HAL Id: inria-00072165
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072165
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
Nearest-Neighbor Searches
Sid-Ahmed Berrani, Laurent Amsaleg, Patrick Gros
To cite this version:
Sid-Ahmed Berrani, Laurent Amsaleg, Patrick Gros. Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast
Nearest-Neighbor Searches. [Research Report] RR-4423, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072165�
ISRN INRIA/RR--4423--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 3
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast Nearest-Neighbor Searches
Sid-Ahmed Berrani — Laurent Amsaleg — Patrick Gros
N° 4423
Mars 2002
- &,/. - 1023546&3"
78:9;=<>"?A@B9DCE@GFHFJILK"8NMPORQSIUT"FV@BK/W+<?AXJIUYZ@B[]\!OR^_ILWJFV8:`badcPFHeUX$\
fhgjikmlnoqpsrBtulVvxwGyztx{}|Gr+gj|GkEkml~:k6wy=g{}rjlG
{k6wGlV Vj|rjrjVlV Vjy|Grjrw{ x uwrylH
Rvx|ltflkml
SwjU|vutSl3vxlVy=gjlVvxy=gjlrnowvx SG(o1wGlV
+V ¡b¢j£ ¤
fhgj{ ¥wLlVvlH uyvu{¦UlV ¥wArl§wjjvx|GwGy=g¨©|v¥LlVvª¨©|Gvukm{rjAl«$y{lrBtwjjvx|J{}k6wtulVrlVwvxlV ªtª~
rl{g¦L|Gv¬ ulVwvxy=glV S{rg{}Gg~Nj{}kmlrL ª{|rwwbtxw¦w ulV V®3fhgj{ ¬wjjvx|GwGy=gw}|b§S _w$¯rlEy|rBtuvx||b°lVv
txgjlvulHy{ ª{|rP|¨txgjlm ªlHwv=y=g¦±¥ ªltªtx{}rj+tugjl1k6wb{}k1²jk³jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±$¨©|v¬w$°GlVyztx|vtxgwbt¬§´|G²jP¦Ll
{rPtxgjllwGyzt(wr u§´lVvµ ultµtx|+¦Ulkm{ u u{}r${}rtugjlmwjvu|J{kmwtulH ult¬|¨¶wr ª§lv= V®pNt¬w x u²jkmlV txgwbt
¨©lHwbtx²jvulE°lHyztx|v= ¬wvul1lry}|B ªlH{r·y² txlv= ®6¸_rjlE|¨¶txgjl6y|GrGtxvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr|¨¶tug{ (wLlVv3{ _txgjl$y|Gk1~
²txwtu{|r$|¨y|GrGtxvu|G}lV6wjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}|Gr ¹|¨,lVwy=g!y² txlvH®fhglV ul_wjvu|J{k6wbtu{|rL RlUlrL$|r+tugjl
j{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r6|¨/wbtxw§{ºtxgj{}r+lVwy=g6y}² ªtulVvV®¹f|wrL ª§lvRw»B²jlVvu±Gtxgjl_ ulVwvxy=gmjvx|ylV x Ry|r u{jlv= "tugjl
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}|Gr "txgwbty|GvuvxlV uL|Gr1tu|1tugjl(lH ª{vulHm}lV°lVL|¨jvxlVy{ u{}|Gr,®fhg{ ´k6wJ±myVw² ulStxgjl(wyztx²w
rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= ´|¨txgjl»B²jlVvu±$U|{rBthtu|6¦Ul3{}Grj|vxlV/®¶¸_²jvkmltugj|/Lgj|b§´lV°lVvVBjvx|¦w¦j{}{ tx{yVw}±
¦U|²rj ¶tugjl¬y=gwrylV R¨©|v´tugj{ Rtx|gwjUlr,®¹fhgj{ ¶LwUlvhw ª|vulH ªlVrGt= ¶wLlVvª¨©|Gvuk6wrLylS ªtu²±6|¨/tugjl
{kmjlkmlrBtxwtu{|r,®¼2l1 ugj|b§3¨©|vµljwkmjltugwtStugj{ Skmltugj|¥{ Skm|vxl(tugwrEtu{kmlV S¨½w ªtulvStugwr
txgjlµ ulV»B²jlVrGtx{w xywrm§gjlVr6{ºt´gwrj}lH ¹km|vxlhtugwrP¾¿ÁÀE¾VÂÃS~s{kElVr u{}|Gr "°lHyztu|Gvx VlV°lrm§gjlVrmtugjl
vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±6|¨km{ u u{}rE|Grjl(|¨tugjl¬txvu²jl3rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= ´{ h¦Ul|b§Ä®Å®
ÆPÇBÈÉxÊË ¡b̤ÎÍ jjvx|J{}k6wtul3rjlHwvxlV ªtSrjl{g¦U|vµ ulVwvxy=gjlGjk²ºtx{{kmlr u{|rw{rl{rjUy|GrGtxlrBtª~
¦Lw ulV!vultuvx{}lV°Jw
ÏRÐÑHÒzÓÔ:ÒzÕ_Ö(×JØÙ:ÚÁÓÛÜJÚÞݶßà¹áãâbäZÝ=ÕJåæçèzçJݪé_êæØÁØÁæ"âbÒzÕÙNÝ=ÚÁÕJæzçê/ë¥èªìHíUîzïzïHèzè´ð/æÔZÔ:ÒzÕHñ½òÛéVÚÁózÕJÛ¹ñLâbä:Ý=ÕJåæzí
ô¹õLö
×JÚÁ÷æ¹ÐæøVÓæsøGçHù©ßù½òúñ½ð/ûßòí
¤ l6v=wjU|vut¬vuH ªlVrGtxlm²jrjl6rj|G²j°lV}ltxlVy=gjr{»B²jl6U|²jv3vxlVy=glv=y=gjlv(lm¨½w|r2wjjvx|~
y=glm}lH (j² (jvx|y=glV (°|G{ u{r (²r2°GlVytul²v¬vxlV»B²tul6w²· ul{r·jlE¦Lw ulV (l$|GrjrjlH (gw²jtulkmlVrGt
k1²j}tu{{}kmlVr ª{|rrjl}lH ® ltutulEtulHy=gjrj{»B²jl6y|rBtxvG}l1wjvxVy{ u{}|Grlmw!vxlVy=glv=y=gjllVr¨©|Gryztx{}|Gr2l
w1jvu|G¦w¦{}{ºtxµk6wb{k6wl¬»B²jl¬|rwl(rjl¬wG ´vxltxvu|G²j°lVv´jwr ´}l(vxV u²jºt=wbthwjjvx|y=gjµ²r!°GlVyztxl²jv
»B²j{h ulv=w{}tjvxV ulrBtEjwr lvuH ª²j}txwtljwGyztV® ltutul!tulVy=grj{»B²jllk6wrlãyl»G²l+lV 1°lVytulV²jvx
u|{lrBtSw²¥jvxVww¦jl¬vxlGvu|G²jUV jwr lV µwvutu{}tu{|rL "!$#&%')("*+%-,z®/.w6y|GrGtxvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr!k6wl²jvxllyl
txvxwJ°bw{}lV ªt_²jrjl1kmtug|jlU|²jv(ywy²j}lVvµ²jrlr ulk1¦j}lEl¨©|GvukmlH Slr|¦wrGtxlV _wjjvx|y=gjlH U|²jv
y=gLw»B²jl0 "!$#&%')("*z®1.,lH ´yVwv=wyztxvx{ ªtu{»B²jlV ¶lV ¶¨©|vxkmlV RlVrj|¦LwrBtulH ¶wjvu|y=gjVlV RjUlrlVrBthl_w1{ ~
txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr+lH ¶°GlVyztxl²jv= ¶w²+ ul{r!l¬y=gw»B²jl0 "!$#&%'2(*(ltw²L u u{LlH ¶r{}°GlVw²j6jlµjvxVy{ u{}|Gr6jvxV¯rj{ ®
|Grb|{rBtulVkElVrBt3 uw+vulH»B²txl/4²tx{}{ uwtul²v(j|{}t¬¨©|G²jvxrj{}v¬²jrãtxw²lEjvuHy{ ª{|r2ywvxwGyztuVvu{ xwrBtSw
»B²w}{}tulwµvuVL|Gr ªl»B²5{ ª|G²jgw{ºtxl®76µrjl´¨©|{ wrylGbwµvulHy=gjlv=y=gjlRr5²tx{}{ ulhw|v= »B²jl¶lV ¨©|GvukmlV
lVrj|¦LwrBtulH wjjvx|y=gjlH »B²j{w²jvx|rBthtu3vu~NyVwy²jlH ´U|²vµyl¬txw²/®¹ps ul¬Ul²jt_w{r u{,»G²8²jr¥|G²
}² u{l²jv= lH j² jvu|y=gjlH 3°|G{ u{r 3ljwGyztx 1² U|{rGtEvulH»B²txl+ ª|G{}lVrBt{}Grj|vxV V®:9S|txvul+kEtugj|l
¦U|vxrjlµjlµ¨½w;|r6vu|G¦w¦j{{ ªtulSlV y=gwrylH RU|²jvh»B²jl_ylwwvxvu{°lG® l_vxwjU|vut¶jvxV ulrBtulSVGw}lVkElVrBt
²rjlPtx²llUvx{kElVrBtxwlPlV +LlVvª¨©|Gvuk6wrylH Ejlyltªtul¥txlVy=gjr{»B²jlG® ltutultu²jlPkE|GrBtuvxlhwv
llkmjl¹»B²jl+U|²jv¾<=À·¾VÂ Ã °lHyztxl²jv= wJ±BwrBt1bj{}kmlrL ª{|r V"wvulHy=gjlv=y=gjl$wjjvx|y=gl6lV ªtµ²L ~
»B²5$E¨©|G{ }² µvxwj{l»B²5²rjlvxlVy=gjlVvxy=gjl3 uV»B²jlVrGtx{}lV}lLk=kml|v= u»B²jl3wmjvx|¦w¦j{}{}tu{rj|GvulVv
²r¥jlV hj² jvx|y=gjlV °G|{ ª{r hljwGyztx h²¥U|{rBtSvulH»G²>tul(lH tS{r¨©vx{l²jvxlEÅ®
?Ë H É £@ ·¤ lVy=gjlVvxy=glmwjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}°Gl6lV 3}² jvx|y=glV (°|G{ u{r {}rLljwbtx{}|Gr·k²j}tu{{kElVr~
u{|rjrjlV}lvxlVy=glv=y=gjl_Lwvh}ly|rBtulVr²
% &
1" !¶
psk6wlhjwbt=w¦wG ªlH wrtugjlVvul¨©|vxlhy|rBtulVrBtª~N¦w ulVvultuvx{}lV°Jw ª± ªtulk6 "gwJ°Gl´¦UlVy|kmlh{}rLyvxlVw u{rj±3{}kE~
U|vutxwrBt{r1k6wrB±wjj{yVwbtx{}|Gr "wvxlVw u²y=gEwG kElH{y{rjlGl|Gv=wjg±J§lVwtugjlVvª~:¨©|vxlVyVw ªtVHkE|G}lHy²jwv
¦{}|G}|G±wvutV" ªlHy²jvx{ºt±GR¿¿V¿ |rBtulVrBtª~N¦w ulVã{}k6wl6vxltuvx{l°bwR u± txlk6 3vxl±|r·{k6wl6vu|ylH u u{rj
txlVy=gjr{»B²jlH Stx|!lBtxvxwGyzt'(% "* '( *+%E¨©vx|k5{kmwlH *)+,3.-0/2143N®65µlH uyvu{tu|Gvx µlry|l1{r¨©|Gvuk6wbtx{}|Gr
