On Distributed Program Specification and Synthesis in Architecture with Cycles

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00306412

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00306412

Submitted on 25 Jul 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

On Distributed Program Specification and Synthesis in Architecture with Cycles

Julien Bernet, David Janin

To cite this version:

Julien Bernet, David Janin. On Distributed Program Specification and Synthesis in Architecture

with Cycles. Internationnal Conference on Formal Methods for Networked and Distributed Systems

(FORTE), Sep 2006, France. pp.175-190. �hal-00306412�

(2)

!" #$ %#&$ #

'()*+,-./0123/4561 )7261(89 +,

:;<,=782361>( >/?52(4/7.,

@A::BC;,D(>1.=1 E1619,@ 2(.=1

FGHIGJ

KLMINIOPMFHN

QRH

STUVWXYVZ

+.4[/3\(\12,]1=7.3/6126/3=21416/342/?84163^.4[13/3\27?A

>1_3,(3 61`.16 ?^ a.81>/ (.6 *73.12 b<cd, 7. \733/?>^ =^=>/= (2=[/41=A

48213]/4[ e127A61>(^ 31_(.4/=3(.6 f>7?(> 3\1=/`=(4/7.3g

h1613=2/?1(8./i72_ j (.6=7_\>141k42(.3>(4/7. 7i4[131\27?>1_3/.47

6/342/?8416 f(_13 \27?>1_3g h1 \2701 4[1 =7221=4.133 7i 4[/3 42(.3>(A

4/7. (.6 ]1 (>377?4(/.,/.4[/33144/.f,(=[(2(=412/e(4/7. 7i 6/342/?8416

(2=[/41=48213]/4[ 61=/6(?>1 3^.4[13/3\27?>1_3g

+4 3[(>> ?1 .7416 4[(4, (3 7\\7316 47 i72_12 (\\27(=[13,e127A61>(^ 31A

_(.4/=3 21l8/213 ( 3\1=/`= 421(4_1.4 i72 _761>/.f /.34(.4(.1783 0(>81

\27\(f(4/7.g m7217012, =^=>/= 61\1.61.=/13 ]/4[ e127A61>(^ 31_(.4/=3

/.07>01 1l8(4/7.3 ]/4[ \741.4/(>>^ _(.^ 37>84/7.3g n==726/.f>^, 31012(>

0(2/(.437i 4[1 6/342/?8416 3^.4[13/3\27?>1_ (21 \27\7316 (.6 3486/16g

opqrstuvqwsp

x"yz#"{y!|z}#"yz#"{|~"||y!y!#z|!yz |{{#"y|#|

y!y # {# !|#!{ y# y!z#z"y$|

"{y""y$|"!"$$|{!"&"||~|"z|#$y|!#&

y y " !|" #|"!#{" $"y| y "| !yz!y&$ "| !# ${$}

#"~#$ {#!#{"!$ # ${$#{#||y!yz|$|"!"$ |~"||y

" #!{"{"!

{ " $|"!"$ !y!#z |~"|| #| !{&$ # y" y #"""y

" !#zy!$$ ~ #$ y|! {y"!y "y!~

y! " !#zy! y "! {y{!!{~ #~ &#!#"y| y "|

!yz #& {y|$!$ #$ |y&$ {~{{ y! #{~{{ #!{"{"!| !yz

|~{!yy| "y #|~{!yy| {yzz{#"y| "!#&$ y! "! {y{!!"

zy$|" y! "y" !y}$#~|z#"{| " y" "y y" y! !y#${#|"

{yzz{#"y {#|

!yz # "y!"{# y" y & |y& # $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz }

! !y!#z|"y |~"|$ y~#& y{# y$y" y# |"#"

y" |~|"z } #zy"|"y |y& # z"#~!#z"#!"# y!z#"y

| !# !yz #| $$ #$ |"$$ #!#$~

y!!{"~# !# y"!|" y! $|"!"$ |~"|| #|$ "y # |}

{#$&!|y yz"#~! #z| ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ §¨©¦¡"#" #z|#" $ #

(3)

|y&$ #!"{#!"|#z|#& $"&#!y|#"yz#"#

#|$ "yy| "#" "|!y{||

"|#!!|"#z #" |"!#""!&#{y"|~ #!y#{

~ & # {#!y!z #${yz"!${"y y $|"!"$ |~"||!y}

z| "y $|"!"$ #z| x| # |y# {" "| !${"y "y }

{" y" " || "#" ${$# {#|| #! |"!{"~ !|!&$ #$ "

|| "#" " {yz"~ y |y& "| !yz| $y| y" {!#| "!y

" !${"y

y!$! "y $y |y |"$~ " $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz " {#|

y #!{"{"!| " {~{| !y}$#~ |z#"{| #$ !#{ "z y#

|{{#"y| "| {#| #| y" {y|$!$ |y #! " y{{!| "#" !y}

$#~ |z#"{| ! ! # |{{ "!#"z" y! zy$ |"#"#y| &#

!y##"y y!y&! {~{{ $${| " !y}$#~ |z#"{| &y&

#"y| " y""#~ z#~ |y"y|x{{y!$~ |&!# &#!#"| y "

$|"!"$ |~"||!yz #!!yy|$ #$ |"$$

!&#{y|"$~ {~{{ #!{"{"!" !y}$#~ |z#"{|!|"

{yz|!yz $"#{!{"|$|#||"!#"$y!|"#{~"{#||{#

y "||""yz#~{y|$!"|y|y#!$#!%|{!"y

##| |{ #| % " zy$| y! #"yz#"{ !y!#z |~"||

"$~ !y}$#~ |z#"{| #|y z#||| #" " #{#"y &

&|"#" !"!zy! " !&#{ y "| #!y#{ &#!y| #}

{#"y $| "{yzz{#"y y! |!&{| $|"!"$ $#"##| y!

#!# |{"{ {yz" "{ | y&! y" " !y| y "| #!

yy #$ y|! y!# y!| #$ zy"&#"y| |"{ "y #

& y #|"!#{"y "#" | #{#"y $$"

!| ""$y" "#" #{#"yy#"yz#"{ $|"!"$ |~"|||"

! !| # y" zy! !|#!{ y!"| y! " y" !{! ${$# !#z}

y!| #$ zy!"!#{"# |y"y|

x

zy$y!y}$#~|~{!yy|#&y!||!|"$"!|"|{"y

#!{"{"!" {~{| " | |y "#" y# #&y!| z#~ y" ~

$$ ~ |"| y y{# #&y!|x{{y!$~"! &#!#"|y" $|"!"$

|~"|| !yz #!$$"#{" |"!{" #$ " $zy{ &#!#"

y"y y !#!{{# #!{"{"!|| $$ #$ |"$$ " |{y$

|{"y " | &#" "y # |z#! y"y $$ ! z# !|" |

" |"#"$" #{ #$ |"!{" &#!#" y " $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz

" #!"!#!~ |{{#"y #! ${$# #$ y~ " $!~

#!{"{"!| !#!{{#

x !yyy"|"y!z |&"y!"#!"y!!{|~#"!!~

!& "$"y y$|"!"$#z|!y&"#"y" &#!#"|y"

(4)

${$# " $!~ #!{"{"! | !#!{{#

yz y !yz| #! !|"$ #|# {y{|y

x

y!$ y # ##"

A

^|^# ^#!"# ^{"y

w : ω → A

^" ^$y^#!$}^{y^|$

$yz#

w(i)

^|^"

i + 1

^" ""! y y!$

w

d om(w)

^| ^" ^|#~

w

^| ^# ^" ^y^!$ ^y"!^|

w

^| ^# ^" ^y^!$ ^"

|w|

^y ^# ^y^!$

w

| " {#!$#"~ y "| $yz# |" y " y!$| !|" y z"~

y!$| y&! ##"

A

^| !""

