• Aucun résultat trouvé

Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast Nearest-Neighbor Searches

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast Nearest-Neighbor Searches"

Copied!
29
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072165

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072165

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Nearest-Neighbor Searches

Sid-Ahmed Berrani, Laurent Amsaleg, Patrick Gros

To cite this version:

Sid-Ahmed Berrani, Laurent Amsaleg, Patrick Gros. Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast

Nearest-Neighbor Searches. [Research Report] RR-4423, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072165�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4423--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 3

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Controlling the Precision of Approximate Fast Nearest-Neighbor Searches

Sid-Ahmed Berrani — Laurent Amsaleg — Patrick Gros

N° 4423

Mars 2002

(3)
(4)

- &,/. - 1023546&3"

78:9;=<>"?A@B9DCE@GFHFJILK"8NMPORQSIUT"FV@BK/W+<?AXJIUYZ@B[]\!OR^_ILWJFV8:`badcPFHeUX$\

fhgjikmlnoqpsrBtulVvxwGyztx{}|Gr+gj|GkEkml~:k6wy=g€{}rjlG

{‚k6w„ƒGlV…V‡†j|rjrjˆVlV…Vjy|Grjr€w„{‰…x…uwr€ylH…

ŠRvx|„‹ŒltflŽkml

Sw„jU|vutS†Žl3vxlVy=gjlVvxy=gjl‘r“’””‡•„n–o˜—™wvx…S•ššG•(o›•œ1€w„ƒGlV…

+žŸV ¡b¢j£ ¤

fhgj{‰…¥€wLlVv†ŽlH…uyvu{‚¦UlV…¥wAr€l§›wjjvx|GwGy=g¨©|v¥LlVvª¨©|Gvukm{‚rjƒAl«$y{‚lrBt™w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulV†r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~

r€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|Gv¬…ulVwvxy=g€lV…S{‚r–g€{}ƒGgŽ~N†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€w­†€wbtxw¦€w…ulV…V®3fhgj{‰…¬wjjvx|GwGy=g™w„­‚­}|b§S…_w$¯€r€lEy|rBtuvx|­|b°lVv

txgjl€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|rP|¨txgjlm…ªlHw„v=y=g¦‡±¥…ªltªtx{}rjƒ+tugjl1k6wbŽ{}k1²jk³jvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tŒ±$¨©|v¬w$°GlVyztx|vtxg€wbt¬§´|G²j­‰†P¦Ll

{‚rPtxgjllŽwGyzt(w„r€…u§´lVvµ…ultµtx|+¦Ulkm{‰…u…u{}r€ƒ${}r™tugjlmw„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tulH†…ult¬|„¨¶wr€…ª§lv=…V®pNt¬w…x…u²jkmlV…txg€wbt

¨©lHwbtx²jvulE°lHyztx|v=…¬wvul1lr€y­}|B…ªlH†–{‚r·y­‚²€…Œtxlv=…®6¸_rjlE|„¨¶txgjl6y|GrGtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr–|¨¶tug€{‚…(€wLlVv3{‚…_txgjl$y|Gk1~

€²Žtxw„tu{‚|r$|¨y|GrGtxvu|G­}­‚lV†6wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}|Gr€…¹|¨,lVwy=g!y­‚²€…ŒtxlvH®fhg€lV…ul_w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtu{‚|rL…R†ŽlUlrL†$|r+tugjl

†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r6|¨/†€wbtxw§{ºtxgj{}r+lVwy=g6y­}²€…ªtulVvV®¹f|w„rL…ª§lvRw»B²jlVvu±G„txgjl_…ulVwvxy=gmjvx|ŽylV…x…Ry|r€…u{‚†jlv=…"tugjl

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}|Gr€…"txg€wbty|GvuvxlV…uL|Gr€†1tu|1tugjl(†ŽlH…ª{‚vulH†m­}lV°lV­L|¨jvxlVy{‰…u{}|Gr,®fhg€{‚…´k6wJ±myVw„²€…ulStxgjl(wyztx²€w„­

r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…´|„¨txgjl»B²jlVvu±$U|{‚rBthtu|6¦Ul3{}ƒGrj|vxlV†/®¶¸_²jvkmltugj|Ž†/Lgj|b§´lV°lVvVBjvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{‰…Œtx{‚yVw„­‚­}±

¦U|²€r€†j…¶tugjl¬y=g€w„r€ylV…R¨©|v´tugj{‰…Rtx|g€wjUlr,®¹fhgj{‰…¶Lw„Ulvhw„­‰…ª|€vulH…ªlVrGt=…¶wLlVvª¨©|Gvuk6w„rLylS…ªtu²€†Ž±6|¨/tugjl

{‚kmj­‚lkmlrBtxw„tu{‚|r,®¼2l1…ugj|b§3Ž¨©|vµljw„kmj­‚l€tug€w„tStugj{‰…Skmltugj|Ž†¥{‰…Skm|vxl(tug€wr–œEtu{‚kmlV…S¨½w…ªtulvStug€wr

txgjlµ…ulV»B²jlVrGtx{‚w­€…xyw„rm§gjlVr6{ºt´g€w„r€†j­}lH…¹km|vxlhtug€wrP¾¿ÁÀE¾VÂÃS•„”„~s†Ž{‚kElVr€…u{}|Gr€…"°lHyztu|Gvx…V„lV°lrm§gjlVrmtugjl

€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±6|¨km{‰…u…u{}r€ƒE|Grjl(|„¨tugjl¬txvu²jl3r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…´{‚…h¦Ul­‚|b§Äš€®š€Å®

ÆPÇBȓÉxÊË ¡b̟¤ÎÍ jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tul3rjlHw„vxlV…ªtSrjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|vµ…ulVwvxy=gjlGjk²€­ºtx{‚†Ž{‚kmlr€…u{‚|r€w­{‚r€†ŽlŽ{‚rjƒ€Uy|GrGtxlrBtª~

¦Lw…ulV†!vultuvx{}lV°Jw­

ÏRÐÑHÒzÓÔ:ÒzÕ_Ö(×JØÙ:ÚÁÓیÜJÚÞݶßà¹áãâbäZÝ=ÕJåŒæçŽèzçJݪé_ê“æŒØÁØÁæ"âbÒzÕÙNÝ=ÚÁÕJæzçê/ë¥èªìHíUîzïzïHèzè´ð/æŒÔZÔ:ÒzÕHñ½òیéVÚÁózÕJÛ¹ñLâbä:Ý=ÕJåŒæzí

ô¹õLö

×JÚÁ÷„æ¹ÐŽæŒøVÓæsøGçHù©ßù½òúñ½ð/ûßòí

(5)

Ÿ ¤ l6v=w„jU|vut¬€vuˆH…ªlVrGtxlm²jrjl6rj|G²j°lV­}­‚ltxlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jl6U|²jv3vxlVy=g€lv=y=gjlv(†Žlm¨½w|r2w„jjvx|„~

y=g€ˆlm­}lH…(j­‚²€…(jvx|‡y=g€lV…(°|G{‚…u{‚r€…(†²€r2°GlVytul²€v¬vxlV»B²tul6w„²·…ul{‚r·†jlE¦Lw…ulV…(†Žl$†Ž|GrjrjˆlH…(g€w„²jtulkmlVrGt

k1²j­}tu{‰†Ž{}kmlVr€…ª{‚|r€rjl­‚­}lH…® ltutulEtulHy=gjrj{‰»B²jl6y|rBtxvG­}l1­‚wjvxˆVy{‚…u{}|Gr–†Žlm­‰w!vxlVy=g€lv=y=gjllVr–¨©|Gr€yztx{}|Gr2†Žl

­‰w1jvu|G¦€w„¦€{}­‚{ºtxˆµk6wbŽ{‚k6w„­‚l¬»B²jl¬­|rw†Žl(rjl¬€wG…´vxltxvu|G²j°lVv´†jwr€…´­}l(vxˆV…u²j­ºt=wbthw„jjvx|Žy=gjˆµ²€r!°GlVyztxl²jv

»B²j{h…ulv=w„{}tjvxˆV…ulrBtE†jwr€…­‚lvuˆH…ª²j­}txw„tljwGyztV® ltutul!tulVy=g€rj{‚»B²jl†Žlk6wr€†Žlãyl»G²€l+­‚lV…1°lVytulV²jvx…

…u|{‚lrBtSw„²¥jvxˆVw­‚w¦j­‚l¬vxlƒGvu|G²jUˆV…†jwr€…†ŽlV…µ€w„vutu{}tu{‚|rL… "!$#&%')("*+%-,z®/.w6y|GrGtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr!k6w„‹Œl²jvxl†Žlyl

txvxwJ°bw{}­lV…ªt_²jrjl1kmˆtug€|‡†jlU|²jv(yw­‚y²j­}lVvµ²jr–lr€…ulk1¦j­}lE†Žl¨©|GvukmlH…Slr€ƒ­‚|¦€wrGtxlV…_w„jjvx|Žy=gjˆlH…U|²jv

y=gLw»B²jl0 "!$#&%')("*z®1.,lH…´yVw„v=wyztxˆvx{‚…ªtu{‰»B²jlV…¶†ŽlV…¶¨©|vxkmlV…RlVrjƒ­‚|¦Lw„rBtulH…¶w„€jvu|Žy=gjˆVlV…R†jˆUlr€†ŽlVrBth†Žl_­‚w1†Ž{‰…Œ~

txvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr+†ŽlH…¶°GlVyztxl²jv=…¶w²+…ul{‚r!†Žl¬y=g€w»B²jl0 "!$#&%'2(*(ltw„²L…u…u{L†ŽlH…¶r€{}°GlVw„²j6†jlµjvxˆVy{‚…u{}|Gr6jvxˆV†Žˆ¯€rj{‰…®

|Grb‹Œ|{‚rBtulVkElVrBt3…uw+vulH»B²txl/­4²Žtx{}­‚{‰…uw„tul²€v(†j|{}t¬¨©|G²jvxrj{}v¬²jrãtxw²Ž–†ŽlEjvuˆHy{‰…ª{‚|r2ywvxwGyztuˆVvu{‰…xw„rBtS­‚w

»B²€w­}{}tuˆ†Žl­‚wµvuˆVL|Gr€…ªl»B²5{‚­Ž…ª|G²jg€w{ºtxl®76µrjl´¨©|{‰…­‰w„r€yˆlGb­‚wµvulHy=gjlv=y=gjlRr5²Žtx{}­‚{‚…ulhw„­‚|v=…»B²jl¶­‚lV…¨©|GvukmlV…

lVrjƒ­‚|¦Lw„rBtulH…wjjvx|Žy=gjˆlH…»B²j{w„²jvx|rBthˆtuˆ3€vuˆ~NyVw„­‰y²j­‚ˆlH…´U|²€vµyl¬txw²Ž/®¹ps­…ul¬Ul²jt_w„{‚r€…u{,»G²8²jr¥|G²

€­}²€…u{‚l²jv=…†ŽlH…j­‚²€…jvu|Žy=gjlH…3°|G{‚…u{‚r€…3ljwGyztx…1†Ž² U|{‚rGtEvulH»B²txl+…ª|G{}lVrBt{}ƒGrj|vxˆV…V®:9S|„txvul+kEˆtugj|Ž†Žl

¦U|vxrjlµ†jlµ¨½w;|r6€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{‚…ªtulS­‚lV…y=g€wr€ylH…RU|²jvh»B²jl_yl­‰ww„vxvu{‚°lG® l_vxwjU|vut¶jvxˆV…ulrBtulSˆVƒGw­}lVkElVrBt

²€rjlPˆtx²€†Žl™l‡Uˆvx{‚kElVrBtxw„­‚lP†ŽlV…+LlVvª¨©|Gvuk6wr€ylH…E†jl–yltªtul¥txlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jlG® ltutul™ˆtu²€†jlPkE|GrBtuvxlh€w„v

lŽlkmj­‚l¹»B²jl+U|²jv¾<=À·¾V à °lHyztxl²jv=…wJ±Bw„rBt1•b”–†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€…V"­‚w–vulHy=gjlv=y=gjl$wjjvx|‡y=g€ˆl6lV…ªtµ‹Œ²L…Œ~

»B²5$œE¨©|G{‚…€­}²€…µvxwj{‰†Žl»B²5²€rjlvxlVy=gjlVvxy=gjl3…uˆV»B²jlVrGtx{}lV­}­‚lLk=kml­‚|v=…u»B²jl3­‰wmjvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tuˆ†{‚ƒrj|GvulVv

²€r¥†jlV…hj­‚²€…jvx|Žy=gjlV…°G|{‰…ª{‚r€…hljwGyztx…h†Ž²¥U|{‚rBtSvulH»G²>tul(lH…ŒtS{‚rŽ¨©ˆvx{‚l²jvxlEš€š€Å®

?Ë  HŸ É £@ Ÿ·¤ lVy=gjlVvxy=g€lmwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}°Gl6†ŽlV…3€­}²€…jvx|‡y=g€lV…(°|G{‚…u{‚r€…{}rL†Žljwbtx{}|Gr·k²j­}tu{‰†Ž{‚kElVrŽ~

…u{‚|rjrjlV­}­‚lŽvxlVy=g€lv=y=gjl_Lw„vh­}ly|rBtulVr‡²

(6)

% &

1" !¶

psk6wƒlh†jwbt=w„¦€wG…ªlH…wr€†tugjlVvul¨©|vxlhy|rBtulVrBtª~N¦€w…ulV†vultuvx{}lV°Jw­Ž…ª±Ž…ªtulk6…"g€wJ°Gl´¦UlVy|kmlh{}rLyvxlVw…u{‚rjƒ­‚±3{}kE~

U|vutxwrBt{‚r1k6wrB±wjj­‚{‚yVwbtx{}|Gr€…"w„vxlVw……u²€y=gEwG…kElH†Ž{‰y{‚rjl„ƒGl|Gƒv=w„jg‡±J§lVw„tugjlVvª~:¨©|vxlVyVw…ªtVHkE|G­}lHy²j­‰w„v

¦€{}|G­}|Gƒ±w„vutV"…ªlHy²jvx{ºtŒ±GR¿¿V¿ |rBtulVrBtª~N¦€w…ulV†ã{}k6wƒl6vxltuvx{‚l°bw„­R…u±Ž…Œtxlk6…3vxl­‚±–|r·{‚k6w„ƒl6€vu|ŽylH…u…u{‚rjƒ

txlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jlH…Stx|!lBtxvxwGyzt'(% "* '( *+%E¨©vx|k5{‚kmwƒlH…*)+,3—.-0/2143N®65µlH…uyvu{‚Žtu|Gvx…µlr€y|Ž†Žl1{‚rŽ¨©|Gvuk6wbtx{}|Gr

¨©|G²jr€† {‚rd{‚k6w„ƒlH…® fhg€l±w„vxlPtŒ±‡j{‚yVw„­‚­}± °lHyztx|v=…6|„¨vxlVw­µr‡²jk¦Ulv=…+†jl¯€rj{‚rjƒ L|G{}rBtx…+{}rÄw gj{‚ƒgŽ~

†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€w­,…ªLwylG®Rfhgjl3…ª{‚km{}­‰w„vx{}tŒ±$|„¨tŒ§´|m{‚k6w„ƒlH…h{‚…wG…u…u²jkmlV†!tx|E¦Ul3jvx|U|vutu{‚|r€w­Utu|mtug€l…ª{‚km{º~

­‰w„vx{}tŒ±$|„¨tugjlV{}v¬†ŽlV…xyvx{‚Žtu|Gvx…VŽ§gj{‰y=g{‰…kmlVwG…ª²€vulH†wG…tugjltŒ±‡j{‰yw„­‚­‚±87R²€y­}{‰†ŽlHw„r ,†j{‚…ªtxwr€yl3¦UltŒ§llVr

txgjl3U|{‚rGt=…S†Žl¯€rjlV†¦‡±$txgjl†ŽlH…uyvu{‚Žtu|Gvx…V®:9‡{‚km{}­‰w„vx{ºtŒ±!…ªlHw„v=y=g!{‰…tugjlVvul¨©|vxl(|„¨tulVrP{}kmj­‚lkmlVrGtxlV†¥w…w

r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|vh…ulVw„v=y=g 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g ,´§{}tugj{‚rtugjl(¨©lHwbtx²jvul3…u€wyl®

9µlVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|vm…ulVw„v=y=gA{‰…m{‚rjgjlvxlrBtx­}±]lŽLlVr€…ª{‚°l¥w„rL† †Žl¯€rj{‚rjƒ l«$y{}lVrGt6kmltxgj|Ž†j…E¨©|v6{‚rŽ~

†jlŽ{}r€ƒE­‰w„vxƒl¬gj{‚ƒgŽ~s†Ž{‚kmlr€…u{}|Gr€w„­,†€wbtxwG…ªltx…hvxlk6w„{‚r€…wr!²jrL…ª|G­}°GlV†!jvu|G¦j­‚lk¥® Í ­‚­,lŽ{‰…Œtx{}r€ƒE{‚r€†ŽlŽ{}rjƒ

…xy=gjlVkElH…Eƒlr€lv=w„­‚­}± §|v<; §´lV­}­h¨©|Gv6­}|b§h~s†Ž{‚kmlr€…u{}|Gr€w„­…u€wylV…V® fhg€l{‚v6LlVvª¨©|Gvuk6w„rLyl´gj|b§l°lVvV¶{‚…

;‡rj|b§rtu|_†jlƒv=w†jl´w…tug€l´r‡²jk1¦LlVv|¨L†Ž{‚kElVr€…u{}|Gr€…|¨jtug€l†ŽlH…uyvu{‚Žtx|v=…,{‚r€yvxlVwG…ªlG®fhgj{‰…€gjlrj|Gkmlrj|Gr

{‰…=;‡rj|b§r·w…¬txgjl "# *+%(> 8'?=(%?@ !'Ab®psr·|„tug€lv§|v=†j…V,r€wJ°‡{}ƒBwbtx{}rjƒ§{}tugj{‚r2tugjl${‚r€†Žlã¦Ul~

y|kmlV…"km|Gvulhy|B…Œtx­}±3txg€w„r6w(…u{}kmj­‚lG¦jvu²jtul¨©|v=ylG…ªlH»B²jlrBtu{‰w„­j…xywr1{‚rEgj{}ƒGgŽ~s†Ž{}kmlVr€…ª{‚|rm…u€wylV…"§gjlVr

…ulVwvxy=g€{}rjƒ6r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…V®B+S|b§l°GlvHL…ulV»B²jlVrGtx{‚w­…xywr€…µwvulEy­‚lVwvu­‚±!{‚rŽ¨©lHw…u{}¦j­‚l1¨©|v¬°lvx±­‚wvuƒGl

{‚k6w„ƒGl(†€wbtxw¦€w…ulV…V®

fhgjlEy²jv=…ul|„¨¶†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€w­}{}tŒ±jgjlr€|kmlrj|Gr™{‰…µ€wvªtx{‚y²j­‰w„vx­}±jvxl°bw„­‚lrBtµ§gjlVr™Ulvu¨©|vxkE{‚rjƒ (<

; ' 9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=gjlV…V®¶fhgjlVvul¨©|vxlŽtxgjlvxl3{‚…_w„r¥{‚r€yvxlVwG…ª{‚rjƒm{}rBtxlvxlV…ªtS{}rPUlvu¨©|vxkm{}rjƒ. *<C ')(=9 9~

…ulVwvxy=g€lV…V,§gjlvxl$vxlV…u²j­}t1»B²€w„­‚{ºtŒ±ã{‚…tuv=w†ŽlH†ã¨©|vvxlV†j²€ylH†2»B²jlVvu±2lŽlHy²Žtx{}|Grãtx{}kmlD)¼FEhšš3:®Pf|™¦Ll

²L…ªl¨©²j­{}r jv=wytu{‰yl¶tugj{‰…Etuv=w†jl~N|?Gd…ª²€ƒƒlH…Œt=…tx|·kmw;l!tugjl¥²€…ulv6w¦j­}ltx|2…ult6gj{‚k6…ªlV­º¨¬tugjl¥jvxlVy{º~

…u{‚|r]|¨Stugjl¥w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul…ªlHw„v=y=g]†ŽlUlrL†Ž{}r€ƒã|Gr]tug€l†ŽlH…ª{‚vxlV†AwGyy²jvxwGy±G®ãpNt6w„­‰…ª|2…ª²€ƒƒlH…Œt=…txg€wbt

txgjl²jrL†Žlvx­}±‡{‚rjƒ$…ulVw„v=y=gjvu|ŽylV…x…hvulH…ªUlVytx…h¨½w{ºtxgŽ¨©²j­‚­}±!tugj{‰…µ…ultutu{‚rjƒ€€tug€w„tS{‚…V€{}tµk1²€…Œt_rj|„tSvxltx²jvurPwr

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlhvulH…ª²j­}t¶|¨w(§´|Gvx…ulS»B²€w„­‚{ºtŒ±1tugLw„rmtug€lµ|r€lSlŽUlVyztxlV†/Bk6w?;‡{‚rjƒ{‚rmtugj{‰…´yVw…ulhtugjl¬…ªltªtx{}rjƒ

kmlHw„rj{‚rjƒ­‚lV…x…V®·fhg€{‚…E{‰…1{‚r ƒlr€lv=w„­¶°Glvx± †Ž{º«$y²j­ºtH´wr€†]km|G…ªtm|„¨Stxgjl¥lŽ{‚…ªtu{‚rjƒ2…Œtx²€†Ž{‚lV…ElŽj­‚|vx{}r€ƒ

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl9 9~s…ulVw„v=y=gjlH…†Ž|$rj|tµjvx|b°B{‰†Žl3…u²€y=g™y|GrGtxvu|G­Z€l{}tugjlVvµ¦UlVyw²€…ul3|„¨¹|b°lVvª~s…ª{‚kmj­‚{º¯€lH†!wG…Œ~

…u²jkmŽtx{}|Gr€…hvulH…ª²€­ºtx{}rjƒ6{‚r¥rj|mvulHw„­,y|rBtuvx|­:Ž|v¦UlVyVw„²€…ul¬tugjl=;‡rj|G¦8½…+,´¨©|vS…ultutu{‚rjƒ6jvxlVy{‰…u{}|GrwGyztu²Lw„­‚­}±

y|rBtuvx|­“­‚|b§h~:­‚l°Gl­/…u±‡…ªtulVk €wvxwkEltulVvx…´tugLwbtV€§gjlrPy=g€wrjƒlH†/‡g€wJ°l¬°lVvu±$|G¦€…xy²jvxl¬y|r€…ulV»B²jlVr€ylH…®

psrmy|GrGtxvxwG…ŒtHJtugj{‰…"€wLlVv"†jlV…xyvx{}¦UlV…"w¬kmltug€|‡†tugLwbt¹jvx|b°B{‰†ŽlH…wrEwGyy²€vxw„tul¶€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{‚…ªtu{‰y´y|rBtuvx|­

|b°Glvtxgjl€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|r¥|„¨¶wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=gjlH…®Sfhg€{‚…_y|rBtxvu|G­g€wG…tug€l{‚rGtxlvxlV…ªtu{‚rjƒ$jvx|Ulvutu{‚lV…

tx|m¦LlH

I ­}lHw„vx­}±!²jr€†ŽlVvx…ªtxwr€†jw¦j­}l3¦‡±lr€†Ž~:²€…ulv=…V® 6_…ªlVvx…SwvulwG…J;GlV†!tu|+jvu|b°‡{‰†Žljtu|ƒGltxgjlv_§{ºtxg¥tugjlV{}v

»B²jlvx±bwS€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±=Kyw„­‚­‚lV†(txgjlB * ( %!(L ("!8Œ¾"M=K!{‚…tug€lvxl¨©|vxl¶yVw„­‚­}lH†(tugjljvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr

­}lV°lV­,®"fhg€{‚…´jvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tŒ±Ey|vxvulH…ªU|r€†€…"tu|tugjl_jvu|G¦€w„¦€{}­‚{ºtŒ±1¨©|vw°GlVyztx|v¹txg€wbth¦Ul­‚|rjƒB…¹tu|tugjl

ljwyt!w„rL…ª§lv+…ult+tu|]¦Ul–wytu²€w­}­‚± kE{‰…x…ª{‚rjƒ]{‚rtugjl2w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tulP…ult+|¨3wr€…u§´lVvx…mtxg€wbt!{‚…

l°GlrBtu²€w­}­‚±$vxltx²jvur€lV†/®

I

f²€r€w„¦j­‚lwbtvx²jrŽ~:tu{‚kml® Í ²€…ulvSyVw„rvulH…ª²€¦jkm{ºtSgj{‰…»B²jlvx±$§{}tugPw6†Ž{NGUlVvulVrBth€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|r¥…ªltªtx{}rjƒ

{º¨gjlµ¨©lVl­‰…´tug€w„t¶tug€l¬y²jvuvxlrBth…ªltªtu{‚rjƒ1{‚…rj|tw†jlV»B²€wbtxl0©tu|‡|1y|Gw„v=…ul¨©|vljw„kmj­‚l ,® g€w„rjƒG{}r€ƒ

tugjlP…ultutu{‚rjƒã§{‚­‚­rj|„t6yw²€…ªlw„r‡± l‡txvxwãy|G…ªtEtu|2¦Ll¥w†j†jlV† |r txgjl¥l°bw„­‚²€wbtx{}|GrA|¨_»B²jlvx{}lH…®

fhgjl(jvx|U|G…ulV†+…xy=gjlVkEl(w„­‚­‚|b§S…¶²€…ulv=…´tu|mƒv=wyl¨©²j­‚­‚±my=gLw„rjƒGlµtxgjl(jvulHy{‰…ª{‚|r…ªltªtx{}rjƒB…Žv=w„r€ƒ{‚rjƒ

(7)

¨©vu|Gktxgjlµ­‚|G…x…u­}lH…u…R…ulVwvxy=gbtu|­‚|b§lvRjvxlVy{‚…u{‚|rm­}lV°lV­‚…V® Í …¶lŽLlHyztulH†/Bgj{}ƒGgjlv´jvxlVy{‰…u{}|GrmyVw„²€…ulV…

gj{‚ƒgjlVvµvxlV…uL|Gr€…ªl¬tx{}kml½k²€y=g¥¨½wG…Œtxlvtxg€w„r™w+…ªlH»G²€lrBtu{‰w„­…ulVwvxy=gjgj|b§l°lVv+,®¶psr™wG†j†Ž{}tu{‚|r,U{ºt

{‚…_U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l3tu|$²L…ªl3txgj{‰…µkmltxgj|Ž†tu|!¦j²j{‚­‚†™w6…u±Ž…Œtxlk³{‚rP§gj{‚y=g¥txgjl€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|r¥|„¨¹txgjlwr€…ª§lv

{}kmjvx|b°lH…hw…tug€l(tu{‚kEl3ƒG|‡lV…h¦‡±®

I Í ­‚­¶y|B…Œt=…(w„vxl1j²L…ªgjlH†™tx|tugjl6|GL~N­}{‚rjlmjg€wG…ªlG®1fhgjl6y|kmj­‚lãyVw„­‰y²j­‰wbtx{}|Gr€…¬|„¨wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

vxwG†Ž{‚²€…ªlH…w„vxl3w„­‚­,LlVvª¨©|GvukmlH†+|GL~N­}{‚rjlG® Í tSvu²€rŽ~Ztx{}kmlGj|r€yl=KA…ultVjtugjl…ulVwvxy=g¥w„­‚ƒ|Gvu{}tugjk‹Œ²L…Œt

rjllH†j…htx|m…ul­‚lVyttugjly|vxvulH…ªU|rL†Ž{}r€ƒ1w„€jvu|Gjvx{‚w„tul¬vxwG†Ž{}²L…ªlH…¶tx|$y|Gr€…ª{‰†ŽlVvV®

I

7¹«$y{‚lrBtV®¶¸_²jv¹kmltugj|Ž†m{‰…"l«$y{‚lrBtR{‚r1txgjlµ…ulr€…ultug€w„tR{ºtR{‰…¹k1²€y=g¨½wG…Œtxlv¹txg€w„rEtxgjlS…ªlH»B²jlrBtu{‰w„­

…uyVw„r–wr€†P{}t¬Ulvu¨©|vxk6w„r€yl†Ž|‡lV…_rj|t¬…ul°lVvulV­}±¥†ŽlVƒv=w†ŽlH…µw…µtug€l1†Ž{‚kmlr€…u{}|Gr™|„¨†jwbt=w+w„rL†J|Gv

tugjl…u{ l3|„¨tugjl†€wbtxw¦€w…ul¬{}r€yvulHw…ul®

fhgjlPkmltugj|Ž† w…x…u²jkmlV…1tug€w„t+°lHyztx|v=…Ewvul¥lVr€y­‚|G…ulV† {}rkm{‚rj{}k1²jk ¦L|G²jr€†Ž{‚rjƒ g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvu{‰yw­

y­}²L…Œtxlv=…®fhgjl†jw„txwmU|{‚rGt=…S¦Ul­‚|rjƒG{}r€ƒmtu|+w6y­}²€…ªtulVvµw„vxl…ªtu|vxlV†!tx|ƒltugjlVv|r™†Ž{‰…;+{‚r™w$…ªlH»B²jlrBtu{‰w„­

k6wrjrjlvH® 7¶wy=gy­‚²€…ªtulvh{‰…w„r€w­}±VlV†6|GL~N­}{‚rjl3w„rL†${‚rwG†j†Ž{}tu{‚|r$tx|Etugjl(ljwGyzthvxwG†Ž{}²L…¶|¨lVwGy=g+g‡±‡LlVvª~

…ujgjlVvulGŽw„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulSv=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…w„vxl_y|kmj²ŽtxlV†/ŽlHwy=g+y|vxvulH…ªU|r€†j{}rjƒtu|mwjvxlV†jltulVvukm{‚rjlV†+­}lV°lV­U|¨

{‚kmjvxlVy{‰…u{}|Gr,®fhg€l_w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtulµvxwG†Ž{}²L…ªlH…¹|„¨wy­‚²€…Œtxlvhw„vxlµw„­‚§hwJ±‡…¶…ªk6w„­‚­‚lv´tug€wr${ºt=…¶ljwyztvxwG†Ž{‚²€…®

f|1wr€…ª§lv´w»B²jlvx±Gtug€lµ²€…ulv´g€w…Rtu|€vu|b°‡{‰†Žlµw„r+{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr6­}lV°lV­Ly|GrBtuvx|­‚­}{‚rjƒ(tug€l¬»B²€w­}{}tŒ±1|¨

txgjl_wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g,®"fhgj{‰…¶{‚kmjvxlVy{‰…u{}|Gr6­}lV°l­U†Žvx{}°GlV…R§g€{‚y=g+wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlvxwG†Ž{‚²€…ªlH…Rk1²€…Œt

¦UlEtxw;lrã{}rBtx|¥wGyy|²jrBt(¦B±¥txgjlE¯€­}tulvx{‚rjƒ¥vu²j­‚lV…_txg€wbt3l­‚{‚kE{‚r€w„tulm{}vxvxl­‚l°bw„rBt3y­‚²€…Œtxlv=…®*7R­}{‚km{}rLwbtu{‚rjƒ

y­}²L…Œtxlv=…|Grtug€l´¦€wG…ª{‰…|„¨jtxgjl{‚v¹w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulRv=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…{}r€…ªtulHw†|rtxgjl¦€w…u{‚…|„¨€tugjlV{}v"ljwGyztv=w†j{}²€…ulV…

k6wJ±+yVw„²€…ul_tugjl8; '4# !rjlVwvulH…Œtu~:r€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|Gvx…´|„¨tugjl»B²jlVvu±+L|G{}rBttu|m¦Ul3{}ƒGrj|vxlV†,®

fhgjlµvulH…ŒtR|¨Ltxgj{‚…¶€w„Ulv¶{‚…¶|vxƒGw„r€{VlV†wG…"¨©|­‚­‚|b§S…®09‡lVytu{‚|r$•(†Ž{‰…uy²€…x…ªlH…¹vulV­‚w„tulH†1§|v<;“® 9‡lHyztx{}|Grmn

