HAL Id: hal-00077464
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00077464
Submitted on 6 Apr 2007
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Three-dimensional numerical study of natural convection in vertical cylinders partially heated from the side.
D. J. Ma, Daniel Henry, Hamda Ben Hadid
To cite this version:
D. J. Ma, Daniel Henry, Hamda Ben Hadid. Three-dimensional numerical study of natural convection
in vertical cylinders partially heated from the side.. Physics of Fluids, American Institute of Physics,
2005, 17, pp.124101 : 1-12. �10.1063/1.2141430�. �hal-00077464�
!" # $$%&
' ! () ! *(+"#
'! ,-) . !/ -&*,0' !1
!
" # $! %& ' !
" (! %& !)
)
%!*
& + !
"
+ , $!
"( -
- % . /0 !
-
*
1 2 3!
!
4
& " 5 " $
" ) / 3 / /4 5
4 6 )4
7 84 3 94
/: ; 3/ /4 < 3 =
5 ) 5 53 5
3/ 6 84 7 3/ 3 )=
) 3 ) ) )
:/) /43)
/3 /4 ) > 3/ < 4 /=
:/ ) 3 4
?
< 5)
5 5 35 ;
3 ) 94/ 4
33 8/ 35 3 / )
535 4
+ 4 133 8/ )
94 ) /3 6 7 )
/ 5 5 5: / )
)/) 3) > 3/
:/
?
@ 5 / 1 3=/
< 153 48 #)
4 ;
5/ 5 /
: < 4=3 48 '/
)
35 /3 1 35
5 55 ) /
=3 133 8/ 94 < ) 5 =
5 . 3 5 ) 4
; 3 3 / 5 5
4 ) 5
+ 55 =3 53 3
153 :/ 55 #) ) 5
3 + 3 )4 > 3=/
) 4 3 > 4
< 5 6 A /(7 / 3 2 B
4 :1 3 A %%2* 4 :1 /
> C 48 =
) @ ) 3 4
=3 133 8/ 94 D =3 =
3 34 4 =3 5 55/
:)3553/#+=
'3 35 435) =5
: ; 3 < 3 3
, 5 33 3 <
/) / ;945 ; /)
5 <33 > /3 35=
/ !354 153
:/)
E 35 "4 9 : )
)5A 4 / )6
/ *7 =5 55 4/ 153
5
5 3 3 3
435
4 62 2
2F 27 3 / 35
5 4
5 8
15 4/ 5513 8
35 3 A
6* 6
77 4
315 Æ
356
A
7
")=#8 54 / < /3)
5
6 7
5) 4 3
;) "3 35 : A6
76
7 < =
3/)/45513
67 4
ÙA% 6*7
Ù
FÙÙA F
ÙF Þ 627
FÙ A
6,7
4 A 3 83 ) A 6
7
6 7 /3/)Þ)
A% 5)5=1A&%
5) 5 =1 + 1= )4 =
6% 7 = 6&% 7
< 3 4 4@
ÙA% 607
A% A*D 2 *2 2F*2 6$7
A% A% A 6-7
A* A* 2 *2 2F*2 6G7
< 5: > ) : > 35 :
15 + 3 3 5 4 3 35
94 4/ 153
53
53 535: /3 5
< ) /)/ 4 4 ; 3 : )3
553/#+ '3 35
3=55/
< /)/ > / =
< ) 35 ) 65 357
/ 3 E 5= 94 )
4
#+ ' /3
3 3 35 >3
4 3 / 1 4 3
5 4 /
+ )3 Æ 4 )/ 3/
353 < 55133 6 #755 4
4
5 <5#+ ' #
!
