INTRODUCTION LES JOURNEES DE L'AAR : L'EPREUVE DE THESE

(1)

HAL Id: hal-02864895

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02864895

Submitted on 23 Jun 2020

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

INTRODUCTION LES JOURNEES DE L’AAR : L’EPREUVE DE THESE

Céline Burger, Camille Mortelette

To cite this version:

Céline Burger, Camille Mortelette. INTRODUCTION LES JOURNEES DE L’AAR : L’EPREUVE DE THESE. 2016. �hal-02864895�

(2)

!"#$%&#%'())*%+%'(",*#-.#%&#%/01

23456789^:;<=4336>9?99^@

?6ABCDEFGHIJFIKLMMNOPQRSTUSVWOXTRYRSZ[XQUSVW\TU]^PQSUQ_Y_WUSYXRPXVSZUST[W`VUXaUSZUSRbcOUS 65de636Afghdge<5di6iA6d36A65A64j5<5di6iAihk6ehk6lei6iAf6AQâUVO^RWOSZ[mVRPÔnSoQâUVO^RW f6p4h<ef46ql36Ar6e566d54s6eA4d2f664=Ak<=t<j56iuef6556vglAAg==6At<ed4Afl wPQORYRSxXUSÙXSZUSRUyÒSZ[WwbYQ_UOSWRYÛQRSYyWQY_WOSYXRPXVSZUSTYSRbWyYR^xXUSZUSTYS z{|}~{{{{65te65<5d65hg=td63<hg=tgA<5d6j2gje<tk466d<=25<j6=65dfl d6ee4dg4e6v95glde6;4364Ad<4dl56sg3g5d2hg==l56f63<t<edf6Afghdge<5di6iA6df6A 65A64j5<5di6iAhk6ehk6lei6iAf6A3<ge<dg4e6Ahg5h6e52Af6A6e<tteghk6e6df6de<s<4336e 65A6=36Alel5teg6dhg==l5vu45f6e<tteghk6e36Afghdge<5di6iA;36teg6df6gle526A Z[WwbYQ_UOSYXRPXVSZUSwURRUSRbWyYR^xXUSUQRVUSTUOfghdge<5di6iA6d36A65A64j5<5di6iAihk6ehk6lei 6iAf6Af42e65dA3<ge<dg4e6Afle2A6<l<2=6ej2vu45A4;36Af6lte6=4e6A2f4d4g5Af6A

PXVQWUOSZUST[mmSOU`RUyVUSSST[oQâUVO^RWSZ[mVRPÔSURSOU`RUyVUSSST[oQâUVO^RWS f664=Ak<=t<j56iuef6556OUSOPQRSORVXwRXVWUOSwPyyUSXQSRUyÒSZ[YwwPy`Y_QUyUQRSURS XQSTÛXSZ[WwbYQ_USYXRPXVSZUSTYS`VPTWyYR^xXUSwUQRVYTUSz{LFHIFIEICEI ¡GF¢FIJC£HIKFI }¤}¥{{{¦{§SÜVRY^QUOSwPyyXQ^wYR^PQOSZWTâVWUOSTPVOSZUSTYSPXVQWUSZ[mVVYOSOPQRS hg336hd26Af<5Ah6te6=46e5l=2egf6ABCDEFGHIJFIKLMMNv6e6hl643hg5Ad4dl6;©te2A65d;l5 Agh36dk2ge4ªl6tglef6teghk<456Ae2364g5A©=656eAleh6dd6dk2=<d4ªl6v

«USwPy^RWSZ[PV_YQÔYR^PQnSwPQOR^RXWS`YVSZUOSZPwRPVYQRUOSZUOSRVPÔSTYPVYRP^VUOS¬mS 4Ahg5d45l4d2A;uee<A9u®<4d6e36>g5f6;u=465A9u®<4d6e;64=A;<e<t4f6=65d wbPÔ^SZ[Y]UVSwUOSPXVQWUOSOXVST[W`VUXaUSZUSRbcOUnSw[UORi©if4e6Ale36Af44hl3d2Ae65hg5de26A t<edgldi6iA6l56Ahk6ehk6lei6iOSÙQZYQRSOPQSZPwRPVYR§S«UOSRbcyUOS`VP`POWOSYXSOU^QSZUST[Y`ÙTS

©hg==l54h<d4g5f63<te6=4e6gle526z{¯}{{°{±}{²}~{{{{³uee<A;

A6td6=e6@´:µ2d<465d¶36·3<fghdge<5di6<h6<l45Ad4dld4g5A¸;¶T[WwPQPy^USZUSRbcOU¸;

