Application of a two-point closure to the dispersion of particles in isotropic and sheared turbulence

HAL Id: hal-00461261

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00461261

Submitted on 4 Mar 2010

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Application of a two-point closure to the dispersion of particles in isotropic and sheared turbulence

Wouter J.T. Bos, Jean-Pierre Bertoglio

To cite this version:

Wouter J.T. Bos, Jean-Pierre Bertoglio. Application of a two-point closure to the dispersion of particles

in isotropic and sheared turbulence. iTi Conference on Turbulence 2005, Sep 2005, Bad Zwischenahn,

Germany. pp.217-220, �10.1007/978-3-540-32603-8_44�. �hal-00461261�

) *$+"%!#,"!$-./!"%0/ ) (#$,"%$ )

#"21 $3# $

4*57698;:=<>?5A@ BDCFE#G7:=BHC9IKJMLN:=<;<O:3>P:=<Q8O5HRHSTLT5

UWV=X9YZQV[\Y^]_Z\`+a7`+bc`OdeV=f7]Ngih7`a7`kjMlnmohA]pa7`OjM`;[MaFqr?dkY=hAjK[\]pgihA`

stdkY=mp`3u!`kfi[vZQVmp`aH`UFwiY=fWx7stdkhAmom_wixylHZQV=fAdO`

z|{A}M~9€ ‚3ƒ+„~…\€M}

>PBD8O†k‡:=SN57<ˆN‰eŠ.‹ŒBH@Œ8O‡:/W<O@Q88;5Ž5H<O‘’BHSNST“”E:=@O†<OLN•:,8;‡F:/SNLTC–—•W:8\‹?:=:C˜FBH<Q8OLT†SN:E9LT@QI

˜W:=<O@;LN57C*BHCFE™8O‡:’‘’Lpš9LTCR#5DŽPB”˜FB7@;@;LN›7:@O†BHSTBH<=œtyLTCF†:8O‡:Ctžt@;:›7:<kBDSBD698O‡5H<k@‡FBŸ›H:

6F@Q:^E8;‡L @%STLNCF–8O5BHEE<;:^@;@!8O‡:˜<O5H•ST:‘¡5DŽtE9L @Q˜:<k@;LN57CtœH¢57<2:šBH‘˜FSN:7žH£¤BH<O†k‡:=›H:^¥76F:

BDCFE¦£t:^@QLT:6F<§ˆ¨iŠ6F@;:=E©8O‡:«ªMEE“©¬BD‘’˜:=E|­36FB7@QLNIK®+5H<O‘¯BDS,°™BD<O–H5i›yL BDC©†ST57@;6<;:

±

ªM¬,­®+°*²%Ž57<M8O‡:,@;†=BDS BD<?@;˜:=†e8O<;6F‘¡8O5@Q8;6WE9“’8;‡:<O:S Bi8;LT›H:E9L @Q˜:<k@QLT5HC³5DŽt˜FBH<Q8OLT†SN:

˜FBDLT<O@=œF´µ<O:=†:CA8<O:›yLN:=‹5HŽ2E9LT@;˜:<k@QLT5HCBDCWE#‘LNš9LNCFR†BDC•:,Ž576CFE#LTC™¢FBDST–H5i›yL †k‡·¶¸

¹iºN»

ˆ¼ŸŠKœ.½vC«8;‡:”˜<;:^@Q:=CA8/‹?57<;–*Lp8LT@@Q‡F5i‹ C*8O‡FBi8’B<O:=†:=CA8:šy8;:=CF@;LN57C¾5DŽ+ªM¬,­®+°

