• Aucun résultat trouvé

Quality Assessment of Electromagnetic Localizers in the Context of 3D Ultrasound

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Quality Assessment of Electromagnetic Localizers in the Context of 3D Ultrasound"

Copied!
19
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072180

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072180

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Quality Assessment of Electromagnetic Localizers in the Context of 3D Ultrasound

François Rousseau, Christian Barillot

To cite this version:

François Rousseau, Christian Barillot. Quality Assessment of Electromagnetic Localizers in the Con- text of 3D Ultrasound. [Research Report] RR-4408, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072180�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--4408--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 3

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Quality Assessment of Electromagnetic Localizers in the Context of 3D Ultrasound

François Rousseau — Christian Barillot

N° 4408

Septembre 2002

(3)
(4)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)

Téléphone : +33 2 99 84 71 00 — Télécopie : +33 2 99 84 71 71

01 $23 46587 9:; !"<>=

?A@CBD-EGFIHKJ3LMFIN"JOJOPQBNSRUTWVYX-@ZHKJ*[CH\B]D_^YB@OHa`K`KF][3b

c,dfe*g3hi<jlknmQophZqsrGt;osuwvGmMdfvGgYg3h*xKg(rytdzuwmfhG{

u|g(r~}GhZZ{€fvymfmf‚ZhZZ{ftvGmfmzr~uƒsprymzthO

„Wqsv~…†h*o‡ˆuƒ†or

‰Šr~‹z‹]vGqŒoŠ€h8qshZtdfhZqstdzhŽm"yQ‘y’“j•”hZ‹ophZg<–fqsh<—~‘G‘G—˜jš™C›‹zr~}GhZ

œM"žZŸ* ¢¡f£yŸy¤6¥W¦

hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmfhosu|t>Œ‹zr~opuƒr

¦,¦

vtZr

¦

uw§Zh*qqsh*‹fqshZph*mQo

¦

v¢¨t*vGŒoYr~m]€ª©zh*«u|–

¦

hpv

¦|¬

osuwvGmª­®vyq

t ¦u|mfuƒt*r ¦ ­®qphZhx\dzr~mz€Uopdfqsh*h¯€fuwg3h*m]Œu|vymzr ¦-¬f¦osqsrGŒv ¬ mz€'Œ°ŒophZg±(c,dfhZuwq8‹h*qp­®vyqsg(r~mzt*hZ˜tvGmz€uwopu|vym“opdfh

rGt*t ¬ qsrGt°(vy­"osdfht*r ¦u|–fqr¢osuwvGmrymz€>opdfh ¬z¦osqsrGŒv ¬ mz€>qphOtvym]†osq ¬ tophO€M²Gv ¦|¬ g3hr~mz€>opdzhqpvG– ¬ ŒopmfhOp,vy­

osdfh³rGt*´ ¬ uƒŒuwopu|vym¯Œosry}yhG±knm(osdfuƒ+Œo¬ €f°y{¨+h³h*²¢r ¦|¬ r~ophosdfhˆqshZpv ¦|¬ opu|vym¯rymz€3osdfh³rGt*t ¬ qsrGt°­®vGqWosqsrymz ¦r¢x

osuwvGmz,r~mz€>qsv~osr~opu|vymz+v~­o†¨+vY¨u|€fhZp‹fqphOry€ ¦vt*r ¦u|§*hZqs+u|m´ ¬ uwoph˜g3hor ¦|¦uƒtˆhZm²Qu|qsvymfg3h*mQoOµ-¶]ryŒopqr~·(r~m]€

¦vt·vy­ ¸$uwq€¹±<º ¬ qˆh*«‹]hZqpu|g3h*mQos»Œdzv¢¨Sopdzr~o³osdfh*u|q³qshZpv ¦|¬ osuwvGm¼­®vyq»‹]vQŒuwopu|vym½u| ¬ mz€hZq8¾f¿ÁÀ¢ÂÂÃr¢o

Ä ¾yÅ;Â'{-r~mz€'osdfh*u|qqshZpv ¦|¬ osuwvGm“­®vGq<vGqpu|h*mQosr~opu|vymÆuƒryqpv ¬ mz€Æ¾f¿¾ Ä €hZ}yqsh*hO*±¼¶fvGqosqsrymz ¦r¢osuwvGmz8–h ¦v¢¨

Ç ¾yÅ;Â'{Èosdfh*u|q<‹vGpuwopu|vymÉrytZt ¬ qryt*°Uuƒ<r~qsv ¬ mz€ËÊG¿Ì~Â>Â'{-r~mz€'osdfhMr~mz} ¬f¦r~qrGt*t ¬ qsrGt°Uuƒ ¬ m]€h*q>ʯ€hx

}GqphZhy±Ac,dfhOŒh˜qshZ ¬f¦oŠpdfv¢¨Íopd]r¢oopdzhZphZŠ€hZ²u|t*hZ,‹fqsv¢²u|€h˜¬Î tu|h*mQoˆrytZt ¬ qryt*°3­®vyq ¬ ph8uwm¼r3t ¦u|mfu|tZr ¦

t*vymQoph*«oZ±

ϼÐQÑIÒsÓ<Ô  ¢Õ"žy¤ g(ry}ymfh*opuƒtˆosqsrGt·uwmf}3€hZ²QuƒthG{opdzqphZhxn€uwg3hZmzŒu|vym]r ¦I¬f¦opqrypv ¬ mz€p°ŒophZgrytZt ¬ qryt*°y±

ÖW×®Ø×ÚÙZÛ½ÜIÝÞCßàá†âaãaßäKåAæOáWØá†ÞCÞCá†ã ç

è

×®Ø×ÚÙZ۽ܹé¹êØ"Ù

(5)

*>˜ " =>&+M >!- !-<#$ 3=><>

$ $23 š=Œ>; !"<587

ž ¤ hZ8p°†ose*g3hZ˜€h3qsh*‹‚*qr~}yhY‚ ¦hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmf‚osu|´ ¬ hOˆqsh*‹zqp‚OŒhZmGosh*mQo ¬ mfh(Œv ¦w¬ opu|vym“pv ¬ ‹ ¦h

h*o(‹]h ¬ vGmf‚*qsh ¬ Œh>‹]v ¬ q ¦hO(Œ°ŒopeZgYhO3€u|g(r~}Gh*qsuwh ¬f¦opqrypvymfvGqphi± h ¬ qsY‹h*qp­®vyqsg3rymzthO3tvym]€ux

osuwvGmfmfhZmGo³­®vyqpophZgYhZmQo ¦rM‹fqs‚ZtuƒpuwvGmU€h ¦r(‹fdzrGŒh€htZr ¦uw–fqr¢osuwvGmÈ{]€ ¬ ²yv ¦w¬ gYh<qphOtvym]†osq ¬ uwo³ryuwmzpu´ ¬ h

¦r>qpvG– ¬ ŒophZsph€h ¦rM‹fd]ryphY€rytZ´ ¬ u|puwopu|vym“€fhZ˜u|g3ry}yhO*±»r~m]»t*hopoph3‚o ¬ €hy{mfv ¬ ˜‚Z²¢r ¦|¬ vymz ¦rMqshx

‹zqpv€ ¬ topu|–fu¦uwop‚3ho ¦r‹fqs‚ZtuƒpuwvGm½h*m“opqr~m]¦r¢osuwvGm½hohZm“qsv~or¢osuwvGm½‹v ¬ q ¦hZ8€h ¬ «“p°†ose*g3hZ ¦hZ˜‹ ¦|¬ 

qs‚*‹]r~mz€ ¬ ˜µ ¦h¶]ryŒopqr~·¯h*o ¦ ¦vt·Mv~­A¸$uwq€¹±ˆvGh*«‹‚*qsu|h*mzt*hZ,g3vymQopqsh*mQoˆ´ ¬ h ¦r3qphZ‹fqpv€ ¬ t;opu|–fu¦uwop‚

hZm3opqr~mz ¦r¢opu|vymYhZŒo u|m­®‚*qsu|h ¬ qsh8¾f¿ÁÀ¢ÂÂ Ä ¾GÅ;Â'{~ho ¦r8qsh*‹fqsv€ ¬ topu|–fu¦uwop‚h*m(qsv~or¢osuwvGmhO†o+€hZmQ²u|qpvGm

