From Heterogeneous Task Scheduling to Heterogeneous Mixed Data and Task Parallel Scheduling

Texte intégral

(1)From Heterogeneous Task Scheduling to Heterogeneous Mixed Data and Task Parallel Scheduling Frédéric Suter, Henri Casanova, Frédéric Desprez, Vincent Boudet. To cite this version: Frédéric Suter, Henri Casanova, Frédéric Desprez, Vincent Boudet. From Heterogeneous Task Scheduling to Heterogeneous Mixed Data and Task Parallel Scheduling. [Research Report] RR-4995, LIP RR-2003-52, INRIA, LIP. 2003. �inria-00071583�. HAL Id: inria-00071583 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071583 Submitted on 23 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. From Heterogeneous Task Scheduling to Heterogeneous Mixed Data and Task Parallel Scheduling Frédéric Suter, Henri Casanova, Frédéric Desprez, Vincent Boudet. No 4995 November 2003. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4995--FR+ENG. ` THEME 1. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4) .

(5) !"$#$%

(6) &

(7) ! '(#*)+,-

(8) &!/.0-"$"1"2!"$#$. 35476986:4<;>=@?

(9) ACB7D:4 ∗ E5F D9G47;IHJLK7JLGMONPJ E 35476:8C6:47;Q=SRD:K<T47D9U EWV ;QG=:D9GB!XYMLA8D9B Z []\1^_`badce<fg_<hjiOkl_$mnfgoOfpmq\1^_<f rWsqtvup_1mwc_<xShjr cwhvy]yPt9szmw{O_-sq_<|*[}_<sq|*[]_~v:j9@a wtj_<^L_1swv9ja`y]hjj_<f lC<1}jj xk_7{y]hvs*hv_< fg^¡jmg[}_I|$tj^¢}~]hmqt9~Ytj£¤{}hm*h

(10) hj~]{Ymqh9fz¥:y]hvs*hv_1fg^¦¡vf§h-yLt¨§_<sz£©i} ¨ hotv£ ~]|$sq_<h9fz~}!mg[}_fq|1hjhj}mpoStv£ _1~:mgsq_|1h9fgfg_<fbtj£ y]hjsqhj_15hjy}y}|<hmgtj~Pf1ª¬«5kOy}tjmg~}Ltvmq[ mpoyL_<fbtv£§y]hvs*hv_< fg^fg^¢i}mqhv~]_1tjiPfzo¦^hj¥j_7fnmbyLt9fqfg}_¢mgt¦{O_1y}tomg[}_7fz_hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~]fItj~@y}hvmz £©t9sg^¬f§|$tj^y}sq fz~}^¢i}®mqy]_b|$tj^y}i}mg_I|1iPfpmq_1s*f1¡:¨[} |*[[]hj_nP_7|$tj^_I~]|1sg_7hjfg~]joyLtjy}i} hvs§~lmg[}_ hjfzm{O_<|<hj{O_9ª¯nt¨§_<j_<s<¡[}j[!yP_<sz£©t9sg^¬hv~P|$_°hvy}y} |1hmqt9~l_1k_7|$iOmqt9~]fhvsq_btj~}o¬yPt:fgfg}_°£

(11) _1±L_7|²mgj_ fq|*[}_7{Oi}~}¢fpmqsqhvmg_19_7f5hvsq_nhhvhj}_jª¤³´[]_n^¢i}®mq®µ|$i]fzmg_<s¶y} hmg£©tjsq^f§hvsq_wy}sq_<{Ot9^~]hj~:mgo[}_1mg_1sqtv 9_1~}_<tji]f<¡}y}sq_1tji]f ¨ tjsq¥lt9~¦^YkO_<{y]hjsqhj_1¤hjy}y}|<hmqt9~¦fq|*[}_7{Oi}~}m*hvsqj_1mqf tj~]o[}tj^t9j_1~]_1tjiPf y]hvmz£©tjsq^¬f1ª¶·µ~!mq[} fwy]hjyP_<sw¨§_-{O_<j_<t9y¦h^_1mg[}tO{!£©tjsw_1kmg_1~P{O~]¬_$kOfzmg~}fq|*[}_<{}i}~}¬hvjt9sgmg[]^f £©t9sYmqhjfg¥:>yPhvs*hv_< hjy}y}|<hmgtj~Pf¢t9~¸[]_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]fy]hvmz£©tjsq^¬f¢mgt¹mg[}_¦^k_7{y]hvs*hv_< |<hjfg_jª2º£» mq_1s°{O_$m*hv~}lmg[}_£©tji}~]{]hmgtj~Pfntj£Wtji}sb^_$mg[]t{@hv~]{@tji}sbhjfqfzi}^yOmqt9~]f<¡P¨ _y}sq_<fg_1~:m°h|1h9fz_Yfpmqi]{Oo ~@¨[]|*[¼¨§_Yj_<~}_1s*hmq_¢h^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1Cj_1s*fgt9~Stv£Wmq[}_YyPt9y}i} hvs-¯w«¶½Z¾fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]!hvjt9sgmg[]^¡ ¨[]|*[¨§_°_<hjiPhmg_-¨mg[hj~!_1k:mq_1~]fgj_-fz_1mtv£5fzî} hmqt9~!_1kOyP_<sg^_1~:mqf<ª ¿À:ÁÃÂqÄÅ ÆCj xS®kO_<{r5hvs*hv_1fg^¦¡:[]_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]f§mqhjfg¥lfq|*[}_<{}i}~}Pª Ç ÈÊÉgËÌ<Í ÉÎCÏËÐ>Ñ$Ò ÓÔÕ×ÖWØ>ÙµÚ1Ø Õ×Ö§Û*Ü×Ö>ÝÛpÞ²Û*Õ×ÜßÛ*àÜ×ÙIÛ*Ö Û-áâÙpÖ>ÙzÛ*áQã>ÔláâÙpävÝ²áâØÝ*åØQÔÙnæOÛ*àvÝ²á>ÛqØQÝ²Õ×áQÙbçÙwÜ è é»ê7åÝ²áâëwÛqØQÕ×ì<íÙwçíî]Û*áQÛ*Ü×Ü×ïpÜ×Õ×Ö>ëÙ ð$ñ²ñ*ò]ó©ô²ôgõ²õ²õ]ö»÷qø7ù1úgûqü1ýgø]ö þ²ÿ1ô Ó¤Ô7Õ×Ö ÃÝ² á nÔÛ*Ö¤àjÙpÙpêbÖQíäävÝ²á©Ø>Ùpç-à

(12) nØQÔÙ5é ¤é@Õ×ê1ØQÙpáQêÛqØ>Õ×Ý²êÛ*Ü}ävÝ²ÖQØ»çÝ1ãµØ>Ý²áQÛ*ÜåíêçÕ×ê ∗. Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France) Téléphone : 04 76 61 52 00 - International : +33 4 76 61 52 00 Télécopie : 04 76 61 52 52 - International : +33 4 76 61 52 52.

(13) +, "z-C!! w&¢ ! " z-!! w&¢ &#*)

(14) _°y]hjsqhje1fg^_I^kmg_j¡ 9i]_<fzmh|$t9^}~]hjfgtj~{O_<fyPhvs*hve< fz^_7f {}_Imj|*[}_7f _$mn{O_.

(15) {}tj~}~}e<_<f<¡j_7fpm¶i]~^toj_1~y}i]fqfghj~:m¶{ hji}j^_<~9mq_1sW _$kmg_<~]fz}mgeb{O_n|1h9fgfg_<f5_<~:mg\1sq_<fW{ hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~]f yPhvs*hv\<_7f1ª _$kOy}tjmqhmqt9~fzî]®m*hv~}e<_n{O_<f§{O_1i}k¢mpoyL_<f {O_wy]hjsqhje1fg^_<f5yL_1sq^_$m {O_I{Oe<y}toj_1sW|1_<f hjy}y}|<hmqt9~]fIfgi}s-{O_7f°js*hvy}yL_<fb{O_js*hvy}yL_<f<ª §_<yP_<~]{}hv~:m7¡{O_<f°_1ke7|$iOmqt9~]fbyP_<sz£©t9sg^¬hj~9mq_<fI~}_¬fzt9~:m fg_1i]_<^Y_<~:m§yLt9fqfz}_<f 9i]_bfgÊ{O_<f fpmqsqhvmge<j_<fW_ |1hj|1_<f { tjs*{Otj~}~Phv~]|1_1^_1~:m fgtj~:m {OfgyLtj~}}_<f<ªºnt9sqf :i}_-_<fwjs*hvy}yL_<f {O_-9sqhjy}yP_7ffzt9~:mw_-y}i]fwfgtji]j_1~:m[}e1mge1sqtj9\1~}_7f1¡O_<f mqsqhhjiOkly}sqe<|1e<{O_<~9m*f{}hv~Pf_ {}tj^¬hv~}_¬{O_¬ t9sq{Ot9~}~]hj~]|$_<^Y_<~:m°_<~y]hvs*hve< fg^Y_^k:mq_|$}_1~:mi}~} :i}_1^_1~:m¢{}_<f°y} hmq_<fzQ£©t9sg^_<f []tj^tj9\1~}_7f1ª ntji]fh9tj~]fY{Oe19_1tjy}yLei}~}_¦ê$mg[]t{}_yLtji]sYe1mg_<~]{Osq_¦{}_<f¬hvjt9sgmg[]^Y_7f_1kOfzmqhj~9m*f1¡ yL_1sq^_$mgmqhv~:m{ t9sq{}tj~}~]hj~]|$_<s

(16) {O_7f

(17) hjy}y}|<hmqt9~]f_1k[]]hj~:mC{Oi¢y]hvs*hve< fg^Y_§{O_Wm j|*[}_7f

(18) fgi}s

(19) {}_<fCy} hmg_7fp £©t9sg^_7f[}e$mqe1sqtj9\1~}_7f1¡]h ]~S{ iOmgfg_1sI_¢y]hvs*hve< fg^Y_-^kmg_jªwºny}sq\<fwh9tjsw{Oe$m*hve_<fw£©tj~]{}hvmgtj~]f _1mn_<f[oyPtjmg[}\7fz_7fw{O_-~}tjmgsq_°mgs*hhvQ¡}~]tji]fwh9tj~]f y]sge7fz_<~9mqe°i}~}_e1mgi]{O_¢{O_|1h9f{}hv~Pf!h :i}_1_-~]tji]f 9e1~}e<sgt9~]fi]~}_§9_1s*fztj# ~ "^Ykmg%_ ${O_ & hvjt9sgmg[]^Y_§{ t9sq{}tj~}~]hj~]|$_<^_1~:mC¯n«¶½Z°ªntji]fCe<hji]tj~]fC|$_1mzmg_ e1mgi]{}_-y]hvsi}~_1~Pfz_<^}_|$t9^Yy]_1m{}_fzî} hmqt9~]f<ª ' Å 7 Â ( r5hjsqhje1fg^_I^kmg_j¡]tjs*{Otj~}~Phv~]|1_1^_1~:m{O_°)m 9|*[}_<ffgi}sy} hmq_<fzQ£©t9sg^_<f [}e1mge<sgt9j\1~]_<f<ª.