¨©|G²jr {rd{k6wlH ® fhgl±wvxlPt±j{yVw}± °lHyztx|v= 6|¨vxlVwµr²jk¦Ulv= +jl¯rj{rj L|G{}rBtx +{}rÄw gj{g~
j{}kmlrL ª{|rw, ªLwylG®Rfhgjl3 ª{km{}wvx{}t±$|¨t§´|m{k6wlH h{ wG u u²jkmlV!tx|E¦Ul3jvx|U|vutu{|rwUtu|mtugl ª{km{º~
wvx{}t±$|¨tugjlV{}v¬lV xyvx{tu|Gvx V§gj{y=g{ kmlVwG ª²vulHwG tugjlt±j{yw±87R²y}{lHwr ,j{ ªtxwryl3¦Ult§llVr
txgjl3U|{rGt= Sl¯rjlV¦±$txgjllH uyvu{tu|Gvx V®:9{km{}wvx{ºt±! ªlHwv=y=g!{ tugjlVvul¨©|vxl(|¨tulVrP{}kmjlkmlVrGtxlV¥w w
rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|vh ulVwv=y=g 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=g ,´§{}tugj{rtugjl(¨©lHwbtx²jvul3 uwyl®
9µlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|vm ulVwv=y=gA{ m{rjgjlvxlrBtx}±]lLlVr ª{°l¥wrL l¯rj{rj l«$y{}lVrGt6kmltxgj|j E¨©|v6{r~
jl{}rEwvxl¬gj{g~s{kmlr u{}|Grw,wbtxwG ªltx hvxlk6w{r wr!²jrL ª|G}°GlV!jvu|G¦jlk¥® Í ,l{ tx{}rE{rl{}rj
xy=gjlVkElH Elrlv=w}± §|v<; §´lV}h¨©|Gv6}|b§h~s{kmlr u{}|Grw uwylV V® fhgl{v6LlVvª¨©|Gvuk6wrLyl´gj|b§l°lVvV¶{
;rj|b§rtu|_jlv=wjl´w tugl´r²jk1¦LlVv|¨L{kElVr u{}|Gr |¨jtugllH uyvu{tx|v= ,{ryvxlVwG ªlG®fhgj{ gjlrj|Gkmlrj|Gr
{ =;rj|b§r·w ¬txgjl "# *+%(> 8'?=(%?@ !'Ab®psr·|tuglv§|v=j V,rwJ°{}Bwbtx{}rj§{}tugj{r2tugjl${rlã¦Ul~
y|kmlV "km|Gvulhy|B tx}±3txgwr6w( u{}kmjlG¦jvu²jtul¨©|v=ylG ªlH»B²jlrBtu{wj xywr1{rEgj{}Gg~s{}kmlVr ª{|rm uwylV "§gjlVr
ulVwvxy=g{}rj6rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= V®B+S|b§l°GlvHL ulV»B²jlVrGtx{w xywr µwvulEylVwvu±!{r¨©lHw u{}¦jl1¨©|v¬°lvx±wvuGl
{k6wGl(wbtxw¦w ulV V®
fhgjlEy²jv= ul|¨¶j{}kmlrL ª{|rw}{}t±jgjlr|kmlrj|Gr{ µwvªtx{y²jwvx}±jvxl°bwlrBtµ§gjlVrUlvu¨©|vxkE{rj (<
; ' 9 9~s ªlHwv=y=gjlV V®¶fhgjlVvul¨©|vxltxgjlvxl3{ _wr¥{ryvxlVwG ª{rjm{}rBtxlvxlV ªtS{}rPUlvu¨©|vxkm{}rj. *<C ')(=9 9~
ulVwvxy=glV V,§gjlvxl$vxlV u²j}t1»B²w{ºt±ã{ tuv=wlH㨩|vvxlVj²ylH2»B²jlVvu±2llHy²tx{}|Grãtx{}kmlD)¼FEh3:®Pf|¦Ll
²L ªl¨©²j{}r jv=wytu{yl¶tugj{ Etuv=wjl~N|?Gd ª²lH t= tx|·kmw;l!tugjl¥² ulv6w¦j}ltx|2 ult6gj{k6 ªlVº¨¬tugjl¥jvxlVy{º~
u{|r]|¨Stugjl¥wjvu|J{k6wbtul ªlHwv=y=g]lUlrL{}rã|Gr]tugllH ª{vxlVAwGyy²jvxwGy±G®ãpNt6w ª|2 ª²lH t= txgwbt
txgjl²jrLlvx}±{rj$ ulVwv=y=gjvu|ylV x hvulH ªUlVytx h¨½w{ºtxg¨©²j}±!tugj{ µ ultutu{rjtugwtS{ V{}tµk1² t_rj|tSvxltx²jvurPwr
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlhvulH ª²j}t¶|¨w(§´|Gvx ulS»B²w{ºt±1tugLwrmtuglµ|rlSlUlVyztxlV/Bk6w?;{rj{rmtugj{ ´yVw ulhtugjl¬ ªltªtx{}rj
kmlHwrj{rjlV x V®·fhg{ E{ 1{r lrlv=w¶°Glvx± {º«$y²jºtH´wr]km|G ªtm|¨Stxgjl¥l{ ªtu{rj2 tx²{lV Elj|vx{}r
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl9 9~s ulVwv=y=gjlH |$rj|tµjvx|b°B{l3 u²y=gy|GrGtxvu|GZl{}tugjlVvµ¦UlVyw² ul3|¨¹|b°lVvª~s ª{kmj{º¯lH!wG ~
u²jkmtx{}|Gr hvulH ª²ºtx{}rj6{r¥rj|mvulHw,y|rBtuvx|:|v¦UlVyVw² ul¬tugjl=;rj|G¦8½ +,´¨©|vS ultutu{rj6jvxlVy{ u{}|GrwGyztu²Lw}±
y|rBtuvx||b§h~:l°Gl/ u± ªtulVk wvxwkEltulVvx ´tugLwbtV§gjlrPy=gwrjlH/gwJ°l¬°lVvu±$|G¦ xy²jvxl¬y|r ulV»B²jlVrylH ®
psrmy|GrGtxvxwG tHJtugj{ "wLlVv"jlV xyvx{}¦UlV "w¬kmltug|tugLwbt¹jvx|b°B{lH wrEwGyy²vxwtul¶vu|G¦w¦j{{ ªtu{y´y|rBtuvx|
|b°GlvtxgjlvulHy{ ª{|r¥|¨¶wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=gjlH ®Sfhg{ _y|rBtxvu|GgwG tugl{rGtxlvxlV ªtu{rj$jvx|Ulvutu{lV
tx|m¦LlH
I }lHwvx}±!²jrlVvx ªtxwrjw¦j}l3¦±lr~:² ulv= V® 6_ ªlVvx SwvulwG J;GlV!tu|+jvu|b°{ljtu|Gltxgjlv_§{ºtxg¥tugjlV{}v
»B²jlvx±bwSvu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±=KywlV(txgjlB * ( %!(L ("!8¾"M=K!{ tuglvxl¨©|vxl¶yVw}lH(tugjljvxlVy{ u{}|Gr
}lV°lV,®"fhg{ ´jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±Ey|vxvulH ªU|r "tu|tugjl_jvu|G¦w¦{}{ºt±1¨©|vw°GlVyztx|v¹txgwbth¦Ul|rjB ¹tu|tugjl
ljwyt!wrL ª§lv+ ult+tu|]¦Ulwytu²w}± kE{ x ª{rj]{rtugjl2wjvu|J{kmwtulP ult+|¨3wr u§´lVvx mtxgwbt!{
l°GlrBtu²w}±$vxltx²jvurlV/®
I
f²rw¦jlwbtvx²jr~:tu{kml® Í ² ulvSyVwrvulH ª²¦jkm{ºtSgj{ »B²jlvx±$§{}tugPw6{NGUlVvulVrBthvulHy{ ª{|r¥ ªltªtx{}rj
{º¨gjlµ¨©lVl ´tugwt¶tugl¬y²jvuvxlrBth ªltªtu{rj1{ rj|twjlV»B²wbtxl0©tu||1y|Gwv= ul¨©|vljwkmjl ,® gwrjG{}r
tugjlP ultutu{rjã§{rj|t6yw² ªlwr± ltxvxwãy|G ªtEtu|2¦Ll¥wjjlV |r txgjl¥l°bw²wbtx{}|GrA|¨_»B²jlvx{}lH ®
fhgjl(jvx|U|G ulV+ xy=gjlVkEl(w|b§S ¶² ulv= ´tu|mv=wyl¨©²j±my=gLwrjGlµtxgjl(jvulHy{ ª{|r ªltªtx{}rjB v=wr{rj
¨©vu|Gktxgjlµ|G x u}lH u R ulVwvxy=gbtu||b§lvRjvxlVy{ u{|rm}lV°lV V® Í ¶lLlHyztulH/Bgj{}Ggjlv´jvxlVy{ u{}|GrmyVw² ulV
gj{gjlVvµvxlV uL|Gr ªl¬tx{}kml½k²y=g¥¨½wG txlvtxgwrw+ ªlH»G²lrBtu{w ulVwvxy=gjgj|b§l°lVv+,®¶psrwGj{}tu{|r,U{ºt
{ _U|G x ª{¦jl3tu|$²L ªl3txgj{ µkmltxgj|tu|!¦j²j{w6 u± txlk³{rP§gj{y=g¥txgjlvulHy{ ª{|r¥|¨¹txgjlwr ª§lv
{}kmjvx|b°lH hw tugl(tu{kEl3G|lV h¦±®
I Í ¶y|B t= (wvxl1j²L ªgjlHtx|tugjl6|GL~N}{rjlmjgwG ªlG®1fhgjl6y|kmjlãyVwy²jwbtx{}|Gr ¬|¨wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
vxwG{² ªlH wvxl3w,LlVvª¨©|GvukmlH+|GL~N}{rjlG® Í tSvu²r~Ztx{}kmlGj|ryl=KA ultVjtugjl ulVwvxy=g¥w|Gvu{}tugjk²L t
rjllHj htx|m ullVyttugjly|vxvulH ªU|rL{}r1wjvu|Gjvx{wtul¬vxwG{}²L ªlH ¶tx|$y|Gr ª{lVvV®
I
7¹«$y{lrBtV®¶¸_²jv¹kmltugj|m{ "l«$y{lrBtR{r1txgjlµ ulr ultugwtR{ºtR{ ¹k1²y=g¨½wG txlv¹txgwrEtxgjlS ªlH»B²jlrBtu{w
uyVwrwrP{}t¬Ulvu¨©|vxk6wryl|lV _rj|t¬ ul°lVvulV}±¥lVv=wlH µw µtugl1{kmlr u{}|Gr|¨jwbt=w+wrLJ|Gv
tugjl u{ l3|¨tugjlwbtxw¦w ul¬{}ryvulHw ul®
fhgjlPkmltugj| w x u²jkmlV 1tugwt+°lHyztx|v= Ewvul¥lVry|G ulV {}rkm{rj{}k1²jk ¦L|G²jr{rj g±LlVvx ujgjlVvu{yw
y}²L txlv= ®fhgjljwtxwmU|{rGt= S¦Ul|rjG{}rmtu|+w6y}² ªtulVvµwvxl ªtu|vxlV!tx|ltugjlVv|r{ ;+{rw$ ªlH»B²jlrBtu{w
k6wrjrjlvH® 7¶wy=gy² ªtulvh{ wrw}±VlV6|GL~N}{rjl3wrL${rwGj{}tu{|r$tx|Etugjl(ljwGyzthvxwG{}²L ¶|¨lVwGy=g+g±LlVvª~
ujgjlVvulGwjjvx|J{}k6wtulSv=w{² ulV wvxl_y|kmj²txlV/lHwy=g+y|vxvulH ªU|rj{}rjtu|mwjvxlVjltulVvukm{rjlV+}lV°lVU|¨
{kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr,®fhgl_wjvu|J{k6wbtulµvxwG{}²L ªlH ¹|¨wy² txlvhwvxlµw§hwJ± ¶ ªk6wlv´tugwr${ºt= ¶ljwyztvxwG{² ®
f|1wr ª§lv´w»B²jlvx±Gtuglµ² ulv´gw Rtu|vu|b°{lµwr+{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr6}lV°lVLy|GrBtuvx|}{rj(tugl¬»B²w}{}t±1|¨