ƒG{}°GlV…3wƒ­‚|¦Lw„­¹|b°lVvu°‡{‚l§ |¨´txgjl$…ulVw„v=y=gãtulVy=g€rj{‚»B²jlG®+fhgjlVr, 9‡lHyztx{}|Gr2”P€vulH…ªlVrGt=…¬tugjl6kmltugj|Ž†ã¨©|v

wGyy²jvxw„tulV­}±·y|GrGtxvu|G­}­‚{‚rjƒ¥tugjljvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr |„¨µwjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=gjlH…® 9‡lVytu{‚|r œ™l°bw„­‚²€wbtxlV…tugjl

Ulvu¨©|vxk6w„r€yl_|¨txgjl(tulHy=gjrj{‰»B²jl3w„r€† 9‡lHyztu{‚|rmy|Gr€y­‚²€†ŽlH…w„r€†¥†Ž{‰…uy²€…x…ªlH…´|GLlVr¥{‚…x…ª²€lV…V®

&(

fhg€{‚…R…ulVytu{‚|r6†Ž{‰…uy²€…x…ªlH…"vulV­‚w„tulV†1§|v<;U®¼ãlS¯€vx…ªtR|b°lVvu°‡{‚l§ txvxwG†Ž{}tu{‚|r€w­Žk²j­}tu{‰†Ž{‚kElVr€…u{}|Gr€w„­j{‚r€†ŽlŽ{}rjƒ

wjjvx|GwGy=gjlV…(wy=g€{}lV°B{‚rjƒ¥ljwGyzt 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g€lV…V®$¼ãl+lV…uLlHy{‰w„­‚­}±–¨©|‡y²€…3|Grãtxgjl6¯€­}tulVvu{‚rjƒPvx²j­‚lV…(txgjlV…ulV…

txlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jlH…S²€…ul3tu|!†Žvxwk6wbtu{‰yw­}­‚±$vxlV†Ž²Lyl3txgjl{‚vµvxlV…uL|Gr€…ul(tu{‚kElH…®¼2ltxgjlr–kE|b°Gl(tu|+wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=g!…xy=gjlkmlH…®

"!$#&%('*)+,'!.-0/21.*

fv=w†Ž{}tu{‚|r€w­k1²j­ºtx{‚†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€w­{‚r€†ŽlŽ{}rjƒ+tulHy=gjrj{‰»G²€lV…µtŒ±B€{‚yVw„­‚­}±¥†Ž{‚°B{‰†Žl1tugjlE†jwbt=w+…u€wyl{‚rGtx|!yl­‚­‚…

y|rBtxw{}r€{}rjƒP°GlVytu|v=…V® l­‚­y|r€…ªtuvx²€yztx{}|Gr]…Œtxvxw„tulVƒ{‚lV…yVw„r ¦Uly­‚wG…u…u{º¯LlV†2{}rAtŒ§´|P¦€vu|Bw† yw„tulVƒ|vx{‚lV…4H

' '( *''? 2mw„r€† % +( *' ' 2E{}rL†ŽlŽ{‚rjƒ3kmltug€|‡†€…®05¬wbtxw„~:Lw„vutu{}tu{‚|rj{‚rjƒ(kmltug€|‡†€…R…ª²Ly=g

wG…Stxgjl43S~sfvxll )E ,=,=/5 3"|Gvµtxgjl9"9B~sfvxll>)¼76 /8 3R†Žl¯€rjlmylV­}­‰…(wyy|v=†Ž{‚rjƒ6tu|!tug€lE†Ž{‰…ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{‚|r–|¨

°GlVytu|v=…V® 9‡Lwyl~:Lw„vutu{}tu{‚|rj{‚rjƒkmltugj|Ž†j…S…u²€y=gw…tug€l3. 9 5 g

~Nfvxll )+µlr /59 3|v$)¼ 9 E /89 3†j{}°‡{‰†Žl(tugjl

†€wbtxwm…u€wyl({}rBtu|6yl­‚­‚…w­}|GrjƒmjvulH†Žl¯LrjlV†!­}{‚rjlH…vulVƒGwvx†Ž­‚lV…x…´|„¨txgjlwytu²€w­,†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr|¨°GlVyztx|v=…®

(8)

9 9~sw„­‚ƒ|vx{}tugjk6…¬tŒ±‡j{‰yw„­‚­‚±P²€…ªlmtxgjl6ƒlV|kmltxvu{‰yw­"jvu|GLlVvªtx{}lH…¬|„¨yl­‚­‰…¬tu|¥l­‚{}km{‚r€wbtxlmtugj|B…ªl6yl­‚­‚…

txg€wbt¹ywrrj|t¹g€wJ°lw„r‡±3{}km€wGyzt"|rtugjlhvxlV…u²j­ºt"|„¨Ltugjlhy²€vuvxlrBt¹»G²€lvx±) ,/Gœ‡+9 /Gœ3:® 7R­}{‚km{}rLwbtu{‚rjƒ

{‚vxvulV­}lV°JwrBt´ylV­}­‰…´wJ°G|{‰†j…RgLwJ°B{‚rjƒtu|1…u²j¦€…ulV»B²jlVrBtu­‚±mwr€w„­‚±l¬w„­‚­€txgjl_°GlVytu|v=…¹txgjl±6y|rBtxw{}r,‡§gj{‰y=g,‡{‚r

tx²jvxr,‡vulH†Ž²€ylH…RvxlV…uL|Gr€…ultu{‚kml®RfvulVl~N¦€w…ulV†E{‚r€†ŽlŽ{‚rjƒkmltugj|Ž†j…¶tŒ±‡j{‚yVw„­‚­}±m²€…ulStxgj{‰…Rtx|jvx²jrjl_lrBtu{‚vul

¦€vxwr€y=gjlV…V® 7R­‚{}km{‚r€wbtx{}rjƒ{‚vuvxl­‚l°bw„rBtµyl­‚­‚…µ{‚…_|„¨txlr™lVrŽ¨©|v=ylH†Pwbtµvx²jrŽ~:tu{‚kml¦‡±wjj­‚±‡{}rjƒ$tŒ§´|$v=wbtxgjlv

…u{‚kE{‚­‰w„v !$'2(*2 *# !(%=®3fhgjl1¯€v=…Œt¬vu²€­}lE{‚…¬w„€j­}{‚lV†ãwbt_tugjlE°lVvu±¥¦Ulƒ{‚rjrj{‚rjƒ!|„¨RtxgjlE…ulVwvxy=gP€vu|ŽylH…u…

wr€†!{‚†ŽlVrBtu{}¯€lV…{‚vxvulV­}lV°JwrBthyl­‚­‚…wG…¨©|­‚­}|b§S…4H

{º¨ &<&<

txgjlr¹{‰…h{}vxvulV­}lV°bw„rBtV

§gjlVvul ! "&<# _{‰…¬tugjl6km{‚rj{‚k²jk †j{‚…ªtxwr€ylm¦UltŒ§llrãtug€l$»G²€lvx±PL|G{}rBt$+wr€†™txgjl$ylV­}­%

wr€†& '("&<# ´txgjl3k6wbŽ{‚k²jk †Ž{‚…ªtxwr€yl(¦UltŒ§llVr&Ew„r€†ylV­}­) ®+*

fhgjl1…ªlHw„v=y=g€vu|ŽylH…u…tugjlVr™vxwr";Ž…tugjl1vulVk6w„{‚rj{}r€ƒ$yl­‚­‰…S|r¥txgjl{‚vµ{‚r€yvulHw…u{}rjƒ6†Ž{‰…ªtxw„rLylV…Stu|,‡®pNt

txgjlr·wyVylH…u…ulV…_yl­‚­‰…_|Grjlmwb¨tulVv¬tugjlm|„txgjlvHU¨©lt=y=gjlV…3w­}­tug€l1°GlVyztx|v=…µlHwy=g2yl­‚­¹y|GrGt=w„{‚r€…V“y|kmj²ŽtxlV…

txgjl6†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl1¦UltŒ§llVr-+wr€†™lHwy=gã°lVytu|Gv_|¨Rtugjl6yl­‚­Z®Efhgj{‚…¬k6wJ±PU|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚±P²jU†€wbtulEtxgjl6y²jvxvulVrBt

…ult|¨txgjl/.$¦UlV…ªtSrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…¨©|²€r€†!…u|E¨½w„vH®

fhgjl_…ªlHy|rL†¯L­ºtxlvx{}rjƒ3vx²j­‚l{‚…¶w„jj­‚{‚lV†1tu|w¦L|Gvªt¹txgjlS…ulVw„v=y=gmw…R…u|‡|r6w…"{}t¶{‰…¶†ŽltulVytulH†Etug€w„tRrj|rjl

|¨txgjl3°lHyztu|Gvx…{‚rPw„r‡±$vxlk6w„{‚rj{‚rjƒEyl­‚­ywr!U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚±${‚km€wyttugjl3y²€vuvxlrBtS…ªltS|„¨rjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|v=…® Í ¨txlv

gLwJ°B{‚rjƒw„¦U|vutulV†™tugjl6…ulVwvxy=g,/w­}­"vxlk6w„{‚rj{‚rjƒ!yl­‚­‚…(w„vxlm…J;‡{‚jLlH†–wr€†™txgjlEvulH…ª²j­}tywr–¦Ul1vxltx²jvur€lV†/®

fhg€{‚……ulVy|r€†+¯€­}tulvx{‚rjƒmvu²j­‚l3{‰…H

{º¨ &< 01"&<32425'´tugjlVrPw„¦U|vutV

§g€lvxl{‚…´txgjl3yl­‚­Utu|mjvx|ŽylV…x…´rjl‡tV01"&<3242 5 ´{‚…´txgjl3†Ž{‚…ªtxwr€yl¬¦UltŒ§llr&w„rL†$txgjl¬y²jvxvulVrGt6.87"9

r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|vH®

fhgjl&:ªy²jvx…ulP|„¨†Ž{‚kmlr€…u{‚|r€w­}{}tŒ±<;¥jvx|¦€­}lVk k6w?;GlV…mtxgjlV…ulP¯€­}tulVvu{‚rjƒ vx²j­}lH…6{‚rjlG“lVytu{‚°l™{‚r gj{‚ƒgŽ~

†j{}kmlrL…ª{‚|r€w­€…u€wylV…V®fhgjlµvulHw…u|r€…"{‚r€y­‚²€†Žlµgj{}ƒGg6|b°lVvu­‰w„E¦LltŒ§´lVlr$yl­‚­‚…¹§g€{‚y=g6jvxl°GlrBtx…¹tugjl_vu²j­‚lV…

tx|E¯€­ºtxlvS|G²Žtk6w„r‡±+ylV­}­‰…Swr€†$tx|mvxwj{‚†j­}±+w¦L|Gvªthtxgjl…ªlHw„v=y=g,®

=?>@>.+ACB 'ED ) GFHFJI<K "+MLON

fhg€l:uy²jv=…ul+|„¨(†Ž{‚kElVr€…u{}|Gr€w„­‚{ºtŒ±<;+jg€lrj|GkElVrj|r {‚…E€wvªtx{‚y²j­‰w„vx­}±·jvxl°bw„­‚lrBtm§gjlr LlVvª¨©|Gvukm{‚rjƒ (<

; ' 9 9~s…ulVw„v=y=gjlH…®¬fhgjlvxl{‰…µtxgjlvxl¨©|Gvul1w„r™{‚r€yvxlVwG…ª{‚rjƒ${‚rBtulVvulH…Œt¬{}r™Ulvu¨©|vxkm{}r€ƒ < *4C ')( 9 9~

…ulVwvxy=g€lV…V§g€lvxl–vxlV…u²j­ºt¥»B²€w„­‚{ºtŒ± {‰…$txvxwG†ŽlV†¨©|Gv+vxlV†Ž²LylV†D»G²€lvx± l‡lHy²Žtx{}|Gr tu{‚kmlHAwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=gjlV…(km{‚ƒgBtkm{‰…u…tugjl6txvu²€l$rjlVwvulH…Œtr€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|Gvx…|„¨S»B²jlvx±–U|{‚rBtx…V®¥—–w„r‡±ãwjjvx|Gwy=g€lV…¬tu|

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=gjlH…3g€wJ°Gl6¦LlVlr]j²€¦j­}{‰…ugjlV†/®–¼ãl¥†ŽlV…xyvx{‚¦Ll$¦Ul­‚|b§ tugjl!|rjlH…3txg€wbtmw„vxl6tugjl

km|B…Œtvxl­‚l°bw„rBthtu|m|²€v§´|Gv;“®

P

Ð,ÑJÚÁÔ¶ÚÁÓ÷JØÁÚÁåŒÚÙ:ØQÝ=ÔZÔ:×JÓæŒÔRÙ:ÑJÝxÙ6RS3åªÒzÕÙ:Ý=ÚÁÕJÔÝxÙhØÁæªÝ=Ô½ÙTéæŒåŒÙZÒzä½ÔuíUÙ:ÑJæŒäWVÚÁÔ:æzçLÙZÑJæSÔ:æªÝ=ä½åNÑ$÷Jä½ÒVåŒæŒÔ:ÔhåªÝ=ÕmÔ½ÙNÝ=ä©Ù

Ý=÷J÷JØQVÚÁÕJóÙ:ÑJÚÁÔXbØÙZæªä½ÚÁÕJóSä½×JØÁæ´ÒzÕHØQ(ÒzÕJåŒæ¶ÚÙ)TÕJÒ3VÔÙZÑbÝxÙ¹æŒÕJÒz×HózÑ3åªæŒØÁØÁÔÑbݪéæ´ÕJÒ=ÙZY„æŒæŒÕXbØÙ:æŒä½æŒÜÒz×VÙÙZÒµóz×JÝ=ä:Ý=ÕÙ[Q3Ù:ÑHæ

æŒøVÚÁÔZÙZæŒÕJåŒæRÒ#\€ÝxÙØÁæªÝ=ÔZÙThéæŒåsÙ:Òzä½Ôuí

(9)

¢Ž¡ @È   Ë  ¡ Ë ¢j£ Ç Ÿ

¼2l¦UlvSwr€† Egjk §{}tugtxgjl{‚vµw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul_°lVvx…u{}|Gr+|¨txgjl Í ~{‚­}lC)¼FEhšš3wr€† .,{/ltµw„­:®§{}tug

