Experience with the PerDiS large-scale data-sharing middleware

Texte intégral

(1)Experience with the PerDiS large-scale data-sharing middleware Marc Shapiro, Paulo Ferreira, Nicolas Richer. To cite this version: Marc Shapiro, Paulo Ferreira, Nicolas Richer. Experience with the PerDiS large-scale data-sharing middleware. 9th International Workshop on Persistent Object Systems (POS), Sep 2000, Lillehammer, Norway. pp.55-69, �10.1007/3-540-45498-5_6�. �hal-01248216�. HAL Id: hal-01248216 https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01248216 Submitted on 24 Dec 2015. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2)

(3) "! #$%&('*)+#,!- . #/0# '*)#$ -

(4) %213 .4. ! 5#$(6 97 8;:=<$>@?A8CBEDF:HG@IJ K LAM8CNEOPGRQAS-:H:TSUDF:=8CVWLA8CXAYZD[< GCO[8C\]DP<=?ESU:HK ^`_RacbTdfehgieUjFkmlon=ginp dfbTq`rEktsAuwv@x;kuzy(n=eUdf{Un|(eh}~ginhvAy(}zawcs~qzpUwx kucvzp-/~dfacsC{hn -(| v ¸ºakf¹¢n(slo¹®»½a {W¼~sCdfehe ¾®nTkh@x~ ¿(hl-;v;Àm[@eU-,CpUa i n;sC- ~nm-Áª;ehUw¡ }z b=Hn=pU}*¢UvzW £zuv+Â¤u*¥¢=¥HÃW¦;Ä § ÜvÅ¨ l©ªe ©+b=©ªÆ;«f}~¬®n ¯±bH° ²eh³ }~¯´² diµCk° vz¶¢¯PÇ-ÜÈC· ¬TÄ-¤-$µ;¦hr*²wn¯cW¨ 0q~n=g p=É0ns~nHÊEvzË~dtp b=nhW@ h-;±Ì~hhWW *ÍCW Îh ¡; ÌWC hÍÏh@v ¤¥¢¥T¦;§ ¨h¨ ©ª©ª©+«f¬® ¯±° ²w³ ¯[² µ;° ¶Í¯P¨h·0¯[² ÐU¤-ÑU¯P¨ Ò ¹ÍmÓ+xzv~l}zp/»wÔWnHglnsCeh*Õ Ö+×CvAÃUÃhÃ,r*awgiÅeWp0ns~nHÊEvzÂeUdikf}~{WpU´ @ UU;± ;-ØCW±Ï ÎhW Î -;h¡;Ì;Î;W± Wzv0¤¥Í¥H¦;§ ¨h¨©+©ª©(° ÙU¬iÚ@° ²w³-ÑH¬iÐh°¦¥i¨ ÂnHdfÀ(aPxàwgpRsCawg®kidfac~}~kfnsº¼ÅnHdfgiawg®kfn k$acszsCwnHãp dfn/¼zcp kij[eUdfvAa Ö fkÛ,n Üs~Ý=nÞ=ß sà@kfáUemÞhnâ p-gin kfq~ns~awg®kidfawz}Ckfns/giqzp-dfa {me-jEwe {- ÖäkfnHdfåszp ktpCuU¹Íkfgæ}zginHdfgæÅn=we { kfeº{hnHeh{Udtp-¼zq~acb=pUwÉCÖÍsCacg®ktp k,p s e Öäkidf}zg®kfa {`n kidfnH¼~dfawgin=g=u¹±k ktp df{hnHkfg»À p-¼z¼zwawbp kface gj[e-d kfq~n$z}zawcs~a {Ra sC}zg®kidiÉEçs~p-ktpRginTkfg p dfn$cp-df{hnp s¼ÅeUa kfnHdiÖ dfawbtq*Ågiaw/}~ktp nHeh}zg dfnpUs~gmp s`}z ¼Es~p-kfn=gp-dfngi}z¼~¼ÅeUdikfnsEzkfq~nHdfn awg e$b=n kidtp- s~p-ktpUzpUginh0$aw{Udtp-kfa {wn={Wp-bHÉèp-¼z¼zwawbp kface gawgRp-b=b=n=gigiawzwn`kfe} gié;awcwnsê¼~dfeUÖ {-dtpU$$nHdfg=u» }~/ ÅnHd,e-jdfnpUp-¼z¼~cawbp kf awe gRq@pÔWnºÅn=n n=akfq~nHdR¼Åe-dikfnsëeUd ãdfakikfn gi¼ÅnHb=aì@bp-cÉ&j[eUdÂnHdfÀ(aPxÅu q~n&j[eUwceã a {9sCn=giaw{ s~n=bHacgiawe gãnTdfnRn=gigin kfacpUkfeºkfqzn&gibpUcpU~awcakÍÉp skfe kfí q~n&}~ginpU~acwa k¢ÉeUj(ÂnH dfÀmaFxEu¹Ígieh cp-kfawe ïî kidtp gf pUbHkfawe gtð/sCn=b=eh}~¼zwn=g }zginHdfg/ jFdfeh e n p eUkfq~nHdu í q~ng®ÉCg®kfn=ås~nHgiac{ ¼~dfe Ô;acs~n=gæsCañEnHdfn kæ{Udtp }~cp-dfakfawn=g=u í q~n¼~dfeUÖ {-dtpU$$a {(pUzg®kidtp-bHkfawe awgªpoì nHÖ±{-dtpUa vU¼ÅnHdfgiawg®kfn kvhawgieUFp kfns/giqzp-dfns/$nH$eUdiÉ v ã akfq$eh;¾® nHbHkfg=v a ÔWe bp-kfawe g+p s l(rAg=u í q~n g®É~g®kf nHò$n=bTqzp acgi$gªp dfnobHeWp-dfginTÖ {-dtpUa nsEvæwe ehgin=É;Ö±b=eh}~¼zwnsóp seU¼~kfaw$awg®kfawbhuªËa nHÖ±{Udtp-a p-¼z¼~cawbp kfawe n kfawkfawn=g p dfnn bp-¼zgi}zcp kfnsa kfe/b=eWp dfginHÖ±{UdtpUa g®ÉCg®kfn=ôn kfakfacnHg=vzdfn=gi¼Ån=bTkfacÔhn=Éb=w}zg®kfnTdfg=v sCeh,pUa g=v~kidtp gfpUbTkface g=v@p s&¼~dfe ¾®n=bHkfg=u õ öz÷oøÅùEúû üýøEþfúo÷ M S-:=ÿD´>BE:HG@DPYÅSh\8 XESHSU<=?EXAGCOPG äGC:$\T?A8;:HDPX ºGCSU:

(5) H?ES iXHS-:HXEShLH?ESRMSU:H\TD[\HS-X ÿD[\ H:TD EN HSUY> TG~:TS zMSU:Hÿ D´>S-XA8EOPSU\m8;BEBAOFD[<-8TDPGCXºBE:HG~:H8RSU:H\TGRNA\tS\T?A8;:HSUYL@< G BEOFS $G fSh< H\+DPX8YÅD[\!T:HD"EN TSUY,S-X#@DF:HGCX SUX$hMSU:Hÿ D´>/DP\08

(6) D[YEYÅOPSm8;:HS OP8%~S-:hL-YÅSh\tDCXEShY äGC: NA\TSDPXº< G@GCBS-:= 8 H"D ~S

(7) &(' ÿ8CBEBEOPDP<U8 TDPGCX*\8C< :HG~\H\OPGC X $YÅD[\ =8;XA<-SU\ 8CXAY`8C<-:TGz\T\0G~): z8;XE"D \T8 TDPGCXA8CO GCNAXAYE8;:HDPSU*\ C>@G SmG +T?ES:H*S ,zNEDP:HS S-X H\8C:T(S TGSh8C\T-S H?ESBGC): TDP X G 8/OPS z8C< 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~.X #êBE:TG C:=8 S-:=\NAXA!\ /@DPOFOPSUYDPXèYÅDP!\ T:HD EN TShYè!\ Å!\ T*S *\ 01TG9\TNEBEBGC): $OP8C): ~S 8;XAYBGCDPX TS-): ®:TD[<=?`YE8 =8$\tS H*\ 0TG&\tNEBAB*G~!: \TD NE"O H8CXES-G~NA\ :HSU8~YE\ 8;X*YNEBYA8 TSh\ 0z8;XAY`\TNEB B*G~!: 2NE"O TDPBEOPSCL ~S-G ~:H8CBE?ED[<-8COFO ®YÅD[!\ H8;X o!\ TG~:H8 CS\T3D HSU*\ iX TS-): ±8C<-DFX 4TGMS-:=ÿ D[>ºDP\(SU8~!\ 8;XAYXA8 TNE:=8;6O 5~8CX 8;BABEOFD[<-8 TDPGCXº8COFOPGÅ<-8 HSU\"D H\(YE8 H8$DP8X 79H?ES MSU:Hÿ D´> 6`8CXA8 ~SUY :;S G~): a (a kfq ¹ kfnHd p-kfawe pU> =eUdfé;giqzeU¼ e ÂnHdfgiawg®kfn k ¿(;¾®n=bHk x;ÉCg®Ö < Âª}~zwawgiqzns kfn=$g=v r*awwcnHq@ pU$$nT d î (eU diãp=É@ ðTv5Ä ?;Ç xCn=¼Ckfn=/ÅnTd U ÃhÃUÃCu ¤¥Í¥H¦;§ ¨h¨©+©ª©ª«t¦ ¦ Ù~° Ú ÐH¬=° ¬¢¥¢« µ;³-Ú@° µ-Ðh°A@B ¨$CA~³¶[ÑU¯FÑU³-Ð=ÑH¬f¨D EGFHW¨.

(8) >@DFX*< IS T?A4S `8 fGC:MSU:Hÿ D´> 8 A\ H:H8~< HDFG~X D[\JfNA\!KSGC:LCLE\T?A8C:TDPX `\tGS/GfSU<DP\fNA\ 8`8!TSU:G \tS!HDFX º8RBGCDPXTS-:2HG`D3$ M fSU< H\ª8C N TG `8 TD[<-8COFO N*Sh< G SB*SU:H\TDP\!TSUX08;X*Y$\t?A8C:TShYGCSU:OT?ES(XESG~:)/1P+:H8CXA\! 8C< HDFG~XA\æD[\TGCO[8 TS(8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXAQ\ ä:TG G~XES8CXEGH?ES-:$%&(8~<=?EDFX8;XAY,:TSUBEOFD[<-8TDPGCXIHSU<=?EXEDR,zNESU\ S-XA\TNE:HSS H?A8 $YE8 =8 D[\8C<U< SU\H\TSUY9S Tº< DPS-X TO 98;XAYó:H8CBED[YÅ"O O'N HG `8 HDP<&B*SU:H\TD[\ HS-XA<-SR8CXAY ~8;L: A 8 CS9< G~OFOPSU< TDPGCUX =8 /CSê%8 (%8 V8C#X G WT?ESê?ESU8~YE8C<=?ESh\ºG \t?A8C:TDP X X M fSh< H\ 8;:HS BE:TG TSh< TShYY ä:HG NE#X (8CX HSUY 8C<-<-SU\H\(GC(: H8 RBS-:HDP X YÅDP!\ T:HD EN TShY 8~<-<-SU\H\(<-GCX T:HGCO8CXAY S-XA<-): @B HDFG~QX '"O T?EG~ N C?êGCNE:/BE:H"D `8;L: H8;L: CS D[Z\ T?ES ENEDPO[YÅDFX 8CXAYó<-GCXA!\ T:HNA< HDFG~X9DPXAYÅNA!\ TL: C+L T?AS TSU<=?AXEGCOP G \T?EG~NEOPYY *S$8;BABEOFD[<-8 EOP