txgjl_wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=g,®"fhgj{ ¶{kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr6}lV°lUvx{}°GlV R§g{y=g+wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlvxwG{² ªlH Rk1² t
¦UlEtxw;lrã{}rBtx|¥wGyy|²jrBt(¦B±¥txgjlE¯}tulvx{rj¥vu²jlV _txgwbt3l{kE{rwtulm{}vxvxll°bwrBt3y² txlv= ®*7R}{km{}rLwbtu{rj
y}²L txlv= |Grtugl´¦wG ª{ |¨jtxgjl{v¹wjjvx|J{}k6wtulRv=w{² ulV {}r ªtulHw|rtxgjl¦w u{ |¨tugjlV{}v"ljwGyztv=wj{}² ulV
k6wJ±+yVw² ul_tugjl8; '4# !rjlVwvulH tu~:rl{g¦L|Gvx ´|¨tugjl»B²jlVvu±+L|G{}rBttu|m¦Ul3{}Grj|vxlV,®
fhgjlµvulH tR|¨Ltxgj{ ¶wUlv¶{ ¶|vxGwr{VlVwG "¨©||b§S ®09lVytu{|r$({ uy² x ªlH ¹vulVwtulH1§|v<;® 9lHyztx{}|Grmn
G{}°GlV 3w|¦Lw¹|b°lVvu°{l§ |¨´txgjl$ ulVwv=y=gãtulVy=grj{»B²jlG®+fhgjlVr, 9lHyztx{}|Gr2PvulH ªlVrGt= ¬tugjl6kmltugj|㨩|v
wGyy²jvxwtulV}±·y|GrGtxvu|G}{rj¥tugjljvxlVy{ u{}|Gr |¨µwjjvx|J{k6wbtxl 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=gjlH ® 9lVytu{|r l°bw²wbtxlV tugjl
Ulvu¨©|vxk6wryl_|¨txgjl(tulHy=gjrj{»B²jl3wr 9lHyztu{|rmy|Gry²lH wr¥{ uy² x ªlH ´|GLlVr¥{ x ª²lV V®
&(
fhg{ R ulVytu{|r6{ uy² x ªlH "vulVwtulV1§|v<;U®¼ãlS¯vx ªtR|b°lVvu°{l§ txvxwG{}tu{|rwk²j}tu{{kElVr u{}|Grwj{rl{}rj
wjjvx|GwGy=gjlV (wy=g{}lV°B{rj¥ljwGyzt 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=glV V®$¼ãl+lV uLlHy{w}±¨©|y² 3|Grãtxgjl6¯}tulVvu{rjPvx²jlV (txgjlV ulV
txlVy=gjr{»B²jlH S² ul3tu|!vxwk6wbtu{yw}±$vxlV²Lyl3txgjl{vµvxlV uL|Gr ul(tu{kElH ®¼2ltxgjlrkE|b°Gl(tu|+wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
9 9~s ªlHwv=y=g! xy=gjlkmlH ®
"!$#&%('*)+,'!.-0/21.*
fv=w{}tu{|rwk1²jºtx{j{}kmlrL ª{|rw{rl{}rj+tulHy=gjrj{»G²lV µt±B{yVw}±¥{°B{l1tugjlEjwbt=w+ uwyl{rGtx|!yl
y|rBtxw{}r{}rjP°GlVytu|v= V® ly|r ªtuvx²yztx{}|Gr] txvxwtulV{lV yVwr ¦UlywG u u{º¯LlV2{}rAt§´|P¦vu|Bw ywtulV|vx{lV 4H
' '( *''? 2mwr % +( *' ' 2E{}rLl{rj3kmltug| ®05¬wbtxw~:Lwvutu{}tu{|rj{rj(kmltug| R ª²Ly=g
wG Stxgjl43S~sfvxll )E ,=,=/5 3"|Gvµtxgjl9"9B~sfvxll>)¼76 /8 3Rl¯rjlmylV} (wyy|v={rj6tu|!tuglE{ ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{|r|¨
°GlVytu|v= V® 9Lwyl~:Lwvutu{}tu{|rj{rjkmltugj|j S u²y=gw tugl3. 9 5 g
~Nfvxll )+µlr /59 3|v$)¼ 9 E /89 3j{}°{l(tugjl
wbtxwm uwyl({}rBtu|6yl w}|GrjmjvulHl¯LrjlV!}{rjlH vulVGwvxlV x ´|¨txgjlwytu²w,{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr|¨°GlVyztx|v= ®
9 9~sw|vx{}tugjk6 ¬t±j{yw±P² ªlmtxgjl6lV|kmltxvu{yw"jvu|GLlVvªtx{}lH ¬|¨yl ¬tu|¥l{}km{rwbtxlmtugj|B ªl6yl
txgwbt¹ywrrj|t¹gwJ°lwr±3{}kmwGyzt"|rtugjlhvxlV u²jºt"|¨Ltugjlhy²vuvxlrBt¹»G²lvx±) ,/G+9 /G3:® 7R}{km{}rLwbtu{rj
{vxvulV}lV°JwrBt´ylV} ´wJ°G|{j RgLwJ°B{rjtu|1 u²j¦ ulV»B²jlVrBtu±mwrw±l¬wtxgjl_°GlVytu|v= ¹txgjl±6y|rBtxw{}r,§gj{y=g,{r
tx²jvxr,vulH²ylH RvxlV uL|Gr ultu{kml®RfvulVl~N¦w ulVE{rl{rjkmltugj|j ¶t±j{yVw}±m² ulStxgj{ Rtx|jvx²jrjl_lrBtu{vul
¦vxwry=gjlV V® 7R{}km{rwbtx{}rj{vuvxll°bwrBtµyl µ{ _|¨txlrlVr¨©|v=ylHPwbtµvx²jr~:tu{kml¦±wjj±{}rj$t§´|$v=wbtxgjlv
u{kE{wv !$'2(*2 *# !(%=®3fhgjl1¯v= t¬vu²}lE{ ¬wj}{lVãwbt_tugjlE°lVvu±¥¦Ul{rjrj{rj!|¨RtxgjlE ulVwvxy=gPvu|ylH u
wr!{lVrBtu{}¯lV {vxvulV}lV°JwrBthyl wG ¨©|}|b§S 4H
{º¨ &<&<
txgjlr¹{ h{}vxvulV}lV°bwrBtV
§gjlVvul ! "&<# _{ ¬tugjl6km{rj{k²jk j{ ªtxwrylm¦Ult§llrãtugl$»G²lvx±PL|G{}rBt$+wrtxgjl$ylV}%
wr& '("&<# ´txgjl3k6wb{k²jk { ªtxwryl(¦Ult§llVr&EwrylV}) ®+*
fhgjl1 ªlHwv=y=gvu|ylH u tugjlVrvxwr"; tugjl1vulVk6w{rj{}r$yl S|r¥txgjl{vµ{ryvulHw u{}rj6{ ªtxwrLylV Stu|,®pNt
txgjlr·wyVylH u ulV _yl _|Grjlmwb¨tulVv¬tugjlm|txgjlvHU¨©lt=y=gjlV 3w}tugl1°GlVyztx|v= µlHwy=g2yl¹y|GrGt=w{r Vy|kmj²txlV
txgjl6{ t=wryl1¦Ult§llVr-+wrlHwy=gã°lVytu|Gv_|¨Rtugjl6ylZ®Efhgj{ ¬k6wJ±PU|G x ª{¦j±P²jUwbtulEtxgjl6y²jvxvulVrBt
ult|¨txgjl/.$¦UlV ªtSrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= ¨©|²r! u|E¨½wvH®
fhgjl_ ªlHy|rL¯Lºtxlvx{}rj3vx²jl{ ¶wjj{lV1tu|w¦L|Gvªt¹txgjlS ulVwv=y=gmw R u||r6w "{}t¶{ ¶ltulVytulHEtugwtRrj|rjl
|¨txgjl3°lHyztu|Gvx {rPwr±$vxlk6w{rj{rjEylywr!U|G x u{}¦j±${kmwyttugjl3y²vuvxlrBtS ªltS|¨rjl{g¦U|v= ® Í ¨txlv
gLwJ°B{rjw¦U|vutulVtugjl6 ulVwvxy=g,/w}"vxlk6w{rj{rj!yl (wvxlm J;{jLlHwrtxgjlEvulH ª²j}tywr¦Ul1vxltx²jvurlV/®
fhg{ ulVy|r+¯}tulvx{rjmvu²jl3{ H
{º¨ &< 01"&<32425'´tugjlVrPw¦U|vutV
§glvxl{ ´txgjl3ylUtu|mjvx|ylV x ´rjltV01"&<3242 5 ´{ ´txgjl3{ ªtxwryl¬¦Ult§llr&wrL$txgjl¬y²jvxvulVrGt6.87"9
rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|vH®
fhgjl&:ªy²jvx ulP|¨{kmlr u{|rw}{}t±<;¥jvx|¦}lVk k6w?;GlV mtxgjlV ulP¯}tulVvu{rj vx²j}lH 6{rjlGlVytu{°l{r gj{g~
j{}kmlrL ª{|rw uwylV V®fhgjlµvulHw u|r "{ry²lµgj{}Gg6|b°lVvuwE¦Llt§´lVlr$yl ¹§g{y=g6jvxl°GlrBtx ¹tugjl_vu²jlV
tx|E¯ºtxlvS|G²tk6wr±+ylV} Swr$tx|mvxwj{j}±+w¦L|Gvªthtxgjl ªlHwv=y=g,®
=?>@>.+ACB 'ED ) GFHFJI<K "+MLON
fhgl:uy²jv= ul+|¨({kElVr u{}|Grw{ºt±<;+jglrj|GkElVrj|r { Ewvªtx{y²jwvx}±·jvxl°bwlrBtm§gjlr LlVvª¨©|Gvukm{rj (<
; ' 9 9~s ulVwv=y=gjlH ®¬fhgjlvxl{ µtxgjlvxl¨©|Gvul1wr{ryvxlVwG ª{rj${rBtulVvulH t¬{}rUlvu¨©|vxkm{}r < *4C ')( 9 9~
ulVwvxy=glV V§glvxlvxlV u²jºt¥»B²w{ºt± { $txvxwGlV¨©|Gv+vxlV²LylVD»G²lvx± llHy²tx{}|Gr tu{kmlHAwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
9 9~s ªlHwv=y=gjlV (km{gBtkm{ u tugjl6txvu²l$rjlVwvulH trl{g¦L|Gvx |¨S»B²jlvx±U|{rBtx V®¥wr±ãwjjvx|Gwy=glV ¬tu|
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=gjlH 3gwJ°Gl6¦LlVlr]j²¦j}{ ugjlV/®¼ãl¥lV xyvx{¦Ll$¦Ul|b§ tugjl!|rjlH 3txgwbtmwvxl6tugjl
km|B tvxll°bwrBthtu|m|²v§´|Gv;®
P
Ð,ÑJÚÁÔ¶ÚÁÓ÷JØÁÚÁåÚÙ:ØQÝ=ÔZÔ:×JÓæÔRÙ:ÑJÝxÙ6RS3åªÒzÕÙ:Ý=ÚÁÕJÔÝxÙhØÁæªÝ=Ô½ÙTéæåÙZÒzä½ÔuíUÙ:ÑJæäWVÚÁÔ:æzçLÙZÑJæSÔ:æªÝ=ä½åNÑ$÷Jä½ÒVåæÔ:ÔhåªÝ=ÕmÔ½ÙNÝ=ä©Ù
Ý=÷J÷JØQVÚÁÕJóÙ:ÑJÚÁÔXbØÙZæªä½ÚÁÕJóSä½×JØÁæ´ÒzÕHØQ(ÒzÕJåæ¶ÚÙ)TÕJÒ3VÔÙZÑbÝxÙ¹æÕJÒz×HózÑ3åªæØÁØÁÔÑbݪéæ´ÕJÒ=ÙZYææÕXbØÙ:æä½æÜÒz×VÙÙZÒµóz×JÝ=ä:Ý=ÕÙ[Q3Ù:ÑHæ
æøVÚÁÔZÙZæÕJåæRÒ#\ÝxÙØÁæªÝ=ÔZÙThéæåsÙ:Òzä½Ôuí
¢¡ @È Ë ¡ Ë ¢j£ Ç
¼2l¦UlvSwr Egjk §{}tugtxgjl{vµwjvu|J{k6wbtul_°lVvx u{}|Gr+|¨txgjl Í ~{}lC)¼FEh3wr .,{/ltµw:®§{}tug
{rl ). P¼djÅ3Ulvu¨©|vxk wjvu|J{k6wbtul 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=glV "¦±1w¦L|Gvªtx{}rj¬txgjlS ªlHwv=y=gEw¨tulVvRgwJ°{}r