< 3 ) 3=5/ :=
; 3 84 =5 3
31 =5 /=H(!8=" /3
) 6*=,7 < 3 > ) 3 =
!8="3 /=H3
)) 3 ; 3 // / 5 =
> < 3 )3 5 <)/
3 3 3 )=
: 35 3533 3 5 4)
) ) /
+ ) >3 ) 1
3 / < /: 3 3 5
I + >3 ! 3 //
35 3 >3 35 )3 Æ
5 5
" # $% %!&$
J / 3 :3 ) : )3
#+ ' 3 : ; 3 94 A 0
A G%% A %%2* < 5 33 94
< 3 ) ) 3 / 4
/ < /) < + /
3133 ) >3 ) 8 /
5 5 3 " 3 6 A %$7 " A
)/ " 3 "A
) 5 5 4
:/ 2 / " 3 4 /) >3
/ A %G$ 6 5 4 " 3 4 /
)7 + 4 3) ) )
3 ; / *K
%
+/3533
>3 35 : )
67A
*
67
2 !
6B7
< % 3 5 133 35 94
3 33 35 < ) ; 3
/ 3 / 94 8 / >3
3 @
" 67 A
Ù67
## 6&7
"
< 94 ) 5 3 6:1 /
/75 4 /313394
> / /3 6 / ,677 )) )1 :
> 3 5 3 ) 48 +
555 9 34 : 4 4
593)3 3/36 /
,677 9 3 1 4
3 / /
4 ) 94443
94 4813355 5)4 5=
/ 5 ) ; 5 3 6: >=
34)3741338/ 22BG
3 3 4 A2 2BG2&
3 4 A* 2& B 3 4 A * < =
3 3 5 3
/ 4 3 / 5 /=
// 55 5 4 9 :
E 5 4/ )5 =3 4 )
=3 =
; / 5 E: /) 5 5 4
3555>3 /
5354 3 153 #)
"=3=5 ) 53 /
5)) )133=8/
< 35 6
7 8 55 6
7
/
94 / 5 5 !/ 5
94
) 135 5 A2 /)
)
A 2%%% 3 5
/ 3 A 2*%% 0- ) 4 )
) 0$, 3 94
/ 35 53 + 4
/ =133 3 A 2 3 4 5
5 3 ) + /
8 /"
) =>) 3 )35
/ 15 4 3 4 3 ) >
35
<945/333 A%3
9 A 2 8 4= 4 94 // 4 1
// 5 5 4 > 55 / ) 4
6 / 07 < 94 )/ 4) 5/
4= 1 33 55 A2
3 3 5 )/ 4) 5
94
35 635 7 )
) 2G 2& 3 3 3
5313394
94 94 // 3 A 2 62G 2BG7
3 A* 62BG2&7 33 :
94 5 )
// A * 3 5 4
:335 / $/)/3
133 8/ 5 A2& +/ /3
313394545)
A2,G$6/)
/= / $7
944 4 A*6C / $7 "44
/3 9444 A2%$%
/332 4 $ )
/*G0% *B-% < L3533
* < 94 5 * 2 3 94
5 ; ) / A* 35 A%
3 944 3 33
*133
A*,*%6= / $7 <)
4 1333 ) 4/ 35
/) ++ 4 2G 2& 3 ) 4 4
3 4 < 1 35
; ) 3 4 4
4 3 ) 5 3
< 354
55 3 33 )) 5 @
3 94 /=
: 55 5 94 35/
: 45
133=8/58=
) 5 2&
A*3 <=333) 53
/ ) , < =3 94 5
3 3 3 35
4 / -=& A0 AB
/5 6AB4 A0%%7 4 / -
94 55 55 4 1/
94 > < 94
5 /) 5 4 ) //
5 / - 3 94 5 5 A % <
3 94 5 5 33 94 // 58
< 5 33 94 35
1339433353 6 / G7 <34
3133 35 A * 3 4 4
) 3336 / G7 555
4 94 : 3 4 4
5 ) / 3
) A * 5 35 3 35 )
3 3 /) ) 5
3 553/ 6 / -6774
4 3 6 3 35;
= A%2$ %%%* 4 3 %%2 A%&7
3 5 6 A 0 4 A G%%7 4 / B
133 94 ) 55
) 3 3 / 5 33 3
35 6 / &7 1 4 4 < 3 4 3133
35 A*3)355
15 4 3 !/ 35 5
33 3 A * 6 / &677 5 55 5
3133 4 4=3 / 4 5 3 38
>3) +333
133=8/ A0
4 ) 133=8/ / 5
3 3 : 55
5 6 2F*27 4 4 35/
53 4 /=
3 4 4 > 55 5 6 5/ 5
A 2 *27 5
** 3
/= 3 A*
)
/= ) / )
5 ! #
!