(9) S TGRG H?ES-:m8;BABEOFD[<-8 TDPGCXYÅG `8;DPXA-\ ?ES-:HSYÅDP!\ T:HD EN TShY 8C<-<-SU\H-\ TGº< G BEOFS L N =8 EOPS,YE8 =8RDP\mXESUSUYÅShOY 'OP[ O H?ES :HSU\TNE"O H\,G MS-:=ÿD´>8;:HS %8 8;DPOP8 EOPSºGCXèG~NES: \S \T"D T^S ]$_`_ ab cc$d[d-dNe3afg9h#i j$e fjagki _e f*le m#gRn#cÅLzDPX48C<U< GC:=YE8CXA< Z S 3D H?G~NE:GCBS-X4\TGCNE:=< S/BGCOPDP< o pUqsrmüþt ù qstuqª÷ ø v wOxzy. {|Q|X}[~*X~ S|X%V;;; {|+*;$|+. wOx9w. ³²{´%~#µO;k~#¶·~#1*. '(NEDPOPYÅDP X 8CXA Y &G~XA\ H:TN*< TDPGC X 7z(S&2:ºBE:HG fSU< ºDP\ :HS-BE:HSU\TS-X TShY 8;XòG fSU< äG~: SU8C<=?m8;OPOÍLDFX*YÅG$LCYÅG@GC:hL )TDPX ALzS=<Pm?ES\TD"USG æ8;XGfSU<oDP\oG 1T?ASGC:=YÅS-:oG 1* IHSU*\ M fSU< H\ 8C:TS<-GCXEXASU< HSU Y #BGCDPX TS-:=

(10) \ 7±S PL~I8 m8;OPOEB*G~DFX =J\ TG8COFOA3D =G\ DPXAYÅG \UL YÅG@GC:=\-L@8C%Y t8~< SUX ((8COFO[\UL AG@G~:(8CXAY <-S-DPOFDP X 0Å8CXA¡Y @DP<-S ¢CSU:H\H8 :'OP1O TG~OPYY T?ESYE8 H8\TD -S/G 8&:HSU8~\tG~XA8 AOFNS ENEDPOPYEDF X `D[\mDP X H?ES$GC:=YÅSU:(G HS-XA\G *S ~8 #TSh\ '2S& BE:H G fSU< G 9TS-XDF#X CG~"O ~SU\ ¤ 8 £!¥ DF): TN*8;ZO ¦oX T:HS-BE:HDP\T*S §7k¥Z¦(:Lm¨8 HS B*G~:H8C): 8;OPOFD[8;XA<-S *S SUS-Xë\tBSU<-DP8COFD[\ =\G mYÅ3D ©S-:HS-X YÅG `8;DPXA\ 7±\TNA<=?è8C\8;:=<=?E"D TSU< H\ULæ\ H:TN*< TNA:H8CO S- X ~DFXESUS-:=\-LC?ESU8 TDP X $GC: SUOFSh< H:TD[< "D R\TBSU< D[8;OPD[\ =L\ : ä:HG uCSUG C:=8;BA?EDP<U8;OP"O iYÅD[\ =8;X 8CXAY N TNA8COFO NE X H:TNA!\ TDP X `< G BA8;XEDPSU*\ M :HS @DFG~NA\m8 )TS B =\8 <-G@GCBS-:=8 TD CSS&(' ª ÿ TG@GCO[«\ # G~NE:BA8C!: HXES-:=W\ ¬ ®QSU:TWS *8C\TSUY GCXë:T*S G TSG fSU< ,DF#X CGÅ<U8 TDPGCX ¬ ¯®65+8<-OFDPS-X 8CBEBEOPDP<U8 TDPGCX:HNEXEXEDP X 4GCXë8 (GCL: /@!\ H8 TDPGCX DF#X CG/CSh\G fSh< H\UL~!\ TG~:TShYDFXº8,:T*S RG TS\TS-L: CSU:UL H?E:HGC N ~?R:HS G TS:HS äSU:TSUXA< Sh\ \ò"D TY? AXES C:=8;DP. X &('ÿG fSh< H[\ T?ADP\(8;:=<=?E"D TSU< TNE:HS:HSU\TNE3O =\oDPX 8 Å)\ `8;OEBS-): äGCL: `8;XA<-SWII 7±SU\TB*Sh< D[8;OP"O G CS-:8 \8' Z DFX48 ¥Z¦(:(NEXEOPSU\H\8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~XA\8;:HS$< G RBAOFS TS-O º:HS ®S- X ~DFXAS-S-:HSUQY M T?ESU:/ 8 !T*S B H\/?A%8 ~SNA\TSUYóG fSh< !®GC:HDPS-X TShY9YE8 =8 A8~\tSh\-XL ?EG~\TSDPX TSU!: ±8~< SRDP\8; B BE:TG~BE:HDP8 TWS HYG T?ADP\/8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXó8C:TSh 8 X°G *S CSU: MWM Zÿ m\ 8;:HS8;:HSXEG /YÅSh\tD CXASUY HG S NA\tShY8C< :HG~\H\\tOPG <-GCXEXASU< HDFG~XA\GC: 8~< :HG~\H\ T:HNA\ GGCNAXAYE8;:HDPSU*\ ;QENE): T?ESU): G~:TS~L SU8C<=?< G BA8;#X 9DP±X T?E¡S ¥N¦ DP\,OFD /CSU"O ²HG4?A%8 CSH?ES-DP:,G Xë\ HGC:=8 CS)\ @!\ T*S 0OT?ESU:TS äGC:HS`84< S-X H:H8CO YE8 =8 A8~\tS<-8CXEXEG

(11) S,8C\H\T N SUOY Pm?E¡ S äGC:HS Gz\ ,:H*S ,zNEDP:T*S S-X D[W\ äGC:&²8 DPYEYEOF*S (8C:TSÒ[%8 CSUW: T?A8 DPXA\tNAOP8 TSU\&8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCX BE:TGC:=8S-:=\ ä:HG¸H?ES$< GRBAOFS@D"TDPSU\mG 0YÅD[\!T:HD"EN TSUYBE:HG~:H8RDPX X°GS*CS-:m\TGS XES (GCL: / D B*SU!: äSh< HDFG~XA\ <U8;XEXAG KSS HG =8;OP"O ¹`8C)\ /CSUQY 0N*<=?9G G~NE: YÅSh\tD CXóS ©GC): ?A8~\ ^ xCn=nxCn=bTkface Ä uc0j[eUdªpo¼ÅnHdij[e-df,p b=nb=eU$¼@p-dfawgie ÅnHkÍãn=n dfn=$e-kfn0a ÔWe bp-kfawe p s ÂnTdfÀmaFx e »oÀòszp ktpCu.

(12) Application. Application. Application. API User Level Library. API User Level Library. API User Level Library. PerDiS Daemon. PerDiS Daemon. PerDiS Daemon. log. disk machine A. â @â ÂnHdfÀmaFx&¼~cp-kij[e-dfôs~n=giaw{ machine B. machine C. º[»"¼ ½. *SUS-XTG8/CS,\TNE:HSIT?ES*G~XEO 8;BAB*Sh8;:8 < OPSU8C:ULEDPXTNED"TDCS&8;XAY< Gz8;:=\tS6~:H8CDFX *G~NEXAY# 8;:HDFSh\ Pm?EDPJ \ D[YEYÅOPS m8;:HS\t?EG~NEO[Y `8/CSmD3SU8C\)WHG\T?A8C:TS(T?AS< GG~XRYE8H8/G 8IENEDPO[YÅDFX BE:TG fSU< *MS-:=ÿDŃ> äNE"O AOPOP\ H?ESU\TS:HS*,zNEDP:HSS-XH\s#/G©SU:TDPX KT?ESm\tDBEOPSU\!UL%G~\! ±8RDPOPDP8C: 'G M 5*8&XAS (GCL: /¢D[YÅSCL@BS-:=\tD[\ HS-X \t?*8;:HSU Y R*S GCL: i X 2S& L(<-GCOPOP8 *G~:H8 TDPGCUX äGCOPOPG \ 8CXåSU\H\tSUX TD[8;OP"O ò\T*S ,zNES-X HDP8CZO (GCL: / AG ´S (S-SUX G~): /#C:HGCNABA\ ëMS-G~BEOPS S "D T?EDPXê 8 G~): /#~:TG~NEB4S E<=?A8C X CS8 ?ED C.? CGCOP N SRG YE8 H8 3D H? SU8C<=? G T?ESU*: (Pm?ES-:HS4DP\ 8è?ED C?åYÅ*S C:HS-S4G NHS BGC:=8;O 8CXAYò\TBA8 HDP8COOFGÅ<U8;OP3D 3D H?EDPXå8 G~): /#C:HGCNAQ B Pm?ESU:TS DP\(8;O[\tGR\tG S:HSU8;O< G~XA< NA:T:HS-XA< CL~DFXA<-OFN*YÅDFX S:H3D HS/<-GCX AD[< =\-L ?ED[<=? <-8;XAXEG *SD CXEG~:TShOY 0[ äG~:DFXA!\ H8CXA< .S G~): /@DP X G~X8C3O HS-:HXA8 H"D ~SóYÅSU\TD CXA\DPXBA8C:H8COFOPS-O/DP\ < G GCXBE:=8C< TD[< S ¦o8~<=?RG 1T?E

(13) S (GCL: /#C:HGCNEB*\+D[\o)\ `8;OPOÍL T:HNA\ HDFX AL~8CXAY @BEDP<U8;OP"O ROPG@<U8 ) SUYó<-GCXEXASU< HSU.Y #9¡8 ±8C!\ 4¾s' 4Z 1 iX<-GCX T:=8C!\ ULYÅ"D ©SU:TSUX N(GCL: /#C:HGCNEBA\G 9HS-8X S-OPGCX HG CS- G C:=8;BE?ADP<U8;OP"O iYÅDP!\ H8CX 8;XA8Y N HNA8;OP"O iYÅD[\ H:TNA!\ TDP X < G BA8CXEDPSU\UL<-GCXEXASU< HSU8Y 9\TOPG $L NEXE:HS-OPDP8 EOFS,8CXAY\tG S TD SU\mDPX TS-L: 3D )TSUX Z\8'Z \ ^Pm?ESh\tS$<-GCXA\TDPYES-:=8 TDPGCX*;\ fNA\ H3D k T?AS < GCX*< S- B mG ²8 ¿ÀÁ¡ÂÃ9ÄAL*S ÅBEO[8;DPXESUYDPX>ÅSU< HDFG~²X Å Pm?ES,YE 8 =8`\ HGC:HSUYDP X H?ES,BEO[8 ) äGCL: \T?EGCNAOPYDPX TS-): ®GCBS-:=8 TNS "D T?9YÅ"D ©SU:TSUX 8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXA\0GCXRYÅ"D ©SU:TSU X BEO[8 ) äGCL: *\ Pm?ED[\+:H*S ,zNEDP:HS S-X J(8~\+\H8 HDP!\ ASUYDFSX T?ESMSU:Hÿ D[>,BE:HG fSU< 4D BEOPS S- X TDP X 48;XêDFX*YÅNA!\ TL: 9\ =8;XAYE8C:HY9DFX TSU!: ±8~< S<-8COFOPSUY>Å

(14) ÿ '

(15) O `BEOPS SUX HDFX > ÿ '

(16) ((8~2\ `8CYÅIS CSU): `Sh8C)\ ¡T?*8; X /Å(\ TG H?ES,\T?A8;:HSUY R*S GCL: 8 A!\ T:=8C< TDPGCX ¬3$Å®¢

(17) . Æ. æù þÊÉ¸ËKÌv@þtýOv. Çq È. m?ESMS-:=ÿD´>&8;:=<=?ED3HSU<TNE:HSmDP\DPOFOPNA\!T:=8HSUYRDFX`Q0DCNE:HSIPm?ESYED3©S-:HS-X BE:HGÅ< SU\H\TSU\0DP\TGCO[8HS < :HNA< D[8;OEBAOP8! äGC:L¤ äNAXA< HDFG~XA\ ä:HG 8;BEBEOPD[<-8HDFG~XA\ULC8;XAY`8CBEBEOPDP<U8HDFG~XA\; ä:TG G~XES8;XAGT?AS-:$ ¢NA\tSh\mB*SUS-:)zHG®B*SUS-:< G@G~B*SU:H8TDCS<-8C<=?ADFX äG~:«*Sh\BS-:) äGC:L`8;XA<-S ' XEGÅYÅS9:HNEXA\ 8½\tDP X ~OF.S Í«ÎÏ!ÐSÃRÑÐSÒ2ÁÀÄu7ÍMoIÿ :Lm8;XAYò8CX X@ N SS-: G ,8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCX9BE:HGÅ< Sh\T\TSU*\ X'BEBEOPDP<U 8 TDPGCX*\DPX TS-:=8C< Z"D T?MS-:=ÿD´¹> T?A:TG~ N C?98C8X '[M OP%8 ~S-:hL ?ED[<=? DFX TSU!: ±8~< Sh(\ TG T?E±S ÓÔÎÏZÕÎÖÎ×+ÕJÃØÏ)ÂÏ Ù.7ÚK¾¾: P.