¾z¿¾ Ä €hZ}yqs‚ZZ±„-v

¬

q$€fhZ,€‚*‹

¦

rGth*g3hZmGo$uwm­®‚Zqpu|h

¬

qs Ç ¾yÅ;Â'{

¦

r<‹fqs‚ZtuƒpuwvGmMh*m>‹]vQŒuwopu|vym>hZŒo,€hZmQ²u|qpvGm

ÊG¿Ì~Â>Â'{h*o

¦r ‹fqs‚ZtuƒpuwvGmÆrymf}

¬z¦

ryuwqsh(hZŒo<u|m­®‚*qsuwh

¬

qsh ªÊ¯€h*}Gqp‚G±"!+hOqs‚Z

¬f¦

osr¢o8g3vymQopqsh*mQo<´

¬

hMt*hZ

p°†ose*g3hZM€h½qsh*‹‚*qr~}Gh¼vymQo

¬

mfh½‹fqp‚OtuƒŒu|vymÍ

¬Î

prymQophU‹v

¬ q ¬

mfh

¬

opu

¦

uƒsr¢opu|vym€zr~mz

¬ m tvGmQoph«osh

t ¦u|mfuƒ´ ¬ hy±

#1Ô ŸOž Ò £$ ž3¤ Œ°ŒopeZgYh»€h»qphZ‹]‚Zqsry}yh‚ ¦hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmf‚osu|´ ¬ hG{y‹fqs‚Zt*u|pu|vym¯€¬ m>p°†ose*g3h ¬z¦osqsrGŒvGmz i%<±

(6)

C D

!-(=>

c,dzqphZhxn€uwg3hZmzŒu|vym]r ¦FEiG ¬f¦osqsrGŒv ¬ mz€(uƒ,–hZtvGg3uwmf}‹]vG‹ ¬f¦r~qr~m]€Mpvyg3h»t*vyg3g3h*qtuƒr ¦ Œ°Œoph*g($dzrG€

r ¦qshZrG€°½ry‹f‹]hOr~qshZ€'u|mÉdfvGp‹fuwosr ¦HE8IJ$KG;± ! ¦rysŒuƒt*r ¦ — ¬f¦osqsrGŒv ¬ mz€'uƒ<tvGg3gYvGm ¦° ¬ phZ€'­®vGq<t ¦u|mfu|tZr ¦

h*«fr~g(–hZtZr ¬ ph,uo"mfvymx\u|mQ²¢rGŒu|²yh+mzr¢o ¬ qphG{¢uo-qphOr ¦ opu|g3h,tZr~‹zry–fu¦uwo†°r~mz€<uo-qph ¦r~opu|²yh ¦°8tdfhOr~‹t*vGŒo"vy­

rGt*´ ¬ uƒŒuwopu|vym±Šc,dfh<‹ ¬ qp‹vGphv~­Aosdfqsh*hxn€u|g3h*mzpuwvGmzr ¦¬f¦opqrypv ¬ mz€uƒŠosv>€uƒpgYuƒsopdzh<g(r~u|m½€qrC¨–zryt·

vy­Šopqry€fuosuwvGmzr ¦ o†¨+vyx\€fuwg3h*m]Œu|vymzr ¦ ¬f¦opqrypv ¬ mz€ªu|g3ry}yu|mf}½¨dzu|td u|YuwosY¨+hOr~·ªt*ry‹zr~–zu¦uo†°Ævy­ˆu|s¬ uwmz}

´ ¬ rymQopuwosr¢osuw²GhrGt*t ¬ qsr~ophg3vyqs‹fdfvyg3h*opqsu|t>uwmf­®vyqsg3r~opu|vymȱͶ ¬ qŒosdfh*qsg3vyqshy{ i% ¬f¦opqrypv ¬ m]€ª­Úryt*u¦uwosr¢oshZ

h*«oph*m]Œu|²yh˜u|mQ²GhZŒopu|}Gr~opu|vym>rymz€r ¦|¦v¢¨Š,rytZt ¬ qr¢osh³g3hOry ¬ qphZg3h*mQos,vy­vyqs}GrymM²Gv ¦|¬ g3hZ E8I™* K

”‹]r¢opuƒr ¦A¦vt*r ¦u|§*hZqs»‹fqsv¢²u|€hopdzh(‹]vQŒuwopu|vymz8rymz€½opdfh3vyqsu|h*mQosr~opu|vymz»v~­,r ŒhZmzŒvGq˜¨uosd'qsh*}Qr~q€ opv

r'osqsrymzpgYuwoŒosh*qO±_c,dfhOŒh“Œ°Œoph*g(¯ryqph ²Gh*qs°

¬

phZ€u|mr

¬

}GgYhZmQophZ€vGq¯²uwqpo

¬ r ¦

qshZr

¦

uwo†°y{,uwmÍ

¬

qs}yuƒt*r

¦

ry‹f‹

¦

u|tZr¢osuwvGmzŠr~m]€r

¦

pv(u|mUiŽqshZt*vymzŒopq

¬

t;osuwvGm v~­-uwg(r~}GhZZ± knm ­®qsh*h*xKdzrymz€ i

¬f¦

osqsrGŒv

¬

mz€u|g3ry}yu|mf}z{

p‹zr~opuƒr ¦A¦vtZr ¦uw§Zh*q8uƒ8g3v ¬ mQoshZ€'vym'opdzhMptZr~m'‹fqsvy–h¯r~mz€'uƒ ¬ phZ€“opv¼·mfv¢¨1opdfh¯‹vGpuwopu|vymzrymz€“opdfh

vGqpu|h*mQor¢opu|vym] vy­osdfh¸+x\st*rymz$¨uosd>qshZp‹]hOt;oosvosdfhLf«hZ€Mopqr~m]Œg3uwoŒophZqZ±NMŠ­oph*qŠopdfhtZr ¦uw–fqr¢osuwvGm>ŒophZ‹

vy­AopdfhYi ¬f¦opqrypv ¬ mz€¼p°†osh*g {]opdfuƒˆ·mfv¢¨ ¦h*}Q€h8‹h*qsgYuwosˆopv>qphOtvGmz†osq ¬ t;o³r(²Gv ¦|¬ g3h¨uwopdUosdfhpho

vy­³¸+x\st*rymzZ±Æc,dzu|­®qr~g3h*¨$vyqs·“hZmztvGg3‹zrysŒhOv ¬ qYŒo ¬ €°Év~­»Œ‹zr~opuƒr ¦$¦vtZr ¦uw§Zh*q*±Æ‡Wr~qsu|v ¬ YŒ‹]r¢opuƒr ¦

¦vt*r ¦u|§*hZqs,r~qsh ¬ ŒhO€uwm¼iˆx6O³”Muwg(r~}Guwmz}z{­®v ¬ qv~­"opdfh8g(r~u|m ¬ ŒhO€ Œ°Œoph*g(ryqphYµ

œ3£ Ô "ž*Ÿ,Pڣƞ ÐRQ ž Ô   c,dzu|8p°†osh*g ¬ phZ˜pv ¬ mz€“–fqsvGrG€ft*rG†osuwmf}>†or¢opu|vym]»rymz€“gYuƒtqsvy‹zdfvymfhO EI™G™ KG;±

c,dzh>‹fqsu|mztu|‹ ¦hMuƒ–]ryphZ€ªvGmÉopdzh>g3hZrG ¬ qph>v~­Šosdfh>‹zqpvG‹zr~}Qr¢opu|vym'osuwg3h v~­³pv ¬ mz€Épuw}Gmzr ¦ {A·mfv¢¨uwmz}

osdfh8‹fqsvy‹zry}Gr~opu|vymMp‹]hZhZ€>uwmosdfhr~u|qZ±Ac,dfh˜‹fqsvy– ¦hZg3t*vymzt*h*qsm¯osdfh8²¢r~qsu|r~opu|vymMvy­"‹zqpvG‹zr~}Qr¢opu|vym>Œ‹h*hO€

vy­,opdfh Œu|}ym]r ¦ u|mªopdzh>r~u|q E€ ¬ hMopv½²¢ryqpuƒr¢osuwvGmz8v~­osh*g3‹h*qr¢o ¬ qphG{"‹zqphOp ¬ qsh¯r~mz€ªd ¬ g3uƒ€uwo†°@G{Wr~mz€ªr