(20)

(21) !"# $%&(' ). . ¢ ¤¬!¶

(22) #$ *. Z

(23) ¨ t¬¥:~]{}fntv£y]hvs*hv_1fg^ |<hv~¦P_¢_$kOy}tjmg_7{!~^t9fzmntv£Wfq|$_1~:mg P|hjy}y}|<hmqt9~,+¶{}hvmqh hv~]{m*hjfg¥9 yPhvs*hv_< fz^¦ª0Z [}_¦£©t9sg^_<s|$tj~Pfz fpm*f~0hjy}y}o~}¹mq[}_@fqhv^_¦tjyL_1s*hmgtj~ ~ yPhvs*hv_<tj~´{O±L_<sg_<~9m _<_<^_1~:mqf§tv£

(24) h¢{}hm*hfg_$m7¡:¨[]_nmq[}_n hmgmg_<s |1tjsqsg_7fzyLtj~P{}fmgt|$t9~]|$i]sgsq_1~:m§|1tj^y}iOm*hmgtj~Pf¶t9~l{O±L_<sg_<~9m {]hmqh¸fz_1mqf<. ª -I~}_¼¨ ho¸mgt ^hvkO^ /1_Smq[}_{O_19sg_<_@tv£¢y]hvs*hv_< fg^ tj£¢h 99_1~ hjy}y}|<hmgtj~ f!mgt |1tj^¢}~]_WPtjmg[¢¥:~]{}f

(25) tv£}yPhvs*hv_< fz^¦ª¤Z []fChvy}y]sgt:hj|*[°fC|1hj_<1{ 02 3456&7 849

(26) :;< =>?@ A0 tjs 0B ;< =@ 0YªW·µ~^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1]hjy}y}|<hmgtj~Pf1¡:fz_<j_1s*hvP{}hm*hy]hvs*hv_<]|$t9^y}iOmqhvmgtj~]f§|1hj~P_ _1kO_<|$i}mg_<{|1tj~]|1i}sqsg_<~9mqol~@hYm*hjfg¥:>y]hjsqhj_1Ê¨ hojª Z [} fw~]|$sq_<h9fz_7fwfq|1hv hv]®mpohjf^t9sg_-y]hjsqhj_1 fz^ |<hv~¸P__1ky]t9®mq_<{ ¨[]_1~¸mg[}_¦^¬hkO^hjwhv^tji]~9mtv£b_1mg[}_<s{}hm*h-tjsYm*hjfg¥9y]hjsqhj_1fg^ []hjfL_1_<~ h9|*[}_1j_7{Êª Z [} f¬|1hjy]hv]®mpo f¬h¹¥j_<o hj{Ohj~9m*hv9_l£©t9s¢mqtO{}ho fy]hjsqhj_1|1tj^y}iOmq~}y} hmg£©tjsq^¬f1ª ·µ~]{O_<_<{Ê¡ mqt£âhj|1_°mg[}_~]|1sg_7hjfg~}|$t9^y}iOmqhvmgtj~hv~P{!^_<^Yt9sgo{O_1^¬hj~]{}ftj£Cy]hjsqhj_1fq|$_1~:mq P|-hjy}y}|<hmqt9~]f1¡ hlsg_7|$_<~9m°hvy}y]sgt:hj|*[¦[]hjfIL_1_1~@mgt¦hv9jsq_19hvmg_°î]®mqy}_|$tj^y}i}mg_|$i]fpmq_1s*fn_<®mq[}_1sb¨mg[}~@t9sbh9|$sqt9fqf ~]fzmgmgiOmqt9~]f<ªCZ [}_7fz_whjj9sg_<9hmq_¶y} hmg£©tjsq^¬f[]hj_ L_1_1~Ymq_1sq^Y_7D { CEAF G×

(27) HPhv~]J{ Ibsq{¢^{]{O_<¨ hjsgK_ G LH y]sgt {O_<fLmq[}_W~}_7|$_<fqfqhvsqonfztj£»mp¨ hjsg_~O£©s*hjfzmgsqi]|²mqi}sg_£©t9s¤hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~{O_<y}to:^_<~9m7ª¤Z§o:y]|<hvo9¡7|1i]fzmg_<sqf tj£-hjsgtjiPflfg= /<_<flhjsg_@i]fz_7{Ê¡whv~P{0{O±L_<sg_<~9m|$i]fpmq_1s*fl|1tj~:mqhj~´~}tO{O_7fl¨mg[ {O®±Ã_1sq_1~:m¦|1hvyPhv}mg_<f {}_1yL_1~]{O~}tj~@mg[}_Ymg_7|*[}~}t9t9johhvhj}_¢hm°mg[}_¢mg^__<hj|*[¼|$i]fpmq_1s°¨ hjfbhjfqfz_<^}_<{ÊªZ []_1sq_$£©tjsq_j¡ mq[}_|$tj^y}i}mg~}!_<~:sqtj~}^_1~:mn f°hmbmg[}_fqhv^_mq^_¬hmgmgs*hj|²mq9_L_<|1hji]fg_¢tj£Wmg[}_Y hvsqj_|1tj^y}iOmq~} yLt¨ _1s7¡hj~]{¦|*[]hv_1~}9~}YL_<|1hji]fg_bmw f [}_$mq_1sqtjj_<~}_1t9i]f<ª ³´[}_Y^t:fpm°^®kO_<{O>y]hjsqhj_1 fz^sg_7fz_7hvs*|*[[]hjfIL_1_1~{Ot9~}_¢~Smq[}_hvsq_<htj£¶y}sqtj9sqhj^Y^~} hv~O 9i]hv9_<2f Mâfg_1N _ G×

(28) H£©t9sbhl}sgt:hj{Sfgi}sqj_<%o O$¡Lh£©i}~]{}hj^_1~:mqhj :i}_7fpmqt9~S~Smg[Phm°tv£§hjy}y}|<hmgtjP ~ "# $%? &'vªwº ~:i]^L_1sntj£WhviOmq[}tjs*f[]h9_-_$kOy}tjsq_<{!mg[} f :i}_7fpmqt9~~¦mq[}_|1tj~:mg_1k:mItv£5[}tj^t9j_1~]_1tjiPf y}hvmz £©t9sg^¬Qf G`<}¡

(29) `¡CS` RO¡

(30) `S HªI¯nt¨§_<j_1s7¡]h9fw_$kOy} hv~}_7{hvLtj_j¡P[}_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]fy]hvmz£©tjsq^¬fw[]h9_-P_7|$t9^Y_ y]sg_<hj_<~:m°hj~]{¼hjsg_Y_$kmqsg_<^Y_<oShvmzmqsqh9|²mgj_¢£©tjs{}_1y}to~}hvy}y] |1hvmgtj~]f°hm-i}~]y}sg_7|$_7{O_1~:mg_7{¼fq|1hj_7f1ª §t9~]fg _ :i}_1~:mqo9¡jmq[}_1sq_w f§h~}_1_7{£©tjs fg|*[]_<{Oi}~}-mg_7|*[}~} :i}_<f¶£©tjs§^YkO_<{y]hjsqhj_1Lhvy}y} |1hmqt9~¬~lmg[}_ []_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]fw|1h9fz_9ªw·µ~mq[}fIy]hjyP_<sI¨ _}i] {tj~@_$kOfzmg~}lfq|*[}_7{Oi}~}hvjt9sgmg[}^¬f £©t9sI[]_$mg_<sgt9j_1 ~]_1tjiPf5y} hmz£©t9sg^¬f G×¡P`<O¡P`j`v¡PS` LO¡OA` HMTFUSU=Vhj9tjsq®mq[}^¬fWfzyL_<|1 L|1hvo¢{O_7fzj~}_7{¢£©tjs5m*hjfg¥9y]hjsqhj_1fg1^ O mqt¬{O_19_1tjy¦fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬f§£©tjs^®kO_7{>yPhvs*hv_< fz^ t9~![]_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]f y}hvmz£©t9sg^¬f<ª Z [} fby]hvyL_1sIfbt9sg:hv~} /1_7{h9fw£©t9t¨wf<8ª W_7|²mgtj~¹{O fg|1i]fqfz_7fnsq_1 hmq_<{¦¨ tjsq¥hj~]{¦£©tjsq^¬hv= /<_<fnmg[}_ y]sgt9}_<^ ¨ _¶hj{]{Osg_7fgf<ª W_7|²mqt9~wfz[]t¨wfÊ[}t¨fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]nhvjt9sgmg[}^¬fL£©t9smqh9fz¥:y]hvs*hv_1vhvy]y} |1hvmgtj~]f t9~-[}_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]fÃy} hmg£©tjsq^¬f¤|1hj~-P_ hj{}hjyOmg_7{bmgtnfgi}y}yLtjsgm¤^k_7{y]hvs*hv_< fg^¡7¨[} |*[-f¤i]fpmqsqhvmg_7{ ¨mg[h-|<hjfg_fpmqi]{OoYN ~ W_7|²mqt9~YPXª WO_<|²mqt9~°y}sq_<fg_1~:mqft9i}sW_1hji]hvmgtj~Y^_$mg[]t{}tjtjjoYhv~]J{ W_7|²mqt9Y~ R y]sg_7fz_<~9m*flt9i}sl_<hvi]hmqt9~ sq_<fgi}®m*f1Z ª W_7|²mgtj~ |1tj~]|1i]{}_<flmg[}_¹y]hvyL_1s¦¨mg[ h fgi}^^hjsgo2tj£tji}s |1tj~:mgsq}iOmgtj~Pf hj~]{¦h{Ofq|$iPfgfgt9~!tj£¤£©iOmqi}sq_-¨§t9sg¥Ãª [. \. ]^T_.

(31) ¬-! `bacdafefghig,ajlkPmonqprgsutwvyxvzvXhls|{Bv}k~vy<vX qg Jrig sljTn hie. xSt9fzmC_1k fzmg~}°^YkO_<{y]hjsqhj_1fg|*[]_<{Oi}~}-hvjtjsqmg[}^¬fG`<}¡O`7¡O`RO¡O`H}y}sgtO|1_1_<{¢~mp¨ tbfzmg_<y]f<ªCZ [}_ Psqfzmfzmg_<y¢hj^¬fhm ]~]{}~}°hv~¢tjyOmq^¬hj=4F&£©t9sC_7hj|*[-m*hjfg¥Ã¡mg[]hvm f

(32) mg[}_ ~i}^¢P_<sCtj£]y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f . ê}>AA. .