A ^∗

^!|

A ⁺

^" ^|" ^y ^" ^y^!$| ^|

!""

A ^ω

^" ^|" ^y^" ^y^!^" ^y^!$|^|!""

A ^∞

^z^"~^y!^$^|

!""

ε

^{y^{#"^#"y ^y ^# ^y!$

u ∈ A ^∗

^#$ ^# ^y^!$

v ∈ A ^∞

^| !""

u.v

& ##"

B

^#

B

^}^#^$

A

^}"! ^| ^# ^#^!"# ^{"y

t : A ^∗ → B

^"

!}{y|$ $yz#

& "y |"|

A

^#$

B

^!"

π A

!|

π B

y! " " !| !"

!y{"y !yz

A × B

^"y

A

^!| ^!yz

A × B

^"y

B

^| ^y"#"y| #!

"$$ "y #~ ||"y

A × B

^#^$ ^y^!$| ^y

A × B

^&

P ⊆ A × B

^!|

w ∈ (A × B) ^∞

^z^#~ ^#|y ^!"

P [1]

^y^!

π A (P )

^#^$

P [2]

^y^!

π B (P)

^!|

w[1]

^y!

π A (w)

^#^$

w[2]

^y^!

π B (w)

^| ^y"#"y| #! !#$ "y #!!

!y${"|

wqrw uqt rsr pqw wq rs

pqwv

"| |{"y !!#| #$ y|!| $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz

y! !y}$#~ |z#"{| #$ #!"!#!~ } y||~ {~{{ } #!{"{"!| "|

{y""#&y!|z#"{| #$#!{"{"! |"!{"!|#!|"$$ #$"!!}

#"$ y" " y"!

!y!#z| {y|$!$ "| #! !y${ # | { y y"" &"| !yz #

| { y " &"| #||z zy!y&! "#" !y!#z| #! ¡ £!!¥¡

#$ "¦£!#¦$¨y y"" &" | !y${$ !y!"y #~ "&" #$ &!~

" &" !y${|y #$ y~ yy"" &"

%&

'

|~{!yy| !y}$#~ #&y! ( ¢ )¥¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

A

^¨

!¥¢)¥¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

B

^¡ ^¨ ^©^¨)⁾^§

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^¡¥ ^¢^¨^¢ ^¢^¦£¦ ^{¦ *}^¡^¢¡ ^¨ ^©^¨))^§

k f : A ^∗ → (A → B)

⁺ ^¨^$$¦ ^¢^¦ ^! ^!,

f

^¡¥ ^¢^¨¢

f (ε) = ε

^¨⁺ ^,^!£ ^¦-¦£

u ∈ A ^∗

^¨

a ∈ A

⁺

f (u.a) = f (u).k f (u)(a)

^.

/ ¢ ¦£¦©¨ ¦£ !, ¢ ¦ ¢¦ *¢

+

¨ ¡ £!!¥¡ "¦£!#¦$¨ ¤¦ ¨- !£

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

¡ ¡ ©)$ ¨$$¦ ¨ | "# {"y ¨

+

,!£ ¦-¦£

u ∈ A ^∗

⁺

k f (u) : A → B

^¡

¨$$¦ ¢ ¦ y}|" #&y! !, ,¥¢ !

f

^¨,^¢¦£ ⁾^¥¢

u

^.

(5)

'

¡¦ ¥¦¢ ¨$,¥¢ !

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^¨¡ ^" ^z^z^y^!~ ⁽ ^¦ ^¢¡ ^¦£^¦$

k f : A ^∗ → (A → B)

^¡ ^¦-¦¢¥^¨$^$ ⁾^¦£^!⁺ ^.^¦^. ^¢^¦£¦ ^¨£¦ ^¡!^©^¦ ^¢^¦§^¦£¡

m

^¨

n

¡¥ ¢ ¨¢

+

,!£ ¦-¦£

u ∈ A ^∗

⁽^¢

|u| > m

⁺ ^,^!£ ^¦-¦£

v ∈ A ^∗

⁽^¢

|v| = n

⁺

k f (u.v) = k f (u)

^.

{# #|~ {{ "#" #{ | "# {"y #| # ! #$

{y&!|~ #{ z#

k : A ^∗ → (A → B)

^| ^" ^! ^y ^# ^|}

"# {"y {~ y! |~"| | "# {"y| "| #zy"|

"y |{~ #$ |~"| "! !|y!y&!|{!| #!"

A → B

^}#^$

A

^}"!| ^y^#^${ ^{y^$ ^!$! ^y^{ ^} ^y^! ^#~ ^y ^"|

| y{| |{ #| y! " z}{#{| } | #&## y! |{{#"y

!y|| #$ " !#"$ " "!}#"yz#"# "y!~ {# #$ y!

|~"|| #y!"z|

xy"! "!|" {#!#{"!|"{y"|y"y y ! |{#~ y! $|}

"!"$ |~"|| | " yy$ #&y! y !| !" {"y {yzy|"y

|{ |yz || " {yzz"| " " y! !{|~ !"

f ; g

^y^! ^"

{yzy|"y

g ◦ f

^y^!^# ^| ^"#^{"y^|

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^#$

g : B ^∗ → C ^∗

^#^$

y!&!~ " | {

u ∈ A ^∗

^y^#^|

k f;g (u) = k f (u); k g (f (u))

y"! y!$|"y}|" #&y!y" | "# {yzy|"y y{}

"y

f

^" ^{"y

g

^#"! ^|yz^"z^|^|" ^" ^| ^"^# ^{yz^y^|"y ^y^"

y}|" #&y!|y

f

^" ^" ^" ^|" ^#&y^!^y

g

^#"! ^" ^|#z ^#^z^y^"

y"z

" |"" $$ ~ # y|! #$ {y|$!$

|| " y!| # | "# #&y!

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^| ^!#^"$ ^~

#

A

^}^!#^{

B

^}#^$

A

^}"!

h f : A ^∗ → B

^" ^!!&#^" ^!y^y^" ^&# ^~

f (ε) = ε

^#^$ ^y^! ^&!~

u ∈ A ^∗

^#^$

a ∈ A

f (u.a) = f (u).h f (u.a)

^"^| ^z^y^$

y!&!~

u ∈ A ⁺

h f (u) ∈ B

^|^" ^#^|"^y^"^"^!y^$^{$ ^#"! ^" ^| ^{

u

" |# {#! "#" "| "y #!y#{| #! &#" " || "#"

"~ y"$"|#z| "#{"y|y&!$# ""#""!