‹vGspuw– ¦h>t ¬ o(v~­Šosdfh Œu|}ymzr ¦ ¨dfh*mËopdfh ¦u|mfh –ho†¨$h*h*m –fqsvGry€zt*ryŒopu|mf}UŒosr~opu|vym rymz€Ég3uƒtqsvy‹fdzvymfh>u|

– ¦vt·yhO€¹±

#1Ð

£?S"¡

Q

PÚ£y¡ $A¡ 

c,dfh³‹fqsvy–hu|5Lf«hZ€¯r~oWopdfhˆh*mz€(vy­Èr8g3hZtdzrymfu|tZr

¦

ryqpg E8I

™?T

K

G{yosd

¬

Wg3hZrG

¬

qshZ

ryqph$mfvyoA€fu|Œo ¬ qs–hZ€Y–°˜opdfhhZmQ²u|qpvGmfg3h*mQoZ±"c,dfhtvGmz†osqsryuwmQou|g3‹]vQŒhO€<–°<r»qsuw}Gu|€<g3hZtdzrymfu|tZr ¦ €hZ²Quƒth

g(rC° tvGgY‹ ¦uƒt*r~oph<st*rymfmfu|mf}¯v~­ pvyg3h<Œopq ¬ to ¬ qshZZ±VUŠv¢¨$h*²Gh*qO{fopdzh<‹fqsvy– ¦h*gqshZ ¬f¦o­®qsvyg4opdfhopqry€fh

v'WU–]h*o†¨+hZh*m­®qsh*hZ€fvygvy­g3v¢²yhZgYhZmQorymz€>‹fqphOtuƒŒu|vym±

X%YŸ,PÚ£G¡ $ˆž ÐZQ ž Ô   k\o»uƒ³opdfh(sr~g3h<‹zqpu|mztu|‹ ¦hYrG˜rytv ¬ Œopuƒt<€hZ²QuƒthY– ¬ o ¬ pu|mf}>vG‹opuƒt*r ¦ ph*m]ŒvGqs E8I’f{

z{W™Z’ KG;±(c,dfhZqph3uƒ8mfv u|mGosh*qp­®h*qsh*mzt*h¨uwopd'osdfh(h*m²uwqsvymzgYhZmQoZ±3¶ ¬ qpopdfhZqpg3vGqphG{¹–Q°½‹ ¦rGtu|mf} ‹fqsvy‹h*q ¦°

€fu|Œopqsuw– ¬ ophO€¼g(r~qs·yh*q³vym¼osdfhY‹fqpvG–]hG{rymz€½rG€f€u|mf}MtZr~g3h*qryZ{]¨$htZr~mUh*«‹]hOt;oˆosv>h ¦u|g3uwm]r¢oph<opdfh ¦uwmfh

vy­"puw}GdQo,‹zqpvG– ¦hZg ±Wc,dfu|$o†°‹h8v~­-Œ°Œoph*g4vWIh*q,r3²yh*qs°(}yvv€>‹fqphOtuƒŒu|vym>– ¬ oˆuƒ,²yhZqp°¯t ¬ g<–h*qpvyg3hy±

[ $Ð £yŸ*  Ô Ë¡2\ Q"Ð Ÿ]Pa£ž ÐZQ ž Ô   c,dfuƒ³p°†osh*g tvym]Œuƒ†oŠvy­Ao†¨+v¯h ¦hZg3h*mQos<µ,r>ŒhZmzpvyqŠ‹ ¦ryt*hZ€ vGm¼opdfh

‹zqpvG–]hrymz€ rYopqr~mzpg3uopoph*qO±^O³Œu|mf}3opdzhg(r~}ymzhopuƒt_Lzh ¦€¼t*qphOr¢ophO€M–°Mopdfh8osqsrymzpgYuwoŒosh*qosv¯€hosh*qsg3uwmfh

p‹zr~opuƒr ¦ ‹]vQŒuwopu|vym]r~mz€Mopdfh˜vGqpu|h*mQosr~opu|vymz$vy­opdzh»‹zqpvG–]hG{opdfuƒŒ°ŒophZgu|ph*m]Œuwopu|²yh»opv3g3hor ¦|¦uƒt»h*m²ux

qsvymzgYhZmQoZ±`UŠv¢¨$h*²Gh*qO{opdfuƒo†°‹h<v~­Wp‹zr¢osu|r ¦È¦vtZr ¦uw§Zh*qŠuƒŠ²Gh*qs°>puwg3‹ ¦h8osv ¬ ph<r~mz€¼€fvQhOŠmfvyo³€uƒ†o ¬ qs–

osdfhYg3rymfu|‹ ¬f¦r¢opu|vym½v~­Wosdfh‹zqpvG–]hG±M ¦v~o³vy­WophOr~g( ¬ ŒhYh ¦hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmfhosu|t<ŒhZmzŒvGqZµ I— K{ I› K{ IT K { IaK{

I™O— K{ I™ J$K { I—~‘ K±

ØØÞ$b2ccde

(7)

c,dfhYh ¦hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmfhosu|t<€h*²uƒthZ³‹fqsv¢²u|€hYr(©zh*«uw– ¦h3r~mz€ ¦v¢¨,x\‹fqpuƒthO€¼Œv ¦w¬ opu|vymȱ¼vGqphZv¢²yh*qO{]t*vymx

osqsryqp°˜osv˜opdfhvyopdfhZqsAp°†osh*g(Z{ ¥ „$º Eh ¦hZt;osqpvGg(r~}ymzhopuƒt+‹]vQŒuwopu|vym(r~m]€<vGqpu|h*mQosr~opu|vymYg3hZry¬ qsh*g3h*mQoG

€fh*²u|t*hZ+dzrC²yh»r<}GqphOr¢o+­®qphZhZ€vGg vy­g3v¢²yhZgYhZmQoZ±Ac,dfh»vym ¦°(tvym]†osqsryuwmQo+uƒ+opvYh*mz ¬ qshˆosdzr¢o$opdzh»ph*mzpvyq

¦u|hZ¨uwopdfu|mUr¯t*h*qposr~u|m qsrymf}yh˜qsh ¦r¢osuw²Gh³osv(opdzh8opqr~mzpg3uopophZq Ery–]v ¬ oÊ* G;±$knmz€hZhZ€¹{]gYhOtdzr~mzu|tZr ¦ ryqpg

d]ry ¦uwg3uwophZ€ g3v¢²Gh*g3h*mQoZ{vG‹opuƒt*r ¦ r~mz€ rGtv ¬ †osu|t˜€hZ²QuƒthO,dzrC²yh»osdfh ¦u|mfh8v~­AŒu|}ydQo»‹fqsvy– ¦h*gõ-opdfhZqph

g ¬ Œo˜mzv~o˜–]h¯rymQ°¼vtZt ¦|¬ Œu|vym'€ ¬ qsuwmz}Mosdfh3h«fr~g ±M$o˜osdfu|»osuwg3hG{ ¥ „$º€hZ²QuƒthO˜ŒhZh*g osv>–h3opdfh

g3vQ†oŠr~‹z‹fqpvG‹fqsu|r~ophZ€>Œv ¦w¬ opu|vym>­®vyqqsv ¬ osuwmfh8ry‹f‹ ¦u|tZr¢opu|vym],uwm dfvQŒ‹fuwosr ¦±