wGyylV x ªlHwr·wvx¦j{}tuv=wvx±UjvulHltxlvxkm{}rjlHãwrP¯lHr²jk1¦LlVv3|¨´yl V®1fhglV ul1t§|!tulVy=grj{»B²jlH (wvxl
l«$y{lrBt{r$txlvxk6 ´|¨,vulH ªU|rL ªlµtu{kElH ¦²tG{}°Glµrj|my²jl¬|r6txgjl3»B²w{ºt±m|¨,tugjl¬vxlV u²jºthvxltu²vurjlHmtu|
txgjl3² ulvSwr+r| ;rj|G¦tu|Etu²jrl(tugj{ S»B²w{}t±®
ÇBË
Ç ¡
£¢@´
¡ Ë
¢j£
Ç
f|3{ryvxlVwG ªl´tugjlµlGlVyztx{}°GlrjlH u "|¨Ltxgjlµw¦L|b°Gl´¯Lºtxlvx{}rj(vx²jlV VG u|kmlwjjvx|GwGy=gjlV txvu±tu|lHyvxlVw ultugjl
|b°Glvxwjj{rjSv=wbtxl|¨Uyl ¦±y|Gr u{lVvu{rj(wrEwjjvx|J{}k6wtu{|r|¨tugl{vR ª{ lH "{}r ªtulHw|¨Uy|r u{lvx{}r
txgjl{v6ljwGyzt$ ª{ lH ®dfhgl± t±j{yw}±AwyVy|G²jrBt1¨©|Gv$wr wjj{ºtx{}|Grw°bw}²jl¥§gjlVr y|kmj²jtu{rj·tugjl
km{rj{k²jkwrãk6wb{k²jk { ªtxwrylH (tu|yl Vk6w;B{rjP u|kmlgj|b§ ylV} :u ªk6wlvE;=®89k6w}lvyl
txlr¬tx|µk6w?;Gl"tugjlR¯ºtxlvx{}rSvu²}lH ,km|vxlR ªlV°lVvulGV§gj{y=g,H{}rtu²jvxr,J{}rLyvxlVw ulV /tugjlRr²jk1¦LlVv|¨{vxvulV}lV°JwrBt
yl V® l 1y|GrGt=w{rj{rj{rGtxlvxlV ªtu{rjP°lHyztx|v= 3km{}GgGt1¦Ll+¯ºtxlvxlV·|G²tV"gj|b§l°GlvH®fhgjl$t§´|w¦L|b°Gl
vx²jlV h¦UlVy|kml
{º¨ &<
&<
M
txgjlr { {}vxvxll°bwrBt
{º¨ &<
01"&<32425¶tugjlVrw¦U|vutV
5_ltxlvxkm{}rj{rj¥txgjl$wjvu|Gjvu{wbtxl1°bw}²jlm¨©|Gv!!{ =;lV±P¨©|vw}´wjjvx|GwGy=gjlV _² u{}rPl|Gkmltuvx{yw}~N¦w ulV
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}|Gr V®
psr)¼FEh 3NJ¼ãlV¦LlVvwr=EGgjkÄw u|hjvulH ªlVrBt/tugjl Í ~(E 95A{}r(§gj{y=g!´{ /lkmj{vx{yVw}±_lV ªtu{kmwtulH
¦±+ xwkmj{rj6jwbt=w¦wG ªl(°lHyztx|v= ®¹fhgjlV±! ugj|b§dtxgwbttxgj{ "{ S¦j{}6lVrj|²g!tu|6{ryvxlVwG ªl_tugjl(¯Lºtxlvx{}rj
U|b§lv|¨tugjl!vu²}lH §gj{}l¥ ukmw}´lrj|G²jgA{}r txgjl+k6w|vx{ºt±2|¨µyVw ulV 3tx|ãwJ°G|{ãkm{ u u{rjtxgjl$txvu²jl
rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= V®psrwGj{}tu{|rtu|6¦Uljwtxw6wr¥»G²lvx±!lVLlVrlrBtHjtuglk6w{r¥jvxwJ§¦wGy;6|¨"tug{
wjjvx|GwGy=g{ ¬txgwbt(txgjl$ uwkml#+{ 3wj}{lVtu|Pw}¹l{ ªtu{rjyl V®mfhgj{ 3j|BlH (rj|twGyy|G²jrBt_¨©|Gv(tugjl
U|G x u{}¦jl6°lVvu±2{NGUlVvulVrGtEjwbt=w{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr 3{rAylV} ®¥¼ gj{l$l«$y{lrBtHtxgjl Í ~(E 95 uy=gjlVkml6{
r|tvulV}{w¦}l({r!txlvxk6 h|¨tugjl3jvxlVy{ u{|r+|¨txgjlwjvu|J{k6wbtul¬ ªlHwv=y=g,®
fhgjl Í ~29 9D xy=gjlVkElµ¨©|v¥~NfvxllV ¶jvxlV ulrBtulH6{}r ) ¶G31½wr$lVvu{°lHm¨©vu|Gk )Í 9-0/59 3,´w u|
vxl{lV 3|Gr]w ª{rjG}l$°bw}²jl$P ult1¦B±ãtugl+² ulvH® +Slvxl¥vulVjvxlV ulrBtx (txgjl+k6w{k²kvxlwbtx{}°Gl6lvxvu|Gv
w}|b§lV¥¦Ult§llrtugjlE{ ªtxwryl¨©vu|Gk tugjlm»B²jlvx±!U|{rBt(wrP{}tx _ljwyt_rjlHwvxlV ªtµrjlV{}GgB¦U|v¬wrtugjl
j{ ªtxwryl(¨©vx|k tugjl»B²jlVvu±!L|G{}rBt_wr{ºt= µwjjvx|J{k6wbtxl¬rlVwvxlV ªtrjl{g¦U|vH®¶psr¥txgj{ _ uy=glkml%mywr
|Grj±+gwJ°Glwm°lvx±$|G¦ uy²jvxl3kElHwrj{rjmtx|6tugjl² ªlVvV®´psrwjj{ºtx{}|Gr,jtxgjl{vµlUlvx{kElVrBtx S ugj|b§lV!tugwtV
{rlrlv=w:Gtxgjl3wytu²wUvxlwbtx{}°Gl_lVvuvx|v{ w}§hwJ± ¶k1²y=g¥ ªk6wlvtugwr&® {wyy{wEwrL+¹wbtxlwEw u|
vulH ªlVrGt¬wrlBtxlr u{|r¥tu| Í ~)9 9 yVw}lH¥ Í ~)9 9®/fhgjl Í ~29 9 uy=glkml² ulV _w$jvx|¦Lw¦j{}{ ªtu{y
txlVy=gjr{»B²jl¹tx|µltulvxkm{}rl¶wr3lH tx{}k6wbtx{}|Gr3|¨tugl´{ t=wrylR¦Ult§llr(txgjl¶»B²jlVvu±¬°lHyztu|GvwrL({ºt= ,rjlHwvxlV ªt
rl{g¦L|GvV®"pNttxgjlrPw¦U|vutx txgjl ulVwv=y=g!wG ª||GrwG h{ºt¨©|G²jrj SwE°GlVyztx|vSy}|B ªlVv´txgwrtxgj{ SlV ªtu{kmwtulH
j{ ªtxwrylG®"fhgl_k6w{r!jvxwJ§¦wGy;|¨ Í ~)9 9Ä{ ´tugwt{}tw x ª²jkmlH :;rj|b§r6txgjl3{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr+|¨wbtxw
wvu|G²jr$tugjl»B²jlVvu±$U|{rBtVj§g{y=g¥km{}GgBthr|tS¦Ul3L|B u u{}¦}l3{r+txgjlGlrjlVvxwyVw ul® Í u|txgj{ xy=gjlVkEl
yVwrrj|tµ ulVwvxy=g+¨©|v .+rjl{g¦U|v= ®
V¢j V £¢@h ¡ Ë ¢j£
psr]y|rBtuv=w ªt3tu|tugjl6txlVy=gjr{»B²jlH jvxlV ulrBtulH w¦U|b°lG 5E´p9 )E // 3h{ rj|t1wl|Gkmltuvx{yw}~N¦w ulV
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}|Grã xy=gjlkml6¦j²jtvxwtugjlVv3vulV}{lV (|Gr·² ª{rj¥txgjl+ ªtxwbtx{ ªtu{ywRjvx|Ulvutu{lV (|¨hjwtxw®85BEp 9
y}²L txlv= µjwtxw$²L ª{rj$txgjl 7¶ 7¹LlHyztxwtu{|rwb{}km{ Vwtu{|r ,µw|vx{}tugjk¥®B5Ep 9 w¦L|Gvªt= txgjl 9 9~
ulVwvxy=gm§gjlVr6tuglµlV ªtu{k6wbtxlV6jvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}t±1¨©|v´wvulVkmw{}r{}rj1jwbt=w¦wG ªlS°GlVytu|vRtu|¦Ul_w¦LltªtulVvhrjl{g~
¦U|v(txgwr2txgjl6|rjlH 3y²jvxvxlrBtu±.;rj|b§r㨽w (¦Ul|b§ wjvxlVjltulVvukm{rjlVtugvulH ªgj|G,® 6Sr¨©|Gvªtx²jrwbtxl±
5Ep 9 {rjgjlVvu{}tx µ¨©vu|Gk5wtxgjlEjvxwJ§¦wGy; |¨ 7¶Î ª²Ly=gw µtugjlE ªlVr ª{}tu{°{ºt±tx|$tugl1{rj{}tu{w" ªltªtu{rjB
txgjlE}{km{ºtxlVr²jk1¦LlVv(|¨¶y² ªtulVvx B7¶ ywrgwrj}lGLtxgjlmw x ª²jkmlH
w² x u{wr{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr|¨¶wbtxw
U|{rBtx ´tugLwbth°lVytu|Gvx ´k6wJ±mwGyztx²w}±mrj|t´¨©|G}|b§d|Gv¶txgjl_|ywU|Gtu{k6w{ºtu¨½wZ®05E´p 9 vxlV»B²j{vulH ¶k6w;G~
{rjk6wrB±· ªtuvx|rjwG u u²jkmtx{}|Gr §gj{y=g]km{gBtrj|t1gj|G {r]jv=wytu{ylGk6w;B{rjPtxgjl!wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
vxlV u²j}t°lvx±6²jrjvxl{w¦jl({}rtugl3lrlv=w/ywG ªlG®
h76
fhg{ ªlHyztx{}|Gr3{°lV w¦jvx{}l¨j|b°lVvu°{l§2|¨j|²vwjvu|Bwy=g¬tu|¬wjvu|J{kmwtul¹rjlHwvxlV ªtª~Nrjl{g¦U|v ulVwvxy=glV V®
fhgj{ Swjjvx|Gwy=gw x ª²kElH ´tugwtS°lVytu|Gvx hwvxl(lry}|B ªlH+{rPy² ªtulv= V®"fhgly²jvxvulVrBth°Glv= ª{|r!|¨"|²jv
w}G|vx{ºtxgjk³¨©|v3y|rBtuvx|}{rj!tugjl6vulHy{ ª{|rã|¨wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl 9 9~s ªlHwv=y=gjlV _vxlV»B²j{vulH ¬y}²L txlv= µtx|P¦Ll
km{rj{k²jk ¦L|G²jr{rj6g±LlVvx ujgjlVvulH ´{r¥wr 7R²y}{lVwrP ªwGylG®
Í }l{ tx{}rj!°lHyztu|Gvx SkE{gBtµr|t_¦Ul{ry}² ªtulVvx µ¦LlHyw² ªltugjlEy² txlvx{}r+w|Gvu{}tugjk tugwt_jvx|~
j²ylHy² ªtulv= Skm{gBt_{ u|wbtul|²tx}{lv= ®_pN¨¹tugjlV±¥l{ ªtV§lw x u²jkmltugLwbt_|G²tu{lv= µwvxl ªtu|GvulH¥{}rw
uUlVy{}¯Ly_¯l(tugwtS§´l¬txvulHwbtS ªlVwv=wbtxl±®
² ªtulv= wvxlµwrw}±VlVm|?GU~N}{rjlStx|1lVvu{°lG¨©vx|k txgjl_ljwyzt´vxwG{}²L ´wrmtugl_ uLlHy{}¯Lyµy=gwvxwGyztxlvu~
{ ªtu{y (|¨lVwGy=g,wjvu|J{k6wbtul1vxwG{² ªlH _tugwt§{}¹²j}tu{kmwtulV}±ã¦Ll6y|Gr u{lVvulHãj²jvu{rj!tugjl$wjjvx|J~
{k6wbtxl 9 9~s ªlHwv=y=gjlV V® |vmlVwGy=g y² ªtulVvV ªlV°lv=whwjvu|J{k6wbtulv=w{² ulV EwvxlltulVvukm{rjlV/lVwGy=g