$"y | z{ #!$! {yzy| {"y| #{" y! # | "#

{"y|

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^#^$

g : B ^∗ → C ^∗

^#^$ ^y! ^&!~ ^" ^| ^{

u ∈ A ^∗

y #|

h f;g (u) = h g (f (u))

^| ^$^{"~ ^"#^| ^y^! ^|"#^{ ^" ^#^!y^#{

!|"$ # ¨¡ £!!¥¡{y$y ¡ £!!¥¡$|"!"$|~"||

!yz| "y $|"!"$ #z| | |yzy #!"{# #|~{!y|z | y"

{||#!~ #| |y "!|" #!

x

| "#{"y|~$"y!y}$#~

"

{#!y&$

# |z#"{# $"y y# y}$#~ #&y!x | "# {"y

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

^| ^!^¦ ^¦$¨^¦ ^y^! ^&!~

u ∈ A ^∗

^&!~

a 1

#$

a 2 ∈ A

f (u.a 1 ) = f (u.a 2 )

^" ^y"" &" !y${$ #"! # & " &" y~ $$|

y " !&y|" &"|

|!&"#" y}$#~| "#{"y|#&# &!~ |z{#!#{"!#}

"y"!z|y"!{"y#!#{"#| "#{"y

f : A ^∗ → B ^∗

| y}$#~ #$ y~ y! &!~

u ∈ A ^∗

^" ^y}|" ^#&^y!

k f (u)

^| ^#

{y|"#" {"y

(6)

! $"y y $|"!"$ #!{"{"! | #$#"$ !yz #$ y|!|

$"y #y |!"z"!#$ {#| #|

%

&

' $|"!"$ #!{"{"!

H

^¡ ^¦^¦ ^¨¡ ^¨ ^{¢¥ )}^$¦

H = hI, S, r, {A c } c∈I∪S i,

( ¢ ¨ ¢¦ ¡¦¢

I

^!, ^§^$!¤¨^$ ⁾^¥¢ ^¨^¦$¡⁺ ^¨ ^¡^! ¢ ^¢^¦ ^¡^¦¢

S

^!, ⁾^£!¦¡¡

¡ ¢¦¡ ¦¢ ¦ ( ¢ !¥¢)¥¢ ¨

¦$¡

+

¨ ©¨)) §

r : S → P(I ∪ S )

^¢^¨¢ ^©^¨)^¡

¦-¦£)£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

^¢! ^¢^¦^¡¦¢ ^!, ^¨^¦$¡

r(p)

⁽^¦£¦⁾^£!¦¡¡

p

^£¦¨ ⁾^¥¢ ^-¨^$¥^¦¡⁺

¨

+

,!£ ¦-¦£ ¨¦$

c ∈ I ∪ S

⁺ ^¢^¦^¢¦ ^¨$) ^¨^¤¦¢

A c

!, )!¡¡ ¤$¦ ¦-¦¢¡ !

¨¦$

c

^.

¦ ¨$(¨¡ ¨¡¡¥©¦ ¢ ¨¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢¡ ¨£¦ )¨ £( ¡¦ ¡! ¢

.

¦ ¨$¡! ¨$(¨¡ ¨¡#

¡¥©¦ ¢ ¨¢

I ⊆ S

{r(p) : p ∈ S}

⁺ ^.^¦^. ^¨ ⁾^¥¢ ^¡ ^£¦¨ ^¤ ^¨¢ ^$¦¨¡¢ ^!^¦⁾^£!¦¡¡^.

'¡ ¨ !¢¨¢ !

+

(¦ (£ ¢¦

A

^,^!£ ^¢^¦ ^¨^$) ^¨¤¦¢ ^!, ^¨$$ ⁾^!¡^¡ ¤$¦ ^¨^¦$ ^¦-¦^¢¡ ^¨¢

¨ § -¦ ¢ ©¦

+

.

¦

.

A = Π c∈I∪S

^.

!£ ¦-¦£ ¡¦¢

!,

¨¦$¡

X ⊆ I ∪ S

⁺ ⁽^¦ ^(£^¢^¦

A X

,

!£ ¢ ¦)£!¥¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

Π c∈X A c

^.

/ )¨£¢ ¥$¨£

+

A r(p)

¡ ¢ ¦ )¥¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

!,

)£!¦¡¡

p

^! ^¢^¦ ^{¤ §§}^¦£ ^¨^¦$^,^!£^©^¦ ^¤ ^¨$^$ ^¨^¦$¡ ^!,

r(p)

^.

-¦ ¨ ¡¦ ¥¦¦

w ∈ A ⁺

^!, ^¨^¦$ ⁾^¥^¢^!^¥¢)^¥¢ ^¦-¦¢¡ ^¢^¦ ^¨£^#

¢¦¢¥£¦

H

⁺ ⁽^¦ ⁽^£ ¢¦

in (w)

^,^!£ ^¢^¦ ^!£^£¦¡)^!^§ ^¡¦ ^¥¦¦ ^!, ^¦-^¦^¢¡

π A I (w)

^!

¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦ )¥¢ ¨¦$¡ ¨ (¦ (£ ¢¦

out (w)

^,^!£ ^¢^¦ ^!££¦¡)^!^§ ^¡^¦ ^¥¦^¦

!, ¦-¦¢¡

π A S (w)

^! ^¨£^¢¦¢¥£¦ ^!¥¢)^¥¢ ^¨^¦$¡^. ^©^$¨£$⁺ ^,^!£ ^¦-¦£ ⁾^£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺⁽^¦^¨$¡^!⁽^£ ¢¦

in _p (w)

^,^!^£^¢^¦^!£^£¦¡)^!^§^¡^¦ ^¥¦¦^!, ^¦-¦¢¡

π A r(p) (w)

^!

)£!¦¡¡

p

⁾^¥¢ ^¨^¦$¡⁺ ^¨

out _p (w)

^,^!£ ^¢^¦ ^!££¦¡)^!^§ ^¡^¦ ^¥^¦^¦ ^!, ^¦-¦^¢¡

π A p (w)

^! ⁾^£!¦¡¡

p

^!¥^¢)^¥¢ ^#^.

'

¡¨)¨£¢ ¥$¨£ ¨¡¦

+

( ¦

r(p) = ∅

⁺⁽^¦^¦^¦

A r(p)

¢! ¤¦¨¡ §$¦¢! ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

+

¡¨

A r(p) = {1}

⁺⁽^¢⁺ ^¢^¡ ^¨¡^¦⁺

in _p (w) = 1 ^|w|

^. ^¦^¢¥ ¢ ! ^¤¦ ^¢^¡ ^¨¡¦

¡ ¢ ¨¢

+

( ¢ ! )¥¢ ¨¦$¡

+

¨ )£!¦¡¡ ¡¢ $$ £¦¦ -¦¡ ¢ ©¦ $ ¡

.

y !y{|||"#" !#$ y" |#z|" y{#| #$"||#!