(18) my_root. print() first. b a. c Y X. pds://perdis.esprit.ec.org/clusters/c1. pds://sor.inria.fr/data/objects. â Aâ 0w}zg®kfnTdfg=v@eh;¾®nHbHkfg(p s,dfn=$eUkfn(dfnTj[nHdfn b=n=g=u. ºG»¼ *Û ÜQxzy. Ý¹|X¶Þ ;. êS `8 CS 8;X½Sh\T\TS-XTD[8;OmYÅD[\HDFX*< TDPGCXV*SSUS-X¨(G8GÅYÅSh\G GCBS-:=8TDPGCXs5+DPXiYÅG`8;DPX äD S FL D H?EDPXå8¨G~:)/#~:TG~NEBæLGCXò8·¾'ZN:º8;X*Y DFXTSU:!iYÅG8CDFX7±S PL[S(S-S-X(GC:L/ C:HGCNEBA\UL@GC:G~S-:8\8'ZN: '½YÅ G `8CDFX$D[\+8\tS ªG (S-OP3O i< G~XEXESU< TShY$8;XAIY &NTNA8COFOzH:TN*\HDFX KG~:)/Å\!H8HDFG~XA\*Pm?ES \t?A8C:TS(YE8 =8NA\TDP X /<-GC?ESU:TSUX 0<-8~<=?EDP X 8;X*Y!\ T:HGC X KT:=8;XA\H8C<TDPGCXA8CO~\TS`8;XTD[<-\*«' YEG`8;DPX DP\YESU\T"D ~XESUY äGC:8 ±8C!\ K¾s' Z < G~XEXESU< TDPGCQX iX<-GC X T:=8C!\ U#L H?ES,BE:HG HGÅ< GCO[2\ S (S-S-X9YEG `8;DPXA\8;:HS,YÅSh\tD CXESh Y äGC:OPG@G~\TS-O i< G~NEBEOPSUY DFX TSU:H8~< HDFG~QX \GCL: /~:TG~NEBA;\ H?A8 YEDP!\ T:HNA!\ SU8C<=?G T?ESU:UL T?EGz\t2S H?A8 oDPX TSU:H8~< DPX ä:T$S ,zNES-X ! O"~L-GCQ: T?EGz\tSo\TS-B*8;:=8 TShNY 8mBGzG~s: \8' Z <-GCXEXESh< HDFG~XæL-\T?EGCNEO[IY S DFX&\tSUBA8;:=8 HSYEG `8;DPXA*\ ¦o8C<=?`YÅ G `8;DPXº?A8C\S8 ßÂà`Îá[ÂÙRXAG@YES:TSh\tBGCX*\tD EOP«S äGC:(DFX HS-:=8C< HDFX 43D H?ºG ©+iYÅG `8;DPX \tSU): ~S-:=\ %Pm?ED[\ z8 HS m%8 <U8C<=?ESh\0:T*S RG TSm< OPNA!\ TS-:=\8;XAYBE:HG zD[YÅSh\+8~<-< Sh\T\ HG/OPGÅ<-8CO@<-OFN*\ HS-:=\ TG`:HS G HS/YÅG `8;DPXA\ \ ¹ / 7 6 ( 3. ÜQx9w. â¡ã1ä$~#$¡ {z**~. ïMSU:Hÿ D´>GfSh< DP\8/\tS$,zNES-XA<-SG #TSU\0:HS-BE:HSU\TS-XHDFX \tGRSmYE8H8/\H:TNA<TNE:HS M fSh< H\ 8;:HS,GCBA8,zNESWTGT?ESMS-:=ÿ D[>BEO[8) äGC:LL8CO3H?EGCN ~?²T?AS&\)@\!TS* \HGC:HSU\8Y@B*SRYÅSU\H< :HDFB TGCI : äG~:$S~S-:L9GfSh< hLæ8;XAYë8;O"T?AGCN ~?êD"H\Wz8;:LA8~S&<-GCOPOFSh< TG~:$DP\$<U8;BA8EOPSRG - äG~OFOPGDPX B*G~DFX TSU:H\mDPX48;XG fSh< $ Pm?E8 S S G~): ïDP\ BA8C!: H3D HDFG~XESUYòDPX TG <-G~8C:H\TS ¢C:=8;DPXï!\ T:HNA< TNE:HSU\ <-8;OPOPSUYå<-OFNA!\ TSU:H*\ 2' < OPNA\ HS-:D[\8/BE#? @\TD[<-8;O ~:TG~NEBEDP X /G *OPG ~DP<U8;OP"O $:HS-O[8 HSUY&G fSh< =\ 'ò<-OFNA!\ TSU:?A8C\N8 8;:HD[8 EOPS 8;XAY NEXEOP"D "D TShY4\tD -S 0E< OPNA\ HS-:=\8;:HS$YÅDP\ fGCDPX * \ò?ES-Xè8;# X 9G fSU< ,DFXè8< OPNA!\ TSU:,DP\$8~<-<-SU\H\tShYê8 \tG RS`\T3D HSCOL H?E¡S ?EG~OFSº<-OFNA!\ TSU:$DP\ <-8C<=?ASUYL \TNEBEBGC): TDP X ±CSU): ± ±8~\ hL OFGÅ<U8;O8C<U< Sh\T\ TG½8COF2O H?ES4G fSU< =\G ZT?ES9<-OFNA!\ TSU*: -' < OPNA\ HS-:`D[\`<-8~<=?ESUYï8;XAY BG~\H\tD EO \ HGC:HSUYï8 º8;OPO\T3D HSU\ ?ESU:TS"D ºDP\DPX NA\tS~L EN ºSh8C<=? < OPNA\ HS-:(?A8C$8YESU\T"D ~XA8 HSUY å ÀÁÎWÔ Ã9à¢Î/!\ TGC:HDP X "D H\(8;N H?EGC:H"D H8 H"D ~S

(19) CSU:H\TDPGCQX Pm?EDP-\ m8C\o8CX 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X :H*S ,zNEDP:HS S-X 2 äGC:OPS z8;O:TSh8C\TGCXA*\ 'X` G fSU< DPXº\TG S< OPNA!\ TS-[: %8 &B*G~DFX GHG,\tG SG T?AS-: G fSU< UL;SU3D H?ES-:DFX H?ES\H8 S < OPNA\ HS-:GC:/DPXê8;XAG T?AS-:/GCXES +Pm?ES8;BABEOFD[<-8 TDPGCX9BA:TG C:=8 XA%8 @D"z8 TSh«\ H?ES&G fSU< N~:H8CBE? ä:T G 8:HG@G *Å>@SUZS äG~:mDFXA!\ H8CXA< SQ0"D ~NE:HNS ' BE:HG ~:H8 æD C? (X*%8 zD~8 TKS ä:TG çT?ES:HGzG B*G~DFX +DPWX H?ESoOPS 9LRGz\ < OPNA!\ TS-:hLhS ÅSU<-N TDP X « äG~:ªDPXA\ =8;XA<-

(20) S è

(21) é gRm#m_Lê#ëìêë íê#ëagki3î$_ï6ðPm?EDP\ "D BEOPDP<-3D H"O OFGz8CYE( \ H?ES,< G~:T:HSU\TBGCXAYÅDP X < OPNA!\ TS-$: '.

(22) ÜQxRÜ. { %ñ;;¨ ò ~};z *|+. ÜQxô. õ- $ *|+;. ÜQx9ú. ûs~#%Êü. MSU:Hÿ D´>48;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXê8C"O m%8 Å\8~<-< Sh\T\TSUK\ T?AS&G fSU< H\/3D $XESUSUYE\/DPXê"D H\/OPGÅ<-8;JO S G~): m?EDP\`8/~SU\$D"&Sh8C$8 äG~:BE:HG~:H8SU:H\/NEXA\)/@DFOPOPSUYèDPX YÅD[\H:TDENHSUY½\)Å\HS`\WHGó\T?A8;:HS DFX äG~:)`8TDPGCXQ>@DFX*< S¡ äNE:)T?AS-:LRG~:TSºYA8H89DP\&<-8C<=?ASUYDFXèO[8;:LCSº<=?@NEX/@\ULQH?ED[\,S-OPDRDPXA8TSU\ T?ES&:TS*RGTS,8~<-< Sh\T\

(23) *G!TOPS-XASU<Ê/1+Pm?AS\!Å\!TS*<U8C<=?ESh\YE8=8Ò[8-DPOCLAD6 SPLAGCXAO"¹?ES-X98CX 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X 8C<U< Sh\T\TSU\"D *&(8~<=?ESU\8 (YE3D ©S-:HS-X (\T"D TSU\(< G@G~B*SU:H8 T«S H4G äS =<=Y? H?ES YE8 H48 T?A8 8;X8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X XAS-SUYA«\ ?EDPOFWS DPXE"D D[\tDP X DPXEBEN )¢G~N TBE N GCBS-:=8 HDFG~XA\ Pm?ESMS-:=ÿ D[ > ' GM 8;OPOFG \ 8C<U< SU\H\8 K?A8 HS ~S-K: ~:H8CX@NEOP8C:T"D ºD[

(24) \ G~!\ /8CBEBE:HGCBE:HD[8 TS 7Pm?ES,YÅS ±8;NE"O DP( \ HG äS H<=?48 ?EGCOPSBA8 ~SDFX TG8;BABEOFD[<-8 TDPGC¹X S GCL: `GCX8RBA8 ~KS ±8CNE3O $ : Pm?ESê8CBEBEOPDP<U 8 TDPGCXBE:TG C:=8 S-Y: `%8 <=?EG@G~\T²S TGï8C<U< SU\H\ 8 !\ `8COFO/G fSh< 8 ¨8 TD RS äGCI : C:HSU8 TSU!\ /<-GCXA<-NE:H:TSUXA< ~L*G~K: HG8~<-<-SU\H\ 8 ?EGCOPSR:H8C X CS&G 8~%Y t8C<-S-X /G fSU< H\/DPXóGCXAS CGAX L äGC:/< G~XA\tD[!\ TS-X*< 1°G (S ~S-«: H?ES!\ Å!\ TS óSU<=?*8;XED[!\ `\/8;:HS< Gz8;:=\tS 6~:H8CDFsX 5?ES-Xó8CX 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X&:H*S ,zNESh\ =\8C<-<-SU\H\ TG$8\tDP X COP(S HSC%L T?A«S ?EGCOPSmS-XA<-OFGz\tDP X < OPNA\ HS-:D[\GCBS-XEShY 8;XA Y E:HGC N ~? DPX TG T?ES,<U8C<=?ESG H?ES,< G~:T:HSU\TB*G~XAYÅDP X &MSÿ ' P. MS-:=ÿD´>\tNABEB*G~!: =\¡8 A:TGz8CY:=8; X ~S$G JT:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA8COO ±8C<-DFOPD"TDPSU\ULXGHD" 8TSUY#¹T?AS&8;B BEOFD[<-8TDPGCXYÅG`8CDFXG < G@GCBS-:=8HD"~S SUX CDPXESUS-:HDFX X MS-:=ÿD´>ïBE:HG zD[YÅSh\ YÅ"D ©SU:TSUX *%8 ~GCNE:=\`G WH:H8CXA\H8C< HDFG~XA\*5K7äD9: <-OP8~\T\TD[<-8;O B*Sh\T\TDRD[\!TD[< 'K&- f ÿ 7'(HG D[<;%L &G~XA\TDP!\ TSUX hL f\TGCO[8 TShYL 8;X*Y$ÿNE:=8 AOFS%: 07±DFD9:GCB TDRD[\!TD[<G'K&- fÿS0h8;XAY7±DFDPDR: <=?ESUÊ< /®GCN ö <=?EShÊ< /®DPQX æMSU\H\tD DP!\ TD[<º<-GCXA<-NE:T:HS-X*< ê<-GCX T:HGCOoOFGÅÊ< /Å\YE8 H²8 ?ADFOPS 8~<-< Sh\T\TSUYæL 8;XAYó?EGCO[YE\/GC.X TG8 OPGÅÊ< /4NEX TDPJO T?ES H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~²X TSU): DPXA8 HSU*\ M B TD RD[!\ TD[<R<-GCXA<-NE:H:TSUX < 9< G~ X T:HGCJO DFOPO 8C<U< Sh\T\/YE8 =8 <-GCXA<-NE:H:TSUX H"O ²"D T?AGCN $OPG@Ê< /@DP X 0< G~X AD[< =\$8;:HSRYÅS TSh< TShY T?E:HGC N ~?YA8 H8 ~S-:=\tDPGCXEDP X X &?ESUÊ< /®GC N ö <=?EShÊ< /®DP«X T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA\<-GCX T:HGCO DPX TSU!: iYÅG `8CDFX\t?*8;:HDF X X7±ÿ G `8CDFXAQ\ SU:TS YÅS AXASUY&DFX>@SU< TDPGCX Å" :s\ò?ESUX&YÅG 8CDFX 'ïXES-ShYE\YE8 =