y|vxvulH ªU|rL{}r!tx|wPjvxlVjltulVvukm{rjlV·l°Gl´|¨jvxlVy{ u{}|Gr,® Í ¶txgjl!wjjvx|J{k6wbtxlEv=wj{}² ulV |¨|rjl
y}²L txlvhwvxl_w§hwJ± ´ ªk6w}lv´tugwr$txgjl(ljwyt´v=w{² ´|¨,txgjl3 uwkEl¬y² ªtulvH® (= <?>'4*!# '
J ' % <>(*% '>( ('" ' (=#&%"(='(: # '2( < *4 '2( *'?#&%(%mfhgj{ _kmltugj|ã§{}¹¦Ll
vulH ªlVrGtxlV!{}rtxgjl(rjltB9lHyztu{|r®
Í
tS»B²jlvx±$ u²j¦jkm{ x u{}|Gr+tx{}kmljwE² ulvhjvx|b°{jlV VBw}|Grj1§{}tug!tugl»G²lvx±wvulHy{ ª{|r!}lV°l/yVw}lH
K y|rBtuvx|{}rj+tugjl$»B²w}{}t±P|¨´tugjl6wjjvx|J{k6wbtxl09 9S~N ulVwvxy=g®*K y|GvuvxlV uL|Grj µtu|tuglEvu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±
¨©|GvSwE°lVytu|Gv´txgwbt¦Ul|rjB tu|Etugl3ljwytwr u§´lVvh ulttx|m¦LlwGyztu²Lw}±6km{ u u{}rE{rtugjlwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
ult|¨"wr ª§lv= l°GlrBtu²w}±6vxltu²vurjlH/®
fhgj{ jvxlVy{ u{|r}lV°l,tugjlVrltxlvxkE{rjlH h§gj{y=gP uLlHy{}¯Lywjjvx|J{k6wbtxl_v=w{² ulV hk1² tS¦Ul3t=w?;lVr
{rBtu|Ewyy|²jrBt¶¦±Etuglµ¯}tulVvu{rjvx²jlV ²jvx{}rtugl 9 9S~N ulVwvxy=g®psvxvulV}lV°bwrBt´y² ªtulVvx wvxltug² ¶¯}tulVvulH
|G²twr$tugjl(vxlk6w{rj{rj1y}² ªtulVvx hwvulµtugjlVr!v=wr";GlV6§{}tugvxlV uLlHyzttu|1tugjl({ t=wryl_|¨tugl{vhylrBtulVvx
tx| tuglã»B²jlvx± L|G{}rBtV® }² ªtulVvx !wvxl¥tugjlVrDwyVylH u ulV |rlãwb¨txlv+tugjlã|tuglvH®¼ gjlrDwAy² txlv!{
wGyylV x ªlH/jw,txgjljwtxwmU|{rGt= {ry|rBt=w{r wvxl(¨©lt=y=gjlV¥{rPkmlkm|vx±®fhgjl ªlHwv=y=g+txgjlry|kmj²txlV
txgjl!j{ ªtxwrylH ¦Ult§llr]w}´L|G{}rBt= {r tugjly² ªtulvEwr2txgjl!»B²jlVvu±2°lHyztx|vH®¥fhg{ 1km{}GgGt1{}r tx²jvxr
²Ujwtul_tugjl(y²vuvxlrBt ulth|¨rjl{g¦U|v= ®pNtkm{gBtw ª|¯ºtxlvh|²jtkm|vxl_y}²L txlv= ®"fhgjl( ªlHwv=y=g$ tx|
§glr .rjlV{}Gg¦L|Gvx gwJ°Gl´¦UllVr¨©|G²jrmwr1§gjlVrtxgjlwjjvx|J{}k6wtulkE{rj{k²jk { ªtxwryltx|_txgjlrjlBt
y}²L txlv{ hvxlVwbtxlvtugLwrtugjly²jvxvulVrGt{ t=wryl(tu|Etugl/.87"9mrjlV{}GgB¦U|vH®
El¨©|Gvulmvxltx²jvur{}rjtxgjl$vxlV u²jºt(tx|¥tugjl6² ulvHw¥ ulV»B²jlVrGtx{wR uyVwr2|¨tugjl$¯}l6§glvxlE|G²tu{lv= 3wvxl
ªtu|GvulH${ Ulvu¨©|vxkElH/®¹fhgj{ km{}GgGtSw u|m²jUwbtul(txgjly²vuvxlrBt ªltS|¨rl{g¦L|Gvx V®
¸_²jvSwjjvx|GwGy=g$lr¨©|GvxylV hwjvu|J{k6wbtul39 9S~N ulVwvxy=glV V®pNtS{ tugjlVvul¨©|vxl_{;l±6txgwbt|rl¬|Gvkm|vxl
°GlVytu|v= tugwt¹wvul´tuglhtuvx²jl´rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= |¨Uw¬»B²jlvx±3U|{rGtRwvulkm{ x ªlH/wr1wvulhy|Gr ulV»B²jlrBtx}±
r|t({}rtugjl6wjvu|J{k6wbtul1wr u§´lVv_ ultH®$¹lVytu|v= ¬wvxlkm{ x ulV¦UlVyVw² ul1tugjlmy² ªtulv= _{}r2§gj{y=gtugl±
wvul*;ljt_wvxl3¯}tulVvulHP|²tH®B9{rylEy² ªtulv= SGvu|G²jP°lHyztx|v= htugwt¬wvul»B²j{}tulE ª{km{}wvH{}t_{ µtugjlVvul¨©|vxl
U|G x u{}¦jl(tugLwbtSkm|G ªtS|¨tugjl3rlVwvxlV ªtª~NrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= |¨¹w6»B²jlvx±$U|{rGtµwvul({rwm²jrj{»B²jly² ªtulvH®RpN¨"tug{
y}²L txlvS{ ¯}tulVvulH¥|²tHtxgjlrPkm|B tµ|¨"tugjl3txvu²lrjlVwvulH tSrl{g¦L|Gvx S|¨Rw$»B²jlvx±+U|{rBt_wvxl3km{ x ulV/®
¼ glr+ ulVwvxy=gj{rj(¨©|Gv.mrjlV{}Gg¦L|Gvx V§gj{}lµtugjl_jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±1|¨,kE{ x ª{rj|Grjltuvx²jl_rjl{g¦U|vR{ K´Btugjl
vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±6|¨km{ u u{}rmw}txgjl/.!rjlVwvulH thrjlV{}GgB¦U|v= { S|¨txgjl3|v=lVv|¨ K tu||®
% $! !"#$%'&( & ]& 1 "´.
´
fhg{ S ulVytu{|rjvxlV ulrBtx txgjlkmltxgj|+txgwbtµy|kmj²txlV htxgjlwjjvx|J{k6wbtxl_v=w{² ulV |¨"lVwGy=gPy² txlv= ®
fhg{ kEltugj|·t=w?;GlV 3{rBtu|wGyy|G²jrBt1wRtxgjl!j{}°Glv= ª{}t±|¨txgjl!y=gLwv=wyztxlvx{ ªtu{y (|¨Sy² txlv= u²y=g]w
txgjl3{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr+|¨tugjl(°lHyztx|v= Rtxgjl±$y|rBtxw{}r,Btxgjl{vS ª{ lH Btxgjl{vhL|Gj²jwbtu{|r®pNtSy|kmj²txlV ´tugjlH ªl
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlRv=w{² ulV ¨©|v¹ ªlV°lVvxwl°lV |¨L{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr,® {°lVrtxgjlh}lV°lB|¨L{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr1wGyztu²Lw}±
ult¹¦±(tugl² ªlVv¹wbt¹vu²r~Ztx{}kmlGJtugjlS u± txlk ullVyzt= ¨©|v"lVwGy=g1y}² ªtulVv"tugjly|vxvulH ªU|rj{}rj¬wjvu|Gjvu{wbtxl
v=wj{}² ´tx|$y|rL ª{lv²vu{rjEtugjl ulVwvxy=g®
9{ryl!wjvu|J{k6wbtu{|rL (|¨Sy² ªtulvxlV wvul!y|rL ª{lvxlV,{}t1{ U|G x ª{¦jl6tugLwbttxgjl$¯Lºtxlvx{}rjvu²jlV
¯LºtxlvE|²tmy² txlv= {r]§gj{y=gA u|kml$|¨txgjl!tuvx²jl+rjlHwvxlV ªtª~Nrjl{g¦U|v= (|¨txgjl!»B²jlVvu±2L|G{}rBt6wvxl®pNt
{ tugjlVvul¨©|vxl+U|G x ª{¦jl$tugLwbtm|rjl|vEkm|vxl$°lHyztu|Gvx tugLwbt1§|²A¦Ll{}rAtugjlljwGyztEwr u§´lVv1 ult6wvxl
wGyztx²w}±kE{ x ª{rjP{rãtxgjl+wjjvx|J{k6wbtxlE ult|¨hwr u§´lVvx ¬l°GlrBtu²Lw}±vxltx²jvxrjlVãtu|¥txgjl$² ulvH®>9²Ly=g
°GlVytu|v= hwvxl¬yVw}lH %+% >L (+ "' *+%z®
pN¨§l_¨©|y² ´|r+|Grjl_ uUlVy{}¯Ly_km{ x ª{rj1°lVytu|GvVB¦LlHyw² ªlµtugjl(wjvu|J{k6wbtul 9 9~s ulVwv=y=g$y|Gr u{lVvx
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl¥vxwG{}²L ªlH 6{}rL txlVw |¨(ljwyzt ½wrL¦L|G²jr{rj ,6vxwG{}²L ªlH ´tugjlVrd§lywrdwG u ulvut6tug{
°GlVytu|v¹{ R|ywtulVm{r$w(°lVvu±1wvutu{y²wv¶wvxlVw¬|¨txgjlµ uLlHy{}¯LySy² ªtulVv¶{r6§gj{y=gmtxgj{ R°lHyztx|vR¦Ul|rjB
wvulHw¦U|²rlV¦Ult§llVr+txgjl3ljwytSwr|rl¬Lwvutu{y²jwvwjvu|J{k6wbtul¬v=w{² |¨tugwtµy² ªtulvH®
fhgj{ ( ªlHyztx{}|GrjvxlV ulrBtx _gj|b§txgjl1°G|²jkml|¨Rtugj{ (wvxlVw$¨©|v¬l°lVvu±P u{}rl1y² ªtulVv_{ (y|rBtxvu|G}lV/
u{rylG¨©|v|Grjly² ªtulvHtug{ °G|²jkml3{ h{r";lH+tx|mtugjl3vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±6¨©|GvµwE°lHyztu|Gv|¨tugwtµy² ªtulvH{}¨
{}th{ h{r$txgjl(ljwyt´vxlV u²jºtHtu|E¦Ll¬km{ x u{}rjE{r+txgjl¬wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlµvxlV u²j}tV® j|Gv¶txgjl3 uw;lµ|¨ywvx{}t±Btugjl
kmltugj|¥{ SlV xyvx{¦LlH!glvxl3¨©|vµw6 u{rjl3{}kmjvxlVy{ u{|r}lV°lywlV K´® 7¹txlr u{}|Gr¥tu|$ ul°Glv=w/l°lV
{ ªtuv=w{g¨©|Gvu§hwv=/®
fhgjl3vulH ªlVrGt=wbtx{}|Gr+|¨tugl(tulVy=grj{»B²jl({ SlHy|kmU|G ulV!{}r$ ªtulL H
Å®h¼ãlh¯Lvx ªtljw{}rE§gjlVvulkm{ x ª{rj(°lHyztx|v= yVwrE|rj±3¦Ll|ywtulV{}rElVwGy=g1y}² ªtulVvVGwr1§g±3tugjl
°|G}²jkml|¨UtxgjlµwvulHw_{rm§gj{y=gmtugjlV±1ywrm|rj±1¦Ul{ ¶{vulHyztx}±EltxlvxkE{rjlHm¦B±tugjlµ{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr
|¨tugjl ulVwvxy=g®