" |#zy!z#"y{# |#|# |!y{||"#"!"|y "y$|"{"

{#|

%

!|{ yyy|& !y}$#~ |z#"{|"y # $|"!"$ #!{"{"!|

#!y!y}"!&# yy#$ y|!"""&$#y$

"y $$|"!"$ #&y!y# #!{"{"!#| "y##&y!!|"

!yz " {yzy|"y y y{# | "# #&y!| y!!y{||

y&! " !y}$#~ |z#"{| yy| z#~ {!#" {~{{ $${|

" " &#| y " y"" {#| |~|"z| y #"y| "#" z#~

#& |&!# |y"y| !y y y! zy! y# #&y!| z#~ {yz#"

"#&|"yy{##&y!|y|$!y!|"#{"|~|"z $!#y

! " "}#$ !y{|| !| !"}#$ !y{|| !"| #" #{ "z "

y{# !|

x

% y " #|" &#| " !#$| y "| "y "| y|

(7)

y "#" " &# y

x

^|

0

^|y^!"

x = 0

^#^$ ^"#^"

y = 1

^y ^{#

"! #&

a = 0

^#^$

b = 0

^y^!

a = 1

^#^$

b = 1

^{ ^"! ^#^! ^|&!# ^y^#

#&y!| {y!!|y$ "y "| |" yy{# #&y!|

∨ ∧

x a y

b

| " y"y y $|"!"$ !##"y y # y# #&y! $$ ~

#$ y|! | y y! {"y#

%&

¦¢

H = hI, S, r, {A c } c∈I∪S i

^¤¦^¨ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

. '

y#

#&y!

f : A ^∗ _I → A ^∗ _S

^!, ^¨^{£ ¢¦¢¥£¦}

H

^¡ ^!#^# ^¤ ^¨ ^¡¦¢ ^!, ^y^{#^#&y^!|

f p : A ^∗ _r(p) → A _p ^∗

⁺^!^¦⁾^¦£⁾^£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺⁽ ^¦ ^¢^¦^,^!$^$!(^§ ^!^¢ ! ^¡ ^¡¨^¢ ¡^¦

,

!£ ¦-¦£ §$!¤¨$ )

¥¢

!¥¢)¥¢

u ∈ A ^∗

⁽^¢

out (w) = f ( in (w))

⁺^,^!£ ^¦-^¦£

p ∈ S

⁺ ^!^¦ ^¨¡

out _p (w) = f p ( in _p (w))

^.

¦¡¦¢

!,

$!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡

{f _p } p∈S

¡ {y!"

£¦¡)

.

#zy

|

( ¦ ¢ £¦¨$#

"¦¡ !

£¦¡)

.

©!£¦¢ ¨ !

¦

§$!¤¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£

.

y!$!"y |y&$|"!"$ |~"|| !yz $ # zy!y{# $}

"y y!## #&y!

%

&

' y# y}|" #&y!

k : A I → A S

¡ y}|" !#$ ¤ ¨ ¡¦¢

!,

y{# y}|" #&y!|

k p : A r(p) → A p

⁺

!¦)¦£ )£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺ ⁽ ^¦ ^¢^¦^,^!$^$!(^§ ^!^¢ ! ^¡ ^¡¨^¢ ¡^¦

,!£ ¦-¦£ §$!¤¨$ )¥

¢

!¥¢)¥¢ ¦-¦¢¡

a ∈ A

⁺ ^¡¥ ^¢^¨¢

out (a) = k( in (a))

⁺

!¦ ¨¡

+

,!£ ¦-¦£)£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺

out _p (a) = k p ( out _p (a))

^.

'

¡¦¢ !, $!¨$ !¦#¡¢¦) ¤¦ ¨- !£

{k p } p∈S

¡ ¨$$¦ {y!" £¦¡)

.

#zy

|

( ¦ ¢ £¦¨$ "¦¡ ! £¦¡)

.

©!£¦ ¢ ¨ !

¦

§$!¤¨$ !¦#¡¢¦) ¤¦ ¨- !£

.

!yz "| $"y y z#~ "z"$ "y !$ !##

y##&y!|#|| "#{"y|

f : A ^∗ _I → A ^∗ _S

^|^{^"^#"^y^!^&!~

u ∈ A ^∗ _I

" y}|" y# #&y!

k f (u)

^#^| ^# ^y^}^|" ^!##"^y

y!"#"~ |{ # $"y y$ !y #| " y$ z|| " #{"

"#"y!&!~!y{||

p

^#"! ^#~^| ^{^y^y^#^"y""

w ∈ A ^∗

^"

out (w) = f ( in (w))

^"^y^}|"^#&y^!^y^&!~^!y^{||

p

^{#^y^~^$^$^y

" " | {

in _p (w)

^#{"#^~ ^!#^$ ^~ ^!y^{||

p

y" $"y| y y}|" #$ !# !##"~ #! |" !#"$ #| y}

y|

'

y##&y!

f : A ^∗ _I → A ^∗ _S

^!, ^¨£^¢^¦¢¥£¦

H

^¡ ^!#^# ^¤ ^¨

¡¦¢ !, y{# #&y!|

f p : A ^∗ _r(p) → A ^∗ _p

⁺ ^!^¦⁾^¦£⁾^£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺^, ^¨ ^!$ ^,⁺^,^!^£

¦-¦£ §$!¤¨$ )¥

¢

!¥¢)¥¢ ¡¦ ¥¦¦ !, ¦-¦¢¡

w ∈ A ^∗

⁽^¢

out (w) = f ( in (w))

⁺

¢ ¦ ¡¦¢ !, !¦#¡¢¦) $!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡

{k f p ( in _p (w))} p∈S

£¦¨$ "¦¡ ¢ ¦ §$!¤¨$ !¦#¡¢¦)

¤¦ ¨- !£

k f ( in (w))

^.

(8)

£!!,

.

y! #~

w ∈ A ^∗

^y! ^#~

v ∈ A

^"

f ( in (w.v)) = out (w.v)

^y^! ^#^~

!y{||

p ∈ S

^y ^#^|

f p ( in _p (w.v)) = out _p (w.v)

^"^|

k f p ( in _p (w))( in _p (v)) = out _p (w). out _p (v)

{

f p ( in _p (w)) = out _p (w)

^"^|^{#!^"#^"^"^y^#^y^}|"^#^&^y!

k f ( in (w))

|!#$~"|"yy{# y}|"#&y!|

{k f p ( in _p (w))} p∈S

{y&!|

| {#!~"!

|!& "#" y ¨$ #!{"{"! # |" y "¦£!#¦$¨ y{# }

#&y!| | ##~|{y!" #$ y #zy| |!&#|y "#" y ¨£¤ ¢£¨£

#!{"{"! # |" y !¦#¦$¨ y{# #&y!| | #|y ##~|{y!" #$ y

#zy|

%

$|"!"$ |~"|| !yz | " yy & # |{{#"y y #

{"$ y# #&y! $ # $|"!"$ !##"y y "

.

¦

.

# |" y y{#

#&y!|yy!#{!y{|||"|{"#""{y!!|y$y##&y!|

z" " |{{#"y

" #!"!#!~ !y}$#~ y{# #&y!| |&!# {#|| #! y|| |

#$| | "y {y|$!"! y|||z#"{| y! " |~"|| !yz

%& % -¦ ¨ ¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

H = hI, S, r, {A c } c∈I∪S i

⁺ ^§ -¦ ^¨ ^¡)^¦^¨¢ !

ϕ

^!, ^¡^¦ ^¥¦¢ ¨$ ^,^¥^¢ !^¡ ⁽^¢ ⁾^¥¢

¨$) ¨¤¦¢

A I

¨ !¥¢)¥¢ ¨$) ¨¤¦¢

A S

⁺

¢ ¦ ¨§¦$

+

¡¢£ ¢ !£

+

£¦¡)

.