+ 55
3 A* / 5 6/ ) 7 4 4
/) ) 34 Æ 1 5
55 !
3 4 /)
+++ < 35 4 )
A26 347 /3
6
A27A0G*2$4
/ ) 4 4
6 A$7 A0G, 6) 1 3 ) 7
5 3 + /= 3
) 3 637 ) /5 6$7
4 35 ; 55 /=
3/ 8 / < 4 / 5
55 5 : > /=
4 3 5 3 / 3 >
+% #
+ 5 33 5 133=
8/ ; 5 4 > 8 /
; 5 4 15
3 6Ú
7 5 6Ú
7 E )
15/ / 8 / #%# 4 /) @
#%
# A
#
#
*
2 Ú
Ú
#MA
Ú
6Ú
Ú
7#M
6Ú
7
#MF
&
#M
A
&
&
&
F&
&
&
F&
&
&
F&
&
&
F
&
&
&
#M
6Ú
7
#MF
&
#M
A%
F%
F%
A%
F%
F%
F% F%
F%
F%
6*%7
+ 8 / %
%
5 5 8 /
3 94 5) %
) 5 58 /
! " "
<> 3 133 33
4 35 133
35 6 A %7 3 4 3=
5 6Ú
7 5 6Ú
7 5) /
< /) 4 5//
5 6AB7 3 5 6A07
/ 5 A B 133 94 4
3394
,B% <13394 3
94 5 / ,67 A,%% 4/ :
555 / *%67/)3>358/
3 >/ 3 3 4 < 3
3 94 ) 48 15 %
6 / )
)74 5 *%K 4 /)/ /
>/ :3
3 < )
3 4 >/ 3
%
3 5 A 0 133 94 4
3394
-G% <13394 3
945 / ,67 A-%% 4/ 1 )
4) <3>358//)
/ *%67 E 3 %
%
4 >/
= ) 5 3 3/ 3 %
3 4 / >/ %
) / 3
%
38
3 >/ 3
3 ; ) 9 )53
5 < 15 4
3 3 /=
3 33 5 133 8/
33 3 ;
: 555 5 3 5
3 3 35 )53
! "
+
353) 3 94
8 / 6*%7 5 =
8/ 94 A2*%% ) L )
2%%%
/ ** /) 8 / 9 + 3 :/
5 9/ 8 / %
394 3
>/33/35%
<:3
3 3/ 3
/3 %
%
5 /
3)>/4%
% 15
1 >/ 5 4
,! ) $ #$!