=

$

M ¥ „$º €h*²uƒthu|˜tvGg3‹]vQŒhO€¼v~­ rMopqr~mzpg3uopophZqZ{Ir>ph*m]ŒvGq³r~m]€Ur~m“h ¦hZt;osqpvGmfuƒttvGmGosqpv ¦w¦h*q³¨dfuƒtd

g(rymzr~}GhZ-osdfh³t*vymfmfhOt;osuwvGm(–]h*o†¨+hZh*m3opdzh³p°ŒophZg vy­ ¦vtZr ¦uw§Or¢opu|vym(rymz€3opdzhˆ¨$vyqs·Œosr~opu|vymȱc,dfhŠosqsrymz†x

g3uwoŒosh*qr~m]€“ph*mzpvyq8t*vymQosryuwm½opdfqsh*h3vyqpopdzvy}yvGmzr ¦ tvGu¦Z±c,dfh3osqsrymzŒg3uwoŒosh*q8tvGu¦˜}yhZmfh*qr¢oshopdzqphZhYvGqŒx

osdfvy}Gvymzr ¦ g(r~}Gmfhosu|tL]h ¦€f*{]¨dfuƒtdUuwm]€ ¬ thOŠh ¦hOt;opqsuƒt*r ¦ t ¬ qsqphZmQosu|m¼opdzhph*mzpvyqŠt*vyu¦Z±Šc,dfhqsh ¦r¢osuw²Gh

­®vGqst*hZ"v~­Iu|mz€ ¬ t*hZ€3t ¬ qsqsh*mQosAryqph ¬ phZ€<opvtZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢osh+osdfh‹vGpuosuwvGm3rymz€<opdfhvGqpu|h*mQosr~opu|vymYv~­]opdfhŠph*mzpvyq

¨uwopd qshZp‹]hOt;o,opv3osdfh˜opqr~m]Œg3uwoŒophZqZ±

c,dfhZqphr~qsh(o†¨$vUo†°‹]hO<vy­ˆ€h*²uƒthOMµ M ! €hZ²u|t*hZYr~mz€ª‹ ¬f¦phZ€x ! €hZ²QuƒthO*±'c,dfh>€fuWIh*qsh*mzt*hZ

qshZ ¬f¦o v~­¹osdfhˆ¨,rC°osdzr¢o$dfv¢¨6g(r~}ymzhopuƒtLzh ¦€z r~qshŠ}Gh*mfhZqsr~ophZ€3rymz€¯€h*ophZtophO€¹±A¸ ¬ oZ{QopdfhOŒhŠo†¨+v8o†°‹hZ

vy­"€hZ²u|t*hZr~qsh˜²yhZqp°Mph*m]Œuwopu|²yh»opv3u|mQoph*qp­®h*qsh*m]thZ,¨uwopd g3hor

¦

{fŒv

¬

qthZ,vy­g(r~}Gmfhosu|t»qry€uƒr¢osuwvGmz

¦

u|·yh

g3vGmfuosvyqvGq

¬z¦

osqsrGŒvGmfvy}Gqsry‹fdȱ

c,dfh³‹fqshZtuƒpuwvGm(v~­p‹zr¢osu|r

¦z¦

vtZr

¦

uw§Zh*q rWhOt;o+€u|qshZt;o

¦

°opdzhˆ‹fqshZt*u|puwvGm(v~­Èu|g(r~}yhOWqsh*}Gu|Œopqr¢osuwvGmY€

¬

qŒx

u|mf}opdfh˜i qshZt*vymzŒopq ¬ t;osuwvGmMŒoph*‹{fr~mz€¯opdfhZqph*­®vyqshˆ–hZtvGg3hZ,r²Gh*qs°3pu|}ymfu L]t*rymQo+­ÚrGt;opvGq ­®vGqryt*t ¬ qryt°

vy­osdfhi ¬z¦osqsrGŒv ¬ mz€Œ°Œoph*g ±

c,dfh ¥ „$ºÃ€h*²uƒthZ+ŒhZmzpuosuw²uwo†°osvu|mGosh*qp­®h*qsh*mzt*hŠu|m>thZqŒor~u|m(h*m²uwqsvymzgYhZmQosAdzrG ¦hZ€(opv<tZr ¬ osuwvGm

u|mUosdfh*u|q8rytZth*‹fosr~m]th­®vGq ¬ ŒhYuwm't ¦uwmzu|tZr ¦ O³”½r~‹f‹ ¦uƒt*r¢osuwvGmzZ±˜¶zvyq»uwm]†or~mzt*hy{¹g3hor ¦|¦uƒt<–hZ€z ¬ ŒhO€Uu|m

dzvGp‹fuor ¦W‹fqsv¢²yvG·yh€uƒ†osvyqpopu|vymz v~­¹g(r~}Gmfhosu|tVLzh ¦€f+‹fqpv€ ¬ thZ€3–°Yopdzh³p°ŒophZg vy­ ¦vtZr¢opu|vym{Qrymz€(t*rym

t*qphOr¢osh³u|g3‹]vGqŒor~mQoŠh*qsqpvGqs+v~­ ¦vtZr ¦uw§Or¢opu|vym E8I™Zi K{ I™O› K

¬ qŒosdfh*qsg3vyqshy{~€ ¬ qpu|mf}˜t ¦uwmfuƒt*r ¦ h«fr~g {¢uwoWu|"mfhOthOpsr~qs°»opv˜vy‹osuwg3u|§*hph*mzpvyq"‹]vQŒuwopu|vymY¨uwopdYqphZ}Gr~q€

osv3opdfh<opqr~mzpg3uopophZqZ±$knmz€hZhZ€¹{zopdfh<€fh*²u|t*h<pdfv ¬f¦€mfv~o³–]h8osvv(­Úr~q­®qsvygopdfhY†o ¬ €u|hZ€ qsh*}GuwvGm E‘f±Á›¢g

osv ™*g { I› K r~m]€ I™ KG+opv(rC²yvGu|€MuwmQosh*qp­®h*qsh*mzt*hZZ{– ¬ oˆr ¦pvosv3–]h˜osdfh8g3vyqsh»‹zqphOtuƒŒh˜ry,‹vGsŒu|– ¦hy±

5 62 “,!-*

! #"$&%

cvg3hZrG ¬ qphosdfh ¥ „$º €hZ²u|t*hŠ‹fqshZtuƒpuwvGm¼{Q¨$hŠdzrC²Gh ¬ phZ€(r‰Š‘~„ J M­®g(rqsvy–v~o(',¨dfuƒtd¯¨,ryWry– ¦h

osv3–]h ¬ phZ€ry,qsh­®hZqphZmzth»­®vGqgYhOry ¬ qshZZ±k\oŠ†or¢osu|t»qshZpv ¦|¬ opu|vymu|¾z¿wÊZÂ>Â'{r~mz€uwosŒosr~opuƒt8ryt*t ¬ qryt°

uƒ¾z¿Ì~Â>Â'±(c,dfhLz} ¬ qph E ™?G˜Œdzv¢¨Š»opdfh(hZmQ²u|qpvGmfg3h*mQosr ¦ tvGmz€uwopu|vymz˜vy­$v ¬ q8h«‹h*qsuwg3h*mQo*± Oˆm ¦u|·yh

I™ K{¹g3hZry¬ qshZ»tv ¬f¦€U–]hosry·yh*m½uwmÆr ¦r~qs}yh¨$vyqs·Œ‹]rythG±˜º³mfh3t*rym½ ¬ ‹f‹vGph<osdzr¢o»opdfhOŒh3tvGmz€uwopu|vymz

ryqph8t ¦vQŒh»opv¯t ¦u|mfuƒt*r ¦ tvGmz€uwopu|vymzZ{h*²Gh*m ¨+vGqsph»¨uosd¼qphZ}Gr~q€f+opdzh8‹]vQppuw– ¦h8g(r~}Gmfhosu|t»u|mQoph*qp­®h*qsh*m]thZ