¦©! ¡#

¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¡¢ ¦¡ ¡)£!¤$¦©

,

!£

hH, ϕi

^¡ ^¢^! ^¨ ^¡¦¢ ^!, ^¢^¦ ^©^¦©^!£ ^$!¨$ ^¡¦#

¥¦¢ ¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£

{f _p } p∈S

¡¥ ¢ ¨¢

#{ {#| ¢ ¦£¦ ¡ ¨¢ $¦¨¡¢ !¦,¥¢ !

f

£¦¨$ "¦ ¤

{f p } p∈S

¡¥ ¢ ¨¢

f | = ϕ

⁺

|"!{" {#| ¢ ¦£¦ ¡ ¨ ¥ ¥¦,¥¢ !

f

^£¦¨$ "^¦ ^¤

{f p } p∈S

¨

+

©!£¦!-¦£

+

f | = ϕ

⁺

!£

+

$zy{{#|¢ ¦¡¦¢!, $!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡

{f p } p∈S

¡ ! ¦£¦¢ ¨,!£ ¦-¦£

,

¥¢ !

f

^£¦¨$ "^¦ ^¤

{f p } p∈S

⁺

!¦ ¨¡

f | = ϕ

^.

""y $"|$"y||"yy " #{

{#|"!y!#zz!#|" yy!""~ "y #$$ "!# y~ z"${y}

"!y {#| " #!{"{"!"#" #y {y"!y y&!"{y{y"y#

#&y!"y!#$"|"!{"{#|"|"!# {y"!y {#|$|{!$

#y&#!y y!$$"#!{"{"!#$"y#|{{#"y#!!}

z||&y "y #y "! z{" {y$ " " #!{"{"! "|

#|" " $zy{{#|"!# {y"!y ||" y" #&##

|!&"#" # $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz "#" #| # |y"y " |"!{"

|z#"{| #|y #| # |y"y " $zy{ |z#"{| z# ||| #y"

"| "! |z#"{| | " ${$#"~ !yz

" y{{!| "#" #| |y " " |{"y y" #{ #$ |"!{" $|}

"!"$ |~"||!yz #!#|"y}$#~ y!" #{~{{{#|${$#

y#!{"{"!|{#$!#!{{#$zy{{#|!z#|#"!y

!yz

(9)

!&!"y"yyy$y#!y{||##!{"{"!|#$|

"y $!#!{{##!{"{"!#$"y |"#"y!z#!|""#{#$

|"!{" {#|

x |z#!y"y | $$ ~!#$ { y"#$"y &}

#" y"y| y !#!{{# #!{"{"!| y " {#|| y #!{"{"! {yzzy

"y y" #!y#{| y&! |{ "| y"y | |yzy |" #$ y! "

|#y {yz"|| & !y! y $"y #$ !#"$ ""y

%&

-¦

¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

H

^¨¡ ^¨¤!-¦⁺^,^!£ ^¦-¦£⁾^£!¦¡¡

p ∈ S

⁺⁽^¦^¦^¦

¢ ¦ y$ !, )£!¦¡¡

p

^¢! ^¤¦ ^¢^¦ !#"|" ¡¦¢ !, ¨¦$¡

K p ⊆ I ∪ S

^¡^¥

¢ ¨¢

,!£ ¨$$

q ∈ K p

⁺

¦ ¢ ¦£

q ∈ I

^¨

q ∈ r(p)

⁺ ^!^£

q ∈ S

⁽^¢

q 6= p

^¨

r(q) ⊆ K p

^.

¦ y$ !#"y

H

¡ ¢ ¦ ¦¦ !

S

^¢^! ^¤¦ ^¢^¦ ^£¦$¨¢ ! ^¦^¦ ^¤

p H q

⁽ ^¦

q ∈ K p

⁺

©¦¨ §

+ ,

!£©¨$$

+

¢ ¨¢ !y{||

p

^y""#~ y| zy! "# !y{||

q

^.

{#{{"#""y$!#"y

H

|# !y!$!"|!&

#$ "!#|"& " | !"

' H

y! " ${$ &#{!#"y

p ' H q

p H q

^#^$

q H p

x" &!~ zyz" # ! $|"!"$ #!{"{"! " ©©¦ ¨¢¦

!($¦§¦ y# !y{||

p

^|^|"^"^| ^{^y^"|^"^|^!{& ^y ^{^#^|

y

r(p)

^#^$ ^" ^| ^{ ^y ^y^"^"| ^" ^| ^!y^${ ^y ^{^#

p

^"$$

z# y "y$!#"y | "y {#"! # y"y y ¦¥ ¤$¦ !($¦§¦

!y{||

p

^z^#~^#&^!y^z ^"| ^y ^z^z^$#^"^y^$

yy zz# &| # |z#"{# {#!#{"!#"y y " y$

!#"y $$ #y&

!£ ¦-¦£ )£!¦¡¡

p

⁺

K p

¡ ¢ ¦ ¡¦¢ !, ¨¦$¡

q

^¡¥ ^¢^¨¢⁺^,^!^£ ^¦-#

¦£

k : A I → A S

¢ ¨¢ ¡ !¦#¡¢¦) £¦¨$ "¨¤$¦

+

,!£ ¦-¦£

a 1

¨

a 2 ∈ A

⁺ ^¡^¥

¢ ¨¢

out (a 1 ) = k( in (a 1 ))

^¨

out (a 2 ) = k( in (a 2 ))

⁺ ^,

in _p (a 1 ) = in _p (a 2 )

^¢^¦

in _q (a 1 ) = in _q (a 2 )

^.

£!!,

.

!yy |yz""$! $"y |#{!|"!{"y|||"#~"

|{| "y !z#! "#" #{ !y{|| |"

q

^"^#" ^| ^y"

K p

| |{ "#" "!

|"|#" {#

x 6∈ r(p)

^#^$ ^# ^#" ^!yz

x

^"y

q

^"#^"^#&y^$|

p

^|^"

#{""#""!|#y}|" !##"yy

k

^y^{# ^|^y^"^#"

in _p (a 1 ) = in _p (a 2 )

#$

in _q (a 1 ) 6= in _q (a 2 )

^#^$ ^y^~

q

^|#"|| ^"| ^#^" ^{y^$^"^y

(10)

!$!"y"yy!#!{{##!{"{"!|"#"|${$ ~"

y"y y !y{||y$

%&

'

¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦ ¡ ¨$$¦ !#!{{# ( ¦ ¢ ¦!($¦§¦£¦$¨¢ !

¡ ¢!¢¨$

+

.

¦

. ,

!£ ¦-¦£

p

^¨

q ∈ S

⁺ ^¦ ¢^¦£

p H q

^!£

q H p

^. ^{¥ -¨$¦¢$}⁺ ^¨

¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦ ¡ ¦£¨£ ¨$ ( ¦ ¢ ¦ ¥!¢ ¦¢ ¡¦¢

S/ ' H

¡ $ ¦¨£$ !£¦£¦ ¤

¢ ¦ £¦$¨¢ !

H

^.