'153 ) ) 5
3 ) #)
< /) ;
5 5 AB A0 AB 3 :
133=8/
$*%
*,*% < /) 35 3 4
A ***% 633 7 A *0$% 6 7
A 0 3 3 133 94
3394
A*0*% /) 35
A 2%,% E 5 4 3 35 4 3 3
153
"$
C 334 )/3 4 153
AB@ 5 133=8/
A,B%
5 5
A B*% ")
)4153)) 3))
/)
A *0$% 4 153 < 5
94 3 2- 6=33
4 A%&$$*%
' A*-%*%
'
(/3,G Æ
!75/
*$ < ) 153 5 4 /)
*%
/ *267 4 3 ) 35 / 5
4 6 A %&%*B%2G% 4 A % A A % 4
/ A%BG$ A%*2$7 15335
4 5 6 A%*2$7 3 3
5556A%BG$7 <35&%2G% 4/
35 *B% 5 3 35
; 3 A %BG$ 6 %2 4 35 35
) A% *B% 7 / 6 %*7 153
/ *, 4 1 ) 94 = A %BG$
3/ 5 3 54 555
9 / 3) 5 5 6 *B% /7 94 4
/ 5 6 % /7 < / 94 5 ))
//
A ,B% + /3 63
A ,B%
A B*%7
= 94 9 33 4 5 5 3 94
6 5 A% 5 / *,7 < /) / *,
33 3 ) /3 6 8
55
7335)4
55 + 55 8==
)) 555
39456/4))7 </3535
) &% 2G% / 4 15
; > 4 / >3 35/
A ***% 4 ) 3
A B*% 4
35 94 5 3 A *0$% 4
4 8== 55
/ *267 4 35 ; =
A %BG$ A ***% 3 A *0$% 3
/ 3 ))/ 35 : 3 94 <
35 ) 3 35 5
/,-5/2* <;4 3
153 3 4 33
"5
A 0 153 ; 3 3 /)
3 133 94 94
A *0*%
4 3 /): 58313394
3394
A-G%
94
A *-,% 35 4
94 3 351 )
A *-,% ) 4
: 55 A *B,% 3 )
3 8== 3 A B 4
; 3 153 4/ 5 )/
4) 4 / 94 5 1 35 4 )
3 A 2%%% ) A 2%,% 4 153
35 /)
/ *04 3 ) 35/544
/ 6 A %G$ A %2$7 < 35 ; /) =
3 4 5 6 A%2$7 55 5
6 A %G$7 35 / 3 4 5
; 3 + /) = 35
3335;6135%%%B35%0$
<3 5 94 3*06
/ *07 5/B ) 15354
/) *% " 5 A% *B%
A&% 2G% 33
5A%64) AB7 < 1)
/) / *$ :3 94 48
3 ; 3 94 5 A 0 /3
4 4 153 3 + 4
153 A 0 94
)/ 4) ) 4 / 94 5 /3 4 4
3 A2 6 0**7
#
< 35 4 153 3 ) 4 3 =
/3 ; 15 /3
5 5 4 3 153
) 3 /3 35
;
) 4 8 3 3
) ) )
4 / 3 4 ) %%2* +
/ ) 3 4
) / 3 4A%%%2
< /3 ; 3
3 6=
5 / 4 35 357 4 Æ
351153 <93
) / ; 6 > 3=/ 4
/ ) 35/ / 7 <
)) 3 4 / 9 3
53
+ 55 ) ; 4 15=
3 3 )4 4 <
35 153 635 337 3 )
153 3 ;) 5 <
;) > 4 / 4 / 55 15=
3 < 15 4 153 A 0
94)/4))4 /945
3 4 2 2$ < 4 35
153 A B 3 3 4
/) /3 4 )
"
<=3 94 ) 3 )
5 3 < ) 4 3=/
) 4 3 > 4
< 5 / 3 2 B 4 :1 3
A%%2*
< 94 )5 5 4
) : 8 133
2 2BG 3 3 4 A2 2BG 2&
3 4 A* 2&B 3 4 A*
< 553555 )5 =3
)=
33 ) 3 35
/ < :3 3
5 34 /=33
3 : 55 3 5
2 2$ 4 5
5 /=133 3 /945
A 2 /3 4 /)
< 5 )/ 4) 5/ 4
6313394 A257
1 3553 35
45 )2G2&
/5 , B 9455 55
58 4 4 1/ 94
> < /=
53 //560$7
)4//34)34
4/ / :5554 3
5 53 ) 9
!354153#)
5A0AB
4 5
58 ) /3
A B 3 : 58 8/ 133
/ 94 94
>8==94 1
") ) 3 153 3
3 A 0 /3 4
153 ! 5 3 4
4 A B 4 153 4 3
133 94 4 /// /5 ")
153) 3 4 3
4 2 2$ < /3) 4 153
153:/43
35
. N C/8 !) 3 /4 + <
)3 2 5/ G**?GB* "= 33
*&&0
.<O/3/4@ 3/153
,B@G, *&&&
. N . "3 E E " ) ) /3 =
:/ G%@GB?&, *&B0
."3 <=333=) )
) 3 4 2*0@$$&?$GB*&&%
E ! H3 <=3 1=
33)34 ,2-@,&&?