­‚{‚r€†Žl ). —P¼dšjÅ3€Ulvu¨©|vxk w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g€lV…"¦‡±1w¦L|Gvªtx{}rjƒ¬txgjlS…ªlHw„v=y=gEw„¨tulVvRg€wJ°‡{}r€ƒ

wGyylV…x…ªlH†™w„r·w„vx¦j{}tuv=w„vx±UjvulH†Žltxlvxkm{}rjlH†ãwr€†P¯€‡lH†–r‡²jk1¦LlVv3|„¨´yl­‚­‚…V®1fhg€lV…ul1tŒ§|!tulVy=g€rj{‚»B²jlH…(w„vxl

l«$y{‚lrBt{‚r$txlvxk6…´|¨,vulH…ªU|rL…ªlµtu{‚kElH…Ž¦€²ŽtƒG{}°Glµrj|my­‚²jl¬|r6txgjl3»B²€w„­‚{ºtŒ±m|¨,tugjl¬vxlV…u²j­ºthvxltu²€vurjlH†mtu|

txgjl3²€…ulvSwr€†+r€| ;‡rj|G¦tu|Etu²jr€l(tugj{‰…S»B²€w„­‚{}tŒ±®

ÇBË

Ç  ¡

£¢@´

¡ Ë

¢j£

Ç Ÿ

f|3{‚r€yvxlVwG…ªl´tugjlµlG“lVyztx{}°GlrjlH…u…"|¨Ltxgjlµw¦L|b°Gl´¯L­ºtxlvx{}rjƒ(vx²j­‚lV…VG…u|kmlw„jjvx|GwGy=gjlV…txvu±tu|†ŽlHyvxlVw…ultugjl

|b°Glvx­‚wjj{‚rjƒSv=wbtxl|¨Uyl­‚­‚…¦‡±y|Gr€…u{‚†ŽlVvu{‚rjƒ(w„rEw„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tu{‚|r|¨€tug€l{‚vR…ª{ lH…"{}r€…ªtulHw†|„¨Uy|r€…u{‰†Žlvx{}r€ƒ

txgjl{‚v6ljwGyzt$…ª{ lH…®dfhg€l± tŒ±‡j{‰yw­}­‚±AwyVy|G²jrBt1¨©|Gv$w„r w†j†j{ºtx{}|Gr€w„­–°bw­}²jl¥§gjlVr y|kmj²jtu{‚rjƒ·tugjl

km{‚rj{‚k²jkw„r€†ãk6wbŽ{‚k²jk †Ž{‚…ªtxwr€ylH…(tu|™yl­‚­‚…Vk6w;B{‚rjƒP…u|kmlgj|b§ ylV­}­‰… :u…ªk6w„­‚­‚lvE;=®89‡k6w­}­‚lvyl­‚­‚…

txlr€†¬tx|µk6w?;Gl"tugjlR¯€­ºtxlvx{}r€ƒSvu²€­}lH…,km|vxlR…ªlV°lVvulGV§gj{‰y=g,H{}rtu²jvxr,J{}rLyvxlVw…ulV…/tugjlRr‡²jk1¦LlVv|¨‡{‚vxvulV­}lV°JwrBt

yl­‚­‚…V® l­‚­‚…1y|GrGt=w„{‚rj{‚rjƒ™{‚rGtxlvxlV…ªtu{‚rjƒP°lHyztx|v=…3km{}ƒGgGt1¦Ll+¯€­ºtxlvxlV†·|G²ŽtV"gj|b§l°GlvH®fhgjl$tŒ§´|™w¦L|b°Gl

vx²j­‚lV…h¦UlVy|kml

{º¨ &<

&<

M

txgjlr {‰…{}vxvxl­‚l°bw„rBt

{º¨ &<

01"&<32425¶tugjlVr™w„¦U|vutV

5_ltxlvxkm{}rj{‚rjƒ¥txgjl$w„j€vu|Gjvu{‰wbtxl1°bw­}²jlm¨©|Gv!!{‰…=;lV±P¨©|vw­}­´w„jjvx|GwGy=gjlV…_²€…u{}r€ƒPƒl|Gkmltuvx{‰yw„­}~N¦€w…ulV†

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}|Gr€…V®

psr)¼FEhšš 3NJ¼ãlV¦LlVvw„r€†=EGgjkÄw­‚…u|hjvulH…ªlVrBt/tugjl Í ~(E 95A{}r(§gj{‰y=g!´{‰…/lkmj{‚vx{‚yVw„­‚­}±_lV…ªtu{‚kmw„tulH†

¦‡±+…xw„kmj­‚{‚rjƒ6†jwbt=w„¦€wG…ªl(°lHyztx|v=…®¹fhgjlV±!…ugj|b§dtxg€wbttxgj{‚…"{‚…S¦j{}ƒ6lVrj|²€ƒg!tu|6{‚r€yvxlVwG…ªl_tugjl(¯L­ºtxlvx{}rjƒ

U|b§lv|¨tugjl!vu²€­}lH…§gj{‚­}l¥…ukmw­}­´lrj|G²jƒgA{}r txgjl+k6w„‹Œ|vx{ºtŒ±2|„¨µyVw…ulV…3tx|ãwJ°G|{‰†ãkm{‰…u…u{‚rjƒ™txgjl$txvu²jl

r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…V®psr™wG†j†Ž{}tu{‚|rtu|6¦Ul†jw„txw6wr€†¥»G²€lvx±!†ŽlVLlVr€†ŽlrBtHjtug€lk6w„{‚r¥†jvxwJ§¦€wGy;6|„¨"tug€{‚…

wjjvx|GwGy=g™{‚…¬txg€wbt(txgjl$…uwkml#+{‰…3w„€j­}{‚lV†–tu|Pw­}­¹l‡{‰…ªtu{‚rjƒyl­‚­‚…V®mfhgj{‚…3†j|BlH…(rj|„twGyy|G²jrBt_¨©|Gv(tugjl

U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l6°lVvu±2†Ž{NGUlVvulVrGtE†jwbt=w™†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr€…3{‚rAylV­}­‰…®¥¼ gj{‚­‚l$l«$y{‚lrBtHtxgjl Í ~(E 95 …uy=gjlVkml6{‚…

r€|„tvulV­}{‰w„¦€­}l({‚r!txlvxk6…h|„¨tugjl3jvxlVy{‚…u{‚|r+|¨txgjlw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul¬…ªlHw„v=y=g,®

fhgjl Í ~29 9D…xy=gjlVkElµ¨©|v—¥~NfvxllV…¶jvxlV…ulrBtulH†6{}r ) Š¶šGš31½wr€†$†ŽlVvu{‚°lH†m¨©vu|Gk )Í — 9-0/59 3,´w„­‰…u|

vxl­‚{‚lV…3|Gr]w™…ª{‚rjƒG­}l$°bw­}²jl$P…ult1¦B±ãtug€l+²€…ulvH® +Slvxl¥vulVjvxlV…ulrBtx…(txgjl+k6w„‡{‚k²€k›vxl­‰wbtx{}°Gl6lvxvu|Gv

w­}­‚|b§lV†¥¦UltŒ§llr™tugjlE†Ž{‚…ªtxwr€yl¨©vu|Gk tugjlm»B²jlvx±!U|{‚rBt(wr€†P{}tx…_ljwyt_rjlHw„vxlV…ªtµrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v¬w„r€†™tugjl

†j{‚…ªtxwr€yl(¨©vx|k tugjl»B²jlVvu±!L|G{}rBt_wr€†{ºt=…µwjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl¬r€lVw„vxlV…ªtrjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|vH®¶psr¥txgj{‚…_…uy=g€lkml%mywr

|Grj­‚±+g€wJ°Glwm°lvx±$|G¦€…uy²jvxl3kElHw„rj{‚rjƒmtx|6tugjl²€…ªlVvV®´psr™w†j†j{ºtx{}|Gr,jtxgjl{‚vµl‡Ulvx{‚kElVrBtx…S…ugj|b§lV†!tug€w„tV

{‚rƒlr€lv=w„­:Gtxgjl3wytu²€w­Uvxl­‰wbtx{}°Gl_lVvuvx|v{‰…w­}§hwJ±Ž…¶k1²€y=g¥…ªk6w„­‚­‚lvtug€wr&Ž® {‰wyy{‚wEw„rL†+Š¹wbtxl­‚­‚wEw„­‰…u|

€vulH…ªlVrGt¬w„r™lBtxlr€…u{‚|r¥tu| Í ~)9 9 yVw„­‚­}lH†¥Š Í ~)9 9®/fhgjlŠ Í ~29 9 …uy=g€lkml²€…ulV…_w$jvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{‰…ªtu{‰y

txlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jl¹tx|µ†Žltulvxkm{}r€l¶w„r3lH…Œtx{}k6wbtx{}|Gr3|„¨‡tug€l´†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€ylR¦UltŒ§llr(txgjl¶»B²jlVvu±¬°lHyztu|Gvw„rL†({ºt=…,rjlHw„vxlV…ªt

r€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|GvV®"pNttxgjlrPw„¦U|vutx…txgjl…ulVw„v=y=g!wG……ª|‡|GrwG…h{ºt¨©|G²jr€†j…SwE°GlVyztx|vSy­}|B…ªlVv´txg€w„rtxgj{‚…SlV…ªtu{‚kmw„tulH†

†j{‚…ªtxwr€ylG®"fhg€l_k6w„{‚r!†jvxwJ§¦€wGy;|¨Š Í ~)9 9Ä{‰…´tug€w„t{}tw…x…ª²jkmlH…:;‡rj|b§r6txgjl3†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr+|„¨†€wbtxw

wvu|G²jr€†$tugjl»B²jlVvu±$U|{‚rBtVj§g€{‚y=g¥km{}ƒGgBthr€|„tS¦Ul3L|B…u…u{}¦€­}l3{‚r+txgjlƒGlrjlVvxw­“yVw…ul® Í ­‰…u|€Žtxgj{‚……xy=gjlVkEl

yVw„rrj|„tµ…ulVwvxy=g+¨©|v .+rjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|v=…®

(10)

  V¢j  ŸV  £¢@h ¡ Ë ¢j£

psr]y|rBtuv=w…ªt3tu|™tugjl6txlVy=gjr€{‚»B²jlH…jvxlV…ulrBtulH† w„¦U|b°lG 5E´p9 )E // 3h{‚…rj|„t1w™ƒl|Gkmltuvx{‰yw„­}~N¦€w…ulV†

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}|Grã…xy=gjlkml6¦j²jtvxw„tugjlVv3vulV­}{‚lV…(|Gr·²€…ª{‚rjƒ¥txgjl+…ªtxwbtx{‚…ªtu{‰yw­Rjvx|Ulvutu{‚lV…(|¨h†jw„txw€®85BEp 9

y­}²L…Œtxlv=…µ†jw„txw$²L…ª{‚rjƒ$txgjl 7¶— 7¹ŽLlHyztxw„tu{‚|r–—–wbŽ{}km{ Vw„tu{‚|r ,µw„­‚ƒ|vx{}tugjk¥®B5Ep 9 w¦L|Gvªt=…txgjl 9 9~

…ulVwvxy=gm§gjlVr6tug€lµlV…ªtu{‚k6wbtxlV†6jvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±1¨©|v´wvulVkmw{}r€{}rjƒ1†jwbt=w„¦€wG…ªlS°GlVytu|vRtu|¦Ul_w¦LltªtulVvhrjl{‚ƒgŽ~

¦U|v(txg€w„r2txgjl6|rjlH…3y²jvxvxlrBtu­‚±.;‡rj|b§r㨽w„­‚­‚…(¦Ul­‚|b§ wjvxlV†jltulVvukm{‚rjlV†–tug€vulH…ªgj|G­‚†,® 6SrŽ¨©|Gvªtx²jr€wbtxl­‚±

5Ep 9 {‚rjgjlVvu{}tx…µ¨©vu|Gk5w„­‚­txgjlE†jvxwJ§¦€wGy;Ž…|„¨ 7¶—Î…ª²Ly=g™w…µtugjlE…ªlVr€…ª{}tu{‚°‡{ºtŒ±tx|$tug€l1{‚rj{}tu{‰w„­"…ªltªtu{‚rjƒB…

txgjlE­}{‚km{ºtxlV†™r‡²jk1¦LlVv(|„¨¶y­‚²€…ªtulVvx…B7¶— yw„r–g€w„r€†j­}lGLtxgjlmw…x…ª²jkmlH†

w„²€…x…u{‚wr–†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr–|„¨¶†€wbtxw

U|{‚rBtx…´tugLwbth°lVytu|Gvx…´k6wJ±mwGyztx²€w„­‚­}±mrj|t´¨©|G­}­‚|b§d|Gv¶txgjl_­‚|Žyw­U|GŽtu{‚k6w€{ºtu¨½w„­‚­Z®05E´p 9 vxlV»B²j{‚vulH…¶k6w;G~

{‚rjƒ™k6wrB±·…ªtuvx|rjƒ–wG…u…u²jkmŽtx{}|Gr€…§gj{‰y=g]km{‚ƒgBtrj|t1gj|G­‚† {‚r]jv=wytu{‰ylGk6w;B{‚rjƒPtxgjl!wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

vxlV…u²j­}t°lvx±6²jrjvxl­‚{‰w„¦j­‚l({}rtug€l3ƒlr€lv=w„­/ywG…ªlG®

h76

fhg€{‚……ªlHyztx{}|Gr3ƒ{‚°lV…w¦jvx{}l¨j|b°lVvu°‡{‚l§2|„¨j|²€vw„€jvu|Bwy=g¬tu|¬w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tul¹rjlHw„vxlV…ªtª~Nrjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|v…ulVwvxy=g€lV…V®

fhgj{‰…Swjjvx|Gwy=gw…x…ª²€kElH…´tug€w„tS°lVytu|Gvx…hw„vxl(lr€y­}|B…ªlH†+{‚rPy­‚²€…ªtulv=…V®"fhg€ly²jvxvulVrBth°Glv=…ª{‚|r!|„¨"|²jv

w­}ƒG|vx{ºtxgjk³¨©|v3y|rBtuvx|­‚­}{‚rjƒ!tugjl6€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|rã|„¨wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl 9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=gjlV…_vxlV»B²j{‚vulH…¬y­}²L…Œtxlv=…µtx|P¦Ll

km{‚rj{‚k²jk ¦L|G²jr€†Ž{‚rjƒ6g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvulH…´{‚r¥w„r 7R²€y­}{‰†ŽlVwrP…ª€wGylG®

Í ­}­lŽ{‰…Œtx{}rjƒ!°lHyztu|Gvx…SkE{‚ƒgBtµr€|„t_¦Ul{‚r–y­}²€…ªtulVvx…µ¦LlHyw²€…ªltugjlEy­‚²€…Œtxlvx{}r€ƒ+w„­‚ƒ|Gvu{}tugjk tug€w„t_jvx|„~

†j²€ylH†™y­‚²€…ªtulv=…Skm{‚ƒgBt_{‰…u|­‰wbtul|²Žtx­}{‚lv=…®_pN¨¹tugjlV±¥lŽ{‚…ªtV“§lw…x…u²jkmltugLwbt_|G²Žtu­‚{‚lv=…µw„vxl…ªtu|GvulH†¥{}r–w

…uUlVy{}¯Ly_¯€­‚l(tug€w„tS§´l¬txvulHwbtS…ªlV€w„v=wbtxl­‚±®

­‚²€…ªtulv=…w„vxlµw„r€w­}±VlV†m|?GU~N­}{‚rjlStx|1†ŽlVvu{‚°lG¨©vx|k txgjl_ljwyzt´vxwG†Ž{}²L…´wr€†mtug€l_…uLlHy{}¯Lyµy=g€wvxwGyztxlvu~

{‰…ªtu{‰y…(|„¨lVwGy=g,w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul1vxwG†Ž{‚²€…ªlH…_tug€w„t§{}­‚­¹²j­}tu{‚kmw„tulV­}±ã¦Ll6y|Gr€…u{‚†ŽlVvulH†ã†j²jvu{‚rjƒ!tugjl$wjjvx|J‡~

{‚k6wbtxl 9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=gjlV…V® €|vmlVwGy=g y­‚²€…ªtulVvV…ªlV°lv=w„­hw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtulv=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…Ew„vxl†ŽltulVvukm{‚rjlV†/lVwGy=g

y|vxvulH…ªU|rL†Ž{}r€ƒ!tx|–wPjvxlV†jltulVvukm{‚rjlV†·­‚l°Gl­´|„¨jvxlVy{‰…u{}|Gr,® Í ­‚­¶txgjl!wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxlEv=w†j{}²€…ulV…|„¨|rjl

y­}²L…Œtxlvhw„vxl_w„­‚§hwJ±‡…´…ªk6w­}­‚lv´tug€wr$txgjl(ljwyt´v=w†Ž{‚²€…´|„¨,txgjl3…uwkEl¬y­‚²€…ªtulvH® (= <?>'4*!# '

J ' % <>(*% '>( ('" ' (=#&%"(='(: # '2( < *4 '2( *'?#&%(%mfhgj{‰…_kmltugj|Ž†ã§{}­‚­¹¦Ll

