• Aucun résultat trouvé

From bounded T-systems to 1-safe T-systemsup to language equivalence

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "From bounded T-systems to 1-safe T-systemsup to language equivalence"

Copied!
19
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071878

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071878

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

From bounded T-systems to 1-safe T-systemsup to language equivalence

Philippe Darondeau, Harro Wimmel

To cite this version:

Philippe Darondeau, Harro Wimmel. From bounded T-systems to 1-safe T-systemsup to language equivalence. [Research Report] RR-4708, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071878�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--4708--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

From bounded T-systems to 1-safe T-systems up to language equivalence

Philippe Darondeau — Harro Wimmel

N° 4708

Janvier 2003

(3)
(4)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)

Téléphone : +33 2 99 84 71 00 — Télécopie : +33 2 99 84 71 71

()+*,"%-% "%-%./0 1324"%*,5!

687:9<;=9<>:>!?A@ABDCFEDG:H:?IBKJMLONQPBKCFCFESRT9<UVUW?X;ZY

[]\^`_babc4dfegihjaikmlona,pqhjrohspt^`_baih

uwvjxmysa,pqzI{

ek}|~|Dxmvjpoa€vjaF‚\~a`v‚‚\~a„ƒ†…{I‡&ˆŠ‰df‹ŠkmƒIŒXŽa`vmˆmˆm%dc’‘%|km“maFh

”•–i—`˜&™~šm—m›8œ a8h\~x&žŸpj\k}pa`Œmaivjrb Kƒ~¡pta%k}ƒ¢Dxml~ƒ~ai_bkmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\xmv[Z¤¥hjrohspta`_¦\Kkmh]kc,¤§hjk}¨©a

ªk}¢Da ªŽªaiŒma`v‚hj«xŠƒž«pj\¬k}ƒA­oa`ƒXpj­`k ªªkmƒ~“mlKk}“maŠ®

¯¬°X±†²t³´ ˜&µ–m› u:a,pjvt8ƒ~a`pthi¶0[Z¤§hrohpjai_bhi¶%_k}vt£maF·“Švtkm|~\hi¶%haF¸Šla`ƒXpj­k ª `xm_b|KxŠƒ~a`ƒXp‚h`¶`«v‚,l¡p‚h`¶

¹ vjƒx ªI¤¥ºq«Œ&k}p]|vjxool,pi¶ ªk}¢Da ªŽªŽƒ~“K¶~|Kaivj_»loptk}pjŽxmƒhi®

¼w½©¾#½À¿iÁÃÂ&ĝłÆǒȒÉʒËw̆˝łȒÍÏÎÏËsÈXÂ&ÐÑ3Ò3ӂÔ,Õ¾Ës֒֒ËsÉ:׆Ësʒ˧ØÚÙÊ&łÛÀÜ3֒ʒ˝łÈ}ÝÎÏÛÀÎÏÉ¥ÅFÞ߫۝à

á'â

֒Îã,ËsÛÀÉ=Îäæåç܂ßéèÍÏʒËsÖ`ê’È’ÛÀë’ÂìÐ}łĥíiê}ËsÛÀ˝ÎÏÄ=íî½æÖFß«Ü3Û<ÆÅtä<ÎÏïmÂñð~Þè!Þ̆ܝØòÕ3ÒóÓ3ÑFÂìôõæÕ3öF÷3÷3÷øèÍÏʒËsÖ`ê’È’ÛÀë

Ù#ùłÛÀÛ<ܒÞúÎÏÆÆËs͡ݽæÖFß«Ü3Û<ÆÅtä<ÎÏïmÞ

â

֒ÎõÀèÍÏʒËsÖ`ê’È’ÛÀë’Þô:û#à

(5)

T!#"% $&-"é*`'.*,"%-%"%-

– › ºqxmlh»_bxmƒXpjvtxmƒKh¸Xl~aptxmlop[Z¤¥hjrohspt^`_ba ƒ!a`p»¢Dxmvtƒ~g|Da`lop,ptvjapjv‚k}ƒh¨©xmvt_bg a`ƒ

[Z¤§hjrIhpj^i_ba4g`pj­¸Xl~a,ptg0c`¤¥htk}l~¨¸Xl~aiƒ~“maiƒovta ªa8_`_ba ªkmƒ~“Škm“maŠ®

´ —F– ² š –¬› egihjaikmlon¬oa»u:a`pjvt<¶†“mv‚k}|\~aihq_bkmvt¸Xl~gFh`¶†[Z¤§hrohpj^`_baFh`¶,xŠ_b|KxXhjkmƒŠptaih hgF¸Šla`ƒXpjŽa ªŽªaFh`¶

`«v‚,l¡p‚h`¶o|~vtxool~«pq

¹

vtƒ~x ªI¤§ºŽŒ’k}pi¶og`pj­¸Šla,ptkm“maŠ¶o|Kaivj_»loptk}pjŽxmƒhi®

(6)

(D»#: 5Ã1,%

[]\a “mxXk ª x}¨]pt\~Žh|k}|Da`vŽh%pjxOk}ƒKhžZa`v œ x ª“Škmƒ~“Oea`­hj«“ h8vtai¸Xl~aFhsp%_kŠoa k}ƒ ¨©xŠvjž]k}v‚oaFOptx¬pj\~a

u:a`pjvtºa,p‚h*)Okmª«ƒ“,+#ŽhpŽƒ-) k}v‚‚\}ˆŠˆ~cŠ® œ x ª¨©“Škmƒ~“ea`­hŽ“bžvjxmpja4«ƒ/.012

34567!6987:;< '"=>8@? BACDE$%$GFHI$#6J674K8JMLN$#"8J6OPQR8@STAC;#6U#WV

XYYZ[CGFH\#]%$"6J6Y,": 'L" AHFS\4K8JJF^67" 6J67 !_"H8J`8@Ha

b*"? F=cd%$*Z[`ef"*$#,"667"ML>"LMRa

g ªk}Ž_hV]Y ";?iF!cdE$*ZjGFH<k;8l`"Pchm58JPZ[`efn8JML!JF>",67"SL>"RL;#o

>? F-GFH"Yc m 8l "E$#Da

œ a»hj\k ª«ª |k}vjpj­k ªŽªrAk}ƒKhžZa`vpt\~­hqvtai¸Xl~aFhspq¢Ir“mŽŒI«ƒ~“k,xŠƒhpjvtl3pt«xŠƒxm¨qp栃¡ptaDrschm¨©xŠv ƒ¡pta»k}ƒK

¢Dxmlƒoai _kmvj£Šai “mv‚k}|~\Kh\cS®¬[]\~akŠhjhjl~_b|opjŽxmƒ pt\k&p0k ªŽª

_k}vt£maF“Švtkm|~\h8lƒoa`v0,xŠƒh­oaivtk}pjŽxmƒ

kmvja- C; %ž]kmh ƒ~x}p€a,no|

ª

­,«p4ŽƒOpt\~a0hptk}pjai_0aiƒXp4xm¨Qpj\~ab|~vtxm¢

ª

a`_A®

¹ h pt\~a0hja,p€x}¨Ãk ª«ª

|~vta, nIaFhqxm¨

žZxmv‚~hŽƒ<t=mJuDvwpæpj\avjaFhsptvj­3ptai<xqro‚£

ª

k}ƒ~“Šlk}“ŠaÃx&ŒŠa`v:xmƒ~aZ|km«vQxm¨K|kmvjaiƒŠpt\~aihjaih r#_bk’r¢Kavtai`xm“mƒ7yiai

¢Ir¬k}ƒ¬lƒX¢Dxmlƒoai _k}vt£mai“Švtkm|~\zp©ž«pj\xmƒ~a»| ªkŠ,a8pt\k&p8,xŠl~ƒXpthpj\~a»l~ƒ~_k&p‚‚\~ai ªa,¨æp€|kmvjaiƒŠpt\~a,¤

hjaih r{kmƒ hja`ai«ƒ“ pj\Kk&pt=mu vŽh4ƒ~xmp4vta`“Šl ªk}vD{†k  ƒ~«pjabl~ƒI¢Dxml~ƒ~aiO_kmvj£Šai¬“Švtkm|~\ `kmƒ~ƒ~xmp€k ªž]k’roh

¢Dapjv‚k}ƒh¨©xmvt_baiSŽƒXpjxkO ƒ~«pja c,¤§htk&¨©a _k}vt£maFS“mv‚k}|\Sž¡pt\Wpt\~ahtk}_ba ªkmƒ~“mlkm“maŠ®}|qx&ž!aiŒma`vD{pj\~a

`xmƒhpjv‚k}ŽƒXp!pt\k&pwchmhj\~xml ª¢Ka8 Kƒ~¡pta8žZkŠh]ƒ~x}pa`no| ª­,«pa`«pj\a`vŽƒpj\~a%hptk}pja`_baiƒŠpxm¨pt\~a8|~vtxm¢ ªa`_A®