0*$ *&&-
< C ))
)34 + 3**@2%GB?2%BB
*&&&
3/ E 4 . N . "3 # =)
) ) 4 5 35 5:
&G@&?*G *&B&
P ./ Q =P5 # 133 8/
) ) /3 /4 :/
22%@,*-?,2$ 2%%%
#) PH3 #C")3)
3 *2%@*%B?**0*&&B
J '/ P ./ ' H Q =P5 # 5
) / ) 4 5
)J'/P./'H Q=P5#<=
3 ) 94 ) 4 5
4 *2-@$B-?$&&2%%0
>/ !" # !
#5/=J/ *&&-
#J 8$! 35E/=
! *&B%
)5)3593%" G&@*0$$
*&G&
H3 55 =5 3 35")=
#8 !" $&@,%B?,2,*&B$
J> C :=;3 =3 3=
5 94 !" *2,@0%2?0*0 *&&-
.# ! # C 3))
9 % *0@2*$G *&G*
! + ! < ; 4 9
/ 34 *%$@2$$*&B,
! + ! ';
9 3 4 2-@B&2 *&B,
Q < C
) 3/3 $*$@,&*?0*, 2%%0
P ./ Q =P5 P # 35
) ) ,BB@,*$?,,0*&&&
6 6
"
176 , , ( $ 552, (( 5 ((,,8 8 3 8 ,
176 5$5$(3 5 8 (( ( ((,22 8,35 8,,3
176 8585 8 5,$$ ((($5 ((,88 855 8,$$
196 , , ( $ 58$$ (3 ((8($8 8,($ 8 $(
196 5$5$(3 58, 8 ((,3 ((3 85 8,8(
196 8585 8 5883 (($3 ((58 855$ 85(
+/:; < 6 % " 2!
" ( "5
2 (88
$ (5$
3 (,(
+/:;<< 7.
&
2 3
(5 3 ,$2 3$3
52(
$2 82(5 ,8((
5 3 ,2($2
+/:;<<< 4 "( . /0
- / 4
@ .3 53
@ " 3 5 5 >3 /
6 7 A %G$ 6 A G%% A %%2* A 07@ ;
3 3
@ #3 67 3 67 133 94 A -%%
A 0 6
A -G%7D 3 67 3 67 133 94
A,%% AB 6
A,B%7
@ 1) A%BG$3/5
4 )/ 4) A2A%%2* A2*%%
6 5 /) )7
@ 5 133=8/
A 2&@ 6*7 627 5 33 6J7
4 4 6C7 3//
133=8/
@ 45 33 AB A0%%@ 67
3 ; 1 = 67 ) : 3 5
6A% A%7
@ 35=33394AB
A0%% 6
A,B%7@ 6=7 /3 A%*2,35
67 / 3 A* >3 )
@ 45 33 A0 AG%%@ 67
3 ; 1 = 67 ) : 3 5
6A% A%7
@ 35=33394A0
AG%% 6
A-G%7@ 6=7 /3 A%*2,35
67 / 3 A* >3 )
@ 9/ 8 / 3> %
A
%%2* 67AB67 A0
@ H/ 9 A2 A2*%% A%%2*
>35 4 /7 ABA%%2* 4 ) 6A%
5 A A%7 67 A*0$% 67 A***%
@ 1) A%BG$ 3/ 5
4/4) ABA%%2* A*0$%
6 5 /) )7
@ <35 / ; 4 6
>3 5 4 /7 A 0 A %%2* A 2%%% 6 A %
5 A A%7 67 A%G$ 67 A%2$
@ 1) A%BG$ 3/ 5
4/4) A0A%%2* A2%%%
6 5 /) )7
z
y x
o
H R
T h
T c
T c
1<=( =
ϕ
- ∂ T/ ∂ z (r= 0. 75, z= A )
1 2 3 4 5 6
0.52 0.54 0.56 0.58 0.6 0.62
FDM 32 × 32 × 128 FDM 48 × 48 × 192 FDM 64 × 64 × 256 FVM 32 × 32 × 128 FVM 48 × 48 × 192 FVM 64 × 64 × 256
1<= : >
"2 "2! " (! "5? -
(c)
(a)
0.933333 0.8
0.6 0.4 0.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
(d)
0.933333 0.8 0.6
0.4 0.2
0.8
0.6 0.4 0.2
(b)
1<=, @ & "8 "5
"82A & ", "$
",$
t = 0 T
+ -
+
t = 0.25 T
- +
+
t = 0.5 T
- +
+
t = 0.75 T
- +
+
1<=5 +& " $2
" !" ( " (
++++ + + + + + ++++
Ra
th e fr e q u en c y o f en er g y o s c ill at io n
1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
A2 V
O
A1
1<= 6&*
" 3? +( + ! 7
)! &*
0.521876
0.52209 0.52227
z=0.25H
0.625
0.65 0.635
z=0.7H
0.99
0.925 0.95
z=0.5H
0.205
0.215
0.225
z=0.9H
x=0 y=0
1<= 8 1 " $ " 5?