(25) 8 ?EGz\tS(?EG Sm\t"D TS(D[\+DPX&YEG `8;DPX L. 8 ßÂà`Îá[ÂÙDFXYÅG `8;DP^X '=8 /~SU\<-GCBEDPSU\ G H?ES&YA8 HY8 äGCK: ±8C!\ TS-:/\tSU): @D[< S8CXAY9%8 8;DP"O 8 EDPOF"D 4Pm?ASNEXE"D oG DPX TS-): iYÅG `8;DPX\t?A8C:TDP X D[\oZ8 ÷+ÏLÀ`øÎÊùà¢L@8BE:TShYÅS *XESUY\TS oG <-OFN*\ HS-:=\ T^ G S 8~<-< Sh\T\TSU.Y HG CS T?ESU*: ;' <=?EShÊ< /®GC N WT:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGC±X E:HDF X z\84BA:TG fSU< W ä:HG "D H\&:TS R G TS$YÅG 8CDFX 7±Ê\ :oDPX TG T?AS<-NE:H:TSUX YÅG `8;DPQX 0@3D D[\<-8~<=?ESUY GC X T?ESOPG@<U8;OO z8 T*S (%8 Pm?AS < OPNA\ HS-:=\mG ;T?ES$BA:TG fSU< <U8;¹X *WS `8CXEDFBANEOP8 TShY8CXAY\t?*8;:HSU Y 3D H?EDFX H?ES,YÅG 8CDFXNA\TDFX T?ESNA\TNA8;OBSU\H\T"D D[\ HDP</GC:mG~ B TD DP!\ TD[Z< T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA*\ zQ0DPXA8;OPO 8<=?ESUÊ< /®GCN -T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX \ HGC:HSUJ \ H?ESNEBYE8 HSUYº<-OFN*\ HS-:=\ G 1H?ESBE:HG fSh< oDPX T?ESUDF::TSh\tBSU< TD CS?EG SYÅG `8CDFXA*\ Pm?AS !\ Å!\ TS YES TSh< =\R 8 H?ED[\&BGCDPX 8C#X BG HS-X TD[8;O<-GCX AD[< =\ [&NE:H:HS-X TO ë3D `D[\NEVB T.G T?AS 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X HG:TSUBA8;DP:\tN*<=?<-GCX AD[< =\ M :HGTSh< HDFX 9YA8H8DPX·¥N¦o\$D[\,DB*G~:!=8;XUL0\tDPXA< S BA8;:)TXESU:H\,DFXèG~XESºBE:HGfSh< 4`8%8S DPX < G BS H3D HDFG~X äGC:8;XEG T?ESU: G~XES M NE: \TSU<-NE:T"D RSh<=?A8;XADP\)`\8¬Aý$®BE:TG@D[YÅS^GH?8C< < SU\H\< G~X H:TG~O8;XAY\tSh< NE:HS< G &NEXED[<-8 HDFG~QX Q¦o8~<=?ó< OPNA\!TSU:$?A8C\$8CXê8C<U< Sh\T\< G~XT:HGCOOFD[\! DFXAYEDP<U8 TDP X ¨H?ESó8~<-< Sh\T\º:TD C? H\ 8C\H\tD CXEShY ¨8 TG 8ëNA\TS-$: þ \`:TG~OF²S "D T?ADFX8 =8C)\ /1>@SU<-NE:HS < G &NEXED[<-8 HDFG~XNA\tSh\BEN EOFD[4< /~S \T<=?E*S SU2\ äG~: \T"D ~XESUYYE8 H8º8~<-< Sh\T\:T$S ,~NASU!\ H\ULA\t?*8;:HSUY /CS Å\ äGC:SUXA< L: @B TDPGCX8;X*Y 8< G SEDPXA8 TDPGCXG sH?EIS (SG äG~:8;N H?ES-X TD[<-8 TDPGCXG ;RSh\T\H8 ~S GC:H"D ~DFXA8 TG~:H*\ .

(26) åþ)v~ø@ù*þË üøqªû´tuqst ú ù ÿ. È. ÷. ª÷ø. tæÌ KÌ[qstuq. ôsxzy. Ý¹*kãJ*~#¤~#¶·|%ü¤ +~#¶·~#1. ôsx9w. Ý¹*kãJ*~# ¹%ã; +~.{|+~#*|+

(27) Ý ²{. Pm?E« S S GCL: W`8;XA8 CS SUX

(28) 7Í7987 :!\ H8 HSDP\:HSU<-GC:=YÅSUYDFX`YE8 H8\!T:HNA< HNE:TSh\\tN*<=?R8~\; ä:TSUS OFD[\=\-L@GfSU<-=8EOPSU\ULÅ:TG@GH\UL~SH<PLÅ< G~OFOPSU<TDCS-Oº<-8COFOPSUYYT?ES797 ÁÎà`Â!¿Âà¢ÂE74S=8iYE8=8 < GCX*\ H3D HN TSh\$8 \T?A8;:HSUYó:TSh\tG~NE:=< SCXL ?ED[<=?êDPX8YÅD[\ H:TD EN HSUY!\ Å\!TS*ó ±8C< Sh\$< G~XA< NE:H:HS-XA< 8;XAY< G~XA\tD[!\ TS-X*< ºD[\T\TNESh\ PªGï%8 CGCD[Y OPG@Ê< /@DP X ÞS H8 iYE8 H8E(L (SóBE:HGCBG~\TSê8 XES H:H8CXA\H8C< HDFG~X G@YES-O¢Lm<U8;OPOFShY ÔÊÙ%Ô à`ÎÁ à6Ï)ÂÄÔÂùà6ÃÀÄÔ 'ô!\ Å!\ T*S H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~X D[\8º\T N 6T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGC±X 7äG 8`NA\TS-«: H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~XX :-T?A8

(29) H8 /CSh\ DFX TGR8C<U< GCNAX -T?ES\TS `8;X TD[<-\G +3D =\oG~B*SU:H8 TDPGCQX #Pm?ES/GCBS-:=8 TDPGCXº<U8;X S-"D T?ESU-: S/8CBEBEOPDFShY D"SUYÅD[8 HS-O 8CXAYNEXAYÅG~XES,"D H?EWS T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCX8 GC): H\ULÅGC:YES-O[%8 CSUY8;X*Y :HSUYEGCXEWS ?ESUX T?EI S H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~X < G R"D H*\ &GCXA\TDPYES-J : äGC:oDFXA!\ H8CXA< SN8 HGCB ®OPS CSUQO 7±8CBEBEOPDP<U8 TDPGC+X :T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX T?A8 < :HSU8 TSU\8XAS < OPNA\ HS-$: Pm?EDP\RG~B*SU:H8 TDPGCX½D[\RS ÅSU<-N TShY DPX "D H\OPGÅ<-8;Om8CYAYÅ:TSh\T\TDP X ê\TBA8C<-S 8CXA·Y "D T?EDPX 8 !\ Å!\ TS T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCQ X M XEO 8 < G "D «TD S$DP2\ H?ES<-OFNA!\ TSU:DP\DFXA\TS-): TShYDF¹X T?AWS COPG A8CO < OPNA\ HS-:OPDP!\ ULNEX*YÅS-:º8\t?AGC): !6TS-L: S E< OPNA\T"D ~S OPGÅÊ< /1¤ ¢ KH?E¹S T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX 8 *G~!: =\-;L T?AS < OPNA\ HS-:D[\XAS CSU:DFX*\tSU!: HSUYDPX T?ES,OPD[\ hLA8;XAYXAS CSU«: *Sh< G RSh

(30) \ @D[\tD EOPIS TGºG T?ESU«: T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA*\ +Pm?ADP\ YÅS-O[%8 CShYGCBS-:= 8 TDPGCXD[\ \H8 äSS *Sh<-8;N*\tSS T?ES&GC:=YÅS-:DP²X H?ESOPDP!\ D[\ "D `8 HS-:HDP8CO TW G H?ES \TS `8;X HDP<U\G æ< OPNA!\ TSU:H*\ ~ZG T

(31) S T?A8 [T?ADPG\ TSU<=?AXED ,zNES \ HDFOPXO (GCL: /Å\DFX 8,YÅD[\T<-GCXEXESh< ) SUYS-#X @DF:HGCX RSUX U L ?ESU:TNS H?ES,DPXA\tSU!: HDFG~XA\<U8;X\T8 äS-O SYÅS-O[%8 CShY NAX HDFsO T?ES$XAS (GCL: /ºDP\ :TSh< GCXAXESU< TSUQY iX< G~ X T:=8C!\ UL\TS S-X :HSU\TS-L: 8 TDPGCXå<U8;XEXAG *SëYÅS-O[%8 CShY SU<-8CNA\T^S (G YÅ"D ©SU:TSUX \t*S S-X H

(32) \ NA!\ XEG ?A%8 CSIH?ES\H8 S,8CYEYE:TSh\T*\ X&:TSh8 HDF X º8XAS \t*S S-X :HSU\TS-L: CSU\m"D H\ 8CYEYÅ:HSU\H\D RShYÅD[8 TSU"O ¨7±NEXAYÅSU: 8º\T?EGC): OPGÅÊ< /@

(33) \ TG %8 ~GCD[¹Y EOFGÅÊ< /@DP X `G H?ES-K: T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXAÊ\ : 8;XAY :TSh< GC:=YE\3D mDPX8CX NEXAYEG&OPG X ¢ T?ENS T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCX 8 GC): H\UL H?ESNEXAYÅGROFG &<U8;XA<-S-O[\"D H\ :TSh\tSU): 8 HDFG~XA*\ i. X G H?ë<U8C\TSU\U1L T?ESº\TS `8CX HDP<U\/G (T?ES`G~B*SU:H8 TDPGCXA\/DP.X H?ESº)\ @!\ T*S T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCXêDP\ SUOF"O 6/@XE G sX 0H?ED[2\ TSh<=?EXERD ,~NAS,<-8;XAXEG «WS CS-XAS-:=8;OPDP\TSUYY TG`8;L: E"D T:=8;L: `G fSh< H*\ . MS-:=\tD[\ HS-XA<-SDPX MS-:=ÿD´>RD[[\ A8~\tShY`GCX :TSh8C<=?A8EDFOPD" ¬ Å®¢uP+G&YÅSh< D[YÅSK?AST?AS-:m8;XºGfSU< DP\:TSh8C<=?A8EOFSD[\,89YÅD"Tº< NEO"BE:HGAOFS* DPX½84YÅD[\H:TDENHSUYè8;X*Yë:TSUBEOFD[<-8TShYêSUX#zDP:HGCX S-X *G\SNA\t S H?E²S ¾ª8C:H<=?A8CX YÅD[!\ T:H"D E N TSUY4&¸RGÅYÅSUO8;X*Y 8CO"~GC:HD3H? ¬ AL®6G' ÿ4& DPK\ RGÅYÅSUOFShY48C\8ºB*SU!: i\t"D TS&< GCX*\ H:TNA< TDCS,<-GB*G~XES-XhL ?ED[<=?4DPYÅSUXTD"ASU\ XES BGCDPXTS-:=\UL 8êBS-): i\t"D TS4YÅSh\ H:TNA< TD CS< G RBGCXAS-X UL ?ED[<=?ïDPYÅSUX T"D ASU\`NAXE:TSh8C<=?A8 EOPS G fSU<H\UL8CXAYï8 YÅDP!\ T:HD EN TDPGCX< G RBGCXAS-X U+L ?ED[<=?óS-X*\tNE:HSU\/< G~XA\TDP!\ TSUXA< G 4&ªRS H8 ®YE8 H8 +¾+8;:=<=?A8;X B*Gz\t"D H

(34) \ CS&GC:=YÅS-:HDFX R:HNEOPSU

(35) \ T?A8 S- X äGC:=< S8º\H8 äSS COPG A8COªGC:=YÅSU:TDP X ¡S (S-S-²X &N H8 TDPGCXæL YE8 =89< G~?ES-:HS-XA<-SCLª8CXAY 4& < G B*G~XES-X H\UL+\TNA<=¨? H?A8 R89YÅSU!\ T:HNA< TD CS4& XE*S CSUS: DP\H!\ SU\R89:HSU8C<=?*8 EOPSºG fSU< $;Pm?ASU\TS :HNEOFSh\&8C:T S CSUXES-:=8;OS-XEG~ N C±? HGêSUXA\tNA:TS\T8 äS G 8CX YÅDP!\ T:HD EN TSh Y 4& L ?A8 HS ~S-:< G~XA\tD[!\ TS-X*< YGÅYÅS-OªDP\mNA\TSUQY MS-:=ÿD´>NA\TSU\(8,XEG ~S-O8;O CG~:T"D T ? u äG~:"D H\mYÅD[\ H:TD EN HDFG~X <-G B*G~XES-X I¬ EL ®®L A8C\TSUY`G~X /GCO[Y *SU): Xþ \,?EDFSU:H8C:H<=?ADP<U8;G O (S-D C? TShY:TS äS-:HS-XA<-S < G~NEX TDP X Þ¬"®¢Pm?ED[\,D[\²8 8C:TD[8 HDFG~XG~X.