œ abk}vta%«ƒK ª«ƒ~aF¬ptx¢Da ª«aiŒmapj\k}p pt\~a»|vjxŠ¢ ªai_ \kmh4hsptªŽª khjx ªlopjŽxmƒ «ƒ pj\~abha`p xm¨Ã«ƒ~ ƒ~«pjac,¤§hjk}¨©a

_kmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\hc~mQž\~a`ƒzcó­h%k}ƒSlƒX¢Dxmlƒoai _k}vt£maF “Švtkm|~\{kmh8a`nokm_b| ª« aFŽƒz«“K®wc{¢~lop

¨©lvpt\~a`v!ž!xŠvj£%­hwƒa`ai~aib¢Da,¨©xmvtapt\~Žh!,xŠƒ&ysai,pjl~vtaq`kmƒ¢Ka ~noai® œ aqh\Kk ªŽª km,pjlk ª«ªr»hjx ªŒma]pt\~aqkm¢Kx&ŒŠa

|vjxŠ¢ ªai_ ¨©xmvZ ƒ~«pja8kmƒ¢Dxmlƒoai[Z¤§hrohpja`_hR{Iž\~Ž‚\a,nIpta`ƒh_bxIx}pt\ ªrx&Œma`vZ_k}vt£maF“mv‚k}|~\Kh`®:[#x

¢Da_bxŠvja |vjaF,­ha;{žZahj\k ªŽª hjx ªŒmabpt\~a|vjxŠ¢ ªai_쨩xŠvl~ƒ ªkm¢Ka ª«ªai [Z¤§hjrIhpjai_h{:kmh%pj\~ahx ªlopt«xŠƒ ¨©xmv

ªk}¢Da ªŽªaiA[Z¤¥hjrohspta`_h]¨©x ª«ªx&žh]pj\a`ƒ¬Ž_0_baFoŽk}pja ªrŠ®Z[]\~a8vtaihpx}¨:pt\~a%|km|KaivŽhxmvt“Šk}ƒ7yiaikmh]¨©x ª«ªx&žh`®

zoai3pt«xŠƒ bvtai`k ª«ªh]pt\~a¢kŠh­%oa` ƒ~«pjŽxmƒOxm¨w[Z¤¥hjrohspta`_hqkmƒA_k}vt£mai“Švtkm|~\hkmƒApj\a`Žv ªk}ƒ~“Šlk}“Šaihi®

zoai3pt«xŠƒS¬vjaFol`aih4pj\a |~vtxm¢

ª

a`_쨩xmv% Kƒ~¡ptak}ƒK¢DxmlƒoaiS[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_h€pjxOkOhjŽ_0

ª

k}v8|~vtxm¢

ª

a`_쨩xmv

 Kƒ~¡pta%k}ƒ¢Dxml~ƒ~ai€{

ª

«ŒŠa8k}ƒhsptvjxŠƒ~“

ªr ,xŠƒ~ƒ~aF3pjaF_kmvj£Šai “Švtkm|~\hi®

œ

a%hj\~x&ž·ŽƒAhjai,pjŽxmƒhZ{k}ƒK

‘pt\k&phjl‚\ _bkmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\Kh _k’rO¢Da hj«_»l ªk}pjaF l~| ptx ªkmƒ~“mlkm“ma0ai¸Xl~ŽŒ&k ªa`ƒ`a0¢Ir¬ Kƒ~¡ptahja,pth€xm¨

`ro ªŽ]|~vtxo,aFhjhjaihQhjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uy`aF»¢Irpj\~a ¹ vjƒx ªI¤¥ºq«Œ&k}pw|~vjxoolK3pq.Žc1¥®:[]\aqhŽ_l ªk}pjŽxmƒbvja ªŽaihw\~aik’ŒIªr

xŠƒŽƒ~£Ša ª¤)¬ai_b_0Ye>$#bƒ~a`pth!.{1Zlhjai kmh%kA¢vj­o“ma¢Da,psžZa`aiƒ _bkmvj£Šai “mv‚k}|\h8k}ƒ `xm_b_l~ƒŽik&p¤

Žƒ~“¬hjai¸Xl~a`ƒXptŽk ª |~vtxI`aihthaFh`® zIaF3pt«xŠƒ}0¬`xmƒIŒmaivp‚hqpt\~a hjrXƒK‚\~vjxŠƒ~Uy`ai|~vtxool3p‚h€x}¨,ro ª­b|~vjxo`aihthaFh

ptxSc,¤§hjk}¨©a»_kmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\hR{#hjx¬¡p%¢vjŽƒ~“Šh4pt\~a hjx ªlopjŽxmƒ pjxApt\~a|~vtxm¢ ªa`_ìpj\k}p%žZkŠh4pjxOhjx ªŒmaŠ®W‚¥p%Žh

k ªhjx xŠ¢haivjŒŠaipj\Kk&p4pj\~a0vjaFhl ªpt«ƒ~“ c,¤§hjk}¨©a%_k}vt£maiA“Švtkm|~\h k}vta ªŽŒmaŠ®w|qx&ž!aiŒmaivR{pj\~airƒa`aiOƒ~x}p€¢Ka

hpjvtxmƒ“ ªrO,xmƒƒ~ai,pjai®zoai3pt«xŠƒS‡hj\~x&žh4pj\Kk&p%k}ƒIrIžZk’rOk ª«ª _k}nIŽ_k ª hpjvtxmƒ~“ ªr `xmƒ~ƒai3ptai ,xŠ_0|Dx}¤

ƒa`ƒXpthxm¨pt\~a8vtaihjl ªpt«ƒ“¬c,¤§hjk}¨©a4_kmvj£Šai “Švtkm|~\Ak}vta4­hjxm_bxmvt|~\~­4l~|ApjxŽƒ~«pj­k ª _k}vt£I«ƒ“Šhi®w[]\~Žh¨Àkm3p

­h ªŽªlKhsptvtk}pjaiAŽƒ hjai,pjŽxmƒ ‰>{Kž\~aivja%pj\~a0,xmƒKhsptvjl,pjŽxmƒh k}vta%|~lop pjxž!xŠvj£xmƒOkhŽ_b| ªa0`kŠhahpjlKorm®

zoai3pt«xŠƒ&ƒ ªxIxm£oh]¢~vt«a„rk&ppt\~a8Ž_0| ª­`k}pjŽxmƒh]xm¨#pj\a8vjaFhl ªpthi®

¾¾ օ~Ԇ‚Ó‡

(7)

a c

b

a c

b b c b

a

Ž“mlvjabc2 ¹ ƒlƒX¢Dxmlƒoai_k}vt£maF “Švtkm|~\kmƒ¡p‚h«ƒ~ ƒ~«pjac,¤§htk&¨©a€Œmaivthj«xŠƒ

½ ¾½æÁ

(8)

ì]:¦$ .(:8A*, $&8 M~#

œ a vtaiik ªŽª \~a`vtapt\~a ¢kŠh­oa, Kƒ~¡pt«xŠƒh%xm¨xmv‚o«ƒKk}vtr u}[Z¤=ƒ~a`pthR{[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_h{:k}ƒ _kmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\h

¢Da,¨©xŠvja8hptk}pjŽƒ~“0pj\~a8|~vtxm¢ ªai_ékm~~vjaFhjhjai«ƒpj\a8|k}|Da`vF®

° — À´ — °O´ ˜&µ ™o˜ ±€² ° —i–  ƒ~«pjaÃxmv‚o«ƒKk}vtru&[Z¤¥ƒ~a`p]8l]"w8AH"`8JKLi"iAHF

c"!$#%'&)(*&,+.- o 4YFH'% "C/( " efn8Jw",8l108JnK#`sE$sQ_8@?i# o ? "6J6Ui4| ªkŠ,aih"Cqpjv‚k}ƒo¤

hj«pjŽxmƒho*#`A> ?#_8JQ#69o"2+435#%768(/-9#:(;6<%.->=@?BAC&EDGF^8l,GFH&? FH"i"?8l`8@?w$ C?_8@ %$

GFH=#NE$=8J ?# ~ LMP%$,JF>'L" AHFHa _bkmvj£IŽƒ~“ E$c 8l!"h," AHI3J%K=MLN'a FH»hsp‚k&pja

“Švtkm|~\ E$wc 8l="&67";i6J67 ^<69_8J@Li"iAHFSo*4K8JJFW":8JML=",Q`8@? # oT4YF>#iWGFH,8l=" LMW67"

6J67 &4K8JJF_"H8J`8@PO]$ 7H H mRQ8J/C"`8@CV/HTSO)UVH mEW 8$<"C^>69&8$io$#W#Q#'A67"?