8;58O‡:’†BH@;:5HŽ2‡5H‘’57RH:CF:5H6W@ 8;6F<;•6FSN:=CF†:‹ Lp8O‡*B6FCLpŽ57<;‘‘’:^BDC¿@O†BHSTBH<+RH<kBHELN:=C78

†BDC*•W:’BD˜F˜SNLT:=E™8;5@;LNCR7SN:IÀ˜WBD<;8;L †ST:E9L @Q˜:<k@QLT5HC*LNC*•W5H8;‡LT@;5D8O<;57˜L †,8;6F<;•6FSN:=CF†:’BDCFE

‡5H‘’5HR7:C576F@Œ@Q‡F:=BD<PÁF5i‹,œ

ÂÄà …Q}Å?Æ\ÇÉÈ3Ê9~…Q„ËÆ\Ç©‚+…;Ì7È,ǤFÌy…\€M}ąQ}ͅQÌA€%~9€MÈ3…Q„Î~9ƒ+Ï3ƒ3Æ\Ǥ}3„nÇ

4*:F<k@\8/†5HCF@;LTE:<BDCLT@;5D8O<;57˜LT†/8;6<O•6ST:CA8,›H:=SN59†Lp8\“#F:=STE*5HC*‹ ‡L †k‡*‹P:LT‘’˜W5A@Q:¯B

†5HCW@\8kBDCA8M6CLNŽ5H<O‘‘’:=BDC8;:‘’˜:<kBi8O6<;:3RH<kBHE9LT:CA8?ÐLTC¯8;‡:ÑHIKE9LT<O:=†e8OLN57CtœHҌ‡:@;†=BDS BD<

LT@ŒBH@O@;6‘’:=ECF5HC9IvE9LNÓ6F@;LT›H:3@;58;‡FBD8?8O‡:3:^¥A6FBi8OLN57CŽ5H<P8O‡:@O†BHSTBH<2ÁF6W†e8;6WBi8;LT5HC—<O:=BHEF@Ô

ÕHÖ

ÕH׏ØÚÙ Ð+Û+ÜÞÝ

±

‰^²

‹ Lp8O‡¯Û

Ü

8O‡:+ÑHIK†5H‘’˜5HC:=C78%5HŽW8O‡: ÁF6F†8;6FBD8;LTCR/›7:ST5y†Lp8\“/F:S E˜H½K8P†BDC’•::=B7@QLTST“@;::C

•A“”LNCA8O:RH<kBi8OLNCFR’8;‡:@O†BHSTBH< :=¥A6FBD8;LT5HC#5i›H:=<B’˜FBD<;8;L †ST:8;<kBiß\:^†e8;57<;“8;‡FBD8+LNC#8O‡L @+†B7@Q:

8;‡:@;†=BDS BD< ÁF6W†e8;6WBi8;LT5HC Ö LT@3E9LT<;:^†e8;ST“—<;:=STBD8;:=E—8O58O‡:›7:<;8;L †BDS.@Q:=˜FBD<kBi8OLN57C#ELT@Q8OBHCF†:

Ñ Ü

5HŽ.8O‡:,˜FBD<;8;L †ST:Ž<;57‘àLN8O@ LTCLN8;L BDSt˜57@;Lp8OLN57CtÔ

Ö

ئÙ

ÐÑ Ü ±

¨H²

è Ñ Üé

è

×êØ

¨ Û3Ñ

Ü

ØÚÙ

¨DÐëËì Û Ö Ý ±

¼7²

LNC‹ ‡LT†k‡/8;‡:P5HCST“6C–yC5i‹ C¥A6FBHCA8;LN8\“L @¤8;‡:Œ@;†=BDS BD<;IÀ›7:ST59†LN8\“+†<O57@O@\Iv†57<;<O:S Bi8OLN57C Û Ö œ