" |# {#!"#"y #!{"{"!|"#" #!{yzzy "y y" $"y|

" $"y !|"$ !#$ " yy ! #$

{

#!"

|#z

p 1 p 3

p 2 p 4 p 5

"#y&#zy#|

p 1 ' p 2 p 3 p 4 ' p 5

"|"!y!!#!{}

{#

¦ ¨§¦$ !£ ¡¢£ ¢ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¡¢ ¦¡ ¡ )£!¤$¦© ,!£ ¨£ ¢¦#

¢¥£¦

H

^¡ ^¦^¨¤$¦ ⁽^¢ ^¨£^¤ ¢£¨£ ^§^$!¤¨$ ^¡)^¦^¨¢ !

ϕ

^, ^¨ ^!^$ ^, ^¢^¦

¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

H

^¡ ^¦£¨£^¨^$^.

£!!,

.

|{"y y" #{ #$ $zy{ $|"!"$ |~"|| !yz y

!#!{{# #!{"{"!| #! {y$$ "y $|"!"$ #z| "

|| y "#" #!"| ${$#

y&!|~#~y!#!{{##!{"{"!{y"#|#${$##""!

" || y y! # y!z#"y y! " || y { " |

${$# & " y}$#~ |z#"{|

{ " y}$#~ |z#"{| | # #!"{#! {#| y |#~ |"!{" !y}$#~

|z#"{| " y}$#~ #||z"y {# {y$$ "y " y# |{{#}

"y"|!|" !#|!&y|!|"y!$|"!"$|~"||!yz|y

#!{"{"!" y# |{{#"y

pvstwp s

wqrw uqt pqw rs

"||{"y|y"#" |"!{"y!#{$|"!"$|~"||!yz|{#

{y$$"y$|"!"$#z|!#!{{##!{"{"!y"|

#z|{"|#z|#!${$#"|${|# ${|y!y{$!y!"

$|"!"$ |~"|| !yz y! !#!{{# #!{"{"!| y! y" |"!{" #$

#{|z#"{|

(11)

%|"!"$#z| #!# |{#$yz"#~!#z|" #!"#y!}

z#"y "$$ "y "#~| |y!""y}#~!#z| #! #~$y

##!""!# { #{ y|"y y|"y "!"!|" #~! {#$

"!y{||y!"y"|{y$#~! {#$"&!yz"%|"!"$#z|

#! # "|y y "y}#~! #z| !

n

^!y^{|| ^#~!| ^#~ ^"y^"^!

##|" y&!yz" #~!

%&

'

!¦# £!¦¡¡ !£ ¢(!)$¨

¦£¡

§¨©¦ ¨£¦¨ ¡

¨ ¢¥ )$¦

G = hP, E, T, si

⁽ ^¦£¦

P

^¡ ^¨ ^¡¦¢ ^!, ^£!¦¡¡ ⁾^!¡^¢ !⁺

E

^¡ ^¨ ^¡^¦¢ ^!,

- £!©¦¢)!¡ ¢ !

+

T ⊆ P × E ∪ E × P

^¡ ^¨ ^¡^¦¢ ^!, ⁾^!¡¡ ¤$¦ ^¢£¨¡^¢ ! ^©^!^-¦¡⁺

¨

s ∈ P ∪ E

^¡ ^¨ ^¢ ¨$⁾^!¡ ¢ !^.

-¦

n

^!^¦# ^£!¦¡¡ ^§^¨©^¦ ^¨£¦¨¡

G i = hP i , E i , T i , s i i

^,^!£

i ∈ [1, n]

⁺ ^¨ ^|~}

{!yy| $|"!"$ #z #!#

G

^¤¥ $¢ ^,^£!© ^¢^¦ ^$!¨$ ^§^¨©^¦ ^¨£¦¨¡

G 1

⁺ ^.^.^.⁺

G n

⁺

¡ ¨ §¨©¦ ¨£¦¨

G = hP, E, T, si

⁽^¢

P = Q

i P i

⁺

E = Q

i E i

¨

s = (s 1 , . . . , s n )

⁺ ^¨ ^¡¥ ^¢^¨¢ ^¢^¦ ^¡^¦¢ ^!, ^©^!-¦¡

T

^¡^¨¢ ¡^¦¡ ^¢^¦^,^!$^$!(^§ ^!^¢ !¡

,

!£ ¦-¦£

u ∈ P

^¨

v ∈ E

£!¦¡¡ ¢¦¨©

(u, v) ∈ T

^, ^¨ ^!^$ ^,^,^!£ ^¦-¦£

i ∈ [1, n]

⁺

(u[i], v[i]) ∈ T i

⁺

- £!©¦¢ ,

(v, u) ∈ T

^¢^¦^,^!^£ ^¦-¦£

i ∈ [1, n]

⁺

(v[i], u[i]) ∈ T i

^.

|!&"#" "!|# $|"!"$#z#!# " !yz "

y{# #!#|

G 1

G n

" z#z# |" y &!yz" zy&| | #!#

!""

G 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ G n

| {#$ " ! |~{!yy| !y${" y " #!#|

G 1

G n

|!&"#" #~y"! $|"!"$ #!#

G

^" ^!yz ^" ^|#z ^y^{# ^#!#^|

{#|"|#|#|#zy"!!y${"y"#$~y||~$|#y

|yz&!yz"zy&|"yy|"#""| |"y"#"y

G ⊆ G 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ G n

"y $y" "| #{"

y! # zy! !# y"y y $|"!"$ " ¨¡#

£!!¥¡ zy&| | $$ y! " |"$~ !|"$ !" #$$"y# !|}

|&||#$ " #|~{!y|z |y" |$ "|#!

{ #!||}

"#~ |"#| y!y$| !|""| #{" z#| y!!|" & |"!y!

%&

-¦ ¨ ¢(! )$¨¦£ §¨©¦ ¨£¦¨

G = hP, E, T, si

⁺ ^¨ |"!#"~ ,!£

¢ ¦ £!¦¡¡ )$¨¦£ £¦¡)

.

¨ |"!#"~ ,!£ ¢ ¦

- £!©¦¢ )

$¨¦£

¡ ¨ ©¨)) §

σ : P ⁺ → E

^£¦¡)^.^¨ ^©^¨))^§

τ : E ⁺ → P

^.

£!© ¢ ¦ ¢ ¨$)!¡ ¢ !

s ∈ E + T

⁺ ^¢^¦⁾^$¨ ^¥¦ ^¤ ^¡^{¢£¨¢¦§ ¦¡}

σ

^¨

τ

,£!© )!¡ ¢ !

s

⁺ ⁽^£^¢¢¦

σ ∗ τ

^¡ ^¦^¦ ^¢! ^¤¦ ^¢^¦ ^©^¨*^©^¨$ ⁽^!£

w ∈ (P + E) ^∞

¡¥ ¢ ¨¢

w(0) = s

^¨^,^!£ ^¦-¦£

i ∈ d om(w)

⁽^¢

i > 0

⁺

(w(i − 1), w(i)) ∈ T

¨

+

§ -¦

w ⁰ = w(0) · · · w(i − 1)

⁺ ^,

w(i − 1) ∈ P

^¢^¦

w(i) = σ ◦ π P (w ⁰ )

^¨ ^,

w(i − 1) ∈ E

^¢^¦

w(i) = τ ◦ π E (w ⁰ )

^.