XZY

%<oH#

X

-'[+\#

X

&)O)-w"]H-m^#

X

-5!H#

X

-`_a+\#

X

&,O)-Gbc+\#:Od&

X

-a<CF>!vjaFkm‚\km¢ ªa]hptk&pta“mv‚k}|~\~%$q"

Žƒ~«pj­k ª7yiaiefKCgM!h#%'&,(]&,+'&,Hci-4K8JJFŽƒ~¡ptŽk ª _k}vt£I«ƒ“2Hci-8l\GFH'#`8@?`8@/%$\8J`"

L" AHF}&JF>,W":8JML<GFH"*,"hiW "? FH $ jHkiMalg 8l Žƒ~¡ptŽk ª«ª

r ª

«ŒŠa^8$,Q#-_"> 8J_8@

O Y ( 8lWGFH!67" 6]E$=" LM&E$W8J`W "? FH"67!"<L"iA>Fmng 8l

ª

ŽŒmah8$io $#PQ#^ ";?iF>"67

W":8JMLcH E$/g osGFHPCl#%'&)(]&+'&)HZ-=8l=8Jn8J`8@"6J69~6O8JQDa ef>8JaefKCN8l%¢KxŠl~ƒoaF 8$W8J`

ii";?iF>"67\ "*L"iA>F-8lKefn8JDa C efKCf8l€c,¤§hjk}¨©aW8$N"6J68J`s "? FH";#6U\W":8JML"

W"iACwi"ML8JML&Q>?oAC&pDqF!w>##`sGFH E$#a=FH¨©vjaia ªk}ƒ“mlkm“maRr*#sg-E$\"!iC;itefK#

g 8l\JF>B%$"6J6 45i\8Jk(

v

GFH"B","? ? A &#!8J@\ ";?iF>"67'"wLi"iAHFSoB? H8@ P"

""W"^4K8JGF&8Jn8J`8@"6€"]H i "CW4K8JGF^"6J6€"# e5C"6Ua<FH ªk}¢Da ªŽªaF ªk}ƒ~“Šlk}“Ša>r/#ugv&xwy-

%$="h zeff#g 4K8JJF/`"H8J_8@ ªk}¢Da ªŽªŽƒ~“A_k}|{w3|(h=~} 8l,GFHW8JW"LM&E$,8J`T$

6U"ML>"LMCGFH>8>WC8@=W_A>FS8l7wP3G(

v

=€}

v

GFH"]ik;CNGFS8l67"; #6J698JSLP," A€a

° — À´ 1)€² – ± –`— ° –»™ µ ™~˜o‚ ° µ„ƒ˜&™`…‡†– 8Jn8J`8@"698sˆDi8J"]eB`8nC#%'&)(]&

+'&,Hci-N8l\"8[Z¤§hrohpja`_ 8$>#Š‰

XZY

%.-R#‹ŒX

‹ŽD‘$‹

X

Œ’‹ŽD-w4YFH/Œ

X

!?pO

Y

({‹+\#Od&

X

-/“!ACF="C

X

Œ]!?oO

Y

({‹+\#

X

&)O)-/“!”A`Fa 8lw"4_k}vt£maib“Švtkm|~\~8$l#Š‰

XPY

%.->#‹Œ X

‹G!DR•‹

X

ŒG‹’!D-Ra

˜ ´

•

°

Š–7—T8JQ# ">e5>8J="h C; #˜g™!š#%'&)(*&,+'&)H i - o*8l,JF>#!"efn8J

"C^ #"%$#~ ;g

m

!7#%

m

&)(

m

&,+

m

&)H

mi

-W"C^"&_"> 8J_8@/67"; #6J698JSLhW"iATw›3(

m

=œ( >?iF

GFH"qGFH!67" 6J67 67"SL>"RL;&E$]g ms8l!x#>"6f^JF>q$ !67"SL>"RL;-%$g o!=®aŠ®h8JP$#'67" oq>?iF

GFH"r/#ug-ž!”r*#sg m&xwy-ZŸ

  ¡

5!1,-ó.(:8A*, +"8¢% -8:"8(P

‚§ƒxmv‚oa`v!pjx0aikŠha4hx

ª

ŒIŽƒ~“|vjxŠ¢

ª

ai_éo®H{Xž!a€hj\~x&ž «ƒpj\Žh]hjai3pt«xŠƒ\~x&ž·pjx0vjaFol,aqpj\~­h]|~vtxm¢

ª

a`_ xŠƒ

[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_hptxkhŽ_b

ª

k}v4|~vtxm¢

ª

a`_ xmƒ hsptvjxŠƒ~“

ª

rA,xmƒƒ~ai,pjai _k}vt£maiO“mv‚k}|~\hi®

œ

a0|~vtxI`a`aFOŽƒOpsžZx

hptkm“maFh2€|~vtxm¢ ªa`_'o®Žh8vtai~l,aF  Kvthp8¨©vjxŠ_ì[Z¤§hrohpja`_h4ptx¬_bkmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\Kh{ƒa,nIp8¨©vjxŠ_ì_k}vt£maF

“Švtkm|~\h!pjxhpjvtxmƒ~“ ªr `xmƒ~ƒai3ptai_k}vt£mai“mv‚k}|~\Kh`®K+a`plhvtai`k ª«ª pt\k&p_k}vt£maF “Švtkm|~\h>#%'&,(]&,+'&,HP-

~aihja`vtŒma8pt\~Žh ƒkm_0a0hŽƒ`a%pj\a`rA_k’r¢Da0`xmƒhj­oa`vtai¬kŠh“mv‚k}|\hqkŠh¨©x ª«ªx&žh2!pj\a0hja,p4x}¨wŒmaivptŽ`aihqŽh

({opj\~a0ha`pqx}¨*p<o«vtai,pjaF>raFo“maFhŽh/%,{

X

­hqkmƒ¬aio“Ša8¨©vtxm_jO]ptx2OEm«¨ž+\#:Od&

X

-!˜Dk}ƒZ+\#

X

&,OEm£-'!˜D{

kmƒ0¨©l~vjpj\~aivj_bxŠvja]pt\~Žh!ai~“ma¢Daikmvth:pt\~aqŽƒXpjai“mv‚k ª _k}vt£H#

X

-3®wzXptvjxŠƒ~“,xŠƒ~ƒ~aF3pjaFoƒ~aFhjhQ\Kkmhw«pthÃlhjlk ª

_baFk}ƒ~Žƒ~“b«ƒpt\~Žh`xmƒXpja`nIpi®

¾¾ օ~Ԇ‚Ó‡

(9)

+#a,p]g !š#%'&)(*&,+'&)Hki-¢Dak  ƒ¡ptabkmƒO¢Dxmlƒoai [Z¤§hrohpja`_A®\‚¥¨!pj\~aivjabk}vta&; "»pjv‚k}ƒKh«pjŽxmƒh

O Y

(\{T8@aJRaptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKh8pj\Kk&p0ik}ƒ~ƒx}p¢Da KvjaFSk&p0kmƒIrvtaikŠ‚\k}¢

ª

a_k}vt£I«ƒ~“n{:vjai_0x&ŒIŽƒ~“A¨©vtxm_4g

k

ª«ª

hlK‚\ pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒh%oxIaFh%ƒ~xmp0k

ª

pjaiv‘r/#ug-3®[]\~a`vta,¨©xŠvja;{#xmƒa_k’rkŠhjhjl~_ba ž8®

ª®“®Apt\k&paiŒmaivjr

ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒTO

Y ( Žh«ƒ¡ptŽk ª«ªr ªŽŒmam®^+#a,plhƒ~a,nIpb,xmƒKh­oa`v| ªkŠ,aFh`®¬zIl~|~|DxŠhja<‹

X

Œ’‹!jAA¨©xmv0hxŠ_ba

| ªkŠ,a

XZY

%,{Xpj\~aiƒ vjai_bx&ŒXŽƒ~“8pt\~­hÃ| ªkm`aqoxIaih!ƒ~xmpZk ªpjaivwpt\~a ªk}ƒ~“Šlk}“Šax}¨pt\~a4[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_A®:zIl|~|KxXha

‹ŒX

‹`!vA¨©xŠv hjxm_ba%| ªkm`a

X

hjl‚\¬pt\k&plH i #X

-!vA>{pt\~a`ƒ vjai_0x&ŒIŽƒ~“bpj\Žh | ªkm,a%pjxm“Ša,pt\~a`vž«pj\ pj\~a

pÀl~ƒ~­¸Xl~aDr ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒ<O4hjl‚\pj\k}p.+\#

X

&,O)-R!šD{«¨Z«p%a,no­hsp‚h{oxIaih€ƒ~xmp8k ªpta`v€pt\~a ªkmƒ~“mlKk}“ma»x}¨Zpj\~a

[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_A®Zr0a ª«_bŽƒk&pt«ƒ~“»¡pta`v‚k&pt«ŒŠa ªr»k ªŽª | ªkŠ,aihwpj\k}p!_ba`a`p!ai¡pt\~a`vZ`kmhjahjxXxŠƒ~a`v!xmv ªk&pta`vD{og_k’r