€vulH…ªlVrGtxlV†!{}rtxgjl(rjl‡tB9‡lHyztu{‚|r®

Í

tS»B²jlvx±$…u²j¦jkm{‚…x…u{}|Gr+tx{}kmljwE²€…ulvhjvx|b°‡{‚†jlV…VBw­}|Grjƒ1§{}tug!tug€l»G²€lvx±Žw€vulHy{‰…ª{‚|r!­}lV°l­/yVw„­‚­}lH†

K y|rBtuvx|­‚­‚{}rjƒ+tugjl$»B²€w­}{}tŒ±P|„¨´tugjl6wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl09 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g®*K y|GvuvxlV…uL|Gr€†j…µtu|tug€lE€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±

¨©|GvSwE°lVytu|Gv´txg€wbt¦Ul­‚|rjƒB…tu|Etug€l3ljwytwr€…u§´lVvh…ulttx|m¦LlwGyztu²Lw„­‚­}±6km{‰…u…u{}r€ƒE{‚rtugjlwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

…ult|¨"wr€…ª§lv=…l°GlrBtu²€w­}­‚±6vxltu²€vurjlH†/®

fhgj{‰…jvxlVy{‚…u{‚|r­}lV°l­,tugjlVr™†ŽltxlvxkE{‚rjlH…h§gj{‚y=gP…uLlHy{}¯Lywjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl_v=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…hk1²€…ŒtS¦Ul3t=w?;lVr

{‚rBtu|Ewyy|²jrBt¶¦‡±Etug€lµ¯€­}tulVvu{‚rjƒvx²j­‚lV…†Ž²jvx{}r€ƒtug€l 9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g®psvxvulV­}lV°bw„rBt´y­‚²€…ªtulVvx…w„vxltug‡²€…¶¯€­}tulVvulH†

|G²Žtw„r€†$tugjl(vxlk6w„{‚rj{‚rjƒ1y­}²€…ªtulVvx…hwvulµtugjlVr!v=w„r";GlV†6§{}tugvxlV…uLlHyzttu|1tugjl(†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl_|¨tug€l{‚vhylrBtulVvx…

tx| tug€lã»B²jlvx± L|G{}rBtV® ­}²€…ªtulVvx…!w„vxl¥tugjlVrDwyVylH…u…ulV† |r€lãwb¨txlv+tugjlã|„tug€lvH®‘¼ gjlrDwAy­‚²€…Œtxlv!{‚…

wGyylV…x…ªlH†/jw„­‚­,txgjl†jw„txwmU|{‚rGt=…{‚r™y|rBt=w„{‚r€…w„vxl(¨©lt=y=gjlV†¥{‚rPkmlkm|vx±®fhgjl…ªlHw„v=y=g+txgjlr™y|kmj²ŽtxlV…

txgjl!†j{‚…ªtxwr€ylH…¦UltŒ§llr]w­}­´L|G{}rBt=…{‚r tugjly­‚²€…ªtulvEw„r€†2txgjl!»B²jlVvu±2°lHyztx|vH®¥fhg€{‚…1km{}ƒGgGt1{}r tx²jvxr

²€U†jw„tul_tugjl(y²€vuvxlrBt…ulth|„¨rjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|v=…®pNtkm{‚ƒgBtw„­‰…ª|¯€­ºtxlvh|²jtkm|vxl_y­}²L…Œtxlv=…®"fhgjl(…ªlHw„v=y=g$…Œtx|€…

§g€lr .rjlV{}ƒGg‡¦L|Gvx…g€wJ°Gl´¦UllVr¨©|G²jr€†mw„r€†1§gjlVrtxgjlw„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulkE{‚rj{‚k²jk †Ž{‚…ªtxwr€yltx|_txgjlrjlBt

y­}²L…Œtxlv{‰…hƒvxlVwbtxlvtugLw„rtugjly²jvxvulVrGt†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl(tu|Etug€l/.87"9mrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|vH®

(11)

El¨©|Gvulmvxltx²jvur€{}rjƒtxgjl$vxlV…u²j­ºt(tx|¥tugjl6²€…ulvHw¥…ulV»B²jlVrGtx{‚w­R…uyVw„r2|„¨tugjl$¯€­}l6§g€lvxlE|G²Žtu­‚{‚lv=…3w„vxl

…ªtu|GvulH†${‰…Ulvu¨©|vxkElH†/®¹fhgj{‰…km{}ƒGgGtSw­‚…u|m²jU†€wbtul(txgjly²€vuvxlrBt…ªltS|„¨r€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|Gvx…V®

¸_²jvSwjjvx|GwGy=g$lrŽ¨©|GvxylV…hw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul39 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g€lV…V®pNtS{‰…tugjlVvul¨©|vxl_­‚{;l­‚±6txg€wbt|r€l¬|Gvkm|vxl

°GlVytu|v=…tug€w„t¹wvul´tug€lhtuvx²jl´r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…|„¨Uw¬»B²jlvx±3U|{‚rGtRwvulkm{‚…x…ªlH†/wr€†1wvulhy|Gr€…ulV»B²jlrBtx­}±

r€|„t({}r–tugjl6w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul1w„r€…u§´lVv_…ultH®$¹lVytu|v=…¬w„vxlkm{‚…x…ulV†™¦UlVyVw„²€…ul1tugjlmy­‚²€…ªtulv=…_{}r2§gj{‰y=g™tug€l±

wvul*;ljt_w„vxl3¯€­}tulVvulH†P|²ŽtH®B9‡{‚r€ylEy­‚²€…ªtulv=…SƒGvu|G²jP°lHyztx|v=…htug€w„t¬wvul»B²j{}tulE…ª{‚km{}­‰w„vH€{}t_{‰…µtugjlVvul¨©|vxl

U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l(tugLwbtSkm|G…ªtS|„¨tugjl3r€lVw„vxlV…ªtª~NrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…|„¨¹w6»B²jlvx±$U|{‚rGtµwvul({‚r™wm²jrj{‰»B²jly­‚²€…ªtulvH®RpN¨"tug€{‚…

y­}²L…ŒtxlvS{‰…¯€­}tulVvulH†¥|²ŽtH€txgjlrPkm|B…Œtµ|¨"tugjl3txvu²€lrjlVwvulH…ŒtSr€l{‚ƒg‡¦L|Gvx…S|„¨Rw$»B²jlvx±+U|{‚rBt_w„vxl3km{‚…x…ulV†/®

¼ g€lr+…ulVwvxy=gj{‚rjƒ(¨©|Gv.mrjlV{}ƒGg‡¦L|Gvx…V„§gj{‚­}lµtugjl_jvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tŒ±1|¨,kE{‰…x…ª{‚rjƒ|Grjltuvx²jl_rjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|vR{‰… K´Btugjl

€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±6|¨km{‰…u…u{}r€ƒmw­}­“txgjl/.!rjlVwvulH…ŒthrjlV{}ƒGgB¦U|v=…{‚…S|„¨txgjl3|v=†ŽlVv|¨ K tu|‡|€®

% $! !"#$%'&( & ]& 1 "´.

´

fhg€{‚…S…ulVytu{‚|rjvxlV…ulrBtx…txgjlkmltxgj|Ž†+txg€wbtµy|kmj²ŽtxlV…htxgjlwjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl_v=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…|„¨"lVwGy=gPy­‚²€…Œtxlv=…®

fhg€{‚…kEltugj|Ž†·t=w?;GlV…3{‚rBtu|–wGyy|G²jrBt1w„­‚­Rtxgjl!†j{}°Glv=…ª{}tŒ±–|¨txgjl!y=gLw„v=wyztxlvx{‚…ªtu{‰y…(|¨Sy­‚²€…Œtxlv=……u²€y=g]w…

txgjl3†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr+|„¨tugjl(°lHyztx|v=…Rtxgjl±$y|rBtxw{}r,Btxgjl{‚vS…ª{ lH…Btxgjl{‚vhL|Gj²j­‰wbtu{‚|r®pNtSy|kmj²ŽtxlV…´tugjlH…ªl

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlRv=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…¨©|v¹…ªlV°lVvxw­­‚l°lV­‚…|„¨L{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr,® {‚°lVrtxgjlh­}lV°l­B|„¨L{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr1wGyztu²Lw„­‚­}±

…ult¹¦‡±(tug€l²€…ªlVv¹wbt¹vu²€rŽ~Ztx{}kmlGJtugjlS…u±Ž…Œtxlk …ul­‚lVyzt=…¨©|v"lVwGy=g1y­}²€…ªtulVv"tugjly|vxvulH…ªU|r€†j{}rjƒ¬w„j€vu|Gjvu{‰wbtxl

v=w†j{}²€…´tx|$y|rL…ª{‰†Žlv†Ž²€vu{‚rjƒEtugjl…ulVwvxy=g®

9‡{‚r€yl!w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtu{‚|rL…(|„¨Sy­‚²€…ªtulvxlV† wvul!y|rL…ª{‰†ŽlvxlV†,{}t1{‰…U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l6tugLwbttxgjl$¯L­ºtxlvx{}rjƒ–vu²j­‚lV…

¯L­ºtxlvE|²Žtmy­‚²€…Œtxlv=…{‚r]§gj{‰y=gA…u|kml$|„¨txgjl!tuvx²jl+rjlHw„vxlV…ªtª~Nrjl{‚ƒg‡¦U|v=…(|„¨txgjl!»B²jlVvu±2L|G{}rBt6w„vxl®™pNt

{‰…tugjlVvul¨©|vxl+U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l$tugLwbtm|rjl|vEkm|vxl$°lHyztu|Gvx…tugLwbt1§|²€­‚†A¦Ll{}rAtugjlljwGyztEwr€…u§´lVv1…ult6w„vxl

wGyztx²€w„­‚­}±–kE{‰…x…ª{‚rjƒP{‚rãtxgjl+wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxlE…ult|¨hwr€…u§´lVvx…¬l°GlrBtu²Lw„­‚­}±™vxltx²jvxrjlV†ãtu|¥txgjl$²€…ulvH®>9‡²Ly=g

°GlVytu|v=…hw„vxl¬yVw„­‚­}lH† %+% >L (+ "' *+%z®

pN¨§l_¨©|‡y²€…´|r+|Grjl_…uUlVy{}¯Ly_km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ1°lVytu|GvVB¦LlHyw²€…ªlµtugjl(w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul 9 9~s…ulVw„v=y=g$y|Gr€…u{‚†ŽlVvx…

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl¥vxwG†Ž{}²L…ªlH…6{}rL…ŒtxlVw† |¨(ljwyzt ½w„rL†¦L|G²jr€†Ž{‚rjƒ ,6vxwG†Ž{}²L…ªlH…´tugjlVrd§l™yw„rdwG…u…ulvut6tug€{‚…

°GlVytu|v¹{‰…R­‚|Žyw„tulV†m{‚r$w(°lVvu±1€w„vutu{‰y²€­‚wv¶w„vxlVw¬|„¨“txgjlµ…uLlHy{}¯LySy­‚²€…ªtulVv¶{‚r6§gj{‚y=gmtxgj{‰…R°lHyztx|vR¦Ul­‚|rjƒB…

wvulHw¦U|²€r€†ŽlV†¦UltŒ§llVr+txgjl3ljwytSw„r€†|r€l¬Lw„vutu{‰y²j­‰w„vw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul¬v=w†Ž{‚²€…|„¨tug€w„tµy­‚²€…ªtulvH®

fhgj{‰…(…ªlHyztx{}|Gr–jvxlV…ulrBtx…_gj|b§txgjl1°G|­‚²jkml|¨Rtugj{‰…(w„vxlVw$¨©|v¬l°lVvu±P…u{}r€ƒ­‚l1y­‚²€…ªtulVv_{‰…(y|rBtxvu|G­}­‚lV†/

…u{‚r€ylGŽ¨©|v|Grjly­‚²€…ªtulvH‡tug€{‚…°G|­‚²jkml3{‚…h­‚{‚r";lH†+tx|mtugjl3€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±6¨©|GvµwE°lHyztu|Gv|„¨tug€w„tµy­‚²€…ªtulvHŽ{}¨

{}th{‚…h{‚r$txgjl(ljwyt´vxlV…u²j­ºtH‡tu|E¦Ll¬km{‚…x…u{}rjƒE{‚r+txgjl¬wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlµvxlV…u²j­}tV® j|Gv¶txgjl3…uw;lµ|¨y­‰w„vx{}tŒ±Btugjl

kmltugj|Ž†¥{‰…S†ŽlV…xyvx{‚¦LlH†!g€lvxl3¨©|vµw6…u{‚rjƒ­‚l3{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{‚|r­}lV°l­yw„­‚­‚lV† K´® 7¹‡txlr€…u{}|Gr¥tu|$…ul°Glv=w„­/­‚l°lV­‚…

{‰……ªtuv=w„{‚ƒgŽ¨©|Gvu§hw„v=†/®

fhgjl3€vulH…ªlVrGt=wbtx{}|Gr+|„¨tug€l(tulVy=g€rj{‚»B²jl({‰…S†ŽlHy|kmU|G…ulV†!{}r”$…ªtulL…H

Å®h¼ãlh¯Lvx…ªtlŽj­‚w{}rE§gjlVvulkm{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ(°lHyztx|v=…yVw„rE|rj­‚±3¦Ll­‚|Žyw„tulV†{}rElVwGy=g1y­}²€…ªtulVvVGw„r€†1§g‡±3tugjl

°|G­}²jkml|¨UtxgjlµwvulHw_{‚rm§gj{‰y=gmtugjlV±1ywrm|rj­‚±1¦Ul{‰…¶†Ž{‚vulHyztx­}±E†ŽltxlvxkE{‚rjlH†m¦B±tugjlµ{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr

|„¨tugjl…ulVwvxy=g®

•Ž®h¼ãlEtxgjlrãlŽj­‰w„{‚r™tug€l1vxl­‰wbtx{}|Gr™¦LltŒ§´lVlr–tugjlEƒ­‚|¦€w­­‚l°Gl­"|„¨´{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr Kw„r€†™tugjlm­‚|Žyw„­

{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{‚|r¥…ªltªtu{‚rjƒB… K txg€wbtSgLwJ°l_tu|m¦Lly|r€…u{‰†ŽlvxlV†wbthtug€l3­}lV°l­/|¨lHwy=g¥y­‚²€…ªtulvH®

(12)

nj®h¼ãl¬txgjlr¥†Žlt=w„{‚­/gj|b§d§l_²L…ªl¬lVwGy=g>K tu|my|kmj²jtul¬tugjl3y|vxvulH…ªU|r€†j{}rjƒ1w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulµv=w†j{}²€…

|„¨"lVwGy=gy­}²€…ªtulVv{º¨"§l(wG…u…u²jkml¬tug€w„tS°lHyztu|Gvx…{‚rPy­‚²€…Œtxlv=…´¨©|­‚­}|b§ w„r{‚…u|„txvu|Gj{‚y(†Ž{‰…ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{‚|r,®

”€®h¼ãl(¯Lr€w„­‚­}±!vulV­‚w„$tug€{‚…SwG…u…u²jkmŽtx{}|Grwr€†+€vulH…ªlVrGtSwmkm|vxl(ƒlVrjlv=w„­“§hwJ±6tu|6y|Gkmj²Žtulwjjvx|J‡~

{}k6w„tul3v=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…VBlV°lVr!{}¨txgjl†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr¥|„¨°GlVytu|v=…{}rPy­}²€…ªtulVvx…h{‰…S…ul°Glvxl­‚±$…J;Gl§lV†/®

. > +8I +,'!.- !.# > +8IL Z>

fhg€{‚…´¯€v=…Œth€wvªtlŽj­‰w„{‚r€…§gjlvxl_km{‰…u…u{‚rjƒ°GlVyztx|v=…´yVw„r!|rj­‚±m¦Ll(­‚|‡yVwbtxlV†${‚r+lHwy=g+y­}²L…ŒtxlvH®¼2l¬¨©|Žy²€…

|Gr¥|rjl…uLlHy{}¯Ly3y­‚²€…ªtulVvV u®´fhg€lkm{}rj{‚k²€k g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul(¦U|²jrL†Ž{}r€ƒ6tugj{‰…Sy­}²€…ªtulVvVUyw­}­‚lV† 4Œ