(33) . UX$%494U. t9~¨[}|*[mq[}_w_1k_7|$iOmqt9~Ymg^Y_ntv£Êh°mqh9fz¥¢f5^~}^hjQª5Z [}_Ifz_7|$tj~P{¢fzmg_<y{O_$mq_1sq^Y~}_7f¶Bh >"< $%=w£©tjs mq[}_hvtO|1hvmg_7{¦mqh9fz¥Of<¡]mq[]hm°fImq[}_¢t9sq{}_1sq~}ltv£5mqh9fz¥Ofnmg[]hvmb^~}^Y/1_7fImg[}_¢mgtjmqhv|$t9^y}_1mgtj~mq^_ tj£Êmg[}_-hjy}y}|<hmgtj~¤ªCº |$ hjfqfz |1hj]^_$mq[}tO{i]fg_<{l~lmg[}_°hvt|<hmqt9~lfpmq_1y!f¶mg[}_b^~]^ /<hmqt9~ltj£mg[}_ >A4 F;#4" G`7 H5+¤mq[}_ntj~]j_<fzm¶y]hvmg[~¬mq[}_Ihjy}y}|<hmgtj~m*hjfg¥¢9sqhjy}[¡ FUSU=VÊmq[}_ny]hvmg[t9~¬¨[} |*[¬mg[}_ fgi}^,tj£§mq[}__<{O9_¬hv~]{¼~}tO{O_¬¨ _1j[:mqfb f°^hvkO^¬hv>ª¬ºw~}tjmg[}_<s-yPt:fgfg}mpoSfbmq[}_¬^~]^ /<hmqt9~¼tj£ mq[}_

(34) > S' ¡Ã¨[} |*[S^_<h9fzi]sg_7fmg[]_¢y}sqtO|$_7fgfgtjsgQmq^_hjsg_7h¬sg_ :i}sq_<{¦omg[]_¢hvy]y} |1hvmgtjP ~ G`1 H>ª Z

(35) tSL_hj}_¬mgt¼_<fzmg^hvmg_lmg[}_!_1jt9i}mgtj~ tv£mq[}_l_1kO_<|$i}mgtj~ mq^_ltj£nhS99_1~mqh9fz¥{O_<yP_<~]{O~}@t9~ mq[}_~i}^¢P_<sntj£Wy}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqfhjtO|1hmq_<{!mgt!®m7¡]mq[}_<fg_¢hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬fi]fg__1mg[]_1sb^YtO{O_<~}t9sny}sqt P~}]ª xSt{}_1 fnhvsq_°y}sq~]|1yPhvo]hjfg_<{t9~Sºw^¬{}hv[]& fw h¨ G` Hª½}t9sn|$t9^Y^¢i}~} |1hvmgtj~]f<¡Omg[]_^t9fzmI|$t9^^Yt9~ ^tO{O_<WfmgtS{O{}_¬mg[}_mqtvm*hv¶hj^Yt9i}~:mtv£w{}hvmqhmgt¦mqsqhj~]fz£©_1s-o@mq[}_¬]hj~]{O¨ {mg[ tj£ mq[}_¬~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥ hj~]{hj{}{ hmg_<~]|$_<f{}_1yL_1~]{O~}¬t9~fgtji}s*|$_°hv~P{!{O_7fpmq~Phmgtj~{}hvmqh{O fpmqsg}iOmqt9~]f<ª ·µ~ G H¡O¨§_-y}sqtjyLt9fg_<{!hv~¦hvjt9sgmg[}^ mg[]hvm y]sgtO|$_<_<{}f ~¦tj~}ot9~}_-fpmq_1yªWZ [}_hjtO|1hvmgtj~ly]sgtO|$_7fgf fWfgi}]fzmgmgiOmq_<{¬omg[}_nh9fgfgtO|$ hmqt9~¢tj£Ãh°fzm¶tj£Ã|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~PfCmgt°mqh9fz¥Of<¡j¨[} |*[f§hv fzt°i]fg_<{~mg[]f ¨ tjsq¥hj~]{{O_$m*hv_7{¢1~ W_<|$mgtj~¬}ª¯wt¨ _19_1s7¡mg[}_Ihvjtjsqmg[}^ ¨ _y}sq_<fg_1~:m5~mq[} f5y]hvyL_1s7¡ji]~}¥j_ mq[]hm ~ G H¡5_$kOy}|1®mqo h9|1|$t9i}~:mqf£©tjsYy}hvmz£©t9sg^ [}_1mg_1sqtj9_1~}_<®mpo9¡5hv~]{ fmg[i]fYhvy}y} |1hv]_¬mqt@sq_<hj®¨§t9sg { ^¢i}mg|1i]fzmg_<sy} hmz£©t9sg^¬f<ª ]^]. `bgx%g,#aefg hig ajk {2v}k(~. <igsj nThe. Z []_Wy}sqtj}_1^ tv£]fq|*[}_<{}i}~}nhmqhjfg¥bjs*hvy}[°tj~:mqtnh[}_1mg_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]fÃy]hvmz£©tjsq^ f

(36) hjf£©tjt¨wf<ª§tj~Pfz {O_1s hIsq_<|$mg_7{Yº|1oO|$|Ibs*hvy}[MnºiIO G = (N , E) ¡vmq[]hmW^tO{O_1 fWhby]hjsqhj_1}hjy}y}|<hmgtj~¤¡v¨[}_1sq_ N = fChnfg_$mCtv£ ~]t{}_<fEM©tjs

(37) mqh9fz¥OfOhj~]{ fChnfg_$mtv£}_7{Oj_7f1ª

(38) «¶hj|*[mqhjfg¥°[]hjf {Ni : i = 1, · · · , N } h|1tj^y}iOm*hmgtj~|$t:fpm7 ¡ SU '(U=V

(39) hY~i}N^L_1stj£C½Ct9y]f<¡O¨[}|*[E_<hj={]f Emgi,jt¬{O±L_<sg_<~9mw|1tj^y}iOm*hmgtj~!mg^_<f t9~ {}®±Ã_1sq_1~:my}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqf<ª¤ºw~Y_<{}j_ ~¢mg[}_ wiº I |$t9sgsq_<fgyPt9~]{}f¤mgt°hwm*hjfg¥{O_<yP_<~]{O_1~P|$N o MQ|$tj^^¢i}~} |1hmqt9~ t9s y}sg_7|$_7{O_1~]|1_b|1tj~]fzmgs*hv~:m<ª OZ

(40) t_<h9|*[l_<{}j_ Ei,j fhjfqfztO|1hvmg_<{ Dij ¡mq[}_hv^tji]~9m tv£{}hm*hY~o9mq_<f mq[]hmm*hjfg¥ Ni fg_1~]{]fCmgtbmqh9fz¥ Nj ª

(41) «§hj|*[fzi]|*[¢mgs*hv~Pfp£©_<s5~]|1i}s*f5hb|1tj^î]~}|<hmqt9~¢|$t:fpmmq[]hm¶{O_<yP_<~]{}f t9~~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥l|<hvy]hj}mg_<f<ª ·mIfIhjfqfzi}^_7{lmq[]hmb®£mp¨ tmqh9fz¥Ofnhjsg_h9fgfgj~}_7{mqt¬mg[}_Yfghj^_-y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9s mq[}_1sq_S f~}t¸|$tj^^¢i}~} |1hmqt9~´|$t9fzm<ªºnfgt]¡¨ _@hjfqfgi}^_¦mg[]hvmfg_1j_<sqhjw|$t9^Y^¢i}~} |1hvmgtj~]f¬^¬ho P_ yL_1sg£©tjsq^_<{hm mg[]_fghj^Y_bmq^_j¡]yPt:fgfg]o_<h9{O~}Ymgt|$t9~:mg_1~:mqt9~ltj~mq[}_-~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥Ãª º m*hjfg¥¨®mq[}tji}mIhv~o¬~}y}iOmn_7{Oj_° fw|1hj_<{hv~ >&<4 mqhjfg¥¨[}_hYmqhjfg¥¨mg[¦~}ttji}mgy}iOmw_7{Oj_ f|1hj_<{ hv~ 4m*hjfg¥Ãª¸º mqh9fz¥ ffghjb { 3 ¹¨[]_1~2hv®m*f¢y]sg_7{O_<|1_<fqfzt9sqf¢[]hj# _ ]~} fz[]_<{ mg[}_<s _1kO_<|$i}mgtj~ª P red(Ni ) {O_1~}tjmg_7f5mg[]_nfz_1mWtv£Ãmg[]_w^^_<{}hvmg_wy}sq_<{}_<|$_7fgfgtjs*fCtv£Ãmqh9fz¥ Ni hj~]{ Succ(Ni) f mg[]_fz_1mwtv£¤mq[}_-^Y^_7{Ohvmg_fgi]|1|1_<fqfzt9sqf§tv£Cmg[]fwfqhv^_bmqh9fz¥Ãª Z [}_ m*hvsqj_$m hvs*|*[}mg_7|²mgi]sg_ f¹9_1~}_<sqhjo h fg_$m tj£![}_1mg_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]f¼y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f P = {Pk : |$tj~]~}_<|$mg_<{ hSh¦£©i}o|1tj~}~]_<|²mq_<{ ~]_$mp¨ tjsq¥Smgt9yPt9t9jo9¡ FUU=Vnhjf¢fzttj~ h9fhm*hjfg¥ k = 1, · · · , p} ] [ 9 h w f $ | 9 t Y ^ ] y 1 _ g m < _ {¡ o:mg_7fwhvsq_fg_1~:mwmgthj

(42) ®m*fnfgi]|1|1_<fqfzt9sqffgî}mqhj~}_1t9i]fzojª§³¼_Yhjfqfzi]^Y_°mq[]hm Ni |1tj^y}iOm*hmqt9~|<hv~P_-Dti,j9_1sqhjy}yP_7{¨mg[|$t9^î}~} |1hvmgtj~ª ³¹_¬{O_1~}tjmg_Yo mq[}_¢_1kO_<|$i}mgtj~Smq^_tv£¶mqhjfg¥ Ni tj~¼y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9s Pj ¡Ê¨[}|*[¼¨§_hjfqfgi}^_mgt L_-¥~}t¨~!£©tjs_<h9|*[wm*i,jhjfg¥9y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs y]hvs<ª Z [}_¦|$t9^î}~} |1hvmgtj~ |1t9fzm¢tj£n_<{O9_ ¡5mq[]hm fmq[}_!mg^Y_!mgt¼mgs*hv~Pfp£©_<s o9mq_<fYtv£n{]hmqh L_$mp¨ _1_<~-mqh9fz¥ Ni MQfg|*[}_7{Oi}_<{-t9~ Pm OmgtnEmqh9i,kfz¥ Nk Mâfq|*[}_<{Oi]_7{tj~ Pn O¤fC{O_ ]~}_<{Di,ko ci,k = βm,n + ¡¨[}_<sg_ hv~]{ hvsq_mg[}_b|$t9^Y^¢i}~} |1hvmgtj~lfzmqhjszmqi}y|$t:fpm hv~]{mq[}_I{]hmqhmgs*hv~]fz£©_1s Di,k × τm,n s*hmq_b£©tjs mg[]_|$tj^^¢i}β~}m,n |1hmqt9~lτ~]m,n ¥!|$t9~}~}_7|²mg~}y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f Pm hv~P{ Pn ª é é.