¢£¨¢¦§

σ

^,^!£ ^£!¦¡^¡ ^¡ ^y ^y^{ ⁽ ^¦⁺^,^!£ ^¦-¦£ ^!¥^¢¦£ ^¡¢£¨¢^¦§

τ

⁺ ^,

σ ∗ τ

^¡^¢¦ ^¢^¦ ^¢ ^¦^¡ ^¨ ^- £!©^¦^¢⁾^!^¡ ¢ !^.

-¦ ¨

n

G ⊆ G 1 ⊗· · ·⊗G n

⁺

¨ £!¦¡¡¡¢£¨¢¦§

σ : P ⁺ → E

^¡ ^¨ $|"!"$ |"!#"~ ( ¦£¦ ¢ ¦£¦ ¡ ¨ ¡¦¢ !, $!¨$ )£!¦¡¡ ¡¢£¨¢¦§ ¦¡

{σ i :

(12)

P _i ⁺ → E} i∈[1,n]

¡¥ ¢ ¨¢

+

,!£ ¦-¦£ (!£

w ∈ P ⁺

⁺

σ(w) = (σ 1 ◦ π P 1 (w), · · · , σ n ◦ π P n (w)

^.

/ !¢ ¦£ (!£¡

+

¨ £!¦¡¡ ¡¢£¨¢¦§ ¡ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ( ¦ ¦-¦£ $!¨$ £!¦¡¡

)$¨¦£ !$ )$¨¡ ,

!$$!( § ¢¡ !( $!¨$ - ¦(

!,

¢ ¦§$!¤¨$)$¨

.

" y$$"|{~y "y |{ # #z y! #~#~

w

"#"

$|#y|"y"y"|{{||y!"{y&"y||"y${#!"#"

w

^|

y~ "!y{||| !|~" &!yz"#$ y~ "#|"y|"y

y

w

^y^| ^"y

E

^!| ^"y

P

^| ^{y^!!|y^$| ^"y ^" ^$# "#" &! #

#~! z#~y" z# # #zzy& #~zy!" yy||"#~

{yy|#!#y$"#z#!## !y{|||"!#"~z#~#|y${

"#~|

x

( § ! ¢ ! y!# $|"!"$#!#

G = hP, E, T, si

^|y^$

"!y!$$ #|# |"

Acc

^y^"^#~|^y ^~^"^!y^{||^.^¦^.^"

y!$|!yz

(P +E) ^ω

^y!$!^"y^$|{!^|{^#^|"^#^"^#~^y^{#^"^!

| |yz ${$#y{ y&! " y!$| "! zy#${ |{y$ y!$! y{

y! y y "| |{##"y||{ #|

µ

^}{#{^| ^y! ^" ^|{y ^y

"|#!y&!$yy"#""y|{{#y""y!z#|z {y|y!

" |{{#"y"!y!|z~ #||z"#"

Acc

^| ^#

ω

^}!^#^!^#^#

&#"~ # ##$#

%

&

%

' $|"!"$

#z ¡ ¨¢¥ )$¦

G = hP, E, T, s, Acci

⁽^¦£¦

hP, E, T, si

^¡ ^¨ ^¡^¢£ ¤¥¢^¦ ^¨£¦¨⁺ ^¨

Acc ⊆ (P + E) ^ω

^¡ ^¨

ω

^{#£¦§¥$¨£} ⁽^§ ^!^¢ !^.

' ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ £!¦¡¡ ¡¢£¨¢¦§

σ

^§^¨©^¦

G

^¡ ^¨ ⁽^§ ^¡¢£¨¢^¦§ ⁽ ^¦ ^¢ ^¡

! ¤$! § ¨,!£ ¨ ¡¢£¨¢¦§

τ

σ ∗ τ

^,^£!^©

¢ ¨$)!¡ ¢ !

s

^¡ ^¢^¦^¢^¦ ^¢ ^¤¦$^!§¡ ^¢!

Acc

^.

( ¢ ¢¨£( §! ¢ !

Acc = (P+E) ^ω

^.^/ ^¢^¡^¨¡^¦⁺⁽^§^¡¢^£¨^¢¦§^¦¡

.

%

!y& ! "#" #zy| !## #&y!| {# {y$$ #| $|}

"!"$ y y{ |"!#"| $|"!"$ #!#|

%&

¦¢

H = hI, S, r, {A c } c∈I∪S i

⁽^¢

S = {1, . . . , n}

^¨

n

^#)^£!¦¡¡

¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

.

¦ ¦¦ ¢ ¦

n

^#)^£!¦¡¡ ^|"!^{" ^$|"!^"$ ^#!#

G _H ^S = hP, E, T, si

G 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ G n

!, ¢ ¦ §¨©¦

¨£¦¨¡

G i

¨¡,!$$!(¡

.

!£ ¦-¦£

p ∈ {1, · · · , n}

G p = hP p , E p , T p , s p i

^¡ ^¦^¦ ^¤

¢¨ §

.

P p = {∗ p , ⊥ p } ∪ A r(p)

.

E p = (A r(p) → A p )

⁺

.

T p

¡ ¢ ¦ ¥ ! !, ¢ ¦ ¡¦¢¡

(P p − {⊥ _p }) × E p

¨

E p × (P p − {∗ _p })

⁺

.

¨

s p = ∗ p

⁺

(13)

+

¨¢ ¦-¦£ ¡¢¦)

+

£!¦¡¡

p

^!!¡¦¡

¨ !¦#¡¢¦) $!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£

A r(p) → A p

¨

!¦ $!¨$ £¦¢ !

.

¦ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¨£¦¨

G _H ^S

,

!$$!(¡ ,

£!© ¨

e = (k p ) p∈[1,n]

⁺

.

!,

!¦#¡¢¦) $!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡

{k _p } _p∈[1,n]

^¡ ^¨

!,

¨ §$!¤¨$ !¦#¡¢¦) ¤¦ ¨- !£

k e

⁺

. , ¡!

+

a = (a c ) c∈I

⁺

!©)¥¢¦ ¢ ¦

!££¦¡)! § §$!¤¨$ !¥¢)¥¢ ¦-¦¢

(a c ) c∈S = k e (a)

⁺ ^¨ ^{¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦} ^¤¨ ^¢!

)£!¦¡¡¦¡¢ ¦ £ !££¦¡)! § $!¨$ )¥¢¡

+

.

¦

.

¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ )!¡ ¢ !

(b p ) p∈[1,n]

( ¢

b p = (a c ) c∈r(p) )

(⊥ 1 , ⊥ 2 , · · · , ⊥ n )

^.

#zy| $|"!"$ #&y!| y #!{"{"!

H

^#! ^{y^$$ ^#^| ^y

y{ $|"!"$ |"!#"| " $|"!"$ #!#

G _H ^S

^#^| ^y^y^| ^&!~

!y{||

p ∈ S

^$^|^|"^~ ^|" ^#^z

G p

"y{# #&y!!y{||

p

#& #!{"{"!

H

^&!yz^" ^#~! ^{^{| ^"^#" ^"| ^{y^{| ^#^!