(36) êSUD"~?HSUY ]S äSU:TSUXA< SW&GCNEXTDPX ¹¬ *L®X?ESU:TS SU8~<=?ºXEGÅYÅS/DFXT?ESYÅD"©NA\TDPGCX¡H:TSUSZ/~S-S-B*\ 8;XDFXAYES-BS-XAYÅSUX < G~NEXmG 0D"H\<=?ADFO[YÅ:HS-X4\tGHG8%~GCD[YY(S-DC?NEXAYÅSU:! *GW Pm?E4 S ¾ª8C:H<=?A8CX m:HNEOPSU\mD B*Gz\tWS H?A8 «H?ES<-GCXA!\ T:HNA< H"D ~S4&å:HNEX S äGC:HS$S~S-XH\«T?A8 8C< GC²X N H8 HGC: NEBYA8 TSh\ 1Pm?ES\TD RBAOFSh\ N(%8 TGºSUX äGC:=< WS H?ED[\D[«\ HG :HNEX4D38

(37) H:H8CXA\! 8C< HDFG~Xå< G "D *(°G (S CSU:º\T<U8;XEXADF X ·T?ESêNEBYA8 TSh\ºD[\ºS @BS-X*\tD CSó8CXAY DPX H:TGÅYÅN*< SU\ 8 * G !TOPS-XASUÊ< /óDPX TG H?ES < G R"D BA8 TQ? PªG9YÅD DFXADP\T±? T?ES "D BA8~< ,GCXëBS-): äGCL: `8;XA<-SCOL (S 8;:HSo< NE:H:HS-X TO IRG @DP X «H?ES(<-GCXA!\ T:HNA< TD CS4&êG~N G T?AS(<-G 3D 0BA8 H?æL 8 sH?ES(S ÅB*SUXA\TS G QGC:HS< G BEOFS \H<=?EShYÅNEOPDF X X ¢mYÅG@SU\oXEG m\tOPG òYÅG X T?EZS T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCX`<-G 3D m8;#X RG~:TS~L8CXAYó<U8;X9:HNEX9DPXóB*8;:=8;OPOFSU O "D T?êOFGÅ<-8CO &N H8 TG~:H\UXL ?ADP<=?8;:HS8;OPOFG (SU²Y TG 8~<-<-SU\H\ T?ES$XE*S "O i< G "D !HSUYYE8 = 8 ° G (S CSU:U L T?ES`< G~XA!\ T:HNA< H"D ~S4& N*\ NAXED[\t.? *S äGC:HS&SU3D H?ES-Z: T?ASYESU!\ T:HNA< H"D ~S4& GCY: H?ESê<-GC?ESU:TSUXA< SóS- X ~DFXES<-8CX8C<U< SU\H\ H?ESêXAS O i< G R"D !HSUYåYA8 H8 -Pm?ED[\ "D BA8~< H\ N =8 TG~:H\mG~X:T*S RG TS$\T3D HSU\U L ?ED[<=?<U8;XEXAG 8C<U< SU\H\< G R"D !HSUYYE8 H8D ShYÅDP8 TSU"O iX S ©SU< Y(S?A%8 CS¹ G CShŸ T?A·S 7äNEXA%8 ~GCD[YE8 AOF%S :<-GCXA!\ T:HNA< H"D ~S4&uG !HOFSUXESUÊ< /Þ ä:TG T?AS T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX4< G "D BA8 T? HYG T?AS:HS G HS,< G &NEXED[<-8 HDFG~X4BA8 HQ? 1Pm?ES8C Y W8CX H8 ~S$DP\ T?A 8 OFGÅ<-8COæ8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXA\8C:TS/XEG \TOPG ShY YÅG ¹X # "D 8;#X ¡GC:HS \. tþTý 0øÅþtúo÷ q&%'"WqªùAþqª÷ ý1q MGC:)TDPX 8CX8CBEBEOPDP<U8HDFG~X8HGT?ESºMSU:Hÿ D[>óBEO[8) äGC:L :TS$,zNEDF:HSU\$YA8H88CXAYë< GÅYÅS`< G~X~S-:) \tDPGCXA\UL?ED[<=?48;:HZS G H?:HS-O[8 H"D ~S-O º\ H:H8C"D ~? ! äGCL: m8;:=YO &G@YES,< GC# X ~S-:=\tDPGCX<-8C¹X SYÅG~XES,DPX9\t*S CSU:H8COO (%8 Å\* Pm?ES\TD"BEOPSU\!D[\«T?ASW äGCOPOFGDPX X5 7äD9:S *ShÞ Y H?ESó8CBEBEOPDP<U8 TDPGCXïDPXå8ëB*Sh\T\T"D D[\ HDP¹< H:H8CXA\H8C< HDFG~ÞX H?A8 ºN*\tSh\ºYÅS ±8CNE"O YE8 =8 8C<-<-SU\HW\ 7±\TS-S>@Sh< HDFG~X Å Å:sL 7±DF9D :(GCBS-X4BS-:=\TDP!\ TSUX :HG@G =\-QL 7±DFDPRD ::TSUBEOP8~< IS :H3D HSU\mDPX HGº8 AOPS 3D H? < G R"D * Pm?ESU\TS\T"D BEOPK S GÅYÅ"D *<-8 TDPGCXA[\ E:TDP X 4`8CX ~8CDFX*\ iXºBA8;): TD[< NAOP8C:UL H?ES-:HSD[\ XASG GC:HS XES-Sh²Y äGCZ: *8 !TSUXEDP X YA8 H8 \ H:TN*< TNA:TSh\-LS ÅBEOPDP<-3D $YÅD[!\ / )ö M L*G~: S @BAOFD[< "D N*S RG~): ¹`8;X 8 C*S S-X *O iXè8CYAYÅ3D HDFG~XæLªYE8 H8YÅD[\ H:TD EN HDFG~XæOL H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~XA\8;XAYBS-:=\tD[\ HS-XA<-S`< G S äG~: ä:TSU S °G *S CS-:m< G~XA< NA:T:HS-XA< ºD[\mOFD 3D HSUOY 0XRG~:TS$<-GCXA<-NE:T:HS-X*< º<-8C X S,8C<=?ADF*S CSUYæLE8 «T?AS < G~!\ G 8 A"D CS-:BE:TG C:=8 DFX S ©G~!: hLªNA\TDP X 9S ÅBEOPD[< "D &YE8 =898C<U< Sh\T\$BA:TD 3D H"D ~SU\UQL T?AS YÅ3D ©S-:HS-X «H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~YX @B*Sh\-LAXEGCX i\TS-:HDP8COFD[\T8 EOPS 8C<U< Sh\T\UL@S H< !"#"#$ 1Ì. úOxzy. {(Ý. ò ~#;~%z)(Y};}J*z|X. m?EDP\\TSU<TDPGCX BA:TSh\tSUX=\G~NE:RSÅB*SU:TDPS-X*< S¹D3H? 8¨&('ÿ :HS-XAYÅSU:TDPX 8;BEBEOPD[<-8HDFG~XQJPm?EDP\ 8;BEBEOPD[<-8HDFG~XëDP\:TSUOP8TDCS-Oê\TDRBAOFS~LsCS:HS-BE:HSU\TS-XH8TDCSG 2H?ESY`8;DPXèOFG@G~BèG 88&('ÿ TG@GCO6 \S,< GBA8C:TSNH?ES,GC:HDCDPXA8;O¢LÅ\=8;XAY#i8;OPGCXASN~S-:=\tDPGCXªLD3H?98¡&G~:)*8R8CXAY8`MS-:=ÿD´> CS-:=\TDFG~QX Pm?ES !\ H8CXA# Y i8;OPGCXE

(38) S ~S-:=\tDPGCX`?*8C[\ 4G GÅYÅNEOPSU*\ Pm?ESS ÏLÎLÂ¿ÁÀ$¿*×Î/BA8;:=\tSh\o8CX ' > &- ) AOFS 8CXAY4DPXA\ =8; X TD[8 HSUZ\ T?ASR<-GC:H:TSh\tBGCXAYEDF X `G fSU< H\/DP8X S GCL: 1Pm?E¹S ÁÂÊ÷÷1Ã9Äß²Á¡À$¿ *×"Î¡H:H%8 ~S-:=\tShZ \ T?ESºG fSU< SC:=8;BA8? H^G CSUXES-:=8 HSº8 ¥ ]^7 ¾ zDPS $L08C<U< GC:=YÅDP X ¹TG4G fSU< CS- G S TL: 87±B*G~"O #CG~XAÊ\ :8CXAY\t*S `8;X TD[<-W\ 7k äGC:DPXA\ =8;XA<-SCLA8ROPG~8~#Y 6SU8C:TDP X (8COFOªDP\<-GCOPGC:HSUY YÅ3D ©S-:HS-X H"O ä:TG 8$BA8;): T"D TDPGC+X : Pm?ASG fSh< (C:=8;BE?`< G~X H8;DPXA\ 8,?EDFSU:H8C:H<=#? &G ?ED C? ®OF*S CSUO G fSh< H\+:HS-BE:HSU\TS-X TDP X BE:TG fSU< H\U*L ENADFO[YÅDP X ~\UL \ HGC:HS Å\ª8CXAY!\ H8CDF:=<-8~\tSh\ $' !\ TG~:T*S <-GCX H8CDFX*\ P.