¢Da€,xmƒXptvtkŠ3pjaFbpjxbk}ƒai¸Xl~ŽŒ&k ªa`ƒXp][Z¤§hjrIhpjai_¦hlK‚\ pj\Kk&p.‹

X

ŒG‹G!$D ¨©xmvZa`Œmaivjrb| ªkm`a

X

k}ƒK2Hki’#

X

-A

ž\a`ƒ~aiŒma`v2‹Œ X

‹!hA~®zIl~|~|DxŠhjabƒ~x&žš‹ŒX

‹|!hA¨©xŠv%hxŠ_0a0| ªkm`a

X

{#k}ƒK ªa,p.O4oa`ƒ~xmpja0pj\a-pÀl~ƒ~­¸Xl~aDr

ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒbhjl‚\bpt\k&p +\#

X

&,O)-5!DŠ® x a, ƒa k}ƒkml~“m_ba`ƒXptai[Z¤§hrohpja`_gž«pj\xmƒ~a| ªkŠ,a

X

:kŠ~oaF

ptx0pj\~a%hja,p]%,{~xŠƒ~a4pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒzOZkmoaipjx0pj\a%ha`p](\{ok}ƒž¡pt\Aa,nIpjaiƒoai_k}|Kh+ k}ƒKcHki8hlK‚\

pt\k&p]+\#Od&

X

)-5!D;{C+\#

X

d&)O-5!$D{`+\#:O &X

-5!vD{~kmƒcHci#

X

)-5!A®

¹

hZpj\~a€ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒzOÍ­h]Žƒ~¡ptŽk ª«ªr

ªŽŒma{pt\~aƒa`ž pjv‚k}ƒhj«pjŽxmƒ{O€­hk ªhjx® zIl~|~|DxŠhja pt\k&par*#ug-a!Kr*#sg m&xwy-\~x ª~h%¨©xmvbhxŠ_0a c,¤§hjk}¨©a

[Z¤§hjrIhpjai_•g mKž¡pt\bpj\~a4ha`pÃx}¨†ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKh‡(qmkmƒ0¨©xmvÃhjxm_ba ªk}¢Da ªŽª«ƒ~“8_km|zwZ3q(qm= (c9t?pOdFŠ®

¹ h

r/#ug-5!”r*#sg- a(

v

{o¡pZ¨©x ªŽªx&žhÃpt\k&pr*#sg-5!r/#ug mx&xw-Þ\~aivja'g mQ­hÃpt\~a8[Z¤¥hjrohspta`_ xm¢~ptk}Žƒ~aF

¨©vtxm_˜g m¢Ir vtaihpjvtŽ,pjŽƒ~“b¡p‚hha`px}¨pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒh(qm†ptxt(sm Pw

u

#:(l-]k}ƒPwZ­hZpj\a8vjaFhsptvj­3pt«xŠƒxm¨‡w

ptxpj\Žh hl~¢Kha`pi®*|aiƒ,a;{K¢IrAk}l~“Š_ba`ƒXpjŽƒ~“hj«_»l ªptk}ƒa`xmlKh ªr‘g ž«pj\OxŠƒ~a%| ªkm`a

X

¨©xŠvqaikŠ‚\A| ªkŠ,a

X

hjl‚\pj\k}pR‹Œ X

‹’!AH{o|~vtxm¢ ªa`_¦~®»_k’r¢Ka4vjaFol`aiptxb«ƒ~«pj­k ªŽªr ªŽŒma€[Z¤¥hjrohspta`_hZ«ƒž\~­‚\‹ŒX

‹G!vD

kmƒ‹

X

ŒG‹G!$D4¨©xmvaiŒma`vtr| ªkm`a

X

{Ipj\Kk&p­hZpjx htk’r{XpjxŽƒ~«pj­k ªŽªr ªŽŒma8_k}vt£maF “mv‚k}|\h`®

+#a,p8ƒ~x&žg@!š#%'&)(*&,+'&)H i -¢Da0kmƒ Žƒ~«pj­k ªŽªr ª«ŒŠa{† ƒ¡ptabkmƒ¬¢Dxml~ƒKoai_k}vt£maiO“mv‚k}|~\®8[]\~a

kŠhjhjl~_b|opt«xŠƒ xm¨%¢KxŠl~ƒoaFoƒ~aFhjha`ƒXptkmªhbpj\Kk&pž\a`ƒ~aiŒma`vk pjv‚k}ƒhj«pjŽxmƒ O Y ( Žhoa`ŒŠxm­ x}¨8Žƒ~|~lop

| ªkŠ,aih&pE8@aJDaSž\a`ƒ+\#

X

&,O)-a!4A¬¨©xmvbk ªŽª

XY

%\r{Qpt\~Žh»ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒW_lhp0¢DaŽhjx ªk&ptai®/|x&žZa`ŒŠa`vD{

pt\~a`vta_bk’r a`nI­hp0ƒ~xŠƒo¤¥Žhjx ªk&ptai ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKhO

Y

(¦ž«pj\xmlop k}ƒIr xml~pj|~lop| ªkm`ap%8@aJRa hjl‚\ pt\k&p

+\#Od&

X

-z!"A ¨©xmv k ª«ª

XY

%\r,® xmv k}ƒIr ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒOŽƒWpt\~­h`kmhja{!xmƒ~a_k’rWhjl~|~| ªa`_ba`ƒXpaikŠ‚\

Žƒ~|~l~p0| ªkm`a

X

x}¨]O%ž«pj\ k `xm_b| ªa`_ba`ƒXptkmvjr | ªkm`a

X

ž¡pt\~xmlopk ªpjaivjŽƒ~“Tr*#ug-Xž\a`vta | ªkm,aFh

X

kmƒ

X

k}vtahtk}­ pjx ¢Da ? qAC6U#W#n" «¨‘+\#

X

&)O)-]bv+\#

X

&,O)-T! D k}ƒ+\#Od&

X

-]bv+\#:Od&

X

-! D

¨©xŠv0k ª«ª O Y

({:kmƒ›Hki’#

X

-žb”Hki’#

X

-%­hpj\~a_bk}no«_k ª Œ&k ªl~avtaikŠ‚\~ai ¢IrH#

X

-ž\~aiƒ{Hvtkmƒ~“maFh

x&ŒŠa`vbpt\~a vtaikŠ‚\k}¢ ªa¬_k}vt£I«ƒ~“Xhbx}¨*g ®„[]\~­hpjv‚k}ƒh¨©xmvt_k&pjŽxmƒ |~vtaihja`vtŒmaFh0pj\~a«ƒ~«pj­k ª4ª«ŒŠa`ƒ~aFhjhxm¨

g kmƒVpj\~avjaFh|Dai,pjŽŒmaA¢KxŠl~ƒ~hvjaFkm‚\~aF ¢XrWpj\~a xmvt«“Š«ƒk ª | ªkm,aFhx}¨]g ® )¬xŠvjaix&Œma`vD{Ãk}¨æpja`vpj\~a

ptvtkmƒh¨©xmvt_bk}pjŽxmƒ{Xa`ŒŠa`vtrb_bk}no«_k ª `xmƒ~ƒ~aF3ptai,xm_b|Dxmƒ~aiƒXpZxm¨yg獭h]hsptvjxŠƒ~“ ªr,xŠƒ~ƒ~ai,pjaF®K‚§ƒ ¨ÀkŠ3pR{~k

hpjvtxmƒ“ ªr€`xmƒ~ƒai3ptai0,xŠ_0|Dxmƒa`ƒXpxm¨g ž¡pt\»ƒ~x€Žƒ,xŠ_b«ƒ~“4ai~“maih\kŠhƒ~x€xmlopt“mxmŽƒ~“ aio“ŠaihR2#«¨K«p:\Kkm€{

pt\~aihjabž!xŠl ª ¢Dal~ƒI¢KxŠl~ƒoaF€{hjŽƒ,abŽƒ~¡ptŽk ªwª«ŒŠa`ƒ~aFhjh4a`ƒXp‚k}ªh ª«ŒŠa`ƒ~aFhjh ¨©xŠv%k ªŽª hsptvjxŠƒ~“ ªrO,xŠƒ~ƒ~ai,pjaF

_kmvj£Šai0“mv‚k}|~\Kh`®:[]\~a_k}vt£maFb“mv‚k}|~\b|~vtxool`aib¢Irpt\~aptvtkmƒh¨©xmvt_bk}pjŽxmƒb_k’rpt\IlhâDa `x&ŒmaivjaF¢Ir

hpjvtxmƒ“ ªr»,xŠƒ~ƒ~aF3pjaF ,xŠ_b|KxŠƒ~a`ƒXpthR{X«ƒ ªlKo«ƒ“%Žhjx ªk&ptai0ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKhÃkmh!k%|kmvptŽ`l ªk}vÁikmhjam®uwvjxŠ¢ ªa`_

