¤}z3u'¬2r;r}v5upn%},nyrº·o~¸d

ò5zKv5EuvnIyº·o~d·ò¬2Jd;cu2+rr¸n%x2rPrztL¬2rv5r@}v5©@n%znyov5u

oupo@sznyrL%v5M?rzGp|r+9o%pn%¬2zu2}rKoypYu2vn·r}v5up|n%}n%r2

pou2}ro!n?v5rp=u2vnN+rru2*sou2rz3sB¢*v5u¤ÀdMv5rv2rJKon@o%p

vppoB¬2srRn%v)oB2or©rn-2%¬2zn%ov5upPo-unyx2rR~v+pbv51+o!%rru+n

}v5u52rn%r@pn%zn%rRz3u2v2z3~+zn%ov5upbznyx»¥v5uo~52r¥ívru

pn%zn%rLzu2¥}s-vprp|n%zn%r©rn%¬2zn%ov5upPzrprzznyrd9c%K}x2vpru

n%x2r3px2v5so%p6nyv5v¦x2o~x_pv5?r*2rn%¬2zn%o-v5u¦v5v5u2r¼p|nyzn%r

}v2s-¤¬2rpo~u2rHn%v¤n%x2rpr}v5u2§v5u2r5dPc%n=}zu¬2rrzGpv5u§v

o!%rru2}r3p¬2r,n-qErru o@2s%prUr3p2v5upr3p z3u2n%z3up|r

%2u},nyov5upKv¬+n%z3ou2rRqEo!nvn%x2rJpK?rn%x2v5=z3u2=v5u2r@oru+n%o!orN¬5¢

n%x2r¼²'oru2r6osn%r*yº·o~d?´ou_pr}n%ov5uÓccc|P¬+n)o!n)x2z5pu2v

ou+s!ru2}rKv5u?r}v5up|ny2}n%ov5u@v5}rpJpYou@n%o-©rI+v5?z3oud

À@d XZ[c\ XZV

b

¨TW/[c\

è "#$%&'()"*?rn%x2v5^x2z5p¬2rru r3pru+nyrXn%v

6.688 6.69 6.692 6.694 6.696 6.698 6.7 6.702

x 10⁴ -1.5

-1 -0.5 0 0.5

samples Ulisn

[V]

real reconstructed

@3+*C"*b6!1%()32*5!==1i4/'04-5!)=>.N'!+-1%(.*6:'*)6E%.N2*5!)+4%-1T24-.N6 i8Ae.0).0%

,/?4-.0%

+. 3'*%('04-)35!,C6¦%(,3.% 2*5!)!4%71¦4-5!)T

6.688 6.69 6.692 6.694 6.696 6.698 6.7 6.702

x 10⁴ -1.5

-1 -0.5 0 0.5

samples Ulisn

[V]

real reconstructed

@#*'"Zb 6!1%):2*5!==1i4-'04/5!)=>.N'!+-1%(.*6'*)36c%(.*2N5¦)3+4%-1@2(4-.N6 i8Ae.)3.%

,/?4-.0%

%.N2*5!)+4<%/1@24/5!)5!,#6!%(,3.%&2N5¦)¡4<%(i1i4/5!)@

(6)