{‰…¶ylrBtulVvulH†m|r w„r€†m{}tx…´v=w†Ž{‚²€…¹{‰… u®¼2l_w„­‰…u|…ª²j€L|B…ªltxg€wbt|rjl_w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tu{‚|rE|„¨/tug€{‚…´y­‚²€…Œtxlv

gLw…¦UllVr–y|GkE€²ŽtulH†P…ª|GkElVgj|b§3®hfhgj{‚…_w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tu{‚|r{‚…_w„r¥g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvulylrBtulVvulH†!|Gr R§{}tug™w

v=w†j{}²€…µlV»B²€w­tx| M ª®¬fhgj{‚…¬w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtulgB±‡Ulv=…ª€gjlvxl{‰…_yVw„­‚­}lH†(ª® ´y|rBtxw{}r€…_…ªlV°lVvxw­

°GlVytu|v=…VU¦€²Žt3|rjlm…ªUlVy{º¯Uy°GlVyztx|vH/yw„­‚­‚lV†m,{‰…_km{‰…u…u{‚rjƒ!{‚rãtugjl6…ult(|„¨wr€…u§´lVvx…µvultu²jvxrjlV†–¦‡±Ptugjl

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl 9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=g–§gj{‚­‚l6{ºt§hw…({‚r€y­‚²€†ŽlH†·{}r2txgjl$…ªlt|„¨hw„r€…u§´lVvx…¬vxltx²jvur€lV†2¦‡±Ptugjl6ljwyzt

…ulVwvxy=g® {‰…tugjlVvul¨©|vxl3w1km{‰…u…u{‚rjƒm°lVytu|GvV®

ElVyVw„²€…ul {‚…SwEkm{‰…u…u{}r€ƒE°GlVytu|vHBtugjlVrtugjl(txgjvulVl(¨©|­‚­}|b§{‚rjƒE­}lVkmkmwG…ywr!¦Ulw…x…ªlVvªtxlV† H

´Ç ]¢

h{‚rã§gj{‰y=g {‰…(g€wG…_¦UllVr2¯€­ºtxlvxlV†–|²Žt3¦‡±Ptug€l1¯L­ºtxlvx{}rjƒ¥vx²j­‚lV…V®m¸µtug€lvx§{‚…ul/{}¨

g€w†+rj|„th¦Ullr!¯€­}tulVvulH†$|²jtV‡tug€lr!w­}­“°GlVyztx|v=…R¨©vx|k §|²j­‰†6g€wJ°Glµ¦Ullr¥y|Gr€…u{‚†ŽlVvulH†6¦‡±mtugjl

w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tul 9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=g,“w„r€†™tugjlVvul¨©|vxl §´|G²j­‚†™g€wJ°l¦UllVrㆎ{‰…xy|b°lVvulH†Pw„r€†–§´|G²j­‰†Prj|„t

¦Ll1km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒL® {‰…S|G¦‡°B{‚|²L…ª­‚±+rj|tS¯€­}tulVvulH†¥|²Žt¬{}r¥txgjl1yVw…ul|„¨"tug€lljwGyztµ…ulVw„v=y=gP…ª{‚r€yl|rjl

|„¨"{ºt=…°lHyztx|vHBrLw„kml­‚±6€{‚…h{‚rtugjlwr€…ª§lv…ultH®,

´Ç ]¢ {‚…_{}r€l°‡{ºt=w„¦j­‚±­}|Žyw„tulH†P{}r™tugjl1°lvx±¥…ªUlVy{º¯Lyw„vxlVw6|¨ ¶§gj{‰y=g™{‚…_²jjUlvu~N¦L|G²jr€†ŽlH†

¦‡±

wr€†2­}|b§lvu~:¦U|²€r€†ŽlV†ã¦‡±

®¥fhgjl+†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl6¦LltŒ§´lVlr5wr€†

yVw„r·rj|t¦Ll

ƒvxlVw„tulvtxg€w„r

j|tugjlVvu§{‰…ul §|²€­‚†!rj|„tS¦Ul­‚|r€ƒmtu|,

®´fhgjl†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl3¦LltŒ§´lVlr w„r€†

ywrPrj|„t¬¦Ll1­}lH…u…Stug€wr M |„tug€lvx§{‚…ul §|²j­‰†¥rjlV°lvµg€wJ°l3¦UllVr™km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ${‚rPtxgjl1…ultµ|¨

w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tul¬w„r€…u§´lVvx…V®"fhgjl¬wvulHw{‚r+§gj{‰y=gyVw„r+|Grj­‚±6¦Ll({‰…yVw„­‚­}lH†6txgjl*2A<>(*2*2$|¨) 

rj|„txlV† ®

´Ç ]¢

pN¨ ! †Žlrj|tulH…txgjl+km{‚rj{}k1²jk*†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€yl+¦UltŒ§llr w™»B²jlvx±ãU|{‚rBt Pwr€† 

tugjlVr! {}r {‰… *(+ %"(!A !N ')('{‚r!txgjl3vxlƒ{‚|r!|„¨ lr€y­}|B…ªlH†+¦UltŒ§llVrtugjl3{‚rBtulv=…ulVyztx{}|Gr

|„¨ w„rL† tug€lãg‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul2ylVrGtxlvxlV†D|rdtxgjl·»G²€lvx± U|{‚rBt §{ºtxg wAvxwG†Ž{‚²€…+lH»B²€w„­

tu| ! ®ÄpN¨§hw…E¨©²jvutugjlVv+wJ§hwJ± ¨©vu|Gk ‡tug€lry|G²j­‰† r€|„t$¦Ul™km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ {‚rtugjl

w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tul(vxlV…u²j­ºtS{}¨¹{ºt_§wG…h{}r¥txgjlljwGyztSvxlV…u²j­ºtS¦UlVyVw„²€…ul3{‚r!txgj{‰…µywG…ªl(txgjly­‚²€…ªtulVvS§´|G²j­‰†

rj|„tgLwJ°lm¦LlVlr2¯€­}tulVvulH†–|G²ŽtV®+fhg€{‚……uUlVy{}¯LyEvxlƒ{‚|r2{‰…({}r€y­}²L†ŽlV†·{‚r w„r€†2{‰…3yw„­‚­‚lV†ãtugjl

2A<>(*- 2|„¨"y­‚²€…ªtulv jrj|tulV† ®

{‚ƒ²jvxlPÅ$jvx|b°‡{‚†ŽlH…3w¥ƒv=w„jg€{‚yVw„­¹vxljvxlV…ulrBtxw„tu{‚|r2|„¨ .,lVkmkmwG…•¥w„rL†2n€wr€† …ugj|b§S…(§g€wbtEw„vxl

wrAg‡±‡LlVvª~Nvx{}rjƒ2w„r€† w„r g‡±BUlvu~syw„¹{}rw2•507¶²€y­‚{‚†jlVw„r…u€wylRgj|b§l°GlvH®]fhgj{‰… {‚ƒ²jvxl¥…ªgj|b§S…

w·²€rj{‚»B²jlãy­‚²€…Œtxlv #"„y=g€w„v=wytulvx{ lV† ¦‡±A{}tx…!ylrBtxlv ½rj|„t+­‰w„¦Ul­‚lV† ,zh{ºt=…$v=w†Ž{‚²€… ½­‚w¦LlV­}lH† w…$%"",

†jl¯€rj{‚rjƒE{ºt=…kE{‚rj{‚k²jk ¦L|G²jr€†Ž{‚rjƒEgB±‡Ulv=…ª€gjlvxl ®"fhg€l¬wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxlµg‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul |¨

#"µ{‰…†Žlj{‰yztxlV†¥w…´txgjl3ƒvxl±$†jwG…ªg€lV†+y{}v=y­‚l(|r+tugjl {‚ƒ²jvxl®19S|tul¬tug€l¬v=w†j{}²€…|¨tug€{‚…Swjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

g‡±‡Ulv=…ªjg€lvxl¶{‰… " M " ®"fhgjlw„vxlVwµ|„¨ " tugLwbt¹{‚…lBtxlvxr€w„­Btx|_txgj{‰…¹w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulRg‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul§gj{‚­}l

(13)

1 1

q C

1

1

dmin + 1 1

dmin r

ε

ε

HC

HR 1

1

{}ƒG²jvxlEÅH¶¸_rjl6+S±‡Ulvu~:vx{}r€ƒEwr€†+|Grjl6+S±‡Ulvu~NyVw„

…ªtu{‚­‚­/lr€y­}|B…ªlH†+{‚r #" …hkm{‚rj{‚k²jk ¦L|G²jr€†Ž{‚rjƒmg‡±BUlv=…ujgjlvxl¬{‚…txgjl(gB±‡Ulvu~:vx{‚rjƒ1|¨y­}²€…ªtulVv #"bŽrj|tulH†

" |rPtxgjl {‚ƒ²jvxl® " y|GrBtxw„{‚r€…µ”+°lHyztx|v=…Un6vulVjvxlV…ulrBtulH†¥¦B±ƒvxl±¥†Ž|tx…V“wr€†Pw„r€|„tug€lvµ°GlVytu|v

vxl€vulH…ªlVrGtxlV†!¦‡±!w6…u|­‚{‚†¦j­‰wy;+†j|„tV®fhgj{‰…S­‰wbtulVv°lHyztu|Gv{‚…6®¶psr™wG†j†Ž{}tu{‚|r,{‚ƒ²€vul6Åw­‚…u|6…ªgj|b§S…w

»B²jlVvu±L|G{}rBt%¬w„r€†1tug€lSkm{}rj{‚k²€k †Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€ylh¨©vu|Gk µtu|/ " " |rEtugjl {‚ƒ²jvxl ,® {‰…Rw¬km{‚…x…u{}rjƒ

°GlVytu|vHbtxgjlvxl¨©|GvulS{}t´yVw„r6|r€­}±E¦Llµ{}r " ®¹—P|vxl|b°GlvH ‘ywrE|Grj­‚±1¦Ulµ{‚rmtugjl¬…ªUlVy{º¯UySw„vxlVw(|¨ "

†jl¯€rjlH†–¦‡±Ptxgjlm{}rBtxlv=…ªlHyztu{‚|rã|„¨´tugjl6g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvulE¦U|²jr€†j{}rjƒ " w„r€†–tug€l6gB±‡Ulv=…ª€gjlvxlEylrBtulVvulH†

|Gr-$tug€w„t(gLw…3w!vxwG†Ž{}²L…_lH»B²€w„­tu| ! " " w„r€†2†ŽlVj{‚ytulH†ãwG…¬wj­‰w„{‚r2ƒvxl±Pw„vxlVw!|r {‚ƒ²€vulÅ®

fhg€{‚…wvulHw1y|vxvulH…ªU|r€†€…¶tx|Etugjl3g‡±‡LlVvª~syw!|¨Z#"„jyw„­‚­‚lV†@#"J®

pNt${‰…6»B²j{ºtxlP|¦‡°‡{}|G²€…1tug€w„t6tugjl¥°G|­‚²jkml|¨µtxgjlPg‡±BUlvu~Nvu{‚rjƒ2|„¨_|GrjlPy­‚²€…ªtulv6{‰…6vxl­‰wbtxlV† tx|·tugjl

{‚kmjvxlVy{‰…u{}|GrA|„¨µtugjlP…ulVw„v=y=g ½gjlrLyltu| ,1¦UlVyw²€…ul+txgjl¥­‚wvuƒGlv1tugjl¥°|G­}²€kEl|„¨_tugjl¥vx{}r€ƒã|¨µ|rjl

y­}²L…ŒtxlvHJtugjlgj{‚ƒgjlVvtxgjl´€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±_¨©|v¹w„r‡±(°lHyztx|v|¨jtugLwbt¹y­‚²€…Œtxlvtu|¬¦Ll­‚|‡yVwbtxlV†3§{}tugj{‚r1tug€w„tvx{}r€ƒ

Zw„r€†!U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚±$§{ºtxgj{‚r!txgjlyw!|Gr€yl¬txgjl»B²jlvx±6L|G{}rBtS{‰… ;‡rj|b§r ,z®Rfhg€l¬r€l‡tµ…ªlHyztx{}|Gr!{‚r‡°lV…ªtu{‚ƒGw„tulH…

txgjl3vxl­‰wbtu{‚|rL…ªgj{‚€…¦UltŒ§llr  @

w„rL† K´®

. % +A%D )A

fhg€ljvxl°‡{}|G²€…S…ulVytu{‚|rP†Žl¯LrjlV†¥g‡±‡LlVvª~Nvx{}rjƒB…€gB±‡Ulvu~NyVw„€…wr€†¥U|{‚rGtxlV†¥|G²ŽtStug€lvulV­‚w„tu{‚|r€…ugj{‚€…¦Ul~

tŒ§llVr tug€l!°G|­‚²jkml$|„¨µvx{‚rjƒG…1w„r€†·txgjl{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gr]|„¨txgjl¥…ªlHw„v=y=g,®ãfhgj{‰…E…ªlHyztu{‚|rA{‚…mwP¯Lvx…ªtE…ªtulV

tx|b§wvx†€…_lŽj­‚w{}r€{}rjƒ¥gj|b§ w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tulEvxwG†Ž{‚²€…ªlH…(y|vxvxlV…uL|Gr€†Ž{‚rjƒ+tx|™wƒ{‚°lr Kdwvul6†Žltulvxkm{}r€lV†/®

fhg€{‚…µ¯€v=…Œt3…Œtxl™€vulH…ªlVrGt=…µg€|b§‘§´l1vulV­‚w„tul K tx|!jvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tu{‚lV…_wbt¬tugjlE­‚l°lV­|¨RlVwGy=g–y­‚²€…ªtulvH“§gj{‰y=g

§{‚­‚­,²j­}tu{‚kmw„tulV­}±$¦Ulwbttxgjl3vx|B|t|„¨txgjly|Gkmj²Žtxw„tu{‚|r|„¨¹w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tul¬vxwG†Ž{‚²€…ªlH…®

7Rrj¨©|v=y{‚rjƒtugjl !N! !´­}lV°lV­¹|„¨¶{‚kmjvulHy{‰…ª{‚|r K w…;Ž…µtx|Py|rBtxvu|G­Z/wbt(txgjlm­}lV°l­"|¨¶lVwGy=gãy­‚²€…ªtulVvV

txgjl=!N < !€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ± K)¨©|vSw1°lVytu|Gv|¨txg€wbtSy­‚²€…ªtulVvVŽ{}¨{}tS{‚…h{‚r!tugjl(ljwGyzthvulH…ª²j­}tV‡tx|m¦Ll(km{‚…x…u{}rjƒ

{‚rtugjlwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlµvxlV…u²j­}tV®

.ltS²€…{‚rBtuvx|Ž†Ž²€yl¬txgjl(¨©|­‚­}|b§{‚rjƒErj|„t=wbtx{}|Gr€…H

I

W E3{‰…(txgjl$jvx|¦€w¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±™¨©|Gvw¥°lHyztu|Gv tugLwbt¦Ul­‚|rjƒB…¬tu|Ptxgjl$vxlV…u²j­}tvultu²jvxrjlV†2¦‡±

w„r™ljwyzt 9 9~s…ulVw„v=y=g¥tu|+¦Ll1kE{‰…x…ª{‚rjƒ+{‚rPtxgjl1…ult¬|„¨¶w„rL…ª§lv=…vxltu²€vurjlH†¥¦‡±!txgjl1wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=gŽpNtk1²€…ŒtS°Glvx{º¨©±

W /3 K´®¶fhgj{‰…h{‰…htugjl3ƒG­}|G¦€w„­“{‚kmjvulHy{‰…ª{‚|r¥y|Gr€…ªtuv=w„{‚rGtH®

I

6 {‰…htugjl3€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±m¨©|GvSw1°GlVytu|vtx|6¦Ll(­‚|‡yVwbtxlV†§{ºtxgj{‚r¥y­}²L…Œtxlv ª®

(14)