®h¼ãlEtxgjlrãljw{rtugl1vxlwbtx{}|Gr¦Llt§´lVlrtugjlE|¦wl°Gl"|¨´{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr Kwrtugjlm|yw
{}kmjvxlVy{ u{|r¥ ªltªtu{rjB K txgwbtSgLwJ°l_tu|m¦Lly|r u{lvxlVwbthtugl3}lV°l/|¨lHwy=g¥y² ªtulvH®
nj®h¼ãl¬txgjlr¥lt=w{/gj|b§d§l_²L ªl¬lVwGy=g>K tu|my|kmj²jtul¬tugjl3y|vxvulH ªU|rj{}rj1wjjvx|J{}k6wtulµv=wj{}²
|¨"lVwGy=gy}² ªtulVv{º¨"§l(wG u u²jkml¬tugwtS°lHyztu|Gvx {rPy² txlv= ´¨©|}|b§ wr{ u|txvu|Gj{y({ ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{|r,®
®h¼ãl(¯Lrw}±!vulVw$tug{ SwG u u²jkmtx{}|Grwr+vulH ªlVrGtSwmkm|vxl(lVrjlv=w§hwJ±6tu|6y|Gkmj²tulwjjvx|J~
{}k6wtul3v=w{² ulV VBlV°lVr!{}¨txgjl{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr¥|¨°GlVytu|v= {}rPy}² ªtulVvx h{ S ul°Glvxl±$ J;Gl§lV/®
. > +8I +,'!.- !.# > +8IL Z>
fhg{ ´¯v= thwvªtljw{r §gjlvxl_km{ u u{rj°GlVyztx|v= ´yVwr!|rj±m¦Ll(|yVwbtxlV${r+lHwy=g+y}²L txlvH®¼2l¬¨©|y²
|Gr¥|rjl uLlHy{}¯Ly3y² ªtulVvV u®´fhglkm{}rj{k²k g±LlVvx ujgjlVvul(¦U|²jrL{}r6tugj{ Sy}² ªtulVvVUyw}lV 4
{ ¶ylrBtulVvulHm|r wrm{}tx ´v=w{² ¹{ u®¼2l_w u| ª²jL|B ªltxgwbt|rjl_wjjvx|J{}k6wtu{|rE|¨/tug{ ´y² txlv
gLw ¦UllVry|GkE²tulHP ª|GkElVgj|b§3®hfhgj{ _wjvu|J{kmwtu{|r{ _wr¥g±LlVvx ujgjlVvulylrBtulVvulH!|Gr R§{}tugw
v=wj{}² µlV»B²wtx| M ª®¬fhgj{ ¬wjvu|J{k6wbtulgB±Ulv= ªgjlvxl{ _yVw}lH(ª® ´y|rBtxw{}r _ ªlV°lVvxw
°GlVytu|v= VU¦²t3|rjlm ªUlVy{º¯Uy°GlVyztx|vH/ywlVm,{ _km{ u u{rj!{rãtugjl6 ult(|¨wr u§´lVvx µvultu²jvxrjlV¦±Ptugjl
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl 9 9~s ªlHwv=y=g§gj{l6{ºt§hw ({ry²lH·{}r2txgjl$ ªlt|¨hwr u§´lVvx ¬vxltx²jvurlV2¦±Ptugjl6ljwyzt
ulVwvxy=g® { tugjlVvul¨©|vxl3w1km{ u u{rjm°lVytu|GvV®
ElVyVw² ul { SwEkm{ u u{}rE°GlVytu|vHBtugjlVrtugjl(txgjvulVl(¨©|}|b§{rjE}lVkmkmwG ywr!¦Ulw x ªlVvªtxlV H
´Ç ]¢
h{rã§gj{y=g { (gwG _¦UllVr2¯ºtxlvxlV|²t3¦±Ptugl1¯Lºtxlvx{}rj¥vx²jlV V®m¸µtuglvx§{ ul/{}¨
gw+rj|th¦Ullr!¯}tulVvulH$|²jtVtuglr!w}°GlVyztx|v= R¨©vx|k §|²j6gwJ°Glµ¦Ullr¥y|Gr u{lVvulH6¦±mtugjl
wjvu|J{kmwtul 9 9~s ªlHwv=y=g,wrtugjlVvul¨©|vxl §´|G²jgwJ°l¦UllVrã{ xy|b°lVvulHPwr§´|G²jPrj|t
¦Ll1km{ x ª{rjL® { S|G¦°B{|²L ª±+rj|tS¯}tulVvulH¥|²t¬{}r¥txgjl1yVw ul|¨"tuglljwGyztµ ulVwv=y=gP ª{ryl|rjl
|¨"{ºt= °lHyztx|vHBrLwkml±6{ h{rtugjlwr ª§lv ultH®,
´Ç ]¢ { _{}rl°{ºt=w¦j±}|ywtulHP{}rtugjl1°lvx±¥ ªUlVy{º¯LywvxlVw6|¨ ¶§gj{y=g{ _²jjUlvu~N¦L|G²jrlH
¦±
wr2}|b§lvu~:¦U|²rlV㦱
®¥fhgjl+{ t=wryl6¦Llt§´lVlr5wr
yVwr·rj|t¦Ll
vxlVwtulvtxgwr
j|tugjlVvu§{ ul §|²!rj|tS¦Ul|rmtu|,
®´fhgjl{ t=wryl3¦Llt§´lVlr wr
ywrPrj|t¬¦Ll1}lH u Stugwr M |tuglvx§{ ul §|²j¥rjlV°lvµgwJ°l3¦UllVrkm{ x ª{rj${rPtxgjl1 ultµ|¨
wjvu|J{kmwtul¬wr u§´lVvx V®"fhgjl¬wvulHw{r+§gj{y=gyVwr+|Grj±6¦Ll({ yVw}lH6txgjl*2A<>(*2*2$|¨)
rj|txlV ®
´Ç ]¢
pN¨ ! lrj|tulH txgjl+km{rj{}k1²jk*{ t=wryl+¦Ult§llr w»B²jlvx±ãU|{rBt Pwr
tugjlVr! {}r { *(+ %"(!A !N ')('{r!txgjl3vxl{|r!|¨ lry}|B ªlH+¦Ult§llVrtugjl3{rBtulv= ulVyztx{}|Gr
|¨ wrL tuglãg±LlVvx ujgjlVvul2ylVrGtxlvxlVD|rdtxgjl·»G²lvx± U|{rBt §{ºtxg wAvxwG{² +lH»B²w
tu| ! ®ÄpN¨§hw E¨©²jvutugjlVv+wJ§hwJ± ¨©vu|Gk tuglry|G²j r|t$¦Ulkm{ x ª{rj {rtugjl
wjvu|J{kmwtul(vxlV u²jºtS{}¨¹{ºt_§wG h{}r¥txgjlljwGyztSvxlV u²jºtS¦UlVyVw² ul3{r!txgj{ µywG ªl(txgjly² ªtulVvS§´|G²j
rj|tgLwJ°lm¦LlVlr2¯}tulVvulH|G²tV®+fhg{ uUlVy{}¯LyEvxl{|r2{ ({}ry}²LlV·{r wr2{ 3ywlVãtugjl
2A<>(*- 2|¨"y² ªtulv jrj|tulV ®
{²jvxlPÅ$jvx|b°{lH 3w¥v=wjg{yVw¹vxljvxlV ulrBtxwtu{|r2|¨ .,lVkmkmwG ¥wrL2nwr ugj|b§S (§gwbtEwvxl
wrAg±LlVvª~Nvx{}rj2wr wr g±BUlvu~syw¹{}rw2507¶²y{jlVwr uwylRgj|b§l°GlvH®]fhgj{ {²jvxl¥ ªgj|b§S
w·²rj{»B²jlãy² txlv #"y=gwv=wytulvx{ lV ¦±A{}tx !ylrBtxlv ½rj|t+w¦UllV ,zh{ºt= $v=w{² ½w¦LlV}lH w $%"",
jl¯rj{rjE{ºt= kE{rj{k²jk ¦L|G²jr{rjEgB±Ulv= ªgjlvxl ®"fhgl¬wjjvx|J{k6wbtxlµg±LlVvx ujgjlVvul |¨
#"µ{ lj{yztxlV¥w ´txgjl3vxl±$jwG ªglV+y{}v=yl(|r+tugjl {²jvxl®19S|tul¬tugl¬v=wj{}² |¨tug{ Swjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
g±Ulv= ªjglvxl¶{ " M " ®"fhgjlwvxlVwµ|¨ " tugLwbt¹{ lBtxlvxrwBtx|_txgj{ ¹wjjvx|J{}k6wtulRg±LlVvx ujgjlVvul§gj{}l
1 1
q C
1
1
dmin + 1 1
dmin r
ε
ε
HC
HR 1
1
{}G²jvxlEÅH¶¸_rjl6+S±Ulvu~:vx{}rEwr+|Grjl6+S±Ulvu~NyVw
ªtu{/lry}|B ªlH+{r #" hkm{rj{k²jk ¦L|G²jr{rjmg±BUlv= ujgjlvxl¬{ txgjl(gB±Ulvu~:vx{rj1|¨y}² ªtulVv #"brj|tulH
" |rPtxgjl {²jvxl® " y|GrBtxw{r µ+°lHyztx|v= Un6vulVjvxlV ulrBtulH¥¦B±vxl±¥|tx VwrPwr|tuglvµ°GlVytu|v
vxlvulH ªlVrGtxlV!¦±!w6 u|{¦jwy;+j|tV®fhgj{ SwbtulVv°lHyztu|Gv{ 6®¶psrwGj{}tu{|r,{²vul6Åw u|6 ªgj|b§S w
»B²jlVvu±L|G{}rBt%¬wr1tuglSkm{}rj{k²k { t=wrylh¨©vu|Gk µtu|/ " " |rEtugjl {²jvxl ,® { Rw¬km{ x u{}rj
°GlVytu|vHbtxgjlvxl¨©|GvulS{}t´yVwr6|r}±E¦Llµ{}r " ®¹P|vxl|b°GlvH ywrE|Grj±1¦Ulµ{rmtugjl¬ ªUlVy{º¯UySwvxlVw(|¨ "
jl¯rjlH¦±Ptxgjlm{}rBtxlv= ªlHyztu{|rã|¨´tugjl6g±LlVvx ujgjlVvulE¦U|²jrj{}rj " wrtugl6gB±Ulv= ªgjlvxlEylrBtulVvulH
|Gr-$tugwt(gLw 3w!vxwG{}²L _lH»B²wtu| ! " " wr2lVj{ytulHãwG ¬wjw{r2vxl±PwvxlVw!|r {²vulÅ®
fhg{ wvulHw1y|vxvulH ªU|r ¶tx|Etugjl3g±LlVvª~syw!|¨Z#"jywlV@#"J®
pNt${ 6»B²j{ºtxlP|¦°{}|G² 1tugwt6tugjl¥°G|²jkml|¨µtxgjlPg±BUlvu~Nvu{rj2|¨_|GrjlPy² ªtulv6{ 6vxlwbtxlV tx|·tugjl
{kmjvxlVy{ u{}|GrA|¨µtugjlP ulVwv=y=g ½gjlrLyltu| ,1¦UlVyw² ul+txgjl¥wvuGlv1tugjl¥°|G}²kEl|¨_tugjl¥vx{}rã|¨µ|rjl
y}²L txlvHJtugjlgj{gjlVvtxgjl´vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±_¨©|v¹wr±(°lHyztx|v|¨jtugLwbt¹y² txlvtu|¬¦Ll|yVwbtxlV3§{}tugj{r1tugwtvx{}r
Zwr!U|G x ª{¦j±$§{ºtxgj{r!txgjlyw!|Gryl¬txgjl»B²jlvx±6L|G{}rBtS{ ;rj|b§r ,z®Rfhgl¬rltµ ªlHyztx{}|Gr!{r°lV ªtu{GwtulH
txgjl3vxlwbtu{|rL ªgj{ ¦Ult§llr @
wrL K´®
. % +A%D )A
fhgljvxl°{}|G² S ulVytu{|rPl¯LrjlV¥g±LlVvª~Nvx{}rjB gB±Ulvu~NyVw wr¥U|{rGtxlV¥|G²tStuglvulVwtu{|r ugj{ ¦Ul~
t§llVr tugl!°G|²jkml$|¨µvx{rjG 1wr·txgjl{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gr]|¨txgjl¥ ªlHwv=y=g,®ãfhgj{ E ªlHyztu{|rA{ mwP¯Lvx ªtE ªtulV
tx|b§wvx _ljw{}r{}rj¥gj|b§ wjvu|J{kmwtulEvxwG{² ªlH (y|vxvxlV uL|Gr{rj+tx|w{°lr Kdwvul6ltulvxkm{}rlV/®
fhg{ µ¯v= t3 txlvulH ªlVrGt= µg|b§§´l1vulVwtul K tx|!jvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}tu{lV _wbt¬tugjlEl°lV|¨RlVwGy=gy² ªtulvH§gj{y=g