(39) í n=g®k . À p-ktp-ginHk gia,+=n xCÂ+Ë ÂeUwÉ;Ö í n=g®k ¿dfaw{ Âªs~g= Âªs~gt 0@p; 0@pW eh;¾®n=bHkfgr*e eh¼~g b=g®kf -Õh Äæ-ÃhÃ ÄUhÃ ÃCÃCuu ÃhÃh× -~huu ×hÃ- -~;uu ÃhhÈÇ hÄ -CÄ uu ×hÄhÃ UÄU;Õ;uu ÈWÃhÃ b=g®kfzÃ-dtsCb ×UhªÃUÈhÃ *ÃW- ÃCu ÃWÇ -~u Ã- Ä;u ÇU 0-W×;u ÕWÄ ÈCUu Õh× b=g®kfzÃ-jPe ÇUhÄ ªÕUhÃ ; - ÃCuw× Cu ÕUÃhÇ hu ÄUÃ È-W;u Õ- 1- ÄU;uwh - sCn=$e UhÄæÃUC.-hÃ0Ç-ÈhÃ/-ªÃhÕC î @ð í n=g®kpU¼~¼zwawbp-kfawe nHÊCn=b=}Ckface kfaw$n=g î gtð î phð í n=g®kpU¼~¼zwawbp-kfawe g ÑU³-Ú ÑU¯[²w³ Ù$µ ¦ ¦ 9 ² ÐHµ ¥f² ~³;° :-;¯Ñ=µ-ÐU¤ ¥®ÑH¬¢¥ ¬iÑt¥0;~©ªÑ$¦h¯c<h² Ú Ñh§>=±µ?A@µCBÑU¶+Ú µ¥iµ ¬iÑT¥1Dz¬t² EHÑ -2 ¶à~FXÜ4DF365²:H½@Gâ89 IÑ 7 =JK>?1D³ @BMLhÑU¯-s¶ FXDF:,N LPO±Ñ=ÐT¥®¬µ ³-Ú,-¶ ¦hN 9 Q9 ~¦ R LPO±ÑHÐT¥®¬=>° =PL?MSUTUÑ=*Ð @¥f² ~³¥f,² BÑH¬(²w³ ¬®Ñ=ÐH~³-ÚW¬H§z ¯[² Ù;²w³-µ 9W¬Í¥iµ ³-Úh«¢µ 9 C³-VÑ <-ÑU¯c¬t² CC³ DXD~ÑUX¯ W0² FRµ ³-SÚ CA Y¯ L-µ,¦U ¯w0¥ ;Zµ;³-HÚ [³ ;Ú ÑH¬=° :TG@G`\ULXm8;OPO[\-LGCBS-XEDPX z\ 8CXAY² AG@G~:H\*0 H?ESU\TSR8C:TS&:TSUBE:HSU\TS-XTShY4OPG2®OFS*CS-OCSUGSH:TD[< GfSh< H\\TNA<=?8C\mBGCO @OFG@GCB*\-LÅBGCO #CGCX*\8;XAY B*G~DFX =\ iY X T?A4S &G~): *8,BGC): U#L T?AS/:HSU8~¡Y GÅYÅNEOPS/D[\mOPG@<U8 HSUYºDPX8&\TS-L: CSU[: ?ED[<=? H?ES-X:HS H8CDFX*\ T?E4 S ~:H8CBE?DF²X S G~): Pm?E4S `8;BABEDFX ¡RGÅYÅNAOFS,D[\8`<-OFDPS-X

(40) H?A8 8~<-<-SU\H\tSh\mG fSh< H\:TS R G TSU"O 8 WT?ASº\tSU): ~S-$: 1P+G4:HSUYÅNA<-S T?ES`BGC): TDP X S ©GC): ULªGCXEO ^ äG~NEW: CSUG S H:TD[<< O[8C\H\tSh\ SU:TSS-XA 8 EOPSUÞY äGC::T*S G TS8C<U< Sh\T*\ Pm?ESB*G~!: TG@G /±GëYE%8 Å\ Pm?ES4<-G@YES HGë8~<-<-SU\H\ G fSh< H\DP.X T?E¡S `8;BABEDFX ¹GÅYÅNEOPS`?A8~^Y H¹G S`< G RBAOFS TS-O 9:HS :H3D )TSUQX QPm?ES äNEXA< TDPGCX 8;OP3D G ;T?ED[«\ CSU:H\TDPGCXDP\:HSUYENA< Sh Y "D T?:HSU\TB*Sh< «HG T?ES,G~:TD CDPXA8CO\TDPXA< S$G~XE"O CSUG S H:TD[< DFX äG~): `8 TDPGCXDP(\ H:H8CXA!\ "D !HSUY8;XA Y H?ES,8;:=<=?E"D TSU< TNE:=8;O\TS `8;X HDP<U\D[\OPG~!\ * i X H?ESMS-:=ÿ D[>&BGC): UL H?ES:TSh8CY GÅYÅNEOPS:TNEX*\ 8C\N8 H:H8CXA\T8~< HDFG~X&DPXGCXESBE:HGÅ< Sh\T\8CXAY \ HGC:HSU\ T?EWS ~:H8CBE? DPX8R<-OFN*\ HS-$: Pm?EIS 8CBEBEDP X G@YENEOFS$:HNEXA\(DPX48;XEG T?ESU:(BA:TGÅ< Sh\T\m8CXAY GCBS-XA(\ H?A8 <-OFNA!\ TSU*: XPm?ESB*G~!: «HGzG /º?A8C3O 8`YE%8 Pm?ES&!\ H8CXA# Y i8;OPGCXE4S ~S-:=\tDPGCX4D[\/8;BEBE:H%G Å"D `8 TS-O \AL ºOFDPXESU\ G «&A]H]&LADPXê8 GC N * < O[8C\H\tSh\æ8;XA4Y (AOPSU*\ iIX T?A2S &GCL: A28 ~S-:=\tDPGCXæLG~XEO (G H?ES<-OP8~\T\TSUQ\ SU:TS `8CYES :T*S G TSU"O 8C<-<-SU\H\tD EOPSC L AN IROFDPXESU\XES-ShYÅSU Y HYG *S&<=?A8; X ~SUOY iX H?ESMSU:Hÿ D[ > ~S-:=\tDPGCXæLÅG~XEO 8* OFDPXESU

(41) \ SU:TS<=?A8;X CSUQY P+ 8 EOFS $< G RB*8;:HSU-\ T?ENS H?E:TSUIS CS-:=\TDFG~XA-\ äGC2: 8;:HDFG~NA-\ TSU!\ \TS H\m8CXAY DPX 8;:HDFG~NA\m< GC X CNE:= 8 HDFG~XA*\ O&G RB*8;:HSUY HG H?ESR!\ H8CXA#Y i8;OPGCXES CSU:H\TDFG~XæLB*SU!: äG~): `8;X*< SD[\/OFG $+L EN IH?EDP\ DP\XEG \tNE:HBE:HDP\TDP X äGC:/8`BE:HGzG 9¢G 9®<-GCXA<-S-B BAOP8 ! äGCL: 1&G RB*8;:HSU¹Y TG 8`:T*S G TS ¢G fSU< !\ Å!\ TS LS ~S-X9¡ 8 `8 HNE:HS,DFX*YÅNA!\ T:HDP8CO+BE:HGÅYÅNA< UL*\TNA<=?ó8~\ M L: E"D L T?ESRMS-:=ÿD´>8;BABE:TGz8C<=? zDPS-O[YE2 \ &NA<=? *S !TSU:BS-): äGCL: 8CXA< S Pm?ESGCXES 6`8~<=?EDFXAS<-GC X XCNE:=8 HDFG~X D[\æ8MS-X HDF N M :HG8 m^7 °

(42) :HNEXEXADF X «\òDPXAYÅG \! Z P^ ¢?*8CW\ %¯²7 #TSU\G

(43) ] '7 8CXAY *`²7 #HSU\G )\ m8;B4\tB*8C< S i¹X T?E4S G K 8~<=?EDPXES< G~ X ~NE:H8 TDPGCX äGC«: &GCL: A8EL T?ES\TS-L: CSU: :HNEXA\ G~X T?ES/\T8

(44) S `8C<=?EDPXES8~\ 8 G CS Pm?ES < OPDPS- X ,:TNAXA\,G~Xë8BGC): H8 EOP¡S 3D H?½89MS-X TDP N Å^7 °KºBE:HGÅ< SU\H\TGC:h&L C4²7 #TSU\ ] '7 8CXAY ýC^7 HSU\o)\ m8;B`\tB*8C< S~L;:HNEXEXEDP X 4\òDPXAYÅG !\ ®ZZ P_ iX H?E

(45) S (G ¢`8C<=?EDPXES

(46) < GC X CNE:=8 HDFG~^X äG~:,MS-:=ÿD´>QL G H?BA:TGÅ< Sh\T\TSU\/:HNEXëGC.X T?ES *:H!\ 4`8C<=?EDPXESCOL ?AS-:HSU8C\"D H\ ?EG S$\t"D TS$D[\G~X H?ES,\tSh< G~XAY G~XES Pm?EDP\/S @BS-:HDPS-XA<-S<-GC X *): `\/GCNE:DPX TNE"D TDPGC.X T?A8 WT?ESBS-:=\tD[!\ TS-X ,YÅD[\ H:TD EN HSUY\ HGC:HS BA8;:=8CYÅD BS-): äGCL: [\ *S !HS-(: T?A8CX 8CX`DFXAYENA\ H): i\ =8;XAYA8;:=Y:T*S RG TS ¢DP#X CGÅ<-8 TDPGCX`!\ Å!\ T*S L äGC: YE 8 H8ë\TS H\ 8;XAYò8C"O ~GC:H3D H ? `S\ H?A8 8;:H S @BED[<-8COG $YÅD[\ H:TD EN HSUUY ¥N¦ 8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~XA*\ .

(47) 8;O[\TG < G~X AL: Y\ T?A8 B GC:)TDPX ½S@D[\!TDPX < GÅYÅS8TGïMS-:=ÿD´>ïDP\ \H:H8CD"~?! äGC:Lm8;:=Y 8CXAY BE:TG@D[YÅSU\¡T?ES^S-XAS =\ G $\T?A8C:TDPX ALYÅDP\!T:HDENTDPGCXå8CXAY BS-:=\tD[\HS-XA<-S^D"T?CSU:) OFD"!HOFS S©GC): * ¢. úOx9w. ûQ* ;;. úOxRÜ. (*z 1*z. Ý *`(~#*ba1*~c6~8zdK~Ý ¢û. m?ES >=8;XAYE8C:HYÿ/8=8W'<-<-SU\H\G iXTSU:! ±8~< S47¢>Åÿ

(48) '

(49) !: DP\o8;X¡ t> M \=8;XAYA8;:=Y' MG T?A88;OPOPG\ &('ÿ 8CBEBEOPDP<U8TDPGCX*\KHG48C<-<-SU\H\ZTG48< GGCX\HGC:HS KPm?ES`\=8;XAYE8C:HYêYÅG@SU\XEG,< GCSU: YE8 =8YÅD[\H:TDENHDFG~XæLNEO"TD"¢N*\tSU:(8~<-< Sh\T\oGC:(\tSh< NE:HD3RD[\T\TNESU\* iX MS-:=ÿD´>(S YÅS*CSUOFG~B*ShY`8 OP8 TS ¢EDPXAYÅDP X /"D BEOPS S-X =8 TDPGCX&G XT?ES>Å

(50) ÿ 'K ªDP¡X &A]H]Pm?ESm< GÅYÅS(DP\8 *G~N VKOFDPXESU\ :T"D !HS-Y X "D T? 79DP<-:TGz\tG 9[¥D[\tN*8;1O &A]H]SUX @DP:TG~ X S-X o8;X*Y`NA\TDF X 4T?ES/79;Q & 7Í74DP<-:TGz\tG 9 QEGCNAXAYE8 HDFG~²X &O[8C\H\TSUÊ\ :<-GCX H8CDFXAS-:=\ Pm?EDP\0:HSU8~YÅS-:+BA8;): 0 G T?ADP;\ GÅYÅNEOPSOPG~8~YE\+8>ÅM¹Q AOFSm8;X*Y,BGCBENEO[8 HSU\8 >E

(51) ÿ '

(52) RGÅYÅSUzO Pm?EW S :T"D TSU:S ÅBGC): H\m8º>Å

(53) ÿ 'K -GÅYÅS-OªDFX8º>ÅMo¨Q AOFS Pm?E S A:=\ 0\ HS-4B m8C1\ HGBGC): QT?ES(< G~X =8;DPXES-:+< O[8C\H\tSh\G E79JQ &7fehg i j_ UL eQj_ gi3î%n*L eFi%f*l_m#g®L eQìgzg9ìé@RL eèZìa@L;8;XAY&8;OP#O T?E( S HS BEO[8 TS<-GCX H8CDFXESU:HÊ\ : %Pm?ED[\B*G~!: HDFX KHGzG /,8 GCN [KSUS /Å\UL RGz\ $ G [?ED[<=.? m8C\\TB*SUX DPXêNEX*YÅS-:=\ =8;XAYEDF X ?EG 79;Q & <-OP8~\T\TSU\8C:TS&"D BEOPS S-X HSUOY Pm?E S eQj_ gi3î$nR< O[8C\HG\ m8CJ\ H?EKS &NA!\ (YÅ"D Tº< NE"O *5Å8;OPOA"D H\GCBS-:=8 HGC:=\8;:HSG CSU:TOPG~8~YÅSUSY TGR%8 CG~DPY YÅNEBEOPDP<U8 HDF X H?ES,!\ T:HDF X `8C:T:=%8 #PªG`YÅ"D ©S-:HS-X TD[8 HWS *S SUS-X48 T:=8;XA\TDFSUX 8CXAY B*SU:H\TDP!\ TSUX < GCX =8;DPXES-:hLS ~S-L: 9S-OPS S-X G m84<-GCX H8CDFXAS-:$D[\,8;OPOFGÅ<U8 TShYDFX T?AS \T8 Sº< OPNA\ HS-:8~I\ T?AS < GCX =8;DPXES-:m"D H\TS-"O \ê S H?ES-X OPDF X /~SUÞY T?ESó>E