I

W 6 ¹{‰…¹tug€lµjvx|¦€w¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±¨©|Gv´w3°GlVytu|v tugLwbt´¦Ul­‚|r€ƒG…¹tx|txgjlµvxlV…u²j­}t¶vultu²jvxrjlH†

¦‡±w„rEljwyt9 9~s…ªlHw„v=y=gtx|¬¦Ulhkm{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ¬{}rEtxgjl…ªlt"|¨Uwr€…ª§lv=…vultu²jvxrjlV†1¦‡±(tugjlSwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

9 9S~N…ulVwvxy=g, ;‡rj|b§{}r€ƒ!txg€wbt°GlVytu|v3{‰…­‚|Žyw„tulV†2§{}tugj{‚r y­‚²€…ªtulv ®¥¸_²€vƒ|Bw„­¹{‰…(tu|¥¯€rL†K

…ª²Ly=g!txg€wbtH+<

" / 6 K)"lrŽ¨©|GvxylV…txgjl3ƒ­‚|¦€w­“{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{}|Gry|r€…ªtuv=w„{‚rBtV®

ElHyw„²L…ªllHwy=g™°GlVytu|v_¦LlV­}|GrjƒG…µtu|!|rjlmw„rL†P|rj­‚±¥|rjlEy­‚²€…ªtulvH $ S¨©|vxkm…¬w$Lw„vutu{}tu{‚|r™|¨Rtugjl

lV°lVrGtS…u€wyl®0+SlVr€ylG

<$EhyVw„r¥¦Ul(¨©|vxk²j­‰wbtxlV†+wG…¨©|­‚­}|b§S…4H

W E

" 6

6 ΁ ,

€vu|GkÎtxgj{‰…!lH»B²€wbtx{}|Gr,§´l2w„vxl™txvu±‡{‚rjƒ tu| †Žltxlvxkm{}rjl

W zµ¨©|vl°Glvx± …u{}r€ƒ­‚l

y­}²L…Œtxlv ®¶¸_²jvƒ|Gw­L{‰…¶tugjlVvul¨©|vxlStu|E…ª|G­}°GlµlH»G²Lwbtu{‚|r ŒÅ ,´w„rL†mtu|1¯€r€†+§g€wbthw„vxlStug€l_jvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tu{‚lV…

K ­‚|‡yVw„­“tx|6lVwy=gy­‚²€…ªtulv {‚r€†Ž²LylV†¦‡±$g€wJ°‡{‚rjƒ6…ªlt K¶®

¼ {}tugj|G²Žt¬wr‡±w6€vu{‚|vx{ ;‡rj|b§­‚lV†ŽƒGl3|rtugjlE†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|GrP|„¨¶†jw„txw6w„rL†J|GvS|r¥txgjlU|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l†Ž{‰…Œ~

txvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Grã|¨Rtug€l$»G²€lvx±P°lVytu|Gvx…V“{ºt3{‰…({}kmU|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l1tx|!lH…Œtx{}k6w„tul

µ¨©|v(lVwGy=g w„r€†ãlVwGy=g

uw„rL†™txgjlvxl¨©|GvulE{}kmU|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚ltx|Py|kmj²jtulKCu,²jr€­}lH…u…(§lEy|r€…u{‰†Žlv¬tugLwbt

W

" / < <L® |Gr€…u{‚†ŽlVvu{‚rjƒ(txgj{‚…¶kmlVw„rL…¹tugLwbt¶txgjlSjvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±|¨,km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒw3°GlVytu|v¶{‚…

²€rj{º¨©|Gvukm­‚±+†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²ŽtxlV†|b°lVvw­}­,y­}²L…Œtxlv=…Ž{‚r€†ŽlVLlVr€†ŽlrBtx­}±!|„¨txgjl{‚vSvxl­‰wbtx{}°Gl_U|G…u{ºtx{}|Gr+tx|Etugjl»B²jlVvu±

U|{‚rBt|v3tx|¥tugjlV{}vL|Gj²j­‰wbtu{‚|r®$¼ãl!w„vxlE§l­‚­¶wJ§hw„vxltxg€wbtEwPyw„vxl¨©²€­Rw„r€w­}±Ž…u{‚…(|¨´txgjl+†jw„txwP…u€wyl

y|²j­‰†ãL|B…u…u{}¦€­}±™ƒG{}°Gl1¦UltutulVvgj{‚rGt=…¬¨©|v3lH…Œtx{}k6wbtx{}r€ƒ

¬w„r€†

W zU|G…x…u{}¦j­‚±

lVrŽ¨©|v=y{‚rjƒãkE|Gvul!jvxlVy{‰…ul!w„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtu{‚|rL…®2fhgj{‚…E{‰…¶gj|b§´lV°lVvV"w„r |UlrA€vu|G¦j­}lVk tug€w„tE§l!k6wJ±

…ªtu²L†Ž±${‚r!txgjl(¨©²Žtx²jvulG®

fhgjlVvul¨©|vxlŽ¦‡±+†ŽlVrj|„tx{}r€ƒ

W M

zj{}tS{‰…hL|B…u…u{}¦€­}l¬tu|6vxl§vx{}tul¬lV»B²€wbtx{}|Gr ªÅ ,hwG…H

W 3 6 K

W 3 6 K

W 3 K Z•,

€vu|Gk Z•;,zj{}tS{‚…SL|B…u…u{}¦€­}l¬tu|6y|r€y­}²€†jl(tug€w„t

" /6 K K/< ½n;,

txg€wbt_{‚…VLlVrŽ¨©|v=y{‚rjƒ

" / 4 KA¨©|vSlHwy=g™y­‚²€…ªtulVv lVr€…ª²€vulH…htug€w„t

$3 FK´®

fhg€lr€l‡t¶…ªlHyztx{}|GrE…ugj|b§S…tug€lvxwG†Ž{}²L…ªlH…|¨“wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl´g‡±‡Ulv=…ªjg€lvxlV…ƒ{‚°lVrtxgjl{}kmjvxlVy{‚…u{‚|r­‚l°Gl­

KAw„vxl¬y|kmj²ŽtxlV†/®

. % +A%D > +8I +,'!.- > +8I5 Z>$ !.# )A =?> >$+ACB'3D ) / "#$'1$I

9ŽlVyztx{}|Gr€…”€®‚Åㆎl¯€rjlH†dg‡±‡LlVvª~Nvu{‚rjƒB…Sg‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„€…!w„r€†D|²Žtx­}{‚rjlV†dtugjl·vxl­‰wbtx{}|Gr€…ªg€{}€…!¦UltŒ§llrDtugjl

°G|­‚²jkml´|¨Lvx{}r€ƒG…w„r€†tugjlh{‚kmjvulHy{‰…ª{‚|r1|„¨Ltugjl…ulVw„v=y=g,® 9‡lVytu{‚|r”L®•_†Žl¯€rjlV†1§g€w„t"{‰…tug€l€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±

(15)

q C HC

dmin + 1

1 dmin r

1 1

1

ε 1

ε

HR 1

1

{}ƒG²jvxl3•"H16µ…u{}rjƒ$wr +µ±‡LlVvuj­‰w„r!tu| Í jjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl #"

¨©|Gv´w3°GlVytu|v¶¦LlV­}|Grjƒ{‚rjƒ3tx|w…uLlHy{}¯LySy­‚²€…ªtulVvRtu|1¦Ll_km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ3{}¨,{ºt{‚…´vxltu²€vurjlH†m¦‡±txgjlµlŽwGyzt¶…ulVwvxy=g,®

fhg€{‚…3…ulVytu{‚|r2{‚…¬txgjlm­‚wG…Œt…ªtul2tx|b§wvx†j…_lŽj­‰w„{‚rj{‚rjƒ¥gj|b§wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl1v=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…(w„vxlm†ŽltxlvxkE{‚rjlH†

ƒG{}°Glr K¶®¹f|_vxlVwGy=gtug€{‚…¹ƒG|Gw­Zb§l¶¯Lvx…ªt¹jvulH…ªlVrBt"g€|b§ tugjlr‡²jk1¦LlVv¹|„¨U°lVytu|Gvx…tug€w„t¶w„vxl´{‚r1tugjlg‡±‡LlVvª~

vx{‚rjƒ$|„¨RlHwy=g–y­}²L…Œtxlvµ{‰…¬†ŽltxlvxkE{‚rjlH†/®_¼2ltxgjlrãlŽj­‰w„{‚rPtugLwbtV“²jrL†Žlv_tugjlE…ªUlVy{º¯Uyw…x…u²jkmŽtu{‚|r™|¨

{‰…u|„tuvx|‡±Gtug€lRr‡²jk¦Ulv,|¨Ž°lVytu|Gvx…Utxg€wbtwvul¹{‚r(tug€lRg‡±BUlvu~syw„(|¨BlHwy=g3y­‚²€…ªtulv{‚…w…ª{‚kmj­}l¶jvu|GL|Gvªtx{}|Gr

|¨¹§g€wbt¬{‚…_{}r¥txgjlg‡±‡Ulvu~:vx{}r€ƒ€®¼2l§{‚­}­tugjlVr™¦UlvxlVw†j±+tx|$jvxlV…ulrBtStug€lr‡²jkmlvx{‚yVw„­kEltugj|Ž†P²L…ªlH†

tx|6y|kmj²jtul3v=w†Ž{‚²€…ulV…V®

f|_lVrŽ¨©|v=yl¶{}rjlH»B²€wbtx{}|Gr½n;,zbtxgjl´r‡²jk1¦LlVv|¨€°lHyztx|v=…/tugLwbt¹w„vxlR­}|ŽyVwbtulH†{‚r3tug€l´g‡±‡LlVvª~syw|„¨€y­}²L…Œ~

txlv ½rj|„txlV† 4@,R|b°Glv¶tugjl¬tu|txw­Lr‡²jk1¦LlVv|¨°lHyztx|v=…R¦Ul­‚|rjƒG{}rjƒtu| ½rj|„txlV† #4-,

k1²€…ªth¦Ul3­‚lV…x…h|vlV»B²€w­“tu| K´ŽtugLwbtS{‰…H

4@

#4 K/< ©” ,

psr€lV»B²€wbtx{}|Gr ©”&,R{‚r€†Ž{‰yw„tulV…Rtug€w„tVBtu|1lrŽ¨©|GvxylBK2wbt´tugjl¬­}lV°lV­€|„¨y­‚²€…Œtxlv Btugjl¬w„j€vu|JŽ{‚kmw„tulSv=w†j{}²€…

txg€wbt†Žltulvxkm{}r€lV…¶tugjl¬°|G­}²jkml_|„¨ k²€…ªth¦Ll(…ª²Ly=g6tug€w„t´txgjl¬vulH…ª²j­}tu{‚rjƒ1gB±‡Ulvu~NyVw„ y|rBtxw{}r€…

w„tkE|B…Œttxgjl3jvx|U|vutu{‚|r K |„¨"w„­‚­/tugjl3°GlVytu|v=…|„¨ ®

#4@¬†ŽlUlrL†j…(|rãtugjl6†Ž{‰…ªtxw„rLylE¦LltŒ§´lVlr +w„rL†ãy­}²€…ªtulVv$ h¦UlVyVw„²€…ulEtugj{‰…({‚kELwyzt=…¬tugjl

½{}r€rjlv,my²jvx°bwbtx²jvul|„¨ @u® j|v6w·y­‚²€…ªtulVv, w„r€† w2ƒ{‚°lrw„€jvu|JŽ{‚k6wbtul!vxwG†Ž{‚²€…¶tugjl¥¨©²€vªtxgjlv

‡,tugjl6¦j{‚ƒƒGlv¬tug€lEg‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„–|¨y­}²€…ªtulVv/ª®5_lUlr€†Ž{‚rjƒP|Gr–txgjl6†Ž{‚…ªtxwr€ylm¦UltŒ§llVr w„r€†ãlVwGy=g

y­}²L…Œtxlv{‰…1°lvx±2jvu|G¦j­‚lk6wbtx{‚y6…u{}rLyl+{}t1{‰…1rj|„tEL|B…u…u{}¦€­}l6tx|ãwGyy|G²jrBt¨©|vEw„­‚­´U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l$­‚|Žywbtx{}|Gr€…|¨

‡®3pNt({‰…_U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l1tu|¦jvulHw?;!tugj{‰…3†ŽlVLlVr€†ŽlrLy±P¦‡±™y|Gr€…ª{‰†ŽlVvu{‚rjƒ+wr–|b°lVvulH…Œtx{}k6w„tu{‚|rP|„¨ ª,yVw„­‚­}lH†

ªL†Žl¯€r€lV†¥w…txgjl3{}rBtxlv=…ªlHyztu{‚|r|„¨"§{ºtxg™w„rg€w„­}¨~s…ª²j¦L…ª€wGylG®Rfhgj{‚…hgLw„­}¨~N…u²j¦€…u€wyl3y|rBt=w„{‚r€…

wr€†m{‰…¶¦U|²jrL†ŽlV†6¦‡±6w„r6g‡±‡Ulvxj­‚wr6|vutugj|Gƒ|Gr€w„­Žtx| &< ¶wr€†m­}|ŽyVwbtulH†$wbtw†Ž{‰…Œt=w„r€ylS|„¨ !

¨©vx|k ‡® 9µ|„txl_txg€wbtS|Grjl¬gB±‡Ulvu~NyVw„†Žl¯€r€lV†!²€…ª{‚rjƒ6…u²€y=g!wr!g‡±‡LlVvu€­‚wr %* !:?A % !N *;("*3tugLw„rtugjl

…xw„kmlSg‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„6†Žl¯LrjlV†6²L…ª{‚rjƒ{}tx…wytu²€w­Ly²€vu°bwbtx²jvxl®"l­‚±‡{}rjƒ|r6g‡±‡LlVvuj­‰w„rL…R{‰…Rtxgjlvxl¨©|GvulSw…xwb¨©l

wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtx{}|Grã…u{}rLyl${}t|b°lVvulH…Œtx{}k6w„tulV…_txgjl$jvx|¦€w¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±Ptu|–kE{‰…x…w¥°lHyztu|GvV® {}ƒG²jvul+•¥…ugj|b§S…3wr

ljw„kmj­‚l3|„¨"tugj{‰…Sg‡±‡Ulvxj­‚wr,L†jlrj|tulV†¥wG…µw6†Ž|tªtulH†P…Œtxvxw{}ƒGgBtS­}{‚rjl® 9µ|„tultugjl°G|­‚²jkml3|„¨"tug€lj­‰w„{‚r

ƒGvulV±EwvulHw3{‚r€yvxlVwG…ªlH†m§{ºtxg+vxlV…uLlHyzt¶tx| {‚ƒ²jvxlÅ® €vu|Gk r€|b§ |r,‡w„­‚­Lg‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„€…¶kElVrBtu{‚|rjlH†6{}r+tugjl

vxlV…ªt|„¨tugj{‰…€wLlVvk²€…ªtS¦Ll3²€r€†Žlv=…ªtu|‡|Ž†!wG…w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tul¬¦B±+gB±‡Ulvxj­‰w„r€…V®

#4@ Rw­‚…u|3†ŽlUlrL†j…¶|GrEtugjlµ†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r6|¨Utxgjlµ†jw„txw(U|{‚rBtx…R§{}tug€{}r ½w„rL†EtugjlVvul¨©|vxl

§{}tug€{}r 4,w„rL†Dw„­‰…u|A|rħgj{‰y=g?:u…ª{‰†Žl ;–|„¨txgj{‰…y­}²L…Œtxlvtugjl »B²jlVvu± U|{‚rBt{‰…Py­‚|G…ul™tx|€® pN¨1tugjl

(16)

†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r1|„¨Žtug€l†jw„txw_L|G{}rBt=…§{}tugj{‚rmy­‚²€…Œtxlv