(43)

(44) !"# $%&('. . Z [}_¢tjOup_7|²mq9_fnmgthjfqfzj~m*hjfg¥fwmgt!y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqfwfgt¬mq[]hmImg[}_Yfg|*[}_7{Oi}__1~}jmg[S fw^~}^Y /1_7{Ê¡ 9h |1|1tji}~:mg~}!£©tjshj5~:mg_<sgy}sqtO|$_7fgfgtjs°|$t9^Y^¢i}~} |1hvmgtj~¹tj_1sq[}_7hj{}f<ª¬Z [}fy}sgt9}_1^, fwrW|1tj^y}_$mg_ ~mg[}_fzmgsqtj~]Yfg_1~]fg_°_19_1~¨[}_1~hv~~ ]~}mg_-~i}^¢P_<swtv£Cy}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqf hvsq_-hhj hv]_BG H>ª º }sqt9h9{S|$ hjfqfntj£¶[}_<i}sg fzmg |1fI£©tjs-fgtj:~}lmg[}_fg|*[]_<{Oi}~}!y]sgt9}_<^ Yf ?@ A4 5 >"< $%?&('jª·µ~¼mg[}_ |1tj~:mg_1kmWtv£Ê[}_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]fCy} hmg£©tjsq^fWyPt9y}i} hvsW[}_<i}sqfzmg |1f5 fpmgfq|*[}_<{}i}~}-[}_<i}sqfzmg |1f5~]|1i]{}6_ 02& 0B$%0 A4 Ff0;7=>4 F& 0Yl A494 F};!AFA4 Mâ r iZ OG`<

(45) H¡ l 40YS'&!

(46) >}M · OrG`j` H>¡. 249> '(>&7$ iA?F A4 &<@ " 0YKMQ¯w«¶½i Z OG }A` H¡vhv~] {

(47) &702F

(48) >(!"# $%&('JM W#OfGS` LH>ª ºn¶mg[}_7fz_¬[]_1i}sqfzmg |1fhvsq_YPhjfg_<{¹tj~¹mg[]_fghj^Y_mp¨ tS|$t9^yPt9~}_1~:mqSf +h ;7AFA4 ¼£©i}~]|$mgtj~¡C¨[} |*[f iPfz_7{mgtt9sq{O_<snhv¤~]t{}_<fw~¦mg[]_mqh9fz¥js*hvy][¦hvmI|$t9^y}_-mq^_ Êhj~]{hv~t9Oup_<|$mgj_°£©i}~]|$mgtj~¡ Fobj ¡ ¨[]|*[î]fzmwL_-^Y~}^= /<_<{ÊªWº 9_1~}_<sg |b fpmgfq|*[}_7{Oi}~}¬hj9tjsq®mq[}^ |1hj~lmq[:iPfP_-¨sqmzmg_<~h9>f + §t9^y}iOmg_bmq[}8 _ ;7AFA4 l£©tjs_<h9|*[!~]t{}_b~mg[}_ niº I l3

(49) : «W~:mgsqo!ZChjfg¥Of ³´[] _ 3 < :

(50) - f~}tvm_<^Yy}mpo rW |*¥mq[}_-~}tO{O_ Ni mq[]hm^¬hkO^= /<_<f mg[]_ priority £©i}~P|²mgtj~ ºnfqfg9~ Ni tj~!mg[}_-y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs Pj mq[]hmw^~}^ /1_7f Fobj (Ni , Pj ) wyÃ{}hvmg _ l

(51) : "$# °

(52) #$

(53) C C! '(#*) .0-"$"$" !"$#$ ³´[]_¬mg[]_lfzmzµfg|*[]_<{Oi}~}Shvjt9sgmg[}^¬f-{O_7fg|1sgL_<{~ W_<|$mgtj~ Oª×tjyL_1s*hmq_¬tj~ h£©i}o¹[]_$mg_<sgt9j_1 ~]_1tjiPfny} hmg£©tjsqo ^ Mâ|1tj^y}iOmq_¢sq_<fgtji}s*|$_7fnhj~]{S~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥~}¥OfO²¡Ê~@t9i}s Psqfzm°hvmzmq_1^yOmhmbi]fz~}!mg[}_7fz_ []_1i}sqfzmg |1f £©t9s^®kO_<{O>y]hjsqhj_1 fz^ ¨ _-^yLt9fg_°mg[}sq_1_°sq_<fzmgsq|$mgtj~]f t9~lmq[}_-y} hmg£©tjsq^ hv~P{lmqfiPfghjj_3+ Mâ@ O¶mq[}_°y}hvmz£©t9sg^ |1tj~]fgfzmqf§tv£h[]_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]f¶|1tj_7|²mgtj~!tv£¤[]tj^tj9_1~}_<tji]f |$i]fzmg_1s*f !Mâ O¶mg[}_°~}_1mz ¨ tjsq¥~:mg_<sq|1tj~}~]_<|²mq~]mg[]_<fg_|1iPfpmq_1s*fn fI£©i}oS|$t9~}~}_7|²mg_7{@hj~]{S[}t9^tjj_<~}_1t9i]f XMâ OI{]hmqhv>yPhvs*hv_< m*hjfg¥OfWhvsq_nhv¨ hof^¬hjy}yP_7{mgt¢sg_7fzt9i}s*|$_<f¨mg[]~lhfz~}j_n|1i]fzmg_<s<ªZ [}_7fz_Isg_7fpmqsg |²mqt9~]fWhvsq_upi]fzmg ]_<{ h9f°£©tjt¨wf1ªc_<fzmgsq|$mgtj~ Mâ@ O-|1_7hvsqo¼^¬hv¥j_7f°mg[]_y}sqtj}_1^ ^Yt9sg_mqsqh9|²m*hv}_¬}iOm f~£âhj|$m[}j[}o sq_1y]sg_7fz_<~9m*hmq9_btj£|1i}sqsg_<~9mqohhvhj}Q_ Ibsq {!y]hvmz£©tjsq^¬f1ª ·µ~]{O_<_<{Ê¡Pmg[]_<fg_-y}hvmz£©t9sg^¬fmpoy} |1hjo!|1tj~O fg fpmWtj£Ã|1i]fzmg_<sqftO|1hvmg_<{hvm¶{O®±Ã_1sq_1~:m¶~]fzmgmgiOmqt9~]f<¡9hv~P{¢~]fzmgmgiOmqt9~]f5mpoy} |1hjo}i] {[}tj^t9j_1~]_1tjiPf |1iPfpmq_1s*f1ªc_<fzmgsq |²mgtj~ M©@ O§ f¶^tjsq_ :i}_7fpmqt9~]hv]_nh9f¶_<~]{>mgtj>_<~]{¬~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥Yy]hmq[]f tj~¬mq[}_b¨{O_1hjsg_7h hjsg_¥~}t¨~mqtL_n[}j[]oY[}_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]f<ª

(54) ¯nt¨§_<j_1s7¡jt9~}_w¥9_1oYfqfzi]_£©tjs fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]^®kO_<{O>y]hjsqhj_1 hjy}y}|<hmqt9~Y fmq[]hm¶tj£ 349Q @ A4A >$%4 F&y+

(55) mq[}_wy}sqtO|$_7fgf5tj£Pmqsqhj~]fz£©_1sqsg~}-hv~]{Ysq_1^¬hvy]y}~]hvy}y} |1h mqt9~S{}hm*hY£©sgt9^ t9~}_fgi}]fg_$mntj£Cmq[}_|1tj^y}iOmq_sg_7fzt9i}s*|$_<f mqtlhv~]tvmg[]_1snfgi}]fg_$m7ª bhm*h¬sq_<{O fpmqsg}iOmqt9~ t9~[}_1mg_<sgt9j_1~]_1tjiPf¤~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥Of

(56) fhb|$t9^Yy]_1mg_1ot9yP_<~y}sqtj}_1^¦¡¨[} |*[YfC¥~}t¨~mqt°P_wrW|1tj^y}_$mg_ ~mq[}_b[}tj^tj9_1~}_<tji]f§|1h9fzB_ G RH>ªW¯nt¨§_<j_1s7¡j~mq[}_°[}tj^t9j_1~]_1tjiPf¶|1h9fz_bh~i}^¢P_<s tj£

(57) hvjt9sgmg[]^fW£©tjs sq_<{}fzmgsq]iOmgtj~¼[]hj_YP_<_1~ {O_<j_1tjyL_<{ G R]¡5`7¡¶`<O¡¤9¡¤v

(58) H# ª §tj~]fg _ :i}_<~:mgoj¡¤h9fgfgi}^~]h[}t9^Yt9j_1 ~]_1tjiPf ~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥lhv^t9~}Y|1iPfpmq_1s*fhvt¨wf i]fmgt¬_<h9fzo^t{}_1sq_<{O fzmgsq}i}mgtj~¦|$t9fzmqf Phjfg_<{!tj~mg[}_7fz_ hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬f1ªC½}i}sgmg[]_1sq^Yt9sg_9¡9~]tY|1i}sgsq_1~:mqohhvhj}_bfztj£»mp¨ hjsg_whjt¨wf§_ |$_1~:m {]hmqh¢sq_<{O fpmqsg}iOmqt9~ ~Sh[}_1mg_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]f ~]_$mp¨ tjsq¥lfz_1mzmq~}Pª½

(59) ~]hjoj¡Psg_7fpmqsg |²mqt9D ~ Mâ@ OwfWupi]fzmIh¬|$t9~:9_1~}_1~:mw¨ homqt¬_1~O fgi}sq_nmq[]hm¨ _-|1hv~!sg_<i]fg_Imq[}_°y]hvs*hv_1Êhvy}y] |1hvmgtj~l^tO{O_<f MSU '(U=V

(60) fgyP_<_<{i}y^YtO{O_<f O¶mgs*hj{Omgtj~Phvo . . ê}>AA. .