§{,²j}tu{kmwtulV}±$¦Ulwbttxgjl3vx|B|t|¨txgjly|Gkmj²txwtu{|r|¨¹wjvu|J{kmwtul¬vxwG{² ªlH ®
7Rrj¨©|v=y{rjtugjl !N! !´}lV°lV¹|¨¶{kmjvulHy{ ª{|r K w ; µtx|Py|rBtxvu|GZ/wbt(txgjlm}lV°l"|¨¶lVwGy=gãy² ªtulVvV
txgjl=!N < !vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt± K)¨©|vSw1°lVytu|Gv|¨txgwbtSy² ªtulVvV{}¨{}tS{ h{r!tugjl(ljwGyzthvulH ª²j}tVtx|m¦Ll(km{ x u{}rj
{rtugjlwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlµvxlV u²j}tV®
.ltS² {rBtuvx|²yl¬txgjl(¨©|}|b§{rjErj|t=wbtx{}|Gr H
I
W E3{ (txgjl$jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±¨©|Gvw¥°lHyztu|Gv tugLwbt¦Ul|rjB ¬tu|Ptxgjl$vxlV u²j}tvultu²jvxrjlV2¦±
wrljwyzt 9 9~s ulVwv=y=g¥tu|+¦Ll1kE{ x ª{rj+{rPtxgjl1 ult¬|¨¶wrL ª§lv= vxltu²vurjlH¥¦±!txgjl1wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
9 9S~N ulVwvxy=gpNtk1² tS°Glvx{º¨©±
W /3 K´®¶fhgj{ h{ htugjl3G}|G¦w{kmjvulHy{ ª{|r¥y|Gr ªtuv=w{rGtH®
I
6 { htugjl3vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±m¨©|GvSw1°GlVytu|vtx|6¦Ll(|yVwbtxlV§{ºtxgj{r¥y}²L txlv ª®
I
W 6 ¹{ ¹tuglµjvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±¨©|Gv´w3°GlVytu|v tugLwbt´¦Ul|rG ¹tx|txgjlµvxlV u²j}t¶vultu²jvxrjlH
¦±wrEljwyt9 9~s ªlHwv=y=gtx|¬¦Ulhkm{ x ª{rj¬{}rEtxgjl ªlt"|¨Uwr ª§lv= vultu²jvxrjlV1¦±(tugjlSwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
9 9S~N ulVwvxy=g, ;rj|b§{}r!txgwbt°GlVytu|v3{ |ywtulV2§{}tugj{r y² ªtulv ®¥¸_²v|Bw¹{ (tu|¥¯rLK
ª²Ly=g!txgwbtH+<
" / 6 K)"lr¨©|GvxylV txgjl3|¦w{}kmjvxlVy{ u{}|Gry|r ªtuv=w{rBtV®
ElHyw²L ªllHwy=g°GlVytu|v_¦LlV}|GrjG µtu|!|rjlmwrLP|rj±¥|rjlEy² ªtulvH $ S¨©|vxkm ¬w$Lwvutu{}tu{|r|¨Rtugjl
lV°lVrGtS uwyl®0+SlVrylG
<$EhyVwr¥¦Ul(¨©|vxk²jwbtxlV+wG ¨©|}|b§S 4H
W E
" 6
6 Å ,
vu|GkÎtxgj{ !lH»B²wbtx{}|Gr,§´l2wvxltxvu±{rj tu| ltxlvxkm{}rjl
W zµ¨©|vl°Glvx± u{}rl
y}²L txlv ®¶¸_²jv|GwL{ ¶tugjlVvul¨©|vxlStu|E ª|G}°GlµlH»G²Lwbtu{|r Å ,´wrLmtu|1¯r+§gwbthwvxlStugl_jvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}tu{lV
K |yVwtx|6lVwy=gy² ªtulv {r²LylV¦±$gwJ°{rj6 ªlt K¶®
¼ {}tugj|G²t¬wr±w6vu{|vx{ ;rj|b§lVGl3|rtugjlE{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|GrP|¨¶jwtxw6wrLJ|GvS|r¥txgjlU|G x ª{¦jl{ ~
txvu{¦j²tx{}|Grã|¨Rtugl$»G²lvx±P°lVytu|Gvx V{ºt3{ ({}kmU|G x ª{¦jl1tx|!lH tx{}k6wtul
µ¨©|v(lVwGy=g wrãlVwGy=g
uwrLtxgjlvxl¨©|GvulE{}kmU|G x ª{¦jltx|Py|kmj²jtulKCu,²jr}lH u (§lEy|r u{lv¬tugLwbt
W
" / < <L® |Gr u{lVvu{rj(txgj{ ¶kmlVwrL ¹tugLwbt¶txgjlSjvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}t±|¨,km{ x ª{rjw3°GlVytu|v¶{
²rj{º¨©|Gvukm±+{ txvu{¦j²txlV|b°lVvw},y}²L txlv= {rlVLlVrlrBtx}±!|¨txgjl{vSvxlwbtx{}°Gl_U|G u{ºtx{}|Gr+tx|Etugjl»B²jlVvu±
U|{rBt|v3tx|¥tugjlV{}vL|Gj²jwbtu{|r®$¼ãl!wvxlE§l¶wJ§hwvxltxgwbtEwPywvxl¨©²Rwrw}± u{ (|¨´txgjl+jwtxwP uwyl
y|²jãL|B u u{}¦}±G{}°Gl1¦UltutulVvgj{rGt= ¬¨©|v3lH tx{}k6wbtx{}r
¬wr
W zU|G x u{}¦j±
lVr¨©|v=y{rjãkE|Gvul!jvxlVy{ ul!wjvu|J{k6wbtu{|rL ®2fhgj{ E{ ¶gj|b§´lV°lVvV"wr |UlrAvu|G¦j}lVk tugwtE§l!k6wJ±
ªtu²L±${r!txgjl(¨©²tx²jvulG®
fhgjlVvul¨©|vxl¦±+lVrj|tx{}r
W M
zj{}tS{ hL|B u u{}¦}l¬tu|6vxl§vx{}tul¬lV»B²wbtx{}|Gr ªÅ ,hwG H
W 3 6 K
W 3 6 K
W 3 K Z,
vu|Gk Z;,zj{}tS{ SL|B u u{}¦}l¬tu|6y|ry}²jl(tugwt
" /6 K K/< ½n;,
txgwbt_{ VLlVr¨©|v=y{rj
" / 4 KA¨©|vSlHwy=gy² ªtulVv lVr ª²vulH htugwt
$3 FK´®
fhglrlt¶ ªlHyztx{}|GrE ugj|b§S tuglvxwG{}²L ªlH |¨wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl´g±Ulv= ªjglvxlV {°lVrtxgjl{}kmjvxlVy{ u{|rl°Gl
KAwvxl¬y|kmj²txlV/®
. % +A%D > +8I +,'!.- > +8I5 Z>$ !.# )A =?> >$+ACB'3D ) / "#$'1$I
9lVyztx{}|Gr ®Åãl¯rjlHdg±LlVvª~Nvu{rjB Sg±Ulvu~NyVw !wrD|²tx}{rjlVdtugjl·vxlwbtx{}|Gr ªg{} !¦Ult§llrDtugjl
°G|²jkml´|¨Lvx{}rG wrtugjlh{kmjvulHy{ ª{|r1|¨Ltugjl ulVwv=y=g,® 9lVytu{|rL®_l¯rjlV1§gwt"{ tuglvu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±
q C HC
dmin + 1
1 dmin r
1 1
1
ε 1
ε
HR 1
1
{}G²jvxl3"H16µ u{}rj$wr +µ±LlVvujwr!tu| Í jjvx|J{}k6wbtxl #"
¨©|Gv´w3°GlVytu|v¶¦LlV}|Grj{rj3tx|w uLlHy{}¯LySy² ªtulVvRtu|1¦Ll_km{ x ª{rj3{}¨,{ºt{ ´vxltu²vurjlHm¦±txgjlµlwGyzt¶ ulVwvxy=g,®
fhg{ 3 ulVytu{|r2{ ¬txgjlmwG t ªtul2tx|b§wvxj _ljw{rj{rj¥gj|b§wjjvx|J{k6wbtxl1v=w{² ulV (wvxlmltxlvxkE{rjlH
G{}°Glr K¶®¹f|_vxlVwGy=gtug{ ¹G|GwZb§l¶¯Lvx ªt¹jvulH ªlVrBt"g|b§ tugjlr²jk1¦LlVv¹|¨U°lVytu|Gvx tugwt¶wvxl´{r1tugjlg±LlVvª~
vx{rj$|¨RlHwy=gy}²L txlvµ{ ¬ltxlvxkE{rjlH/®_¼2ltxgjlrãljw{rPtugLwbtV²jrLlv_tugjlE ªUlVy{º¯Uyw x u²jkmtu{|r|¨
{ u|tuvx|±GtuglRr²jk¦Ulv,|¨°lVytu|Gvx Utxgwbtwvul¹{r(tuglRg±BUlvu~syw(|¨BlHwy=g3y² ªtulv{ w ª{kmj}l¶jvu|GL|Gvªtx{}|Gr
|¨¹§gwbt¬{ _{}r¥txgjlg±Ulvu~:vx{}r®¼2l§{}tugjlVr¦UlvxlVwj±+tx|$jvxlV ulrBtStuglr²jkmlvx{yVwkEltugj|P²L ªlH
tx|6y|kmj²jtul3v=w{² ulV V®
f|_lVr¨©|v=yl¶{}rjlH»B²wbtx{}|Gr½n;,zbtxgjl´r²jk1¦LlVv|¨°lHyztx|v= /tugLwbt¹wvxlR}|yVwbtulH{r3tugl´g±LlVvª~syw|¨y}²L ~
txlv ½rj|txlV 4@,R|b°Glv¶tugjl¬tu|txwLr²jk1¦LlVv|¨°lHyztx|v= R¦Ul|rjG{}rjtu| ½rj|txlV #4-,
k1² ªth¦Ul3lV x h|vlV»B²wtu| K´tugLwbtS{ H
4@
#4 K/< © ,
psrlV»B²wbtx{}|Gr ©&,R{r{ywtulV RtugwtVBtu|1lr¨©|GvxylBK2wbt´tugjl¬}lV°lV|¨y² txlv Btugjl¬wjvu|J{kmwtulSv=wj{}²
txgwbtltulvxkm{}rlV ¶tugjl¬°|G}²jkml_|¨ k² ªth¦Ll( ª²Ly=g6tugwt´txgjl¬vulH ª²j}tu{rj1gB±Ulvu~NyVw y|rBtxw{}r
wtkE|B ttxgjl3jvx|U|vutu{|r K |¨"w/tugjl3°GlVytu|v= |¨ ®
#4@¬lUlrLj (|rãtugjl6{ ªtxwrLylE¦Llt§´lVlr +wrLãy}² ªtulVv$ h¦UlVyVw² ulEtugj{ ({kELwyzt= ¬tugjl
½{}rrjlv,my²jvx°bwbtx²jvul|¨ @u® j|v6w·y² ªtulVv, wr w2{°lrwjvu|J{k6wbtul!vxwG{² ¶tugjl¥¨©²vªtxgjlv
,tugjl6¦j{Glv¬tuglEg±Ulvu~NyVw|¨y}² ªtulVv/ª®5_lUlr{rjP|Grtxgjl6{ ªtxwrylm¦Ult§llVr wrãlVwGy=g
y}²L txlv{ 1°lvx±2jvu|G¦jlk6wbtx{y6 u{}rLyl+{}t1{ 1rj|tEL|B u u{}¦}l6tx|ãwGyy|G²jrBt¨©|vEw´U|G x u{}¦jl$|ywbtx{}|Gr |¨
®3pNt({ _U|G x u{}¦jl1tu|¦jvulHw?;!tugj{ 3lVLlVrlrLy±P¦±y|Gr ª{lVvu{rj+wr|b°lVvulH tx{}k6wtu{|rP|¨ ª,yVw}lH
ªLl¯rlV¥w txgjl3{}rBtxlv= ªlHyztu{|r|¨"§{ºtxgwrgw}¨~s ª²j¦L ªwGylG®Rfhgj{ hgLw}¨~N u²j¦ uwyl3y|rBt=w{r
wrm{ ¶¦U|²jrLlV6¦±6wr6g±Ulvxjwr6|vutugj|G|Grwtx| &< ¶wrm}|yVwbtulH$wbtw{ t=wrylS|¨ !