)+*

äaä-,/.0102,~á†âaã-3546!7Þ87æ539354:wâ;0<72:>=7?4â-31@A3äaã

×®ê"ØÈ×Û

(8)

¶u|}

¬

qph3™yµW‰Švy–v~opuƒt˜r~mz€ ¼hOtdzr~mfuƒt*r

¦¹¥

m²uwqsvymfg3hZmGovy­opdzh

¥

«‹]hZqpu|g3h*mQosZ±

tZr ¬ phZ€<–°<‹fqshZph*mzt*h+vy­]g3hor ¦ u|mopdfhqsvvyg EgYvGmfuwopvyq-t ¦vGphZ€<opv»opdzhqpvG–]vyo-€v8mzv~oW€uƒ†o ¬ qp– ¥ „$º

g3hOry ¬ qphO"–]hOt*r ¬ Œh+opdfhŠ€fu|Œosrymzth,–ho†¨$h*h*mYg(r~}Gmfhosu|t,ph*mzpvyq-r~mz€g3vymfuwopvGqs-uƒ ¬ ‹f‹h*q-osv3Ê* E8I™O› KG G;±

'hY‹]vQŒuwopu|vymfhO€ opdzhYph*mzpvyq»vym“r¯‹ ¦ryŒopuƒtŒosr ¦·osvMor~·yhuo8rC¨,rC°¯­®qsvyg opdzhg3hor ¦|¦uƒt*r ¦ ryqpg vy­Wopdfh

qsvy–v~oO±³”v]{uwo³uƒ³‹]vQppuw– ¦h<opvMhZ²¢r ¦|¬ r¢osh8opdfhYg(r~mf}Ghosu|tph*m]ŒvGq³rytZt ¬ qryt*°¯­®vGqˆosdfhosdfqphZhosqsrymz ¦r¢osuwvGm

rymz€'opdzh¯opdzqphZh¯qpvyosr~opu|vymzZ±¼cqr~mzpg3uopophZqr~m]€Æh ¦hZt;osqpvGmfuƒt¯tvGmGosqpv ¦w¦h*qr~qsh¯r~qsqsrymf}yhO€½vGmÉr¼¨+vv€hZm

or~– ¦hy{u|mopdfht*h*mQophZqv~­"opdfh8¨$vyqs·uwmz}p‹zryt*hy±

'h˜ophO†oshZ€Mo†¨+v(€u WIh*qsh*mQo ¥ „$º €h*²uƒthO˜µA„"v ¦dzh*g ¬ ¶zryŒopqr~· EM !G8rymz€¯osdfh.MˆsthZmzpuwvGmchZtdx

mzv ¦vy}y°¯¶ ¦vt·¯v~­A¸$uwq€ E„ ¬f¦ŒhO€x !GG±

knm'–]vyopd't*ryphZZ{I¨+hY‹vGpuosuwvGmfhZ€ osdfh(ŒhZmzpvyq»vym½r>‹ ¦ryŒopuƒtŒosr ¦· ¨dfuƒtd½¨,ry³dfvvy·GhZ€ ¬ ‹'vym½opdfh

ryqpgv~­osdfh8qsvy–v~oZ± ¥ rytd Œ°Œoph*g4‹fqsv¢²Quƒ€hO+‹vGpuwopu|vymz,vy­osdfhŒhZmzpvyq,uwmosdfh !$r~qpophOŒuƒr~mtvvyq€u|mzr¢osh

p°†osh*gvy­osdfh˜opqr~m]Œg3uwoŒophZqZ{frymz€Mopdfqsh*h8r~mz} ¦hZ E®¥ ¬f¦hZqpuƒr~mqsh*‹fqshZph*mQosr~opu|vym GW­®vyqˆuo,vyqsuwhZmGor¢osuwvGmȱ

¶zvyq(–v~opd̀hZ²u|t*hZZ{ osvÉtvyg3‹zryqph €u|qphOt;o ¦°ªosdfh ¬ mf‹zqpvthOpphZ€ g3hZrG¬ qshZZ{ ¨$h¼€uƒ€ mzv~o ¬ ph opdfh

g(rym ¬ ­Úryt;o ¬ qsh*qVL ¦ophZqs˜¨dzu|tdÆt*rym“ ¦u|}ydQo ¦°½t*vyqsqphOt;o³g3hOry ¬ qphO*±Y¶fvGqŒo†°¼‹vyu|mQos8r~qshosr~·Gh*m½­®vyq8hZrGtd

g3hOry ¬ qphG±"c,dzh»€uƒŒosr~m]th»–]h*o†¨+hZh*m¯osdfh8ŒhZmzpvyq,r~mz€¯opdfh³opqr~mzpg3uopophZq$uƒ$uwm>–]h*o†¨+hZh*m Ç ¾yÅÂrymz€UÊZ“±

c,dzh ¬ ‹I€fr¢osh<qr¢oph<v~­-opdfhYŒhZmzpvyqˆ€vhOŠmfvyo³²¢r~qs°>€ ¬ qpu|mf}(osdfh<h*«‹h*qsu|gYhZmQosZ±“h ¬ ŒhO€ opdzh<– ¬ u¦o³u|m

€fh­Úr ¬z¦o$qsr~ophyµ+™Z‘Gi˜gYhOry ¬ qsh*g3h*mQos¢phZt*vymz€<­®vyq opdfh»¶ ¦vt·Yv~­È¸$uwq€(r~mz€ ™C—~‘˜g3hZrG¬ qphZgYhZmQos¢phZtvGmz€

­®vGq,opdfh¶]ryŒopqr~·I±

*

äaä-,/.010 6!6!6$4, 3

*

á=Cã 4+31=

*

äaä-,/.010 6!6!6$47ã†á†ÞCãKß3;ÞOÜ|äKá

* 4+31=

ØØÞ$b2ccde

(9)

E G E G

¶"u|} ¬ qsh(—µ E GYµ ³u|Œopqsuw– ¬ opu|vym'v~­$‹]vGuwmQosuwm“opdfh(¨$vyqs·Œ‹]ryth E€u|g3h*mzpuwvGmÆv~­ osdfh3–]vC« µ»Q‘¢«G‘~«fiy‘

Etg G E G<µ ¥ «fr~g3‹ ¦h<vy­+r(osqsr~…†hZt;osvyqs°M}Guw²Gh*mU–°¼r ¥ „,º €hZ²Quƒthuwm½opdfhY¨$vyqs·p‹zrGth Est*r ¦h<u|»u|m

t*g G

c,dfh Lz}

¬

qph¼—

E

Gpdfv¢¨ŠopdfhophO†oshZ€Ë‹]vGuwmQos3€uƒŒopqsuw–

¬

opu|vymËu|mÉosdfh ¨+vGqp·p‹zryt*hy{Ar~m]€Æopdfh Lz}

¬

qsh

—

E

GWpdfv¢¨Š-opdzhŠ‹]vQŒuwopu|vym(vy­¹‹]vGuwmQos g3hZry

¬

qshZ€Y–°osdfh

¥

„,º:€h*²uƒthŠrGt*tvGqs€fuwmf}»osv8opdfhˆopqr¢…†hOt;opvGqp°

‹h*qp­®vyqsg3hZ€>–°(opdfh8qsvy–v~oO±

- "

”osr¢osu|t3qshZpv ¦|¬ osuwvGm“‹h*qsg3uo˜opvUrGpphZs³opdfh(qsh*‹hZr~osr~–zu¦uo†°½v~­,hZrytd'h ¦hZtopqsvyg(r~}Gmfhosu|t3€hZ²u|t*hy±4M³8uo

d]ry³–]hZh*m½sr~uƒ€¼‹fqsh*²u|v ¬  ¦°G{zosdfhY‹]hZqŒ­®vGqpg(r~m]thvy­+Œ‹]r¢opuƒr ¦"¦vtZr ¦uw§Zh*q³u|»tq¬ tuƒr ¦ –hZt*r ¬ ph<uwo»Œopqsvymf} ¦°