(61) R. UX$%494U. _<^y}to9_<{¹~¼mq[}_l^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1fg^,®mq_1s*hmgi]sg_G`v¡¤3H>ª §tj~P|$_1hv}oj¡¤mg[} fsq_<fzmgsq |²mgtj~ |1tji} {P_ sq_1^t9_<{£^YtO{O_<f £©t9sy]hvs*hv_1hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~!tj~¦[}_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]f§y} hmz£©t9sg^¬f ¨ _1sq_-hhj hv]_9ª ·µ~0fgi}^^¬hvsqoj¡ tji}s|1tj^y}iOmq~] y} hmz£©t9sg^ |$t9~]fz fzmqf¬tj£ |$i]fzmg_<sqf<¡§¨[]_1sq__<hj|*[´|1i]fzmg_<s Kj ¡ £©t9s j = 1, . . . , M ¡|1tj~:mqhj~Pf Pj {O_1~:mg |1hj¶y}sqtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f1ª¦Z M [}_|$i]fpmq_1s*fhjsg_¬~:mg_1s*|$t9~}~}_7|²mg_7{hSh []tj^tj9_1~}_<tji]f

(62) ~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥Ãª¤ºnfJ~ W_<|$mgtj~Y}ª }¡¨§_{O_<~}tvmq_§o βm,n hv~]{¢o τm,n mq[}_|$tj^^¢i}~} |1hmqt9~ fzmqhjszmqi}y@|1t9fzm°hj~]{mq[}_Y{]hmqhlmgs*hv~Pfp£©_<sIs*hmq_£©tjs-|1tj^î}~]|<hmgtj~@P_1mp¨§_<_1~@y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjsbfz_1mqf Sm hv~P{ ¡}¨[}_1sq_°_<h9|*[!fg_$mw fh¬fzi}Pfz_1m tj£hfg~]j_°|1iPfpmq_1s7ª Sn Z

(63) tliOmq /1_Y fpmgfq|*[}_7{Oi}~}hvjt9sgmg[}^¬f £©t9snmq[}_Yy}i}sqyPt:fz_¢tv£¶fq|*[}_<{Oi]~}l^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1¤hjy}y}® |<hmqt9~¡P¨ _~:mgsqtO{Oi]|$_mg[}_|$t9~]|$_<yOmItj£¶h &'3$% 4 F&Pªbº |$t9~ ]9i}sqhvmgtj~¦ fb{}_ ]~}_7{Shjfbhlfgi}]fg_$m tj£mg[}_fg_$mItv£mg[}_y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqfhhv hv}_°¨®mq[}~¼h|$i]fzmg_1s7ª Ihvmqhy]hjsqhj_1Ãm*hjfg¥fIhvsq_fg|*[]_<{Oi}_<{t9~ |1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f1ª

(64) ³´[}_°~lm*hjfg¥fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]mq[}_-fz^¬hv_<fzm |1tj^y}iOm*hmgtj~PhvÃ_1_1^_1~:m fh¢y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs7¡ ~t9i}sC¨§t9sg¥bmg[]_ fg^¬hv_7fpmC_1_1^_1~:mfhb|$t9~ ]ji]sqhvmgtj~ª³¹_ ^yLt9fg_ hwmg_7|*[}~} |1hvsq_<fzmgsq|$mgtj~o-^Y mg~}|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf¶mqt|$t9~9m*hv~¦~:i]^L_1s*f tv£y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqf§mg[PhmIhjsg_°yLt¨§_<sqf tv£ ª¶Z [} fsg_7fpmqsg |²mqt9~ f-|$t9~j_1~]_<~9Jm M©L_<|<hvi]fg_®m-sq_<{OiP|$_<fbmq[}_~i}^L_1s-tj£§yLt9fqfz}_|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f On2hv~]{¼ fbmpo:y]|<hvC£©tjs ^t:fpm5{}hm*hy]hvs*hv_1hvy}y} |1hmqt9~]f<ª

(65) ºw fgt]¡£©t9s

(66) mq[}_fghj¥j_ tv£Pfg^Yy] |$mpoj¡v¨ _ tj~}o|$t9~]fg{O_<ssg_7|²mqhj~}ji]hjs |1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f mg[]hvmbfgy]hv~S|1tj~:mgji]tji]fy]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f<ª Z [} fw fmq[}_mpoy} |1hj¤i]fg_tj£Wy]hvs*hv_<¤|$t9^y}iOmg_ sq_<fgtji]sq|1_<f<ªW½

(67) ~]hjoj¡]£©tjswhjj_<~|$tj~ ]ji}s*hmqt9~fg /1_j¡]¨§_-t9~}o|$t9~]fz {O_<sw|$tj~ ]ji}s*hmqt9~]f mg[Phm£©tjsq^ h~}tj~}>t9_1sqhjy}y}~}°mg~}Ytv£mq[}_°|$i]fpmq_1s M U '(U=VÊ£©tjsh|1i]fzmg_<s ¨®mq[ L¢y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqf5¨ _btj~}o¬|$tj~Pfz {O_1s mp¨ t 1 × 4 |$tj~ ]ji}s*hmqt9~]f<¡9mp¨ t 4 × 1 |1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f hv~]{lmp¨§t 2 × 2 |$t9~ ]9i}sqhvmgtj~]f O²ªC«W~O£©t9sq|1~] ~]tj~Otj_<sg hvy}y]~}|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]fn_<~]fgi}sg_7fwmq[]hmhj5|$t9~ ]9i}sqhvmgtj~]fntv£Wmq[}_¬fghj^_Yfg= /<_Y|<hv~¼P_iOmq® /1_<{¢|$t9~]|$i}sqsq_1~:mgo°:o¢hny]hjsqhj_1hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~ªCºw~Y_$k}hv^y}_ tv£Phjmq[}_ |1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f¤¨ _ |$tj~Pfz {O_1s £©t9shv~ Ly}sqt|1_<fqfzt9sI|1i]fzmg_<s-f°99_1~¼~ ZChv}_¦`jª¬ºwmg[}_7fz_¬sq_<fzmgsq |²mgtj~Pfbhjsg_¢£©tjsfg^Yy] |$mpo@hv~P{ |1tj~j_<~}_1~]|1_Yhj~]{|1hv~L_¬_<h9fzo@sg_<^Yt9_<{Êª¯nt¨§_<j_<s<¡Êsq_1^t~]!mq[}_¬sq_<fzmgsq|$mgtj~¹tv£ sg_7|²mqhj~}ji]hjs hj~]{|$tj~:mq9i}tji]f |1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf¶^¬ho^¬hv~P{}hmq_°fgtjy][}fzmg |1hvmg_7{lhvy]y} |1hvmgtj~yP_<sz£©t9sg^¬hj~]|$_b^t{}_1 f1ª . !.

(68) .

(69) .

(70) .

(71) .

(72) .

(73) .

(74) .

(75) .

(76) .

(77) .

(78) Z hj}_Y`+ fpmtj£|1tj~]fg{}_1sq_<{l|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f§£©tjswhv~Ly}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs |$i]fpmq_1s7ª ·µ~@fgi}^^¬hvsqoj¡P£©tjsnmg[}_¢y}i}sqyPt:fz_tj£¶fg|*[]_<{Oi}~}]¡]mg[}_mqhvsqj_1mIhvs*|*[}mg_7|²mgi]sg_ fnhj]fzmgs*hj|²mq_<{h9fn|$t9® _<|$mgtj~]f tj£ c |1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf C = {Ck : k = 1, · · · , c} fzi}}up_<|²m mgt¢mg[]_bsq_<fzmgsq |²mgtj~Pf¶fzmg_7{lhjPt9_jª ºn~¦i}y}yL_1swLtji}~P{lt9~!mq[}_-~i}^L_1stj£C|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf§ Sf + W^ hvsqoSmgtSmg[}_l{}_ ]~}mgtj~ y]sgt9js*hv^fw^YtO{O_<_7{:o!h wºiI. M blogX 2 (Pi )c X i=1. j=0. (j + 1). . Pi . 2j. MpÒ. tj£ hSy]hvs*hv_<5y}sqtjjs*hv^ jj_1~¹~ W_<|$mgtj~ Oª×O¡Ch¦^®kO_<{O>y]hjsqhj_1 ¡]¨[}_1sq_ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ fh¬fg_$mtv£ ∗ {]hmqhv>yPhvs*hv_<mqhjfg¥Ofhv~P{ E = Ei,jG = f(N hfg_$,mYE)tv£_<{O9_<f-sqN_1y]sg=_7fz_<{N ~9mqi~]S: i{O=_1yL1_1~]· {}· ·_1N~]|1_7}fhv^t9~}¦mg[}N_7fz_ m*hjfg¥Of1ª³´[}_1sq_<h9f-~ mg[}_ly}i}sq_1o@m*hjfg¥9y]hjsqhj_15|1h9fz_¬_7hj|*[m*hjfg¥ Ni ~mq[}_ wiº I¨ hjfhjfqfzj~}_7{¼h |1tj^y}iOmq_-|$t9fzm<¡[}_<sg_°¨ _-hjfqfzj~l h

(79) A4

(80) >45-mgt_<h9|*[ly]hjsqhj_1Lm*hjfg¥Lª5Z [}_-|1t9fzm 9_<|$mgtjs sq_1y}sq_<fg_1~:mqf mq[}_|$t9^Yy]iOmg_|$t:fpmtv£Img[}_m*hjfg¥ ¨[}_1~ ^¬hvy}yL_<{ mgt_7hj|*[¸|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~ Ck ¡ k = 1, . . . , c ª¸³¹_ é é.

(81) .

(82) !"# $%&('. {}_1~}tjmg_Img[}_°|$t9^Yy]iOmg_°|$t:fpm tv£m*hjfg¥ ∗ t9~!|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~ :o ∗ ª5Z [} f |1t9fzm |<hv~L_°fz_1m§mqt ∞ £§h{}hm*hy]hvs*hv_1m*hjfg¥S|1hj~}~}tvm°^¬hvN¥9i_i]fg_¢tj£§h!y]hvsgmg |$i} hvCs°k|$t9~ ]w9i,k i}sqhvmgtj~PMSU '(U=V§{Oi}_Ymqt!^_1^t9sgo |1tj~]fzmgs*hv~:mqf O²ª Z

(83) t¬^t{}_1 ri,s,j,d ¡}mq[}_-mg^_~}_<_<{O_7{mgt¬sq_<{O fpmqsg}iOmq_°mg[}_¢hv^tji}~:mwtj£5{]hmqh Di,j L_$mp¨ _1_<~¦mqh9fz¥ O hj~]{!mqh9fz¥ ∗ Mâfq|*[}_<{Oi]_7{!t9~lmq[}_fgtji}s*|$_-|$t9~ ]9i}sqhvmgtj~ ∗ Mâfq|*[}_<{Oi]_7{!t9~{}_<fzmg~]hmqt9~¦|1tj~O N N s j Pjii}s*hmqt9~ O²¡ ¨ _[]hj_mgt |1tj~]fg {O_1smp¨ t |1C j h g f < _ < f ´ ª · £ j h ] ~ { hvsq_{O f©upt9~:mlfg_$mqf<¡ mg[}_<~2mg[}_ Cs Cd sq_<{}fzmgsq]iOmgCtjd~¦|$t:fpmw|1hj~lmq[}_1~¦L_-¨sgmzmq_1~hjfS+ ri,s,j,d =. Di,j τs,d + max |Cs |. . |Cd | |Cs | , |Cs | |Cd |. . MQ3O. βs,d .. Z []_ ]sqfzm-mg_<sg^ |$tjsqsq_<fgyPt9~]{}fImgt¦mq[}_]hj~]{O¨ {mg[ |$t9~]fgi}^yOmgtj~ hv~P{@¨ _hjfqfzi]^Y_Ymq[]hm¢hjWfgtji]sq|1_ y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f§yP_<sz£©t9sg^ |1tj^î}~]|<hmgtj~Pf§~¦y]hvs*hv_1>ª}-nmq[}_1sw|1tj^î}~]|<hmgtj~!^t{}_1 f|1hv~L_-_<hjfgo y]i}9j_7{ ~¸[}_1sq_l¨mg[]tjiOm~hv {}hmq~}¼tji}shvy]y}sgt:hj|*[ª¹Z [}_¦fz_7|$tj~P{mg_<sg^ |$t9sgsq_<fgyLtj~]{}fmgt¼mg[}_ hmq_1~]|1_7f1ª@·m¢ f]h9fz_7{ tj~mq[}_l^¬hkOî}^ ~i}^¢P_<stv£w^_7fgfqhv9_<f°mqt@L_l_$k}|*[]hj~}j_7{¹~ mq[}_!{]hmqh sq_<{}fzmgsq]iOmgtj~¡Ã¨[} |*[¼{}_1yL_1~]{}f°t9~Smq[}_¢sq_1 hmq9_~i}^¢P_<sbtj£§fgtji}s*|$_Yhv~]{¼{O_<fzmg~]hmqt9~Sy}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f |$ hvi]fg_jª¬·£ hv~]{ fg[]hjsg_y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f1¡Êfgtj^_{}hm*h¨WL_|$tjy]_7{ hj~]{¼f-99_1~¹oSmg[]_ t9~2mg[}_¹|$t9^Y^t9~ý}sgtOmax |1_<fqfzt9sqf¬hj~]{2mg[]_<Cfg_@s |$t9y}_7Cfld|<hv~´L_¼^¬hj{}_S~ y]hvs*hv_<Q¡ ¨[} |*[ fqhj_7ffzt9^_ Phv~]{O¨ {mq[¦hj~]{!tj~}_° hmg_<~]|$o|$t:fpm+ ri,s,j,d = max. . Di,j Di,j Di,j Di,j − , − |Cs | |Cd | |Cd | |Cs |. . . τs,d + max. . |Cd | |Cs | , |Cs | |Cd | . . . − 1 βs,d .. MâO. ³´mg[¹tji}s°~}_<¨ sq_1y}sq_<fg_1~:mqhvmgtj~tj£Wmg[}_y} hmg£©tjsq^ hjf°hl|1tj_7|²mgtj~¼tv£§|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~¡Lh!j_<~}_1sq | []_$mg_<sgt9j_<~}_1t9i]f¶^kO_<{¦{}hm*hhv~]{!mqh9fz¥ly]hvs*hv_<Êfg|*[}_7{Oi}~]hj9tjsq®mq[}^ |1hj~lmq[}_1~¦L_-¨sgmzmq_1~hjfS+ §t9^y}iOmg_bmq[}J _ 02 8;!AFA4 £©t9s_<hj|*[~}tO{O_°tv£Cmg[]_-js*hvy}[ l3