{yz#" y " #y"! |{ # #~"#""!|" y##&y!|

$$ #$ "|#| #{y!"#$ #zy|$|"!"$ !##"y

'

¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¡¢£¨¢¦§

σ = σ 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ σ n

¡ ! ¤$! § ¢ ¦

§¨©¦ ¨£¦¨

G _H ^S

^, ^¨ ^!$ ^, ^¢^¦ ^¡¦¢

{f σ p } p∈S

!, ¢ ¦ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡ ¦¦ ! $!¨$

§¨©¦¡

G 1

⁺ ^.^.^.⁺

G n

¤ ¡¢£¨¢¦§ ¦¡

σ 1

⁺ ^.^.^.⁺

σ n

¡ ¢ ¦ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ £¦¨$ "¨¢ ! !, ¨

f σ : A ^∗ _I → A ^∗ _S

^.

/)¨£¢ ¥$¨£

+

¨ ¡¢£¨¢¦§

σ

¢ !

f σ

¡ ¢¦$ §¦¦£¨¢¦

.

¦

.

£!!,

.

"

σ : P ^∗ → E

^# ^y ^y^{ $|"!"$ |"!#"~ y! " !y{||

"#z "

σ = σ 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ σ n

~$"y!yz &!~{y!"#$ #zy|

e ∈ E

^"!^| ^#

z#

k e : A I → A S

y{#~ !#$ ~

e

^y^!y&! ^y^! ^&!~ ^" ^&#

a ∈ A I

"! | y #$ y~ y y|"y

p e,a ∈ P

^! ^&!y^z^" ^#~!

{# zy& "y #$ zy!y&!&#

a

^{# ^!#$ ^&#^| ^|"y^!$

p e,a

{

# y|"y|

{p e,a } a∈A I

#!$|"{" y!yz " y"!

" yy| "#" "!| # z#

h σ : A ^∗ _I → P ⁺

^|^{ ^"^#"

h σ (ε) = (∗ 1 , · · · , ∗ n )

^#^$ ^y! ^&!~

u ∈ A ^∗ _I

^y^! ^&!~

a ∈ A I

&

e = σ(h σ (u))

^y

#|

h(u.a) = h σ (u).p e,a

$ " " z#

k σ : A ^∗ _I → (A I → A S )

^" ^,^¥^¢ !^¨$ ^¦£^¦$

y " | "# {"y ${$ ~ |"!#"~

σ

^~ ^"# ^y! ^&!~

u ∈ A I

k σ (u) = k e

"

e = σ(h σ (u))

~ {y|"!{"y

k σ

| " {"y# ! y # #zy|~ !##

#&y!

f σ

y#!{"{"!

H

^#{"^y!^&!~

u ∈ A _I ^∗

^"^&!y^z^"^y^|"y

σ(h σ (u))

^|^" ^y^{#^!#^#"y^y

k σ (u)

^|^{ ^"^| ^# ^{y!" ^#^$^#z^y^|

y|"y { zz# #|

(14)

y&!|~"

f : A ^∗ _I → A ^∗ _S

^# ^$|"!^"$ #!{"{"! #&y! !#$

~ # {y!" #$ #zy| |" y y{# !y{|| #&y!|

{f p } p∈S

&

y! &!~

p ∈ S

^# ^y ^y^{ ^|"!#^"^~

σ p

#z

G p

"#" {y!!|y$| "y

#&y!

f p

" |y"#!$"y |"#""$|"!"$ |"!#"~

σ f = σ 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗σ n

| y y{ " $|"!"$ #!#

G H

%

!y&!"#"{y!"!###&y!|{#{y$$#|yy{

$|"!"$ |"!#"| $|"!"$ #!#|

%&

'

§¨

+

$¦¢

H = hI, S, r, {A c } c∈I∪S i

^( ¢

S = {1, . . . , n}

^¨

n

^#

)£!¦¡¡ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¨£ ¢¦¢¥£¦

.

¦

¦ ¢ ¦

n + 1

^#)^£!¦¡¡ ^#^{ $|"!"$

#!#

G _H ^A = hP, E, T, si

G 0 ⊗ G 1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ G n

¨¡

,

!$$!(¡

.

!£ ¦-¦£

p ∈ {1, · · · , n}

G p = hP p , E p , T p , s p i

^¡ ^¦^¦ ^¨¡

¢ ¦ ¡¢£ ¢ ¨¡¦

¡

¦¦

¦

¢ !

¨ ¢ ¦§¨©¦ ¨£¦¨

G 0 = hP 0 , E 0 , T 0 , s 0 i

^¡

¦

¦ ¨¡

,

!$$!(¡

.

P 0 = {∗ 0 , ⊥ 0 } ∪ A I

.

E 0 = (A I → A S )

⁺

.

T 0

¡ ¦¦¢!¤¦¢ ¦¥ !!, ¢ ¦¡¦¢¡

(P 0 −{⊥ 0 })×E 0

¨

E 0 ×(P 0 −{∗ 0 })

⁺

.

¨

s 0 = ∗ 0

^.

¦ ¢¦¦ ©¦¨ §

!,

+

¨¢ ¦-¦£ ¡¢¦)

+

£!¦¡¡

0

^!!¡¦¡

¨ !¦#¡¢¦) y# #&y! ¨

)¥¢

.

¦ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦ ¨£¦¨

G _H ^A

,

!$$!(¡ ,

£!© ¨

e = (k p ) p∈[0,n]

⁺

.

!,

!¦#¡¢¦) $!¨$ ¤¦ ¨- !£¡

{k p } p∈[1,n]

¡ ¨

y}|" !##"y

!,

¢ ¦§$!¤¨$ !¦#¡¢¦) ¤¦ ¨- !£

k 0

⁺

. ,

¡!

+

a = (a c ) c∈I

⁺

!©)¥¢¦ ¢ ¦

!££¦¡)! § §$!¤¨$ !¥¢)¥¢ ¦-¦¢

(a c ) c∈S = k e (a)

⁺ ^¨ ¡¢£ ¤¥¢¦¡ ¤¨ ¢!

)£!¦¡¡¦¡¢ ¦ £ !££¦¡)! § $!¨$ )¥¢¡

+

.

¦

.

)!¡ ¢ !

(b p ) p∈[0,n]

( ¢

b p = (a c ) c∈r(p)

( ¦

p ∈ [1, n]

^¨

b p = a

⁽^¦

p = 0

(⊥ 0 , ⊥ 1 , ⊥ 2 , · · · , ⊥ _n )

^.

y!"$|"!"$#&y!|y#!{"{"!

H

^#^!^{y^$$^#^|^y^y^{

$|"!"$|"!#"|"$|"!"$ #z

G H

#|yy|&!~!y{||

p ∈ S

$| |" ~ |" #z

G p

" y{# #&y! !y{||

p

^#&

#!{"{"!

H

^#^$^!y^{||

0

^$^|^|"^~^|"^"^"^$$^y^#^!#^#

#&y! &!yz" #~! {{| "#" "| {y{| #!{yz#" y

" "y"!|{ ##~"#" "{y|y# #&y!$$ ~#~!

0

|!## ~" {y!" "y y||~ #zy||" yy{# #&y!|

"#" #! " ~ " y"! #~!|

On Distributed Program Specification and Synthesis in Architecture with Cycles

HAL Id: hal-00306412

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00306412

Submitted on 25 Jul 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.