~®0_k’rpt\~a`vta,¨©xŠvja€¢Da8vjaFol,aFpjxb_k}vt£mai“mv‚k}|\h],x&ŒmaivjaF ¢Ir~«vtai,pjaiA`«v‚,l~«pthR{ož\~aivja%k}p ªaikŠhsp

xŠƒ~a| ªkŠ,aA­hb_bkmvj£ŠaiWxmƒ aikm‚\ ,Žvt`l~«p^p<hŽƒ`aAk ª«ª ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒhbk}vtaŽƒ~«pj­k ªŽªr ªŽŒmaDr#{!| ªlhb­hjx ªk&pjaF

ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒh`® ‚§ƒ¬`kŠha€ž\~aiƒ¬k»_kmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\hjk}pj­hs aFhZpj\~aFha%`xmƒ~¡pt«xŠƒh]¢~lopq«p­h]ƒ~x}pq`xmƒ~ƒ~aF3ptai€{

pt\~­h:_bkmvj£Šai8“Švtkm|~\_k’r8¢Dahaia`ƒbkmhpj\~a\8J ?# {g !g u bRg!x}¨psžZx€h_k ªŽªa`v:_k}vt£mai%“mv‚k}|~\h

g u ! #% u &)( u &+ u &)Hki u -k}ƒK2g.! #%’&)(G&,+q&)Hkip-{†_baikmƒ~Žƒ~“pj\Kk&p?B% u &,%qF0k}ƒ?o( u &)(F0k}vta

|Kk}vjpj«pjŽxmƒhxm¨%'k}ƒ (\{vtaihj|Dai3pt«ŒŠa ªr{+\#

X

&)O)-8!€A k}ƒ„+\#Od&

X

-8! ASž\~aiƒ~a`ŒŠa`v

X Y

%k}ƒK

O Y

(»ž«pj\‘“!n{k}ƒ pj\~ab_k}|Khl+k}ƒK Hki]kmvja»pj\~abŽƒol`aivjaFhsptvj­3pt«xŠƒh x}¨+ k}ƒ HcibxŠƒ

½ ¾½æÁ

(10)

#%*6( -59 #( *6›%-0k}ƒWxmƒ%{Ãvtaihj|KaF3pjŽŒma

ª

rŠ®W[]\~a

ª

kmƒ~“mlKk}“makr*#sg-­h0pj\a`ƒ xm¢IŒI«xŠlh ªr pj\~a

hj\Il

ax}¨†pj\a

ª

kmƒ~“mlKk}“maFh‡r*#ug

u

-Qk}ƒar/#ugp-3®Q[]\IlhR{m«¨†pj\~aFha

ª

k}ƒ“mlkm“maihQkmvja]vtaihj|KaF3pt«ŒŠa

ª

rai¸Xlk

ª

pjx

r/#ug mu

&xw

u

-Qk}ƒKtr/#ug

m

q&xw B-¨©xmv*p<o­h©ysxŠ«ƒXp rc,¤§hjk}¨©aZ_kmvj£Šai»“mv‚k}|~\hg mu

kmƒ>g

m

kmƒ0¨©xmv

ª

k}¢Da ªŽª

«ƒ~“

_km|hwubk}ƒ{w {:žZaƒ~ai`aihthjkmvjªrO“ma`pr*#ug-.!jr*#sg mlub{g m &wubw -€ž\~a`vtazwubw Žh%pj\~a

~«vtai,p4hjl~_ñx}¨wpt\~a0_bkm|hRwCuk}ƒK<w {K8@aJDaz#^wCu'b w -E#:O)-*!˜w #:O)-¨©xmv4pt\~a»lƒ~Ž¸Xl~a Y

?’D’&`F»hlK‚\

pt\k&p w #:O)-:­hwoa` ƒ~ai®:[]\ahx ªlopt«xŠƒbx}¨†|~vjxŠ¢ ªa`_ ~® ¨©xŠvÃk€_k}vt£mai»“mv‚k}|\»ž«pj\ƒ~x8| ªkŠ,aihQkmƒ0xmƒ~a

pÀŽhjx ªk&ptai>rwpjv‚k}ƒKh«pjŽxmƒ ­h!pjvt«ŒI­k ª {ok}ƒIr,xmƒƒ~ai,pjai_k}vt£mai “mv‚k}|~\pt\k&p]_k’r¢Ka€,x&ŒŠa`vtaib¢Ir ,Žv‚,l~«pth

­hhpjvtxmƒ~“ ªr `xmƒ~ƒ~aF3ptai€{kmƒk}ƒIrhpjvtxmƒ~“ ªr `xmƒ~ƒ~aF3ptai_bkmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\Žh ªŽŒma€«¨:kmƒxŠƒ ªr ¡¨Q«p\kmh

ƒx»oaFkmbptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKh`®:[]\~a`vta,¨©xŠvja;{m«p]hj\~xŠl ª ¢Ka€ ªaikmvwpj\Kk&p]|~vjxŠ¢ ªa`_o®%vtaiol`aihwpjx%pt\~a ¨©x ªŽªx&žŽƒ~“®

˜ ´

•

°

–J˜—T8JQ#^"n5efn8Jw"' C oY698JQ"_SL69<?i>i?i\,": wLi"iAHF/g !

#%'&)(]&+'&)HkiB-o8l]GFHs"Kefn8J*"C\ "E$#q,": *L"iA>Fg m|!#%m^&,(qm:&+m&,H&m

i

-*"\"N_"> 8J_8@

6U" #6J6O8JML," AawP3q(qm= ( >? F'JF>"YJF>T67" 6J67 67"ML>"LM5r/#ug m^&w-T8lTx>"6wJF>€$ B6U"ML>"LM

r/#ug-ZŸ

: "8¢% -8"%(k 5Z+ 1,5Z"€1`-ñ/0 »1,"%* (:4

5!#

¹ ,vtl,­k ª ¨Àkm,p%pj\k}p»žª«ª ,xŠƒhjŽoaivtkm¢ ªr \~a ª| lKhŽƒWhjx ªŒXŽƒ~“¬|~vtxm¢ ªai_.®«c ­hpj\~a¨©x ªŽªx&žŽƒ~“>2bk}ƒIr

hpjvtxmƒ“ ªr ,xŠƒ~ƒ~ai,pjaF_kmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\ _k’r ¢Dapjv‚k}ƒKhs¨©xŠvj_baiŽƒŠptxOk ªkmƒ~“mlKk}“mabaF¸Šl«Œ&k ªa`ƒXp%_k}vt£maF

“Švtkm|~\0pj\k}pZik}ƒ ¢Da `x&Œma`vtai»¢Iro«vtai,pjaF,Žvt`l~¡p‚hq4K8JGF&8l108Jnf@w%$s LM#‚®w[]\ŽhèÀkm,pZoxIaihÃ~x}p

ƒa`ai k}ƒ¬a ªk}¢Dxmv‚k&ptai|~vtxIx}¨E{†hŽƒ,a»¡p€hl`aihpjxhjl~|~| ªai_0aiƒXp aikŠ‚\¬| ªkm,až¡pt\ k ,xŠ_b| ªai_ba`ƒXptkmvjr

| ªkŠ,a ¡¨0ƒ~x}p¬k ªvjaFkmor |~vtaihja`ƒXpD{ k}ƒK pj\a`ƒpjx oai`xm_b|KxXhapj\a _kmvj£Šai “Švtkm|~\·ŽƒŠptx `«v‚,l¡p‚hxm¨

ªa`ƒ“}pj\H{Zoa` ƒ~aFVŽƒ k}ƒ xm¢IŒI«xŠlhbž]k’rS¨©vjxŠ_ø|km«v‚hbx}¨8,xŠ_0| ªai_0aiƒXptk}vtrS| ªkm`aihi® |x&žZa`ŒmaivR{ ªaFhjh

hjrohspta`_k&ptŽOpjv‚k}ƒh¨©xmvt_k&pt«xŠƒhptxWpt\~a htk}_baa †ai3p¬_k’r ¢Ka |~vta,¨©aivjvtai€{ k}ƒŸž!a h\Kk ªŽª _k}£Ša ƒ~x

|Kk}vjpj­,l ªk}vkmhthjl~_b|opjŽxmƒxmƒpj\~a ªa`ƒ“}pj\Axm¨,Žv‚,l~«pthi®

vjxŠ_¦ƒ~x&ž·xŠƒ{ ªa`p5g !$#%'&,(]&,+'&,H i -Z¢Ka4pt\~a8k}_k ª“Škm_bk}pjaFhjl~_¦xmƒA,xŠ_b_0xŠƒ ptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKh!xm¨

k» ƒ¡pta€¨Àk}_bªrxm¨ ª«ŒŠa8k}ƒA,ro ª­4_bkmvj£Šai“mv‚k}|~\hng !;#% &,( &,+ &,H i -

g !œ?gy‹dD> 5‡F

8@aJDa]?o%KuB&&%|F€­hZk»|kmvpt¡pt«xŠƒ x}¨pt\~a8ha`p'%,{`(!(u 9 9a({~k}ƒ pj\~a4_k}|h'+„kmƒ2H i k}vta

pt\~abo«vtai,p€hjl~_h x}¨wpt\~a»vtaihj|Dai3pt«ŒŠa%¨Àkm_0

ª

«aFh xm¨Ã_k}|hl+ kmƒ8H i®q¨!`xml~v‚ha;{Dk,ro

ª

­%_k}vt£maF

“Švtkm|~\ _baFk}ƒh€\~aivjak_k}vt£maF “Švtkm|~\ ž\~­‚\ Žh%k}p€pj\~a htk}_ba0pjŽ_ba k~«vtai,pjai ,Žv‚,l~«pi®=xmv8aikŠ‚\