¶36d6ee<456d36f4AhgleAAh465d44ªl6¸6d3<¶hg5Adelhd4g5flfghdge<5d;65de6tgAdle66d

¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹¹

:ghd6le6;54s6eA4d2f664=Ak<=t<j56iuef6556;hglee463ºh63456vlej6e»¼<kggvev

@ghdge<QRUnSoQâUVO^RWSZ[mVRPÔnSwPXVVÛTºh<=4336v=ged636dd6»j=<43vhg=v

(3)

!!"## $"%&'(")&*+',"-.//012345.06 7089:;<=072>61?@ABCDE13>

3DC//46@"!+&%"$$*$(,%+FG*+"46@HD3 12346@A1ID7C4@A07DC/I4JK 3LM0N/DCM238D23D0I7^O6MM3NCC D3LDDDNEED6377 7NJ

P7030NDQRSTUVWXYUXZ[\\]X!+&!&$"*' !"+^*("#_ 'F`+"( !!+,a"'("+# /I7Cb3//MNM7/0NM0D3738C>

C3D0037NNCDC70INDDb3ND

#ccde#"fg$"!G"_h+"igjkel#m'Fn"+$FG,(c+G&F$lc++ $o"$ +GF%#"$&'G,G,+,! +GF$"' D3>38236C70I73C13>CD3C 70D//3EEJ

A70I38237308CD230C1pC0I ( !!+,a"'("+#"G"++ F'!&*+#"$)"*'"$%a"+%a"*+EEJALCD3NCN0 0b3DC//677/7CC//3EE1pD78CN023

! +q&F$F' GG"'(*"$"G',%"$$FG"! +%&'$,r*"'G("$F'G"++&s"+$*+# (,_ +%a"r*F#"$

_`'"'G *tG"++ F'$o"$G( '$%"G"$!+FGr*"$F'$%+Fn"'G#"$r* G+"!+,$"'G GF&'$+"G"'*"$

D3823Ju6vwxyzw{|}~xzwzxwz}5u86.0=000

#F("'GFG,(*("#%a"+%a"*+E731C33773>p3JC3 73CI06CC7C23D33@(,G+ 's"+$*+#"G"++ F'"'#F##*$G+ 'G! + N3D0NDD0033N7N7/N1C0DD3>CCEP7C 5CM23=JP/237CCBC//3ED3>776CL3>D

5u86.0=6D3>M837 73L6#&'G _"',l+"'%&'G+"+("$(FqqF%*#G,$( %%`$l#F'q&+_ GF&'r*F!&$"7C3 CM0308CD230C13>78CND301p

# +,$F$G '%"(*G"++ F'o"GG"(FqqF%*#G,("#&! %FG,(*G"++ F'_23NMC0C 7NDvzyz}||}|}5u86.0=6DCL3>7 3C}7C23N3DMNMCu123PC63b F'(F$$&%F h#"("%"#*F("# %%`$"G("#(Fqq*$F&'("#F'q&+0JA r*"$GF&'("#&! %FG,

O K¡u ¡¢6£uKN859:;O=6¤¥¦¥§¨©ª«¬¥©«¬¥©®ª¯«©¨©¥ª§¥ª°¬±²¥ª¥§ª²«¨¥§«¥²ª²³«¨´µ¥²6NDJ

KK6O¶:7J

(4)

!! !"#$%#!&

'()*+,(-+,(.-/(/)*012-34.(56*'1*)+3(5+(7*89:;<9=>?8@ABC9;A*DEF*G1236(-*'(*HI5J(K*FL3(5)MK* 1N-ONO(*(5*NOIN-1P,3(K*PI)(*'1*4.()63I5*J(*'1*J3003+.'6O*J.*6-136(L(56*J.*6(--135*4.15J*'()*

!Q$!7*

*

R#SS/(/)*5I.)*1LT5(*U*.5(*)(+I5J(*-.2-34.(*6-136156*J.*

PI)363I55(L(56*J.VJ(*'1*+,(-+,(.-/(*(6*J(*'1*P-O)(56163I5*J(*)I5*I2W(6*J(*-(+,(-+,(7*X()*J(.Y*

1-63+'()*J(*+(66(*-.2-34.(*P-O)(56(56*J()*6-1Z1.Y*J(*6,T)(*+I5J.36)*)('I5*J()*LIJ1'36O)*

1JL353)6-163Z()*4.3*350'.(56*5O+())13-(L(56*).-*'()*-(+,(-+,()*(6*'(*PI)363I55(L(56*J.*V*J(*'1*

+,(-+,(.-/(7*[@C<\>?];>^<=?DEF*G1236(-*'(*HI5J(K*FL3(5)M_*(5*6,T)(*`abcEK*-(5+I56-(*J()*

P-I2'TL()*J(*PI)363I55(L(56*(56-(*)I5*1+63Z36O*J(*-(+,(-+,(*(6*)I5*1+63Z36O*1.*`I5)(3'* dO5O-1'*J(*'1*eILL(*J.*0136*5I61LL(56*J(*JO+1'1N()*(56-(*'()*6(!