¨©vx|k ® 9µ|txl_txgwbtS|Grjl¬gB±Ulvu~NyVwl¯rlV!² ª{rj6 u²y=g!wr!g±LlVvuwr %* !:?A % !N *;("*3tugLwrtugjl
xwkmlSg±Ulvu~NyVw6l¯LrjlV6²L ª{rj{}tx wytu²wLy²vu°bwbtx²jvxl®"l±{}rj|r6g±LlVvujwrL R{ Rtxgjlvxl¨©|GvulSw xwb¨©l
wjjvx|J{}k6wbtx{}|Grã u{}rLyl${}t|b°lVvulH tx{}k6wtulV _txgjl$jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±Ptu|kE{ x w¥°lHyztu|GvV® {}G²jvul+¥ ugj|b§S 3wr
ljwkmjl3|¨"tugj{ Sg±Ulvxjwr,Ljlrj|tulV¥wG µw6|tªtulHP txvxw{}GgBtS}{rjl® 9µ|tultugjl°G|²jkml3|¨"tugljw{r
GvulV±EwvulHw3{ryvxlVwG ªlHm§{ºtxg+vxlV uLlHyzt¶tx| {²jvxlÅ® vu|Gk r|b§ |r,wLg±Ulvu~NyVw ¶kElVrBtu{|rjlH6{}r+tugjl
vxlV ªt|¨tugj{ wLlVvk² ªtS¦Ll3²rlv= ªtu||!wG wjjvx|J{}k6wtul¬¦B±+gB±Ulvxjwr V®
#4@ Rw u|3lUlrLj ¶|GrEtugjlµj{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r6|¨Utxgjlµjwtxw(U|{rBtx R§{}tug{}r ½wrLEtugjlVvul¨©|vxl
§{}tug{}r 4,wrLDw u|A|rħgj{y=g?:u ª{l ;|¨txgj{ y}²L txlvtugjl »B²jlVvu± U|{rBt{ Py|G ultx|® pN¨1tugjl
j{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r1|¨tugljwtxw_L|G{}rBt= §{}tugj{rmy² txlv
¨©|G}|b§S wSjvx{}°{}lVlH{vulHyztu{|r #4
§{}
¦UlS°Glvx±1{NGUlVvulVrBtR{º¨¬{ Rw ª|w}{rlVE§{ºtxg6tug{ ´{}vxlVytu{|r:©{rmtug{ ywG ªl 4@ "§{}L¦LlµwvuGl ,z
|Gv{º¨E{ |vutugj|G|GrwUtu|mtxgj{ µ{vulHyztx{}|Gr ½{}r¥txgj{ µywG ªl #4@ h§{}¦Ll1 ªk6w,z® |vµ u{kE}{y{}t±
§lhw x ª²jkml´{}r1tugjlhvxlV ªt|¨jtug{ ¹ ulVytu{|rtxgwbt"U|{rGt= {}rElVwGy=g ¨©|}|b§]wr8% '4*@ $'%'4*!# 'L®
9lVyztx{}|Gr®jbgj|b§l°GlvHvxlVy|r u{jlv= /tug{ w x ª²kEjtu{|rwrwyVy|G²jrBtx /¨©|Gvkm|vxl¶vxlVw}{ ªtu{yR{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr
km|lV V®
ElVyVw² ul$U|{rBtx {rAw}´gB±Ulvu~:vx{rjG wvul$ u²jjU|G ulV tu|P¨©|G}|b§ wr { ª|tuvx|j{y6{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr,"tugjl
r²jk1¦LlVv|¨°GlVyztx|v3{r |rjl6g±Ulvu~NyVw2{ 1w¥jvu|GL|Gvªtx{}|Grã|¨htugjl$r²jk1¦LlVv|¨°GlVyztx|v= ({}r·txgjl+y|vxvul~
uU|r{rjmg±LlVvª~Nvu{rjL®fhgjlVvul¨©|vxl #4@hywr!¦Ul3ljvxlV x ulV+wG H
4@ #( @
@
#(
@
?M
Z,
§glvxl
h{ htxgjl°|G}²kEl(|¨txgjl3g±LlVvª~syw!|¨
h{ htxgjl°|G}²kEl3|¨txgjlg±LlVvª~
vx{rj|¨Z
¹txgjl_°G|²jkmlS|¨tugjl_kE{rj{k²jk g±Ulv= ªjglvxlµ¦U|²jrj{}rj wr
txgjl3°|G}²kEl(|¨Z Swjjvx|J{k6wbtxlµg±LlVvx ujgjlVvulG®
6_ ª{rj6lV»B²wtu{|r Z ,j{}tS{ U|G x u{}¦jl¬tu|mvxl§vx{ºtxl¬{rjlH»G²Lwbtu{|r ©&,hw ¨©|G}|b§S H
4M
( #4
#4 K ;,
7¹jylt
4Bw}jtugjltxlvxk6 ¹{}r6{rjlH»G²Lwbtu{|r:,¹lVLlVrm|rEtuglµ ª{ l|¨tugjlµwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl
g±Ulv= ªjglvxl|¨Cª®¹fhgjl_vxwG{² R|¨/tugj{ ´wjjvx|J{}k6wbtxlg±BUlv= ujgjlvxl{ Rtxgjlµ²jr ;Br|b§rmtu|¯Lrm¨©vx|k
txgj{ m²jrj{»G²l!lH»G²Lwbtu{|r®]¼ãlP u|°l{}rlV»B²wbtx{}|Gr ;,¦B±]¯vx ªtmkmw;{}rjãtugl!¨©|G}|b§{rjjvxl{kE{rwvu±
vxlk6wv; 4H
I 4 hyVwrrj|tS¦Ul3ljvxlV x ªlH+wrw±Btu{yw±®
I 4
hlHyvxlVwG ªlH ´§glrtugjl3v=wj{}² |¨ wjjvx|J{k6wbtxl_g±LlVvx ujgjlVvul({ryvxlVwG ªlH ®
I 4 { rj|ty|rBtu{r²j|²L wr!°bwvx{}lH h§{ºtxgj{}r ]®
{°lVrtuglV ul1vxlk6wv<; U{}t({ ¬L|B u u{¦j}ltu|vulH ª|G}°Gl ># ("* < !!AP{rjlV»B²wtu{|r ;,¬wrPtu||¦t=w{r
txgjl+°bw}²jl+¨©|vtugjlvxwG{² |¨tugjlwjjvx|J{}k6wtul6g±LlVvx ujgjlVvul$|¨@ G{}°Glr |rl+ ªUlVy{º¯Uy8K´®2fhgjl
r²jkmlVvu{yw/kEltugj|§l¬²L ªl3vxl{}lH h|r¥wm¦j{ ªlHyztu|Gvª~N¦wG ªlH$ txvxwtulV±$§{}tugj{rtugjl3{rBtulVvu°bwÂ< ® 5_²jl
tx|mwGy;$|¨" ªwGylG§´l3|6rj|t{}ry}²Ll3gjlvxl¬tugjly|vxvulH ªU|rL{}r1 ul²L|~sy|lG®
æÜJÒ(ÕHÒ=ÙhÝ=ÔZÔ:×JÓæzçÑJÒEV/æséæäªçjÙZÑbÝxÙhÝ=ØÁØLÑ QV÷æä½ñä½ÚÁÕJózÔ´Ò#\Ý=ØÁØUåØÁ×JÔZÙZæäZÔÝ=äZæSÚÁÜJæÕÙ:ÚÁåªÝ=Øí_Ð,ÑJæÚÁä¶ÜHÚÁÔZÙZäZÚYJ×VÙ:ÚÁÒzÕmÒzÕHØQ
Ô:ÑbÝ=ä½æ"Ù:ÑHæ¶ÚÁÔZÒ=Ù:ä½Òz÷JÚÁåR÷Jä½Òz÷æªä©Ù[Qí
. = +$' ) + "+ '5) +,' 1) 'A !$ '!
fhgl+jvxl°{|² E ªlHyztx{}|Gr]jvxlV ulrBtulH·tugjl¥wjvu|Bwy=g·² ulV]tu|ãy|kmj²txlwjjvx|J{}k6wbtxl6g±BUlv= ujgjlvxlV
§glr¥tugl°lHyztx|v= h{}rPtxgjlg±Ulvu~:vx{}rG ¨©||b§wr¥{ u|txvu|Gj{y3j{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r,®Sfhg{ ¬w x ª²kEjtu{|rP|lV
y}lHwvx}±Erj|t´gj|Gm{r$txgjlµGlrjlVvxwLywG ªlG®fhglvxl¨©|vxlG{ºt{ ´U|G x ª{¦jlStu|1ltulVrmtxgjl_wjjvx|Gwy=gEtx|1y|GLl
§{}tugwvx¦j{}tuv=wvx±mj{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r ´|¨°lHyztu|Gvx ¶§{ºtxgj{r!g±LlVvª~Nvx{}rjB R|Gr!w1LlVvhy}²L txlvh¦w u{ BtugLwbth{ Vtugjl
w}G|vx{ºtxgjkwGjwt= "{ºt= ¹¦UlgwJ°{|v"tu|(txgjlS uLlHy{}¯Ly{ txvu{¦j²tx{}|Gr6lry|²jrBtulVvulH{rml°Glvx± ª{rjG}ly² ªtulVvV®
fhgjl_jvxl°{}|G² ¶ ulVytu{|r+wG u u²jkmlV6wr$ltxvulVkEl_yw ulS{r6tugl¬ ulr ultxgwbt{ºtw x ª²kElHEtugjl_{ u|txvu|Gj{y
j{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|r!tu|6gj|G+¨©|vSw}
® Í
r|tuglvltxvulVkEl3yVw ul¬{ tu|6y|r u{jlvhtugLwbttugl3°lVytu|Gvx ´{}rPw}
txgjlµg±Ulvu~:vx{}rG ¹|¨wLl{ ªtu{rjy² ªtulVvx *(6 !!,{ry²lH6{}r$tugjlV{}vhw x ª|y{wtulVmg±Ulvu~NyVw,®psr6tug{
yVw ultxgjl°GlVyztx|vµj{ ªtuvx{}¦²tu{|rP{ S ul°lVvulV}±! J;Gl§lV¥wrtxgjl{ ª|tuvx|j{y3w x u²jkmtu{|rP|lV Srj|tµg|
wr±Bkm|GvulG®
psr¥¨½wGyztVL¨©|v_w6{°lVr K´Ltugjl1vulHw{ ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{|rP|¨¹°GlVyztx|v= h{}rPg±Ulvu~:vx{}rG h{ L¨©|vSlHwy=gPy² ªtulVvV
¦Ult§llVrEtugjlht§|w¦U|b°lltuvxlkmlSyVw ulV V®¼2lµywrtxgjlvxl¨©|Gvultuvx±tx|3lV ªtu{k6wbtulG¨©|GvRlVwGy=gEy}² ªtulVvVtugjl
vu|G¦w¦j{{ºt±¥¨©|Gv(tugjlm{ ª|tuvx|j{ym{ ªtuvx{¦j²tu{|rãtu|¥gj|G,® |vy}² ªtulVv/ª/txgj{ 3jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±P{ 3yVw}lH
z®¶fhg{ hjvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}t±+w}|b§S ´tu|mvulV§vu{}tul
" /EhwG H
W E
"
" , 1 ,
§glvxl
W h{ Stxgjljvx|¦Lw¦j{}{}t±+|¨RgwJ°{}r km{ x ª{rj$§glrPtxgjl1y}² ªtulVvµ{ S{ ª|tuvx|j{y®
9²jjU|G u{}rj1tug{ SwG u u²jkmtx{}|Gr+gj|Gj ´¨©|Gv tuglr
W / ´yVwr¦Ll3lH²ylV+¨©vu|Gk {}rlV»B²wb~
tx{}|Gr ,z®¬pN¨¶{}t_{}t(|lH µrj|t_gj|G,LtxgjlrL¨©vx|k ½ ,z
" / ,
®¬pNt¬{ µtugjlVvul¨©|vxl
U|G x u{}¦jl¬tu|mvxl§vx{ºtxl= 1 ,hwG H
W E
@
M
#4
4 !
" 4
#4
$#
K
psr tug{ 6{rjlH»G²Lw{ºt±G
E{ EtxgjlP|r}± ²jr";rj|b§r,®psrlVrjlv=w:´ltulVvukm{rj{}r2§gLwbt${ mtugjl
vx{gBt¶°bw²jl¨©|GvRtug{ ´jvx|¦w¦j{}{}t±¨©|vlVwGy=g6y² txlv´vulH»G²{}vxltu|² ªl¬ t=wbtx{ ªtu{ywLwjvu|Bwy=gjlH ®j|v´|rjl
y}²L txlv) wr(G{}°Glr(|rjl¶jvulHltxlvxkm{}rjlH=K¶J{}t{ ,U|G x ª{¦jl¹tu|µlV ªtu{kmwtul
¦±_¯vx ªty|kmj²tx{}rj
¶wjjvx|J{}k6wtulgB±Ulv= ªgjlvxlh²jrlVv¹tugjlSwG u u²jkmtx{}|GrE|¨UgLwJ°B{rj3wrE{ ª|tuvx|j{yh{ ªtuvx{¦j²tu{|rGwrL
txgjlrmlH tx{}k6wbtxlSgj|b§ kmwr±°lHyztx|v= ¨½w}L{}r ¹g±Ulvu~NyVw,®fhgjlr, ul°lVvxwvxwr|k°lVytu|Gvx ¹yVwrm¦Ll
GlrjlVvxwtulH!wr¥² ulV¥w S»B²jlVvu{lV V®pNtµ{ tug² SU|G x u{}¦jl3tx|$y|²rGtSg|b§ k6wrB±!°lHyztu|Gvx h|¨ kE{ x S{r
txgjl(wjjvx|J{}k6wtulvxlV u²jºtH® |kmwvx{rj3tugl_lH tx{}k6wbtxlV+rB²k¦Ulv|¨,km{ x u{}rj1°lHyztu|Gvx Rtu|tugjl¬r²jk¦Ulv
|¨°GlVyztx|v= ´tugwtµwyztx²w±$km{ x h{ ;l±$tu|Etu²jrl
®