`ro ªŽq_bkmvj£Šaib“Švtkm|~\gE{ ªa`pR‹Hkix‹Xoa`ƒ~xmpjaqpj\~a4ž\~x ªaqƒIl~_»¢Kaiv!xm¨pjxŠ£maiƒhwŽƒ pt\~a4hjl~¢hja,pZx}¨#| ªkŠ,aih

%j®~«ƒk ª«ªr ªa`p ¢Kapj\~a ªaFkmhp»,xŠ_b_0xŠƒS_l ªpjŽ| ªaxm¨]pj\~aƒXl_¢Da`v‚hc‹Hci‹¨©xmv v‚k}ƒ“mŽƒ~“¬x&Œmaiv

?DG&|&‡FŠ®

Za ªx&ž «ƒ pt\~­hhjai,pjŽxmƒ{]žZa h\x&ž pt\k&ptg _bk’rV¢Ka hŽ_l ªk}pjai ¢Ir kSƒIl~_¢Da`vx}¨

‹Hki‹

`xm_b_lƒ~Žik&pt«ƒ~“haF¸Šla`ƒXpj­k ª |~vjxo`aihthaFh{8aFkm‚\Úx}¨ ž\Ž‚\Úptvtk’ŒŠa ªhApj\vjxŠl~“m\„k ªxIxm|„ž«pj\ ªaiƒ~“}pt\

#‹Hci,‹-R6‹%x‹#¨©xmv0pj\~a¬`xmvtvjaFh|Dxmƒ~«ƒ~“ ¹ hkvjaFhl ªpR{wpj\~aAx&Œmaivtk ª«ª hUy`aAxm¨pj\~aAŽ_b| ªai_ba`ƒo¤

p‚k&pt«xŠƒ­h 6 ‹%2‹® ‚¥p­hÞZxmvjpj\IžªaqpjvtrXŽƒ~“pjxboai`vjaFkmhjafpjx»pj\a ªx&ž!aFhspZ|KxXhjhjŽ¢ ªa4Œ&k ªl~a4ž¡pt\~xmlop

‚\Kk}ƒ~“Š«ƒ~“Rr/#ug-3® œ a hj\k ªŽª ƒ~xmpÃa`ƒXpta`vÃ\a`vta«ƒXpjx»oa,p‚k}ªhR{m¢~l~p!«pÃ_k’r¢Da¨©xmlƒhl¡p‚k}¢ ªapjx_0xoo«¨©r

¾¾ օ~Ԇ‚Ó‡

(11)

¨©xŠvZpj\k}pZ|~lvj|DxŠhjaqpt\~a€«ƒ¡ptŽk

ª

_bkmvj£IŽƒ~“Hki4x}¨g {o¢Ir kŠ~oŽƒ~“»xŠv]vjai_0x&ŒIŽƒ~“8ptxm£maiƒh!pjx0xmvZ¨©vtxm_¦k}ƒIr

| ª kŠ,a

X

hl‚\pt\k&pH#

X

->“!„Abk&paiŒma`vtrvtaikm‚\Kk}¢

ªa _kmvj£IŽƒ~“‘Hìx}¨g ®

+#a,pÃlh!hsp‚k}vjp

ª

xXxŠ£I«ƒ~“4¨©xŠvwpj\xŠhja,xm_b_»l~ƒ~­`k&pt«ƒ“%haF¸Šla`ƒXpj­k

ª

|vjxo,aFhjhjaihi®Yxmv!ƒ~x}p‚k&pjŽxmƒKk

ª

`xmƒIŒma`¤

ƒ«aiƒ,a;{ož!a€k ªŽªx&ž xŠl~v‚ha ªŒŠaih!«ƒpj\~a8hjai¸Xl~a ª ptx0­oaiƒŠpt¡¨©raikm‚\| ªkm,a

X

«ƒAk_kmvj£Šai“Švtkm|~\ž«pj\pj\~a

lƒ~Ž¸Xl~a0|km«v€x}¨!pjv‚k}ƒhj«pjŽxmƒht#:Od&,OEm£-4hjl‚\Opt\k&p.+\#:Od&

X

-l!7Dbk}ƒK +\#

X

&)OEm1-*!jDm®0[]\~ab,xmƒKhsptvjl,pjŽxmƒh

žZakmvjak}¢Dxmlop»pjx a`no| ªkm«ƒWvja ªr xmƒVkzpÀhjai`xmƒ>r»,vtl`Žk ª xm¢KhaivjŒ&k&pt«xŠƒ{:ž\~­‚\ Žhpj\Kk&p\r*#ug-oxIaih

ƒx}p‚\k}ƒ“maqž\a`ƒagçk}ƒKk ª«ª _k}vt£maF “mv‚k}|\hg k}vta4«ƒXpjaivj|vja`pjaik ªpjaivjƒk}pjŽŒma ªrkmhB«¨©x}¤¥ƒ~a,p‚hw.{1=®

[]\Žh k}_bxml~ƒXp‚hpjx_bkm|Ok ªŽª ptxm£maiƒhŽƒ8H i Žƒ&ysai,pjŽŒma ªrA«ƒ{SsDG&B‹H i ‹kmƒApj\a`ƒ `xmƒhjŽ~a`vaFkm‚\A| ªkm,a

X

!$#:Od&,OEmŠ-Ãkmh!k8 ~¨©x»¢~l †a`vD{Xž«pj\ pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ\Owk&p!pj\~a4«ƒ|~lopZkmƒž«pj\pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ\OEmKk}pÃpt\~aqxŠlopj|~l~pR{

hjl‚\pj\k}p' "? F^R:;#8J>8J_8@"6J69w$# W8J>wA67"?

X

"f$#i#Q#8J~GFH Q ??698@?W W":; 'L" AHFg

4YF8@?iF

X

67SL<}®%[]\Ilh{k pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ8Oqik}ƒO¢Da KvjaFO«¨!k}ƒOxmƒ ªr¬¡¨Zk ªŽª «pth4Žƒ~|~lop€¢~l †a`v‚h€k}vta

ƒxmƒo¤¥a`_b|opsr;{Kk}ƒK vjŽƒ~“bpt\~Žhqpjv‚k}ƒKh«pjŽxmƒ¬`kmlhjaihxŠƒ~a8pjxŠ£maiƒApjxW„x&ž¨©vtxm_ pj\~a»«ƒ~|lopq¢~l †a`v4x}¨nOZpjx

pt\~axml~pj|~lop!¢~l †a`vwxm¨O:Žƒ0aFkm‚\0_k}vt£mai»“mv‚k}|\lghjl‚\0pj\k}p5O

Y

(s®

¹

pwŽƒ~¡ptŽk ªUyik}pjŽxmƒ{mpjxŠ£ma`ƒKhQk}vta

¨©aFŽƒXpjx€¢~l †a`v‚h:Žƒ0kmvj¢~«pjv‚k}vtr€xmv‚oa`vF®ºqa`ŒŠa`vjpj\~a ªaFhjhR{’pj\~­hQxŠvtoaiv­h:|~vtaihja`vtŒmaF8pjx8hjxm_baZa,nIpjaiƒŠpQl~ƒKoa`v

k ª«ª  vtŽƒ~“Šhi®

¹

3pjlKk ªŽªr;{Š¨©xŠv]aikm‚\

Y

SuD’&{ ªa`p! Ou O w¢Da8kvta`|Da,pt¡pt«xŠƒ¨©vta`a4a`ƒIl~_ba`v‚k&pt«xŠƒ

xm¨J(#ž\~aivja aikŠ‚\ ,xmƒKhaF,lopt«ŒŠaq|km«v

X

*!;#:O u &)Oo-w­hZk%| ªkm`aqx}¨g »pt\XlKh

X

u !$#:O d&)Ou -

­hwk ªhjx%k8| ªkm`ax}¨Cg

®Q[]\~a`ƒ{Špj\aq,xŠƒ`k}pja`ƒKk&pjŽxmƒbxm¨†k ª«ª ¢~l †a`v‚h

X

¨©vjxŠ_ t!D]ptx ‘!„H

{ŠŽƒbpj\Žh

xŠvt~a`vD{~rI«a ª~h k hjai¸Xl~a`ƒK,a%xm¨Qpjxm£Ša`ƒh

ŽƒXŒ&kmvj­k}ƒXpl~ƒ~a`v k ª«ª  vt«ƒ~“Xhl~|Aptx`xmƒ&ysl~“Xk&pt«xŠƒxm¨Qž!xŠvt~h

ž\~aivja4psžZxbž!xŠvt~h k}ƒOk}vta8hjkmŽpjxb¢Da!?iE0LM"3®

g xŠƒh­oaiv%k nIaFpjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ<O

Y

(%®W+#a,p\?