¨©|G­}­‚|b§S…wSjvx{}°‡{‚­}lVƒlH††Ž{‚vulHyztu{‚|r #4

§{‚­}­

¦UlS°Glvx±1†Ž{NGUlVvulVrBtR{º¨¬{‰…Rw„­‰…ª|w­}{‚ƒr€lV†E§{ºtxg6tug€{‚…´†Ž{}vxlVytu{‚|r:©{‚rmtug€{‚…ywG…ªl 4@ "§{‚­}­L¦Llµ­‚wvuƒGl ,z

|Gv{º¨E{‰…|vutugj|Gƒ|Gr€w„­Utu|mtxgj{‰…µ†Ž{‚vulHyztx{}|Gr ½{}r¥txgj{‰…µywG…ªl #4@ h§{‚­}­¦Ll1…ªk6w„­‚­,z® €|vµ…u{‚kE€­}{‰y{}tŒ±

§lhw…x…ª²jkml´{}r1tugjlhvxlV…ªt|¨jtug€{‚…¹…ulVytu{‚|rtxg€wbt"U|{‚rGt=…{}rElVwGy=g ¨©|­‚­}|b§]wr8% '4*@ $'%'4*!# 'L®

9ŽlVyztx{}|Gr”€®”jbgj|b§l°GlvHvxlVy|r€…u{‚†jlv=…/tug€{‚…w…x…ª²€kEjtu{‚|rwr€†wyVy|G²jrBtx…/¨©|Gvkm|vxl¶vxlVw­}{‰…ªtu{‰yR†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr

km|Ž†ŽlV­‚…V®

ElVyVw„²€…ul$U|{‚rBtx…{‚rAw­}­´gB±‡Ulvu~:vx{‚rjƒG…wvul$…u²jjU|G…ulV† tu|P¨©|G­}­‚|b§ w„r {‰…ª|tuvx|j{‰y6†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr,"tugjl

r‡²jk1¦LlVv|„¨°GlVyztx|v3{‚r |rjl6g‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„2{‚…1w¥jvu|GL|Gvªtx{}|Grã|¨htugjl$r‡²jk1¦LlVv|„¨°GlVyztx|v=…({}r·txgjl+y|vxvul~

…uU|r€†Ž{‚rjƒmg‡±‡LlVvª~Nvu{‚rjƒL®fhgjlVvul¨©|vxl #4@hywr!¦Ul3lŽjvxlV…x…ulV†+wG…H

4@ #( @

@

#(

@

?M

Zœ,

§g€lvxl

h{‰…htxgjl°|G­}²€kEl(|¨txgjl3g‡±‡LlVvª~syw!|¨ 

h{‰…htxgjl°|G­}²€kEl3|¨txgjlg‡±‡LlVvª~

vx{‚rjƒ|„¨Z 

¹txgjl_°G|­‚²jkmlS|„¨tugjl_kE{‚rj{‚k²jk g‡±‡Ulv=…ªjg€lvxlµ¦U|²jr€†j{}rjƒ wr€†

txgjl3°|G­}²€kEl(|¨Z …Swjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxlµg‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvulG®

6_…ª{‚rjƒ6lV»B²€w„tu{‚|r Zœ ,j{}tS{‚…U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l¬tu|mvxl§vx{ºtxl¬{‚rjlH»G²Lwbtu{‚|r ©”&,hw…¨©|G­}­‚|b§S…H

4M

( #4

#4 K ;,

7¹jylŽt

4Bw­}­jtugjltxlvxk6…¹{}r6{‚rjlH»G²Lwbtu{‚|r:,¹†ŽlVLlVr€†m|rEtug€lµ…ª{ l|¨“tugjlµwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl

g‡±‡Ulv=…ªjg€lvxl|„¨Cª®¹fhgjl_vxwG†Ž{‚²€…R|¨/tugj{‰…´wjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxlg‡±BUlv=…ujgjlvxl{‰…Rtxgjlµ²jr ;Br€|b§rmtu|¯Lr€†m¨©vx|k

txgj{‰…m²jrj{‰»G²€l!lH»G²Lwbtu{‚|r®]¼ãlP…u|­‚°l{}r€lV»B²€wbtx{}|Gr ;,¦B±]¯€vx…ªtmkmw;‡{}rjƒãtug€l!¨©|G­}­‚|b§{‚rjƒ–jvxl­‚{‚kE{‚r€wvu±

vxlk6wv;Ž…4H

I 4 hyVw„rrj|„tS¦Ul3lŽjvxlV…x…ªlH†+wr€w„­‚±Btu{‰yw„­‚­‚±®

I 4

h†ŽlHyvxlVwG…ªlH…´§g€lrtugjl3v=w†j{}²€…|¨ …wjjvx|J‡{‚k6wbtxl_g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul({‚r€yvxlVwG…ªlH…®

I 4 {‰…rj|ty|rBtu{‚r‡²j|²L…w„r€†!°bw„vx{}lH…h§{ºtxgj{}r ]®

{‚°lVr™tug€lV…ul1vxlk6w„v<;Ž…U{}t({‰…¬L|B…u…u{‚¦j­}ltu|vulH…ª|G­}°Gl ># ("* < !!AP{‚rjlV»B²€w„tu{‚|r ;,¬w„r€†Ptu||¦Žt=w„{‚r

txgjl+°bw­}²jl+¨©|vtugjlvxwG†Ž{‚²€…|¨tugjlw„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tul6g‡±‡LlVvx…ujgjlVvul$|¨@ ƒG{}°Glr |r€l+…ªUlVy{º¯Uy8K´®2fhgjl

r‡²jkmlVvu{‰yw­/kEltugj|Ž†§l¬²L…ªl3vxl­‚{}lH…h|r¥wm¦j{‰…ªlHyztu|Gvª~N¦€wG…ªlH†$…Œtxvxw„tulVƒ±$§{}tugj{‚rtugjl3{‚rBtulVvu°bw„­Â< ® 5_²jl

tx|m­‚wGy;$|„¨"…ª€wGylGŽ§´l3†Ž|6rj|t{}r€y­}²L†Žl3gjlvxl¬tugjly|vxvulH…ªU|rL†Ž{}r€ƒ1€…ul²L†Ž|„~sy|Ž†ŽlG®

æÜJÒ(ÕHÒ=ÙhÝ=ÔZÔ:×JÓæzçŽÑJÒEV/æséæŒäªçjÙZÑbÝxÙhÝ=ØÁØLÑ QV÷„æŒä½ñä½ÚÁÕJózÔ´Ò#\Ý=ØÁØUåŒØÁ×JÔZÙZæŒäZÔÝ=äZæSÚÁÜJæŒÕÙ:ÚÁåªÝ=؉í_Ð,ÑJæŒÚÁä¶ÜHÚÁÔZÙZäZÚYJ×VÙ:ÚÁÒzÕmÒzÕHØQ

Ô:ÑbÝ=ä½æ"Ù:ÑHæ¶ÚÁÔZÒ=Ù:ä½Òz÷JÚÁåR÷Jä½Òz÷„æªä©Ù[Qí

(17)

. = +$' ) + "+ '5) +,' 1) 'A !$ '!

fhg€l+jvxl°‡{‚|²€…E…ªlHyztx{}|Gr]jvxlV…ulrBtulH†·tugjl¥w„€jvu|Bwy=g·²€…ulV†]tu|ãy|kmj²Žtxlwjjvx|JŽ{}k6wbtxl6g‡±BUlv=…ujgjlvxlV…

§g€lr¥tug€l°lHyztx|v=…h{}rPtxgjlg‡±‡Ulvu~:vx{}r€ƒG…¨©|­‚­‚|b§wr¥{‚…u|„txvu|Gj{‚y3†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r,®Sfhg€{‚…¬w…x…ª²€kEjtu{‚|rP†Ž|‡lV…

y­}lHw„vx­}±Erj|t´gj|G­‚†m{‚r$txgjlµƒGlrjlVvxw­LywG…ªlG®fhg€lvxl¨©|vxlG{ºt{‚…´U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚lStu|1l‡tulVr€†mtxgjl_wjjvx|Gwy=gEtx|1y|GLl

§{}tugw„vx¦j{}tuv=w„vx±m†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r€…´|„¨°lHyztu|Gvx…¶§{ºtxgj{‚r!g‡±‡LlVvª~Nvx{}rjƒB…R|Gr!w1LlVvhy­}²L…Œtxlvh¦€w…u{‰…BtugLwbth{‚…V‡tugjl

w­}ƒG|vx{ºtxgjkwG†jw„Žt=…"{ºt=…¹¦Ulg€wJ°‡{‚|v"tu|(txgjlS…uLlHy{}¯Ly†Ž{‰…Œtxvu{‚¦j²Žtx{}|Gr6lr€y|²jrBtulVvulH†{‚rml°Glvx±…ª{‚rjƒG­}ly­‚²€…ªtulVvV®

fhgjl_jvxl°‡{}|G²€…¶…ulVytu{‚|r+wG…u…u²jkmlV†6wr$l‡txvulVkEl_yw…ulS{‚r6tug€l¬…ulr€…ultxg€wbt{ºtw…x…ª²€kElH†Etugjl_{‚…u|„txvu|Gj{‰y

†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|r!tu|6gj|G­‚†+¨©|vSw­}­

® Í

r€|„tug€lvl‡txvulVkEl3yVw…ul¬{‰…tu|6y|r€…u{‚†jlvhtugLwbttug€l3°lVytu|Gvx…´{}rPw­}­

txgjlµg‡±‡Ulvu~:vx{}r€ƒG…¹|¨w„­‚­Ll‡{‰…ªtu{‚rjƒy­‚²€…ªtulVvx… *(6 !!,{‚r€y­‚²€†ŽlH†6{}r$tugjlV{}vhw…x…ª|Žy{‚w„tulV†mg‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„,®psr6tug€{‚…

yVw…ulŽtxgjl°GlVyztx|vµ†j{‚…ªtuvx{}¦€²Žtu{‚|rP{‰…S…ul°lVvulV­}±!…J;Gl§lV†¥w„r€†txgjl{‰…ª|tuvx|j{‰y3w…x…u²jkmŽtu{‚|rP†Ž|‡lV…Srj|„tµg€|­‰†

wr‡±Bkm|GvulG®

psr¥¨½wGyztVL¨©|v_w6ƒ{‚°lVr K´Ltugjl1vulHw„­†Ž{‰…ªtuvx{}¦j²jtu{‚|rP|„¨¹°GlVyztx|v=…h{}rPg‡±‡Ulvu~:vx{}r€ƒG…h{‰…L¨©|vSlHwy=gPy­‚²€…ªtulVvV

¦UltŒ§llVrEtugjlhtŒ§|w„¦U|b°ll‡tuvxlkmlSyVw…ulV…V®¼2lµywrtxgjlvxl¨©|Gvultuvx±tx|3lV…ªtu{‚k6wbtulG„¨©|GvRlVwGy=gEy­}²€…ªtulVvVtugjl

€vu|G¦€w„¦j{‚­‚{ºtŒ±¥¨©|Gv(tugjlm{‰…ª|tuvx|j{‰ym†Ž{‚…ªtuvx{‚¦j²Žtu{‚|rãtu|¥gj|G­‚†,® €|vy­}²€…ªtulVv/ª/txgj{‰…3jvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tŒ±P{‚…3yVw„­‚­}lH†

z®¶fhg€{‚…hjvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±+w­}­‚|b§S…´tu|mvulV§vu{}tul

" /EhwG…H

W E

"

" , 1 ,

§g€lvxl

W h{‰…Stxgjljvx|¦Lw„¦j{‚­}{}tŒ±+|¨Rg€wJ°‡{}r€ƒ km{‚…x…ª{‚rjƒ$§g€lrPtxgjl1y­}²€…ªtulVvµ{‰…S{‰…ª|tuvx|j{‰y„®

9Ž²jjU|G…u{}rjƒ1tug€{‚…SwG…u…u²jkmŽtx{}|Gr+gj|G­‚†j…´¨©|Gv ‡tug€lr

W / ´yVw„r¦Ll3†ŽlH†Ž²€ylV†+¨©vu|Gk {}r€lV»B²€wb~

tx{}|Gr ,z®¬pN¨¶{}t_{}t(†Ž|‡lH…µrj|t_gj|G­‚†,LtxgjlrL¨©vx|k ½” ,z

" / ,

®¬pNt¬{‰…µtugjlVvul¨©|vxl

U|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l¬tu|mvxl§vx{ºtxl= 1 ,hwG…H

W E

@

M

#4

4 !

" 4

#4

$#

K

psr tug€{‚…6{‚rjlH»G²Lw„­‚{ºtŒ±G

E{‚…EtxgjlP|r€­}± ²jr";‡rj|b§r,®psrƒlVrjlv=w„­:´†ŽltulVvukm{‚rj{}r€ƒ2§gLwbt${‰…mtugjl

vx{‚ƒgBt¶°bw„­‚²jl¨©|GvRtug€{‚…´jvx|¦€w¦j{}­‚{}tŒ±¨©|vlVwGy=g6y­‚²€…Œtxlv´vulH»G²€{}vxltu|²€…ªl¬…Œt=wbtx{‚…ªtu{‰yw­Lw„€jvu|Bwy=gjlH…®j|v´|rjl

y­}²L…Œtxlv) w„r€†(ƒG{}°Glr(|rjl¶jvulH†Žltxlvxkm{}rjlH†=K¶J{}t{‰…,U|G…x…ª{‚¦j­‚l¹tu|µlV…ªtu{‚kmw„tul

“¦‡±_¯€vx…ªty|kmj²Žtx{}rjƒ

…¶w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulgB±‡Ulv=…ª€gjlvxlh²jr€†ŽlVv¹tugjlSwG…u…u²jkmŽtx{}|GrE|¨UgLwJ°B{‚rjƒ3w„rE{‰…ª|tuvx|j{‰yh†Ž{‚…ªtuvx{‚¦j²Žtu{‚|rGw„rL†

txgjlrmlH…Œtx{}k6wbtxlSgj|b§ kmwr‡±°lHyztx|v=…¨½w­}­L{}r …¹g‡±‡Ulvu~NyVw„,®fhgjlr,‡…ul°lVvxw­‡vxwr€†Ž|k°lVytu|Gvx…¹yVw„rm¦Ll

ƒGlrjlVvxw„tulH†!wr€†¥²€…ulV†¥w…S»B²jlVvu{‚lV…V®pNtµ{‚…tug‡²€…SU|G…x…u{}¦j­‚l3tx|$y|²€rGtSg€|b§ k6wrB±!°lHyztu|Gvx…h|¨ kE{‰…x…S{‚r

txgjl(w„jjvx|JŽ{}k6w„tulvxlV…u²j­ºtH® |km€w„vx{‚rjƒ3tug€l_lH…Œtx{}k6wbtxlV†+rB²€k¦Ulv|„¨,km{‚…x…u{}rjƒ1°lHyztu|Gvx…Rtu|tugjl¬r‡²jk¦Ulv

|¨°GlVyztx|v=…´tug€w„tµwyztx²€w„­‚­‚±$km{‚…x…h{‚… ;l±$tu|Etu²jr€l

®

Références

Documents relatifs

Nous avons inclus dans notre étude tous les patients qui avaient une paralysie radiale périphérique haute isolée avec une force musculaire des muscles donneurs au moins à 4

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

107 Tableau 16 : Tableau comparatif des études de la littérature et notre étude selon l’incidence annuelle des pleurésies purulentes (tuberculeuses ou non selon les cas) ...112

Les fonctions localisées sont obtenues par la résolution autocohérente d,une équation de Kohn-Sham locale, avec un potentiel qui coincide avec le potentiel du cristal à

Dans cette étude, nous nous sommes proposé de voire les modalités de prise en charge du Kyste Hydatique du Foie dans 13 provinces avec 150 Médecins

- Caractère envahissant du trouble : les critères doivent être rempli dans plus d’une situation, par exemple, l’association d’une inattention et

Le trouble bipolaire est une maladie a différente facette comprend plusieurs types, portant de similarité accrue avec d‟autre types de troubles mentales, le trouble

L’étude réalisée au cours de cette thèse a un double objectif : le développement d’un système de conversion vocale performant et robuste que nous pouvons appliquer à la