€fhophZqpg3u|mfhZŠopdfh3´ ¬ r ¦uwo†°>vy­AopdfhYt*r ¦u|–fqsr~opu|vymUŒophZ‹½r~mz€osdfh3ryt*t ¬ qryt°>v~­Aosdfh<qshZt*vymzŒopq ¬ t;oshZ€ ¬f¦opqr¢x

pv ¬ mz€ ²yv ¦w¬ g3hG±ˆ”vz{ryŠdzuw}GdUryt*t ¬ qryt°>u|ˆqphO´ ¬ uwqshZ€­®vGq`Lzmzr ¦ qshZ¬f¦osZ{zuwo³uƒŠmfhOthOpsr~qs°¯osv¯hZŒopu|g(r¢oph

osdfhrytZt ¬ qryt*°3v~­-hZrytd p‹zr¢osu|r ¦¹¦vt*r ¦u|§*hZqZ±

ŸO¡Ÿ]Pa£

ž Ô $Ÿ]P

Ô Q

”osr¢osu|tŠqphOŒv ¦w¬ osuwvGmuƒW}Guw²Gh*mY–°<osdfhˆrC²yhZqsry}yh$h*qsqpvGq-v~­Iopdfh³€h*²uƒth,­®vyq+r8}yu|²yhZm‹vyu|mQoZ±-k\o uƒ t*r ¦t ¬f¦r¢ophO€

¨uwopd¼rY‹vyu|mGoˆphoO{­®vyq²¢r~qsu|v ¬ ,‹vGpuosuwvGmzr~m]€>€u WIh*qsh*mQoŠvyqsuwhZmQosr¢osuwvGmzZ±

'h opvvy·É­®vyq(hZrGtdËoshZŒophO€Ë‹vyu|mQoMr~–v ¬ o3­®vyqpo†°Ég3hZrG ¬ qphO*±6¶fvGq(hZrytd6sr~g3‹ ¦hy{WosdfhUŒosr~m]€fr~q€

€fh*²u|r~opu|vym¼uƒ³tZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢oshZ€­®vGqŠopdzh<osdfqphZh<r¢«hO*±Šk\o»}yu|²yhO ¬ ³uwmf­®vyqsg3r~opu|vymUry–]v ¬ oŠopdzhYp°†osh*g r~–fu¦uwo†°

osv3qphZ‹fqpv€ ¬ th»opdfhsr~g3h˜g3hZrG ¬ qshZZ±

×®ê"ØÈ×Û

(10)

ŸO¡Ÿ]Pa£¼œY£G£ ¢¡f£ Ñ³Ô ž,P®Ÿ,PÔ(Q

c,dzh8‹fqphOtuƒŒu|vymv~­"opdzh<Œ‹]r¢opuƒr ¦¹¦vt*r ¦u|§*hZqu|g3hOry ¬ qphO€M–°Mopdfh<tZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢osuwvGm>vy­-€fu|ŒosrymzthO*±!$r ¦u|–fqr¢osh

g3vyopu|vymzWtZr~m(–h³tZr~qsqpu|hZ€v ¬ o+¨uosd(opdfh³qpvG–]vyo r~mz€(t*vyg3‹zryqphO€¨uwopd3osdfvGphŠvG–osryuwmfhO€3–°<osdfh ¥ „$º

€fh*²u|t*hy±c,dfh*qsh­®vGqphG{Wuo¯uƒY‹]vQppu|– ¦hosvÆtZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢osh€fu|ŒosrymzthO–ho†¨$h*hZmr ¦w¦ osdfh ‹]vGuwmQo3v~­ˆosdfh¼Œh*oZ±

c,d ¬ Z{Qopdfh ¦vt*r¢osuwvGmz+}yu|²yh*m>–°3opdfh»qpvG–]vyo,ryqph»tvGgY‹]r~qshZ€(¨uwopd>opdfh ¦vt*r¢osuwvGmz$t*r ¦t ¬z¦r~ophZ€¯­®qpvGg opdfh

€zr¢osrY}Guw²Gh*m–Q°¯opdfh ¥ „,º&€fh*²u|t*hy±

!" #$ E ™,G

&%'

(

(

) (

(

*(

(

E—'G

¨dfhZqph3µ

± µW€uƒ†or~mzt*h8t*r ¦t ¬z¦r~ophZ€>¨uwopdopdfh€zr¢osrY}Guw²Gh*m–Q°¯opdfh8qsvy–v~oO{

± % µW€u|ŒosrymzthtZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢oshZ€>¨uosdopdfh€fr~osrY}yu|²yhZmM–°¯osdfh ¥ „$º €hZ²u|t*hy{

±,+ h*o.-UµAqph ¦r~opu|²yh»uwm]€h«hZopvYo†¨+v3‹vyu|mQos,u|m r3t*v ¬ ‹ ¦hy{

± (

µ+rC²yhZqsry}yh»v~­"opdfhtvvyq€u|mzr¢oshZ,g3hZrG ¬ qshZ€–°¯osdfh<p°†osh*g­®vGqopdzh‹]vGuwmQo/++vym osdfh xnr¢«uƒ*±

(

102

4365 (

ŸO¡Ÿ]Pa£¼œY£G£ ¢¡f£ Ñ X( ?PÐZQ ŸZ¡Ÿ,PÔ(Q

Mˆqpg qpvyosr¢osuwvGm“tZr~m½–h(h«‹fqshZsphZ€U¨uwopdÆrqpvyosr~opu|vym“ryqpv ¬ mz€Uopdfh3dfh ¦uƒt*r ¦ r¢«u|Z± Ídfh*m“opdfh¯ryqpg vy­

osdfhYqpvG–]vyoˆqphZ²yv ¦²GhZŠryqpv ¬ mz€¼r~m'r¢«uƒˆrytZtvGqs€u|mf}(osv>rym½r~mf} ¦h {¹¨$h<¨,r~mQoˆosvMhZŒopu|g(r¢oshopdzu|˜r~mz} ¦h

¨uwopd½opdfh3g3hZrG ¬ qphOˆvy­ ¥ „$º €h*²uƒthG± uƒ˜t*r ¦t ¬f¦r~ophO€¼–° ¬ Œu|mf}>opqr~mzŒ­®vyqsg(r¢osuwvGm¼¨dfu|td'r ¦|¦v¢¨Š

osv¯‹zrGp,­®qsvyg4opdzh<qsv~osr~opu|vym g(r¢osqpuw«87.opv¯opdfhqpvyosr¢osuwvGm ²yhZtopvGqZ±,c,dfh­®v ¦w¦v¢¨u|mf}3­®vyqsg ¬f¦r3}yu|²yhO ¬ 

osdfh8²¢r ¦|¬ h˜v~­ rytZtvyq€u|mf}opv97 EI™ a$KG;µ

:;=<?>@>@A&BDCFE/G

7 H Ê

À I Ei G

¨dfhZqph3µ

±

EJG

7 . Â 5K5 Â

K

ÂMLKLy±

±J7 ONP

>#AQBRS>#A&BT >@A&BRBUWVDTXBYU4V,Z["BYU4VJR>#A&B\Z >#AQBR]BYU4VDTX>@A&B^Z_`BYU4VJRBUWV,Z

BYU4VJR>#A&BT BYUWVJR]BYU4VDTXBYU4V,Z_`>@A&BR>#A&B\Z BUWVDRBYUWVDTX>#A&B\Z[a>@A&BRBUWV,Z

bBYU4V,T >@A&B\TXBYUWV,Z >#AQB\TX>#AQB^Z cd

¨dzh*qsh

R uƒ,opdfh8qsv~or¢osuwvGm>r~qsv ¬ mz€¯osdfh x\r~«uƒZ{ T r~qsv ¬ mz€¯osdfh x\r~«u|,r~m]€ Z ryqpv ¬ mz€¯opdfh x\r~«uƒZ±

ØØÞ$b2ccde

(11)