(84) : «W~:mgsqo!ZChjfg¥Of ³´[] _ 3 < :

(85) - f~}tvm_<^Yy}mpo rW |*¥mq[}_-~}tO{O_ N ∗ mq[]hmw^¬hkO^= /<_<f mg[]J_ 02 8;!AFA4 ¬£©i}~]|$mgtj~ ºnfqfg9~ N ∗ tj~!mg[}i_|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~ Cj mq[]hmw^~}^ /1_7f Fobj (N ∗, Cj ) i wyÃ{}hvmg _ li

(86) :. ¤ Y

(87) !0 Z

(88) tbiPfpmqsqhvmg_ tji}s5hjy}y}sqt9hj|*[¨§_ |*[}t9fg_§mgt°_$kmg_<~]{mg[}_ mqh9fz¥:y]hvs*hv_1fg|*[}_7{Oi}~]I[}_<i}sqfzmg | y}sgt9yPt:fz_7{ o Z

(89) i}yL|1i}tj9i 46Ub ~ G }A` H¡W¯w_$mq_1sqtj9_1~}_<tji]f«¶hvsq_<fzmY½C~} fz[ Z ^D _ MQ¯w«¶½iZ O$¡

(90) mqt@mq[}_l^kO_<{ yPhvs*hv_<

(91) |1h9fz_9ª°·mb fn^yPt9szm*hv~:mbmgtl~]tvmg_¢mg[Phm°tji}s°hvy}y]sgt:hj|*[¦fb9_1~}_<sqhj

(92) hv~P{@hvy]y} |1hj}_mgttvmq[}_1s m*hjfg¥:>y]hjsqhj_1fq|*[}_7{Oi}~}l[}_1i}sq fpmq|<f1ª ³¹_¢|*[}t:fz_¯n«¶½ZP_7|1hji]fz_®mn fbfz^y}_9¡PyLtjy]i}hjs<¡Lhv~]{¦¨ hjf fg[}t¨~mqt¼L_!|1tj^yP_1mgmgj_b ~ G }A` Hª¼·µ~ mg[} f¢fg_<|$mgtj~ ¨ _lsq_<|<hv¶mq[}_lPhjfg|<ftj£n¯w«¶½Z hj~]{ fg[}t¨ []t¨mg[}_y}sqtjsq®mpoShj~]{St9Oup_<|$mgj_Y£©i}~]|$mgtj~]f-hjsg_hj{}hjyOmg_7{£©t9sb^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1fg^ mgt{O_<j_1tjy@mg[}_ x¯n«¶½Z MQx®kO_7{¯n«¶½iZ O [}_<i}sg fzmg |vª ê}>AA. .

(93) L. UX$%494U. J{. ^T_. `. Z []_y}sqt9sgmpo£©i]~]|²mqt9~Si]fg_<{o¦¯w«¶½Z fnPhjfg_<{¦tj~pi}y¨ hvs*{sqhj~}¥~}*ªZ [}_¢i}y¨ hjsq{¦s*hv~]¥!tj£5h m*hjfg¥ Ni f{O_]~}_<{sq_<|1i}sqfgj_1o¬o!+ M©( O ranku (Ni ) = wi + max (ci,j + ranku (Nj )) , N ∈Succ(N ) ¨[]_1sq_ wi = Pp wi,j /p f

(94) mq[}_ h9_1s*hv9_5_$kO_<|1iOmgtj~Y|$t9fzm

(95) tj£}mqh9fz¥ Ni tj_1sChvOhhj hv]_Wy]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f<ª Z []_h9_1s*hv9_|$t9j=1 ^Y^¢i}~} |1hvmgtj~¼|1t9fzm ci,j tv£ hj~@_7{Oj_ Ei,j f-{O_ P~}_<{¹hjf ci,j = β + Di,j τ ¡¤¨[]_1sq_ Y f g m } [ _ h j < _ q s j h j _¬mqsqhj~]fz£©_1s¬s*hmg_¦hv^t9~}@mq[}_y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs*f~¸mq[}_{Otj^¬hj~2hv~]{ β fYmq[}_Shj_<sqhjj_ τ|1tj^î]~}|<hmqt9~!fzmqhvsgmgi]yª Z [}_bsq_<hj{}om*hjfg¥f§hvsq_nfgtjsgmg_<{¨mg[!sg_<9hjsq{¢mgtmg[}_°{O_7|$sq_<hjfg~}-tjs*{O_1s§tv£Êmq[}_ hji}_7f1ª5Z [}_ m*hjfg¥¨mg[¬mq[}_w[}j[]_<fzm¶y}sqt9sgmpo f¶fg_1_<|$mg_<{ªC·£Ãmp¨ t|1hj~]{O {}hmq_w~}tO{O_<f¶[]hj_ mq[}_nrank fqhv^_wu y}sqtjsq®mpo9¡vtj~}_ tj£¤mq[}_1^ fwfg_1_<|$mg_7{ls*hv~]{}tjô9ª _$£©t9sg_~9mqsgtO{OiP|$~}@mq[}_¦tjOup_7|²mq9_l£©i}~P|²mgtj~ tv£°¯w«¶½Z°¡Wfgtj^_~}tvm*hmgtj~PfYhjsg_~}_<_<{O_7{Êª¸Z [}_ «§hvsq_<fzrm W:m*hvsgm Z ^B_ M EST O¶hv~]{mq[}_°«¶hvsq_7fpm ½

(96) ~} fz[Z ^Y_ M EF T O5tv£¤mqhjfg¥ Ni t9~y}sqt|1_<fqfzt9s Pj hjsg_°{O_ ]~}_<{¦h9f £©tjt¨wSf + j. EST (Ni , Pj ) = max Avail(Pj ),. i. max. Nk ∈P red(Ni ). (AF T (Nk ) + ck,i ) ,. MQ3O MFRO. ¨ []_1sq_ Avail(Pj ) fwmq[}_Y_<hvsq_7fpmmq^_hmI¨[]|*[Sy]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs Pj fwsq_<h9{Ool£©t9snmq[}_m*hjfg¥!_1kO_<|$i}mgtj~ª Z []_¢~}~}_<s }tO|*¥¦~@mg[}_ _ 9iPhmgtj~@sg_<y}sg_7fz_<~:mqfmq[}_ 3 4 0Y¢£©t9sbmqhjfg¥ ¡}FUU=VWmg[}_ mq^_w¨[]_1~¬max hv}~}_<_<{O_7{¬{}hm*h°[]hjEST f5hjsgsq9_<{¢tj~y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs Pj ª AF T (Nk ) {O_1~]tvmg_7fmg[]_ N>4 i$< &<@ " ¡ FUSU=V mg[]fmqhjfg¥@[Phjf-L_1_<~ fg|*[}_7{Oi}_<{¹tj~ h¦y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs7¡¤hj~]{¹®m*f ]~} fg[mg^Y_lf E 0J!tv£ mqhjfg¥ Nk ¥~}t¨~¤ª ¯n«¶½Z i]fg_<f T hjfbmq[}_tjOup_7|²mgj_Y£©i}~P|²mgtj~¼£©tjsfg_1_<|$mg~}mg[}_L_<fzmy}sqt|1_<fqfzt9sn£©t9s-h!~]t{}_jª Z []_¬sqhvmgtj~]hj_ f°EF mg[]hvm-mg[}_fq|*[}_7{Oi}_¬_<~}vmq[¹ f°mq[}__<hjsg_<fzm P~}fg[¹mg^_tv£ mg[}_¬_1kO®m~}tO{O_9ª!Z [}_ ~]t{}_ Ni f¶mg[i]f hjfqfg9~}_<{¢mgtmg[}_Iy}sqt|1_<fqfzt9s Pj mg[]hvm§^~]^ /1_<f EF T (Ni, Pj ) ªWZ [}_ EST hji]_<f £©t9s_<h9|*[!tj£¤mg[]_-sg_<^hj~]~}~}tO{O_-hj~]{!mg[}_fg_$mtv£sq_<hj{}omqhjfg¥Ofhvsq_nmq[}_1~¦i}yÃ{}hvmg_<{ª EF T (Ni , Pj ) = wi,j + EST (Ni , Pj ),. ^].