í+@;LNCR³8;‡:ªM¬,­®+°0†SN5A@Q6F<;:Ž57<+8O‡:@O†BHSTBH<QIK›H:=SN59†LN8\“³†<;5A@;@QIK†5H<O<;:=STBD8;LT5HC³@;˜:=†e8O<;6F‘

ˆîWž¤ïŸŠKž Û Ö

†BHC*•:¯:›iBDST6FBD8;:=Etœ¤ÒŒ‡:’<;:^@Q6FSp8OLNCR#˜<O:=ELT†8;LT5HCF@Ž57<8;‡:¯‘’:=BHC¾@;¥A6FBH<;:^E

E9LT@;˜S BH†:‘’:CA82BD<O:MŽ576CFELTCR75y5yEBDR7<;:=:‘’:CA8‹ Lp8O‡8O‡:†S BH@O@;LT†=BDS9E9L @Q˜:<k@QLT5HC8;‡:=5H<O“

5DŽ%Ò.BŸ“yST5H<ˆðDŠÀœFҌ‡F:<O:=@;6SN8O@BH<;:@;‡5i‹ C”LTC—FRH6F<;:’‰Hœ

10 ^-5 10 ^-4 10 ^-3 10 ^-2 10 ^-1 10 ⁰ 10 ¹

0.01 0.1 1 10 100

ñMòNóôõyô.öM÷^ø øù ú\ûüùý+÷=þ9ÿötþAù÷=þ =ù;úŒú\ù þ ^øH÷Qûüùýkøÿ=ùTúQú\ù=þ

…;ÌAÈ,ÇtFÌy…\€M}ͅQ}! +€#" €2Å2Ǥ}+Çt€Mƒ+Ì Ì$ ÇtÊ&%3€('

Ò.BŸ“yST5H<’˜<O:=E9L †e8O:=E B ×*) •:‡WBŸ›ALT5H6F<’Ž5H<’8;‡F:‡5H<OL,+=5HCA8OBHS E9LT@;˜:<k@QLT5HC LNCÎ@Q8OBi8OLN57CFBD<O“

‡5H‘’5HR7:C:=5H6F@@Q‡F:=BD<ÁF5i‹,œ!4·LNST:#¬3®¾L @›7:<O“*STLT‘LN8;:^E¾8O5*‘¯BD–7:S BD<ORH:8OLN‘’:—5H<

STBH<;R7:.- :“yC57STE@?Cy6‘•:<?˜<O:=E9L †e8OLN57CF@žyB,<O:=†:CA8M:šy8O:CF@;LN57C5DŽn8O‡:ª?¬­®3°Í8;‡:=5H<O“

8;5’@;†=BDS BD<P‘LNš9LNCFRLTC³‡57‘’5HRH:=C:576F@P@Q‡:^BD<?ÁF5i‹Úˆ/^ŠtBDSTSN5i‹@M8;5’@Q8;6FE9“8;‡:E9L @Q˜:<k@QLT5HC

LNC—‡5H<OL+5HCA8kBDSËBDCFE³›H:=<Q8OLT†=BDSËE9LT<;:^†e8;LT5HC”Ž5H<ŒST5HCR8;LT‘’:=@ BHCFE³›yLT<Q8O6FBDSTST“‹ Lp8O‡5H68ŒSTLT‘LN8

LNC0- :=“ACF5HS E@ŒCy6‘•:<^œ

4*:’†57CF@QL E9:=<‡F5H‘’5HR7:C:=5H6F@@Q‡F:=BD<3ÁF5i‹Ú‹ LN8;‡·B”‘:^BDC*›H:ST59†LN8\“RH<kBHE9LT:CA821

Ø

è435iè ÑFœ^Ҍ‡:M›7:<;8;L †BHS7E9L @Q˜FSTB7†:‘’:=C78!5H•:“9@¤8;‡:Œ@;BH‘’:?BDCWBDST5HRH“3‹ Lp8O‡B+C5HC9IvE9LNÓ6W@QLT›H:

@;†=BDS BD<+B7@ LNC¿LT@;5D8O<;57˜LT†8O6<O•6ST:CF†:HœWҌ‡F:/‡5H<OL+5HCA8kBDS¤E9L @;˜STB7†:=‘:=CA8+LT@+‡5i‹P:›H:=< :šyI

˜SNL †LN8;ST“”BDÓ:^†e8O:=E—•y“¯8;‡:,‘’:^BDC—›H:ST59†LN8\“nÔ

Õ76

Ü

Ü;: Ñ Ü1%Ý

±

îA²

‹ Lp8O‡

8 Ü

8;‡: 6 IK†5H‘’˜5HC:=C78 5HŽ¤8;‡F:3ÁW6F†e8O6FBi8OLNCR’›7:ST5y†Lp8\“’W:S E˜F´C#BHEFE9Lp8OLN57CFBDSn8O:<O‘

‡FBH@Œ8O5¯•W:BHEE9:^E”8;5’8;‡F:/@;†=BDS BD< :=¥A6FBD8;LT5HC—8;5¯57•98OBHLNCB¯E9LT<O:=†e8+BHCFBDST5HR7“Hœ9Ҍ‡:/:^¥A6FBiI

8;LT5HCF@Ž5H<8O‡:*@O†BHSTBH<O@ Ö BDCFECB|†5H<O<;:^@Q˜5HCWE9LNCFR*8O5¾8;‡F:¿›H:=<Q8OLT†=BDS+BHCFE ‡57<;L+57C78kBDS

E9LT@;˜S BH†:‘’:CA8O@ BH<;:C5i‹<;:^@Q˜:=†8;LT›H:=SN“nÔ

ÕHÖ

ÕH× ØÚÙ

ÐEDeÛ Ü ±

ïH²

Õ B

Õ7× ØµÙ ÐGF

8 Ü Ù Ö 1 ±

ð7²

½vC³8O‡:=@;:3:^¥A6FBi8OLN57CF@ŒÐED3LT@ŒB‘:^BDC#@;†=BDS BD<?RH<kBHE9LT:CA8ŒLNC³8;‡:,ÑHIKE9LT<O:=†e8OLN57C³BDCWE³ÐGF”LT@ŒB

‘:^BDC@O†BDS BD< R7<OB7E9LT:CA8 LNC#8O‡: 6 IvE9LT<;:^†e8OLN57CtœFҌ‡:,:^¥76WBi8;LT5HCW@ŒŽ5H< 8O‡:/‘’:=BHC@;¥A6FBH<;:^E

E9LT@;˜S BH†:‘’:CA8E9L @\8kBDCF†:,<;:^BHEËÔ

Õ Ñ Üé

Õ7×êØ

¨ Û ÜÑ Ü ±

/D²

Õ 6 ÜÑ Ü

Õ7× Ø 8 ÜÑ Ü : Û Ü6 Ü : Ñ Üé 1

±IH

²

Õ 6 Üé

ÕH× Ø ¨ 8 Ü6 Ü : ¨ Ñ Ü6 Ü1

±IJ

²

±

‰K7²

Ҍ‡:†<O57@O@QIK†5H<O<;:=STBD8;LT5HCF@

8 ÜÑ Ü

BDCFE Û ÜÑ Ü

BD<O:,BDR7BHLNC—8O<;:^Bi8;:^E#BH@@O†BHSTBH<?ÁW69š9:=@=žFLTC”8O‡:

†BH@;:,5DŽ2B¯›7:<;8;L †BHSt‘’:=BDC™@O†BHSTBH< RH<kBHE9LT:CA8‹ LN8;‡›iBDST6:

Ù

‰7œWҌ‡:†<O57@O@\Iv†57<;<O:S Bi8OLN57CF@

8 Ü6 Ü

BDCFE Û Ü6 Ü

BD<O: 8;<O:=BD8;:=E¯B7@M@O†BHSTBH<%ÁF69š9:=@?LTC¯8;‡:3˜<O:=@;:CF†:5DŽtB/‡F5H<OL,+=5HCA8OBHS‘’:=BDC

@;†=BDS BD<MR7<OB7E9LT:CA8=ž78OBH–ALTCRLNCA8;5’BH†=†576CA8M8;‡F:†5H6˜STLTCR8O:<O‘

± Ù Ö 1M²2LTC³:^¥76WBi8;LT5HC

±

ð7²œ

Ҍ‡:LNC9ÁW6:CF†:,5DŽ.8;‡L @†576˜STLNCFR8O:<O‘àLT@C:R7SN:^†e8;:^E³LTC”8;‡:,:^¥76WBi8;LT5HC³Ž5H<Œ8O‡:8;<OLN˜FSN:

†5H<O<O:S Bi8;LT5HCW@œÒŒ‡:E9:8kBDLTST@’5HŽ+8O‡:†ST57@;6<;:—6F@;:=E§8;5·5H•8OBDLTC ¥76WBDCA8;LN8OBD8;LT›H:—<;:^@Q6SN8O@=ž

•FBH@;:=E”5HC”8;‡:/ª?¬­®3° 8;‡:=5H<O“Hž†BHC”•:Ž5H6FCFE—LNC>P57@,ˆ/=ŠKœ

Ҍ‡:<O:=@;6SN83L @+@;‡5i‹ C™LTCFRH6F<;:¨œÒŒ‡F:•FBHSNSTLT@Q8;L †/<O:R7LN‘’:LT@+˜<;:^@Q:=CA8BDRABDLTC™BDCFE

BiŽü8;:=<3B’8O<OBHCF@;Lp8OLN57CFBDSt˜WBD<;8+B ×*) •:‡FBŸ›yLT5H6<+LT@+5H•F@;:<O›H:^E˜´P8+8O‡:/ST5HCR7:=@Q88;LT‘’:=@ 8O‡:

:š9˜W57C:CA8OLTBHSFRH<O5i‹Œ8;‡’5HŽ8O‡:+–yLTC:8OLT†+:C:=<;R7“LTC¯‡5H‘’57RH:CF5H6F@2@;‡:^BD<%ÁF5i‹Î†=BD6F@;:=@8O‡:

E9LT@;˜:<k@QLT5HC”8;5¯E9:=›AL Bi8O:Ž<;57‘ 8;‡FLT@@O†BHSNLTCR’BDCFE”8O5R7<;5i‹ ŽBH@Q8;:<Œ8O‡FBDC ×*) œ

LNM*€?}+„ËÆQƒ3Ìy…\€M}

Ҍ‡:¿BDCWBDST5HRH“¾5HŽ8;‡:™:^¥A6FBi8OLN57C Ž57<¯8;‡F:¿@;†=BDS BD<’ÁF6W†e8;6WBi8;LT5HC LTC B8;6<O•6ST:CA8ÁW5i‹

‹ Lp8O‡·B—‘’:=BHC·˜FBH@O@QLT›H:’@O†BDS BD<R7<OB7E9LN:=CA8BHCFE™8O‡:E9:=˜STB7†:=‘:=CA8/5DŽPB”ÁF6FLTE˜FBH<Q8OLT†SN:

BDSTSN5i‹@8O5/6F@;:+†ST57@;6<O:=@2E:›H:=SN57˜W:^EŽ5H<M˜WBH@O@QLT›H:@O†BHSTBH<2‘’Lpš9LTCR,8;55H•98kBDLTC¯<;:^@Q6SN8O@%Ž5H<

ÁF6L E˜FBH<Q8OLT†SN:ŒE9L @Q˜:<k@;LN57Ctœ^Ҍ‡F:Œª?¬­®3° †SN5A@Q6<O:HžŸE9:=›H:ST5H˜:=E/Ž5H<!8;‡F:Œ@O†BHSTBH<tÁF6šnžiL @

6F@Q:^E‹ LN8;‡57698Œ‘59E9LNW†=Bi8;LT5HC³LNC³8;‡L @M‹P5H<O–8;5˜<;:^E9L †e8 @QLTCRHST:+˜WBD<;8;L †ST:3E9L @Q˜:<k@;LN57C¯LNC

LT@;5D8O<;57˜LT†!8O6<O•6ST:CF†:?BDCWE‡5H‘’5HR7:C:=5H6F@Ë@;‡:^BD<ËÁF5i‹,œ^Ҍ‡:2<O:=@;6SN8O@¤BH<;:%LTCBHRH<O::‘’:=C78

‹ Lp8O‡#†STB7@;@;L †BDSË@O†BHSNLTCR’STBŸ‹@=œ

10 ^-6 10 ^-5 10 ^-4 10 ^-3 10 ^-2 10 ^-1 10 ⁰ 10 ¹ 10 ² 10 ³ 10 ⁴

0.01 0.1 1 10 100

< x’ 2 >

St t ²

t ³

ñMòNóô(PFô(QRQùST=þAû÷^ønÿ=ù ú;ú\ùþUV+÷,ú\ù þ ^øWH÷Qûüùýkøù þYX72* Z;þ[*?\HúúX;v÷(]W