'()*6(LPI-1'36O)*J(*'1*-(+,(-+,(*L13)*1.))3*J()*J3003+.'6O)*'3O()*U*'1*JI.2'(*+1)4.(66(*(LP'IfO(*

J.*`I5)(3'*dO5O-1'*(6*JI+6I-156(7*[9g<\\>?hB;A>\>AA>?DEF*i3)+I5635.36O)K*F--1)MK*1Z(+*)()*

6-1Z1.Y*).-*'1*-(+I5Z(-)3I5*J.*21))35*L353(-*J.*jI-J/k1)/i(/`1'13)K*)I.'3N5(*'()*J3003+.'6O)*

4.(*P(.6*-(5+I56-(-*.5/(*O6.J3156/(*(5*P-(L3T-(*155O(*J(*JI+6I-16*(6*35)3)6(*).-*'1*J3003+.'6O*J(*

!lmSSn*

*

X()*J(.Y*-.2-34.()*-()6(56*3563L(L(56*'3O()*o*+ILL(56*1PP-O,(5J(-*'(*6(--135*)15)*

"*P-IP-(*3J(5636O*(6*+ILL(56*P1-Z(53-*U*.5*PI)363I55(L(56*J15)*'1*-(+,(-+,(*

)15)*4.()63I55(-*)I5*350'.(5+(*).-*'()*-O).'616)*J(*+(66(*J(-53T-(*p**

*

qm r!!rSr !5J3-*+()*4.()63I5)*-('163Z()*1.*PI)363I55(L(56*J.*V*J(*'1*W(.5(*+,(-+,(.-/(*

).-*)I5*6(--135K*U*)1*5O+())13-(*PI)6.-(*J15)*.5*+,1LP*J(*-(+,(-+,(*P1-63+.'3(-*I.*(5+I-(*U*)I5*

-1PPI-6*1.Y*35)636.63I5)*J(*'1*-(+,(-+,(7*F35)3K*(5*)(P6(L2-(*stuvK*w9=xyz@\{=>?|<>}\y

~9=>\:AA<*lr!! "!!l k'.-31'K*P1-61N(136*1Z(+*5I.)*)I5*-1PPI-6*J(*)1'1-3O(*J.*P-3ZO*1Z(+*'()*35)636.63I5)*J(*'1*

-(+,(-+,(*.53Z(-)3613-(*o* ¡¢£¤¥¡¢¦¤

§§¨©ª«§

¬¤¥®7*F.))3K*+ILL(56*P1-Z(53-*U*+I5J.3-(*.5(*-(+,(-+,(*1JI))O(*U*)I5*1+63Z36O*)1'1-3O(*p*

kI.-*[}9;\BAA>?¯B:°B=*DEF*i3)+I5635.36O)K*F--1)MK*WI.-51'3)6(*P(5J156*J3Y*15)*(6*I003+3(-*J(*

%!rQ # I2W(6*J(*-(+,(-+,(*).-*±*" ²%"Q!!

(5)

!"#$"!% &%'$"(!')#*#$%"#%"#"+'$,$#*#$%-./01 2 (#))#"&"345!#$%5"#$"!#3%#*64#"789:";"<44&!="!($%54#!!#"& >"#?45!"(@&6%&6)%5"#"A'$#

BCDEFGHD.

IJCDDKLDMEDNLNDK.IE O' 4$5#!"&"*'%5"(& %&$%"$'%4#"')'$%5"#"+'$%$ #4";",&'4!#4"+#!"5+@&$?#!="!"4&4#!="#$%4#"

DGGKDGGGNNGGDDNLHDFDPQRSTUVWXYQZYQ [\]^YQ_.`10$5#!"'$%"3#4*!")&"+45&%'$"( $"#!3&+#"#"!+ !!'$"' #4%"#%"

aBDDGGKDGGNNGGb"+#!"#4$#4!"$(@5!%&$%"

CDcHaJLJCLC.IDCND L'$"#!"O' 4$5#!"#")(<<d"#!%"34'?4&**5#"3' 4"$'#*64#"789e";")(f$#4!%5"#"

gDhi.

jklmnonpqrllmsltksnumvnpmwlmxyvQzQ{Y^Q[Y|[Y^Q}YQ^~}[QS^Q~UY{{YY}[Q}~U^QYQ\~V|QSQ[Q {SV^^QSX|QZ~[~US}[^QZYQpmvnyvmslmynvkxvnkymnuqryltwpmnkxQZYQ~X}VS[V~}Q~US{YQYQWXVQ Y|{VWXYQ{YXUQ\[U~}V[Q