(97)

(98) ` J{ m. µ· ~mq[} f§fg_<|$mgtj~¬¨ _wy}sq_<fg_1~:m¶^tO{O L|1hmqt9~]f5mqt-mg[]_ny}sqt9sgmpo¢hj~]{tj}up_<|²mq9_£©i}~]|$mgtj~]f§tv£Ãmq[}_I¯n«¶½Z hj9tjsq®mq[}^ mqtl{O_1sqj_-h^®kO_<{O>y]hjsqhj_1¤y]hvs*hv_<Êj_<sqfgt9~¡}x¦µ¯w«¶½Z-ª ³¹_ ]s*fpmnh9{}hvyOmmq[}_|1tj^y}iO m*hmqt9~tv£ ranku ¡:mq[}_-¯w«¶½Zý}sqtjsq®mpoY£©i}~]|$mgtj~ª5³¹_b~:mgsqtO{Oi]|1_wmg[]_I^k_7{y]hvs*hv_<]i}y¨ hvs*{¬s*hv~}¥ tj£¤m*hjfg¥ N ∗ {O_ ]~}_7{!sq_<|1i}s*fzj_<o¬hjSf + i M> O rank ∗ (N ∗ ) = w∗ + max ri,j + ranku N ∗ , u. i. i. j. Nj∗ ∈Succ(Ni∗ ). ¨[]_1sq_ w∗ fmq[}_h9_1s*hv9_Y^kO_<{y]hvs*hv_1¶_1kO_<|$i}mgtj~ |1t9fzm¢tv£m*hjfg¥ N ∗ hj~]{ ri,j fmg[}_¦hj_<sqhjj_ sq_<{}fzmgsq]iiOmgtj~¦|$t:fpmwtj£hj~_7{Oj_ Ei,j ªrW_19_1s*hvÊtjy}mgtj~]fhjsg_°yLt9fqfz}_°£©tjisn{O_]~}~}mg[]_<fg_hj_1s*hv9_<f<ª ·µ~mq[}f yPhvyL_1s¨ _|$tj~Pfz {O_1s mq[}_¢yPt:fgfg]_-{O_]~}mgtj~]f £©t9s w∗ + i. é é.

(99) .

(100) !"# $%&('. ½}t9t¨~]_$k}hj|$mgo@mq[}_!fqhv^_hvy]y}sgt:hj|*[ hjf¯w«¶½Z°¡5|$t9^Yy]iOmg_ w∗ h9f°mg[]_!fgi}^ tv£ mg[}_|$t9^¢ y}iOmq_mq^_<fw£©tjs N ∗ t9_1snhj `$y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs|$t9~ ]ji]sqhvmgtj~]f<¡P{O{}i_<{o!mg[}_¢~:i]^L_1sbtv£WfziP|*[ |$t9~ ]ji]sqhvmgtj~]Kf MqFUiU=V¤mq[}_-~i}^L_1stj£Cy]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f§~mg[]_-y}hvmz£©t9sg^1O²ª º{}hjyOmg~}w¯n«¶½Z {Osq_<|$mgowmqtmg[}_¶^YkO_<{y]hjsqhj_1j|<hjfg_j¡<tj~}_¶|<hv~-|$t9^y}iOmg_ w∗ h9f Pc w∗ /c ¡ ¨[}_1sq_ c fÊmg[]_W~i}^L_1stj£}|$tj~ ]ji}s*hmqt9~]f<ª §i}m¤~°mq[} f¤|1h9fz_Wfg_19_1s*hv {O_1~:mg |1ihj9|1tj~ ]j=1 9i}s*hi,jmgtj~Pf hvsq_¬hj|1|1tji}~:mq_<{£©t9s-~_7hj|*[|$i]fpmq_1s7¡¨[} |*[¼^¬hoSsq_<fgi}m-~ h} hjfg~}¦tj£¶mg[]_hj_1s*hv9_jªY½}tjs ~Pfpm*hv~]|1_j¡~!hvN ~ Lv>y}sqtO|$_7fgfgtjs¶|1iPfpmq_1s7¡jmq[}_bhjPt9_£©tjsqî]h°£©t9s ¨P~]|$t9sgyLtjs*hmq_n|$t9^y}iOmg_ |$t:fpm*fb£©tj6s L{}_1~:mg |1hj`$y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sb|1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf1ªYZ¤thjt9{Swmgi∗[}_¬]h9fz~}¦tv£§mg[}_h9_1s*hvj_9¡ ¨§_¬_<~O£©tjs*|$_mq[]hm7¡¤£©t9sh¦jj_<~¹|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~¹fg= /<_j¡

(101) tj~}o@t9~}_|$t9~ ]ji]sqhvmgtj~¹P_¬m*hv¥9_1~¹~:mgt hj|<|$tji]~9m £©t9s_<hj|*[¦|$i]fzmg_<s<ª WO^hjsgoj¡O¨ _°i]fz_°mq[}_b£©tjt¨~}Y{O_ P~}®mqt9~]f £©t9s + ri,j ºnf§~l¯w«¶½Z°¡Ohjfqfgi}^_nfz_<sg hvP|$tj^^¢i}~} |1hmqt9~]f¶hj~]{|1tj^y}iOmq_ hjfWmg[}_bfzi]^ tj£Êmg[}_bhj_<sqhjj_ ~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥bhvmg_1~P|$o-hv~]{tv£Omg[]_§{}hvmqhnfg /1_¶{O{}_<{oImg[}_ hj_<sqhjjr_i,j~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥b]hv~P{O¨{Omg[ª

(102) ·µ~mg[]f y]hvyL_1s ¨ _nt9~}o¬|1tj~]fg{}_1s [}tj^tj9_1~}_<tji]fW~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥Of1¡fztmg[}_°hj_<sqhjj_ hmq_1~]|1ohj~]{Phv~]{O¨ {mq[ hvsq_° _ :i]hvÃmqtYmg[}_- hmq_1~]|1o!hv~P{l]hj~]{O¨ {mg[¦tj£Chv~o~]_$mp¨ tjsq¥¬~}¥Ãª Æ º{}hjyOmg~} ¯w«¶½Z {Osq_<|²mqo mqt,mg[]_ ^®kO_7{>yPhvs*hv_<¸|1h9fz_9¡0tj~]_ |1hj~ |$t9^Yy]iOmg_ ri,j hjf Pc 2 ªC¯w_<sg_ hv9hj~¤¡fg_19_1s*hvv {O_<~9mq|<hv:sg_7{O fpmqsg}iOmqt9~]f¤hjsg_ hj|1|1tji}~:mq_<{b£©tjs7¡¨[} |*[ ^¬hs,d=1 osg_7fzri]i,s,j,d ®m5~Y/c hb} hjfg~]btj£]mq[}_whj_<sqhjj_jªÊ³¹_ _1~O£©t9sq|1_ mg[]hvm5£©tjs5hbjj_1~fgtji}s*|$_ |$t9~ ]ji]sqhvmgtj~ fz /1_hv~P{¼h!jj_<~@{O_<fzmg~]hvmgtj~¼|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~@fz /1_9¡Êtj~}otj~]_¢sq_<{O fzmgsq}i}mgtj~@L_¢mqhv¥9_1~¼~:mgt hj|<|$tji]~9m7ª ·µ~¸mg[]f¬yPhvyL_1s¬¨ _¦|1tj~]fg {O_1smq[}_£©tjt¨~}¹mp¨§t|$t9^}~]hvmgtj~]ftj£nmg[]_ShvLtj_¦{O_ ]~]®mqt9~]f¬tv£ w∗ hj~]{ ri,j £©t9s°mg[}_x¦µ¯w«§½CZ¾y}sqt9sgmpo¦£©i}~]|$mgtj,~ +1MQh O MQS| O°hj~]{ Mâ O MQ<{ O²¡C¨[} |*[¼¨ _¬{O_1~]tvmg_oi x¯n«¶½Z°`hv~]{x¦µ¯w«¶½ZwOª Z

(103) t|1tj^y}_$mq_¢t9i}s-{O_<fq|$sqy}mgtj~@tj£§x¦µ¯w«¶½Z-¡Ê¨ _Y~}_1_7{mgt¦{O_ ]~}_®m*fbtjOup_7|²mgj_¢£©i}~]|$mgtj~ª¢³¼_ iPfz_Ymg[]_fqhv^_¬hvy]y}sgt:hj|*[@h9f-¯w«¶½Z°¡]iOm^t{}®£©omq[}_|$t9^y}iOmqhvmgtj~¹tv£§mg[}_ EST hv~]{@mg[}_ EF T hji}_7f-mqt@fzi]y}yPt9szmh^®kO_7{>yPhvs*hv_<W_$kO_<|1iOmgtj~¤ªS³¼_!~:mqsgtO{Oi]|1_ EST ∗ hv~]{ EF T ∗ {}_ ]~}_7{ hjf £©t9t¨wSf + EST ∗ (Ni∗ , Cj ) = max Avail(Cj ),. max. Nk∗ ∈P red(Ni∗ ). (AF T (Nk∗ , Cl ) + rk,l,i,j ) ,. ∗ EF T ∗ (Ni∗ , Cj ) = wi,j + EST ∗ (Ni∗ , Cj ),. MFLO MâO. ¨ []_1sq_ Avail(Cj ) fmg[}_-_7hvsq_<fzm mg^Y_¢hmw¨[} |*[hvÊmg[}_-y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs*f tv£Cmg[}_|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~ Cj hvsq_ sq_<h9{Oo£©t9smg[]_-mqh9fz¥_$kO_<|1iOmgtj~¤ª ntvmg_mg[}_iPfz_tj£mg[}_sq_<{}fzmgsq]iOmgtj~S|1t9fzm ¡P¨[}|*[sq_1y]h9|$_<f mq[}_|$tj^^¢i}~} |1hmqt9~ |$t:fpm ck,i ~ mg[}_¼mqh9fz¥:y]hvs*hv_1I¯n«¶½Z°ªºnf~ mg[}_¼rmqk,l,i,j h9fz¥:y]hvs*hv_1w9_1s*fztj~¡ {O_<~}tvmq_<fImg[}_ l4 $< &<@ " 0Jtv£Wm*hjfg¥ ∗ }¡ FUU=VWmq[}fIm*hjfg¥[]hjfbhvsg_7hj{Oo¦L_1_<~ AF T (Nk∗ , Cl ) fq|*[}_7{Oi}_<{!tj~¦hY|1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~ Cl ¡]hj~]{lmqf ]~} fz[mg^_-f ¥N~}tk¨~¤ª ê}>AA. .