^ ÇE_OǤÇ¤}+„nÇ.Ì

`a.bcadea ã!V[\df@A`kmoY=Z a <Œ]ghAjv]oY^f]pf·VUhy`kmpaY?>.@AYi,Y=ç^`kf7`kY^h7j,[\h7Z\XAh7mo`kfAdk` a ]a `OhAmo`OZ\]pV=f

VfyV=m_wHjv]ojaj \Dú\ûIk4l7knmyýOùkpo#;úqkrmstk j x áuOvAwTxvOZyzDx `T{ O {7a

áZa b a UVZ\d@7`t|[}`egihA`3V=fAa”b a UF`kjv]o`kh7Z ac~ @A`V==Amo]odeV[\]oY^f”Y>.`eaAaDwDåÀa7Vi2=9`eai/VZ*€ŸY|D]NVf

dkmoY=jvh7Z\`kjŒ[\Y/[*@A`c=7Z\Y^X7mo`ti Y?>%a7]oj=9`OZ\jv]oY=f”Y?>=yVZv[\]odkmo`e=yV]oZ\j

a

l7kG‚„ƒkýQ÷þAù…q\;;x

á z u``

ATx

` AO7x `T{†7`a

A a.bca lAV=m‡€ŸY|D]pdf@Wx deasb Vtˆ`ka‰t€D]üxFb a[Š `OZ\çŸVjvjvY^mpV a æËVZv[\]odkmo`kjŒV=fyaYhA`kmpa7jM]of‹AhA]pa[\hHZ\XAh7å

mo`kf7dk` a o#Œkp‚eÿvkŽ(Xútkox[w?A‘’OZ“u{` Ax { wyDx á zz `a

O a.”[a• `OZvZexAU aæ a7â V=fAçHxyVfyaU a–a u!Y^momo]ofAja sE<R—™˜ bši,YDa7`OmFY?>tV›=AV=jvjv]‡|Ÿ` jvdeVmNVZœˆ2]_[*@

Vh7fA]> YZ*ii,`eV=fç=ZQV=a7]o`kfi[ a ŽžXúqkŸ!ø\DùÿúQx †u` y †† x `t  z † x `T{{ 7a

y aPâCaä a~™a ã!Y=jkx •caG~ Y=hA]omüx¤V=fAa¿ä aåÞæ a ã!`OZv[\Y=ç^mo]oY a0– `OwHfAY=mpa7jfDhiX9`OZ3a7`q=9`kfyaH`kfAdOw—Y>

[*@7`MjvdkV=mpVZW‹Ah¡3j=9`kdO[vZ\h;iÉ]of,]ojvY=[vZ\Y=7]od?[\h7Z\X7hAmo`kf7dk`Wˆ2]o[*@V hAf7]> Y=Z*ijvdeV=mpVZ%ç=ZQV=a7]o`kfi[

a

Ž(XútkpŸ!ø\Dùÿ=ú\x ` w7‘`eá “;x á zzy a

 a.bca¢e~ VewHmoY=Z a <Œ]ghAjv]oY^f*XDw™dOY^fi[\]ofHh7Y^h7j2i,Y?|^`ti,`kfi[\j a ŽWeýk#£=þ9ÿvþ¤‚”÷=ûX;kœm$eýkpx

á ‘á zv“ u‡`t{  x á`eá x `T{^á`a

w aPâCaä a~™a ã!Y=j a ŽM÷úQú\ù¥Œm9ý\÷^øo÷?ù¦=ùTþ ?ù þ3û’\7q§q\Hø;þAûv]W a æG@;<™[*@A`kjv]ojkxstdkY^mo`2u!`kfi[vZQVmp`

aH` UFwiY=fWx á zzvy a