X

& &X

F¢Dabpj\~a hja,p%xm¨Zk ª«ª ¢l Daivth€ž«pj\

ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ„Obk}ppt\~a xŠlopj|~l~pi® xmvaikm‚\

Y

SsDG&_{ ªa,p8¢Ka pj\~a haF¸Šla`ƒ`aOx}¨8ptxm£maiƒhhpjxŠvjaF

k}p4Žƒ~«pj­k ª7yFk&pt«xŠƒO«ƒpj\a0`xmƒik&pjaiƒk&ptai¬¢l Daivth4xm¨wpj\~a0 ~¨©xm¤=ƒa,pg {hsp‚k}vjpjŽƒ~“ pt\~Žh€`xmƒik&pjaiƒk&pt«xŠƒ

ž«pj\ pt\~abxmlopt|~lop%¢~l †a`vx}¨Ãptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ<O€hlK‚\ pt\k&p%k}ƒIr¬psžZx¬hlK`,aFhjhjŽŒma¢l Daivthk}vta»ƒ~ai«“Š\I¢KxŠl~vth

ŽƒSpt\~Žh0ƒ~a`pi®/+a`p"! ¢Kapj\a ªkmhp»ƒIl~_»¢Kaiv»ŽƒSpj\ahjai¸Xl~aiƒ,a# ® []\IlhR{wk&p»pj\~a v‚hsp»pjŽ_0až\~aiƒ

ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒzOZŽhZ vtai{~¡pžªŽª ,xmƒKhl~_ba4pjxŠ£maiƒ$! ¨©vtxm_é¢~l †a`v

X

:¨©xmvaikŠ‚\

Y

SuD’&¥®

¹

¨æpta`vpt\~­h{

pt\~abƒ~a`ž haF¸Xl~a`ƒ`a»xm¨Ãptxm£maiƒh€hsptxmvtai «ƒpj\~a`xmƒik&pjaiƒk&ptai ¢~l †a`v‚h xm¨Ãpt\~a0 ~¨©x}¤¥ƒ~a,p]g {#hptkmvpt«ƒ“

km“Škm«ƒ¬¨©vtxm_ pt\~abxmlopt|~lop8¢~l †a`v8xm¨Ãptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒ O{Žh pt\~a,xmƒ}ysl~“Šk}pja0x}¨% xm¢op‚k}Žƒ~ai ¢Ir h\¡¨æpt«ƒ~“&!

¨©vtxm_.pt\~a ªkŠhspb|KxXh«pjŽxmƒ pjxpj\~a v‚hsp0|KxXh«pjŽxmƒ#® []\~a`vta,¨©xŠvja;{Qxmƒ~aA`kmƒW_k}£Šak}ƒVa,n~km,p ªŽhpbx}¨ k ª«ª

`xm_»¢~«ƒKk&pjŽxmƒKh8x}¨' ptxm£maiƒh=p©¨©vjxŠ_ pt\~a vtaihj|KaF3pt«ŒŠa ~¨©xOƒ~a`pthlg r€pt\k&pžªŽª kŠ3pjlKk ªŽªr a`ƒkm¢ ªapj\~a

hjli,aihthj«ŒŠa vt«ƒ“Šh]x}¨pjv‚k}ƒhj«pjŽxmƒzO3®w[]\Žhp<,ro ªŽDr ª­hphptkmvp‚hZž¡pt\pt\~a(X¤=pjl~| ªa\#)!uB&J&!*-{~vtaikŠ

¨©vtxm_ pj\a ªkmhp|KxXh«pjŽxmƒKh%x}¨]pt\~avtaihj|KaF3pt«ŒŠahaF¸Xl~a`ƒ`aih+;ubpjx,-*S{Qk}ƒ aFkm‚\ hjl~¢hjai¸Xl~a`ƒXp«pjai_'Žh

xŠ¢optkm«ƒaiOhj«_bªkmvªrOk&¨æpta`v€khjŽ_l ªptkmƒ~a`xŠlh hj\~«¨æp8x}¨!k ª«ª hjai¸Xl~a`ƒK,aih ¢Ir¬xmƒ~a»|KxXh«pjŽxmƒ#® ¹ h8k vtaihjl ªpR{

pt\~aqƒIl~_»¢Kaiv%."/:xm¨†«pjai_h͎ƒpj\Žh ª­hp!­hQpj\a ªaikmhp!`xm_b_bxmƒ_l ªpt«| ªa4x}¨†pj\~a ƒIl~_¢Da`v‚h/‹H i ‹mž\~aiƒ

†v‚k}ƒ“maih:x&ŒŠa`vSsDG&=® xqaiƒ~x}pta¢Ir10'/pt\~a#œ6(C-Qk}vtv‚k’r8x}¨Dpjxm£Ša`ƒbƒIl~_¢Da`v‚hQxŠ¢optkm«ƒ~aF0¢Xr0vta`|Daik&pt«ƒ“

pt\~­h ª­hp."/wpjŽ_0aFhŽƒOhaF¸Šla`ƒ`am®Ã[]\IlhR{~aikŠ‚\ptxm£Ša`ƒx&žƒ~ai¢Irhjxm_ba€“mŽŒmaiƒƒ~a`p g hlK‚\pt\k&p

O Y ( :xoi,l~v‚h ‹Hci,‹Špt«_baih«ƒ20 / p©Žƒ¬,x ªl~_bƒ2:hl‚\pj\Kk&p ‡! r3®

œ aÃ~x&žS`xmƒIŒmaivpk}vtv‚k’rIh30 / pjxqhjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uyik}pjŽxmƒ ptk}¢ ªaFh54‡( / x&Œma`vƒa`ž k ª|~\km¢Ka`pth†pt\k&pžªŽª pt\~a`ƒ

¢Dalhjai ptxO,xmƒKhsptvjl,p€pj\~ahjai¸Xl~aiƒXpj­k ª |~vtxo,aihthjaih8hjl~¢oysai,p8pjxOhjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uyik}pjŽxmƒ p<haiabpj\~aoa,p‚k}ªaF

a`n~k}_b| ªa“mŽŒmaiƒS«ƒ haF3pt«xŠƒW‰;r,®76!km‚\Sp‚k}¢ ªa$4n( / ­h»~a`vt«ŒŠai ¨©vtxm_.pj\a`xmvtvjaFh|Dxmƒ~«ƒ~“Okmvjv‚k’r,0 /

¢Irvjai| ªkŠ,Žƒ~“0pj\~a%hjli,aihthj«ŒŠa4xoi,l~vtvjaiƒ,aFhZx}¨QaikŠ‚\ptxm£maiƒ$8{Žƒ¬,x ªl~_bƒ2:ž\~aivja+8Okm|~|KaFk}v‚h{ož«pj\

ƒa`ž hjrI_¢Dx ªh>O #8&EDo- &)O #8 &’-d& &)O #8&‹Hki‹-#{#ž\~aivja /! {Žƒ pj\~­h8xmv‚oaivi®0[]\~a haF¸Xl~a`ƒXpj­k ª

|vjxo,aFhjhjaihÃk}vta]pj\~aiƒoa, Kƒ~ai kŠhQ¨©x ª«ªx&žh`®96ÃkŠ‚\b ~¨©xƒ~a`pg“Š«ŒŠaihQvtŽhjaptx»kmhw_bkmƒIr»|~vtxo,aFhjhjaih5%;:`#8-

½ ¾½æÁ

(12)

kŠh4pj\~aivjakmvja0pjxŠ£maiƒh 8 «ƒTHkij®=~xŠv8aikm‚\pjxŠ£maiƒ,8 hpjxŠvjaFk}p€Žƒ~«pj­k

ª

7yFk&pt«xŠƒŽƒShxŠ_0ab¢~lDaiv

X

pÀž¡pt\ pjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ<O k&p€pj\~axŠlopj|lop r#{%;:`#8|-€­h4pj\~a `rI

ª

­b|~vtxo,aihth pj\k}p%¡pta`v‚k&ptaih€a`ƒK

ª

aFhjh

ª

r¬pj\~a

 Kƒ~¡pta%haF¸Xl~a`ƒ`a8x}¨Qkm,pjŽxmƒhkŠhZ¨©x ªŽª

x&žhR{~ž\~aivjaRr! ‹Hci,‹okmƒAhaF,xŠƒhjl~¢ht,vtŽ|opthkmvja8oa` ƒ~aF

_bxool ªx0pj\~a8ƒIl~_»¢KaivH x}¨#ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒh]x}¨|g 2

ox O #8&EDB-

O uq#8 &EDB-

O

uq#8 &EDB-

O ’#8&’-

O u #8 &’-

O u #8 &’-

O ’#8&,r-

O u #8 &,r-

O u #8 &,r- xo

[]\a ,x ªŽªai3pt«xŠƒxm¨Zk ª«ª |vjxo,aFhjhjaih>%;:`#8|-Wp8

Y

SuD’& Gr{#`xm_b|DxŠhjai«ƒ |kmvtk ª«ªa ª kmƒhjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uy`aF

kŠ``xmv‚o«ƒ“Apjx¬pt\~avtx&žh8x}¨]pt\~ahjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uyik}pjŽxmƒ ptkm¢ ªaFh14‡( / p:O