(104) `7. UX$%494U. I"$!-

(105) #$ '(

(106) ¬!"1 ³¹_wsq_<fgtjsgm5mgtfgî} hmqt9~£©tjs¶_<hvi]hmq~}-t9i}s§hjy}y}sqt9h9|*[Yh9f5®m hvt¨wfWi]f5mqtyP_<sz£©t9sg^hfzmqhvmg fpmq|<hvo fgj~} P|1hj~:m¶~i}^L_1s§tv£_$kOyL_1sq^_<~9m*f¶hj~]{¬^¬hv¥9_<f5 f¶yLt9fqfg}_mqt_$kOy}tjsq_wh¨ {O_ws*hv~]j_wtj£Ãy]hvmz£©tjsq^ |1tj~ Pji}s*hmqt9~]f1ª´³¹_Si]fg_¦mg[] _

(107) mgttj¥®m G }¡I`<

(108) HIh9fmg[]_£©tji}~P{}hmqt9~ tj£-tji}sfg^¢i} hmgt9s<ª ly}sqt: {O_7f¤]h9fz_hj]fpmqsqh9|²mqt9~]f£©t9sCmg[}_{O fg|1sg_1mg_1>_<j_1~:mfzî} hmqt9~¢tj£]y]hjsqhj_1Ohvy]y} |1hvmgtj~]f ~ {O fpmqsg}iOmq_<{¹_1~sqtj~]^Y_<~:mqf°hv~]{¹¨ hjf-fgyP_7|$ P|1hjo@{O_7fzj~]_<{@£©tjs-mq[}_¬_1hvi]hvmgtj~¹tv£fg|*[}_7{Oi}~] hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬f1ªC³¹_b{O_1mqhjLP_<t¨0mg[}_by} hmz£©t9sg^¬f<¡:hjy}y}|<hmqt9~]f1¡hv~P{lfq|*[}_<{Oi]~}¢hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬f5mq[]hm ¨§_ iPfz_°~t9i}swfg^¢i}hvmgtj~]f<ª ^T_. . Dqvyx af<c k. ³¹_-|$t9~]fz {O_<s y]hvmz£©tjsq^¬f mg[]hvmw|$tj~Pfz fpmtj£§`j¡]}¡O]¡Ot9srL|1i]fzmg_<sqf<ª«¶hj|*[¦|$i]fzmg_<sw|$tj~:m*hv~]f h¢s*hv~P{Otj^ ~i}^¢P_<s¬tv£by}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9sqf¢P_1mp¨§_<_1~2 hv~]{ RvP¡¶~}tjm¬^®mq_<{¸mgt yLt¨§_<sqfYtj£°Oª2rWsqtO|$_7fgfgtjs¬fgyP_<_<{¸f []tj^tj9_1~}_<tji]fl¨®mq[}~ _<h9|*[ |1i]fzmg_<s ¢|$i]fpmq_1s¦y}sqtO|$_<fqfgtjs!fgyL_1_<{]fhjsg_fqhv^y}_<{´£©sqtj^ h¸i}~}£©tjsq^ y]sgt9]hv}®mpoY{Ofzmgsq}iOmgtj~¤¡j£©t9s¶hvsqt9i]fW^_7hv~]f§hv~]{s*hv~}9_<f<¡j¨mg[¬mq[}_ns*hv~]j_L_1~}y}sqtjyLtjsgmgtj~]hjOmgt mq[}_-^_<hj~ª5³¼_{}_ ]~}_-y]sgtO|$_7fgfgtjs fgyP_<_<{¦hjf mq[}_-~i}^L_1swtj£

(109) }tj ~ ]t:hmg~}yLtj~9mwt9yP_<sqhvmgtj~]f yL_1s fg_<|1tj~]{ MI°½Ctjy vfz_7S| O²ª½}t9sWhv_$kOyP_<sg^_1~:mqf¨ _hjfqfzi]^Y_§mg[Phm5mg[]_ ~]_$mp¨ tjsq¥-[]hjf5h°I^f hmq_1~]|1ohv~P{ h`<Q I m fg_<|w]hv~]{}¨{mq[ª5³¹_n¥j_<_1ymq[}_n~}_1mp¨§t9sg¥Y|*[]hvs*hj|$mg_<sg fpmq|<f }kO_<{lhv~]{hvsqo¢mg[}_Iy}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9s fgyL_1_<{]f¶mqt¢_1kOyP_<sg^_1~:m ¨mg[hs*hv~]j_ntj£¤y} hmg£©tjsq^|1tj^î]~}|<hmqt9~ |1tj^y}iOm*hmgtj~lsqhvmgt9f<ªCZChv}_b fpm*fÃmg[}_¶hji]_<f¨ _5i]fg_<{I£©tjs¤mg[}_7fz_5yPhvs*hv^_$mq_1s*f1¡1mg[}_¶|1tj^¢}~Phmgtj~°tj£:¨[} |*[-j_<~}_1s*hmq_<f3 Lj {O±L_<sg_<~9m y]hvmz£©tjsq^ |1tj~ ]9i}s*hmgtj~Pf1ª´wtjmg_¦mq[]hml_7hj|*[ ~Pfpm*hv~:mg hmqt9~¸[]h9f¬s*hv~]{Ot9^ _1_1^_<~9m*f1¡ ~]hj^Y_<o mg[}_ ~i}^¢P_<stv£y}sqt|1_<fqfzt9sqf yL_1sn|1iPfpmq_1s7¡]hv~]{!_<h9|*[¦y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9s fgyP_<_<{Êª Z [}_1sq_$£©t9sg_9¡¨§_-9_1~}_<sqhvmg_-fz_<j_<sqhj fqhv^y}_<f £©t9s_<h9|*[ly} hmg£©tjsq^ |$t9~ ]9i}sqhvmgtj~ª ~:i]^L_1stv£|$i]fzmg_1s*f `j¡]O¡]]¡#L ^Y_7hv~y}sqt|1_<fqfzt9s fgyL_1_<{ M I°½

(110) tjy fg_<S| O `j¡]O¡¤`<}¡}j}¡Ê`<9}¡}v9}¡Ã`<9j y}sgtO|1_<fqfzt9s fgyP_<_<{s*hv~}9_ }¡ 0.2 × mean ¡Êª<ª1ª1¡ 1.8 × mean ~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥¬hvmg_<~]|$o Mâ^¬f O ~}_$mp¨ tjsq¥¬]hv~P{O¨{Omg[ MI m fg_<| O `< ZChv}_% +r5hvs*hv^_1mg_1s*f§£©tjswfg^¢i} hmg_7{ly]hvmz£©tjsq^¬f1ª. ^] l nT!vyx#nqahlk. ³¹_¦|$tj~Pfz {O_1s¢mp¨ t¼|$ hjfqfg_<ftj£Ihvy]y} |1hvmgtj~ n ºiI°f1¡¶{}_1y} |²mq_<{ ~¸½Cji}sq_¹`j¡Whv~P{ ¨[} |*[ ¨ _!{O_1mqhj L_1t¨-ª. 1}7 À ·µ~@`73 R9}%¡ W:mgs*hjfqfz_<~y}sqtjyLt9fg_<{hj~lhvjt9sgmg[]^¾mqtY|1tj^y}iOmq_nmq[}_by}sgtO{OiP|²m tv£mp¨ t ¬^ hvmgsq|1_<f mg[Phmw~}_<_<{}fn¢^¢i}®mqy] |1hvmgtj~]f ~]fzmg_<h9{tv£yLG×vH>ªWZ [}_-_<9[:m ^¢i}mgy} |1hvmgtj~¦ fsg_<y} 2hj×|$_7{2 oYh-fz_1mWtv£Ê_1j[:mg_<_1~¬hj{]{O®mqt9~]f5tj£Lt¨§_<sW|$t9^Yy]_1kmpojªZ [} fWhvjt9sgmg[]^¾|1hj~P_nhjy}y}_7{Ysg_7|$i}s*fzj_<o mqt 2 × 2 }t|*¥^¬hvmgsq|1_<fbmgt¦hj|*[]_<j_hv~hjfgo:^yOmqtvmq|Y|$t9^Yy]_1kmpotv£ O(nlog(7)) ¡¨[}_1sq_ n fbmg[}_ é é.

(111) `9`.

(112) !"# $%&('. +. + + *. + +. * +. * +. + + *. + +. + +. * +. W:mqsqh9fgfg_1~. * +. + *. +. +. ½

(113) ji]sg_`3+5ºny}y}|<hmgtj~ w ºiI°f<ª. ½]tjsq¥99tj~. {}^_1~Pfztj~´tj£bmq[}_@^¬hvmgsq|1_<f<ª Z []_@_$£»m!yPhvsgmtv£½C9i}sq_ `@fz[]t¨wfmg[}_ wiº I |$t9sgsq_<fgyLtj~]{O~}¹mgt mq[}_]s*fpm°_<j_<Ctj£ {O_7|$t9^YyLt9fgmgtj~@tj£Wmg[]_JWmgs*hjfqfz_<~¼hvjt9sgmg[]^¡Ã¨[}_<sg_Y~}tO{O_7f°^hjsg¥9_<{¨mg[h sq_1y]sg_7fz_<~9m°^¬hmqsgk¹h9{}{Omgtj~]f<¡¤hv~P{@mq[}t9fg_^¬hvsq¥j_<{¼¨mg[ h Êsg_<y}sq_<fg_1~:m-^hvmgsq®k¼î}mgy}|<hmgtj~Pf1ª ³¹_~]fzmqhv~:mqhvmg_ R¬fziP|*[ niº I°f1¡P¨[}|*[¦¨ _|1hj Wmgs*hjfqfz_<~O d £»t9s d = 2, ..7 ¡Pfzi]|*[mq[]hmw_7hj|*[mqh9fz¥!~ Wmgs*hjfqfz_<~O t9yP_<sqhvmg_<f t9~h ^¬hmqsgkÊª d (1000 × 2d ) × (1000 × 2d ).

(114) Å Â ÊÅ ³¹_bhjfgt_1kyL_1sq^Y_<~:m§¨mg[¦fz^y}_n£©tjsq¥:upt9~ nºiI°f fgtmq[]hm ¨ _I|1hj~l_<hjiPhmg_Itji}s hj9tjsq®mq[}^¬f°£©tjs¢js*hv[]f¨®mq[ [}j[ {O_<jsq_1_¬tv£m*hjfg¥:>y]hjsqhj_1 fz^¦ª·µ~ y]hvsgmg |$i} hvs7¡

(115) mg[}_lmqhjfg¥:>yPhvs*hv_< ¯n«¶½Z´[}_<i}sg fzmg |wfz[]tji} {¬L_n_$±Ã_<|$mgj_£©t9s fgi]|*[¬9sqhjy}[]f<ª

(116) ³¹_n~]fzmqhv~:mqhvmg_£©t9sg¥:uptj~ wºiI°f¶¨mg[@`<}¡ j}¡Chv~]{2`7j!mqh9fz¥Of<ª!«¶h9|*[¹mqhjfg¥¹f-_<®mq[}_1sYh¦^¬hmgsqk¹hj{]{O®mqt9~ tjs^¬hvmgsq®k¹î}mgy}|<hmgtj~ Mâ¨[} |*[ ^¬hj¥j_<f®mYyPt:fgfg}_lmgt¼sg_<i]fz_!tjsY{}hm*hy]hvs*hv_<¶hvy]y} |1hvmgtj~ yL_1sg£©tjsq^ ^YtO{O_<f O²ª¹³¹_hjfgt@hjfqfgi}^_ mq[]hmYmg[]_l_1~:mqsgo¹mqh9fz¥ fg_1~]{ mp¨§t@^hvmgsq|1_<fmgt¼_<hj|*[ ~}~]_1s¢mqhjfg¥Ã¡Whv~]{ mg[]hvmY_7hj|*[ ~}~}_<sm*hjfg¥fg_1~P{ mq[}_sq_<fgi}mtv£ mg[}_l^hvmgsq®ktjyL_1s*hmqt9~¡ FUU=Vtj~}_¬^¬hvmgsq®kÊ¡

(117) mgtmq[}__1~P{¹mqhjfg¥Ãª!³¹_9_1~}_<sqhvmg_ wiº I°f ¨mg[j

(118) ¡¤j

(119) l¡Êhv~]{v