@ Z@?4-.% +-8i)!4;.N++

r,nyr?ourn%x2r;?z3ou¤}zprv1mc@o%p|n-2%¬2z3u2}rv5o~ou2znyr

v5TzwvqEr*rsr},nyv5u2o}3p¨}v5u52rn%rdLfYxo%p¯nyr@v5zs)zu2

r¿ru2}J¢6?rn%x2v5p@}z3u6pr=ro!nyx2r@?rzGp|r?run1po~+uzs%p@v5

po@2szn%ov5updmc>n<x2z5pE¬2rru'zsor;n%v;z?¬2v5vpnEpqEon%}x2ou2~;}rss%

qExrr12vq<rh@5ºMf2v5s!nyz~r@o%pEpx2vqEu=zGpln%x2r1?zouRmk

z}n%v5mzu@r}v5up|n%}n%ov5up9qEv5tpY¿o!n%rI~+v5v5Nzu2PzGp|nd

zso}zn%o-v5upEp|}x=z5pMiNk[ÍiNk6¬2v5vpnm}v5u52rn%r}z3u?¬2rbpr?n%v

r}v5up|ny2}n1~rurzn%r6rn2%¬2zn%ov5up?zu2ou2v+nIn%x2r=so-u+tp

o@2s%prRr3p2v5uprL}z3u)¬2rRr,our¥ouv5+rEn%vr3p}oB¬2r?Yc

zn%xpd

hEu2}r'n%xr*+o!%rru+nRn%z3upr%u2}n%ov5up;z3r't2u2vq<uPo!nLo%p

vppoB¬2srn%vP}x2z3u2~r[n%x2r<pxzrKvmpv}r3p\q<z2rv5LpM!2v5s!nyz~rp

v5?}2ru+n1v°pr?o}v5u252}n%v5JpMn%v}x2r},t¯x2vqXo!n<ou+s!ru2}rp

n%x2r rn%¬2zn%ov5upÃpx2z2r$z3u2VsrJ2rsd¨º·v5Óoupn%zu}r3Hpv%n

pqEo!n%}x2o-u2~Ò?z¢¾¬2r$ou52r3pn%o~zn%r¾2r%¢ ¿5o}t2sB¢dèEu2vn%x2r

ou+nyrr3pn%ou2~z+so}znyov5u*px2vs)¬2rRn%vpn23¢;n%x2r=ou+s!ru2}rRv

n%x2r?oB2rKou)x2z3)p|q<o!n%}x2ou2~Rv5}r3ppd2º·v5Koupn%z3u2}r¸nyx2r@v5sr

vE~znyrRr3poyp|n%v51oupo@2sr?oB2rJpb}z3u=¬2r?rzGpo-sB¢{u2rs-ou2r¸d

?z¢Rn%x+pM¬2r@o??r+o-zn%rsB¢=}x2r}t2rdfYx2rrv5r3²'oru2rMos!n%r

}zu1¬2rKzKvqEr%snyv5v5s¸5ou2~Pn%xrKrpo~u@2v5}r3ppd

os!n%r§rpo~ud;cu$v5+rHn%vXrz}x n%x2rrn-2%¬2zn%ov5u$srJ2rs

r3p|nyo}n%r ¬5¢$YcÔp|nyzu2zpp2o!nyz¬2sr«os!n%rÔpx2vsX¬2r

ou+s!ru2}rvn%x2rÓo!%rru+n*n¢52rÓvo-s!n%rJpwv5u^~+ru2rznyr

rn-2%¬2zn%ov5udè ¬2r,n-n%rtu2vqEs-r~r v¦mkT~+ru2rznyov5u

?r}xzu2o%pLp6qEvszs-svqVz*¬2rnn%r;os!n%rp%¢+u+n%xrpo%pd@èK%n%r

v¬+n%z3ou2ou2~Ózu Rv+nyo?zs*R'osn%r'v5*rz3}x p|n%zn%r3{on;?z¢§¬2r

pn2or;x2vqnyv=}v51¬2our°nyx2rÃo-u+n%v=z=pou2~srLpn%2}nr5d9º·o~¸d

í+Jd?fYx2oyp'z2v5z3}xqEo-ss?¬2r¨rx2zpr3pru+nyr`ou¦%+n-2r

qEv5t·d

g

_&@_&^Z_

\ X _ ¨

#$% C

X

57+4-''& _ V

'!5!1%(.& C@5¦%(.*+4&

¨ V

.0,/.,7%(.)(JaE1@'*)¡4-,/2*'04/5!) '*)6

=>)3=>*!'04/5!)>5¦, 2*5!)6!1@24/.*6)!4/.%/,/.%(.)32*.*+&i.)3.%('04-.N6);3'*%6:+-9:4-20;):'*)6