Y

(sr#{:¢Kai\k’ŒmaFh%Žƒoa`aF ªŽ£mapj\~a

u:a`pjvtƒ~a,pžg kmh]žZa8h\~x&ž«ƒpt\~a8ƒ~a,nIpqhjai,pjŽxmƒ®

"8*`1, 1,-.1` *,"€1`%

œ

ahj\~x&ž  v‚hsp%pt\k&p0a`ŒŠa`vtrO vt«ƒ“ haF¸Xl~a`ƒ`a x}¨]pt\~a'en$#ƒ~a`plg _k’r¢Dahj«_»l

ª

k&pjaFS¢Ir kOvjl~ƒSxm¨

pt\~ahrIƒ‚\vjxŠƒ~7yiai |~vjxo`aihthaFh/%;:`#8|-€|~vtxool,Žƒ~“pj\~ahtk}_ba0pjv‚km`a&p<k&¨æpjaiv8vjai| ªkm,Žƒ~“ž¡pt\TO4k ªŽª pj\~a

xoi,l~vtvjaiƒ,aFh]x}¨whjrXƒK‚\~vjxŠƒ~Uy`aikm,pjŽxmƒh¨©vjxŠ_ aFkm‚\ptkm¢ ªa 4‡( /r,® œ a»hj\~x&žMƒ~a,nIppt\k&p a`Œmaivjrvjl~ƒ¬xm¨

pt\~a€hrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ7yiai|~vtxo,aFhjhjaih%;:`#8-Z_k’r¢Da4hjŽ_l ªk&ptai ¢Ir k vt«ƒ~“bhjai¸Xl~a`ƒK,a4x}¨pt\~aeB#_8ƒa,p5g

ž«pj\ pj\~a€hjkm_bapjv‚km`am® ¹ hr*#ug-Í­hw­oa`ƒXpj­`k ª ž\a,pj\a`v‡gŽhZhaia`ƒkŠhÃk% ~¨©xƒ~a`p!xŠvÃ~xmpR{ok}ƒxŠ¢XŒIŽxmlh

`xmƒ ªlKhŽxmƒ¨©x ªŽªx&žhi®

ºqx&žW¨©xŠv:pj\~a] v‚hpQhjŽ_l ªk&pt«xŠƒ®

¹

hwk4|~vta ª«_bŽƒk}vtr%vta`_k}vt£{&xm¢hja`vtŒma!pj\k}pÃk4“mŽŒma`ƒbkm,pjŽxmƒtO #8&C-

xoi,l~v‚ha,n~km,p ªr8xmƒ`aZŽƒ»pj\~a,ro ª­Z|~vjxo`aihth%;:`#8-Qkmƒ%a`nokŠ3p ªr%xŠƒ,aZŽƒ»pt\~ahrIƒ‚\vjxŠƒ~7yFk&pt«xŠƒ8ptkm¢ ªa

4n(/t®96Ãkm‚\km,pjŽxmƒ‘O #8 &C-:ž«pj\0pjxŠ£maiƒ(8x&žƒ~aF¢Ir8pt\~aƒ~a,p g ,xŠƒIŒma`roh|~vtai,­hja ªr8pj\~aŽƒo¨©xŠvj_k&pt«xŠƒ

pt\k&ppj\~apjxm£Ša`ƒ 8VŽh\„x&ž«ƒ“¬¨©xmvpj\~a$

/

pt«_ba pt\~vtxml~“Š\ pj\~apjv‚k}ƒhj¡pt«xŠƒO{Qž\~a`vta ­h,xŠl~ƒXpjaF

_bxool ªx ‹Hki,‹¡®56ÃkŠ‚\|~vtxo,aFhjh%;:`#8-oaFhj`vjŽ¢Daih«ƒpj\~­h:ž]k’r pt\~a!pjv‚k’Œma ª x}¨pj\~aZpjxŠ£maiƒ 80pj\~vtxml~“Š\

pt\~aptvtkmƒh«pjŽxmƒKh€x}¨]pj\~aƒ~a,p/gŽƒ k}ƒIr vtl~ƒ x}¨]pt\~a ~¨©xOƒa,p/g ®6Ãkm‚\ p‚k}¢ ªa 4‡( / {ž\a`ƒ ŒI«aiž!aF

kŠh kmƒOŽ_0|

ª

­,«p€hjai¸Xl~aiƒXpj­k

ª

k}ƒO`ro

ª

Ž|~vjxo`aihth{Da`ƒ`xooaih4hŽ_b

ª

k}v

ª

rpt\~a»|vjxmysai3pt«xŠƒOx}¨ÃkmƒIrvtl~ƒOxm¨

pt\~a» ~¨©xƒa,pg xmƒ¬ptvtkmƒhj¡pt«xŠƒ8O3®+6Ãkm‚\O vjŽƒ~“AhaF¸Xl~a`ƒ`axm¨Qpj\~a0 ~¨©xƒ~a,p]gîpt\~a`vta,¨©xŠvja%ŽƒolK,aih4¢Ir

|vjxmysai3pt«xŠƒkbhjrXƒK‚\~vjxŠƒ~Uy`aivtl~ƒxm¨k ª«ª |vjxo,aFhjhjaih'%;:`#8|-]ž«pj\¬k}ƒŽ~a`ƒXpj­`k ª pjv‚km`am®

‚¥¨:ž!a8\Kkm«ƒXpjvtxool`aixmƒ~a€_bxmvta8haF¸Šla`ƒXpj­k ª |~vtxo,aFhjhZ|Da`vp‚k}¢ ªa 4‡( / { ªa,p

%;:`#:O)-! ox 4‡( / SuD

4‡( / S

4‡( / S #xo {

kmƒ hjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uy`aFAa`ŒŠa`vtrAkŠ3pt«xŠƒ,4‡( / S:¨©vtxm_ aikŠ‚\ |~vtxo,aFhjh/%;:Ž#O)- ž¡pt\ k ª«ª km,pjŽxmƒhlO #8&C-¨©vtxm_

pt\~a]|~vtxI`aihthaFh%;:`#8-Qhjl‚\»pj\k}p 4n( / S|!;# J&,O #8 &C-d&-{Šk4`xmƒIŒmaivthja!hjŽ_l ªk&pt«xŠƒx}¨Kpj\~ahjrohspta`_

xm¨wk ªŽª |~vtxo,aihthjaih%;:`#8|-qkmƒZ%;:`#:O)-q¢Xrpj\a8 ~¨©x ƒ~a`pg žZxml ªA«_b_bai~Žk}pja ªr¨©x ªŽªx&ž2]haF¸Xl~a`ƒ`aihxm¨

kŠ3pt«xŠƒhxm¨opj\~aZhrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ7yiai€|~vtxo,aihthjaihžZxml ª€vtaikm8~«vtai,p ªr€kŠh vtŽƒ~“ hjai¸Xl~aiƒ,aFhx}¨opt\~aw ¨©xqƒ~a`pg ®

|qx&ž!aiŒmaivR{IžZa8|~vja`¨©a`v\a`vta8«ƒXpjaivj|vja`pjŽƒ~“0ptk}¢ ªaFh'4‡( / kŠhw#`Zxm¨:hjrIƒ‚\~vtxmƒ~Uyik}pjŽxmƒŒŠai,pjxmv‚hR{~oa, ƒ«ƒ~“

pt\~aysxŠ«ƒXp8km,pjŽxmƒhqx}¨wpt\~a|~vtxo,aFhjhjaih/%;:Ž#8- ž«pj\~xŠlop4Ž_b|KxXhŽƒ~“/"A8@8:k}ƒIrAhaF¸Šla`ƒXpj­k ª xmv‚oa`vtŽƒ~“

¢Da,psžZa`aiƒpj\aÃysxŠ«ƒXpZkŠ3pt«xŠƒh!~a, ƒ~aFŽƒaikŠ‚\bptkm¢ ªa+4‡( / ®:[]\a4hjrohspta`_ l~ƒoaivZ`xmƒhj­oa`v‚k&pt«xŠƒŽhÃpj\Ilh

|vjaF,­ha ªr pj\~a

¹

vjƒx ªI¤¥ºq«Œ&k}p%|~vjxoolK3pxm¨k ª«ª |~vjxo`aihthaFhR%;:Ž#8-ž¡pt\ pj\~avjx&žh8xm¨]k ª«ª ptkm¢ ªaFh(4‡( /

¾¾ օ~Ԇ‚Ó‡

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to