‰vyosr~opu|vym –]h*o†¨+hZh*m>o†¨+v¯t*vvyq€uwm]r¢oph˜p°ŒophZg(u|rWhOt;oshZ€–° Lzq†oŠqsv~or¢osuwmf}opdzqpv ¬ }yd Z r~qsv ¬ mz€

osdfh xnr¢«uƒ*{osdfh*mosdfqpv ¬ }yd T r~qsv ¬ m]€(opdzh xnr¢«uƒ*{rymz€ Lzmzr ¦|¦°(opdfqsv ¬ }yd R r~qsv ¬ m]€(opdzh xnr¢«uƒ*±

k\­ BUWV 5

Àf{uoŠ¨$v ¬f¦€>–]h8–hopoph*qŠopv ¬ ph»opdfh˜­®v ¦w¦v¢¨uwmz}Yh*«‹fqphOppu|vym½µ

:;=<?>@BYUWV C Ê

À

 5 L ÂML 5  5  5

Â8L

 L

I ERG

!$r ¦t ¬f¦r~opu|mf}(osdfh<Œosr¢osu|t<ryt*t ¬ qryt°>vyqsuwhZmQosr¢osuwvGm v~­-opdfh ¥ „$º €hZ²u|t*hvym ¦°mfh*hO€fosvMtvGgY‹]r~qsh

osdfhr~mz} ¦h³}Guw²Gh*m–Q°¯opdfh ¥ „,º ¨uosd>osdfhr~mz} ¦h³}Guw²Gh*m–Q°¯opdfh8qsvy–v~oO±

>;

!

ŸO¡Ÿ]Pa£ ž Ô $Ÿ]P Ô Q

¶"u|} ¬ qshZ»i E Gˆrymz€ E Gˆpdfv¢¨1¶]ryŒopqr~·¼r~mz€“¶ ¦vt·¼v~­$¸+u|q€½Œosr¢osu|tqshZpv ¦|¬ opu|vymUqshZ ¬f¦os»vy–fosr~u|mfhO€ ­®vyq

osqsrymz ¦r~opu|vymMu|m«¹{°>r~m]€M§G±

c,dfuƒ$†o ¬ €°3Œdfv¢¨ŠWopdzr~o osdfhˆ¶zrG†osqsry·Yp°†osh*g }yu|²yhŠ ¦u|}ydQo¦°Y–]h*oŒosh*q$qphO ¬f¦osWopdzrymM¶ ¦vt·Yv~­È¸$uwq€¹±

Uˆv¢¨+hZ²yhZqZ{*opdfhOŒh o†¨+vˆ€fh*²u|t*hZ–]hZdzrC²yh ²yh*qs°»¨+h ¦w¦µÈr¢o-r~–v ¬ o5T¢‘Št*g3­®qsvyg opdfh opqr~mzpg3uopophZqZ{¢Œosr~m]€fr~q€

€fh*²u|r~opu|vym¯uƒ ¦hOp+osdzr~m‘f±Á›8g3g ­®vyq+opdzh³‹vGpuosuwvGm>rymz€ ¦hZs+opdzrym>‘f±€fh*}yqsh*hOW­®vGq osdfh˜vyqsuwhZmQosr¢osuwvGmzZ±

‰ŠhZ ¬f¦o,v~­-–]vyopd¼p°ŒophZg(r~qsh³²Gh*qs°MŒu|g3u¦r~qO±

cv(h*²¢r ¦|¬ r~oph»opdfhŒosr~opuƒt»qphOŒv ¦w¬ osuwvGmÈ{¸,r~qsqsr~oŒo `$ E8I™ KG$dzrC²Gh³u|mQopqsv€ ¬ thO€¯osdfht*qpuwophZqpu|vym'µ

[ \ ^ E›'G

¨uwopdƵ

± !Y ^ µAg3hZry ¬ qshZ€M‹]vQŒuwopu|vym ²yhOt;osvyqO{

±

"! Q

µAg3hZr~m‹vGpuosuwvGm>²GhZt;osvyqO±

knmY­ÚrGt;oZ{Gopdzu|Wt*qpuwophZqpu|vymYuƒ ¦hZsAryt*t ¬ qr¢oph$osdzr~m3osdfhvymfhŠ€fhLzmfhO€3uwm¯iz±iz±w™,–hZtZr ¬ ph$opdfhosdfqsh*h‹vGpuosuwvGm

²GhZtopvyq³h ¦h*g3h*mQoˆ}Guw²Gh*mU–°opdfh ¥ „$º €h*²uƒth3r~qsh<r~mzr ¦rC°phZ€>opvG}yh*opdfhZqZ±˜‰h*‹zqpv€ ¬ topu|–fu¦uwo†° h*qsqpvGq

d]rC²yh³opv3–]h˜uƒŒvyopqsvy‹fuƒt³– ¬ oopdzu|,uƒmfvyo,mzhZthOpsr~qs°YopdfhtZryphy±-¶"uw} ¬ qph˜(pdfv¢¨Š+opdfh˜h*²Gv ¦|¬ opu|vymv~­

­®vGqŠr ¦|¦ opdfh˜oshZŒophO€>‹vyu|mQosZ±

œY£G£ ¢¡f£ Ñ

¶"u|} ¬ qsh³›8pdfv¢¨6rytZt ¬ qryt*°rysphZsŒg3h*mQoO±"c,dfhOŒhˆqphO ¬f¦os+r~qshŠ¬ gYg(ryqpuƒŒhO€3uwm¯opdfhˆosr~– ¦h™G±Ac,dfhŠg3hZrym

hZqpqsvyq³r~mz€ osdfh3†or~mz€fryqs€¼€fh*²u|r~opu|vymUryqphYt*r ¦t ¬z¦r~ophZ€­®vGq³²¢ryqpu|v ¬ ³€uƒ†or~mzt*hZ E™Z‘Gtg4opv J ‘yt*g G;±˜¶fvyq

osqsrymz

¦

r~opu|vym–h

¦

v¢¨ Ç ¾yÅ;Â'{~¶zrG†osqsry·8h*qsqpvGquƒ"–]h

¦

v¢¨_Êy¿$# ÇyÇ Â> r~m]€osdfh¶

¦

vt·8v~­I¸+u|q€<hZqpqsvyq"u|"–h

¦

v¢¨

ÊG¿Ç ÊOÀ~Â>Â'±¯knmÉi

¬f¦

osqsrGŒv

¬

mz€'h«fryg3Z{­®vyq²Gv

¦|¬

g3h(gYhOry

¬

qsh*g3h*mQosZ{Èosdfh¯‹fqsvy–h(g3v~osuwvGm'uƒvy­ophZm

×®ê"ØÈ×Û

(12)

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0

0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

axis x axis y axis z

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

axis x axis y axis z

E G E G

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 0.2 0.4

alpha beta gamma

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 0.2 0.4

alpha beta gamma

E G E G

¶"u|} ¬ qsh˜ifµW”Qosr~opuƒtˆqshZpv ¦|¬ osuwvGm¯­®vyq$osdfh»opdfqsh*h˜r¢«hZ EE G,r~mz€ E GG,rymz€MŒosr~opuƒtˆqshZpv ¦|¬ opu|vymM­®vyq,vyqsu|h*mQosr~x

osuwvGmz EE G,r~m]€ E G Gzry–zpt*u|ssr¯µW€uƒ†or~mzt*h³–ho†¨$h*hZmph*m]ŒvGq$rymz€¯osqsrymzpgYuwoŒosh*qO{vyq€uwm]r¢ophYµWŒosr~m]€fr~q€

€fh*²u|r~opu|vym Etg ­®vyq³‹]vQŒuwopu|vym“r~mz€U€fh*}yqsh*h­®vyqˆvGqpu|h*mQor¢opu|vym(G;± E Gˆrymz€ E G;µŠ¶ ¦vt· vy­ ¸+u|q€ E GŠr~m]€

E G»µ]¶zryŒopqr~·I±

ØØÞ$b2ccde

(13)