- & ! % "
"
(a)
7.3E-03
(b)
1.9E-04
(c)
1.8E-05
(d)
7.4E-02
(e)
1<=2 6 " $!
"5
",$? "( , !
"(
0.98
0.84 0.89
z=0.5H
0.63
0.72 0.67
z=0.7H
0.21
0.23
0.25
z=0.9H 0.54
0.55 0.57
z=0.25H
x=0 y=0
1<= $ 1 " 5 " 2?
- & ! % "
"
(a)
1.4E-02
7.2E-03 (b)
1.6E-03
2.1E-04 (c)
4.0E-04
1.6E-04 (d)
2.1E-01
2.1E-01
8.5E-02 (e)
1<=3 6 " 5!
"2
"82? "( , !
"(
Ra
380 390 400 410 420
-1 -0.75 -0.5 -0.25 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
K v1 +K v2 +K v4 +K v5 K v3
K b K d
Ra
670 680 690 700
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
K v1 +K v2 K v3 K v4 K v5 K b
1<=( 6 *
" (
t
2865 2870 2875 2880 2885 2890
-1.2 -0.8 -0.4 0 0.4 0.8 1.2
1.6 K v
K b
K d K v1 K v2 K v3
K v4 K v5
1<=(( B " ! " (! " (
Te m p .
0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45
Height z=0.875H
t
Te m p .
0 2 4 6 8 10
0.25 0.3
0.35 ϕ=90 deg ϕ=180 deg
ϕ=270 deg ϕ=0 deg Height z=0.125H
Te m p .
0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45
Height z=0.875H
t
Te m p .
0 2 4 6 8 10
0.25 0.3
0.35 ϕ=90 deg ϕ=180 deg
ϕ=270 deg ϕ=0 deg Height z=0.125H
1<=( -
! " $! " ( "
" "
+
-
t = 0 T
+
-
t = 0.5T
+
-
t =0.25T
+ -
t =0.75T
1<=(, +& " $2
"$!" ( "(5
0 2 4 t 6 8 10 0.338
0.34 0.342 0.344 0.346 0.348
0.35 ϕ= 0 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.788 0.79 0.792 0.794 0.796 0.798
0.8 ϕ = 180 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.622 0.624 0.626 0.628 0.63 0.632 0.634
ϕ= 90 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.622 0.624 0.626 0.628 0.63 0.632 0.634
ϕ = 270 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.52 0.522 0.524 0.526 0.528 0.53 0.532
ϕ = 90 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.494 0.496 0.498 0.5 0.502 0.504 0.506
ϕ = 0 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.52 0.522 0.524 0.526 0.528 0.53 0.532
ϕ = 270 deg
0 2 4 t 6 8 10
0.598 0.6 0.602 0.604 0.606 0.608
0.61 ϕ = 180 deg
1<=(5 -
! "5! " ( " "
" "
+
-
t = 0 T
+
-
t = 0.5T
+
-
t =0.25T
+
-
t =0.75T
1<=( +& " $2
"5!" ( "