*!.0%5:21%/%(.)¡4#+-9:4/2;3)32*.N??(+&

YEU

_

X-,

* &.*¥

!@. * @

#/ % U f

1@+0*N)221@&43 V ¨

2;3'*).0) & E Y ??'*%(6&

U X

;7%*!'*)5(

Y

2N21%('04-.G=>576i.*?)3B5!,

?'*835!1i4 3'*%('!+4/2G4-5e,/5¦%(.*2N'!+4 _ fPW

.0=>44-.*6e,%5!= ' X X

2*5!),3.%4-.0%(6&

U _

¨X87

&

Y

'!20;.0) &9.0%-=>'*)i8

#¥ % ^Z5i++.(44/5&:9 3'**!& $ .)¡4-;(Z5i5i+4 9:4;< *e+-9:4-20;)

,%(.?!1@.)328 i%5#,36i)3L5¦1i471¦4 ,35i?4-'!i.G+4-'!3?*¡'04-5!)e'*)36L2*5!=?'*)32*. 9:4<;

_

fPX

+4-'*)367'*%(67++(+&

W

_&_&_ 4%'*)3+&5!) W/Y¨

&

57?¥ ) @'&30'*)

.:/

7A7 7

# % E AB6¦%(5¦9 .(4 '!?&B(

Y

67'!¡4-,. )5i+. 2*'*)32*.N??)@" i%()32*3?. '*)6

'!?2*'04/5!)++(+&

W

_&_&_

U

%(572N.*.N67)i+6&

5i? ¥A&:.*2!* &TC!(* /

!@

#% E^Z.,5i?&.3*^Z5!1@6i.4&3 V ¨

20;'*)3.)A&

U V

5i*¡.*?.4-(_

f§W

+41@6!8 5!, 'E4<;i%.N. i;'!+(.

),3.%4-.%

@.*6

f

5N4-5!% c%(,3.*++(+&

W/Y¨:7

&

¨

.*'044-?.&

[

24/53.%D/

7 7

# % 3X X

%$E3.%$&3N^Z5¦1T67.(40&3N V ¨

20;'*)3.)A&(_

fPW

'*)'!?8+(+5!,`+)37?. 7;3'!+.

U X

3575i+4 %(.*2(4-,/.%`) 4<;3.c,%(.?!1@.0)208 6i5¦=>'!)(6&@^Z.,71@.

W

)¡4-.0%-)3'04-5¦)3'!?.:67.F94E0).

_&?.N24%?¦1@.&

5i?/)A@6/**(* &:/D / ¡

# % 3V ¨ 20;'*)3.)A&

V 305!1%(67'*)A&3N^Z5!1@6i.4:(

V

'*835¦1i4E5!4/=>*¡'04-5¦) 4-5 %(.*6!1@2*.>_

fPW

5!,#'

¨fPUC¨

(6&

U

.N+2-/

7 7

/ &

X

'!%/)+6&iac1T.*.)3+?'*)6&

Y

1@+4<%('!?'i

#% C

X

5i+4-''&3_ V

'!35¦13%.&7C!AB?=>5N40&i#!@5¦%(.*+4G

V

.N+%$H&7C!^Z.i8 &i^EZ'*1@+.%(.&

X

G^Z5¦=3'*1i4&

Y ) )i)35+,3'04-,. i'04-. 6!%,.]4/5 2N5¦)¡4<%(5i?P.*?.*2(4<%(5¦=>'!!).(4-2

3.%4<1%'04/5!)+:.=>44-.N6 78G'

f

5i+-,/.(4Z2;35.0%6I>_

U _ ,

** &

V

'*1@+'*)i).&

¨

1@+(+.&

¨ .¡4-.0=.0%J**(*@

#* %

¨

'!+(.*!;K

Y

6+,3'*)2N.6774-'!?&+¦)3'!? i%5i2*.N++)3 '*)36 )357+.%.N6¦1T24-5¦)AI

/

7 7A7

35!;i)Ae?.08:L

¨

5¦)3+

V

4-6