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0

0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06

E G E G

¶"u|} ¬ qsh¯]µ E E G<r~mz€ E G G(µ ¥ ²¢r ¦w¬ r~opu|vymªvy­opdfh>qphZ‹fqpv€ ¬ t;opu|–fu¦uwo†°'¨uosdªopdfh tqsuwoph*qsu|vym EE G¯µ

¦vt·>vy­-–zuwq€Ur~m]€ E G8µ¶zrG†osqsry·@G ry–zstuƒpsr µ€u|Œosrymzth<–]h*o†¨+hZh*m½ph*mzpvyq³r~mz€osqsrymzŒg3uwoŒosh*q EÅ; G;{

vGqs€fuwmzr~ophYµ EÅ; G;±

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

−0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

−3

−2.5

−2

−1.5

−1

−0.5 0 0.5 1

E G E G

¶"u|} ¬ qsh ›µ MtZt ¬ qryt*°ˆrysphZsŒg3h*mQoO± MŠ–zstuƒpsr˜µÈ€uƒ†or~mzt*hA–]h*o†¨+hZh*mph*mzpvyqÈrymz€³opqr~mzpg3uopophZqZ{Ovyq€u|mzr¢osh

µ opdfhY€u WhZqphZmzth8–ho†¨$h*hZmU€u|Œosrymztht*r ¦t ¬z¦r~ophZ€¨uwopd¼osdfh<€fr~osr3}Guw²Gh*m –°Mosdfhqsvy–v~o³rymz€ €u|Œosrymzth

tZr ¦t ¬f¦r¢oshZ€M¨uosd¯opdzh˜€zr¢osr}yu|²yhZmM–°3opdzh ¥ „$ºÃ€fh*²u|t*h E E G³µW¶ ¦vt·(vy­–fu|qs€>r~mz€ E G³µ-¶]ryŒopqr~·2G;±

×®ê"ØÈ×Û

(14)

c"r~– ¦h¼™Gµ

# """4$(A (A $" A A']) ) !.$" !!@" ! ? /A$ (!

! !@Z

PڞZŸZ¡ Q £ Ð

£%

£

£%

£

£%

£

¶]ryŒopqr~· ¼hOr~m ¥ qsqpvGq x\‘z±‘ZT'T T xn‘f±|™ a ›y— xn‘f±Á—¢ZTy— x\‘z±›y— T xn‘f±’f™G™y™ xs™G±w™O‘y’G›

¦vt·¯v~­-¸+u|q€ ¼hOr~m ¥ qsqpvGq ‘f±‘~ J › ‘z±w™OiG— T ‘f±Á—™Z J ‘z±— J —y› ‘f±Á— a T™ ‘z±›G› T¢

¶]ryŒopqr~·M”Qor~mz€zr~q€³h*²uƒr¢opu|vym ‘f±‘y‘G›y’ ‘z±‘Q›~‘f™ ‘f±|™O—yiy‘ ‘z±—f™*z™ ‘f±Á›y—G› a ‘z±J › T a

¦vt·¯v~­-¸+u|q€”Qor~mz€zr~q€³h*²uƒr¢opu|vym ‘f±‘y‘~ J ‘z±‘z™ a › ‘f±|™?T~iy’ ‘z±w™C› a › ‘f±Á— a ™ J ™G±‘ a  a

–h ¦v¢¨ —~‘vyq+iG‘yt*g±-¶fvGq+‹]r~qpopuƒt ¬f¦r~q$r~‹f‹ ¦uƒt*r¢osuwvGmz ¦u|·yh³tZr~qsv~osu|€3²Gv ¦|¬ g3hŠg3hZry ¬ qsh*g3h*mQoO{yosqsrymz¦r¢osuwvGm

g3vyopu|vymz³r~qsh8–]h ¦v¢¨ ™Z‘Gtg ±¶fvGqŠopqr~m]¦r¢osuwvGm–h ¦v¢¨ ™Z‘Gtg {fosdfh<¶zrG†osqsry·MhZqpqsvyqŠuƒŠ–h ¦v¢¨Ž¾f¿$# # #CÂÂ

rymz€Mopdfh¶ ¦vt·Mv~­A¸+u|q€MhZqpqsvyq$u|Š–]h ¦v¢¨ ¾f¿ Ä Ì~Â>Â'±

PažZ£%žOž]PÔ Q

¬ qsuwmz}Æt ¦u|mfuƒt*r ¦ h*«fr~g(*{ opdfh¼€uƒŒosr~m]th –]h*o†¨+hZh*m opdfh¼ph*mzpvyq(rymz€Éosdfhopqr~mzpg3uopophZq(u|(t*vymQosryuwmfhO€

–ho†¨$h*hZm Ç ¾yÅÂr~mz€ÊZÂ4r~m]€<osdfhŠ‹fqsvy–hg3v~osuwvGm(u|A–h

¦

v¢¨Ì~¾GÅ;“±"c,dfhŠ‹fqshZph*mQo Œo

¬

€f°qshZ

¬f¦

osWpdfv¢¨

osdzr¢oŠh

¦

hOt;osqpvGg3ry}ymfh*opuƒt³p‹zr~opuƒr

¦¹¦

vtZr

¦

uw§Zh*q,t*r~m–h

¬

ŒhO€¯­®vGqqpv

¬

opu|mfh

¬f¦

opqrypv

¬

m]€Mh*«ryg(*±

#" /" " ! +

c"r~– ¦hˆ—fµ

35$2"$/8?")$ZV A$)+$"V 6$ )! !!@" ! B02H 6$ )!_ !!@" !8` 102`5

"#$ $

[ X # Õ

Ð PÚ£

Ð

ŸZ¡Ÿ,PÚ£ ¡f£G£ C¡z£

Ñ

ŸO¡Ÿ]Pa£¡z£y£ ¢¡f£

Ñ

Ô  MŸ* ¢¡ Q ž$a¡Ÿ]PÔ Q Ô   Ô  $P ÐRQ ŸO¡Ÿ]PÔ Q ž

¶zrG†osqsry· Eg(rym ¬ ­Úryt;o ¬ qsh*qG ‘z±T J g3g‰½” ¾f¿|ÊOÌ

¦vt·¯vy­-¸$u|qs€ Eg(rym ¬ ­Úryt;o ¬ qsh*qG ™G±’yg3g‰½” ¾f¿ÁÌ 7"!

¸,r~qsqsr~oŒo `$ EI™ KG ‘z±w™ J g3g$# i a t*g ¾f¿ÁÀ&% Ä' Eqsrymf}yhGµ ¾z¿%QÀ$x+¾z¿% Ä %G

Eph*m]ŒvGqvym>opdfh8‹fqsvy–h,G

¼u¦mzh `$ E8I™Zi KG ™G±’)( ™y±J ( Eqsrymf}yhGµwÊ*sx†À~¾G

„WqshZph*mQo³”Qo ¬ €° ¢¶]ryŒopqr~· ™G±T~iyig3g ‘f±Á›¢

„WqshZph*mQo³”Qo ¬ €° ¢¶-º»¸ ™G±iz™O—<g3g ‘f±Á› a

¸,r~qsqr¢oŒo _$ E8I™ KG˜r~mz€ ¼u¦mfh _ EI™Oi KGˆd]rC²yhYvym ¦°Uh*²¢r ¦w¬ r~ophopdfh(‹h*qp­®vyqsg(r~mzt*hZ»v~­+opdfh

¦vt·vy­¹¸$u|qs€È±knm(osdfuƒ+phZtopu|vymÈ{G¨+hˆt*vyg3‹zryqph,osdfhˆg(r~m ¬ ­ÚrGt;o ¬ qphZqs €fr¢or8¨uosd(opdzhŠqphO¬z¦oWvy–fosr~u|mfhO€

u|m I™ K rymz€ I™Oi K r~mz€>osdfu|ˆt ¬ qsqphZmQo,Œo¬ €f°y±

ØØÞ$b2ccde

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to