(54) ÿ '

(55) O[%8 CS-: "D T? T?AS4B*SU:H\TDP!\ TSUX `<-GCX H8CDFXAS-:=\-JL "D T?å\TG S RDPXEG~« : RGÅYÅ"D *<U8 TDPGCX*\ Pm?ES >Å

(56) ÿ 'K "D BEOPS S-X =8 TDPGCX (8~\ I8 CSU): &B*Gz\t"D TD CSS ÅB*SU:TDPS-XA<-S Pm?ESMS-:=ÿ D[>>Å

(57) ÿ 'K S#TSUXAYE\ T?ES!\ H8CXAYE8;:=Y%L `8 /@DP X "D YÅDP!\ T:HD EN TShY&8CXA4Y ~NA8;:=8;X HS-S-DP X /\tSh< NE:H3D * ¢ \T?EG (SUY T?A 8 R:HS-O[8 H"D ~S-O ë<-G BEOPS ;L DPYÅSU"O ®NA\TSUY½OPD E:H8C:TDPSU\&\tN*<=? 8C\R79JQ &58;XAYï>Å

(58) ÿ 'K <-8CÞX S B*G~!: HSUY "D T?SU8C\TSCLGCXA<-^S H?ESêG~:TD CDPXA8CO\tG~NE:=< Só<-G@YES8CXAUY T?ASêMS-:=ÿ D[U> GÅYÅSUO ?A%8 ~S *SUS- X SUOFONEX*YÅS-:=\ HG@G@QY JPm?ADP\ @DPXAYÅD[<-8 HSU\RGCNA:RBA:T*S zDPGCN*\S @BS-:HDPS-XA<-S DPX BGC): TDP X T?AS &A]H] > =8;XAYA8;:=Y P+S BEO[8 H^S ¾æD E:=8;L: 7Í> P«¾;: ('#X ï\TDP X COPS ®BE:HG@<-SU\H\8;BEBEOPD[<-8 HDFG~X T?A8 NA\tSh\(S-"D T?ESU2: T?ES$> P«¾GC(: T?AS7ó;Q & <-GCX H8CDFXESU:H\ULzGC(: T?ES,>ÅKÿ '

(59) LE<-8CX S$< GC#X ~S-): TSU¡Y TG8 YÅDP!\ T:HD EN TShY L &NE3O H3D ®NA\TS-:hLÅB*SU:H\TD[\ HS-X GCXES$\T"D BEO Y# OPDP X /@DF X DPXGCNE:OP"D A:H8C:TDPSU*\ P. MGC:)TDPX ½8è:HSU8;O/8;BEBAOFD[<-8TDPGCXUTG MS-:=ÿD´>ïDP\ XEG8;Om8%@\`8CXåSU8~\!ÞH8~\!/12Pm?ES^`8fG~: YÅ3D Tº<-NE3O ëGÅ<-<-NE:=\$DFX OF*S ~8C< ê8CBEBEOPDP<U8TDPGCX*\IT?A8&< G~XH8;DPX±T?AS-DP:GXèDRBAOFS*RSUXH8HDFG~X G

(60) H?ES4MS-:=ÿD´±> ±8~< DPOF"D TDPSU\UL\tNA<=?ï8C\RBS-:=\tD[\HS-XA<-SJ\SBA:TG@D[YÅS ?ESU:TS\TGS SE8BEOPSU\UL T?A 8 KS&YÅDP\H< G ~S-:HSUY ?ES-X4BGC): TDP X '(HOP8CX HDPS\ 7± 8 &(' ¤ ÿ HGzG~OæBE:HG @DPYÅSh¹Y T?ASMS-:=ÿD´> BA8;): TXESU«: ¦jO: \ò?ES-X8;X 8CBEBEOPDP<U 8 TDPGCX DP\m< G~XA< SU"D ~SU¡Y "D T?AGCN \tNABEB*G~!: - äGC:m8;N HG `8 HDP<B*SU:H\TD[\ HS-XA<-S T?ESBE:H G ~:H8 SU:S ÅBEOPDP<-3D H"O ê\T%8 ~SU\G fSU< HZ\ TGYÅD[!\ /1O¾ª8 TSU:U1L ?ESU^X T?AG~\TS&G fSU< H\8;:HS :TSh8CÞY ä:TG YÅD[!\ / DFX G~:HYÅSU: T¨G S98C<U< SU\H\TSUYï8 ~8CDFXªLXES DFX*\ =8;XA<-SU\º8C:TS4< :HSU8 TShY 8CXAY DFXE"D TD[8;OPD -SUY "D TY? T?E

(61) S 8COFNESh\ :HSU8~SY ä:HG 5YÅD[!\ /1\ò3D H¡? T?ED[G\ Sh<=?A8;XED[)\ L T?ES/< G~XA\ H:TN*< TG~: DP\`DP#X CG/CSUY SU8~<=Þ? H"D Só8CX G fSh< ºD[\º:HSU8CÞY ä:HG YEDP)\ /1oZG TS T?*8 YH?EDP\ < G~XA\ H:TN*< TG~: ¸ xCn=n¤¥Í¥H¦;§ ¨h¨©+©ª©°w¦hÑU¯FÚC² ¬=° ÑH¬T¦h¯[² ¥=° Ñ=ÐU° ¯cÙ ¨-µ;¦¶´¨-¬iÚ µh² ¨j[e-d$e-dfns~nTktpUawú.

(62) DFX#CGÅ<U8TDPGCX&YÅG@SU\0XEGGÅ<-<-NE:+DPXMS-:=ÿD´>10hD3D[\+DPX#CG/CSUYG~XEOW?ES-XST?ESmG fSU< D[\0<-:TSh8HSUY 8;XAY XEG

(63) ?AS-X `8;BEBSUYDPX HG R*S GCL: ¡ ä:TG YÅD[!\ /1 iXOPS ~8~< 8;BEBAOFD[<- 8 TDPGCXA \ 3D H?XAG 8; N TG `8 TD[<óBS-:=\tD[!\ TS-X*< Sê\TNEBEBGC): BE:TG C:=8 S-:=\ NA\tN*8;OP"O 4\TBEOF"D $G fSh< =\DPX TGB*SU:H\TDP!\ TSUX /8;X*²Y T*S B*G~:H8C): ~L*6D S +T?EGz\tS T?A8 YEG XEG /?A%8 ~S T8 G S\T%8 ~SUYèG~X YÅD[!\ /±?ESU·X T?AS8CBEBEOPDP<U8 TDPGCX S-XAYE*\ ; iX MS-:=ÿ D[>ë"D DP\&XEG XESh< SU\H\H8;L: T G 8 /CS\tNA<=?ï8óYÅD[!\ TDPXA< HDFG~QX 'XïG fSh< DP\R\T%8 ~SU±Y HGYEDP)\ /ë3D /3D DP\R:HSU8~<=?A8 EOP¡S ä:HG T?ESBS-:=\tD[\ HS- X &:HG@G $>ÅGAL3D ZCGCN ?A%8 CS8;X 8CBEBEOPDP<U8 HDFG~ÞX "D Tu ? £T*S B*G~:H8C): G fSh< =)\ §AL CGCÞ N DFOPOm?A%8 CS¡HGêSUXA\TNE:TS T?A8 H?ES ½8C:TS XEG :TSh8C<=?A8 EOP¡S ä:TG >T?ESB*SU:H\TD[\ HS-X R:HG@G $0 G T?AS-L: DP\TSCL T?E*S ¹DPOPO SR\H%8 CSh Y TG YEDP)\ /1+Pm?ED[\ OFSh8CYE

(64) \ TG YESU< :HSU8~\tShYB*SU!: äG~): `8;X*< S8CXAY TG`NEXEXASU< Sh\T\H8;L: ºYÅD[!\ / G@<U< NEB* 8 TDPGCsX k Ç)$Ì0m ø lHúoù t Ìvvqsv#v#tuqª÷ø 'YÅS H8;DPOPSUY`8C\H\TSU\H!\ S- X G +H?ESBAOP8 ! äGCL: ?*8CG\ S-SUXºBE:HGÅYÅNA< Sh²Y ¬3%%®¢Pm?E

(65) S `8CDFX <-GCXA<-OF N \tDPGCXA\8C:TS:HS-BE:HGÅYÅNA<-SUYº?AS-:HSU8 9HS-$: nQxzy. oY zk$*X~² $*~#$*¶Þ~1. nQx9w. oY 1$k$*X~^ $$~$$¶·~#1. m?ESYEDP\!T:HD"ANTShY\T?A8;:HSUYS*RG~:)GÅYÅS-OG RMS-:=ÿD´> D[\ 8ï\tDBEOPSóBA8C:H8~YÅD" T?A8 8;BEBSU8COP\YTG 8CBEBEOPDP<U8HDFG~XåYÅS~S-OPGCBS-:=\oQAGC:T?ES8H8;:LCSTShYò8;BEBEOPD[<-8HDFG~XåYÅG`8CDFXæLD3DP\ NA<=? G~:TS9DPXTNED"TDCS.T?*8;X8CO3HS-:HXA8HD"~SU\º\TNA<=?8~\ :HS-O[8HDFG~XA8;OYA8H8A8C\TS9G~: :HSGHS DF#X CGÅ<U8 TDPGCsX Q ¢4 ä:HS-SU\,NA\tSU:HW\ ä:TG S ÅBEOPD[< "D &YÅSU<-DP\TDPGCXA\,8 *G~N G fSU< B*SU:H\TD[\ HS-XA<-SCLª8CXAY \tD BEOF"D ASh\< G~XA\tD[YÅSU:H8 E"O H?ES$BGC): TDP X G +OPS z8C< 8;BEBAOFD[<-8 TDPGCXA*\ Pm?ES$YÅDP!\ T:HD E N TDPGCX GÅYÅS-OªG 0MSU:Hÿ DÝ> `8 /~SU\("D SU8C)\ ¡HGºYÅDP!\ T:HD EN TS$YE8 H8 AQENE): T?AS-): RG~:T¹ S H?E²S C:=8;X@NEO[8;:H3D ëG YÅD[!\ T:H"D E N TDPGCX DP\`\TS-OPSU< H8 EOFS~L ?ED[<=? `8 /CSU\R"D \TNEB*SU:TDPGC: HG AXES ¢C:=8;DPXë!\ Å!\ TS `\$\TNA<=?ë8C\,W ÿ & M 7 GC: &GCL: A8 1'(W*:H!\ 8C<U< SU\H\ULæ8 O[8;L: CS ~:H8CXzNAOFSRDP\ <-8C<=?ASUYèOPGÅ<-8;OPO +0s äNE): T?ESU:R8~<-< Sh\T\TSU\&8;:HSºOPG@<U8;O¢L ?ADP<=?½D BE:HG CSU\S ÅSU<-N TDPGC·X TD RSG CSU: &GCL: A 8 # 8 ±8~< TG~:G V7k äGCp: G fSh< =L\ : LEG S GCL: #8 ±8C< TG~:G «q7k äGC4: $ G fSh< HÊ\ : -Pm?ES9YÅ:=%8 «A8CÊ< /èD[\ T?*8 <-NE:T:HS-X H"O ¨H?ES98;BABEOFD[<-8 TDPGCUX N*\ \TB*Sh< "D k G fSU< C:HGCNEBEDP X z-\ `8CXzN*8;OP"O Pm?ES,< NE:H:HS- X "D BEOPS S-X =8 TDPGCX?A8~2\ /@XEG X OPD R"D H8 TDPGCXA*\ +&NE:H:HS-X TO ¡T?AS,!\ Å!\ TS DP\ CS-L: ?AG G ~S-XESUGCNA\ULEO[8CÊ< /@DFX º8ºYE8 =8 T:=8;X*\tO[8 HDFG~XO[%8 CSU:ULÅG fSU< :HS-OPGÅ<-8 HDFG~¨X 7£tBGCDPX TSU: !\ D UOFDP X §¬"*®9: L8CXAYò\tNABEB*G~!: äGC¡: H?ESó*S CGCOPN HDFG~XïG ,\t?A8C:TShY < O[8C\H\tSh\ G iXòG~:HYES-¡: HG < GC:H:HSU< T?ESh\tS(\t?AGC): H< G DF X z\-LW8)\ Å\ HS ª äG~:+S H:H8~< HDF X K@B*S(DF X äGCL: 8 TDPGCWX ä:HG ADFXA8C): AOFSh \ m8C\YÅS ~S-OPGCBSU¹Y ¬3® E N G(8~\XES ~S-:DFX HS C:=8 HSUY&DFX H?ESBEO[8 ! äG~): ¤ äGC:O[8CÊ< /,G TD S P. êS(?A8%CSYÅGCXES(,zNA8;XTD"H8TDCSo8~\T\TSU\H\)RSUXH\æG A\tS*CSU:H8COC8C\TB*Sh< =\ªG T?ESmMS-:=ÿD´>/BEO[8) äGC:L¹ >@G SSU:TSRYÅGÅ< N S-XHSUY9DPXSU8;:HOPDFSU: \TSU< HDFG~XA\ G GH?EDP\B*8;BS-:$0*?ESU:TS(SS äGÅ< N*\ G~XEOG~X CS-XAS-:=8;OB*SU:! äG~:)`8CXA< S Pm?ES$S ÅBS-:H"D S- X =8;Oæ< G~XAYÅ"D TDPGCXA\8;:HZS H?EIS äGCOPOPG DF X X5EMS-:=ÿD´> BEO[8 ! äG~): CS-:=\TDFG~\X "~L < G BEDPOPSUY&DFXR:TSUOFSh8C\T[S GÅYÅWS 7ä6D S FL;<-G BEDPOFSU:GCB H"D D[\T8 TDPGCXA\0GCXªLWYES E N CDP X /DFX äG~): `8 TDPGCX G©[: 4\SNA\TSUY (GCL: /Å\ =8 TDPGCX*\ "D T?º8$MSUX TDP N ) JÅ^7 °KZ&([M Ú,XL $¯/87 ½G 1S G :)~L~8;X*Y:TNEXAXEDFX KZ P_ \êZS SU8C\TNE:HSUY8;X*YBE:TG AOPSUY T?A«S T?EZS G~!\ < G G~XE"O ®NA\TSUY \.

(66) M <-8COFO[\ êSºDPXA<-OFNAYES`?ES-:HS T?ES`X@N *SU:H\ äGC: T?AS T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX< :HSU8 HDFG~XêBA:TD D HD ~S zL T?AS,< G D 8CXAY8 GC: mBA:TD D HD ~S 8CXAY 8CX SUXAY TG S-XAY S-XA<=? 8C: T?A8 &8;OPOFGÅ<U8 TSh\ G fSh< H\ D H?EDFX½8 H:H8CXA\H8C< HDFG~X OFO T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA\ SU8~\tNE:HSUY`8C:TS B*Sh\T\TD RD[\ TD[< oQAGC: E:TS @D (S/<-G S-X G~XEO G~X T?AS A:=\ (\TS mG XzN S-:=\. ' G *O\ W I ¡ 3 " î$fd _ g9ìî$jLìl _Li mî " ) 3 " Nfî%h _ gRìî%j)ìl_Li m î #6 ± )/^ * 4 3 ¹ QG7' [ ( ! A: ( * 3 " Y K ! S . pWð³-ÑT© ¥T¯Pµ ³ ¬iµ-ÐT¥t² ~³#r hÇî u ÕUÕh$$g. ÅðÑU³-Ú ¥H¯Fµ ³ ¬iµUÐt¥t² C³#r hÇî ÇUÕ;uw ÄUÈ,$g. b ð³-Ñt© ¥T¯Fµ;³ ¬iµ-ÐT¥f² ~³#s =î ÃhÃhÃUt-µ9 9 ;Ð=µ¥iÑ ²w³ps ÑU³-Ú ¥H¯Fµ ³ ¬iµ-ÐT¥t² C³#r Ä-WÈ;u ÄUÕ-$g ºG»¼ âuEâ ÓæÊCn=b=}Ckfawe kfaw$nmCdfnpUéCs~eã g=u. +Q DCNA:TS

(67) ÅY7Í8:o\t?EG\T?ES SÅSU<-NTDPGCXHD"S

(68) E:HSU8/ÅYÅGXTG\!H8C:!8,XEST:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCXs G (T?ESHD"SCL`8;:L/CSUY£T]SU8CY8 ä:HG Mÿ >ÅS-XAYëYE8H8 TG9MÿL §DP\$\TBS-X&< G NEXED[<-8TDPX YD"T?²H?ES&MÿH?E:TG~N C?^PK&(M2ö% fMò\TGÅ<Ê/CS=\47äG~X²T?AS&\H8S4`8C<=?EDPXES%: XPm?AS 8 GCNEX G YE8 H8\tSUX mD[\)\ `8;OPOÍLE8CXAY \TS-X*YÅDFX ºYE8 =8&DP#X CG~"O ~SU\(XEG (8C3D 2 äG~2: T?E4S ÚZ¾s¾G \ò?ES-¨ X H?E S ÚZ¾s¾:TSh8CYE\&YE8 =8 ä:TG >T?ESMoÿ&L+"D R<U8;X½SU3D H?ES-: *S8C< TNA8COFO ê:HSU8~YÅDP X YE8 =²8 ä:HG T?AS\TGÅÊ< /CS hL+G~: m8;"D TDP X . äGC: T?ESMo´ ÿ HG<-G BEOPS TS8;X GCBS-:=8 TDPGCÞX *S äGC:HS :TS TNE:HXEDP X &W8 8COFNES # i¡X T?ED[\(OP8 !HS-:m<-8C\TSCL~3D 2EOPGÅÊ< /@\oDFXW8 äNEX*< TDPGCX<-8COFOPSUY d[ìi _ wkm#g gfaRg éÅL ?ES-:HSU8~\$:TSh8CYÅDP X äNEX*< TDPGCX*I\ 8H?E¡S äGCL: S-:<U8C\TS êYÅG9XAG SEOPGÅÊ< /.AN &8C< TNA8COFO :TSh8CY YE8 =K8 ä:HG ¤T?ES\TGÅÊ< /CS $;>@GA%L H?E2S TD S\tBS-X G#WT?ASMoÿ TGBS-): äGCL: ô"D HJ\ =8C)\ /@\0D[\ 8;O G~!\ S*,zNA8;1O HG T?EIS H"D S,\TB*SUX

(69) YT?E4S ÚZ¾s¾ëDPX d[ìi _ wkm#g gfaRg é iX8COF; O T?AS TSU!\ HI\ (SRB*SU!: äG~): SUYæ1L T?E¡S ÚK¾¾ \tBS-X $GCXEO ó8 äS æRG~:TS DFOPOPDP\TSU<-GCXAYE\ DF.X d[ìi _ wkm#g gRfaxg éYH?A8;XêDF.X T?ES äNEX*< TDPGCX:HSU8CYEDF X ä:TG óT?ES`\TGÅÊ< /CS $+Pm?ADP\\T?EG Z\ T?A8 :TSh8CYÅDP X ² ä:HG T?ES\TG@Ê< /~S &8~<-<-GCNEX HW\ äGC:R?A8;"O G «H?ES <-G NEXADP<U8 TDPGC±X H"D SDFX*YÅNA< ShY 8 î%fd _ gRìî%j)ìl_Li m îR<U8;OPzO 1&GCXA\T*S ,zNESUX H"O ~ L H?E4S =8C)\ /@«\ H8 /@DP X YG~!\ G ;H?ES,S @Sh< N HDFG~X TD RS,8C:TN S H?ES$GCXESh\m?ESU%8 @DP"O º<-G NAXEDP<U8 HDF X "D T¹? T?AS,Moÿ Pm?E. S *8C\TDP<\tSh< NE:H"D ½<=?ESUÊ< /Å\R8;XAÞY T?ES4!\ H8C!: G

(70) H?ES4!\ Å!\ T*S T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCX 8C:T S T?AS RGz\ S ÅB*SUXA\tD CS2=8C)\ /Å\B*SU!: äG~): SUYRDP X T?E

(71) S ÚZ¾s¾ äG~: T?AS\ =8;): G 8XES T:=8;X*\T8~< TDPGCsX ' CO[8;XA<-S/ 8 «T?ES$< GÅYÅS$\T?EG (\ T?*8 2T?ESh\tNS (G H8C)\ /Å\m8;:HS/XAG G CSU): ?ESU"O DP X CO `< G RBAOFS 10 ?ES-XA<-SC%L G~!\ +G T?E-S TD SmDP\0\tBS-X DFXR< G &NEXED[<-8 TDPGCX8CXAY%L GC:H[S CSUXES-:=8;OPO CL-DPX&)\ Å\ HS <-8;OPO[\ Uvò G #T?AGS TG H8COCS ÅSh< N HDFG~ZX H"D SG #T?ED[\+BE:TD 3D H"D ~SDP\+\tBS-X 0DFWX D[\T<-S-OPOP8CXES-G~NA\æ\TNA<=? 8C\DPX HS-:HXA8;O YE8 =8ë?A8;XAYEOFDP X 7äS Xo< G~XA\ H:TN*< TG~:H\`8CXAY YÅSU!\ T:HNA< TGC:=\UL0OPD[\ ?*8;XAYÅOPDP X "A:L ýNv.

(72) T?A8 8C<-<-GCNEX äGC:ÒPSU\H\ T?A8CX vSU8~<=?QPm?ESU\TS4<-8COFO[\`8;:HS8CO"Gz\`DPXE?ES-:HS-XTGÞ&A]H] BE:TG C:=8 DFX ALÅ8;XAY8;:HSNEXA8%~GCD[YE8EOPS iX \tN `8C: ~L T?AS MS-:=ÿ D[>ëBAOP8! äGC:L>NA\!S S* 8;OPNA8HSUY äGC:?A8&D"&D[\-L0Dz SPL8 :TSh\tSh8;:=<=? BEO[8 äGC: H\ `8;DPX¹ äGÅ< NA\D[\2HSU\!TDPX º8XEGCSUOæ8;BEBA:TGz8C<=?YHGº\t?*8;:HDFX `YE8H8DPX T?ES iX HS-:HXES TSh\ HDFX 9XES 5BA8C:H8~YÅD `\-L+8C\H\tSh\T\TDFX äSh8C\T"D ADFOP3D ~L+8CXAYëS 8;OPNA8 TDP X T?ESUDF: < G~\ MS-: äGC: `8;XA<-S (8~\,XEG SH?ES BE:HD 8C): . äGÅ< NA\U;L EN ?A%8 @DF X êYÅS GCX*\ H:H8 TSUŸ äSU8C\T"D EDFOPD G /G~NE:`DPYESU8C\UL BS-: äGCL: `8;XA<-¹S SU<-G SU\ºSU\H\tSUX HDP8C«O T±G H?ES-DP: 8~<-< SUB H8 EDPOF"D [Pm?AS MS-:=ÿD´> GÅYÅSUODP\ äSh8C\TD EOPSCL AN «T?ESU:TSD[2\ NA<=?:HGzG ¸ äGC:mBS-): äGCL: `8;XA<-S/D BE:HG CSSUX +>@G S`:TSh\tSh8;:=<=?óD[\T\TNESU\:HS-O[8 HSU8Y TG4BS-): äGCL: `8;XA<-S8C:TS`!\ TDPOFOoGCBS-XæLª\TNA<=?è8CI\ *S RG~): 8CXA8 ~S S-X hLE8;XAY T:=8;XA\H8C< TDPGCXA8CO\tNEBAB*G~!: $ . ) Q ) L¹ ¢ « Y $5Q !* ) L ¡ " ) Y ( " * . nQxRÜ. y-~$$|X;z~#~#. XëD"BGC:)H8CX,D[\H\tNESDPXT?ESºYÅSh\tDCXG MS-:=ÿ D[>8(8~\ZTG²A8COP8CXA< S(G<-GCX *DP<TDPX :TS ,~NADF:HSS-X=\5 «'5\tD BEOFS~+ L T:=8;XA\TBA8;:HS-X hLANEXE"D äGCL: DPX HS-): ±8C<-SC+L T¹G `8 /CS&3D $Sh8C\TDFSU